/$75$0$ Ê LQXWLOH FKH VXD PDGUH LQVLVWD OD UD JD]]DQRQYXROHVSRVDUHLOYHFFKLRFRQ WDGLQR DUULFFKLWR FKH YLHQH D OH]LRQH GL LWDOLDQR GD VXR SDGUH 7UD O¶HVLPLR SUR IHVVRUH GL JLQQDVLR H OD PRJOLH VRUJRQR FRQWLQXLEDWWLEHFFKL3HUIRUWXQDF¶q1HO ODODQXRYDFDPHULHUDFKHFLVDGDYYH URIDUHLQRJQLSLFRPSOLFDWDVLWXD]LRQH FRQDPDELOHVFDOWUH]]DOHLVDSUjULVROYH UH WXWWL L SUREOHPL ( DOOD ILQH IRUVH GD VHUYDGLYHQWHUjSDGURQD /D &RPSDJQLD ³/XFFKLQL ULVFRSUH GDO GLPHQWLFDWRLR XQD EHOOD FRPPHGLD GL 7HVWRQL FRQ EULOODQWL SHUVRQDJJL VXOOR VIRQGRGHOOD%RORJQDGHJOLDQQL¶ 7(6721,"(3(5&+e12 (6721,"(3(5&+e12 1HOODIHPPHGHFKDPEUH52%(57$%$/%2 )UDQFHVFR0DUURQFHOOL*,$11,*,8/,$12 /XLJLDOSURIHVnXU*,$1&$5/2$1*(/,1, $GHODLGHODPXMqU$11$0$5,$/8&&+,1, &DUOLQDODIL{OD*,8/,$2/,9,(5, (YDULVWRDOIL{O$/%(5727$52==, 8JRDQYnXGHG)UDQFHVFR/8&$520$1(//, $JDWDODVrUYDGTXvGVnXUD52%(57$%,$9$7, ,OVLJQRU)DFFKLQHWWL/(21$5'20$&&$*1$1, /DVLJQRUD)DFFKLQHWWL)5$1&(6&$&$03$1,1, $GDOJLVD)DFFKLQHWWL0$5,$526$7,%$/', $OPDVVWHUHGPX LFD'$1,(/(%(57$*1,1 /XF\%HOPRQW5266(//$=$*12/, $OGyFFD/8&$520$1(//, $OOLIWGDO+RWHO%DJOLRQL0$66,029$&&$5, 8QIDFKpQ/(21$5'20$&&$*1$1, 8QqWHUIDFKpQ0$66,029$&&$5, /·D]LRQHVLVYROJHD%RORJQDQHO 5HJLDVFHQDHFRVWXPL '$9,'($0$'(, 2UJDQL]]D]LRQH $11$0$5,$/8&&+,1, 7HFQLFR 67()$12&,35(66, &ROODERUDWRULWHFQLFL *,$1&$5/2$1*(/,1, 52%(57$%$/%2 0$66,029$&&$5, /(21$5'20$&&$*1$1, 5DPPHQWDWULFH 0$5,$526$7,%$/', 6DUWD *,$11$&$03267(//$ 1HLFDUWHOORQLSHWURQLDQLRUPDLGLUDGRVL OHJJHLOQRPHGHO³SDSjGHOWHDWURGLDOHW WDOHERORJQHVH´DIDYRUHLQYHFHGLDGDW WDPHQWLGDFRPPHGLHVWUDQLHUH ³/H FRPPHGLH GL 7HVWRQL VRQR YHFFKLH VRUSDVVDWH´ DOFXQL GLFRQR 6H IRVVH YH URDOORUDSHUFKpVLUHFLWDQRDQFRUD*RO GRQL6KDNHVSHDUHR6RIRFOH" /D TXHVWLRQH QRQ q FRVD VL PHWWH LQ VFHQDPDFRPHORVLID 7HVWRQL ULFKLHGH XQ LPSHJQR PDJJLRUH DJOL LQWHUSUHWL XQR VWXGLR GHL FDUDWWHUL H GHOO¶DPELHQWD]LRQH /D &RPSDJQLD /XFFKLQL DPD DIIURQWDUH OHVILGHHGXQTXHQHOJLURGLGLHFLDQQL DIIURQWDTXHVWRDXWRUHSHUODWHU]DYROWD VFHJOLHQGRXQFRSLRQHVWUDQDPHQWHPDL SLUDSSUHVHQWDWRGDO 6DUj O¶RFFDVLRQH SHU UDFFRQWDUH XQR VFRUFLR ERORJQHVH GHOOD VWRULD LWDOLDQD TXDQGR VL FDQWDYD ³*LRYLQH]]D´ H VL LQ VHJQDYDDQRQSDUODUHLQGLDOHWWRTXDQ GROHVHGX]LRQLGHLWDEDULQVYXRWDYDQRL SRUWDIRJOL GL FKL OD JXHUUD O¶DYHYD IDWWD QRQ LQ WULQFHD PD LQ ERWWHJD TXDQGR OH GRQQHDFTXLVWDYDQRFRQLOODYRURLOGLULW WRGLGLUHODORURQHOODPRGHUQDVRFLHWj 7HVWRQL FRO VXR XPRULVPR VRWWLOPHQWH SLFFDQWH FL LQVHJQD DQFRUD XQD YROWD D VRUULGHUH VXL QRVWUL GLIHWWL H VXOOD PH VFKLQLWjGHOOHDPEL]LRQLXPDQH /$ &203$*1,$ ³/8& ³/8&&+,1,´ &+,1,´ q XQR GHL SL DWWLYL JUXSSL GL WHDWUR GLDOHWWDOH EROR JQHVH HG q LO QDWXUDOH SURVHJXLPHQWR GHOO¶DUWH GL $UULJR /XFFKLQL O¶LQGLPHQWLFD ELOH DWWRUH H DXWRUH GL FRPPHGLH OLEUL UDFFRQWLHSRHVLHGLDOHWWDOL 1HOYHQHQGRDPDQFDUHTXHVWREH QLDPLQR GHO SXEEOLFR SHWURQLDQR OD VXD FRPSDJQLD WHDWUDOH JOL YROOH UHQGHUH R PDJJLR FRQWLQXDQGRQH O¶DWWLYLWj HG LQWLWR ODQGRLOJUXSSRDOXL'DDOORUDJUD]LHDOOD JXLGDSULPDGL&ODUD&RORPELQLSRLGL$Q QDPDULD/XFFKLQLULVSHWWLYDPHQWHPRJOLH HILJOLDGL$UULJRODFRPSDJQLDKDUDSSUH VHQWDWR LQ WHDWUL GL %RORJQD H GHOOD SUR YLQFLD GHFLQH GL FRPPHGLH LQ GLDOHWWR OH FODVVLFKH WHVWRQLDQH &$5',1$/( /$0 %(57,1, FRQ *XLGR )HUUDULQL H 7HDWUR$ SHUWR ,1 'Ï99 6 0e77 *$5,%$/'," H (/ )1Ê67(5 '$9$17, SRL 81 352 %/(0$'$/'e'¶,1&ÓGL9DOHULR)LRULQL ,1 &¬ 0Ì &0$1'$ /¶,7Æ/,$ GL 0RQHWWL HG L WHVWL GL $UULJR /XFFKLQL $O ),Ð/ (' &$9e&&¶ %Ð1$ 3Æ648$ $0('(2 &20( 0( 81 /Ê7 3$5 67$1Ñ7 81 %Ê/&$6e1=b17&Ï009¬HORVSHW WDFRORPXVLFDOH%b10Ñ'$%c1" 2UD OD &RPSDJQLD ³/XFFKLQL KD TXDVL WUHQW¶DQQLGLYLWDHKDWXWWHOHLQWHQ]LRQLGL FRQWLQXDUHSHUPROWRWHPSRDQFRUDDGRI IULUH QRQRVWDQWH OH PLOOH GLIILFROWj GLYHUWL PHQWRHVLPSDWLDDGXQSXEEOLFR³LQDPXUq HG %XOnJJQD´ SURSULR FRPH $UULJR /XF FKLQL &RPSDJQLD 'LDOHWWDOH%RORJQHVH ´$UULJR/XFFKLQLµ Z ZZDUULJROXFFKLQLLW LQIR#DUULJROXFFKLQLLW