$1121 'RPHQLFDRWWREUH /·LQFRQWUR 6XSSOHPHQWRGH³/¶DQ]LDQR´GLVHWWHPEUHQ'LUHWWRUHGRQ$UPDQGR7UHYLVLRO$XWRUL]]D]LRQHGHO7ULEGL9(QGHO 6HWWLPDQDOHGLLQIRUPD]LRQHHIRUPD]LRQHSHULIHGHOLGHOOD&KLHVD6&URFHGHO&LPLWHURGL0HVWUHHSHUJOLDPLFLGHO&HQWUR GRQ9HFFKLSHUO¶DVVRFLD]LRQH³&DUSHQHGRVROLGDOH´HSHUODSDVWRUDOHGHOOXWWR&HOOXODUHLQIR#FHQWURGRQYHFFKLLW /$0$'211$'(/526$5,2 /DFKLHVDLQYLWDLIHGHOLDUHFLWDUHLO6DQWR5RVDULRVHPSUHPDVSHFLDOPHQWHGXUDQWHLOPHVHGLRWWR EUH/RVFRUUHUHGHLJUDQLGHOODFRURQDHLOULSHWHUVLGROFHHLQVLVWHQWHLOQRPHGL0DULDUDVVHUHQDOR VSLULWRHSRUWDSDFHDOFXRUH ,1&2175, OLPLWLHGHEROH]]HPLVHULHHIUDJLOLWjPD DQ]LYLLQGLFRTXHVWHVSOHQGLGHÀJXUHSHU FKpVLDWHHVLJHQWL HVWLPRODQWLSHUFKpq XQGLULWWRVDFURVDQWRGLFKLFUHGHHGLFKL QRQ FUHGH G·DYHUH TXHVWL SXQWL GL ULIHUL 8135(7(&+(121+$3$85$',6325&$56, /$721$&$5$&&2*/,(1'25,),87,'·8202 8 Q QRWR HGLWRULDOLVWD GHO ´&RUULHUH GHOODVHUD3DQHELDQFRµFKHFHUWD PHQWH QRQ SXz HVVHUH WDFFLDWR GL FOHULFDOH R ELJRWWR KD VFULWWR FKH GLHWUR DFHUWHLVWLWX]LRQLEHQHÀFKHRGLFHUWHDV VRFLD]LRQL XPDQLWDULH WURYL TXDVL VHPSUH ODWRQDFDGLXQSUHWHRGLXQIUDWH3DQH ELDQFR KD UDJLRQH SRWUHL VÀGDUH SXEEOL FDPHQWHFKLFFKHVVLDDSURYDUPLVHQRQ VLDYHURWXWWRTXHVWRPDLWURYLFRPHDQL PDWRUH VRVWHJQR R JXLGD GHOOH VWUXWWXUH FKH DFFROJRQR FRQVRODQR H SURWHJJRQR JOL´XOWLPLµGHOODQRVWUDVRFLHWjSDUWLWLGL GHVWUDRGLVLQLVWUDUDGLFDOLRQRJOREDV DWHLRPDVVRQLOLEHUDOLROLEHULSHQVDWRUL VRFLRORJL R SVLFRORJL PD VH JUDWWL VROD PHQWHXQSR·WLWURYLODWRQDFDGLXQSUHWH RGLXQIUDWHWDORUDGLXQDVXRUDJOLDOWUL GLFRQRSDURORQLLQGLFRQRWDYROHURWRQGH VWLODQR VDJJL R SURWHVWH SURPXRYRQR UL YROX]LRQLIDQQRFRPL]LRJULGDQRSHUOH SLD]]HSHUzTXDVLPDLVLJLRFDQRODYLWD DQ]LTXDVLVHPSUHLQWDVFDQRODXWLVWLSHQGL VROFDQRLPDULFRQOXVVXRVLSDQÀOLDELWDQR LQDSSDUWDPHQWLGLOXVVRVRQRFRLQWHUHV VDWLDVRFLHWjRSHUD]LRQLOXFURVHJLUDQRLO PRQGRLQFRPRGLDHUHLVLVHUYRQRLQXQD SDUROD GHL SRYHUL H GHJOL XOWLPL SHU IDUH DIIDULOXFURVLHUDJJLXQJHUHPHWHDPELWH ,SUHWLHLIUDWLXQSR·PHQRVRQRWUDOH FDWHJRULHGLSHUVRQHWUDOHSLFULWLFDWH RJQXQR VL ULWLHQH LQ GLULWWR GL FULWLFDUH H GL GLUH PDOH IRUVH WDOYROWD QRQ D WRUWR SHUz VH F·q JHQWH FKH FUHGH QHOOD FDULWj H VL FXUD GHOO·XRPR SRYHUR GHUHOLWWR XPLOLDWR H LPSRWHQWH VRQR VHPSUH ORUR LSUHWL(·JLXVWRDQ]LVDFURVDQWRFKHVLD FRVuSHUFKpHVVLKDQQRVFHOWRG·HVVHUHGL VFHSROL GL XQ 0DHVWUR FKH KD DIIHUPDWR ´$PDLOSURVVLPRWXRFRPHWHVWHVVRµH SHUFLzYHUUHEEHURPHQRDOODORURYRFD]LR QHVHQRQSXQWDVVHURVXTXHVWRREELHWWLYR HVXTXHVWRVHUYL]LR1RQWXWWLLSUHWLVRQR FRVuSHUzYHQHVRQRIRUWXQDWDPHQWHDQ FRUDWDQWL1RQWXWWLVRQRRSRVVRQRHVVH UHFDPSLRQLSHUzLWLWRODULGHLUHFRUGVLQ XPDQLWj VRQR DQFRUD ORUR VRQR L SUHWL D GHWHQHUH L UHFRUGV SL DPELWL H GLIÀFLOL 5LFRQRVFHUHTXHVWLPHULWLqXQGRYHUHGL JLXVWL]LDHVRSUDWWXWWRXQYDORUL]]DUHXQD ULFFKH]]D FKH O·XPDQLWj H VRSUDWWXWWR LO QRVWUR3DHVHSRVVLHGHHJXDLVHQRQIRVVH FRVu SHUFKp DOWULPHQWL JOL ´XOWLPLµ GHO OD QRVWUD VRFLHWj VDUHEEHUR SURSULR DOOR VEDUDJOLR3RFRWHPSRIDYLKRSUHVHQWD WR FDUL DPLFL GRQ =HQR LO IRQGDWRUH GL 1RPDGHOÀD RJJL YL SUHVHQWR GRQ 2UHVWH %HQ]L 5LWDJOLR GDOOD VWDPSD FKH OHJJR FRQHGLÀFD]LRQHHGRUJRJOLRTXHVWHVWR ULHHYLULSURSRQJRLQWHJUDOPHQWHLTXHVWL WHVWL FKH QRUPDOPHQWH L FDQDOL PLJOLRUL GHLQRVWULPDVVPHGLDQRQULSRUWDQRSHU FKpSUHQGLDWHFRVFLHQ]DGLFKHFDPSLRQL SRVVLDPR FRQWDUH DQFRUD GL FKH SURIHWL HFKHWHVWLPRQLVRQRDQFRUDSUHVHQWLQHO QRVWURWHPSR1RQYLLQGLFRTXHVWHVSOHQ GLGH ÀJXUH GL SUHWH SHUFKp VLDWH LQGXO JHQWL FRO FOHUR DFFHWWLDWH SDVVLYDPHQWH PHQWRLQTXHVWHWRQDFKHORJRUHHYHFFKLH SHUzFKHTXDVLVHPSUHVRQRGHOOHEDQGLH UHSHUFKLVRJQDXQPRQGRPLJOLRUHHSL IUDWHUQR 'RQ$UPDQGR7UHYLVLRO '21(51(672%(1=, 6DFHUGRWHFKHQRQVLVWDQFDGLUDFFRJOLHUHDPRUHYROPHQWH UL¿XWLGLXRPLQLHGRQQHGHOODQRVWUDVRFLHWj & ·q XQD YHFFKLD 9RONVZDJHQ IHU PD DG XQ LQFURFLR YLFLQR DO SDU FKHJJLRGHOO·´,WDOLDLQPLQLDWXUD (· XQD PH]]DQRWWH GL OXJOLR H SRFKLV VLPHDXWRSDVVDQRGDTXHVWDSHULIHULD GL 5LPLQL 6XO FLJOLR GHOOD VWUDGD XQD ELRQGDLQPLQLJRQQDIXPDXQDVLJDUHW WD6HGXWDLQPDFFKLQDF·qODVXDFRP SDJQD8Q·DXWRVFXUDVLIHUPDDFFDQWR DOOD9RONVZDJHQ/HGXHGRQQHJXDUGD QRFRQVWXSRUHLOYHFFKLRLQWRQDFDQHUD FKHQHVFHQGHHVLDYYLFLQD©&RPHWL FKLDPL"ªFKLHGHO·LQDVSHWWDWRSDVVDQ WH DOOD ELRQGD 4XHOOD OR JXDUGD ©,FK VSUHFKH QLFKW ,WDOLHQLVFKª ´1RQ SDU OR LWDOLDQRµ ULVSRQGH VHQ]D QHPPHQR JXDUGDUOR0DJDULSHUXQFOLHQWHXQSR· GLLWDOLDQRVHORULFRUGHUHEEHPDTXHO O·XRPRqHYLGHQWHQRQqOuSHUTXHVWR 6·DIIDFFLD GDOO· DXWR LQYHFH OD FRPSD JQDHFRQVEDORUGLPHQWRW·DFFRUJLFKH DYUj VHVVDQW·DQQL q JUDVVD GLVIDWWD HSSXUHDSSHQDFRSHUWDGDXQDVRWWRYH VWHQHUDGLVHWD'LFHFRQDFFHQWRWHGH VFR GL HVVHUH DXVWULDFD H GL FKLDPDUVL 0DULD'LFHFKHIDTXHVWRODYRURGD DQQL ©3HUFKp FRQWLQXL DQFRUD"ª FKLH GHO·XRPRLQWRQDFDDPLFKHYROPHQWH FRPH FRPPRVVR GD TXHVWD SRYHUDFFLD FKH DQFRUD EDWWH DOOD VXD HWj ©1RQ SRVVRVPHWWHUH+RELVRJQRGLVROGLªID OHL DO]DQGR OH VSDOOH 1HOOD QRWWH GHO OD &LWWj GHOOH YDFDQ]H 0DULD FRQ WXWWL L VXRL DQQL VHJQDWL VXOOD IDFFLD H TXHO OD VRWWRYHVWH QHUD q O·LPPDJLQH GHOOD UDVVHJQD]LRQH D XQ GHVWLQR LQHVRUDEL OH0DGRQ2UHVWH%HQ]LQRQVLDUUHQGH PDL©ORSRVVRDLXWDUWLDFDPELDUHYLWD 'DYYHUR1HQRDLXWDWHWDQWHFRPHWH 3UHQGLTXHVWRELJOLHWWRqLOQXPHURGHO PLRFHOOXODUHFKLDPDPLTXDQGRYXRLª /D YHFFKLD DOOXQJD OD PDQR OHJJH ©0DJDULWLFKLDPRªIDHVLWDQWH©6DLLR KRXQVRJQRVFULYHUHXQOLEURHUDFFRQ WDUHWXWWRTXHOORFKHKRFDSLWRLQTXHVWL DQQL6uPDJDULXQJLRUQRWLFKLDPRª /D ELRQGD LQWDQWR VL q DOORQWDQDWD VFRFFLDWD 4XHOO·XRPRIDSHUGHUHWHPSRHGqJLj PH]]DQRWWH*LRYDQLVVLPDVRWWRLOWUXF FR IRUWH KD JLj OR VJXDUGR GL XQD FKH QRQVLDVSHWWDSLQLHQWHGDQHVVXQR¶ 'RQ%HQ]LULVDOHLQDXWRVLULSDUWH 6·qDO]DWRFRPHRJQLJLRUQRDOOHFLQ TXH PHQWUH QHOOD FLWWj DWWRUQR JOL XO WLPL QRWWDPEXOL DQGDYDQR D GRUPLUH H JOL RPEUHOORQL FKLXVL DVSHWWDYDQR LQ ÀODFRPHVROGDWLLOOHYDUVLGHOVROHVXO OD VSLDJJLD SDOOLGD GHOO·DOED ( D TXH VW·RUDODVXDJLRUQDWDQRQqÀQLWD&·q DQFRUDGDIDUHF·qDQFRUDTXDOFXQRGD DQGDUHDFHUFDUH/XLFRPSLUjODQQL DVHWWHPEUH©0DQRQqVWDQFR"ªFKLH GLDPR©1R2QRQPHQHDFFRUJRQRQ FLSHQVRª/·DXWREOXSHUFRUUHOHQWDOD 6WDWDOHIUD5LPLQLH5LFFLRQH6RQRSR FKLVVLPHRUPDLTXLOHSURVWLWXWHSHUOH VWUDGHPHQWUHDQQLIDLQTXHVWD]RQD FHQ·HUDQRRJQLQRWWHDFHQWLQDLDFRPH IDOHQHDWWRUQRDLIDOzQHLSUDWL0ROWH OH VWUDQLHUH VRQR VWDWH ULPDQGDWH D FDVDFROIRJOLRGLYLD(PROWHIRUVH H[WUDFRPXQLWDULHVFKLDYHGHJOLVIUXWWD WRULVRQRVWDWHOLEHUDWHGD%HQ]L2UDD 5LPLQLODSURVWLWX]LRQHqQHJOLDSSDUWD PHQWLHQRQVLYHGH(GLIÀFLOHLQFRQ WUDUHXQDUDJD]]DDGXQDQJRORHFKLH GHUOH VH YXRL YHQLUH YLD 0D OD QRWL]LD GLTXHVWRVLQJRODUHSUHWHVLqVSDUVDLQ WXWWD,WDOLDHTXDVLRJQLJLRUQRXQDQL JHULDQDRUXPHQDRPROGDYDGDTXDOFKH FLWWj JOL WHOHIRQD PL KDQQR GHWWR FKH OHLPLSXzDLXWDUHSRVVRLQFRQWUDUOD" /·HVWDWHGL%HQ]LqXJXDOHDRJQLDOWUD VWDJLRQH &DPELD VROR 5LPLQL DWWRUQR VXUUHDOH TXDQGR LO YHQWR G·LQYHUQR QH VSD]]D OH VSLDJJH YXRWH H FKLDVVRVD DYLGD GL YLWD DGHVVR QHO FROPR GHOOD VWDJLRQH 0D LO SUHWH LQ WRQDFD OXQJD VHQRQqLQYLDJJLRSHUOHFRPXQLWj WHUDSHXWLFKHGHOOD*LRYDQQL;;,,,VSDUVH QHOPRQGRRJQLPDWWLQDqQHOVXRXIÀ FLRQHOTXDUWLHUH*URWWD5RVVD5LFHYH GDOOHDOOHFKLXQTXHDEELDELVRJQR GL OXL $SSHVR DOOD SDUHWH XQ FDUWHOOR JUDQGLVVLPR©6HFKLDPDTXDOFXQRGDO OD VWUDGD H FKLHGH GL YHQLUQH YLD GLUH FKHGRQ2UHVWHYXROHDLXWDUOLHGDUHLO QXPHUR GHO VXR FHOOXODUHª /D VFULWWD PDUFDWD LQ SHQQDUHOOR QHUR SDUH O·RU GLQHGHOODFDVD 'RQ%HQ]LF·qVHPSUHDGRJQLRUDSHU FKL DEELD ELVRJQR GL OXL &RPH 6WHOOD XQD UDJD]]D QLJHULDQD DSSHQD DUULYDWD GDOOD 6LFLOLD$YUj SRFR SL GL DQQL XQDJUDQFKLRPDGLWUHFFLQHQHUHÀWWLV VLPHXQDIDFFLDSXOLWD6LVLHGHHLQXQ LWDOLDQRVWHQWDWRFRPLQFLDDSDUODUHGL JHWWR(QDWDUDFFRQWDLQXQYLOODJJLR VHFRQGDGLVHLVRUHOOHHTXDWWURIUDWHO OL'HVWLQDWDLQVSRVDÀQGDEDPELQDD XQXRPRPDWXURHEHQHVWDQWH$YHQW· DQQLSHUzVLLQQDPRUDGLXQFRHWDQHRH KDGDOXLXQDEDPELQD/·XRPRFXLHUD SURPHVVDVLLQIXULDHIDGDUHXQDOH]LR QH DO UDJD]]R 8QD EDQGD GL VJKHUUL OR SLFFKLDDPRUWH 6WHOOD VFDSSD GDO YLOODJJLR PD LO VXR IXWXUR PDULWR OD ULQWUDFFLD OD FKLXGH LQFDVDHODYLROHQWDSHUJLRUQLËODÀ JOLD GHOO·XRPR FKH LPSLHWRVLWD OLEHUD OD SULJLRQLHUD 6WHOOD VL ULIXJLD SUHVVR XQ·DPLFDLOFXLÀGDQ]DWROHSURSRQHGL DQGDUH LQ ,WDOLD GRYH OH JDUDQWLVFH XQ ODYRUR/HLLPSHJQDLOWHUUHQRGLIDPL JOLDSHUSDJDUHLOYLDJJLRGDO*KDQDDOOD 6YL]]HUDDOOD6LFLOLD0DTXDQGRDUULYD OD DFFRPSDJQDQR VX XQD VWUDGD DOOD SHULIHULD GL *HOD /H PHWWRQR LQ PDQR XQ SUHVHUYDWLYR LO WXR ODYRUROH GLFR QR q TXHVWR /HL FKH VL ULÀXWD YLHQH ULSHWXWDPHQWHYLROHQWDWDGDOSURWHWWR UH)LQFKpVLDUUHQGH,OQXRYRSDGURQH SUHWHQGHXQ´ULVFDWWRµGLPLODHXUR ©6RQRULXVFLWDDGDUJOLHQHVRORPLODª GLFH6WHOOD'RQ%HQ]LDVFROWDLQVLOHQ ]LRODVWRULDFKHVHQWHSHUODFHQWHVLPD YROWD©/HLKDLGHDVLULYROJHDQRLGL TXDQWLXRPLQLKDVXEuWRTXHVWDUDJD]]D SHUDUULYDUHDTXHOODVRPPD"ª)HUPD WDODQLJHULDQDLPSORUD©LQJLQRFFKLRª GLFH L SROL]LRWWL SHUFKq QRQ OD ULPDQ GLQR LQ 1LJHULD VHQ]D XQD OLUD HVSRVWD DOODYHUJRJQDQHOYLOODJJLR0DQHJDUL VROXWDPHQWHGLDYHUHXQSURWHWWRUH6D FKHÀQHIDQQRTXHOOHFKHSDUODQR/H WURYDQRQHLIRVVLRQHLFDVVRQLGHOO·LP PRQGL]LD )LQFKp XQ· DPLFD OH GLFH GL TXHOSUHWH&KHDELWDORQWDQRDOQRUG /H GXH ¶LQVLHPH WURYDQR LO FRUDJJLR GL VFDSSDUH,OWUHQRGDOOD6LFLOLDSDUHFRVu OHQWR H ORUR GXH KDQQR L SDGURQL DOOH FDOFDJQD 0D RUD 6WHOOD FH O·KD IDWWD qLQVDOYR/HPDQLQHUHVLWRUPHQWDQR PHQWUHUDFFRQWDODVXDVWRULDLSLHGLVL DJLWDQR VRWWR OD VHGLD 'DYYHUR TXHO O·XRPRODDLXWHUj"6DUHEEHLOSULPR/H PDQLGLGRQ2UHVWHLQYHFHVRQRJURVVH HTXLHWH,SLHGLVRWWRODVFULYDQLDPRELOL QHOOHJURVVHVFDUSHQHUHOHVXROHOLVH ©6WDL WUDQTXLOOD q ÀQLWD QRQ WRUQHUDL SL VXOOD VWUDGDª ,O VXR FHOOXODUH QHO IUDWWHPSRQRQKDPDLVPHVVRGLVXRQD UH8QDUDJD]]LQDFKHDYHYDDFFROWRLQ XQDFDVDIDPLJOLDEUXWDOPHQWHDEEDQ GRQDWD GDL JHQLWRUL q VWDWD ULDEEUDF FLDWD GDOOD PDGUH GRSR DQQL %HQ]L HVXOWD©/RVDSHYR&LFRQWDYR/·DYHYR FKLHVWRDOOD0DGRQQDª4XHOOD0DGRQ QDFKHWURQHJJLDLQXQDVWDWXDGLJHVVR QHO VXR XIÀFLR H LQ FXL TXHVWR VDFHU GRWH KD XQD ÀGXFLD DVVROXWD ©/HLQRQ WUDGLVFHPDLª ( GRPDQL YLD XQ DOWUR YLDJJLR YHUVR XQ·DOWUDFRPXQLWj,QDXWRFRQO·DXWL VWD©O·DXWRqODPLDFDVDHPLDFDSSHO OD,QDXWRVSHVVRGLFRLOPDWWXWLQROH ORGLLOURVDULR(SRLLYHVSULHFRPSLH WD ( DSSHQD DUULYR VHPSUH OD PHVVD RJQLJLRUQRGDDQQLª Ë VWUDQR 4XHVWR SUHWH FDQXWR H FRVu IRUWHQHOFXRUHGHOODFLWWjGHOOHYDFDQ ]HGHOUXPRUHGHOGLYHUWLPHQWRFRPH IXJDGDVp3HUTXHVWRYHQJRQRTXLGD WXWWD (XURSD H WRUQDQGR EUXFLDWL GDO VROH GDOOD VSLDJJLD DO WUDPR SHQVDQR FRPH VSUHPHUH ÀQR DOO· XOWLPD JRFFLD ODQRWWH0DOHLGRQ%HQ]LFLVWDEHQH TXL" ´%HQLVVLPRIDFFLR FRQWHPSOD]LR QH GHQWUR OD FLWWjµ &RQWHPSOD]LRQH D5LPLQL"©&HUWR&RQWHPSODUHVLJQLÀFD ULFRQRVFHUH&ULVWRLQWXWWHOHFRVHHLQ WXWWH OH IDFFH FKH LQFRQWUR $QFKH LQ TXHOOHGHLWXULVWLFKHVLVWRUGLVFRQRLQ GLVFRWHFD,RORVRTXHOORFKHLQIRQGR &DPELRGLRUDULR GHOOD60HVVDIHULDOH QHOODFKLHVDGHO &LPLWHUR &ROGLRWWREUH OD60HVVDQHOOD FKLHVDGHOFLPLWHUR YLHQHFHOHEUDWD DOOHRUH DQ]LFKqDOOHRUH DOFXRUHLJQDULDVSHWWDQRª(ODWRQDFD QHUDFRQWLQXDDSHUFRUUHUH5LPLQL$OOD ÀQH GHOOD QRWWH LQFRQWUD XQ·DOWUD UD JD]]DURPHQDVRODQHOEXLR$QFKHD OHLGjLOVXRQXPHURGLWHOHIRQR&RPH D0DULDODYHFHDXVWULDFDLQVRWWRYHVWH GLVHWD%HQ]LDVSHWWD'RPDQLIUDXQ PHVHFKLVVj 0DULQD&RUUDGL &26$+$)$772(&26$67$ )$&(1'2'21%(1=, $¿DQFRGHLSRYHUL SHUULGDUHVSHUDQ]D ©$ EEUDFFLDPRRJQLJHQHUHGL SRYHUWjDQGLDPRDFHUFD UHFKLQRQEXVVDDOODQRVWUD SRUWD YLYLDPR GRYH O·DOWUR VRIIUH &RQGLYLVLRQHqODSDURODG·RUGLQHPD VHQ]D GHFLGHUH D WDYROLQR OD QRVWUD SUHVHQ]D ODVFLDQGR FL LQYHFH JXLGD UH GDOOR 6SLULWR 6DQWR H GDOOH ULFKLH VWHGHLYHVFRYLª3DURODGL*LDPSLHUR &RIDQR UHVSRQVDELOH JHQHUDOH GHO VHUYL]LRDQWLWUDWWDXQRGHJOLXOWLPL VHUYL]LDYYLDWLGDOO·$VVRFLD]LRQH3DSD *LRYDQQL;;,,,1DWRD5LPLQLQHO JUD]LHDOFDULVPDGLGRQ2UHVWH%HQ]L HVXELWRVYLOXSSDWDVLSHURSHUDGLXQ JUXSSR GL JLRYDQL H DOFXQL VDFHUGRWL WUHQW·DQQLGRSRqVWDWDULFRQRVFLXWD FRPH $VVRFLD]LRQH ,QWHUQD]LRQDOH GL 'LULWWR3RQWLÀFLR,QWLWRODWDD*LRYDQ QL;;,,,LO3DSDEXRQR©VHPSOLFHGL WXWWLHWUDWXWWLGLVDUPDWRHVHQ]DWL WRORªQRQF·qIDWWRGLHPDUJLQD]LRQH FKHQRQODYHGDSUHVHQWH$WWXDOPHQ WH FRQWD LQ ,WDOLD FDVHIDPLJOLD DOO·LQL]LR SHQVDWH FRPH SURQWR VRF FRUVRĊVRFLDOHRJJLLQWHVHFRPHYHUH IDPLJOLHVRVWLWXWLYH$FFDQWRDTXHVWH VRQRVRUWHFDVHGLDFFRJOLHQ]DGHO OD IUDWHUQLWj H FDVH GL SUHJKLHUD 2JQLJLRUQRFLUFDPLODSHUVRQHQHO PRQGR VL VLHGRQR DOOH PHQVH GHOOD FDULWj SUHGLVSRVWH GDOO·$VVRFLD]LRQH PLODQHOODVROD$IULFD/D3DSD*LR YDQQLULFRQRVFLXWDDQFKHDOOH1D]LR QL 8QLWH LQIDWWL RSHUD LQ 3DHVL GL WXWWLHFLQTXHLFRQWLQHQWL,OVHUYL]LR DQWLSURVWLWX]LRQH LQ DQQL KD DLX WDWRROWUHPLODYLWWLPHGLFXLLO PLQRUHQQL OH VWUXWWXUH GL SURQWD DFFRJOLHQ]D DQWLWUDWWD H SURQ WR VRFFRUVR SHU VLWXD]LRQL GL GLVDJLR DGXOWH ,Q ,WDOLD FL VRQR FRPXQLWj WHUDSHXWLFKH SHU WRVVLFRGLSHQGHQWL DWWXDOPHQWHRVSLWDQRUDJD]]LFKH LQWHQGRQRXVFLUHGDOWXQQHOGHOODGUR JD 'DOO·HVSHULHQ]D GHOO·$VVRFLD]LRQH VRQRQDWHFRRSHUDWLYHVRFLDOLH FHQWUL GLXUQL RVSLWDQR JLRUQDOPHQ WH SHUVRQH $WWUDYHUVR XQD 2QJ RSHUD DOO·HVWHUR SHU SURJHWWL GL FRR SHUD]LRQH VYLOXSSR H FRQGLYLVLRQH 'HL YRORQWDUL GL VHUYL]LR FLYLOH VRQR ©FDVFKL ELDQFKLª LQYLDWL QHL WHUULWRULGLJXHUUD'LUHFHQWHqQDWD D 0HUFDWLQR &RQFD 38 OD 6FXROD GL IRUPD]LRQHDOODSDFH$OO·LQWHUQRGHO O·$VVRFLD]LRQH F·q XQ VHWWRUH FRPX QLFD]LRQHHGLWDOLEULDXGLRYLVLYLHLO PHQVLOH©6HPSUHªHLOJUXSSRPXVL FD5LVDOHDOODSULPDHVSHULHQ]D PLVVLRQDULDJUD]LHD3DROR7RQHOORWWR HDOODPRJOLH$QQDPDULDFKHSDUWLURQR SHULO&LOH©SHUVHJXLUH*HVSRYHURH VRIIHUHQWHFRQGLYLGHQGRODYLWDGHJOL XOWLPL H ULPXRYHQGR OH FDXVH GHOO· HPDUJLQD]LRQH(ODYRFD]LRQHFKHKD VSLQWRPHHVSLQJHDQFRUDRJJLWDQWL IUDWHOOL GHOO·$VVRFLD]LRQH D ODVFLDUH O·,WDOLD SHU DEEUDFFLDUH L GHEROL GHL 3DHVLSLSRYHULª 3DROR*XLGXFFL VWD]LRQH QHO FRQ XQ JUXSSR GL JLRYDQLHDOFXQLVDFHUGRWLFRVWLWXLVFH LO QXFOHR RULJLQDULR GHOO· $VVRFLD]LR QH 3DSD *LRYDQQL ;;,,, /R VSHFLÀFR FDULVPD YRWDWR DOOD PLVVLRQH D DOOD FRQGLYLVLRQHYLHQH©VSHVRªGDSSULPD FRQJOLKDQGLFDSSDWLHLQVHJXLWRFRQ L EDPELQL VHQ]D IDPLJOLD H OH SURVWL WXWH L EDUERQL H L QRPDGL L PDODWL GL PHQWH H L WRVVLFRGLSHQGHQWL 1R QRVWDQWH LO FRQWULEXWR VHQ]D ULVSDU PLRDOOD&KLHVD©DVVHGLDWDGDWXWWHOH SDUWLª GRQ 2UHVWH YDQWD DQFKH XQD VWHUPLQDWD SURGX]LRQH VDJJLVWLFD GL FRQIHUHQ]LHUH H FROODERUD]LRQL FRQ GHFLQHGLWHVWDWHJLRUQDOLVWLFKH 3* 7(67,021,$1=$'(,&5,67,$1, '(//$',2&(6,',9(1(1=,$ /HYLHGHO6LJQRUHVRQRYHUDPHQWHLQ¿QL WHJUD]LHD*DEULHOHPLVRQRUDYYLFLQDWD DOODIHGHJUD]LHD6WHIDQRH3DWUL]LDKR FRQRVFLXWRORIHGH * &+,(·'21%(1=, ,OVDFHUGRWHGDOOD³WRQDFDOLVD´ 4 XHOODWRQDFDqVHPSUHOLVDPD QRQ JOL VL q ORJRUDWD DGGRVVR FRPH SURPHVVR DL ÀJOL GL 'LR SRWUHPPR GLUH SDUDIUDVDQGR OD %LE ELD ©6DFHUGRWH GDOOD WRQDFD OLVDª q O·DSSHOODWLYR FKH JOL q VWDWR DSSLFFL FDWRDGGRVVRLQTXHVWLTXDVLDQQLGL YLWDVDFHUGRWDOHQHLTXDOLGRQ2UHVWH %HQ]LVLqVSHVRLQRJQLIDWWRGLHPDU JLQD]LRQH 6HWWLPR GL QRYH ÀJOL GRQ %HQ]L D DQQL q DQFRUD XQ·LQVWDQ FDELOH DQQXQFLDWRUH GL ©XQ LQFRQWUR VLPSDWLFRFRQ&ULVWRªO·RELHWWLYRFKH SHUVHJXLYD JLj GDJOL DQQL &LQTXDQWD GDQGRYLWDDGXQRULJLQDOHPRYLPHQ WR HGXFDWLYR SHU L SUHDGROHVFHQWL 0HQWUH QHO PRQGR VFRSSLD OD FRQWH DEULHOHORFRQREELQHOµ1RQIX XQFROSRGLIXOPLQHDQ]LDOO¶LQL ]LR QRQ F¶HUD QHPPHQR VLPSDWLD UHFLSURFD 0D FRPH GLFH LO SURYHUELR ³FKL GLVSUH]]D FRPSUD´ H JUD]LH DQFKH DOOH DWWLYLWj GL YRORQWDULDWR IDWWH LQVLHPH ¿QLPPRFRQO¶LQQDPRUDUFL/XLHUDWXWWRLO PLRPRQGRLRLOFHQWURGHOVXR$YHYD DQQLSLGLPHHPLKDLQVHJQDWRDGHVVH UHXQDSHUVRQDPLJOLRUH'HYRDOXLVHKR LPSDUDWRDHVVHUHSLULÀHVVLYDSLDWWHQ WD DJOL DVSHWWL QHJDWLYL GHO PLR FDUDWWHUH PD VRSUDWWXWWR GHYR D OXL O¶DYHU ULPHVVR LQGLVFXVVLRQHOHPLHLGHHVXOODUHOLJLRQH 1RQHURQpDWHDQpFUHGHQWH/XLQRQPL LPSRVHLOVXRSXQWRGLYLVWDPDPLFKLHVH LOSHUFKp*OLVSLHJDLFKHD DQQLDYHYR GHFLVR GL QRQ IDUH OD FRPXQLRQH 'XH L PRWLYL OD PDODWWLD FKH FROSu PLR QRQQR IDFHQGRPLVRUJHUHXQGXEELR³VHqYHUD PHQWHFRVDEXRQDHJLXVWDFRPHSXzSHU PHWWHUH WXWWR FLz"´ OD VHQVD]LRQH FKH JOL DOWULEDPELQLIDFHVVHURODFRPXQLRQHVROR SHULUHJDOL&KHVHQVRDYHYD"1RLRQRQ YROHYRIDUOD*DEULHOHPLDVFROWzVDSHYD TXDQWREHQHYROHYRDPLRQRQQRDQFRUD YLYRDQFRUDPDODWRHPLUDFFRQWzLQYHFH ODVXDHVSHULHQ]D1RQLQVLVWHWWHPDL &RQ OD VXD FDOPD FRQ OD VXD SD]LHQ]D q ULXVFLWR D IDUPL FDSLUH D IDUPL YHGHUH OH FRVH VRWWR XQ¶DOWUD OXFH /¶XQLFD FHOHEUD ]LRQHFXLSDUWHFLSDPPRDVVLHPHIXLOIX QHUDOHGLPLRQRQQRQHOIHEEUDLRGHOµ ,O WHPSR YROz H GHFLGHPPR FKH GRSR OH YDFDQ]H VDUHPPR DQGDWL D SDUODUH FRQ LO ³GRQ´ GHOOD PLD GHFLVLRQH GL IDUH FRPX QLRQH H FUHVLPD H GHO QRVWUR IXWXUR 3XU WURSSRFLDQGDLVROD*DEULHOHqPRUWRLO DJRVWRGHO,OPDWWLQRGHOODJRVWROD VRUHOODPLLQIRUPzFKH*DEULHOHHUDLQULD QLPD]LRQH5HVWDLFROWHOHIRQRLQPDQRLQ FDSDFHGLUHDJLUH)XO¶LQL]LRGLXQLQFXER JLRUQLSHUVSHUDUHHSUHJDUHLO6LJQRUH GLFXLOXLPLDYHYDSDUODWR 'HO IXQHUDOH ULFRUGR SRFR OD FDPHUD DU GHQWHODOHWWqUDFKHPLRIUDWHOOROHVVHLQ FKLHVDODEDUDFKHYHQLYDGHSRVWDOHPLH ODFULPH $YUHL SRWXWR WRUQDUH VXL PLHL SDVVL DU UDEELDUPL GL QXRYR FRQ 'LR GRSRWXWWR LO PLR$PRUHQRQF¶HUDSLLQRVWULSURJHWWL VIXPDWL0DQRQO¶KRIDWWROHSDUROHFKH *DEULHOH PL DYHYD GHWWR HUDQR PDWXUDWH GHQWUR GL PH &RVu DQGDL GDO ³GRQ´ 1HO GXEELRFKHORIDFHVVLVRORSHUHVDXGLUHXQ GHVLGHULRGL*DEULHOHPLSURSRVHXQFDP PLQR GL IHGH $FFRQVHQWLL FKLHGHQGRJOL GL IDUOR FRQ XQD FRSSLD FKH DYHYR FRQR VFLXWR DOOH VXSHULRUL 6WHIDQR H 3DWUL]LD 0LDYHYDQRDFFROWDQHOJUXSSRFKHVHJXL YDQRQHOODORURSDUURFFKLDGLFHQGRFKHOD GLYHUJHQ]D GL LGHH VSHVVR SURGXFH IUXWWL PLJOLRUL(LOSULPRIUXWWRFKHSURGXVVHIX ODQRVWUDDPLFL]LD&RVuLQL]LzLOPLRSHU FRUVRGLIHGH6WHIDQRH3DWUL]LDSXUDYHQ GR GXH ELPEH PL DFFROVHUR D FDVD ORUR &LWURYDYDPRRJQLOXQHGuHOHQWDPHQWHPL IHFHUR VFRSULUH OD IHGH PL DYYLFLQDURQR DOOH6FULWWXUHIDFHQGRPHOHOHJJHUHHFRP PHQWDQGROH SRL LQVLHPH VSLHJDQGRPL OH FRVHSLRYYLHFKHSHUPHHUDQRXQDVFR SHUWD0LKDQQRVRUUHWWDQHLJLRUQLSLEXL KDQQR VDSXWR DVFROWDUPL PD VRSUDWWXWWR PLKDQQRWUDVPHVVRWXWWRLOORURFDORUH,O DSULOHGHOHPR]LRQDWDFRPHXQD EDPELQD DFFDQWR DOOH SHUVRQH D PH SL FDUHKRULFHYXWRSHUODSULPDYROWDLO&RU SR GL &ULVWR *UD]LH D *DEULHOH PL VRQR ULDYYLFLQDWD DOOD IHGH JUD]LH D 6WHIDQR H 3DWUL]LDKRFRQRVFLXWRODIHGH6HULSHQVR DFRP¶HURODQQLIDPDLPLVDUHLDVSHW WDWD GL YHGHUPL GRYH VRQR RUD FUHGHQWH SUDWLFDQWHHFDWHFKLVWD/HYLHGHO6LJQRUH VRQRYHUDPHQWHLQ¿QLWH$QRLQRQqGDWR VDSHUOH PD PL SLDFH SHQVDUH FKH *DEUL IRVVHLO6XRPH]]RSHUULSRUWDUPLD/XL ÊODWHVWLPRQLDQ]DGLIHGHLQWHQVDHVRI IHUWD PD VRSUDWWXWWR PROWR VHUHQD FKH DUULYDGD0DLODGHOODSDUURFFKLDGL0LUD 7DJOLR 81,1&21752&+(&$0%,$/$9,7$ 9 DGR GDO EDUELHUH RJQL WDQWR VSLQWR VRSUDWWXWWR GDOOH YRFL IHPPLQLOL GHOOD IDPLJOLROD FKH LQVLVWHSHUDYHUHXQSDSjSUHVHQWDEL OH H FRVu WUD XQD VIRUELFLDWD HG XQD FKLDFFKLHUD KR O·RSSRUWXQLWj GL VIR JOLDUH FHUWL JLRUQDOL G· DWWXDOLWj FKH VHPEUDQRQFRPSHULQHVVXQRPDFKH GLFHUWRYHQJRQRYHQGXWLYLVWRFKHOL WURYLGDSSHUWXWWR(·LQXQDGLTXHVWH IRQWLGLVDSLHQ]DFKHKROHWWRXQDIUD VHFKHPLKDIDWWRSHQVDUHGHWWDGD )ODYLR %ULDWRUH QRWLVVLPR SHUVRQDJ JLR GHOOH FRUVH DXWRPRELOLVWLFKH FKH RFFXSD VSHVVR OH SDJLQH GHL JLRUQDOL GL FXL VRSUD ´/·LQFRQWUR FRQ %HQHW WRQKDFDPELDWRODPLDYLWDµ$QFK·LR KRDYXWRXQLQFRQWURLPSRUWDQWHQHO ODPLDYLWDHQRQFRQXQSHUVRQDJJLR FRVu QRWR PD FRQ XQ EDPELQR GL DQQL FKH VL FKLDPDYD $QGUHD H QRQ O·KR SL GLPHQWLFDWR $OORUD DYHYR WDOPHQWH VHGLFL DQQL FKH FUHGHYR IRVVHURWUHQWDGXHHWUDXQJXDLRHG XQDOWURWURYDLLOWHPSRGLDFFHWWDUH O·LQYLWRGLXQDPLFRGLDQGDUHLQSHOOH JULQDJJLRD/RUHWRDIDUHLOEDUHOOLHUH 3HQVDYRDGXQDVFDPSDJQDWD$SDUWH OHFURFHURVVLQHQRQDYHYRODSLSDO OLGD LGHD GL FKL DYUHL LQFRQWUDWR QHO YLDJJLRHEHQSRFRGLTXHOORFKHDYUHL GRYXWR IDUH )DWWR XQ YLDJJLR TXDVL VSHQVLHUDWRHDUULYDWLDOODVWD]LRQHGL /RUHWR V·DYYLFLQz XQR GHL EDUHOOLHUL SLDQ]LDQLFKHGDWHFLOHEUHWHOOHGD EDUHOOLHULFLGLVVHDQGDWHDOODFDUUR] ]D RVSHGDOH D GDUH XQD PDQR 1HOOD FRQIXVLRQH SHUVL VXELWR O·DPLFR H PL GLUHVVLYHUVRTXHOYDJRQHFRVuGLYHUVR GDJOLDOWULFRQXQDJUDQGHFURFHURV VDGLSLQWDHGDFXLYHQLYDQRVFDULFDWH OH EDUHOOH GHJOL DPPDODWL SL JUDYL &·HUDGDWUDVSRUWDUOLDLYDULFDPLRQFL QLDWWUH]]DWLFKHOLDYUHEEHURSRUWDWL 35(*+,(5(VHPLGL63(5$1=$ $,87$&,$3(56(*8,5( /$3$&( 6LJQRUH GRQDFLODWXDSDFH 'RQDFLODGHOLFDWH]]DGLXQFXRUHVHQVLELOH LOFRUDJJLRSHUO¶DPRUH ODQRVWDOJLDGLXQDEEUDFFLR OHODEEUDSHUODWHQHUH]]D XQDSDURODVHQ]DDVSUH]]D WXQRQGDLODSDFH FRPHODLQWHQGHLOPRQGR RFFKLRSHURFFKLRGHQWHSHUGHQWH QHOO¶HTXLOLEULRGHOWHUURUH QHOQXPHURGHLPLVVLOL QHOOHLPSRVL]LRQLGHJOLVWUDWHJKL 6LJQRUHLOQRVWURFXRUH VLDOLEHURGDOODSDXUD SHUFLzGRQDFLLOFRUDJJLR SHUODGLVXEELGLHQ]D GRQDFLODIRU]D SHUGLUH³QR´ GRQDFLLOGLVFHUQLPHQWR SHULQVHJXLUHODSDFH VXOOHVWUDGHHVXOOHSLD]]H FRQWXWWLTXHOOL FKHFRQGLYLGRQRTXHVWLVHQWLPHQWL $PHQ 8ZH6HLGHO VXO FROOH GHO 6DQWXDULR SHU OD VLVWH PD]LRQHQHJOLDOORJJL6HO·DWPRVIHUD GHO YLDJJLR HUD VWDWD OLHWD H VHUHQD TXL OD VLWXD]LRQH DSSDULYD GLYHUVD H O·LPSUHVVLRQHHUDFKHQHVVXQRDYHVVH YRJOLD GL SHUGHUVL LQ FKLDFFKLHUH 8Q EDUHOOLHUHPLFKLDPzHVHGDUDJD]]R ,2)%862/,1VQF GL%XVROLQ(& $*(1=,$2125$1=()81(%5, &$53(1('29(9LD6'RQjD DQJRORYLD9DOORQ 7HOID[ 3DUWLWD,9$ LRIEXVROLQ#YLUJLOLRLW DQGDYR ÀHUR GHO PLR DVSHWWR VYHJOLR H DOOHJUR FUHGR FKH LQ TXHO PRPHQ WRHLQTXHOO·DPELHQWHQRQULXVFLVVLD GDUH OD VWHVVD LPSUHVVLRQH ´3UREOH PL"µ ´1Rµ PHQWLL ´$OORUD YLHQL FRQ PHFKHDQGLDPRDSUHQGHUH$QGUHDµ 6DOLPPRVXOODFDUUR]]DHWUDODJHQWH FKHDQGDYDHYHQLYDFLDYYLFLQDPPR DGXQDVLJQRUDLQSLHGLYLFLQRDGXQD EDUHOODSRVWDDPHGLDDOWH]]D0LGDYD TXDVLOHVSDOOHPDYHGHYRLOVXRYLVR PHQWUH VWDYD SDUODQGR DOOD SHUVRQD GLVWHVD QHO OHWWLQR *OL RFFKL OH VRU ULGHYDQR H V·DLXWDYD QHO UDFFRQWDUH FRQSLFFROLJHVWLGHOOHPDQLFRPHSHU GDUH YLWD DL SHUVRQDJJL H DOOH ÀJXUH FKHDYHYDLQPHQWH&LIHUPDPPRXQ SR·GLVFRVWLSHUODVFLDUODÀQLUH ´$QGUHD q DPPDODWR GL LGURFHIDOuDµ GLVVHODPLDJXLGDHGLRIUHVFRGHOVH FRQGRDQQRGLOLFHRUHDOL]]DLPHQWDO PHQWHFKH´LGURVµYROHYDGLUHDFTXD H ´NHIjOLµ YROHYD GLUH WHVWD 0HQWUH QRQULXVFLYRDPHWWHUHLQVLHPHLOVHQ VRGHOOHGXHFRVHODVLJQRUDVLVSRVWz HULXVFLLFRVuDYHGHUHLOEDPELQRGL VWHVR )X FRPH VH PL PXRYHVVHUR LO WHUUHQRGLVRWWRHPLPDQFzLOÀDWR 6LFXUH]]H FHUWH]]H VSDYDOGHULH VL SROYHUL]]DURQRLQXQDWWLPRHODPDQR GHOOD PLD JXLGD FKH P·DVSHWWDYD DO YDUFRPLVWULQVHIRUWHLOEUDFFLRHPL GLVVH ´'jL FKH DGHVVR WRFFD D QRLµ 0L REEOLJDL D PXRYHUPL VSRVWDPPR OD EDUHOOD LQÀODL OH EUHWHOOH QHL PD QLFL H FL LQFDPPLQDPPR LR GLHWUR SHU XVFLUH ,O EDPELQR HUD GDOOD PLD SDUWH HG LR LPSHJQDWLVVLPR D FHU FDUH GL QRQ LQFLDPSDUH VHQWLYR IRU WHLOVXRVJXDUGRVXGLPHWDQWRFKH GRYHWWL JLUDUPL HG LQFURFLDUOR$YHYD GXHRFFKLOLPSLGLLGHQWLFLDTXHOOLGL VXDPDGUHTXDVLSHUVLQHOODVSURSRU ]LRQHGLTXHOFDSRULVSHWWRDOFRUSRH VRUULGHYDQRTXHJOLRFFKLVRUULGHYDQR DPH´&LDR$QGUHDµEDOEHWWDL HVXD PDGUH YLFLQLVVLPD ULVSRVH ´+DL YL VWR$QGUHDFKHKDLXQQXRYRDPLFR"µ 1HLSRFKLJLRUQLFKHUHVWDPPROIHFL VSHVVRTXHOSLFFRORVHUYL]LRHSRUWDUH LQ JLUR LO PLR DPLFR$QGUHD H OXL PL ULQJUD]LDYD FRQ L VXH RFFKLRQL VRUUL GHQWL 8Q LQFRQWUR FKH PL q UHVWDWR GHQWURHVHWLVHPEUDODFRVDSLQD WXUDOH GHO PRQGR YHGHUH FRUUHUH LQ JLDUGLQR PLHL ÀJOL SHQVR FRQ TXDQWD QDWXUDOH]]DTXHOODPDGUHUDFFRQWDYD DOVXR$QGUHDTXDQWRIRVVHEHOORTXHO PRQGRGLIXRULFKHOXLSRWHYDVRORLP PDJLQDUH *LXVWR&DYLQDWR ,',(&,&20$1'$0(17, 1RQDYUDLDOWUR'LRDOO¨LQIXRULGLPH 3 HUXQDUHOLJLRQHPRQRWHLVWLFDTXDOH qODUHOLJLRQHFDWWROLFDLOSULPRFR PDQGDPHQWRFRVuFRPHqHVSUHVVR SRWUHEEH VHPEUDUH SDUDGRVVDOH FRPH q SRVVLELOHLQIDWWLGDOPRPHQWRFKHQRLUL FRQRVFLDPRXQVROR'LRFRQFHSLUQHGHJOL DOWUL",FULVWLDQLDGLIIHUHQ]DGHLSDJDQLL TXDOL VRVWHQJRQR O¶HVLVWHQ]D GL SDUHFFKLH GLYLQLWjFRPHEHQFLULFRUGDODVWRULDGH JOLDQWLFKLJUHFLHURPDQLUL¿XWDQRRJQL DOWUD GLYLQLWj SHU ULFRQRVFHUH LQYHFH XQ VRORXQLFR'LR 'L TXHVWR TXDQWRPHQR VLDPR WXWWL FRQ YLQWL PD 'LR LO 6LJQRUH VD EHQH LQYHFH FKHO¶XRPRGLTXDOVLDVLHSRFDqFDSDFHGL DYHUHHGLLQYHQWDUVLDOWULGHLDVXRXVRH FRQVXPR(LQTXHVWRPRGRLQIDWWL(JOLVL HVSULPHQHOSULPRGHLGLHFLFRPDQGDPHQ WL3HUFDSLUHEHQHTXHVWRSUHFHWWRGREELD PRFRPLQFLDUHFROFKLHGHUFLLQQDQ]LWXWWR FKLq'LR"&KHFRVDLQWHQGLDPRFRQODSD UROD³'LR´HVXFFHVVLYDPHQWHSRWUHPRFD SLUHFRPHVLDSRVVLELOHFKHO¶XRPRVLFUHL GHJOLDOWULGHL6HFRQGRLOYRFDERODULR'LR qO¶(VVHUHVXSUHPRFRQFHSLWRFRPHFUHD WRUHRUGLQDWRUHHFRQVHUYDWRUHGLWXWWDOD UHDOWj'REELDPRTXLQGLLPPHGLDWDPHQWH VIDWDUHRJQLDOWUDLGHDRUDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH DQWURSRPRU¿FDFKHSRVVLDPRHVVHUFLFUHD WLVXGL/XL'LRQRQqXQYHFFKLRVDJJLR VHGXWRIUDOHQXYROH'LRGLIDWWRQRQOR SRVVLDPRFRQRVFHUHPDDWWUDYHUVROH6D FUH 6FULWWXUH SRVVLDPR DSSUHQGHUH PRO WL GHL VXRL DWWULEXWL 'LR VD WXWWR 0DWWHR 'LR q VHPSUH SUHVHQWH 0DWWHR 'LRqRQQLSRWHQWH0DWWHR 'LR q VDQWR $SRFDOLVVH 'LR DPD 3LHWUR'LRqJLXVWR3LHWUR 'LRqSHUVRQDOH$WWL'LRqDPR UH*LRYDQQL$PHSLDFHSHQVDUOR FRVu RQQLSUHVHQWH H FKH SHQHWUD WXWWH OH FRVHFRPHO¶DULDFKHUHVSLULDPRLOOLPLWDWR QHOOHVXHSRVVLELOLWjHQHOVXRDJLUHFRPH QHVVXQ DOWUR HVVHUH VXOOD WHUUD VRPPR EHQHFKHQRQFRQFHSLVFHLOPDOHXQJUDQ GHSHQVLHURGL$PRUHFKHWXWWRDEEUDFFLDH WXWWR DYYROJH XQ¶HQHUJLD LQWHOOLJHQWH FKH WXWWR FRQRVFH XQD OHJJH GL JLXVWL]LD FKH FUHD H PDQWLHQH O¶HTXLOLEULR QHO PRQGR $QFKH 6$JRVWLQR LQ XQD GHOOH VXH SL IDPRVH RSHUH OR KD GHVFULWWR /HJJLDPR LQIDWWLQH³/HFRQIHVVLRQL´³&RVDVHLGXQ TXHRPLR'LR"&RVDVHLFKLHGRVHQRQ LO6LJQRUH,GGLR",QIDWWLFKLqLO6LJQRUHVH QRQ LO 6LJQRUH" &KL q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¶RSHUD PD QRQ PXWL LGHD 5LFHYL TXHO FKH WURYL PD QRQORKDLPDLSHUGXWRQRQVHLSRYHURPD WLUDOOHJULGHOJXDGDJQRQRQVHLDYDURPD HVLJLJOLLQWHUHVVL7LVLGjPROWRSHUIDUWL GLYHQWDUHGHELWRUHPDFKLSRVVLHGHTXDO FRVD FKH QRQ DSSDUWHQJD D WH" 1RQ GHYL QXOODDQHVVXQRHSDJKLLGHELWLULPHWWLL GHELWL H QRQ SHUGL QXOOD´ 3HU O¶XRPR GL IHGHFKHFUHGHQHOO¶HVLVWHQ]DGLXQ(VVHUH VXSHULRUHDFXLWXWWRVLULFRQGXFHGLYHQWD GXQTXHOHFLWRQRQWDQWRFKLHGHUVLVHDYHUH XQ'LRPDSLXWWRVWRFKLVLDLOQRVWUR'LR 5LFRUGRFKHXQPLRYHFFKLRSURIHVVRUHGL UHOLJLRQHDOOLFHRLQVHJQDYDFKH'LRqSHU QRL FLz FKH FRVWLWXLVFH LO VHQVR OR VFRSR ¿QDOH GHOOD QRVWUD HVLVWHQ]D 6XOOD EDVH GL XQD HUURQHD LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH GL TXHVWD DIIHUPD]LRQH PROWH FRVH TXLQGL SRVVRQR ULVFKLDUHGLGLYHQWDUH³LOQRVWURGLR´LOGH QDURLOSRWHUHLOODYRURHVHUFLWDWRDOO¶HF FHVVRODVXSHUVWL]LRQHLSLDFHULPDWHULDOL LQJHQHUHLOSHUVHJXLUHTXHVWLRELHWWLYLFL DOORQWDQDGDOYHUR'LRSRQHQGRO¶XRPRLQ VWDWR GL GLSHQGHQ]D H VXGGLWDQ]D GD HVVL LQYHFHFKHLQSRVL]LRQHGLGRPLQLRHFRQ WUROOR ,O FRQIURQWR FRQ JOL LGROL SHUFKp WDOL HVVL VRQR VH DWWUDYHUVD WXWWD OD VWRULD GL ,VUDHOH FRPH OHJJLDPR QHOOD %LEELD DWWUDYHUVD DQFKH OD QRVWUD VWRULD JOL LGR OL VRQR HVDJHUD]LRQL H DVVROXWL]]D]LRQL GL TXHOOR FKH q LPSRUWDQWH SHU JOL XRPLQL $ VHFRQGD GHOOH VLWXD]LRQL GHOOH HSRFKH HVVL SRVVRQR HVVHUH DVVDL GLYHUVL PD LQ IRQGR WXWWH OH LGRODWULH VL FRQFHQWUDQR VX WUHRJJHWWLLOSRWHUHLOSRVVHVVRLOSLDFHUH 'RYH VL DGRUDQR IDOVL GHL VL JLXQJHUj DG HVDOWDUHVRORFLzFKHqPRQGDQRHSDVVHJ JHURSHUGHQGRGLYLVWDORVSLULWRHGLFRQ VHJXHQ]D OD QRVWUD VDOYH]]D $OORUD FKL GREELDPRDGRUDUH"/DULVSRVWDqXQLYRFD O¶$PRUHLQWXWWHOHVXHIRUPHFRPHHVVR VFDWXULVFHGDOQRVWURFXRUHTXDQGRFRQL QRVWULHUURULQRQJOLLPSHGLDPRGLPDQL IHVWDUVL2SSRUWXQDPHQWHDTXHVWRSXQWR PLSLDFHFLWDUHXQHSLVRGLRGH,3URPHV VLVSRVLFDS;;,,,GRYHO¶,QQRPLQDWR WURYDQGRVL GL IURQWH DO FDUGLQDO )HGHULJR %RUURPHR LQYRFD 'LR SHU EHQ WUH YROWH GHVLGHUDQGRYHGHUORVHQWLUOR«´'LR'LR 'LR6HORYHGHVVL6HORVHQWLVVL'RY¶q TXHVWR'LR"´ ( LO &DUGLQDOH %RUURPHR ULVSRQGH ³9RL PH OR GRPDQGDWH" 9RL" H FKL SL GL YRL O¶KDYLFLQR"1RQYHORVHQWLWHLQFXRUHFKH Y¶RSSULPHFKHY¶DJLWDFKHQRQYLODVFLD VWDUHHQHOORVWHVVRWHPSRDWWLUDYLIDSUH &DPELRGLVWDJLRQH &ROFDPELRGL VWDJLRQHqEHQH YHULILFDUHLOJXDUGDURED HSRUWDUHDL PDJD]]LQL60DUWLQR YGHLFDPSL &HQWURGRQ9HFFKL FLzFKHQRQVLXVDSL VHQWH XQD VSHUDQ]D GL TXLHWH GL FRQVROD ]LRQHG¶XQDFRQVROD]LRQHFKHVDUjSLHQD LPPHQVD VXELWR FKH YRL OR ULFRQRVFLDWH OR FRQIHVVLDWH OR LPSORULDWH"´ /D ULFHUFD GXQTXHYDIDWWDQHOSURSULRFXRUHQHOO¶LQ WLPR GHOO¶XRPR %DVWHUj DOORUD XQ VXRQR GL FDPSDQH SHU ULVYHJOLDUH LQ QRL LO VHQ VR GHO GLYLQR H JXLGDWL GD TXHVWR VHQVR LQL]LDUH OD ULFHUFD GL 'LR FKH VL ULYHOHUj $OORUDDQFKHQRLFRPHO¶,QQRPLQDWRSR WUHPRHVFODPDUH³'LRYHUDPHQWHJUDQGH 'LRYHUDPHQWHEXRQR´(VDWWDPHQWHFRPH OR GH¿Qu O¶DSRVWROR *LRYDQQL TXDVL GXH PLODDQQLID³'LRqDPRUHHFKLULPDQH QHOO¶DPRUHULPDQHLQ'LRH'LRLQOXL´ $GULDQD&HUFDWR ,17(59,67$6(77,0$1$/($' 813(5621$**,2'(/9$1*(/2 (/,6$%(77$ 1 RQ VR YRL PD D PH TXHVWR$QWL QRULQRQSLDFHXQPHGLFRFKHGD DQQL VRGGLVID LO GHVLGHULR GL PD WHUQLWjGLGRQQHDQ]LDQHXOWUDVHVVDQWHQQL FKH RUPDL DYUHEEHUR SHUVR OD VSHUDQ]D GLDYHUHXQORUREDPELQR1RQPLSLDFH FRPHQRQPLSLDFFLRQRWXWWLJOLDOWULVLVWH PLSHUSURFUHDUHFKHQRQFLWRPDFKHWXWWL EHQFRQRVFRQRHFKHYDQQRROWUHLOQRVWUR XPDQRHFULVWLDQRFRQFHWWRGLDPRUHHGL PRUDOH0DSHUFKpPLFKLHGRIRU]DUHOD QDWXUD H QRQ DFFHWWDUH FRQ VHUHQLWj TXHO OR FKH OD VRUWH KD ULVHUYDWR D FLDVFXQR GL QRL"(SHUFKpTXDQGRQHOPRQGRFLVRQR JLjPLJOLDLDGLEDPELQLFKHDYUHEEHUREL VRJQR GL XQD PDPPD " 0D TXHOOR GHOOH DGR]LRQL q XQ GLVFRUVR WURSSR OXQJR GD DSSURIRQGLUH &RPXQTXH PL VRIIHUPR D JXDUGDUH OH IRWR GL TXHVWH PDPPHQRQ QH GDO YLVR VFLXSDWR PHQWUH FRFFRODQR H EDFLDQRWHQHUDPHQWHOHORURFUHDWXULQHDS SHQDQDWHJOLRFFKLDQ]LDQLLOOXPLQDWLGD XQDJLRLDLPPHQVDLOFXRUHDSHUWRDOORUR IXWXUR OH EUDFFLD GLVSRQLELOL DOOH IDWLFKH FKHTXHVWDWDUGDPDWHUQLWjSRWUjSRUWDUH QRQVRFRVDSHQVDUH0LYHUJRJQRDGLUOR VR FKH LO SDUDJRQH QRQ FDO]D PD LVWLQWL YDPHQWH PL YLHQH GD SHQVDUH DG XQ¶DOWUD FUHDWXUDGLYHQXWD PDPPD IHOLFH LQ WDUGD HWj QRQ SHU PHULWR GL $QWLQRUL PD SHU YRORQWj GL 'LR $ELWD DG $P.DULP XQD ERUJDWD GHOOD *LXGHD .P D HVW GL *H UXVDOHPPH4XDVLTXDVLFLYDGRDSDUODUH WDQWRSDJDODUHGD]LRQH$UULYRDOO¶RUDGL SUDQ]RVWDQFDHVXGDWD'DORQWDQRVFRUJR LOSDHVHDSSROODLDWRVXO¿DQFRGLXQPRQWH EUXOOR O¶HVWDWH KD EUXFLDWR OD SRFD YHJH WD]LRQH 5LHVFR D IDUH TXDOFKH IRWRJUD¿D GHO SRVWR FDVL DQWLFR H FDUDWWHULVWLFR GHO YLRWWRORGHLUDGLXOLYLFRQWRUWLLQYHFHQRQ SRVVR FDWWXUDUH TXHVWR SURIXPLQR FHOHVWL D,HGLDUURVWRFKHTXDOFXQRVWDSUHSDUDQ GR &KLHGR GHOOD FDVD GL =DFFDULD PH OD LQGLFDQRHQRQqFRPHTXHOOHLOOXVWUDWHGDL SLWWRUL GHO µ 6XOOD VRJOLD F¶q OHL (OL VDEHWWD1RQqSRLFDVLDQ]LDQDRGDYYH UR OD PDWHUQLWj O µKD ULQJLRYDQLWD" +D LQ EUDFFLR LO VXR ELPEHWWR VFXUR H SLHQR GL FDSHOOL RUPDL GRYUHEEH DYHUH GXH R WUH PHVL&KLHGRVFXVDSHUO¶RUDOHLDFFHQQD XQOLHYHLQFKLQRFROFDSRHGLFHTXDOFRVD FKHQRQFDSLVFRPDGDOVRUULVRHGDOJH VWRGHOODPDQRFKHLQYLWDDGHQWUDUHFUH GRGLLQGRYLQDUHFKHPLGLDLOEHQYHQXWR SHUORURO¶RVSLWHqVDFUR3RVDLOEDPELQR DGGRUPHQWDWRQHOODFXOODHPHWWHLQWDYROD WUHFRSHUWL6RORDGHVVRYHGRLQFRQWUROX FHHQWUDUHLOYHFFKLR=DFFDULDOXLVLFKH GLPRVWUDWXWWLLVXRLDQQLFROVXREDUERQH JULJLRHLQPDQRXQYDVVRLRFRQO¶DJQHOOR IXPDQWHHUDOXLFKHFXRFHYDDOORVSLHGR" ,OSUDQ]RqIUXJDOH&RQODFDUQHXQ¶LQ VDODWDGLHUEHDPDUHPLGLFRQRDULFRUGR GHOO¶DPDUD VFKLDYLW H XQ SDQH D]]LPR SHU UDPPHQWDUH OD IXJD IUHWWRORVD GDO O¶(JLWWRFKHQRQGLHGHLOWHPSRGLOLHYLWDU ORHDQFRUDYLQR¿FKLHFDQQHOOD³&KHEHO EDPELQRFRPHVLFKLDPD"´¿QJRGLQRQ VDSHUH³*LRYDQQLYXROGLUH'LRIDJUD]LH (¶ OD JUD]LD FKH 'LR KD IDWWR SHU SULPL D QRL GXH SRYHUL YHFFKL´ GLFH RUJRJOLRVR =DFFDULDDOOXQJDQGROHOXQJKHGLWDVFDUQH DFDUH]]DUHODVXDWHVWROLQDQHUD³6LHWHIH OLFL YHUR ³ ³2K VL PROWR IHOLFL HVFODPD (OLVDEHWWD QRQ VSHUDYDPR SL GL DYHUH XQ EDPELQR OR DYHYDPR GHVLGHUDWR WXWWD OD YLWD TXDVL FL YHUJRJQDYDPR GDYDQWL DJOLXRPLQLFRPHIRVVHXQDQRVWUDFROSD PD FL HUDYDPR UDVVHJQDWL DOOD YRORQWj GL 'LR´³$OORUDVLqWUDWWDWRGLXQPLUDFROR ³³/XLDO]DJOLRFFKLDOFLHORDYHYDXQ DOWUR GLVHJQR 1RVWUR ¿JOLR q GHVWLQDWR D XQDJUDQGHPLVVLRQHSHUTXHVWRODQRVWUD JLRLDqDQFRUDSLJUDQGH´³&KHFRVDYXRL GLUH ³ ³9HGL XQ DQJHOR OR KD SUHGHWWR D =DFFDULDHUDO¶DUFDQJHOR*DEULHOH*OLDS SDUYHQHOVDQWXDULRGXUDQWHLOVXRWXUQRDO WHPSLR4XHVWRQRVWUR¿JOLRVDUjXQXRPR SLRHJLXVWRHVDUjGHVWLQDWRDSUHSDUDUHOD YHQXWDGHO&ULVWRULFRQGXFHQGRLOSRSROR G¶,VUDHOH DOOH OHJJL GHO 6LJQRUH =DFFDULD QRQFLYROHYDFUHGHUHFKLHGHYDXQDSUR YDHSHUFLzLO6LJQRUHJOLGLHGHXQVHJQR TXDVLXQDSXQL]LRQHSHUODVXDLQFUHGXOLWj JOL KD WROWR OD SDUROD ¿QR DO JLRUQR GHOOD QDVFLWDGHOEDPELQR´1RQULHVFRDFRQWH QHUHODPLDXPDQDFXULRVLWj³(OXLDOORUD FRPHKDIDWWRDUDFFRQWDUWLTXHOORFKHJOL HUDVXFFHVVR³(OLVDEHWWDULGHQHOULFRUGR ,QTXHLPHVLOXLSHUIDUVLFDSLUHVFULYHYD VXXQDWDYROHWWDFRVuFLFDSLYDPRVFULVVH DQFKH LO QRPH VFHOWR GD 'LR SHU LO EDP ELQR*LRYDQQL´³(OLVDEHWWDLPPDJLQROD WXDJLRLDPDLRVRFKHDTXHVWDJLRLDVHQH qDJJLXQWDXQ¶DOWUD´³2KVLWXYXRLGLUH ODYLVLWDGL0DULDORKDLVDSXWR³³,QIDWWL PHQHYXRLSDUODUH³³4XHOODUDJD]]DqFDVL PRGHVWDHGHYRWDXQ¿RUHUDURSHUTXHVWR LO6LJQRUHO¶KDSUHVFHOWDqFRVLJLRYDQH HSSXUHWDQWRPDWXUD$ELWDD1D]DUHW$Q FKH D OHL q DSSDUVR W¶DUFDQJHOR *DEULHOH YHGRFKHVDLJLjSHUFKp(OHLQRQqVWDWD VFHWWLFDFRPH=DFFDULDVRUULGHVLqUL PHVVDVXELWRDOODYRORQWjGL'LR4XDQGR KDVDSXWRFKHHURLQFLQWDqSDUWLWDVXELWR SHUYHQLUHDGDLXWDUPLHGqULPDVWDFRQQRL WUHPHVL´³+DLGHWWRFKHqWDQWRJLRYDQH 1D]DUHWqORQWDQDFKLO¶KDDFFRPSDJQDWD ¿QTXDDWWUDYHUVRODPRQWDJQD"´³1HVVX QRqYHQXWDGDVRODVLqXQLWDDGXQDFDUR YDQDGLSHOOHJULQL0HODVRQRYLVWDFRP SDULUH ,O VXO VHQWLHUR GD GRYH VHL DUULYDWD WXHVRQRULPDVWDFRPHIROJRUDWD(¶VWDWR FRPH VH LQ OHL VSOHQGHVVH OD OXFH LO PLR EDPELQRTXLO¶KRVHQWLWRVDOWDUHGLJLRLD KRFDSLWR(PLVRQRJHWWDWDDLVXRLSLH GLLRYHFFKLDDGDEEUDFFLDUHOHLJLRYDQH ODPDGUHGHOQRVWUR6DOYDWRUH´ /DXUD1RYHOOR /·8202,17(5,25( / D&KLHVDFLLQVHJQDFKHRJQLXRPRq ´XQLWjGLDQLPDHFRUSRµHGqIDWWR ´DGLPPDJLQHHVRPLJOLDQ]DGL'LRµ 1HOOD%LEELDLQIDWWLDSSUHQGLDPRFKHO·XR PRFUHDWRDLPPDJLQHGL'LRqXQHVVHUH LQVLHPHFRUSRUDOHHVSLULWXDOHXQHVVHUH FLRqFKHSHUXQDVSHWWRqOHJDWRDOPRQ GRHVWHULRUHHSHUO·DOWURORWUDVFHQGH3HU O·XRPR H· HVVHQ]LDOH TXLQGL VDSHUH FKH ROWUHDOVXRFRUSRPDWHULDOHHJOLSRVVLH GHDQFKHXQFRUSRVSLULWXDOHFKHULVXOWD LQYLVLELOHHQRQPDQLIHVWRDLQRVWULVHQVL 4XHVWDYHULWjVXOO·XRPRqSHUDOWURRJJHW WRGHOODQRVWUDVWHVVDIHGH $ SURSRVLWR GHO FRUSR PDWHULDOH H VSLUL WXDOHFRVLVLHVSUHVVH6DQ3DRORQHOODVXD SULPDOHWWHUDDL&RULQWL²´6L VHPLQD XQ FRUSR FRUUXWWLELOH H ULVRUJH LQFRUUXWWLELOHVLVHPLQDLJQRELOHHULVRU JH JORULRVR VL VHPLQD GHEROH H ULVRUJH SLHQRGLIRU]DVLVHPLQDXQFRUSRDQLPD OHULVRUJHXQFRUSRVSLULWXDOHµ(SRLFKp LO FRUSR PDWHULDOH GXUD VROR LO WHPSR GL XQDYLWDPHQWUHLOFRUSRVSLULWXDOHqSHU VHPSUHYDOHODSHQDGLDVFROWDUHDOFXQH ULÁHVVLRQLIDWWHGDFKLFLKDSUHFHGXWRQHO FDPPLQR GHOO·DVFHVL 1HOOD VXD ,PLWD]LR QHGL&ULVWR7RPPDVRGD.HPSHQVFULVVH ´/·XRPR LQWHULRUH SULPD GL RFFXSDUVL GL DOWUHFRVHJXDUGDGHQWURGLVpHLQWHQ WR GLOLJHQWHPHQWH D VH VWHVVR q SRUWDWR D WDFHUH GHJOL DOWUL 6RODPHQWH VH VWDUDL ]LWWR VXJOL DOWUL JXDUGDQGR VSHFLDOPHQWH DWHVWHVVRJLXQJHUDLDXQDYHUDHGHYRWD LQWHULRULWjµ $QFKH6$JRVWLQRSDUOHUjGHOODQHFHVVLWj GHOO·XRPRDYROJHUHORVJXDUGRHO·DWWHQ ]LRQHDOODSURSULDLQWHULRULWj ©7RUQD LQ WH VWHVVR QHOO·XRPR LQWHULRUH DELWDODYHULWjHVHWURYHUDLFKHODWXDQD WXUDqPXWDELOHWUDVFHQGLWHVWHVVRªSHU WURYDUH'LRIRQWHGHOODOXFHFKHLOOXPLQD ODPHQWH,QIDWWLLQVLHPHDOODYHULWjF·q QHOO·XRPRLQWHULRUHODPLVWHULRVDFDSDFL Wj G·DPDUH )RQGDPHQWDOH GXQTXH SHU ULFRVWUXLUH LO QRVWUR FRUSR VSLULWXDOH q DOORQWDQDUVL GDOOH SDVVLRQL SURYRFDWH GDO PRQGRHVWHUQRHJXDUGDUHGHQWURVHVWHV VL ODVFLDQGR SRVWR DOO· DPRUH ,Q TXHVWR VHQVRFLHVRUWDDQFRUD63DRORQHOODVXD OHWWHUD DJOL (IHVLQL ´6SRJOLDWHYL GHOYHFFKLRXRPRµ 'DQGR GXQTXH YLWD DOO·© XRPR LQWHULRUH ª O·XRPR SURFHGH QHOOD VDQWLÀFD]LRQH GL WXWWR O·HVVHUH FRVu FRQWLQXD 6 3DROR ©&RPHDYHWHPHVVROHYRVWUHPHPEUDD VHUYL]LRGHOO·LPSXULWjHGHOO·LQLTXLWjDSUR GHOO·LQLTXLWj FRVu RUD PHWWHWH OH YRVWUH PHPEUD D VHUYL]LR GHOOD JLXVWL]LD SHU OD YRVWUD VDQWLÀFD]LRQH >@ 2UD OLEHUDWL GDOSHFFDWRHIDWWLVHUYLGL'LRYRLUDFFR JOLHWHLOIUXWWRFKHYLSRUWDDOODVDQWLÀFD ]LRQHHFRPHGHVWLQRDYHWHODYLWDHWHUQD ª5P (·GXQTXHTXHVWDODYLDGHOODSHUIH]LRQH VSLULWXDOH QHOOD SURVSHWWLYD VHPSUH LQ WHQVDPHQWHPLUDWDGLUDJJLXQJHUHOD&LWWj FHOHVWHODQXRYD*HUXVDOHPPH6HJXHQGR TXHVWDYLDO·XRPRLQWHULRUHVDUjHOHYDWR D XRPR QXRYR HVVHQGR LQ &ULVWR QXRYD FUHD]LRQH&RUH*DO /·XRPR FDUQDOH WXWWDYLD VL DFFRUJHUj SUHVWRGHOODGLIÀFROWjFKHLQFRQWUHUjQHO VXRFDPPLQRGLSHUIH]LRQDPHQWRVHQRQ LQYRFKHUj O·DLXWR GLYLQR ,QIDWWL FRPH GLUj 6 3DROR 5P ,R QRQ ULH VFR D FDSLUH QHSSXUH FLz FKH IDFFLR LQ IDWWLQRQTXHOORFKHYRJOLRLRIDFFLRPD TXHOORFKHGHWHVWR,RVRLQIDWWLFKH LQPHFLRqQHOODPLDFDUQHQRQDELWDLO EHQHF·qLQPHLOGHVLGHULRGHOEHQHPD QRQODFDSDFLWjGLDWWXDUORLQIDWWLLRQRQ FRPSLRLOEHQHFKHYRJOLRPDLOPDOHFKH QRQ YRJOLR ,R WURYR GXQTXH LQ PH TXHVWDOHJJHTXDQGRYRJOLRIDUHLOEHQH LOPDOHqDFFDQWRDPH,QIDWWLDFFRQVHQWR DOODOHJJHGL'LRVHFRQGRO·XRPRLQWHULR UH PD QHOOH PLH PHPEUD YHGR XQ·DOWUD OHJJHFKHPXRYHJXHUUDDOODOHJJHGHOOD PLDPHQWHHPLUHQGHVFKLDYRGHOODOHJJH GHOSHFFDWRFKHqQHOOHPLHPHPEUD´ $QFKH6*LRYDQQL&ULVRVWRPRFLHVRUWDD ,QYHVWLLOWXRWHPSR VXOYRORQWDULDWR $LPDJD]]LQL 6 0DUWLQR H 6 *LXVHSSH GDQQRLOFHQWRSHUXQR 7HO JXDUGDUH DOOH FRVH GHOOR VSLULWR &RVu LQ IDWWLVFULVVH´1RQYHGLFKHJOLRFFKLGHO FRUSR TXDQGR SHUPDQJRQR QHO IXPR ODFULPDQR FRQWLQXDPHQWH TXDQGR LQ YHFH VRJJLRUQDQR QHOO·DULD WHUVD LQ XQ SUDWR GLYHQWDQR SL DFXWL H SL VDQL" ,GHQWLFDqODFRQGL]LRQHDQFKHGHOO·RFFKLR GHOO·DQLPDVHVLQXWUHQHOSUDWRGHOOHUL ÁHVVLRQLVSLULWXDOLVDUjSXUROLPSLGRHG DFXWRGLYLVWDVHLQYHFHVHQHYDQHOIXPR GHJOLLQWHUHVVLPRQGDQLODFULPHUjHSLDQ JHUj DO PDVVLPR JUDGR DGHVVR H DOORUD *OL LQWHUHVVL XPDQL VRQR LQIDWWL VLPLOL DO IXPRµ /D YHULWj GHOOD QRVWUD HVLVWHQ]D GXQTXHSXzHVVHUHULFRQRVFLXWDDWWUDYHU VR XQ RFFKLR LQWHULRUH XQ ´VHVWR VHQVRµ FKH 3DVFDO GHQRPLQDYD ´HVSULW GH ÀQHV VHµ VSLULWR GL ÀQH]]D 7DOH RFFKLR YLHQH GHÀQLWR´RFFKLRGHOFXRUHµFRPSLWRGHO QVSHUIH]LRQDPHQWR VSLULWXDOH FKH RJQL FULVWLDQRGHYHSHUVHJXLUHqTXHOORGLSX ULÀFDUHTXHVWRVHQVRLQWHULRUHFRQLOTXDOH O·XRPR JLXQJHUj D VFRSULUH LO PLVWHUR GL 'LRHUDJJLXQJHUjODVDOYH]]D0DSHUUDJ JLXQJHUHODWDQWRVRVSLUDWDVDOYH]]DFKH WXWWDYLDFLYLHQHFRQFHVVDLQIRU]DGHOVD FULÀFLRGL&ULVWRHSHUPLVHULFRUGLDGLYLQD GLSHQGHPROWRDQFKHGDQRLGLSHQGHFLRq VHFLDWWLYHUHPRFRQFUHWDPHQWHQHOOD´UL FRVWUX]LRQHµ GHO QRVWUR XRPR LQWHULRUH VDSHQGRFKHHVVRqLOWHPSLRGL'LR6HFL DWWLYHUHPRDIDUHTXHVWRORVSLULWRGL'LR YHUUjDGLPRUDUHLQQRLHQRL´SRUWHUHPR PROWR IUXWWRµ 'REELDPR TXLQGL TXDQWR PHQRFRPLQFLDUHTXHVWRODYRURVDSHQGR WXWWDYLD FKH VDUj 'LR FKH ² DO PRPHQWR RSSRUWXQR ² WHUPLQHUj O·RSHUD FKH QRL DYUHPRDYYLDWRSURSULRFRPHVFULWWRQHO 6DOPR´,O6LJQRUHFRPSOHWHUjO·RSHUD PLD6LJQRUHODWXDERQWjGXUDSHUVHP SUH QRQ DEEDQGRQDUH O·RSHUD GHOOH WXH PDQLµ 3HUWDQWRFKLQRQVLLQFDPPLQDLQTXHVWR SHUFRUVRQRQVLFKLHGDXQJLRUQRQHOPR PHQWRGHOELVRJQRRGHOODVFLDJXUD´GR Y·q'LRµR´VH'LRHVLVWHµVLFKLHGDSLXW WRVWRSHUFKq'LRQRQqYHQXWRDGDELWDUH LQOXL&DSLUjDOORUDFKHO·XQLFRHVVHUHGD ULWHQHUH UHVSRQVDELOH DOWUL QRQ q VH QRQ VHVWHVVR 'DQLHOD&HUFDWR &$5,5$*$==,6,$7( 277,0,67, 8QEHOPHVVDJJLRGLRWWLPLVPRGLGRQ0D]]L + R ULFHYXWR XQD HPDL WUD OH WDQWH FKHPLKDXQSR·SUHRFFXSDWR 1RQPLSUHRFFXSDLSHVVLPLVPRGH JOLDGXOWLPROWRLQYHFHTXHOORGHLJLRYDQL /DHPDLOGLFHYDFRVu©&DURGRQ0D]]LKR DSSHQDOHWWRLOVXROLEUR(ORJLRGHOVRPDUR q XQ OLEUHWWR QHO TXDOH ULVSRQGR DG DO FXQH GRPDQGH SRVWHPL GD XQ JUXSSR GL UDJD]]LGL$OEDTXDOFKHPHVHID0LqSLD FLXWRPROWLVVLPRSHUzPLFKLHGRFRPHOHL IDFFLDQRQRVWDQWHWXWWRTXHOORFKHFDSLWD LQTXHVWRPRQGRDGDYHUHDQFRUDÀGXFLD QHLJLRYDQL'RYHWURYDWDQWRRWWLPLVPR" +RDQQLHJXDUGDQGRPROWLUDJD]]LGHO ODPLDHWjPLFKLHGRFRPHVDUjLOIXWXUR 1RQ VL YHGRQR SL YDORUL H VL FRQWLQXD D SHJJLRUDUH4XDQGRFLSHQVRKRSDXUDH PLGLFRFKHSUHIHULUHLXQGRPDQLQRQDYHU ÀJOLSLXWWRVWRFKHFUHVFHUOLLQXQPRQGR FRVuRUULELOHªODUDJD]]DFKHPLVFULYHq FHUWDPHQWHULÁHVVLYDLPSHJQDWDHFUHGR DQFKH FULVWLDQD SUDWLFDQWH ( LR FL SHUGR LOVRQQR 0L FKLHGR SHUFKp QRL SUHWL DEELDPR RI IHUWR TXHVWH GUDPPDWLFKH SURVSHWWLYH VXJOLDQQLDYHQLUH9RUUHLODQFLDUHDWXWWL TXHOOLFKHPLOHJJRQRVSHFLHVHJLRYDQL XQPHVVDJJLRGLVSHUDQ]D,OPRQGRqJLj VWDWRUHGHQWRQRQGDOVDQJXHGLXQXRPR TXDOVLDVLPDGDOVDQJXHGL&ULVWR1RQq FROSD PLD TXLQGL VH VRQR RWWLPLVWD QRQ SRWUHEEHHVVHUHDOWULPHQWL &HUFKLDPRGXQTXHGHQWURDOPRQGRQRQ LVHJQLGHOODGLVSHUD]LRQHPDLVHJQLGHOOD ULVXUUH]LRQH&LVRQRVRQRWDQWLVRQRDE EDVWDQ]D YLVLELOL VRQR GLVVHPLQDWL RYXQ TXHDQFKHODGGRYHWXWWRIDUHEEHSHQVDUH DOFRQWUDULR 5LEDGLVFRHYYLYDO·RWWLPLVPR GRQ0D]]L /$)$92/$'(//$6(77,0$1$ &2168/(1=$ 6 WR SHU DQGDUH LQ SHQVLRQH SHU UDJJLXQWL OLPLWL GL HWj H PL GL VSLDFH 3DUODQGR FRQ JOL DPLFL GLFHYR ULGHQGR FKH QRQ YHGHYR O·RUD FKHDUULYDVVHTXHVWRPRPHQWRFRVuPL VDUHLULSRVDWRGHÀQLWLYDPHQWHPDQRQ SRVVR PHQWLUH D PH VWHVVR PL VHQWR DQFRUD JLRYDQH KR YRJOLD GL ODYRUDUH KR PROWH ULVRUVH DQFRUD GLVSRQLELOL H GHYR EXWWDUH DO YHQWR OD PLD HVSH ULHQ]DO·DELOLWjGLVDSHUPLQLPL]]DUHL SLFFROLLQFRQYHQLHQWLWXWWRTXHVWRQRQ VHUYHSLSHUFKpKRUDJJLXQWRLOLPLWL GLHWj9LVHPEUDFRUUHWWR"6RQRWUH DQQLFKHODYRURLQWHQVDPHQWHIDFHQGR WXUQL GL RWWR RUH JLRUQDOLHUH H D YRO WH DQFKH GL SL QRQ KR PDL FKLHVWR QLHQWH VH QRQ TXDOFKH FROSR GL IHUUR SHU WRJOLHUH OH JULQ]H R VDOGDUH XQ ERWWRQH SHQ]RODQWH H OD ULFRPSHQVD FKH RUD ULFHYR q GL HVVHUH VFDUWDWR FUHGHWHPLQRQqXQDPLDIDQWDVLDKR VHQWLWRDIIHUPDUHGDOODPRJOLHGHOPLR ´LQGRVVDWRUHµ FKH VRQR REVROHWR QRQ VRQRSLGLPRGDHTXLQGLLOPLRSURVVL PRYLDJJLRQRQPLSRUWHUjDOODWLQWRULD PDLQTXDOFKHGLVFDULFDSHUHVVHUHGL VWUXWWR H GL PH QRQ ULPDUUj QHSSXUH XQDFXFLWXUDXQÀOR6RQRXQDELWRGL VDUWRULDVRQRVWDWRFUHDWRVXPLVXUD SHULOPLRSDGURQH6RQRVWDWHWDQWHOH GRPDQGHGHOVDUWRFKHWLSRGLWHVVXWR XVDUH",OFRORUHGRYHYDHVVHUHFKLDUR RVFXUR"/DVFHOWDGHLERWWRQLqVWDWD OXQJD H VRIIHUWD QRUPDOL R GRUDWL" (UDQR QHFHVVDUL L WDVFKLQL DOO·LQWHU QR SHU OH SHQQH D VIHUD LO FHOOXODUH LO SRUWDIRJOL" /H FXFLWXUH DYUHEEHUR GRYXWRHVVHUHGRSSLHRVLQJROH"6RQR VWDWR GLVHJQDWR SULPD VX GL XQ IRJOLR HXQDYROWDSUHVHOHPLVXUHqLQL]LD WD OD PLD YHUD FUHD]LRQH SH]]R GRSR SH]]R FXFLWXUD GRSR FXFLWXUD SURYD GRSR SURYD ÀQR DO JLRUQR GHOOD PLD QDVFLWD H SRL LO SULPR JLRUQR GL ODYR UR6RQRVWDWRHORJLDWRPLKDQQRWRF FDWR GLFHQGR FKH HUR EHOOR PRUELGR XQ DELWR GL JUDQ FODVVH HG RUD" 1RQ VHUYR SL 6RQR DQ]LDQR GHYR HVVHUH PHVVRGDSDUWHQRQSRVVRWUDPDQGD UHODPLDHVSHULHQ]DDQHVVXQRSHUFKp L JLRYDQL QRQ YRJOLRQR FRQVLJOL SRWUHL HVVHUHLQGRVVDWRLQJLRUQLPDJDULSLR YRVL FRVu QRQ VDUHEEH XQ WUDJHGLD VH EDJQDQGRPL UHVWDVVL PDFFKLDWR HG LQYHFH VRVWHQJRQR FKH GHYR HVVHUH GLVWUXWWRWROWRGDOO·DUPDGLRLOSLSUH VWRSRVVLELOHSHUODVFLDUHVSD]LRDOPLR VXFFHVVRUHQHSSXUHLOWHPSRGLGDUJOL XQ·RFFKLDWD R GL VWULQJHUJOL OD PDQLFD SHUDXJXUDUJOLEXRQODYRUR1RQDYHQ GR QLHQWH GD IDUH ULPDQHQGR DSSHVR ÀQRDOJLRUQRGHOPLRXOWLPRYLDJJLRKR WHPSRSHUSHQVDUH3URSRUUHLXQ·LGHD QRQ SRWUHL IDUH XQD FRQVXOHQ]D" 3R WUHPPR FHUFDUH XQ VLJQRUH FRQ OD VWHVVD FRUSRUDWXUD GHO PLR ´LQGRVVD WRUHµHSDVVDUPLDOXLORVDUHLGLVSR QLELOH D GLYHQWDUH XQ FRQVXOHQWH QRQ FKLHGHUHL XQD VWLUDWXUD JLRUQDOLHUD R XQ UDPPHQGR SHUIHWWR LQ FDVR GL QH FHVVLWj PD PL SLDFHUHEEH FRQWLQXDUH DGHVLVWHUHODYRUDUHHVVHUHXWLOHDOOD VRFLHWjVRQRDQ]LDQRPDKRDQFRUDXQD JUDQGH YRJOLD GL YHVWLUH TXDOFXQR OH PLH FXFLWXUH VRQR SHUIHWWH L ERWWRQL VHPEUDQR QXRYL QRQ KR PDFFKLH YLVL ELOHDQ]LQRQQHKRSURSULRSRWUHLFRVu YLVLWDUHSRVWLQXRYLHQWUDUHLQDUPDGL GLYHUVLVHQWLUHLOSURIXPRGLXQFRUSR GLIIHUHQWH LQFRQWUDUH FROOHJKL FRQ L TXDOLSDUODUHGHOSDVVDWRHGHOIXWXUR (VVHUH DQ]LDQL QRQ VLJQLÀFD QHFHVVD ULDPHQWHODURWWDPD]LRQHPDHVLVWHOD PRELOLWjLRQRQWLVHUYRSLHTXLQGLPL FKLHGLODGLVSRQLELOLWjDWUDVIHULUPL $SURQR O·DQWD q DUULYDWR LO EUXWWR JLRUQRVDOXWRJOLDPLFLDELWLSDQWDOR QLFDPLFLHFRQODSUHJKLHUDGLSRUWDUH LPLHLVDOXWLDQFKHDPXWDQGHHFDO]LQL FKHPLVRQRVWDWLWDQWRYLFLQLLQWXWWLL PRPHQWLEHOOLRGLIÀFLOLqSURSULRRUD GLDQGDUH9HQJRSLHJDWRDWWHQWDPHQ WHFKLVVjSHUFKpYLVWRFKHQRQVHUYR SLHSRUWDWRLQPDFFKLQDPDGRYH",O FDVVRQHWWRGHLULÀXWLqGDYDQWLDFDVD PD QRQ DQGLDPR Ou SURVHJXLDPR VLD PRDUULYDWLYHQJRVROOHYDWRGDLVHGLOL H GHOLFDWDPHQWH YHQJR LQVHULWR LQ XQ FDVVRQHWWREHOORHJUDQGH'LWHPLFKH q YHUR GLWHPL FKH QRQ VWR VRJQDQGR QRQYHUUzGLVWUXWWRPDULFLFODWREUXW WRPRGRSHUGLUHFKHGLYHQWHUzXQFRQ VXOHQWH $YHYR VHQWLWR LO VDFHUGRWH GXUDQWH XQ·RPHOLD SDUODUH GL TXHVWL FDVVRQHWWL*OLLQFDULFDWLYHGHQGRPLLQ SHUIHWWRVWDWRPLDVVHJQHUDQQRVLFX UDPHQWHDGXQQXRYR´LQGRVVDWRUHµH SRWUzFRVuFRQWLQXDUHDODYRUDUH1RQ KROHODEEUDDOWULPHQWLEDFHUHLLOFDV VRQHWWRHDQFKHLOSUHWHFKHKDDYXWR TXHVWD EULOODQWH LGHD SHUFKq ULWHQJR QRQ VLD JLXVWR VEDUD]]DUVL GHOOH FRVH FKH SRVVRQR HVVHUH XWLOL]]DWH DQFRUD HFRPHPHLQEXRQRVWDWRQHHVLVWRQR WDQWLTXLQGLSHUIDYRUHQRQEXWWDWHFL YLDVRORSHUFKpVLDPRSDVVDWLGLPRGD LOQRVWURODYRURORSRVVLDPRIDUHDQFR UDHEHQHHODSHUVRQDFKHFLLQGRVVHUj IDUj EHOOD ÀJXUD H QRQ SHU YDQWDUPL VRSUDWWXWWRFRQPH 0DULXFFLD3LQHOOL 3$6725$/( '(//8772 &ROPHVHGLQRYHPEUHSDUWLUDQQRJOL LQFRQWULSHUO¾HODERUD]LRQHGHOOXWWR 3HU LQIRUPD]LRQL WHOHIRQDUH D GRQ $UPDQGR FHOO ',$5,2',8135(7(,13(16,21( '$7,7(&1,&, /XQHGu EELDPRDFFROWRHWHQWDWRGLDLXWDUH XQRGHLWDQWLUHOLWWLFKHOHRQGHGHO QRVWURWHPSRHGHOODQRVWUDVRFLHWj VEDOORWWDQRTXDHOjHFKHVRQRFRVWUHWWL DYLYHUHG·HVSHGLHQWL0LHURDIIH]LRQDWR DOXLDLVXRLEDPELQLGHLTXDOLVRYHQWH PL PRVWUDYD OH IRWRJUDÀH GHOOD PRJOLH GL FXL SDUODYD PHQR HG HUR VHPSUH SL SUHRFFXSDWR GL FHUFDUH VROX]LRQL SHU FKpODVXDYLWDIRVVHXQSR·SLXPDQDH QRUPDOH0·HUDTXDVLXQDVSLQDQHOFXRUH SHQVDUHDTXHVW·XRPRVRORFRQXQYRFD ERODULRULGRWWRHGLQFHUWRVHQ]DDJJDQFL VHQ]D UDSSRUWL YHUL H FRQ TXDVL QHVVXQD SURVSHWWLYDSHULOGRPDQLORVRFKHD0H VWUH FL VRQR FHQWLQDLD GL XRPLQL H GRQQH H[WUDFRPXQLWDUL LQ TXHVWH FRQGL]LRQL H FKHLQ,WDOLDVRQRIRUVHGHFLQHGLPLJOLDLD ORSHUzFRQRVFHYROXL*OLDVVLFXUDLLOSD VWRTXDOFKHFHVSLWHVLFXURHSURJHWWDYR TXDORUD IRVVH DQGDWD LQ SRUWR XQD FHUWD RSHUD]LRQH G·DVVXPHUOR PDJDUL SDUW WLPH QHOOD VSHUDQ]D FKH TXHVWD SRWHVVH HVVHUH XQD SUHPHVVD SHU XQ GRPDQL SL QRUPDOH /H FRVH DQGDURQR GLYHUVDPHQ WH XQD YHFFKLD PDODWWLD SVLFRORJLFD HUD LQ DJJXDWR H O·HWLOLVPR O·DVSHWWDYD DOOH SULPHGLIÀFROWj,QSRFKLJLRUQLV·DEEUXWWu WRWDOPHQWHVDOWDURQROHLQLEL]LRQLLOVXR FRPSRUWDPHQWRGLIIXVHSULPDULÀXWRSRL SDXUDIUDJOLDQ]LDQLGHOGRQ9HFFKLFRVLF FKpIXJLRFRIRU]DSURLELUJOLGLDYYLFLQDU VLPLQDFFLDQGRORGLULFRUUHUHDOODSROL]LD 0L FKLHVH GD GRUPLUH TXDVL VXSSOLFDQGR EDUEDOXQJDRFFKLVWUDOXQDWLSLHGLFRQOH SLDJKH SHU LO OXQJR FDPPLQDUH D YXRWR PD LR QRQ VRQR RUD QHSSXUH LQ JUDGR GL GDUJOL FRQVLJOLR *OL GLHGL LQGLFD]LRQL SHU PDQJLDUH GDL IUDWL HG DOOD 69LQFHQ]R H FRQ TXHVWR FRPPLDWR HJOL V·DYYLz YHUVR LO SDUFR FKH SHU L SURVVLPL JLRUQL VDUj LO VXRDOEHUJRFRQPLOOHVWHOOHVHQRQIDUj WHPSRUDOH $ 0DUWHGu HOSRPHULJJLRPLVRQRSUHVRLOOXVVR GLDQGDUHGDXQYHFFKLRSDHVDQRGL XQ WHPSR SHU SUHQGHUH GHL VDOXPL SHUODIHVWDFKHVWLDPRRUJDQL]]DQGRSHUL 1 FLQTXDQW·DQQLGLYLWDUHOLJLRVDGLVXRU0L FKHOD+RLQFRQWUDWRLOWLWRODUHGHOODÁRUL GDD]LHQGDFRQGRWWDDOLYHOORDUWLJLDQDOH GDTXHVWDSLFFRODIDPLJOLDLQWUDSUHQGHQWH HVHULDPHQWHLPSHJQDWD/XLPLFRQRVFH YDEHQHQHOPLRSDHVHWXWWLVLFRQRVFRQR HVHDQFKHQRQFLYLYRSLGDPH]]RVHFR ORWXWWLFRQRVFHYDQRPLRSDGUHPLDPD GUHHGLPLHLIUDWHOOLSHUFLzFRQRVFHYDQR PDJDUL LQGLUHWWDPHQWH DQFKH PH 0L KD VRUSUHVR TXHVWR SLFFROR LPSUHQGLWRUH GL FRPPHUFLR FRVu GHFLVDPHQWH VFKLHUDWR FRQWURO·DWWXDOHJRYHUQRPDVRSUDWWXWWR FRQWUR TXHOOL FKH HJOL FKLDPDYD TXDVL LQ PDQLHUD RVVHVVLYD L ´FDWWRFRPXQLVPLµ H YL FRPSUHQGHYD QRQ VROWDQWR L FDWWROLFL PLOLWDQWL QHOO·8QLRQH PDVRSUDWWXWWR IH GHOLHSUHWLÀDQFKHJJLDWRUL(UDPROWRFKH QRQVHQWLYRSXOVDUHODSDVVLRQHSROLWLFDLQ PDQLHUDFRVuLQWHQVDHGHWHUPLQDWD0Lq SDUVRGLULWRUQDUHDLWHPSLGHOODPLDDGR OHVFHQ]D TXDQGR LQ YDFDQ]D GDYR XQD PDQR D PLR SDGUH DG DWWDFFDUH PDQLIH VWLFRQWURLOIURQWHSRSRODUH&·HUDVSLULWR GL FURFLDWD QRQ VL DQGDYD WURSSR SHU LO VRWWLOHVLORWWDYDSHULOWULRQIRGHOODFUR FH FRQWUR OD IDOFH HG LO PDUWHOOR (UD GD PROWRFKHQRQSHQVDYRDTXHOODVWDJLRQH GHOODPLDYLWDHTXDVLLQVSLHJDELOPHQWH KR VHQWLWR XQ VHQWLPHQWR GL YHUD H SUR IRQGDULFRQRVFHQ]DSHUTXHOODGHWHUPLQD ]LRQHHTXHOODFRPEDWWLYLWjFKHFLKDQQR VDOYDWR GDOOD PLVHULD GDOO·LQWROOHUDQ]D H GDOO·RVFXUDQWLVPR GL XQ PRYLPHQWR FKH HUDFRQWURODFLYLOWjODIHGHLOEHQHVVHUH HVRSUDWWXWWRFRQWURODOLEHUWjHODGHPR FUD]LD)RUWXQDWDPHQWHFLVRQRVWDWHSHU VRQH FKH KDQQR FDSLWR DQQL ID TXHOOR FKH LO FDSR GHO QRVWUR VWDWR FDSLVFH VROR RJJL 0HUFROHGu RVRQRSURIRQGDPHQWHFRQYLQWRGLQRQ DYHUHODSUHSDUD]LRQHHO·DWWUH]]DWXUD PHQWDOHSHUSUHQGHUHSRVL]LRQHLQPD QLHUDVHULDVXPROWLSUREOHPLFKHDQJXVWLD QRLOQRVWURWHPSRSHUzWDOYROWDWUDJJR GDOOHHVSHULHQ]HGHOODYLWDDOFXQHVHQVD ]LRQL FKH RULHQWDQR TXDVL LVWLQWLYDPHQWH LOPLRSHQVLHUR6RFRQOXFLGLWjFKHODQR VWUDVRFLHWjVDUjVHPSUHSLPXOWLHWQLFDH PXOWLUHOLJLRVDHFKHTXHVWDYRJOLDRQRQ YRJOLDVDUjVHPSUHGLSLODFDUDWWHULVWLFD GHO GRPDQL GHO QRVWUR 3DHVH 4XHOOR FKH QRQ FDSLVFR LQYHFH q FRPH DIIURQWDUH LO SUREOHPD TXDOL VLDQR OH VROX]LRQL GD SUHQGHUH /D SUHVHQ]D GHL PXVXOPDQL LQ ,WDOLDqXQIDWWRRUPDLDVVRGDWRHFKHLQ IXWXURVDUDQQRPROWLSLGLRJJLqDOWUHW WDQWR FHUWR SHUz FRVD IDUH PL q SURSULR GLIÀFLOH LPPDJLQDUOR 4XDOFKH JLRUQR ID VRQR VWDWR GD XQ PXVXOPDQR FKH YLYH D 0HVWUHSHUIDYRULUHODFDXVDGLXQSRYHUR GLDYRORFKHHUDVWDWRVXRRVSLWHHFKHOXL DYHYDFDFFLDWRGLFDVD0LVRQRWURYDWRGL IURQWHDGXQDIUHGGH]]DDGXQDGHWHUPL , 6RQR DWWXDOPHQWH L FROOD ERUDWRULGHOVHWWLPDQDOH LSXQWLGLGLVWULEX]LRQH OHFRSLHVWDPSDWHRJQL VHWWLPDQD ODVWDPSDVLDYYDOHGHOO¾XOWLPD YHUVLRQHELFRORUHGHOOD5LVRJUDI /¾LQFRQWUR KD UDJJLXQWR XQD VXD SHFXOLDUH ILVLRQRPLD XQLFD QHO VXR JHQHUH H KD JL HGLWR XQYROXPHÀ,QXRYRGLVFHSROLGL *HV¨ VSRQVRU GHO VHWWPDQDOH ,2) %862/,1&DUSHQHGR QD]LRQH HG XQ·LQVHQVLELOLWj XPDQD ROWUH DGXQ·DUURJDQ]DGLIHGHHGLUD]]DFKHPL KDIDWWRDYYHUWLUHTXDQWRORQWDQRGLYHU VRHSUHVVRFKpLQFRPXQLFDELOHIRVVHTXHO PRGRGLSHQVDUHHGLDJLUH+RSDXUDGHL PXVXOPDQLKRSDXUDGHOODORURHVSDQVLR QHKRSDXUDGHOO·RFFXSD]LRQHPHWRGLFD HG LQDUUHVWDELOH FKH VWDQQR IDFHQGR QHO QRVWUR 3DHVH , FULVWLDQL GL /HSDQWR GL 9LHQQD R GHOOD 6SDJQD LQ XQ FHUWR TXDO PRGRHUDQRSLDWWUH]]DWLSHUODORURGLIH VDQRLVLDPRGLVDUPDWLLQHUPLHSHUÀQR SRFR FRQYLQWL GHL QRVWUL YDORUL FKH VRQR LQÀQLWDPHQWHPLJOLRULGHLORUR'HWWRTXH VWRSHUzULPDQHLQSLHGL´&RVDIDUH"µ *LRYHGu XRU 0LFKHOD TXHVW·DQQR FHOHEUHUj L FLQTXDQW·DQQLGLYLWDUHOLJLRVDOHVXH QR]]HG·RURFRQ'LR6XRU0LFKHODq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q GLVVROWR FRPH QHYH DO VROH $OWULULFRUGLGHOYLOODJJLR60DUFRGRYHOD VXD FRQJUHJD]LRQH DQFRUD PROWR DWWLYD IRUWHPHQWH PRWLYDWD D OLYHOOR UHOLJLRVRH JXLGDWD GD GRQQH IRUWL LQWUDSUHQGHQWL H FRUDJJLRVH DYHYD FRVWUXLWR SULPD TXHOOD JUDQGH FDVD FRQ DVLOR D H VFXROD GDYDQ WLDOODFKLHVDHSRLLOOLFHROLQJXLVWLFRDO 6 SDGUHODVXDWHVWLPRQLDQ]DGLIHGHHOD VXDFRHUHQ]DGLYLWD1XOODYDSHUGXWR SHUFKpSULPDRSRLÀRULVFHHSRUWDIUXW WR3HUTXHVWRFUHGRFKHSUHWLJHQLWRUL HGHGXFDWRULLQJHQHUHGHEEDQRVHPSUH VHPLQDUHJHQHURVDPHQWHDQFKHLQWHP SLHVLWXD]LRQLGLIÀFLOLSHUFKpODEXRQD VHPHQWHVLLPEDWWHSULPDRSRLQHOWHU UHQRFKHIUXWWLÀFDRUDDOWUHQWDRUDDO VHVVDQWDRDOFHQWRSHUFHQWRËVHPSUH TXLQGLLPSRUWDQWHVHPLQDUHFRPXQTXH O·LQL]LR GHO YLDOH Ë OHL GRQQD PDWXUD FKH SUHQGH LQ PDQR O·DPPLQLVWUD]LR QHDLXWDLQFXFLQDHVLVSHQGHSHUXQD PDUHDGLPDUPRFFKLLUUHTXLHWLHYLYDFL 3RL WUHQW·DQQL D &DUSHQGR SRUWDQGR DYDQWL O·HVSHULHQ]D FKH GRYHYD VHJQD UH LO GRPDQL O·LQQRYD]LRQH SHU OD VXD FRQJUHJD]LRQH H GHOOD TXDOH OHL H VXRU 7HUHVDVRQRULPDVWHVROLWDULHWHVWLPRQL ,QÀQHLO'RQ9HFFKLDSLGLRWWDQW·DQQL SHUFRQGLYLGHUHFRQWDQWLDOWULYHFFKLOD VWDJLRQHGHOODVHUDSHUzDQFRUDGDYDQWL DOO· DOWDUH GHO VXR 6LJQRUH D FXL DYHYD GHWWRGLVLPH]]RVHFRORIDSHUULSHWH UH LO VXR GRQR H OD VXD GLVSRQLELOLWj DG DPDUORQHLIUDWHOOL 9HQHUGu URLQFLPLWHURTXDQGRXQDVLJQRUD FKH FRQRVFHYR ÀQ GDL WHPSL GL 6 /RUHQ]RPLVLVHGHWWHDFFDQWRSHU SHURUDUH OD FDXVD GL XQD VXD SURWHWWD 0DQPDQRFKHTXHVWDGRQQDGDOODYRFH FDOGD H VXDGHQWH SURFHGHYD QHO VXR GLVFRUVR SUHQGHYD IRUPD H VHPELDQ]D GHQWURGLPHXQDYHFFKLDFRQRVFHQ]D6L WUDWWDYDGLXQ·DQ]LDQDVLJQRUDQRQWDQ WR YHFFKLD FKH GD VHWWLPDQH GRUPLYD DUURWRODWDLQXQDFRSHUWDQHOOHYLFLQDQ ]HGHOOD´VWD]LRQHWWDµGL&DUSHQGR8QD ÀJXUD XQ SR· EL]]DUUD FRPH DEELJOLD PHQWRHÀORVRÀDGLYLWDFUHGRFKHWXWWR VRPPDWRHOODDOPHQRQHOVXEFRQVFLRVL ULIHULVFD D 6 )UDQFHVFR G·$VVLVL H YR JOLDLPLWDUORVHJXHQGRQHJOLHVHPSLFRQ ´PDGRQQDSRYHUWjµ1RQFKLHGHQLHQWH QRQYXROHQLHQWHPDYLYHUDQGDJLDVHQ ]DÀVVDGLPRUDLQFRQGL]LRQLPLVHUULPH /D JHQWH O·KD RVVHUYDWD O·KD FRPSDWL WDHGKDWLUDWRGULWWRSHUODVXDVWUDGD ÀQFKp QRQ q SDVVDWD GD TXHOOH SDUWL OD VLJQRUDFKHPLVLqVHGXWDDFFDQWRFKH O·KD ODYDWD H VL q PHVVD D FHUFDUH XQD VROX]LRQHFRQGHWHUPLQD]LRQHSLIRUWH GL RJQL ORJLFD H GL RJQL SUXGHQ]D 1HO SDVVDWR SHUFKp VRQR DQQL HG DQQL FKH TXHVWDSRYHUDFUHDWXUDYLYHFRVuDYHYR WHQWDWRGLGDUOHXQDVWDQ]DDO3LRYHQWR PD QH HUD QDWR XQ WDOH YHVSDLR FRQ OH YHFFKLHFRLQTXLOLQHFKHGRYHWWLSUHJDU ODGLDQGDUVHQH2UDDGLVWDQ]DGLDQQL LOFDVRVLULSURSRQHYDHSHUIRUWXQDVXD VLHUDLPEDWWXWDLQXQDVDPDULWDQDFKH QRQVRORHUD´VFHVDGDFDYDOORµPDFKH QRQV·qGDWDSDFHÀQFKpQRQO·KDYLVWD FRQ XQ WHWWR VRSUD OD VXD WHVWD %XVVz DOODSRUWDGLGRQ'DQLORFKHQRQDYHYD DYXWR FRPH PH FRQWDWWL SUHFHGHQWL H O·DFFROVH QXRYDPHQWH DO 3LRYHQWR XQD SLFFRODFDVDLQFXLYLYRQRVHLDQ]LDQH 8QDYROWDDQFRUDPLGRPDQGRTXDVLFRQ HVDVSHUD]LRQHµ3RVVLELOHFKHODWUHQWLQD GLSDUURFFKLHPHVWULQHQRQSRVVDQRGR WDUVL GL XQ ULIXJLR GRYH DOORJJLDUH TXH VWLUHOLWWLG·XRPRFKHQRQPDQFKHUDQQR PDLLQFLWWj"µ3HQVRFKHVRORTXHVWRVLD LOWHUPRPHWURGHOODIHGH ( 'RPHQLFD ULPD LO 3DWULDUFD DO 5HGHQWRUH HG RUDGRQ%RQD]]DLQWHUYHQJRQRVXO OD VFXROD LQ PDQLHUD DSHUWD VHQ ]D FRPSOHVVL H VHQ]D SHOL VXOOD OLQJXD 4XHVWH SUHVH GL SRVL]LRQH PL SLDFFLRQR TXDQWR PDL HUD RUD 8QD FRVD FKH PL ID TXDQWR PDL WULVWH]]D q LO FRPSOHVVR G·LQIHULRULWjHVXGGLWDQ]DFKHPROWLFUH GHQWL ODLFL H SUHWL WURYDQR QHL ULJXDU GLGHOODVLQLVWUDSLRPHQRHVWUHPDOD TXDOH V·q VHPSUH DUURJDWD LO GLULWWR GL VHQWLUVL FRPH O·HVSUHVVLRQH GHOOD GH PRFUD]LDHGHOODOLEHUWjPHQWUHLQYHFH UDSSUHVHQWD WXWWR O·RSSRVWR UDSSRU WDQGRVLDGHVVHLQEDVHDOODJUDGD]LRQH GHO URVVR O·HVWUHPR q OD QHJD]LRQH LQ DVVROXWR PHQWUH LO URVD PDQLIHVWD JLj O·HVVHUHEDFDWDGDTXHVWRWDUOR1RQVR D TXDOH VWDGLR VL FROORFKL LO QXRYR PL QLVWURGHOO·LVWUX]LRQH)LRURQLFRPXQTXH FUHGRFKHOHVXHSRVL]LRQLFLUFDODVFXROD PHULWLQR LO ULÀXWR QHWWR H GHFLVR %HQH IDGRQ%RQD]]DDVÀGDUORLQXQGLEDWWLWR SXEEOLFRLJHQLWRULKDQQRLOVDFURVDQWR GLULWWR GL HGXFDUH FRPH FUHGRQR L ORUR ÀJOL SHUFKp HVVL VRQR ORUR QRQ GHOOR 6WDWR FKH KD VRODPHQWH LO FRPSLWR GL JDUDQWLUH D WXWWL OLEHUWj H GHPRFUD]LD QRQTXHOORGLDUURJDUVLLOGLULWWRGLFUH VFHUOLFRPHFUHGHRGLPHWWHUOLLQEDOLD GL JHQWH FKH OD SHQVD GLYHUVDPHQWH GD FKLKDGDWRORURODYLWDHVHQHIDFDULFR %HQSRFRLQYHULWjKDQQRIDWWROD0R UDWWL H %HUOXVFRQL SHU OD VFXROD OLEHUD PDRUDSDUHFKHLOQXRYRJRYHUQRFRP· HUD SUHYHGLELOH YRJOLD WRJOLHUH DQFKH TXHOSRFRFRQODEHQHGL]LRQHGHOFDSR GHO JRYHUQR FKH DSSDUH RJQL JLRUQR GL SL´UHWUDYLFHOORµ 3 &KLFUHGHFKHFROGHQDURVLSRVVD DYHUHTXDOVLDVLFRVDGLVROLWRq GLVSRVWRDIDUHTXDOVLDVLFRVDSHU LOGHQDUR 6DEDWR ´& KL VHPLQD UDFFRJOLHµ GLFH XQ YHFFKLR SURYHUELR &R QRVFHYR XQ SDUURFFKLDQR RQHVWR JDODQWXRPR H ULFFR GL IHGH FKH V·LPSHJQz D FUHVFHUH LQ PDQLH UD FRHUHQWH L VXRL ÀJOL 3XUWURSSR XQ LQFLGHQWH LQWHUUXSSH LPSURYYLVDPHQ WH OD VXD YLWD ODVFLDQGR DOOD PRJOLH LO VXRSURJHWWR&RPSLWRGLIÀFLOHRJJLSHU XQDGRQQDFUHVFHUHGDVRODQHOWLPRUGL 'LRXQDQLGLDWDGLUDJD]]LLQXQDVRFLH Wj FKH UHPD VHPSUH FRQWUR /·LPSUHVD IRUWXQDWDPHQWHQRQDQGzPDOHQHOVXR FRPSOHVVR VHPEUD SHUz FKH FL IRVVH DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOD QLGLDWD OD VROLWD SHFR UD VH QRQ QHUD DOPHQR XQ SR· FULWLFD H VFRQWURVD 4XDOFKH JLRUQR ID SHUz HEEL XQD EHOOD H FRQVRODQWH VRUSUHVD TXHVWDÀJOLRODFRQXQDWHOHIRQDWDFKLH GHYDGLLQFRQWUDUPL/DFRVDPLVRUSUH VH HG DWWHVL FRQ XQD FHUWD FXULRVLWj H WUHSLGD]LRQHTXHVWRLQFRQWURPDOHPLH SUHRFFXSD]LRQLHUDQRLQIRQGDWHSHUFKp PL FKLHVH GL VSRVDUOD 6RQR VWDWR WDQWR IHOLFHGHOODQRWL]LDFKHVDUHLDQGDWRDQ FKHLQFDSRDOPRQGRSHUEHQHGLUHTXH VWRDPRUH1RQSRWHLQRQULFRUGDUHVXR 127,=,(',&$6$12675$ 81$0$12$68257(5(6$ 6XRU7HUHVDVRSSRUWDGDVRODO·RQHUH GHOO·LQVHULPHQWR GHL WHVWL GH ´/·,Q FRQWURµLQFRPSXWHU4XHVWRODYRURq OXQJRHGDQFKHXQSR·IDWLFRVR6HFL IRVVHTXDOFXQRFKHYROHVVHGDUHXQD PDQRDTXHVWDVXRUDLQTXHVWRVHUYL ]LRDIDYRUHGHOO·HYDQJHOL]]D]LRQHH GHOODSURSRVWDFULVWLDQDqSUHJDWRGL SUHQGHUHGLUHWWDPHQWHFRQWDWWRFRQ 6XRU7HUHVDWHO &,148$17·$11, ', 9,7$ 5(/,*,26$ ',68250,&+(/$ 6XRU 0LFKHOD GHOOD FRQJUHJD]LR QH GHOOH VXRUH GL 1HYHUV VDEDWR VHWWHPEUH KD FHOHEUDWR OH ´QR]]H G·RURµ GL YLWD UHOLJLRVD /D FHOHEUD ]LRQH KD DYXWR OXRJR DOOH RUH QHOOD 6DOD GHL 7UHFHQWR GRYH RJQL /$35,0$ &$1'(/,1$ '( ´/·,1&21752µ $ ILQH RWWREUH LO QRVWUR VHW WLPDQDOH FRPSLH LO SULPR DQQRGLYLWD3HUIHVWHJJLDUH LOOLHWRHYHQWRGRQ$UPDQGR KDLQYLWDWRDFHQDWXWWLLYR ORQWDUL FKH UHDOL]]DQR RJQL VHWWLPDQD TXHVWR VWUXPHQWR GLHYDQJHOL]]D]LRQHHGL SURSRVWDUHOLJLRVD VHWWLPDQDGRQ$UPDQGRFHOHEUDOD6 0HVVDSUHIHVWLYDSHUWXWWLLUHVLGHQWL DO FHQWUR GRQ 9HFFKL 'RQ $UPDQGR KD LQWURGRWWR OD FHOHEUD]LRQH FRQ SDUROH DSSURSULDWH LO FRUR 6 &HFL OLD KD DQLPDWR OD 6 0HVVD DOOD ÀQH GHOODTXDOHJOLRVSLWLGHOGRQ9HFFKL KDQQRGRQDWRD60LFKHODXQDSLDQWD HGXQDUDGLR'RSRODFHOHEUD]LRQH ODSLFFRODFRPXQLWjUHOLJLRVDIRUPD WDGD6XRU0LFKHODH6XRU7HUHVDKD RIIHUWRDWXWWLLUHVLGHQWLXQULQIUHVFR D FDUDWWHUH FDVHUHFFLR FRQ JUDQGH OHWL]LDGLWXWWL ,/ &252 ', 3/,1,2 %25*+, $/ 6( 1,255(67$85$17 ,O VHWWHPEUH L PHPEUL GHO FRUR GLUHWWR GDO PDHVWUR 3OLQLR %RUJKL KD SUDQ]DWR DVVLHPH DJOL DQ]LDQL DO 6HQLRU 5HVWDXUDQW 'RQ $UPDQGR KD LQYLWDWRLOFRURFRPHVHJQRGLULFR QRVFHQ]DSHUOHIUHTXHQWLDQLPD]LR QL FKH VXGGHWWR FRUR KD WHQXWR DOOD PHVVD GHOOH RUH LQ FLPLWHUR DOOD GRPHQLFD 4XHVWR FRUR QHO WHPSR V·q VSHFLDOL]]DWR LQ FDQWL JUHJRULDQL HFDQWLUHOLJLRVLSRSRODUL'RQ$UPDQ GR VSHUD FKH TXDQGR VDUj FRVWUXLWD OD QXRYD FKLHVD LO FRUR DQLPL RJQL GRPHQLFD OD OLWXUJLD HXFDULVWLFD FKH YLHQHFHOHEUDWDQHOFDPSRVDQWR *,29$11,%210$5&2 'RPHQLFDDJRVWRqSDVVDWRDPL JOLRU YLWD LO FRQFLWWDGLQR *LRYDQQL %RQPDUFR ,O IUDWHOOR FKH FL KD OD VFLDWRHUDQDWRD&KHUVRLOJLXJQR VL HUD VSRVDWR FRQ *LRYDQQD *KHUVLQL GDOOH FXL QR]]H QDFTXHUR FLQTXH ÀJOL ,O VLJQRU *LRYDQQL VXEu WXWWH OH GUDPPDWLFKH WUDYHUVLH FKH FRLQYROVHUR L IUDWHOOL LVWULDQL H GDO PDWLGRYHQGRODVFLDUHODVXDDPDWD WHUUD FRO JUDQGH HVRGR FKH VUDGLFz GDOORURPRQGRODJUDQSDUWHGLLWD OLDQL GL TXHOOD WHUUD 'D XQD FRQGL ]LRQHDJLDWDGLLPSUHQGLWRUHQHOVHW WRUH EDUFKH *LRYDQQL YHQHQGR LQ ,WDOLD GRYHWWH FRPLQFLDUH GD FDSR ODYRUDQGR FRPH DQDOLVWD FKLPLFR LQ PROWH FLWWj WHUPLQDQGR OD VXD VWD JLRQH ODYRUDWLYD DOOD 0RQWHGLVRQ GL 0DUJKHUD ,O VLJQRU %RQPDUFR IX XRPR GL UHWWR VHQWLUH FRHUHQWH H JHQHURVR DPDQWH GHOOD IDPLJOLD HG DWWDFFDWRDOODFKLHVDSDVVzO·XOWLPR WHPSR SUHJDQGR H UDFFRPDQGDQGR ODVXDDQLPDDO6LJQRUH'RQ$UPDQ GRKDFHOHEUDWRLOULWRGHOFRPPLDWR QHOOD FKLHVD GHO FLPLWHUR VDEDWR DJRVWRDOOHRUHHGKDHVSUHVVR DOOD PRJOLH DL ÀJOL HG DL IDPLOLDUL L VHQWLPHQWL GHO VXR IUDWHUQR FRUGR JOLR LQYLWDQGR WXWWL DG DIÀGDUH DOOD SDWHUQLWjGL'LRO·DQLPDGHOIUDWHOOR H GL SUHJDUH SHUFKp DEELD JDXGLR H JORULDLQFLHOR &$5/2%$/',1(//, 6DEDWR DJRVWR GRQ $UPDQGR KD FHOHEUDWR QHOOD FKLHVD GHO FLPLWHUR LO IXQHUDOH GHO FRQFLWWDGLQR &DUOR %DOGLQHOOL SRLFKp OD VXD SDUURFFKLD HUD RFFXSDWD FRQ XQ PDWULPRQLR ,O VLJQRU &DUOR HUD QDWR D 5RPDQR GL /RPEDUGLD LQ SURYLQFLD GL %HUJD PR · DJRVWR VSRVDWR DYHYD DYXWRGDOVXRPDWULPRQLRGXHÀJOLH FRQ OH TXDOL KD VHPSUH PDQWHQXWR XQ UDSSRUWR GL FDOGR DIIHWWR LQIDW WLTXHVWDIDPLJOLDqVHPSUHULPDVWD SURIRQGDPHQWH XQLWD 'RSR LO IXQH UDOH OD VDOPD q SDUWLWD SHU 5RPDQR GL/RPEDUGLDDYHQGRLOGHIXQWRGH VLGHUDWR ULWRUQDUH DOPHQR GD PRUWR QHOODVXDWHUUDQDWDOH'RQ$UPDQGR HVSULPH DOOD PRJOLH DOOD ÀJOLD HG D WXWWL L IDPLOLDUL L VHQWLPHQWL GHO VXR IUDWHUQR FRUGRJOLR HG LQYLWD WXWWL D ULFRUGDUHQHOODSUHJKLHUDGLVXIIUDJLR LOIUDWHOOR&DUORFKHFLKDODVFLDWR /$&5267$7$','(/%(//2 ,O SDQLÀFLR 'HO %HOOR FKH q VLWR LQ 9LD 9DOORQ HVHUFL]LR FKH RIIUH RJQL JLRUQR LO SDQH RFFRUUHQWH DO 6HQLRU 5HVWDXUDQW H FKH RJQL YROWD FKH DO GRQ 9HFFKL VL RUJDQL]]D TXDOFKH IH VWDSDUWLFRODUHRIIUHJUDWXLWDPHQWHL VXRLSURGRWWLGXUDQWHLOPHVHGLDJR VWRKDRIIHUWRSXUHODFURVWDWDDWXWWL LFRPPHQVDOLGHO6HQLRU5HVWDXUDQW *OL RVSLWL H OD GLUH]LRQH GHO &HQWUR GRQ 9HFFKL ULQJUD]LDQR VHQWLWDPHQ WHHGDGGLWDQRDOODFLWWDGLQDQ]DTXH VWLJHVWLGLJHQHURVLWjHGLDWWHQ]LRQH YHUVRJOLDQ]LDQLGHOODFLWWj */, 263,7, ', 9,//$ )/$1*,1, 3(5 /$&$6$',263,7$/,7$· *OLRVSLWLGHOO·XOWLPRWXUQRGLYLOOHJ JLDWXUDD9LOOD)ODQJLQLKDQQRRUJDQL] ]DWRXQDORWWHULDDIDYRUHGHOODFDVD GLRVSLWDOLWjFKHVLVSHUDGLFRVWUXLUH YLFLQRDOQXRYRRVSHGDOH,OULFDYDWR GL(XURqVWDWRFRQVHJQDWRDGRQ $UPDQGRSHUDLXWDUORDUHDOL]]DUHLO VXR SURJHWWR 'RQ $UPDQGR ULQJUD ]LD SXEEOLFDPHQWH GLFKLDUDQGR FKH O·RIIHUWD GHJOL DQ]LDQL VDUj DGRSH UDWDSHUSRUUHODSULPDSLHWUDSHULO FRPSOHVVR FKH VDUj GHQRPLQDWR ´,O 6DPDULWDQRµ %(1(),&(1=$ /DVLJQRUD7DUWDURKDPHVVRDGLVSR VL]LRQH GL GRQ $UPDQGR HXUR RIIHUWD FKH GRQ $UPDQGR KD GHVWL QDWR D ´,O 6DPDULWDQRµ OD VWUXWWXUD FKHHJOLKDLQSURJHWWRGLDSULUHDID YRUH GHL GHJHQWL H GHL IDPLOLDUL FKH DYUDQQR D FKH IDUH FRO QXRYR RVSH GDOH/DVLJQRUD'DQLHOD&UHVFHQWH HGLOPDULWRSHUIHVWHJJLDUHOHQR]]H GL 9DOHULD 3LRYHVDQD KDQQR RIIHUWR HXUR VRPPD FKH GRQ $UPDQGR KD GHVWLQDWR DOOD FRVWUX]LRQH GH ´,O 6DPDULWDQRµ , JHQLWRUL GL TXHVWD QXRYD VSRVD KDQQR PHVVR D GLVSRVL ]LRQHGLGRQ$UPDQGRHXURSHU IHVWHJJLDUHOHQR]]HGHOODÀJOLD/D VLJQRUD 2UQHO,D 0DWWHU SHU RQRUDUH ODPHPRULDGHOPDULWRSURI*LRUJLR '·$JQLQL PRUWR SRFR WHPSR ID KD RIIHUWRHXUR7XWWHTXHVWHRIIHU WHGRQ$UPDQGROHKDGLURWWDWHSHULO SURJHWWRGHOODFDVDSHUJOLDPPDODWL HGLORURIDPLOLDUL,VLJQRUL$QQDHG $OEHUWR &DOOHJDUL KDQQR RIIHUWR HXURSHUIHVWHJJLDUHOHQR]]HGL9DOH ULD3LRYHVDQD/DVLJQRUD1RUPDKD PHVVRDGLVSRVL]LRQHGLGRQ$UPDQGR HXURSHURSHUHGLEHQH 3(5/·,1&21752 /D IDPLJOLD =XOLDQL &UHVFHQWH KD RI IHUWR HXUR SHU LO QRVWUR VHWWLPD QDOH/DVLJQRUD9LUJROLQKDRIIHUWR HXURSHUORVWHVVRPRWLYR *5$=,( *OL DQ]LDQL GHO &HQWUR 'RQ 9HFFKL FKH KDQQR XVXIUXLWR GHO VHUYL]LR UL VWRUD]LRQH SUHVVR LO 6HQLRU 5HVWDX UDQWGXUDQWHWXWWRLOPHVHGLDJRVWR ULQJUD]LDQR VHQWLWDPHQWH LO JUXSSR GLYRORQWDULFKHKDJHVWLWREULOODQWH PHQWH LO VHUYL]LR GXUDQWH LO SHULRGR HVWLYR8QDYROWDDQFRUDODFRPXQLWj KDGLPRVWUDWRGLVDSHUHVSULPHUHGDO VXR LQWHUQR SHUVRQH FDSDFL H YROHQ WHURVHGLVSRVWHDIDUVLFDULFRJHQH URVDPHQWHGHOOHHVLJHQ]HGHOSURVVL PRLQGLIÀFROWj4XDORUDODGLUH]LRQH GHO&HQWURGRQ9HFFKLDYHVVHDQFRUD ELVRJQR GL TXHVWD FROODERUD]LRQH SXz FRQWDUH VX TXHVWR YRORQWDULDWR HIÀFLHQWHHJHQHURVR