CRAFT08 paper status
D. Piccolo
Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati INFN
D. Piccolo
meeting RPC Italia - Ischia
september 20-22 2009
1
status
• The final version of the paper can be find on CADI:
http://cms.cern.ch/iCMS/analysisadmin/analysismanagement?awg=
CFT
• First revision from RPC internal referees
– M. Abbrescia and Sijin
• The paper is under review of the ARC: M. Dalla Valle, D. Giordano,
L. Litov, P. Marage
– Several comments received both of technical nature and regarding
style.
• Style modifications done
• Technical comments have required more work: almost all the requests have been
fulfilled
• We are waiting for the final approval of the ARC referees (should arrive in few days)
• As soon as the ARC referees approve the paper, the CMS Collaboration Wide Review
will start
• Main news respect to previews version:
–
–
–
Operation section inserted
Cluster size and residual analysis repeated with a cut on ±20 degrees in angle respect to
perpendicular to RPC plane
Dropped section on HV scan
D. Piccolo
meeting RPC Italia - Ischia
september 20-22 2009
2
•
•
17 pages
16 figures
paper layout
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Introduction
System layout
Detector operation and monitor
Synchronization of RPC data
Detector performance
Conclusions
D. Piccolo
meeting RPC Italia - Ischia
september 20-22 2009
3
Detector monitoring
C. Viviani
D. Piccolo
meeting RPC Italia - Ischia
september 20-22 2009
4
Noise and data synchronization
A. Ocampo
D. Piccolo
M. Konecki
meeting RPC Italia - Ischia
september 20-22 2009
5
Cluster size - 1
C. Carillo
D. Piccolo
meeting RPC Italia - Ischia
september 20-22 2009
6
Cluster size - 2
C. Carillo
Open issues to be better understood:
1 – tails of distributions
2 – asymmetry in cls vs angle:
NOT in the paper
Minimum not at 0
D. Piccolo
meeting RPC Italia - Ischia
september 20-22 2009
7
residuals
Open issue:
RB2in residuals
C. Carillo
D. Piccolo
meeting RPC Italia - Ischia
september 20-22 2009
8
efficiency
C. Carillo, R. Trentadue
D. Piccolo
meeting RPC Italia - Ischia
september 20-22 2009
9
Conclusions
• The paper is in the last stage of approval
from ARC referees
• CMS Collaboration Wide review should
start in the coming days
• Thanks to
– RPC internal referees (M. Abbrescia, Sijin)
– All people contributing with plots, infos
• C. Viviani, A. Ocampo, C. Carrillo, R. Trentadue, S
Tupputi, Sungeen
D. Piccolo
meeting RPC Italia - Ischia
september 20-22 2009
10