,/326,=,21$0(172*36$'81$9,$%$6$7268/6,67(0$67$5),5( 7(6763(5,0(17$/,,102'$/,7$¶67$7,&$(&,1(0$7,&$ $QGUHD&KLRUEROL± 0DUFR*DWWL 'LSDUWLPHQWRGL,QJHJQHULDGHOO¶8QLYHUVLWjGHJOL6WXGLGL)HUUDUDYLD6DUDJDW± )HUUDUD (PDLOPJDWWL#LQJXQLIHLW /DYRURILQDQ]LDWRFRQLQFRQWULEXWL&RILQ5HVSRQVDELOHQD]LRQDOH3URI*LRUJLR0DQ]RQL 5LDVVXQWR /¶DUWLFROR GHVFULYH L WHVW GL ODERUDWRULR H OH SURYH GL FDPSDJQD HVHJXLWLFRQLOVLVWHPD 9%6³6WDU)LUH´FRPPHQWDQGRQHLULVXOWDWLVLDLQWHUPLQLRSHUDWLYLFKHLQWHUPLQLGLDFFXUDWH]]HQHO SRVL]LRQDPHQWR WULGLPHQVLRQDOH , ULVXOWDWL FRQIHUPDQR VLD O¶RSHUDWLYLWj GHO VLVWHPD FKH OH DFFXUDWH]]HGLSRVL]LRQDPHQWRIRUQLWHGDOODOHWWHUDWXUDDQJORVDVVRQH $EVWUDFW7KLVDUWLFOHGHVFULEHVVRPHODERUDWRU\DQGILHOGWHVWVFDUULHGRXWZLWKWKH³6WDUILUH´9%6 V\VWHP 7KH UHVXOWV DUH FRPPHQWHG ERWK RYHU SUDFWLFDO DVSHFWV DQG DFFXUDF\ DVSHFWV LQ WKH WKUHH GLPHQVLRQDO SRVLWLRQLQJ 7KH ILQDO UHVXOWV FRQILUP ERWK IXQFWLRQDO DVSHFWV DQG SRVLWLRQLQJ DFFXUDFLHVUHSRUWHGE\$QJOR6D[RQOLWHUDWXUH 3DUROHFKLDYH9%69566WDU)LUH1DY&RP ,1752'8=,21( /D SRVVLELOLWj GL IRUQLUH XQ VHUYL]LR GL FRUUH]LRQH GLIIHUHQ]LDOH *36 LQ WHPSR UHDOH VYLQFRODQGRVL GDOODSUHVHQ]DGLXQULFHYLWRUH0DVWHUSXzHVVHUHUDJJLXQWDVRORDSDUWLUHGDLQIRUPD]LRQLDFTXLVLWH GDOOHVWD]LRQLSHUPDQHQWLHGHODERUDWHGDXQFRPXQHFHQWURGLFDOFROR 7DOL LQIRUPD]LRQL KDQQR LQIDWWL OD SRVVLELOLWj GL SURGXUUH LQ WHPSR UHDOH OD PRGHOOD]LRQH GHJOL HIIHWWL VLVWHPDWLFL SURSUL GHO SRVL]LRQDPHQWR ³VWDQG DORQH´ FRQVHQWHQGR DG XQ XWHQWH FKH VL WURYL DOO¶LQWHUQRGHOSHULPHWURGDHVVHGHOLPLWDWRSRVL]LRQDPHQWLDXWRQRPLGHWWLDQFKHDGXQDYLDFRQ DFFXUDWH]]H FHQWLPHWULFKH (¶ LO FDVR GHOOH 9%6R GHOOH956ULVSHWWLYDPHQWHDFURQLPRGL9LUWXDO %DVH 6WDWLRQ H GL 9LUWXDO 5HIHUHQFH 6WDWLRQ 6HQ]D HQWUDUH WURSSR QHO GHWWDJOLR H ULPDQGDQGR DOOD ELEOLRJUDILD:XHEHQQDHWDO&LQDHWDO3XJOLDQRHWDOSRVVLDPRGLUHFKHVL WUDWWD GL UHWL GL VWD]LRQL SHUPDQHQWL ORFDOL]]DWH LQ DPELWR UHJLRQDOH FKH LQYLDQR DG XQ FHQWUR GL FRQWUROOR OH LQIRUPD]LRQL DFTXLVLWH GD XQD FRVWHOOD]LRQH GL VDWHOOLWL ,O FHQWUR GL FRQWUROOR HODERUD TXHVWH LQIRUPD]LRQL GHWHUPLQDQGR JOL HUURUL G¶RUELWD H GL DWPRVIHUD GL FXL q DIIHWWR LO SRVL]LRQDPHQWR³VWDQGDORQH´HOLLUUDGLDDJOLXWHQWLPRELOLFKHLQWDOPRGRSRVVRQRGHWHUPLQDUHOD ORUR SRVL]LRQH SUHFLVD 1HOOD YDULDQWH 956 LO ULFHYLWRUH PRELOH WUDVPHWWH OD VXD SRVL]LRQH ³VWDQG DORQH´DOFHQWURGLFDOFRORH QHULFHYHVLDOHFRUUH]LRQLGLIIHUHQ]LDOLFKHOHLQIRUPD]LRQLGLPRGHOOR LQWHUSRODWHRYYHURYLUWXDOPHQWHJHQHUDWHGDXQDVWD]LRQHGLEDVHSRVWDQHOODSRVL]LRQHHTXLYDOHQWHD TXHOODIRUQLWDGDOOR³VWDQGDORQH´ 8QVLVWHPD9%6qLOVLVWHPD6WDU)LUH+DWFKHWDO,OVLVWHPD6WDU)LUHqXQVLVWHPD:LGH $UHD JHVWLWR SULYDWDPHQWH GDOOD 1DY&RP 7HFKQRORJ\ ,QF H GDOOD -RKQ 'HHUH FKH OR KDQQR FRQFHSLWR SHU OH DSSOLFD]LRQL QDYLJD]LRQDOL LQ SDUWLFRODUH SHU LO SRVL]LRQDPHQWR GL IORWWH GL PDFFKLQH RSHUDWULFL 6KDUSH HW DO ,Q TXHVWR PRPHQWR LO VLVWHPD VWD FRQRVFHQGR DQFKH LQ ,WDOLDXQXWLOL]]RVRSUDWWXWWRLQFDPSRWRSRJUDILFRHJHRGHWLFR%RUWX]]R 1HOO¶DPELWR GL XQ¶DWWLYLWj GL ULFHUFD YROWD D VSHULPHQWDUH HG D YDOXWDUH OD TXDOLWj GHO VHJPHQWR GL SRVL]LRQDPHQWR GL XQD IORWWD GL PDFFKLQH RSHUDWULFL *DWWL H 0DODJXWL LO 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL ,QJHJQHULD GHOO¶8QLYHUVLWj GL )HUUDUD KD FRQGRWWR DOFXQH SURYH GL ODERUDWRULR H GL FDPSDJQD VXO VLVWHPD GL SRVL]LRQDPHQWR 6WDU)LUH ,Q TXHVWR DUWLFROR GRSR XQD EUHYH GHVFUL]LRQH GHO VLVWHPD YHQJRQR FRPPHQWDWL L ULVXOWDWL RWWHQXWL GDOOH SURYH VLD LQ WHUPLQL RSHUDWLYL FKH LQ WHUPLQL GL DFFXUDWH]]HQHOSRVL]LRQDPHQWRWULGLPHQVLRQDOH ,/6,67(0$9%667$5),5( ,O VLVWHPD 9LUWXDO %DVH 6WDWLRQ ³6WDU)LUH´ q FRVWLWXLWR GD XQD UHWH GL VWD]LRQL *36 WHUUHVWUL GLVWULEXLWH LQ FRQWLQHQWL &LDVFXQD GL HVVH LQYLD L GDWL *36 H OH LQIRUPD]LRQL GL LQWHJULWj GHL VDWHOOLWLLQYLVWDDGXHFHQWULGLFDOFROR,FHQWULODYRUDQRLQPDQLHUDDXWRQRPDFRPELQDQGRLGDWL JLXQWLGDWXWWHOHVWD]LRQLSHUJHQHUDUHGHOOHFRUUH]LRQLGLIIHUHQ]LDOL/HFRUUH]LRQLYHQJRQRLQYLDWH DOOH VWD]LRQL GL WUDVPLVVLRQH H GD TXHVWH DG DOFXQL VDWHOOLWL GL WHOHFRPXQLFD]LRQH FKH OH ULWUDVPHWWRQRDWWUDYHUVRODEDQGD/DJOLXWLOL]]DWRUL,OVLVWHPD9%6GHOOD6WDU)LUHqFRPSRVWRGDO VHJPHQWRGLFRQWUROORGDOVHJPHQWRGLWUDVPLVVLRQHHGDOVHJPHQWRGLXWLOL]]R)LJXUD )LJXUD6FKHPDGHOVLVWHPD6WDU)LUHGD+DWFKHWDO ,OVHJPHQWRGLFRQWUROORqFRVWLWXLWRGDXQDFLQTXDQWLQDGLVWD]LRQL*36GXHFHQWULGLFDOFRORHGXQ FHQWUR GL WUDVPLVVLRQH GHL GDWL DL VDWHOOLWL &LDVFXQD VWD]LRQH q GRWDWD GL GXH ULFHYLWRUL 1DY&RP 1&7' D GRSSLD IUHTXHQ]D FROOHJDWL DG HQWUDPEL L FHQWUL GL FDOFROR GD GLVSRVLWLYL GL FRPXQLFD]LRQH PRGHP ,6'1 URXWHUV HFF H GD JUXSSL GL FRQWLQXLWj H GL FRQWUROOR UHPRWR GHOO¶DOLPHQWD]LRQH/HVWD]LRQLRSHUDQRLQPRGRLQGLSHQGHQWHULFHYHQGRLOVHJQDOHGDLVDWHOOLWLHG LQYLDQGR L ULVXOWDWL GHO SRVL]LRQDPHQWR DL FHQWUL GL FDOFROR 2OWUH DOOH FRUUH]LRQL GLIIHUHQ]LDOL LQ FRGLFH H IDVH L ULVXOWDWL LQFOXGRQR OD TXDOLWj GHO VHJQDOH VDWHOOLWDUH *36 H /EDQG DOFXQL YDORUL VWDWLVWLFL GL HUURUH O¶HWjGHOOHFRUUH]LRQLGLIIHUHQ]LDOLLO3'23HGDOWULSDUDPHWUL4XHVWLGDWLVRQR FRQWUROODWLGDXQVHUYL]LRDXWRPDWLFRGLDOOHUWDPHQWRLOTXDOHQHOFDVRGLDYDULHQHOVLVWHPDLQYLD PHVVDJJLYLDLQWHUQHWWHOHIRQLFLHID[DOSHUVRQDOHGHOVHUYL]LRGLPDQXWHQ]LRQH 8QD GHOOH FDUDWWHULVWLFKH LQQRYDWLYH GHO VLVWHPD q UDSSUHVHQWDWR GDOO¶DOJRULWPR :&7 :LGH $UHD &RUUHFWLRQ 7UDQVIRUP 8WLOL]]DQGRLGDWLLQGRSSLDIUHTXHQ]DVLDVXLFRGLFLFKHVXOOHSRUWDQWL RVVHUYDWLLQWHPSRUHDOHGDLVDWHOOLWLLQYLVWDVXFLDVFXQDVWD]LRQHILVVDOHHIIHPHULGLWUDVPHVVHH ULFHYXWH GDOOH VWD]LRQL ILVVH LQ WHPSR UHDOH OH FRRUGLQDWH GHL FHQWUL GL IDVH GHOOH DQWHQQH GHOOH 7HFQLFDPHQWH OD SRVVLELOLWj GL WUDVPHWWHUH OD FRUUH]LRQH GLIIHUHQ]LDOH q DVVLFXUDWD GD XQ QXRYR VHJQDOH GLVSRQLELOH RYXQTXHHGLQPRGRFRVWDQWHJUD]LHDLVDWHOOLWLJHRVWD]LRQDUL,Q0DUVDW VWD]LRQLILVVHO¶DOJRULWPR:&7FDOFRODLYDORULGL³SVHXGRUDQJH´FRUUHWWLGDJOLHIIHWWLLRQRVIHULFLH WURSRVIHULFLHYLUWXDOPHQWHSULYLGDHUURULGLPXOWLSDWK4XHVWLYDORULYHQJRQRXOWHULRUPHQWHOLVFLDWL GDJOLHUURULGL³RIIVHW´GHJOLRURORJLGHLULFHYLWRULJHQHUDQGRLQILQHODPHGLDSHVDWDGHOOHFRUUH]LRQL GL³SVHXGRUDQJH´GLFLDVFXQVDWHOOLWHGHWWH³FRUUH]LRQLGLSVHXGRUDQJHZLGHDUHD´/¶LQVLHPHGHOOH FRUUH]LRQLYLHQHFRQYHUWLWRLQPHVVDJJLRELQDULRFRPSUHVVRHGLQYLDWRDLVDWHOOLWLJHRVWD]LRQDULGHO VLVWHPD 8Q ULFHYLWRUH ³URYHU´ LQ GRSSLD IUHTXHQ]D ULFHYH QHOO¶DUHD FRQWLQHQWDOH LQ FXL VL WURYD LO PHVVDJJLR GL FRUUH]LRQH GLIIHUHQ]LDOH H OR DSSOLFD DOOD VXD SRVL]LRQH ³VWDQG DORQH´ RWWHQHQGR SUHFLVLRQLGLSRVL]LRQDPHQWRPDJJLRULHGXQLIRUPL ,YDQWDJJLFKHFRQVHJXRQRGDOODSRVVLELOLWjGLXWLOL]]DUHXQPHVVDJJLR'*36:,'($5($VRQR PLQLPD QHFHVVLWj GL ODUJKH]]D GL EDQGD QHOOD WUDVPLVVLRQH GD VDWHOOLWH JHRVWD]LRQDULR 4XHVWR FRPSRUWDXQDQRWHYROHULGX]LRQHGHLFRVWLQHOO¶XVRGHOVDWHOOLWHJHRVWD]LRQDULRSRLFKpLFDQRQL GL XWLOL]]R VRQR SURSRU]LRQDOL DOOD SRWHQ]D QHFHVVDULD QHOOD WUDVPLVVLRQH OD TXDOH q OHJDWD DOOD ODUJKH]]DGLEDQGD JHVWLRQH GD SDUWH GL XQ XQLFR FHQWUR GL FDOFROR GHOO¶DOJRULWPR GL JHQHUD]LRQH GHOOH FRUUH]LRQH 4XHVWRIRUQLVFHODSRVVLELOLWjGLDJJLRUQDUHHPLJOLRUDUHO¶DOJRULWPRQHLVROLFHQWULGLFRQWUROOR VHQ]DGRYHUPRGLILFDUHLOILUPZDUHGHJOLXWHQWLILQDOLFRPHDYYLHQHQHOODWHFQLFD57.FODVVLFD 1HJOL XOWLPL DQQL GD XQD FROODERUD]LRQH VFLHQWLILFD FRQ LO -3/ GHOOD 1DVD +XGVRQ HW DO q QDWRXQVLVWHPDGLFDOFROREDVDWRVXOFRGLFH*,36<LQJUDGRGLSURGXUUHLQWHPSRUHDOHPHVVDJJL GLFRUUH]LRQL*36GLDOWDTXDOLWjLQIRUPDWRLGRQHRDOODWUDVPLVVLRQHDJOLXWHQWLILQDOL ,SXQWLFKLDYHGHOVLVWHPDGHQRPLQDWR5HDO7LPH*,36<57*VRQRLVHJXHQWL VWLPDGHJOLHUURULGLFLDVFXQVDWHOOLWH*36ULFDOFRODWHRJQLSRFKLVHFRQGL FRUUH]LRQL GHOOH RUELWH GHL VDWHOOLWL *36 DJJLRUQDWH RJQL SRFKL PLQXWL JUD]LH DOOD GLVWULEX]LRQHGHOOHVWD]LRQLGLULIHULPHQWR HODERUD]LRQH GHL GDWL SURYHQLHQWL YLD ,QWHUQHW GDOOD UHWH PRQGLDOH -3/ FRVWLWXLWD GD VWD]LRQLGLULIHULPHQWR ,YDQWDJJLGHULYDQWLGDOODVLQHUJLDGHLGXHDOJRULWPL:&7H57*SRVVRQRHVVHUHFRVuULDVVXQWL OH FRUUH]LRQL VXJOL HUURUL GHJOL RURORJL H GHOOH RUELWH GHL VDWHOOLWL KDQQR YDOHQ]D DVVROXWD TXHVWR VLJQLILFD FKH L VHW GL GDWL FDOFRODWL SHU FLDVFXQ VDWHOOLWH VRQR DSSOLFDELOL DJOL XWHQWL RYXQTXHHVVLVLDQRSRVWL OD DFFXUDF\ RWWHQXWD GDL ULFHYLWRUL *36 LQ GRSSLD IUHTXHQ]D GHJOL XWHQWL ILQDOL V q GLFKLDUDWDLQFLUFDFP ,O VHJPHQWR GL XWLOL]]R)LJXUDqFRVWLWXLWRGDXQ¶DQWHQQDPXOWLIXQ]LRQHLQJUDGRGLULFHYHUHLO VHJQDOH *36 HG L VHJQDOL ,QPDUVDW /¶DQWHQQD q VWDWD FRQFHSLWD SHU IXQ]LRQDUH DQFKH FRQ DQJROL ULGRWWL GL HOHYD]LRQH GHO VDWHOOLWH JHRVWD]LRQDULR GL WUDVPLVVLRQH DPSOLDQGR LQ WDO PRGR O¶DUHD GL IXQ]LRQDPHQWRGDXQULFHYLWRUHLQ/EDQGFKHUHJLVWUDHFRQYHUWHLOPHVVDJJLR6WDU)LUHSURYHQLHQWH GDLVDWHOOLWLJHRVWD]LRQDULHGDXQULFHYLWRUH*36LQGRSSLDIUHTXHQ]D1DY&RPXWLOL]]DELOHDQFKHSHU ULOHYDPHQWL*36FODVVLFL,GXHULFHYLWRULVRQRLQWHJUDWLLQXQXQLFRHOHPHQWR )LJXUD 6HJPHQWR GL XWLOL]]R $ $QWHQQD 7ULEDQG % 5LFHYLWRUH /EDQG SHU OD ULFH]LRQH GHO PHVVDJJLR6WDU)LUH(¶DVVHPEODWRFRQO¶DQWHQQD*36&5LFHYLWRUH*361DY&RP (¶LOFDVRGLVRWWROLQHDUHFKHDOILQHGLDFFHOHUDUHO¶DFTXLVL]LRQHGHOVHJQDOH6WDU)LUHLOULFHYLWRUH 1DY&RP LQYLD DO ULFHYLWRUH LQ /EDQG XQ PHVVDJJLR GL VLQFURQL]]D]LRQH SHU OD FDOLEUD]LRQH GHJOL RVFLOODWRUL /$67580(17$=,21(87,/,==$7$ 'XUDQWH L WHVW VSHULPHQWDOL HVHJXLWL SUHVVR O¶8QLYHUVLWj GL )HUUDUD q VWDWD XWLOL]]DWD OD VHJXHQWH VWUXPHQWD]LRQH)LJXUD XQULFHYLWRUH1DY&RP6)0DFDQDOL//H&$33GLFXLGXHGHGLFDWLDO VLVWHPD:$$6(*1261HOIXQ]LRQDPHQWR³5RYHU57.´qSRVVLELOHODFRGLILFDGHLPHVVDJJL 57&0H&05O¶LQWHUYDOORPLQLPRGLFDPSLRQDPHQWRQHOODYHUVLRQHFKHqVWDWDXWLOL]]DWDq GLVHFRQGR XQDDQWHQQDSHUODULFH]LRQHGHLVHJQDOL*36H6WDU)LUH XQ SDOPDUH L3$4 FRQ VRIWZDUH LWDOLDQR 3I*36 VSHFLILFDWDPHQWH UHDOL]]DWRSHUO¶XWLOL]]R FRQLOVLVWHPD6WDU)LUH )LJXUD 6WUXPHQWD]LRQH XWLOL]]DWD QHOOH SURYH DQWHQQD ULFHYLWRUH 1DY&RP 6)0 SDOPDUH FRQ VRIWZDUH 3I*36 1HO ULTXDGUR L ³OHG´ UHODWLYL DOOD TXDOLWj GHO FROOHJDPHQWR 6WDU)LUH H TXHOOL DVVRFLDWLDOSRVL]LRQDPHQWR*36 '(6&5,=,21('(,7(67 7HVWSUHOLPLQDUL $OILQHGLYHULILFDUHODULSHWLELOLWjGHOSRVL]LRQDPHQWRLQWHPSRUHDOHVLqHIIHWWXDWRXQSULPRWHVWLQ PRGDOLWjVWDWLFDSRQHQGRO¶DQWHQQDGHOULFHYLWRUH6WDU)LUHVXXQYHUWLFHGLFRRUGLQDWHQRWH)LJXUD ,O YHUWLFH q PDWHULDOL]]DWR VXO WHWWR GHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL,QJHJQHULDGHOO¶8QLYHUVLWjGL)HUUDUDD ILDQFR GHOO¶DQWHQQD GHOOD VWD]LRQH SHUPDQHQWH *36 /H VXH FRRUGLQDWH VRQR QRWH FRQ SUHFLVLRQH FHQWLPHWULFD )LJXUD 0RQXPHQWD]LRQH GHOOD VWD]LRQH *36 GL )HUUDUD ,Q HYLGHQ]D O¶DQWHQQD GHO ULFHYLWRUH 6WDU)LUH /D UHJLVWUD]LRQH GHOOH SRVL]LRQL VWDWLFKH q VWDWD JHVWLWD PHGLDQWH LO VRIWZDUH 3I*36 UHVLGHQWH VX SDOPDUH&RPSDTL3$4FROOHJDWRFRQXQDSRUWDVHULDOHGHOULFHYLWRUH,OVRIWZDUH3I*36YLVXDOL]]D OH FRRUGLQDWH *36 DVVRFLDQGR D FLDVFXQ HSRFD XQ LQGLFH GL TXDOLWj JOREDOH 7DOH LQGLFH SUHYHGH YDORULFRPSUHVLIUDSRVL]LRQDPHQWRSHVVLPRHSRVL]LRQDPHQWRRWWLPR,OULFHYLWRUH)LJXUD qGRWDWRGLGXHEORFFKLFRVWLWXLWLFLDVFXQRGDWUHOHGOXPLQRVL,OSULPREORFFRLQGLFDODTXDOLWj GHO VHJQDOH GHOOD WUDVPLVVLRQH GHOOH FRUUH]LRQL GLIIHUHQ]LDOL PHQWUH LO VHFRQGR q DVVRFLDWR DOOD WLSRORJLD GHO SRVL]LRQDPHQWR LQ DWWR DXWRQRPR FRQ FRUUH]LRQL (*126 FRQ FRUUH]LRQL6WDU)LUH 4XHVW¶XOWLPDLQIRUPD]LRQHqSUHVHQWHSXUHQHOODVFKHUPDWDGL3I*36 $OO¶DFFHQVLRQHGHOULFHYLWRUHVLDVVLVWHDOVXVVHJXLUVLFRQFDGHQ]DGLFLUFDXQPLQXWRIUDXQHYHQWR HG LO VXFFHVVLYR GHO SRVL]LRQDPHQWR DXWRQRPR *36 GHOOD ULFH]LRQH H GHO SRVL]LRQDPHQWR DWWUDYHUVR LO VHJQDOH (*126 H GHO GHILQLWLYR DJJDQFLR GHO VHJQDOH 6WDU)LUH /¶LQWHUR SURFHVVR ULFKLHGH LQ FDPSR DSHUWR FLUFD WUH PLQXWL 3HUWDQWR GXUDQWH O¶HODERUD]LRQH GHL GDWL GHO SRVL]LRQDPHQWR VWDWLFR VL VRQR HVFOXVL L SULPL GLHFL PLQXWL GL UHJLVWUD]LRQH DO ILQH GL RWWHQHUH SRVL]LRQLGHULYDQWLHVFOXVLYDPHQWHGDOVLVWHPD6WDU)LUH 3HU TXHVWR WHVW HVHJXLWR QHO VHWWHPEUH VRQR VWDWH HIIHWWXDWH LQ WXWWR SURYH FRQ GXUDWD YDULDELOHIUDHRUHHGLQWHUYDOOLGLFDPSLRQDPHQWRGLHVHFRQGL1HOODWDEHOODYHQJRQR SUHVHQWDWLLULVXOWDWLULSRUWDQGRLQVLHPHDOODGXUDWDGHOODVHVVLRQHGLUHJLVWUD]LRQHHGDOO¶LQWHUYDOORGL FDPSLRQDPHQWRODGLIIHUHQ]DWUDOHFRRUGLQDWHGHOYHUWLFHQRWHDSULRULHTXHOOHPHGLHUHJLVWUDWHHG LOIDWWRUHGLTXDOLWj/HGLIIHUHQ]HHGLORURHTPVRQRHVSUHVVHQHOODWHUQDWRSRFHQWULFD 3URYD ,QWHUYDOORGL 'XUDWD FDPSLRQDPHQWR VHFRQGL V V V V K K G1r r VG1P r r r r r r 7DEHOOD5LVXOWDWLGHLWHVWVWDWLFLSUHOLPLQDUL )DWWRUHGL TXDOLWj G(r r VG( P G8r r VG8P PHGLR r r r r r r r r r r r r /HSUHFLVLRQLGHOOHFRPSRQHQWLSODQLPHWULFDHGDOWLPHWULFDULVXOWDQRLQOLQHDFRQTXHOOLULSRUWDWLLQ OHWWHUDWXUD6KDUSHHWDO+DWFKHWDO ,QILQH D WHVWLPRQLDUH FKH LO VLVWHPD q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jFLQHPDWLFD 1HOODSULPDSURYDO¶DQWHQQDGHOULFHYLWRUH*366WDU)LUHqVWDWDUHVDVROLGDOHDOODSDUWHPRELOHGLXQ FDUUHOORHOHYDWRUH)LJXUD,OFDUUHOORqLQJUDGRGLHIIHWWXDUHXQDWUDVOD]LRQHXWLOHGDOILQHFRUVD LQIHULRUHDOILQHFRUVDVXSHULRUHGL FLUFDP6RQRVWDWHHIIHWWXDWLFLFOLGLPLVXUD]LRQHFLDVFXQR GHLTXDOLFRVWLWXLWRGD FLUFDHSRFKHGLUHJLVWUD]LRQHVWDWLFKHRWWHQXWHFRQO¶DQWHQQDIHUPDQHOILQHFRUVDVXSHULRUH XQDWUDVOD]LRQHYHUVRLOILQHFRUVDLQIHULRUHDOODYHORFLWjPHGLDGLFPV XQULWRUQRDOILQHFRUVDVXSHULRUHDOODPHGHVLPDYHORFLWj 3HUWXWWDODSURYDO¶LQWHUYDOORGLFDPSLRQDPHQWRqVWDWRLPSRVWDWRDGVHFRQGR )LJXUD/DSURYDVXFDUUHOORHOHYDWRUH 1HOODSURYDqVWDWDDQDOL]]DWDODULSHWLELOLWjGHOOHFRRUGLQDWHUHJLVWUDWHGDOULFHYLWRUHQHOODSRVL]LRQH GHOILQHFRUVDVXSHULRUHRFFXSDWRDOO¶LQL]LRGLFLDVFXQFLFOR)LJXUD /H GHYLD]LRQL VWDQGDUG ULVSHWWR DOOD PHGLD GHO FDPSLRQH GL FRRUGLQDWH LVWDQWDQHH HVSUHVVH LQ FRRUGLQDWHWRSRFHQWULFKHVRQR ULSRUWDWHQHOOD7DEHOOD 3RVL]LRQLLVWDQWDQHH LQXQJHQHULFRFLFOR 9DORULPHGLGHOOHSRVL]LRQL QHLFLFOL 1RUG>FP@ 1RUG>FP@ (VW>FP@ (VW>FP@ )LJXUD $ VLQLVWUD YDORUL PHGL GHOOH SRVL]LRQL SODQLPHWULFKH ULOHYDWH LQ FLDVFXQR GHL FLFOL /¶RULJLQH FRUULVSRQGH DOOD SRVL]LRQH PHGLD FRPSOHVVLYD FDOFRODWD VX WXWWL L FLFOL $ GHVWUD GLVWULEX]LRQHGHOOHSRVL]LRQLLVWDQWDQHHFDPSLRQDWHLQXQVLQJRORFLFOR V( V1 VK r P r P r P 7DEHOOD(TPYDOXWDWLVXOOHSRVL]LRQLVWDWLFKHQHOILQHFRUVDVXSHULRUH $QFKH QHOOD VHFRQGD SURYD O¶DQWHQQD HUD VROLGDOH DOOD SDUWH PRELOH GHO FDUUHOOR HOHYDWRUH PD LQ TXHVWRFDVRYHQLYDHIIHWWXDWDXQDWUDVOD]LRQHRUL]]RQWDOHGHOFDUUHOORVWHVVRFRQXQDFRUVDXWLOHGL r FP TXHVW¶XOWLPR YDORUH q VWDWR PLVXUDWR VX XQD PHGLD GL GHWHUPLQD]LRQL HIIHWWXDWH FRQXQDVWD]LRQHWRWDOH 6RQRVWDWLHIIHWWXDWLFLFOLGLUHJLVWUD]LRQLLQWHUYDOORGLFDPSLRQDPHQWRGLVHFRQGRFLDVFXQR FRQVLVWHQWH LQ XQ SRVL]LRQDPHQWR VWDWLFR LQ XQ HVWUHPR GHOOD GXUDWD PHGLDGLHSRFKHVHJXLWR GDOOD WUDVOD]LRQH GHOO¶DQWHQQD DOOD YHORFLWj PHGLD GL FPV YHUVR O¶HVWUHPR RSSRVWR H ULFDPSLRQDPHQWR VHPSUH GL HSRFKH DQFKH LQ TXHVW¶XOWLPD SRVL]LRQH 6RQR VWDWH RWWHQXWH FRSSLH GL FRRUGLQDWH WRSRFHQWULFKH SLDQH SHU FLDVFXQR GHL GXH HVWUHPL $ SDUWLUH GD TXHVWH FRRUGLQDWHVL VRQRFDOFRODWHGLVWDQ]HIRUQLWHGDOOHFRPELQD]LRQLGLFRRUGLQDWHPLVXUDWHQHLVROL FLFOL WHPSRUDOPHQWH FRQVHFXWLYL ,QROWUH VL VRQR FDOFRODWH OH GLVWDQ]H LQ QXPHUR VXSHULRUH D RWWHQXWHGDOOHSHUPXWD]LRQLGLWXWWHOHFRSSLHGLFRRUGLQDWHRWWHQXWH1HOODWDEHOODVRQRULSRUWDWLL ULVXOWDWL GHOOD SURYD VRWWR IRUPD GL OXQJKH]]D GL GLVWDQ]D WUD L GXH HVWUHPL TXHVW¶XOWLPD q VWDWD GHGRWWD GDOOD UDGLFH TXDGUDWD GHOOD VRPPD GHOOH GLIIHUHQ]H GL FRRUGLQDWH SLDQH WRSRFHQWULFKH HOHYDWHDOTXDGUDWR 6RORWUDVOD]LRQL FRQVHFXWLYH 7XWWHOH FRPELQD]LRQL 1XPHURGL RVVHUYD]LRQL 'LVWDQ]D 'LVWDQ]D0LQ 'LVWDQ]D0D[ PHGLD 1DY&RPFP 1DY&RPFP 1DY&RPFP r r 7DEHOOD 3URYD GL WUDVOD]LRQH RUL]]RQWDOH FRQ FRUVD HIIHWWLYD GL r FP /H GLVWDQ]H VRQR ULIHULWHDOSLDQRWRSRFHQWULFR &RPH HPHUJH GDL ULVXOWDWL GHOOD SURYD OH GLVWDQ]H FDOFRODWH DWWUDYHUVR OH FRRUGLQDWH 6WDU)LUH UHJLVWUDWHQHOOHGXHSRVL]LRQLHVWUHPHULVXOWDQRSURVVLPHDOODOXQJKH]]DGHOODEDVHGLFDOLEUD]LRQH FP 4XHVWR FRQIHUPD FKH O¶HYHQWXDOH HUURUH ³VLVWHPDWLFR´ GL FXL VRQR DIIHWWH OH FRRUGLQDWH UHJLVWUDWH QRQ SXz FKH HVVHUH OR VWHVVR LQ GXH SRVL]LRQL YLFLQH 7DOH HUURUH YLHQH HOLPLQDWR DWWUDYHUVRODGLIIHUHQ]DGHOOHFRUULVSRQGHQWLFRRUGLQDWH 7HVWLQPRGDOLWjGLWUDFFLDPHQWR ,QTXHVWDSURYDVLqYROXWDWHVWDUHODFDSDFLWjGHOULFHYLWRUH6WDU)LUHDULSHWHUHSLYROWHXQDVWHVVD WUDLHWWRULD3HUUHDOL]]DUHLOWHVWqVWDWRPDWHULDOL]]DWRXQDOOLQHDPHQWRGDOODOXQJKH]]DGLFLUFD P /¶ DOOLQHDPHQWR HUD FRVWLWXLWR GD GXH SLFFKHWWL PHWDOOLFL IUD LTXDOLqVWDWRSRVWRXQILORWHVRD WHUUD)LJXUD )LJXUD3DUWLFRODUHGHOO¶DOOLQHDPHQWR6WUXPHQWD]LRQHXVDWDSHUSURYH ,OSHUFRUVRUHWWLOLQHRqVWDWRSHUFRUVRSLYROWHSRQHQGRO¶DVWDSRUWDDQWHQQDGHOULFHYLWRUH6WDU)LUH DO GL VRSUD GHO ILOR WHVR 'XUDQWH GXH GHOOH FLQTXH SURYH FRPSOHVVLYDPHQWH HVHJXLWH OH SRVL]LRQL UHJLVWUDWH YHQLYDQR LQYLDWH LQ WHPSR UHDOH DG XQ WHUPLQDOH UHPRWR FKH OH YLVXDOL]]DYD VX XQD FDUWRJUDILD GL EDVH /D WUDVPLVVLRQH GHOOH FRRUGLQDWH q VWDWD HIIHWWXDWD DWWUDYHUVR XQD FRSSLD GL PRGHP *60 , ULVXOWDWL GL XQD GHOOH FLQTXH SURYH VRQR ULDVVXQWL QHO JUDILFR GL ILJXUD ,Q SDUWLFRODUH LO JUDILFR HYLGHQ]LD OH GLVSHUVLRQL GHOOH SRVL]LRQL UHJLVWUDWH VXO SHUFRUVR 3RLFKp O¶DVVH GHOOH DVFLVVH FRLQFLGH FRQ O¶DOOLQHDPHQWR PDWHULDOL]]DWR VL SXz QRWDUH FKH OH SRVL]LRQL UHJLVWUDWH VRQRLQWHUQHDGXQDIDVFLDGLDPSLH]]DPFLUFDFHQWUDWDVXOO¶DVVHVWHVVR$QDORJKLULVXOWDWLVL VRQRRWWHQXWLDQFKH SHUOHDOWUHSURYH ,OWHVWKDLQGHILQLWLYDHYLGHQ]LDWRODFDSDFLWjGHOVLVWHPD6WDU)LUHGLWUDFFLDUHLQWHPSRUHDOHGHOOH SRVL]LRQLLQPRYLPHQWRFRQSUHFLVLRQLLQWRUQRDOYDORUHGLDPSLH]]DLQGLFDWR 'LVWDQ]D GDOO DOOLQHDPHQWR >P@ 3URYDQ 3HUFRUVRQ 3LFFKHWWL 'LVWDQ]DSURJUHVVLYDVXOO DOOLQHDPHQWR>P@ )LJXUD5LVXOWDWLGHOODSURYDQGHOWHVWGLWUDFFLDPHQWR/¶DVVH[FRLQFLGHFRQODGLUH]LRQHGHO ILORWHVRDWHUUD &RQIURQWLWUDLOVLVWHPD6WDU)LUHHGXQVLVWHPD57.FODVVLFR 1HOO¶XOWLPD VHULH GL WHVW VL VRQR FRQIURQWDWH OH SUHVWD]LRQL GHOOR 6WDU)LUH FRQ XQVLVWHPD 57. WUDGL]LRQDOH,QVLHPHDOULFHYLWRUH6WDU)LUHVRQRVWDWLXVDWLGXHULFHYLWRUL7RSFRQPRGHOOR2G\VVH\ H /HJDF\ ( ,O ULFHYLWRUH 2G\VVH\ IXQJHYD GD 0DVWHU HG LUUDGLDYD OH FRUUH]LRQL GLIIHUHQ]LDOL LQ IRUPDWR 57&0 VXOOD UHWH ,QWHUQHW ,O ULFHYLWRUH /HJDF\ ( IXQJHYD GD 5RYHU ,O ³OLQN´ WUD L GXH ULFHYLWRULqVWDWRUHVRSRVVLELOHGDXQSDOPDUH&RPSDTL3$4FRQPRGXOR*3568QVHFRQGR SDOPDUH3VLRQP[FRQVRIWZDUH)LHOG)DFHqVWDWRXWLOL]]DWRSHUODJHVWLRQHHO¶DUFKLYLD]LRQHGHO ULOHYDPHQWR57.)LJXUD )LJXUD3DUWLFRODUHGHOODGRWD]LRQHVWUXPHQWDOHGHOODVWD]LRQH³5RYHU´FRPSXWHUSDOPDUHL3$4 FRQ PRGXOR *356 ULFHYLWRUH 7RSFRQ /HJDF\( FRPSXWHU SDOPDUH 3VLRQ P[ HG DQWHQQD FLQHPDWLFD/HJDQW( , ULOHYDPHQWL VRQR VWDWL HVHJXLWLLQ GXH DUHH XUEDQH GLVWLQWH ,O SULPR VL q VYROWR SUHVVR XQ SDUFR XUEDQRDFLUFDNPGDOODVWD]LRQH0DVWHU,QTXHVWRWHVWODSUHVHQ]DGLILODULGLDOEHULDGDOWRIXVWR KDLPSHGLWRO¶HVHFX]LRQHGHOULOHYDPHQWR57.FRPSOHWR,OULOHYDPHQWRHVHJXLWRFRQOR6WDU)LUHKD LQYHFH WUDFFLDWR FRUUHWWDPHQWH L SRFKL VDWHOOLWL LQ YLVWD GHQXQFLDQGR SDUDPHWUL GL DFTXLVL]LRQH GL EXRQDTXDOLWj,QSRVWHODERUD]LRQHLOULVXOWDWRGHOOR6WDU)LUHVLqSHUzULYHODWRPHGLRFUHQRQRVWDQWH IRVVHURVWDWHVHOH]LRQDWHOHSRVL]LRQL FRQIDWWRUHGLTXDOLWjJOREDOHVXSHULRUHD ,OVHFRQGRULOHYDPHQWRVLqVYROWRSUHVVRLOSDUFKHJJLRLQWHUQRGHOOD)DFROWjGL,QJHJQHULDDSRFKH FHQWLQDLDGLPHWULGDOODVWD]LRQH0DVWHU'XUDQWHOHRSHUD]LRQLGLPLVXUDVLVRQRULOHYDWHSLYROWHOH SRVL]LRQL GL YHUWLFL PDWHULDOL]]DWL VXOOD SDYLPHQWD]LRQH GHO SDUFKHJJLR 6RQR VWDWL HIIHWWXDWL ULOHYDPHQWL57.FODVVLFLXQULOHYDPHQWRFRQLOVLVWHPD6WDU)LUHHGXQULOHYDPHQWRFRQXQDVWD]LRQH WRWDOH,ULVXOWDWL7DEHOODH)LJXUDGHQXQFLDQRVFRVWDPHQWLPHGLGLFLUFDFPSLPDUFDWL OXQJRODFRPSRQHQWH1RUG &RQIURQWR 57.± 57. 6WDU)LUH± 57. 6WDU)LUH± 57. '(P FP r r r '1P FP r r r 7DEHOOD &RQIURQWR GHL ULOLHYL HVHJXLWL FRQ WHFQLFKH 57. H 6WDU)LUH VX SXQWL EDWWXWL ,' VL ULIHULVFRQRDOODPHGLDGHOOHGLIIHUHQ]HGHOOHFRRUGLQDWHUHJLVWUDWHVXLYHUWLFL 1RUG>P@ 6WDUILUH 57.VHULH 57.VHULH (VW>P@ )LJXUD5LVXOWDWRGHLULOLHYLHVHJXLWLFRQWHFQLFKH57.H6WDU)LUHVXSXQWLULOHYDWL ,Q VHJXLWR JOL VWHVVL SXQWL VRQR VWDWL ULEDWWXWL FRQ XQD VWD]LRQH WRWDOH ,Q TXHVWR PRGR q VWDWR SRVVLELOHFRQIURQWDUHDQFKHOHGLIIHUHQ]HGLTXRWDGHLYHUWLFLRWWHQXWHFRQOHGLIIHUHQWLWHFQLFKHGL PLVXUDHVWUXPHQWD]LRQH7DEHOOD &RQIURQWR 57.± 57. 6WDU)LUH± 57. 6WDU)LUH± 57. 6WDU)LUH 6WD]WRW 57.6WD]WRW 57.6WD]WRW '+FP r r r r r r 7DEHOOD&RQIURQWLVXOOHGLIIHUHQ]HGLTXRWDHORURHTP ,O FRQIURQWR GHL ULVXOWDWL RWWHQXWL FRQ LO VLVWHPD 6WDU)LUH H FRQ OH DOWUH WHFQLFKH GL PLVXUD FRQIHUPDQROHSUHFLVLRQLGLFKLDUDWH $QFKHSHULWHPSLGLULOHYDPHQWR7DEHOODOHGXUDWHVRQRVRVWDQ]LDOPHQWHFRQIURQWDELOLWHQXWR FRQWRFKHDOFRQWUDULRGHOVLVWHPD57.OR 6WDU)LUHULFKLHGHXQWHPSRGLLQL]LDOL]]D]LRQHFLUFD PLQXWLSLOXQJR 57. 57. 6WDU)LUH 1XP3XQWL 7DEHOOD'XUDWDGHOULOHYDPHQWR 'XUDWDULOLHYR PLQ PLQ PLQ (SRFKHFDPSLRQDWHSHU FLDVFXQSXQWR &21&/86,21, 1HOO¶DPELWR GHOOH SURYH HIIHWWXDWH QHOOD SUHVHQWH DWWLYLWj GL ULFHUFD LO VLVWHPD 6WDU)LUH VL q GLPRVWUDWRWDQWRSLDIILGDELOHTXDQWRSLVRQRDFFXUDWHOHRSHUD]LRQLGLLQL]LDOL]]D]LRQH /H SUHFLVLRQL GHULYDWH GDL WHVW VRQR FRQJUXHQWL FRQ TXHOOH LQGLFDWH LQ OHWWHUDWXUD WUD L FP GL DFFXUDWH]]DQHOODFRPSRQHQWHSODQLPHWULFDWUDLFPSHUTXHOODDOWLPHWULFD /H SUHFLVLRQL QHO SRVL]LRQDPHQWR LQ WHPSR UHDOH HG LQ TXHOOR GLQDPLFR QRQ VRQR TXLQGL DQFRUD SDUDJRQDELOLFRQTXHOOHRWWHQLELOLFRQXQULOHYDPHQWR57.FODVVLFRYDSHUzVRWWROLQHDWRFKHQHOOH VWHVVHFRQGL]LRQLRSHUDWLYHLOVLVWHPD6WDU)LUHKDLOYDQWDJJLRGLSRWHUJHVWLUHLOULOHYDPHQWRFRQXQ VRORULFHYLWRUHHFRQWHPSLDYHQWLGXUDWHFRPSDUDELOL ,OVLVWHPDFRQFHSLWRQHOVXRFRPSOHVVRSHULOWUDFFLDPHQWRGLYHLFROLqVHQ]¶DOWURLGRQHRDQFKHSHU O¶HIIHWWXD]LRQHGLULOHYDPHQWLWRSRJUDILFLFODVVLFL ,QILQH O¶XWLOL]]R GHO VHUYL]LR 6WDU)LUH q VXERUGLQDWR DOOD VRWWRVFUL]LRQH GL XQ DEERQDPHQWR LO FXL FRVWR FLUFD ¼DQQR q WXWWDYLD ODUJDPHQWH FRPSHQVDWR GDOOH VHPSOLILFD]LRQL SURGRWWH QHOO¶DWWLYLWjGHOULOLHYR 5,1*5$=,$0(17, *OLDXWRULSRUJRQRXQVHQWLWRULQJUD]LDPHQWRDO6LJ0DUFR0DUFKHVLQLGHOOD'LWWD*XLGR9HURQHVL VUO GL %RORJQD SHU DYHU UHVR SRVVLELOH O¶HVHFX]LRQH GL TXHVWD VSHULPHQWD]LRQH PHWWHQGR D GLVSRVL]LRQHODVWUXPHQWD]LRQH*361DY&RP6WDU)LUH %,%/,2*5$),$ %RUWX]]R$³3URFHGXUHHULVXOWDWLGLYHULILFDUHODWLYLDLQXRYLULFHYLWRUL*361DYFRQFRQ FRUUH]LRQLGLIIHUHQ]LDOL67$5),5('*36´*HRPHGLDQSS &LQD $ 0DQ]LQR $ 3LUDV 0 5RJJHUR 0 ³6WLPD GL &RUUH]LRQL GLIIHUHQ]LDOL QHO SRVL]LRQDPHQWR *36 0XOWL 5HIHUHQFH 6WDWLRQ´ 9,, &RQIHUHQ]D 1D]LRQDOH $6,7$ 9HURQD RWWREUH *DWWL00DODJXWL)³5HPRWH&RQWURODQG$XWRPDWLF0RQLWRULQJRIWKH*URXQG0RYLQJ 0DFKLQHV LQ WKH 5RDG &RQVWUXFWLRQV´ 3URFHHGLQJV RI WKH WK ,QWHUQDWLRQDO 6\PSRVLXP RQ $XWRPDWLRQ 5RERWLFV LQ &RQVWUXFWLRQ ,6$5& 6HSWHPEHU (LQGRYHQ 1HGHUODQGV 3XJOLDQR*$OYHV3&DQQRQ0(/DFKDSHOOH*³9DOXWD]LRQHGHOOHSUHVWD]LRQLGLXQ DSSURFFLR PXOWLUHIHUHQFH VWDWLRQ DYDQ]DWR SHU OD QDYLJD]LRQH GLIIHUHQ]LDOH´ $WWL GHOO¶,VWLWXWR ,WDOLDQRGL1DYLJD]LRQHQSS +DWFK 5 6KDUSH 7 *DO\HDQ 3 ³6WDU)LUH $ *OREDO +LJK $FFXUDF\ 'LIIHUHQWLDO *36 6\VWHP´ WK ,QWHUQDWLRQDO 6\PSRVLXP RQ *36*166 DW :XKDQ 8QLYHUVLW\ 1RYHPEHU &LQD +XGVRQ5-6KDUS7´*OREDOO\&RUUHFWHG*36*F*36&1DY*366\VWHP´'\QDPLF 3RVLWLRQLQJ&RQIHUHQFH6HSWHPEHU 6KDUSH 7 +DWFK 5 1HOVRQ ) ³-RKQ 'HHUH¶V 6WDU)LUH 6\VWHP :$'*36 IRU 3UHFLVLRQ $JULFXOWXUH´WK ,QWHUQDWLRQDO0HHWLQJRIWKH6DWHOOLWH'LYLVLRQRIWKH,21,QVWLWXWHRI1DYLJDWLRQ 6HSWHPEHU6DOW/DNH&LW\86$ :XHEHQQD*(XOHU+-.HHQDQ&5=HEKDXVHU%(³6WXG\RID6LPSOLILHG$SSURDFK LQ8WLOL]LQJ,QIRUPDWLRQIUR3HUPDQHQW5HIHUHQFH6WDWLRQ$UUD\V´/HLFD*HRV\VWHPVSDSHU