81 ),/262)2 1(//$&$6$'(, 3$==, $XJXVWH&RPWHSD]LHQWHGL(VTXLURO 1HOODSULPDYHUD GHO $XJXVWH&RPWH DIIHWWR GDXQD FULVLGL PDQLDPDOLQFRQLD ² HJOLVWHVVRODGHILQLUjSLWDUGL©XQHFULVHFpUp EUDOHª ² YLHQH ULFRYHUDWR QHOOD FOLQLFD SULYDWD GHO GRWWRU(VTXLURO DOOD UXH GH %XIIRQ GL IURQWH DOOD 6DOSrWULqUH &RPH VL q JLj GHWWR (VTXLUROODGLULJHYDDVVLHPHDXQVXRQLSRWHO DOLHQLVWD-XOHV0LWLYLp FKH DLXWHUjLOFHOHEUH]LR DQFKHQHOODJHVWLRQHGHOOD FOLQLFDSULYDWDGL ,YU\ DSHUWDQHO &RPWH HQWUD GXQTXH QHOOD 0DLVRQ GH 6DQWp GHOOD UXH GH%XIIRQ QHOO DSULOHGHO SRFR GRSR DYHULQL]LDWR ² FRPHDSSUHQGLDPR GD+HQUL*RXKLHU ²LOVXR&RXUVGHSKLORVRSKLHSRVLWLYHQHOVXRDS SDUWDPHQWR DOQ GHOODUXHGX)DXERXUJ0RQWPDUWUH'RPHQLFD DSULOH DPH]]RJLRUQR &RPWHWHQQHODVXDSULPDOH]LRQH'RSROD WHU]DVpDQFHLO&RXUVYHQQHLQWHUURWWRDFDXVDGHOODFULVLFHUHEUDOHVR SUD ULFRUGDWD &RPWH WRUQHUj DOOD VXDYLWDQRUPDOH VROR DOODILQH GHO O DQQRLQFXLGRSRODFULVLGHO DYHYDFHUFDWRGLVXLFLGDUVL *LRYD ULFRUGDUH FKHDQFKH 6DLQW6LPRQ VXRPDHVWURWUDLO HLO DYHYDWHQWDWRLOVXLFLGLR TXDWWURDQQLSULPD 1HO (VTXLURO QHOOD SLHQH]]D GHOOD VXD PDWXULWj VFLHQWLILFD ² DYHYD DQQLHGDOFXQLWUDLVXRLSLLPSRUWDQWLODYRULHUDQRJLj XVFLWLQHO©'LFWLRQQDLUH GHV VFLHQFHVPpGLFDOHVª GL3DQFNRXFNH ² LQFRQWUD TXLQGL &RPWH DOORUDYHQWRWWHQQH FRPH GHJHQWH GHOOD VXD 0DLVRQGH6DQWH /RULYHGUjGLQXRYRLOJHQQDLRGHO QHOVXR )RQGDPHQWDOHLOODYRURGL+ *RXKLHU/DMHXQHVVHG $XJXVWH&RPWHHWODQDLVVDQFHGX SRVLWLYLVPH3DULV9ULQ YROO /( 3$66,21, ( /$ 6725,$ QXRYRDSSDUWDPHQWRDO GHOODUXH6DLQW-DFTXHVOu&RPWHDYHYD ULSUHVRLOVXR&RXUVLQWHUURWWRWUHDQQLSULPD DOODSUHVHQ]DGLPROWL LQWHOOHWWXDOL H VFLHQ]LDWL IDPRVL WUD FXL )RXULHU VHJUHWDULR SHUSHWXR GHOO¶$FDGpPLHGHV 6FLHQFHVGH%ODLQYLOOH3RLQVRWH1DYLHUPHPEUL GHOO $FDGpPLH %URXVVDLV ORVWHVVR(VTXLUROH%LQHW 1HOODSUHID]LR QHDOSULPRYROXPHGHO&RXUVGHO &RPWHHOHQFDFRQRUJRJOLR WDOLQRPLSUHVWLJLRVLSUHVHQWLWUDLOVXRXGLWRULR©DX[TXHOV²HJOLDI IHUPD ² MH GRLV LFL WpPRLJQHU SXEOLTXHPHQW PD UHFRQQDLVVDQFH SRXUOD PDQLqUH GRQW LOV RQW DFFXHLOOLFHWWHQRXYHOOHWHQWDWLYHSKLOR VRSKLTXHª &LWD GXQTXH FRQ RUJRJOLR H GHIHUHQ]DOR VWHVVR (VTXL URO FKHOR DYHYD FRQRVFLXWR FRPHSD]LHQWH H DOTXDOHSLWDUGL ² QHOODIDPRVD3UpIDFHSHUVRQQHOOHDOVHVWRWRPRGHO&RXUVHQHO /µ$SSHQGLFH DO TXDUWR WRPR GHO VXR 6\VWqPH GH SROLWLTXH SRVLWLYH ² ULYROJHUj FULWLFKHPROWRSHVDQWL LQ UHOD]LRQH DOOD VXDGH JHQ]D GHO 4XHVWDGXQTXHODFRUQLFHGHJOLDYYHQLPHQWLFRVuFRPHFLYLHQH UHVWLWXLWDGDOODSRFKHPDHORTXHQWLIRQWLGLVSRQLELOL ,QWDOHFRQWHVWR VL VLWXDO HSLVRGLRFHQWUDOHDLILQLGHOODQRVWUDDQDOLVL O DIIURQWDPHQWR GLUHWWR WUD LOPHGLFR DOO LQWHUQR GHOUHFLQWR DVLODUH HLOILORVRIR 8Q HSLVRGLRULFFRGLYDOHQ]HVLPEROLFKHGDOTXDOHYRUUHPPRSDUWLUHSHU PHWWHUHDIXRFRDOFXQLSUREOHPLGLFDUDWWHUHVLDWHRULFRFKHSROLWLFR UHODWLYLDOODSVLFKLDWULDQDVFHQWH / DIIURQWDPHQWR WUDO DOLHQLVWD HLOILORVRIR VHPEUDGDYYHUR GUDP PDWLFR VHQ]D HVFOXVLRQH GL FROSL 6WDQGR DOOD ULFRVWUX]LRQH GHO :HWWOH\ (VTXLURODWWULEXuD&RPWHXQDSDUWLFRODUHIRUPDGLPRQR PDQLD ² OD PHJDORPRQLD R GHOLULR GLJUDQGH]]D ² FRQVLGHUDWDLQ TXHOO HSRFD FRPH XQD PDODWWLD GLIILFLOPHQWH FXUDELOH 8Q LQIOXHQ]D GLUHWWDGL&RPWHVX(VTXLURO ² FRPHSUHWHQGH'|UQHU ² SXzHV VHUH UDJLRQHYROPHQWH HVFOXVD SHU UDJLRQL GL IRQGR FKH HVDPLQHUH PRSLDYDQWLPDDQFKHSHUUDJLRQLFRQWLQJHQWLHELRJUDILFKH'RSR &IU$&RPWH&RXUVGHSKLORVRSKLHSRVLWLYH3DULV5RXHQIUqUHV W ,,OWRPRD FDXVD GHOIDOOLPHQWR GHOO HGLWRUH YLHQH ULVWDPSDWRWUH DQQL GRSR GD%DFKHOLHU D3DULJL VHP SUH FRQODGDWDGHO 6LYHGDO LPSRUWDQWHDQWRORJLDFXUDWDGD+HQUL*RXKLHU $ &RPWH (XYUHVFKRLVLHV 3DULV$XELHU0RQWDLJQH LOSDVVRFLWDWRQHOWHVWRqTXLDS3HU XQR VJXDUGRG DVVLHPHVLYHGD$ 1HJUL,QWURGX]LRQHD&RPWH%DUL/DWHU]D FRQULFFD ELEOLRJUDILD 3HUODSUpIDFHSHUVRQQHOOH FIU $ &RPWH (XYUHVFKRLVLHV FLW SS 3HUO¶$S SHQGLFHVLYHGDLOTXDUWRHXOWLPRWRPRGL$&RPWH6\VWqPHGHSROLWLTXHSRVLWLYHRX7UDLWpGH VRFLRORJLHLQVWLWXDQWODUHOLJLRQGHO +XPDQLWp3DULV0DWKLDV $:HWWOH\'LH7ULHEOHKUH$XJXVWH&RPWHVLQ©&RQI3V\FKLDWª ,, S FLWDWR GD'|UQHU VLYHGDODQRWDVHJXHQWH .'|UQHUERUJKHVHHLOIROOH6WRULDVRFLDOHGHOODSVLFKLDWULD%DUL/DWHU]D SS 81),/262)21(//$&$6$'(,3$==, HVVHUHVWDWRHVSXOVRGDOO¶(FROH3RO\WHFKQLTXH ² LQVHJXLWRDGHSLVR GLGLULEHOOLRQHVWXGHQWHVFDFKHORFRLQYROVHUR ² &RPWHWRUQzD3D ULJLQHO DGHUHQGRVXELWRDOODFHUFKLDGL6DLQW6LPRQ 3XEEOLFz VFULWWL VX ULYLVWH GL 6DLQW6LPRQ QRUPDOPHQWH VHQ]D ILUPDUOL ,O VXR RSXVFRORSLLPSRUWDQWH ² HGLWRODSULPDYROWDQHO FRQWLUDWX UD OLPLWDWD HVHPSODUL ² IX ULVWDPSDWR LQ HVHPSODUL QHO VXO&DWpFKLVPHGHV,QGXVWULHOV GL 6DLQW6LPRQ FRQXQQXRYR WLWROR6\VWqPHGHSROLWLTXHSRVLWLYHLOWLWRORGHO HUD3URVSHFWXVGHV WUDYDX[VFLHQWLILTXHVQpFHVVDLUHVSRXUUpRUJDQLVHUODVRFLpWpHFRQOD ILUPDGL&RPWH,O qDQFKHO DQQRGHOODURWWXUDWUD&RPWHH6DLQW 6LPRQ 1HOO RSXVFROR GHO FRPSDUH SHUODSULPDYROWD LQ IRUPD GLVSLHJDWD ODIDPRVDWHRULDGHLWUHVWDGL ² TXHOOR7HRORJLFRRILWWL ]LRTXHOOR0HWDILVLFRRDVWUDWWRHTXHOOR6FLHQWLILFRRSRVLWLYR²DOOD TXDOH VHFRQGR '|UQHU (VTXLURO VL VDUHEEH LVSLUDWR LQ SDUWLFRODU PRGRQHLVXRLODYRULVXOVXLFLGLRHVXOODGHPRQRPDQLD'|UQHUqVWD WR IRUVH WUDWWR LQ LQJDQQR GDO IDWWR FKH WDOLODYRUL FRPSDUYHUR FRPH FDSLWROLGHO'HVPDODGLHVPHQWDOHVQHO PDYHQQHURSXEEOLFDWL SHU ODSULPDYROWD FRPHYRFL QHO FLWDWR ©'LFWLRQQDLUHª GL 3DQFNRX FNHOD'pPRQRPDQLHqGHOLO6XLFLGHGHO6LWUDWWDTXLQGL GL VFULWWL FKHSUHFHGRQR LO3URVSHFWXV FRPWLDQR GHO XQ RSHUD FRPH VLqJLjGHWWR FKHFRQWLHQHODSULPDIRUPXOD]LRQHGHOODWHRULD GHL WUH VWDGL H FKH XVFu VHQ]D LO QRPH GHOO DXWRUH Ê SRVVLELOH FKH (VTXLUROO DEELDOHWWD HGqDQFKHSUREDELOHFKH FRQRVFHVVHO LGHQWLWj GHO VXR DXWRUH / RSXVFROR IX LQIDWWL DSSUH]]DWR GD XQ SHUVRQDJJLR FRPH *XL]RW FRQ LO TXDOH &RPWH HQWUz LQ FRQWDWWR WUD LO H LO FRPH DSSUHQGLDPR GLUHWWDPHQWH GDOOD 3UpIDFH SHUVRQQHOOH (VTXLUROSXzGXQTXHDYHUOHWWRWDOHRSXVFROR PDqGDHVFOXGHUH LQ RJQLFDVR FKHQHDEELDVXELWRO LQIOXVVR (VVRDSSDUYHQRQORVLGL PHQWLFKL VRWWR O HJLGD GL 6DLQW6LPRQ DXWRUH WRWDOPHQWH HVWUDQHR DOOD VHQVLELOLWj SROLWLFD H DOOD FXOWXUD PHGLFRILORVRILFD GHO FHOHEUH DOOLHYRGL3LQHO,OSULPRWRPRGHO&RXUVHVFHQHOTXDQGRTXDVL WXWWLJOLVFULWWLGL(VTXLUROVRQRJLjVWDWLSXEEOLFDWL$OOHSULPHVpDQ FHV GHO LQWHUURWWH GDOOD FULVL GL IROOLD DVVLVWRQR SHUVRQDJJL GL VSLFFRGHOODFXOWXUDVFLHQWLILFDGHOWHPSRWUDFXLLJLjFLWDWL%ODLQYLOOH ELRORJRH3RLQVRWPDWHPDWLFRDVVLHPHDGHVVLYLqDQFKHTXHOO $ OH[DQGHUYRQ+XPEROGW YLFLQR DJOLDPELHQWLGHOOD1D 6XOO RSXVFRORGHO HVXOOHVXHYDULHHGL]LRQLFIU+*RXKLHU/DSKLORVRSKLHG $XJXV WH&RPWH 3DULV9ULQ5HSULVH SS OHSDJLQHFLWDWHVRQRODULVWDPSDGLXQDUWLFROR GL*RXKLHU SXEEOLFDWRQHO VXOODULYLVWD©/HV(WXGHV3KLORVRSKLTXHVª FRQ LOWLWROR/ 2 SXVFXOH IRQGDPHQWDO /( 3$66,21, ( /$ 6725,$ WXUSKLORVRSKLHWHGHVFD FLWDWRH FRQRVFLXWRSHUVRQDOPHQWHGD(VTXL UROHYLVVXWRTXDVLVHPSUHD3DULJLWUDLOHLO*UD]LHDTXH VWR ILORVRIRVFLHQ]LDWR JHQLDOH HG HFFOHWWLFR ERWDQLFR H JUDQGHYLDJ JLDWRUH ² FKHRJJLDQFKHJOLDQWURSRORJLULYHQGLFDQRWUDLSDGULIRQ GDWRULGHOODORURGLVFLSOLQD ² (VTXLUROSXzDYHUDYXWRQRWL]LDGHOO L QL]LR GHO &RXUV /D GHJHQ]D GL &RPWH QHOOD 0DLVRQ GH 6DQWp HG LO VXFFHVVLYR DQQXQFLR SXEEOLFR GLIIXVR QHO GHOOD ULSUHVD GHO &RXUV ² XQDQQXQFLR FKHFLUFRODYDJLjPDQRVFULWWRQHO HFKH HUD VWDWR DUULFFKLWR GDO SLDQR GHWWDJOLDWR GHOOH OH]LRQL ² SXz DYHU VSLQWR (VTXLURO D SUHVHQ]LDUH DOOD OH]LRQH LQDXJXUDOH GHO JHQQDLR DOODTXDOHVLqDFFHQQDWR 0DWRUQLDPRDOODGLDJQRVLGHOO DOLHQLVWD FRPHVLqGHWWRHVVDOD VFLDSRFRVSD]LRDOODVSHUDQ]D PRQRPDQLDFRQGHOLULRGLJUDQGH]]D PHJDORPDQLD LQFXUDELOH 1RQ KR WURYDWR ILQRUD QHVVXQ UHVRFRQWR FOLQLFRGLTXHOORFKHDEELDPRFKLDPDWRVFKHPDWL]]DQGRXQSR ODVL WXD]LRQH O DIIURQWDPHQWR WUD L GXH $EELDPR VROR TXDOFKH WHVWLPR QLDQ]D GLUHWWD GHO SD]LHQWH LQ SDUWH FRPH VL GLFHYD QHOOD 3UpIDFH SHUVRQQHOOHGHO LQSDUWHQHOODFLWDWD$SSHQGLFHGHO ©7UL VWHVLWXDWLRQª©WULVWHH[SpULHQFHª©WHUULEOHpSLVRGHª©DQRPDOLHPp PRUDEOHª FRVuVLHVSULPH&RPWHQHOOD3UpIDFHSHUVRQQHOOHSHUGHIL QLUHLOVXRVRJJLRUQRQHOOD0DLVRQGH6DQWpHODFDXVDFKHO KDSURYR FDWR &RPWHKDSRWXWR©XWLOLVHUSKLORVRSKLTXHPHQWOHVOXPLqUHVSHU VRQQHOOHVª FKH TXHVWD ©WULVWH H[SpULHQFHª HUD ULXVFLWD D SURFXUDUJOL (VVDKDUDSSUHVHQWDWRXQDFRQIHUPDGHOODYDOLGLWjGHOODVXDOHJJHGHL WUHVWDGL XQDFRQIHUPD©H[SpULPHQWDOHª FKHJOLFRQVHQWuGLLGHQWLIL FDUVL DWWUDYHUVR LO FDPPLQR SURJUHVVLYR GDOOD IROOLD DOOD VDOXWH LQ RJQXQRGHLWUHVWDGLWHRORJLFRPHWDILVLFRVFLHQWLILFRRVHVLSUHIHUL VFHILWWL]LR DVWUDWWR SRVLWLYR 1HOOD SULPD IDVH TXHOOD FKHYD GDOOR VWDWRQRUPDOHDOORVWDWRSDWRORJLFR&RPWHSHUFRUUHLVWDGLLQVHQVR LQYHUVR1HOODIDVHFKHORULSRUWDDOODJXDULJLRQHLOSDGUHGHOSRVLWLYL VPRYHULILFDVXVHVWHVVRODFRLQFLGHQ]DWUDSHUFRUVRHYROXWLYRGHLSR SROLGHOOHFXOWXUHHLWLQHUDULRLQGLYLGXDOHYHUVRODOLEHUWjGHOORVSLUL WR 9DOHODSHQDFLWDUHSHUHVWHVRO DXWRUH /H WULPHVWUH R O LQIOXHQFH PpGLFDOH GpYHORSSHOD PDODGLH PHILW JUD GXHOOHPHQW GHVFHQGUH GX SRVLWLYLVPH MXVTX DX IpWLFKLVPH HQ P DUUrWDQW G DERUGDXPRQRWpLVPHSXLVGDYDQWDJHDXSRO\WKpLVPH'DQVOHVFLQTPRLV VXLYDQWVjPHVXUHTXHPDOJUpOHVUHPqGHV PDVSRQWDQHLWpUDPHQDO H[LVWHQ FHQRUPDOHMHUHPRQWDLOHQWHPHQWGXIpWLFKLVPHRXSRO\WKpLVPHHWGHFHOXL FL DX PRQRWKpLVPH G RMH UHYLQV SURPSWHPHQW jPDSRVLWLYLWpSUpDODEOH (QPHSURFXUDQWDXVVLW{WXQHFRQILUPDWLRQGHFLVLYHGHPDORLGHVWURLVpWDWV 81 ),/262)2 1(//$ &$6$ '(, 3$==, HWPHIDLVDQWPLHX[VHQWLUODUHODWLYLWpQpFHVVDLUHGHWRXWHVQRVFRQFHSWLRQV FH WHUULEOHpSLVRGHPHSHUPLWHQVXLWHGHP LGHQWLILHUGDYDQWDJHDYHFO XQH TXHOFRQTXHGHVSKDVHVKXPDLQHVG DSUqVPDSURSUHH[SpULHQFH/HSURILW FRQWLQX TXHM HQDLWLUpSRXUO HQVHPEOHGHPHVPpGLWDWLRQVKLVWRULTXHVPH GRQQHOLHX G HVSpUHUTXHPHVOHFWHXUV FRQYHQDEOHPHQWSUpSDUpVSRXUURQW XWLOLVHUDXVVLFHWWHVRPPDLUHLQGLFDWLRQG XQH DQRPDOLHPpPRUDEOH 0DOJUpOHVUHPqGHV&RPWHULWRUQDGXQTXHDOODVDOXWH 'LSLOD PLD FULVL GLFH &RPWH ©VDJHPHQW OLYUqH j VRQ FRXUV VSRQWDQpª DYUHEEHEHQSUHVWRULVWDELOLWRORVWDWRQRUPDOH ² FRPHqGLPRVWUDWR GDOVXRHVLWRVXFFHVVLYR ² VHQRQIRVVHVWDWRSHULOGLVDVWURVRLQWHU YHQWRGLXQDPHGLFD]LRQHHPSLULFD©ODGpVDVWUHXVHLQWHUYHQWLRQG X QHPpGLFDWLRQHPSLULTXHGDQVO¶pWDEOLVVHPHQWG¶(VTXLUROROHSOXVDE VXUGHWUDLWHPHQWPHFRQGXLVLWUDSLGHPHQWjXQHDOLpQDWLRQWUqVFDUDF WpULVpHª 'RSRFKHODPHGLFLQD FRQWLQXD&RPWHPLGLFKLDUz©IH OLFHPHQWHª LQFXUDELOH ©ODSXLVVDQFH LQWULQVqTXH GH PRQ RUJDQLVD WLRQ WULRPSKD GHODPDODGLHHWVXUWRXWGHVUHPqGHVª7XWWRTXH VWRQHOOD3UpIDFH,QXQDOHWWHUDD%ODLQYLOOHGHODSULOH&RPWH DYHYD DIIHUPDWR FRQSDULRUJRJOLRHVHPSUHLQDWWHJJLDPHQWRGLSH VDQWHSROHPLFD PLVRQRWUDWWDWRPLVRQRFXUDWRGDVROR©MHPHVXLV WUDLWpPRLPrPHªYLVWRFKHHURDVVROXWDPHQWHLVRODWRHGq©DTXH VWD IHOLFH HG LQIOHVVLELOH QHFHVVLWj FKH DWWULEXLVFR OD PLD JXDULJLRQH +RDSSHQDIDWWR ² FRQFOXGH ² XQPLRSLDQRGLFRQYDOHVFHQ]Dª,Q TXHVWD OHWWHUD SLHQD GL HUURUL GL JLXGL]LR H GL VRWWROLQHDWXUH VHQ]D VHQVR &RPWH VLILUPD'RFWRU0pGLFXV '0 FRHUHQWHPHQWHFRQOD VXDFRQYLQ]LRQHGLHVVHUHOXLVWHVVRLOPHGLFRGHOODSURSULDIROOLD $QGLDPRRUDXQSR SLDIRQGRVHPSUHULPDQHQGRDQFRUDWLDOOD WHVWLPRQLDQ]DGL&RPWHVXOVLJQLILFDWRGLTXHVWDHVSUHVVLRQHSROHPL FD PpGLFDWLRQ HPSLULTXH 6DQJXLVXJKH VDODVVL GRFFHEDJQLIUHGGL TXHVWLLULPHGLDSSOLFDWLDOPDODWR FRQLOSUHWHVWR FRPHGLFH*HRU JHV 'XPDV ©GH OXL UHIUDvFKLUOHV LGpHVª 1HOOD JLj FLWDWD$SSHQGLFH GHO &RPWHqDQFRUDSLHVSOLFLWR LOWUDWWDPHQWRqVWDWRLQXPD QR SHUSHWUDWR GDPHGLFLLQFRPSHWHQWL DVVLPLODELOL D GHLYHWHULQDUL GDOPRPHQWR FKH©LOV Q pWXGLHQWHQQRXV TXHO DQLPDOHWQRQO KRP $&RPWH6\VWqPHGHSROLWLTXHSRVLWLYHFLWW,,,S ,FRUVLYLVRQRPLHL ,,SDVVRqWUDWWRGDOOD3UpIDFHSHUVRQQHOOH&IU$&RPWH 2(XYUHV FKRLVLHVFLWS ,YL SS /HWWHUDFLWDWD LQ 6 .RIPDQ$EHUUDWLRQV /HGHYHQLUIHPPHG $XJXVWH&RPWH 3DULV $XELHU)ODPPDULRQ S 3HUXQ DQDOLVLGLTXHVWDOHWWHUDHGLWXWWDODYLFHQGDFIU * 'XPDV 3V\FKRORJLH GH GHX[0HVVLHVSRVLWLYHV 6DLQW6LPRQ HW$XJXVWH &RPWH 3DULV $OFDQ /( 3$66,21, ( /$ 6725,$ PHª /DSDUWHLQWHOOHWWXDOHHGDIIHWWLYDGHOO XRPRqVWDWDQHJOHWWD DE EDQGRQDWD GDO GLUHWWRUH GHOO RVSHGDOHSVLFKLDWULFR DOO D]LRQH DUELWUD ULD GL DJHQWL VXEDOWHUQL H UR]]L ©VXEDOWHUQHV HW JURVVLHUVª OD FXL FRQGRWWD ©DJJUDYHSUHVTXHWRXMRXUVODPDODGLH TX LOV GHYUDLHQW FRQ WULEXHU j JXpULUª &RPWHHVFHQRQJXpULGDOOD0DLVRQGH6DQWp 6XELWRGRSRODPD GUH FRQOD FRPSOLFLWjGL/DPHQQDLV ² SRFRSULPD GHOWHQWDWLYRGL VXLFLGLR ² RUJDQL]]DSHULOILJOLRXQPDWULPRQLRUHOLJLRVR 'XUDQWH OD FHULPRQLD &RPWHILUPDJOLDWWLXIILFLDOLFRQLOQRPHGL%UXWXV%R QDSDUWH&RPWHFLzDFFDGHLOGLFHPEUHDQQLYHUVDULRGHOODEDW WDJOLDGL$XVWHUOLW]GXHPHVLGRSRODGpPLVVLRQ& qXQQXFOHRIRUWH ² XQQXFOHRGLYHULWj ² QHOODGHQXQFLDGL&RPWHHQHOODVXDVLQJR ODUHSRVWXUD©DQWLSVLFKLDWULFDªLOWUDLWHPHQWPRUDOqLQUHDOWjXQWUDW WDPHQWRILVLFR XQDWHUDSLDG XUWRILQDOL]]DWD DOODSURGX]LRQHGLFKRF HPRWLYL WDOLGDDJJUDYDUHODPDODWWLDHGDVSLQJHUHODFULVLGLIROOLDDL VXRLOLYHOOLSLDOWLPHWWHQGRWDORUDDUHSHQWDJOLRODVDOXWHPHQWDOHH ODVWHVVDLQFROXPLWjILVLFDGHOVRJJHWWRLQWHUQDWR 8QILORURVVR FROOH JD O DSSDVVLRQDWD GHQXQFLD GL &RPWH DOOD OXFLGD SROHPLFD GL(VSULW %ODQFKH FKHQHO HQHO DYHYDDWWDFFDWRIURQWDOPHQWH)UDQ oRLV /HXUHW HOD VXD FRQFH]LRQH GHOWUDLWHPHQWPRUDO 0RQRPDQLDG RUJRJOLRHGHOLULRGLJUDQGH]]D 5LWRUQLDPR RUD DOODSUHVXQWDPHJDORPDQLDGHOILORVRIR FHUFDQGR GL WURYDUH XQ QHVVR FUHGLELOH WUD OD GLDJQRVL HVTXLUROLDQD HG DOFXQL DVSHWWLHVVHQ]LDOLGHOO RSHUD HGHOODSHUVRQDOLWjGL$XJXVWH&RPWH Ê IDFLOHSUHVXSSRUUHFKHLOFRQWHQXWRGHOGHOLULRGLJUDQGH]]DQRQUDS SUHVHQWDVVHQXOO DOWUR FKHXQ LSHUWURILDGHOO HOHYDWDFRVFLHQ]DHVWLPD GL VpH GHOOD VXDPLVVLRQH FKHLOJLRYDQH&RPWHPDQLIHVWz VFRSHUWD PHQWHVLDQHJOLRSXVFROLVFULWWLWUDLOHGLOVLDQHOOHOHWWHUH VRSUDWWXWWRQHOODFRUULVSRQGQ]DFRQLOIHGHOHDPLFR9DODWFKHKDWXW WR O DQGDPHQWR GL XQ MRXUQDO LQWLPH VFULWWR DSSRVLWDPHQWH SHU GDUH IRUPD FRPSLXWDDXQ LPPDJLQHIRUWHGLVp GHOSURSULRGHVWLQR GLVDYDQWHGLULIRUPDWRUHGHOODSURSULDPLVVLRQHGLULJHQHUDWRUHGHO $&RPWH6\VWqPHW ,Y$SSHQGLFHS 'L(VSULW%ODQFKHILJOLRG DUWH DOLHQLVWDHILODQWURSRVLYHGD 'XFODQJHU GHVULJXHXUVFRUSRUHOOHVGDQVOHWUDLWHPHQWGHODIROLH 3DULV*DUGHPEDV HSHUJOLVWHVVL WLSL'HO pWDWDFWXHOGXWUDLWHPHQWGHODIROLHHQ)UDQFH\3DULV &IU OD 3UpIDFH SS GL 3DXOR ( GH %HUUrGR &DUQHLUR H 3LHUUH $UQDXG D $ &RPWH(FULWVGHMHXQHVVH 3DULV/D+D\H0RXWRQ 81 ),/262)2 1(//$ &$6$ '(, 3$==, O XPDQLWj8QRGHLPRWLYLFKHORVSLQJRQRDGHGLFDUVLDOODVFLHQ]DD ODYRUDUH HG D VFULYHUH ² GLFHLOYHQWXQHQQH&RPWH D9DODW LQXQD OHWWHUDGHO VHWWHPEUH ² q©ODSHQVpHGHFRQWULEXHUXQSHX TXHOTXH MRXU j O DPpOLRUDWLRQ GX VRUW GX SDXYUH JHQUH KXPDLQª 6FLHQ]D ULJHQHUD]LRQH EHQHVVHUH PLVVLRQH GHVWLQR WDOL SDUROH UL FRUURQRVRYHQWHQHOODOHWWHUDGL&RPWHHJHWWDQRRJJLQXRYDOXFHVXO OD IDPRVD VYROWD PLVWLFRXPDQLWDULD VXFFHVVLYD DOOD FULVL QHUYRVD GHO DOOHJDPH FRQ&ORWLOGH GH9DX[ HG DOODVXDPRUWHSUHPDWXUD DYYHQXWDO DQQR VHJXHQWH ,OWRQRVROHQQHHSURIHWLFRO DWWHJJLDPHQWRPHVVLDQLFR ²SURED ELOPHQWHHVDVSHUDWL FRPHVLGLFHYD GXUDQWHOD©FULVHFpUpEUDOHª ² WURYDQR ULVFRQWUR DQFKH QHO 3URVSHFWXV GHO ,Q TXHVW RSHUD VFULWWD DOO HWj GL DQQL O DXWRUH DIIHUPD LQIDWWL GL DYHU UHGDWWR XQ SURJUDPPDWHRULFRXWLOHDULIRUPDUHHDULRUJDQL]]DUHODVRFLHWj©- DL RVpFRQFHYRLUFHSODQ² DIIHUPD&RPWH² HWMHOHSURSRVHVROHQQHO OHPHQW DX[ VDYDQWV GHO (XURSHª 8Q IDWWR FL VHPEUD FRPXQTXH DOTXDQWR VWUDQR H PHULWD TXDOFKH ULIOHVVLRQH LQWXWWDO RSHUDGL(VTXLUROQRQYLqDOFXQFHQQRHYLGHQWH DOWUDLWHPHQWGHOOD PRQRPDQLD GL&RPWH 8Q RSHUDWXWWDJLRFDWDVXO UpFLWGHOOHVWRULHFOLQLFKH ² SLHQDGLTXHJOLXWLOLVVLPLH©DGPLUDEOHV WDEOHDX[ª EHQQRWLDOODJUDQGHSLVFKLDWULDFODVVLFDQRQVRORIUDQFH VH GLILQH VHFROR ² QRQFRQWLHQHQHVVXQULIHULPHQWR DTXHVWR FDVR VWUDRUGLQDULR XQ FDVR FKH VHFRQGR OD WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GHOOR VWHVVR &RPWH WHUPLQz FRQ OD JXDULJLRQH ( GDYYHUR FUHGLELOH OD YHUVLRQH GHO ILORVRIR" Ê SURSULR YHUR FKH LO SD]LHQWH JXDUu D GLVSHWWR GHOOD GLDJQRVLHQRQRVWDQWHLOWUDLWHPHQW FKHGDSULQFLSLR DYHYD DFXLWROD FULVLLQYHFHGLVHGDUOD" 6DSSLDPR LQUHDOWj FKHLOSD]LHQWHODVFLzOD FOLQLFDGRSRVHWWHPHVLQRQJXpUL' DOWURFDQWRLOWHQWDWRVXLFLGLR GHO HOHGXHVXFFHVVLYHFULVLPHQWDOLGL&RPWH QHO HQHO VHPEUDQR GDYYHUR FRQIHUPDUH OD GLDJQRVL GL QRQ JXDULJLRQH FRQFXLLOSDGUHGHOSRVLWLYLVPRIXGLPHVVRGDOOD0DLVRQGL(VTXLURO QHO ,O WHQWDWLYR GL VXLFLGLR PDWXUDWR SRFR GRSR OD GpPLVVLRQ GDOOD 0DLVRQGH6DQWp HUDFRPXQTXHLPEDUD]]DQWHSHUO DOLHQLVWD & qSRL $&RPWH3ODQGHVWUDYDX[VFLHQWLILTXHVQpFHVVDLUHVSRXUUpRUJDQLVHUODVRFLpWp3DULV $XELHU0RQWDLJQH S &IU (5pJLV0DQXHOSUDWLTXHGHPpGHFLQHPHQWDOH3DULV S)XXQPDQXDOH FHOHEUH ODSULPDHGL]LRQHqGHO VFULWWRSHUO LQVHJQDPHQWR HULHGLWRSLYROWH / DXWRUH GLHGHDQFKHXQFHUWRVSD]LRDOODQDVFHQWHGRWWULQDIUHXGLDQD DVVHJQDQGRXQDPDWULFH©IUDQFH VHªDLSLLPSRUWDQWLFRQFHWWLSVLFRDQDOLWLFL /DULFRVWUX]LRQHSLFRPSOHWD DWXWW RJJL qTXHOODJLjFLWDWD GL*HRUJHV'XPDV /( 3$66,21, ( /$ 6725,$ GDGLUHFKHODQRWRULHWjGL&RPWH VRSUDWWXWWRDSDUWLUHGDOODSXEEOL FD]LRQH QHO GHO SULPR WRPR GHO &RXUV SXz DYHU LQGRWWR (VTXLURO DGXQSUXGHQWHULVHUER (JOLDYUHEEHSRWXWRURPSHUORXWL OL]]DQGRLOFDVR&RPWHFRPHVWRULDFOLQLFDSURSULRLQRFFDVLRQHGHO ODSXEEOLFD]LRQHGHOODVXDVLOORJHQHO $GLIIHUHQ]DGHJOLDOWUL LO FDSLWROR LQWLWRODWR 'H OD PRQRPDQLHYLHQH UHGDWWR GD (VTXLURO LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GL 'HV PDODGLHV PHQWDOHV 7XWWDYLD QRQ WURYLDPR Qp LQ TXHVWR FDSLWROR Qp DOWURYH QHVVXQ ULIHULPHQWR DOFDVR&RPWH QHSSXUHQHOODIRUPD FULSWLFDDELWXDOPHQWHXVDWDGDO O DXWRUH TXDQGR FLWD FRPH G XVR LO QRPH GHL VXRL SD]LHQWL FRQ OH OHWWHUHLQL]LDOLRSSXUHFRQODVRODPHQ]LRQHGHOODTXDOLILFDSURIHVVLR QDOH /D GLDJQRVL GL PHJDORPDQLD H GL GHOLULR GL JUDQGH]]D QRQ GHYH VWXSLUFL QRQ VROWDQWRSHUFKp FRQRVFLDPRODSHUVRQDOLWj GL&RPWHH ODVXDFRQWLQXDSURSHQVLRQHDGHVDOWDUHLOSURSULRUXRORGLVDOYDWRUH ODSURSULDPLVVLRQH GLVDYDQWULJHQHUDWRUH GHOO XPDQLWj PD DQFKHH VRSUDWWXWWR SHUFKp YHUVR TXHVWD SDUWLFRODUH IRUPD GL PRQRPDQLD VL HUDQRLQGLUL]]DWLFRQSDUWLFRODUHDWWHQ]LRQH ² DFRPLQFLDUHSURSULR GD(VTXLURO ² WXWWLJOL DOLHQLVWLRSHUDQWLLQ)UDQFLDQHOSHULRGRLP SHULDOH H QHOO HWj GHOOD UHVWDXUD]LRQH 'HOLUL GLJUDQGH]]D PRQRPD QLH G RUJRJOLR LGHHDPEL]LRVH PHJDORPDQLH TXHVWHWLSRORJLHULFRU URQRIUHTXHQWHPHQWHQHOWUDWWDWRGL(VTXLURO PDDQFKHLQDOFXQLWH VWLGLTXDOFKHVXR DOOLHYR DGHVHPSLRQHLGXHOLEULGL/HXUHW)UDJ PHQWVSV\FKRORJLTXHVVXUODIROLH GHO ² XQWHVWROHWWRHFLWDWR GD )UHXG ² H QHO SL FHOHEUH 'X WUDLWHPHQW PRUDOGH ODIROLH GHO $OOD PDQLD H DOOD PDOLQFRQLD RUJRJOLRVD (VTXLURO GHGLFD XQ FHUWRVSD]LRJLjQHOODWKqVHGHO9DOHODSHQDGLFLWDUHSHUHVWHVR XQR GHLSDVVDJJLSLVLJQLILFDWLYLGHGLFDWLD TXHVWRWHPD ,OULWUDWWR FKHLPRUDOLVWLKDQQRWUDFFLDWRGHOO RUJRJOLRSUHVHQWDOHVWHVVH FDUDWWHULVWLFKH GHOOD PDQLD R GHOODPDOLQFRQLD RUJRJOLRVD / XRPR GLYRUDWR GDTXHVWDIXQHVWDSDVVLRQHRVWHQWDXQDJUDQGH]]D FKHWUDHLQLQJDQQRHFKH LVSLUDULVSHWWR HJOLJLXGLFDHGHFLGHVXWXWWRVHQ]DGLVFUH]LRQHHVHQ]DSUX GHQ]DWXWWRFLzFKHqLQRSSRVL]LRQHFRQOHVXHLGHHqLQJLXVWRRLUUDJLRQH YROHODUHVLVWHQ]DORLQDVSULVFHHQRQIDFKHULQIRU]DUORQHLVXRLVHQWLPHQWL ÊUDURFKHHJOLFHGDDOOHULPRVWUDQ]HHDOODUDJLRQHDPHQRFKHHVVHQRQOX VLQJKLQRLOVXRDPRUSURSULR6HORVLFRQWUDULDVLLQFROOHULVFHHPHGLWDYHQ GHWWD 3LHQRGLVHVWHVVR GHOSURSULRPHULWRHGHOOHVXHSHUIH]LRQLHJOLFUH ,,qDQFKHO¶DQQRLQFXLHVFHLOWHU]RWRPRGHO&RXUV,OVHFRQGRWRPRVHPSUHSHU LWLSLGL%DFKHOLHUHUDXVFLWRQHO -('(VTXLURO'HOOHSDVVLRQLFLWSS 81 ),/262)2 1(//$ &$6$ '(, 3$==, GHGLHVVHUHGHJQRVROWDQWRGHOODVWLPDGDFXLqFLUFRQGDWR GHOODSRVL]LRQH FKHRFFXSDQHOODVRFLHWj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qILHURHDOWH]]RVRLOORURWRQRLPSRQHQWHYLYRQRULWLUDWL H UHVWDQR VROL FRQ VH VWHVVL 2VDQR DPDODSHQDULYROJHUHODSDUROD D FRORUR FKH OL DYYLFLQDQR QRQ VLPHVFRODQR DIIDWWR FRQ LORUR FRPSDJQLPDODWL VL EXUODQR GHOOD ORUR EDVVH]]D GHOOD ORUR VRWWRPLVVLRQH GHOOD ORUR GRFLOLWj SDUODQRFRQGLVSUH]]RDLGRPHVWLFLFKHOLVHUYRQR (FFRQH XQR FKH VLRFFXSD VROR GHL VXRL DOWL GHVWLQL VL FUHGHXQHVVHUH SULYLOHJLDWR XQ LQYLDWR GHO FLHOR XQ UH XQ LPSHUDWRUH RUGLQD FRPDQGD FRPHXQFDSR HLQWHQGHHVVHUHREEHGLWR VLLUULWDGLYLHQHPLQDFFLRVRHIX ULRVRVHJOLVLUHVLVWHVHORVLFRQWUDULD (FFRQH XQ DOWUR FKH FUHGH GL SRVVHGHUH WXWWH OH FRQRVFHQ]H GLVVHUWD FRQSUHVXQ]LRQHVXRJQXQDGLHVVHHVLFRPSLDFHGHOOHVXHGLVFXVVLRQLGHOL UDQWL RSSXUHVLFUHGHSRVVHVVRUHGLWXWWRFLzFKHYHGHHQHGLVSRQHVHFRQ GRLOVXRFDSULFFLRHODVXDEL]]DUUDJHQHURVLWj 4XDQGRHQWUDQRLQIXURUHTXHVWLDOLHQDWLQRQFHGRQRFKHDOODDELOLWjFD SDFHGLXWLOL]]DUHLOORURGHOLULRSHUULFRQGXUOLDOODFDOPD ÊSURSULRODFRQWLQXLWjWUDSDVVLRQHRUJRJOLRVDDOORVWDWRQRUPD OH H PDQLDPDOLQFRQLD G RUJRJOLR FLz FKHUHQGH TXHVWDPDODWWLDWUD OH SL GLIILFLOL GD FXUDUH 'LFH LQIDWWL/HXUHW QHO VXR 7UDLWHPHQWGHO D SURSRVLWR GHOOH ©PRQRPDQLHV SDU RUJXHLOª ©OHV JHQUHV GH IROLHVTXLQHVRQWTXHO H[DJpUDWLRQGHVGpIDXWVQDWXUHOVDX[PDODGHV JXpULVVHQW SOXV GLIILFLOHPHQW TXH OHV DXWUHV SDUFH TX LOV SUHQQHQW OHXU VRXUFH GDQV OH FDUDFWqUH PrPH GHV LQGLYLGXVª 3DUDGRVVDO PHQWH OD GLIILFROWj R O LPSRVVLELOWjGLJXDULUHHPHUJRQRSURSULRQHL PRPHQWLGLSLDFFHQWXDWDFRQWLQXLWjWUDUDJLRQHHIROOLD3LLQSDU WLFRODUH QHLPRPHQWLHQHLFDVLLQFXLWDOHFRQWLQXLWjVLJLRFDDWWRUQR DSDVVLRQL SDUWLFRODUPHQWH GLIIXVHLQXQD GHWHUPLQDWD HSRFD VWRULFD 'LFHLQIDWWL/HXUHWQHL)UDJPHQWVDOO LQL]LRGHOFDSLWRORFKHKDSHUWL WROR0RQRPDQLH G RUJXHLO©/D SDUW GH O RUJXHLO HVW VLODUJH GDQV OD VRFLpWp TXH O RQ V pWRQQH SUHVTXH GHYRLUOHV H[FqV GH FHWWH SDVVLRQ ) /HXUHW'XWUDLWHPHQWPRUDOGHODIROLHFLWS )/HXUHW)UDJPHQWVSV\FKRORJLTXHVVXUODIROLHFLWS /( 3$66,21, ( /$ 6725,$ FRPSWHUDXQRPEUHGHVDEHUUDWLRQVGHO HVSULWª1RQqFHUWRXQFDVR VHQHOO RSHUDGHO OHPRQRPDQLHOHJDWHDOO RUJRJOLRDOO DPEL]LRQH DO GHOLULR GLJUDQGH]]D RFFXSDQR XQR VSD]LRSULYLOHJLDWR HSUHSRQ GHUDQWH XQ WHU]R GL WXWWR LOOLEUR ,GHH DPEL]LRVH FRQFH]LRQL GHOL UDQWL ©FLYLOLVDWHXUV HWUpJpQHUDWHXUV GXPRQGHª ©SRUWHXUVGHWLWUHV HW GH GLJQLWpV LPDJLQDLUHVª LGHH GL JUDQGH]]D TXHVWH HVSUHVVLRQL XVDWHGD/HXUHWPHWWRQRFDSRDXQ DPSLDHGHWWDJOLDWDFDVLVWLFDFOLQL FD ULFFDGLLPSOLFD]LRQLGLFDUDWWHUHSROLWLFRHLGHRORJLFR ,FLYLOLVD WHXUVHLUpJpQHUDWHXUVVRQRDOLHQDWLDIIHWWLGDXQDPRQRPDQLDIRQGD WDHVVHQ]LDOPHQWHVXOODYDQLWpHVXOO RUJXHLO1HOOHSDJLQHGL(VTXLURO H GL/HXUHW GHGLFDWHD TXHVWRWHPD VLDYYHUWHIDFLOPHQWHODSUHVHQ]D GLXQDSROHPLFDULYROWDFRQWURODYDQLWDHO RUJRJOLRGLPROWLFLYLOLVD WHXUVHUpJpQHUDWHXUVFKHDSSDUWHQHYDQRDOODVRFLHWjGHOO HSRFD 6WX GLDPRHFHUFKLDPRGLJXDULUH GLFH/HXUHWLQ)UDJPHQWVODYDQLWjH O RUJRJOLR VSLQWL DOO HFFHVVR ROWUH L OLPLWL GHOOD QRUPD 6WXGLDPR H FHUFKLDPRGLJXDULUHLFLYLOL]]DWRULIROOL H©SHXWrWUHXQMRXURQV HQ WHQGUDDXVVLSRXUIDLUHMXVWLFHGHV DXWUHVª FLRqGHLULJHQHUDWRULQRU PDOL FKH SRSRODQR OD VFHQD VRFLDOH H SROLWLFD /R VWUDOH QRQ SR WUHEEH HVVHUH SL FKLDUR ,Q TXHVWR DWWHJJLDPHQWR LO SURJUHVVLVWD /HXUHW ² LOSURJUHVVLVWDFKHVWXGLDLOSDXSHULVPRHO LQGLJHQ]DD3D ULJL LOSURJUHVVLVWDFKHQHO VFULYHODSUpIDFHDOO RSHUDVXOODSUR VWLWX]LRQH GL 3DUHQW'XFKkWHOHW ² QRQ VL GLVWLQJXH GDO VXR PDH ,YLS $3DUHQW'XFKkWHOHW'HODSURVWLWXWLRQGDQVODYLOOHGH3DULVFRQVLGpUpHVRXVOHUDSSRUW GHO K\JLqQHSXEOLTXHGHODPRUDOHHWGHO DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ3DULV-%%DLOOLqUH YRO(GL ]LRQHSRVWXPD SXEEOLFDWDGDLSDUHQWLGHOO DXWRUHHGDOO DPLFR)UDQoRLV/HXUHW )XULHGLWDQHO QHO DXPHQWDWDGLFDSLWROLFRPSDUDWLYLVXOODSURVWLWX]LRQHLQ(XURSDHLQILQHLQULHGL ]LRQHSDU]LDOH QHO 1HO DSSXQWR /HXUHWHORJLDYDLUDSSRUWLUHGDWWLGDOO DPLFRSHU LO&RQVHLOGHVDOXEULWp UDSSRUWLQHLTXDOL3DUHQW'XFKkWHOHW©YLVLWDLWOHVRXYULHUV FDXVDLWDYHF HX[ V DVVXUDLWGHO pWDWGHOHXUVDQWpSUHQDLWGHVUHQVHLJQHPHQWVVXUOHXUORQJpYLWpVXUOHJHQ UHGHOHXUPDODGLH ,OpFULYDLW VHVREVHUYDWLRQVHWLOOHVFRPSWDLW /HVPRWV VRXYHQW TXHOTXH IRLVQ HQWUDLHQWMDPDLVGDQVVHVQRWHV LOOXLIDOODLWGHVFKLIIUHV6LO RQFRQVLGqUHOHJUDQGQRP EUHHW3LPSRUWDQFHGHVIDLWVGRQWLODHQULFKLO K\JLqQHODPROWLWXGHG HUUHXUVGRQWLOO DGpED UDVVpHHWODPpWKRGHTX LOOXLDDSSOLTXpHRQSHXWGLUHTXHGHOXLGDWHSRXUFHWWHVFLHQFHXQH qUHQRXYHOOHª 6RQRJOLDQQLIHFRQGLLQFXLO¶K\JLqQHSXEOLTXHODVWDWLVWLTXHPRUDOHODPHGLFLQD OHJDOHHODSVLFKLDWULDIRUHQVHVLLQFRQWUDQRGDQGROXRJRDOOHSULPHLQGDJLQLGLJUDQGHUHVSLUR FKHSRWUHPPRRJJL DVVHJQDUH DEXRQGLULWWR DOODVRFLRORJLD XUEDQD 'D TXHVWDVWUDRUGLQDULD FRQJLXQWXUD WHRULFD VWLPRODWD GDOJUDQGH VYLOXSSRGHPRJUDILFRGL3DULJLHGDOOHSDWRORJLHXU EDQHFKHQHGHULYDQRQDVFRQROHLPSRUWDQWL©$QQDOHVG +\JLqQHSXEOLTXHHWGH0pGHFLQHOH JDOHªIRQGDWHQHO GDOORVWHVVR3DUHQW'XFKkWHOHW FRDGLXYDWRGD9LOOHUPp2UILOD0DUF HORVWHVVR(VTXLURO/DVWRULFLWjGHOOHFDWHJRULHQRVRJUDILFKHGL(VTXLURO ²ODORURVWHVVDFDSD FLWjGLHVLELUHTXHOORFKHQHOWHU]RFDSLWRORDEELDPRGHILQLWRXQFRUWRFLUFXLWRWUDOHFDXVHVR FLDOLGHOODIROOLDHLVXRLFDUDWWHUL² QRQVRQRSHQVDELOLIXRULGDTXHVWDVWHVVDFRQJLXQWXUDWHR ULFD8QDFRQJLXQWXUDFKHFLIDGXQTXHPHJOLRFRPSUHQGHUHODFXUYDWXUDSHUFRVuGLUHVRFLR ORJLFDGHOO DOLHQLVWLFDQDVFHQWH FKHFLVSLHJDDQFKHPHJOLRODVXFFHVVLYDXWLOL]]D]LRQHQHOPD WXUR 2WWRFHQWR GL TXHVWD SVLFKLDWULD GHOOH RULJLQL GD SDUWH GL 7DLQH DG HVHPSLR FL RFFX 81),/262)21(//$&$6$'(,3$==, VWUR(VTXLURO FRQVHUYDWRUHHXRPRG RUGLQHORVWHVVR(VTXLUROQRQ ORVLGLPHQWLFKLFKHQHO GLYHQWD,VSHWWRUHJHQHUDOHGHOOD)DFRO WjGL0HGLFLQDO LQGRPDQLGHOODFRQWHVWD]LRQHVWXGHQWHVFDGHO D VHJXLWR GHOOD TXDOH OD )DFROWj HUD VWDWD FKLXVD H TXDOFKH HVSRQHQWH GHOODYHFFKLDJXDUGLDUHSXEEOLFDQD ² ORVWHVVR3LQHODVVLHPHD-XV VLHXH0RUHDXGHOD6DUWKH ² HUDVWDWROLTXLGDWRFRQO LSRFULWDHSX QLWLYD PLVXUD GHOSUHSHQVLRQDPHQWR ,Q TXHVWR FRQWHVWRYDQQR LQVHULWHOHSDJLQHGL/HXUHW PD DQFKH ODGLDJQRVLGL(VTXLUROVXOODPRQRPDQLDLQFXUDELOHGL&RPWH DTXHO WHPSR DQFRUD VHJXDFH GL 6DLQW6LPRQ FRPHVLqGHWWR XQµDSSDUWH QHQ]D FKHLOFHOHEUHDOOLHYRGL3LQHOGLFHUWRQRQLJQRUDYDÊO HSRFD GHOOH XWRSLH GHOOH IDODQJL IRXULHULVWH GHO QXRYR FULVWLDQHVLPR VDLQW VLPRQLDQR 6DLQW6LPRQPXRUHQHO O DQQRLQFXLYLHQHSXEEOL FDWRLOVXR1XRYR&ULVWLDQHVLPR )RXULHUVFRPSDUHXQSR SLWDUGL QHOPDLOVXR1XRYR0RQGR,QGXVWULDOHH6RFLHWDULRHUDJLjXVFL WRQHO/D7HRULDGHLTXDWWURPRYLPHQWLHUD GHOLO7UDWWDWR GLDVVRFLD]LRQH GRPHVWLFD H DJULFROD GHO (VTXLURO HUD DQFRUD YLYRTXDQGR WUDLO HLO OHLGHHGL)RXULHUHUDQRGLIIXVHGDOOD ULYLVWD ©/H 3KDODQVWqUHª , FDUDWWHUL GHOOHSDVVLRQL GRPLQDQWL GHOO H SRFD FRVWLWXLVFRQR LQVRPPD LO VRVWUDWR O RVVDWXUD GHOOH QXRYH FDWH JRULH QRVRJUDILFKH LQ SDUWLFRODU PRGR GHOOD PRQRPDQLD ©,O \ D ORQJWHPSVTX RQDGLWTXHODIROLHHVWODPDODGLHGHODFLYLOLVDWLRQ ² VFULYH(VTXLUROQHO ²LOrXWpWpSOXVH[DFWGHOHGLUHGHODPR QRPDQLH HQ HIIHW OD PRQRPDQLH HVW G DXWDQW SOXVIUpTXHQWH TXHOD FLYLOLVDVWLRQHVWSOXVDYDQFpHª &ULWLFDGHOODFLYLOWjHGHOSURJUHVVR GXQTXH FKHLPSOLFD FRPH VXD DUWLFROD]LRQHFRQVHJXHQWH XQDGXUD FRQGDQQDGHOODULYROX]LRQH ² GHOOHFRPPRWLRQVSROLWLTXHVSHUGLUOD FRQ(VTXLURO ² HGHLVXRLHFFHVVL 7DOHFRQGDQQDUDSSUHVHQWDYDXQ FDYDOOR GLEDWWDJOLD GLWXWWRLOSHQVLHUR WUDGL]LRQDOLVWD GHOO HSRFD ² /DPHQQDLV GH%RQDOG GH0DLVWUH ²QHOTXDOHULWURYLDPRDWWHJJLD PHQWL WHPL H PRWLYL FDUL DG (VTXLURO LQ SULPR OXRJR DSSXQWR OD FULWLFD GHOOD FLYLOLVDWLRQ GHOSURJUqV H GHOOD JUDQGH ULYROX]LRQH GHO O 'H %RQDOG q VHQ]D GXEELR LOWUDGL]LRQDOLVWDSLYLFLQR VRWWRLO SURILORLGHRORJLFRHSROLWLFRDOFRQVHUYDWRULVPRHVTXLUROLDQR/DVXD RSHUD IRQGDPHQWDOH 7KpRULH GX SRXYRLUSROLWLTXH HW UHOLJLHX[ GHO SHUHPR GL TXHVWR WHPD LQ TXHVWR VWHVVR FDSLWRORHVRSUDWWXWWRQHOVXFFHVVLYR RSSXUH VXXQ YHUVDQWH WRWDOPHQWHRSSRVWR OD VXDSRVVLELOHXWLOL]]D]LRQH DWWXDOH DOO LQWHUQRGLXQUDIIRU]DWR WHQWDWLYRGLSRWHQ]LDUHO¶DVFROWRGHOODIROOLDHGLGDUHVHPSUHPDJJLRUVSD]LRDOOHPDQLIHVWD]LRQL GHO VXR YLVVXWR q TXDQWR FHUFKHUHPR GLSURSRUUH PROWR VREULDPHQWH QHOO HSLORJRGLTXHVWR OLEUR -('(VTXLURO'HVPDODGLHVPHQWDOHVFLWW , S /( 3$66,21, ( /$ 6725,$ PHVVD DO PDFHUR VRWWR LO 'LUHWWRULR FLUFROD HJXDOPHQWH GRSR qOHWWD GD &KDWHDXEULDQG GD 6LH\qV GDOOR VWHVVR 1DSROHRQH /RXLVGH%RQDOGIDSDUWHQHO GHOSULPR*UDQG&RQVHLOGHO 8 QLYHUVLWp 6HL DQQL GRSR GLYHQWD DFFDGHPLFR GL )UDQFLD H SDUL GL )UDQFLD 'RSRODFDGXWDGL&DUOR[ QHO VLULWLUDDYLWDSULYDWD &RPHORGHILQLVFHDFXWDPHQWH$OEHUW7KLEDXGHW IX FRQGH0DLVWUH JLXGLFHFULVWLDQRGHOODULYROX]LRQHHSURIHWDGHOODUHVWDXUD]LRQH$XWHQ WLFR FDSRVWLSLWH GL TXHO FRPSOHVVRSROLWLFRVRFLDOHIUDQFHVH FRVu ©WH QDFHªHGXUDWXURFKHVLqVROLWLFKLDPDUHUHD]LRQH'D7DLQHILQRD 0DXUUDV LO ULIHULPHQWR D %RQDOG ULPDQH IRQGDPHQWDOH SHU WXWWD OD QXRYD VFXRODUHD]LRQDULD FKH VLVYLOXSSzLQ)UDQFLD DSDUWLUHGDOVH FRQGRWHU]RGHOVHFRORVFRUVR'DOOD7KpRULHGHODOOD/pJLVODWLRQ SULPLWLYHGHOILQRDOOH5HFKHUFKHVSKLORVRSKLTXHVGHO%R QDOG VYLOXSSD ² D SDUWLUH GDOOD FULWLFD GHOOD ULYROX]LRQH GDO ULILXWR GHOSURJUHVVR HGHOO LGHDGLSHUIHWWLELOLWjXQ LGHDGLVFLHQFHGHODVR FLpWpFHQWUDWDVXOODQR]LRQHGLKRPPHVRFLDOXQ LGHDFKHWHPDWL]]DOD VRFLpWpFLYLOH FRPH XQLRQH LQGLVVROXELOHGLXQ DQLPD OD VRFLHWjUHOL JLRVD HGLXQFRUSRODVRFLHWjSROLWLFDVWDGLRGHOODPDWXULWjHGHOOD SHUIH]LRQH GRYHQDWXUHGHO KRPPHLQTXDQWRQDWXUHSHUIHFWLRQQpH qVLQRQLPRGLFLYLOLVDWLRQ TXHVWDFLYLOLVDWLRQ ² QHOODTXDOHO KRPPH VRFLDOUHDOL]]DODVXD DSSDUWHQHQ]DDGXQDYLWDFRPXQLWDULDVHQ]DEL VRJQR GLQHVVXQSDWWR VRFLDOH ² qVWDWDGLVJUHJDWD qVWDWDGLVWUXWWD GDO VLVWHPD ULYROX]LRQDULR ,O V\VWqPH UpYROXWLRQQDLUH q SHU %RQDOG XQD VRUWD GLFRQFHWWRDPDOJDPD GRYHWURYDQRSRVWRULIRUPHHULYR OX]LRQL5RXVVHDX9ROWDLUHJOL(QFOLFORSHGLVWLJOLVFULWWRULULYROX]LR QDUL PD DQFKHJOLXRPLQLGHOOD5LIRUPD FRPH/XWHUR H&DOYLQR ,O V\VWqPH UpYROXWLRQQDLUH GLVWUXJJH OR VWDWXVTXR FLRq OD FLYLOLVDWLRQ IRQGDWD VXOOD PRQDUFKLD H VXOOD UHOLJLRQH XQ RUJDQLVPR VRFLDOH FKH VWDDJOLDQWLSRGLDOORVWDWRGLQDWXUDGL5RXVVHDXSURSULRQHOODPLVX UD LQ FXL LQFDUQD XQD QDWXUHSHUIHFWLRQQpH FKH VL LGHQWLILFD FRQ OD FRQVHUYDWLRQHODWUDGL]LRQH/DFRQVHUYD]LRQHGHOO RUGLQHPRQDUFKL FRIRQGDWRVXOODUHOLJLRQHqODJDUDQ]LDGHOO HTXLOLEULRGHJOLLQGLYLGXL H GHOOD ORUR LQHOLPLQDELOH DSSDUWHQHQ]D D XQ DQLPD H D XQ FRUSR FRPH VL GLFHYD GHOOD VRFLHWj FLYLOH /D QR]LRQH GLFRPPRWLRQSROLWL TXHFDUDDG(VTXLUROqPROWRVLPLOHDOFRQFHWWRGLVLVWHPDULYROX]LR QDULR HODERUDWRGD%RQDOG / HVSUHVVLRQH VSHVVRULIHULWDDJOLRUDJHV 6LULFRUGLFKHQHO (VTXLUROqJLjD3DULJL &LWR TXL GDTXHOO DXWHQWLFRJLRLHOORGHOODFULWLFDOHWWHUDULD ² SLHQRGLVWLPRODQWLSUR VSHWWLYHVXOUDSSRUWRWUDIHQRPHQROHWWHUDULR VXFFHGHUVLGHOOH©JHQHUD]LRQLªHUHDOWjVRFLRSR OLWLFD ² FKHqGL$7KLEDXGHW+LVWRLUHGHODOLWWpUDWXUHIUDQoDLVHGHjQRVMRXUV3DULV (GLWLRQV6WRFN SS 81 ),/262)2 1(//$ &$6$ '(, 3$==, GH OD UpYROXWLRQ VLHVWHQGHILQR DG DEEUDFFLDUHTXDOVLDVLDOWHUD]LRQH GHOO DVVHWWR SROLWLFR HVLVWHQWH FRQVLGHUDWD IRULHUD GHO GLVRUGLQH PR UDOH HSRUWDWULFH GL XQ HFFHVVR GLSDVVLRQH FKHVLLGHQWLILFD FRPHq QRWR FRQODSUHVHQ]DGHOODIROOLD 5LJHQHUDWRULGHOO XPDQLWjHPRVWULGHOO RUGLQHPRUDOH $UWLFROD]LRQHHFRQVHJXHQ]DGLUHWWDGLTXHVWDLPSRVWD]LRQHVHP EUDHVVHUHODWHPDWL]]D]LRQHGHOODPRQRPDQLDG RUJRJOLRHGHOGHOLULR GLJUDQGH]]DFKHSUHVXSSRQHORVLqYLVWRXQDWWHJJLDPHQWRQHJDWL YR TXDQGR QRQ GL FRQGDQQD H GLHVHFUD]LRQH YHUVR WXWWLLSURJHWWL GLULIRUPD GHOOD VRFLHWjHGLULJHQHUD]LRQHGHOO XRPR HTXLQGLYHUVR WXWWL FRORUR FKH D TXHVWL SURJHWWL ² GD VDQL R GD PDODWL RSSXUH FRPHQHOFDVRGL&RPWHLQHQWUDPEHOHFRQGL]LRQL²KDQQRGHGLFD WRODORURHVLVWHQ]D 7DOHLPSRVWD]LRQHDIIRQGDOHVXHUDGLFL²TXHVWRqLQQHJDELOH² QHOO RVVHUYD]LRQHHPSLULFDFLRqQHLGDWLHPHUJHQWLGHOODSUDWLFDFOLQL FD %DVWHUHEEHLQYHQWDULDUH DSDUWLUHGDOODVLOORJHHVTXLUROLDQDHGDL GXH OLEUL FLWDWL GL /HXUHW WXWWHOHPRQRPDQLH G RUJRJOLR UDFFRQWDWH GDJOL DOLHQLVWLLQ FXL FRPSDUH VXOODERFFDGHLIROOL R QHLORUR VFULWWL GHOLUDQWL LO WHUPLQH ULJHQHUD]LRQH FRVu IUHTXHQWH DG HVHPSLR QHL VDLQWVLPRQLDQLHQHJOLVWHVVLVFULWWLGL&RPWH8QDGHOOHVWRULHSLVL JQLILFDWLYHUDFFRQWDWHGD/HXUHWQHOWHVWRGHO qTXHOODGHOULOHJD WRUH IROOH RVVHVVLRQDWR GDOO LGHD GL GDUH XQDYHVWH WLSRJUDILFD ILVVD H LQYDULDELOHDWXWWLJOLDWWLSXEEOLFLDXWRUHGLXQDEURFKXUHODVSHGLVFH DOJLRUQDOHGHLQRWDLDGXQPLQLVWHURDOO $FDGpPLHGHVVFLHQFHVPR UDOHV HW SROLWLTXHV H OD ODQFLD LQ XQD FLQTXDQWLQD GL HVHPSODUL QHO EHO PH]]R GHOOD FDPHUD GHL GHSXWDWL VXEHQGR LPPHGLDWDPHQWH XQ DUUHVWRHO LQWHUQDPHQWRD%LFrWUH2FFRUUH ² VFULYHTXHVWRJHQHUR VR PRQRPDQH ² ©UpIRUPHUOHPRQGH UpJpQpUHUO KRPPH HQDUUD FKDQWO KLVWRLUHDX[PDLQVGHODEDUEDULHª 8QDOWURULJHQHUDWRUH² FLWDWRVHPSUHGD/HXUHW ² qDXWRUHGLXQDEURFKXUHFKHKDSHUWLWR OR/ +XPDQLVDWLRQ RXOHUpJpQpUDWHXUSDUIDLWHWXQLYHUVHOª /DEDVHHPSLULFDLOIRQGDPHQWRHPSLULFRFOLQLFRGHOODPRQRPD QLD G RUJRJOLR H GHO GHOLULR GL JUDQGH]]D q GXQTXH LQFRQIXWDELOH ) /HXUHW'XWUDLWHPHQW FLWS ,YLS /( 3$66,21, ( /$ 6725,$ 3RVVLHGHWXWWDYLD FRPH VL GLFHYD XQ VRWWLQWHVRSROLWLFR DOWUHWWDQWR HYLGHQWHHIRULHURGLFRQVHJXHQ]HQRQWUDVFXUDELOLLQWXWWRORVYLOXS SRGHOO DOLHQLVWLFDRWWRFHQWHVFD,O*XODJGHLGLVVLGHQWLJHVWLWRFRQOD FDX]LRQH FRPSLDFHQWH GLXQDSVLFKLDWULD DVVHUYLWD GDLVWDQ]H GL FRQ WUROOR H GL UHSUHVVLRQH GHO GLVVHQVR WURYD LQ TXHVWD FRQJLXQWXUD HG LQTXHVWLWHVWLLOVXRDWWRGLQDVFLWDRTXDQWRPHQRODVXDFRQGL]LRQH GL SRVVLELOLWj $OO RVVHUYD]LRQH FOLQLFD FKH UHJLVWUD IHGHOPHQWHO HVL VWHQ]D GLPRQRPDQLHOHJDWH D GHOLUL GL JUDQGH]]D DIROOLSURJHWWL GL ULIRUPD GLULJHQHUD]LRQHRGLULYROX]LRQHVLDIILDQFDEHQSUHVWRXQ L VWDQ]DGLSDWRORJL]]D]LRQHGHOGLVVHQVRGHOSURJHWWRSROLWLFRVRYYHU WLWRUH GHOOD SUDWLFD H GHOOD VSHUDQ]D GL ULYROX]LRQH XQ LVWDQ]D FKH WURYHUj HQWUROD FRPXQLWjGHJOLSVLFKLDWUL FRQYLQWLDVVHUWRULPDDQ FKH ² RFFRUUHVRWWROLQHDUOR ² SROHPLFLGHWUDWWRUL %ULHUUHGH%RL VPRQW ² DXWRUHGLXQDLPSRUWDQWHPRQRJUDILDVXOVXLFLGLR ² RVVHU YDGRSRJOLDYYHQLPHQWLGHOFKHLVHJXDFLGHOSDUWLWRFRQVHUYD WRUH VRQR DIIHWWL GD ©PRQRPDQLH GHSUHVVLYHª PHQWUH L VRVWHQLWRUL GHOOHQXRYHLGHHVRQRDIIHWWLGDPDQLHRGD©PRQRPDQLHJDLHª/R VWHVVR%ULHUUHGRSROD&RPXQHGL3DULJLFRQLDSHUGHILQLUHO DWWLYLWj ULYROX]LRQDULDGHLFRPXQDUGLO HVSUHVVLRQHIROLHGpPDJRJLTXHHFRQ VLJOLD SHU L IROOL GHPDJRJLFL VRJJHWWL SDUWLFRODUPHQWHSHULFRORVL OD FRVWUL]LRQH PHFFDQLFD &RQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH 0RUHO VL SURQXQFLD FRQWUR TXHVWDWHQWDWDSVLFKLDWUL]]D]LRQH GHOULYROX]LRQDULR ,ULYROX ]LRQDUL SHU0RUHO QRQ VRQRIROOL PD VROWDQWR GHLPRQVWUHVGHO RU GUH PRUDO 'LFH7DJXHWQHO LQXQDUWLFRORGRYHQRQPDQFDQRLULFKLD PLDOOHLGpHVGHJUDQGHXUGL(VTXLUROROWUHFKHO DFFHWWD]LRQHGHOFRQ FHWWR GL OLSHPDQLD O¶LJQREOH &RPPXQH L ©FOXEV GHV IHPPHVª ©OD SUHVVHUDGLFDOHªVRQRWXWWLIDWWRULHGDYYHQLPHQWLFKHKDQQRHVHUFLWD WR XQD ©LQIOXHQFH FRQVLGpUDEOHª ©VXUODSURGXFWLRQ GHO DOLpQDWLRQ $%ULHUUH'H%RLVPRQW'XVXLFLGHHWGHODIROLHVXLFLGH3DULV*HUPHU%DLOOLqUH 3HUODFLWD]LRQHFIU$%ULHUUH'H%RLVPRQW,QIOXHQFHGHVGHUQLHUVpYpQHPHQWVVXUOHGpYHORS SHPHQWGHODIROLH LQ©/ 8QLRQPpGLFDOHª OXJOLR ,GXHFRQWULEXWL ² TXHOORGL%ULHUUHHTXHOORGL0RUHO ² FRPSDLRQR HQWUDPELQHOOD VWHVVD DQQDWD LO QHOOH©$QQDOHV0pGLFR3V\FKRORJLTXHVª 9HQJRQRFLWDWLGD%'H)Up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pIXQ]LRQDOLDGXQFHUWRPRGRGLLQWHUSUHWDUHODYLWDVRFLRSROLWLFDHGLSUR FHVVLVWRULFL 81 ),/262)2 1(//$ &$6$ '(, 3$==, PHQWDOHª 1HOOR VWHVVR DUWLFROR VLXWLOL]]D DQFRUD QRQ VHQ]D TXDO FKHHVLWD]LRQHLOWHUPLQHPHJDORPDQLDFRPHOHPPDGHOYRFDERODULR SVLFKLDWULFR / LPSRVWD]LRQHHVTXLUROLDQDVRSUDYYLYHDQFKHLQXQSH ULRGRFDUDWWHUL]]DWRLQDPELWRSVLFKLDWULFR GDOODFULVLGHOODQRVRJUD ILD GHL SDGUL IRQGDWRUL ,O IDPRVR LQWHUYHQWR WHRULFR GL-HDQ 3LHUUH )DOUHW²'HODQRQH[LVWHQFHGHODPRQRPDQLH²HUDJLjXVFLWRVXOOH ©$UFKLYHVJpQpUDOHVGH0pGHFLQHªQHO ,OWUDWWDWRGL)DOUHWFKH GDYDIRUPD FRHUHQWHH VLVWHPDWLFD DTXHVWDURWWXUD ULVDOLYD DO &LyQRQRVWDQWH O DSSDUDWRFRQFHWWXDOHPRELOLWDWRGDLSDGULIRQGDWRUL SHU DIIURQWDUH LO UDSSRUWR WUD ULYROX]LRQH ©FRPPRWLRQV SROLWLTXHVª HIROOLD VRSUDYYLYH 6RSUDYYLYHHGHPLJUDDQFKHLQDOWULDPELWLVLJQL ILFDWLYL EDVWL SHQVDUH DOO RSHUD GL ,SSROLWR 7DLQH H LQ SDUWLFRODU PRGRDOODVXDJUDQGHLPSUHVDVWRULFD/HVRULJLQHVGHOD)UDQFHFRQ WHPSRUDLQH LOJUDQGHOLEURGHOFRQVHUYDWRULVPRUHD]LR QDULRHGHOODGHVWUDIUDQFHVH FXLDWWLQVHURSRLDSLHQHPDQLL%DUUqV HL0DXUUDV'RSRODVWRULDJHQHUDOHHILORVRILFDXVFLWDGDJOLDPELHQ WL GHOO ,QVWLWXW GRSR TXHOOD QDUUDWLYD H SLWWRUHVFD j OD 0LFKHOHW VL LPSRQHFRQ7DLQHODVWRULDSVLFRORJLFD RPHJOLRXQDOHWWXUDSVLFROR JLFDGHLJUDQGLSHULRGLHGHLJUDQGLDYYHQLPHQWLGHOODVWRULDGL)UDQ FLD GHOO DQFLHQUpJLPH GHOOD5LYROX]LRQH GL1DSROHRQH 8QDLQWHU SUHWD]LRQHSVLFRORJLVWLFDDOODTXDOH7DLQHHUDDUULYDWRGRSRXQOXQJR DSSUHQGLVWDWR DQQLGLODYRURFKHORSRUWDURQRQHODSXE EOLFDUHLOIDPRVRVDJJLR'HO¶LQWHOOLJHQFHFKHWDQWDLQIOXHQ]DHVHUFLWz VXL PHGLFL VXJOL LQWHOOHWWXDOL VXL ILORVRIL 6XJOL VWHVVL DOLHQLVWL 1HO OH©$QQDOHV0pGLFR3V\FKRORJLTXHVªRVSLWDQRXQLQWHUYHQWR GL&KDUOHV)HD WXWWRGHGLFDWR DOO LOOXVWUD]LRQHGLTXHVWROLEUR 3HU VSLHJDUH LO FRPSRUWDPHQWR GHL FDSLJLDFRELQL7DLQH XWLOL]]D ODUJDPHQWH OH FDWHJRULH HVTXLUROLDQH LQ SDUWLFRODU PRGR TXHOOH GL PRQRPDQLD&LWHUzGXHSDVVLWUDWWLGDOODWUDGX]LRQHLWDOLDQDGL2ULJL QHVXVFLWDSHULWLSLGL7UHYHVDJOLLQL]LGHOQRVWURVHFROR /HLGHHGL FRQWUDWWR VRFLDOH GL VRYUDQLWj GHO SRSROR GL UDJLRQ GL VWDWR GLFH 7DLQH LQVHGLDWHLQFHUYHOOLULVWUHWWL ² TXHOOLSHUO DSSXQWRGHLFDSL JLDFRELQL ² GLYHQWHUDQQR XQD ©PRQRPDQLD IUHGGD HIXULRVDª 0D UDWqLOSLPRVWUXRVRHJOLFRQILQDFRQO DOLHQDWRHQHSUHVHQWDLWUDWWL + 7DJXHW (WXGH FOLQLTXH GX GpOLUH GHV JUDQGHXUV HQ GHKRUV GH OD SDUDO\VLH JHQHUDOH LQ ©$QQDOHV0pGLFR3V\FKRORJLTXHVªJHQQDLR SSOHFLWD]LRQLGHOWHVWRVRQRSUHVH GDOODSÊTXHVWDODVHFRQGDSDUWHGHOODYRURGL7DJXHWODSULPDqGHO HGqFRPSDUVD QHOOD VWHVVD VHGH FKH RWWHQQH LO3UL[(VTXLURO ,O SXQWR GLYLVWD GL7DJXHW HUDGXQTXH FRQGLYLVRGDPROWLDOWULDOLHQLVWL ² DQFKHVHQRQGDWXWWL ² HFRQVLGHUDWRFRPXQTXHDVVROXWD PHQWHOHJLWWLPR GDOO LQWHUD FRPXQLWj GHJOL DOLHQLVWL 7RPR[YPHVHGLPDJJLR /( 3$66,21, ( /$ 6725,$ SULQFLSDOL O HVDOWD]LRQHIXULRVDODVRYUDHFFLWD]LRQHFRQWLQXDO DWWLYL Wj IHEEULOH LOIOXVVRLQHVDXULELOHGLVFULWWXUD O DXWRPDWLVPR GHOSHQ VLHURHLOWHWDQRGHOODYRORQWjVRWWRODYLROHQ]DHODGLUH]LRQHGHOO LGHD ILVVDROWUHDFLzLVLQWRPLILVLFLRUGLQDULO LQVRQQLDODWLQWDSOXPEHD LOVDQJXHEUXFLDWRLOVXGLFLXPHGHJOLDELWLHGHOODSHUVRQDILQDOPHQ WHHGXUDQWHLFLQTXHHXOWLPLPHVLGHOOHHUSHWLHGHLSUXULWLSHUWXWWR LOFRUSRª &RQTXHVWRVWLOHGDFDUWHOODFOLQLFD7DLQHGHVFULYHO HVDO WD]LRQHOXFLGDODIROOLDUDJLRQDQWHGLXRPLQLFKHHJOLULWLHQHDOGLTXD GHOODSD]]LDDQFKHVHDGHVVDPROWRYLFLQLXRPLQLGXQTXHUHVSRQVD ELOLGHOORURDJLUH PDODFXLFRQGRWWDSXzGLYHQWDUHLQWHOOHJJLOHVROR IDFHQGR ULFRUVR DOOH FDWHJRULH HG DOOH FODVVLILFD]LRQL GHOODSVLFKLDWULD HVTXLUROLDQD &RVuFRQWLQXDVHPSUHDSURSRVLWRGL0DUDW©4XDQGRXQDOLHQD WRYHGHGRYXQTXHLQWRUQRDVpVXOSDYLPHQWRVXOOHSDUHWLVXOVRIILW WR GHJOLVFRUSLRQL GHLUDJQL XQEUXOLFKLRGLSLGRFFKLIHWHQWLHYHOH QRVLHJOLQRQSHQVDSLFKHDVFKLDFFLDUOLHODPDODWWLDPHQWDOHHQWUD QHOVXRXOWLPRSHULRGRGRSRLOGHOLULRDPEL]LRVRODPDQLDGHOOHSHU VHFX]LRQLHO LQFXERILVVR ODPRQRPDQLDRPLFLGDVLqGLFKLDUDWDª &RVuFRQFOXGH LQILQH HVWHQGHQGRODGLDJQRVLGDOO LQGLYLGXRDOO LQWH UDFROOHWWLYLWj ©'DOSULQFLSLRDOODILQHHJOLqVWDWRQHOGLULWWRILORGHOOD 5LYROX]LRQH OXFLGR DIRU]DGLDFFHFDPHQWR JUD]LH DOODVXDORJLFDGL SD]]RJUD]LHDOODFRQFRUGDQ]DGHOODVXDPDODWWLDSULYDWDDOODPDODWWLD SXEEOLFD JUD]LH DOOD SUHFRFLWj GHO VXR GHOLULR FRPSOHWR IUD JOL DOWUL GHOLUL LQFRPSOHWLHWDUGLYL VRORLPPXWDELOH VHQ]DULPRUVL WULRQIDQ WH FROORFDWR GL SULPR EDO]R VXOOD FLPD DJX]]D FKH L VXRL ULYDOL QRQ RVDQRDVFHQGHUHRQRQDVFHQGRQR FKHWHQWRQLª 4XHVWD WUDVPLJUD]LRQH GL FRQFHWWL GD (VTXLURO D 7DLQH SRUWD FRQ Vp DQFKH XQ VLJQLILFDWLYR PXWDPHQWR GL SURVSHWWLYD WHRULFD 6H GDSULQFLSLRqODULYROX]LRQH FRPHSURFHVVRVWRULFRDGLQIOXLUHVXOOD SURGX]LRQH GHOOD IROOLD SL WDUGL GRSR (VTXLURO ² GD %ULHUUH GH %RLVPRQW D7DLQH ² VDUj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jDOSURSULRLQWHUQRHFKHFXOPL QD FRQ O¶H[SHUWLVH GL GXH DOLHQLVWLWHGHVFKL .DKQ H .UDHSHOLQ GDOOD TXDOH ULVXOWD FKH L FDSL GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD GHL &RQVLJOL GL 0RQDFR TXHOOL ULPDVWL LQ YLWD H VRWWRSRVWL D SHUL]LD SVLFKLDWULFD HUDQR GHJOL SVLFRSDWLFL /D PHJDORPDQLD GHL ULJHQHUDWRUL TXHOOD FKH QHO (VTXLURO DYHYD YLVWR LQ &RPWH ² OD VWHVVD FKH /HXUHW DYHYD ULVFRQWUDWR LQ PROWLGHOLULGLJUDQGH]]DFKHDELWDYDQROHFDVHGHLSD]]L ² GLYHQWD FRQLOSDVVDUHGHOWHPSR XQXWHQVLOHFRQFHWWXDOHFKHFRQVHQWHDOO D OLHQLVWD GL DVVHJQDUH D GHLSURFHVVLSDWRORJLFL LQGLYLGXDOL LO UXROR GL IRU]DPRWULFHGHOODEDUEDULHGHOO RGLRGHOODVHWHGLVDQJXHGHOODYLR OHQ]D VRFLDOH GLIIXVD FKH VFDQGLVFRQR XQSURFHVVR ULYROX]LRQDULR ,IROOLGHPDJRJLFLGL%ULHUUHGH%RLVPRQWLQJUDQSDUWHUHVSRQVD ELOLGHOODYLROHQ]DULYROX]LRQDULD² PDDOWHPSRVWHVVRLUUHVSRQVDELOL SURSULRLQTXDQWRDOLHQDWL²YDQQRLVRODWLVHJUHJDWLGDOODVRFLHWjFL YLOHVRWWRSRVWLD©FRVWUL]LRQHPHFFDQLFDªVHSRVVLELOHFXUDWL4XHOOD GL %ULHUUH q XQD SUHVD GL SRVL]LRQH SROHPLFD QHL FRQIURQWL GHJOL VFLHQ]LDWLHGHJOLSVLFKLDWULWHGHVFKLFRPHLOFHOHEUH9LUFKRZRO DOLH QLVWD&DUO6WDUN FKHDWWULEXLYDQRDOSRSRORIUDQFHVHQHOVXRDVVLHPH XQDGHJHQHUD]LRQHSDWRORJLFD FKHUDSSUHVHQWDYDO DXWHQWLFDPDWULFH GHJOLHFFHVVLULYROX]LRQDUL $WDOLSRVL]LRQL IDFHYDQRHFRDQFKHDOLH QLVWLGLSHVRFRPH/HJUDQGGX6DXOOHFKHVFULYHXQVDJJLR6XOORVWDWR PHQWDOH GHJOL DELWDQWL GL 3DULJL GXUDQWH JOL DYYHQLPHQWL GHO FRPSDUVRFRPHDSSHQGLFHGLXQDSXEEOLFD]LRQHFRQVDFUDWDDO 'pOLUHGHVSHUVpFXWLRQV%ULHUUHLQSROHPLFDFRQLWHGHVFKLHFRQOR VWHVVR/HJUDQGLPSXWDGXQTXHORVYLOXSSRGLXQSURFHVVRULYROX]LR QDULRDOODIROOLDGHPDJRJLFDGHLFDSLHQRQDOODGHJHQHUD]LRQHHGDOOD PDODWWLDPRUDOHGLXQLQWHURSRSRORGLXQ LQWHUDQD]LRQH0RUHOGDO FDQWR VXR ² FKHDYHYDYLVWRODVXDSVLFKLDWULDGHOODGpJpQpUHVFHQFH &IU$7KLEDXGHWRSFLWS5HQDQ7DLQH²VFULWWRULHVWRULFL²DEEDQGRQDQR VHFRQGR7KLEDXGHWLORURFDQWLHULVFLHQWLILFLSHUGLYHQWDUH©OHVPpGHFLQVGHOD)UDQFHª7XWWD ODOHWWHUDWXUDGLTXHVWRGRSRJXHUUDGLYHQWDFRVuXQH OLWWpUDWXUHGHFRQVXOWDWLRQ , GXHDUWLFROLGL.UDHSHOLQ HGL.DKQ ² FKHQRQKR SRWXWR FRQVXOWDUH GLUHWWDPHQWH ²YHQJRQRFLWDWLGD.'|UQHURSFLWS + /HJUDQG'X6DXOOH6XUO pWDWPHULWDLGHVKDELWDQWVGH3DULVSHQGDQWOHVpYpQHPHQWV GHLQ©$QQDOHV0pGLFR3V\FKRORJLTXHVª9, /( 3$66,21, ( /$ 6725,$ XWLOL]]DWDLQFKLDYHDQWLIUDQFHVHGDJOLDXWRULWHGHVFKL²ULVSRQGHFRQ VRWWLOH SHUILGLD UHVSLQJHOH WHRULH GL /HJUDQG SXUQRQ DFFHWWDQGR LO WHUUHQRVFHOWRGD%ULHUUHFRPHVLqGHWWRWUDWWDLOHDGHUVULYROX]LRQD ULFRPHPRQVWUHVGHO RUDUHPRUDOHQRQFRPHDOLHQDWLPDDOWHPSR VWHVVRULFRUGDFRQHQIDVLFKLVRQRTXHVWLOHDGHUVHGDGRYHYHQJRQR 6RQR WHGHVFKL 6RQR L FDSLGHOO ,QWHUQD]LRQDOH FKH VL VRQR GDWL DS SXQWDPHQWR ² GLFH0RUHO FRQHYLGHQWHDOOXVLRQHD0DU[ ² QHOOD QRVWUD GLVJUD]LDWD FDSLWDOH 6L SXz IRUVH DIIHUPDUH FKH 7DLQH RSHUD XQD VLQWHVL GHOOH WHVL GL %ULHUUH GL 0RUHO H GL /HJUDQG DWWUDYHUVR XQ DUJRPHQWD]LRQH FLUFRODUH GRYH OD GHJHQHUD]LRQH ULYROX]LRQDULD YLHQH FRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH ULIHULWD DOOD QD]LRQH PDODWD HG DO FRP SRUWDPHQWR GHOLUDQWH GHJOL DJLWDWRUL H GHL FDSL JLDFRELQL FDSL FKH UDSSUHVHQWDQR XQD VRUWD GL SXQWR LQWHUPHGLR WUD YL]LR H IROOLD WUD SHUYHUVLWjFRQVDSHYROHHTXLQGLLPSXWDELOHHPRQRPDQLDUDJLRQDQ WH FRQVDSHYROHPDQRQLPSXWDELOH ELVRJQRVD VHPPDL GLXQDGLD JQRVL VLFXUD ROWUH FKH GL HIILFDFL PLVXUH GL FRVWUL]LRQH H GLSUHYHQ ]LRQH$QFRUDXQDYROWDRFFRUUHVRWWROLQHDUHFKHSHURSHUDUHTXHVWD JHQLDOH VLQWHVL 7DLQH KD ELVRJQR GHOOD SVLFKLDWULD GL (VTXLURO SL FKHGLTXHOODVXFFHVVLYDDODOO DQQRFLRqLQFXLO LQWHURHGLILFLR FRQFHWWXDOH VX FXL SRJJLD LO FRQFHWWR GL PRQRPDQLD YLHQH UDGLFDO PHQWHFRQIXWDWR7DLQHKDELVRJQRGLXQDSVLFKLDWULD ² TXHOODGHOOH RULJLQL ² WXWWDJLRFDWD VXOORVFDQGDORGHOODFRQWLQXLWjWUDUDJLRQHH IROOLDWUDSDVVLRQLHGDOLHQD]LRQHWUDYL]LRHPRQRPDQLDWUDWULVWH]]D HOLSHPDQLD WUDSHUYHUVLWjGLFXRUHHPRQRPDQLDRPLFLGD 7DLQHKD ELVRJQRGLXQDSVLFKLDWULDIRQGDWDVXOODSDU]LDOLWjHVXOO XQLWjGHOGH OLULR SL FKHGLXQD GRWWULQD FKH VFRSUDQHOIROOHODPROWHSOLFLWjGHO GHOLULR HODWUDVIRUPD]LRQHFRPSOHWDGLSHUVRQDOLWj XQDGRWWULQDFKH QRQDUULYHUjPDL©jFRQIRQGUHODIROLHDYHFOHVHUUHXUVGHO HVSULWKX PDLQª FRPH HUD LQYHFH DFFDGXWR VHFRQGR )DOUHW D 3LQHO H DG (VTXLURO -3)DOUHW'HODQRQH[LVWHQFHGHODPRQRPDQLHFLWS