Gilbert of Poitiers: Modalities and Counterfactual Identity – Essential Bibliography Lisbon 05-‐04-‐2013 Fonti primarie Agostino: De civitate Dei, 2 voll., eds. B. Dombart -‐ A. Kalb, Turnhout 1955. De dono perseverantiae, PL 45 coll. 995-‐1034, Paris 1861. De natura et gratia, eds. C. Urba -‐ J. Zyncha, CSEL 60, Wien – Leipzing 1913. De perfectione iustitiae hominis, eds. C. Urba -‐ J. Zyncha, CSEL 42, Wien – Leipzing 1902. De praedestinatione sanctorum, PL 44 coll. 959-‐992, Paris 1861. Anselmo d’Aosta: Opera Omnia, ed. F. Schmitt, Edinburgh 1946-‐61 Aristotele: Categoriae et liber De interpretatione, ed. L. Minio-‐Paluello, Oxford 1949. Categoriae vel predicamenta. Translatio Boetii, ed. L. Minio-‐Paluello, Bruges – Paris 1961 [Aristoteles Latinus I 1] Categoriae vel predicamenta. Editio composita (Vulgata), ed. L. Minio-‐Paluello, Bruges – Paris 1961 [Aristoteles Latinus I 2] Categoriarum supplementa. Pophyrii Isagoge translatio Boethii et Anonymi fragmentum vulgo vocatum 'Liber sex principiorum' Accedunt Isagoges fragmenta, eds. L. Minio-‐ Paluello – B. G. Dodd, Aristoteles Latinus, ALPE De interpretatione vel Periermeneias. Translatio Boetii, ed. L. Minio-‐Paluello, Bruges-‐ Paris 1965 [= Aristoteles Latinus II 1] De sophisticis elenchis. Translatio Boetii, ed. G. Dod, Leiden-‐Bruxelles 1975 [Aristoteles Latinus VI 1] Boezio : De consolatione philosophiae, ed. L. Bieler, Turnhout 19842 [=CCSL 94] De divisione, ed. J. Magee, Leiden – Boston-‐ Köln 1998. De hypoteticis syllogismis, ed. L. Orbetello, Brescia 1969. Commentarii in librum Aristotelis Peri Ermeneias, 2 voll., ed. K. Meiser, Teubner 1877 e 1880. Commentari in Ciceronis Topica, ed. J. C. Orelli e J. G. Baiter, in M. Tulli Ciceronis opera omnia V, 1, Zurich 1833. De syllogismo categorico, Paris 1847 [PL 64, coll. 793c-‐832a] De topicis differentiis, ed. D. Z. Nikitas, Athens-‐ Paris-‐ Bruxelles 1990. In Isagogen Porphyrii commenta, ed. G. Schepss e S. Brandt, Wien – Leipzing 1906 [CSEL 48, 1] Opuscula Theologica. De Consolatione Philosophiae, ed. C. Moreschini, Monaco 20052 Gilberto Porretano: The Commentaries on Boethius, ed. N. M. Häring, Toronto 1966 Giovanni Duns Scoto: Opera Omnia, Lyon 1639. Opera Omnia, I-‐(XIII), Città del Vaticano 1950-‐(2011). Gilbert of Poitiers: Modalities and Counterfactual Identity – Essential Bibliography Lisbon 05-‐04-‐2013 Guillelmi de Ockham: Opera philosophica et theologica. Opera philosophica I, Summa logicae, New York, St. Bonaventure, 1974 Pier Damiani: De Divina omnipotentia, ed. A Cantin, Paris 1972 Studi − Becker-‐Freysing, A., Die Vorgeschichte des philosophischen Terminus “contingens”: Die Bedeutungen von “contingere” bei Boethius und ihr Verhältnis zu den Aristotelischen Möglichkeitsbegriffen, Heidelberg 1938. − Berthaud, A., Gilbert de la Porrée, évêque de Poitiers, et sa philosophie, Poitiers 1892 − Braakhuis, H.A.G. -‐ Kneepkens, C.H. (eds.), Aristotle’s Peri hermeneias in the Latin Middle Ages, ARTS 10, 2010. − Catalani, L., I Porretani. Una scuola di pensiero tra alto e basso Medioevo, Turnhout 2008. − Chisholm, R. M., “Identity through Possible Worlds: Some Questions”, Noûs, 1 (1967), 1–8 − Ciola, G., Nozioni modali in Gilberto Porretano, tesi magistrale, Istituto Universitario di Studi Superiori (IUSS), Pavia, ottobre 2012 − Corsi, G. -‐ Mangione, C. -‐ Mugnai, M., Atti del convegno internazionale di storia della logica. Le teorie della modalità, Bologna 1989. − De Rijk, L. M., Logica Modernorum, 2 voll., Assen 1962-‐67. − De Rijk, L. M., « Die Wirkung der neuplatonischen Semantik auf das mittelalterlische Denken über das Sein », in Sprache und Erkenntnis im Mittelalter, eds. W. Kluxen et al., Berlin 1981, p. 19-‐35. − De Rijk, « Boèce logicien et philosophe: ses positions sémantiques et sa métaphysique de l’être », in L. Oberiello (ed.), Atti del Congresso internazionale di studi boeziani (Pavia 1980), Roma 1981, 141-‐156 − De Rijk, L. M., « On Boethius’ Notion of Being: A Chapter of Boethian Semantics», in N. Kretzmann (ed.), Meaning and Reference in Medieval Philosophy, Dordrecht 1988, 1-‐29. − De Rijk, L. M., “Semantics and Metaphysics in Gilbert of Poitiers. A Chapter of Twelfth Century Platonism”, Vivarium XXVI,2(1988), 73-‐112 e XXVII,1 (1989),1-‐35. − Ebbesen, S., “What Must One Have an Opinion About?”, Vivarium 30, 1 (1992), 62-‐79. − Ebbesen, S., “Medieval Latin Glosses and Commentaries on Aristotelian Logical texts of the Twelfth and Thirteenth Centuries”, in C. Burnett (ed.), Glosses and Commentaries on Aristotelian Logical Texts, London 1993, p. 129-‐177. − Ebbesen, S., “A Porretan Commentary on Aristotle’s Categories”, Cahiers de l’Institut du Moyen Âge grec et latin, 72 (2001), p. 35-‐88 Gilbert of Poitiers: Modalities and Counterfactual Identity – Essential Bibliography Lisbon 05-‐04-‐2013 − Ebbesen, S. -‐ Iwakuma, Y., “Logico-‐Theological Schools from the Second Half of the 12th Century: A List of Sources”, Vivarium 30 (1992), p. 173-‐210. − Ebbesen, S. -‐ Fredborg, K.M. -‐ Nielsen, L. (eds.), “Compendium Logicae Porretanum ex codice Oxoniensi Collegii Corporis Christi 250: A Manual of Porretan Doctrine by a Pupil of Gilbert”, Cahiers de l’Institut du Moyen-‐âge grec et latin, 46 (1983). − Elswijk, H. C. van, Gilbert Porreta, sa vie, son œuvre, sa pensée, Louvain 1966. − Elswijk, H. C. van, “Gilbert Porreta als glossator van het Psalterium”, in Jubileumbundel voor Prof. Mag. Dr. G. P. Kreling O.P., Nijmegen 1953, 282-‐303 − Fontana, M., “Il commento ai Salmi di Gilberto della Porrée”, Logos 13 (1930), 283-‐301 − Forest, A., “Gilbert de la Porrée et les écoles du XII siècle”, Revue des cours et des conférences, LXXXV,II (1934), 410-‐429 e 640-‐651 − Forest, A., «Le réalisme de Gilbert de la Porrée dans le commentaire du De Hebdomadibus », Revue néoscholastique de Philosophie 1934, 101-‐110 − Fredborg, K. M. – Kneepkens, « Grammatica Porretana », Cahiers de l’institut du Moyen Âge grec et latin, 57 (1988), 11-‐67 − Gammersbach, S., Gilbert von Poitiers und seine Prozesse im Urteil der Zeitgenossen, Colonia 1959. − Gibson, M., “The Opuscula Sacra in the Middle Ages”, in M. Gibson (ed.), Boethius: His Life, Thought and Influence, Oxford 1981, 214-‐234 − Gracia, J. E., Introduction to the Problem of Individuation in the Early Middle Ages, München – Wien 19882 − Gracia, J. E., “Thierry of Chartres and the Theory of Individuation”, New Scholasticism 58 (1984), 1-‐23 − Green-‐Pedersen, N. J., The Tradition of the Topics in the Middle Ages, Munich I984 − Gross-‐Diaz, T., The Psalms Commentary of Gilbert of Poitiers. From “Lectio Divina” to the Lecture Room, New York – Leiden – Köln 1996 − Hayen, A., « Le concile de Reims et l’erreur théologique de Gilbert de la Porrée », Archives d’Histoire Doctrinale et Littéraire du Moyen Âge, 10 (1935-‐6), 29-‐102 − Häring, N. M., “The Case of Gilbert De la Porrée Bishop of Poitiers (1142-‐1154),” Medieval Studies 12 (1951), 1-‐40 − Häring, N. M., “Zur Geschichte der Schulem von Poitiers im 12. Jahrundert”, Archiv für Kulturgeschichte 47 (1965), 23-‐47 − Häring, N. M., “Das sogenannte Glaubensbekenntnis des Reimser Konsistoriums von 1148”, Scholastik 40 (1965), 55-‐90. − Häring, N. M. (ed.), The Commentaries on Boethius by Gilbert of Poitiers, Toronto 1966 Gilbert of Poitiers: Modalities and Counterfactual Identity – Essential Bibliography Lisbon 05-‐04-‐2013 − Häring, N. M., “Paris and Chartres Revisited”, in J. R. O’Donnell (ed.), Essays in Honour of Anton Charles, Toronto 1974, 268-‐329 − Hintikka, J., Time and Necessity: Studies in Aristotle’s Theory of Modality, Oxford 1973. − Hintikka, J. -‐ Remes, U. -‐ Knuuttila, S., Aristotle on Modality and Determinism (Acta Philosophica Fennica 29,1), Amsterdam 1977 − Jacobi, K., “Statements about Events. Modal and Tense Analysis in Medieval Logic”, Vivarium 31, 2 (1893), 85-‐108 − Jolivet, J. -‐ de Libera, A. (a cura di), Gilbert de Poitiers et ses contemporains, Napoli 1987. − Jolivet, J., « Trois versions médiévales sur l’universel et l’individu: Roscelin, Abélard, Gilbert de la Porrée », Revue de métaphysique et de morale 97 (1992), 11-‐155 − King, P., “Duns Scotus on Possibilities, Powers and the Possible” in T. Buchheim -‐ C. H. Kneepkens -‐ K. Lorenz (eds.), Potentialität und Possibilität: Modalaussagen in der Geschichte der Metaphysik, Stuttgart-‐ Bad Canstatt 2001, p. 175-‐199. − Knuuttila, S., Reforging the Great Chain of Being, Dordrecht 1981 − Knuuttila, S., «Topics in Late Medieval Intensional Logic», I. Niiniluoto – E. Saarinen (eds.), Intensional Logic: Theory and Applications (Acta Philosophica Fennica 35), Helsinky 1982, 26-‐41 − Knuuttila, S., Modalities in Medieval Philosophy, London -‐ New York 1993. − Knuuttila, S., “Positio impossibilis in Medieval Discussions of the Trinity”, in C. Marmo (ed.), Vestigia, imagines, verba. Semiotics and Logic in Medieval Theological Texts, Turnhout 1997, p. 277-‐288. − Knuuttila, “Time and Creation in Augustine”, in W. Stump – N. Krretzmann (eds), The Cambridge Companion to Augustine, Cambridge 2001, 103-‐105. − Knuuttila, S., “On the History of Theory of Modality as Alternativeness”, in T. Buchheim -‐ C. H. Kneepkens -‐ K. Lorenz (eds.), Potentialität und Possibilität: Modalaussagen in der Geschichte der Metaphysik, Stuttgart-‐Bad Canstatt 2001, 219-‐236. − Knuuttila, S., “Anselm on Modality”, in B. Davies – B. Leftow (eds.), The Cambridge Companion to Anselm, Cambridge 2004, 111-‐131 − Knuuttila, S., «Medieval Modal Theories and Modal Logic», in D. M. Gabbay – J. Woods (eds.), Handbook of the History of Logic. II: Medieval and Renaissance Logic, Amsterdam 2008, 505-‐ 578. − Kretzmann, N., “Nos ipsi principia sumus: Boethius and the Basis of Contingency”, in T. Rudavsky (ed.), Divine Omniscience in Medieval Philosophy, Dordrecht 1985, p. 23-‐50. − Lagerlund, H., Modal Syllogistics in the Middle Ages, Leiden 2000. − Langston, D.C., "Scotus and Possible Worlds", in S. Knuuttila -‐ S. Ebbesen -‐ R. Tyoerinoja (eds.), Knowledge and the Sciences in Medieval Philosophy, Proceedings of the Eighth International Congress of Medieval Philosophy II , Helsinki, 1990, p. 240-‐247. − Lohr, C.H., Medieval Latin Aristotle Commentaries, 2 voll., New York 1967-‐1974. Gilbert of Poitiers: Modalities and Counterfactual Identity – Essential Bibliography Lisbon 05-‐04-‐2013 − Maioli, B., Gilberto Porretano. Dalla grammatica speculativa alla metafisica del concreto, Roma 1979. − Marenbon, J., “Gilbert of Poitiers”, in P. Dronke (ed.), A History of Twelfth-‐century Western Philosophy, Cambridge 1988, 528-‐352. − Marenbon, J., “A Note on the Porretani”, in P. Dronke (ed.), A History of Twelfth-‐century Western Philosophy, Cambridge 1988, p. 353-‐357. − Marenbon, J., “Medieval Latin Commentaries and Glosses on Aristotelian Logical Texts, Before c. 1150 AD”, in Ch. Burnett (ed.), Glosses and Commentaries on Aristotelian Logical Texts, London 1993, p. 77-‐ 127. − Marenbon, J., Le temps, l'éternité et la prescience de Boèce à Thomas d'Aquin, Paris 2005. − Miano, V., “Il commento alle lettere di S. Paolo di Gilberto Porretano”, Scholastica ratione historico-‐ critica instauranda, Roma 1951, 169-‐199 − Minio-‐Paluello, L., Twelfth Century Logic, Roma 1956. − Mondadori, F., “Leibniz on Compossibility: Some Scholastic sources”, in R.L. Friedman -‐ L. O. Nielsen (eds.), The Medieval Heritage in Early Modern Metaphysics and Modal Theory, 1400-‐1700, Dordrecht 2003,pp. 324-‐326. − Mugnai, M., Possibile/Necessario, Bologna 2013 − Nielsen, L., “On the Doctrine of Logic and Language of Gilberto Porreta and his Followers”, Cahiers de l’Institut du Moyen Age grec et latin 17 (1976), 40-‐69. − Nielsen, L., Theology and Philosophy in the Twelfth Century: A Study on Gilbert Porreta’s Thinking and Theological Expositions of the Doctrine of the Incarnation during the Period 1113-‐1180, Leiden 1982. − Normore, C., “Future Contingents”, in N. Kretzmann -‐ A. Kenny -‐ J. Pinborg (eds.), The Cambridge History of Later Medieval Philosophy, Cambridge 1982, p. 358-‐381. − Normore, C., “Duns Scotus’ Modal Theory”, in T. Williams (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Duns Scotus, Cambridge 2003, p. 129-‐160. − Pagliari, A., “Il presunto commentario ai Salmi di S. Lorenzo Giustiniani opera di Gilberto Porretano”, Aevum 36 (1962), 414-‐429 − Pelster, F., “Gilbert de la Porrée, Gilbertus Porretanus oder Gilbert Porreta?”, Skolastik 19-‐24 (1944-‐ 1949) − Poole, R.L., « The Masters of the Schools at Paris and Chartres in John of Salisbury’s Time », English Historical Review 35 (1920), 321-‐342 − Rijen, J. van, “The Principle of Plenitude. The de onmi – per se Distinction and the Development of Modal Theory”, Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie 66 (1984), 61-‐88 − Simon, M., “La glose de l’épître aux Romains de Gilbert de la Porrée”, Revue d’histoire ecclésiastique 52 (1957), 51-‐81 Gilbert of Poitiers: Modalities and Counterfactual Identity – Essential Bibliography Lisbon 05-‐04-‐2013 − Schmidt, M.A., Gottheit und Trinität nach dem Kommentar des Gilbert Porreta zu Boethius, De Trinitate, Basel 1956. − Thom, P., Medieval Modal Systems: Problems and Concepts, Aldershot 2003. − Uckelman, S. L., Modalities in Medieval Logic, PhD dissertation, University of Amsterdam, 2009 − Wilks, I., “Peter Abelard and his Contemporaries”, in D. Gabbay – J. Woods (eds.), Handbook of the History of Logic, II, Amsterdam 2008, 85–155. − Valente, L., Logique et théologie, Les écoles parisiennes entre 1150 et 1220, Paris 2008 − Valente, L., “Praedicaturi supponimus. Is Gilbert of Poitiers' approach to linguistic reference a pragmatic one?”, Vivarium 49 (2011), 50-‐74 − Valente, L., “Un realismo singolare: forme e universali in Gilberto di Poitiers e nella Scuola Porretana”, Documenti e studi sulla tradizione filosofica medievale 19 (2008), 191-‐246 − Valente, L., “Cum non sit intelligibilis, nec ergo significabilis. Modi significandi, intelligendi ed essendi nella teologia del XII secolo”, Documenti e studi sulla tradizione filosofica medievale 11 (2000), 132-‐194 − Valente, L., “Essentiae. Forme sostanziali ed 'esistenza' nella filosofia porretana (XII secolo)”, in Mots médiévaux offerts à Ruedi Imbach, a cura di Calma, D. -‐ König-‐Pralong, C. -‐ Zavattero, I., Porto 2011, 353-‐364. − Valente, L., « Langage et théologie pendant la 2nde moitié du XIIe siècle», in Geschichte der Sprachtheorie (ed. Peter Schmitter), vol. III: Sprachtheorien in Spätantike und Mittelalter, a cura di S. Ebbesen, G. Narr, Tuebingen 1995, 33-‐54. − Valente, L., “Names which can be said of everything: Porphyrian Tradition and 'transcendental' Terms in 12th Century Logic”, in The Many Roots of Medieval Logic: the Aristotelian and the Non-‐Aristotelian Traditions, a cura di J. Marenbon, Leiden 2007, 298-‐310 [Atti del convegno, 15 th European Symposium on Medieval logic and Semantics, Cambridge, 2004] − Valente, L., “Logica e teologia trinitaria in Pietro Lombardo e nel trattato porretano Summa Zwettlensis”, in Pietro Lombardo. Atti del XLIII Convegno storico internazione, a cura di CISAM -‐ Accademia Tudertina, CISAM, Spoleto 2007, 23-‐49 [Atti del convegno, Pietro Lombardo. XLIII Convegno storico internazione, Todi, 2006] − Vanni-‐Rovighi, S., « La filosofia di Gilberto Porretano », Miscellanea del Centro Studi Medievali 58 (1956), 1-‐64 Vernet, F., “Gilbert de la Porrée”, in Dictionnaire de théologie catholique, VI, Paris 1920, coll. 1350-‐ 1358 − − Vicaire, M. H., « Les Porrétains et l’avicennisme avant 1215 », Revue des sciences philosophiques et théologique 26 (1937), 449-‐482 − Westley, R.J., “A Philosophy of the Concreted and the Concrete. The Constitution of Creatures according to Gilbert de la Porrée”, Modern Schoolman 37 (1959-‐60), 54-‐90 Gilbert of Poitiers: Modalities and Counterfactual Identity – Essential Bibliography Lisbon 05-‐04-‐2013 − Williams, M. E., The Theaching of Gilbert Porreta on the Trinity as Found in His Commentaries on Boethius, Roma 1951