$SHUWXUDGLXQYDQRSRUWDLQSDUHWHGLPXUDWXUDSRUWDQWH $QDOLVLGHLFDULFKL &DULFRGRYXWRDOSHVRPXURVRYUDVWDQWH VSHVVRUHPXUR VPV FP DOWH]]DPXUR K PV P SHVRVSHFLILFR ZPV .1 P FDULFRDOPHWUROLQHDUH VPV K PV ZPV T PV .1 P &DULFRGRYXWRDOORVFDULFRGHOVRODLRVRYUDVWDQWH OXFHGHOVRODLRDGHVWUD OG[ P FDULFRDJHQWH S G[ .1 P OXFHGHOVRODLRDVLQLVWUD OV[ P FDULFRDJHQWH S V[ .1 P FDULFRDOPHWUROLQHDUH TV S G[ OG[ OV[ S V[ .1 P 5LJLGH]]DGHOPDVFKLRPXUDULR .P (P *P VP OP K P α KP §¨ V O ·¸ P P α (P ¨ ¸ © ¹ KP *P VP OP GRYH x DJUDGRGLYLQFRORLQWHVWDSHUHVWUHPROLEHURFRPSRUWDPHQWRDPHQVRODGHOPDVFKLR PXUDULRSHUHVWUHPRLQFDVWUDWR x V PVSHVVRUHGHOPDVFKLRPXUDULR x KPDOWH]]DGHOPDVFKLRPXUDULR x OPOXQJKH]]DGHOPDVFKLRPXUDULR x (PPRGXORHODVWLFRGHOODPXUDWXUD x *PPRGXORGLHODVWLFLWjWDQJHQ]LDOHGHOODPXUDWXUD 5HVLVWHQ]DDWDJOLRGHOPDVFKLRPXUDULR /DUHVLVWHQ]DDWDJOLRGHLSDQQHOOLPXUDULSXzHVVHUHFDOFRODWDDWWUDYHUVRODVHJXHQWHIRUPXOD 9W O V τ β σ τ § σ · O V ¨ ¸ β © τ ¹ GRYH x WqODUHVLVWHQ]DPHGLDDOWDJOLRGHOODPXUDWXUD x VVSHVVRUHGHOPDVFKLRPXUDULR x EFRHIILFLHQWHFRUUHWWLYRGLSHQGHQWHGDOUDSSRUWRKOHGDVVXPHXQYDORUHFRPSUHVRWUDHG x OOXQJKH]]DGHOPDVFKLRPXUDULR x VWHQVLRQHQRUPDOHPHGLDULIHULWDDOO DUHDWRWDOHPHGLD 6WDWR$QWH2SHUDP 5LJLGH]]DGHOSDQQHOORPXUDULR /HFDUDWWHULVWLFKHJHRPHWULFKHHPHFFDQLFKHGHOODPXUDWXUDVRQR 6SHVVRUHGHOODPXUDWXUD VPXU FP 0RGXOR(ODVWLFR (PXU 1 PP 0RGXORGLHODVWLFLWjWDQJHQ]LDOHGHOODPXUDWXUD *PXU 1 PP 5HVLVWHQ]DPHGLDDOWDJOLR τPXU 1 FP SHVRVSHFLILFRGHOPXUR ZPXU .1 P /XQJKH]]D $OWH]]D *UDGRGLYLQFROR OPXU P K PXU P αPXU 6RVWLWXHQGROHYDULDELOLQHOODIRUPXODSULPDHVSOLFLWDWDVLKDODULJLGH]]DGHOSDQQHOORPXUDULRFKH VDUjSDULD .PXU .1 P 5HVLVWHQ]DDWDJOLRGHOODSDUHWH 3HULOFDOFRORGHOODUHVLVWHQ]DDWDJOLRRFFRUUHGHWHUPLQDUHODWHQVLRQHQRUPDOHPHGLDWUDPLWHOD VHJXHQWHIRUPXOD K O σ K O K VXS L V Z T T V Z K VXS L V Z L T T O V GRYH x KVXS qODGLVWDQ]DWUDLOVRODLRVXSHULRUHHGLOOLPLWHVXSHULRUHGHOYDQR x x VqORVSHVVRUHGHOODPXUDWXUD LqLQGLFDWRO LQWHUDVVHWUDLFDULFKLGLVWULEXLWLDJHQWLDOGLVRSUDGHOSDQQHOORFRVuGHIQLELOH LT O DG DV O DG DV FRQ x DVODUJKH]]DGHOO DSHUWXUDDVLQLVWUD x DGODUJKH]]DGHOO DSHUWXUDDGHVWUD ,QTXHVWRFDVR LQWHUDVVH LPXU P WHQVLRQHQRUPDOHPHGLD σPXU 1 FP FRHIILFHQWHFRUUHWWLYR βPXU qTXLQGLSRVVLELOHGHILQLUHODUHVLVWHQ]DDWDJOLRGHOODSDUHWH 9PXU 1 6LGHWHUPLQDLOWDJOLRXOWLPRGHOODSDUHWHFRQODVHJXHQWHHVSUHVVLRQH 9WX 9 K . 9WPXU PLQ 9 K . .1 6WDWR3RVW2SHUDP 9DULD]LRQHGLULJLGH]]DGHOODSDUHWH /DYDULD]LRQHGLULJLGH]]DGHOODSDUHWHqFDOFRODWDFRPHGLIIHUHQ]DWUDODULJLGH]]DGHOODVLWXD]LRQH DQWHRSHUDPHGLTXHOODSRVWRSHUDP1HOODVLWXD]LRQHILQDOHVLDYUDQQRGXHPDVFKLPXUDULGL DOWH]]DSDULDTXHOODGHOYDQRULFDYDWRFKHVLLQQHVWDQRQHOODIDVFLDGLSLDQRFKHVLqYHQXWDD FUHDUHFRQYLQFRORGLLQFDVWUR ,OSULPRPDVFKLRDYUjTXHVWHFDUDWWHULVWLFKHJHRPHWULFKHRYYLDPHQWHUHVWDQRLQYDULDWHTXHOOH PHFFDQLFKH /XQJKH]]D O P $OWH]]D K P *UDGRGLYLQFROR α 6RVWLWXHQGROHYDULDELOLQHOODIRUPXODSULPDHVSOLFLWDWDVLKDODULJLGH]]DGHOSDQQHOORPXUDULRFKH VDUjSDULD .1 .PXU P 5HVLVWHQ]DDWDJOLRGHOSDQQHOORPXUDULR 7HQVLRQHQRUPDOHPHGLD σ 1 FP 5HVLVWHQ]DDWDJOLRGHOSDQQHOOR 9 7DJOLRXOWLPRGHOSDQQHOOR 9X .1 .1 FRQ KPLQ P DOWH]]DPLQLPDWUDWXWWLLSDQQHOOL ,OVHFRQGRPDVFKLRDYUjTXHVWHFDUDWWHULVWLFKHJHRPHWULFKHRYYLDPHQWHUHVWDQRLQYDULDWHTXHOOH PHFFDQLFKH /XQJKH]]D O FP $OWH]]D K P *UDGRGLYLQFROR α 6RVWLWXHQGROHYDULDELOLQHOODIRUPXODSULPDHVSOLFLWDWDVLKDODULJLGH]]DGHOSDQQHOORPXUDULRFKH VDUjSDULD .PXU .1 P 5HVLVWHQ]DDWDJOLRGHOSDQQHOORPXUDULR 7HQVLRQHQRUPDOHPHGLD σ 1 FP 5HVLVWHQ]DDWDJOLRGHOSDQQHOOR 9 7DJOLRXOWLPRGHOSDQQHOOR 9X .1 .1 7DJOLRXOWLPRGHOODSDUHWHSRVWRSHUDP 9SDUSR 9X 9X .1 &RPHVLYHGHVLYHULILFDXQDFDGXWDGLULJLGH]]DHGLUHVLVWHQ]DGRYXWDDOODFUHD]LRQHGHOYDQR SRUWD /DFDGXWDGLULJLGH]]Dq .PXU .PXU .PXU '. .1 P 0HQWUHODFDGXWDGLUHVLVWHQ]Dq '5 9WPXU 9SDUSR .1 6LSUHYHGHODUHDOL]]D]LRQHGLXQWHODLRFKLXVRLQDFFLDLRGLULJLGH]]DHUHVLVWHQ]DWDOLGD ULSULVWLQDUHDFRQGL]LRQHSUHHVLVWHQWHVHQ]DSRUWDUHDGXQLQFUHPHQWRHFFHVVLYRGHOODULJLGH]]D GHOODSDUHWH 'LPHQVLRQLGHOYDQR /DUJKH]]DQHWWDGHOYDQR % FP /DUJKH]]DORUGDGHOYDQR E FP $OWH]]D1HWWDGHO9DQR + P $OWH]]DORUGDGHOYDQR K P 'LPHQVLRQDPHQWRGHOWHODLR 0RGXOR(ODVWLFRGHOPDWHULDOHXWLOL]]DWRSHULOWHODLRDFFLDLR ( 1 PP 1XPHURGLFRORQQHGHOWHODLR Q FRO ,QHU]LDPLQLPDQHFHVVDULDGHOODVLQJRODFRORQQD -FRO Q FRO § ¨ '. © · ¸ FP ( ¹ + &RPHFRORQQDVLVFHJOLHGXQTXHXQ SURILOR +(% FKHKDXQPRPHQWRGLLQHU]LD DGHJXDWR ,F FP &DOFRORGHOO DUFKLWUDYH 6XOO DUFKLWUDYHVLJHQHUDXQHIIHWWRGLYROWDFKHVLVFDULFDDLODWLSHUWDQWRVLFRQVLGHUDQRJUDYDQWL VXOO DUFKLWUDYHVRORLFDULFKLFKHULHQWUDQRLQXQWULDQJRORHTXLODWHURFRQODWRSDULDOODOXFH GHOO DUFKLWUDYHVWHVVD &DULFRGRYXWRDOSHVRGHOODPXUDWXUDVRYUDVWDQWH SHVRGHOODPXUDWXUD γP .1 P EDVHGHOWULDQJRORHTXLODWHURFRQVLGHUDWR EW FP DOWH]]DGHOWULDQJRORHTXLODWHURFRQVLGHUDWR KW FP 4 γP VPXU % K W 1 7DOHqODULVXOWDQWHGHOFDULFRFRQULIHULPHQWRDOODGLVWULEX]LRQHWULDQJRODUH6LDGRSHUDXQD FRUUH]LRQHLQPRGRGDFRQVLGHUDUHXQFDULFRXQLIRUPHILWWL]LRFKHSURGXFHLQPH]]DULDORVWHVVR PRPHQWRGDWRGDOODGLVWULEX]LRQHWULDQJRODUH6LGLPRVWUDFKHWDOHFRUUH]]LRQHqSDULD &DULFRGRYXWRDOVRODLRVRYUDVWDQWH T VRO 6FDULFRGHOVRODLRVRYUDVWDQWH TV P .1 P KV GLVWDQ]DWUDO DUFKLWUDYHHGLOVRODLRFRQVLGHUDWR KT DOWH]]DGDFRQVLGHUDUHQHOFDOFRORGHOFDULFR TVRO K T 4 E W .1 KW FP FP &DULFRGRYXWRDOSHVRSURSULRGHOO DUFKLWUDYH SHVRSURSULRGHOSURILODWR 4 γV γV E W 1 P 1 /DULVXOWDQWHGHLFDULFKLVXOO DUFKLWUDYHqGXQTXHSDULD 4WRW 4 4 4 1 GDFXL T WRW 4WRW EW 1 P &DOFRORGHOODIRU]DVLVPLFD / D]LRQHVLVPLFDGDDSSOLFDUHDOWHODLRqSDULD 4WRW 6J ) FRQ 6J 1 9HULILFDDOORVWDWROLPLWHXOWLPRGHOWHODLR 6LFRQVLGHUDXQWHODLRLQFHUQLHUDWRDOODEDVHLQTXDQWRVLSUHYHGHO LQVWDOOD]LRQHGLXQDODVWUDVL DFFLDLRFKHFROOHJKLDOODEDVHLSLHGULWWLSHUQRQDYHUHSUREOHPLFRQOHDOWH]]HGHOSDYLPHQWR /HFRPELQD]LRQLGLFDULFRGDFRQVLGHUDUHVRQR &RPELQD]LRQH6/8 &RPELQD]LRQHVLVPLFD &LzqJLXVWLILFDWRGDOIDWWRFKHVXOWHODLRDJLVFRQRVRORFDULFKLSHUPDQHQWLHO D]LRQHVLVPLFD x &RPELQD]LRQH6/8 &DOFRORGHOODVROOHFLWD]LRQHGRYXWDDOFDULFRYHUWLFDOH 0RPHQWRDOO LQFDVWUR 0% T WRW E 1 P ª § ,W K · º « ¨ ¸ » ¬ © ,F E ¹ ¼ 0RPHQWRPDVVLPRDOFHQWURGHOWUDYHUVR 04 T WRW E 0% 1 P &DOFRORGHOODVROOHFLWD]LRQHGRYXWDDOODIRU]DRUL]]RQWDOH 0RPHQWRPDVVLPRDOO HVWUHPLWjGHOWUDYHUVR ) K 0) 1 P 0RPHQWRUHVLVWHQWH 0 F5G :SO I\N γ0 1 P FRQ :SO FP PRGXORGLUHVLVWHQ]DSODVWLFR 0RPHQWRUHVLVWHQWHDOOLPLWHHODVWLFR 0 HO5G :F I\N γ0 1 P FRQ :F &RPELQD]LRQHGLFDULFR 0 %& γ* 0 4 1 P 9HULILFD 0 F5G 0 %& !TXLQGLODYHULILFDqVRGGLVIDWWD 9HULILFDDOOLPLWHHODVWLFR 0 HO5G 0 %& FP PRGXORGLUHVLVWHQ]DHODVWLFR !TXLQGLODYHULILFDqVRGGLVIDWWD x &RPELQD]LRQH6LVPLFD 0 %& 9HULILFD 0 F5G 0 %& 0% 0) 1 P !TXLQGLODYHULILFDqVRGGLVIDWWD 9HULILFDDOOLPLWHHODVWLFR 0 HO5G !TXLQGLODYHULILFDqVRGGLVIDWWD 0 %& 7XWWHOHYHULILFKHV LDVWDWLFKHFKHGLQDPLFKHVLVPLFKHVRQRVRGGLVIDWWH 6LGHWHUPLQDQRRUDODULJLGH]]DHODUHVLVWHQ]DGHOWHODLRSUHYLVWR 5LJLGH]]DDOODWUDVOD]LRQHGHOWHODLR ,QHU]LDFRPSOHVVLYDGHOOHFRORQQH .7 Q FRO ,F -FWRW ( -FWRW + FP .1 P 5HVLVWHQ]DDOWDJOLRGHOWHODLR 0RPHQWRPDVVLPRVRSSRUWDELOHGDOWHODLR ,OWHODLRQRQHQWUDPDLLQFDPSRSODVWLFRHGLFRQVHJXHQ]DqOHFLWRXVDUHLOPRPHQWRUHVLVWHQWHDO OLPLWHHODVWLFRFRPHPDVVLPRPRPHQWRVRSSRUWDELOHGDOWHODLRQHOO LQFDVWUR 0W .1 P 0 HO5G ,OFRUULVSRQGHQWHVSRVWDPHQWRDOOLPLWHHODVWLFRFKHGHWHUPLQDLOPDVVLPRPRPHQWRq G WHO 0W + PP ( ,F /DIRU]DFKHSURYRFDORVSRVWDPHQWRVXGGHWWRWDJOLRXOWLPRGHOWHODLRq )WX G WHO .7 .1 9HULILFDGHOODULJLGH]]DGHOODSDUHWHSRVWRSHUDP /DYHULILFDqVRGGLVIDWWDVHODULJLGH]]DWRWDOHSRVWRSHUDPULVXOWDPDJJLRUHGLTXHOODDQWHRSHUDP .SRVWRSHUDP .PXU .PXU .7 .DQWHRSHUDP .PXU .1 P .1 P /DYHULILFDqVRGGLVIDWWD / LQFUHPHQWRGLULJLGH]]DqQRQPDJJLRUHGHOULVXOWDQGRSDULD ∆. 9HULILFDGHOODUHVLVWHQ]DGHOODSDUHWHSRVWRSHUDP /DYHULILFDqVRGGLVIDWWDVHODUHVLVWHQ]DWRWDOHSRVWRSHUDPULVXOWDPDJJLRUHGLTXHOODDQWH RSHUDP 9SRVWRSHUDP 9X 9X )WX 9DQWHRSHUDP 9WPXU P P .1 .1 P /DYHULILFDqVRGGLVIDWWD / LQFUHPHQWRGLUHVLVWHQ]DqQRQPDJJLRUHGHOULVXOWDQGRSDULD ∆5 P