40$*&5®*5"-*"/" %*(*/&$0-0(*" &045&53*$*" &RPHSUHYHQLUHHDIIURQWDUHOD GHSUHVVLRQHSRVWSDUWXP 4XHVWRRSXVFRORqSHQVDWRSHU HVVHUHG·DLXWRDWXWWHOHGRQQHFKH KDQQRSDUWRULWRRDVSHWWDQR ,QGLFH XQEDPELQR1RQSHQVDUH /DGHSUHVVLRQH SRVWSDUWXPFKHFRV·q FKHLOSUREOHPDQRQWL &RPHULFRQRVFHUOD ULJXDUGLODGHSUHVVLRQH /HFDXVH SRVWSDUWXPqXQ SUREOHPDSL GLIIXVRGLTXDQWR ,ULVFKLSHUODPDPPDHLOEDPELQR &RPHDIIURQWDUH ODGHSUHVVLRQHSRVWSDUWXP VLSHQVLHFRQRVFHUOD qLOSULPRSDVVRSHU ULXVFLUH DGDIIURQWDUOD /·RSXVFRORqUHDOL]]DWRQHOO·DPELWRGHOODFDPSDJQDGL VHQVLELOL]]D]LRQH1RQ/DVFLDPROH6ROHSURPRVVDGDOOD 6RFLHWj,WDOLDQDGL*LQHFRORJLDH2VWHWULFLD6,*2 /DGHSUHVVLRQHSRVWSDUWXP FKHFRVµq /DGHSUHVVLRQHSRVWSDUWXPqXQDYHUDHSURSULDFRQGL]LRQHSDWRORJLFD FKHVHFRQGRODOHWWHUDWXUDFROSLVFHQHLSDHVLRFFLGHQWDOLFLUFDLO GHOOHGRQQHËSLIUHTXHQWHLQVHJXLWRDOODQDVFLWDGHOSULPRILJOLRHVLSXz SUHVHQWDUHILQGDOOHSULPHVHWWLPDQHGRSRLOSDUWRRQHLPHVLVXFFHVVLYL )RUWXQDWDPHQWHTXHVWRSUREOHPDRSSRUWXQDPHQWHWUDWWDWRSXzHVVHUH ULVROWRFRPSOHWDPHQWHLQWHPSLEUHYL ,VLQWRPLVRQRGLYHUVLHVSHVVRQRQYHQJRQR LQWHUSUHWDWLFRUUHWWDPHQWH,SLIUHTXHQWLVRQR LQVWDELOLWjRVEDO]LHPRWLYL IDFLOLWjDOSLDQWR PDQFDQ]DGLHQHUJLH VHQVRGLLQDGHJXDWH]]DHSHQVLHULSHVVLPLVWLFL GXEELHWLPRULFLUFDOHFDSDFLWjGLSUHQGHUVLFXUDGHO EDPELQR VHQWLPHQWLDPELYDOHQWLYHUVRLOEDPELQR VHQVRGLFROSD DQVLD VHQWLUVLSULYHGLYDORUH GLVWXUELGHOVRQQRHGHOO·DOLPHQWD]LRQH SDXUDGHLFRQWDWWLHVWHUQLFKLXVXUD SHUGLWDGLLQWHUHVVHVHVVXDOH SHQVLHULIUHTXHQWLVXOODPRUWHHDYROWHVXOVXLFLGLR /DGHSUHVVLRQHSRVWSDUWXPQRQYDFRQIXVDFRQLO PDWHUQLW\EOXHVREDE\EOXHVHQHOOHFRQGL]LRQLSL JUDYLSXzGHJHQHUDUHLQSVLFRVLSRVWSDUWXP ,OPDWHUQLW\REDE\EOXHVqXQSHULRGRWUDQVLWRULR PROWRIUHTXHQWHORVSHULPHQWDFLUFDO· GHOOHGRQQH6LWUDWWDGLXQPRPHQWRILVLRORJLFR FDUDWWHUL]]DWRGDXQ·DOWDLQVWDELOLWjHPRWLYDWLSLFR GHOOHSULPHGXHVHWWLPDQHGRSRLOSDUWRHFKHVL HVDXULVFHLQJHQHUHQHOJLURGLSRFKLJLRUQL$QFKH LOPDWHUQLW\EOXHVVLSUHVHQWDFRQWULVWH]]DFULVLGL SLDQWRVWDQFKH]]DLUULWDELOLWjDQVLDQHLFRQIURQWL GHOEDPELQRHVHQVRGLLQDGHJXDWH]]DSHUzTXHVWL VHQWLPHQWLQRQSHUPDQJRQRSHUO·LQWHUDJLRUQDWDPD FRPSDLRQRDLQWHUPLWWHQ]D'LVROLWRTXHVWRGLVWXUER VLULVROYHQHOO·DUFRGLXQSDLRGLVHWWLPDQHVHQ]D QHFHVVLWjGLDOFXQWUDWWDPHQWR /DSVLFRVLSRVWSDUWXPFKHULFKLHGH XQLPPHGLDWRLQWHUYHQWRSVLFKLDWULFR qLQYHFHXQDFRQGL]LRQHSDWRORJLFDSL JUDYHHIRUWXQDWDPHQWHSLUDUDGHOOD GHSUHVVLRQHFLUFDFDVRRJQL QDVFLWH/HGRQQHFRQSVLFRVL SRVWSDUWXPSUHVHQWDQRXPRUH HFRPSRUWDPHQWLJUDYHPHQWH GLVWXUEDWLHLQJHQHUH FRQIXVLRQHDJLWD]LRQH DOOXFLQD]LRQL GLVRUJDQL]]D]LRQH HVWUHPDHSXOVLRQL LQIDQWLFLGH &RPH ULFRQRVFHUOD 6HKDLSDUWRULWRGDSRFR HWHPLFKHLVHQWLPHQWL HOHVHQVD]LRQLFKHVWDL VSHULPHQWDQGRQRQVLDQR ´QRUPDOLµHVLVWHXQR VWUXPHQWRVHPSOLFHFKH WLSXzDLXWDUHDFDSLUH VHODWXDVLWXD]LRQHSXz HVVHUHFRQVLGHUDWD´D ULVFKLRµ6LFKLDPD6FDOD GL(GLPEXUJRËLOWHVWSL DFFUHGLWDWRGDOSXQWRGL YLVWDVFLHQWLILFRHGKDLO YDQWDJJLRGLHVVHUHPROWR VHPSOLFHSXRLULVSRQGHUH DQFKHGDVROD6LWUDWWD GLEDUUDUHODULVSRVWDFKH PHJOLRFRUULVSRQGHDOWXR VWDWRG·DQLPRGHOO·XOWLPD VHWWLPDQDHVRPPDUHLO SXQWHJJLR 6HLOSXQWHJJLRq VXSHULRUHDSXzHVVHUH RSSRUWXQRULYROJHUVL DGXQRVSHFLDOLVWDH QRQWUDVFXUDUHTXHVWD VHQVD]LRQHGLPDOHVVHUH 4XHVWRQRQVLJQLILFDFKH WXVLDGHSUHVVDRVLD GHVWLQDWDDGLYHQWDUOR 6RQRVWDWDLQJUDGRGLULGHUHHYHGHUHLOODWRGLYHUWHQWHGHOOHFRVH FRPHKRIDWWRVHPSUH QRQSURSULRFRPHDOVROLWR DVVROXWDPHQWHPHQRGHOVROLWR QRSHUQLHQWH 0LVRQRSRVWDLQPRGRSRVLWLYRYHUVRJOLDOWUL FRPHDOVROLWR XQSR·PHQRGHOVROLWR DVVROXWDPHQWHPHQRGHOVROLWR QRSHUQLHQWH 0LVRQRVHQWLWDFROSHYROHVHQ]DPRWLYRTXDQGROHFRVHQRQDQGDYDQREHQH VuODPDJJLRUSDUWHGHOOHYROWH VLDOFXQHYROWH QRQPROWRVSHVVR QRPDL 6RQRGLYHQWDWDDQVLRVDRSUHRFFXSDWDVHQ]DPRWLYR QRSHUQLHQWH VLWDOYROWD TXDVLPDL VLPROWRVSHVVR 0LVRQRVHQWLWDVSDYHQWDWDRQHOSDQLFRVHQ]DXQEXRQPRWLYR VLVSHVVR QRQRQPROWR VLTXDOFKHYROWD QRPDL 0LVRQRVHQWLWDVRSUDIIDWWDGDOOHFRVHFKHDFFDGHYDQR VuLOSLGHOOHYROWHQRQVRQRLQJUDGRGLDIIURQWDUOH VuWDOYROWDQRQOHDIIURQWREHQHFRPHDOVROLWR QRLOSLGHOOHYROWHOHKRDIIURQWDWHSLXWWRVWREHQH QROHKRDIIURQWDWHEHQHFRPHVHPSUH 6RQRFRVuLQIHOLFHFKHKRGLIILFROWjDGRUPLUH VuODPDJJLRUSDUWHGHOOHYROWH QRQPROWRVSHVVR VuTXDOFKHYROWD PDL 0LVRQRVHQWLWDWULVWHRDYYLOLWD VLODPDJJLRUSDUWHGHOOHYROWH QRQPROWRVSHVVR VuSLXWWRVWRIUHTXHQWHPHQWH PDL 6RQRFRVuLQIHOLFHFKHKRSLDQWR VuODPDJJLRUSDUWHGHOOHYROWH VRORRFFDVLRQDOPHQWH VuSLXWWRVWRIUHTXHQWHPHQWH PDL ,OSHQVLHURGLIDUPLGHOPDOHPLqYHQXWRLQPHQWH VuDEEDVWDQ]DVSHVVR TXDVLPDL TXDOFKHYROWD PDL /HFDXVH 1RQVLFRQRVFRQROHFDXVHVFDWHQDQWLGHOODGHSUHVVLRQHSRVWSDUWXPPD qQRWRFKHHVLVWRQRIDWWRULGLULVFKLRELRORJLFLSVLFRORJLFLHDPELHQWDOLFKH SRVVRQRUHQGHUHODGRQQDSLYXOQHUDELOH HSLVRGLGLDQVLDRGHSUHVVLRQHGXUDQWHODJUDYLGDQ]D VWRULDSHUVRQDOHRIDPLOLDUHGLGHSUHVVLRQH HYHQWLWUDXPDWLFLQHOO XOWLPRDQQROXWWL FRQIOLWWLSUREOHPLUHOD]LRQDOLFRQLOSDUWQHU LVRODPHQWRVRFLDOHRFRQGL]LRQLVRFLRHFRQRPLFKHVIDYRUHYROL VWRULDGLVLQGURPHSUHPHVWUXDOHRGLVWXUERGLVIRULFR SUHPHVWUXDOH SUHFHGHQWLHSLVRGLGLGHSUHVVLRQHSRVWSDUWXP GLVWXUELGHOODIXQ]LRQDOLWjWLURLGHD JLRYDQHHWjQHOOHQHRPDPPHDGROHVFHQWLLOULVFKLRGL'3 VDOHGDODO FRQGL]LRQHGLUDJD]]DPDGUH VROLWXGLQHRFRPXQTXHVUDGLFDPHQWRULVSHWWRDOODIDPLJOLD GLRULJLQH DEXVRGLVRVWDQ]H ,QJHQHUHODFRQGL]LRQHGLGHSUHVVLRQHVLVYLOXSSDGDOO·LQWHUD]LRQHIUDGXHR SLGLTXHVWLIDWWRUL /·LQVRQQLDLSUREOHPLGHOVRQQRVRQRXQLPSRUWDQWHFDPSDQHOOR G·DOODUPH(VLVWRQRVWXGLFKHGLPRVWUDQRO·LPSRUWDQ]DGHOVRQQRFRPH UHVSRQVDELOHGHLGLVWXUELGHOO·XPRUH&KLHGLDOWXRJLQHFRORJRFRQVLJOLH LVWUX]LRQLSHUO·DOODWWDPHQWRQRWWXUQR 6HVLULVFRQWUDQRDOFXQLVLQWRPLFDUDWWHULVWLFLHVLqLQSUHVHQ]DGLXQRRSL IDWWRULGLULVFKLRqRSSRUWXQRULYROJHUVLFRQWHPSHVWLYLWjDOSURSULRPHGLFRGL IDPLJOLDRJLQHFRORJRLOTXDOHYDOXWHUjODVLWXD]LRQHHSUHVFULYHUjDOODSD]LHQWH ODWHUDSLDULWHQXWDSLLGRQHD,SRVVLELOLWUDWWDPHQWLYDULDQRLQUHOD]LRQHDOOD JUDYLWjGHLVLQWRPLHDOOHFRQGL]LRQLILVLFKHGHOODGRQQD ,ULVFKLSHUODPDPPDHLOEDPELQR /DGHSUHVVLRQHSRVWSDUWXPVSHVVRYLHQHGLDJQRVWLFDWDWDUGLYDPHQWH /HFDXVHGLTXHVWRULWDUGRVRQRVRSUDWWXWWR VFRUUHWWDLQWHUSUHWD]LRQHGHLVLQWRPLGDSDUWHGHOODGRQQD HGLFKLOHYLYHYLFLQR QHJD]LRQHGHOSUREOHPDGDSDUWHGHOODGRQQD ULILXWRGLSDUODUHGHOSUREOHPDSHUYHUJRJQDRVHQVR GLFROSD 8QDGLDJQRVLWDUGLYDRPDQFDWDR XQWUDWWDPHQWRLQDGHJXDWRSRVVRQR HVSRUUHODGRQQDDOULVFKLRGL GHSUHVVLRQHULFRUUHQWHHGDXPHQWDQR HVSRQHQ]LDOPHQWHOHSRVVLELOL ULSHUFXVVLRQLQHJDWLYHVXOOD UHOD]LRQHFRQLOEDPELQR ,QSDUWLFRODUHVHLOWUDWWDPHQWRDYYLHQHLQULWDUGRDXPHQWDLOULVFKLRGL UHFXSHURLQFRPSOHWRHFRQXQDSURJQRVLPHQRIDYRUHYROH SRVVLELOLULFDGXWH GLVWXUELQHOORVYLOXSSRSVLFRVRFLDOHHDIIHWWLYRGHOEDPELQR DXPHQWRGHOODFRQIOLWWXDOLWjIDPLOLDUH FRPSURPLVVLRQHGHOODUHOD]LRQHPDGUHEDPELQR DEXVRGLVRVWDQ]H /HSLJUDYLFRQVHJXHQ]HGHOODGHSUHVVLRQHVLPDQLIHVWDQRLQVFDUVH FXUHYHUVRLOEDPELQRFRQXQDXPHQWRGHOULVFKLRGLFRPSRUWDPHQWL LPSXOVLYLRSRWHQ]LDOPHQWHDXWROHVLYLLO´)HWDODEXVHµRDGGLULWWXUD LOQHRQDWLFLGLR,QSDUWLFRODUHODIUXVWUD]LRQHGHOELVRJQRGL DWWDFFDPHQWRGHOQHRQDWRLQGHEROLVFHODFRVWUX]LRQHGHOODVXD SHUVRQDOLWjHYLHQHFRPSURPHVVRDQFKHO·DSSUHQGLPHQWRGHO ´OLQJXDJJLRDIIHWWLYRµGHOEDPELQR /DGHSUHVVLRQHSRVWSDUWXPLQYHFHVHWUDWWDWD LQPRGRDGHJXDWRUHJUHGLVFHHJXDULVFH FRPSOHWDPHQWH &RPHDIIURQWDUH ODGHSUHVVLRQHSRVWSDUWXP /DGHSUHVVLRQHSRVWSDUWXPRULJLQDGDOODLQWHUD]LRQHIUDIDWWRULELRORJLFL SVLFRORJLFLHDPELHQWDOLQRQHVLVWHTXLQGLXQ·XQLFDPRGDOLWjGLWUDWWDPHQWR YDOLGDSHUWXWWHOHGRQQHPDELVRJQDVFHJOLHUHXQDSSURFFLRSHUVRQDOL]]DWR 3UREDELOPHQWHLOWUDWWDPHQWRSLHIILFDFHqTXHOORPXOWLIDWWRULDOHFKHDEELQD HOHPHQWLSVLFRORJLFLHELRORJLFL 3HUOHIRUPHOLHYLRPHGLHVRQRLQGLFDWLWUDWWDPHQWLSVLFRORJLFLFRXQVHOOLQJ LQGLYLGXDOHSVLFRWHUDSLDLQGLYLGXDOHRGLFRSSLDWHUDSLDGLJUXSSRSHUTXHOOH SLJUDYLSXzHVVHUHLQYHFHQHFHVVDULRXQLQWHUYHQWRIDUPDFRORJLFR 5LYROJLWLFRQILGXFLDDOWXRPHGLFRGLIDPLJOLDRDOWXR JLQHFRORJRFKHVDSUjLQGLYLGXDUHODVROX]LRQH SLDGDWWDDOWXRFDVR (FFRDOFXQLFRQVLJOLSUDWLFL SHUFKLVWDVSHULPHQWDQGRXQDFRQGL]LRQH GLGLIILFROWjLQVHJXLWRDOSDUWR 3DUODUQH&RQIURQWDUVLFRQDOWUHPDPPHFRQLOFRPSDJQR FRQDPLFLHIDPLOLDULRFRQLOPHGLFRSXzDLXWDUHDYLYHUHLO SURSULRVWDWRG·DQLPRLQPDQLHUDGLYHUVDHDQRQVHQWLUVL VROH )DUVLDLXWDUH/DVFLDUHFKHDPLFLHSDUHQWLGLDQRXQDPDQR QHOODJHVWLRQHGHOODFDVDHGHOEDPELQR)DUVLDLXWDUHQHL ODYRULGRPHVWLFLHFRQGLYLGHUHLOSLSRVVLELOHODFXUDGHO EDPELQRFRQLOSDGUH 5LFDYDUHGHJOLVSD]LSHUVp3HUXQDQHRPDPPDSXz VHPEUDUHLPSRVVLELOHPDFLVLSRVVRQRULFDYDUHGHLPRPHQWL SHUVpPDJDULPHQWUHLOEDPELQRGRUPH'HGLFDUHDQFKH VRORSRFKLPLQXWLDOJLRUQRDGDWWLYLWjFKHVLDQRJUDWLILFDQWL OHJJHUHFROWLYDUHLOQRVWURKREE\IDUHXQEDJQRULSRVDUVL )DUHDWWLYLWjILVLFD$SSURILWWDUHGHOOHRFFDVLRQLGL PRYLPHQWRRIIHUWHGDOODYLWDTXRWLGLDQDIDUHOHVFDOHSRUWDUH LOEDPELQRDVSDVVRHFF/·DWWLYLWjILVLFDVRSUDWWXWWRVH DOO·DULDDSHUWDFRQWULEXLVFHDPLJOLRUDUHODVHQVD]LRQHGL EHQHVVHUH 0DQJLDUHEHQHHLQPDQLHUDVDQD6FHJOLHUHDOLPHQWL VDOXWDULIUXWWDFHUHDOLYHUGXUDHOLPLWDUHLOFRQVXPRGL FDIIHLQDDOFROJUDVVLH]XFFKHUL 7HQHUHXQGLDULR0HWWHUHSHULVFULWWROHSURSULHVHQVD]LRQL SXzHVVHUHXQDPDQLHUDHIILFDFHGL´VFDULFDUVLµ5LOHJJHUH DSRVWHULRULLSURSULSHQVLHULqLQROWUHXQRWWLPRPRGRSHU IRFDOL]]DUHLSURJUHVVLFRPSLXWL 3RUVLXQVRORRELHWWLYRSHURJQLJLRUQDWD8QDGHOOH VHQVD]LRQLSLGLIIXVHqTXHOODGL´QRQULXVFLUHDFRPELQDUH QXOODµËQRUPDOHVHQWLUVLVRSUDIIDWWLGDOOHUHVSRQVDELOLWjH GDLWDQWLQXRYLLPSHJQL&LYXROHLQHYLWDELOPHQWHGHOWHPSR SHUDGDWWDUVLDLFDPELDPHQWLFKHXQILJOLRFRPSRUWD &HUFDUHGLPDQWHQHUHLOFRQWDWWRFRQLOEDPELQR'HGLFDUH LOJLXVWRWHPSRHGDWWHQ]LRQHDOO·DOODWWDPHQWRVFHJOLHUHXQ SRVWRWUDQTXLOORFHUFDUHGLULODVVDUVLHGLJRGHUHGHOFRQWDWWR FRQLOEDPELQRJXDUGDQGRORQHJOLRFFKL*OLVWHVVLFRQVLJOL YDOJRQRDQFKHVHQRQVLDOODWWDDOVHQR3UHQGHUHVSHVVRLQ EUDFFLRLOEDPELQRHSDUODUJOLGROFHPHQWHGHGLFDUHODJLXVWD DWWHQ]LRQHDOVXRULSRVRROWUHFKHDOQRVWUR 40$*&5®*5"-*"/" %*(*/&$0-0(*" &045&53*$*" 7JBEFJ4PMEBUJ 3PNB 5FM 5FMGBY GFEFSB[JPOF!TJHPJU 5HDOL]]D]LRQH *OUFSNFEJB 7HO )D[ LQWHUPHGLD#LQWHUPHGLDQHZVLW