QUATERNARIA NOVA, VIII, 2004, 263-275 F. ANTONIOU*, G.B. CARULU""\ S. FURLANI**"', R. AURIEMMAo, R. MAROCCO** THE ENIGMA OF SUBMERGED MARINE NOTCHES IN NORTHERN ADRIATIC SEA keywords: tidal notches, Holocene, Tectonic, North Adriatic 1. INTRODUCTION AND PREVIOUSRESEARCH The aim of this study is to identify e!ements for the understanding of the mechanisms that controlled the recent vertical movements of the northern Adriatic carbonatic coastline. On the basis of the peculiar morphology of the Istria peninsula, various Authors assumed that the area underwent active tectonic subsidence movements. One of the factors that led to these hypotheses is the absence of marine deposits at altitudes higher than the Present sea leve!. This contrasts with most of the Italian coasts, where MIS 5.5 deposits (Tyrrhenian, 125 ky BP) were found in the stable coastal areas, at 5-9 meters above sea leve!. Moreover, various Roman Age ruins were observed at lower altitudes than predicted by the Lambeck mode! (Lambeck et al. 2004). One of the first Authors who integrated this hypothesis with geomorphological data is MarkoviéMarjanovié (1971), who summarized the situation quoting various Yugoslavian Authors: the geomorphological research carried out along the coasts of Istria reveals the absence of emerged marine terraces. On the opposite, the whole coast presents various submerged terraces at depths comprised between -20 and -123 m. In his work, Degrassi (1957) quotes Gnirs (1908), who described the disco- * ENEA, Rome, Italy - [email protected] ** Dipartimento di Se. Geologiche, Ambientali e Marine University of Trieste [email protected];marocco@ univotrieste.it *** Società di Studi Nettuno, Trieste, Italy - [email protected] o Dept. of Archaeology, University of Lecce - [email protected] 263 very of the first submerged docking structures and hypothesized a sea level rise of ca. 1.5 m. Later, D'Ambrosi (1958) assumed that, in the last two thousand years, the sea level varied differently along the Istrian coast, i.e. with lower rates in the south, where he recorded a variation of -1.6 m in Pola and up to 4.0 m in Trieste. In Muggia, Auriemma et al. (2003) observed that the top portions of the submerged docking structures pointed out by Gobet (Fig. 1) and Frenopoulos at Punta Sottile are located at ca. -1.2 \ -1.5 m below sea level. Even considering the removal of the upper rows of blocks in these litde piers and with a failing estimate, a sea level change less than 1 m couldn't be considered, since the surface had to be at least 30\50 cm over sea leve!. The bed of blocks juxtaposed ("platea"), from which the Punta Sottile SW pier juts out, is stili more significant: in this case the visible surface is the original, a removal of material is not likely; the depth is nowadays at -1.2 m, but to estimate the sea level change one must consider that this "platea" had to rise enough to be protected from the waves and the high tide. Fig. 1: Muggia, Punta Sottile SW: pier of Roman age (photo: Società di Studi Nettuno). Along the Croatian Coast, Fouache et al. (2000) recently carried out a series of divings in order to look for geomorphological and archaeological indicators of ancient sea-Ievels. "A submerged notch, corresponding to a sea level that is lower than the present one by about 50 cm, can be observed in several sites along the Croatian Coast between Porec and Zadar. A number of submerged archaeological remains like Roman quarries, fish-ponds and cisterns prove that the 264 above mentioned notch corresponds to the sea leve! of Roman antiquity, i.e. 2000 years. South of this area, from Zadar to Split, Roman submerged archaeological remains give evidence of a sea leve! that is lower than the present one byabout 1.50 m. We are presenting our observations along the Croatian coastline, from Porec to Split, to discuss the possibility of regional neotectonic effects in the last 2000 years". 2. COASTAL AREASTUDIED The study area is located on the north eastern end of the Adriatic Sea and it is comprised between the coastal sectors of the so called ClassicCarso to the North and the Istrian Peninsula to the South. The sectors stretch out for over two hundred kilometres, from the cliffs of Duino (province of Trieste) to the NW, down to the coast of Opatija (Abbazia) in Croatia to the SE (Fig. 2). The CARSO 1"' "GeomOrphological and archaeological evidences ,:,.CLASSICO ' :~'::nare ,sea ~ Ii of level variations LEGEND . ~ 1__'" d -.. i " _ . ... Archeologicalremainssurvayad by authors Notches surveyed byauthors Archeological remains surveyed by Fouacha at al. (2000) Notchassurveyedby Fouache al al. (2000) ISTRIA Fig. 2: Study area with loeation of the mentioned sites. 265 coast, whieh is mostly calcareous, preserved some interesting evidence of ancient sea IevelsIocated at altitudes that are Iower than the present one and in sites that are lithologically,morphologically and climatically different. The Classie Carso is made up of a strong carbonatie succession; in the Trieste sector, the succession goes from Aptian p.p. to Lower Eocene p.p. and it was subdivided by Cucchi et alii (1989) into various informal Members. The most recent of these is followed by the Lower-Mid Eocene torbiditie deposits (Flysch). The succession is structured as an asymmetrieal antidinal whose axis bears dinaric direction and whose south western side appears from very steep to toppled; from a tectonie point of view, the succession tends to thrust southwestwards over the Flysch through a Iow-angled fault. The Istrian stratigraphie succession, characterized by a mainly carbonatic component, is instead comprised between Batonian and Mid Eocene (Velié et al. 2000) and it is followed by a torbiditie unit of Mid-Upper Eocene age. The Istrian peninsula was subdivided by various Authors into three sectors, using the names given by the ancient populations: Red [stria, whieh constitutes the southern and western portions of the peninsula; this portion, whieh is characterized by wide outcroppings of red soils, consists of the carbonatie jurassie-cretacic-paleogenie platform; Green or Grey [stria,whieh occupies the eastern and north-eastern sector and is characterized by SW-directed thrusts; this part consists of an area with dastie-carbonatie sedimentation of cretaceous-paleogenie age; White [stria, représented by the central paleogeriie basin, composed of strongly folded Eocene limestones thrusting southwards over Green Istria. The Duino-Sistiana coastal sector, whieh is the northernmost of the studied sectors (Fig. 2), is characterized by the in/ormaI Member of Borgo Grotta Gigante (Cucchi et al. 1989). The limestones are light coloured, with strong stratifieation, decimetrie to metrie period and strong abundance of radioliths and hippurites (Upper Cenomanian\Maastriehtian). In the portion considered, the strata dip in the opposite direction of the face slope and they present a very high slope, from sub-vertieal to, in same cases, overturned. This structural setup strongIy favours the development of tidal notches, as the physieal and chemieal action of sea waters acts on a surface (the stratum surface) that, unlike the joints, is structurally and compositionally homogeneous. Moving eastwards, the nearby stretch of Sistiana Bay-Costadei Barbari presents the thrust that brought the Cretaceous limestones over the Holocene Flysch (Carulli, Cucchi 1991), whieh therefore constitutes the foot of these carbonatie diffs. This is characterized by strong verticalIayers of sandstone. The base of the foot shows a small beach placed on a not very wide coastal pIatform. Such a morphologieal and structural pattern repeats itself, with different magnitudes, up to the Gulf of Pirano (Slovenijaand Croatia), where the Flysch is replaced by the Istrian limestone formations. The high erodibility of the Flysch section does not present any trace of the ancient tidal notches, whieh suggests a Iack of notches in the stretch of coast comprised between Costa dei Barbari-Gulf of Piran: nevertheless, in Canovella de' Zoppoli, Forti (1985) observed a notch on a series of blocks of limestone breccias that collapsed over the Flysch of the over1yingdiff. 266 Moving southwards, after the Gulf of Pirano, limestone is the only existing lithology unti! Opatija (Abbazia). Within the limestones, Veliéet al. (2000) identified four mega-sequences: the most ancient one, from Batonian to Lower Kimmerigian, involves the area around Rovinj (Rovigno). The second mega-sequence outcrops to the north and to the south with Upper Titonian to Upper Altonian strata, which, given the structural pattern of the area -that is characterised by a wide anticlinal- includes the area of Porec (Parenzo) and, southwards, some km of coast from Rovinj (Rovigno) to Kolone (Porto Colonne). The third megasequence, from the Upper Aptian to Lower Campanian involves a large portion of the remaining Istrian coasts, in particular from Porec (Parenzo) to Secovlije (Sicciole) and from Kolone (Porto Colonne) to the coast of Opatija (Abbazia). The morphological and structural characteristics with which these limestones outcrop in the north western part do not allow the development of tidal notches as the coast is low and because of the sub-horizontality of the strata which are very lightly tectonised; to the south, in the Pula (Pola) area and on the Eastern Istria high cliffs dipping into the sea, the structural and morphological conditions favour instead the development of notches. 3. DATA For the present study, coastal and submarine research was carried out in the Trieste coast and in the Istrian peninsula down to the Krk Island (Fig. 2). Remains of marine fossils were searched in the Italian, Croatian and Slovenian territories and inside the coastal marine caves, but nothing was found above sea leve!. A continuous submerged marine notch was measured (04.2002) on the limestone cliffs between Sistiana and Duino (Gulf of Trieste) at the tide corrected altitude of -1.7 :t 0.2 m (Figs. 3 and 4). The notch is continuous but it presents different morphologies and concavities depending on the exposure of the spot it occupies and on differences of lithology. Recent research in the Miramare Park pointed out the existence of a notch at ca. - 0.7 m (11.2003), in correspondence of the huge Eocene limestone olistoliths which, enveloped in the Flysch, constitute the homonymous promontory. Along the Western Istrian Coast, a submerged tidal notch was observed at depths similar to those observed by Fouache et al. (2000) (see the points in Fig. 2). In particular, a notch was found and measured (10.2002)at - 0.8 m (tide corrected) within the Limski Kanal (Fig. 5). Along the Eastern Istrian Coast, the tidal notch was observed at depths similar to the Gulf of Trieste (-1.8 :t 0.2 m, measured on 07.2003). The complete lack of present day notches (or other coastal morphologies) was verified in the area comprised between Sistiana and Duino (Fig. 6). Some areas by Savudrija show sea level scarps scarps whose formation is due to particular lithological conditions whose formation is due to particular lithological conditions (Fig. 7). On the opposite, in the Istrian area up to the Island of Krk, the present day notch seems to be carved alI the way through, though its morphological evidence is not very strong if compared to the Tyrrhenian notches (Fig. 8). 267 Fig. 3: Submerged notch at -1.7 m by Duino. Fig. 4: Submerged notch at -1.7 m by Sisriana. Fig 5: The submerged ridal notch measured in the Limski Kanal (Croatia) at -0.8 m. 268 Fig. 6: The carbonatic coast between Duino and Sistiana (TS, Italy). There is no sign of the Present day tidal notch. Fig 7: The coast by Savudrija (TS, Italy). The particular morphology seems to show an ancient quarry at about -0.5 m m.s.1. 269 t,. , , l-..' . '1."" .,,' \0".;-'_' _. ~., _,. _<,. J ~~~.~~ ,., ~ 8Ml '. .~ ., ~,. ~~ Fig 8: The carbonatic coast of the Limnski Kanal. Above the notch, at sea leve!, it is possible to observe a scarp with a small terrace. 4. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION Sea levd change along the Italian coast is the sum of eustatic, glacio-hydroisostatic, and tectonic factors (Lambeck et al. 2004). Marine notches are frequent in limestone lithologies and a marine notch is normally carved in 1-4 centuries depending on the locallithology. The use of tidal notches as sea levd markers is very important for sea levd change study, especially in low-tide seas such as the Mediterranean. In some Italian tectonically active coastal areas (for example eastern Sicily)there is a lack of Present day marine notches as tectonic rates are faster than the carving rates; but there may be other factors, that are not necessarily rdated to tectonics, which may restÙt in a lack of the Present day marine notch (see also Kershaw, Antonioli 2004). A continuous submerged marine notch was observed on the limestone cliff between Sistiana and Duino (Gulf of Trieste, north Adriatic sea) and in Brsec at the tide corrected altitude of about .1.7 m; a similar notch was measured by Fouache et al. (2000) along the Croatian coast; the notch was well carved and located at about -0.5 m, Le. at a lower depth than the Duino notch. In Trieste instead, the Present day notch is missing. These differences between the various notches may be the restÙt of a different equilibriums between eustatic sea levd, hydro-glacio isostasy and tectonics in the three areas. 270 The deeper submerged marine notch on the limestones of Trieste, together with the absence of the Present day marine notch could be explained as resulting from a Plio-quaternary tilting of the Carso plateau, which gently dips to NW, as illustrated by other observations from Carulli et al. (1980). This may also be related to the increasing weight of the external fronts of the Southalpine and of External Dinarides mountain ranges. Both chains are characterized by strong seismic activity with consequent neotectonics effects far from Trieste. . The following points give further evidence of a continuous NW-oriented tectonic tilting: 1) the altitude of the submerged marine notch is about -1.7 m at Trieste, and between -0.5 and -0.8 m in Istria (Croatian coast); 2) the Trieste area lacks a Present day marine notch in Trieste. This is possibly due to higher subsidence in the Trieste area; the nearby Istria Peninsula is instead characterized by a well carved Present day notch; 3) the MIS 5.5 highstand is located at different altitudes; Amorosi et al. (1999) observed that the highstand is located at -120 m in the delta Po river (about -lmm/yr); Kent et al. (2002) observed the highstand at -79 m (about -0.7 mm/yr). These factors, together with the absence of MIS 5.5 deposits outcropping in the Istria and Trieste area show a clear E-W oriented gradient; 4) when compared with the predicted sea level change curve by Lambeck et al. (2004), the altitude of the Holocene lagoonal deposits of Grado (Marocco's papers) indicates a subsidence rate of about -0.3 mm/yr, which fits the MIS 5.5 data; 5) in the Gulf ofTrieste, Albrecht and Mosetti (1987)found a karsticcave(seemap) at -100 m and a submerged series of well carved marine terraces, the last one of which, placed at an altitude of -35 m is presumably related to MIS 5.5; 6) the presence of a topographic paleo surface (Fig. 9) separated by a visible scarp due to a lithological discontinuity (Flysch limestone) highlights the lowering of the area by ca. 60-70 m in 50 km in SE-NW direction. A few questions must still be answered: why was a late Holocene marine notch carved in a tectonically subsiding area like the northern Adriatic? Marine notches are in fact usuallyexpected in a stillstand (land and sea) area, or in coastal areas showing the same sea level uplift rates (like in Taormina, Kersaw and Antonioli, this volume). However, Lambeck's model excludes positive isostatic movements for all Italian coasts. A solution to this "enigma" could be a late Holocene coseismic event or an unexpected isostatic movement of opposite direction, such as a relative sea levellowering which lasted for a period of time that allowed the formation of the notch. This may have occurred because of an extraordinary positive isostatic behaviour originating from the Alps, as recently predicted by Carminati et al. 2003. Doubts occur when the current tectonic subsidence calculated from the archaeological data of the last 2 ka (ca 1 meter in 2000 years, therefore 0.5 mm/year) are compared to 0.3 mm/year calculated 271 J km --- 1 2 Fig 9: The DEM of the Trieste area;it is possible to observe the topographic surface (bordered by scarps seawards)which lowers in SElNW direction; the numbers indicate meters above sea leve!. by Lambeck et al. (2004) for the Trieste area, or to the 1.3 mm/year calculated on the basis of the observations from the Trieste tide gauge in 110 years that are similar from Istria and Dalmazia tide gauge (0.9 mm/year at Rovinj and 1.1 mm/year at Bakar (Emery et al. 1988). Archaeological remains along Istrian coast, in part located by A. Degrassi 50 years ago (1957), and recently re-examined like markers ofHolocenic sea-level changes by Fouache et al. (2000), deserve a deeper analysis. Unpublished researches - to be completed - about the pier of U. Busuja (Porto Bussolo) bay indicate that the top of the structure is now at - 1.2/1.5 m (courtesy of M. B. Carre and V. Kovacié). Also the two breakwaters ofRoman age that protect the Ivan Bay (S. Giovanni della Cometa) have the top at -1 m below sea level; as we know by the ancient sources, the breakwaters had to emerge, to be not a danger for sailing. Even presuming a partial dismantlement of the structures, caused by marine activity, the sealeve! in the beginning of the Imperial age, when those were built, had to be at least 1 m lower. Specific researches are scheduled on the presumed fish-ponds of Zaliv Sv. Jemej (S. Bartolomeo, Slovenija), in collaboration between the Trieste University and the Piran Museum, and on those of Kupanja, N of Porec (Parenzo) to be done under the direction of the Porec Museum (V. Kovacié), with the collaboration of CNRS (Centre Camille Julien, M. B. Carre). The situation of these presumed vivaria suggests, only on the ground of preliminary 272 surveys, a sea level change of about 1 m. - - ._~- Specific researches are schedtÙed on the presumed fish-ponds of Jernejeva Draga (S.Bartolomeo, Slovenija),in collaboration between the Trieste University and the Piran Museum, and on those of Kupanja, N of Porec (Parenzo) to be done under the direction of the Porec Museum (V.Kovacié), with the collaboration of Centre Ausonius (F.Tassaux,Université Bordeaux 3) and M.E. Carre (UMR 6375 CNRS). The enigma on the submerged notch of the Adriatic sea has not been solved yet; however, we believe that we have found the elements for the identification of the vertical movements in progress, although we stili must find a way to date the notch. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We wotÙd like to thank ing. Maurizio Sbogar and Marco Rizzo for the kind assistance and improvement for this work REFERENCES ALBRECHT P., MOSETTIE 1987, Karst evolution and sea level. Mem. Soc. Geol. It. 40, 383-387. AMOROSI A., COLALONGO M.L., PASINIG., PRETID. 1999.Sedimentary responseto Late Quaternary sea-levelchangesin the Romagna coastalplain (N. Italy). Sedimentology 46,99-121. ANTONIOLI E 1991, Geomor/ologiasubacqueae costieradel litorale compresotra Punta Stendardo e TorreS. Agostino (Gaeta). Il Quaternario 4/asc. II, 257-274. AURIEMMA R., FRENOPOULOS S., FURLANI S. 2003, Il livello del mare a Muggia duemila anni fa. Borgolauro XXIV, 43, pp 39-41. CARMINATI E., MARTINELLI G., SEVERIP. 2003, In/luence o/ glacialcycles and tectonics on natural subsidence in the Po Plain (Northern Italy): Insights /rom 14C ages. G3 (ElectronicJournal) 4, lO, 1-14. CARULLIG.B., CAROBENEL., CAVALLINA., MARTINISB., ONOFRI R. 1980, Evoluzione strutturale plio-quaternaria del Friuli e della Venezia Giulia. In: "Contributi preliminari alla realizzazione della Carta neotettonica d'Italia", pubbl. n° 356 P.E Geoinamica, 489-545, C.N.R. CARULLIG.B., CUCCHIE 1991, Proposta di interpretazione strutturale del Carso triestino. Atti Tic. Se. Terra 34, 161-166. CUCCHI E, PllUNI RADRIZZANIc., PUGLIESEN. 1989, The carbonate stratigraphic sequence o/ the Karst o/Trieste (Italy). Mem. Soc. Geol. Ital. 40, 35-44. Proc. Of« Iot. Symp. On« Evolution of the karstic carbonate platform », Trieste, 1st-6th June 1987. D'AMBROSIC. 1958, Recenti misure mareografiche confermerebbero il persistere di tendenze epirogeniche in Istria. Boll. Soc. adriat. Sci. nato 50, 9-25. DEGRASSIA. 1957, I porti romani dell'Istria. Anthemon, Firenze, , 119-169. EMERYK.O., AUBREYD.G., GOLDSMITHV. 1988, Coastal neo-tectonics o/ the Mediterranean /rom tide-gauge records. Marine Geology 81, 41-52. FORTI E 1985, Fenomeni di carsismo marino (Studi sul Carso Triestino). Atti e Mem. Comm. Grotte« E. Boegan» 23, (1984),47-60. 273 FOUACHEE., FAIVRES., DUFAURE].J., KOVACIév., TAssAux F. 2000, New observations on the evolution 0/ the Croatian shoreline between Poreç ad Zadar over the past 2000 years. Z. Geomorph. N. F., Suppl.-Bd. 122,33-46. GALASSIP., MAROCCOR. 1999, Relative sea level rise and subsidence in the Caorle Lagoon (Northern Adriatic) sea, Italy, during Holocene. Il Quaternario 12,249-256. GNIRSA. 1908, Beobachtungen uber den Fortschritt einer sakularen Niveau-schwankung des Meeres wahrend der letzten zwei Jahrtausende. Mitteilungen der Geographischen Gesellschaft in Wien, 1-56. KENT D., RIo D., MASSARIF., KUKLAG., LANCI L. 2002, Emergence 0/ Venice during the Pleistocene. Quaternary Science Review 21,1719 -1727. KERSHAWS., ANTONIOLIF. 2004, Tidal notches at Taormina, east Sicily: why is the midHolocene notch well-/ormed, but no modern notch is present in the same locality? Quaternaria Nova 8, 155-169. LAMBECKK., ANTONIOLIF., PURCELLA., SILENZIS. 2004, Sea level change along the Italian coast /or the past 10,000 yrs. Quat. Science Reviews, 23, 1567 -1598. MARKOVIé-MAR]ANOVIéJ. 1971, Coast Lines, Pleistocene Sediments and Fauna 0/ the Eastern Part 0/ Adriatic in Yugoslavia. Quaternaria 15,187-195. MAROCCOR. 1989, Evoluzione quaternaria della laguna di Marano (Friuli Ve-nezia Giulia). Il Quaternario 2,125-137. MAROCCOR. 1991, Evoluzione tardopleistocenica-olocenica del delta del F Tagliamento e delle lagune di Marano e Grado, (Golfo di Trieste). Il Quater-nario 4 (lb), 223-232. VELIé 1, TISL]AR].,MAnCEé D., VLAHOVIé1 2000, Introduzione alla geologia dell'Istria. 80° Riunione estiva Trieste della Società Geologica Italiana, 6-8 settembre 2000, 237 -245. ZANFERRARIA., BOLLETTINARIG., CAROBENEL., CARTONA., CARULLIG.B., CASTALDINI D., CAVALLINA., PANIZZAM., PELLEGRINIG.B., PIANETII F., SAUROU. 1982, Evoluzione neotettonica dell'Italia nord-orientale. Mem. Soc. Geol. It. 35, 3 carte neotettoniche 1:400.000. 274 -- - -- ABSTRACT The analysisof tidal marine notches on the northern Adriatic coast allowed to identify useful elements for the understanding of coastal tectonic mechanisms. The depth of the submerged marine tidal notches (ranging between -0.5 m and -1.7) and the lack of a Present day tidal notch on the Trieste coast, together with other stratigraphic and structural observations are elements that lead to the hypothesis that a SE-NW subsidence tilting is in progress in the whole study area. RIASSUNTO La ricerca ha avuto come oggetto l'individuazione di elementi stratigrafici e morfologici in grado di permettere la valutazione di recenti meccanismi tettonici in atto nella zona di Trieste e penisola Dalmata. Numerosi Autori riportano, sulla base di osservazioni morfologiche, che l'intera area sembra avere subito un costante recente abbassamento. Nell' area non sono presenti forme o depositi Tirreniani tipici invece della maggior parte delle coste stabili o in sollevamento Italiane. Nella zona tra Duino e Sistiana sono stati individuati e misurati solchi marini mareali sommersi alle quote medie di circa -1,7 e constatata l'assenza del solco attuale. Tali solchi sono stati misurati a circa 0,7 poco ad est, nei pressi di Trieste. In tutta la costiera Istriana invece Fouache et al. (2000) hanno misurato tali solchi alla profondità di circa -0,5 e li hanno attribuiti all'epoca Romana, in questa zona costiera inoltre è presente il solco attuale. Più a sud sul versante orientale dell'Istria sono stati misurati a -1,8 m. Ricerche archeologiche hanno rinvenuto e misurato dei muri portuali nella zona di punta Sottile ad una profondità di -1,2\1,5 m. Alla luce di dati relativi a depositi quaternari più antichi, indagini geofisiche, dati provenienti da sondaggi, si rileva un tilting di subsidenza tettonica che si abbassa progressivamente da SE verso NW. Rimane aperto il problema di quale origine abbia il solco di battente sommerso, nel lavoro vengono fatte alcune ipotesi compresa quella di una isostasia anomala dovuta allo scioglimento dei ghiacci delle Alpi. 275