Studi Africanistici Serie Etiopica 9 La Serie Etiopica è diretta da Yaqob Beyene Rodolfo Fattovich Paolo Marrassini Alessandro Triulzi UNIVERSITÀ DEGLI STUDI DI NAPOLI “L’ORIENTALE” DIPARTIMENTO ASIA, AFRICA E MEDITERRANEO Studi Africanistici Serie Etiopica 9 ÆTHIOPICA ET ORIENTALIA STUDI IN ONORE DI YAQOB BEYENE A cura di ALESSANDRO BAUSI - ANTONELLA BRITA - ANDREA MANZO con la collaborazione di CARMELA BAFFIONI - ERSILIA FRANCESCA VOLUME I NAPOLI 2012 © Copyright 2012 Università di Napoli “L’Orientale” Dipartimento Asia, Africa e Mediterraneo Piazza San Domenico 12, Pal.zo Corigliano I-80134 Napoli www.unior.it ISBN 978-88-6719-026-3 6200$5,2 92/80(, &$50(/$%$)),21, 3UHVHQWD]LRQH, $/(66$1'52%$86, *OLVFULWWLGL<DTRE%H\HQH,,, )5$1&,6$1)5$< 2EVHUYDWLRQVVXUODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH &$50(/$%$)),21, ³&LWWjSHUIHWWH´HUHJLPLSROLWLFLQHOO¶,VODPDQGDOXVR $/(66$1'52%$86, 8QD³OLVWD´HWLRSLFDGLDSRVWROLHGLVFHSROL $1721(//$%5,7$ ,O*DGOD$OƝI 3$75,=,$&$5,27, /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ 6$1'5$0$5,1$&$5/(77, 4XDQGRLOJLDOORVLWLQJHGLURVVRLURPDQ]LGL4LX;LDRORQJ /8&,$&$7(5,1$ %UHYLQRWHVXOO¶LFRQRJUDILDFLQHVHGHOO¶DUWHG¶HVSRUWD]LRQH *,2,$/&+,$8==, &XIUD±7LPEXFWX0XWD]LRQL3LDQRGHOO¶RSHUDHGLVFRUVRGHOVHFRQGR VDKDULDQR $*267,12&,/$5'2 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD7HUPLQLUHODWLYLDOOHSUDWLFKHGLFXOWR 526$&217( /¶(WLRSLDHLO3UHWH*LDQQL 5,&&$5'2&217,1, 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH )5$1&2&5(9$7,1 7UHQRWHGLILORORJLDHJL]LDQD 6RPPDULR 6$/9$725(',*/,2 0HJDFLWLHV3ULPDWH&LWLHVDQG:RUOG*OREDO&LWLHV7KH(YROYLQJ8UEDQ6\VWHPVLQ3DFL ILF$VLD $11$0$5,$',72//$ 1RWHVXLWHVWLRUDOLEHUEHULGHO0DURFFR *,$11,'25( 1RWHVXOOHVVLFRSDVWRUDOHNXQDPD 52'2/)2)$7729,&+ /DFDGXWDGL0HQJKLVWXXQULFRUGRSHUVRQDOH 92/80(,, *,29$11,*$5%,1, <DWKDPDU:DWDU³LOYHQGLFDWRUH´HJOLLQL]LGL6DED $/(66$1'52*25, )LWQDWUDL0XVXOPDQLHWLRSLFLWUHIRQWLLVODPLFKHVXãD\প=lNNDU\DV )(/,&(,65$(/ 6WXGLVX*UD]LDGLR,VDLD$VFROLVHPLWLVWDFRQRVFHQ]DGHOO¶HWLRSLFR *,$1&$5/2/$&(5(1=$ /DUHJLQDGL6DEDQHO7DUJXPGL*LREEH $0('(20$,(//2 0DOLN$PEDUHODGLDVSRUDۊDEDãƯQHOO¶2FHDQR,QGLDQR 5,&&$5'20$,6$12 *LURODPRH'DQWH1RWHGLOHWWXUDDOFRPPHQWRD,VDLD $1'5($0$1=2 6XOILOHOOHQLVPRGHLSULQFLSLDNVXPLWL&RQVLGHUD]LRQLVXDOFXQLRJJHWWLG¶DUWHGLWLSRHOOH QLVWLFRURPDQRGD$NVXP 6,/9$1$3$/0$ ,VWUX]LRQHLQFRORQLD/DVFXRODJRYHUQDWLYDSHULQGLJHQLGL$VPDUD 526$11$3,5(//, ,O³'LUHWWRUHGHOOH7UXSSH6WUDQLHUH´QHLWHVWL)DUDRQLFLGHO0HGLR5HJQR %$572/20(23,521( /DPRUWHGL*LXVHSSHO¶(EUHR $11$0$5,$48$*/,277, $*DQGKDUDQUHOLHILQWKH*RYHUQPHQW0XVHXPDQG$UW*DOOHU\&KDQGLJDUK$EULHIQRWH *,$1&$5/25,1$/', 2UGRSHUVHFXWRUXP1RWHVSDUVHLQPDUJLQHDOUDSSRUWRWUD6HQDWRURPDQRHFULVWLDQHVLPR 3$2/26$17$1*(/2 ³$GOLELWXP´UqQ\uԫHUqQTtQJԫᛵOLFHQ]DRDXWRUHDOL]]D]LRQH" 6RPPDULR /8,6$6(51,&2/$()('(5,&$68/$6 &RQWLQXLWjHFDPELDPHQWRQHOSDHVDJJLRUXUDOHGL$NVXPGDWLDUFKHRORJLFLHWQRJUDILFLH SDOHRDPELHQWDOL $'2/)27$0%85(//2 /¶,WDOLDHOHUHOD]LRQLQLSSRHWLRSLFKHQHJOLDQQLWUHQWDGHOQRYHFHQWR 0$''$/(1$726&$12 3ULPHLQGDJLQLVXLWHUPLQLXWLOL]]DWLLQULIHULPHQWRD(WLRSLDH$ELVVLQLDLQDOFXQLWHVWLFRQ WHPSRUDQHLVZDKLOL &+,$5$=$==$52 +LVWRULFDODQGDUFKDHRORJLFDOUHFRUGVWRUHIOHFWRQWKHPDULWLPHFRPSRQHQWVRIWKH$NVX PLWHVRFLHW\ &$50(/$%$)),21, 3UHVHQWD]LRQH ÊFRQSDUWLFRODUHVRGGLVID]LRQHFKHSUHVHQWRLYROXPLLQRQRUHGHO&ROOH JDHDPLFR<DTRE%H\HQHTXDOH'LUHWWRUHRUPDLSHUORVFRUFLRGHOO¶DQQRGL TXHO ³'LSDUWLPHQWR GL 6WXGL H 5LFHUFKH VX $IULFD H3DHVL $UDEL´ FKH DOFXQL DQQLIDGHFLVHGLSURPXRYHUHTXHVWDLQL]LDWLYD 6LDPRLQXQPRPHQWRGLWUDQVL]LRQHQXRYHVILGHFLDWWHQGRQRLQSLVWUHWWD FROODERUD]LRQHFRQ&ROOHJKLFKHVRQRILQRUDDSSDUWHQXWLD'LSDUWLPHQWLSDUWLFR ODUPHQWHDIILQLDOOHULFHUFKHFKHVLVRQRFRQGRWWHQHOQRVWUR(PLDXJXURFRQ WXWWRLOFXRUHFKH<DTREVLDFRQQRLSHUYLYHUHDVVLHPHTXHVWHVILGH 4XDQGR VRQR YHQXWD DOO¶2ULHQWDOH QHO IHEEUDLR GHO IHFL DIIHUHQ]D DOO¶DOORUD³'LSDUWLPHQWRGL6WXGL$VLDWLFL´3HUFLzQRQFRQREELVXELWR<DTRE FKH IDFHYD SDUWH GHO ³'LSDUWLPHQWR GL $IULFDQLVWLFD´ &RQIHVVR FKH DOORUFKp PROWLGLQRLFRQIOXLURQRFRQLFROOHJKLDIULFDQLVWLGDQGRDSSXQWRYLWDDOQXR YR ³'LSDUWLPHQWR GL 6WXGL H 5LFHUFKH VX $IULFD H 3DHVL DUDEL´ HEEL LQL]LDO PHQWH TXDOFKH GLIILFROWj DG LQWHUDJLUH FRQ TXHVWL FROOHJKL 'L FRQVHJXHQ]D FRPLQFLDLDFRQRVFHUH<DTRESLDQSLDQRHVRSUDWWXWWRGDTXDQGRGLYHQQH'L UHWWRUHGHO'LSDUWLPHQWR'DDOORUDSHUzODQRVWUDDPLFL]LDVLqPROWRDSSUR IRQGLWDH±FHUWDPHQWHDQFKHJUD]LHDOXL±VLqRSHUDWDXQDVHPSUHFUHVFHQWH DUPRQL]]D]LRQHIUDLFROOHJKL³DUDELVWL´HLFROOHJKL³DIULFDQLVWL´2JJLFRPH RJJLQRQPLVHPEUDUHWRULFRSDUODUHGLDPLFL]LDIUDQRLSHUFXLODYRUDUHQHO 'LSDUWLPHQWRqGLYHQWDWRVHPSUHSLSURILFXRHVWLPRODQWH 1DWXUDOPHQWH ELVRJQD ULFRQRVFHUH FKH XQ UXROR LPSRUWDQWH LQ TXHVWR SURFHVVRqVWDWRVYROWRDQFKHGDOSHUVRQDOHDPPLQLVWUDWLYRGHO'LSDUWLPHQWR 5LVSHWWRDWXWWLGRFHQWLHQRQGRFHQWLQHO'LSDUWLPHQWRHLQJHQHUDOHDOO¶2 ULHQWDOH<DTREqWXWWRUDXQSXQWRGLULIHULPHQWRFRVWDQWH1HOODVXDSDUWHFL SD]LRQH VHPSUH DWWHQWD PD GLVFUHWD q VHPSUH SRVVLELOH SDUODUJOL GL WXWWR H VHPSUHVLSRVVRQRDYHUHSDUHULEDVDWLVXOODVXDSURIRQGDFRQRVFHQ]DGHOO¶2 ULHQWDOH PD VRSUDWWXWWR VXO VXR HTXLOLEULR 4XDQWL FRQVLJOL JOL KR FKLHVWR LQ ,, 3UHVHQWD]LRQH TXHVWLDQQLLQFXLDQFKHGHFLVLRQLGLIILFLOLKDQQRGRYXWRHVVHUHSUHVHWDORUD DQFKHLPSRSRODUL«'¶DOWURFDQWRSDUODQGRFRQ<DTREqVSHVVLVVLPRSRVVLEL OH FRJOLHUH HFKL GHO VXR SDHVH GL RULJLQH GHOOD VXD OLQJXD GHOOD VXD FXOWXUD XQDFXOWXUDDPHHVWUDQHDSXUWURSSRHDOORUDSHQVRDTXDQWRVRQRIRUWXQDWL JOLVWXGHQWLFKHSRVVRQRDSSUHQGHUHGDOXL ,YROXPLDFXLQXPHURVLVVLPL&ROOHJKLKDQQRFRQWULEXLWRFRQJUDQGHVODQ FLRHPROWLDOWULDYUHEEHURYROXWRSDUWHFLSDUHVLVRQRDYYDOVLGHOO¶LPSDJDELOH RSHUD GL DOFXQL QRVWUL SL JLRYDQL &ROOHJKL H DPLFL $OHVVDQGUR %DXVL FKH SURVHJXH DG $PEXUJR OD JORULRVD WUDGL]LRQH GL VWXGL HWLRSLFL GHOO¶2ULHQWDOH $QGUHD0DQ]RODFXLVROHU]LDHSURQWH]]DQHOVROOHYDUPLHDQFKHQHOVROOH YDUFLGDLQFRPEHQ]HWHFQLFKHQRQDOODSRUWDWDGLWXWWLqSDULDOODVXDFRPSH WHQ]DQHOVHWWRUHDUFKHRORJLFRDIIHUHQWHDQFKHDOO¶(WLRSLD$QWRQHOOD%ULWDDO OLHYDGL%DXVLHRUDDQFK¶HOODDG$PEXUJR$ORURYDLOPLRSLVHQWLWRULQJUD ]LDPHQWRFRPHSXUHDOODFROOHJD(UVLOLD)UDQFHVFDFKHFRPHPHVWHVVDKDFRO ODERUDWRDOODUHGD]LRQHGHOO¶RSHUDVLDSXUHLQPLVXUDPROWRPLQRUH 1RQ SRVVR QRQ FRQFOXGHUH FRQ XQ ULQJUD]LDPHQWR D <DTRE GD SDUWH GL WXWWLQRLSHUWXWWRTXHOORFKHFLKDGDWRLQTXHVWLDQQLHFRQXQDXJXULRFHUWD PHQWHQRQPHQRFRQGLYLVRFKHYRJOLDDQFRUDHVVHUHSDUWHGHO'LSDUWLPHQWRGL $VLD $IULFD H 0HGLWHUUDQHR FKH YRJOLD DQFRUD RIIULUFL LO VXR VDSHUH H OD VXD DPLFL]LDFRVLFFKpDQFRUDPROWRDOWULSRVVDQRDYHUHLOSULYLOHJLRGLFRQRVFHUORH GLDSSUHQGHUHGDOXL 1DSROLGLFHPEUH $/(66$1'52%$86, *OLVFULWWLGL<DTRE%H\HQH 3UHVHQWDUH SHU TXDQWR DVVDL LQ EUHYH JOL VWXGL H OH ULFHUFKH GL <DTRE %H\HQH QHJOL VFULWWL ILQRUD SXEEOLFDWL HOHQFDWL SL VRWWR H ULFKLDPDWL LQ QRWD SHUDQQRQRQSRVVRVHQ]DSULPDGLUHTXDOFRVDGDOPLRSXQWRGLYLVWD±VRJ JHWWLYR FHUWDPHQWH SDU]LDOH PD VLQFHUR QHOOH LQWHQ]LRQL ± GL <DTRE FRPH SHUVRQDSHUFRPHO¶KRFRQRVFLXWRLRQHLQRQSRFKLDQQLXQDYHQWLQDLQFXL KRDYXWRPRGRGLIUHTXHQWDUORSULPDGDVWXGHQWHSUHVVRLO'RWWRUDWRLQ$IUL FDQLVWLFD GHOO¶DQFRUD ,VWLWXWR 2ULHQWDOH GL1DSROL SRLGD FROOHJD GHO'LSDUWL PHQWRGL6WXGLH5LFHUFKHVX$IULFDH3DHVL$UDELFRQGLYLGHQGRFRQOXLSHU TXDVLWUHTXDUWLGLTXHVWRYHQWHQQLRTXRWLGLDQDPHQWHHVSHVVRLQSULPDOLQHD OH YLFHQGH H OH DFFDYDOODQWHVL ULIRUPH GHOO¶XQLYHUVLWj LWDOLDQD XQ LPSHJQR VSHVVRLQJUDWRFXL<DTREPDLVLqVRWWUDWWRGLHWURODVFXVDIUHTXHQWHGHOO¶³LQ FRPSHWHQ]D´RGHOOD³VFDUVDSURSHQVLRQH´GHGLFDQGRVLDOO¶LVWLWX]LRQHLQPRGL FKH VL SRWUDQQR FRPH TXHOOL GL DOWUL FULWLFDUH QHO PHULWR PD VHPSUH DVVX PHQGRVLVHQ]DHVLWD]LRQHOHSURSULHUHVSRQVDELOLWj (WLRSLFR³LQPLVVLRQHFLYLOL]]DWULFHLQ,WDOLD´±FRPHULVSRVHDQQLDGGLH WUR QHO PRGR WDQWR JDUEDWR TXDQWR IHUPR H ULVROXWR FKH JOL q SURSULR D XQR VJXDLDWRFRPPHQWRUD]]LVWDULYROWRJOLSHUVWUDGD±<DTRE%H\HQHKDYLVVXWR DOPHQRGXHYROWHODFRQGL]LRQHGLPLQRUDQ]DPLQRUDQ]D³QHUD´QHOO¶,WDOLDGHO ERRPHPLQRUDQ]DLQ(WLRSLDQHOODSULPDJLRYHQWSHUFKpQDWRHFUHVFLXWRLQ XQDIDPLJOLDFRPSRVLWDWLJULQDGHOO¶HVWUHPRQRUGGHO7HJUƗ\HVƗKRµƗVƗZU WƗFULVWLDQDPDGLIHGHFDWWROLFDLQTXHOGLVWUHWWRGHOO¶µ$JƗPƝFKHqDQFKH XQR GHL SULPL WRSRQLPL HWLRSLFL JLj GRFXPHQWDWL LQ HWj DNVXPLWD H GRYH 1HO7HJUƗ\RULHQWDOHFRQFHQWURSULQFLSDOHµ$GGLJUƗWLPPHGLDWDPHQWHDULGRVVRGHOO¶DWWXDOH FRQILQHFRQO¶$NNDOD*X]Ɨ\LQ(ULWUHD ,9 $OHVVDQGUR%DXVL XQ¶HQFODYHFDWWROLFDVWDELOLWDGDLPLVVLRQDULOD]]DULVWLSRVHSUHVWRTXDUWLHUHVLQ GDO;,;VHFRORYDQWDQGRLQEUHYHODUJRVHJXLWR *LRYDQH EULOODQWH DYYLDWR DOOD IRUPD]LRQH GHO VHPLQDULR q D 5RPD ± RVSLWHGHOFHOHEHUULPR&ROOHJLR(WLRSLFRGL6DQWR6WHIDQRGHL0RUL±FKH<D TREFRPSLHODVFHOWDGHFLVLYDTXHOODQRQVFRQWDWDGLODVFLDUHODSUHGHVWLQDWD FDUULHUDHFFOHVLDVWLFDSHUDOWULVWXGLDYHYDGDVXELWRDPDWRPROWLVVLPRODILOR VRILDFKHJOLWRUQHUjXWLOHSRLSHULVXRLODYRULVXOODWHRORJLDHWLRSLFDDOO¶DO ORUDJLjYHFFKLR,VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOH$1DSROL<DTRESHUFRUUHLQ XQ OXQJR WRUQR GL DQQL WXWWL L JUDGLQL GHOOD YLWD DFFDGHPLFD ± GD VWXGHQWH D LPSLHJDWRELEOLRWHFDULRILQRDOODGRFHQ]DHDOODFDWWHGUDHDGLYHUVHFDULFKH DFFDGHPLFKH GLUHWWRUH GL GLSDUWLPHQWR SUHVLGHQWHGL FRUVR GL ODXUHD FXUUL FXOXPHSUHVHQ]DFKHQHKDQQRIDWWRSHUWDQWLDQQLXQDGHOOHILJXUHDWWHVHHLU ULQXQFLDELOL GHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL 6WXGL H 5LFHUFKH VX$IULFD H3DHVL$UDEL H GHOOHVXHSUHFHGHQWL³LSRVWDVL´HGHOO¶LQWHUDLVWLWX]LRQH 'HFLVLYRLQTXHVWRVQRGRLOFRQWDWWRHODFRRSWD]LRQHVLGLUHEEHRJJLGL /DQIUDQFR5LFFLLOPDJJLRUHWLRSLVWDLWDOLDQRGHOVHFRQGRGRSRJXHUUDQRQFKp WUDLSRFKLHXOWLPLDOOLHYLGL&DUOR&RQWL5RVVLQLVXOODFXLPDUFDQWHSUHVHQ]D DOO¶2ULHQWDOH H QHOO¶(WLRSLVWLFD LWDOLDQD SHU XQ FLQTXDQWHQQLR VX XQR VIRQGR JUDYDWRGLFXSHPHPRULHWDQWHFRQIHVVLRQLKRUDFFROWRGDOODYLYDYRFHGL<D TRE ( 5LFFL ± FXL <DTRE SUHVWDYD LQL]LDOPHQWH RSHUD FRPH LQIRUPDWRUH FRQVXOHQWH H UDFFRJOLWRUH GL PDWHULDOL ± q QHFHVVDULDPHQWH O¶LVSLUDWRUH H LO PHQWRUHGHLSULPLODYRULGL<DTRELQGLUL]]DWLGDVXELWRDGXHGHJOLLQWHUHVVL FRVWDQWLGHOODVXDSURGX]LRQHODOLQJXDWLJULQDHODVXDOHWWHUDWXUDHJOLVFULWWL GLFDUDWWHUHWHRORJLFR,QWHUHVVLFKHVLWHQGHUHEEHDLQWHUSUHWDUHHQWUDPELVXO GDWRELRWLFRGHOODFRVWDQWHSHUFH]LRQHGLXQDGLVWDQ]DSHUVLVWHQWHHDWUDWWLGR ORURVD'LVWDQ]DGDOWLJULQROLQJXDPDGUHLQUDSLGDHYROX]LRQHVXOODVSLQWDGL WHQGHQ]HILVLRORJLFKHPDDQFKHLQFRQVHJXHQ]DGLWUDJLFLDYYHQLPHQWLLOFL /¶DQWLFR³2VSL]LRGHJOL$ELVVLQL´ULHYRFDWRLQXQVXRVFULWWR /DIUHTXHQWD]LRQHGHOVHPLQDULRHODVFHOWDQRQIDFLOHGLDEEDQGRQDUORDOLPHQWHUDQQRQHOWHP SRLQ<DTREXQDFRVWDQWHDWWUD]LRQHHFXULRVLWjSHULOPRQGRHFFOHVLDVWLFRQRQVRORHWLRSLFR XQLWHVHPSUHDXQRVJXDUGRWDQWRDFXWRHSHQHWUDQWHTXDQWRGLVLQFDQWDWR 5LFFLVLHUDODXUHDWRFRQOXLQHOSHUODVFLDUHVXELWRGRSRO¶,WDOLDSHUO¶$IULFD2ULHQWDOH, WDOLDQDGRQGHVDUHEEHULHQWUDWRGRSRTXDVLGLHFLDQQLLQFOXVLGLYHUVLGLSULJLRQLD 'L/DQIUDQFR5LFFL<DTREqVWDWRFRHGLWRUHGHOYROXPHGLVWXGLLQRQRUHFRVuFRPHH VWHQVRUHGLXQDVFLXWWRTXDQWRGHQVRQHFURORJLRSHUODVXDPRUWH *OLVFULWWLGL<DTRE%H\HQH 9 FOLFRFRQIOLWWRIUDWULFLGDWUDHWLRSLFLHGHULWUHLHSXUDQFKH±VLGLUHEEHVHFLz PDLSRWHVVHGDUHXQVHQVRDOO¶DVVXUGR±WUDWLJULQRIRQLHWLRSLFLHGHULWUHLFRQ JOLVFRQYROJLPHQWLJHRSROLWLFLFRQQHVVLOLQJXDSHUGXWDHGLVFRQRVFLXWDQHOOD VXDYDULDQWHGLVWDPSDSHULRGLFDHGHLPHGLDGHOODPRGHUQLWjHFRPHWDOHRV VHUYDWD H PRQLWRUDWD 'LVWDQ]D DQFKH GDOOH GLYHUVH IHGL FULVWLDQH GUDVWLFD PHQWH ULGRWWH DOOD GLFRWRPLD FDWWROLFDRUWRGRVVD GHO SURSULR SDHVH$OOD WHQ VLRQHLUULVROWDWUDODIHGHPLQRULWDULDHIDPLOLDUHGHOFDWWROLFHVLPRTXLLQWHUHV VDRYYLDPHQWHVRORODILGHVTXDHFUHGLWXUODKD\PƗQRWGHJOLHWLRSLFLHODIH GH FKH O¶(WLRSLD FULVWLDQD KD UDSSUHVHQWDWR FRPH QD]LRQH SHU VHFROL VL GHYH IRUVH LQ SL GL XQ FRQWULEXWR GL <DTRE OD ULFHUFD FRVWDQWH GHOOH FRQYHUJHQ]H VRVWDQ]LDOLVRORDSSDQQDWHGDOOHGLYHUJHQ]HDFFLGHQWDOL $OWULODYRUL<DTREKDGHGLFDWRDLPRPHQWLGLFULVLGHOODVWRULDHWLRSLFD R DOOD SUHVHQWD]LRQH GL WHVWL WUD FXL OD SULPD VWRULD G¶(WLRSLD LQ WLJULQR PDL SXEEOLFDWDFKHQHLOOXVWUDQRODDXWRUDSSUHVHQWD]LRQHQHOODSURVSHWWLYDWUDGL ]LRQDOHRDGDOWULDVSHWWLJHQHUDOLGHOFULVWLDQHVLPRHWLRSLFR $OWUD SURGX]LRQH GL <DTRE %H\HQH GD ULFRQGXUUH IRUVH DOOD WHQVLRQH GL FXLVRSUDqTXHOODVXJOLDVSHWWLGHOODYLWDVRFLDOHG¶(WLRSLDYLVWLLQXQDSURVSHW WLYDFKHqUHFLSURFDGLTXHOODFDQRQLFDDQWURSRORJLFD³RVVHUYD]LRQHSDUWHFL SDQWH´GXQTXHSLXWWRVWRGDOO¶LQWHUQRGHOODVRFLHWjRVVHUYDWDYHUVRXQDFRQVD SHYROHTXDQWRQHFHVVDULDWDOYROWDLURQLFDHREOLTXDSUHVDGLGLVWDQ]D 'L SULPR SLDQR H FRQQHVVR DL WHPL JLj HOHQFDWL q DQFKH LO FRQWULEXWR GL <DTREDOORVWXGLRGHOGLULWWRFRQVXHWXGLQDULRWLJULQRDOODFXLSXEEOLFD]LRQHH LQWHUSUHWD]LRQHHJOLVLqGDWRFRPHQHVVXQDOWURQHJOLXOWLPLGHFHQQL /¶RSHUDLQDVVROXWRSLLPSRUWDQWHGL<DTRE±VLDSHUODJUDQGHHVWHQVLR QHHO¶LPSHJQRFRPSOHVVLYRULFKLHVWRTXDWWURYROXPLSHUROWUHPLOOHSDJLQH VLDSHULOULOLHYRDVVROXWRGHOO¶RJJHWWRGLVWXGLR±UHVWDSHUzO¶HGL]LRQHHWUDGX ]LRQHGHO/LEURGHOPLVWHURGHOWHRORJRHDEDWH*L\RUJLVGL6DJOƗRSHUDGLI E ED EE F DDDD 9, $OHVVDQGUR%DXVL ILFLOHDUGXDHFRQFHWWRVDUHVDLQXQLWDOLDQRVRUSUHQGHQWHPHQWHVFRUUHYROHH DGHUHQWH FKH qXQDQLPHPHQWH FRQVLGHUDWD XQR GHLFDSRODYRUL H XQD VRUWD GL ULFDSLWROD]LRQH GHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD JHµH] QRQFKp XQD VXPPD WKHRORJLFD GHO VD SHUH UHOLJLRVR GHOO¶(WLRSLD DJOL DOERUL GHOO¶DXUHRVHFROR ;9 FKH VDUj SRL GL =DU¶D<ƗµTREHDQFRUDIRULHUD±FRPH<DTREDYHYDSUHGHWWRDXQVRVSHWWRVR HXQSR¶LQFUHGXORJLRYDQHFROOHJDGL'LSDUWLPHQWRGLYHUVLDQQLDGGLHWUR±GL ULOHYDQWLQRYLWjFKHFRQWLQXDQRDHPHUJHUHFRQVRUSUHQGHQWLULYHOD]LRQL 5LHYRFDQGR TXHVW¶HSLVRGLR FKH PL KD ULJXDUGDWR QRQ SRVVR WDFHUH FKH GLVSRQLELOLWjYHUVRLSLJLRYDQLDFROORTXLDUHHDGLVFXWHUHFRQORURDOHJJHU QH L ODYRUL DQFRUD LQ ILHUL H D FRPPHQWDUOL PLQXWDPHQWH DVVXPHQGRVL VHQ]D PDLIDUORSHVDUHQRWHYROLFDULFKLGLODYRURFRQODFRVWDQWHPDLLPEDUD]]DWD IUHVFDFXULRVLWjGLDSSUHQGHUHDVXDYROWDRDQFKHODVFKLHWWDGHWHUPLQD]LRQH GL WHQHUH VXO SXQWR VHQ]D DFFHWWDUH PDL VRILVWLFKH H DUWLILFLRVH VROX]LRQL GL FRPSURPHVVRVRQRTXDOLWjFKHD<DTREQRQVRQRPDLPDQFDWHHFKHO¶KDQQR IDWWRDPDUHGDJLRYDQLRUPDLPHQRJLRYDQLFKHUDSSUHVHQWDQRO¶(WLRSLVWLFD WDQWRGLRJJLTXDQWRGLGRPDQLQHLGLYHUVLFDPSLHFKHHJOLQRQKDHVLWDWRD VRVWHQHUH D YLVR DSHUWR QRQ GL UDGR LQ VLWXD]LRQL VFRPRGH HVSRQHQGRVL H VSHQGHQGRVLLQSULPDSHUVRQD ,Q TXHVWH SRFKH LQDGHJXDWH ULJKH VX <DTRE XQ WLWROR KR ODVFLDWR LQWHQ ]LRQDOPHQWHSHUXOWLPRLQTXHVWDPRGHVWDSUHVHQWD]LRQHGHLVXRLVFULWWLTXHO ORVXOEHDWR*LXVWLQR'H-DFRELVFKHQHOWLWRORIHOLFH±³O¶DUWHGHOGLDORJR´± LQGLFD FLz FKH <DTRE KD UHSXWDWR OD TXDOLWj SL JUDQGH ULWURYDWD QHO EHDWR H FXLDVXRPRGRKDVHPSUHFRQYLQWDPHQWHDVSLUDWRODWROOHUDQ]DODFRQYLYHQ ]DJDUEDWDFRQLOSURVVLPRLOULVSHWWRSHUJOLDOWULVHPSUH 0LIDSLDFHUHULHYRFDUHDOORUDSHUFKLXGHUHXQHSLVRGLRUDFFROWRGDOODYL YDYRFHGL<DTREFKHLOOXVWUDFRPHDOO¶8RPRQRQVLDSHUzPDQFDWRLOFRUDJ JLR GL GDU FRUSR DOOH SURSULH FRQYLQ]LRQL FRQ JHVWL GL LQDVSHWWDWD SDUUKHVtD ,QWHUURJDWRGDSDSD*LRYDQQL;;,,,LQYLVLWDDO&ROOHJLR(WLRSLFRVXOSHUFKp GHOVXRULILXWRDOHJJHUHGXUDQWHLOFRQYLYLRVHPLQDULDOHJOLVFULWWLGHOFDUGLQDO *XJOLHOPR0DVVDMD<DTREQRQHVLWzDVSLHJDUHFKHQRQSRWHYDIDUORSHUFKp ³O¶DSRVWRORGHL*DOOD´LOSURSXJQDWRUHGHOFDWWROLFHVLPR³GLULWRODWLQR´HUDLQ (WLRSLDULWHQXWRLOFDPSLRQHGHOO¶LQWROOHUDQ]DLQWUDQVLJHQWH(GRWWRGDOODVSLH JD]LRQHSDSD*LRYDQQLSDVVzDGDOWUR3DUHFKHQHO&ROOHJLR(WLRSLFRGDDOOR UD0DVVDMDQRQVLVLDSLOHWWR $PEXUJRGLFHPEUH F *OLVFULWWLGL<DTRE%H\HQH 9,, 6&5,77,',<$42%%(<(1( ³/HSUHSDODWDOLQHOGLDOHWWRWLJULQRGHO6ƗµVL¶µ$JƗPl´LQ$QQDOLGHOO¶,VWLWX >@ WR2ULHQWDOHGL1DSROLSS ³5ƗV6HEতƗWLQDOFXQHFRPSRVL]LRQLSRHWLFKHWLJULQHGHOO¶µ$JƗPl´LQ$QQDOL >@ GHOO¶,VWLWXWR2ULHQWDOHGL1DSROLSS ³/¶LPSHUDWRUH *LRYDQQL ,9LQ DOFXQH FRPSRVL]LRQL SRHWLFKH WLJULQH´ LQ$Q >@ QDOLGHOO¶,VLWXWR2ULHQWDOHGL1DSROLSS ³8Q PDQRVFULWWR FDWWROLFR LQ WLJULQR GHO ;,; VHFROR´ LQ $QQDOL GHOO¶,VWLWXWR >@ 2ULHQWDOHGL1DSROLSS 8QRSXVFRORFDWWROLFRGLSROHPLFDWHRORJLFDLQWLJULQRGHO;,;VHFROR1DSR OL,VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOH6XSSOHPHQWRDJOL$QQDOLGHOO¶, >@ VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOH &RQWURYHUVLHFULVWRORJLFKHLQ(WLRSLD&RQWULEXWRDOODVWRULDGHOOHFRUUHQWLH GHOODWHUPLQRORJLDQHOVHFROR;,;1DSROL,VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWD OH 6XSSOHPHQWR DJOL $QQDOL GHOO¶,VWLWXWR 8QLYHUVLWDULR 2ULHQWDOH >@ ³8QD WUDGX]LRQH LQ WLJULQR GHO 1XRYR 7HVWDPHQWR´ LQ $QQDOL GHOO¶,VWLWXWR >@ 2ULHQWDOHGL1DSROLSS /¶XQ]LRQHGL&ULVWRQHOODWHRORJLDHWLRSLFD&RQWULEXWRGLULFHUFDVXQXRYLGR FXPHQWLHWLRSLFLLQHGLWL5RPD3RQWLILFLR,VWLWXWR2ULHQWDOH2ULHQ >@ WDOLD&KULVWLDQD$QDOHFWD ³,OGDJL\àW6HEàJàGHVLQDOFXQLWHVWLWLJULQLLQHGLWL´LQ$QQDOLGHOO¶,VWLWXWR2 >@ ULHQWDOHGL1DSROLSS ³/DORWWDSHUO¶LQGLSHQGHQ]DGHOO¶(ULWUHDHGL3DHVL$UDEL´LQ&OHOLD6DUQHOOL &HUTXDDF6WXGLDUDERLVODPLFLLQRQRUHGL5REHUWR5XELQDFFLQHOVXR VHWWDQWHVLPRFRPSOHDQQR,1DSROL,VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOH >@ SS 9,,, $OHVVDQGUR%DXVL ³,OSULPRYRFDERODULRWLJULQRPRQROLQJXD´LQ4XDGHUQLGL6WXGL(WLRSLFL >@ SS )HVVHۊD *L\RUJLV 6WRULD G¶(WLRSLD 1DSROL ,VWLWXWR 8QLYHUVLWDULR 2ULHQWDOH >@ ³7HUPLQRORJLDPDU[LVWDOHQLQLVWDLQWLJULQR´LQ5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL(WLRSLFL >@ >@SS *L\RUJLVGL6DJOƗ,OOLEURGHO0LVWHUR0Dۊ܈DID0HVܒLU/RYDQLL,Q$HGLEXV (3HHWHUVH&RUSXV6FULSWRUXP&KULVWLDQRUXP2ULHQWDOLXP >@ H6FULSWRUHV$HWKLRSLFLH ³/DGRWWULQDGHOOD&KLHVDHWLRSLFDHLOµ/LEURGHOPLVWHUR¶GL*L\RUJLVGL6D JOƗ´LQ5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL(WLRSLFL>@SS >@ >FIU@ <DTRE%H\HQH5RGROIR)DWWRYLFK3DROR0DUUDVVLQL$OHVVDQGUR7ULXO]LD F(WLRSLDHROWUH6WXGLLQRQRUHGL/DQIUDQFR5LFFL1DSROL,VWLWXWR8 QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOH'LSDUWLPHQWRGL6WXGLH5LFHUFKHVX$IULFDH3DHVL >D@ $UDEL6WXGL$IULFDQLVWLFL6HULH(WLRSLFD ³,O+D\PƗQRWD$EDZ4DGGDPWGL.LGàQD:DOG.HIOòߌLQSS >E@ ³7KHWUDGLWLRQDO(WKLRSLDQ&RQFHSWLRQRI+LVWRU\DQG+LVWRULRJUDSK\´LQ7KH (DVW DQG WKH 0HDQLQJ RI +LVWRU\ ,QWHUQDWLRQDO &RQIHUHQFH 1R YHPEHU 5RPD 6FLHQ]H H /HWWHUH 6WXGL2ULHQWDOL SS >F@ ³&RQJUHVVRSHULO&HQWHQDULRGHOODYLWWRULDGLµ$GZàIHEEUDLRPDU]R ´LQ5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL(WLRSLFL>@SS >@ ³,WDEDOLPHQWDULHLOFULVWLDQHVLPRHWLRSLFR´LQ5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL(WLRSLFL >D@ >@SS *OLVFULWWLGL<DTRE%H\HQH ,; UHFHQVLRQHGL$WR:DOGD$E0HUX܈ƗWµDQTD܈ƗWDWR:DOGD$E$V VDQƗGƗ¶L7HNZàER$UDVVHµ>$UWLFROLVFHOWLGL:DOGD$E$FX UDGL7HNZàER$UDVVHµ@$VPDUD+HGUL3XEOLVKHUVLQ5DVVHJQDGL >E@ 6WXGL(WLRSLFL>@SS ³'LULWWR&RQVXHWXGLQDULRGHO/RJJRࣩXZàߌLQ5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL(WLRSLFL >@ >@SS UHFHQVLRQH GL $$99 0D]JDED TƗOƗW WƱJUƱxƗ EƱWƱJULxƗ $GGLV $EDEƗ QƗ\ ,W\R\Ɨ TZƗQTZƗWƗW $NNƗGƗPL ± NHIOL WHJUHxxƗ LQ 5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL(WLRSLFL>@SS >@ ³'LULWWRFRQVXHWXGLQDULRGHO6DতDUWGHO/ƗP]ƗGHO:DTƗUWGHO'ƗPEƗFRQ $SSHQGLFH´ LQ 5DVVHJQD GL 6WXGL (WLRSLFL >@ SS >D@ ³/DWUDGL]LRQHGHOFULVWLDQHVLPRHWLRSLFR´LQ1HOORGHO*DWWRDF&RUVRGL SHUIH]LRQDPHQWRLQ6WRULDGHO&ULVWLDQHVLPR$QWLFRGLUHWWRGD/XLJL&LULO OR H *LDQFDUOR 5LQDOGL $WWL 1DSROL PDU]RJLXJQR 1DSROL ('L68 1DSROL'LSDUWLPHQWRGL6WXGL$VLDWLFL,VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOH >E@ 6HULH'LGDWWLFDSS ³>'LULWWR FRQVXHWXGLQDULR GL +DEVHOOXV@´ LQ 5DVVHJQD GL 6WXGL (WLRSLFL >D@ >@SS ³/¶DVVRFLD]LRQHGHOFDOLFHLQ(WLRSLDPƗېEDUD܈HZZƗµ´LQ6LPRQHWWD*UD]LD QLFRQODFROODERUD]LRQHGL0DULD&&DVDEXUL*LDQFDUOR/DFHUHQ]DD F6WXGLVXO9LFLQR2ULHQWH$QWLFRGHGLFDWLDOODPHPRULDGL/XLJL&DJQL 1DSROL ,VWLWXWR 8QLYHUVLWDULR 2ULHQWDOH 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL 6WXGL $VLDWLFL LQ FROODERUD]LRQHFRQ,VWLWXWR,WDOLDQRSHUO¶$IULFDHO¶2ULHQWH'LUH]LRQH*H QHUDOHGHL0XVHL9DWLFDQL6HULHV0LQRUSS >E@ ³*LXVWLQRGH-DFRELVO¶DUWHGHOGLDORJR´LQ2OWUHJOL2UL]]RQWL/HVILGHGHOOD ³0LVVLRQH DG JHQWHV´ LHUL H RJJL ;;,9 &RQYHJQR GL$QLPD]LRQH 9LQ FHQ]LDQD &DSDFL 3$ VHWWHPEUH 5RPD &/9 (GL]LRQL 9LQFHQ]LDQH SS ³-XVWLQ GH -DFRELV 7KH $UW RI 'LDOR >F@ JXH´LQ9LQFHQ]LDQDSS ; $OHVVDQGUR%DXVL ³'LULWWRFRQVXHWXGLQDULRGHOORĿDZµDWWDµ$QVDED´LQ5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL(WLR >D@ SLFLQVSS ³&ULVWLDQHVLPRH,VODPLQ(WLRSLD´LQ6WXGL0DJUHELQL>@ &DUPHOD%DIILRQL*LXVHSSLQD,JRQHWWL9LQFHQ]R6WULNDDF6FULWWL LQ 2QRUH GL *LRYDQQL 2PDQ 1DSROL 8QLYHUVLWj GHJOL 6WXGL GL 1DSROL ³/¶2ULHQWDOH´'LSDUWLPHQWRGL6WXGLH5LFHUFKHVX$IULFDH3DHVL$UDEL SS >E@ ³'LULWWR FRQVXHWXGLQDULR GHOOR âDZµDWWD µ$QVDED ,,D SDUWH´ LQ 5DVVHJQD GL 6WXGL(WLRSLFLQVSS >D@ ³,O WHQWDWLYR WXUFRGL LVODPL]]DUHO¶(WLRSLD´LQ8JR0DUD]]LDF7XUFLFDHW ,VODPLFD 6WXGL LQ PHPRULD GL $OGR *DOORWWD , 1DSROL 8QLYHUVLWj GHJOL VWXGLGL1DSROL³/¶2ULHQWDOH´'LSDUWLPHQWRGL6WXGL$VLDWLFL,VWLWXWR,WD OLDQRSHUO¶$IULFDHO¶2ULHQWH6HULHV0LQRUSS >E@ ³/¶(WLRSLDDOO¶RPEUDGL63LHWUR´LQ/XLJL&LULOOR*LDQFDUOR5LQDOGLDF 5RPDOD&DPSDQLDHO¶2ULHQWHFULVWLDQRDQWLFR*LXELOHR$WWLGHO &RQYHJQR GL 6WXGL 1DSROL RWWREUH 1DSROL 8QLYHUVLWj GHJOL 6WXGL GL 1DSROL ³/¶2ULHQWDOH´ )DFROWj GL /HWWHUH H )LORVRILD SS >@ ³&RQVHJXHQ]HGHOODFDUQHLQVFDWROD3ROLWLFDFRORQLDOHHUHOLJLRQHLQXQHSL VRGLRGHOOHUHOD]LRQLLWDORHWLRSLFKHQHO;;VHFROR´LQ6WXGL0DJUHELQL QV $QQD0DULDGL7ROODDF6WXGLEHUEHULHPHGLWHUUDQHL 0LVFHOODQHDRIIHUWDLQRQRUHGL/XLJL6HUUD,,1DSROL8QLYHUVLWjGHJOL 6WXGLGL1DSROL³/¶2ULHQWDOH´'LSDUWLPHQWRGL6WXGLH5LFHUFKHVX$IUL >@ FDH3DHVL$UDEL&HQWURGL6WXGL0DJUHELQLSS ³/DFURFHQHOODWUDGL]LRQHFXOWXUDOHHWLRSLFD´LQ%RULV8OLDQLFKFRQODFRO ODERUD]LRQHGL8OGHULFR3DUHQWHDF/D&URFH,FRQRJUDILDHLQWHUSUH WD]LRQH VHFROL , LQL]LR;,9 $WWL GHOFRQYHJQRLQWHUQD]LRQDOH GL VWXGL 1DSROLGLFHPEUH,,1DSROL(OLRGH5RVDHGLWRUHSS >@ ³,Q PHPRULDP /DQIUDQFR 5LFFL ´ LQ $HWKLRSLFD ,QWHUQDWLRQDO -RXUQDORI(WKLRSLDQDQG(ULWUHDQ6WXGLHVSS >@ *OLVFULWWLGL<DTRE%H\HQH ;, ³, SUHVWLWL LWDOLDQL LQ DPDULFR H WLJULQR´ LQ5DVVHJQD GL 6WXGL (WLRSLFL QV >@ >@SS Yaqob Beyene )5$1&,6$1)5$< 2EVHUYDWLRQVVXUODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH /H 3pULSOH GH OD PHU (U\WKUpH G¶XQ DXWHXU DQRQ\PH RIIUH OD SOXV DQ FLHQQHDWWHVWDWLRQGXQRPG¶$[RXP(OOHGDWHGXSUHPLHUVLqFOHGHQRWUHqUH $XGHX[LqPHVLqFOH3WROpPpHOH*pRJUDSKHIDLWpWDWG¶XQH©UpVLGHQFHUR\DOHª j$[RXP8QHLQVFULSWLRQJUHFTXHGH'DTTL0DKDULHQ(U\WKUpHPHQWLRQQH XQ ©URL GHV URLV G¶$[RXP OH JUDQG 6HPEURXWKqVª8QH DXWUH GH $GGL *H OHPRDXQRUGHVWGHO¶(WKLRSLHGDWpHGXWURLVLqPHVLqFOHjVHVGpEXWVSDUOH GH ©*DGDU URL G¶$[RXPª&HV LQGLFDWLRQV PDQLIHVWHQW TX¶j O¶RUpH GX SUH PLHU PLOOpQDLUH OH UR\DXPH G¶$[RXP GpSORLH VHV MHXQHV IRUFHV j WHOOH HQ VHLJQH TX¶LO YD rWUH ELHQW{W FRPSWp VL O¶RQ V¶HQ UDSSRUWH DX[ .HSKDODLD GH 0DQL WURLVLqPH VLqFOH DX QRPEUH GHV TXDWUH JUDQGV UR\DXPHV GX PRQGH 'HX[IDFWHXUVH[SOLTXHQWFHWHVVRUOHWUDILFHQPHU5RXJHV¶LQWHQVLILHDXSUH PLHUVLqFOHGHQRWUHqUHHWFRQVpTXHQFHGHFHWWHDFWLYLWpPDULWLPHOHSURJUqV GX QpJRFH JDJQH QRQ VHXOHPHQW OHV FRPSWRLUV GX OLWWRUDO PDLV OHV FRQWUpHV YRLVLQHV ± GRQW OH UR\DXPH D[RXPLWH IDLW SDUWLH /D FRQMRQFWXUH IDYRULVH OD FUpDWLRQGHSODFHVPDUFKDQGHVVXUOHKDXWSODWHDXpU\WKUpHQ3DU3OLQHO¶$Q FLHQ HW OH 3pULSOH RQ VDLW TXH O¶LYRLUH ILJXUH DX SUHPLHU SODQ GX FRPPHUFH G¶$[RXP FHWWH GHQUpH IDLW O¶REMHW GHV FRQYRLWLVHVGX PRQGH PpGLWHUUDQpHQ $GRXOLV©jYLQJWVWDGHVGHODPHUªHVWOHFDUUHIRXUGHVWUDQVDFWLRQV/¶pFDLOOH &DVVRQSS 3WROpPpH*pRJUDSKLHOLE,9FKDSY&I'HVDQJHVSQ %HUQDQGSS %HUQDQG'UHZHV6FKQHLGHUSQU 0RQQHUHWGH9LOODUGSS )UDQFLV$QIUD\ GHWRUWXHHWODFRUQHGHUKLQRFpURVV¶\pFKDQJHQWDYHFELHQG¶DXWUHVPDUFKDQ GLVHV $O¶RULJLQHGHO¶HVVRUD[RXPLWHVRQWjVLWXHUDXVVLGHVVLqFOHVG¶XQHpYR OXWLRQ GRQW RQ QH FRQQDvW HQFRUH TX¶LPSDUIDLWHPHQWOHV pWDSHV /H UR\DXPH G¶$[RXPOHXUGRLWHQSDUWLHVHVDVVLVHVpFRQRPLTXHVHWFXOWXUHOOHV6DFLYLOL VDWLRQSUHQGUDFLQHGDQVFHSDVVpPXOWLVpFXODLUH'qVOH9,,,HVLqFOHDYDQW- & DSSDUDLVVHQWGHV UpDOLVDWLRQV DUFKLWHFWXUDOHVGRQW FHUWDLQHV QH ODLVVHQW SDV G¶LPSRVHUWHOFHWHPSOHGH<HKDGRQWOHVPXUVGHSLHUUHGHWDLOOHV¶pOqYHQW HQFRUHDXMRXUG¶KXLjSOXVGHGL[PqWUHV±VXUXQVRFOHjJUDGLQVGpWDLOTXLD VRQLQWpUrW8QHpFULWXUHHPSUXQWpHjO¶$UDELHGX6XGGpYRLOHGqVFHWWHpSR TXHO¶H[LVWHQFHG¶XQUR\DXPHGH'DDPDWHOOHIDLWFRQQDvWUHGHVQRPVGHVRX YHUDLQVHWGHGLYLQLWpVWXWpODLUHV'HVVWUXFWXUHVSROLWLTXHVVHPHWWHQWHQSODFH DXFRXUVGXPLOOpQDLUHTXLDSUpFpGpQRWUHqUH0DLQWVVLWHVDUFKpRORJLTXHVOL YUHQWGHVYHVWLJHVGHFHUR\DXPHDX[SDUWLFXODULWpVPDUTXDQWHV-XVTX¶jXQH GDWHUpFHQWHOHVROG¶$[RXPODYLHLOOHPpWURSROHV¶pWDLWPRQWUpDYDUHGHWp PRLJQDJHVFRQFUHWVVXUFHSDVVpUHFXOp /HVWUDYDX[GHVXQLYHUVLWpV GH1DSOHV©/¶2ULHQWDOHªHW GH%RVWRQVRXV ODGLUHFWLRQGH5RGROIR)DWWRYLFKHWGH.DWKU\Q%DUGRQWPLVDXMRXUVXUOD KDXWHFROOLQHGH%LHWD*L\RUJLVVXUSORPEDQWODORFDOLWpDFWXHOOHOHVUXLQHVGH SOXVLHXUVFRQVWUXFWLRQVHQOHVTXHOOHVLO\DOLHXGHYRLUVHORQOHVIRXLOOHXUVOHV SOXVDQFLHQVYHVWLJHVGHFHTXLGHYLHQGUDDX[SUHPLHUVVLqFOHGHQRWUHqUHOD FDSLWDOHGXUR\DXPH6XUODFROOLQHDXOLHXGLW2QD1DJDVWRQWpWpGpFRXYHU WHV OHV VXEVWUXFWLRQV G¶XQ ©PRQXPHQWDO EXLOGLQJª DSSDUWHQDQW j OD SpULRGH SURWRD[RXPLWHGDWpHGX,9HDX,HUVLqFOHDYDQW-&DSSHOpH©WKHIRUPDWLYH SHULRGRIWKHNLQJGRPª'DQVOHPrPHVLWHO¶pTXLSHG¶DUFKpRORJXHVDLGHQWL ILpOHVUHVWHVG¶XQ©SDODFHªGHODSpULRGHVXLYDQWH©HDUO\DNVXPLWHª/¶pGLIL FHPHVXUDLWGRX]HPqWUHVGHF{Wp /¶LPSRUWDQFHGHFHVUpVXOWDWVWLHQWHQWUHDXWUHVFKRVHVDXIDLWTX¶LOVUpYq OHQW OHV SOXV DQFLHQV pOpPHQWV G¶DUFKLWHFWXUH GH OD SpULRGH D[RXPLWH LQLWLDOH FRPSULVHG¶DSUqVODFKURQRORJLHpWDEOLHSDU5RGROIR)DWWRYLFKHQWUHOHSUH 3OLQH+LVWRLUH1DWXUHOOHOE9,FKDSYYLQ5DFNKDPHGS,GOE ;,, FKDS Y LQ 5DFNKDP HG S ,G OE ;;;9,;;;9,, LQ (LFKKRO] HGSS $QIUD\SS )DWWRYLFK%DUG3RXUXQHOLVWHGHUpIpUHQFHVSOXVFRPSOqWHVVXUOHVXMHW VHUHSRUWHUj)DWWRYLFK%DUG3HWUDVVL3LVDQRQRWDPPHQWSS 2EVHUYDWLRQVVXUODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH PLHU VLqFOH DYDQW -& HW OH ,,H VLqFOH DSUqV'DQV FHV PRQXPHQWV GH 2QD 1DJDVW VH GLVFHUQHQW FHUWDLQV GHV FDUDFWqUHV GH OD WUDGLWLRQ FODVVLTXH WHOV TX¶RQOHVREVHUYHVXUGHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVDVVLJQDEOHVjXQHSpULRGHFRXUDQWGX ,,,HDX9,,HVLqFOH'XUDQWFHVVHSWVLqFOHVXQHIRUPHDUFKLWHFWXUDOHVHFUpHHW V¶pWHQGjODJpQpUDOLWpGHVpGLILFHVPDMHXUVGXWHUULWRLUHD[RXPLWH /HVVLWHV /HV YHVWLJHV GHV DQWLTXHV FRQVWUXFWLRQV GH OD SpULRGH D[RXPLWH VH UHQ FRQWUHQW GDQV XQH UpJLRQ TXL YD G¶$[RXP j O¶RXHVW j $GRXOLV j O¶HVW R V¶DWWHLQWOHOLWWRUDOGHODPHU5RXJH&¶HVWHQYLURQWURLVFHQWVNLORPqWUHVjSDU FRXULU SDU OD URXWH EHDXFRXS PRLQV j YRO G¶RLVHDX /HV VLWHV SULQFLSDX[ R SHXYHQWrWUHREVHUYpVOHVpGLILFHVPDMHXUVRQWSRXUQRPV$[RXP(WFK0D Up$JRXOD0DWDUD7RNRQGD4RKD\WR$GRXOLV6DXIFHGHUQLHUWRXVVRQWj SOXVGHPqWUHVG¶DOWLWXGH/HVVXEVWUXFWLRQVG¶pGLILFHVTX¶LOVFRQVHUYHQW DSSDUWLHQQHQWjGHVFHQWUHVXUEDLQVSOXVRXPRLQVFRQVLGpUDEOHVHQpWHQGXH $XOLHXGLW(QGD0DU\DP7VLRQ7DKRWQRQORLQG¶$GLJUDWO¶XQGHFHVPRQX PHQWVSUpVHQWHOHVWUDLWVGHODFRQVWUXFWLRQFODVVLTXHG¶$[RXP&¶HVWXQVRX EDVVHPHQW G¶pGLILFH VRXV XQH pJOLVH G¶pSRTXH PpGLpYDOH LO VHPEOH LVROp PDLVDXFXQH[DPHQDSSURIRQGLQ¶DpWpHIIHFWXpGDQVVHVDOHQWRXUVILJ 6XUOHSODQDUFKpRORJLTXHO¶DUFKLWHFWXUHD[RXPLWHHVWUHSUpVHQWpHSDU GHV VRXEDVVHPHQWV G¶pGLILFHV GRPHVWLTXHV TXL VRQW REMHW SULQFLSDO G¶LQWpUrWGDQVFHVSDJHV GHVVRXEDVVHPHQWVG¶pGLILFHVFXOWXHOVGRQWLOHVWTXHVWLRQGHPDQLq UHLQFLGHQWHFDUOHXUWHFKQLTXHGHFRQVWUXFWLRQHVWLGHQWLTXHSRXUO¶HVVHQWLHOj FHOOHGHO¶DUFKLWHFWXUHGRPHVWLTXH )DWWRYLFKQG 3RXUODELEOLRJUDSKLHGHFHVVLWHVFRQVXOWHU*RGHWSSSRXU$[RXPSSRXU (WFK0DUpj0DNHGD*XOR0DNHGDYRLUDXVVLSSRXU%HW4RUTRVLPSRUWDQWVLWHD[RX PLWHHWSSRXU$JRXOD9RLUDXVVL*RGHWSSSRXU0DWDUDSS SRXU 7RNRQGD SS SRXU 4RKD\WR SS SRXU $GRXOLV HW S SRXU =DOD%HW 0HNDTXLHVWXQDXWUHVLWHLPSRUWDQW$FHVUpIpUHQFHVUDVVHPEOpHVGDQVOHUpSHUWRLUHG¶(ULF *RGHWLO\DOLHXG¶DMRXWHUSRXU$[RXP0XQUR+D\UpVXOWDWVGHVUHFKHUFKHVGH1H YLOOH&KLWWLFNj$[RXPGHj3KLOOLSVRQHW&DUWHGHVVLWHVGDQV$Q IUD\S *RGHWS )UDQFLV$QIUD\ GHV FDYHDX[ IXQpUDLUHV GRQW V¶DJLVVDQW GH FRQVWUXFWLRQV LO Q¶H[LVWH JXqUHG¶H[HPSOHVFRQQXVTX¶j$[RXPHWj0DWDUD /DFRQVWUXFWLRQGRPHVWLTXHj$[RXP /¶DQWLTXHFDSLWDOHFRQVHUYHOHVSOXVUHSUpVHQWDWLIVGHVYHVWLJHVGHODFRQ VWUXFWLRQ D[RXPLWH FODVVLTXH 7URLV PRQXPHQWV TXL QH VRQW SOXV YLVLEOHV DX MRXUG¶KXLTXHSDUGHVUHVWHVpSDUVGHPDoRQQHULHRQWUHoXGHVDSSHOODWLRQVTXL QHUHPRQWHQWSDVjO¶$QWLTXLWp2QOHVFRQQDvWVRXVOHVQRPVGH(QGD6HPRQ ODSODFHGH6HPRQ(QGD0LNDHOODSODFHGH0LNDHOHW7DDNKD0DU\DPOH SDODLVGH0DULH6LVHORQODSOXVKDXWHGHVSUREDELOLWpVLOVVRQWjFRQVLGpUHU FRPPH GHV UpVLGHQFHV UR\DOHV LO HVW LPSRVVLEOH GHOHV DWWULEXHU j O¶XQ TXHO FRQTXH GHV DQFLHQV URLV GRQW RQ VDLW OHV QRPV SDU GHV WpPRLJQDJHV KLVWRUL TXHVGHVLQVFULSWLRQVHWSRXUODSOXSDUWG¶HQWUHHX[SDUOHVPRQQDLHVTX¶LOV RQWpPLVHV,OQ¶HVWSDVFKLPpULTXHGHSHQVHUTXHGHVUHFKHUFKHVIXWXUHVHQ WUHSULVHVDX[SDUDJHVGHFHVJUDQGHVGHPHXUHVDPqQHQWODGpFRXYHUWHG¶DX WUHV©SDODLVª '¶DXWUHVUpVLGHQFHVQREOHVIXUHQWpGLILpHVGRQWLOUHVWHoDHWOjGHVUXLQHV LPSRUWDQWHVQRWDPPHQWj O¶RXHVWGHODORFDOLWpGDQVOH VHFWHXUGH$GGL.LO Wp$XOLHXGLW'RQJRXUXQGHFHVpGLILFHVpWDLWODUpVLGHQFHGHJHQVjLPDJL QHUG¶XQVWDWXWVRFLDOpOHYpILJ /HV©SDODLVª (QGD6HPRQ (QGD0LNDHO HW 7DDNKD0DU\DP RFFXSDLHQW XQH VLWXDWLRQ FHQWUDOHGDQVODFLWpDQWLTXH,OVQHVRQWVpSDUpVTXHSDUXQHIDLEOHGLVWDQFH /HXUVGLPHQVLRQVpWDEOLHVVXUODEDVHG¶pOpPHQWVGHVXEVWUXFWLRQVSUpVHUYpV &HVSDJHVQHV¶RFFXSDQWTXHGHODFRQVWUXFWLRQGRPHVWLTXHLOQHVHUDSDVWUDLWpG¶DUFKLWHFWXUH IXQpUDLUH(OOHUHYrWXQFDUDFWqUHGHSDUWLFXOLqUHLPSRUWDQFHj$[RXPHWj0DWDUD6XUWRXWj $[RXPFHVPRQXPHQWV TXH VRQW OH 1HIDV 0DZWFKD OH ©0DXVROpHª OD 7RPEH GH OD IDXVVH SRUWHOHVVWUXFWXUHVGHEULTXHVHWVXUODFROOLQHDXQRUGHVWGHODORFDOLWpOHVFDYHDX[GH.D OHEHW*HEUD0DVTDO6HUHSRUWHUj0XQUR+D\2QODLVVHDXVVLGHF{WpOHEDUUDJHGH 6DIUDj4RKD\WRTXLHVWXQHFRQVWUXFWLRQUHPDUTXDEOHGHODSpULRGHD[RXPLWH3DUSOXVLHXUV DVSHFWVLOUHOqYHGHODWHFKQLTXHD[RXPLWHGHFRQVWUXFWLRQ $LQVLDXOLHXGLW$EUDKD$WVEHKDGHVLQGLFHVPpULWHUDLHQWSHXWrWUHTXHOTXHDWWHQWLRQ 'DQVOHPrPHVHFWHXUHVWjPHQWLRQQHUOHVRXEDVVHPHQWG¶XQDXWUHpGLILFHD[RXPLWHTXH6DO YDWRUH3XJOLVLPLWDXMRXUHQ4XDGULODWqUHLUUpJXOLHUSXLVTXHVRQF{WpQRUGPHVXUH PHWVRQF{WpRXHVWP3XJOLVLSS 2EVHUYDWLRQVVXUODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH GDQVOHVROOHVRQWIDLWWHQLUSRXUGHV©SDODLVª/HXUVYHVWLJHVRQWpWpGpFULWV SDU XQH PLVVLRQ DOOHPDQGH TXL OHV D pWXGLpV DX GpEXW GX VLqFOH GHUQLHU OHV GHVVLQVTXLHQSURSRVHQWODUHFRQVWLWXWLRQRQWODUJHPHQWFRQWULEXpjOHXULOOXV WUDWLRQ,OVSHUPHWWHQWHQHIIHWGHVHIDLUHXQHLGpHGXSODQHWGHODVWUXFWXUH G¶XQpGLILFHD[RXPLWHTX¶LOV¶DJLVVHGHGHPHXUHVSULQFLqUHVRXGHUpVLGHQFHV pGLILpHVSDUGHVKDELWDQWVIRUWXQpVWDQWLOHVWDSSDUHQWTXHFHVUpVLGHQFHVUH SURGXLVHQW DYHF GHV YDULDQWHV G¶RUGUH VHFRQGDLUHOHV WUDLWV GH O¶DUFKLWHFWXUH ©SDODWLDOHª /HVWURLV©SDODLVªRQWOHPrPHSODQDXVROTXDGULODWpUDO8QFRUSVGHOR JLVFHQWUDOHVWHQWRXUpGHGpSHQGDQFHVHQDOLJQHPHQWVXUOHVF{WpVH[WpULHXUV SDUGHOjGHVFRXUVLQWpULHXUHV (QGD6HPRQOHSOXVJUDQGVLO¶RQHQMXJHSDUOHVGLPHQVLRQVGHVRQEk WLPHQW FHQWUDO PHVXUDLW PqWUHV GH F{Wp OH EkWLPHQW FHQWUDO GH (QGD0L NDHOPqWUHVHWPqWUHVFHOXLGH7DDNKD0DU\DP 7DDNKD0DU\DP HVW OH SOXV VRXYHQW UHSURGXLW GH FHV©SDODLVª ELHQ TXH VHV GLPHQVLRQV VRLHQW LQIpULHXUHV j FHOOHV GHV GHX[ DXWUHV FHOD WLHQW DX IDLW TX¶pWDQWPRLQVFHQWUDODXGpEXWGXYLQJWLqPHVLqFOHO¶KDELWDWpWDLWSHXGHQVH jODSpULSKpULHGHODORFDOLWpFHTXLSHUPLWjODPLVVLRQDOOHPDQGHG¶H[DPLQHU SOXVFRPSOqWHPHQWTXHSRXUOHVDXWUHVOHVPXUVGHO¶HQVHPEOHVHVJUDQGVF{ WpVSXUHQWrWUHPHVXUpVIRUPDQWUHFWDQJOHO¶HQVHPEOHDYDLWGHVF{WpVGH PqWUHVSDUPqWUHV3RXUOHVGHX[DXWUHVpGLILFHVTXLQHSXUHQWrWUHpWXGLpV TXHSDUWLHOOHPHQWRQLJQRUHODORQJXHXUGHOHXUVF{WpVH[WpULHXUV /HEkWLPHQWFHQWUDOGRQWVXEVLVWDLWOHKDXWVRXEDVVHPHQWjJUDGLQVFRP SRUWDLW XQ ODUJH SHUURQ H[WpULHXU 8QH DOWHUQDQFH GH SDUWLHV VDLOODQWHV HW GH SDUWLHV UHQWUDQWHV U\WKPDLW OH WUDFp DX VRO GHV IDoDGHV GX EkWLPHQW FHQWUDO FRPPHFHOXLGHVJUDQGVF{WpV/¶HQVHPEOHFRUSVFHQWUDOHWGpSHQGDQFHVp WDLWFRQVWUXLWVXUXQVRXEDVVHPHQWjJUDGLQVFHOXLGXFRUSVGHORJLVFHQWUDOp WDQWVHQVLEOHPHQWSOXVKDXW /DPDoRQQHULHGHSLHUUHVJUDQLWHWEDVDOWHpWDLWOLDLVRQQpHSDUXQPRU WLHUGHWHUUH 'RQJRXUXQHJUDQGHUpVLGHQFH 8QpGLILFHGpFRXYHUWGDQVOHVDQQpHVVRL[DQWHDXOLHXGLW'RQJRXUjHQ YLURQFLQTFHQWVPqWUHVjO¶RXHVWGHODORFDOLWpDFWXHOOHSRVVqGHGHVFDUDFWqUHV DQDORJXHVjFHX[GHVWURLV ©SDODLVªILJ'DQVVHVJUDQGHVGLPHQVLRQVLO .UHQFKNHU )UDQFLV$QIUD\ IRUPH XQ TXDGULODWqUH LUUpJXOLHU DX[ JUDQGV F{WpV GH ORQJXHXUV GLIIpUHQWHV QRUGPRXHVWPVXGPHVWPDYHFGHVGLVFRQWL QXLWpVGDQVO¶DOLJQHPHQW/¶HQVHPEOHSUpVHQWHO¶DVSHFWG¶XQFDUUpDSSUR[LPD WLI /HEkWLPHQWFHQWUDOIRUPHXQFDUUpSUHVTXHUpJXOLHUVHVPXUVRQWXQH ORQJXHXUPR\HQQHGHPjODEDVH8QHTXDUDQWDLQHGHSLqFHVRUGRQ QpHVHQTXDWUHvORWVSHXV\PpWULTXHVVRQWJURXSpHVDXWRXUGXEkWLPHQWFHQWUDO HQWRXUpGHFRXUHWWHV&HPrPHEkWLPHQWFRPSUHQDLWQHXISLqFHVH[LJXsVGRQW QHVXEVLVWHQWTXHOHVRXEDVVHPHQWILJHWODSDUWLHLQIpULHXUHGHVPXUVGX UH]GHFKDXVVpH$O¶HVWXQHVFDOLHUPRQXPHQWDOjWULSOHYROpHGHVHSWPDU FKHV HVFDOLHU GHSUHVWLJH PDUTXH O¶HQWUpH SULQFLSDOH GXEkWLPHQW $ O¶LQVWDU GHV©SDODLVªFHEkWLPHQWFHQWUDOpWDLWpOHYpVXUXQKDXWVRXEDVVHPHQWjJUD GLQVFHX[FLGRQQDQWjVRQSURILOXQDVSHFWWUDSp]RwGDOILJ/DKDXWHXUGH FHVRXEDVVHPHQWPHVXUHP&LQTOLWVGHPRHOORQVOLDLVRQQpVG¶XQPRU WLHUGHWHUUHFRPSRVHQWFKDTXHJUDGLQKDXWGHjFHQWLPqWUHV&HVJUD GLQVVRQWDXQRPEUHGHTXDWUHDXQLYHDXLQIpULHXUOHSUHPLHUHVWSUqVGXVRO jODSDUWLHVXSpULHXUHXQOLWGHSLHUUHVSODWHVSHXpSDLVVHVpJDOLVHODVXUIDFH GHVJUDGLQVHWSURWqJHODPDoRQQHULHGHO¶LQILOWUDWLRQGHVHDX[SOXYLDOHV$X VRPPHWGHO¶HPEDVHPHQWFRXUWXQEDQGHDXGHEORFVUpJXOLqUHPHQWDSSDUHLOOpV HWGUHVVpV'HVFKDvQHVG¶HQFRLJQXUHUHQIRUFHQWOHVDQJOHV /HVSLqFHVGXUH]GHFKDXVVpHpWDLHQWSDYpHVGHGDOOHVLUUpJXOLqUHVKRU PLVOHYHVWLEXOHG¶HQWUpHSULQFLSDOHRXQFDUUHODJHpWDLWJpRPpWULTXHPHQWDU UDQJp'DQVGHX[SLqFHVGLDJRQDOHPHQWRSSRVpHVXQGLVSRVLWLIGHPDoRQQH ULH FRQVWLWXDLW YUDLVHPEODEOHPHQW OH VXSSRUW G¶XQ HVFDOLHU GH ERLV PHQDQW j O¶pWDJHVXSpULHXU 2XWUHOHJUDQGSHUURQGHO¶HVWOHVRXEDVVHPHQWHVWIODQTXpjO¶RXHVWHWDX VXGGHGHX[HVFDOLHUVjGRXEOHYROpHGHPDUFKHV$XF{WpQRUGODSDUWLHPp GLDQHDFFXVHXQUHWUDLWVHORQXQWUDFpRUGLQDLUHGDQVODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH R OHV IDoDGHV QH VRQW MDPDLV UHFWLOLJQHV /HV WURLV DXWUHV IDFHV FRPSRUWHQW DXVVLGHVUHWUDLWVPpGLDQVPRLQVDSSDUHQWVPDVTXpVSDUODSUpVHQFHGHVHVFD OLHUV&HWWHDOWHUQDQFHGHUHGHQWVHWGHUHQWUDQWVV¶REVHUYHFRPPHDX[ ©SD ODLVªVXUOHVF{WpVH[WpULHXUVGHO¶HQVHPEOHDYHFj'RQJRXUGHVLUUpJXODUL WpV SDU H[HPSOH HQ F{Wp VXG R O¶RQ YRLW VH VXFFpGHU XQH VpULH GH UHQWUDQWV TXLGHYDLHQWGRQQHUjODIDoDGHXQDVSHFWFRQFDYH&HWWHIDFHVXGjHPEDVH PHQWGHJUDGLQVSRXUYXHDXPLOLHXG¶XQGRXEOHHPPDUFKHPHQWG¶HQWUpHVH $QIUD\*RGHWQG 2EVHUYDWLRQVVXUODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH WHUPLQHjO¶DQJOHVXGHVWGHO¶pGLILFHSDUXQUHWUDLWGHVL[PqWUHVDYDQWODIDFH HVWFRPPHVLODSODQLILFDWLRQDYDLWpWpUpDOLVpHGHPDQLqUHKDVDUGHXVH 'DQVSOXVLHXUVVDOOHVGHVGpSHQGDQFHVGHVSLOHVURQGHVHQPDoRQQHULH JpQpUDOHPHQWSDUGHX[RXSDUTXDWUHHQWHUUpHVGDQVOHVROVHUYDLHQWGHEDVHj GHVSRWHDX[GLVSDUXVTXLVRXWHQDLHQWOHSODIRQGGHODSLqFHHQUH]GHFKDXV VpH 'DQV OH EkWLPHQW FHQWUDO GHV PXUV pSDLV DYDLHQW OD PrPH IRQFWLRQ TXH OHVSLOHVURQGHVDVVXUHUXQHDVVLVHIHUPHDX[SRWHDX[GHVRXWLHQGXSODQFKHU GHO¶pWDJHVXSpULHXURpWDLHQWOHVSLqFHVG¶KDELWDWLRQSURSUHPHQWGLWHVDORUV TXH FHOOHV GX UH]GHFKDXVVpH pWDLHQW SUREDEOHPHQW UpVHUYpHV HQ SDUWLH DX PRLQVjO¶HPPDJDVLQDJHGHGHQUpHV 7URLV IRXUV GH EULTXHV FXLWHV pWDLHQW PDoRQQpV GDQV OH VHFWHXU RXHVW GH O¶pGLILFH ,QVWDOODWLRQ XQLTXH j FH MRXU GDQV O¶DUFKpRORJLH G¶$[RXP 8QLTXH DXVVLGDQVXQHSLqFHGHVGpSHQGDQFHVXQDXWUHDPpQDJHPHQWGHEULTXHV(Q FDUUpDXWRXUG¶XQIR\HUFHQWUDOVXUXQVROSDYpGHEULTXHVGHVSLOHWWHVGHEUL TXHV OpFKpHV SDU OH IHX FRQVWLWXHQW GHV JDOHULHV V\PpWULTXHPHQW GLVSRVpHV 8QHFHQGUHpSDLVVHpWDLWDFFXPXOpHVXUOHSDYDJH$TXHOXVDJHUpSRQGDLWFHW WHLQVWDOODWLRQHQSDUWLHUXLQpH"2QSHQVHjXQK\SRFDXVWHPDLVLOHVWGLIILFLOH G¶rWUHUpVROXPHQWDIILUPDWLI 'HVFDYLWpVPpQDJpHVDX[DQJOHVH[WpULHXUVGXSHUURQSULQFLSDOODLVVHQW VXSSRVHUTX¶XQDXYHQWSRXYDLWDEULWHUO¶HQWUpH 6LODSLHUUHpWDLWOHPDWpULDXXWLOLVpSRXUO¶HQVHPEOHGHODFRQVWUXFWLRQOH ERLV\DYDLWXQHSODFHPDLVUHVWUHLQWHGHVFDYLWpVKRUL]RQWDOHVHQFHUWDLQVHQ GURLWVSHXQRPEUHX[GHVPXUVLQGLTXHQWTXHGHVSLqFHVGHERLV\DYDLHQWpWp LQVpUpHVGRQWOHU{OHpWDLWGHUHQIRUFHUODFRKpVLRQGHODPDoRQQHULHILJ GHVKXLVVHULHVGDQVODSDUWLHKDXWHGHO¶pGLILFHGpUDVpGHYDLHQWrWUHHQERLVHQ ERLV DXVVL OHV HVFDOLHUV LQWpULHXUV OHV SRWHDX[ GH VRXWLHQ OHV SODQFKHUV GH O¶pWDJHHWOHVODPERXUGHVTXLOHVVXSSRUWDLHQWOHXUVWrWHVDSSDUDLVVDLHQWVDQV GRXWHjO¶H[WpULHXUDXQLYHDXGHO¶pWDJHFRPPHOHPRQWUHQWOHVUHOLHIVVFXOS WpV GHV VWqOHV JpDQWHV &HW HPSORL GX ERLV pWDLW VRPPH WRXWH OLPLWp 4XHOOH SODFHDYDLWLOGDQVODVWUXFWXUHPrPHGHODPDoRQQHULH"5pSRQVHLQFHUWDLQH /H VRXEDVVHPHQW G¶XQ DXWUH EkWLPHQW D[RXPLWH VH UHPDUTXH DX VXGHVW GH 0D\+HGMD OH VHFWHXU GHV JUDQGHV VWqOHV ,O VHUW GH VRFOH j O¶pJOLVH 0D U\DP7V\RQ ILJ TXL HQ VRQ pWDW DFWXHO GDWH GX ;9,,H VLqFOH (OOH D pWp FRQVWUXLWHVXUOHVUXLQHVG¶XQDQFLHQEkWLPHQWGHODSpULRGHD[RXPLWH&HVRX EDVVHPHQW GRQW LO \ D OLHX GH SHQVHU TX¶LO IXW FHOXL G¶XQH JUDQGH EDVLOLTXH SUpFpGpH SHXWrWUH G¶XQ VDQFWXDLUH DQWpULHXU j OD FKULVWLDQLVDWLRQ Q¶HVW TXH WUqV SDUWLHOOHPHQW YLVLEOH ,O RIIUH XQ W\SH GH FRQVWUXFWLRQ VHPEODEOH j FHOXL GHV©SDODLVªHWGHO¶pGLILFHGH'RQJRXUPRQXPHQWPDVVLIjJUDGLQVUHGHQWV HWUHQWUDQWVHWDXVRPPHWGHVJUDGLQVXQEDQGHDXGHEORFVDSSDUHLOOpV )UDQFLV$QIUD\ (QG¶DXWUHVHQGURLWVGXWHUULWRLUHGHVpWDEOLVVHPHQWVDQWLTXHVRQO¶DGLW FRQVHUYHQWGHVUXLQHVG¶pGLILFHVFRPSDUDEOHVSDUEHDXFRXSG¶DVSHFWVDX[PR QXPHQWVG¶$[RXP 0DWDUD 6XU OH KDXW SODWHDX pU\WKUpHQ DX SLHG GH O¶$PED 6DwP TXL FXOPLQH j PqWUHVG¶DOWLWXGHV¶pWHQGXQHDJJORPpUDWLRQUXLQpHGHSXLVOH9,,HVLq FOH GRQW OHV RULJLQHV UHPRQWHQW j SOXV G¶XQ PLOOpQDLUH DYDQW QRWUH qUH j VH IRQGHUVXUODSRWHULHGXQLYHDXSURIRQGGXVLWH'DQVOHVDQQpHVVRL[DQWHOHV UHFKHUFKHV GH O¶,QVWLWXW pWKLRSLHQ G¶DUFKpRORJLH RQW PLV DX MRXU GDQV OH QL YHDXVXSpULHXUOHVUHVWHVGHTXDWUHUpVLGHQFHVGHGHX[pJOLVHVHWG¶XQTXDU WLHU G¶KDELWDWLRQV RUGLQDLUHV FRPSUHQDQW XQH WUHQWDLQH GH ORJLV HW SUREDEOH PHQWG¶pFKRSSHV /HVTXDWUHUpVLGHQFHVDXF°XUGHODYLOOHSUpVHQWHQWXQHJUDQGHXQLWpGH SODQHWGHVW\OHDUFKLWHFWXUDOEkWLPHQWFHQWUDOFDUUpVXUXQKDXWVRXEDVVHPHQW jJUDGLQVHVFDOLHUVH[WpULHXUVILJFRXUHWWHVRXSDVVDJHVHWDXWRXUOHVGp SHQGDQFHV DYHF OHXUV IDFHV HQ DOWHUQDQFHV GH UHGHQWV HW GH UHQWUDQWV 0rPH PDoRQQHULHGHPRHOORQVOLDLVRQQpVSDUXQPRUWLHUGHWHUUHTXLQHGLIIqUHTXH SDUODQDWXUHGXPDWpULDXFRUUHVSRQGDQWjFHOOHGHVURFKHVHQYLURQQDQWHVWUD FK\WHJUqVHWVFKLVWHSULQFLSDOHPHQW'DQVOHVFRPSDUWLPHQWVGHVVRXEDVVH PHQWV VH UHQFRQWUHQW OHV SLOHWWHV URQGHV GH PDoRQQHULH /HV FRUSV GH ORJLV FHQWUDX[ RIIUHQW OD PrPH GLVWULEXWLRQ GH QHXI SLqFHV DYHF VHV GLVSRVLWLIV GH PDoRQQHULHSRXUHVFDOLHUV $XWRXU GH FHV UpVLGHQFHV OHV KDELWDWLRQV RUGLQDLUHV MRLQWLYHV VRQW FDU UpHVRXUHFWDQJXODLUHVGHGLPHQVLRQVH[LJXsVGDQVOHVHFWHXU(HOOHVVRQW UpSDUWLHV GH SDUW HW G¶DXWUH G¶XQH UXHOOH pWURLWH 8Q PrPH ORJLV FRPSRUWDLW WDQW{WXQHWDQW{WGHX[SLqFHV5LHQTXLSHUPHWWHG¶LGHQWLILHUXQHFDJHG¶HVFD OLHU FHWWH DEVHQFH SHXW VLJQLILHU TX¶LO Q¶\ DYDLWSDV G¶pWDJH FRPPH GDQV OHV UpVLGHQFHV/DUpSDUWLWLRQGHFHVORJLVGDQVOHFDGUHGHO¶DJJORPpUDWLRQDSSD UDvWVDQVFRKpUHQFHODLVVpHDX[KDVDUGVG¶XQHFURLVVDQFHXUEDLQHDQDUFKLTXH 8QW\SHG¶KDELWDWLRQLQWHUPpGLDLUHHQWUHOHVJUDQGHVGHPHXUHVHWOHVKD ELWDWLRQV RUGLQDLUHV D pWp REVHUYp PrOp j FHV GHUQLqUHV ,O SRVVqGH FHUWDLQV WUDLWVGHVUpVLGHQFHVPDLVDYHFPRLQVG¶H[WHQVLRQ&¶HVWXQHKDELWDWLRQFDUUpH GRQWOHVIDFHVPRQWUHQWXQHLPLWDWLRQGHVRXEDVVHPHQWDYHFXQRXGHX[JUD GLQVHWXQUHQWUDQWHQWUHGHX[UHGHQWVQHXISLqFHVH[LJXsVjO¶LQWpULHXUGRQW $QIUD\SSSODQGXVLWHS 2EVHUYDWLRQVVXUODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH FHUWDLQHV SHXYHQW DYRLU GHV SLOHV GH PDoRQQHULH TXL ODLVVHQW VXSSRVHU O¶H[L VWHQFHG¶XQpWDJH &HV WURLV W\SHV GH FRQVWUXFWLRQ UHIOqWHQW XQHGLYHUVLWp HW VDQV GRXWH XQH KLpUDUFKLHGHVWUDWHVVRFLDOHV $O¶HVWGXVLWHRQWpWpGpFRXYHUWVOHVVRXEDVVHPHQWVGHGHX[pJOLVHVGRQW ODWHFKQLTXHGHFRQVWUXFWLRQHVWHQWRXVSRLQWVDQDORJXHjFHOOHGHVDXWUHVpGL ILFHV/¶XQHG¶HOOHVRIIUHXQSODQUpJXOLHUEkWLPHQWFHQWUDOODEDVLOLTXHPH VXUDQWTXLQ]HPqWUHVSDUGL[PqWUHVDYHFDXSRXUWRXUHQUHFWDQJOHSDUGHOj GHVFRXUVXQDOLJQHPHQWGHSLqFHVDQQH[HVPqWUHVSDUPqWUHVVRQWOHV JUDQGHVGLPHQVLRQV2QQRWHXQPDQTXHGHUpJXODULWpVXUWRXWGDQVOHSODQGX EkWLPHQW FHQWUDO R VH PDQLIHVWH XQH GLVV\PpWULH WRXFKDQW O¶RUGRQQDQFH GHV UHGHQWVHWUHQWUDQWV$FHWpJDUGO¶DXWUHpJOLVHEDVLOLTXHHOOHDXVVLP[ PRIIUHGDYDQWDJHGHFRQIRUPLWpDYHFOHVSURJUDPPHVFODVVLTXHV 4RKD\WR $ XQH WUHQWDLQH GH NLORPqWUHV DX QRUG GH 0DWDUD FH VLWH G¶XQH JUDQGH pWHQGXHFRQVHUYHSOXVLHXUVPRQXPHQWVGHO¶pSRTXHD[RXPLWHHVVHQWLHOOHPHQW GHVVXEVWUXFWLRQVGHUpVLGHQFHVHWVXUWRXWGHVDQFWXDLUHV/HVVRXEDVVHPHQWV G¶DQFLHQVpGLILFHVGRPLQHQWXQFKDPSGHUXLQHVRVHGpFqOHQWOHVUXLQHVGH GpSHQGDQFHVDXWRXUGHFHUWDLQVGHVEkWLPHQWVHWVXUXQYDVWHHVSDFHGHVYHV WLJHV GH PXUV TXL VRQW j Q¶HQ SDV GRXWHU GHV UHVWHV G¶KDELWDWLRQV pERXOpHV 8QHSDUWLFXODULWpGLVWLQJXHFHSHQGDQWFHVLWHGHVSLOLHUVGHSLHUUHjDQJOHVD EDWWXVDYHFSDUIRLVOHXUFKDSLWHDXG¶XQVHXOWHQDQWVHGUHVVHQWHQFRUHDXFHQ WUHGHVUXLQHVGHFHUWDLQVpGLILFHVILJ4XHOTXHVXQHVGHFHVFRQVWUXFWLRQV jSLOLHUVSRXYDLHQWrWUHGHVVDQFWXDLUHVG¶DYDQWODFKULVWLDQLVDWLRQGXSD\VDX TXDWULqPHRXFLQTXLqPHVLqFOH&HW\SHGHSLOLHUIXWXWLOLVpDLOOHXUVLOHQHVWj $[RXPGDQVOHMDUGLQSXEOLFHWSUqVGH0DU\DP7V\RQILJLOV¶HQUHQ FRQWUHDXVVLHUUDWLTXHVj(WFK0DUp=RTROOR7RNRQGD+DPHW$GRXOLV $GRXOLV $X GpEXW GX YLQJWLqPH VLqFOH 5LFKDUG 6XQGVWU|P HW 5REHUWR 3DULEHQL GpFRXYULUHQW GDQV FH VLWH OHV UXLQHV G¶pGLILFHV GRQW O¶DUFKLWHFWXUH UHOqYH GX $SURSRVG¶pGLILFHVFXOWXHOVGHSpULRGHD[RXPLWHWDUGLYHVHUDLWHQFRUHjPHQWLRQQHUO¶pJOLVH GH(QGD7FKHUTRVSUqVG¶$[RXP&IGH&RQWHQVRQSS 4RKD\WR3RXUO¶RUWKRJUDSKHGHFHQRPYRLU5LFFLSS )UDQFLV$QIUD\ VW\OHD[RXPLWH$XFRPPHQFHPHQWGHVDQQpHVVRL[DQWHG¶DXWUHVFRQVWUXF WLRQVDXOLHXGLW%HW.KDOLIDIXUHQWpWXGLpHVSDUO¶,QVWLWXWpWKLRSLHQG¶DUFKpROR JLH /HVXpGRLV56XQGVWU|PGpJDJHDOHVYHVWLJHVG¶XQJUDQGpGLILFHUHFWDQ JXODLUHPqWUHV[PTXHOHIRXLOOHXUDSSHOD©SDODFHªPDLVTXLDpWp UHFRQQXFRPPHXQHEDVLOLTXHGHX[JDOHULHVGHFRORQQHVHQFRQVWLWXDLHQWOHV QHIV3DUWLFXODULWpQRWDEOHXQHQGXLWUHFRXYUDLWHQFRUHOHPXUH[WpULHXUVXGGX EkWLPHQW$'RQJRXUXQHQGXLWIDLWG¶XQHVRUWHGHSOkWUHEODQFUHYrWDLWDXVVL XQHSRUWLRQGHPXU$FRQVLGpUHUVHVGLPHQVLRQVFHEkWLPHQWG¶$GRXOLVHVWOH SOXV JUDQG GH FHX[ TXL RQW pWp H[KXPpV j FH MRXU GDQV O¶DQFLHQ SD\V D[RX PLWHpWDQWUpVHUYpOHFDVGHO¶DQWLTXHEDVLOLTXHG¶$[RXPGRQWOHVGLPHQVLRQV SUpFLVHVQHVRQWSDVFRQQXHVFDUVHVYHVWLJHVVRQWDXGHVVRXVGHO¶DFWXHOOHp JOLVH0DU\DP7V\RQ (Q G¶DXWUHV VHFWHXUV G¶$GRXOLV OHV ,WDOLHQV GLULJpV SDU 5 3DULEHQL Gp FRXYULUHQW G¶DXWUHV YHVWLJHV LPSRUWDQWV GH OD SpULRGH D[RXPLWH pGLILFHV UHF WDQJXODLUHVGHVW\OHQHWWHPHQWD[RXPLWHHWJURXSHVG¶KDELWDWLRQVjSODFHUGDQV ODFDWpJRULHGHVORJLVRUGLQDLUHVHWVDQVGRXWHDXVVLSDUPLHOOHVGHVpFKRS SHV 3DUWLFXOLqUHPHQWW\SLTXHGHVEkWLPHQWVGXVLWHGXSRLQWGHYXHDUFKLWHF WXUDOHVWFHOXLTXH3DULEHQLDEDSWLVp©$UDGHO6ROHª$VLPSOHPHQWUHJDUGHU OHVSKRWRJUDSKLHVGXPRQXPHQWGDQVO¶RXYUDJH5LFHUFKHQHOOXRJRGHOO¶$Q WLFD $GXOLVRQ VH UHQG FRPSWH TX¶LO V¶DJLW G¶XQ VRXEDVVHPHQW j JUDGLQV GX VW\OH D[RXPLWH OH SOXV FODVVLTXH /H SODQ HVW UHFWDQJXODLUH DYHF HQ F{Wp HVW XQUHQWUDQWHQWUHGHX[UHGHQWVHWVXUOHVORQJVF{WpVUHGHQWVHWUHQWUDQWVDOWHU QpV &RPPH GDQV WRXWHV OHV FRQVWUXFWLRQV VLPLODLUHV DX VRPPHW GH FKDFXQ GHV JUDGLQV FRXUW XQ OLW GH SODTXHWWHV LFL SOXV pSDLVVHV TX¶j 0DWDUD SRXU pJDOLVHUODVXUIDFH2QREVHUYHTXHGDQVFHPRQXPHQWLOQ¶\DSDVFHVFKDvQHV G¶DQJOH QL FH ODUJH EDQGHDX GH EORFV TXL VH YRLHQWj 'RQJRXU j 0DU\DP 7V\RQHWSRXUOHVFKDvQHVG¶DQJOHj0DWDUD$ILJHW&HQUHYDQFKHLO HVWHQFHODFRPSDUDEOHDXPRQXPHQW%GHFHGHUQLHUVLWHDLQVLTX¶jFHOXLGp FRXYHUWSDU63XJOLVLj$[RXPILJ 5 3DULEHQL PLW DX MRXU OHV YHVWLJHV GH GHX[ EDVLOLTXHV GRQW O¶XQH pWDLW EkWLHVXUOHVRXEDVVHPHQWGH©O¶$UDGHO6ROHªHOOHFRPSRUWDLWGHVSLOLHUVTXL RXWUHOHSUREDEOHVXSSRUWG¶XQHWHUUDVVHDYDLHQWVHUYLjODGLYLVLRQWULSDUWLWH GHO¶pJOLVHO¶DXWUHj O¶HVWGHODYLOOH&HWWHGHUQLqUHSRVVpGDLWHQVRQFHQWUH 6XQGVWU|PSS 3DULEHQLWDYY9,,,HW,;GHVFULSWLRQS 2EVHUYDWLRQVVXUODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH XQ DPpQDJHPHQW GH SLOLHUV GLVSRVpV HQ FHUFOH /¶XQH HW O¶DXWUH DYDLHQW pWp FRQVWUXLWHVVHORQOHPRGqOHFODVVLTXHVLO¶RQV¶HQUDSSRUWHjOHXUVFDUDFWpULV WLTXHVSULQFLSDOHVHWDX[WHFKQLTXHVGHFRQVWUXFWLRQDORUVHQXVDJH %HW.KDOLID (QHWOHVIRXLOOHVHIIHFWXpHVSDUO¶,QVWLWXWpWKLRSLHQG¶DUFKpR ORJLHGDQVODFRXFKHVXSpULHXUHGHFHOLHXGLWDPHQqUHQWODGpFRXYHUWHGHVXEV WUXFWLRQVG¶pGLILFHVTXLVHORQO¶DSSDUHQFHSXUHQWDYRLUpWpGHVKDELWDWLRQVRU GLQDLUHVHWSRXUFHUWDLQHVSLqFHVGHVpFKRSSHVRXGHVPDJDVLQV'DQVO¶DQ JOH VXGHVW GX VHFWHXU pWXGLp XQH GHV FRQVWUXFWLRQV SDUWLHOOHPHQW IRXLOOpH SUpVHQWH XQ SODQ HW GHV WUDLWV TXL pYRTXHQW FHV KDELWDWLRQV GH W\SH LQWHUPp GLDLUH REVHUYpHV j 0DWDUD ( HW ( VRXEDVVHPHQWGH IDLEOH KDXWHXU DYHF GHX[ RX WURLV JUDGLQV DOWHUQDQFH GH UHGHQWV HW UHQWUDQWV F{Wp RXHVW XQ UHQ WUDQW TX¶HQFDGUHQW GHX[ UHGHQWV SLOHV GH PDoRQQHULH GDQV GHV SLqFHV LQWp ULHXUHVXQHFRXUHWWHDXQRUGXQHVSDFHPHQWjO¶RXHVW/HVREMHWVUHFXHLOOLV YDVHVHQWHUUHFXLWHXQIR\HUGHFXLVLQHQRPEUHXVHVPRQQDLHVLQGLTXHQWTXH ODEkWLVVHGHYDLWrWUHjXVDJHGRPHVWLTXH2QSHXWFRQVWDWHUDXVVLTXHODFRQV WUXFWLRQ Q¶HVW SDV VDQV DQDORJLH DYHF OHV YHVWLJHVTXH 5 3DULEHQL GpFRXYULW VXUODULYHGX+DGGDV /DPDoRQQHULHGHPRHOORQVHWPRUWLHUGHWHUUHQHVHGLIIpUHQFLHHQULHQ GHODPDQLqUHWUDGLWLRQQHOOHVXUOHKDXWSODWHDX &HWWHUHYXHG¶HQVHPEOHGHVPRQXPHQWVPDMHXUVGHO¶DUFKLWHFWXUHFODVVL TXHG¶$[RXPSHUPHWGHIDLUHDSSDUDvWUHTXHGDQVOHVFHQWUHVXUEDLQVGXUR \DXPHRQWpWpPLVHQ°XYUHSHQGDQWTXHOTXHVL[VLqFOHVXQSURJUDPPHHWGHV WHFKQLTXHVGHFRQVWUXFWLRQG¶XQHVXUSUHQDQWHVLPLOLWXGH,OSHXWVHPEOHUXWLOH GHUDVVHPEOHUOHVGLVSRVLWLRQVHVVHQWLHOOHVGHFHWDUWGHEkWLUD[RXPLWH &DUDFWpULVWLTXHVSULQFLSDOHVGHODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH XQEkWLPHQWFHQWUDOpOHYpVXUXQKDXWVRXEDVVHPHQWHVWHQWRXUpSDU GHOjGHVFRXUVGHVHVGpSHQGDQFHVDOLJQpHVDXSRXUWRXU $QIUD\ 3DULEHQLSSILJSDUWLHQRUGGXSODQ 'HSXLV'DLQHOOL0DULQHOOLSS.HQFNHU&RQWL5RVVLQLSS ODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWHDIDLWO¶REMHWGHSOXVLHXUVpWXGHV3DUPLOHVSOXVUpFHQWHVGHX[ VRQWjFLWHULFLGH0XQUR+D\SSHW0DQ]R )UDQFLV$QIUD\ OHSODQGHO¶HQVHPEOHDUFKLWHFWXUDODSSHOpLFLO¶pGLILFHHVWUHFWDQJX ODLUHRXFDUUp OHSODQDXVROGXEkWLPHQWFHQWUDOHVWJpQpUDOHPHQWFDUUp ODPDoRQQHULHHVWIDLWHGHPRHOORQVGpJURVVLVOLDLVRQQpVSDUXQPRU WLHUGHWHUUH OH VRXEDVVHPHQW GX EkWLPHQW FHQWUDO V¶pOqYH HQ JUDGLQV TXDWUH RX FLQTKDXWVGHTXDUDQWHFLQTjFLQTXDQWHFHQWLPqWUHVHWODUJHVHQKDXWGHFLQT RX VL[FHQWLPqWUHV HQ PR\HQQH OHXUSDUWLH VXSpULHXUH HVW FRQVWLWXpH G¶XQ OLW GH SODTXHWWHV SRXU QLYHOHU OHXU VXUIDFH HW SUpPXQLU OD PDoRQQHULH FRQWUH OHV LQILOWUDWLRQVGHVHDX[GHSOXLH FHV JUDGLQV GRQQHQW DX VRXEDVVHPHQW PDVVLI XQ DVSHFW WUDSp]RwGDO VRFOHGXEkWLPHQWLOOXLSURFXUHXQHDVVLVHIHUPH GDQVSOXVLHXUVFDVGHVEORFVGHSLHUUHSDUHPHQWpVFKDvQHVG¶DQJOH VRQWSODFpVGDQVODPDoRQQHULHDX[DQJOHVGXVRXEDVVHPHQWSRXUDVVXUHUOD FRKpVLRQHWODVWDELOLWpGHODVWUXFWXUH SDUIRLVj$[RXPQRWDPPHQWXQEDQGHDXGHJURVEORFVDX[SDUH PHQWVUpJXOLqUHPHQWGUHVVpVFRXUWDXWRXUGXVRXEDVVHPHQWHQVDSDUWLHVXSp ULHXUH XQGHX[RXWURLVHVFDOLHUVVRXYHQWGHVHSWPDUFKHVGRQQHQWDFFqV HQKDXWGXVRXEDVVHPHQWDXEkWLPHQWFHQWUDOLOVRQWXQHGHX[RXWURLVYR OpHVGHPDUFKHVODSODWHIRUPHGXSHUURQHVWGDOOpH UHGHQWV HW UHQWUDQWV DOWHUQDWLYHPHQW U\WKPHQW OHV IDFHV GX VRXEDV VHPHQW FHWWH DOWHUQDQFH pWDLW UHSURGXLWH VXU OHV IDFHV GX EkWLPHQW pULJp DX GHVVXV JpQpUDOHPHQWVXUFKDFXQHGHVIDFHVGXEkWLPHQWFHQWUDOHQVDSDUWLH PpGLDQHXQUHQWUDQWV¶HQFDGUHGHGHX[UHGHQWV LQWpULHXUHPHQWOHVRXEDVVHPHQWSRVVqGHXQHVWUXFWXUHDOYpRODLUHFRU UHVSRQGDQWjODUpSDUWLWLRQGHVSLqFHVGXUH]GHFKDXVVpHGHO¶LPPHXEOHGDQV OHV FRPSDUWLPHQWV DLQVL IRUPpV FRPEOpV GH WHUUH HW GH FDLOODVVH GHV SLOHV URQGHVGHPDoRQQHULHXQHGHX[WURLVRXTXDWUHVRQWHQWHUUpHVFHVSLOHVVXU OHVTXHOOHVHVWSODFpHXQHSLHUUHSODWHVRQWGHVWLQpHVjIRXUQLUXQHEDVHIHUPHj GHVSRWHDX[GHVRXWLHQHQERLVJpQpUDOHPHQW QHXISLqFHVWURLVSDUWURLVVHSDUWDJHQWOHUH]GHFKDXVVpHHOOHVVRQW GDOOpHVSRXUODSOXSDUWRQOHFRQVWDWHTXDQGOHGDOODJHQ¶DSDVGLVSDUXGDQV XQH RX GHX[ GH FHV SLqFHV XQ GLVSRVLWLI GH PDoRQQHULH VXJJqUH O¶H[LVWHQFH 3XJOLVLSODQGHO¶pGLILFHQUILJS 2EVHUYDWLRQVVXUODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH G¶XQHVFDOLHUGHERLVSRXUFRQGXLUHjO¶pWDJHGHVSRWHDX[GHERLVpWDLHQWLQV WDOOpVGDQVFHVSLqFHV GHV FRXUHWWHV RX GHV HVSDFHPHQWV SOXV RX PRLQV ODUJHV VpSDUHQW OH EkWLPHQWFHQWUDOGHVGpSHQGDQFHV FHUWDLQHVSLqFHVGHFHVGpSHQGDQFHVFRPSRUWHQWHQWHUUpHVGHVSLOHV URQGHVGHPDoRQQHULHSRXUSRWHDX[GHVXSSRUW VRXYHQW DX EDV GHV PXUV LQWpULHXUV GHV SLqFHV FRXUW XQ UHVVDXW GH SLHUUHVJUDGLQLOHVWjODKDXWHXUGHODGDOOHTXDQGHOOHHVWHQFRUHHQSODFH TXLUHSRVHVXUOHVSLOHVGHPDoRQQHULHLOLQGLTXHDLQVLOHQLYHDXGXVROKDELWp H[WpULHXUHPHQWOHVPXUVGHVGpSHQGDQFHVHQFORVHQWVXUOHXUVTXDWUH F{WpVO¶HQVHPEOHGHO¶pGLILFHODSDUWLHLQIpULHXUHGHFHVPXUVSUpVHQWHXQHP EDVHPHQWjJUDGLQVTXLUHSURGXLWHQPRLQVpOHYpOHSURILOGXEkWLPHQWFHQ WUDO HW O¶DOWHUQDQFH GHV UHGHQWV HW UHQWUDQWV U\WKPH OHV IDFHV H[WpULHXUHV GH O¶pGLILFH VRXYHQW GHV JRXWWLqUHV G¶pYDFXDWLRQ GHV HDX[ HQ SURYHQDQFH GHV FRXUHWWHVWUDYHUVHQWOHVPXUVGHVRXEDVVHPHQW VXU OHV IDoDGHV H[WpULHXUHV HVFDOLHUV RX UDPSHV G¶DFFqV PDUTXDLHQW OHVHQWUpHVGHO¶pGLILFH VLOHVPXUVpWDLHQWUHYrWXVG¶XQHQGXLWULHQSRXUOHPRPHQWQHSHU PHWGHO¶DIILUPHUFHUWDLQHVSRUWLRQVGHPXUVj'RQJRXUHWj$GRXOLVDYDLHQW pWpUHFRXYHUWHVG¶XQHQGXLWVXUXQHIDLEOHpWHQGXH DXFXQHVXSHUVWUXFWXUHG¶pGLILFHD[RXPLWHQ¶D\DQWpWpFRQVHUYpHLOHVW PDODLVpGHVHSURQRQFHUVXUODIRUPHGHVWRLWVLO\DWRXWOLHXFHSHQGDQWGH VXSSRVHUTX¶LOVpWDLHQWSODWVHQWHUUDVVHODWUDGLWLRQIDYRULVHFHWWHK\SRWKqVH VHUHSRUWHUjO¶pJOLVHGH'HEUD'DPRHWjG¶DXWUHVpJOLVHVDQFLHQQHVGXQRUG GHO¶(WKLRSLHDLQVLTX¶DX[PDLVRQVWUDGLWLRQQHOOHV OD FRQVWUXFWLRQ D[RXPLWH GDQV VRQ JURV °XYUH HVWXQ OLPRXVLQDJH VRQPDWpULDXSULQFLSDOHVWODSLHUUH3RXUOHGLUHHQSDVVDQWRQQHFRQQDvWULHQ GHVKDELWDWLRQVUXUDOHVWUDKLHVSDUOHXUVPDWpULDX[ /HERLVDYDLWSODFHGDQVODFRQVWUXFWLRQ'HVSLqFHVKRUL]RQWDOHVpWDLHQW HQFDVWUpHV GDQV OD PDoRQQHULH QRWDPPHQW DX[ DQJOHV SRXU OD VWDELOLWp GHV PXUVOHVHVFDOLHUVLQWpULHXUVGHYDLHQWrWUHHQERLVFRPPHO¶pWDLHQWDXVVLOHV SODQFKHUVOHVSRWHDX[GHVXSSRUWOHVVROLYHVGHVSODIRQGVGRQWOHVH[WUpPLWpV DSSDUDLVVDLHQWHQOLJQHVKRUL]RQWDOHVjO¶H[WpULHXUGHVPXUVWHOOHVTXHUHSUR GXLWHVGDQVODSLHUUHGHVVWqOHVJpDQWHVHWFRPPHOHVFKkVVLVGHVSRUWHVGRQW 0XQUR+D\SVLJQDOHj$[RXPO¶HPSORLG¶XQ PRUWLHUGHFKDX[©LQEULFNFRQV WUXFWLRQEXWLWLVUDWKHUUDUHª&I3DULEHQLFRO )UDQFLV$QIUD\ OHVpJOLVHVRQWFRQVHUYpODWUDGLWLRQMXVTX¶jQRVMRXUV&HVFKkVVLVGHSRUWHVHW GHIHQrWUHVVRQWILJXUpVVXUOHVVWqOHVPDLVRQOHVYRLWDXVVLGDQVOH©0DXVR OpHªGH0D\+HGMDHWOHVFDYHDX[GH.DOHEFHTXLDWWHVWHXQHFRXWXPHGpMj REVHUYpHDX,,,HVLqFOHGHQRWUHqUH /D EULTXH pWDLW XQ PDWpULDX G¶XVDJH GDQV OD FRQVWUXFWLRQ D[RXPLWH QRQ SDVSRXUO¶pGLILFDWLRQGHVPXUVPDLVFRPPHpOpPHQWVGHVWUXFWXUHVSDUWLFX OLqUHV DUF VXU O¶HQWUpH GH WRPEHDX[ j $[RXP 0D\+HGMD IRXUV HW ©K\SR FDXVWHVª j 'RQJRXU GDQV OHV UXLQHV GHV pJOLVHV GH %LHWD*L\RUJLV2Q OD WURXYHj0DWDUDHPSOR\pHGDQVXQEORFPDVVLIGHVLJQLILFDWLRQLQFHUWDLQHj $GRXOLV GDQV OH VHFWHXU GH %HW.KDOLID SRXU VXUpOHYHU XQ VHXLO GH SLqFH 5 3DULEHQL HQ D FRQVWDWp O¶HPSORL DLOOHXUV GDQV OH VLWH'DQV OH QRUG GX SD\V D[RXPLWH j $UDWRX DX QRUGHVW GH .HUHQ $EHOH 3LYD IDLW pWDW GDQV VHV UH FKHUFKHV GH G¶ ©XQD JDOOHULD LQ PDWWRQL OXQJD TXDWWUR PHWUL H PH]]RHGDOWDSRFRSLXGLXQPHWURªHWG¶XQPXUHQEULTXHVGHIRUPHUHFWDQ JXODLUHRXFDUUpH©GLFP[[RGL[[ªFHTXLHVWjSHX SUqV OD GLPHQVLRQ GHV EULTXHV GH ©O¶K\SRFDXVWHª j 'RQJRXU/HV EULTXHV UHFWDQJXODLUHVGH$UDWRXPHVXUHQWFP[FP[FPFHTXLFRUUHVSRQGj OD GLPHQVLRQ GHV EULTXHV GHV IRXUV GH 'RQJRXU HW GH FHOOHV G¶$GRXOLV$X VXGj0DU\DP.HGLKGDQVXQVLWHG¶pSRTXHD[RXPLWHRQUHFXHLOOHpSDUVVXU OHVRODXPLOLHXGHWHVVRQVGHSRWHULHGHVIUDJPHQWVGHEULTXHVO¶XQHG¶HOOHV FRQVHUYpHHQVRQHQWLHUPHVXUH[[FP ,ODSSDUDvWGRQFTX¶HQWUHOHWURLVLqPHVLqFOHGHQRWUHqUHHWOHVHSWLqPH XQSDWURQDUFKLWHFWXUDODpWpV\VWpPDWLTXHPHQWVXLYLGDQVVHVpOpPHQWVSULQFL SDX[&HUWHVHQWRXVHQGURLWVGHVYDULDQWHVV¶REVHUYHQWPDLVHOOHVQHWRXFKHQW SDVOHSURJUDPPHJpQpUDOQLOHVWHFKQLTXHVGHFRQVWUXFWLRQ'HVLUUpJXODULWpV VHPDQLIHVWHQWGDQVOHWUDFpGHVSODQVDLQVLj'RQJRXUOHVFKDvQHVG¶DQJOH HW OHV EDQGHDX[ DSSDUHLOOpV DX VRPPHW GX VRXEDVVHPHQW TXL Q¶H[LVWHQW TXH GDQVTXHOTXHVPRQXPHQWV2QUHPDUTXHDXVVLGHVGLIIpUHQFHVGDQVO¶DSSDUHLO 5LFFL)DWWRYLFKSS%ULTXHVj2QD1DJDVW)DWWRYLFK%DUGS 'DQVODSDUWLHGXVLWHTXLDIDLWO¶REMHWGHIRXLOOHVDUFKpRORJLTXHVLOQ¶DpWpREVHUYpGHEULTXHV FXLWHVTX¶HQXQVHXOHQGURLWORFXVGXVHFWHXU(ROHEORFVHUYDLWVDQVGRXWHGHVXSSRUWj XQHLQVWDOODWLRQGHQDWXUHLQGpWHUPLQpH 3DULEHQLFRO IRXLOOHV GH 6XQGVWU|P YRLU .UHQFNHU YRQ /SNH =DKQ S 3LYDSS 0DQ]RS $QIUD\S 2EVHUYDWLRQVVXUODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH GHPDoRQQHULHTXLYDGH©O¶RSXVLQFHUWXPªGHODSOXSDUWGHVVRXEDVVHPHQWVj XQ DVVHPEODJH GH PRHOORQV UpJXOLqUHPHQW WDLOOpV GLVSRVpV HQ OLWV UpJXOLHUV FRPPHDXPRQXPHQW%GH0DWDUDRO¶RQSRXUUDLWSDUOHUG¶XQDSSDUHLOSUH VTXHLVRGRPH (GLILFHVOHXUpOpYDWLRQ /HV ©SDODLVª HW OHV UpVLGHQFHV QREOHVVROLGHPHQW pGLILpHV VXU XQ VRX EDVVHPHQWDXODUJHHPSDWWHPHQWpWDLHQWHQVXUpOpYDWLRQSDUUDSSRUWDX[KDEL WDWLRQVRUGLQDLUHV4XHOSRXYDLWrWUHOHQRPEUHGHOHXUVpWDJHV"/HVGHVVLQVGH .UHQFNHU GDQV O¶RXYUDJH GH OD PLVVLRQ DOOHPDQGH DWWULEXHQW DX ©SDODLVª GH (QGD6HPRQ GHX[ pWDJHV DXGHVVXV GX UH]GHFKDXVVpH LO HVW j QRWHU TXH OH GHVVLQDWHXUDFUXGHYRLUPXOWLSOLHUOHVPDUFKHVGXJUDQGHVFDOLHUSRXUOHSUR SRUWLRQQHUjODKDXWHXUDFFRUGpHDXEkWLPHQWTXDQGOHGpJDJHPHQWQ¶HQUpYp ODLWTXHVHSW$WLOpWpLQIOXHQFpSHXWrWUHLQFRQVFLHPPHQWSDUO¶LPDJHGHV VWqOHV JpDQWHV VXU OHVTXHOOHV RQ YRLW XQH VXSHUSRVLWLRQ GH QRPEUHX[ pWDJHV ILJXUDWLRQREpLVVDQWVDQVGRXWHjXQHYRORQWpG¶H[SULPHUXQV\PEROLVPHG¶RU GUHPpWDSK\VLTXHHWQRQGHUHSURGXLUHGDQVFHFDVSUpFLVXQHUpDOLWp"2QSHXW GRXWHU j SDUWLU GH O¶REVHUYDWLRQ DUFKpRORJLTXH TXH OHV UpVLGHQFHV QREOHV DLHQW HX SOXV G¶XQ pWDJH DXGHVVXV GX UH]GHFKDXVVpH /D PDoRQQHULH GHV PXUVHQVLPSOHOLPRXVLQDJHGHPRHOORQVHWOHXUpSDLVVHXUFHQWLPqWUHVHQ PR\HQQHpWDLHQWHOOHVHQPHVXUHG¶DVVXUHUODVWDELOLWpG¶XQEkWLPHQWGHSOX VLHXUVpWDJHV"/DFKRVHSDUDvWSHXSUREDEOH/DWUDGLWLRQDUFKLWHFWXUDOHSHUSp WXpHVRLWGDQVODFRQVWUXFWLRQGRPHVWLTXHVRLWGDQVOHVpJOLVHVPpGLpYDOHVQH SRVVqGHQXOWpPRLQGHFHWWHPXOWLSOLFLWpG¶pWDJHV'DQVO¶$QWLTXLWpD[RXPLWH SRXUOHVJUDQGHVUpVLGHQFHVXQpWDJHDXGHVVXVGXUH]GHFKDXVVpHpWDLWWUqV SUREDEOHPHQWODIRUPXOHUHWHQXH /HVKDELWDWLRQVRUGLQDLUHVVDQVpWDJHVXSpULHXUpWDLHQWJURXSpHVDXWRXU GHV UpVLGHQFHV QREOHV HW GHV pJOLVHV &HV PDLVRQV EDVVHV MRLQWLYHV DYDLHQW SODFHGDQVO¶DJJORPpUDWLRQVDQVTX¶XQHRUGRQQDQFHTXHOFRQTXHSUpVLGHjOHXU UpSDUWLWLRQ &RPPH LO D pWp REVHUYp j 0DWDUD ( HW VHPEOHWLO j $GRXOLV SDU 5 3DULEHQL GHV UXHOOHV SHUPHWWDLHQW OH SDVVDJH HQWUH OHV KDELWDWLRQV /HPRW©QREOHªHVWjSUHQGUHDXVHQVSUHPLHUGXGLFWLRQQDLUHTXLVHGLVWLQJXHSDUFHUWDLQVFD UDFWqUHV GH VXSpULRULWp TXL HVW DXGHVVXV GX FRPPXQ ©,O QRELOH HGLILFLRª pFULYDLW 5 3D ULEHQLFROjSURSRVGXPRQXPHQW©$UDGHO6ROHª/RJLVGHPDvWUHVHUDLWLOXQPRW PLHX[DGDSWp" 3DULEHQLWDY;©8QDYLDGHOO¶DQWLFD$GRXOLVª )UDQFLV$QIUD\ '¶DXWUHSDUWHQQXOVLWHDUFKpRORJLTXHLOQ¶DpWpGpFRXYHUWTX¶XQUHPSDUWHQ IHUPDLW OHV JURV ERXUJV LO HVW SUREDEOH TXH OHV PXUV H[WpULHXUV GHV PDLVRQV SpULSKpULTXHVHQWHQDLHQWOLHXVLO¶RQSHXWGLUH &KURQRORJLH 'DWHUFHVPRQXPHQWVG¶DUFKLWHFWXUHIDLWDVVH]VRXYHQWSUREOqPH$SOX VLHXUVG¶HQWUHHX[LOHVWDWWULEXpXQHGDWHFRUUHVSRQGDQWjODGHUQLqUHSKDVHGH OD SpULRGH D[RXPLWH ± HQ JURV OHV FLQTXLqPH VL[LqPH HW VHSWLqPH VLqFOHV &HWWH GDWDWLRQ SUHQG DSSXL SULQFLSDOHPHQW VXU O¶H[DPHQ DUFKpRORJLTXH GHV VLWHVTXHIDYRULVHO¶pWXGHGHODSRWHULHHWGHVILJXUHVTXLO¶RUQHPHQWHQW /DVLPLOLWXGHGHOHXUIRUPHDUFKLWHFWXUDOHV¶DJLVVDQWGHVVRXEDVVHPHQWV SRXUUDLWG¶HPEOpHFRQGXLUHjSHQVHUTX¶LOVGDWHQWWRXVGHODPrPHpSRTXH6L ODSOXSDUWDSSDUWLHQQHQWDX[GHUQLHUVVLqFOHVGHO¶qUHD[RXPLWHLOHVWKRUVGH GRXWHTXHGHVUpVLGHQFHVHWGHVpGLILFHVFXOWXHOVYRLUHGHV©SDODLVªRQWXQH SOXV JUDQGH DQFLHQQHWp2QD WRXW OLHX GH FRQVLGpUHU TXH OD VLPLOLWXGH DSSD UHQWHGHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVPDMHXUHVUpVXOWHG¶XQHSHUPDQHQFHGHFRXWXPHTXLVH FRQVWDWHHQG¶DXWUHVGRPDLQHVGHODFXOWXUHPDWpULHOOHGHV$[RXPLWHV'¶DXWUH SDUWLOVHPEOHTXHOHUR\DXPHQ¶DLWSDVFRQQXGHFHVFRQIOLWVGHVWUXFWHXUVTXL LPSULPHQWGDQVOHVROGHVFLWpVUDYDJpHVFHVPDUTXHVGHUXSWXUHTXLDLGHQWOHV DUFKpRORJXHVjSpULRGLVHUOHSDVVp4XHOHVDJJORPpUDWLRQVD[RXPLWHVQ¶DLHQW SDVpWpFHLQWHVGHUHPSDUWVSDUDvWG¶DLOOHXUVFRUURERUHUO¶K\SRWKqVH &HQ¶HVWSDVjGLUHSRXUDXWDQWTXHGHVPRGLILFDWLRQVQHVHVRQWSDVSUR GXLWHV DX FRXUV GHV VLqFOHV /D SRWHULH SDU H[HPSOH GDQV VHV IRUPHV HW VHV GpFRUVRIIUHELHQGHVGLVVHPEODQFHV/¶H[DPHQGHVVWUXFWXUHVDUFKpRORJLTXHV FRQMXJXpjO¶DQDO\VHGHVHQVHPEOHVGHFpUDPLTXHSHUPHWGHIDYRULVHUXQHGD WDWLRQKDXWHGHFHUWDLQVPRQXPHQWV&¶HVWDLQVLTX¶LO\DOLHXGHVLWXHUDX,,,H ,9HVLqFOHOHPRQXPHQW$GH0DWDUDDXTXHODVVRFLHUpYHQWXHOOHPHQWOHPR QXPHQW&HWjODPrPHpSRTXHOHPRQXPHQW©$UDGHO6ROHªG¶$GRXOLV FRQIRUPpPHQWG¶DLOOHXUVjO¶HVWLPDWLRQGH53DULEHQL $QIUD\SHWSILJFHW\SHGHYDVHFDUpQpHVWW\SLTXHG¶XQHSRWHULHTXLVH UHWURXYHDLOOHXUVGDQVOHVLWH,OHVWJpQpUDOHPHQWGHWHUUHFXLWHQRLUH&HUWDLQVVRQWPDUTXpV G¶XQHLQVFULSWLRQGDQVXQHIRUPHG¶pFULWXUHTXHOHVpSLJUDSKLVWHVGDWHQWGX,,,HVLqFOH&HYDVH GXVLWH$GH0DWDUDV¶DVVRFLHQRWDPPHQWDXQLYHDXDQFLHQGHODSpULRGHD[RXPLWH&I%HU QDQG'UHZHV6FKQHLGHU,SQUHWSQU,,SODQFKHVHW /HYDVHQUSGX7,DpWpLQGLTXpGDQVOH5HFXHLOFRPPHpWDQWGHSRWHULHURXJH HQUpDOLWpLOHVWGHSRWHULHQRLUHFRPPHPDUTXpGDQV$QIUD\SQUHWSODQ FKH&;D 2EVHUYDWLRQVVXUODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH /HV pJOLVHV G¶$[RXP %LHWD*L\RUJLV GH 0DWDUD HW G¶$GRXOLV RQW pWp GDWpHVGHVVL[LqPHHWVHSWLqPHVLqFOHV/HFRQWH[WHDUFKpRORJLTXHLQGLTXHFHW WHpSRTXHDLQVLTXHOHVFLUFRQVWDQFHVKLVWRULTXHVRQVDLWTXHF¶HVWVXUWRXWHQ FHWHPSVOjTXHODUHOLJLRQFKUpWLHQQHVHSURSDJHDGDQVODFRQWUpH&HVpJOLVHV GXUqUHQW ORQJWHPSV /¶REVHUYDWLRQ GH OHXUV YHVWLJHV PRQWUH TX¶HOOHV IXUHQW O¶REMHWGHUHPDQLHPHQWVHWGHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVSDUWLHOOHVDXJUpGHVQpFHVVLWpV j0DWDUD)XQHVXSHUSRVLWLRQGHGDOODJHVWUDKLWOHSDVVDJHGXWHPSV5LHQ Q¶HPSrFKHTXHOHXUGDWHGHIRQGDWLRQSXLVVHUHPRQWHUDXFLQTXLqPHVLqFOH /HVRULJLQHVGHODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH /D SpUHQQLWp GH WUDGLWLRQV TX¶RQ REVHUYH DX ORQJ GH O¶qUH D[RXPLWH QH FRQVWLWXHSDVXQSKpQRPqQHSDUWLFXOLHUjFHWWHpSRTXHFHUWDLQHVOXLVRQWPr PH YHQXHV GHV VLqFOHV DQWpULHXUV $YDQW O¶DGRSWLRQGH OD UHOLJLRQ FKUpWLHQQH DX,9HVLqFOHXQHGLYLQLWpDQFLHQQH$VWDUGHPHXUHSUpVHQWHGDQVOHSDQWKpRQ D[RXPLWH XQH LQVFULSWLRQ G¶(]DQD HQ WpPRLJQH /H V\PEROH GLVTXH VXU FURLVVDQW LVVX GH OD YLHLOOH VRXFKH VXGDUDELTXH ILJXUH HQFRUH VXU OHV PRQ QDLHV GH SOXVLHXUV URLV MXVTX¶j (]DQD &H V\PEROH HVW UHSUpVHQWp VXU GHX[ VWqOHV GX WURLVLqPH VLqFOH j 0DWDUD HW j $Q]D/H V\VWqPH JUDSKLTXH GqV ORQJWHPSV VRUWL G¶XVDJH UpDSSDUDvW VXU GHV WDEOHWWHV GH VFKLVWH DX GHX[LqPH VLqFOHVRXVXQHIRUPHFXUVLYHGHO¶pFULWXUHVXGDUDELTXH/DSRWHULHD[RXPLWH GLIIqUHGHODSRWHULHSUpD[RXPLWHPDLVWUDFHUGHVOHWWUHVHWGHVPRWVVXUGHV YDVHV HQ WHUUH FXLWH HVW XQH FRXWXPH GH O¶kJH SUpD[RXPLWH TXL VH SHUSpWXH GDQV OD SpULRGH D[RXPLWH$XWDQW G¶LQGLFHV G¶XQH SHUVLVWDQFH GH SUDWLTXHV SURIRQGpPHQWDQFUpHVGDQVXQWHUUHDXFXOWXUHOPXOWLVpFXODLUH<DWLOjGRX WHUTXHOHVDQFLHQVPDoRQVGH'DDPDWQ¶DLHQWHX[DXVVLOpJXpjWUDYHUVOHV VLqFOHVXQHSDUWGHOHXUVDYRLUIDLUHDX[EkWLVVHXUVD[RXPLWHV" 4XHOHVVWqOHVJpDQWHVG¶$[RXPDLHQWHXjYRLUDYHFOHVWRXUVG¶KDELWD WLRQVXGDUDELTXHVFRPPHSDUH[HPSOHFHOOHVGH6KDEZDGDWpHVGHVSUHPLHUV VLqFOHVGHQRWUHqUHFHUWDLQVO¶RQWDIILUPp$SUHPLqUHYXHHQHIIHWXQHSDUHQ Wp GH IRUPHV DUFKLWHFWXUDOHV HQWUH GHV PRQXPHQWV G¶$[RXP HW FHUWDLQV GH 6KDEZDSDUDvWPDQLIHVWH/HVKDXWHVKDELWDWLRQVGH6KDEZDpWDLHQWpULJpHVVXU GHVVRFOHVPDVVLIVGHGHX[jTXDWUHPqWUHVGHKDXWHXULOHQpWDLWDYHFGHVGH %HUQDQG'UHZHV6FKQHLGHU,SQUO 6WqOHGH0DWDUD%HUQDQG'UHZHV6FKQHLGHU,,SODQFKHVHW $QIUD\S )UDQFLV$QIUD\ JUpV8QHUHVVHPEODQFHGHVLOKRXHWWHDYHFOHVVRXEDVVHPHQWVD[RXPLWHVSHXW FRQGXLUHjSHQVHUTXHOHVFRQVWUXFWHXUVD[RXPLWHVVHVHUDLHQWLQVSLUpVGHFHWWH VWUXFWXUH±FHTXLQ¶HVWSDVLPSRVVLEOH&HSHQGDQWXQHREVHUYDWLRQGpWDLOOpH GHV PRQXPHQWV HQWUDvQH j OD FRQVWDWDWLRQ TXH OHV GLVSDULWpV HQWUH OHV WHFK QLTXHVGHFRQVWUXFWLRQGHVGHX[FRQWUpHVVHUpYqOHQWFRQVLGpUDEOHVODPDoRQ QHULHPLVHHQ°XYUHj$[RXPQ¶HVWHQULHQFRPSDUDEOHjFHOOHGHVDUWLVDQVGH 6KDEZDOHVSURJUDPPHVHWSODQVVRQWGLIIpUHQWVG¶XQSD\VjO¶DXWUHj6KDE ZD OHV PXUV GHV VXSHUVWUXFWXUHV pWDLHQW FRQVWLWXpV G¶XQH DUPDWXUH GH ERLV j UHPSOLVVDJHGHEULTXHVFUXHVTXLSHUPHWWDLWXQHpOpYDWLRQGHSOXVLHXUVpWDJHV ©XQ PLQLPXP GH pWDJHVª/H ERLV GDQV O¶pGLILFH UHSUpVHQWDLW XQ TXDUW GHVPDWpULDX[XWLOLVpVFHTXLpWDLWORLQG¶rWUHOHFDVj$[RXPRXG¶DXWUHSDUW ODEULTXHFUXHpWDLWLQFRQQXHQRQODEULTXHFXLWHTXLHOOHQ¶HQWUDLWTXHGDQV ODFRQVWUXFWLRQGHVWUXFWXUHVSDUWLFXOLqUHV$XWUHGLIIpUHQFHQRWDEOH©OHVPDL VRQVGH6KDEZDLQGpSHQGDQWHVQHFRPSRUWHQWSDVGHPXUV PLWR\HQVª/H FRQWUDLUHj0DWDUD 6XUXQSODQJpQpUDOHQGpSLWGHUHODWLRQVMDPDLVLQWHUURPSXHVHQWUHOHV GHX[FRQWUpHVODPDUTXHGHO¶$UDELHVXUODYLHPDWpULHOOHG¶$[RXPDSSDUDvW IDLEOH HW V¶LO \ D GHV LQIOXHQFHV j GpWHUPLQHU LO FRQYLHQW VDQV GRXWH GH OHV FKHUFKHU GDYDQWDJH HQ GLUHFWLRQ GHV SD\V GH OD 0pGLWHUUDQpH RULHQWDOH DORUV VRXV GRPLQDWLRQ URPDLQH6\ULH HW (J\SWH QRWDPPHQW 0DLQWV pOpPHQWV HQ SURYHQDQFHGHFHVUpJLRQVGHYLHQQHQWXQHSDUWFRQVWLWXWLYHGDQVTXHOOHPH VXUH" GH OD WUDGLWLRQ D[RXPLWH 8Q VHXO H[HPSOH WDUGLI OH PRQQD\DJH LQV WDXUp DX ,,,H VLqFOH SRUWH GH PDQLqUH TX¶RQ SRXUUDLW GLUH V\PEROLTXH O¶HP SUHLQWHGH5RPH'HVVRXUFHVYDULpHVUHQVHLJQHQWVXUODSUpVHQFHj$[RXPGH YR\DJHXUV GH PDUFKDQGV HW SHXWrWUH G¶DUWLVDQV WRXWHV FHV LQVFULSWLRQV HQ JUHFQ¶pWDLHQWHOOHVSDVSRXUHX["&¶HVWGDQVOHXUVLOODJHTXHOHFKULVWLDQLVPH JDJQDOHUR\DXPHSDUOHVFLUFXLWVGHODPHU5RXJH4XHOIXWOHXUU{OHpYHQ WXHOGDQVO¶LQYHQWLRQG¶XQSDUWLSDWURQDUFKLWHFWXUDOG¶XQHRULJLQDOLWp PDU TXpH"/HSRLQWUHVWHjpWDEOLU 6XU FH VXMHW GHV UHODWLRQV G¶$[RXP DYHF O¶$UDELH GX 6XG LO HVW HVVHQWLHO GH OLUH O¶pWXGH GH 0DQ]R/¶DXWHXUDUDVVHPEOpWUqVFRPSOqWHPHQWOHVpOpPHQWVHQMHXGDQVFHWWHTXHVWLRQ GHVUDSSRUWVHQWUHOHVGHX[FRQWUpHV2QWURXYHUDUpXQLVGDQVFHWDUWLFOHOHVPpULWHVG¶XQHV\Q WKqVHSHUWLQHQWHHWODVROLGLWpG¶XQHGRFXPHQWDWLRQGpWDLOOpH &RQFHUQDQW6KDEZDFRQVXOWHU%UHWRQHWGDQVFHWRXYUDJHFROOHFWLIYRLUODFRQWULEXWLRQ GH'DUOHV -6HLJQHFLWpSDU'DUOHVS $QIUD\QRWDPPHQWSS³/DFLYLOLVDWLRQD[RXPLWH/HVIDFWHXUV´3RXUO¶LQIOX HQFHE\]DQWLQHHWOHVEDVLOLTXHVG¶$GRXOLVYRLU+HOGPDQQ 2EVHUYDWLRQVVXUODFRQVWUXFWLRQD[RXPLWH %,%/,2*5$3+,( $QIUD\ ) ³/D SUHPLqUH FDPSDJQH GH IRXLOOHVj 0DWDUD´ LQ $QQDOHV G¶(WKLRSLH SS ²³&KURQLTXHDUFKpRORJLTXH´LQ$QQDOHVG¶(WKLRSLHSS ²³1RXYHDX[VLWHVDQWLTXHV´LQ-RXUQDORI(WKLRSLDQ6WXGLHVSS ²³'HX[YLOOHVD[RXPLWHV$GRXOLVHW0DWDUD´LQ,9&RQJUHVVR,QWHUQD]LRQDOHGL6WXGL (WLRSLFL5RPDDSULOH5RPD$FFDGHPLD1D]LRQDOHGHL/LQFHLSS ²³,QWURGXFWLRQ´LQ%HUQDQG'UHZHV6FKQHLGHU,SS ² ³$[RXP GX ,HU DX ,,,H VLqFOH /HV WpPRLJQDJHV PDWpULHOV´ LQ & /HSDJH pG eWXGHV pWKLRSLHQQHV$FWHVGHOD;H&RQIpUHQFHLQWHUQDWLRQDOHGHVpWXGHVpWKLRSLHQQHV3DULVDRW 3DULV$VVRFLDWLRQ)UDQoDLVHSRXUOHVpWXGHVpWKLRSLHQQHVSS $QIUD\)*RGHW(QG/HVLWHGH'RQJRXUjO¶LPSUHVVLRQ %HUQDQG('UHZHV$-6FKQHLGHU55HFXHLOGHV,QVFULSWLRQVGHO¶(WKLRSLHGHVSp ULRGHVSUpD[RXPLWHHWD[RXPLWH,,,3DULV$FDGpPLHGHV,QVFULSWLRQVHW%HOOHV/HWWUHV %HUQDQG(5HFXHLOGHVLQVFULSWLRQVGHO¶(WKLRSLHGHVSpULRGHVSUpD[RXPLWHHWD[RXPLWH ,,,$/HVLQVFULSWLRQVJUHFTXHV3DULV$FDGpPLHGHV,QVFULSWLRQVHW%HOOHV/HWWUHV %UHWRQ-)pG)RXLOOHVGH6KDEZD,,,%H\URXWK,QVWLWXW)UDQoDLVG¶$UFKpRORJLHGX 3URFKH2ULHQW &DVVRQ / HG 7KH 3HULSOXV 0DULV (U\WKUDHL 7H[W ZLWK LQWURGXFWLRQ WUDQVODWLRQ DQG FRPPHQWDU\3ULQFHWRQ3ULQFHWRQ8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV &RQWHQVRQ+GH$QWLTXLWpVpWKLRSLHQQHV6DLQ0DXUGHV)RVVpVeG6qSLD%LEOLRWKqTXH 3HLUHVF &RQWL5RVVLQL & 6WRULD G¶(WLRSLD 3DUWH SULPD GDOOH RULJLQL DOO¶DYYHQWR GHOOD GLQDVWLD VDORPRQLGH%HUJDPR,VWLWXWR,WDOLDQRGL$UWL*UDILFKH&ROOH]LRQHGLPRQRJUDILHDFXUD GHO0LQLVWHURGHOH&RORQLH 'DLQHOOL*0DULQHOOL25LVXOWDWLGLXQYLDJJLRQHOOD&RORQLD(ULWUHD)LUHQ]H*DOOHWWL H&RFFL 'DUOHV&³eWXGHW\SRORJLTXHGHO¶DUFKLWHFWXUHFLYLOHLQWUDPXURV´LQ%UHWRQpG SS (LFKKRO] '( + HG 3OLQ\ 1DWXUDO +LVWRU\ :LWK DQ (QJOLVK WUDQVODWLRQ LQ WHQ YRO XPHV 9ROXPH ; /LEUL ;;;9,;;;9,, &DPEULGJH 0DVVDFKXVVHWWV +DUYDUG 8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV/RQGRQ:LOOLDP+HLQHPDQQ/WG7KH/RHE&ODVVLFDO/LEUDU\ )DWWRYLFK 5 QG ³&RQWLQXLW\ DQG &KDQJH LQ WKH 5HJLRQ RI $NVXP 7LJUD\ )URP 3UH $NVXPLWH WR 3RVW$NVXPLWH 7LPHV FD WK %&$' $UFKDHRORJLFDO 3HUVSHFWLYH´ FRPPXQLFDWLRQ j OD UHQFRQWUH2UELV $HWKLRSLFXV &RQIHUHQFH &RQWLQXLW\ DQG &KDQJHLQ (WKLRSLDQ&XOWXUH&DPEULGJH6HSWHPEHU )DWWRYLFK5%DUG.$³6FDYL$UFKHRORJLFLQHOOD]RQDGL$NVXP)2QD1DJDVW%LHWD *L\RUJLV´LQ5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL(WLRSLFLSS ² ³6FDYL DUFKHRORJLFL QHOOD =RQD GL $NVXP * 2QD (QGD $ERL =HXJp H 2QD 1DJDVW %LHWD*L\RUJLV´LQ5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL(WLRSLFLSS ²³7KH3URWR$NVXPLWH3HULRG$QRYHUYLHZ´LQ$QQDOHVG¶(WKLRSLHSS ² ³6FDYL DUFKHRORJLFL QHOOD =RQD GL $NVXP . %LHWD *L\RUJLV´ LQ 5DVVHJQD GL 6WXGL (WLRSLFLQVSS )DWWRYLFK5%DUG.$3HWUDVVL/3LVDQR97KH$NVXP$UFKDHRORJLFDO$UHD$ SUHOLPLQDU\ $VVHVVPHQW 1DSROL ,VWLWXWR 8QLYHUVLWDULR 2ULHQWDOH :RUNLQJ 3DSHU GHO /D ERUDWRULRGL$UFKHRORJLDGHO'LSDUWLPHQWRGL6WXGLH5LFHUFKHVX$IULFDH3DHVL$UDEL )UDQFLV$QIUD\ *RGHW(³5pSHUWRLUHGHVVLWHVSUpD[RXPLWHVHWD[RXPLWHVGX7LJUp(WKLRSLH´LQ$E ED\SS ²³5pSHUWRLUHGHVVLWHVSUpD[RXPLWHVHWD[RXPLWHVG¶(WKLRSLHGX1RUG,,qPHSDU WLH(U\WKUpH´LQ$EED\SS +HOGPDQQ0³(DUO\%\]DQWLQH6FXOSWXUDO)UDJPHQWVIURP$GXOLV´LQ&/HSDJHpG eWXGHV pWKLRSLHQQHV $FWHV GH OD ;H &RQIpUHQFH LQWHUQDWLRQDOH GHV pWXGHV pWKLRSLHQQHV 3DULVDRW3DULV$VVRFLDWLRQ)UDQoDLVHSRXUOHVpWXGHVpWKLRSLHQQHVSS .UHQFNHU'YRQ/SNH7=DKQ5'HXWVFKH$NVXP([SHGLWLRQbOWHUH'HQNPlOHU 1RUGDEHVVLQLHQVYRO%HUOLQ*HRUJ5HLPHU 0DQ]R$³%UHYHQRWL]LDVXXQYLDJJLRGL6WXGLRLQ(ULWUHD´LQ5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL(WLRSL FLSS ² ³&RQVLGHUD]LRQL VXOO¶$UFKLWHWWXUD GHOO¶(WLRSLD DQWLFD´ LQ 5DVVHJQD GL 6WXGL (WLRSLFL SS 0RQQHUHW GH 9LOODUG 8 ³$NVXP H L TXDWWUR UH GHO PRQGR´ LQ $QQDOL /DWHUDQHQVL SS 0XQUR+D\6&([FDYDWLRQVDW$NVXPDQDFFRXQWRIWKHUHVHDUFKDWWKHDQFLHQW(WKLR SLDQFDSLWDOGLUHFWHGLQE\WKHODWH1HYLOOH&KLWWLFN/RQGRQ7KH%ULWLVK,QVWLWXWH LQ(DVWHUQ$IULFD%ULWLVK,QVWLWXWHLQ(DVWHUQ$IULFD0HPRLU 3DULEHQL5³5LFHUFKHQHOOXRJRGHOO¶DQWLFD$GXOLV´LQ0RQXPHQWLDQWLFKLFROO 3KLOOLSVRQ':³7KH%,($$NVXP([FDYDWLRQV´LQ1\DPH$NXPDSS ²7KH0RQXPHQWVRI$NVXPDQLOOXVWUDWHGDFFRXQWEDVHGRQWKHZRUNLQ$'RI WKH 'HXWVKFH $NVXPH[SHGLWLRQE\( /LWWPDQQ ' .UHQFNHUDQG 7K9RQ /SNH %HUOLQ /RQGRQ7KH%ULWLVK,QVWLWXWHLQ(DVWHUQ$IULFD 3LYD$³8QDFLYLOWjVFRPSDUVDGHOO¶(ULWUHD´LQ1XRYD$QWRORJLDSS 3XJOLVL 6 ³3ULPL 5LVXOWDWL GHOOH LQGDJLQL FRPSLXWH GDOOD 0LVVLRQH DUFKHRORJLFD GL $N VXP´LQ$IULFD,WDOLDQDSS 5DFNKDP + HG 3OLQ\ 1DWXUDO +LVWRU\ :LWK DQ (QJOLVK WUDQVODWLRQ LQ WHQ YROXPHV 9ROXPH,,/LEUL,,,9,,&DPEULGJH0DVVDFKXVVHWWV+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV/RQGRQ :LOOLDP+HLQHPDQQ/WG7KH/RHE&ODVVLFDO/LEUDU\ 5DFNKDP + HG 3OLQ\ 1DWXUDO +LVWRU\ :LWK DQ (QJOLVK WUDQVODWLRQ LQ WHQ YROXPHV 9ROXPH ,9 /LEUL ;,;9, &DPEULGJH 0DVVDFKXVVHWWV +DUYDUG 8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV /RQ GRQ:LOOLDP+HLQHPDQQ/WG7KH/RHE&ODVVLFDO/LEUDU\ 5LFFL/³,VFUL]LRQLUXSHVWULGHOO¶(ULWUHD´LQ5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL(WLRSLFLQVSS 5LFFL/)DWWRYLFK5³6FDYLDUFKHRORJLFLQHOOD]RQDGL$NVP%%LHWD*L\RUJLV´LQ 5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL(WLRSLFLSS 6XQGVWU|P5³5HSRUWRIDQ([SHGLWLRQWR$GXOLV´LQ(/LWWPDQQ³3UHOLPLQDU\5HSRUW RI WKH 3ULQFHWRQ 8QLYHVLW\ ([SHGLWLRQ WR $E\VVLQLD´ LQ =HLWVFKULIW IU $VV\ULRORJLH SS Fig. 1. Plan du monument axoumite à Enda-Maryam-Tsion-Tahot, non loin G¶$GLJUDW Fig. Fig. Fig. 4. Cavités horizontales sur les murs indiquant que des pieces de bois y avaient été inserées pour renforcer la cohésion de la maçonnerie. Fig. 6RXEDVVHPHQW G¶XQ EâWLPHQW D[RXPLWH TXL VHUW GH VRFOH D O¶pJOLVH Maryam-Tsyon à Axoum. Fig. Fig. 7. Haut soubassement à gradins de édifice du tertre A à Matara. Fig. 8. Fig. centre des ruines. à Qohayto avec piliers se dressant encore au Fig. 10. Base et fragment de piler dans le jardin public et près de Maryam Tsyon à Axoum. &$50(/$%$)),21, ³&LWWjSHUIHWWH´HUHJLPLSROLWLFLQHOO¶,VODPDQGDOXVR /DSROLWLFDQHOO¶,VODPFODVVLFRVLIRQGDGDXQDSDUWHVXOODUHOLJLRQHLVOD PLFDHGDOO¶DOWUDVXOO¶HUHGLWjDQWLFD,UDSSRUWLIUDFDOLIIDWRRVXFFHVVLRQHSUR IHWLFDFKHDYHYDDQFKHLOFRPSLWRGLJRYHUQDUHSROLWLFDPHQWHHVXOWDQDWRR SRWHUHPRQGDQRVRQRIUDLSLYDULFRPSOHVVLHWRUPHQWDWLGHOODVWRULDGHOO¶, VODP6FKHPDWL]]DQGRDOO¶HVWUHPRF¶qXQDUHOD]LRQHIUDLO3URIHWDHLTXDWWUR ېXODIƗ¶DOUDãƯGnjQLFDOLIILEHQJXLGDWLGDXQDSDUWHHLOVXFFHVVLYRPXONUH JQRRJRYHUQRWHPSRUDOHGDOO¶DOWUD,QDJJLXQWDJOLâƯµLWLGRYHYDQRWURYDUH FKLIRVVHGRWDWRGLFDUDWWHULVWLFKHWDOLGDSRWHUVYROJHUHLQTXDQWR/HJLVODWRUH LFRPSLWLFKHLO3URIHWDDYHYDDIILGDWRDOO¶LPƗPVXRGLVFHQGHQWHGLUHWWRHGH WHQWRUHGHOODYHULWjHVRWHULFDGHOOD5LYHOD]LRQH $QFKHOHGRWWULQHSROLWLFKHJUHFKHGL3ODWRQHLQSDUWLFRODUHVRQRQRWHH DPSLDPHQWH SUHVH D PRGHOOR GDJOL DXWRUL PXVXOPDQLFKH OH ULHODERUDQR VH FRQGROHSURSULHFRQYLQ]LRQLUHOLJLRVH3HUFLzLILORVRILGHOO¶,VODPJLRFDURQR XQUXRORLPSRUWDQWHQHOGLEDWWLWRSROLWLFRDOLYHOORGRWWULQDOHHDQFKHSHUHVSH ULHQ]DGLUHWWDXVXIUXHQGRGHOPHFHQDWLVPRGHOOHYDULHFRUWLRRSHUDQGRSUHV VRGLHVVHFRPHPHGLFLJLXGLFLHVFLHQ]LDWL 5LSHUFRUUHUz TXL EUHYHPHQWH OH WHRULH SROLWLFKH LQ VHQVR SL R PHQR VWUHWWRGHLWUHJUDQGLSHQVDWRULDQGDOXVL,EQ%ƗMMD,EQؽXID\OH$YHUURqSR QHQGROHDFRQIURQWRFRQTXHOOHGHJOL³RULHQWDOL´,পZƗQDOৡDIƗ¶R)UDWHOOLGHO OD3XULWjHDO)ƗUƗEƯP /D SROLWLFD IX LQWURGRWWD LQ ,VODP SURSULR FRQ ODFRQWURYHUVLD VXOOD VXFFHVVLRQH FDOLIIDOH ,Q SUHFHGHQ]D HVVD HUD QHJOHWWD IUDLQWHVD R DWWDFFDWDD FDXVD GHOOD WHRFUD]LD LQVLWD QHOODãDUƯµD 1DMMDUSS /¶XOWLPDUHGD]LRQHGHOODORURFHOHEUHHQFLFORSHGLDVLFROORFDQHOO¶XOWLPDSDUWHGHO;VHFROR )RQGDWRUHGHOODILORVRILDSROLWLFDLQ,VODP1DMMDUS$PSLRFRQIURQWRIUDOHORUR &DUPHOD%DIILRQL 6LDJOL,পZƗQDOৡDIƗ¶VLDDO)ƗUƗEƯGHVFULYRQR±FRQOHGRYXWHGLIIHUHQ]H ± XQD FLWWj SHUIHWWD DOPDGƯQD DOIƗڲLOD ,O WHUPLQH IƗڲLO VLJQLILFD SURSULD PHQWH ³YLUWXRVR´ H LQ TXDQWR DSSDUWLHQH DOO¶DPELWR GHOOD PRUDOH SRQH LP PHGLDWDPHQWH OD SROLWLFD LQ UDSSRUWR FRQ OD GLPHQVLRQH UHOLJLRVD GHOO¶,VODP 3HUDO)ƗUƗEƯODUHOLJLRQHGHVWLQDWDDOOHPDVVHqXQ¶HVSUHVVLRQHILJXUDWDGHOOD ILORVRILD1HOVXRVLVWHPDILORVRIRHSURIHWDFRLQFLGRQR3HUODUHOLJLRQHLOIL QHGHOO¶XRPRqIDUHODYRORQWjGL'LRFRPXQLFDWDQHOODãDUƯµDPDGDWRFKHOD YHULWj q XQD L ILORVRIL VRQR JOL HUHGL GHO 3URIHWD H DG HVVL VSHWWHUj GL SURVH JXLUQHDQFKHODIXQ]LRQHSROLWLFD(QWUDPELJOLRELHWWLYLGHJOL,পZƗQDOৡDIƗ¶ HGLDO)ƗUƗEƯ±ODULFHUFDGHOEHQHLQTXHVWRPRQGRHQHOO¶DOWURHODIHOLFLWj± FRUULVSRQGRQRGDOSXQWRGLYLVWDUHOLJLRVRDOODVDOYH]]DPDVLFRQVHJXRQR LQ FRQWHVWL ILORVRILFL DWWUDYHUVR O¶XQLRQH FRQ O¶,QWHOOHWWR $JHQWH 9LUWXRVL H SHUIHWWDPHQWH IHOLFL JUD]LH D WDOH XQLRQH L JRYHUQDQWLILORVRIL IDUDQQR WXWWR TXDQWR QHFHVVDULR DIILQFKp DQFKH ODXPPD UDJJLXQJD LO ILQH XOWLPR '¶DOWUD SDUWHVHODILORVRILDLVODPLFDLGHQWLILFDODYLUWFRQODFRQRVFHQ]DFKHIRQGDOD FLWWjSHUIHWWDVHFRQGRLOPRGHOORSODWRQLFRFLVLFKLHGHTXDQWRGHOO¶DQWLFRIL ORVRIRUHULPDQJDLQFROXLFKHODJRYHUQDHFKLVLDLQYHULWjLOJRYHUQDQWHGHO ODFLWWjSHUIHWWD,SHQVDWRULGHOO¶2ULHQWHLVODPLFRIDQQRSHUORSLULIHULPHQWR DOOR ãƯµLVPR H FRQ O¶LPƗP ãƯµLWD SXz HVVHUH LGHQWLILFDWR LO JRYHUQDQWH GHJOL ,পZƗQ DOৡDIƗ¶ H GL DO)ƗUƗEƯ/D QR]LRQH ãƯµLWD GLWDµOƯP GRFHQ]D WURYD LQ TXHVWHGRWWULQHLOVXRUXRORQRQDFDVRLJRYHUQDQWLGHVFULWWLSDUODQRDOODJHQ WHVLDDSHUWDPHQWHRYYHURDWWUDYHUVRVLPEROLVLDLQVHJUHWRFLRqVHQ]DSLUL FRUUHUHDWDOLVLPEROLDVHFRQGDGHOODFDSDFLWjGHJOLLQWHUORFXWRULGLFRPSUHQ GHUHHDVVLPLODUHLOORURPHVVDJJLR ,SHQVDWRULVHPEUDQRFUHGHUHQHOODFRQFUHWDUHDOL]]D]LRQHGHOODFLWWjSHU IHWWD QRQRVWDQWH FKH JOL ,পZƗQ DOৡDIƗ¶ LQGLFKLQRTXDWWUR WLSL GL RVWDFROL DO FRQVHJXLPHQWR GHOOR VFRSR XOWLPR GHOOD FLWWj SHUIHWWD FIU S HV %XVWƗQƯ GRWWULQHLQ%DIILRQL :DONHU SS 3HUFLz VROR OD ³YHUD´ ILORVRILD SXz VDOYDJXDUGDUH GDOOR VFLVPD H GDOO¶HUHVLDODUHOLJLRQHYHUDPDLOILORVRIRVLVSLQVHWURSSRROWUHQHOO¶LPSRUUHLFULWHULGLYHULWj HLVLVWHPLGLYDORUHGHOODILORVRILD(QGUHVVS 5RFKH$UQDVS /D ILORVRILD GL DO)ƗUƗEƯ VDUHEEH DSSXQWR XQD JLXVWLILFD]LRQH WHRUHWLFD GHOOR ãƯµLVPR 1DMMDU SS3LFDXWDPHQWH(QGUHVVSSQRWDFKHVHSXUHHJOLSRWpHVVHUH VWDWR LQFRUDJJLDWR GDLFLUFROL LQWHOOHWWXDOL ãƯµLWL GL 'DPDVFR H GHO &DLUR D IDUH GHOOD ILORVRILD XQDSURIHVVLRQHDFFHWWDDOODWHRFUD]LDLVODPLFDOHJJHUHODVXDSROLWLFDFRPHXQDULYHQGLFD]LR QHWHRUHWLFDGHOORãƯµLVPRSROLWLFRVLJQLILFKHUHEEHIUDLQWHQGHUQHO¶RELHWWLYRILORVRILFR &LWWjSHUIHWWHHUHJLPLSROLWLFLQHOO¶,VODPDQGDOXVR (S,9SSHFKHDO)ƗUƗEƯGLDQHOVXROLEURXQUHVR FRQWRGHWWDJOLDWRGHOOHTXDWWURVSHFLHGLFLWWjFRUURWWH±LGHQWLILFDWHDWWUDYHUVR XQD WHUPLQRORJLD GLFKLDUDWDPHQWH UHOLJLRVD $O)ƗUƗEƯ FDS 6H q TXDVLLPSRVVLELOHULQWUDFFLDUHULIHULPHQWLVWRULFLLQDO)ƗUƗEƯXQRGHJOLRELHW WLYLSROLWLFLGHJOL,পZƗQDOৡDIƗ¶SXzHVVHUHVWDWRLOIDPRVRFDOLIIRµDEEƗVLGH DO0D¶PnjQ'¶DOWURFDQWRSRLFKpHVVLSUHVHQWDQRODORURFRQIUDWHUQLWDFRPH LO PLJOLRUH PRGHOOR GL FLWWj SHUIHWWD q GDWR LSRWL]]DUH FKH VL FRQVLGHULQR PHPEUL HPLQHQWL GHOOH UDSSUHVHQWDQ]H ILORVRILFRSURSDJDQGLVWH GHO UHJLPH IƗؾLPLGHLQFXLORãƯµLVPRWURYzDSSXQWRDWWXD]LRQHSROLWLFD ,EQ %ƗMMD P FRQGLYLGH FRQ L VXRLSUHGHFHVVRULRULHQWDOL VLD O¶DW WHQ]LRQHSHUO¶HUHGLWjSROLWLFDDQWLFD$YHPSDFHSVLDO¶R ELHWWLYR±FLRqODULFHUFDGHOODIHOLFLWj0DJLjLQDSHUWXUDGHOVXRFHOHEUH5H JLPHGHOVROLWDULRDIIHUPDFKHO¶HVLVWHQ]DGLXQDFRPXQLWjFRVWLWXLWDGDILORVR ILFLRqGDFKLKDFRQVHJXLWRLOILQHXOWLPRUHDOL]]DQGRO¶XQLRQHSHUIHWWDFRQ O¶,QWHOOHWWR$JHQWHHGqSHUFLzFKLDPDWRHJOLVWHVVRIƗڲLOYLUWXRVRDQ]LLOƗKƯ GLYLQRqGHOWXWWRLUUHDOLVWLFD&DUDWWHULVWLFDSULQFLSDOHGHOODFLWWjSHUIHWWDq FKHQRQYLVL WURYDQRQp PHGLFLQpJLXGLFLHVVHQGRLFRUSLHOHDQLPHGHJOL DELWDQWLSHUIHWWDPHQWHVDQLJUD]LHDOORURFRPSRUWDPHQWRYLUWXRVRSS 3HU L ILORVRIL FKH DELWDQR OH FLWWj LPSHUIHWWH QRQ HVLVWH QHSSXUH XQ QRPH,EQ%ƗMMDGHYHDOORUDVHUYLUVLGLXQWHUPLQHIƗUƗELDQRFDSRYROJHQGRQH LOVLJQLILFDWRHJOLFKLDPD³SLDQWH´QDZƗELW±LQXQVHQVRULVWUHWWRSUHFLVD ± FRORUR FKH KDQQR RSLQLRQL VDQH HVWUDQHH DOOD FLWWj LPSHUIHWWD SS HUEDFFHFKHVRIIRFDQRO¶HUEDHFKHYDQQRSHUFLzHVWLUSDWH 'XQTXHSHU,EQ%ƗMMDLOILORVRIRqGHVWLQDWRDGHVVHUHXQ³VROLWDULR´QHOOH FLWWjQRQSHUIHWWHS4XHVWRSHVVLPLVPRFKHORSRUWDDFRQFOXGH 1DMMDUSSHQVDDL&DUPDWLFRPHVXRPRGHOOR %DIILRQLH 6XOO¶LVPƗµƯOLVPRGHJOL,পZƗQDOৡDIƗ¶FIU6WHUQ%DIILRQLH 6HEEHQHULFRUGLDQFKHFKH³LQXQDOWUROXRJR´qVWDWRGHWWRFKHHVVLVRQRODFDXVDGHOODIRUPD ]LRQH GHOOD FLWWj SHUIHWWD S 4XHVWR ³DOWUR OXRJR´ SRWUHEEH HVVHUH LO/LEUR VXOOD VFLHQ]DSROLWLFDRUDSHUGXWRFIU,ELGQ1HVVXQDVXJJHVWLRQHGD,EQ%ƗMMD$YHPSDFH S 3RLFKpO¶DVVHQ]DGLJLXGLFLHPHGLFLqFLWDWDJLjLQ3ODWRQH,EQ%ƗMMDGHYHDYHUOHWWROD5H SXEEOLFDGLUHWWDPHQWHHQRQDWWUDYHUVRDO)ƗUƗEƯ5RVHQWKDOS 3HUDO)ƗUƗEƯQDZƗELWVRQRFRORURFKHYDULDPHQWHVLRSSRQJRQRDOODFLWWjSHUIHWWD$O)ƗUƗEƯ FDS6XOWHUPLQHFIU5RVHQWKDOSSH$]DQ]D(OtRS &DUPHOD%DIILRQL UHFKHLILORVRILQRQGRYHVVHURLQJHULUVLLQDIIDULOHJDWLDOODJHVWLRQHGHOODVR FLHWjqXQDFRQVHJXHQ]DGHOODSROLWLFDDOPRUDYLGH"4XDOHFKHVLDODULVSR VWDVHXQDFLWWjGHLILORVRILQRQSXzDWWXDOL]]DUVLD,EQ%ƗMMDQRQUHVWDDGLI IHUHQ]D GHL VXRL SUHGHFHVVRUL RULHQWDOL FKH VSLHJDUH FRPH XQ ILORVRIR SRVVD HVVHUHIHOLFHYLYHQGRLQXQRVWDWRLPSHUIHWWR1HOOHFLWWjLPSHUIHWWHOD³JHQWH IHOLFH´ OR q VWDQGRVHQH GD SDUWH FRPH VWUDQLHUL S ,O SHVVLPLVPR UDJJLXQJHO¶DSLFHTXDQGR,EQ%ƗMMDDUULYDDVXJJHULUHLOVXLFLGLRFRQGDQQDWR GDOODUHOLJLRQHPXVXOPDQDFRPHLOPLQRUHGHLPDOL ,EQؽXID\OPYLYHVRWWRLOUHJLPHDOPRKDGH/DVXDVRODRSHUD VXSHUVWLWHqLOFHOHEUHURPDQ]RILORVRILFRۉD\\LEQ<DTܲƗQণD\\LEQ<DTƗQ ³LOYLYHQWHILJOLRGHOGHVWR´qYLVVXWRVLQGDOODQDVFLWDVXXQ¶LVRODFRPSOH WDPHQWH GHVHUWD GRYH q SDVVDWR DWWUDYHUVR XQD VHULH GL YDULHJDWH HVSHULHQ]H FXOPLQDWH QHOOD YLVLRQH GL 'LR4XDQGR YHUVR L FLQTXDQW¶DQQL LQFRQWUDƖ VƗO FKH JLXQJH QHOO¶LVROD DOOD ULFHUFD GHO VLJQLILFDWR QDVFRVWR GHOOD VXD UHOL JLRQHD\\ULFRQRVFHQHOOHVXHFRQYLQ]LRQLODSURSULDHVSHULHQ]DVSLULWXDOH HVSUHVVDSHUzLQWHUPLQLVLPEROLFL3HUFLzHVVLGHFLGRQRGLWRUQDUHDOO¶LVRODGL ƖVƗOSHUVSLHJDUHDWXWWLLOYHURVLJQLILFDWRGHOODORURUHOLJLRQHD\\QRQULH VFHDFDSLUHSHUFKpLO3URIHWDDEELDWUDVPHVVRVRORGHLVLPEROLFKHKDQQRLQ GRWWRJOLXRPLQLDGDWWULEXLUHD'LRXQFRUSRHTXDOLWjFKHLQUHDOWjQRQJOLDS SDUWHQJRQR Qp ULHVFH DG DSSUH]]DUH OD ULFFKH]]D HWXWWL L EHQL QRQ QHFHVVDUL D\\EHQ<DTGKkQS'RSRLOIDOOLPHQWRGHOORURWHQWDWLYR D\\HƖVƗOIDQQRULWRUQRDOODORURLVRODDQFRUDIHGHOLQHOFXRUHDOORURDQWL FRLGHDOH±ODULFHUFDGHOVXEOLPHDOVHUYL]LRGL'LRSS 3HU,EQؽXID\OLILORVRILVSDJQROLKDQQRSDVVDWRODYLWDGHGLFDQGRVLDOOH VFLHQ]HVSHULPHQWDOLDXQOLYHOORPROWRDOWRPDQRQVRQRVWDWLFDSDFLGLDQGD UHROWUHQpODORJLFDOLKDDLXWDWLDUDJJLXQJHUHODYHULWjSHUIHWWDS 4XHVWDFRQFOXVLRQHSDUHXQDWWDFFRDOUHJLPHYLJHQWHHDOVXRGLYLHWRDOODVSH FXOD]LRQHPHWDILVLFD0DROWUHFKHFRQODVLWXD]LRQHSROLWLFDODJHQHVLGHOO¶R 7UDLULIHULPHQWLFRQFUHWLODUHVSRQVDELOLWjGHOIDOOLPHQWRGHLJRYHUQLVWRULFLSDUHDWWULEXLWDDL JLXGLFLDOWURRELHWWLYRSROHPLFRGHOO¶RSHUDVRQRL UH\HVGHWDLIDVSSDFRQ IURQWRGHLTXDOLLOJRYHUQRDOPRUDYLGHFKHVDOYzORVWDWRGDOGLVRUGLQHVRFLDOHqFRQVLGHUDWR LOPDOHPLQRUH/DFRUUX]LRQHQHOJRYHUQRVLULWLHQHFDXVDWDGDFRORURFKHVSHVVRGLGLVFHQ GHQ]DDULVWRFUDWLFDLQWHUHVVDWLXQLFDPHQWHDLJRGLPHQWLPDWHULDOLFRUURPSRQRODSRSROD]LR QH H SRVVRQR GHWHUPLQDUH OD FDGXWD GL XQD GLQDVWLDVDInjOD DOGXZDO VHFRQGR OD OH]LRQH GL $VtQ3DODFLRVFLWLQ$YHPSDFHSQ %UJHOS(ODPUDQL-DPDOS &LWWjSHUIHWWHHUHJLPLSROLWLFLQHOO¶,VODPDQGDOXVR SHUDqVSLHJDWDFRQO¶LQIOXHQ]DصnjILHODVILGDGHOO¶DXWRUHDLILORVRIL ,EQؽX ID\OSRWUHEEHHVVHUVLFRQWUDSSRVWRDLSHQVDWRULGLFXLIDODVWRULDSHUVSLHJDUH ODSURSULDHVSHULHQ]DFRQWHPSODWLYD 1HO &RPPHQWR DOOD 5HSXEEOLFD SHUYHQXWRFL QHOOD VROD YHUVLRQH HEUDL FD$YHUURq P DIIHUPD ± VXOOD OLQHD GL 3ODWRQH ± FKH D FDSR GHOOR VWDWRLGHDOHGHEERQRHVVHUHLVDSLHQWLVRORDWWUDYHUVROHVFLHQ]HWHRUHWLFKHVL SXz FRJOLHUH LO ILQH XOWLPR GHOO¶XRPR /HUQHU SS TXHVWR VWDWR VDUj VDJJLR FRUDJJLRVR H PRGHUDWR S )URGH H LQJLXVWL]LD VRQR SURSULH GHOOH FLWWj LJQRUDQWL FRPH OD VDOXWH q XQD DQFKHOD YLUW q XQD FRVu OD FLWWj SHUIHWWDOHFLWWjLPSHUIHWWHLQYHFHVRQRPROWHFRPHPROWHSOLFLHGLYHUVLVRQR LYL]LS$QFKH$YHUURqULIHULVFHFKHORVWDWRLGHDOHQRQKDELVRJQRQp GLPHGLFLQpGLJLXGLFLSHDQFKHSHUOXLO¶LQVHJQDPHQWRGHOILORVRIRq GXSOLFHDWWUDYHUVRDUJRPHQWLGLPRVWUDWLYLGHVWLQDWLDJOLHOHWWLHDUJRPHQWLSHU VXDVLYLHSRHWLFLULYROWLDOOHPDVVH,ELG&LzFKHSLLPSRUWDLWHUPLQL³ILOR VRIR´³UH´³/HJLVODWRUH´H³LPƗP´VRQRDQFRUDXQDYROWDVLQRQLPL 6HJXH XQ HOHQFR GL TXDOLWj GHO JRYHUQDQWH VLPLOL D TXHOOH GDWH GDJOL ,পZƗQDOৡDIƗ¶HGDDO)ƗUƗEƯ6HEEHQHVLGLFDFKHHVVHQRQVLWURYDQRVRORLQ XQDFLWWjSHUIHWWDFKpLQWDOFDVRODFLWWjSHUIHWWDQRQVLUHDOL]]HUHEEHPDLLIL ORVRILQRQSRVVRQRHVVHUHGLDOFXQDLXWRQHOOHFLWWjLPSHUIHWWHLQFXLYLYRQR 7RUQHURSPDHJOLLQTXHVWRQRQHEEHFRQWLQXDWRULSS3LFDXWDPHQWH &RUQHOO S RVVHUYDYD FKH SXUFRQGLYLGHQGR PROWL SXQWL ILORVRILFL H GRWWULQDOLFRQ صnjIL PDƥUHELQL H DQGDOXVL ,EQ ؽXID\O QH GLIIHULVFH TXDQWR DO PHWRGR GL TXL LO SHVVLPLVPR VFDWXUHQWHGDOO¶HVSHULHQ]DGL D\\FRPHGRFHQWH5DGWNHSVRWWROLQHDFKHO¶LPSR VWD]LRQHQHRSODWRQL]]DQWHGLVWLQJXH,EQ ؽXID\OGDO صnjILVPR (ODPUDQL-DPDOS /DWUDGX]LRQHqGL5DEEL6DPXHOEHQ-XGDKEHQ0HVKXOODPEHQ,VDDFEHQ6RORPRQGL 0DUVLJOLD0RVHVEHQ5DEEL,VDDF5LHWLFRSLzLOWHVWRQHO/HUQHUSSH /DFRPSUHQVLRQHGHOFRPPHQWRGL$YHUURqGHYHEDVDUVLVXTXDQWRGLFHDO)ƗUƗEƯSHUFKp LOWUDGXWWRUHHEUHRIUDLQWHVHVSHVVRO¶RULJLQDOH5RVHQWKDOS3HUO¶LPSRUWDQ]DGHOOD 5HSXEEOLFDFIU5RFKH$UQDVSS ,OULFKLDPRDOO¶XQLWjqWRSLFDFRVWDQWHGHJOL,NKZDQDOৡDIƗ¶HGLDO)ƗUƗEƯ 2VVHUYDQGRFKH$YHUURqIXPHGLFRHJLXGLFH±VYROVHFLRqJOLXIILFLQHFHVVDUvQHJOLVWDWLLP SHUIHWWL±5RVHQWKDOSVLFKLHGHVHFLzVLJQLILFDFKHVHLOILORVRIRQRQSXzJRYHUQD UH GHYH SHUz VHUYLUH OR VWDWR LQ DOWUL PRGL R VH$YHUURq YROHYD FULWLFDUH ODSROLWLFD GHO VXR WHPSR /¶LGHQWLILFD]LRQHGLTXHVWLWHUPLQLVLVSLHJDFROIDWWRFKHODFLWWjLGHDOHqODVRFLHWjJLXVWDVH FRQGROHSRVVLELOLWjQDWXUDOLJRYHUQDWDSHUFLzGDOILORVRIR5RFKH$UQDVS &DUPHOD%DIILRQL &RPH XQD PDODWWLD SXz HVVHUH DJJUDYDWD GDO FLER ULFHUFDWR LQ Vp HFFHOOHQWH FRVu L VHPL GHOOH SLDQWH PLJOLRUL VL WUDVIRUPHUDQQR LQ TXHOOL GHOOD SHJJLRUH VSHFLHVHQRQKDQQRODJLXVWDVHGHHQXWULPHQWR3HUFLzVHXQYHURILORVRIRVL WURYDDFUHVFHUHLQXQDFLWWjLPSHUIHWWDILQLVFHSHULVRODUVLHYLYHUHODYLWDGL XQVROLWDULRPDQRQF¶qPRGRGLVDOYDUHOHFLWWjVHQRQDFRQGL]LRQHFKHVLDQR UHWWHGDSHUVRQHFRPHTXHVWHSSSDVVLP &RPH 3ODWRQH$YHUURq DSSURIRQGLVFHO¶HGXFD]LRQHGHO JRYHUQDQWH SS 'DWRFKHODYLWDDVVRFLDWDVHUYHVLDSHUODSURWH]LRQHILVLFDFKH SHUODULFHUFDGHOSUHIHULELOHSDVVDDFRQVLGHUDUHOHOHJJLGHOODVXDHSRFDS VHQ]D ULQXQFLDUH DOO¶LGHD VHFRQGR FXL HVVH GHEEDQR VHJXLUH OD VDSLHQ]D DQWLFD7XWWLHTXDWWURLWLSLGLSHUIH]LRQHYLUWWHRUHWLFKHDUWLSUDWLFKHYLUW FRJLWDWLYHH YLUW PRUDOLSFRQFRUURQRDOODSHUIH]LRQHWHRUHWLFDS 6ROROHVFLHQ]HWHRUHWLFKHGLVSRQJRQRDOO¶D]LRQHS±RYYHURDOJRYHUQR SROLWLFRPDDYHQGR$YHUURqLQPHQWHROWUHDOODSROLWHLDLGHDOHDQFKHODLOƗ IDLGHDOHO¶LQWHQ]LRQHFRQULIHULPHQWRDOO¶D]LRQHqULFRQGRWWDDQFKHDOODSUR IH]LDS ,O JRYHUQR UHJDOH VL UDJJLXQJH TXDQGR LO JRYHUQDQWH SRVVLHGH VDSLHQ]D FRPSUHQVLRQHSHUIHWWDEXRQDFRQYLQ]LRQHEXRQDLPPDJLQD]LRQHHDWWLWXGLQH DOOD JXHUUD VHQ]D LPSHGLPHQWL ILVLFL 0D HVVR SXz HVLVWHUH DQFKH VH TXHVWH TXDOLWjVLWURYDQRLQXQJUXSSRGLLQGLYLGXLFKHFRRSHULQRSSLOJR YHUQDQWHVDUjDOORUDHVSHUWRQHOOHOHJJLVWDELOLWHGDOIRQGDWRUHGHOORVWDWRFD SDFH GL LQWHUSUHWDUOH H GL VFRSULUH FLz FKH LO IRQGDWRUH QRQ DYHYD VSLHJDWR ± FRQRVFHUjFLRqLOGLULWWRVHqDQFKHDELOHQHOODJXHUUDVDUjFRQVLGHUDWRUHS /D FRPPLVWLRQH GL LQVHJQDPHQWL ãDUDµLWLFL H LGHH GL RULJLQH JUHFD q HYLGHQWHQHOO¶DVVHU]LRQHFKHILQHGHOO¶XRPRqFRPSLHUHODYRORQWjGL'LRFKH FL q UHVD QRWD GDOOD SURIH]LD PD OD YRORQWj GLYLQD FRQFHUQH DQFKH OD FRQR VFHQ]D 1RQRVWDQWHGLFKLDULGLYROHUULFRUGDUHJOLDUJRPHQWLVFLHQWLILFLQHFHVVDUL DOODVFLHQ]DSROLWLFDFRP¶HUDQRHVSRVWLLQ3ODWRQHS$YHUURq±OHWWRUH GL DO)ƗUƗEƯ ± ULHFKHJJLD QXPHURVL WHPL VYLOXSSDWLGDL VXRL SUHGHFHVVRUL VLD RULHQWDOLFKHRFFLGHQWDOLHJOLDYHYDXQDFRQRVFHQ]DGLSULPDPDQRGHJOLDIID 5RVHQWKDOS 3XULVSLUDQGRVLDVWUDWWDPHQWHDOODãDUƯµD$YHUURqDYHYDIRUVHLQPHQWHLGXHFDOLIILDOPRKDGL FKHORDSSRJJLDURQR,QPROWLUHJQLPXVXOPDQLFKLFRPEDWWHqGLYHUVRGDFKLJLXGLFD5RVHQ WKDOS &LWWjSHUIHWWHHUHJLPLSROLWLFLQHOO¶,VODPDQGDOXVR UL GL VWDWR H IX PROWR LQWHUHVVDWR DOOD SROLWLFD FRQFUHWDFRPH GLPRVWUDQR L QXPHURVLULIHULPHQWLVWRULFLGHOFRPPHQWR 1RQRVWDQWHODFRPXQDQ]DGHOOHLGHHVRORLSHQVDWRULRULHQWDOLSDUODQRGL FLWWjSHUIHWWD±FLRqVRORLSHQVDWRULRULHQWDOLGLFKLDUDQRHVSOLFLWDPHQWHLOORUR ILQHSROLWLFR0HQWUHLOOHJDPHFRQO¶HUHGLWjFODVVLFDqXQDQLPHPHQWHFRQGLYL VRFXUULFXODVFLHQWLDUXPQHJOL,পZƗQDOৡDIƗ¶HLQDO)ƗUƗEƯFRPPHQWDULDG $ULVWRWHOHGD,EQ%ƗMMDH$YHUURqQHJOLDXWRULRULHQWDOLLWUDWWLGLVWLQWLYLGHO ILORVRIRDSDUWHODOLVWDGLTXDOLWjVLPLOLDTXHOOHGL3ODWRQHFKHVLWURYDLQHQ WUDPELVRQRVWDWLDVVRUELWLLQTXHOOLGHOO¶LPƗPãƯµLWDFKHKDUHDOL]]DWRODVXD XQLRQHFRQO¶,QWHOOHWWR$JHQWHÊSHUTXHVWRPRWLYRFKHOHORURGLVFXVVLRQL VL SRVVRQR FRQVLGHUDUH VWULFWR VHQVX SROLWLFKH H RUPDL UDGLFDOPHQWH GLYHUVH GDOOHIRQWLDQWLFKH(LSHQVDWRULDQGDOXVL" &RQRVFLWRULGHOOHGRWWULQHGHJOL2ULHQWDOLHVVLULILXWDQRO¶LPSHJQRSROLWL FRGHOILORVRIRQRQWHQWDQRQHSSXUHLQWHRULDGLSRUORDFDSRGHOODFLWWjSHUIHW WD/jGRYH$YHUURqFHUFKHUjDOPHQRGLULYLYLILFDUHO¶LGHDSODWRQLFDGLILORVR ILDSROLWLFDLOSHVVLPLVPRGL,EQ%ƗMMDQRQSXzHVVHUHPLWLJDWRHQWUDPELUH FXSHUDQR O¶LPPDJLQH GHO ³VROLWDULR´ WUDWWDWD LQ5HVS 9, ROWUH FKH LQ DO 5RVHQWKDOSHS ,UHJLPLDULVWRFUDWLFLVRQRFROOHJDWLDJOLDQWLFKL3HUVLDQLS4XDQGRSDUODGHOOHWUDVIRU PD]LRQLGHLJRYHUQLFLDVFXQRLQTXHOORLPPHGLDWDPHQWHLQIHULRUHFROORFDODWUDVIRUPD]LRQH GHOJRYHUQRYLUWXRVRLQTXHOORWLPRFUDWLFRDOWHPSRGL0XµƗZL\DPS(VHPSLR GHOODWUDVIRUPD]LRQHGHOJRYHUQRWLPRFUDWLFRQHOO¶HGRQLVWLFRVRQRJOL$OPRUDYLGLQHLJLRUQL GHOIRQGDWRUHLOORURJRYHUQRHUDEDVDWRVXOQRPRVOD/HJJHFRQVXRILJOLRGLYHQQHWLPRFUD WLFRQHLJLRUQLGHOQLSRWHHGRQLVWLFRHLQILQHDQGzLQURYLQDS&RPHDWWHVWDODVWRULD DQWHFHGHQWHHFRQWHPSRUDQHDDG$YHUURqODFLWWjGHPRFUDWLFDSHULVFHUDSLGDPHQWHS XQHVHPSLRGLWUDVIRUPD]LRQHGHOODFLWWjGHPRFUDWLFDLQWLUDQQLFDqLOJRYHUQRGL&RUGRYDGR SRLO+>G&@SSÊLQILQHPHQ]LRQDWR,EQƤƗQL\DXQRSSRVLWRUHGHOOD GLQDVWLDDOPRKDGHODFXLIDPLJOLDWHQWzGLUHVWDXUDUHLOJRYHUQRDOPRUDYLGHLQ1RUG$IULFDS 5RVHQWKDOSSH 6LSXzGXQTXHEHQGLUHFKHDO)ƗUƗEƯDEELDGDWRLOVXRFRQWULEXWR±DOPHQRDOLYHOORWHRUHWLFR ±DOODSROLWLFDVHEEHQHVLDVWDWRWDFFLDWRGLTXLHWLVPR.UDHPHUSFIUDQFKH5R VHQWKDO S H FKH JOL ,পZƗQ DOৡDIƗ¶ YL VL VLDQR LPSHJQDWL DQFKH DWWLYDPHQWH .UDHPHUS;,HS9,,, (VVHQGRWXWWRDVFULYLELOHDOUHJLPHDOPRUDYLGH(QGUHVVSS,QIDWWLSHU,EQ%ƗM MDVXOODOLQHDGL3ODWRQHLOJRYHUQRSHUIHWWRqTXHOORLQFXLQRQqQHFHVVDULRDJJLXQJHUQXOOD $]DQ]D(OtRSSH &DUPHOD%DIILRQL )ƗUƗEƯ3DUODQGR GHOOH TXDWWUR SHUIH]LRQL SURSULH GHO ILORVRIR $YHUURq DJ JLXQJHDQFKHFKHVDUHEEHDGGLULWWXUDPLUDFRORVRFKHHVVHVLWURYDVVHURULXQLWH LQXQXRPRVRORSSDUROHFKHEHQSRWUHEEHURHVVHUHULYROWHDOOHFRQFH ]LRQLSROLWLFKHGHJOL,পZƗQHGLDO)ƗUƗEƯ %LVRJQDFKLHGHUVLVHWDOHDWWHJJLDPHQWRVLVSLHJDVRORFRPHXQDUHD]LRQH DLUHJLPLVRWWRLTXDOLLSHQVDWRULDQGDOXVLYLYHYDQRFKHDYUHEEHURVFRUDJJLD WRRJQLWHQWDWLYRGHLILORVRILGLDVVXPHUHXQUXRORSROLWLFRPDUJLQDOL]]DQGROL RQRQVLDSLXWWRVWRGDFRQVLGHUDUVLFRPHXQDULVSRVWDXQDUHD]LRQHDOLYHOOR WHRUHWLFRDOODILORVRILDGHJOL2ULHQWDOL &LzVLSXzGHGXUUHJLjGDVLQJROLDVSHWWLGHOOHORURWUDWWD]LRQLÊEHQYHUR DGHVHPSLRFKHLGHQWLILFDQGRO¶HVVHQ]DGHOODILORVRILDQHOO¶XQLRQHFRQO¶,QWHO OHWWR $JHQWH ,EQ %ƗMMD VL SRQH VXOOD VFLD GHJOL2ULHQWDOL H FKHTXDQGR SDUOD QHO5HJLPHGHOVROLWDULRGLXQDVRUWDGL³YLVLRQH´LQFXLUDSSUHVHQWD]LRQHWD صDZZXUHDVVHQVRWDصGƯTVLSURGXFRQRVLPXOWDQHDPHQWH$YHPSDFH SSRWUHEEHHVHPSOLILFDUHTXHOODGHO3URIHWDVHFRQGR$YLFHQQD0DO¶R SHUDVLFRQFOXGHVHQ]DXQDSDURODGHILQLWLYDVXOPRGRLQFXLLOILORVRIRUHDOL] ]DODVXDXQLRQHFRQO¶,QWHOOHWWR$JHQWH'XQTXH,EQ%ƗMMDQRQRQRUDO¶LPSH JQRFKHVLHUDSUHILVVDWRFRPHEHQULPDUFD,EQؽXID\OFKHORJLXGLFDFRPHLO SL YLFLQR DOOD YHULWj IUD L VXRL SUHGHFHVVRUL PDDVVRUELWR GDO PRQGR SULPD FKHODOXPLQRVLWjGHOODVXDVFLHQ]DUDJJLXQJHVVHO¶DSLFHD\\EHQ<DTGKkQ S 4XDQWR D ,EQ ؽXID\O H $YHUURq QRQ SDUOHUDQQR DIIDWWR GHOO¶,QWHOOHWWR$JHQWHLOFKHDSSDUHWDQWRSLSUREOHPDWLFRGDWRFKH³D\\ LEQ<DT٤ƗQ´HUDLOQRPHGHOODSHUVRQLILFD]LRQHGLWDOH ,QWHOOHWWRQHOO¶RPRQL PRUDFFRQWRDYLFHQQLDQRHFKHLOFRPPHQWRD3ODWRQHQHWDFHTXDQGRSL DYUHEEH GRYXWR SDUODUQH FLRq GLVFXWHQGR GHOOD SHUIH]LRQH GHO ILORVRIR DOORU FKpDWWLQJHOHVFLHQ]HWHRUHWLFKH/HUQHUS /¶RSHUDGL,EQؽXID\OVHPEUDRIIULUHXQFRQWULEXWRUDGLFDOHDOODVROX]LR QHGLTXHVWRLQWHUURJDWLYR3UREOHPDWLFRJLjQHOODTXDOLILFDFRPHURPDQ]R %UJHOS ,EQ৫XID\OVLGLVFRVWzGDOO¶LGHDQHRSODWRQLFDGHOO¶XQLRQHFRQO¶,QWHOOHWWR$JHQWHLQIDYRUHGL XQ³PLVWLFLVPRILORVRILFR´%UJHOS 5DGWNHSRSSRQHDOO¶XQLRQHFRQO¶,QWHOOHWWR$JHQWHFKHVDUHEEHGLVFXVVDQRQVROR GD,EQ%ƗMMDHGDDO)ƗUƗEƯPDDQFKHGD$YHUURqXQ¶XQLRQHGLUHWWDFRQ'LRLQ ,EQ৫XID\O FKHDYYHUUHEEHJUD]LHDOڴDZT /¶HWLFKHWWDVDUHEEH GLVYLDQWH O¶LQWURGX]LRQH FRQIHULVFH LQIDWWL³VHULHWj ILORVRILFD´DOODWUDWWD ]LRQH+DZLESSS'LRSLQLRQHFRQWUDULD%UJHOS &LWWjSHUIHWWHHUHJLPLSROLWLFLQHOO¶,VODPDQGDOXVR QRQVROWDQWRO¶HVLWRILQDOHFRQODVFHOWDGHOO¶DEEDQGRQRGHOPRQGRGLIIHUHQ ]LDO¶DXWRUHWDQWRGDJOL2ULHQWDOLTXDQWRGDJOL$QGDOXVLSURORJRHFRQFOXVLRQH FRQWHQJRQRFULWLFKHUDGLFDOLDLSUHGHFHVVRULGDFXLQRQqHVHQWHQHSSXUHFROXL LOFXLSHQVLHURVHFRQGRXQDFHUWDLQWHUSUHWD]LRQH,EQؽXID\OVLDFFLQJHUHEEH DVSLHJDUH 6RSUDWWXWWRqVWDWDVRWWROLQHDWDODVFDUVDVLPSDWLDGL,EQؽXID\OSHUDO)Ɨ UƗEƯFKHWDFFLzGLDWHLVPRHGLFXLFULWLFzOHLGHHVXOODSURIH]LDHVXOGHVWLQR GHOO¶DQLPDGRSRODPRUWH0DODSUHIHUHQ]DGLDO)ƗUƗEƯSHUODILORVRILDPL QDYDODULYHOD]LRQHYDQLILFDQGRO¶HVSHULHQ]DGLD\\RSSXUHODFRQWHPSOD ]LRQH LQ VROLWXGLQH GL FRVWXL UHQGH GL IDWWR LQXWLOH OD UHOLJLRQH FKH DO)ƗUƗEƯ FRQVLGHUDYDDOPHQRFRPHXQ¶LPLWD]LRQHGHOODILORVRILD"/DSULPDDOWHUQDWL YDQRQqVRVWHQLELOHSHUFKpTXLODFRQRVFHQ]DGLD\\VDUHEEHXQDFRQRVFHQ ]D UHOLJLRVD FKH FRPH WDOH JOL DELWDQWL GHOO¶LVROD QRQ DYUHEEHUR ULILXWDWR /D VHFRQGD DOWHUQDWLYD UHQGHUHEEH LQYHFH EHQ FKLDUR LO PRWLYR GHOOR VFDFFR GL D\\HƖVƗO0DQHOODPLVXUDLQFXLODUHOLJLRQHYLHQH SUHVHQWDWD±DQFKH± FRPH XQ PH]]R SHU FRQVHUYDUH O¶RUGLQH H OD VLFXUH]]D HVVD FL ULSRUWD DOOD PHQWHLOFRQFHWWRGL³DUPDWXUDHVVRWHULFD´LPSRVWDVHFRQGR6WUDXVVDOODILOR VRILD SHU VRSUDYYLYHUH LQ GHWHUPLQDWH VRFLHWj/D SDUWH ILQDOH GL D\\ LEQ <DTܲƗQDYUHEEHDSSXQWRORVFRSRGLPRVWUDUHFRVDVLDLQDFFRUGRFRQODPR UDOHYLJHQWHHFRVDQRQGHEEDHVVHUHULYHODWR,QWDOFDVRSHUz,EQؽXID\O±DO PHQRLQDSSDUHQ]DVLQRWLFKHHJOLQHSSXUTXLULQXQFLDDOYHORGHOO¶DOOHJRULD ±VLDOOLQHHUHEEHVHPSOLFHPHQWHDOODSROLWLFDDOPRKDGHHVDUHEEHGLIILFLOHFD 'DLEHUS0DOOHWS $QFKHVHLQRPLGHLSURWDJRQLVWLVRQRULSUHVLGDFHOHEUL³UDFFRQWLYLVLRQDUL´GL$YLFHQQDSHU +DZL ,EQ ؽXID\O VHJXH JOL DQWLFKL QHOO¶XVR GHOO¶DOOHJRULD VROR SHU HVSRUUH LGHH SLHQDPHQWH RULJLQDOLESSHSFIU(ODPUDQL-DPDOS3HUDOFXQH DIILQLWjFROSHQVLHURGL$YLFHQQDFIU+RXUDQLSH%UJHOSSHUOHGL YHUJHQ]HSS%UJHOS +DZLDS$OODILQHSHUzDQFKH,EQؽXID\OFRQFOXGHUHEEHFRPHDO)ƗUƗEƯGLFHQ GRFKHO¶DQLPDGLD\\VLGLVWUXJJHUHEEHVHQRQDYHVVHUDJJLXQWRODYLVLRQHGHOO¶(VVHUHQH FHVVDULR 4XHVWD FRQWUDGGL]LRQH VL VSLHJD FRO IDWWR FKH JUD]LH DOO¶DOOHJRULD ,EQؽXID\O SRWp VRVWHQHUH HQWUDPEH OH SRVL]LRQL TXHOOD ILORVRILFD SHU FXL OH DQLPH GHL PDOYDJL VDUDQQR GL VWUXWWHGRSRODPRUWHHTXHOODUHOLJLRVDSHUFXLWXWWHOHDQLPHVRQRLPPRUWDOLSS &RVu+DZLDS &RVu'DLEHUS 3HUVHFXWLRQDQGWKH$UWRI:ULWLQJ,OOLQRLV*OHQFHSFLWLQ+RXUDQLS +RXUDQLSS &DUPHOD%DIILRQL SLUH SHUFKp HJOL IDFFLD ULIHULPHQWR QHO WLWROR GHOOD VXD RSHUD DOOD ³VDSLHQ]D RULHQWDOH´ ÊLPSRUWDQWHQRWDUHFKHLQD\\LEQ<DTܲƗQSHUODSULPDYROWDVLPHQ ]LRQDHVSOLFLWDPHQWHXQDUHOLJLRQH±HODUHOLJLRQHLVODPLFDSURIHVVDWDQHO O¶LVRODGDFXLYLHQHƖVƗOD\\EHQ<DTGKkQS1HOORVWHVVR WHPSRYLVLQDUUDGLXQRVFDFFRF¶qTXDOFXQRFKHYRUUHEEHVYROJHUHXQ¶DWWLYL WjGLGRFHQ]DDQ]LGLJXLGDPDFKHYLHQHULILXWDWRGDLSRWHQ]LDOLGLVFHQWL6H O¶LVRODqUHWWDGDOODãDUƯµDSHUFKpOD³YLD´GLD\\QRQqUHFHSLWDGDJOLDELWDQ WLGHOO¶LVRODGLƖVƗO"'LFKHWLSRqLOPHVVDJJLRUHVSLQWR" 'L VROLWR 6DOƗPƗQ H ƖVƗO VRQR LQGLFDWL FRPH L UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GHOOH GL PHQVLRQLHVVRWHULFDHGHVRWHULFDGHOODUHOLJLRQH'DOFROORTXLRFRQƖVƗOSUL PD GL GHFLGHUH SHU OD SUHGLFD]LRQH PL SDUH LQYHFHVL SRVVD GHGXUUH FKH q D\\LOGHSRVLWDULRGHOVLJQLILFDWRHVRWHULFRGHOOD5LYHOD]LRQH±PHQWUHƖVƗO QHqVHPSOLFHPHQWHDOODULFHUFD3RWUHPPRGXQTXHVXSSRUUHFKHODYLVLRQHGL D\\ SUHVHQWDWD GDOO¶DXWRUH FRPH O¶LQWHUSUHWD]LRQHHVRWHULFD GHOOD UHOLJLRQH SHUIHWWD VLD FRQWHQXWLVWLFDPHQWH PROWR VLPLOH D TXHOOD GHOO¶LPƗP ãƯµLWD FKH SHUO¶,VODPSRVVLHGHLQPRGRHPLQHQWHLOVLJQLILFDWRHVRWHULFRGHOOD/HJJH 0DTXDQGR,EQؽXID\OULPDUFDFKHODFRQRVFHQ]DGLD\\qVWDWDDFTXLVLWDX QLFDPHQWHFRQOHVXHSURSULHIRU]HHJOLPLUDHYLGHQWHPHQWHDGHOHJLWWLPDUQH O¶DVVLPLOD]LRQHTXDOLWDWLYDDTXHOODGHOO¶LPƗPFKHqLQYHFHHUHGLWDWD /H GRWWULQH RULHQWDOL DYHYDQR FRQIHULWR DOO¶LQWHOOH]LRQH XQD GLPHQVLRQH WHRORJLFDHVSLHJDWRODSURIH]LDPDVVLPRJUDGRGHOO¶LVSLUD]LRQHUHOLJLRVDFR PH XQ SURFHVVR FRJQLWLYR GHOO¶LQWHOOHWWR DFTXLVLWR FRQIHUPDQGR OD ILORVRILD FRPHODUHOLJLRQHGHJOLLQWHOOHWWXDOL&RQLORURVLOHQ]LULJXDUGRDOO¶,QWHOOHWWR $JHQWHJOL$QGDOXVLSRWUHEEHURDYHUYROXWRVIXJJLUHSURSULRDOO¶³LQWHOOHWWXD OL]]D]LRQH´ GHO PHVVDJJLR SURIHWLFR FKH FRQVHJXLYD GDO ULIHULPHQWR GHOO¶X QLRQHFRQWDOH,QWHOOHWWRDQFKHDO3URIHWD0DVHLOVLJQLILFDWRHVRWHULFRGHOOD 5LYHOD]LRQHSXzHVVHUFROWRVHQ]DDOFXQDLXWRFDGHORVWDWXWRSDUWLFRODUHGHO O¶LPƗPãƯµLWDHFRQHVVROH³FLWWjSHUIHWWH´FKHHJOLSRWUHEEHJXLGDUH 'DOODSDUWLFRODUHQDWXUDGHOO¶HVSHULHQ]DGLD\\VLqGHGRWWRFKHSHU,EQ ؽXID\O OD SUHRFFXSD]LRQH PDJJLRUH GHO ILORVRIR IRVVH OD FXUD GHOOD SURSULD 6HFRQGR%UJHOS,EQؽXID\OSDUODGHOO¶,VODPPDVHQ]DHVFOXGHUHOHDOWUHGXHUH OLJLRQLPRQRWHLVWLFKH%UJHOS1RQSHQVDLQYHFHDOO¶,VODP:DONHUS %UJHOSH>,EQ7XID\OH,EQ5XVKG@S[Y $QFKH(ODPUDQL-DPDOSQRVVHUYD±VLDSXUFRQGLYHUVRRELHWWLYRSROHPLFR± FKHO¶HVSHULHQ]DGLD\\VLULIHULVFHDOODYLVLRQHFRQWHPSODWLYDGHOODZLOƗ\D (QGUHVVS &LWWjSHUIHWWHHUHJLPLSROLWLFLQHOO¶,VODPDQGDOXVR DQLPDQRQLOUDSSRUWRGHOODILORVRILDFRQODUHOLJLRQHHQHSSXUHLOUXRORGHOOD UHOLJLRQHLQXQDVRFLHWj,OQXRYRULWUDUVLLQVROLWXGLQHGHLSURWDJRQLVWLVFDWXUL UHEEHGDOGHVWLQRLPSRVWRDOO¶DFFUHGLWD]LRQHUHOLJLRVDGHOODILORVRILDHGXQ TXHODVXDQRQVDUHEEHXQ¶RSHUDSROLWLFD0DSURSULRQHOJHQHUHSROLWLFRULHQ WUDO¶RSHUDVHWDOHHVSHULHQ]DVRVWLWXLVFHTXHOODGHOO¶LPƗPãƯµLWD 8QDSUHVDGLGLVWDQ]DGDOOHFRQQRWD]LRQLGHOO¶LPƗPãƯµLWDVLQRWDSHUDOWUR JLj LQ ,EQ %ƗMMD FKH DG RQWD GL TXDQWR RVVHUYDWR VXOOD VXD YLVLRQH GL WLSR ³SURIHWLFR´ GHQRPLQDQGRPXۊDGGD ܔOHWW ³FROXL D FXL VL SDUOD´ FKL ULFHYH O¶LVSLUD]LRQHGLYLQDPLUDYDDFDQFHOODUHTXDOVLDVLEDUOXPHGLTXHOODFRQRVFHQ ]DDXWRQRPDFKHLQYDULDPLVXUDORãƯµLVPRDFFRUGDYDDOSURIHWDHVRSUDWWXWWR DOO¶LPƗP 4XDQWR DG $YHUURq HJOL QRQ GDUj DOFXQD VSLHJD]LRQH SVLFRORJLFD GHOODSURIH]LDSHUOXLLO3URIHWDqXQSXUROHJLVODWRUHHTXDQGRGLFHFKHO¶L PƗPOHWW³FROXLFKHqVHJXLWRQHOOHVXHD]LRQL´/HUQHUSSXzHV VHUH FRUURWWR GD FLUFRVWDQ]H SROLWLFKH HG HFRQRPLFKH FKH OR VFUHGLWDQR QRQ SHQVDFHUWRDOO¶LQIDOOLELOHLPƗPãƯµLWD D\\LEQ<DTܲƗQVLSURSRQHFRPHVHGHG¶HOH]LRQHSHUGLVFXWHUHGHOODQD WXUDHGHJOLVFRSLGHOODILORVRILD±FRQODTXDOHVHFRQGRXQDFHUWDOHWWXUDOD WHRORJLDqLQFRQWUDVWRULJXDUGRDOO¶RULJLQHGHOODFRQRVFHQ]DHDOODIRQWHGHOOD IHOLFLWjIRFXVGHOODGLVFXVVLRQHqODSRVL]LRQHGHJOL2ULHQWDOLHGHJOL$QGD OXVLDULJXDUGR 4XHVWD LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH LPSOLFD XQ ULSHQVDPHQWR VXOOD QDWXUD GHOO¶HVSH ULHQ]D GLD\\ FKH QRQ YD FRQVLGHUDWD FRPH DQWLLQWHOOHWWXDOLVWLFD R LQWXLWL YDHDPDJJLRUUDJLRQHQHSSXUHPLVWLFD6HJLjVRQRVWDWHLQGLYLGXDWHLQ ,EQ ؽXID\O SUHFLVH PDWULFL ILORVRILFKHYD VRSUDWWXWWR FRQVLGHUDWR FKH QHOOD +RXUDQLSH0DOOHWS 5RVHQWKDOS 7RUQHURS ,EQ ؽXID\O q GXQTXH VSHVVR DFFRVWDWR DQFKH D 6XKUDZDUGƯ H DOO¶LãUƗT 5RVHQWKDO S Q+DZLSSHQ>,EQ7XID\OH,EQ5XVKG@S[LLLHSHUVL QRD,EQµ$UDEƯ%UJHOS 0DJDULVXOODOLQHDGHJOL³VWUDQLHUL´GL,EQ%ƗMMD5RVHQWKDOS6XXQDSSURFFLRGL WLSR³PLVWLFR´FIU+RXUDQLSS/DJDUGqUHS(QGUHVVS +DZLS0DOOHWS7RUQHURSSH &RPH TXHOOD DULVWRWHOLFD H QHRSODWRQLFD 'DLEHU S GL XQ ³DULVWRWHOLVPR´ GL ,EQ ؽXID\OSDUODYDJLj%UJHOSDWWULEXHQGRORSHUzDOO¶LQWHQWRGLFDWWXUDUHLOPDJJLRU QXPHURSRVVLELOHGLOHWWRULPDLQPDQFDQ]DGLSRVVLELOLWjGLVYLOXSSRSHUO¶DULVWRWHOLVPRSHU WUDVFHQGHUHODOHJJHUHOLJLRVDHJOLVDUHEEHVWDWRFRVWUHWWRDIDUULFRUVRDOPLVWLFLVPRS 'LLQIOXVVLQHRSODWRQLFLLQ,EQؽXID\OSDUOD+RXUDQLS &DUPHOD%DIILRQL FRQFOXVLRQH HJOL SDUOD GL XQ ³PHWRGR GHL WHRUHWL´ ܒDUƯTD DKO DOQDܲDU GHO TXDOHQRQFKLDULVFHHVSOLFLWDPHQWHODQDWXUDUDPPDULFDQGRVLSHUzFKHHVVR± SLUDURGHOOR]ROIRURVVRS±QRQSRVVDHVVHUHVHJXLWRDOVXRWHPSR 1RQ FUHGR FKH OD ORFX]LRQH VL ULIHULVFD DG $YLFHQQDEHQVu DSSXQWR D ,EQ ؽXID\O FRO FKH SDUUHEEH FKH HJOL YRJOLD GHVFULYHUHXQ LWLQHUDULR HVFOXVLYD PHQWHILORVRILFR ,QVRPPD ,EQؽXID\OVLVDUHEEHSRVWRIRUVHSUHFHGHQGRLOFHOHEHUULPR )DصODOPDTƗOVFULWWRSULPDGHOLOSUREOHPDGHOWD¶ZƯOGHLILOR VRILHTXLQGLGHOODORURSDUWHFLSD]LRQHDOODVFLHQ]DGLYLQDGLFXLLQ&RU,,, &RPH$YHUURqGjQDWXUDOPHQWHXQDULVSRVWDSRVLWLYDPDSHURSSRUUHLQ PRGR UDGLFDOH HVSHULHQ]D UHOLJLRVD HG HVSHULHQ]D ILORVRILFD3HU JOL ,পZƗQ DOৡDIƗ¶HDO)ƗUƗEƯOD YLUW SHUIHWWDFRQVLVWHQHOUDJJLXQJLPHQWRGHOODFRQR VFHQ]DGLYLQDHGXQTXHLOSLSHUIHWWRIUDJOLXRPLQLQRQSXzHVVHUHVHQRQ O¶LPƗPFKHFRPHJXLGDGHOODVXDFRPXQLWjDVVXPHLOUXRORGHOUHILORVRIRGL 3ODWRQH3HU$YLFHQQDLOILORVRIRGHYHSHQHWUDUHODYHULWjLQVLWDQHOODULYHOD ]LRQHQHLUpFLWVqLOOXVWUDWDLQPRGRLPPDJLQDWLYR±FLRqUHOLJLRVR±ODILORVR /R]ROIRURVVRqXQVLPERORDOFKHPLFRHVLULIHULVFHDOO¶DJHQWHFDSDFHGLWUDVIRUPDUHO¶DUJHQWR LQRURPDO¶HVSUHVVLRQHqXVDWDVSHVVRGDLصnjILSHULQGLFDUHPHWDIRULFDPHQWHO¶HFFHOOHQ]DGHO OLYHOORVSLULWXDOHUDJJLXQWRGDXQVDQWRRZDOƯ$GGDVSQ &RPHYXROH+DZLSFKHVXTXHVWDEDVHDVVHULVFHSQFKH,EQؽXID\O QRQDQQRYHUDYD$YLFHQQDIUDLPLVWLFL *LjSHU&UX]+HUQDQGH]HJOLUDSSUHVHQWDXQD³WHU]DYLD´IUDO¶HVRWHULVPRUDGLFDOHGL6XKUD ZDUGƯHO¶DULVWRWHOLVPRGHOODVFRODVWLFDODWLQDS,EQؽXID\OqSUHVHQWDWRFRPHQD WXUDOLVWDHVRORLQXQVHFRQGRWHPSRFRPHPLVWLFRGD+DZLDSHSSH 3HU%UJHOSVHGLVYLOXSSRGHOODPHQWHXPDQDVLGHYHSDUODUHVLDOOXGHSHUz D TXHOOD GL XQ ILORVRIR QHRSODWRQL]]DQWH FKH QRQ VL DFFRQWHQWD GL SDGURQHJJLDUH O¶DULVWRWHOL VPRPDGLDUULYDUHVLQRDOODYLVLRQHGL'LR 3HU&RQUDGSSO¶LSRWHVLFKHLOURPDQ]RVLDVWDWRVFULWWRGRSRLOQRQqGHOWXWWR DWWHQGLELOHHVVRSRWUHEEHHVVHUHVWDWRVFULWWRDGGLULWWXUDILQRDO 3HU(QGUHVVS$YHUURqDSURSRVLWRGHOIDUڲµDTOƯSURQXQFLzXQDYHUDHSURSULDID WZƗ 3URSULRFRQXQULIHULPHQWRDTXHVWRYHUVHWWRVLDSUH0DOOHWSHLO)D܈OTXDQWXQTXH VFHYUR GD PLVWLFLVPR q FRQVLGHUDWR XQ SURGRWWR GHOOD PHGHVLPD WUDGL]LRQH ILORVRILFD GL ,EQ ؽXID\O>,EQ7XID\OH,EQ5XVKG@SS[Y[YL %HQRVVHUYD&UX]+HUQiQGH]SFKH$YHUURqQRQDVVRFLz,EQؽXID\ODOODVXDFULWL FDGL$YLFHQQD >,EQ7XID\OH,EQ5XVKG@S[LL6RORJUD]LHDOWD¶ZƯOODFRQRVFHQ]DGLD\\DSSDULUj LGHQWLFDDTXHOODGLƖVƗO,OWD¶ZƯOVROOHYHUjGDOORVFHWWLFLVPRULVHUYDWRDOODUHOLJLRQH%UJHO SS &LWWjSHUIHWWHHUHJLPLSROLWLFLQHOO¶,VODPDQGDOXVR ILDDULVWRWHOLFDHODYLDSLDOWDSHUO¶DFTXLVL]LRQHGHOODYHULWjVLLGHQWLILFDFRQ TXHOODGHOµDTOTXGVƯO¶³LQWHOOHWWRVDQWR´GHO3URIHWDD\\LQYHFHVFRSUHVHQ ]D LQWHUD]LRQL XPDQH L SULQFLSL VLD GHOOD ILORVRILD FKH GHOOD UHOLJLRQH,Q WDO PRGRHJOLVLRSSRQHDLSHQVDWRULRULHQWDOLSHULTXDOLLOWD¶ZƯOqSRVVLELOHSUH YLDLGHQWLILFD]LRQHGHOILORVRIRFRQO¶LPƗPãƯµLWD3HUTXHVWRGRSRORVFDFFR ƖVƗOULWUDWWDSXEEOLFDPHQWHOHSURSULHSRVL]LRQLHDFFHWWDFKHLSDVVLRVFXULGHO WHVWRVDFURVLDQRDFFROWLVRORSHUIHGHHFKHOHLQQRYD]LRQLPXۊDGGDܔƗWVLD QRPHVVHGDSDUWHSS4XL,EQؽXID\OVHPEUDDFFRJOLHUHOD OHWWXUDWUDGL]LRQDOHGL&RU,,,LQYLVWDGHOIDWWRFKHODUHOLJLRQHLVODPLFDH ODOHJJHPXDPPDGLFDVFRUDJJLDQRO¶DSSUHQGLPHQWRGHO³PHWRGRGHLWHRUHWL´ HQRQVHQHILGDQRS $TXHVWRSXQWRSRWUHEEHHVVHUOHJLWWLPRFKLHGHUVLSHUFKpO¶DWWLYLWjGLGR FHQ]D QRQ SRVVD HVVHUH VYROWD GDL ILORVRIL$QFRUD XQD YROWD OD ULVSRVWD GL ,EQؽXID\OSUHFRUUHUjTXHOODGL$YHUURqSHULOTXDOHJOLDOWULFLWWDGLQLQRQVH JXLUHEEHURLOILORVRIRHFRPXQTXHODPDJJLRUSDUWHGLFRORURFKHVLGHGLFDQR DOODILORVRILDVRQRWXWW¶DOWURFKHSHUIHWWL/HUQHUSSHJOLRVVHU YHUjFKHSHUVLQRLSRFKLGRWDWLGLFRQRVFHQ]DDYYLFLQDWLGDD\\HƖVƗOD\\ EHQ<DTGKkQSVLDOORQWDQDQRGDORURDFDXVDGHOODORURLP SHUIH]LRQHSHVVHQGRDQFK¶HVVLVRPPHUVLGDOO¶LJQRUDQ]DS H FULWLFKHUj VLVWHPDWLFDPHQWH L SURSUL SUHGHFHVVRUL QHOO¶LQWURGX]LRQH H QHO SURORJR'¶DOWURQGH LO ³PHWRGR GHL WHRUHWL´ SXz HVVHUHDFTXLVLWR VROWDQWR GD XQDSHUVRQDDOODYROWDSHTXL,EQؽXID\ODOOXGHIRUVHDVHVWHVVR'D TXHVWDRSSRVL]LRQHVFDWXULVFHLOSHVVLPLVPRFKHqDQWLWHWLFRDOODILORVRILDSR OLWLFDGHJOL2ULHQWDOL :DONHUS +RXUDQLSVRWWROLQHDO¶DVVROXWDGLYHUVLWjGHOURPDQ]RGL,EQؽXID\OGDO)D܈OHGDL VXRLSURSRVLWLFRQFLOLDWRULGLILORVRILDHUHOLJLRQH Ê VWDWR GHWWR FKH LOSHVVLPLVPR GL ,EQ %ƗMMD SLFKH DOIDWWRFKH ODFRQRVFHQ]DFRQGL]LRQH GHOODIHOLFLWjIRVVHULWHQXWDFRQVHJXLELOHFRQODILORVRILDHQRQDWWUDYHUVROD5LYHOD]LRQHHUD GRYXWRDOIDWWRFKHODFRQRVFHQ]DSRUWDVuD'LRHYLHQHGDLSURIHWLPDQRQF¶qELVRJQRGHOOD 5LYHOD]LRQHSHUJXLGDUHODFRPXQLWj5RVHQWKDOSSHUVLQRSHU1DMMDUSS ODYHUDIHOLFLWjqGDWDGDOODILORVRILDPDODIHOLFLWjXPDQDqDVVLFXUDWDGDOODILORVRILD SROLWLFDQRQGDOODUHOLJLRQH4XDQWRDG$YHUURqHJOLFRPPHQWDQGROD5HSXEEOLFDDYHYDLQ PHQWHO¶LGHQWLILFD]LRQHGHOORVWDWRLGHDOHFRQTXHOORLVODPLFRHGXQTXHO¶DIIHUPD]LRQHGHOOD VXSHULRULWjGHOODOHJJHUHOLJLRVD5RVHQWKDOSO¶DWWHJJLDPHQWRQHJDWLYRULJXDUGR DOO¶LPSHJQR SROLWLFR GHO ILORVRIR H DOOD VXD FDSDFLWj GL SURYYHGHUH DOOD IHOLFLWj GHOO¶XRPR VL VSLHJDDOORUDFROIDWWRFKHLOILORVRIRQRQqLQJUDGRGLHPDQDUHOHJJLFKHVLUDGLFKLQRQHO&R UDQRSFRQULIHULPHQWRDO7DKƗIXWS D\\qLQHIIHWWLPDHVWUR%UJHOSPDVRORGLƖVƗO &DUPHOD%DIILRQL 4XDOqDOORUDLOVHJUHWRGHOODVDSLHQ]DRULHQWDOH"(VVRVHPEUDFRQVLVWHUH QHOO¶LQIRQGDWH]]DGLRJQLULIHULPHQWRDOSURIHWLVPRVXOSLDQRJQRVHRORJLFR,Q WDOVHQVRO¶RSHUDGL,EQؽXID\OSLFKHXQDSSURIRQGLPHQWRDSSDUHXQDFRQ IXWD]LRQHGHOODQDWXUDGHOODILORVRILDRULHQWDOHTXDOHUDQRWDDOVXRWHPSRTXD VLODGHQXQFLDGLXQD³PLVWLILFD]LRQH´HJOLLQIDWWLFLGLFHGLHVVHUHVWDWRVSLQWR DULYHODUHLOVHJUHWRGHOOD³ILORVRILDRULHQWDOH´GDDOFXQHLGHHHUUDWHLQYRJDDO VXR WHPSR H GDOOH EXJLH GHJOL SVHXGRILORVRIL SS ,EQ ؽXID\O SRWUHEEHFLRqDYHUYROXWRSHUIH]LRQDUHO¶LPSUHVDFKH,EQ%ƗMMDDYHYDFRPSLX WRVRORSDU]LDOPHQWHFRQGLYLGHQGRQHO¶³LQWHOOHWWXDOLVPR´±SHUTXDQWRVLD RSSRUWXQRULPDUFDUHFKHDQFK¶HJOLQRQIDFKHSUHVHQWDUHGLHWURLOYHORGHOO¶DO OHJRULDGHOODYLVLRQHGLD\\OR³VWDWR´LQFXLVLWURYDFKLO¶KDUDJJLXQWR /jGRYHOHVROX]LRQLRULHQWDOLVXSHUDYDQRLOSUREOHPDGHOO¶DFFRUGRIUDIL ORVRILDHUHOLJLRQHPDQLIHVWDWRVLFRQODQDVFLWDGHOODILORVRILDLQDO.LQGƯVXO SLDQRGHLFRQWHQXWLLO³YXRWR´ODVFLDWRGDOORãƯµLVPRVDUjULHPSLWRLQ$QGDOXV GDOGLEDWWLWRVXOUDSSRUWRIUDIHGHHUDJLRQH&LzSHUzGLYHUUjHYLGHQWHVROR FRQ$YHUURq&LzFKHVLYXROHDIIHUPDUHLQD\\LEQ<DTܲƗQQRQqO¶RSSR VL]LRQHIUDODUHOLJLRQHLVODPLFDHLOVXRVLJQLILFDWRHVRWHULFRPDTXHOODIUD ODGRFHQ]DUHOLJLRVDHODGRFHQ]DILORVRILFD6HEEHQHLQWHRULDLQTXDQWRUD ]LRQDOHO¶HVSHULHQ]DGLD\\VLDDOODSRUWDWDGLFKLXQTXHLOFRQIURQWRFRQJOL DELWDQWLGHOODFLWWj±VHEEHQHUHWWLGDOODUHOLJLRQHSHUIHWWD±VFRQVLJOLDTXDOVLDVL WHQWDWLYR GL DYYLFLQDUOL DOOD YHULWj ILORVRILFD3HU ,EQ ؽXID\O XQ¶HVSHULHQ]D ,EQ%ƗMMDQRQDYUHEEHPDQWHQXWRODVXDSURPHVVDIRUVHSHUFKpJOLHQHPDQFzLOWHPSRIRUVH SHUWLPRUHGLHVVHUHIUDLQWHVRRIRUVHDFDXVDGHOOHVXHGHEROH]]HPRUDOLSSH± 7RUQHURS$]DQ]D(OtRSSEHQFKpHJOLVHPEULWDORUDGHVFULYHUH XQ¶HVSHULHQ]D PLVWLFD /DJDUGqUH SS (ODPUDQL-DPDO S SDUOD GL ³PLVWLFDLQWHOOHWWXDOLVWLFD´PDVRWWROLQHDQGRFKHQHOO¶(SLVWRODGHOO¶$GGLR,EQ%ƗMMDFULWLFDYD FRPH³LPPDJLQD]LRQHFKHSUHWHQGHGLVRVWLWXLUVLDOODYHULWj´OHHVSHULHQ]HPLVWLFKHGHO0XQ TLڴSQ %UJHOSSDUODGL³OLQJXLVWLFPHGLDWLRQVRIHVRWHULFWUXWKV´ 4XHVWLRQH FKH QRQ LQWHUHVVzSHUz ,EQؽXID\O +RXUDQL SSFRQWUR *DXWKLHU H 5RVHQWKDOSQ/DILORVRILDSXzHVVHUHFRQFLOLDWDFRQODUHOLJLRQHVRORHVVRWH ULFDPHQWH1DMMDUS &IUSHV%UJHOS %UJHOS 6HFRQGR%UJHOSVHEEHQHQRQVHJXDLOFXUULFXOXPWUDGL]LRQDOHGHLILORVRIL,EQ ؽXID\OVRVWLHQHFKHODILORVRILDSXzGDUHLQVHJQDPHQWRUHOLJLRVR'DLEHUSSVL &LWWjSHUIHWWHHUHJLPLSROLWLFLQHOO¶,VODPDQGDOXVR JQRVHRORJLFDVLDSXUFXOPLQDQWHLQXQDYLVLRQHGLWLSRUHOLJLRVRQRQSXzVR VWLWXLUHDOLYHOORGLGRFHQ]DO¶DSSOLFD]LRQHJLXULGLFDGLXQD/HJJHUHOLJLRVD 6H q XQ WDµOƯP GL WLSR ãƯµLWD TXHOOR FKH JOL DELWDQWL GHOO¶LVRODULILXWDQRD\\ LEQ<DTܲƗQFLRIIULUHEEHXQDPRWLYD]LRQHWHRUHWLFDGHOSHUFKpORãƯµLVPRQRQ DWWHFFKuLQ$QGDOXV1DWXUDOPHQWHSRLFKpODYHULWjqXQDVRODLOYDORUHGHO O¶HVSHULHQ]DJQRVHRORJLFDLYLGHVFULWWDUHVWDLQWDWWRORVFDFFRqVRORGHOODUHOL JLRQHYLJHQWHFKHQRQqLQJUDGRGLFRPSUHQGHUQHODQDWXUD,OSHVVLPLVPR GXQTXHKDYDOHQ]DPHUDPHQWHSROLWLFD /D SUHVHQWH OHWWXUD GLD\\ LEQ <DTܲƗQ WLHQH FRQWR GHOOD UHOD]LRQH GHO O¶DXWRUHFRQDOƤD]ƗOƯPEHQGLYHUVDGDTXHOODGL$YHUURqLQWHUHVVDWR VROWDQWRDUHVSLQJHUHJOLDUJRPHQWLSROHPLFLGHOWHRORJRFRQWURLILORVRILSUH WHVLLQWHUSUHWLGHOOD3DURODGLYLQD,QHIIHWWLVRORDOƤD]ƗOƯqDOPHQRLQSDUWH ULVSDUPLDWRGDOOHDFFXVHGL,EQؽXID\OSSH3HUOXLLOIDW WR FKH L ILORVRIL ULVHUYDVVHUR O¶DOOHJRULD DL SURIHWL HTXLYDOHYD D VPLQXLUOLH SUREDELOPHQWH VX TXHVWD OLQHD ,EQ ؽXID\O FULWLFD LO ULIHULPHQWR GL DO)ƗUƗEƯ FKLHGHVHTXHOODGLD\\SRVVDHVVHUHFRQVLGHUDWDFRPHJLjQHO¶XQDIRUPDVXSHULRUHGL UHOLJLRQH 6XOOD SUHWHVD LPPDJLQH GL XQ DO$QGDOXV VHQ]D HUHVLH ELGDµ ± H VHQ]D VFLLVPR FIU )LHUUR 6HO¶KRLQWHVDFRUUHWWDPHQWHQRQFUHGRTXLQGLFRQGLYLVLELOHO¶LGHDGL(ODPUDQL-DPDO S FKH RJJHWWR GHOO¶LQVHJQDPHQWR GL ,EQ ؽXID\O VDUj O¶HVSHULHQ]D FRQWHPSODWLYD SURSULDGHOO¶DXWRUH ,EQ ؽXID\O FULWLFD DOFXQL DVSHWWL GHOO¶,VODP HVVRWHULFRGHO VXR WHPSR /¶DPELJXLWj GHOOD VXD SRVL]LRQHDSSDUHDOORUFKpVLULYROJHDJOLDELWDQWLGHOO¶LVRODFRQXQ YHUVHWWRFKHDOOXGHDLPL VFUHGHQWL1HOORVWHVVRWHPSRORVWDWRPLVWLFRGLD\\KDDPRGHOOROD%LEELD,VDLDH QRQLO&RUDQRHSRFRLPSRUWDO¶DIILQLWjGLWDOHHVSHULHQ]DFRQXQۊDGƯܔTXGVƯ%UJHO SSHSS 1RQDFDVR%UJHOSRVVHUYDFKHLOULWLURGHLSURWDJRQLVWLGDOPRQGRqXQGLVWDFFR GD FKL FRPH DUPHQWL FIU &RU ;;9 QRQ q LQ JUDGR GL UHFHSLUH DOFXQWD¶ZƯO %UJHO S VL q FKLHVWR VH ,EQ ؽXID\O QRQ SRVVD HVVHUH FRQVLGHUDWR XQ ³FULSWRHUHWLFR´ 1RQ FUHGR LQYHFH FKH HJOL YROHVVH DVVHULUHFKH OD OHJJH UHOLJLRVD KDVXSUHPD]LD VXOODFRQR VFHQ]DUD]LRQDOH5RFKH$UQDVS ,EQؽXID\ODOFRQWUDULRDWWLQJHDPSLDPHQWHDOILORVRIRDãµDULWD(ODPUDQL-DPDOS +DZL SS FRQ ULVHUYH HVSUHVVHDS 5DGWNH SS 7RUQHURSS )RUVHSHUzQRQQHOVHQVRLSRWL]]DWRGD5DGWNHSFLRqFKH,EQؽXID\OVPLQXLUHEEH ODFULWLFDGLDOƤD]ƗOƯHGHOصnjILVPRGDSDUWHGL,EQ%ƗMMD 1DMMDUS &DUPHOD%DIILRQL GHOODIDQWDVLDDOSURIHWD4XDQWRDOO¶LPƗPDWRVWDYDPROWRDFXRUHDGDOƤD ]ƗOƯ PD VROR SHUFKp XQ FDOLIIR OHJLWWLPR HUD QHFHVVDULR SHU OD YDOLGLWj GHOOD /HJJH QRQ SHUFKp HJOL OR YHGHVVH FRPH LO JRYHUQDQWH LGHDOH 8QD ³VFLHQ]D SROLWLFD´ FRPH TXHOOD IƗUƗELDQD QRQ DYHYD SRVWR QHO VXR SHQVLHUR O¶RJJHWWR GHOODVL\ƗVDHUDFRQVLGHUDWRQHO0XQTLסFRPHHVFOXVLYDPHQWHPRQGDQROHJD WRFLRqDOVXOWDQRIRQGDPHQWRQHHUDODOHJJHULYHODWDPHQWUHHUDLQDFFHWWD ELOHO¶LGHDGHO3URIHWDFRPHILORVRIRVXSUHPR 6HODPLDLQWHUSUHWD]LRQHqVRVWHQLELOHLOURPDQ]RGL,EQؽXID\ODSSDUH GHGLFDWRSLDOSHQVLHURGHJOL2ULHQWDOLLQJHQHUHFKHQRQDOODILORVRILDRULHQ WDOH GL $YLFHQQD OD ULSUHVD GL DOFXQL GHL QRPL GHL UpFLWV SRWUHEEH HVVHUH XQ VHPSOLFHPRGRGLUDFFRUGDUVLDTXHOSHQVLHURQHOODVXDJOREDOLWj6HSRLO¶RSH UD VL FRQVLGHUD FRPH XQD UHIXWD]LRQH GHOOR ãƯµLVPR ,EQ ؽXID\O VL LQVHULUj D SLHQR WLWROR QHO ILORQH GHL ILORVRIL SROLWLFL PXVXOPDQL H OH GRWWULQH SROLWLFKH GHLSHQVDWRULDQGDOXVLVDUDQQRVWDWHULFRPSUHVHQHOODOLQHDGLTXHOOHGHJOL2 ULHQWDOL &RQ,EQؽXID\OLOGLVFRUVRVXOO¶LQVHSDUDELOLWjGHOO¶DXWRULWjUHOLJLRVDHSR OLWLFDVLFKLXGHLQPRGRGHILQLWLYRHGDWRFKHODSRVWDLQJLRFRqLOUDSSRUWR IUDJOLDVSHWWLHVRWHULFRHGHVVRWHULFRGHOOD5LYHOD]LRQHODPRWLYD]LRQHWHRULFD QH q O¶LQDPPLVVLELOLWj GHOOD FRQQRWD]LRQH HSLVWHPRORJLFD GHOO¶LPƗP ãƯµLWD H DQFKH LQ TXHVWR HJOL SRWUHEEH HVVHUVL IRQGDWR VXOOH EHQ QRWH SRVL]LRQL DQWL LVPƗµƯOLWHGLDOƤD]ƗOƯ %,%/,2*5$),$ $GGDV&4XHVWIRUWKH5HG6XOSKXU7KH/LIHRI,EQµ$UDEƯ7UDQVODWHGIURPWKH)UHQFK E\3HWHU.LQJVOH\&DPEULGJH7KH,VODPLF7H[W6RFLHW\HGRU*DOOLPDUG $YHPSDFH,OUHJLPHGHOVROLWDULR0&DPSDQLQL$,OOXPLQDWLDFWHVWRDUDERDIURQ WH0LODQR5L]]ROL $]DQ]D (OtR $ ³$OJXQRV DVSHFWRV GH OD SROtWLFD GH $YHPSDFH HQ (O UpJLPHQ GHO VROL WDULRF´LQ-0$\DOD0DUWtQH]HG$YHUURHV\ORVDYHUURtVPRVDFWDVGHO (VVDDYUHEEHGRYXWRDLXWDUORDUHSHULUHLVLPEROLDWWLDVSLHJDUHDOOHPDVVHOHYHULWjGRQDWHJOL GDOO¶,QWHOOHWWR$JHQWHPDGLIUDLQWHQGLPHQWRSDUOD+DZLDS -DQVVHQVS (QGUHVVSS 6HEEHQHIRUVH,EQؽXID\OULWHQHVVHLOVXRPHWRGRSLHIILFDFHGHOVLPEROLVPRƥD]DOLDQR+D ZLS &LWWjSHUIHWWHHUHJLPLSROLWLFLQHOO¶,VODPDQGDOXVR ,,,&RQJUHVR1DFLRQDOGH)LORVRILD0HGLHYDO=DUDJR]D6RFLHGDGGH)LORVRItD0HGLHYDO SS %DIILRQL & ³$OPDGƯQDK DOIƗןLODK LQ DO)ƗUƗEƯ DQG LQ WKH ,NKZƗQ DOشDIƗ¶ D FRP SDULVRQ´LQ6/HGHU+.LOSDWULFN%0DUWHO7KRXPLDQ+6FK|QLJHGV6WXGLHVLQ $UDELFDQG,VODP/HXYHQ3HHWHUV2ULHQWDOLD/RYDQHQVLD$QDOHFWDSS ² ³,GHRORJLFDO 'HEDWH DQG 3ROLWLFDO (QFRXQWHU LQ WKH ,পZƗQ $OৡDIƗ¶´ LQ $ 3HOOLWWHUL DF0D÷Ɨ]&XOWXUHHFRQWDWWLQHOO¶DUHDGHO0HGLWHUUDQHR,OUXRORGHOO¶,VODP3DOHUPR 8QLYHUVLWjGL3DOHUPRSS ²³7HPSRUDODQG5HOLJLRXV&RQQRWDWLRQVRIWKHµ5HJDO3ROLF\¶LQWKH,NKZƗQDOشDIƗ¶´ LQ ( *DQQDJp 3 &URQH 0 $RXDG HGV 7KH *UHHN 6WUDQG LQ ,VODPLF 3ROLWLFDO 7KRXJKW3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH+HOGDWWKH,QVWLWXWHIRU$GYDQFHG6WXG\3ULQFH WRQ-XQH%HLUXW0pODQJHVGHO¶8QLYHUVLWp6DLQW-RVHSKSS ²³+LVWRU\/DQJXDJHDQG,GHRORJ\LQWKH,NKZƗQDOشDIƗ¶9LHZRIWKH,PƗPDWH´LQ% 0LFKDODN3LNXOVND $ 3LNXOVNL HGV $XWKRULW\ 3ULYDF\ DQG 3XEOLF 2UGHU LQ ,VODP /HXYHQ3HHWHUVSS ²³)XUWKHUHOHPHQWVRQWKHSROLWLFDOFRPPLWPHQWRIWKH,NKZDQDOৡDID¶´LQ'%UHGL /&DSH]]RQH:'DKPDVK/5RVWDJQRDF6FULWWLLQRQRUHGL%LDQFDPDULD6FDUFLD $PRUHWWLYROO5RPD(GL]LRQL4YRO,SS ²³3URSKHF\,PDPDWHDQG3ROLWLFDO5XOHLQWKH,NKZƗQDOصDIƗ¶´LQ$$IVDUXGGLQHG ,VODP WKH 6WDWH DQG 3ROLWLFDO $XWKRULW\ 0HGLHYDO ,VVXHV DQG 0RGHUQ &RQFHUQV 1HZ <RUN3DOJUDYH0DFPLOODQSS %UJHO-&³,EQؽXID\ODQGKLVD\\,EQ<DT٤ƗQ$7XUQLQJ3RLQWLQ$UDELF3KLORVRSKL FDO:ULWLQJ´ LQ 6. -D\\XVL HG7KH /HJDF\RI 0XVOLP6SDLQ /HLGHQ ± 1HZ <RUN ± .|OQ%ULOOSS ²³µ6\PEROVDQG+LQWV¶6RPH&RQVLGHUDWLRQVFRQFHUQLQJWKH0HDQLQJRI,EQؽXID\O¶V D\\ LEQ <DTܲƗQ´ LQ /, &RQUDG HG7KH :RUOG RI ,EQ ؽXID\O ,QWHUGLVFLSOLQDU\ 3HU VSHFWLYHVRQD\\LEQ<DTƗQ/HLGHQ±1HZ<RUN±.|OQ%ULOOSS %XVWƗQƯ % HG 5DVƗ¶LO ,NKZƗQ DO܇DIƗ¶ ZD ۏXOOƗQ DO:DIƗ¶ YROV %D\UnjW 'ƗU DO ৡƗGLU &RQUDG/,³,QWURGXFWLRQ7KH:RUOGRI,EQؽXID\O´LQ/,&RQUDGHG7KH:RUOGRI ,EQ ؽXID\O ,QWHUGLVFLSOLQDU\ 3HUVSHFWLYHV RQ D\\ LEQ <DTƗQ /HLGHQ ± 1HZ <RUN ± .|OQ%ULOOSS &RUQHOO9-³D\\LQWKH/DQGRI$EVƗO,EQؽXID\ODQGشnjILVPLQWKH:HVWHUQ0DƥULE GXULQJ WKH 0XZDLG (UD´ LQ /, &RQUDG HG7KH :RUOG RI ,EQ ؽXID\O ,QWHUGLVFLSOL QDU\3HUVSHFWLYHVRQD\\LEQ<DTƗQ/HLGHQ±1HZ<RUN±.|OQ%ULOOSS &UX] +HUQiQGH] 0 ³,VODPLF 7KRXJKW LQ WKH ,EHULDQ 3HQLQVXOD´ LQ 6. -D\\XVL HG 7KH/HJDF\RI0XVOLP6SDLQ/HLGHQ±1HZ<RUN±.|OQ%ULOOSS 'DLEHU +³7KH UHFHSWLRQ RI ,VODPLFSKLORVRSK\ DW 2[IRUG LQ WKH WK FHQWXU\ WKH 3R FRFNV¶IDWKHUDQGVRQFRQWULEXWLRQWRWKH XQGHUVWDQGLQJRI ,VODPLFSKLORVRSK\LQ(XUR SH´LQ&(%XWWHUZRUWK%$.HVVHOHGV7KHLQWURGXFWLRQRI$UDELFSKLORVRSK\LQWR (XURSH/HLGHQ%ULOOSS (ODPUDQL-DPDO$³([SpULHQFHGHODYLVLRQFRQWHPSODWLYHHWIRUPHGXUpFLWFKH],EQؽX ID\O´LQ0$$PLU0RH]]LpG/HYR\DJHLQLWLDWLTXHHQWHUUHG¶,VODP$VFHQVLRQVFp OHVWHVHWLWLQpUDLUHVVSLULWXHOV/HXYHQ±3DULV3HHWHUVSS (QGUHVV*³7KHGHIHQVHRIUHDVRQWKHSOHDIRUSKLORVRSK\LQWKHUHOLJLRXVFRPPXQLW\´ LQ=HLWVFKULIWIU*HVFKLFKWHGHU$UDELVFK,VODPLVFKHQ:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ0DMDOODW7ƗUƯNKDO µ8OnjPDOµ$UDEƯ\DZD¶O,VOƗPƯ\DSS $O)ƗUƗEƯ6FULWWLSROLWLFLLQ0&DPSDQLQLDF7RULQR87(7 &DUPHOD%DIILRQL )LHUUR0,³+HUHV\LQDO$QGDOXV´LQ6.-D\\XVLHG7KH/HJDF\RI0XVOLP6SDLQ /HLGHQ±1HZ<RUN±.|OQ%ULOOSS +DZL66D³$VSHFWVRIDO)ƗUƗEƯ¶VWKRXJKWLQWKHOLJKWRI,EQ7XID\O>VLF@FULWLFLVP´LQ ,VODPLF6WXGLHV,VODPDEDGSS ²E³3KLORVRSKXVDXWRGLGDFWXV+HOOHQLFDQG0XVOLPWUDGLWLRQV´LQ,VODPLF6WXGLHV,VOD PDEDGSS ²³,EQؽXID\O RQ ,EQ 6LQDDQG DOƤD]]DOL¶V 9LHZV $Q (YDOXDWLRQ RI 6RPH $VSHFWV RI ,EQؽXID\OV¶V7KRXJKW´LQ,TEDO5HYLHZSS D\\EHQ<DTGKkQ5RPDQSKLORVRSKLTXHG¶,EQ7KRIDwO7H[WHDUDEH«HWWUDGXFWLRQIUDQ oDLVH«SDU/*DXWKLHU«%H\URXWK,PSULPHULH&DWKROLTXHHpG +RXUDQL *) ³7KH SULQFLSDO VXEMHFW RI ,EQ ؽXID\O¶V ۉD\\ LEQ <DTܲƗQ´ LQ -RXUQDO RI 1HDU(DVWHUQ6WXGLHVSS ,EQ %ƗǔǔD $YHPSDFH(O 5pJLPHQGHO VROLWDULR>7DGEƯU DOPXWDZDۊۊLG@ ,QWURGXFFLyQ WUDGXFFLyQ\QRWDVGH-/RPED0DGULG(GLWRULDO7URWWD >,EQ7XID\OH,EQ5XVKG@7ZR$QGDOXVLDQSKLORVRSKHUV7KHVWRU\RI+D\\LEQ<DT]DQQ E\ $EX %DNU 0XKDPPDG ,EQ ؽXID\O 7KH GHILQLWLYH VWDWHPHQW E\ $EX ¶O :DOLG 0X KDPPDG LEQ 5XVKG 7UDQVODWHG IURP WKH $UDELF ZLWK DQ LQWURGXFWLRQ DQG QRWHV E\ -LP &ROYLOOH/RQGRQ±1HZ<RUN7KH.HJDQ3DXO$UDELD/LEUDU\YRO9, -DQVVHQV-$OƤD]]ƗOƯ¶V3ROLWLFDO7KRXJKW(OHPHQWVRI*UHHN3KLORVRSKLFDO,QIOXHQFHLQ (*DQQDJp3&URQH0$RXDGHGV7KH*UHHN6WUDQGLQ,VODPLF3ROLWLFDO7KRXJKW 3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH+HOGDWWKH,QVWLWXWHIRU$GYDQFHG6WXG\3ULQFHWRQ -XQH%HLUXW0pODQJHVGHO¶8QLYHUVLWp6DLQW-RVHSKSS .UDHPHU-/3KLORVRSK\LQWKH5HQDLVVDQFHRI,VODP$Enj6XOD\PƗQDO6LMLVWƗQƯDQGKLV &LUFOH/HLGHQ%ULOO ²³7KHMLKƗGRIWKHIDOƗVLID´LQ-HUXVDOHP6WXGLHVLQ$UDELFDQG,VODPSS ² +XPDQLVP LQ WKH 5HQDLVVDQFH RI ,VODP 7KH &XOWXUH 5HYLYDO GXULQJ WKH %X\LG $JH /HLGHQ±1HZ<RUN±.|OQ%ULOOQGHG /DJDUGqUH9³/¶eSvWUHG¶,EQ%kMMDVXUODFRQMRQFWLRQGHO¶LQWHOOHFWDYHFO¶HVSULWKXPDLQ´ LQ5HYXHGHV(WXGHV,VODPLTXHVSS /HUQHU5$YHUURHVRQ3ODWR¶V³5HSXEOLF´7UDQVODWHGZLWKDQ,QWURGXFWLRQDQG1RWHV ,WKDFD/RQGRQ&RUQHOO8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV 0DOOHW'³4XLHQVHLJQHTXL"´LQ$UDELF6FLHQFHDQG3KLORVRSK\SS 1DMMDU)³)ƗUƗEƯ¶VSROLWLFDOSKLORVRSK\DQG6KLµLVP´LQ6WXGLD,VODPLFDSS 5DGWNH%³+RZ&DQ0DQ5HDFKWKH0\VWLFDO8QLRQ",EQؽXID\ODQGWKH'LYLQH6SDUN´ LQ/,&RQUDGHG7KH:RUOGRI,EQؽXID\O,QWHUGLVFLSOLQDU\3HUVSHFWLYHVRQD\\LEQ <DTܲƗQ/HLGHQ±1HZ<RUN±.|OQ%ULOOSS 5RFKH$UQDV3³(OJRYHUQDQWH\HOJRELHUQRUHFWRHQOD([SRVLFLyQGHOD©5HS~EOLFDªGH 3ODWyQGH$YHUURHV´LQ-0$\DOD0DUWtQH]HG$YHUURHV\ORVDYHUURtVPRVDFWDVGHO ,,,&RQJUHVR1DFLRQDOGH)LORVRILD0HGLHYDO=DUDJR]D6RFLHGDGGH)LORVRItD0HGLHYDO SS 5RVHQWKDO(3ROLWLFDO7KRXJKWLQ0HGLHYDO,VODP$Q,QWURGXFWRU\2XWOLQH&DPEULGJH DWWKH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV ²$YHUURHV¶&RPPHQWDU\RQ3ODWR¶V5HSXEOLF(GLWHGZLWKDQ,QWURGXFWLRQ7UDQVODWLRQ DQG1RWHV&DPEULGJHDWWKH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVVWHG 6WHUQ 60 ³1HZ ,QIRUPDWLRQ DERXW WKH $XWKRUV RI WKH µ(SLVWOHV RI WKH 6LQFHUH %UHWK UHQ¶´LQ,VODPLF6WXGLHV,VODPDEDGSS 7RUQHUR(³6REUHODJpQHVLV\ODLQWHQFLyQGHµ(OILOyVRIRDXWRGLGDFWR¶´LQ$O4DQؾDUD 5HYLVWDGH(VWXGLRV$UDEHVSS &LWWjSHUIHWWHHUHJLPLSROLWLFLQHOO¶,VODPDQGDOXVR :DONHU3(³3KLORVRSK\RI5HOLJLRQLQDO)ƗUƗEƯ,EQ6ƯQƗDQG,EQؽXID\O´LQ7/DZ VRQHG5HDVRQDQG,QVSLUDWLRQLQ,VODP7KHRORJ\3KLORVRSK\DQG0\VWLFLVPLQ0XV OLP7KRXJKW(VVD\VLQ+RQRXURI+HUPDQQ/DQGROW/RQGRQ1HZ<RUN,%7DXULVLQ DVVRFLDWLRQZLWKWKH,QVWLWXWHRI,VPDLOL6WXGLHV/RQGRQSS $/(66$1'52%$86, 8QD³OLVWD´HWLRSLFDGLDSRVWROLHGLVFHSROL /D³OLVWD´HWLRSLFDGLDSRVWROLHGLVFHSROLFKHTXLVLSXEEOLFD±FRVuSHU VHPSOLFLWjFRQSLHQDFRQVDSHYROH]]DGHLSUREOHPLGLGHILQL]LRQHGHOJHQHUH HYLGHQ]LDWLGD)UDQoRLV'ROEHDXHDFFRJOLHQGRODVXDVWHVVDVROX]LRQH±qXQ EUHYH PD QRQ WUDVFXUDELOHWHVWR DSRFULIR QHRWHVWDPHQWDULR YHLFRODWR QHO6L QRGRVODPDJJLRUHFROOH]LRQHFDQRQLFROLWXUJLFDGHOOD&KLHVDHWLRSLFDHDS SDUWHQHQWHDOJUXSSRGLWHVWLDFFRPXQDWLLQPLVXUDGLYHUVDGDOODFDUDWWHULVWLFD GHOOD³WUDGL]LRQHPLQRULWDULD´7DOLWHVWL±WUDLTXDOLVLDQQRYHUDQRO¶(SLVWROD GL&LSULDQRGL&DUWDJLQHHOH5LVSRVWHFDQRQLFKHDWWULEXLWHD3LHWURGL$ OHVVDQGULD±WUDVPHVVLGDXQQXPHURULGRWWRGLWHVWLPRQLFKHQHOFDVRGHOOD OLVWDVFHQGHDVROLGXHFXLXQWHU]RVLDJJLXQJHGDOOHFDUDWWHULVWLFKHSHFXOLDUL DSSDLRQRDSULPDYLVWDDFFHVVRULDOQXFOHRIRQGDPHQWDOHGHOODUDFFROWD &IU'ROEHDX$)UDQoRLV'ROEHDXVRQRGHELWRUHQRQVRORGLLQIRUPD]LRQLELEOLRJUDIL FKHPDDQFKHGLLQGLFD]LRQLLPSRUWDQWLSHUO¶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¶(SLVWRODFIU%DXVLHGL]LRQHFKHQRQKDSRWXWRWHQHUFRQWRGHOPVȈFIURO WUHFKHSXUHODDWWHVWDHFKHWUDPDQGDWUDO¶DOWURODOLVWDFRPSOHWDGHLPLWWHQWLHGHLGHVWLQD WDUL,GEHDSHUFRPSOHPHQWLHODGLVFXVVLRQHGHLUDSSRUWLFRQODYHUVLRQHVLULDFD &IU%DXVLD 6XXQTXDUWRWHVWLPRQHVHJQDODWRFIUROWUH $OHVVDQGUR%DXVL /DVWRULDqSUREDELOPHQWHDVVDLSLFRPSOHVVD*LXQWRFLLQXQDUHFHQVLR QHVWDELOL]]DWDVLQRQSLWDUGLGHO;,9VHFDVHJXLWRGLXQDUHYLVLRQHVWUXWWX UDOHHSURIRQGDVXOODEDVHGLWHVWLDUDERFULVWLDQLGLLPPHGLDWDGHULYD]LRQHH JL]LDQDLO6LQRGRVFRVuFRPHFLqQRWRGDOODVWUDJUDQGHPDJJLRUDQ]DGHLWH VWLPRQLGLFXLLSLDQWLFKLQRQDQWHGDWDQRLO;,9VHFKDFHUWDPHQWHVRVWLWXL WR XQD SL DQWLFD FROOH]LRQH FDQRQLFROLWXUJLFD DUFDLFD SUREDELOPHQWH GL HWj DNVXPLWDHGLVFHQGHQWHGD9RUODJHJUHFDPDKDDQFKHPDQWHQXWRDOSURSULR LQWHUQRVSHVVRGLVRUJDQLFDPHQWHWHVWLGLWUDGL]LRQHDQWLFDULVDOHQWLDOODFROOH ]LRQHSUHFHGHQWHFKHGHQXQFLDQRLQSLFDVLDQFK¶HVVLXQDPELHQWHGLRULJL QHHJL]LDQR&RVuqSHUODOLVWDGLDSRVWROLHGLVFHSROLFRPHVLHYLQFHGDYDUL LQGL]LWUDFXLO¶HVSDQVLRQHGHOODQRWL]LDVXOO¶DSRVWROR0DUFR 'HLWUHPDQRVFULWWLFKHDWWHVWDQRODOLVWDGXHVRQRWHVWLPRQLGHO6LQRGRV XVXDOH$GGLV$EDEDH&ROOHJHYLOOH0LQQHVRWD(WKLRSLDQ0DQXVFULSW0L FURILOP/LEUDU\(00/;9VHFIROOUUGLVHJXLWRLQGLFDWRFRQ ǁ3DULV%LEOLRWKqTXH1DWLRQDOHGH)UDQFHeWKLRSLHQ;,;VHFIROO YEUDGLVHJXLWRLQGLFDWRFRQƽ,OWHU]RWHVWLPRQH(WLRSLDFROOH]LRQH SULYDWD;,,,;,9VHFIROOUDYDGLVHJXLWRLQGLFDWRFRQȈVRORGDDOFXQL DQQLQRWRGLJUDQOXQJDLOSLDQWLFRHLQTXHVWRFDVRDQFKHLOSLDXWRUHYROH GHLWUHUHVWDDOPRPHQWRLOWHVWLPRQHXQLFRGLTXHOSHFXOLDUHFRUSXVFDQRQL FROLWXUJLFRGDLWUDWWLDUFDLFL±XQD&ROOH]LRQHDNVXPLWDFRPHKRULWHQXWRGL FKLDPDUOD ± FKH WDQJLELOPHQWH UDSSUHVHQWD O¶DQWHFHGHQWH GHO 6LQRGRV H GHO TXDOHVSDUVHWUDFFHVRWWRIRUPDGLIUXVWXOLPDLQTXDOFKHFDVRDQFKHSLDP SLH VH]LRQL GL JHQHUH OLWXUJLFR VWRULFR H SDWULVWLFR LQWUDWWHQJRQR XQ UDSSRUWR &IU%DXVLE &IU%DXVL&DPSODQLFVW 8QTXDUWRWHVWLPRQHGHOWHVWRSXUWURSSRQRQDFFHVVLELOHSHUODFRVWLWX]LRQHGHOWHVWRGLTXHVWD HGL]LRQH KR VHJQDODWR LQ XQ PDQRVFULWWR GHO 6LQRGRV SUHVVR LO PRQDVWHUR HULWUHR GL 'DEUD $EXQD$EUàQ\RVLQ(ULWUHDFIU%DXVL/XVLQL7DGGLDVSHFSSFRQODPHQ ]LRQHGHOODOLVWD©6XJOL$SRVWROLªDS &IU*HWDWFKHZ+DLOHSSQUVSHFS©2QWKHILUVWIROORZHUVRI-HVXV LQFOXGLQJ WKH GLVFLSOHV ZLWK WKH FRXQWULHV ZKHUH WKH\ WDXJKW« FIU $UWLFOH RI WKH'LGHV THO\Ɨª 1HOO¶LQWHQ]LRQH GL QRQ XWLOL]]DUH SHU O¶HGL]LRQH GL WHVWL GHO6LQRGRV LGHQWLFKH VLJOH SHU WHVWL PRQLGLYHUVLKR PDQWHQXWRSHULOPV(00/ODVLJODǁJLjXWLOL]]DWDLQ%DXVL GHJOLDOWULGXHKRPXWDWRLQƽHƿ ƿOHVLJOHǜHǟ ǟJLjXWLOL]]DWHQHOO¶HGL]LRQHGHOOH5LVSRVWHFD QRQLFKHDWWULEXLWHD3LHWURGL$OHVVDQGULD &IU&KDvQHSSPVQUVSHFS©1RWLFHVVXUOHV$S{WUHVª &IU%DXVLF 8QD³OLVWD´HWLRSLFDGLDSRVWROLHGLVFHSROL FRPSOHVVRFRQXQDYDVWDJDPPDGLWHVWLJLjQRWLHLQTXDOFKHFDVRQRQDQFR UDQRWLLQHWLRSLFRHLQDOWUHOLQJXHQHO6LQRGRVHDOGLIXRULGLHVVR /DOLVWDHWLRSLFDqDQDOL]]DELOHLQVHLGLVWLQWHVH]LRQL$%&'() /DVH]LRQH$QHOO¶HGL]LRQHFRPSUHQGHEUHYLQRWL]LHQXPHUDWH QUUQHOO¶RUGLQHVX3LHWUR$QGUHD*LDFRPRILJOLRGL=HEH GHR *LRYDQQL HYDQJHOLVWD )LOLSSR %DUWRORPHR 7RPPDVR 0DWWHR0DUFR*LDFRPRILJOLRGL$OIHR7DGGHR6LPRQHIL JOLRGL&OHRSD0DWWHR0DWWLD3DROR'DWRFKHSHUFRQIURQWRFRQDO WUH UHFHQVLRQL OD OXQJD QRWL]LD VX 0DUFR q YHURVLPLOPHQWH LO ULVXOWDWR GL X Q¶LQVHU]LRQHOHQRWL]LHSUHFHGHQWLD0DUFRVRQRVWDWHDWWULEXLWHDXQDVRWWRVH ]LRQH$DTXHOODVX0DUFRDXQDVRWWRVH]LRQH$EHOH QRWL]LHVHJXHQWLD0DUFRDXQDVRWWRVH]LRQH$F /DVH]LRQH%FRPSUHQGHEUHYLQRWL]LHQXPHUDWHQUU VX7LWR&UHVFHQWHHO¶HXQXFRGHOODUHJLQD&DQGDFH /DVH]LRQH&FXLq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¶H[SOLFLWGLXQDOHWWHUDIH &IU =XXUPRQG 3DUW , S VHJQDODWR DQFKH GD .DQ\ S PVV (00/ QRQ FDWDORJDWR IRO U H /RQGRQ %ULWLVK /LEUDU\ 2ULHQW IRO U FIU :ULJKW SSQUH=XXUPRQGSS 1H KD GDWR WUDVFUL]LRQH GDO PV (00/ QRQ FDWDORJDWR IRO U H WUDGX]LRQH DQFRUD =XXUPRQG 3DUW , SS FKH OR VHJQDOD DQFKH QHL VRSUDFLWDWL PVV (00/ IROUH/RQGRQ%ULWLVK/LEUDU\2ULHQWIROU'HOWHVWRSXEEOLFDWRGD=XXUPRQGVLq GDWRFRQWRLQDSSDUDWR $OHVVDQGUR%DXVL VWDOHLQRFFDVLRQHGHOOD3DVTXD)ƗVHNƗ4XHVW¶XOWLPRGDWRIRUQLVFHXQLQGL ]LRVXOODSUREDELOHSURYHQLHQ]DLPPHGLDWDGHOWHVWRHWLRSLFRFRVuDVVHPEODWR HVVRHUDVWDWRIRUVHLQVHULWRHQWURXQDOHWWHUDIHVWDOHGLDPELHQWHDOHVVDQGULQR YLVWR O¶HYLGHQWH ULOLHYR FKH QHOOD OLVWD DVVXPH ODQRWL]LD VX 0DUFR VH]LRQH $E1RQVLWUDWWDRYYLDPHQWHFKHGLXQDSULPLVVLPDLSRWHVLGDYHULILFDUHHDS SURIRQGLUHXOWHULRUPHQWHLQDOWUDVHGHFKLDUHQGRSLSUHFLVDPHQWHLOFRQWHVWR FULWLFRWHVWXDOHHVWRULFRFXOWXUDOHGHOWHVWR &Lz GHWWR LO VROR GDWR HVWHUQR GHO FRQWHVWR WUDGL]LRQDOHEDVWD D LQGLFDUH FKHODOLVWDHWLRSLFDDSSDUWLHQHFRQJOL$WWLGL0DUFRDOULVWUHWWLVVLPRJUXS SRGLDSRFULILDSRVWROLFLHWLRSLFLDWWULEXLELOHDHWjDNVXPLWDHFRQSUHVXPLEL OH 9RUODJH JUHFD ,O FRQVHJXHQWH FDUDWWHUH VWUXWWXUDOPHQWH DUFDLFR DQWH 9,, VHFSLSUREDELOPHQWH99,VHFGHOWHVWRRULJLQDULRqFRQIHUPDWRGDSUHFLVL HOHPHQWL LQWHUQL OD OLVWD HWLRSLFD FRQGLYLGH SHFXOLDULWj WHVWXDOL VLJQLILFDWLYH FRQXQDGHWHUPLQDWDIRUPDUHFHQVLRQDOHDUFDLFDLQGLYLGXDWDGD'ROEHDXLQ WHVWLPRQLJUHFLHODWLQLDOO¶LQWHUQRGLHGL]LRQLHVWXGLSUHFHGHQWLRYHQRQHUD VWDWD GLVWLQWDPHQWH HYLGHQ]LDWD 7DOH IRUPD UHFHQVLRQDOH q DWWHVWDWD GD GXH PVVJUHFL&LWWjGHO9DWLFDQR%LEOLRWHFD$SRVWROLFD9DWLFDQD*UDHFXV 'HJQDWDILQRUDGLDWWHQ]LRQHGHOWXWWRVSRUDGLFDFIU%DXVLDSS FS &IU *HWDWFKHZ +DLOH FXL VL GHYH O¶DWWULEX]LRQH GHO WHVWR D HWj DQWLFD /XVLQL 3HUXOWHULRULHOHPHQWLVXOODWUDGL]LRQHGHJOL$WWLDSRFULILGHJOL$SRVWROLLQHWLRSLFRFIU%DXVL E &IU'ROEHDXVSHFSSVJJSSHSSFRQULIHUL PHQWL DQFKH DOOD WUDGL]LRQH RULHQWDOH H 8Q¶LPSRUWDQWHUDVVHJQDGHOOD WUDGL]LRQH FRSWR DUDEDHWLRSLFD VXOOD FHOHEUD]LRQH GHJOL DSRVWROL DOOD OXFH GHOO¶(QFRPLXP LQ ;,, DSRVWRORV GL 3VHXGR6HYHULDQRGL*DEDODKDIRUQLWRGLUHFHQWH9RLFX/DWUDGL]LRQHFRSWDDQQRYHUD LQROWUHXQDRPHOLDFULVRVWRPLFDVWUHWWDPHQWHFRQYHUJHQWHFRQDWWHVWD]LRQLVXRVWUDFDFIU'H SX\GW HW DO WHVWR WUDG &UXP 2 &UXP H %LHGHQNRSI =LHKQHU2%ULW0XV&RSW,,&KRDW'HODWWUH &IULULIHULPHQWLUHODWLYLLQ'ROEHDXSSQHSQ1HOODVWR ULDWUDGL]LRQDOHGHOOHOLVWHVRODPHQWHODYHUVLRQHODWLQDQHOPV9HURQD%LEOLRWHFD&DSLWRODUH /,SXEEOLFDWDGD7XUQHUSSSRWUHEEHHVVHUHSLDUFDLFD7DOHIRUPDUHFHQ VLRQDOH q DQFKH QRWD FRPH/LVWD DQRQLPD , GL HVVD SUHSDUD XQD QXRYD HGL]LRQH &KULVWRSKH *XLJQDUG WHQHQGR FRQWR GL XQ XOWHULRUH WHVWLPRQH JUHFR FRQVHUYDWR D 6DQ 3LHWUREXUJR H VH JQDODWRGD$QGUHM9LQRJUDGRY/HVLJOHSHULPVVJUHFLTXLDGRWWDWHFRUULVSRQGRQRDTXHOOH GHOODQXRYDHGL]LRQHGL*XLJQDUG 8QD³OLVWD´HWLRSLFDGLDSRVWROLHGLVFHSROL ROLP*URWWDIHUUDWHQVLVTXLLQGLFDWRFRQODVLJOD$ 0RQWH$WKRV0R QDVWHUR9DWRSHGLROLPTXLLQGLFDWRFRQODVLJOD9HGDXQDYHU VLRQHODWLQDWUDPDQGDWDQHOPV3DULV%LEOLRWKqTXH1DWLRQDOHGH)UDQFH/DW /RVFRSRFKHTXHVWDQRWDVLSUHILJJHqODSUHVHQWD]LRQHGHOWHVWRHWLRSLFR FRQWUDGX]LRQHLQXQDIRUPDDXVSLFDELOPHQWHDFFHVVLELOHDQFKHDJOLVWXGLRVL QRQ HWLRSLVWL /¶DQDOLVL VL OLPLWD TXLQGL D SRFKL SXQWL HVVHQ]LDOL VWUHWWDPHQWH IXQ]LRQDOLDOODHGL]LRQHGHOWHVWRFRQLPSOLFLWRULQYLRDOO¶DSSDUDWRSHUODGR FXPHQWD]LRQHSXQWXDOHJOLLQGL]LDIDYRUHGLXQD9RUODJHJUHFDGHOWHVWR HWLRSLFRLUDSSRUWLWUDLWUHWHVWLPRQLHWLRSLFLDGLELWLSHUO¶HGL]LRQHHU URULG¶DUFKHWLSRLQQRYD]LRQLUDSSRUWLFRQODWUDGL]LRQHJUHFDHODWLQD ,QGL]LGLXQD9RUODJHJUHFD 2OWUHDXQDYDOXWD]LRQHJHQHUDOHGHOODUHVDIRQHWLFDGHLQRPLSURSULGHO WXWWRLQFRPSDWLELOHFRQLOSDVVDJJLRDWWUDYHUVRXQDQWHFHGHQWHDUDERDIDYRUH GLXQD9RUODJHJUHFDSRVVRQRDGGXUVLOHVHJXHQWLHYLGHQ]H ±O¶HWLRSLFRWUDGXFHFRQۊHOODWSHUېHOODWFLRqFDQQDKDUXQGRPD DQFKHǖʌǗǍǘǛǞHǖǍǗʌǘǓLOWRSRQLPRFKHqƷǍǗǍǘʒǙǓƷǍǗǍǘǓǙʐQHOODWUD ,O WHVWR FRUULVSRQGHQWH DOOH VH]LRQL $D $F % & ' GHOODSUHVHQWH HGL]LRQH FIU DSSDUDWRq UDSSUHVHQWDWR QHOO¶DSSDUDWR GL 6FKHUPDQQ SS +LSSRO\WL LQGH[ DSRVWRORUXP FIU%+*QUDSS,QGH[DSRVWRORUXPFXPDSSHQGLFXOLVFIU%+*QUFH SXEEOLFDWR GD 7XUQHU SS LQ IRUPD GLSURWRWHVWR JUHFR ULFRVWUXLWR FRQ FRQVH JXHQWHUHOHJD]LRQHLQDSSDUDWRGLQXPHURVLSDVVLWUiGLWLLQVLQRVVLFRQLOWHVWRODWLQRIRUWH PHQWHFRQJHWWXUDOHGDWDODVFDUVDOHJJLELOLWjGHOFRGLFHGHOPV9HURQ/, ,OWHVWRFRUULVSRQGHQWHDOOHVH]LRQL$%&GHOODSUHVHQWHHGL]LRQHFIUDSSDUDWRqSXEEOLFDWR SHUH[FHUSWDUHODWLYLDLVLQJROLDSRVWROLHGLVFHSROLFIU/LSVLXVSS LOPV9DWRSLYLVHPSUHLQGLFDWRXQWHVWRVL PLOHDOODVH]LRQH$EqSXEEOLFDWRDQFKHGD6FKHUPDQQS(SLSKDQLLLQGH[GLVFLSX ORUXPFIU%+*QUFODVH]LRQH$EGHOPV9DWRSqSXEEOLFDWDDQFKHGD'ROEHDX S ,OWHVWRFRUULVSRQGHQWHDOOHVH]LRQL$%&'qSXEEOLFDWRGD'ROEHDXSSGD ULOHYDUHSHUzFKHODVH]LRQH$qLOULVXOWDWRGHOODFRQIOD]LRQHWUDXQWHVWRJUHFRHLO%UHYLD ULXPDSRVWRORUXPSHULOTXDOHFIU'ROEHDX,ELGSQHFKHODQRWL]LDVX0DUFR$E qFROORFDWDGRSRTXHOODVX3DROR &IU'LOOPDQQF/HVODXSE $OHVVDQGUR%DXVL GL]LRQHJUHFD&DODPLDLQTXHOODODWLQDLOWHVWRHWLRSLFRULSRVDVXXQWHVWRR XQDOHWWXUDƷǍǗʌǘǓ H±LOQRPHGL$OHVVDQGULDQHOVRORPVƿULFRUUHQHOOHIRUPHGL GHULYD]LRQH JUHFD ¶(ODNDVDQGHU\Ɨ ¶$OHNVDQGHU\Ɨ ¶(OHNVHQGHU\Ɨ ¶(ODNVHQ GHU\ƗHFRVuLOQRPHGL$OHVVDQGURQHOODIRUPD¶(ODNVHQGHURVWDOLIRUPHVL RSSRQJRQRDTXHOOHQRUPDOLQHOODWUDGL]LRQHHWLRSLFDGLGHULYD]LRQHDUDEDDW WHVWDWHGDLPVVǁƽ¶(OOD¶(VNHQGHU\Ɨ¶(OOD¶HVNHQGHU\Ɨ¶(OODVNHQGHU\ƗSHU $OHVVDQGULDH¶(OOD¶(VNHQGHURV¶(OODVNHQGHURVSHU$OHVVDQGURHFKHGHYR QRLQWHQGHUVLGRYXWHDXQSURFHVVRGLDGHJXDPHQWRLQFRUVRGLWUDGL]LRQH ±LOQRPH4LOLQRVFRQOHYDULDQWL4DOƝQƗV4DOLQRVqLQGXEELDPHQ WHLOULVXOWDWRGHOODPDQFDWDGLYLVLRQHGHOƷƮƶƸƶƺƼƿGLXQWHVWRJUHFRLQPD LXVFRODFRPHDWWHVWDQRǖǍʑǗ˫ǙǛǞRǖǍʑƸʒǙǛǞGHOOHHGL]LRQL 5DSSRUWLWUDLWHVWLPRQLHWLRSLFL &RQXQ¶XQLFDHFFH]LRQHDOGRYHDOODOH]LRQHFRUUHWWD0ƗUTRVGL>ƽ VLRSSRQHO¶HUURQHR<ƗµTREGLƿLOPVƿSUHVHQWDSUHVVRFKpVLVWHPDWLFDPHQWH OH]LRQLVXSHULRULSHUFKpSLDUFDLFKHHRSLYLFLQHDOOHUHFHQVLRQLSDUDOOHOHD TXHOOHGLYƽFKHGDOFDQWRORURGLVFHQGRQRSUREDELOPHQWHGDXQVXEDUFKHWL SRFRPXQH ± 0DUPƗUHTƝ GL ƿ FRQWUR 0ƗUHTL GL <ƽ q FRQIRUWDWR GDO JUHFR ƹǍǝǘǍǝǕǖ˝Ǟ H±¶(QGDNƝGLƿqSLDUFDLFRGL+HQGDNƝGL<ƽFIUULVSHWWLYD PHQWHɗǙǐǛ˫ǞHɗǙǐǕǖ˝ǞGHOJUHFR &IU:HLVFKHUSGRYHDSURSRVLWRGHO4ƝUHOORVQRWDFKH©2IFRXUVHWKHDUFKHW\SH RIWKHWH[WKDVVRPHWLPHVEHHQFRUUHFWHGE\WKHFRS\LVWV7KH\GLGQRWXQGHUVWDQGYHU\DUFKD LF*HµH]ZRUGVWKHQDPHJLYLQJKDVEHHQHPHQGHGDIWHUWKH$UDELFSDWWHUQIRUH[DPSOH(OOD (VNHQGHU\ƗWKHPRQNVDWWKHVDPHWLPHFRSLHGRWKHUWH[WVZKLFKDUHEDVHGRQ$UDELFRULJL QDOVªDIIHUPD]LRPHFKHFRQIRUWDO¶DWWULEX]LRQHDHWjDQWLFDDQFKHGLWHVWLFKHSRUWLQRIRUPH DUDEL]]DQWL FRPH¶(OOD (VNHQGHU\Ɨ FRQWUR $OWKHLP 6WLHKO S ©$OOHLQƟVNƟQGƟ U\Ɨ ƟOD ƟVNƟQGƟU\Ɨ DOV %H]HLFKQXQJ $OH[DQGUHLDV PWH ]HLJHQ GD HLQH DUDELVFKH hEHU VHW]XQJ GLH XQPLWWHOEDUH 9RUODJH GHU lWKLRSLVFKHQ JHELOGHW KDWª O¶RFFRUUHQ]D GLIRUPH JUH FL]]DQWLYDOHGXQTXHSHUODOLVWDDIRUWLRULFRPHLQGL]LRGLDQWLFKLWj 6XOO¶RFFRUUHQ]DGHOWRSRQLPRLQDOWULWHVWLHWLRSLFLFIURUD%DXVLSS $QFKHLQTXHVWRFDVRQRQqGDHVFOXGHUVLXQDGHJXDPHQWRLQFRUVRGLWUDGL]LRQHDOODSLFR PXQHIRUPDGLGHULYD]LRQHDUDEDFRQDVSLUDWDLQL]LDOHFIU+HQGƗNƝ+HQGDNƝ©,QGLDªFRPH OXRJRGLSUHGLFD]LRQHGL7RPPDVRQHL&DQRQLGRSRO¶$VFHQVLRQHWHVWRFRQFHUWD9RU ODJHDUDEDHQWURLO6LQRGRVFIU%DXVLSSWHVWRWUDG 8QD³OLVWD´HWLRSLFDGLDSRVWROLHGLVFHSROL ±¶,\DUX\ƗGLƿqOHFWLRGLIILFLOLRUULVSHWWRD¶,\DUXVDOƝPGL<¶,\D UXVƗOƝPGLƽHPHJOLRFRQFRUGDFRQOHYDULDHOHFWLRQHVGHOJUHFRFIU˹Ǒ Ǒɏ VLFȳǙɘǑǝǑʒǑǕɘǑǝʎǦɘǑǝʎǓɘǑǝʎǑǕ ±6LPRQGLƿqOHFWLRGLIILFLOLRUULVSHWWRD6HPµRQGL<H1ƗWQƗ¶ƝOGL ƽqHUURUHFIULOJUHFRƿʒǘǥǙ H±LQHQWUDPELLFDVLDO0ƗWƝZRVGLƿFHUWDPHQWHOHFWLRGLIILFL OLRUVLRSSRQJRQRLO0àWW\àVR0ƗWW\ƗQGL<ƽHLQHQWUDPELLFDVLODWUDGL ]LRQHJUHFDVLVIUDQJLDFRQLO9DWRS$FKHSRUWDƹǍǠǔǍ˫ǛǞHLO9DWJU 9FKHSRUWDƹǍǠǔʒǍǞ ±4LUHVTLVGLƿ qOHFWLR GLIILFLOLRU ULVSHWWR D4LQàTLV GL< DYDOODWD GDOJUHFRƷǝʐǟǖǓǞƷǝʒǟǖǓǞPHQWUH4LUTRVGLƽqEDQDOL]]D]LRQH ± OD SULPD RFFRUUHQ]D GHO QRPH %DUQƗEƗV q SUHVHQWH VROR LQ ƿ RPHVVD GD <ƽ IRUVH SHU HOLPLQD]LRQH LQWHQ]LRQDOH GHOOD GRSSLDRFFRUUHQ]D GHO QRPH FKH ULFRUUH HUURQHDPHQWH DQFKH DO SHU FRUUX]LRQH GHO JUHFR ǎǍǝǟǍǎǎʌǞƯǍǝǟǍǎˎǞLQ%DUQƗEƗV ±0ƗWƝZRVGLƿqRPHVVRGD<ƽ ±:D*HEUDDZƗU\ƗWGLƿH=XXUPqOH]LRQHFRUUHWWDGLFRQWUR DOO¶HUURUHFRQJLXQWLYR:DQJƝODGLǁH:DQJƝOD]D0ƗWƝZRVGLƽ (UURULG¶DUFKHWLSRLQQRYD]LRQLUDSSRUWLFRQODWUDGL]LRQHJUHFDHODWLQD ± OD OH]LRQH 6DJDGL\ƗQ GL ƿ FRQ YDULDQWL PLQLPH GL <ƽ VHJXH ƿǛǏǐǕǍǙǛ˫ǞGHO9DWRSFRQWURɥǏǐǛǍǙǛ˫ǞGHO9DWJUH2JGLDQLGHO 3DULV/DW ±O¶HWLRSLFRDQWHSRQH*LDFRPRD*LRYDQQLFRPHQHO9DWRSHQHO 9DWJU ±ODQRWD]LRQHGHOO¶HWLRSLFRFKHFRQ)LOLSSRULSRVDURQR©OHVXHTXDW WURILJOLHYHUJLQLªWURYDFRQIHUPDQHO9DWRSǘǑǠʋ Ǡ̇Ǚ į̌ ǍɫǠǛ˺ ǔǡǏǍǠʎ ǝǥǙ H QHO 3DULV /DW FXP ILOLDEXV VXLV TXLHVFLW PD QRQ QHO 9DW JU ±ODPHQ]LRQHGHOYHVFRYR7HRQDqQHO9DWRSȷǙǔǍ ǖǍʑ ǜʌǙǠǑǞ Ǜɐ ȳǜʒǟǖǛǜǛǕ ǖǑ˫ǙǠǍǕ Ǜɐ ǜǝʓ ƵǑǥǙˎHQHO3DULV/DWXEL!HWRPQHV HSLVFRSLLDFHQWTXLDQWH7KHRQHPIXHUXQtPHQWUHPDQFDQHO9DWJU ±QHOO¶HWLRSLFRPDQFDLOQXPHURGHJOLDQQLGLYLWDGL6LPRQHILJOLR GL&OHRSDSUHVHQWLQHOJUHFR ± ¶$ؾU\ƗQRV GHOO¶HWLRSLFR UDSSUHVHQWD SUREDELOPHQWH LO QRPH GL 7UDLDQRFRPHQHOJUHFRHODWLQRǀǝǍǦǍǙǛ˺ǀǝǍǕǍǙǛ˺7UDLDQRFRQVYLOXSSR GL SURVWHVL FRPH DQFKH VL ULOHYD DO SHU¶$ةUREDQƝ IRUPD PLJOLRUH GL ¶$ةDURERQL¶$ةDUREƗQLSUREDELOPHQWHGDȳǙ Ǡ˞ ƽǝǛǎʌǙ˛FRPHQHO9DWJU SLFKHGDȳǙ ǀǍǜǝǛǎǍǙ˞ǀǍǜǝǛǎʌǙ˛GHO9DWRSPDQRQVLSXz $OHVVDQGUR%DXVL HVFOXGHUHFKH¶$ؾU\ƗQRVUDSSUHVHQWL$GULDQRHVLDLOULVXOWDWRGLXQRVFDPELRǠ ǐIUHTXHQWHQHOJUHFRG¶(JLWWR H±LQHQWUDPELLFDVLDO0ƗWƝZRVGLƿFHUWDPHQWHOHFWLRGLIILFL OLRUVLRSSRQJRQRLO0àWW\àVR0ƗWW\ƗQGL<ƽHLQHQWUDPELLFDVLODWUDGL ]LRQH JUHFD VL VIUDQJLD FRQ LO PV 9DWRS FKHSRUWD ƹǍǠǔǍ˫ǛǞ H LO PV 9DWJUFKHSRUWDƹǍǠǔʒǍǞ ± OD QRWL]LD VX &OHPHQWH 4DODPƝQؾRV RULJLQDULDPHQWH ULIHULWD D &OHPHQWH $OHVVDQGULQR QHOOD WUDGL]LRQH JUHFD H ODWLQDSUHVHQWD QHOO¶HWLRSLFR XQR VYLOXSSR GHO WXWWR RULJLQDOH LO &OHPHQWH FKH ©SUHGLFz H VFULVVH OD OHJJH GHOODFKLHVDSHULةƗةƗVLSUHVELWHULHSHURJQLSHUIH]LRQDPHQWRGHOO¶RUGLQD ]LRQHHFFOHVLDVWLFDªqFHUWDPHQWHOR3VHXGR&OHPHQWHGL5RPDSURWDJRQLVWD GHOODOHWWHUDWXUDFDQRQLFROLWXUJLFD ±O¶HWLRSLFRGHIRUPDLOǎǍǝǟǍǎǎʌǞƯǍǝǟǍǎˎǞGHOODWUDGL]LRQHJUH FDLQ%DUQƗEƗV 6HJXRQR GRSR OD %LEOLRJUDILD WHVWR H WUDGX]LRQH GHOOD ³OLVWD´ HWLRSLFD GL DSRVWROL H GLVFHSROL /¶HGL]LRQH q ULFRVWUXWWLYD LQ DOWUL WHUPLQL QHRODFKPDQ QLDQDHLQWHQGHSUHVHQWDUHODIRUPDLSRWHWLFDPHQWHSLDQWLFDGHOODYHUVLRQH HWLRSLFD/LPLWDWDPHQWHDOOHYDULDQWLSXUDPHQWHJUDILFKHVLVRQRPHVVHDWH VWROHOH]LRQLGLƿLQFRQVLGHUD]LRQHGHOO¶DQWLFKLWjGHOWHVWLPRQH/H]LRQLGLƿ OLQJXLVWLFDPHQWH SHFXOLDUL VL VRQR PHVVH D WHVWR LQ VSHFLILFL FDVL LO WHUPLQH ZDQJƝO©9DQJHORªLQYDULDELOHDOO¶DFFXVDWLYRWHUPLQLGL QRUPDVHJXLWLGDQRPLSURSULLQYDULDELOLDOORVWDWRFRVWUXWWREHƝU©WHUUDUH JLRQHªKDJDU©SDHVHFLWWjª PHGU©WHUUDªH]E©SRSRORªOHVVƗQ©OLQJXDªQD JDU©OLQJXDªRFFDVLRQDOHDVVHQ]DGLVWDWRFRVWUXWWRLQXQDOWURFD VR FRQ WHUPLQH VHJXLWR GD QRPH SURSULR ODVDE¶ 6DJƗGL\ƗQ IRUVH HUUR QHDPHQWHLQWHUSUHWDWRFRPHSDUWLFLSLRSOXUDOHDWWULEXWLYR9LVRQRFDVLGLDO WHUQDQ]D WUD SULPR H TXDUWR RUGLQH LO WHUPLQHةƗةƗV q VFULWWR ةDةDV DOWULFDVLGLDOWHUQDQ]DVRQRGRYXWLDSUHVHQ]DGLODULQJDOHSHUHVDO EƗKH\D/DIRUPDGHOODSUHSRVL]LRQHKH\DWWƝSHUKH\DQWDFRQDVVLPL OLD]LRQH H WHUPLQD]LRQH ±Ɲ q WLSLFR DUFDLVPR SDUWLFRODUPHQWH IUHTXHQWH LQ &IU*LJQDFSSVJJRYHORVFDPELRqGHILQLWR©PRVWIUHTXHQWªVSHFEE 3HUO¶DSSOLFD]LRQHGHOFULWHULRQHRODFKPDQQLDQRQHOODILORORJLDGHLWHVWLHWLRSLFLFIUGDXOWLPR 0DUUDVVLQLFIUDQFKH%DXVLGD 8QD³OLVWD´HWLRSLFDGLDSRVWROLHGLVFHSROL ƿ&RQTXHVWHSRFKHSUHFLVD]LRQLQRQVLLQWHQGHDIIDWWRHVDXULUHODWUDWWD]LR QH GHOOH SHFXOLDULWj JUDILFKH H OLQJXLVWLFKH GLƿ FKH q GD ULPDQGDUH DG DOWUD RFFDVLRQH /¶HGL]LRQHGHOWHVWRSUHYHGHWUHDSSDUDWLDSLqGLSDJLQDLOSULPRLQGLFD OD EDVH PDQRVFULWWD HWLRSLFD H LO ULIHULPHQWR DOOHHGL]LRQL GHL WHVWL SDUDOOHOL JUHFLHODWLQLLOVHFRQGROHYDULDQWLWHVWXDOLLOWHU]RODLQWHUSXQ]LRQH/¶DSSD UDWRDOODWUDGX]LRQH±ROWUHDVLJOHHDEEUHYLD]LRQLQHOODSULPDSDJLQD±ULSRUWD YDULDQWLHOH]LRQLGHLWHVWLSDUDOOHOLJUHFLHODWLQL %,%/,2*5$),$ $OWKHLP)U6WLHKO5³'HUlWKLRSLVFKHòUôOĬV´LQ'LH$UDEHULQGHUDOWHQ:HOW,,, %HUOLQ:DOWHUGH*UX\WHU&RSS %DXVL$,O6ƝQRGRVHWLRSLFR&DQRQLSVHXGRDSRVWROLFL&DQRQLGRSRO¶$VFHQVLRQH&D QRQLGL6LPRQH&DQDQHR&DQRQLDSRVWROLFL/HWWHUDGL3LHWUR/RYDQLL,QDHGLEXV3HHWHUV &RUSXV6FULSWRUXP&KULVWLDQRUXP2ULHQWDOLXP6FULSWRUHV$HWKLRSLFL ² ³/¶(SLVWROD GL &LSULDQR GL &DUWDJLQH LQ YHUVLRQH HWLRSLFD´ LQ$HWKLRSLFD SS ² ³$OFXQH RVVHUYD]LRQL VXO*DGOD ۊDZƗU\ƗW´ LQ $QQDOL GHOO¶,VWLWXWR 2ULHQWDOH GL 1DSROLSS ²D ³6DQ &OHPHQWH H OH WUDGL]LRQL FOHPHQWLQH QHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD HWLRSLFD FDQRQLFROLWXUJL FD´LQ3K/XLVLHUDF6WXGLVX&OHPHQWH5RPDQR$WWLGHJOL,QFRQWULGL5RPDPDU ]RHQRYHPEUH5RPD3RQWLILFLR,VWLWXWR2ULHQWDOH2ULHQWDOLD&KULVWLDQD$QDOHF WDSS ²E³&\SULDQRI&DUWKDJH´LQ6LHJEHUW8KOLJHG(QF\FORSDHGLD$HWKLRSLFD9ROXPH $&:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]9HUODJS ²D³1RWHDJJLXQWLYHVXOO¶(SLVWRODGL&LSULDQRYHUVLRQH HWLRSLFDHYHUVLRQHVLULDFD´ LQ0%HUQDUGLQL1/7RUQHVHOORDF6FULWWLLQRQRUHGL*LRYDQQL0G¶(UPH6DJJLGL FROOHJKLHDPLFLLQRFFDVLRQHGHOVXRFRPSOHDQQR,1DSROL8QLYHUVLWjGHJOL6WXGLGL1D SROL³/¶2ULHQWDOH´'LSDUWLPHQWRGL6WXGL$VLDWLFL6HULHV0LQRUSS ²E ³&RPEDWV GHV $S{WUHV 5HFXHLO eWKLRSLHQ ,QWURGXFWLRQ 1RWH VXU OH WH[WH´ LQ 3 *HROWUDLQ -' .DHVWOL pGVeFULWV DSRFU\SKHV FKUpWLHQ ,, 3DULV *DOOLPDUG %LEOLR WKqTXHGHOD3OpLDGHSS ²F³$QFLHQW)HDWXUHVRI$QFLHQW(WKLRSLF´LQ$HWKLRSLFDSS ²D ³/D YHUVLRQH HWLRSLFD GHOOH 5LVSRVWH FDQRQLFKH GL 7LPRWHR , DWWULEXLWH D 3LHWUR GL $OHVVDQGULD &3* ,, QU ´ LQ 6FULQLXP 5HYXH GH SDWURORJLH G¶KDJLRJUDSKLH FUL WLTXH HW G¶KLVWRLUH HFFOpVLDVWLTXH % /RXULp $9 0XUDYLHY pGV 8QLYHUVXP +D &IU%DXVLFSS /¶HGL]LRQHqVWDWDUHDOL]]DWDHLPSDJLQDWDFRQLOVRIWZDUH&ODVVLFDO7H[W(GLWRUHODERUDWRGD 6WHIDQ+DJHOFXLVRQRJUDWRSHUODSUH]LRVDHSXQWXDOHDVVLVWHQ]DWHFQLFDSUHVWDWD $OHVVDQGUR%DXVL JLRJUDSKLFXP 0pPRULDO 53 0LFKHO YDQ (VEURHFN VM 6DLQW3pWHUVEXUJ 6RFLpWpGHVpWXGHVE\]DQWLQHVHWVODYHVSS ²E³7KH$NVXPLWHEDFNJURXQGRIWKH(WKLRSLFµ&RUSXVFDQRQXP¶´LQ8KOLJSS ²F³/D&ROOH]LRQHDNVXPLWDFDQRQLFROLWXUJLFD´LQ$GDPDQWLXV $&DPSODQLDF ,O3DWULDUFDWRGL$OHVVDQGULDQHOODWDUGDDQWLFKLWjHQHO0HGLRHYR%UHVFLD0RUFHOOLDQD SS ²G³&XUUHQW7UHQGVLQ(WKLRSLDQ6WXGLHV3KLORORJ\´LQ8KOLJSS ²³3KLORORJ\ DV 7H[WXDO &ULWLFLVP µ1RUPDOL]DWLRQ¶ RI (WKLRSLDQ 6WXGLHV´ LQ(WKLRSLDQ 3KLORORJ\%XOOHWLQRI3KLORORJLFDO6RFLHW\RI(WKLRSLD$GGLV$EDEDSS ²³7KH¾VRFDOOHG7UDGLWLRDSRVWROLFD½SUHOLPLQDU\REVHUYDWLRQVRQWKHQHZ(WKLRSLFHY LGHQFH´LQ+*ULHVHU$0HUNW+UVJ9RONVJODXEHLPDQWLNHQ&KULVWHQWXP3URI'U 7KHRIULHG%DXPHLVWHU2)0]XU(PHULWLHUXQJ'DUPVWDGW:LVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH%XFKJHVHOO VFKDIWSS ²D³3KLORORJ\UHVHDUFKLQ´LQ68KOLJLQFRRSHUDWLRQZLWK$%DXVLHGV(QF\FORSDH GLD$HWKLRSLFD9ROXPH2;:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]9HUODJSS ²E³6HQRGRV0lৢতDIl6HQRGRV´LQ68KOLJLQFRRSHUDWLRQZLWK$%DXVLHGV(QF\ FORSDHGLD$HWKLRSLFD9ROXPH2;:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]9HUODJSS ²UHFHQVLRQHGL25DLQHUL,O*DGOGLVDQ3LHWURSDWULDUFDGL$OHVVDQGULDHXOWLPRGHLPDUWLUL (GL]LRQHGHOWHVWRHWLRSLFRHWUDGX]LRQHLWDOLDQD7XUQKRXW%HOJLTXH%UHSROV3DWURORJLD 2ULHQWDOLV>@LQ/D3DURODGHO3DVVDWRSS %DXVL$&DPSODQL$FVW³1HZ(WKLRSLF'RFXPHQWVIRUWKH+LVWRU\RI&KULVWLDQ(J\SW´ LQ 5 %RXWURV HG 3URFHHGLQJV RI WKH WK ,QWHUQDWLRQDO &RQIHUHQFH RI &RSWLF 6WXGLHV &DLUR6HSWHPEHU/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV %DXVL$/XVLQL*7DGGLD,³0DWHULDOLGLVWXGLRGDO6lUD¶ò(ULWUHD/HLVWLWX]LRQL PRQDVWLFKHHODVWUXWWXUDGHOODSURSULHWjIRQGLDULD´LQ$IULFD5RPDSS %LHGHQNRSI=LHKQHU $ .RSWLVFKH 2VWUDND , 2VWUDND DXV GHP %ULWLVFKHQ 0XVHXP LQ /RQGRQ:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW] %+* )+DONLQ%LEOLRWKHFDKDJLRJUDSKLFDJUDHFD%UX[HOOHV6RFLpWpGHV%ROODQGLVWHV 6XEVLGLDKDJLRJUDSKLFDD &KDvQH0³6XSSOpPHQWDX&DWDORJXHGHVPDQXVFULWVpWKLRSLHQVGH+=RWHQEHUJ ´LQ&DWDORJXHGHVPDQXVFULWVpWKLRSLHQVGHOD&ROOHFWLRQ$QWRLQHG¶$EEDGLH3DULV ,PSULPHULH1DWLRQDOHSS &KRDW0³7KRPDVWKHµ:DQGHUHU¶LQD&RSWLF/LVWRI$SRVWOHV´LQ2ULHQWDOLDQRYDVHU SS &UXP:(&RSWLF2VWUDFDIURPWKH&ROOHFWLRQVRIWKH(J\SW([SORUDWLRQ)XQGWKH&DL UR0XVHXPDQG2WKHUV/RQGRQ7KH(J\SW([SORUDWLRQ)XQG 'HODWWUH$³8QQRXYHDXWpPRLQGHVOLVWHVG¶DSRWUHVDSRFU\SKHVHQFRSWH´LQ2ULHQWDOLD QRYDVHUSS 'HSX\GW/HWDO+RPLOHWLFDIURPWKH3LHUSRQW0RUJDQ/LEUDU\6HYHQ&RSWLF+RPLOLHV $WWULEXWHGWR%DVLOWKH*UHDW-RKQ&KU\VRVWRPDQG(XRGLXVRI5RPH/RYDQLL,QDHGLEXV 3HHWHUV&RUSXV6FULSWRUXP&KULVWLDQRUXP 2ULHQWDOLXP6FULSWRUHV&RSWLFL 'LOOPDQQ&)U$/H[LFRQ/LQJXDH$HWKLRSLFDH/LSVLDH72:HLJHO 'ROEHDX)U³'HX[RSXVFXOHVODWLQVUHODWLIVDX[SHUVRQQDJHVGHOD%LEOHHWDQWpULHXUVj ,VLGRUHGH6pYLOOH´LQ5HYXHG¶+LVWRLUHGHV7H[WHVSS 'ROEHDX)U³/LVWHVODWLQHVG¶DS{WUHVHWGHGLVFLSOHVWUDGXLWHVGXJUHF´LQ$SRFU\SKD SS 8QD³OLVWD´HWLRSLFDGLDSRVWROLHGLVFHSROL ² ³/LVWHV G¶$S{WUHV HW GH 'LVFLSOHV´ LQ 3 *HROWUDLQ -' .DHVWOL pGVeFULWV DSR FU\SKHVFKUpWLHQ,,3DULV*DOOLPDUG%LEOLRWKqTXHGHOD3OpLDGHSS *HWDWFKHZ+DLOH³$QHZ(WKLRSLFYHUVLRQRIWKH$FWVRI6W0DUN(00/IIU U´LQ$QDOHFWDEROODQGLDQDSS ²$ FDWDORJXHRI (WKLRSLDQ PDQXVFULSWV PLFURILOPHG IRU WKH(WKLRSLDQ 0DQXVFULSW 0L FURILOP/LEUDU\$GGLV$EDEDDQGIRUWKH+LOO0RQDVWLF0DQXVFULSW/LEUDU\&ROOHJHYLOOH ,; 3URMHFW 1XPEHUV &ROOHJHYLOOH 0LQQHVRWD +LOO 0RQDVWLF 0DQXVFULSW /L EUDU\6W-RKQ¶V$EEH\DQG8QLYHUVLW\ *LJQDF)U7K$*UDPPDURIWKH*UHHN3DS\ULRIWKH5RPDQDQG%\]DQWLQH3HULRGV, 3KRQRORJ\ 0LODQR &LVDOSLQR *ROLDUGLFD 7HVWL H GRFXPHQWL SHU OR VWXGLR GHOO¶DQWLFKLWj .DQ\5³-QJHU´LQ5HDOOH[LNRQIU$QWLNHXQG&KULVWHQWXPSS /HVODX:&RPSDUDWLYH'LFWLRQDU\RI*HµH]&ODVVLFDO(WKLRSLF:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW] /LSVLXV5$'LHDSRNU\SKHQ$SRVWHOJHVFKLFKWHQXQG$SRVWHOOHJHQGHQ(UJlQ]XQJVKHIW %UDXQVFKZHLJ&$6FKZHWVFKNHXQG6RKQ0%UXKQ /XVLQL*³/HV$FWHVGH0DUFHQpWKLRSLHQUHPDUTXHVSKLORORJLTXHVHWKLVWRLUHGHODWUD GLWLRQ´LQ$SRFU\SKDSS ² ³(WKLRSLD LQ WKH WK &HQWXU\ 7KH $SRFU\SKDO$FWV RI 0DUN EHWZHHQ $OH[DQGULD DQG $NVXP´LQ8KOLJSS ²³*OL$WWLDSRFULILGL0DUFR´LQ$HWKLRSLFDSS 0DUUDVVLQL 3 ³3UREOHPV LQ &ULWLFDO (GLWLRQ DQG WKH 6WDWH RI (WKLRSLDQ 3KLORORJ\´ LQ -RXUQDORI(WKLRSLDQ6WXGLHVSS 6FKHUPDQQ 7K 3URSKHWDUXP 9LWDH )DEXORVDH ,QGLFHV $SRVWRORUXP 'LVFLSXORUXPTXH 'RPLQL'RURWKHR(SLSKDQLR+LSSRO\WR$OLLVTXH9LQGLFDWD/LSVLDH,QDHGLEXV*%7HXE QHULL%LEOLRWKHFDVFULSWRUXP*UDHFRUXPHW5RPDQRUXP7HXEQHULDQD 7XUQHU&+³$SULPLWLYHHGLWLRQRIWKH$SRVWROLFDO&RQVWLWXWLRQVDQG&DQRQVDQHDUO\ OLVWRI$SRVWOHVDQG'LVFLSOHV´LQ7KH-RXUQDORI7KHRORJLFDO6WXGLHVSS 8KOLJ 6 HG 3URFHHGLQJV RI WKH ;9WK ,QWHUQDWLRQDO &RQIHUHQFH RI (WKLRSLDQ 6WXGLHV +DPEXUJ-XO\:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]9HUODJ$HWKLRSLVWLVFKH)RUVFKXQ JHQ 9RLFX 6 ³3VHXGR 6HYHULDQR GL *DEDOD (QFRPLXP LQ ;,, $SRVWRORV &3* JOL VSXQWLDSRFULIL´LQ$SRFU\SKDSS :HLVFKHU%0³+LVWRULFDODQG3KLORORJLFDO3UREOHPVRIWKH$[XPLWLF/LWHUDWXUHHVSH FLDOO\LQWKH4pUHOORV´LQ-RXUQDORI(WKLRSLDQ6WXGLHVSS $EED6DODPD >@SS :ULJKW:&DWDORJXHRIWKH(WKLRSLF0DQXVFULSWVLQWKH%ULWLVK0XVHXPDFTXLUHGVLQFH WKH\HDU/RQGRQ*LOEHUWDQG5LYLQJWRQ =XXUPRQG 5 1RYXP 7HVWDPHQWXP $HWKLRSLFH 7KH 6\QRSWLF *RVSHOV *HQHUDO ,QWUR GXFWLRQ (GLWLRQ RI WKH *RVSHO RI 0DUN 6WXWWJDUW )UDQ] 6WHLQHU 9HUODJ bWKLRSLVWLVFKH )RUVFKXQJHQ 54 1 2 3 Alessandro Bausi ӂԺњ֓ тӽќԝҧ֓ ԊӚъ֓ ѢҒӛ֓ ӺԊд֓ ҢџՂъ֓ ӂԺ ѝҤиы֓ кк֓ Ӓтԣ֓ ӺԊӚъд֓ Ӓԇњջ֓ ӺҲҒд֓ Ң Ѳҗћ֔ ֛֓ ѧяԈӇ֓ ԊҢѢяԚ֓ զѠѧ֓ ѢҒӚ֓ кҗцџ֓ բ|Ӈ Ӈ֓ Ӻҗцџ֓ ԺнҤԝ֓ Ӻкҗцџ֓ ѲբԨѴԝ֓ Ӻкҗц џ֓ Ҕҥӄԝ֓ Ӻкҗцџ֓ ӔՕпԝ֓ Ӻкҗцџ֓ Ӓѧԝ֓ Ѣ ҒӚ֓ ӺӇԾп֓ ӺӒԇњպ֓ җцџ֓ Ѡю֓ Ғъӽԇк֓ ӆѠӇ֓ ӇԻї֔ ӺӚъԏ֓ Ӓԇњպ֓ ӗӇԊ֓ ѿпѳп֓ џӗѣ֓ ӺӚ ъԏ֓ ӒѧҢҒѿԈ֓ кӇԻї֓ ӗӇԊ֓ ԟҗр֓ ӔҧѧѲкӄ֓ Ӛъ֓ ӗԿԌӗԚ֓ ӺӚъԏ֓ ѢѲр֓ ѿпѿк֓ Ӻҗцџ֓ Ѡю֓ ѲҒѠ֔ Aa ͧ126ra Testes: ͩ Y ͧ Lips. Sch. Turn. Dolb. 1,1 ӂԺњ֓ ߑ 3 ҢѲҗћ֔] Sch. p. 164.1-2 (Index apostolorum discipulorumque Domini Pseudo-Hippolyti, ms. D = Vat. gr. 1506); Turn. p. 63 (ms. Vat. gr. 1506; versio latina e ms. Veron. LI 49 non adhibetur) 2,1 ֛֓ ߑ 3,4 ѲҒѠ֔] Lips. p. 44 (ms. Vatop. 853, 635 in Lips.); Turn. p. 63; Sch. p. 164.3-6; Dolb. p. 127, num. 25 (versio latina e ms. Paris. lat. 4886) 1,1 ӂԺњ֓ тӽќԝҧ֓] ͩ; om. Yͧ | ԊӚъ֓ ߑ ҢџՂъ֓] ͩ; ԊӚъ֓ ҢџՂы֓ ӺѢҒӛ֓ Y; ԊӚъ֓ ѢҒӛ֓ ӺԊӚъ֓ ҢџՂы֓ ͧ 2 кк֓ ߑ ӺԊӚъд֓] ͩ; кк֓ ֛ӺԊ" Y; кк֛ӺԊӚъԏд֓ ͧ | ҢѲҗћ֔] ͩY; "њ֓ ͧ 2,1 ֛֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | ѧяԈӇ֓] ͩY; զѠѧ֓ ͧ | զѠѧ֓] ͩY; Ӟս֓ ͧ | кҗцџ֓ բӇӇ֓] ͩ; "њ֓ ըӇѧ֓ Y; "њ֓ բ" ͧ 2 Ӻҗцџ֓ ԺнҤԝ֓] ͩ; кҗцњ֓ Ժнҧԝ֓ Y; Ӻкҗцњ֓ Ժнҧԝ֓ ͧ | Ӻкҗцџ֓ ѲբԨѴԝ֓] ͩ; кҗцњ֓ ѲբԨѷԝ֓ Y; "њ֓ ѲզԨѷԝ֓ ͧ | Ӻкҗцџ֓2 ߑ 3 Ҕҥӄԝ֓] ͩ; кҗцњ֓ ҔҥӇԝ֓ Y; "њ֓ ҔҥӇԝ֓ ͧ 3 Ӻкҗцџ֓ ӔՕпԝ֓] ͩ; кҗцњ֓ ӒՕ" Y; "њ֓ ӒՕ" ͧ | Ӻкҗцџ֓ Ӓѧԝ֓] ͩ; кҗцњ֓ Ӗѧԝ֓ Y; "њ֓ ӗѧԝ֓ ͧ 4 ӺӇԾп֓] ͩ; "к֓ Yͧ | җцџ֓ Ѡю֓] ͩ; җцњ֓ Ѡю֓ Y; Ғҗцњ֓ Ѡю֓ ͧ 3,1 Ӓԇњպ֓] ͩY; om. ͧ | ѿпѳп֓] ͩͧ; ѿпѿп֓ Y 2 ӒѧҢҒѿԈ֓] ͩ; ӒѧҢҒѿԀ֓ Y; ӒѧҢҗѿԈ֓ ͧ ԟҗр֓] ͩ; ԟҗп֓ Yͧ | ӔҧѧѲкӄ֓] ͩ; "ѷкӄ֓ Yͧ 3 ӗԿԌӗԚ֓] ͩͧ; ӒянӜԝ֓ (!) Y ѢѲр֓] ͩY; ѧѷр֓ ͧ | ѿпѿк֓] ͩ; ѿпѿмҢ֓ Y; ѿпѳмҢ֓ ͧ | Ӻҗцџ֓ ߑ 4 Ѡю֓] ͩ; Ӻҗцњ֓ Ѡю֓ Yͧ 4 ѲҒѠ֔] ͩͧ; ҢѲҗњ֓ Y 1,2 ҢѲҗћ֔] ֔ et ad caput versus ͩ 2,5 ӇԻї֔] ֔ ͧ 3,4 ѲҒѠ֔] ֔ ͩYͧ; ad caput versus ͩ Una lista etiopica di apostoli e discepoli Aa 55 Storia degli apostoli, di come predicarono, chi tradusse le parole di ciascuno, come morirono e dove furono sepolti. 1 1. Sem߇on, che fu chiamato ॊòؾros, predicÑ per la terra di ॊanؾon, la terra di Galàtiyà, per la terra di Qaةadoqiyà, per la terra di Bitàniyà, per la terra di ߈Iؾàlyà, per la terra di ߈Asyà; predicÑ il Vangelo e morË nella terra di Romò nei giorni del re Nòron; morË in questo modo: con la testa capovolta, e implorÑ il re dicendogli: Non crocifiggermi come il mio Signore, e cosË lo crocifisse capovolto e lo seppellË la terra di Romò. 2 3 Sigla: ͩ: codex unicus collectionis aksumiticae; Y: Ethiopian Manuscript Microfilm Library 3515; ͧ: Paris, BibliothÇque Nationale de France, ¨thiopien 181; Lips.: R. A. Lipsius, Die apokryphen Apostelgeschichten und Apostellegenden. ErgÃnzungsheft; Sch.: Th. Schermann, Prophetarum Vitae Fabulosae Indices Apostolorum; Turn.: C. H. Turner, A primitive edition; Dolb.: Fr. Dolbeau, Deux opuscules latins; Zuurm.: R. Zuurmond, Novum Testamentum Aethiopice, Part I; add.: addit; em.: emendavit; in m.: in margine; lac.: lacuna; n.l.: non liquet; om.: omittit; pr.: praemittit; s.l.: supra lineam 1,1 Storia ߑ 2 sepolti] ǐǕǍǠʌǚǑǕǞ Ǡ̇Ǚ ȣǜǛǟǠʔǗǥǙ ǐǕʋ ƷǗʐǘǑǙǠǛǞ ǠǛ˫Ǟ ȷǔǙǑǟǕ ȣǜǛǟǠǍǗǑ˫ǟǍǕ Lips. p. 3; ƽǑǝʑǠ̇ǙǐʘǐǑǖǍȣǜǛǟǠʔǗǥǙȳǙǜǛʒǛǕǞǠʔǜǛǕǞȳǖʐǝǡǚǍǙǖǍʑȳǙǜǛʒǛǕǞ ȳǠǑǗǑǕʘǔǓǟǍǙ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.1-2, Turn. p. 63 2,1 Sem߇on] ͩͫ; ॊòؾros ͧ; ƿʒǘǥǙ Lips. p. 44, in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.3, Turn. p. 63 | ॊòؾros] ͩͫ; Kòfà ͧ; ƽʎǠǝǛǞ Lips. p. 44, in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.3, Turn. p. 63 2 ॊanؾon] ͩ; ॊonؾos ͫ; ॊanؾos ͧ; ǜʔǙǠǥ Lips. p. 44; ȳǙƽʔǙǠ̅ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.3; ƽʔǙǠ̅ Turn. p. 63 | Galàtiyà] ͩ; Galàtyà ͫͧ; ǏǍǗǍǠʒǍ Lips. p. 44; ưǍǗǍǠʒˌ Sch.(Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.3, Turn. p. 63 | Qaةadoqiyà] ͩ; Qaةadoqyà ͫ; Qaةòdoqyà ͧ; ǖǍǜǜǍǐǛǖʒǍ Lips. p. 44; ƷǍǜǜǍǐǛǖʒˌ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.3, Turn.urn. p. 63 3 Bitàniyà] ͩ; Bitànyà ͫͧ; ǎǕǔǡǙʒǍ Lips. p. 44; ƯǕǔǡǙʒˌ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.3, Turn. p. 63 | ߈Iؾàlyà] ͩ; ߈Aؾàlyà ͫͧ; ǦǠǍǗʒǍ Lips. p. 44; ɗǠǍǗʒˌ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.3; non habet Turn. p. 63 | ߈Asyà] ͩ; ߈ñsyà ͫ; ߈Esyà ͧ; ȣǟʒǍ Lips. p. 44; ȫǟʒˌ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.3, Turn. p. 63 5 Nòron ߑ 3,3 capovolto] ȳǜʑǙʎǝǥǙǛǟǟǠǍǡǝǛ˺ǠǍǕǖǍǠǍǖǑǢǍǗ˝ǟǍɫǠǛ˺ ǠǛ˺ǠǛȣǚǕʘǟǍǙǠǛǟ Lips. p. 44; ǛɰǠǥǞǍɫǠǛ˺ȣǚǕʘǟǍǙǠǛǞȳǜʑƺʎǝǥǙǛǞǟǠǍǡǝǛ˺ǠǍǕ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.6; ȳǜʑƺʎǝǥǛǙǛǞǟǠǍǡǝǛ˺ǠǍǕ Turn. p. 63 3,3 seppellË] ǖȣǖǑ˫ǔʌǜǠǑǠǍǕ Lips. p. 44; ǖǍʑǔʌǜǠǑǠǍǕȳǖǑ˫ varia lectio ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.6 56 4 5 6 7 8 Alessandro Bausi ֜֓ ӗӇԧџԝѧ֓ ѢҒӚ֓ кҗцџ֓ ӒѧѲҤԝ֓ кѢҗӗ֓ ѢԺԤԝӇ֓ ӺкѢҗӒ֓ ѢѴѧ֓ ѢҒӚ֓ ӺӒԇњպ֓ Ғҗцџ֓ ե ѝ֓ ԊӒӝԟԝ֔ | ֝֓ ԝԇѸҗ֓ ӺпԢ֓ ԊҗԦԀѧ֓ ѢҒӚ֓ кԂђџҢ֓ Ӻӟ пӖң֓ Ӓԏэԧ֓ ԇҗѝӼԝӇ֓ ӺѲҢр֓ жѠԧѧ֓ ӇԻ ї֓ Ғъҕҷ<ҧ>֓ ҒвԺџ֓ ӒѴ֓ ԊъџэџѶ֔ ֞֓ ԠтӇѧ֓ ԊӒտѲѠ֓ ӗԿԌӗӂ֓ ӺӇԾнӼ֓ Ӓԇњպ֓ Ғҗцџ֓ ӖվѨӇ֔ ֟֓ ռпըѧ֓ Ӓԇњպ֓ Ғҗцџ֓ տџԼԝ֓ ӺѲҒџԀ֓ ҒвԺџ֓ жѠըмѧ֓ Ғҗцџ֓ Ӓѧԝ֓ яѧк֓ Ӓџҕԇ֓ ԢӅԿ п֓ ӒӽпԤг֔ ֠֓ ҒџҢрюԀѧ֓ ѢҒӚ֓ кѢҗӗ֓ ӗӇԢӞ֓ ѢҒӚ֓ Ӻ ӇԾп֓ ӺӒԇњպ֓ ҒӒпҕӅ֓ вԺџ֓ Ғяԧџ֓ зџюӇԝ֔ ͩ39rb Testes: ͩ Y ͧ Lips. Sch. Turn. Dolb. 4,1 ֜֓ ߑ 3 ԊӒӝԟԝ֔] Lips. p. 31; Sch. p. 164.7-8; Turn. p. 63; Dolb. p. 127, num. 26 5,1 ֝֓ ߑ 3 ԊъџэџѶ֔] Lips. p. 79; Sch. p. 165.3-5; Turn. p. 63; Dolb. p. 127, num. 27 6,1 ֞֓ ߑ 2 ӖվѨӇ֔] Lips. p. 26; Sch. pp. 164.9-165.2; Turn. p. 63; Dolb. p. 127, num. 28 7,1 ֟֓ ߑ 3 ӒӽпԤг֔] Lips. p. 72; Sch. p. 165.6-7; Turn. p. 63; Dolb. p. 127, num. 29 8,1 ֠֓ ߑ 2 зџюӇԝ֔] Lips. p. 73; Sch. p. 165.8-10; Turn. p. 63; Dolb. pp. 127-128, num. 30 4,1 ֜֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | кҗцџ֓ ӒѧѲҤԝ֓] ͩ; "њ֓ ӒѧѲԝ֓ Y; "њ֓ Ӓѧѵҧԝ֓ ͧ | кѢҗӗ֓ ߑ 2 ѢԺԤԝӇ֓] ͩ; кѢ" ѢԺԧԝӇ֓ Y; кѢҗӒ֓ ѢԽԧԝӇ֓ ͧ 2 ѢѴѧ֓] ͩͧ; ѧѴѧ֓ Y | Ғҗцџ֓ ߑ 3 ԊӒӝԟԝ֔] ͩ; җцњ֓ բҧѝ֓ Ԋӗӝ" Y; кҗцњ֓ բҧѝ֓ ԊӒ" ͧ 5,1 ֝֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | ԊҗԦԀѧ֓] ͩͧ; ԐҗԦԀѧ֓ Y | кԂђџҢ֓ ߑ 2 Ӓԏэԧ֓] ͩ; к֤Ӻ֝ӒԏэԢ֓ Y; кӒԏэԢ֓ ͧ 2 ԇҗѝӼԝӇ֓] ͩY; "ѝӿ" ͧ | ӇԻї֓] ͩ; om. Yͧ 3 Ғъҕҷ<ҧ>֓] conieci; ҒъҕҷҢ֓ ͩ; ӺъҒчҧ֓ Y; къҕҷҧ֓ ͧ ҒвԺџ֓ ߑ ԊъџэџѶ֔] ͩ; "њ֓ ӒѴ֓ ԊэџѴ֓ Yͧ 6,1 ֞֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | ԊӒտѲѠ֓] ͩY; "ѷѠ֓ ͧ | ӺӇԾнӼ֓] ͩͧ; ӺӇԾкӼ֓ Y 2 Ғҗцџ֓ ӖվѨӇ֔] "њ֓ ӖվѨӇ Yͧ 7,1 ֟֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | ռпըѧ֓ Ӓԇњպ֓] ͧ; տпըѧ֓ Ӓԇњպ֓ Y; n.l. ͩ | Ғҗцџ֓ տџԼԝ֓] ͩ; җцњ֓ տџԿԝ֓ Y; "њ֓ տџԿԝ֓ ͧ 2 ҒвԺџ֓ жѠըмѧ֓] ͩ; вԺњ֓ жԠեмѧ֓ Y; "њ֓ цԠբмѧ֓ ͧ | Ғҗцџ֓ Ӓѧԝ֓] ͩ; ӺҒҗцњ֓ ӗѧԝ֓ Y; "њ֓ ӗѧԝ֓ ͧ | Ӓџҕԇ֓] ͩY; {֞}֓ s.l. em. ͧ 8,1 ֠֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | кѢҗӗ֓ ӗӇԢӞ֓] ͩ; 4,3 ԊӒӝԟԝ֔] ֔ Yͧ; ad caput versus ͩ 5,3 ԊъџэџѶ֔] ֔ ͩYͧ; ad caput versus ͩ 6,2 ӖվѨӇ֔] ֔ ͩYͧ; ad caput versus ͩ 7,3 ӒӽпԤг֔] ֔ ͩYͧ; ad caput versus ͩ 8,2 зџюӇԝ֔] ֔ Yͧ; ad caput versus ͩ 4,1 ߈Enderyàs] ȫǙǐǝʎǍǞ Lips. p. 31, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.7, Turn. p. 63 | ߈Asqatiyà] ͩ; ߈Asqatyà ͫ; ߈Asqàtyà ͧ; ƿǖʖǔǍǕǞ Lips. p. 31, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.7, Turn. p. 63 2 Sagadiyàn] Una lista etiopica di apostoli e discepoli 57 2. ߈Enderyàs predicÑ per la terra di ߈Asqatiyà, alle genti Sagadiyàn, e predicÑ alle genti di Saqis; morË nella terra di ॊaؾrà di ߈Akàyeyà. 4 3. Yà߇qob figlio di Zabedòwos predicÑ alle dodici tribØ ebraiche e lo uccise il re Hòrodes di spada nella citt¿ di ߈Aqi di Marmàreqò. 5 4. Yoannes, che nostro Signore amÑ, l߈evangelista, morË nella terra di ߈ñfòson. 6 5. Fileةos morË nella citt¿ di Fregiyà e lo seppellirono nella citt¿ di Hòroةolis in terr¿ di ߈Asyà con le sue quattro figlie vergini. 7 6. Bartalomòwos predicÑ alle genti di ߈Endakò, predicÑ il Vangelo e morË nella citt¿ di ߈Albànà, nella terra di Hermònyà. 8 ͩ; Sagadyàn ͫ; Sagàdyàn ͧ; ƿǛǏǐǕǍǙǛ˫Ǟ Lips. p. 31; ɥǏǐǛǍǙǛ˫Ǟ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.8, Turn. p. 63; Ogdiani: Dolb. p. 127, num. 25 | Saqis] ͩͧ; Seqis ͫ; ƿʌǖǍǕǞ Lips. p. 31, in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.8, Turn. p. 63 | ॊaؾrà] ͩ; ॊatrà ͫͧ; ȳǙƽʌǠǝǍ Lips. p. 31; ȳǙ ƽʌǠǝǍǕǞ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.8; non habet Turn. p. 63 3 ߈Akàyeyà] ͩͧ; ߈Ekàyeyà ͫ; Ǡ˝Ǟ ȫǣǍ˪ǍǞ Lips. p. 31, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.8; non habet Turn. p. 63 5,1 Yà߇qob] ɗʌǖǥǎǛǞ Lips. p. 79; ' ɗǥʌǙǙǑǞ ante ͺ' ܹ܅Ώ΅Έ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) pp. 164-165, sed ǏɗʌǖǥǎǛǞ ante ǐɗǥʌǙǙǑǞ ponit ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.9, Turn. p. 63 | Zabedòwos] ͩͧ; Zobedòwos ͫ; ɠǠǛ˺ ƳǑǎǑǐǍʒǛǡ Lips. p. 79, in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.4 (recte p. 165.3), Turn. p. 63 | alle ߑ 2 ebraiche] non habet Lips. p. 79; ȳǙǠ˞ɗǛǡǐǍʒˌ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.3; non habet Turn. p. 63 2 Hòrodes] ɬǜʓɈǝʘǐǛǡ Lips. p. 79, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.4, Turn. p. 63 | nella ߑ 3 Marmàreqò] ȳǖǛǕǘʐǔǓȳǙȧǖǓ (sic) Ǡ˝ǞƹǍǝǘǍǝǕǖ˝Ǟ Lips. p. 79; ȳǖǛǕǘʐǔǓǐʍȳǙȫǖǑʑǘǠ˝ǞǘǍǝǘǍǝǕǖ˝Ǟ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.4-5, Turn. p. 63; in archa marmorica: Dolb. p. 127, num. 27 3 Marmàreqò] ͩ; Màreqi ͫͧ 6,1 Yoannes] ǐɗǥʌǙǙǑǞȳǙȫǟʒˌȳǚǛǝǕǟǔǑʑǞȳǙƽʌǠǘ̅ǐǕʋǠʓǙ ǗʔǏǛǙǠǛ˺ǖǡǝʒǛǡǟǡǙʎǏǝǍǤǑǙ (ǟǡǙʎǏǝǍǤǑ Sch., Turn.) Ί݀ (om. Sch.) ǑɫǍǏǏʎǗǕǛǙ Lips. p. 26, in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.9-10, Turn. p. 63 2 ߈ñfòson] ȳǙȹǢʎǟ̅ Lips. p. 26, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.2; non habet Turn. p. 63 7,1 Fileةos] ͧ; Feleةos ͫ; n.l. ͩ; ǂʒǗǕǜǜǛǞ Lips. p. 72, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.6, Turn. p. 63 | Fregiyà] ͩ; Fregyà ͫͧ; ȳǙǂǝǡǏʒˌ Lips. p. 72, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.6, Turn. p. 63 2 Hòroةolis] ͩ; Hòyoةàlis ͫ; òyoةalis ͧ; ǠʎǔǍǜǠǍǕȳǙ ɘǑǝǍǜʔǗǑǕǠ˝ǞȫǟʒǍǞ Lips. p. 72; ǟǠǍǡǝǛ˺ǠǍǕǖǍǠǍǖʎǢǍǗǍǠʎǔǍǜǠǍǕȳǙɘǑǝǍǜʔǗǑǕǠ˝ǞȫǟʒǍǞ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.6-7, Turn. p. 63 | ߈Asyà] ͩ; ߈Esyà ͫͧ | con ߑ 3 vergini] ǘǑǠʋ Ǡ̇ǙǐǍɫǠǛ˺ǔǡǏǍǠʎǝǥǙ Lips. p. 72; non habent Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165, Turn. p. 63; cum filiabus suis quiescit: Dolb. p. 127, num. 29.3 8,1 Bartalomòwos] ƯǍǝǔǛǗǛǘǍ˫ǛǞ Lips. p. 73, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.8, Turn. p. 63 | ߈Endakò] ͩ; Hendakò ͫͧ; ɗǙǐǛ˫Ǟ Lips. p. 73, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.8, Turn. p. 63 | predicÑ2 ߑ 2 Vangelo] ɠǞǖǍʑǠʓǖǍǠʋƹǍǠǔǍ˫ǛǙǑɫǍǏǏʎǗǕǛǙǍɫǠǛ˫ǞǐʎǐǥǖǑǙ Lips. p. 73; ǛɖǞ ǖǍʑ Ǡʓ ǖǍǠʋ ƹǍǠǔǍ˫ǛǙ ǑɫǍǏǏʎǗǕǛǙ ǍɫǠǛ˫Ǟ ǐʎǐǥǖǑǙ ǜǝʓ Ǡ˝Ǟ ǟǢǍǏ˝Ǟ ȳǖǐǍǝǔǑʑǞ ʀǟǜǑǝ ǔʐǗǍǚ ǖǍʑ ȷǜǑǕǠǍ ǜǍǝǍǠǛǘǓǔǑʑ ɼǞ ɠ ƽǍ˺ǗǛǞ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.8-10, Turn. p. 63 2 ߈Albànà] ȳǙȫǗǎǍǙǥǜʔǗǑǕ Lips. p. 73; non habet Turn. p. 63; ȳǙȫǗǗǍǙ̈ Sch., cum variis lectionibus ȫǎǗǍǙ̈ ȫǗǍǏ̈ ȫǗǍǙ̈ ȫǗǎǍǙ̈ ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.10; in 58 9 10 11 Alessandro Bausi ֡֓ Ҩэѧ֓ ѢҒӚ֓ ӺӇԾп֓ Ғҗцџ֓ սџѧ֓ кчԏҗ֓ բњҥԝ֓ Ӻкчԏҗ֓ սџѧ֓ Ӻкчԏҗ֓ эԥԟ֓ Ӻк чԏҗ֓ Ѳ|џэӃѧ֓ Ӻкчԏҗ֓ ӺџѵӇѧ֓ Ӻкчԏҗ֓ Ғѳ Փџѧ֓ ӺӒԇњպ֓ ҒвԺџ֓ чкҧ֓ ԊӗӇԢӞ֔ | ֢֓ эҦԀѧ֓ ѢҒӚ֓ ӺӇԾп֓ ҒӂԺњ֓ ԇҗѝӼԝӇ֓ Ӻ Ӓԇњպ֓ ҒвԺџ֓ ӔԚћԝ֓ Ғҗцџ֓ սџѧ֔ ֣֓ эџѸѧ֓ ѢҒӚ֓ ӺӇԾп֓ Ғҗцџ֓ ӗкӚѢӇԧџԝ֓ ӺҒҗцџ֓ Կҗկ֓ ӺӒԇњպ֓ ҒӒпӟѢӇԧџԝ֓ Ғъӝӂ֓ ѵդӇ֓ ӺѲҒџԀ֓ ҒъӝӇ֓ Ԋѧы֓ Ғѳл֓ ҒъџՓџ֓ Ԋтӂժ֓ кџӗѣ֓ яѧк֓ Ӕѳџ֓ Ѣэԇҧ֓ ԊҧӛӇ֓ ͧ126rb ͩ39va Ab Testes: ͩ Y ͧ Lips. Sch. Turn. Dolb. 9,1 ֡֓ ߑ 4 ԊӗӇԢӞ֔] Lips. p. 25; Sch. p. 166.1-4; Turn. p. 63; Dolb. p. 128, num. 31 10,1 ֢֓ ߑ 2 սџѧ֔] Lips. p. 76; Sch. p. 165.11-12; Turn. p. 63; Dolb. p. 128, num. 32 11,1 ֣֓ ߑ 12,3 եեѥҧ֔] Lips. p. 82, etiam Dolb. p. 88; Sch. p. 116 (Epiphanii Textus); Dolb. p. 129, num. 38 "Ӓ֓ зӇԢӞ֓ Y; кҗцњ֓ зӇԢӞ֓ ͧ | ӺӇԾп֓] ͩ; "к֓ Yͧ 2 Ғяԧџ֓ зџюӇԝ֔] ͩ; Ғяԧњ֓ зџюӇԝ֓ Yͧ 9,1 ֡֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | ӺӇԾп֓] ͩ; "к֓ Yͧ | Ғҗцџ֓ սџѧ֓] ͩ; "њ֓ ջџѧ֓ Y; кҗцњ֓ ս" ͧ | кчԏҗ֓ ߑ 2 բњҥԝ֓] ͩ; Ӻкч" բѝҧԝ֓ Y; "Ғ֓ բѝҧԝ֓ ͧ 2 Ӻкчԏҗ֓ սџѧ֓] ͩ; ӺчԏҒ֓ ս" Y; "Ғ֓ ս" ͧ | Ӻкчԏҗ֓ эԥԟ֓] ͩ; "Ғ֓ ьԢԟ֓ Y; "Ғ֓ юԢԟ֓ ͧ | Ӻкчԏҗ֓3 ߑ 3 ѲџэӃѧ֓] ͩY; "Ғ֓ Ѳ" ͧ 3 Ӻкчԏҗ֓ ӺџѵӇѧ֓] ͩ; "Ғ֓ ӺџѲѧ֓ Y; "Ғ֓ ӺџѵӇ֓ ͧ | Ӻкчԏҗ֓ ҒѳՓџѧ֓] ͩ; "Ғ֓ Ѷћѧ֓ Y; "Ғ֓ ѴՓџѧ֓ ͧ 4 ҒвԺџ֓ ߑ ԊӗӇԢӞ֔] ͩ; "њ֓ ч" зӇԢӞ֓ Y; "њ֓ ч" ӺԊзӇԢӞ֓ ͧ 10,1 ֢֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | ӺӇԾп֓] ͩ; "к֓ Yͧ 2 ҒвԺџ֓ ӔԚћԝ֓] ͩ; вԺњ֓ ӔԚћѢоя֓ Y; "њ֓ ӔԚћѥоя֓ ͧ | Ғҗцџ֓ սџѧ֔] ͩ; җцњ֓ ջ" Y; "њ֓ ս" ͧ 11,1 ֣֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | эџѸѧ֓] Yͧ; ԝԇѸҗ֓ ͩ | ӺӇԾп֓] ͩ; "к֓ Yͧ | Ғҗцџ֓ ӗкӚѢӇԧџԝ֓] ͩ; җцњ֓ ӗк֓ ӗѧӟӇԧџԝ֓ Y; кҗцњ֓ ӗкӗѧӟӇԧџԝ֓ ͧ 2 ӺҒҗцџ֓ ߑ ҒӒпӟѢӇԧџԝ֓] ͩ; (per homoeoteleuton) om. Y; кҗцњ֓ Կҗշ֓ ӺӒԇњպ֓ ҒӗкѧӟӇԧџԝ֓ ͧ | Ғъӝӂ֓ ߑ 3 ѵդӇ֓] ͩ; "Ӈ֓ ѲՔӇ֓ Y; Ғъ" ѲդӇ֓ ͧ 3 Ғѳл֓ ҒъџՓџ֓] ͩ; Ғѿл֓ ҒъџՓп֓ Y; Ғѳл֓ ҒъџՓп֓ ͧ 4 Ӕѳџ֓] ͩ; ӓѳՓџ֓ Y; ӓѳџ֓ ͧ | ԊҧӛӇ֓] ͩ; ҧӛӇ֓ Yͧ 9,4 ԊӗӇԢӞ֔] ֔ ͩYͧ; ad caput versus ͩ 10,1 ӺӇԾп֓] ֖ ͩ 2 սџѧ֔] ֔ ͩYͧ; ad caput versus ͩ Albano: Dolb. p. 128, num. 30 | Hermònyà] Ǡ˝ǞǘǑǏʌǗǓǞȫǝǘǑǙʒǍǞ Lips. p. 73, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.10; non habet Turn. p. 63 9,1 Tomàs] ǒƹǍǠǔǍ˫ǛǞ ante ǓƵǥǘˎǞ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) pp. 165-166, sed ǒƵǥǘˎǞ ante Ǔ Una lista etiopica di apostoli e discepoli Ab 59 7. Tomàs predicÑ il Vangelo nella citt¿ di Fàrs al popolo di ॊaratayà, al popolo di Fàrs, al popolo dei Màdày, al popolo di Qarmànus, al popolo di Warqànes, al popolo di Baquؾures, e morË nella citt¿ di ellat di ߈Endakò. 9 8. Màtòwos predicÑ il Vangelo nella lingua degli Ebrei e morË nella citt¿ di ߈Iyaruyà nella terra dei Fàrs. 10 9. Màrqos predicÑ il Vangelo nella terra di ߈Elakasanderyà e nella terra di Geb صe morË ad ߈Aleksanderyà nel luogo di Qàةiؾon; lo seppellirono nel luogo il cui nome Ç Baqulu, nel sacello che costruË per sÈ con il martire ߈Iquؾor, che fosse nella 11 ƹǍǠǔǍ˫ǛǞ ponit ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 164.10, Turn. p. 63; cf. etiam Lips. p. 3 | Fàrs] ͩͧ; Furs ͫ; non habent Sch. (Ps. Ipp.), Turn. p. 63 2 ॊaratayà] ͩ; ॊaràtyà ͫͧ; ƽʌǝǔǛǕǞ Lips. p. 25, Turn. p. 63; ȳǙ ƽʌǝǔǛǕǞ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.1; Partis: Dolb. p. 128, num. 31 | Fàrs] ƽʎǝǟǍǕǞ Lips. p. 25; ȳǙƽʎǝǟǍǕǞ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.1; non habet Turn. p. 63; Persis: Dolb. p. 128, num. 31 | Màdày] ͩ; Midày ͫ; Mòday ͧ; ƹʐǐǛǕǞ Lips. p. 25, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.1, Turn. p. 63; Medis: Dolb. p. 128, num. 31 3 Qarmànus] ƷǍǝǘǍǙǛ˫Ǟ Lips. p. 25, in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.1, Turn. p. 63; non habet Dolb. p. 128, num. 31 | Warqànes] ͩ; Warqas ͫ; Warqàn ͧ; ƼɫǝǎǍǙǛ˫Ǟ Lips. p. 25; ɴǝǖǍǙǛ˫Ǟ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.1, Turn. p. 63; Ircanisque: Dolb. p. 128, num. 31 | Baquؾures] ͩ; Qòؾerus ͫ; Qiؾures ͧ; ƯʌǖǠǝǛǕǞ Lips. p. 25, Turn. p. 63; ƯǍǖǠǝǛ˫Ǟ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.2; Bactrianis: Dolb. p. 128, num. 31 4 ellat] ellat pro ellat, i.e. canna, harundo, cf. Dillmann, Lex. c. 574, ideoque a ǖǍǗʌǘǓ suspicor; ȳǙǜʔǗǑǕƷǍǗǍǘʒǙ˛ Lips. p. 25; ȳǙ ǜʔǗǑǕ ƷǍǗǍǘǓǙ˞ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.3; non habet Turn. p. 63; in Calamia: Dolb. p. 128, num. 31 | ߈Endakò] ͩ; Hendakò ͫͧ; Ǡ˝ǞɗǙǐǕǖ˝Ǟ Lips. p. 25, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.3; non habet Turn. p. 63; Indis: Dolb. p. 128, num. 31 10,1 Màtòwos] ƹǍǠǔǍ˫ǛǞ Lips. p. 76, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.11, Turn. p. 63 2 ߈Iyaruyà] ͩ; ߈Iyarusalòm ͫ; ߈Iyarusàlòm ͧ; ȳǖǛǕǘʐǔǓ ǑɏǞ ˹Ǒ Ǒɏ (sic) Ǡ˝Ǟ ƽǍǝǔʒǍǞ Lips. p. 76; ɘǑǝǛǡǟǍǗʐǘ ǖǍʑ ȳǖǛǕǘʐǔǓ ȳǙ ɘǑǝǑʒǑǕ Ǡ˝Ǟ ƽǍǝǔʒǍǞ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.12; ƿǕʘǙ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.11, Turn. p. 63; ɘǑǝʎǦ ɘǑǝʎǓɘǑǝʎǑǕ variae lectiones ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.12 | Fàrs] ͩͧ; Furs ͫ; Ǡ˝ǞƽǍǝǔʒǍǞ Lips. p. 76, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 165.12; non habet Turn. p. 63 11,1 Màrqos] ͫͧ; Yà߇qob ͩ; ƹʌǝǖǛǞ Lips. p. 82; Sch. (Epiph.) p. 116.6 et p. 116.14; non habet Turn. | ߈Elakasanderyà] ͩ; ߈Ella ߈Eskenderyà ͫ; ߈Ella߈eskenderyà ͧ; (ƮɏǏǡǜǠʒǛǕǞ ǖǍʑ) ȫǗǑǚǍǙǐǝǑ˺ǟǕǙ Lips. p. 82; ȫǗǑǚǍǙǐǝǑʒǍǞ Sch. (Epiph.) p. 116.6; ȫǗǑǚǍǙǐǝǑ˺ǟǕ Sch. (Epiph.) p. 116.14; non habet Turn. 2 Geb ]صƮɏǏǡǜǠʒǛǕǞ (ǖǍʑȫǗǑǚǍǙǐǝǑ˺ǟǕǙ) Lips. p. 82; ȣǜʓƮɏǏʖǜǠǛǡ Sch. (Epiph.) p. 116.8; non habet Turn. | ߈Aleksanderyà] ͩ; (per homoeoteleuton) om. ͫ; ߈Ellaskenderyà ͧ; ȳǙƮɏǏʖǜǠ̅ Lips. p. 82; ȳǙ ȫǗǑǚǍǙǐǝǑʒˌ Sch. (Epiph.) p. 116.9; Sch. (Epiph.) p. 116.16; non habet Turn. 3 Qàةiؾon] ͩ; Qàؾin ͫ; Qaةiؾon ͧ; ǛɏǖʐǟǍǞ ȳǙ ǠǛ˫Ǟ ƷǍǜʒǠǥǙǛǞ Lips. p. 82; ȸǥǞ Ǡ̇Ǚ ǖǍǗǛǡǘʎǙǥǙ ȫǏǏʎǗǥǙ Sch. (Epiph.) p. 116.11; non habet Turn.; in Capitonis: Dolb. p. 129, num. 38 | Baqulu] ͩͧ; Baqwelu ͫ; ȳǙ ȫǗǑǚǍǙǐǝʒˌ ȳǙ ǠǛ˫Ǟ ƯǛǡǖʔǗǛǡ Lips. p. 82; ȳǙ ǠǛ˫Ǟ ƯǛǡǖʔǗǥǙ Sch. (Epiph.) p. 116.16; non habet Turn.; in Bucolis: Dolb. p. 129, num. 38 4 sacello] marؾur ͩ; marؾul ͫͧ; Ǡ̈ǘǍǝǠǡǝʒ̅ Lips. p. 82; non habet Turn. | ߈Iquؾor] ͩ; ߈Uquؾur ͫ; ߈Uquؾor ͧ; ǘǑǠʋ Ƽɫ˪ǖǠǛǝǛǞ ̲ ǜǝǥǠǛǘʌǝǠǡǝǛǞ Lips. p. 82; ǘǑǠʋ ɛǖǠǍǝǛǞ ̲ ǜǝǥǠǛǘʌǝǠǡǝǛǞ Sch. (Epiph.) p. 116.16-17; non habet Turn.; cum Victore: Dolb. p. 129, num. 38 60 12 13 14 15 Alessandro Bausi ҒвԺџ֓ кѸӇ֔ ӺњӚҘ֓ ӗкӟѧӇԧѠѧ֓ ӇԻї֓ Ӓԇկя Ҥг֓ ҒвԺџ֓ лѸӇ֓ ӺӒӿњԨ֓ ӒԇկяҤг֓ ҒвԺџ֓ ӗпӟѧӇԧџԝ֓ ӺѲҒѠ֓ яѧк֓ ҦԀӅ֓ мѲ֓ եեѥҧ֔ ֤֓ ԝԇѸҗ֓ ӺпԢ֓ ӗпտԠѧ֓ Ӓԇњպ֓ ԊѲҢпԀ֓ Ӓ ԟгԧ֓ ҒѐԿџҢ֓ ӗҗӇ֓ ҒӔԚћѥоя֓ ӺӿѧҢ֓ еԺ ѝ֓ ѲҒџԀ֓ ѷћҒ֓ яӧѝҗ֔ ֤֛֓ ҥԦԀѧ֓ ԊҢѢяԚ֓ ԟгԥ֓ ҒеԺњ֓ ӖԦѧԝ֓ | ӺҒҗцџ֓ ъѢբъԝ֓ ѢҒӚ֓ ӺӇԾп֓ Ғъӽԇк֓ Ӓӿ ԽѠѧ֓ ӇԻї֓ ӖԨѥѧ֓ ӺѲҒџԀ֓ ҒвԺџ֓ Ҕџѧ֔ ֤֜֓ ѤѐӇ֓ ӺпԢ֓ ѲоԀե֓ ӗяԧҷњ֓ ԝԇѸҗ֓ խ ԧѲ֓ іяԀ֓ բբѧ֓ кӔԚћѥоя֓ Ӻӧл֓ ъӽԇк֓ ч ԟӺң֓ <> ԅъҧ֓ ӺѢѲпԀ֓ Ғъӽԇк֓ Ӓџԝӈ ѧ֓ ӇԻї֓ ҒвԺњ֓ ӔԚћѥоя֔ | Ac ͩ39vb ͧ126va Testes: ͩ Y ͧ Lips. Sch. Turn. Dolb. 13,1 ֤֓ ߑ 3 яӧѝҗ֔] Lips. p. 80; Sch. p. 166.5-7; Turn. p. 63; Dolb. p. 128, num. 33 14,1 ֤֛֓ ߑ 3 Ҕџѧ֔] Lips. p. 78; Sch. p. 166.8-9; Turn. p. 63; Dolb. p. 128, num. 35 15,1 ֤֜֓ ߑ 4 ӔԚћѥоя֔] Lips. p. 77; Sch. p. 166.10-12; Turn. p. 64; Dolb. p. 128, num. 34 5 ҒвԺџ֓ кѸӇ֔] ͩ; "њ֓ рѸӇ֓ Y; "њ֓ нѸӇ֓ ͧ 12,1 ӗкӟѧӇԧѠѧ֓] ͩ; ӗк֓ ӗѧӟӇԧѠѧ֓ Y; ӗкѧӟӇԧѠѧ֓ ͧ 2 ҒвԺџ֓ лѸӇ֓] (om. ͧ); ͩ; "њ֓ рѸӇ֓ Y ҒвԺџ֓1 ߑ ӒԇկяҤг֓] om. ͧ | ӺӒӿњԨ֓ ߑ 3 ӗпӟѧӇԧџԝ֓] om. Y | ҒвԺџ֓2 ߑ 3 ӗпӟѧӇԧџԝ֓] (om. Y); ͩ; "њ֓ ӗкѧӟӇԧџԝ֓ ͧ 3 яѧк֓] ͩY; om. ͧ 13,1 ֤֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y 2 ҒѐԿџҢ֓] ͩ; ҒӿԿњҢ֓ Y; ҒѐԺџҢ֓ ͧ | еԺѝ֓] ͩͧ; "џ֓ Y 3 ѷћҒ֓] Yͧ; "җ֓ ͩ | яӧѝҗ֔] ͩY; яӛѝҒ֓ ͧ 14,1 ֤֛֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y 2 ӺҒҗцџ֓ ъѢբъԝ֓] ͩ; "њ֓ Ӻѥяԝ֓ Y; "њ֓ ъѧըяԝ֓ ͧ | ӺӇԾп֓] ͩ; "к֓ Yͧ ӒӿԽѠѧ֓] ͩͧ; ӒӿԿԠѧ֓ Y 3 ӇԻї֓ ӖԨѥѧ֓] ͩͧ; ӇԻї֓ Ӗԥѧѧ֓ Y | ҒвԺџ֓ Ҕџѧ֔] ͩ; "њ֓ Ҕџѧ֓ Yͧ 15,1 ֤֜֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | ѤѐӇ֓] ͩ; ѧяԈӇ֓ Y; ӅҧӅӖп֓ ͧ | ѲоԀե֓] ͩ; ѵк֓ Ԡբ֓ Y; ѲкԠե֓ ͧ | ӗяԧҷњ֓] ͩY; Ӻӗ" ͧ | խԧѲ֓] ͩY; "ѷ֓ ͧ 2 բբѧ֓] ͩY; եեѧ֓ ͧ | кӔԚћѥоя֓] ͩͧ; "Ѣоя֓ Y | Ӻӧл֓] ͩY; Ӻӧры֓ ͧ 3 <>] lacunam suspicor | ԅъҧ֓] ͩ; Ӻԅъң֓ Yͧ; ֪߃ add. ͧ Ӓџԝӈѧ֓] ͩY; ӒӇџ" ͧ 4 ҒвԺњ֓ ӔԚћѥоя֔] ͩ; ֦вԺњ֓ ӔԚ" Y; вԺњ֓ ӔԚ" ͧ 11,5 кѸӇ֔] ֔ ͧ 12,3 мѲ֓ եեѥҧ֔] ֔ ͩYͧ; ad caput versus ͩ 13,3 яӧѝҗ֔] ֔ ͩYͧ; ad caput versus ͩ 14,3 Ҕџѧ֔] ֔ ͩYͧ; ad caput versus ͩ 15,4 ӔԚћѥоя֔] ֔ ͩY; ad caput versus ͩ Una lista etiopica di apostoli e discepoli Ac 61 citt¿ di Laqon; il re ߈Elaksenderos trovÑ le sue ossa nella citt¿ di Luqon, e fece scendere le sue ossa nella citt¿ di ߈Eleksenderyà e lo seppellË con il patriarca Tòwonà. 12 10. Yà߇qob figlio di ߈Elfyos morË ucciso dai Giudei per lapidazione a ߈Iyarusàlòm e nella sua citt¿ lo seppellirono vicino al Tempio. 13 11. Tàdòwos, che fu chiamato Yehudà, nella citt¿ di ߈ñdòsyàe nella terra di Masaةaؾomayà predicÑ il Vangelo nei giorni di ߈Awgàros re di ߈ñdossàs e lo seppellirono a Bireؾos. 14 12. Simon figlio di Qalòwoةà dopo Yà߇qob il giusto lo nominarono ةàةàs per ߈Iyarusàlòm e tutti i giorni della sua vita (furono di) <> anni; lo crocifissero nei giorni del re ߈Aؾryànos nella citt¿ di ߈Iyarusàlòm. 15 5 Laqon] ͩ; Loqon ͫ; Làqon ͧ; ȳǙ Ǡ˞ Ƹǡǖ̇Ǚ Lips. p. 82; ǠǛ˺ ȳǙ Ǡ˞ Ƹʖǖ̅ Sch. (Epiph.) p. 116.17; non habet Turn.; in Tico: Dolb. p. 129, num. 38 12,1 ߈Elaksenderos] ͩ; ߈Ella ߈Eskenderos ͫ; ߈Ellaskenderos ͧ; ɤǙȫǗʎǚǍǙǐǝǛǞǖǍǠʐǙǑǏǖǑǙ Lips. p. 82, Sch. (Epiph.) p. 116.17; non habet Turn. 2 Luqon] (om. ͧ); ͩ; Loqon ͫ | ߈Eleksenderyà] (om. ͫ); ͩ; ߈Ellaskenderyà ͧ | e2 ߑ 3 Tòwonà] ȷǙǔǍǖǍʑǜʌǙǠǑǞǛɐȳǜʒǟǖǛǜǛǕǖǑ˫ǙǠǍǕǛɐǜǝʓƵǑǥǙˎ Lips. p. 82; ȷǙǔǍǜʌǙǠǑǞǛɐȳǜʒǟǖǛǜǛǕǖǑ˫ǙǠǍǕ Sch. (Epiph.) p. 116.18; non habet Turn.; <ubi> et omnes episcopi iacent qui ante Theonem fuerunt: Dolb. p. 129, num. 38 13,1 Yà߇qob] ɗʌǖǥǎǛǞ Lips. p. 80, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.5, Turn. p. 63 | ߈Elfyos] ȫǗǢǍʒǛǡ Lips. p. 80, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.5, Turn. p. 63 2 ߈Iyarusàlòm] ȳǙɘǑǝǛǟǛǗʖǘǛǕǞ Lips. p. 80, in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.5, Turn. p. 63 14,1 Tàdòwos] ƵǍǐǐǍ˫ǛǞ Lips. p. 78, in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.8, Turn. p. 63 | Yehudà] ɠǖǍʑƸǑǎǎǍ˫ǛǞǖǍʑɗǛʖǐǍǞ Lips. p. 78, Turn. p. 63; ɠǖǍʑƸǑǎǎǍ˫ǛǞɠǖǍʑ ɗǛʖǐǍǞ Sch. in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.8 2 ߈ñdòsyà] ƮɏǐǑǟǟǓǙǛ˫Ǟ Lips. p. 78; ƮɏǐǑǟǕǙǛ˫Ǟ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.8; ȹǐǑǟǟǓǙǛ˫Ǟ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.8; ȹǐǑǟǓǙǛ˫Ǟ Turn. p. 63 | Masaةaؾomayà] ͩ; Wasàؾomyà ͫ; Maseةoؾomyà ͧ; ƹǑǟǛǜǛǠǍǘʒˌ Lips. p. 78, Turn. p. 63; ƹǑǟǛǜǛǠǍǘǑʒˌ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.8 3 ߈Awgàros] ͩͧ; ߈Awgyos ͫ; ȳǜʑ ȫǎǏʌǝǛǡ Lips. p. 78, Turn. p. 63; ȳǜʑ ƮɫǏʌǝǛǡ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.9; sub ߑ Augaro: Dolb. p. 128, num. 35 | ߈ñdossàs] ͩͧ; ߈ñdàsses ͫ; ǎǍǟǕǗʎǥǞƮɏǐǑǟǟǓǙ̇Ǚ Lips. p. 78; ǎǍǟǕǗʎǥǞ ȹǐǑǟǟǓǙ̇Ǚ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.9; ǎǍǟǕǗʎǥǞ ȹǐǑǟǓǙ̇Ǚ Turn. p. 63 Bireؾos] ͩ; Bireؾos ͫͧ; ȳǙƯǓǝʖǠ̅ Lips. p. 78; ȳǙƯǑǝǕǠ̈ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.9; ȳǙƯǡǝǕǠ̈ Turn. p. 63 15,1 Simon] ͩ; Sem߇on ͫ; Nàtnà߈òl ͧ; ƿʒǘǥǙ Lips. p. 77, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.10 | Qalòwoةà] ͩ; Qàla Yoةa ͫ; Qalayoةà ͧ; ɠǠǛ˺ƷǗǑʔǜǍ Lips. p. 77, in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.10, Turn. p. 64 | Yà߇qob] ǘǑǠʋɗʌǖǥǎǛǙǠʓǙǐʒǖǍǕǛǙ Lips. p. 77, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.11, Turn. p. 64 2 ߈Iyarusàlòm] ȳǜʒǟǖǛǜǛǞ ǏǑǙʔǘǑǙǛǞ (ǏǑǙǛǘʎǙǛǞ) ɘǑǝǛǟǛǗʖǘǥǙ Lips. p. 77, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.11, Turn. p. 64 3 <>] lacunam suspicor; ǒʐǟǍǞȷǠǓǝǖLips. p. 77, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.12, Turn. p. 64 4 ߈Aؾryànos] ͩͫ; ߈Anؾeryànos ͧ; ǟǠǍǡǝ̈ȳǘǍǝǠʖǝǓǟǑǙȳǜʑǀǝǍǦǍǙǛ˺ (ǀǝǍǕǍǙǛ˺ Sch.) Lips. p. 77, in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.12, Turn. p. 64; sub Traiano: Dolb. p. 128, num. 34 | ߈Iyarusàlòm] non habent Lips. p. 77, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166, Turn. p. 64 62 16 17 18 19 Alessandro Bausi ֤֝֓ эҦԀѧ֓ Ӓтԣ֓ ӗяѢҗԅ֓ Ӓџԥӗ֓ ӗԿԌӗӂ֓ ԊҢҢӟк֓ зԚҦ֓ ԟгԥ֓ ӒѧѸњҥӼ֓ ӺӒԇњպ֓ ӺҢѲҗ њ֓ ҒвԺџ֓ ӔԚћѥоя֔ ֤֞֓ եӿрѧ֓ тӽџԝ֓ ѢҒӚ֓ ӗявԺњ֓ ӔԚћѥо я֓ ӗѧӚ֓ җцџ֓ ӔԚќӠ֓ Ӻҗцџ֓ Ѡю֓ Ӻҗцџ֓ ӒѧեӇԝ֓ ӺҒъӽԇк֓ ӆѠӇ֓ ӇԻї֓ ѲҢр֓ Ғъҕҷ ҧ֓ ӺѲҒћ֓ ӒԇկяҤг֓ Ғҗцџ֓ Ѡю֔ ֤֟֓ ՔӇ֓ Ғҗцџ֓ ѷџՔѧ֓ ҒтԟѲ֓ ԢѦҧ֓ Ѣ Ғ|Ӛ֓ ӺӇԾк֓ ӺҒӿѧҢ֓ ԟӗҤ֓ ԢѦҧ֓ Ӓԇњպ֔ ֤֠֓ ѴџѧѴѧ֓ Ғҗцџ֓ ԺнҤԝ֓ ӿӗң֓ ҷկӽ֓ кӚ ӇԢӞ֓ ӇԿїҢ֓ ӔҧԠէԝ֓ Ғҗцџ֓ ӒѝҔԝ֓ Ԋҗц џ֓ Կҗկ֓ ӺҒӒէѠҒӆ֓ ҒԢѦҧ֓ Ғҗцџ֓ ӔҧԠդԝ֓ Ѣэԇҧ֓ ҕзԚ֓ Ӡӂ֔ B ͩ40ra Testes: ͩ Y ͧ Lips. Sch. Turn. Dolb. 16,1 ֤֝֓ ߑ 3 ӔԚћѥоя֔] Lips. p. 81; Sch. p. 166.13-15; Turn. p. 64; Dolb. p. 129, num. 36 17,1 ֤֞֓ ߑ 4 Ѡю֔] Lips. p. 45; Sch. p. 167.1-5; Turn. p. 64; Dolb. p. 129, num. 37 18,1 ֤֟֓ ߑ 19,4 Ӡӂ֔] Lips. p. 87; Sch. p. 127.1-7 (De Timotheo, Tito, Crescente, eunucho reginae Candacis, mss. E = Vat. gr. 1506, et F = Vatop. 835); Turn. p. 64; Dolb. p. 129, num. 40 16,1 ֤֝֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | эҦԀѧ֓] ͩ; эҧԝӇ֓ Y; эҧԝѧ֓ ͧ | Ӓтԣ֓] ͩ; om. Y; ֛߃ ͧ | ӗяѢҗԅ֓] ͩY; ӗя֪Ӻ֛߃ ͧ | Ӓџԥӗ֓] ͩ; Ӓџԧӗҧ֓ Yͧ 2 ԊҢҢӟк֓] ͩͧ; ԊҢӚкк֓ Y | зԚҦ֓] ͩ; зԚӇҢ֓ Yͧ | ӒѧѸњҥӼ֓] ͩY; ӒѧѸѠҥӼ֓ ͧ | ӺӒԇњպ֓] ͩͧ; om. Y 3 ҒвԺџ֓ ӔԚћѥоя֔] ͩ; ҒӔԟћѢоя֓ Y; "њ֓ ӔԚћѥоя֓ ͧ 17,1 ֤֞֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | тӽџԝ֓] ͩͧ; om. Y | ӗявԺњ֓ ӔԚћѥоя֓] ͩͧ; om. Y 2 җцџ֓ ӔԚќӠ֓] ͩ; "њ֓ ӔԝќӠ֓ Yͧ | Ӻҗцџ֓ Ѡю֓] ͩ; "њ֓ Ѡ" Yͧ | Ӻҗцџ֓2 ߑ 3 ӒѧեӇԝ֓] ͩ; "њ֓ Ӓѧբ" Yͧ 3 ӺҒъӽԇк֓] ͩ; Ғъӽԇк֓ Yͧ | Ғъҕҷҧ֓] ͩͧ; "Ғчҧ֓ Y 4 ӺѲҒћ֓] ͩY; "Ѡ֓ ͧ | Ғҗцџ֓ Ѡю֔] ͩ; ҒвԺњ֓ Ѡю֓ Y; "њ֓ Ѡю֓ ͧ 18,1 ֤֟֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | ՔӇ֓] ͩY; ҤҨӇ֓ ͧ | Ғҗцџ֓ ѷџՔѧ֓] ͩ; җцњ֓ Ѳџ" Y; "њ֓ Ѳџ" ͧ; ѢҒӚ֓ pr. Y 2 ӺҒӿѧҢ֓] Yͧ; {Ӻ}ҒӿѧҢ֓ ͩ | Ӓԇњպ֔] ͩY; Ӓԇњպ֓ in m. ͧ 19,1 ֤֠֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | ѴџѧѴѧ֓] ͩ; ѴӅѴѧ֓ Y; ѴџѸѧ֓ ͧ | Ғҗцџ֓ ԺнҤԝ֓] ͩ; "њ֓ Ժкҧԝ֓ Y; "њ֓ Ժнҧԝ֓ ͧ | ӿӗң֓] Yͧ; ӗң֓ (!) ͩ | ҷկӽ֓] ͩY; чշӺ֓ ͧ | кӚӇԢӞ֓ ߑ 2 ӇԿїҢ֓] ͩ; кӇԿѧҢ֓ Y; кзӇԢӞ֓ ӇԿ" ͧ 2 Ғҗцџ֓ ӒѝҔԝ֓] ͩ; "њ֓ Ӓѝҗԝ֓ Yͧ Ԋҗцџ֓ ߑ 3 Կҗկ֓] ͩ; "њ֓ Կ" Yͧ 3 ӺҒӒէѠҒӆ֓] Y; ӺҒӒբѠҘӄ֓ ͩ; ӺҒӒբѠҕӄ֓ ͧ | Ғҗцџ֓ ӔҧԠդԝ֓] ͩ; "њ֓ ӔҧԠէԝ֓ Yͧ 4 Ѣэԇҧ֓ ߑ Ӡӂ֔] ͩ; Ѣ"Ң֓ Ӡӂ֓ Y; Ѣ"Ң֓ ҒзԚ֓ Ӡӂ֓ ͧ 16,3 ӔԚћѥоя֔] ad caput versus ͩ 17,4 Ѡю֔] ֔ ͩYͧ; ad caput versus ͩ 18,2 Ӓԇњպ֔] ad caput versus ͩ 19,4 Ӡӂ֔] ֔ ͩYͧ; ad caput versus ͩ Una lista etiopica di apostoli e discepoli B 63 13. Màtòwos, uno dei settanta discepoli di nostro Signore, che fu sostituito al posto di Yehudà ߈Asqorotàwi; morË e fu sepolto nella citt¿ di ߈Iyarusàlòm. 16 14. ॊàwlos apostolo predicÑ dalla citt¿ di ߈Iyarusàlòm fino alla terra di ߈Iyariko, la terra di Romò e la terra di ߈Asةànyà; nei giorni del re Nòron, lo uccise di spada e seppellirono le sue ossa nella terra di Romò. 17 15. ؽiؾon nella terra di Qreؾis, sulla costa dell߈isola predicÑ il Vangelo e in quell߈isola morË. 18 16. Qiresqis fu nella terra di Galàtyà. L߈eunuco di Kandakò, regina di ߈Ityoةyà, nella terra di ߈Aràbiyà, che Ç terra di Gebص, e in ߈Aةrobanò, nell߈isola, nella regione di ߈Ityoةyà: qui fu martire. 19 16,1 Màtòwos] ͩ; Màttyàn ͫ; Màttyàs ͧ; ƹǍǠǔǍ˫ǛǞ Lips. p. 81; ƹǍǠǔʒǍǞ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.13, Turn. p. 64; Mathias: Dolb. p. 129, num. 36 | uno ߑ discepoli] ǑɖǞ ɽǙ Ǡ̇Ǚ ȴǎǐǛǘʐǖǛǙǠǍ (ǛSch., Turn.) ǘǍǔǓǠ̇Ǚ Lips. p. 81, in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.13, Turn. p. 64 2 che ߑ ߈Asqorotàwi] ȣǙǠʑɗǛʖǐǍǠǛ˺ɗǟǖǍǝǕʘǠǛǡ (ɗǟǖǍǝǕʔǠǛǡ Sch.) Lips. p. 81, in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.15, Turn. p. 64 3 ߈Iyarusàlòm] non habent Lips. p. 81, Turn. p. 64; ȳǙ ɘǑǝǛǡǟǍǗʐǘ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 166.14 17,1 ॊàwlos] ƽǍ˺ǗǛǞ Lips. p. 45, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 167.1, Turn. p. 64 | ߈Iyarusàlòm] ȣǜʓɐǑǝǛǟǛǗʖǘǥǙ Lips. p. 45; ȣǜʓɘǑǝǛǡǟǍǗʐǘ Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 167.2, Turn. p. 64 2 ߈Iyariko] ͩ; ߈Iyàriko ͫͧ; ȸǥǞǠǛ˺ɗǗǗǡǝǕǖǛ˺ Lips. p. 45, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 167.3, Turn. p. 64 | Romò] ɗǠǍǗʒǍǞ Lips. p. 45, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 167.3, Turn. p. 64 | ߈Asةànyà] ͩ; ߈Asةanyà ͫͧ; ǟǜǍǙʒǍǟ Lips. p. 45; ɘǟǜǍǙʒǍǞ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 167.4; ɗǟǜǍǙʒǍǞ Turn. p. 64 3 Nòron] ȹǜʑ ǐʎ ƺʎǝǥǙǛǞ Lips. p. 45, Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 167.4, Turn. p. 64 4 Romò] ۡ ި݅ͽ Lips. p. 45; ȳǙ ̀ʘǘ˛ in ms. D ad Sch. (Ps. Ipp.) p. 167.5, Turn. p. 64 18,1 ؽiؾon] ͩͫ; Titon ͧ; ǀʒǠǛǞ Lips. p. 87, Sch. (De Timotheo etc.) p. 127.1, Turn. p. 64 Qreؾis] ͩ; Qareؾis ͫͧ; ƷǝʐǠǍǕǞ Lips. p. 87, Turn. p. 64; ȳǜʒǟǖǛǜǛǞƷǝʐǠǓǞ Sch. (De Timotheo etc.) p. 127.1 19,1 Qiresqis] ͩ; Qinàqis ͫ; Qirqos ͧ; ƷǝʐǟǖǓǞ Lips. p. 87, Sch. (De Timotheo etc.) p. 127.3; ƷǝʒǟǖǓǞ variae lectiones ad Sch. (De Timotheo etc.) p. 127.3, Turn. p. 64 Galàtyà] ͩ; Galatyà ͫ; Galàtyà ͧ; ȳǙưǍǗǗʒǍǕǞ Lips. p. 87, Sch. (De Timotheo etc.) p. 127.3; ȳǙ ưǍǗǗʒˌ Turn. p. 64 | Kandakò] ͩ; om. ͫ; Hendakò ͧ; ƷǍǙǐʌǖǓǞ Lips. p. 87, Sch. (De Timotheo etc.) p. 127.5, Turn. p. 64 2 ߈Ityoةyà] ƮɏǔǕʔǜǥǙ Lips. p. 87, Sch. (De Timotheo etc.) p. 127.5, Turn. p. 64 | ߈Aràbiyà] ͩ; ߈Aràbyà ͫͧ; ȳǙȫǝǍǎʒˌǠ˞ǑɫǐǍʒǘǛǙǕ Lips. p. 87, Sch. (De Timotheo etc.) p. 127.5-6, Turn. p. 64 3 Geb ]صnon habent Lips. p. 87, Sch. (De Timotheo etc.) p. 127, Turn. p. 64 | ߈Aةrobanò] ͫ; ߈Aةaroboni ͩ; ߈Aةarobàni ͧ; ȳǙǀǍǜǝǛǎǍǙ˞ (ǀǍǜǝǛǎʌǙ˛ Sch.) Ǚʐǟ̅ Lips. p. 87, Sch. (De Timotheo etc.) p. 127.6; ȳǙǠ˞ƽǝǛǎʌǙ˛ Turn. p. 64 | ߈Ityoةyà] Ǡ˞ȳǙ Ǡ˞ȳǝǡǔǝˏ Lips. p. 87, Turn. p. 64; ǖǍʑȳǙɤǗ˛Ǡ˞ȳǝǡǔǝˏ Sch. (De Timotheo etc.) p. 127.6-7 64 20 21 22 23 24 25 Alessandro Bausi ֤֡֓ Ӻӗятӽџԝ֓ ԊӗԿԌӗӂ֓ ӺӒџԧӗҧ֓ ԊӗяҸ пѺ֓ ԊѢҗԅ֓ Ӓтԣ֓ ӗяӆиы֓ ѲкюӇѧ֓ ԊѢҒӚ֓ Ӻժтպ֓ чԺ֓ ҖҢ֓ ӟџѧҤԝӇ֓ кբբѥҧ֓ ӺкѲѥӿѧҧ֓ Ӻкӧл֓ տխю֓ єъҢ֓ ҖҢ֓ ӟџѧҤԝӇ֔ ӺҒџӅҕѧ֓ ֛֓ ӺѦѧҦӇѧ֓ ֛֓ Ѷսѧ֓ Ԋѧы֓ Ӛъ<֓ Ԋ>զѠѧ֓ мѲ֓ тӽџԝҧ֓ эҦԀѧ֓ ԊҢҺкѺ֓ яѧк֓ Ԃђџң֓ ӺӒтԣ֓ тӽџԝҧ֔ эҦԀѧ֓ ֛֓ ҒџӅҕѧ֓ ֛֓ Ѵмӈ ѧ֓ Ԋժтպ֓ ҲҒ֓ ՔѐҦԀѧ֓ њԧӓ֓ кբӿрѧ֓ ҥԦ Ԁѧ֓ | Ӻ|ѲоԀեѧ֔ ӺӇԾк֓ ԊѢҒӚ֓ эҦԀѧ֓ ҒпѥӇ֓ ԇҗѝӼԝӇ֓ ҒӔԚ ћѥоя֓ ҢџՂъ֓ ҒӂԺџ֓ կџӗ֓ яѧк֓ ԠтӇѧ֔ ӺӇ Ծк֓ ԊэќѸѧ֓ զѠѧ֓ ҢџՂъ֓ ҒӂԺџ֓ կџӗ֓ Ғҗ цџ֓ Ѡю֔ ӺӇԾк֓ Ԋлѵѧ֓ ҢџՂъ֓ ӝпӓ֓ лѵѧ֓ C Y94r ͧ126vb | ͩ40rb D Testes: ͩ Y ͧ Lips. Sch. Turn. Dolb. 20,1 ֤֡֓ ߑ 22,3 ӺѲоԀեѧ֔] Lips. p. 3; Sch. pp. 127.13-128.4 (De LXX discipulis apud Clementem Alex., mss. B = Vat. gr. 1506, et C = Vatop. 835); Turn. pp. 64-65; Dolb. p. 129-130, num. 40 23,1 ӺӇԾк֓ ߑ 27,2 կџӗ֔] Lips. Sch. Turn. Dolb. Zuurm. Sch. p. 129.6-17 (De quattuor evangeliis, ms. A = Vat. gr. 1506); Turn. p. 65; Dolb. p. 130, num. 41; Zuurm. p. 13 20,1 ֤֡֓] in m. ͩͧ; om. Y | Ӻӗятӽџԝ֓] ͩY; ӗятӽџԝҧ֓ ͧ 2 ԊѢҗԅ֓ Ӓтԣ֓] ͩ; ֪Ӻ֛߃ Yͧ | ѲкюӇѧ֓] ͩ; Ѳньѧ֓ Y; ѲояӇѧ֓ ͧ 3 ҖҢ֓ ӟџѧҤԝӇ֓] ͩͧ; ҖҢ֓ "ҧԝӇ֓ Y | кբբѥҧ֓] ͩ; кեեѥҧ֓ Yͧ 4 Ӻкӧл֓] ͩY; Ӻӧл֓ ͧ 21,1 ӺҒџӅҕѧ֓] ͩ; om. Yͧ 2 ֛֓1] ͩ; om. Y; ֤Ӻ֛߃ ͧ | ӺѦѧҦӇѧ֓] ͩ; ӺѧҦӇѢ֓ Y; ӺѧҤӄѧ֓ ͧ | ֛֓2] =ͩY; om. ͧ | Ӛъ<֓ Ԋ>զѠѧ֓] conieci Ӛъԏ֓ զѠѧ֓ ͩ; om. Yͧ 3 эҦԀѧ֓] ͩ; эҧԝѧ֓ Yͧ | ԊҢҺкѺ֓] ͩ; ԊҢҸкѺ֓ Yͧ | Ԃђџң֓ ߑ 4 тӽџԝҧ֔] ͩ; ֤Ӻ֜т" Yͧ 22,1 ֛֓1] ͩ; ֛߃ Yͧ | ҒџӅҕѧ֓] ͩͧ; ӺҒџӅҒѧ֓ Y | ֛֓2] ͩ; ֛߃ Yͧ Ѵмӈѧ֓] ͩ; ѲоӅѧ֓ Y; Ѳмӈѧ֓ ͧ 2 Ԋժтպ֓] ͩY; "ր֓ ͧ | кբӿрѧ֓] ͩY; кե" ͧ 3 ӺѲоԀեѧ֔] ͩY; ӺѲнԠե֓ ͧ 23,1 ӺӇԾк֓] ӺӇԾп֓ Zuurm. | эҦԀѧ֓] ͩ Zuurm.; om. Yͧ | ҒпѥӇ֓] ͩ; ҒпѢӂ֓ Y; "ӂ֓ ͧ Zuurm. | ҒӔԚћѥоя֓] ͩ Zuurm.; "Ѣоя֓ Y; ҒӔԝ" ͧ 2 ҒӂԺџ֓] ͩ; Ғпѥӂ֓ Yͧ; ҒӂԺњ֓ Zuurm. 24,1 ӺӇԾк֓] ͩ; "п֓ Yͧ Zuurm. 2 ԊэќѸѧ֓] ͩ; ԊэџѸѧ֓ Yͧ Zuurm. | ҒӂԺџ֓] ͩ Zuurm.; Ғпѥӂ֓ Yͧ | Ғҗцџ֓ ߑ 3 Ѡю֔] ͩ; җцњ֓ Ѡю Y; "њ֓ Ѡю֓ ͧ Zuurm. 25,1 ӺӇԾк֓] ͩ; "п֓ Yͧ Zuurm. ҢџՂъ֓ ߑ лѵѧ֓] ͩ Zuurm.; om. Yͧ 20,1 Ӻӗятӽџԝ֓] ֔ ͧ 4 ҖҢ֓ ӟџѧҤԝӇ֔] ֔ ͩYͧ; ad caput versus ͩ 21,4 тӽџԝҧ֔] ֔ ͩͧ 22,2 кբӿрѧ֓] ֔ Y 23,2 ԠтӇѧ֔] ֔ ͩͧ Zuurm. 24,3 Ѡю֔] ֔ ͩYͧ Zuurm. 20,1 Tra ߑ 2 settantuno] ȹǖǠ̇ǙȣǜǛǟǠʔǗǥǙǠǛ˺ǟǥǠ˝ǝǛǞǠ̇ǙȴǎǐǛǘʐǖǛǙǠǍ (΅' Sch., Una lista etiopica di apostoli e discepoli C D 65 17. Tra gli apostoli di nostro Signore e i discepoli, del numero dei settantuno, di essi Qalamònؾos, che predicÑ e scrisse la legge della chiesa per i ةàةàs, i presbiteri e per ogni perfezionamento dell߈ordinazione ecclesiastica. E Barnàbàs1, Sòstònos 1, Qòfàs, il cui nome Ç come quello di ॊòؾros, capo degli apostoli; Màtòwos, che fu annoverato con gli undici apostoli. Màtòwos 1, Barnàbàs 1, Qilinos, che scrisse a ؽimotòwos, discepolo di ॊawlos, Tàdòwos e Qalòwoةàs. 20 Il Vangelo che Màtòwos predicÑ nella lingua degli Ebrei a ߈Iyarusàlòm lo tradusse in lingua greca con Yoannes. Il Vangelo di Màriqos, ॊòؾros lo tradusse in lingua greca nella terra di Romò. Il Vangelo di Luqàs un altro Luqàs lo tradusse in lingua 23 24 21 22 25 Turn.) Lips. p. 3, Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 127.13, Turn. p. 64 2 Qalamònؾos] ͩ; Qalàmiؾos ͫ; Qalòmenؾos ͧ; ɼǞɐǟǠǛǝǑ˫ƷǗʐǘǓǞȳǙǜʎǘǜǠ˛Ǡ̇ǙɬǜǛǠǡǜʔǟǑǥǙ Lips. p. 3, Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 127.14, Turn. p. 64 | che ߑ 4 ecclesiastica] non habent Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 127, Turn. p. 64; cf. ǐǕǍǠʌǚǑǕǞ Ǡ̇Ǚ ȣǜǛǟǠʔǗǥǙ ǐǕʋ ƷǗʐǘǑǙǠǛǞ ǠǛ˫Ǟ ȷǔǙǑǟǕȣǜǛǟǠǍǗǑ˫ǟǍǕ Lips. p. 3 21,1 Barnàbàs1] ͩ; om. ͫͧ; ƯǍǝǙʌǎǍǞ Lips. p. 3, Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 127.14, Turn. p. 64 | Sòstònos] ͩ; Setònesa ͫ; Setinis ͧ; ƿǥǟǔʎǙǓǞ Lips. p. 3, Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.1, Turn. p. 64 2 Qòfàs] ƷǓǢˎǞ (ƷǓ@ǢˎǞB Lips.) Lips. p. 3, Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.1, Turn. p. 64 | ॊòؾros] ɠǘʘǙǡǘǛǞƽʎǠǝ̅ Lips. p. 3, Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.1, Turn. p. 64 3 Màtòwos] ͩ; Màttyàs ͫͧ; ǘǍǠǔǍ˫ǛǞ [i.e. ǘǍǠǔʒǍǞ] Lips. p. 3; ƹǍǠǔʒǍǞ Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.1, Turn. p. 64; ƹǍǠǔǍ˫ǛǞ in ms. C ad Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.1 22,1 Màtòwos] non habet Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.), sed pro ƹǍǠǔʒǍǞ (cf. 21) Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.1, ƹǍǠǔǍ˫ǛǞ ms. C ad Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.1 2 Barnàbàs] ͩͧ; Barnàbas ͫ; ǎǍǝǟǍǎǎʌǞ Lips. p. 3, ; ƯǍǝǟǍǎˎǞ Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.3, Turn. p. 64 | Qilinos] ͩ (a ƷƮƶƸƶƺƼƿ male distincto suspicor); Qaònàs ͫ; Qalinos ͧ; ǖǍʑ Ǘ˫ǙǛǞ Lips. p. 3, Turn. p. 64; ǖǍʑ ƸʒǙǛǞ Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.3 | ؽimotòwos] ǀǕǘǛǔʎ̅ Lips. p. 3, Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.3, Turn. p. 65 3 ॊawlos] ͩͫ; ॊàwlos ͧ; ƽǍ˺ǗǛǞ Lips. p. 3, Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.3, Turn. p. 65 | Tàdòwos] ƵǍǐǐǍ˫ǛǞ Lips. p. 3, Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.4, Turn. p. 65 | Qalòwoةàs] ͩͫ; Qalàyoةà ͧ; ƷǗǑʔǜǍǞ Lips. p. 3, Sch. (De LXX discipulis etc.) p. 128.4, Turn. p. 65 23,1 Màtòwos] ͩ Zuurm.; om. ͫͧ; ǀʓǖǍǠʋ ƹǍǠǔǍ˫ǛǙǑɫǍǏǏʎǗǕǛǙ Sch. (Quattuor sunt Evangelia) p. 129.6, Turn. p. 65 2 ߈Iyarusàlòm] ȳǙ ɘǑǝǛǡǟǍǗʐǘ Sch. (Quattuor sunt Evangelia) p. 129.7, Turn. p. 65 | Yoannes] ɬǜʓɗǥʌǙǙǛǡ Sch. (Quattuor sunt Evangelia) p. 129.7, Turn. p. 65 24,2 Màriqos] ͩ; Màrqos ͫͧ Zuurm.; ǀʓ ǖǍǠʋƹʌǝǖǛǙ Sch. (Quattuor sunt Evangelia) p. 129.8, Turn. p. 65 | ॊòؾros] ɬǜʓƽʎǠǝǛǡ Sch. (Quattuor sunt Evangelia) p. 129.8, Turn. p. 65 3 Romò] ȳǙ ̀ʘǘ˛ Sch. (Quattuor sunt Evangelia) p. 129.8, Turn. p. 65 25,1 Luqàs1] ǀǛ˺ (Ǡʓ Turn.) ǐʍǖǍǠʋƸǛǡǖˎǙɬǜʓƸǛǡǖˎ ǘǍǔǓǠǛ˺ ɬǜʌǝǣǛǙǠǛǞ ǠǛ˺ ȣǜǛǟǠʔǗǛǡ ƽǍʖǗǛǡ Sch. (Quattuor sunt Evangelia) p. 129.13-14, Turn. p. 65 | un ߑ 2 greca] ͩ Zuurm.; (per homoeoteleuton) om. ͫͧ 66 26 27 28 29 30 Alessandro Bausi ҒӂԺџ֓ կџӗ֓ ӗѧъ֓ ӿӗң֓ њԧӓ֓ кեӿрѧ֓ ӺӚъԏ֓ ժтպ֓ ҒӒтԣ֓ ъկтտ֓ ӗӇԊ֓ ԟҗп֓ Ӓ ъҲӟы֓ лѵѧ֓ ԅѵҖ֓ їѝԟ֓ տѳѝӇԚ֔ ӺԿҗњ֓ тӽџԝҧ֓ лѵѧ֓ ӺӇԾнӼ֓ ҢџՂъ֓ ҒӂԺџ֓ կџӗ֓ ӗӇԊ֓ Ғԇҗѝԟѧ֓ вр֔ ӺӇԾк֓ ԊԠтӇѧ֓ ҢџՂъ֓ ԠтӇѧ֓ բբѧ֓ ҒӂԺџ֓ կџӗ֔ ӺӔԚѣѧ֓ ӟџѧҨѧ֓ ҢӺпԢ֓ ҒҖҧ֓ пця֓ ԟг ԥ֓ ҒӒџҗԅ֓ ӺӟпӖ֓ ԅъҧ֓ ъӇԿїң֓ кӒՇѥѧ֓ ӇԻђ֓ Ѡю֓ Ғъӽԇк֓ ӔмդԧԠӇ֓ ъӢӇӇ֔ ҢӢӂ| ӂ֓ ӗԿԌӗӂ֓ ӗячԏҗ֓ Ӓԟгԧ֓ Ғъӽԇк֓ жѠԧѧ֓ ӺпԢ֓ ӒӇՔզѠѧ֓ ҒеԺџ֓ ӒѧѵрӇ֓ Ӻѧъ֓ ӗы֓ кжѠԧѧ֓ Ѹџԝ֓ Ԋӗяҗцџ֓ ӒѝҔԝ֔ Ӻӧл֓ ӗӇӚ֓ ъҷђї֓ ѢѤн֓ ӺҢҕдр֓ ӧл֓ Ӛъԏ֓ ԟԺҗћ֓ ӺкӒҵӿӄ֓ ӗк֓ ӿѧҢ֓ կҕч֓ ҒӚ ъ֓ ԟԺҗћ֓ ҒѠю֓ ӺҒӗкӟѧӇԧџԝ֓ ӺҒԇԥӇд֓ | ӧ ры֓ Ӛъ֓ ӧл֓ ҒӒтҤ֓ ԇкҧ֓ Ғҷғњ֓ ѵп֓ Ӈվ Ӄ֓ ժрҢ֓ Ғѷԧѧҧ֓ ԇкҢ֓ սѧӝ֓ Ӻԅкы֓ ӧры֓ ӗк֓ ӔҲ<җ>ћ֓ яѧк֓ ӝпӒӄиы֔ Testes: ͩ Y ͧ Dolb. Zuurm. E ͩ40va F ͧ127ra 28,1 ӺӔԚѣѧ֓ ߑ 30,6 ӝпӒӄиы֔] non habent Lips. Sch. Turn. 2 ҒӂԺџ֓ կџӗ֓] ͩ; "њ֓ կџӗ֓ Yͧ Zuurm. | кեӿрѧ֓] ͩ Zuurm.; кբ" Y; кեрӿ" ͧ 3 ҒӒтԣ֓ ъկтտ֓] ͩ; Ғ֛ъ" Yͧ; om. Zuurm. | ӒъҲӟы֓] ͩ; ӒяҲӟы֓ Y Zuurm. (varia lectio); Ӓъҷӟы֓ ͧ; ӗяҲҖӟы֓ Zuurm. 4 ԅѵҖ֓] ͩͧ Zuurm.; ԂѲҖ֓ Y | տѳѝӇԚ֔] ͩͧ; "Ӈԝ Y; տѳџԚ֓ Zuurm. 26,1 ӺԿҗњ֓ ߑ 2 тӽџԝҧ֓] ͩ Zuurm.; ӺӇԾк֓ Y; ӺӇԾп֓ ԊэҦԀѧ֓ ͧ 2 ӺӇԾнӼ֓] ͩͧ Zuurm.; om. Y ҒӂԺџ֓ կџӗ֓] ͩ; "њ֓ կџӗ֓ Yͧ Zuurm. 3 Ғԇҗѝԟѧ֓] ͩY; "ѧՔ֓ ͧ Zuurm. 27,1 ӺӇԾк֓] ͩ; "п֓ Yͧ Zuurm. 2 բբѧ֓] ͩ; եեѧ֓ Yͧ Zuurm. | ҒӂԺџ֓ կџӗ֔] ͩ; ҒвԺњ֓ կџӗ֓ Y; "њ֓ կџӗ֓ ͧ Zuurm. 28,1 ҒҖҧ֓ ߑ ԟгԥ֓] ͩ; ҒҖҢ֓ п" Ԋԟ" Yͧ 2 ҒӒџҗԅ֓ ߑ ԅъҧ֓] ͩ; Ғ֧Ӻ֜ԅъҢ֓ Y; ҒӺԅъҢ֓ lac. ͧ | кӒՇѥѧ֓] ͩ; кӒԿѧѧ֓ Y; кӒՀѧѧ֓ ͧ 3 ӔмդԧԠӇ֓] ͩ; ӔмդԤԠӇ֓ Y; ӔмզԠӇ֓ ͧ 29,2 ӗячԏҗ֓] ͩ; ӗячԏҒ֓ Yͧ 3 ӒӇՔզѠѧ֓] ͩ; ӒӇՔզѧѠѧ֓ Y; ӘӇՔդ" ͧ ҒеԺџ֓ ӒѧѵрӇ֓] ͩ; ӒѧѲрӇ֓ Y; "њ֓ ӒѧѲ" ͧ 4 Ԋӗяҗцџ֓ ӒѝҔԝ֔] ͩ; Ԋӗҗцњ֓ Ӓѝҗԝ֓ Y; "њ֓ Ӓѝҗԝ֓ ͧ 30,1 Ӻӧл֓] ͩY; Ӻӧр֓ ͧ | ъҷђї֓] ͩ; эҷѧѧ֓ Y; эҷ" ͧ | ѢѤн֓] Y; ѥѤн֓ ͩ; ѢѤнӇ֓ ͧ | ӺҢҕдр֓] ͩ; ӺҢҗдр֓ Yͧ ӧл֓] ͩ; ӧр֓ Yͧ 3 ҒѠю֓] ͩͧ; ҒѠяԝ֓ Y | ӺҒӗкӟѧӇԧџԝ֓] ͩ; ӺҒӗк֓ ӗѧӟԧџԝ֓ Y; ӺҒӗкѧӟӇԧџԝ֓ ͧ | ӺҒԇԥӇд֓] ͩY; Ӻҕԇ" ͧ | ӧры֓] ͩY; ры֓ ͧ 4 ӧл֓] ͩͧ; om. Y | ҒӒтҤ֓] ͩͧ; ԊҒӒтҤ֓ Y | Ғҷғњ֓] ͩͧ; Ғчғџ֓ Y 5 ԇкҢ֓] Una lista etiopica di apostoli e discepoli greca; invero egli era discepolo di ॊàwlos e cosË scrisse in un libro, dicendo: Vi saluta Luqàs medico, diletti miei. Gli Atti degli Apostoli Luqàs l߈evangelista li tradusse in lingua greca, mentre (prima) erano in ebraico. Il Vangelo di Yoannes lo tradusse Yoannes ةàةàs in lingua greca. E F 67 26 27 GesØ Cristo nacque a Bòt Leòm di Yehudà nel quarantaduesimo anno di ߈Agwesàؾos re di Romò nei giorni del governatore ߈Iliةidyon; fu condannato nostro Signore dal popolo dei Giudei nei giorni di Hòrodes figlio di ߈Anؾiةòؾros nella citt¿ di ߈Asqàlon; il nome della madre di Hòrodes Ç Qoؾeryà, della terra di ߈Aràbiyà. 28 Eliminata dunque ogni controversia e convenuto ognuno, cosË facevano. Anche ai fratelli che sono a Oriente, come facevano a Romò e a ߈Elaksenderyà, e anche (a) tutti gli altri, come un tutt߈uno, nello stesso giorno, all߈unisono, inviamo la preghiera nel santo giorno di Fàsekà. Firmarono tutti quelli che non erano con gli altri. 30 29 ͩY; ԇкҧ֓ ͧ | սѧӝ֓] ͩ; սѤӝ֓ Yͧ 6 ӔҲ<җ>ћ֓] conieci; ӔҲҒћ֓ ͩ; ӔԚҲҗћ֓ Y; ӔԚҷҗћ֓ ͧ | ӝпӒӄиы֔] ͩ; ӚпӒӄиы֓ Yͧ 25,4 տѳѝӇԚ֔] ֔ ͩYͧ Zuurm. 26,3 вр֔] ֔ ͩYͧ Zuurm. 27,2 կџӗ֔] ֔ ͩͧ Zuurm. 29,3 ӒѧѵрӇ֓] ֔ Yͧ 4 ӒѝҔԝ֔] ֔ ͩ 30,2 ԟԺҗћ֓] ֔ ͧ 5 սѧӝ֓] ֔ Y 6 ӝпӒӄиы֔] ֔ Y; ֔֔֔ ͧ; ad caput versus ͩ 2 ॊàwlos] ͩͧ Zuurm.; ॊawlos ͫ 26,1 Gli ߑ 2 Apostoli] ͩ Zuurm.; Evangelium Matthaei ͧ;Evangelium ͫ. 3 mentre ߑ ebraico] non habet Sch. (Quattuor sunt Evangelia) p. 129, Turn. p. 65 27,1 Yoannes] ǀʓǘʍǙǏʋǝǖǍǠʋɗǥʌǙǙǓǙǑɫǍǏǏʎǗǕǛǙǖǠǗ ante ǀǛ˺ǐʍǖǍǠʋ ƸǛǡǖˎǙ ǖǠǗ (cf. 25) ponit Sch. (Quattuor sunt Evangelia) p. 129, Turn. p. 65 28,2 ߈Agwesàؾos] ͩ; ߈Agesؾos ͫ; ߈Agosؾos ͧ 3 ߈Iliةidyon] ͩ; ߈Iliةidiyon ͫ; ߈Iliةòyon ͧ 29,2 ߈Anؾiةòؾros] ͩ; ߈Anؾiةòsros ͫ; ߈Onؾiةiؾros ͧ 3 ߈Asqàlon] ͩ; ߈Asqalon ͫͧ 4 ߈Aràbiyà] ͩ; ߈Aràbyà ͫͧ 30,3 Romò] ͩͧ; Romyà ͫ | ߈Elaksenderyà] ͩ; ߈Ella ߈Eskederyà ͫ; ߈Ellaskenderyà ͧ $1721(//$%5,7$ ,O*DGOD$OƝI ,O*DGOD$OòIqXQWHVWRDJLRJUDILFRDPELHQWDWRLQHWjDNVXPLWDDOO¶HSRFD GHL UH .ƗOƝE H *DEUD 0DVTDO 99, VHF PD VFULWWR PROWL VHFROL GRSR ;; VHF(VVRFRQWLHQHLOUDFFRQWRLQHGLWRGHOODORWWDVSLULWXDOHGHOPRQDFR$OòI XQRGHL1RYH6DQWLFRQVLGHUDWLQHOODWUDGL]LRQHHWLRSLFDLSURWDJRQLVWLGLTXHO SURFHVVRGLFULVWLDQL]]D]LRQHFKHKDDYXWRLQL]LRQHOODVHFRQGDPHWjGHO9VH FRORHFKHqQRWRFRPH³VHFRQGDFULVWLDQL]]D]LRQH´GHQRPLQD]LRQHFRQLDWD GDJOLVWXGLRVLPRGHUQLQHO;;VHFRORSHUGLVWLQJXHUHTXHVWDIDVHGDXQDSUH FHGHQWHDQWHULRUHGLFLUFDXQVHFRORWUDPDQGDWDWUDO¶DOWURQHOOD+LVWRULD(F FOHVLDVWLFDGD5XILQR,HGHILQLWD³SULPDFULVWLDQL]]D]LRQH´ ,OUDFFRQWRqFRQVHUYDWRLQGXHPDQRVFULWWLGDPHIRWRJUDIDWLLODSULOH GHOQHOYLOODJJLRGL$VHµàQHLFXLSUHVVLVLWURYDODFKLHVDGHGLFDWDDO VDQWR/DULFHUFDGLIRQWLVXOFDPSRQRQVHPSUHYDDEXRQILQHHVSHVVRVLWUD VIRUPD LQ XQ SHUFRUVR SLHQR GL LQVLGLH H GL FRQWUDWWHPSL FKH FRVWULQJRQR DG RSHUDUHGHOOHVFHOWHHDVDFULILFDUHLSURSULSURJHWWLQHOODVSHUDQ]DGLDYHUHX Q¶DOWUDRFFDVLRQHSHUULIDUVLGHJOLLQVXFFHVVL4XDQGRSRLVLODYRUDLQWHUULWRUL GRYHDQFKHOHEUHYLGLVWDQ]HGLYHQWDQRHQRUPLDFDXVDGHOOHGLIILFROWjRJJHW WLYHGLVSRVWDPHQWRHGRYHLOWHPSRDGLVSRVL]LRQHQHOO¶DUFRGHOODJLRUQDWDGL SHQGHHVFOXVLYDPHQWHGDOOHRUHGLOXFHGLVSRQLELOLO¶DQVLDHODIUHWWDGLSRUWDUH D WHUPLQH O¶RELHWWLYR SUHILVVR VL VFRQWUDQR LQHYLWDELOPHQWH FRQ OD VWDWLFLWj GL %XGJHS&ROLQSS*HWDWFKHZ0DFRPEHUSSVSHF S*ULHUVRQ,UYLQH6HLIXS.LQHIH5LJESQU5DLQHUL %UDNPDQQSS%ULWDH&RQWL5RVVLQLSS'LOOPDQQ SS*HWDWFKHZ0XQUR+D\8OOHQGRUII $QWRQHOOD%ULWD FRVWXPLHDELWXGLQLTXRWLGLDQHFKHGLIILFLOPHQWHDPPHWWRQRVWUDYROJLPHQWLGD SDUWHGLHVWUDQHLLOFXLLQWHUHVVHSHUOHWUDGL]LRQLFXOWXUDOLORFDOLQRQqVHPSUH FRPSUHVR,QUHDOWjXQSULPRWHQWDWLYRGLUDFFRJOLHUHTXHVWRPDWHULDOHHUDJLj VWDWRIDWWRQHOO¶RWWREUHGHOO¶DQQRSUHFHGHQWHPDHYHQWLDYYHUVLPLDYHYDQRFR VWUHWWDDULPDQGDUH(UDLQIDWWLDFFDGXWRFKHDOO¶DOEDGHOO¶RWWREUHGHO GRSRDYHUSUHYHQWLYDPHQWHSUHVRDFFRUGLFRQXQPRQDFRGHOPRQDVWHURGL$ OƝI DIILQFKp FL DFFRPSDJQDVVH H FL LQWURGXFHVVH DLSUHWL GHOO¶DPEƗ $OƝI LQ PRGRGDHYLWDUHLQXWLOLHVSLDFHYROLFRQWUDWWHPSLORDEELDPRWURYDWRDGDVSHW WDUFLDGµ$GZƗVHGXWRDOO¶RPEUDGLXQDOEHURLQXQDQJRORGHOODVWUDGDLQWHQ WRQHOODOHWWXUDGLXQVDOWHULR,OPRQDFRqVDOLWRLQPDFFKLQDFRQQRLHDEELD PR IDWWR LO YLDJJLR LQVLHPH 'DEUD 0ƗপHZ QRWD DQFKH FRPH DPEƗ $OƝI VL WURYD QHOO¶DUHD GL %Hত]Ɨ R %Hµ]ƗVXO YHUVDQWH GHOOD FDWHQD PRQWXRVD GHO 6HPòQFKHDSSDUWLHQHDO7HJUà\,QOLQHDG¶DULDQRQGLVWDPROWRGDµ$GZàPD ODVWUDGDqDVVDLVFRQQHVVDSHUFXLLOWHPSRGLSHUFRUUHQ]DGLSHQGHVLDGDOWL SRGLDXWRFRQFXLFLVLPXRYHVLDGDOOHFRQGL]LRQLDWPRIHULFKHHGHOSHUFRU VR 'RSR ROWUH TXDWWUR RUH GL YLDJJLR DEELDPR UDJJLXQWR LO YLOODJJLR GL $VHµàFKHVLWURYDDOOHSHQGLFLGHOO¶DPEà$EELDPRODVFLDWROuODPDFFKLQD,O PRQDFRFKHHUDYHQXWRFRQQRLHXQJLRYDQHGHOSRVWRVRQRDQGDWLDFHUFDUHLO SUHWHUHVSRQVDELOHGHOODFKLHVDPHQWUHLRLOPLRFROODERUDWRUH'àZLWHO¶DX WLVWD$NOLOXFLVLDPRLQFDPPLQDWLDSLHGLSHUVDOLUHVXOO¶DPEà'RSRDYHUSHU FRUVRXQSR¶GLVWUDGDQRQYHGHQGRDUULYDUHQHVVXQRDEELDPRGHFLVRGLIHU PDUFLDOO¶RPEUDGLXQJURVVRVLFRPRURHGLDVSHWWDUHFKHLGXHPRQDFLHLOUD JD]]RFLUDJJLXQJHVVHUR$EELDPRDWWHVRSHUGXHOXQJKHRUHHLFRUYLQHULFKH YRODYDQRVXOOHQRVWUHWHVWHQRQFLHUDQRDIIDWWRGLFRQIRUWRDQ]LFROVHQQRGL SRLLQXQ3DHVHGRYHRJQLFRVDWLSDUODHUDQRSURSULRLOSUHVDJLRGLXQILQDOH LQIDXVWR,QIDWWLGRSRFLUFDWUHRUHGLDWWHVDqDUULYDWRLOJLRYDQHFKHDYHYDDF FRPSDJQDWRLOPRQDFRGDVRORFRQXQPHVVDJJLRGDSDUWHGHLGXHPRQDFL TXHOORUHVSRQVDELOHGHOODFKLHVDLPSHJQDWRQHLFDPSLFLPDQGDYDDGLUHFKH GRYHYDODYRUDUHHQRQDYHYDQHVVXQDYRJOLDQpGLDSULUFLODFKLHVDQpGLPR VWUDUFLLOOLEURTXHOORFKHHUDYHQXWRFRQQRLSHUIDUHGDPHGLDWRUHFRQLSUHWL ORFDOLDYHYDSHQVDWREHQHGLIDUHXQDVFDPSDJQDWDHFLPDQGDYDDGLUHFKHVD UHEEHDQGDWRDWURYDUHLVXRLSDUHQWLQHO YLOODJJLRHFKHDYUHPPRGRYXWRD VSHWWDUHLVXRLFRPRGLSULPDGLWRUQDUHDGµ$GZà,QXWLOHGLUHFKHVLDPRDQ GDWLYLDVHQ]DGLOXLHFKHGDDOORUDWUDGLQRLSHUVFKHU]RqQDWDODOHJJHQGD GLTXHVWRPRQDFRFKHYDJDGLQRWWHWUDOHLHQHVXOODYLDSHUµ$GZà)RUWXQD WDPHQWHLRTXHOO¶RFFDVLRQHO¶DQQRVXFFHVVLYRO¶KRDYXWD ,QHQWUDPELLPDQRVFULWWLVRQRDWWHVWDWHWXWWHHGXHOHIRUPH ,O*DGOD$OƝI , GXH FRGLFL FKH FL WUDPDQGDQR LO WHVWR HVVHQGR SULYL GL XQD VHJQDWXUD VRQRVWDWLGDPHLGHQWLILFDWLULVSHWWLYDPHQWHFRQ*DGOD$OòI*$OH*DG OD $OòI *$O,O SULPR *$O q GDWDWR $0 $' I UEPHQWUHLOVHFRQGR*$OqGDWDWR$0$'(QWUDPEL GHULYDQR GD XQ XQLFR DUFKHWLSR*$O FRPLQFLD UHJRODUPHQWH FRQ O¶LQFLSLW GHO WHVWR I UD PD VL LQWHUURPSH EUXVFDPHQWH DOO¶HSLVRGLR VXOOD QDVFLWD GHO VDQWRIYEHULFRPLQFLDGDFFDSRDOIUD(QWUDPELLPDQRVFULWWLSRLLQXQD OHWWXUD D SDUWH DOOD ILQH GHO JDGO ULSUHQGRQR OD QDUUD]LRQH GHOOD QDVFLWD GHO VDQWR ILQR DOOD SUHVD GHOO¶DVNƝPƗ *$O II YDYE *$O II UDYD FRQDOFXQLGHWWDJOLLQSLULVSHWWRDTXHOOLFKHVLWURYDQRQHOO¶LQFLSLWGHOJDGO ,OWHVWRqVXGGLYLVRLQEUHYLOHWWXUHPHQVLOLGRGLFLLQ*$OHQRYHLQ*$O± FRQO¶DJJLXQWDLQHQWUDPELGLTXHOODVXOODQDVFLWDGHOVDQWRJLjPHQ]LRQDWD± RJQXQDGHOOHTXDOLVLFKLXGHFRQXQDIRUPXODGLEHQHGL]LRQHRJQLYROWDGHGL FDWD D XQD SHUVRQD GLYHUVD LO PHVH q VHPSUH LQGLFDWR VXO PDUJLQH VXSHULRUH GHOODSDJLQDLQFRUULVSRQGHQ]DGHOO¶LQL]LRGHOQXRYRFDSLWROHWWR/¶DQGDPHQ WRGHOWHVWRLQ*$OQRQqGLYHUVRGD*$OPDORqODVXGGLYLVLRQHLQWHUQD GHOOHOHWWXUHQHOSULPRVRQRRPHVVLLPHVLGL0DVNDUDPGLؽHUUGL0DJJàELW$OJDGOVHJXHXQDVH]LRQHGLPLUDFROLFKHLQFOXGHTXDUDQWDPLUDFROLQHO PDQRVFULWWR*$OIIYEYEHWUHQWDQRYHQHOPDQRVFULWWR*$OIIYD YE7XWWDYLDLQTXHVW¶XOWLPRVLULOHYDXQ¶DOWHUD]LRQHGHOODORURVHTXHQ]DQX PHULFDLOPLUDFRORQUqVWDWRFRQWDWRHUURQHDPHQWHFRPHQUIUD SHUFXLWXWWLLQXPHULVHJXHQWLULVXOWDQRDXPHQWDWLGLXQDXQLWjILQRDOQU FKHqVWDWRULSHWXWRGXHYROWHIIUDHUD1HOPDQRVFULWWR*$OLQYHFHLO PLUDFRORQUIUEYDFRQWLHQHVRORODIRUPXODLQL]LDOHGLULFKLHVWDGLEH QHGL]LRQH VHQ]D UDFFRQWR H LO WHVWR GHO PLUDFROR VXFFHVVLYR LO QU II YEYDFRLQFLGHFRQLOQUGHO*$OIIYEYE2JQLPLUDFRORVLD SUHHVLFKLXGHFRQXQDIRUPXODGLEHQHGL]LRQHDQFKHLQTXHVWRFDVRGHGLFDWD RJQL YROWD D XQD SHUVRQD GLYHUVD (QWUDPEL L FRGLFL FRQWHQJRQR DQFKH XQ VDOàP*$OIIUDUD*$OIIYEYEGHGLFDWRDOVDQWRHLOQRPHGL 6LYHGD%ULWDSSGRYHYLHQHIRUQLWDDQFKHXQDGHVFUL]LRQHILVLFDGHLGXHFRGL FL /¶LQGLFD]LRQH GHOOH OH]LRQL GLYHUJHQWL WUD L GXH WHVWL VL OLPLWD DG DVSHWWL SXUDPHQWH IRUPDOL ULQYLDQGRDXQIXWXUDHGL]LRQHFULWLFDO¶HVDPHFRPSOHWRHLOFRQIURQWRWHVWXDOHWUDLGXHPDQR VFULWWL FRPH SXUH O¶DQDOLVL GHL FRQWHQXWL LQ SDUWH JLj PHVVL LQ HYLGHQ]D LQ %ULWD SS /DSDUWHUHODWLYDDLPLUDFROLSHUUDJLRQLHGLWRULDOLQRQKDWURYDWRVSD]LRLQTXHVWRFRQWULEXWR SHUFXLYHUUjSXEEOLFDWDLQXQ¶DOWUDVHGH $QWRQHOOD%ULWD FROXLFKHKDGRQDWRLOPDQRVFULWWRDOODFKLHVDGLDEEƗ$OƝIQHOFRORIRQHGHO PDQRVFULWWR*$OIUEqLQGLFDWRLOQRPHGHOFRPPLWWHQWHFKHFRUULVSRQ GHDQFKHDOGRQDWRUHXQFHUWR ©*DEUD0ƗU\ƗPªFRQO¶HOHQFRGLWXWWL LVXRL IDPLOLDUL PHQWUH QHO FRORIRQH GHO PDQRVFULWWR *$O II YEUD LO QRPH GHOGRQDWRUHqRPHVVRTXHOORGHOFRPPLWWHQWHQRQVLOHJJHSHULQWHURSHUFKp VFULWWRVXOPDUJLQHVXSHULRUHLQWHUQRGHOIRJOLRLQSDUWHVWUDSSDWRHVVRqFR PXQTXHULFRVWUXLELOHGDOOD IRUPXODGLEHQHGL]LRQHFKHFKLXGHO¶XOWLPR PLUD FRORIYD©7DVIà0àU\àP*DEUD:DOGª6LWUDWWDVLFXUDPHQWHGLGXHSHU VRQHGLVWLQWHSHUFKpODIRUPXODOLLQWURGXFHFRPHӒԿҗџҤг©VXRLVHUYLª*D EUD:DOGqPHQ]LRQDWRGLYHUVHYROWHHQHOJDGOHQHLPLUDFROLPHQWUH7DVIƗ 0ƗU\ƗPqPHQ]LRQDWRVRORQHLPLUDFROL,GXHQRPLVLDQHOO¶XOWLPRPLUDFROR VLDQHOFRORIRQHVRQRVHJXLWLGDDSSHOODWLYLDOIHPPLQLOHZDODWWDۊDZƗU\ƗW ©ILJOLDGHJOLDSRVWROLªDPDWDصH\RQ©DQFHOODGL6LRQªVHJQRFKHSUREDELO PHQWHTXHVWRPDQRVFULWWRLQSULQFLSLRHUDVWDWRFRQFHSLWRSHURVSLWDUHLOQR PHGLXQDGRQQDLQTXHVWHGXHIRUPXOH /¶LPSRUWDQ]D GHL WHVWL VXOO¶HWj DNVXPLWD UHGDWWL LQ HSRFD WDUGD GL FXL LO FLFOR DJLRJUDILFR GHL 1RYH 6DQWL ID SDUWH FRP¶q JLj VWDWR SL YROWH VRWWROL QHDWRYDROWUHLOOLPLWHRJJHWWLYRGLSRWHUIRUQLUHHOHPHQWLVWRULFLFKHSRVVDQR DLXWDUFLDFKLDULUHEHQHLOFRQWHVWRLQFXLKDDYXWRRULJLQHODGLIIXVLRQHGHOOD IHGHFULVWLDQDLQ(WLRSLD(VVLIRUQLVFRQRXQHVHPSLRVWUDRUGLQDULRGLFRPHXQ SRSRORULVFULYHLOSURSULRSDVVDWRUHLQWHUSUHWDQGRORDOODOXFHGHLGDWLGLVSRQL ELOL H GHOO¶LPSRUWDQ]D GHYR]LRQDOH FKH OD PHQWDOLWj FROOHWWLYD DWWULEXLVFH D TXHVWLSDGULIRQGDWRULGHOPRQDFKHVLPRHWLRSLFRFRPHODWRULGHOPHVVDJJLRH GHOODYRORQWjGLYLQDHSURWHWWRULHFXVWRGLGLOXRJKLHGLSRSROD]LRQLDVVRJJHW WDWHDOOHOHJJLGLXQDQDWXUDQRQVHPSUHFOHPHQWHLQXQWHUULWRULRPHUDYLJOLR VDPHQWHDVSURTXDOHTXHOORGHO7HJUƗ\ 'LVHJXLWRYHUUjIRUQLWRXQULDVVXQWRGHOFRQWHQXWRGLTXHVWRUDFFRQWRD JLRJUDILFR1HOODVFHOWDGHOODUHVDGHOWHVWRVLqSUHIHULWRULVSHWWDUHLOFDUDWWHUH OHWWHUDOH GHOOD VXD WUDGX]LRQH DQFKH ODGGRYH L FRQFHWWL HVSUHVVL SRVVDQR LQ TXDOFKHPRGRDSSDULUHVLQJRODUL'DOSXQWRGLYLVWDJUDILFRLQYHFHVLqVFHOWR GL PDQWHQHUH O¶DUWLFROD]LRQH GHO WHVWR LQ OHWWXUHLQWURGRWWH GDO ULIHULPHQWR DO PHVHLQFXLYDQQROHWWH ,O*DGOD$OƝI 3HULOPHVHGL0DVNDUDP 1HOODFLWWjGL&HVDUHDYLYHYDXQXRPRPROWRULFFRGLQRPH$ZORJLVFRQ VXDPRJOLH7LNOD4HGGHVW,GXHHUDQRHVWUHPDPHQWHGHYRWLDO6LJQRUHVLUH FDYDQRLQFKLHVDWXWWLLJLRUQLHGLJLXQDYDQRRJQLVHWWLPDQDPDQRQSRWHYDQR DYHUHILJOL8QJLRUQRDYHQGRDFFROWRLQFDVDORURXQPRQDFRVROLWDULRULFH YHWWHURGDTXHVWLXQDQRWL]LDFKHOLODVFLzDWWRQLWLSUHVWRVDUHEEHQDWRORURXQ ILJOLRFKHQRQDYUHEEHDYXWRQLHQWHGLWHUUHQR 1DFTXHFRVuLOORUREDPELQRURVVRG¶DVSHWWRHVLUDOOHJUDURQRLVXRLJH QLWRULHLORURSDUHQWLHSHUIHVWHJJLDUHRUJDQL]]DURQRXQJUDQGHEDQFKHWWRSHU L PHQR IRUWXQDWL GHOOD FLWWj ,O SLFFROR HUD GLYHUVR GDJOL DOWUL EDPELQL QRQ SLDQJHYDPDLDQ]LULGHYDHJLRFDYDFRQJOLDQJHOLHLVXRLJHQLWRULDYHQGR LQWXLWRODQDWXUDQRQWHUUHQDGHOORURILJOLRORJOLFKLHGHYDQRGLIDUOLVWDUH LQ VDOXWH D OXQJR /R EDWWH]]DURQRQHOOD FKLHVD GHGLFDWD DOOD 0DGRQQD D&HVD UHD GRYH VL ULXQu WXWWR LO FOHUR GHOOD FLWWj H PHQWUH JOL LPSRQHYDQR LO VDFUD PHQWRHLOQRPHXQDFRORPEDELDQFDGLVFHVHVXGLOXLHVLSRVzVXOODVXDWH VWD ODVFLDQGR VWXSLWL WXWWL LSUHVHQWL FKHFRPLQFLDURQR D LQQDO]DUH ORGL DO 6L JQRUHHDOOD0DGRQQD5LWRUQDWLDFDVDLVXRLJHQLWRULRUJDQL]]DURQRXQDJUDQ GHIHVWDLQYLWDURQRWXWWDODSRSROD]LRQHHGLVWULEXLURQRDLYHVFRYLRURDUJHQ WRYHVWLSUH]LRVHSLDWWLHFDOLFLG¶RURGDGHVWLQDUHDOODFKLHVDHFLzFKHHUDD YDQ]DWRORUHJDODURQRDLSRYHULDOOHYHGRYHHDJOLRUIDQL1HOIUDWWHPSRTXHO IDQFLXOOR FUHEEH H VL IRUWLILFz QHOOR 6SLULWR 6DQWR LPSDUz L 6DOPL L OLEUL GHL 3URIHWLO¶$QWLFRHLO1XRYR7HVWDPHQWRHOH5HJROHGHOOD&KLHVD 4XDOFKHWHPSRGRSRLOVROLWDULR±ORVWHVVRFKHDYHYDDQQXQFLDWRODVXD QDVFLWD±UDSu$OƝIGLQRWWHORFRQGXVVHQHOGHVHUWRGL6FHWHHUDFFRQWzODVXD VWRULDDGDEEà3DFRPLR,OIDQFLXOORIXDFFROWRGDOODFRPXQLWjGHLPRQDFLFRQ LPPHQVRDPRUHSHUFKpLQOXLGLPRUDYDODJUD]LDGHO6LJQRUHPDODVXDLP SURYYLVDVFRPSDUVDDYHYDWUDVIRUPDWRODJLRLDGHLVXRLSDUHQWLLQWULVWH]]DOD FULPH H ODPHQWL 3LDQVHUR LQLQWHUURWWDPHQWH SHU TXDUDQWD JLRUQL H TXDUDQWD QRWWLLQVLHPHDLFRQFLWWDGLQLFKHVLHUDQRULXQLWLSHUFRQGLYLGHUHLOORURGROR UH,VXRLJHQLWRULGHFLVHURDOORUDGLUHFDUVLQHOGHVHUWRGL6FHWHHSLDQJHQGR FKLHVHURDGDEEà3DFRPLRGLVROOHYDUOLGDOODORURWULVWH]]D,OPRQDFRULVSRVH ORURGLIDUHULWRUQRLQSDFHQHOODORURFLWWj LQTXDQWRLO ORURILJOLRORQRQHUD *$ORPHWWHO¶LQGLFD]LRQHGHOPHVH ,OQRPHGHOODPDGUHGL$OƝIFRPSDUHLQTXHVWDIRUPDLQHQWUDPELLPDQRVFULWWLDOO¶LQL]LRGHO JDGOIRUVHFRUUX]LRQHGL7ƝNODPHQWUHDOODILQHGHOUDFFRQWRTXDQGRYLHQHULSHWXWRO¶HSLVR GLRVXOODQDVFLWDGHOVDQWRHVVRKDIRUPDµ7DNOD¶ $QWRQHOOD%ULWD SDUWHGLORURDOXLVLVDUHEEHURSURVWDWLWXWWLLUHGHOODWHUUDHDYUHEEHVRJJLR JDWR WXWWL L SRSROL H ULFHYXWR LQ GRQR RUR DUJHQWR H QRELOL YHVWL 1HOO¶XGLUH TXHVWDSURIH]LDODORURWULVWH]]DVLDOOHJJHUuHIHFHURULWRUQRQHOORURSDHVH,Q WDQWR$OòIFKHVLHUDQDVFRVWRSHUQRQLQFRQWUDUOLSRLFKp©ODVXD PHQWHHUD VWDWD WUDILWWD GDOO¶DPRUH GL &ULVWRª DXPHQWz OH VXH RSHUH FDULWDWHYROL H EHQ SUHVWR ULFHYHWWH O¶DVNòPà SHU PDQR GL 3DFRPLR &RVu ULPDVH LQ TXHO OXRJR DPPLQLVWUDQGR L PRQDFL VRGGLVIDFHQGR L ELVRJQL GLJUDQGL H SLFFROL H FRP SLHQGRPLUDFROL/DVXDIDPDVLVSDUVHLQWXWWHOHUHJLRQLG¶(JLWWR 3RFRGRSRLVXRLJHQLWRULPRULURQRDGLVWDQ]DGLSRFKLJLRUQLO¶XQRGDO O¶DOWUDVXRSDGUHO¶HVXDPDGUHLOGHOPHVHGL6DQò/DVXDSHQDIXLP PHQVDSLDQVHODFULPHDPDUHHLPRQDFLGHOODFRPXQLWjVLULXQLURQRSHUFRQ VRODUORLQVLHPHD3DFRPLRFKHXVFLWRGDOODVXDVSHORQFDVLDGRSHUzSHUIDUOR FDOPDUHHWUDQTXLOOL]]DUH $OòIHUDVROLWRYDJDUHQHOGHVHUWRSUHVWDQGRDLXWRDFKLQHDYHVVHELVR JQR'LJLXQDYDRJQLVHWWLPDQDHDVVDJJLDYDFLERHDFTXDVRORLO6DEDWR8Q JLRUQR3DFRPLRJOLDQQXQFLzFKHTXHOGHVHUWRQRQHUDLOVXRSXQWRG¶DUULYRH FKHSHUWURYDUHODVDOYH]]DGHOODVXDDQLPDVLVDUHEEHGRYXWRULYROJHUHDOO¶( WLRSLDGRYHDYUHEEHDYXWRXQDGLVFHQGHQ]DVSLULWXDOHHGRYHVDUHEEHVWDWDFR VWUXLWD XQD FKLHVD LQ VXR QRPH *OL DIILGz OH DOL GHOOD OXFH FKH OR DYUHEEHUR WUDVSRUWDWR RYXQTXH DYHVVH YROXWR 1HO VDOXWDUH L VXRL FRQIUDWHOOL VFRSUu FKH HVVL DYHYDQR GHFLVR GL VHJXLUOR FRVu GRSR DYHU FKLHVWR LO SHUPHVVR D 3DFR PLRSDUWLURQRWXWWLLQVLHPHSHUUHFDUVLLQ(WLRSLD*LXQVHURQHOODFLWWjGL$N VXPHIXURQRDFFROWLQHOSDOD]]RUHDOH/DORURIDPDVLGLIIXVHSUHVWR©LQWXWWH OH UHJLRQL G¶$]òE H G¶(WLRSLDª H WXWWL L UH GHOOD WHUUD VL SURVWUDYDQR D ORUR ODPELYDQRODSROYHUHGDLORURSLHGLHYHQLYDQRJXDULWLGDLORURPDOL/DWHUUD G¶(WLRSLDYHQQHVDQWLILFDWDGDOFDOFDUHGHLORURSLHGLHGXUDQWHLOSHULRGRGHOOD ORURSHPDQHQ]DDOWHPSRGHOUH.àOòEHGLVXRILJOLR*DEUD0DVTDOLQTXHO SDHVHQRQYLIXPDODWWLDQpPRUWHQpVRIIHUHQ]DQpIDPHQpVHWHQpIUHGGR QpQXGLWjQpWXPXOWLQpSHUVHFX]LRQLQRQYLIXURQRSDUDOLWLFLQp]RSSLQp VRUGRPXWLQpFLHFKLQpSRVVHGXWLQpVSLULWLPDOYDJLQRQYLIXLQJLXVWL]LDQp UDSLQDQpD]LRQLPDOYDJH5HJQDURQRODSDFHO¶DEERQGDQ]DHLOFLER±PLHOH ODWWHHROLR±GLVFHVRGDOFLHORFRPHUXJLDGD1RQHVLVWHYDQRSRYHULPDWXWWL HUDQRULFFKLHQRQEHYHYDQRDFTXDHELUUDPDYLQRHLGURPHOH,JLXGLFLHL SULQFLSLOHSHUVRQHLPSRUWDQWLGHOODFLWWjOHPRQDFKHJOLDGROHVFHQWLVLSUR VWUDYDQR D TXHL VDQWL FHOHEUDYDQR LO ORUR QRPH H OL RVVHTXLDYDQR (VVL GDO FDQWR ORUR VDQWLILFDYDQR OD 6LRQ FHOHVWH H LO ©WàERW GHOOD OHJJH GHO JUDQ 5H FRQ L VDFHUGRWL FKH OD DWWRUQLDYDQR H FRQ OR 6SLULWR 6DQWR FKH OD FRURQDYDª >*$OIIUDYE*$OIIUDUE@ ,O*DGOD$OƝI 3HULOPHVHGLؽHTHPW 8QJLRUQRDSSDUYHO¶DQJHORGHO6LJQRUHHGLVVHDL1RYH6DQWL©VXFFHVVR ULGHLGRGLFLDSRVWROLªGLQRQULPDQHUHLQXQXQLFROXRJRPDGLGLYLGHUVLHGL DQGDUHDSUHGLFDUHLOYDQJHOR/DQRWL]LDGHOODORURSDUWHQ]DVXVFLWzJUDQFOD PRUHHPDOLQFRQLDLQFLWWj$QFKHLOUH.àOòEDFFRPSDJQDWRGDVXRILJOLR*D EUD0DVTDODQGzDVDOXWDUOLHFKLHVHODORUREHQHGL]LRQHIDFHQGRXQGLVFRUVR GLSURIRQGDIHGH,VDQWLGL5RPUDFFRQWDURQRD.àOòEODVWRULDGHOORURYLDJ JLRIDFHQGRORFRPPXRYHUH DOSXQWRFKHFKLHVHORURGL VHJXLUOLHGL ULFHYHUH GDORURO¶DVNƝPƗ3RLLOUHSURPLVHGLFRVWUXLUHXQDFKLHVDLQWLWRODWDDFLDVFXQR GHL ORUR QRPL FRQ RUQDPHQWL G¶RUR H G¶DUJHQWR H SRVVHGLPHQWL LQ WHUUH SHU FROWLYDUHTXDQWRQHFHVVDULRDOIDEELVRJQRGHLPRQDFLVLIHFHDQFKHSURPHWWH UHGDVXRILJOLRLQTXDOLWjGLVXRHUHGHGLFXVWRGLUHWXWWRTXDQWRHGLHVHJXLUH LQRJQLPRPHQWRODYRORQWjGHLVDQWL(VVLORULQJUD]LDURQRJOLGLHGHURODEH QHGL]LRQHHIHFHURULWRUQRQHOODORURUHJLRQH3RL.ƗOƝEUDFFRPDQGzDOVXRH UHGHGLFXVWRGLUHODVXDOHJJHGLRQRUDUHLVXRLJHQLWRULHLOVXRSURVVLPRGL RQRUDUHLO6DEDWRGLHVVHUHXQSDGUHSHUJOLRUIDQLGLJLXGLFDUHFRQUHWWLWXGL QHFRPH&RVWDQWLQRGLDPDUHLOGLJLXQRHODSUHJKLHUDGLUHFDUVLLQFKLHVDDO PDWWLQRGLHODUJLUHDLSRYHULDJOLRUIDQLHDOOHYHGRYHHGLQRQDPDUHODULF FKH]]DWHUUHQD*DEUD0DVTDODYHQGRWURYDWRODJUD]LDGLIURQWHDVXRSDGUH VLSURVWUzGLQDQ]LDOWàERWGHO'LRG¶,VUDHOHHSUHJzGLULFHYHUHODIRU]DSHUJR YHUQDUH LO VXR UHJQR .àOòE PRUu DQ]LDQR PD QHO SLHQR GHO VXR YLJRUH H VL ULXQLURQRLOFOHURHLSRWHQWLGHOODFLWWjSHUSLDQJHUHLOORURVRYUDQR/RVHSSHO OLURQRQHOVHSROFURGHLUH>*$OIIYEYE*$OIIUEUE@ 3HULOPHVHGLHGƗU *DEUD0DVTDOVHGHWWHVXOWURQRGLVXRSDGUHHRUJDQL]]zXQFRQYLWRGX UDQWHLOTXDOHYHQQHURRIIHUWLFLELHEHYDQGHLQDEERQGDQ]DLQQXPHUHYROLFDSL GL EXRL DJQHOOL H FDSUL IXURQR VJR]]DWL SHU O¶RFFDVLRQH 9HQQH DQFKH GLVWUL EXLWRRURHDUJHQWRDLILJOL GHLGDEWDUàHFHUDHYHVWLSUH]LRVHSHUODFKLHVD 6DFHUGRWLHFDQWRULVDOPRGLDYDQRHFDQWDYDQRVXRQDQGRLWLPSDQLHFKLHGHQGR OXQJDYLWDHIRU]DSHULOORURUH8QDFRURQDG¶RURIXSRVWDVXOVXRFDSRIXRU QDWRFRQDELWLG¶RURHGLJHPPHVFLQWLOODQWLHLQGRVVzFDO]DULG¶RUR&RQFHVVH DLVDFHUGRWLWXWWRFLzFKHGHVLGHUDYDQRHOLIHFHVHGHUHDOODVXDPHQVDRUGLQDWL LQEDVHDOORURJUDGRIHFHVHUYLUHFLERHEHYDQGHHULYHVWuJUDQGLHSLFFLQLFRQ DELWLFDQGLGLHFRVWRVLLQRQRUHGHOOD6LRQFHOHVWH$OWHUPLQHGRSRDYHUEHQH GHWWRVXRSDGUHVLUHFzQHOODUHJJLDGRYHVLWURYDYDQRL1RYH6DQWLSHUHVVHUH EHQHGHWWRGDORUR6LLPSHJQzDFRVWUXLUHXQDFKLHVDLQWLWRODWDDFLDVFXQRGL HVVLHGRQzORURPROWRRURHDUJHQWRVHFRQGRTXDQWRGHVLGHUDYDQR $QWRQHOOD%ULWD ,Q VHJXLWR D FLz L1RYH 6DQWL VL GLYLVHUR RJQXQR VL UHFz QHO OXRJR PR VWUDWRJOLGDOO¶DQJHORGHO6LJQRUH$EEà$OòIVLGLUHVVHDVXGGL$NVXPHJLXQ VH LQ XQD FLWWj FKLDPDWD 0à\ 'àµUR GRYH SDVVz OD QRWWH SHU UHQGHUVL FRQWR GHOOHFRQGL]LRQLLQFXLYHUVDYD,QHIIHWWLPDQFDYDO¶DFTXDSHUGLVVHWDUHLOEH VWLDPH LQ TXDQWR OD IRQWH SL YLFLQD QRQ HUD IDFLOPHQWH DFFHVVLELOH ,O VDQWR UHFLWzGHOOHSUHJKLHUHHFKLHVHDOVXRGLVFHSRORGLIDUVLSRUWDUHGHOO¶DFTXDGD JOLDELWDQWLGHOOXRJR9ROHQGRYHULILFDUHO¶RSHUDWRGLTXHOODJHQWHVLVSRVWz LQXQ¶DOWUD]RQDSHURVVHUYDUOLPDTXDQGRHVVLORYLGHURVLVSDYHQWDURQRPROWR HVLSURVWUDURQRDOXLFKLHGHQGRJOLVHIRVVHXQDQJHORRSSXUHXQXRPR8PLO PHQWH $OòI ULVSRVH GL HVVHUH XQ XRPR WHUUHQR FRQVLGHUDWR QLHQWH SUHVVR JOL XRPLQL H VRWWRPHVVR DO SRSROR ,QWDQWR LO VXR GLVFHSROR HUD WRUQDWR UHFDQGR FRQVpSDQHYLQRHDFTXDFRQFXLODYDUVLLSLHGLHOHPDQLHLOVDQWROLRIIUuDL SUHVHQWL 0DQJLDURQR H ULQJUD]LDURQR WXWWL 4XDOFKH WHPSR GRSR JOL XRPLQL GHOODFLWWjSRUWDURQRGHOSDQHHGHOYLQRSUHVVRLOVDQWRSHUIDUOLEHQHGLUHPD IXURQR EORFFDWL GDO VXR GLVFHSROR SHUFKp HJOL VWDYD SUHJDQGR 4XDQGR HEEH WHUPLQDWR OL ULFHYHWWH HG HVVL VL SURVWUDURQR D OXL FKLHGHQGRJOL FRPH VL FKLD PDVVH(JOLULYHOzLOVXRQRPHHODVXDFLWWjG¶RULJLQH&HVDUHDHDJJLXQVHFKH LOQRPH$OòIVWHVVRQRPHGL'LRJOLHUDVWDWRGDWRGDXQDQJHORPDFKHQRQ VL VHQWLYD GHJQR GL SRUWDUOR FRQVLGHUDQGRVL XQ SHFFDWRUH4XHJOL XRPLQL JOL FKLHVHURGLULPDQHUHOuFRQORURHGHJOLVLDQJXVWLzQHOYHGHUHTXDQWRJUDQGH IRVVH O¶DPRUH FKH SURYDYDQR QHL VXRL FRQIURQWL 5LPDVH DOFXQL JLRUQL FRP SLHQGRJUDQGLPLUDFROLHIDFHQGRVJRUJDUHDFTXDFRUUHQWHGDLSLHGLGHLJUDQGL DOEHUL*OLDELWDQWLGHOODFLWWjJUDQGLHSLFFLQLHUDQRLQJLXELOR6LULXQLURQRH GL FRPXQH DFFRUGR GHFLVHUR GL FRVWUXLUH XQD GLPRUD SHU LO VDQWR QHOOD ORUR FLWWj4XDQGRSHUzJOLFRPXQLFDURQRODQRWL]LD$OòIVSLHJzORURFKHQRQSRWH YDUHVWDUHSHUFKp'LRDYHYDDOWULSURJHWWLSHUOXL(VVLDOORUDIHFHURULWRUQRDO OHORURFDVHWULVWLHVFRQVRODWL 8QDQRWWHLOVDQWRXVFuHDQGzLQFKLHVDSHUSUHJDUHHSHUFKLHGHUHDO6L JQRUHGLPRVWUDUJOLODYLDGDSHUFRUUHUH$OVXRULWRUQzWURYzFKHLOVXRGLVFH SRORLQYHFHGLSUHJDUHDYHYDGRUPLWRWXWWDODQRWWHHORULPSURYHUzVHYHUD PHQWH 3RL GLVVH DL EDPELQL GL DQGDUH D FKLDPDUH LORUR SDGUL H RUGLQz ORUR FKHJOLSRUWDVVHURWXWWLLPDODWLGHOODFLWWjHOLJXDUu'RSRDYHULPSDUWLWRJOL XOWLPLLQVHJQDPHQWLULSUHVHLOFDPPLQRLQVLHPHDLVXRLFRPSDJQLODVFLDQGR VLDOOHVSDOOHSLDQWLHODPHQWLSHUODVXDSDUWHQ]D3HUYHQQHURSUHVVRXQILXPH VHFFRLVXRLGLVFHSROLHUDQRDVVHWDWL$OƝIVLGLVWDQ]LzXQSR¶SHUUHFLWDUHXQD SUHJKLHUDEHQHGLVVHXQDURFFLDHIHFHVJRUJDUHXQDIRQWHSHUPHWWHQGRORURGL GLVVHWDUVL3RLOLDPPRQuFRQGLVFRUVL©GLYLWDHGLJLXVWL]LDLQFLWDQGROLDVDO YDUVLGDOGHPRQLRHDFRQILGDUHQHOODSRWHQ]DGHO6LJQRUHª$OWHUPLQHULSUH VHURLOYLDJJLRHJLXQVHURSUHVVRXQJUDQGHILXPH$OFXQLSDVWRULSRUWDURQRLQ GRQRGHOODWWHHVLDYYLFLQDURQRDOVDQWR4XHVWLFKLHVHORURVHDYHYDQRDGL ,O*DGOD$OƝI VSRVL]LRQH DFTXD SHU GLVVHWDUH OH ORUR PDQGULH PDL SDVWRUL VL ODPHQWDURQR SHULOIDWWRFKHO¶DFTXDHUDORQWDQD(JOLDOORUDFKLHVHGHOVDOHSHUFRQVDFUDUHLO ILXPH FRVu GD PRVWUDUH OD SRWHQ]D GL 'LR /¶DFTXD IX UHVD SRWDELOH H IHUWLOH FRQ©LOVDOHGHOYDVRGLDUJLOODªHSHUTXHVWRPRWLYRTXHOOXRJRIXFKLDPDWR 0Ɨ\ ࣩDZ /XQJR OD VWUDGD QHO GHVHUWR LO VDQWR IHFH VJRUJDUH DFTXD LQ VHL SXQWLGLYHUVL(RJQLYROWDFKHGDYDQWLDOVXRFDPPLQRVLWURYDYDSRFDDFTXD LOVDQWRIDFHYDDXPHQWDUHLOVXRIOXVVR3URVHJXHQGRJLXQVHLQXQDUHJLRQHDO ODTXDOHGLHGHLOPRPHGL%Hµ]Ɨ>*$OIIUDUE*$OIIUEUD@ 3HULOPHVHGL7Ɨĺàĺ 4XDQGR LO WƗERW GHO 'LR GL 6LRQ IX SRUWDWR LQ (WLRSLD LQVLHPH D HVVR JLXQVHXQXRPRGLQRPH*DEUDৡH\RQILJOLRGHOODVRUHOODGHOVDFHUGRWH6àGRTHILJOLRGHOIUDWHOORGHO UH0HQƝOHNHULFHYHWWH LQHUHGLWjODFLWWjGL$VHµà,QVXRQRPHTXHOODFLWWjIXFKLDPDWDGL%ƗUƗ\ILQRDRJJL(JOLGLHGHDOOD JHQWHGLTXHVWDUHJLRQHODVDPEXFD%Hµ]ƗGHOOD*HUXVDOHPPHFHOHVWHFKH YHQLYDVXRQDWDGDYDQWLDGHVVDQHLJLRUQLGLIHVWDSHUTXHVWDUDJLRQHTXHOOXR JRIXFKLDPDWR%Hµ]Ɨ $OƝI SHUYHQQH LQ TXHVWR OXRJR H GHFLVH GL ULSRVDUVL DL SLHGL GHO PRQWH 6DWDQDORFKLDPzDYRFHDOWDHJOLFKLHVHTXDOHIRVVHODUDJLRQHGHOODVXDYH QXWD1HOIUDWWHPSRJOLXRPLQLGHOODUHJLRQHDWWLUDWLGDOODYRFHGHOGHPRQLR DUULYDURQRFRUUHQGR©FRPHFDYDOOLªHFKLHVHURDOVDQWRFKLORDYHVVHPDQGDWR (JOLULVSRVHGLDYHUHIHGHQHO6LJQRUHLOTXDOHDYUHEEHVRWWRPHVVRODOLQJXDGL 6DWDQDFKHDYHYDXUODWRGDOODFLPDGHOPRQWH'HWWRTXHVWRFRPLQFLzODVXD DVFHVDHDRJQLSDVVRLOVDQWRIDFHYDLOVHJQRGHOODFURFHSHUVFDFFLDUHYLDLO GHPRQLR,QILQHORDIIHUUzFRQODVXDPDQRHJOLRUGLQzGLQRQIDUVLPDLSLUL YHGHUHLQTXHOOXRJRVDQWR*OLDVWDQWLVLVSDYHQWDURQRHVLSURVWUDURQRDLVXRL SLHGL PHQWUH LO GHPRQLR VL GLVVROVH LQ XQ QXJROR GL IXPR 4XHVWR IX LO VXR SULPR PLUDFROR LQ TXHO OXRJR 'HFLVH GL FKLDPDUH LO PRQWH 'DEUD 0ƗপHZ ©PRQWHGLYHWURªSRLFKpGDHVVRVLYHGHYDQROHFLWWjGHOORণƗPƗVƝQOHFLW WjGL(JJDOƗ$তVHµƗH0DGDEƗ\HVWDELOuFKHTXHOODVDUHEEHVWDWDODVXDGH VWLQD]LRQH(QWUzLQXQDQIUDWWRURFFLRVRVXOODWRVHWWHQWULRQDOHGHOPRQWHHFR PLQFLzDSUHJDUHDOORUDO¶DQJHORIHFHGLVFHQGHUHGDOFLHORSHUOXLLOSDQHHLO 4XLFRPLQFLDODOHWWXUDSHULOPHVHGL7ƗĞƗĞLQ*$O 'LOOPDQQFRO 'LOOPDQQFRO $QWRQHOOD%ULWD FDOLFHGLYLQR(JOLOLFRQVDFUzVSH]]zLOSDQHHQHGLVWULEXuDLVXRLGLVFHSROL 3HUVHWWHJLRUQLULPDVHFKLXVRQHOODVXDFHOODHYHQQHQXWULWRGDJOLDQJHOLFRQ LOSDQHGHOODYLWDHLOFDOLFHGLYLQR>*$OIIUEUE*$OIIUDUE@ 8QJLRUQRYROHQGRDPPLUDUHGDOEDVVRODEHOOH]]DGHOPRQWHLOVDQWR GLVFHVHFRQXQVXRGLVFHSRORHLQVLHPHIHFHURWUHJLULLQWRUQRDHVVR0HQWUH ULVDOLYDQRVLLPEDWWHURQRLQXQJURVVRVHUSHQWHFKHLQVHJXuLOVXRGLVFHSRORH ORGLYRUz$OòIJOLRUGLQzGLULJXUJLWDUORLPPHGLDWDPHQWHVRIILzVXGLOXLOR VSLULWRGLYLWDHGHJOLWRUQzDYLYHUH4XHOVHUSHQWHIXULGRWWRLQSH]]LHLOVXR VDQJXHqDQFRUDRJJLYLVLELOHVXOODYLDFKHFRQGXFHDOPRQWHLQPRGRFKHOD JHQWHSRVVDWRFFDUHFRQPDQRHULIHULUHTXHVWRVXRSURGLJLR7RUQDWLLQFLPDLO VDQWRIHFHFKLDPDUHDUDFFROWDLVXRLGLVFHSROLHGRSRDYHUUDGXQDWRSLHWUHH DOEHULFRVWUXLURQRXQFRQYHQWRFRQDQQHVVLXQDGLPRUDSHULSHOOHJULQLHXQ UHIHWWRULR GRYH SRWHUVL VHGHUH D WDYROD WXWWL LQVLHPH >*$O II UEUD *$OIIUEYE@ 3HULOPHVHGLؽHUU ,Q VHJXLWR VL ULXQLURQR JOL XRPLQL GHOOD UHJLRQH HPLVHUR DO FRUUHQWH LO VDQWR GHL QXPHURVL PDODWL H SRVVHGXWL FKH VL WURYDYDQR LQ HVVD (JOL FKLHVH FKHYHQLVVHURFRQGRWWLSUHVVRGLOXLVSLHJDQGRFKHVHIRVVHVWDWRLQJUDGRGL JXDULUOLORDYUHEEHIDWWR/LDFFRPSDJQDURQRFRQGXFHQGROLQHOOHORUREDUHOOH HGDYDQWLDOODVXDSRUWDLGHPRQLXUODYDQRHVLULEHOODYDQR,OVDQWRVHSSHJXD ULUHWXWWLFRQODVXDSDUROD&RVuLQTXHOWHPSRQRQYLIXURQRSLPDODWLHVRI IHUHQWL JUD]LH DL VXRL PLUDFROL FKH HUDQR ©FRPH OHVWHOOH GHO FLHOR H FRPH OD VDEELDGHOPDUHª $LSLHGLGL'DEUD0ƗপHZYLHUDXQROHDVWURH6DWDQDDYHQGRDVVXQWROH VHPELDQ]HGLXQOHRSDUGRYLVLHUDDGDJLDWRVRSUDHLQIDVWLGLYDODJHQWHFKH SDVVDYD GL Ou SHU DQGDUH D WURYDUH LO VDQWR 4XHVWL YHQXWR D FRQRVFHQ]D GHO IDWWR VL SUHFLSLWz H OR WUDILVVH LQVLHPH DOO¶DOEHUR 'D TXHOOD IHVVXUD YLVLELOH DQFRUDRJJL VJRUJzXQD IRQWH G¶DFTXD WHUDSHXWLFDSHUPDODWL H SHU OHGRQQH VWHULOL$WDOSURSRVLWRYLHUDXQDIDQFLXOODLQFLQWDLOFXLIHWRHUDDWWDFFDWRDO O¶XWHURVDOuVXOPRQWHEHYYHO¶DFTXDHJXDUuVXELWR'LHGHDOODOXFHXQILJOLR JUD]LRVRHEHQHGHWWRFKHFKLDPz$OƝIHRJQLJLRUQRJOLUDFFRQWDYDOHYLFHQGH GHOVDQWR4XDQGRIXDGROHVFHQWHORFRQGXVVHSUHVVRODVXDFKLHVDHORDIILGz DLPRQDFLGRSRDYHUORURUDFFRQWDWRWXWWDODVXDVWRULD,OIDQFLXOORIXLVWUXLWR 4XLFRPLQFLDODOHWWXUDSHULOPHVHGL7ƗপĞƗĞLQ*$O *$ORPHWWHO¶LQGLFD]LRQHGHOPHVH ,O*DGOD$OƝI QHOOH6DFUH6FULWWXUHHQHOOH5HJROHGHLPRQDFLHULFHYHWWHO¶DVNƝPƗGHJOLDQ JHOL4XHOO¶DOEHURVLWURYDDQFRUjOuHSUHVVRGLHVVRFRQWLQXDQRDYHULILFDUVL PLUDFROL>*$OIIUDUE*$OIIYEYE@ 3HULOPHVHGL<DNNƗWLW ,QVHJXLWRDTXHVWRHYHQWRDEEƗ$OƝIVLULWLUzQHOODVXDVSHORQFDHGLJLXQz SHUTXDUDQWDJLRUQLHTXDUDQWDQRWWL4XHOPRQWHHUDVLPLOHDXQDFURFHDXQD FDSDQQDHDXQDWHQGDHGHUDLUULJDWRGDTXDWWURILXPL9LHUDQRIUXWWHWLGLR JQLWLSRHYLYLYHYDQRPROWLSDGULVDQWL/RVSLULWRGL$OƝIVLUDOOHJUDYDQHOYH GHUHTXHOSRVWRHQHOO¶DVSLUDUQHLOEXRQSURIXPR ,O PRQDVWHURDYHYD LQROWUH VHWWDQWDILQHVWUHHFLQTXDQWDSRUWHFKHQRQYHQLYDQRPDLFKLXVHQpGLJLRUQR QpGLQRWWH1RQDYHYDHJXDOLVXOODWHUUDHLQ3DUDGLVRXQSRVWRFRPHTXHOOR GRYHQRQHVLVWHYDODQRWWHRLOJLRUQRLOVROHRODOXQDSHUFKpHVVRYLYHYDGL OXFHSURSULDHLJLXVWLDORURYROWDYLYHYDQRGLTXHOODOXFH,PRQDFLFRQWDPL QDWLGDOSHFFDWRWHUUHQRFRUURWWLDJJKLQGDWLFRQYHVWLRUQDWHHSUH]LRVHQRQ SRWHYDQR YHGHUOR H QRQ SRWHYDQR HQWUDUYL ,Q HVVR HEEH VHGH LO WƗERW GHOOD 9HUJLQH FRVWUXLWR FRQ RUR DUJHQWR H SLHWUH SUH]LRVH FRQ JHPPH ]DIILUL H VPHUDOGLHFKHOXFFLFDYDSLGHOVROHGHOODOXQDHGHOOHVWHOOH /HVXHDFTXH HUDQRVDSRULWHSLGHO PLHOHGHOOR]XFFKHURHGHOODWWH GHO3DUDGLVR$PPL UDQGRTXHOORVSOHQGRUHLOSDGUHVDQWRJOLGHGLFzXQLQQR4XHOODFKLHVDGHGL FDWDDOOD0DGRQQDHUDQDVFRVWDHQRQDFFHVVLELOHDWXWWL>*$OIIUEUD *$OIIYEUD@ 3HULOPHVHGL0DJJƗELW ,SUHIHWWLORFDOLLQROWUHFRVWUXLURQRVXOPRQWHXQ¶DOWUDEHOODFKLHVDLQWLWR ODWDDOQRPHGL$OòILOFXLLQJUHVVRDGLIIHUHQ]DGLTXHOODGHGLFDWDDOOD0D GRQQDHUDFRQVHQWLWRDWXWWLPRQDFLSHFFDWRULSHUVRQHFRPXQLXRPLQLGRQ QHDQ]LDQLEDPELQLHYHGRYH7XWWDTXHVWDJHQWHSRWHYDVRVWDUHQHOODSDUWHH VWHUQDPHQWUHODSDUWHSLLQWHUQDHUDGHVWLQDWDDJOLHOHWWLFRPHHUHGLWjSHUSH WXD$OƝIFKLHGHYDHRWWHQHYDPROWHFRQFHVVLRQLGDVRYUDQLJLXGLFLHSULQFLSL RURDUJHQWRYHVWLSUH]LRVHSDUDPHQWLHOLEULVDFULGDGHVWLQDUHDOODFKLHVDH FLERSHULPRQDFL,WULEXWLGHOOHWHUUHGLণƗPƗVƝQâLতDJH$তVHµƗYHQQHURX WLOL]]DWL SHU FRVWUXLUH OH FDVH LO UHIHWWRULR SHUL PRQDFL SHU OH YHGRYH SHU L *$ORPHWWHO¶LQGLFD]LRQHGHOPHVH $QWRQHOOD%ULWD SHOOHJULQLHOHPXUDGHOFRQYHQWRHGHOODFKLHVD/DSRSROD]LRQHGHOORণƗPƗ VƝQLQROWUHGLSURSULDLQL]LDWLYDLQYLDYDSHUORURFLERPLHOHROLRROLYHHIUX PHQWRPHQWUHSHUODFKLHVDLWULEXWLGHOORURRURHGHOORURDUJHQWRFRPHD YHYDQRGLVSRVWRLUH.àOòEH*DEUD0DVTDO%XRLHSHFRUHYHQLYDQRDPPD] ]DWLHVHUYLWLLQRFFDVLRQHGLIHVWHVROHQQLHLQQXPHUHYROLIXURQROHGLVSRVL]LR QLSHUO¶LPPDJLQHGHOODFKLHVD 4XDOFKHWHPSRGRSR$OƝIFKLHVHDLVXRLILJOLVSLULWXDOLGLFRVWUXLUHXQVH SROFURSHULOVXRFRUSRQHOODFKLHVDGHGLFDWDDOOD0DGRQQDD'DEUD0ƗপHZ VXDDPDWDGLPRUD*LXGLFLHUHDYHYDQRPROWRULVSHWWRSHU$OòIHSHULVXRLGL VFHSROLHVHJXLYDQRFRVWDQWHPHQWHODORURYRORQWjHLOVDQWROLDVVLVWHYDQHOOH JXHUUHHIDFHYDLQPRGRFKHULWRUQDVVHURDOOHORURGLPRUHYLWWRULRVLHLQVDOX WH4XHLJLXVWLYHJOLDYDQRVHPSUHVXGLORURHSHUTXHVWRPRWLYROLRQRUDYDQR H DVFROWDYDQR L ORUR GLVFRUVL GL VDQWLWj ,O UH *DEUD 0DVTDO WHQQH IHGH DOOD SURPHVVDIDWWDDVXRSDGUHDVVLFXUzDLPRQDFLLWULEXWLLQRURDUJHQWRYHVWL SUH]LRVHFLERPLHOHHROLR,OVXRIXXQUHJQRGLSDFHGXUDQWHLOTXDOHQHVVX QRVRIIUuODIDPHRODVHWH1RQYLIXVLFFLWjQpFDOGRHFFHVVLYRHPDLQLHQWH PLQDFFLzLUDFFROWLQpJUDQGLQHQpORFXVWHQpEUXFKLQpFDYDOOHWWHQpWRSL SRLFKpTXHOODWHUUDHUDVWDWDVDQWLILFDWDFRQO¶LPSURQWDGHLORURSLHGL,QWXWWD ODUHJLRQHVLUHVSLUDYDDULDGLDPRUHHGLSDFHGLDOOHJULDHGLWUDQTXLOOLWjGL GHOL]LDHGLDEERQGDQ]DHTXDQGRFDSLWDYDQRGHLSHOOHJULQLJOLDELWDQWLGLTXHO OXRJRIDFHYDQRDJDUDDFKLGRYHVVHRVSLWDUOL4XDQGRSRLYHGHYDQRXQPR QDFRFRUUHYDQRDGDFFRJOLHUORHJOLODYDYDQRLSLHGLHOHPDQL,PRQDFLLQRO WUHFRQVDFUDYDQRLPDODWLFRQIRUPXOHULWXDOLSHUJXDULUOLHVFDFFLDYDQRLGH PRQL>*$OIIUDUD*$OIIUDUD@ 3HULOPHVHGL0L\Ɨ]\Ɨ $OƝI YLVVH GD UHFOXVR SHU VHWWDQWD DQQL D 'DEUD 0ƗপHZ VWDQGR LQ SLHGL FRPHXQDFRORQQD$LODWLGHOVXRFRUSRVLVWHPzGHJOLDFXOHLGLIHUURFKHJOL IHULYDQRLILDQFKLHOHVXHODFULPHVFRUUHYDQRFRPHSLRJJLDVHQ]DLQWHUUX]LR QH QRQ FKLXGHYD PDL JOL RFFKL SHU IDUOL ULSRVDUH H DPDYD LO VLOHQ]LR 2JQL JLRUQR FRPSLYD PLJOLDLD GL SURVWUD]LRQL TXDWWURPLOD DO PDWWLQR H VHWWHPLOD GXUDQWHODQRWWH,OVXRVXGRUHVFRUUHYD©FRPHXQULYRORGLSLRJJLDHFRPHOH RQGHGHOPDUHªHYHQLYDUDFFROWRLQXQUHFLSLHQWHHXVDWRSHUJXDULUHLPDODWL HLSDUDOLWLFL 8QJLRUQRVLPDQLIHVWDURQRDOXLLO6LJQRUHDWWRUQLDWRGDPLJOLDLDGLDQ JHOL 0LNƗ¶ƝO *DEUH¶ƝO 6XUƗIƝO .LUXEƝO $IQLQ 5ƗJX¶ƝO 6ƗTX¶ƝO 5XIƗ¶ƝO µ8UH¶ƝO6XU\ƗO6DGƗN\ƗOOD0DGRQQDDFFRPSDJQDWDGDOOHYHUJLQLGDTXD UDQWDWUHGRQQHVDQWHGDLTXDWWURHYDQJHOLVWLGDLTXLQGLFLSURIHWLGDLGRGLFLD SRVWROL GDL VHWWDQWDGXHGLVFHSROL GDL FLQTXHFHQWR FRQIUDWHOOL GDL WUHFHQWRGL ,O*DGOD$OƝI FLRWWR RUWRGRVVL GHO &RQFLOLR GL 1LFHD GDL GXHFHQWR PHPEUL GHO &RQFLOLR GL (IHVR GDL FHQWRTXDUDQWD GHO &RQFLOLR GL &RVWDQWLQRSROL GDL TXDWWURFHQWR IDQFLXOOL'DYLGHUHG¶,VUDHOHFRQLOVXRPƗVDQTRPHQWUHFDQWDYDLYHUVLGHL 6DOPL ,O 6LJQRUH JOL SDUOz H JOL DQQXQFLz OD VXD LPPLQHQWH PRUWH *OL GLVVH FKHORDYUHEEHIDWWRULSRVDUHGDOVXRODYRURHFKHJOLDYUHEEHFRQFHVVRLQHUH GLWjODFLWWjGRYHVFRUUHODWWHHPLHOHSHUDYHUULILXWDWRLOPRQGRJOLDYUHEEH FRQFHVVR LQROWUH OH QR]]H QHL FLHOL SHU HVVHUVL DVWHQXWR GDOOH QR]]H WHUUHQH *OLGLVVHFKHORDYUHEEHIDWWRVGUDLDUHQHOJUHPERGL$EUDPRGL,VDFFRHGL *LDFREEHHLQYLUWGHOIDWWRFKHHUDULPDVWRLQSLHGLSHUVHWWDQWDDQQLWUDILJ JHQGRVLLILDQFKLFRQDFXOHLGLIHUURDJX]]LFKHORDYUHEEHIDWWRUHJQDUHSHU VHWWDQWD DQQL QHOOD *HUXVDOHPPH FHOHVWH FRQ L UH JLXVWL H FRQ L PDUWLUL *OL SURPLVHFKHLQRPLGLWXWWLFRORURFKHDYHVVHURVFULWWRRFRPPLVVLRQDWRLOVXR JDGOVDUHEEHURVWDWLVFULWWLQHOOLEURGHOODYLWDHFKHFKLDYHVVHVIDPDWRO¶DIID PDWRHGDWRGDEHUHDOO¶DVVHWDWRQHOVXRQRPHDYUHEEHULFHYXWRGDPDQJLDUHLO SDQHGHOODYLWDHGDEHUHO¶DFTXDGHOODYLWDFKHVFRUUHQHOO¶(GRPGHO3DUDGLVR *OLSURPLVHDQFKHFKHDYUHEEHDFFROWRQHO6XRUHJQRFKLXQTXHDYHVVHSUHVWD WRQHOVXRQRPHDLXWRDLVRIIHUHQWLHFKHDYUHEEHSURWHWWRGDRJQLPDOHGDQ GRVROOLHYRHULSRVRDLORURSDGULFKLXQTXHDYHVVHFKLDPDWRLSURSULILJOLFRQ LOVXRQRPH'HWWRTXHVWRJOLFRQFHVVHLONLGƗQHODSRVVLELOLWjGLFRQWHPSODUH ODJUDQGH]]DGHJOLDQJHOLHGHJOL$SRVWROLO¶RQRUHGHLSURIHWLHODJUDQGH]]D GHLPDUWLULODJORULDGL0DULD6XDPDGUHODJUDQGH]]DGL*LRYDQQLFKH/R DYHYDEDWWH]]DWRQHO*LRUGDQRHTXHOODGL0LFKHOHDQJHORGHO6XRFRQVLJOLR HGL*DEULHOHSRUWDWRUHGHOOLHWRDQQXQFLRODPDJQLILFHQ]DGHL4XDWWUR$QL PDOLGHLYHQWLTXDWWURVDFHUGRWLGHOFLHORHGHLTXDWWURHYDQJHOLVWLFKHKDQQR DQQXQFLDWR OD SDUROD GLYLQD H DWWLQWR DL WRUUHQWL GHOOD ORGH OD JUDQGH]]D GHL JLXVWLFKHUHFDQRQHOO¶DQLPRODFURFHGHOOD6XDPRUWH$QFRUDJOLGLVVHGLRV VHUYDUHODJUDQGH]]DGL$EUDPR6XRDPDWRGL*LDFREEH6XRIHGHOHGL,VDF FR6XRVHUYLWRUHGL1Rq6XRVHUYRGL'DYLGHUHIHGHOHGL6DPXHOHGL,VD LDGL(OLD>«@ 1HOO¶XGLUHTXHVWHSDUROHXQWUHPRUHVLLPSRVVHVVzGHOFRUSRGL$OƝIVHQ Wu FKH OH IRU]H JOL YHQLYDQR D PDQFDUH H DYHYD O¶DVSHWWR GL XQ FDGDYHUH *OL DQJHOLORDIIHUUDURQRHORVRVWHQQHURLQFRUDJJLDQGRORPHQWUHLO6LJQRUHGR SRDYHUULEDGLWRLOVXRJLXUDPHQWRVFRPSDUYHGDOODVXDYLVWD>*$OIIUD YD*$OIIUDUE@ ©&LQTXHFHQWRªQHO*$O $QWRQHOOD%ULWD 3HULOPHVHGL*HQERW ,OVDQWRULXQuWXWWLLVXRLGLVFHSROLHUDFFRQWzORURO¶DFFDGXWR3RLVLDP PDOzHO¶GHO PHVHGL0DJJƗELWUHVHODVXDDQLPD(VVLSLDQVHURHIXURQR GLVWUXWWLGDOGRORUH/RVHSSHOOLURQRFDQWDQGRHLQQDO]DQGRLQQLGLORGHDO6L JQRUH QHOOD FKLHVD GHGLFDWD DOOD 0DGRQQD FRVWUXLWD QHOOH YLVFHUH GL 'DEUD 0ƗপHZGRYHVRORLVXRLGLVFHSROLSRWHYDQRDFFHGHUH$EEà'àQ¶òOIXQRPL QDWR VXR VXFFHVVRUH D FDSR GHO PRQDVWHUR FRVWUXLWR DOO¶LQWHUQR GHO PRQWH 4XHOOXRJRVHPEUDYDLOSDHVHGHLEHDWLHWXWWLJRGHYDQRGLRWWLPDVDOXWHQRQ YLHUDQpVRIIHUHQ]DQpPDODWWLDQpPRUWHQpWULVWH]]DQpIDPHQpVHWHSHU FKpLQHVVRVJRUJDYDO¶DFTXDGHOODYLWDHLOVXRRGRUHVRDYHUDSLYDLFXRUL'D EUD 0ƗপHZ HUD GXQTXH DWWUDYHUVDWR GD TXDWWUR ILXPL XQR VFRUUHYD VXO ODWR RULHQWDOHHYHQLYDFKLDPDWR0Ɨ\DৡƝQƗ,LQYLUWGHOVXRSURIXPRXQRVFRU UHYDVXOODWRRFFLGHQWDOHXQRVFRUUHYDVXOODWRPHULGLRQDOHHYHQLYDFKLDPDWR 0Ɨ\D'HOGHOXQRVXOODWRVHWWHQWULRQDOH7XWWLHTXDWWURDYHYDQRRULJLQHDO O¶LQWHUQRGHOPRQWHLUULJDYDQRLULJRJOLRVLYLJQHWLGHLPRQDFLHDWWUDYHUVDYD QRODUHJLRQHGL%HK]Ɨ,SHUPHWWHQGRDJOLDELWDQWLHDOOHORURPDQGULHGLGLV VHWDUVL$FDSRGHOPRQDVWHURHVWHUQRDOPRQWHIXSRVWRDEEƗ0DUতD.UHVWRV LO TXDOH VL UHFz SUHVVR LO JUDQGH DQWUR URFFLRVR GRYH DYHYD GLPRUDWR $OƝI H SUHJDQGRFKLHVHGLYHGHUHLOVDQWXDULRLQWHUQRHLOVHSROFURGHOVDQWR4XHVWL JOL DSSDUYH H JOL GLVVH FKH QRQ JOL HUD FRQVHQWLWRGL YHGHUOL PD FKH GRYHYD LPSHJQDUVLDJXLGDUHLOVXRSRSRORQHOODUHWWLWXGLQHHQHOODJLXVWL]LDDIILQFKp DQFKH HJOL SRWHVVH GLYHQLUH LPPDJLQH GHL FLHOL ,OPRQDFR DOORUD VL UHFz QHO FRQYHQWRHUDFFRQWzTXDQWRJOLHUDDSSHQDVXFFHVVR,PRQDFLULPDVHURDWWRQL WLHLQQDO]DURQREHDWLWXGLQL 8QJLRUQR0DUতD.UHVWRVDQGzQHOYLJQHWRSHUFRQWUROODUHFKHRJQLFRVD IRVVH DO VXR SRVWR H WURYz L VXRL GLVFHSROL FKH VL LQWUDWWHQHYDQR FRQ DOFXQH GRQQH4XHVWLFROWLVXOIDWWRLPSDOOLGLURQRHFHUFDURQRGLJLXVWLILFDUVLDGGX FHQGREDQDOLVFXVH,OPRQDFROLSLFFKLzFRQXQDVFXWLFDHOLULPSURYHUzVHYH UDPHQWH/HGRQQHVSDYHQWDWHVFDSSDURQRLQWXWWHOHGLUH]LRQLPHQWUHLPR QDFLEDVWRQDWLFKLHVHURSHUGRQRSURPLVHURGLQRQULSHWHUHSLORVWHVVRHUUR UHIDWWRQHOO¶LJQRUDQ]DHSUHJDURQRGLHVVHUHLVWUXLWLQHOO¶RSHUDHQHOODOHJJH GHOORVSLULWR$OORUD0DUতD.UHVWRVWRUQzDOPRQDVWHURUDFFRQWzDJOLDOWULPR QDFLFLzFKHHUDVXFFHVVRHGLVSRVHFKHLOYLJQHWRIRVVHFXVWRGLWRGDORURDWXU 'LOOPDQQFROծӅRGRU 0DQFDLOQRPHGHJOLDOWULGXHILXPLLQHQWUDPELLPDQRVFULWWL 6LFLQHQWUDPELLFRGLFL ,O*DGOD$OƝI QR6~ELWRGXHGLHVVLIXURQREHQHGHWWLGDOXLHGDJOLDQ]LDQLHSUHVHURLOSRVWR GLTXHLGLVFHSROLSHFFDWRULFKHIHFHURULWRUQRQHOORURSDHVH3HUTXHVWRDOWHU QDUVLGLPRQDFLQHOYLJQHWRGDTXHOJLRUQRTXHOODWHUUDSUHVHLOQRPHGL0HGUD )DOƗVi©WHUUDGHOSHOOHJULQRª4XHLPRQDFLIXURQRJUDGLWLDOO¶DEDWHLQTXDQWR LQFUHPHQWDURQRODGHGL]LRQHDOODYRURHOHYLWLGDYDQRIUXWWLWUHYROWHDOO¶DQQR 5HVHUR TXHO OXRJR VLPLOH D 0HGUD 6DNƝPFDYHUQD GRSSLD3LDQWDURQR L QROWUHPROWHSLDQWHHYHUGXUHSHULOIDEELVRJQRGHLPRQDFLHRIIULURQRLORUR IUXWWLHLOYLQRDQFKHDUHJLXGLFLHSULQFLSLULFHYHQGRLQFDPELRRURDUJHQWR HYHVWLSUH]LRVHHODFRPPHPRUD]LRQHGHOVDQWR$OƝIRJQLPHVHWXWWLJOLDQQL >*$OIIYDUD*$OIIUEUD@ 3HULOPHVHGL6DQƝ 9LHUDXQPRQDFRGLQRPHDEEƗ<HVতDTXRPRSLRHVHQ]DPDOL]LDFKHVL UHFDYDLQFKLHVDDWXWWHOHRUHGHOJLRUQRHGHOODQRWWHHQRQSDUODYDFRQQHV VXQR ,QGRVVDYD LO FLOLFLR H QRQ YHGHYD LO YROWR GL XQD GRQQD GD TXDQGR HUD EDPELQR'LJLXQDYDWXWWHOHVHWWLPDQHHVLQXWULYDVRORGLRUWDJJLVHOYDWLFL8Q JLRUQR HEEH OD IRUWXQD GL YHGHUH LO PRQDVWHUR DOO¶LQWHUQR GHO PRQWH H LO VXR VDQWXDULRVLLQQDPRUzGLTXHOOXRJRDWDOSXQWRFKHGHFLVHGLPRULUHOu8QR GHLPRQDFLJOLPRVWUzDQFKHLOVHSROFURGHOVDQWR$OòILOUHIHWWRULRGHLVROLWDUL HLOOXRJRLQFXLVLWURYDYDO¶DFTXDFXUDWLYDFKHDYHYDLOVDSRUHGHOPLHOHHGHO ODWWHHJOLHQHGLHGHGDEHUH$EEƗ<HVতDTDOORUDVLFDOzLQXQDEXFDDYHQGROD VFHOWDFRPHVXDGLPRUDPDLOPRQDFRJOLGLVVHFKHQRQSRWHYDULPDQHUHOuH FKHVDUHEEHGRYXWRDQGDUHLQXQFRQYHQWRSLDOWRHDQQXQFLDUHDWXWWLFLzFKH DYHYD YLVWR4XHOO¶XRPRSLRSLDQVHSHUFKpGHVLGHUDYDSLGLRJQLDOWUDFRVD PRULUH Ou H SHQVz FKH SHU L VXRL SHFFDWL QRQ JOL IRVVH FRQVHQWLWR 0HQWUH LO &IU$W 4XHVWRQRPHVHPEUHUHEEHIDUULIHULPHQWRDOODFDYHUQDGL0DNSHODDFTXLVWDWDD$EUDPRFR PHVHSROFURHQRPLQDWDLQ*HQH*HQFIU'LOOPDQQFRO,OQRPHHEUD LFR0DNSHODqVWDWRWUDGRWWRQHOODYHUVLRQHGHL6HWWDQWDSURSULRFRQǠʓ ǟǜʐǗǍǕǛǙ Ǡʓ ǐǕǜǗǛ˺Ǚ ©ODFDYHUQDGRSSLDª,OWHVWRQHOPDQRVFULWWR*$OULSRUWDOHWWHUDOPHQWHӺњѢԟӽ֓ кԟӗҤ֓ ъӝӇ֓ Ӛъ֓ яԧњ֓ ѢӞя֓ ҒԅҢ֓ӝԇҒҧ֓ Ӻҥպќ֓ Ғԅъҧ֓ ֝ԼԎ©UHVHURTXHOOXR JRVLPLOHD0HGUD6DNƝPODFDYHUQDGRSSLDHIUXWWLILFDYDWUHYROWHDOO¶DQQRªPHQWUHQHOPD QRVFULWWR*$OVLOHJJHӺњѢԟӽ֓ кԟӗҤ֓ ъӝӇ֓ Ӛъ֓ яԧњ֓ ѢӞя֓ ҒԅҢ֓Ӛъ֓ ҥպќ֓ӝԇҒҢ֓ ҒҒԅъҧ֓ ֝ԼԎ©UHVHURTXHOOXRJRVLPLOHD0HGUD6DNƝPODFDYHUQDFR PHIUXWWLILFDGRSSLDPHQWHRJQLDQQRWUHYROWHªLOWHVWRqHYLGHQWHPHQWHFRUURWWR'HYROHLQ IRUPD]LRQL ELEOLFKH ULSRUWDWH LQ TXHVWD QRWD DOOD FRUWHVLD H DOOD GLVSRQLELOLWj GHO PLR DPLFR /HRQDUGR/HSRUH $QWRQHOOD%ULWD PRQDFRFHUFDYDGLVSLHJDUJOLOHUDJLRQLSHUFXLJOLHUDVWDWRFRQFHVVRGLYHGH UH 'DEUD 0ƗপHZ HJOL XVFu GDOOD EXFD H VFRPSDUYH LQJRLDWR GDOOD FKLHVD ,O PRQDFRVLSUHFLSLWzVXOPRQWHHUDFFRQWzO¶DFFDGXWRDLVXRLIUDWHOOL,QVHJXLWR PRUuO¶GHOPHVHGL0DJJƗELWHIXVHSSHOOLWRQHOODFKLHVDLQDOWRFRQRQRUH H FRQ JLXELOR H TXHVWR PLUDFROR IX VFULWWR QHO OLEUR GHOOD ORWWD VSLULWXDOH GHO VDQWR$OƝI 2JQLDQQRXVFLYDGDOVHSROFURGHOVDQWRXQDOXFHFKHDYHYDLOFRORUHGL XQDURVDHLOSURIXPRGHOO¶LQFHQVRHFRQHVVDLVDQWLJXDULYDQRJOLDPPDODWL /DJHQWHVLUDGXQDYDGDRJQLOXRJRSHUDVVLVWHUHDTXHVWRSURGLJLR8QPRQD FRGLQRPHDEEƗ%HVƗ\SUHJzQHOPHVHGLܑHTHPWSHUTXDUDQWDJLRUQLHTXD UDQWDQRWWLFKLHGHQGRGLYHGHUHLOVDQWXDULRQDVFRVWRPDXQRGHLVXRLPRQDFL DSSDUVRJOLLQYLVLRQHJOLULVSRVHFKHDQHVVXQRHUDFRQFHVVDXQFRVDVLPLOH 3RLJOLFRQVLJOLzGLQRQYDJDUHGDXQPRQDVWHURDOO¶DOWURPDGLULPDQHUHLQ XQXQLFROXRJRSHUVHPSUH>*$OIIUDYD*$OIIUDYD@ 3HULOPHVHGLۉDPOƝ 'XHIUDWHOOLGLQRPHৡDµƗGƗH7DZDOGDVLGLYLVHURWUDGLORURODUHJLRQHGL %Hত]ƗFRPH&DOHEH*LRVXqVLHUDQRGLYLVLODWHUUDGHOO¶HUHGLWj(VVLVLFKLD PDYDQRFRPHLORURSDGULHEUHLTXHLOHYLWLFKHHUDQRJLXQWLFRQLOWƗERWGHO 'LRG¶,VUDHOHHGHUDQRFRPHLORURSDGUL$GDPR1Rq$EUDPR,VDFFRH*LD FREEH (UDQR PROWR ULFFKL H FHOHEUDYDQR OD FRPPHPRUD]LRQH GL $OƝI RJQL PHVH H IDFHYDQR RSHUH GL EHQH FRQ VROOHFLWXGLQH SURPXRYHQGR LO VXR FXOWR >*$OIIYDYE*$OIIYDYD@ 3HULOPHVHGL1DDVƝ 8QVROLWDULRGLQRPH(QEƗTRPFKHYLYHYDD'DEUD0ƗপHZSURIHWL]]zLQ SXQWR GL PRUWH FKH LO PRQDVWHUR HVWHUQR GL $OƝI VDUHEEH DQGDWR GLVWUXWWR H FKHTXHOOXRJRVDUHEEHULPDVWRGHVHUWRIUHTXHQWDWRVRORGDXFFHOOLUDSDFLHGD DVLQL VHOYDWLFL 1HVVXQ PRQDFR VRWWRPHVVR DO GLJLXQR H DOOD SUHJKLHUD OR D YUHEEHSLIUHTXHQWDWRHVRODPHQWHSRFKLXRPLQLVDUHEEHURVRSUDYYLVVXWL/H FDXVH GL TXHVWR GLVDVWUR VDUHEEHUR GLSHVH GDO SURJUHVVLYR GHJUDGR VSLULWXDOH GHOVXRFOHUR/HFRQWLQXHGRQD]LRQLGLRURDUJHQWRHYHVWLSUH]LRVHIDWWHGDL VRYUDQLLQQRPHGHOVDQWR$OƝIDYUHEEHURLQIDWWLFDXVDWRO¶DEEDQGRQRGHOWL 6LFLQHQWUDPELLFRGLFL ,O*DGOD$OƝI SRGLYLWDVSLULWXDOHDYDQWDJJLRGLVROOD]]RHGLYHUWLPHQWR,PRQDFLDYUHEEH URDEEDQGRQDWRRJQLEXRQDD]LRQHSHUGHGLFDUVLDXQRVWLOHGLYLWDGLVVROXWRH YROXWWXRVR SULYLOHJLDQGR OD FXUD GHO FRUSR D TXHOOD GHOOR VSLULWR , SUHVHQWL QHOO¶XGLUHLOVXRGLVFRUVRVLDOODUPDURQRHGHFLVHURGLIDUHLOSRVVLELOHDIILQ FKpODVXDSURIH]LDQRQVLDYYHUDVVH'HWWRTXHVWRLOPRQDFRPRUuHORVHSSHO OLURQR FRQ RQRUH SLDQJHQGR SHU L ORUR SHFFDWL , PRQDFL GL TXHO PRQDVWHUR UDJJLXQVHUR LO QXPHUR GL FHQWRFLQTXDQWDTXDWWUR PHQWUH LO QXPHUR GHL ORUR PDHVWULRUQDWLFRQYHVWLG¶RURIXGLTXDUDQWDFLQTXH,PRQDFLGHOPRQDVWHUR LQWHUQR LQYHFH QRQ HEEHUR Qp QXPHUR Qp PLVXUD SRLFKp HVVL RVVHUYDYDQR OD /HJJHHOD5HJRODGHO5HJQRGHL&LHOL>*$OIIYEYD*$OIIYD YD@ 6XOODQDVFLWDGHOSDGUHQRVWUR$OƝI $ TXHVWR SXQWR GHO WHVWR q LQVHULWR DQFRUD XQD YROWD O¶HSLVRGLR LQL]LDOH VXOODQDVFLWDGL$OƝI©VFHOWRGDOYHQWUHGLVXDPDGUHFRPH*LRYDQQL%DWWLVWDH LOSURIHWD*HUHPLDª 1HOODFLWWjGL&HVDUHDYLYHYDQRXQXRPRGLQRPH$ZORJLVHVXDPRJOLH 7ƝNOƗHUDQRPROWRULFFKLPDQRQSRWHYDQRDYHUHILJOLHSHUTXHVWRVLSURVWHU QDYDQRWXWWLLJLRUQLQHOODFKLHVDGHGLFDWDDOOD0DGRQQDFKHVLWURYDQHOODFLWWj GL &HVDUHD3UHJDYDQR GL JLRUQR HGL QRWWH H GLJLXQDYDQR RJQL VHWWLPDQD 6L VRWWRSRVHURDQFKHDXQGLJLXQRGLTXDUDQWDJLRUQLHVLPRVWUDURQRDOVDFHUGR WH2UJDQL]]DURQRXQEDQFKHWWRSHULSRYHULOHYHGRYHHJOLRUIDQLHWXWWDOD SRSROD]LRQHHUDWULVWHSHUORURSHUTXHOODFRQGL]LRQHGLVWHULOLWj8QVROLWDULR DQQXQFLzORURFKHJOLVDUHEEHQDWRSUHVWRXQILJOLRFKHQRQDYUHEEHDYXWRQXO ODGLWHUUHQR3DVVDWLTXDWWURPHVLGDTXHOO¶DQQXQFLRQDFTXH$OƝI&LIXJUDQ GHJLRLDLQFLWWjHLVXRLJHQLWRULRUJDQL]]DURQRXQJUDQGHEDQFKHWWRSHUWXWWL /R FXVWRGLURQR SHU TXDUDQWD JLRUQL QHOOD FKLHVD GRSRGLFKp OR EDWWH]]DURQR FKLDPDQGRORFRQLOQRPHLQGLFDWRJOLGDTXHOVROLWDULRRVVLD$OƝI,OIDQFLXOOR IXDOOHYDWRQHOODVDSLHQ]DHQHOJLXGL]LRVHFRQGRLYDORULGHOODVXDVWLUSHDS SUHVH OH 6DFUH 6FULWWXUH H IX SLHQR GHOOR 6SLULWR 6DQWR ,O 6LJQRUH OR HEEH LQ JUD]LDHGHJOLVLVRWWRPLVHDOGLJLXQRHDOODSUHJKLHUD6LUHFzSRLQHOGHVHUWR GL6FHWHODVFLDQGRLVXRLIDPLOLDULSURIRQGDPHQWHDGGRORUDWL/DSRSROD]LRQH GL&HVDUHDVLXQuDORURSHUFRQGLYLGHUQHODVRIIHUHQ]D,QVHJXLWRLVXRLJHQL WRULVLUHFDURQRQHOGHVHUWRGL6FHWHHUDFFRQWDURQRDGDEEƗ3DFRPLRODORUR VWRULD$OƝIDOORURDUULYRVLHUDQDVFRVWRQHOYHVWLERORGHOODFKLHVDDIILQFKp =DOHGDWX©6XOODVXDQDVFLWDªLQ*$O $QWRQHOOD%ULWD QRQORYHGHVVHUR3DFRPLRVSLHJzORURFKHLOGHVWLQRGHOILJOLRHUDTXHOORGL ULFHYHUHO¶DVNƝPƗGHJOLDQJHOL'RSRSRFKLJLRUQL$OƝIULFHYHWWHO¶DVNƝPƗGDO OHPDQLGL3DFRPLRHULPDVHOuDPPLQLVWUDQGRLPRQDFLHIDFHQGRLQQXPHUH YROL PLUDFROL 3UHJDYD GL JLRUQR H GL QRWWH H DVVXPHYD FLER H DFTXD VROR GL VDEDWR/DVXDIDPDVLGLIIXVHLQWXWWHOHUHJLRQLG¶(JLWWRHDUULYzILQRDOO¶(WLR SLD>*$OIIYDYE*$OIIUDYD@ %,%/,2*5$),$ %UDNPDQQ+'LH(LQZXU]HOXQJGHU.LUFKHLPVSlWDQWLNHQ5HLFKYRQ$NVXP%RQQ%R UHQJlVVHU %ULWD $ ³1LQH 6DLQWV´ LQ 6 8KOLJ HG (QF\FORSDHGLD $HWKLRSLFD 9ROXPH +H1 :LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]9HUODJSS ²,UDFFRQWLWUDGL]LRQDOLVXOOD©VHFRQGDFULVWLDQL]]D]LRQHªGHOO¶(WLRSLD,OFLFORDJLRJUD ILFR GHL 1RYH 6DQWL 1DSROL 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL 6WXGL H 5LFHUFKH VX $IULFD H 3DHVL $UDEL 8QLYHUVLWjGHJOL6WXGLGL1DSROL³/¶2ULHQWDOH´6WXGL$IULFDQLVWLFL6HULH(WLRSLFD %XGJH($:7KH%RRNRIWKH6DLQWVRIWKH(WKLRSLDQ&KXUFK$WUDQVODWLRQRIWKH(WKL RSLF6\QD[DULXP0DصDID6HQNHVVƗUPDGHIURPWKHPDQXVFULSWV2ULHQWDODQGLQ WKH%ULWLVK0XVHXPYROO&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV &ROLQ * /H 6\QD[DLUH pWKLRSLHQ 0RLV GH 0DJJàELW 7XUQKRXW %UHSROV 3DWURORJLD 2ULHQWDOLV>@ &RQWL5RVVLQL&6WRULDG¶(WLRSLD3DUWH3ULPD'DOOHRULJLQLDOO¶DYYHQWRGHOODGLQDVWLD VDORPRQLGH%HUJDPR,VWLWXWR,WDOLDQRGL$UWL*UDILFKH$IULFD,WDOLDQD&ROOH]LRQHGLPR QRJUDILHDFXUDGHO0LQLVWHURGHOOH&RORQLH 'LOOPDQQ$/H[LFRQ/LQJXDH$HWKLRSLFDH/LSVLDH72:HLJHO ²³=XU*HVFKLFKWHGHVD[XPLWLVFKHQ5HLFKHVLPYLHUWHQELVVHFKVWHQ-DKUKXQGHUW´LQ$E KDQGOXQJHQGHU.|QLJO$NDGHPLHGHU:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ]X%HUOLQ3KLOKLVW.ODVVH%HUOLQ %XFKGUXFNHUHLGHU.|QLJOLFKHQ$NDGHPLHGHU:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ*9RJWSS *HWDWFKHZ+DLOH³1LQH6DLQWV´LQ$WL\D$]L]6XU\DOHG7KH&RSWLF(QF\FORSHGLDYRO 1HZ<RUN0DFPLOODQ3XEOLVKLQJ&RPSDQ\SS *HWDWFKHZ +DLOH 0DFRPEHU :) $ FDWDORJXH RI (WKLRSLDQ PDQXVFULSWV PLFURILOPHG IRU WKH (WKLRSLDQ 0DQXVFULSW 0LFURILOP /LEUDU\ DQG IRU WKH +LOO 0RQDVWLF 0DQXVFULSW 0LFURILOP /LEUDU\ &ROOHJHYLOOH 9RO 9 3URMHFW 1XPEHUV &ROOHJHYLOOH +LOO 0RQDVWLF0DQXVFULSW/LEUDU\6W-RKQ¶V$EEH\DQG8QLYHUVLW\ *ULHUVRQ5³$OHI´LQ68KOLJHG(QF\FORSDHGLD$HWKLRSLFD9ROXPH$&:LHV EDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]9HUODJS ,UYLQH $. 6HLIX 0HWDIHULD ³$OòI´ LQ 0 %HOD\QHVK 6 &KRMQDFNL 5 3DQNKXUVW HGV 7KH 'LFWLRQDU\ RI (WKLRSLDQ %LRJUDSK\ 9ROXPH, IURP HDUO\WLPHV WRWKHHQG RI WKH=DJZHG\QDVW\F$'$GGLV$EDED,QVWLWXWHRI(WKLRSLDQ6WXGLHV$GGLV$ED ED8QLYHUVLW\ .LQHIH5LJE=HOOHNH³%LEOLRJUDSK\RIWKH(WKLRSLF+DJLRJUDSKLFDO7UDGLWLRQV´LQ-RXU QDORI(WKLRSLDQ6WXGLHVSS 0XQUR+D\6&³6DLQWO\6KDGRZV´LQ:5DXQLJ6:HQLJ+UVJJ$NWHQGHU(UVWHQ ,QWHUQDWLRQDOHQ/LWWPDQQ.RQIHUHQ]ELV0DLLQ0QFKHQ:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDV VRZLW]0HURLWLFDSS ,O*DGOD$OƝI 5DLQHUL 2 ³$OƝI´ LQ $$99 %LEOLRWKHFD 6DQFWRUXP 2ULHQWDOLXP (QFLFORSHGLD GHL 6DQWL/H&KLHVH2ULHQWDOL,5RPD&LWWj1XRYDS 8OOHQGRUII(³1RWHRQWKH,QWURGXFWLRQRI&KULVWLDQLW\LQWR(WKLRSLD´LQ$IULFDSS 3$75,=,$&$5,27, /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ /DIRQGD]LRQHGHOOD92& ,O PDU]R QDVFHYD OD &RPSDJQLD 5LXQLWD GHOOH ,QGLH 2ULHQWDOL 9HUHHQLJGH*HRFWR\HHUGH2RVWLQGLVFKH&RPSDJQLH92&VXOODEDVHGLXQD &DUWDDSSURYDWDGDJOL6WDWL*HQHUDOLG¶2ODQGDFKHOHFRQFHGHYDSHUDQQL LOPRQRSROLRGHLFRPPHUFLOXQJRODURWWDGHO&DSRGL%XRQD6SHUDQ]DHTXHO ODGHOOR6WUHWWRGL0DJHOODQR,QFRQVLGHUD]LRQHGHJOLLQFRQYHQLHQWLGHULYDQWL GDOO¶HVLVWHQ]DGLSLFRPSDJQLHQRQFKpGHLQRWHYROLSURILWWLFKHXQ¶HYHQWXDOH XQLRQHDYUHEEHDVVLFXUDWROHDXWRULWjRODQGHVLVWDELOLURQRGLGDUYLWDDXQ¶XQL FD RUJDQL]]D]LRQH FKH UDFFRJOLHVVH LQ Vp OH QDVFHQWL IRU]H HFRQRPLFKH GHL 3DHVL %DVVL H JHVWLVVH H FRQGXFHVVH L FRPPHUFL RULHQWDOL QHO QRPH FRPXQH GHOOH 3URYLQFH 8QLWH /R VWDWXWR UHGDWWR H DSSURYDWR FRQIHULYD XQD FKLDUD VWUXWWXUDDOODQDVFHQWH&RPSDJQLDGRWDQGRODGLRUJDQLGHFLVLRQDOLEHQSUHFLVL FKH QH ULVSHFFKLDYDQR OD FRPSRVL]LRQH LQL]LDOH ,QIDWWL OH 6HL &DPHUH >ND PHUV@VRVWLWXLYDQROHSUHFHGHQWLFRPSDJQLHGL$PVWHUGDP=HODQGD0LGGHO EXUJ 5RWWHUGDP 'HOIW +RRUQ HG (QNKXL]HQ /R VWDWXWR GHO DYUHEEH FRQVHUYDWR OD SURSULD YDOLGLWj ILQR DO ,O FDSLWDOH VRFLDOH DPPRQWDYD D ILRULQL GL FXL VRWWRVFULWWL GD $PVWHUGDP GD 0LGGHOEXUJ GD 'HOIW GD 5RWWHUGDP GD +RRUQ H GD (QNKXL]HQ OH XOWLPH TXDWWUR FLWWj FRPH $PVWHUGDP WXWWH LQ 2ODQGD/DVSDUWL]LRQHGHOOHPROWHSOLFLDWWLYLWjOHJDWHDOOHVSHGL]LRQL߃ODFR VWUX]LRQH GHOOH QDYL OD JHVWLRQH GHL YLDJJL FRPPHUFLDOL OD FRPSUDYHQGLWD *DDVWUD:LWWHYHHQ&RROKDDV*DDVWUD%OXVVpGH0RRUSS &DWHULQRSS/DFK9DQ.OH\,,,SS%OXVVp%R[HU E%R[HU,VUDHOSS)XUEHU1DJD]XPL<ǀNǀ 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL GHOOHPHUFL߃QRQFKpODGLVWULEX]LRQHGHLUHODWLYLSURILWWLYHQLYDHVSOLFLWDPHQ WH VWDELOLWD H VXGGLYLVD QHOOD &DUWD QHOOR VSHFLILFR OD PHWj WRFFDYD DG $P VWHUGDPXQTXDUWRDOOD=HODQGDHLOULPDQHQWHTXDUWRYHQLYDGLYLVRLQVHGLFH VLPLHDWWULEXLWRDOOHUHVWDQWLTXDWWUR&DPHUHPDQRQSURSRU]LRQDOPHQWHDJOL LQYHVWLPHQWL GL FDSLWDOH LQL]LDOH /D =HODQGD LQIDWWL WHPHYD GL ULPDQHUH VFKLDFFLDWD GDOOD VXSHULRULWj HFRQRPLFD GL $PVWHUGDP TXDORUD LO FRQWUROOR GHOOD92&IRVVHGLSHVRGDXQDSURSRU]LRQHOHJDWDDLFDSLWDOLLQYHVWLWL ,O QXPHUR GHL JRYHUQDQWL EHZLQGKHEEHUV YHQQH ILVVDWR LQL]LDOPHQWH D WDQWLTXDQWLHUDQRLGLUHWWRULGHOOHSUHFHGHQWLFRPSDJQLHDOPRPHQWRGHOOD IXVLRQHPDIXURQRULGRWWLDQHOJLURGLSRFKLDQQLVHQ]DQXRYHQRPLQHVR VWLWXWLYH LQ FDVR GL GHFHVVR SHU OD &DPHUD GL$PVWHUGDP SHU TXHOOD GHOOD =HODQGD H VHWWH SHU RJQXQD GHOOH UHVWDQWL &DPHUH ,O FROOHJLR GHL ;9,, 6LJQRUL +HHUHQ ;9,, O¶RUJDQR GLUHWWLYR GHOOD &RPSDJQLD HUD FRPSRVWRGD RWWR PHPEUL HOHWWL GDOOD &DPHUD GL $PVWHUGDP TXDWWUR HOHWWL GDOOD &DPHUD GHOOD=HODQGDHXQHOHWWRGDFLDVFXQD&DPHUDULPDQHQWH,OPHPEURYHQL YDVFHOWRDWXUQRQHOJUXSSRGHOOD=HODQGDRGLXQD&DPHUDPLQRUHDURWD]LR QHLQWHRULDLPHPEULGHOOD&DPHUDGL$PVWHUGDPSRWHYDQRHVVHUHPHVVLLQ PLQRUDQ]D QHOOH YRWD]LRQL PD QHL IDWWL߃ FRPH VL FRPSUHQGH ߃ $PVWHUGDP HUD VHQ]¶DOWUR SUHGRPLQDQWH QHOOH VFHOWH SROLWLFKHGHOOD &RPSDJQLD /H ULX QLRQLGHOFROOHJLRGHL;9,,6LJQRULDYYHQLYDQRUHJRODUPHQWHGXHRWUHYROWH O¶DQQR H VWDELOLYDQR OH OLQHH JXLGD GHOOD SROLWLFDFHQWUDOH GHOOD 92& JOL LQ FRQWUL VL VYROJHYDQR DG $PVWHUGDP H D 0LGGHOEXUJ /¶DYYRFDWR GHOOD &RP SDJQLD HOHWWR GDL ;9,, 6LJQRUL H XQLFR RUJDQR PRQRFUDWLFR WHQGHYD DG DV VXPHUHVHPSUHSLXQUXRORJXLGDQHJOLDIIDUL /D &DUWD FRQIHULYD DOOD 92& SLHQLSRWHUL GL DJLUH LQ2ULHQWH LQ QRPH H SHU FRQWR GHJOL 6WDWL *HQHUDOL RODQGHVL ,Q VLQWHVL OD &RPSDJQLD RWWHQHYD LO PRQRSROLRDVVROXWRGHOFRPPHUFLRQHLPDULRULHQWDOLDGHVVDHUDDVVHJQDWRLO SRWHUHGHOHJDWRGLVWLSXODUHDFFRUGLWUDQVD]LRQLHFRQWUDWWLGLFRVWUXLUHIRUWL GL QRPLQDUH JRYHUQDWRUL HPDJLVWUDWL GL UHFOXWDUHVROGDWL ,Q DOWUH SDUROH JOL 6WDWL *HQHUDOL RSHUDYDQR QHOOH ,QGLH 2ULHQWDOL DWWUDYHUVR OD QDVFHQWH VRFLHWj 1RQRVWDQWHTXHVWRODVXSHULRULWjGL$PVWHUGDPHUDHYLGHQWHPROWLGHLVXRLLQYHVWLWRULDJLYD QRDWWUDYHUVRSUHVWDQRPHSUHVVROHDOWUH&DPHUHLQVLHPHDXQFHUWRQXPHURGLLQJOHVLHWHGH VFKLFKHRSHUDYDQRSUHVVROD%RUVDGHOODFLWWj9HUVRODILQHGHO;9,,VHFRORDGHVHPSLRD 0LGGHOEXUJILJXUDYDQRVRFLVWUDQLHULFRQXQDVRPPDWRWDOHGLILRULQLSLGHOOD PHWj GHOO¶LQWHUR FDSLWDOH H GL TXHVWL FRQ O¶DSSRUWR GL ILRULQL SURYHQLYDQR DS SXQWRGD$PVWHUGDP&DWHULQRS *DDVWUDSS /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ SULYLOHJLDWD FKH VL IDFHYD VWUXPHQWR HVHFXWLYR GHO JRYHUQR RODQGHVH,Q WDO VHQVRVHFRQGRORVWRULFR)HPPH6*DDVWUDOD92&QRQHUDXQVRJJHWWRGL GLULWWRQpJRGHYDGLDOFXQDGHOHJDGLVRYUDQLWjGDSDUWHGHOJRYHUQRRODQGHVH PDHUDXQDGLUHWWDHPDQD]LRQHGLTXHVWR$OWULVWXGLRVLLQYHFHVRQRGLGLYHU VRSDUHUHSHUFKpLQGLYLGXDQRQHOODQDVFHQWH&RPSDJQLDO¶HPEULRQDOHIRUPD ]LRQHGLXQRµ6WDWRQHOOR6WDWR¶WDQWRSLFKHLPDJJLRUHQWLGHOOHGXHLVWLWX ]LRQLTXDVLFRLQFLGHYDQR1HOFRUVRGHOWHPSRVHPSUHPHQRLQIOXHQ]DSRWH URQR HVHUFLWDUH OH DXWRULWj RODQGHVL VXOOH GHFLVLRQL GHO FROOHJLR GHL ;9,, 6L JQRULVHEEHQHTXHVWHGRYHVVHURHVVHUHDSSURYDWHGDJOL6WDWL*HQHUDOLQHLIDW WLWDOHUHJRODIXEHQSUHVWRGLVDWWHVD$QFKHJOLDOWLXIILFLDOLGHOOD92&GRYH YDQR REEHGLHQ]D DOO¶DXWRULWj VXSUHPD GHJOL 6WDWL *HQHUDOL PD QHO FRQFUHWR VIXJJLYDQRDOUHDOHFRQWUROORJRYHUQDWLYRLQTXDQWRSRUWDWRULGLLQWHUHVVLSDU WLFRODULQRQVHPSUHDOOLQHDWLFRQTXHOOLGHOODPDGUHSDWULD /H3URYLQFH8QLWHJUD]LHDOODIRQGD]LRQHGHOOD&RPSDJQLDDYHYDQRD GRWWDWR XQD FRPXQH VWUDWHJLD HFRQRPLFD SHU SHQHWUDUH VXL PHUFDWL RULHQWDOL &RPHYHGUHPRSURSULRODVDOGDVWUXWWXUDLQWHUQDQRQFKpO¶DXWRQRPLDGLIDWWR DFTXLVLWDHGHVHUFLWDWDDQFKHULVSHWWRDOODVWHVVDVRYUDQLWjGHJOL6WDWL*HQHUDOL VDUHEEHUR VWDWL JOL HOHPHQWL YLQFHQWL GHOOD 92& QHOOR VFDO]DUH LO SUHGRPLQLR LEHULFRHQHOO¶DIIHUPDUVLTXDOHSUHVHQ]DGRPLQDQWHQHOO¶$VLDGHO;9,,VHFROR /D VWUXWWXUD ROLJDUFKLFD LQWHUQD H OD VXD VWUHWWD FRQQHVVLRQH FRQ L JUXSSL GR PLQDQWL GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD SHUPHWWHYDQR DL GLUHWWRULGL FRQGXUUH JOL DIIDUL ED GDQGR SUHYDOHQWHPHQWH DL SURSUL LQWHUHVVL /D SROLWLFD FRPPHUFLDOH DGRWWDWD REEOLJDYDDOSXQWXDOHSDJDPHQWRGHLGLYLGHQGLHQRQSUHYHGHYDO¶DFFXPXOD ]LRQHGLXQFDSLWDOHGLULVHUYDQRQRVWDQWHFKHOD&RPSDJQLDDYHVVHELVRJQR GLJURVVHVRPPHGDLQYHVWLUHQHOOHLPSUHVHLQ$VLDSHUFXLVLJLXQVHEHQSUH VWRDXQDFURQLFDPDQFDQ]DGLOLTXLGLWj,OFDSLWDOHGLEDVHQRQYHQQHPDLFRQ VLGHUHYROPHQWH DXPHQWDWR H VL SUHIHUu SLXWWRVWR ULFRUUHUH D SUHVWLWL FRSHUWL FRQ OH VFRUWH GHOOH PHUFL LPSLHJDWH SHU ³PDQRYUDUH´ L SUH]]L 'DWR FKH WDOL SUHVWLWL HUDQR VRWWRVFULWWL VRSUDWWXWWR GDL GLUHWWRUL H GDL ORUR IDPLOLDUL ULVXOWD HYLGHQWHFKHHVVLDQWLFLSDYDQRGHQDURDOOD&RPSDJQLDVHQ]DFRUUHUHDOFXQUL VFKLRHULFDYDYDQRLQYHFHJURVVLLQWHUHVVLVXOOHVSHVHGHLSDUWHFLSDQWLDELWXD OL %OXVVpGH0RRUSS 6RPHUV6WHHQVJDDUG*DDVWUDSS&DWHULQRSS%R[ HUSS $\PDUGGHQ+DDQ0DQVYHOW&DWHULQRSS 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL 2UJDQL]]D]LRQHHVWUXWWXUD *LXQJHUHDFRVWLWXLUHXQD³&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDGHOOH,QGLH2ULHQWDOL´QRQ HUDVWDWRVHPSOLFH,O*UDQ3HQVLRQDULRG¶2ODQGD-RKDQYDQ2OGHQEDUQHYHOGW FKHHEEHSDUWHGLUHWWDQHOOHWUDWWDWLYHSHUFRQWRGHJOL6WDWL*HQHUDOLDYHYDDU JRPHQWDWR OD VFHOWD GL XQD IXVLRQH VXOOD EDVH GL GXH RELHWWLYL SULRULWDUL OD VFRQILWWD GHO QHPLFR RYYHUR GHOOR VFKLHUDPHQWR LEHULFR OH FRURQH XQLWH GL 6SDJQDH3RUWRJDOORHODGLIHVDGHOODPDGUHSDWULDPLQDFFLDWDQHOODVXDLQGL SHQGHQ]DQRQVRORSROLWLFDPDDQFKHHFRQRPLFD7XWWDYLDLPROWHSOLFLLQWH UHVVLVSHVVRFRQWUDSSRVWLGLPHUFDQWLLQIOXHQWLHROLJDUFKLHFLWWDGLQHFRVuFR PHJOLLQWHUHVVLEHQGLVWLQWLGHOOHVLQJROHFRPSDJQLHSULYDWHHVLVWHQWLGRYHYD QR DYHUH XQ SUHFLVR FRUULVSHWWLYR QHOOD VWUXWWXUD H QHOO¶RUJDQL]]D]LRQH GHOOD 92&HDOORVWHVVRPRGRGRYHYDHVVHUHORURJDUDQWLWRXQHVSOLFLWRWRUQDFRQWR LQ WHUPLQL GL GLYLGHQGL/¶HOHPHQWR HFRQRPLFR DOOD ILQH ULVXOWz TXHOOR SL FRQYLQFHQWH$OODOXFHGLTXHVWRHUDFKLDURDWXWWLFKHODQFLDUVLDOODFRQTXLVWD GHL PHUFDWL RULHQWDOL DYUHEEH FRPSRUWDWR OR VFRSSLR GL FRQIOLWWL DUPDWL FRQ SRUWRJKHVLHVSDJQROL/DVWUXWWXUDHO¶RUJDQL]]D]LRQHVWHVVDGHOOD&RPSDJQLD SHUWDQWR QRQSRWHYDQR QRQWHQHU FRQWR GHOOD GXSOLFH IXQ]LRQH FXL L VXRL GL SHQGHQWL HUDQR FKLDPDWL O¶HVVHUH VROGDWL H PHUFDQWL DOOR VWHVVR WHPSR 8Q FRPSLWR LQFRQVXHWR H GL FHUWR QRQ VHPSOLFH FRPH OD VFHWWLFD RSLQLRQH GHO O¶DPPLUDJOLR &RUQHOLV 0DWHOLHII DYUHEEH ULOHYDWR TXDOFKH DQQR GRSR QHO 8QD WDOH GLFRWRPLD XQD YRFD]LRQH PLOLWDUH H PHUFDQWLOH DOOR VWHVVR WHPSRIXLQHIIHWWLHOHPHQWRFRQQDWXUDWRDOOD92&VLQGDOODVXDIRQGD]LRQH (QHUDSSUHVHQWzDQFKHLOWUDWWRYLQFHQWHQHOSHULRGRGHOODVXDDVFHVDSHUJUDQ SDUWHGHO6HLFHQWR 6WDSHO,,SS,,,SS/DFN9DQ.OH\,,,SS /DPSDQWHHVHPSLRGLWDOHFRQIOLWWXDOLWjFLYLHQHGDWRGDOFDVRGL,VDDF/H0DLUHXQRGHLGLUHW WRUL GHOOD 92& DOO¶DWWR GHOOD IRQGD]LRQH GLPHVVRVL QHO TXHVWL GLHGH YLWD D VSHGL]LRQL FRPPHUFLDOL DXWRQRPH FKH FRQIOLJJHYDQR FRQ LO PRQRSROLR GHOOD &RPSDJQLD 5LXQLWD (UD XQR GHL SL DFHUULPL ULYDOL GHOOD 92& LQ DOOHDQ]DFRQ L IUDQFHVL SHU OD FRVWLWX]LRQH GL XQD &RPSDJQLD IUDQFHVH ,Q RFFDVLRQH GL XQR GHL YLDJJLQHOOH ,QGLH 2ULHQWDOL LOILJOLR-DFRE /H 0DLUH FHUFz GL FRQYLQFHUH -RKDQ YDQ 2OGHQEDUQHYHOGW D URPSHUH LO PRQRSROLR GHOOD 92& 1HLIDWWLL/H0DLUHFRVWLWXLURQRXQ¶DOWUDFRPSDJQLDFKHµFRQWUDEEDQGDYD¶LSURGRWWLDOO¶RP EUDGHOOD92&SHUJLXQJHUHLQILQHDIRQGDUHOD$XVWUDOLVFKH&RPSDJQLHFRQLOFRQVHQVRGHO OD &RPSDJQLD 5LXQLWD VHEEHQH ODGLDWULED SURVHJXLVVH DQFRUDD OXQJR 6L YHGD LQ SURSRVLWR /DFK9DQ.OH\,,,SS %R[HUS /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ &RHUHQWHPHQWHFRQTXDQWRHVSRVWRODVWUXWWXUDGHOOD&RPSDJQLDULIOHVVH TXHVWDGXSOLFHDQLPDVYLOXSSDQGRXQ¶RUJDQL]]D]LRQHFHQWUDOL]]DWDJHUDUFKL FD H PLOLWDUPHQWH HIILFLHQWH GRWDWDGL XQ DSSDUDWREXURFUDWLFR IXQ]LRQDQWHH GL DJLOH IOHVVLELOLWj LQ DPELWR FRPPHUFLDOH &RPH DFFHQQDWR LQ SUHFHGHQ]D XQDQRWHYROHDXWRQRPLDHDXWRVXIILFLHQ]DDQFKHULVSHWWRDJOL6WDWL*HQHUDOL FRQVHQWLURQRDOOD92&GLDJLUHDOPHJOLRHWHPSHVWLYDPHQWHLQTXHVWLRQLVLD PLOLWDULFKHPHUFDQWLOLFRPHQHLUDSSRUWLGLYROWDLQYROWDVWDELOLWLLQ$VLDFRQ LJRYHUQLHOHDXWRULWjORFDOLFRQLTXDOLVLFRPSRUWDYDFRPHXQYHURSRWHUH DXWRQRPR H LQGLSHQGHQWH ,O FROOHJLR GHL ;9,, 6LJQRUL FRPH DEELDPR YLVWR QHOSDUDJUDIRSUHFHGHQWHHUDO¶RUJDQRVXSUHPRGHOOD&RPSDJQLD/DVHOH]LR QHGHLVXRLPHPEULFKHQHOODPDJJLRUDQ]DGHLFDVLQRQDYHYDQRDOFXQDHVSH ULHQ]DGLUHWWDGHOO¶$VLDDYYHQLYDLQSLHQRDFFRUGRFRQOHDXWRULWjFLWWDGLQHH OHORFDOLROLJDUFKLHFLzFRQVHQWuQHOWHPSRXQDVHPSUHPDJJLRUHFRPSHQHWUD ]LRQHGHOODOHDGHUVKLSGHOOD92&FRQJOLLQWHUHVVLHFRQRPLFLGHOOHSULQFLSDOL FLWWjGHL3DHVL%DVVL,OFRQQXELRWUDFODVVHJRYHUQDQWHHFODVVHPHUFDQWLOHIX IRULHURGLFULWLFKHLQHIIHWWLLQFDVRGLODPHQWHOHSURWHVWHRILQDQFKHGHQXQFH FRQWURSRVVLELOLDEXVLRFRPSRUWDPHQWLVFRUUHWWLGHOOD92<XHUHODQWLWUR YDYDQRDGLULPHUHWDOLFRQWURYHUVLHJOLVWHVVLDWWRULFRQWURLTXDOLOHLVWDQ]HYH QLYDQR VROOHYDWH &Lz GLPRVWUD LO SURIRQGR H VWUDWLILFDWR WHVVXWR VRFLDOH QHO TXDOHOD&RPSDJQLDDYHYDVYLOXSSDWROHSURSULHUDGLFLHO¶LGHQWLWjGLILQLHGL LQWHUHVVLFUHDWRVLWUDOHROLJDUFKLHRODQGHVLHODGLULJHQ]DGHOOD92&$SDUWLUH GDOFLUFDXQDVRUWDGLFRPPLVVLRQHSHUPDQHQWHSUHSRVWDDWDOLFRPSLWL KDDJVFKHEHVRLJQHVUDFFRJOLHYDHOHJJHYDODFRUULVSRQGHQ]DHODGRFXPHQWD ]LRQHLQDUULYRVHOH]LRQDYDLOPDWHULDOHSUHSDUDYDOHULVSRVWHHVRWWRSRQHYDDO FROOHJLR GHL ;9,, 6LJQRUL OD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH GD ILUPDUH H VRWWRVFULYHUH D TXHVW¶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¶DOOHVWLPHQWRGHO *DDVWUD SS %R[HU SS &DWHULQR SS %OXVVp GH 0RRU %OXVVp 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL OD IORWWD DO QXPHUR GHOOH QDYL GDO UHFOXWDPHQWR GHJOL HTXLSDJJL DOO¶LPEDUFR GHOOH PHUFL WXWWDYLD FRPSHWHYD DL ;9,, 6LJQRUL DSSURYDUH OD VWUXWWXUD H OD FRPSRVL]LRQHGHILQLWLYDGHOODVSHGL]LRQHFRPPHUFLDOHLQSDUWHQ]DSHUOH,QGLH 2ULHQWDOLFKHDYUHEEHLVVDWRORVWHQGDUGRGHOOD&RPSDJQLDODEDQGLHUDRODQ GHVHDWUHVWULVFHRUL]]RQWDOLFRQLOPDUFKLR92&QHOODSDUWHELDQFDVRUPRQ WDWRGHOO¶LQL]LDOHGHOOD&DPHUDFXLDSSDUWHQHYDODQDYH &RQ LO SURJUHVVLYR VYLOXSSR GHL FRPPHUFL H GHOOH UHODWLYH EDVL LQ $VLD GLYHQQHVHPSUHSLQHFHVVDULRSHUOD&RPSDJQLDDYHUHXQTXDUWLHUHJHQHUDOH LQORFRVWDELOLWR߃FRPHYHGUHPR߃D%DWDYLDO¶DWWXDOH-DNDUWDQHOFRQ O¶DVVHJQD]LRQHGLXQJRYHUQDWRUHJHQHUDOH3RVWRVRWWRLOFRQWUROORGHOODVHGH FHQWUDOH GL %DWDYLD LQ RJQL VLQJROD VHGH IX QRPLQDWR XQ RSSHUKRIGW FDSR GHOO¶DJHQ]LD FRPXQHPHQWH FKLDPDWR µJRYHUQDWRUH¶ SHU SURYYHGHUH DOOD JH VWLRQHORFDOH,QRJQLVHGHDJOLRUGLQLGHOJRYHUQDWRUHVLWURYDYDXQRVWDIIGL DOWLXIILFLDOLGLYDULRJUDGRHFRQPDQVLRQLGLYHUVLILFDWHQRQXOWLPDTXHOODGL UHGLJHUHLUHJLVWULGHOOHDWWLYLWjFRPPHUFLDOL$OWUDLPSRUWDQWHIXQ]LRQHVYRO JHYDQR JOL LQWHUSUHWL JOL XQLFL LQ JUDGR GL FRPXQLFDUH GLUHWWDPHQWH FRQ OD UHDOWj FLUFRVWDQWH DQFKH LQFROODERUD]LRQHFRQ JOL LQWHUSUHWL ORFDOL7XWWH OH VHGL GRYHYDQR PDQGDUH UHJRODUPHQWH L ORUR UHVRFRQWL TXRWLGLDQL GDJUHJL VWHUV DOOD EDVH FHQWUDOH GL %DWDYLD FKH SURYYHGHYD SRL D WUDVPHWWHUH D VXD YROWDDOFROOHJLRGHL;9,,6LJQRULUHJRODULUHVRFRQWLVXOOHDWWLYLWjGHOOD92& 'H 'DJK5HJLVWHUV JHKRXGHQ LQ¶W .DVWHHO %DWDYLD H 'H *HQHUDOH 0LVVLYHQ VRQRWUDOHIRQWLSULPDULHSLLPSRUWDQWL&RPHVLFRPSUHQGHODGRFXPHQ WD]LRQHVFULWWDHUDSRQGHURVDHULFKLHGHYDXQLPSHJQRFRVWDQWHHVLJQLILFDWLYR LFRQWHQXWLVSD]LDYDQRGDOOHDWWLYLWjTXRWLGLDQHSLRPHQRUHJRODULHPRQRWR QHDLUHJLVWULFRPPHUFLDOLHGLJHVWLRQHGHOODVHGHGDOOHVFHOWHFRPPHUFLDOLH SROLWLFKHGLYROWDLQYROWDSHUVHJXLWHDJOLLQFLGHQWLLQQDYLJD]LRQHGDJOLVFRQ *DDVWUDSS%R[HU $GHVHPSLRD+LUDGRGDODOHSRLD'HVKLPDGDODOLQ*LDSSRQHD 7DLZDQQHOODVHGHGL+HW.DVWHHO=HHODQGLDGDODOHD&DQWRQLQ &LQDSHUTXDQWRFRQFHUQHO¶(VWUHPR2ULHQWH <DR.HLVXNHSS 'DJK5HJLVWHUVJHKRXGHQLQ¶W&DVWHHO%DWDYLDZDQWSDVVHUHQGHGDHUWHUSODHWVHDOVRYHUJH KHHO1HGHUODQGV,QGLDDFXUDGL-$YDQGHU&KLMV%DWDYLD±7KH+DJXH*HQH UDOH0LVVLYHQYDQ*RXYHUQHXUV*HQHUDDOHQ5DGHQYDQ,QGLsDDQ+HUHQ=HYHQWLHQGHU9HUH QLJGH2RVWLQGLVFKH&RPSDJQLHDFXUDGL:3K&RROKDDVGDO,DOO¶9,,,DFXUDGL-YDQ*RRU OD,;DFXUDGL-(6FKRRQHYHOG2RVWHUOLQJOD;,7KH+DJXH /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ WUL PLOLWDUL FRQ L QHPLFL LEHULFL DOOD YLROHQWD FRQIOLWWXDOLWj R LQILGD FROODERUD ]LRQHFRQOHPDULQHULHRULHQWDOL ,VHUYDQWVRYYHURLGLSHQGHQWLGHOOD&RPSDJQLDHUDQRGLYLVLLQYDULHFD WHJRULH,SLLPSRUWDQWLHUDQRLGLSHQGHQWLFKHVYROJHYDQRIXQ]LRQLGLFDUDW WHUHPHUFDQWLOHGLYDULRJUDGRGDOO¶RSSHUNRRSPDQVRUWDGL³PHUFDQWHDQ]LD QR´FRQIXQ]LRQLGLFRPDQGRDOO¶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¶HVSDQVLRQHHXURSHDLQFRQIURQWRDOJUDQGHVSD]LRGDWRDLPLV VLRQDULFDWWROLFLVRSUDWWXWWRJHVXLWLPDFKHSXUHHEEHURXQUXRORULOHYDQWHQHO FRQWHVWRRULHQWDOHFRPHDGHVHPSLRD7DLZDQDOPRPHQWRGHOO¶LQVHGLDPHQWR RODQGHVHVXOO¶LVROD/RVWHVVR-DQ3LHWHUV]RRQ&RHQQHSRVWXODYDODSUHVHQ]D SHUIDYRULUHODGLVFLSOLQDHO¶HGXFD]LRQHGHLPDULQDLHGHLVROGDWLRODQGHVLRO WUHFKHGHLIXWXULFRORQL,QXOWLPRYHQLYDQRJOLDUWLJLDQLHLFDUSHQWLHULJHQH ULFDPHQWHFKLDPDWLDPEDFKWOLHGHQFKHULFHYHYDQRXQDSDJDPLJOLRUHULVSHWWR DL VHPSOLFL VROGDWL R PDULQDL GDWR LO ORUR DOWR OLYHOOR GL VSHFLDOL]]D]LRQH ,O SHUVRQDOHHUDDVVROGDWRDWWUDYHUVRGHOOHOLVWHQRPLQDWLYHDOOHTXDOLWXWWLHUDQR OLEHULGLLVFULYHUVLPDVSHVVROHULFKLHVWHSHUOHSRVL]LRQLSLXPLOLYHQLYDQR IDWWHGDHOHPHQWLSRFRUDFFRPDQGDELOLFKHVFHJOLHYDQRGLLPEDUFDUVLVXOOHQD YLGLUHWWHLQ2ULHQWHSHUDYHUHXQ¶XOWLPDRFFDVLRQHGLFDPELDUHYLWD /¶DVFHVDGHOOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWD &RPHDFFHQQDWRHUDQRSRFKLL'LUHWWRULGHOOD92&FKHDYHVVHURDOORUR DWWLYRXQDSHUVRQDOHHVSHULHQ]DLQ$VLDQHOODPDJJLRUDQ]DGHLFDVLVLWUDWWDYD (VXODGDOSUHVHQWHODYRURSUHQGHUHLQHVDPHOHSURIRQGHFRQIOLWWXDOLWjHVLVWHQWLDGHVHPSLR FRQLOPHUFDQWLOLVPRFLQHVHLQPHULWRDOOHTXDOLVLVRQRVYROWHSUHFHGHQWLULFHUFKHQHOFRQWH VWRGHOO¶$VLDRULHQWDOHDOODPHWjGHO6HLFHQWRIXODWHPLELOHRUJDQL]]D]LRQHGHL=KHQJDWHQH UH WHVWD DOOD 92& 6L YHGD LQ SURSRVLWR &DULRWL &DULRWL &DWHULQD &DULRWL D 6XOO¶LQVHGLDPHQWRRODQGHVHD7DLZDQVLYHGD&DULRWL&DWHULQD&DULRWLD %R[HUSS*DDVWUDSS&DWHULQRSS 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL GLXQDFRQRVFHQ]DLQGLUHWWDSLXWWRVWRIXPRVDHSRFRDWWHQGLELOH,OFROOHJLRGHL ;9,, 6LJQRUL FHUFz GL RYYLDUH D XQD WDOH RJJHWWLYDGLVIXQ]LRQH GDQGR YLWD QHOJLURGLSRFKLDQQLDXQ$OWR&RQVLJOLR>+RJH5HJHHULQJ@FRQVHGHQHOOH ,QGLHFRQDFDSRXQJRYHUQDWRUHJHQHUDOH/HILQDOLWjHUDQRHYLGHQWLUHQGHUH ODVWUXWWXUDGHOOD&RPSDJQLDTXDQWRSLHIILFLHQWHSRVVLELOHSHURWWLPL]]DUQH OHDWWLYLWjGXQTXHLULVXOWDWLHFRQHVVLLSURILWWL,QXQ¶HSRFDLQFXLLQ(XUR SDVLHUDSURVVLPLDOODGHILQL]LRQHGLXQDWHRULDGHOPHUFDQWLOLVPROH3URYLQFH 8QLWHGDYDQRYLWDFRQOD92&DXQDVRUWDGLJLJDQWHVFDHSULPRUGLDOHVRFLHWj SHUD]LRQLHVSOLFLWDHPDQD]LRQHGHOOR6WDWRXQHVSHULPHQWRHFRQRPLFRSHU IHWWDPHQWHULXVFLWRFKHLQSRFKLDQQLFRQVHQWuDJOLRODQGHVLGLVPDQWHOODUHLO PRQRSROLRLEHULFRQHLWUDIILFLRULHQWDOLHGLDIIHUPDUHODSURSULDHJHPRQLDWUD OH SUHVHQ]H HXURSHH LQ FRQFRUUHQ]D VXL PHUFDWL DVLDWLFL $QFKH LQ SDWULD OD &RPSDJQLDHUDGLYHQXWDODSLLPSRUWDQWHLPSUHVDQD]LRQDOHFKHROWUHDSUR FXUDUHLQJHQWLSURILWWLDJOLLQYHVWLWRULGDYDODYRURDPLJOLDLDGLSHUVRQHWUDR ODQGHVLHDOWULHXURSHL 8Q WDOH VXFFHVVR HUD LQ SDUWH DVFULYLELOH D XQ¶DWWHQWD VWUDWHJLD GL HVSDQ VLRQHFKHWURYDYDDQFKHQHOOHFDSDFLWjGHLVLQJROLXQ¶DGHJXDWDDWWXD]LRQHLQ DOWUHSDUROHODVFHOWDGHJOLXRPLQLJLXVWLSHUJOLLQFDULFKLGLUHVSRQVDELOLWjHUD IRQGDPHQWDOH FRVu FRPH OR HUD JRGHUH GL XQ¶DXWRQRPLD GHFLVLRQDOH FKH WH QHVVHFRQWRGHOOHUHDOLFLUFRVWDQ]HLQFXLOD92&VLWURYDYDDRSHUDUHHGHVVH LPPHGLDWD HG HIILFDFH ULVSRVWD DOOH LVWDQ]H FKH VLSUHVHQWDYDQR GL JLRUQR LQ JLRUQR 6H O¶$OWR &RQVLJOLR GHOOH ,QGLH FRQ LO VXR JRYHUQDWRUH JHQHUDOH UL VSRQGHYDJLjLQSDUWHDWDOHHVLJHQ]DOD&RPSDJQLDQHFHVVLWDYDDQFKHFRQWH VWXDOPHQWH GL XQD VHGH VWDELOH SL YLFLQD DOO¶DUHD RSHUDWLYD XQD SRVWD]LRQH FKHVLSRWHVVHUDJJLXQJHUHIDFLOPHQWHHVLWURYDVVHLQSULPDOLQHDULVSHWWRDOOH SULQFLSDOLFRUUHQWLGLWUDIILFRHUDLQGLVSHQVDELOHVWDELOLUHXQDEDVHQHOOH,QGLH 2ULHQWDOLFKHIXQJHVVHGDTXDUWLHUHJHQHUDOHGRYHLQVHGLDUHLO&RQVLJOLRGHOOH ,QGLHHLOVXRSUHVLGHQWHLOJRYHUQDWRUHJHQHUDOH 1HO SURFHVVR GL ULRUJDQL]]D]LRQH GHJOL RUJDQL GHFLVLRQDOL GHOOD &RPSD JQLDDYHYDDYXWRSDUWHGLUHWWDO¶DPPLUDJOLR&RUQHOLV0DDWHOLHIIFKHVRSUDW WXWWRGRSRDYHUVSHULPHQWDWRLOIDOOLPHQWRGHLVXRLDWWDFFKLDOOHEDVLLEHULFKH SLGLXQDYROWDDYHYDULEDGLWRDL;9,,6LJQRULDQFKHDWWUDYHUVRFRSLRVHUHOD ]LRQLVFULWWHODQHFHVVLWjGLXQDVWUXWWXUDVXOPRGHOORSRUWRJKHVHGHOO¶(VWDGR *DDVWUD SS &DWHULQR SS &RROKDDV %R[HU SS %R[HUGH*URRW0DQVYHOW %OXVVpGH0RRUSS$\PDUG,VUDHO 6RPHUV6WHHQVJDDUG /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ GH,QGLDFKHULVSRQGHVVHDOOHUHDOLHVLJHQ]HGHOO¶HVSDQVLRQHRODQGHVHLQ$VLD *OLRELHWWLYLLQGLYLGXDWLHUDQRWUHFUHDUHXQ$OWR&RQVLJOLRGHOOH,QGLHFRQXQ VXR SUHVLGHQWH LO JRYHUQDWRUH JHQHUDOH GL FXL DEELDPR JLj SDUODWR VWDELOLUH XQDVHGHSHUPDQHQWHFRPHOXRJRGLFRQFHQWUD]LRQHGHOOHIORWWHGHOOD92&LQ $VLDSHUULFHYHUHJOLRUGLQLHOHQXRYHGHVWLQD]LRQLSHULULIRUQLPHQWL OHH YHQWXDOL ULSDUD]LRQL L FDPEL GL SHUVRQDOH HFF VWDELOLUH GHL PRQRSROL VXOOD SURGX]LRQH H LO FRPPHUFLR GHOOH VSH]LH FKH GLYHQWDYDQR D TXHVWR SXQWR LO FXRUH GHOOH DWWLYLWj GHOOD &RPSDJQLD /¶HUURUH SULQFLSDOH FRPPHVVR GDL SRU WRJKHVLLQIDWWLHUDVWDWRO¶LQFDSDFLWjGLDFTXLVLUHLOFRQWUROORGLUHWWRHLPPH GLDWRGHOODSURGX]LRQHHGHOFRPPHUFLRGHOOHVSH]LHSLSUHJLDWHSHUFXLQRQ HUDQRVWDWLLQJUDGRGLDVVLFXUDUVLXQULIRUQLPHQWRFRVWDQWHDSUH]]LFRQFRUGDWL HVRSUDWWXWWRGLJDUDQWLUVLFKHDOWULQRQSRWHVVHURDSSURYYLJLRQDUVLDOOHPHGH VLPHIRQWLPLQDQGRGLIDWWROHEDVLVWHVVHGHOORURPRQRSROLR 1HLSULPLVVLPLDQQLGLDWWLYLWjGHOOD92&GXQTXHODSULRULWjDVVROXWDHUD ULWDJOLDUVL XQR VSD]LR QHL WUDIILFL LQWHUDVLDWLFLFLz VLJQLILFDYD VWDELOLUH GHOOH EDVL VH SRVVLELOH VRWWUDHQGROH DL SRUWRJKHVL H DJOL VSDJQROL H ULIRUQLUVL GL PHUFDQ]LH D FRQGL]LRQL YDQWDJJLRVH SRVVLELOPHQWH LQ UHJLPH GL PRQRSROLR VXOOHTXDOLVSHFXODUHQHOODYHQGLWDDLFRQVXPDWRULHXURSHL,OSULPRRELHWWLYR IXO¶LQVHULPHQWRQHOWUDIILFRGHOOHVSH]LHFKHVRSUDWWXWWRQHOSULPRWUHQWHQQLR GLYLWDGHOOD&RPSDJQLDPDDQFKHSHUTXDVLWXWWRLOUHVWRGHO6HLFHQWRUDS SUHVHQWDURQRXQDYRFHIRQGDPHQWDOHQHOELODQFLRGHOOD92&(XQSULPRFRQ FUHWRSDVVRIXFRPSLXWRFRQO¶LQVHGLDPHQWRQHOOH,VROHGHOOH6SH]LHDSDUWLUH GDO1HOORVWHVVRDQQRLSRUWRJKHVLIXURQRHVSXOVLGD7LGRUHFKHQHO IX ULFRQTXLVWDWD H WHQXWD SHU PH]]R VHFROR GDJOL VSDJQROL SURYHQLHQWL GDOOH)LOLSSLQH1HO7HUQDWHVLSRVHVRWWRODSURWH]LRQHRODQGHVHHVWLSX Oz XQ FRQWUDWWR SHU OD IRUQLWXUD HVFOXVLYD GHL FKLRGL GL JDURIDQR*OL DELWDQWL GHOOHLVROH%DQGDVLWURYDURQRFRVWUHWWLGDOODSUHVHQ]DRODQGHVHDVWLSXODUHQHO FRQWUDWWL SHU LO PRQRSROLR GHOOH PHUFL FKH SRL DQQXOODURQR DQFKH VH QRQ SHU PROWR VRWWR O¶LQIOXHQ]D GHL FRQFRUUHQWL GHOOD &RPSDJQLD 5LXQLWD L JLDYDQHVLHJOLLQJOHVL 9DQ9HHQ.OLMQ%R[HUSS*DDVWUDSS:LQLXVGH 6DOGDQKDGH2OLYHLUD0DUTXHV,G6RX]D ,OVHJQDODFRQTXLVWDGL)RUWH9LFWRULDDG$PERLQDHO¶LPSRVL]LRQHGLXQFRQWUDWWRSHULO PRQRSROLRGHOODFRPPHUFLDOL]]D]LRQHGHOOHVSH]LHFIU)XUEHUSS /DFK9DQ.OH\,,,SS,,,SS%OXVVpGH0RRU SS)XUEHUSS,VUDHOSS$UDVDUDWQDP,G &KDXGKXUL0F3KHUVRQ.HDUQH\6KDIIHU 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL ,OSULPRJRYHUQDWRUHJHQHUDOHIX3LHWHU%RWKQRPLQDWRQHOPDHQ WUDWR LQ VHUYL]LR QHO HULPDVWR LQ FDULFD ILQR DO/D FUHD]LRQH GL XQDVHGHVWDELOHHUDGLYHQXWDHVVHQ]LDOHHSHUUDJLRQLVWUDWHJLFKHGRYHYDHVVH UHVLWXDWDQHOO¶DUHDGHOOD3HQLVRODGL0DODFFDLOSXQWRGLSDVVDJJLRREEOLJDWR DWWUDYHUVRFXLWUDQVLWDYDODPDJJLRUSDUWHGHOFRPPHUFLRLQWHUDVLDWLFRODSUL PD VFHOWD ULFDGGH VX %DQWHQ QHO H TXDVL LPPHGLDWDPHQWH GRSR QHO VX-DFDWUDVLWXDWDSRFRROWUHOR6WUHWWRGHOOD6RQGDFKHJUD]LHDOODQXR YDURWWDLQGLYLGXDWDGDJOLRODQGHVLVLSUHVHQWDYDFRPHODYLDSLIDFLOHSHUHQ WUDUH QHOO¶DUFLSHODJR LQGRQHVLDQR H UDJJLXQJHUH GLUHWWDPHQWH OH ,VROH GHOOH 6SH]LHXQDFLWWjJLjLQGLYLGXDWDGD0DDWHOLHIIHULWHQXWDSLLGRQHDGL%DQWHQ SHURVSLWDUHLOTXDUWLHUJHQHUDOHGHOOD&RPSDJQLD /DUHWHFRPPHUFLDOHGHOOD92& 6LQ GDOOH SULPLVVLPH VSHGL]LRQL L GXH RELHWWLYL SULRULWDUL GHOOD &RPSD JQLDULVXOWDURQRFKLDULVFDO]DUHJOLLEHULFLGDOOHORURSRVWD]LRQLSHUSUHQGHUQH LOSRVWRVWDELOLUHDFFRUGLFRPPHUFLDOLPROWRYDQWDJJLRVLFRQLSRWHQWDWLORFDOL FRQRVHQ]DO¶XVRGHOODIRU]D,QFLzDSSDUHHYLGHQWHTXDQWRO¶HOHPHQWRPLOLWD UHGHOOD&RPSDJQLDULVXOWDVVHIRQGDPHQWDOHVLDQHOFRPEDWWHUHLSRUWRJKHVLH JOL VSDJQROL VLD QHOO¶LPSRUUH DOOH DXWRULWj GHL YDUL 6WDWL DQFKH H VRSUDWWXWWR FRQOHDUPLFRQWUDWWLFDSHVWURHFRQGL]LRQLLQDFFHWWDELOL4XHVWDWDWWLFDGLH VSOLFLWD DJJUHVVLRQH H VIUXWWDPHQWR DFFRPSDJQz WXWWR LO SURFHVVR GL DWWHVWD ]LRQH GHOOD &RPSDJQLD QHOOH ,QGLH 2ULHQWDOL H FRQO¶HFFH]LRQH GHOOD &LQD H GHO*LDSSRQHGRYHOD92&VLWURYzDGRYHULQWHUDJLUHFRQGXHLPSHULVRYUD QLOHVWUDWHJLHGLHVSDQVLRQHGHL;9,,6LJQRULULVFRVVHURXQQRWHYROHVXFFHV VRULXVFHQGRDLPSRUVLQHOFRPPHUFLRORFDOHHLQTXHOORLQWHUDVLDWLFR 1HO FRUVR GHOOD SULPD PHWj GHO 6HLFHQWR LQIDWWL OD &RPSDJQLD ULXVFu D VWDELOLUVL VDOGDPHQWH QHL PDUL RULHQWDOL H D FRVWLWXLUYL XQ¶LPSRUWDQWH UHWH GL WUDIILFLGHOLQHDWDGDOOHSURSULHEDVL8Q¶LQFHVVDQWHFDPSDJQDGLDVVDOWRDLFD SLVDOGLQHPLFLIHFHVuFKHJUDGXDOPHQWHOD92&VLVRVWLWXLVVHDO3RUWRJDOORH DOOD6SDJQDQHOFRQWHVWRDVLDWLFRGDO*ROIR3HUVLFRDO*ROIRGHO%HQJDODGDL PDULGHOOD&LQDDTXHOOLGHO*LDSSRQHLQXQ¶LQDUUHVWDELOHDVFHVDLOSUHGRPL QLRLEHULFRHVHUFLWDWRQHOSUHFHGHQWH;9,VHFRORIXGHILQLWLYDPHQWHVPDQWHO 6WDSHOSS %R[HUSS*DDVWUDSS%OXVVpGH0RRUSS %R[HU,VUDHOSS$\PDUG /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ ODWR6LPHQ]LRQDQRDOFXQHGHOOHSULQFLSDOLSRVWD]LRQLGHOOD92&VuGDFRP SUHQGHUHQHOFRQFUHWRODSRUWDWDGHOO¶HVSDQVLRQHRODQGHVHLQ$VLD/D&RPSD JQLD5LXQLWDVLLQVHGLzD+LUDGRGDOD'HVKLPD7DLZDQ7DLQDQ GDODOHDQFRUDQHOQRUGHQHOVXGGHO9LHWQDPQHO 6LDP DG $\XWWKD\D VXOO¶LVROD GL 6XPDWUD D 3DOHPEDQJ VXOOH FRVWHGHOO¶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jGHL;9,,6LJQRULFKHORFRQVLGHUDYDQR HFFHVVLYDPHQWHHVXEHUDQWHFRQLGHHHLQL]LDWLYHVSHVVRWURSSRFRVWRVHHSRFR UHPXQHUDWLYH9DQ'LHPHQULPDVHLQFDULFDILQRDOODVXDPRUWH/DVXDRI IHQVLYD LQL]LDWD QHO PLUDYD DOO¶DSSURSULD]LRQH GHO FRPPHUFLR GHOOD FDQQHOODGL&H\ORQHGHOSHSHGHO0DODEDUOHGXHXQLFKHVSH]LHGLYDORUHUL PDVWHIXRULGDOFRQWUROORRODQGHVH&RQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWHYDQ'LHPHQLQYLz /DFK 9DQ .OH\ ,VUDHO 1DJD]XPL )XUEHU 6LQQDSSDK ,G 0F3KHUVRQ 6RX]D YDQ 9HHQ .OLMQ %R[HU ,G,G ,GD,VUDHOSS$\PDUG*DDVWUD%OXVVpGH0RRU %OXVVp 6WDSHOSS $GHVHPSLRO¶LGHDGLLQYLDUH$EHO7DVPDQDHVSORUDUHOHFRVWHGHOO¶$XVWUDOLDQHOH QHO/DFK9DQ.OH\,,,S , VLJQRUL GHO SULQFLSDWR GL .DQG\ QHOO¶LQWHUQR GL &H\ORQ HUDQR GD PROWR WHPSR LQ FRQIOLWWR FRQLSRUWRJKHVLHSHQVDYDQRGLSRWHUVLVHUYLUHGHJOLRODQGHVLSHUVFDFFLDUOL1HOOD92& FRQTXLVWz%DWWLFRODDHVWHQHO*DOOHQHOVXGFLRqOHGXHSULQFLSDOLFLWWjGHOWHUULWRULR 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL RJQLDQQRDSDUWLUHGDOXQDIORWWDDEORFFDUHLOSRUWRGL*RDODFDSLWDOH GHOO¶(VWDGR GD ,QGLD SRUWRJKHVH &RQ OD SDUDOLVL GL *RD LO FRQWUROOR DWWXDWR ILQRDGDOORUDGDLSRUWRJKHVLVXOFRXQWU\WUDGH>FRPPHUFLRGLWHUUD@GLYHQQH SUHVVRFKp LPSRVVLELOH H L FROOHJDPHQWL FRQ 0DODFFDH0DFDR YHQQHUR LQWHU URWWL$OORUFKpDQFKH0DODFFDQHOFDGGHQHOOHPDQLGHJOLRODQGHVLFKH ODWHQQHURSHUGXHVHFROLQRQRVWDQWHODSURJUHVVLYDSHUGLWDGLLPSRUWDQ]DGHO VXRSRUWRLOUXRORGHLSRUWRJKHVLQHLPDULRULHQWDOLHUDSUDWLFDPHQWHILQLWRH 0DFDRULPDVHLVRODWD *OLLQJOHVLIRQGDWDOD(,&QHOVHJXLYDQRDUXRWDJOLRODQGHVLFHU FDQGRGLULWDJOLDUVLLORURVSD]LLQXQPRQGRLQJUDQGHIHUPHQWRO¶LQHYLWDELOH ULYDOLWj WURYz HVSUHVVLRQH LQ XQR VFRQWUR HVSOLFLWR EUHYH H XIILFLRVR JLj QHO SUHOXGLRDOODIRQGD]LRQHGL%DWDYLDVHJXLWRGDOODEUHYHDOOHDQ]DGHOOD )OHHW RI 'HIHQVH GDO DO GL IDWWR PLUDWD D FROSLUH L SRUWRJKHVL D 0DFDRQHO/¶DQQRVXFFHVVLYRLO³PDVVDFURGL$PERLQD´RVVLDO¶XFFL VLRQHGDSDUWHGHOORFDOHJRYHUQDWRUHRODQGHVHGHOODFRORQLDGLPHUFDQWLLQ JOHVL H GHL ORUR LQWHUSUHWL DFFXVDWL GL WUDPDUH FRQWUR OD &RPSDJQLD 5LXQLWD ULEDGLYDODVXSUHPD]LDRODQGHVHQHOOH,VROHGHOOH6SH]LH/¶LQFLGHQWHDYUHEEH GDWRYLWDDXQ¶DFFHVDULYDOLWjXWLOL]]DWDGDJOLLQJOHVLSHUVFDWHQDUHGXHJXHUUH FRQWURJOLRODQGHVLHODVHFRQGDGHOOHTXDOLVLVDUHE EHFRQFOXVDFRQODSDFHGL%UHGDFKHDYUHEEHFRQVHQWLWRDJOLLQJOHVLGLRWWHQH UHFRPHULSDUD]LRQHSHULOWRUWRVXELWRODFLWWjGL1XRYD$PVWHUGDPO¶DWWXDOH 1HZ <RUN LQ FDPELR GHOOD ULQXQFLD GHILQLWLYD D RJQL SUHWHVD VXOOH 0ROXF FKH'DTXHOPRPHQWROD(,&VLVDUHEEHFRQFHQWUDWDVRSUDWWXWWRVXOO¶,QGLD QHOODTXDOHDYUHEEHEHQSUHVWRDVVXQWRXQDSRVL]LRQHGRPLQDQWHDQFKHJUD]LH DOO¶DFTXLVL]LRQHGL%RPED\LQVHJXLWRDOPDWULPRQLRGHOODSULQFLSHVVD SRUWRJKHVH &DWHULQD GL %UDJDQ]D FRQ O¶HUHGH DO WURQR LQJOHVH &DUOR ,, OD VFLDQGRDOOH3URYLQFH8QLWHLOFRQWUROORGHOO¶,QGRQHVLD GHOODFDQQHOOD)XUEHUSHLQJHQHUDOHSSVLYHGDDQFKH6LQQDSSDK SS0F3KHUVRQSSHLQJHQHUDOHSS*DDVWUDSS :DWVRQ $QGD\D $QGD\D SS /DFK 9DQ .OH\ ,,, SS *DDVWUDSS)XUEHUSS6RX]D YDQ'\NHSS /DFK9DQ.OH\,,,SS)XUEHUSS,VUDHOSVXL FRQIOLWWLDQJORRODQGHVLSSHLQJHQHUDOH )XUEHUSSHLQJHQHUDOHSS/DFK9DQ.OH\ ,,,SHLQ JHQHUDOHSS /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ -DQ3LHWHUV]RRQ&RHQGD%DQWHQD-DFDWUD /¶HQHUJLFDSROLWLFDGLDOFXQLGHLSULPLJRYHUQDWRULJHQHUDOLVLULYHOzIRQ GDPHQWDOH SHU JDUDQWLUH OD VROLGD FRVWUX]LRQH GHOOD 92& LQ $VLD WUD TXHVWL QRQSRVVLDPRRPHWWHUH-DQ3LHWHUV]RRQ&RHQFKHIXJRYHUQDWRUHJHQHUDOHGDO DOHGLQXRYRGDODO)XGXUDQWHLOVXRPDQGDWRFKHOD &RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDFRPSuLOYHURVDOWRGLTXDOLWjULXVFHQGRILQDOPHQWHDVWD ELOLUHXQDEDVHSHUPDQHQWHLQ,QGRQHVLDULVSRQGHQWHDOOHUHDOLHVLJHQ]HRSHUD WLYHRYYHURFRVWUXLUHXQDVHGHFRQHGLILFLGLSURSULHWjGHOOD92&HVXXQWHU ULWRULRVXOTXDOHHVHUFLWDUHXQDSLHQDVRYUDQLWj,SUHFHGHQWLJRYHUQDWRULJH QHUDOLQRQHUDQRULXVFLWLQHOO¶LQWHQWR%DQWHQGRYHOD&RPSDJQLDVLHUDLQVH GLDWD DOO¶LQL]LR VL HUD VYLOXSSDWD QRWHYROPHQWH FRPH FHQWUR DPPLQLVWUDWLYR FRQO¶LQVHGLDPHQWRGHO&RQVLJOLRPDQRQHUDULXVFLWDDHPHUJHUHFRPHTXDU WLHUH JHQHUDOHGHOOH IORWWH ,O UHJJHQWH GL %DQWHQFKH JRYHUQDYD LQ QRPH GHO VRYUDQRDQFRUDLQWHQHUDHWjQRQDYHYDDOFXQDLQWHQ]LRQHGLFRQFHGHUHDXQD QD]LRQH VWUDQLHUD SULYLOHJL HFFH]LRQDOL VXO SURSULR WHUULWRULR WDQWR SL FKH LO FRPPHUFLRPDULWWLPRHUDO¶HQWUDWDSLFRVSLFXDSHUOHFDVVHGHOUHJQRSHUFKp PDLIDYRULUH OD92&FRQSULYLOHJLFKHDYUHEEHURGDQQHJJLDWRO¶HFRQRPLDGL %DQWHQ",QROWUH LO FRPPHUFLR GHO SHSH HUD JHVWLWR GDOOH PDULQHULH FLQHVL FKHD%DQWHQDYHYDQRXQDORURFRQVLVWHQWHFRPXQLWj 4XDQGR &RHQ SUHVH VHUYL]LR H JLXQVH D %DQWHQ VL UHVH VXELWR FRQWR GL DYHUHSRFRVSD]LRGLPDQRYUDVLDSHUO¶LPSRVVLELOLWjGLVRWWUDUUHLOPRQRSROLR GHOSHSHGHWHQXWRGDLFLQHVLVLDSHUODIRU]DWDFRQGLYLVLRQHGHLFRPPHUFLFXL HUD FKLDPDWR QHL FRQIURQWL GHOOD (,& FKH SXUH DYDQ]DYD L SURSUL GLULWWL *Lj SUHFHGHQWHPHQWH -DFDWUD HUD VWDWD LQGLYLGXDWD FRPHSRVVLELOH DOWHUQDWLYD DOOD SRFRIUXWWXRVD%DQWHQLQTXDQWRLOSULQFLSHGHOOXRJRVHPEUDYDDYHUHXQDW WHJJLDPHQWR SL IDYRUHYROH QHL FRQIURQWL GHJOL HXURSHL FXL HUD GLVSRVWR D FRQFHGHUHPDJJLRUHOLEHUWj&RHQSHUWDQWRGHFLVHGLUHQGHUHFRQFUHWDTXHVWD SRVVLELOLWjQHOVLPRVVHLQWDOVHQVRPDLOFRQIOLWWRFKHLQVRUVHFRQJOL LQJOHVLQHOODEDLDGL-DFDWUDORFRVWULQVHDFHUFDUHVRVWHJQRD0DODFFD'XUDQWH ODVXDDVVHQ]DJOLLQJOHVLOHIRU]HGL%DQWHQHTXHOOHGL-DFDWUDVLDOWHUQDURQR 6WDSHOSS )XUEHU SS GH *URRW .DWKLULWKDPE\ :HOOV SS 0F3KHUVRQ $QFKHGDTXHVWRSXQWRGLYLVWDOD&RPSDJQLDGRYHYDFHGHUHLOSDVVRHGLSHQGHUHGDOODPH GLD]LRQHFLQHVH,QHIIHWWLIXSURSULRODSUHVVRFKpWRWDOHGLSHQGHQ]DGHOOD92&GDOOHPDULQH ULHFLQHVLSHULOULIRUQLPHQWRGLPROWHPHUFDQ]LHDFRVWLWXLUHLOOLPLWHLQYDOLFDELOHGHOVXRVYL OXSSR 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL QHOO¶DVVHGLRDJOLRODQGHVLPDVHQ]DDOFXQFRRUGLQDPHQWR$OULHQWURGL&RHQ ODEDWWDJOLDIXYLQWD-DFDWUDRSHUPHJOLRGLUHODQHRQDWD%DWDYLDGLYHQLYDLO TXDUWLHUHJHQHUDOHGHOOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDLQ$VLD&RUUHYDO¶DQQR 2OWUH DOOD IRQGD]LRQH GL %DWDYLD LO JUDQGH PHULWR GL -DQ 3LHWHUV]RRQ &RHQIXTXHOORGLDYHUFRQFHSLWRXQDVWUDWHJLDGLSHQHWUD]LRQHDJJUHVVLYDPD PLUDWDHGHIILFDFHPHWWHQGRLQSUDWLFDFLzFKHDQFRUDXQDYROWDO¶DPPLUDJOLR 0DDWHOLHIIDYHYDSUHFRFHPHQWHLQWXLWROD92&GRYHYDSUHQGHUHSDUWHDLWUDI ILFLLQ$VLDVHFRQGRXQVLVWHPDGLFRPPHUFLRLQWHUDVLDWLFRRYYHURVRVWLWXHQ GRVLDOOHPDULQHULHHSLUDWHULHRULHQWDOLQHOODJHVWLRQHGHLWUDIILFLLQWHUQD]LRQDOL GHOO¶2FHDQR,QGLDQRHGHO3DFLILFR&LzVLJQLILFDYDWUDUUHSURILWWRGDOWUDVSRU WRGHOOHVHWHFLQHVLLQ*LDSSRQHGDOWUDVIHULPHQWRGHOO¶DUJHQWRGDOO¶DUFLSHODJR QLSSRQLFR DOO¶,QGRQHVLD GDOOD FRPSUDYHQGLWD GHOOHVSH]LH GHO 6XGHVW DVLDWL FRGHOO¶,QGLDGHO*ROIR3HUVLFR8QDSDUWHGLTXHVWHPHUFLDYUHEEHFHUWDPHQ WHUDJJLXQWRO¶(XURSDPDODPDJJLRUHSHUFHQWXDOHGHLJXDGDJQLVDUHEEHVFD WXULWDGDLFRPPHUFLLQWHUDVLDWLFL,QHIIHWWLWDOHVLVWHPDULFDOFDYDDJJLRUQDQ GRORLOPRGHOORSRUWRJKHVHSDUWHGHOODVWUDWHJLDGL&RHQYHQQHHIIHWWLYDPHQ WH LQGLUL]]DWD D GHVWDELOL]]DUH LO SL SRVVLELOH OH FRPXQLFD]LRQL LEHULFKH FRQ FRQWLQXLDVVDOWLDLJDOHRQLVSDJQROLHSRUWRJKHVL /Dµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ 1RQRVWDQWHFKH-DQ3LHWHUV]RRQ&RHQYROHVVHRQRUDUHLOVXROXRJRQDWLR FKLDPDQGR1LHXZ+RRUQODYLQWD-DFDWUDL;9,,6LJQRULLPSRVHURLOQRPHGL %DWDYLDSHUFHOHEUDUHODJXHUUDG¶LQGLSHQGHQ]DFRQWUROD6SDJQDFRQLOULFRU GRGHOODWULEGHL%DWDYLULEHOODWLVLDOO¶HJHPRQLDURPDQD6XGLVHJQRGHOPD WHPDWLFR H VXSHUYLVRUH 6LPRQ 6WHYLQ IX GDWR LQL]LR DOOD FRVWUX]LRQH GHOO¶D YDPSRVWRRODQGHVH(PXODQGRLSRUWRJKHVL&RHQYROOHFKHIRVVHFRVWUXLWRXQ FDVWHOORSHUGRPLQDUHHFRQWUROODUHJOLLQJUHVVLYLDPDUHDOODEDLDGHOODFLWWj 1XPHURVLSLFFROLLVRORWWLHUDQRVSDUSDJOLDWLDOVXRLQJUHVVRJDUDQWHQGRLQWDO PRGRDFTXHVHPSUHFDOPHHUDXQSRUWRLGHDOH/DVHGHRODQGHVHIXFRPSOHWD WDGDOODFKLHVDGDXQYLDOH SHUOHSDVVHJJLDWHHQHOWHPSRGDRVSHGDOLFKH VHUYLYDQRSHUULFRYHUDUHJOLHTXLSDJJLPDODWLJLXQWLFRQOHIORWWHGHOOH,QGLHR JOL DELWDQWL GHOOD FLWWj FROSLWL GDOOH PDODWWLH WURSLFDOL )X FLUFRQGDWD GD PXUD LQWRUQRDJOLDELWDWLPDDGLIIHUHQ]DGHJOLLQVHGLDPHQWLLEHULFLGRYHULJRURVD PHQWH OH DOWUH HWQLH H OD FRPXQLWj FLQHVHLQ SULPLV YHQLYDQR SRVWH HVWHUQD %OXVVp SS %OXVVp GH 0RRU SS YDQ GHU &KLMV &RROKDDV /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ PHQWHDOODFLQWDQHOFDVRGL%DWDYLDWXWWLJOLDELWDQWLULVLHGHYDQRDOO¶LQWHUQR DQFKHSHUFKpILQRDOO¶DUPLVWL]LRVWLSXODWRDOODPHWjGHJOLDQQLµODFLWWjIX VRJJHWWD D QXPHURVL DVVDOWL GD SDUWH GL %DQWHQ 0DF¶HUD DQFKH XQD UDJLRQH FRQFUHWD L FLQHVL UHVLGHQWL D %DWDYLD DYHYDQR SDUWHFLSDWR SHU ROWUH GXH WHU]L DOOHVSHVHGLFRVWUX]LRQHGHOODFLQWDPXUDULDFRVuFRPHDOOHDOWUHRSHUHSXE EOLFKH/DFLWWjHUDVLWXDWDDOODIRFHGHOILXPH&LOLZRQJHGHUDSURWHWWDGDFDQ QRQLHGDWRUULGLDYYLVWDPHQWR,OFOLPDHUDSLXWWRVWRJUDGHYROHFRQVLGHUDQGR OD SRVL]LRQHFRVu YLFLQD DOO¶HTXDWRUH XQD EUH]]D PDWWXWLQD H XQD VHUDOH DOOH YLDYDQRODFDOXUD(UDQDWDODµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ /DIXQ]LRQHGLVHGHFHQWUDOHGLUDFFRUGRGHLFRPPHUFLLQWHUQD]LRQDOLGHO OD 92& HUD UHVD HYLGHQWH GDL QXPHURVL PDJD]]LQL DGLELWL DOOD UDFFROWD GHOOH PHUFDQ]LHLQWUDQVLWR,QROWUHSRLFKpHUDLOOXRJRGLUDGXQRGHOOHIORWWHGHOOD &RPSDJQLDHUDLQGLVSHQVDELOHFKHODFLWWjGLVSRQHVVHGLJUDQGLTXDQWLWjGLFL ERSRLFKpGRYHYDSURYYHGHUHQRQVRORDOVRVWHQWDPHQWRJLRUQDOLHURGHOODSR SROD]LRQH PD DQFKH DO ULIRUQLPHQWR GHOOH QDYL FKHSURSULR D %DWDYLD DFTXL VWDYDQROHVFRUWHQHFHVVDULHSHUDIIURQWDUHODQDYLJD]LRQHYHUVRODGHVWLQD]LR QHVWDELOLWD(JUD]LHDOOHPHUFLLQWUDQVLWRODEDVHSRWHYDJRGHUHGLFLELHEH YDQGHWUDLSLHVRWLFLHYDULDWLVHEEHQHVLIDFHVVHJUDQGHIHVWDDOOHQDYLSUR YHQLHQWLGDOO¶2ODQGDFRQLOWDQWRDJRJQDWRFDULFRGLSURGRWWLGHOODPDGUHSD WULDFDUQLVDODWHSDQFHWWDYLQLHELUUD/DVHGHGRYHYDLQROWUHHVVHUHSHUIHWWD PHQWHDWWUH]]DWDSHUDIIURQWDUHOHHPHUJHQ]HHUDIRQGDPHQWDOHSRWHUHIIHWWXD UHOHGRYXWHULSDUD]LRQLDOOHQDYLFKHQHDYHYDQRELVRJQRHVVHQGR%DWDYLDOR VFDORGLULIHULPHQWRSHUOHIORWWHLQYLDJJLRGDHYHUVRO¶$VLD$QFKHODFXUD GHOOHFLXUPHHUDXQDQHFHVVLWjSULRULWDULDVSHVVRJOLXRPLQLJLXQJHYDQRVWUH PDWLDPPDODWLGHQXWULWLDYROWHLQILQGLYLWDHGRYHYDQRHVVHUHULIRFLOODWLH ULSRUWDWLLQEXRQDVDOXWHSHUFKpLFRPSLWLFKHDYUHEEHURGRYXWRDIIURQWDUHRO WUHPDUHHUDQRHVWUHPDPHQWHJUDYRVL ,ODYRULGLUDGGREERGHOOHQDYLVLVYROJHYDQRLQFLWWjRQHLFDQWLHULVRUWL QHOOHLVROHDOODUJRGHOODFRVWD(UDQRVWDELOLPHQWLGLJUDQGLGLPHQVLRQLGRWDWL GLDPSLVFDOLHGLPRGHUQHDWWUH]]DWXUHWUDFXLVHJKHULHD]LRQDWHGDPXOLQLD YHQWRFRPHLQ2ODQGDIRUJHDUJDQLFRUGHULHHYHOHULH,QPROWLFDVLOD92& FRPPLVVLRQDYDDTXHVWLLPSLDQWLODFRVWUX]LRQHGLQDYLGHVWLQDWHDLWUDIILFLLQ WHUDVLDWLFLTXDQGRQRQXWLOL]]DYDTXHOOHLQGLVDUPRGDOODURWWDHXURSHD,OSUR EOHPD SULQFLSDOH HUD ULXVFLUH D SURFXUDUVL L PDWHULDOL GD FRVWUX]LRQH DGDWWL %OXVVp SS /DFK 9DQ .OH\ ,,, SS %OXVVp 5DEHQ YDQGHU&KLMV %OXVVpSS1LHPHLMHU7D\ORU 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL SHUFKpVRORLQSDUWHVLSRWHYDVRSSHULUHFRQOHULVRUVHORFDOL,OUHVWRGRYHYD JLXQJHUHGDL3DHVL%DVVLDFRVWLFRPSUHQVLELOPHQWHDOWLHFRQJUDYLULVFKLGL GHWHULRUDPHQWRRGLSHUGLWDDFDXVDGHOOXQJRYLDJJLR,QROWUHELVRJQDYDIDUH LFRQWLFRQODPDQFDQ]DGLPDHVWULG¶DVFLDYHUDPHQWHSUHSDUDWLHGLPDQRGR SHUDDGGHVWUDWDDOODYRURFRQOHPDFFKLQHXWHQVLOL,WHFQLFLJLXQWLGDOO¶(XURSD FHUFDYDQRGLIHUPDUVLLOPHQRSRVVLELOHHQRQVHPSUHHUDQRFDSDFLGLWUDVPHW WHUHLVHJUHWLGHOPHVWLHUHDLORURDOOLHYLLQGLJHQL,OSRUWRGL%DWDYLDHUDSUR WHWWRGDGXHPROLOXQJKLXQPLJOLDLRGLPHWULFLDVFXQRHSRWHYDRVSLWDUHILQRD XQDWUHQWLQDGLQDYLFRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWHLOFKHQHIDFHYDLO PDJJLRUHLQVH GLDPHQWRHXURSHRROWUHLO&DSRGL%XRQD6SHUDQ]D ,O JRYHUQDWRUH JHQHUDOH GRYHYD VXSHUYLVLRQDUH WXWWH TXHVWH DWWLYLWj QRQ XOWLPDODYHULILFDGHOFDULFRHGHOORVFDULFRGHOOHPHUFLHLUHODWLYLUHJLVWUL,Q DJJLXQWD D OXL FRPSHWHYD OD VXSHUYLVLRQH GHOO¶RSHUDWR GHL JRYHUQDWRUL GHOOH YDULHVHGLGLVORFDWHLQ$VLDO¶HVDPHGHLORURUHQGLFRQWLHUHOD]LRQLODVFHOWD GHOOH VWUDWHJLH H GHOOH VLQJROH SROLWLFKH GD DGRWWDUH 8Q FRPSLWR LPPDQH DO TXDOH SDUWHFLSDYDQR DQFKH L FLQTXH PHPEUL GHO &RQVLJOLR GHOOH ,QGLH >5DDG YDQ,QGLs@HXQ'LUHFWHXU*HQHUDDOVRUWDGLYLFHJRYHUQDWRUHFKHVYROJHYD VRSUDWWXWWRFRPSLWLRSHUDWLYL&RQLOSDVVDUHGHOWHPSRIXDJJLXQWRXQRVWDII SHUFRDGLXYDUORLQWXWWHOHIXQ]LRQLFRPSRVWRGDOO¶LVSHWWRUHJHQHUDOHUHVSRQ VDELOHGHOOHVXFFXUVDOLGDOO¶DYYRFDWRILVFDOHXQDVRUWDGLVRVWLWXWRSURFXUDWR UHGHOODUHSXEEOLFDHXQLQFDULFDWRSHUJOLDIIDULPLOLWDULHOHIORWWH,TXDWWUR JRYHUQDWRULGL$PERLQDGHOOH0ROXFFKHGHOOH%DQGDHGL&H\ORQHUDQRUDS SUHVHQWDWLLQORURDVVHQ]DGDFRQVLJOLHULVWUDRUGLQDUL%DWDYLDHLVXRLGLQWRUQL HUDQR VRWWR LO GLUHWWR FRQWUROOR GHO JRYHUQDWRUH JHQHUDOH ,QROWUH F¶HUDQR RWWR JRYHUQDWRULFKHDJLYDQRDILDQFRGHLTXDWWURWLWRODULGL0DNDVVDUGHOODSDUWH QRUGRULHQWDOHGL*LDYDHGHO6XGDIULFD8QVLVWHPDFRPSOHVVRFKHULFKLHGHYD XQDJUDQGHFDSDFLWjRUJDQL]]DWLYDHVRSUDWWXWWRXQFRQWUROORIHUUHRVXOOHDUHH GLLQWHUHVVHVWUDWHJLFR3LGLRJQLDOWUDFRVDLQIDWWLHUDQHFHVVDULRFRRUGLQDUH O¶DUULYR H OD SDUWHQ]D GHOOH IORWWH GHOOD &RPSDJQLD LO UHODWLYR FDULFR LQ EDVH DOODSURYHQLHQ]DHDOODGHVWLQD]LRQHDOOHULFKLHVWHULFHYXWHDOOHILQDOLWjVSHFL ILFKHHUDTXHVWRLOODYRURSLFRPSOHVVRHGHVVHQ]LDOHSRLFKpODUHWHGHLWUDI ILFLQHOVLVWHPDFRPPHUFLDOHLQWHUDVLDWLFRQHFHVVLWDYDGLSHUIHWWRVLQFURQLVPR HSUHFLVLRQH &DWHULQRSS *DDVWUD SS %R[HU ,G %OXVVp SS 1LHPHLMHU 7D\ORU /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ %DWDYLDFURFHYLDLQWHUQD]LRQDOHGHOOD92& ,OQXRYRVLVWHPDGLSRWHUHRODQGHVHQRQHUDSRLWDQWRGLVVLPLOHGDTXHOOR SRUWRJKHVHFRPHVDUHEEHOHFLWRVXSSRUUHVXOODEDVHGHOODGLIIHUHQWHVWUXWWXUD RUJDQL]]DWLYDXQFDSLWDOLVPRGL6WDWRTXHOORSRUWRJKHVHFRQWUDSSRVWRDXQD VRFLHWjSHUD]LRQLIRUPDOPHQWHDQFKHVHQRQVRVWDQ]LDOPHQWHSULYDWDTXHOOD RODQGHVH'LVSRUUHGLXQDUHWHGLFDSLVDOGLFRVuYDVWDHDUWLFRODWDVLJQLILFzSHU JOL RODQGHVL SRWHU LVWLWXLUH XQD VHULH GL OLQHH GL QDYLJD]LRQH UHJRODUL FKH GDOO¶(VWUHPR2ULHQWHDO6XGHVWDVLDWLFRHGDOO¶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¶$VLDSLGLQDYLPHUFDQWLOLQDYLGDJXHUUD LPSLHJDWLHXQHVHUFLWRSULYDWRGLXRPLQL/D&RPSDJQLDVSHV VRGHWHQHYDLOPRQRSROLRGHOODSURGX]LRQHQHLOXRJKLLQFXLVLULIRUQLYDGLGH WHUPLQDWHPHUFLOH,VROHGHOOH6SH]LHPDQRQVRORHTXLQGLSRWHYDVWDELOLUH LQWXWWDOLEHUWjLSUH]]LDSURSULRHVFOXVLYRYDQWDJJLRVLDULVSHWWRDLSURGXWWRUL DVLDWLFLVLDULVSHWWRDJOLDFTXLUHQWLHXURSHL /DFRPSOHVVDORJLVWLFDGHOFRPPHUFLRLQWHUDVLDWLFRGHOOD92&WURYDXQD FKLDUDHVSRVL]LRQHQHLODYRULGLVWXGLRVLTXDOL)HPPH*DDVWUD/HRQDUG%OXV Vp R 5REHUW 3DUWKHVLXV FKH KDQQR DQDOL]]DWR LO IXQ]LRQDPHQWR GHO VLVWHPD RODQGHVH FHUFDQGR GL LQGLYLGXDUQH OH UDJLRQL GHOO¶HIILFLHQ]D VLD LQ DPELWR SURSULDPHQWHFRPPHUFLDOHVLDSHUORVYROJLPHQWRGLFRPSLWLGLGLIHVDHGXQ TXHDQFKHPLOLWDUL/DULVSRVWDFKHYLHQHGDWDqFRQQHVVDDOODWLSRORJLDGHOOH LPEDUFD]LRQLXWLOL]]DWHRJQXQDGLYHUVDSHUGLPHQVLRQLHFODVVHDVHFRQGDGHO ODGHVWLQD]LRQHHGHOOHILQDOLWjDWWHVH1HJOLDQQLGDODOLOQXPHUR GHLYLDJJLGHOOHIORWWHGHOOD92&IXDOTXDQWRYDULDELOHFLUFDLQWRUQRDO &DSRGL%XRQD6SHUDQ]DHQHLPDULRULHQWDOL6LULSRUWDVLQWHWLFDPHQWH ODVWUXWWXUDQHOVXRVFKHPDJHQHUDOHFRQDOFXQHGHOOHGHVWLQD]LRQLSULQFLSDOL FRVuGDSRWHUQHFRPSUHQGHUHLOIXQ]LRQDPHQWR 6WHHQVJDDUG $\PDUG *DDVWUD %R[HU ,G E ,VUDHO 1DJD]XPL)XUEHU6LQQDSSDK,G0F3KHUVRQ6RX]D YDQ9HHQ.OLMQ %OXVVpSS3DUWKHVLXV 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL ,YLDJJLHUDQRQDWXUDOPHQWHFRQGL]LRQDWLGDOULWPRVWDJLRQDOHGHLPRQVR QL/DVFLDYDQR%DWDYLDQHLPHVLWUDPDJJLRHOXJOLROHQDYLLQSDUWHQ]DSHULO *LDSSRQHGRYHHVSRUWDYDQRWHVVLOLLQGLDQLHRODQGHVLSHOOLGLDQLPDOLHVSH ]LH YL VL ULIRUQLYDQR GL PRQHWH G¶RUR H G¶DUJHQWR ODFFKH SRUFHOODQH VHWH UDPHWqHDOFXQLSURGRWWLLPSRUWDWLGDOOD&LQD$OWUHQDYLVDOSDYDQRLQDXWXQ QR SHU JLXQJHUH D IHEEUDLR R PDU]R LQ 3HUVLD R QHO %HQJDOD H ULWRUQDYDQR GRSRDYHU FRPSOHWDWR LO FDULFR FRQ DOWUL SURGRWWL FLQHVLROWUH DOOR VWDJQR DF TXLVWDWRD0DODFFD/HQDYLGHVWLQDWHDOODFRVWDRULHQWDOHGHOO¶,QGLDIDFHYDQR YHODWUDDSULOHHDJRVWRSDVVDQGRSHU&H\ORQSHUSRLJLXQJHUHD3XOLFDWOuVL ULIRUQLYDQRGLODVWURQLLQSLHWUDVDOQLWURWHVVLOLGLDPDQWLHULHQWUDYDQRD%D WDYLD LQ VHWWHPEUH 3HU &H\ORQ 6XUDW H OD 3HUVLDOH QDYL ODVFLDYDQR JOL RU PHJJLLQVHWWHPEUHFRQXQFDULFRGLVSH]LHHRUGLQDWLYLYDULLQRWWREUHSURVH JXLYDQRVHFRQGRLYHQWLSHULO0DODEDUH:LQJXUODGRYHVLULIRUQLYDQRGLSH SHHDOWUHPHUFDQ]LHYDULHWUDFXLQRFLGLFRFFRSHUULIRUQLUH6XUDWH3HUVLD $OFXQH QDYL YHQLYDQR PDQGDWH GLUHWWDPHQWH LQ 3HUVLD H D 6XUDW GD &H\ORQ FRQVSH]LHSHSHUDPHHVWDJQR 7UDIHEEUDLRHPDU]ROHQDYLYHQLYDQRSUHSDUDWHSHULOULHQWURD%DWDYLD VHWHSHUVLDQHIUXWWLEURFFDWLWHVVLOLJLRLHOOLHFDYDOOLFRVWLWXLYDQRLOORURFDUL FR$PDJJLR&H\ORQLQYLDYDGLUHWWDPHQWHD%DWDYLDGXHQDYLVSHFLDOLFDULFKH GLFDQQHOODFKHHUDLOSURGRWWRSULQFLSDOHGHOO¶LVROD7UDOXJOLRHDJRVWRSDUWL YDQROHQDYLSHULO%HQJDODFRQDERUGRO¶DUJHQWRJLDSSRQHVHFKHGRYHYDSUR FXUDUH VHWH SHU LO *LDSSRQH H WHVVXWL GL FRWRQH H RSSLR SHU *LDYD ( DQFRUD YDQQR PHQ]LRQDWH OH GHVWLQD]LRQL GL 6XPDWUD 0DODFFD LO 6LDP O¶RGLHUQD 7KDLODQGLD HFF FKH IRUQLYDQR WXWWD XQD VHULH GL SURGRWWL GHVWLQDWL D LQFUH PHQWDUHLSURILWWLGHOOD&RPSDJQLDHDPDQWHQHUHLOFRQWUROORVXOOHSULQFLSDOL OLQHHGLFRPXQLFD]LRQH8QXOWLPRFHQQRYDIDWWRVSHFLILFRSHUOH0ROXFFKH OH³,VROHGHOOH6SH]LH´FXLYHQLYDQRGHVWLQDWHOHIORWWH FKHVDOSDYDQRWUDGL FHPEUHHIHEEUDLRFRQXQFDULFRGLULVRSDQFHWWDDFHWRYLQRHROLRFKHGR YHYDULIRUQLUHJOLRODQGHVLLQVHUYL]LRSUHVVROHPROWHSOLFLVHGLGHOOD92&'D HVVHDUULYDYDQRODQRFHPRVFDWDLFKLRGLGLJDURIDQRHLOPDFLVFKHFRVWLWXL YDQR L FDULFKL SL SUH]LRVL GHOOH IORWWH GHOOH ,QGLH VLD LQ UHOD]LRQH DL WUDIILFL FRQO¶(XURSDVLDDTXHOOLFRQOD&LQDHLO*LDSSRQH 1HOSHULRGRWUDPDJJLRHDJRVWRSHUFLzODYLWDD%DWDYLDHUDSDUWLFRODU PHQWHPRYLPHQWDWDDFDXVDGHOORVYLOXSSRGHLFRPPHUFLLQWHUDVLDWLFLGDVHW WHPEUHDQRYHPEUHPROWHIORWWHHUDQRGLULWRUQRGDOOHORURGHVWLQD]LRQLHQH FHVVLWDYDQRGHOODGRYXWDPDQXWHQ]LRQHSHUHVVHUHSURQWHSHUODVWDJLRQHVXF 6LYHGDLQSURSRVLWR-DFT+HUJRXDOF¶KSS /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ FHVVLYD 7UD O¶DOWUR RFFRUUHYD ULPSLD]]DUH JOL XRPLQL GHFHGXWL TXHOOL FKH VL HUDQR DPPDODWL H TXHOOL FKH DYHYDQR GLVHUWDWR VSHVVR LQJDJJLDQGR DYYHQWX ULHUL H GHOLQTXHQWL PDJDUL LQGLJHQL FKH SRL IDWLFDYDQR D VRSUDYYLYHUH QHL FOLPLULJLGLGHOOHDOWHODWLWXGLQLPHULGLRQDOLHVHWWHQWULRQDOL,QHIIHWWLFRQO¶HF FH]LRQHGLDOFXQLYLDJJLGLUHWWLSHU&H\ORQWXWWHOHQDYLGHOFRPPHUFLRLQWHUD VLDWLFRFRVuFRPHGLTXHOORHXURSHRGRYHYDQRIDUHVFDORREEOLJDWRULDPHQWHD %DWDYLDFKHVYROJHYDXQDIXQ]LRQHGLKXE6LFRPSUHQGHFRPHXQWDOHVLVWH PD SHU TXDQWR PDFFKLQRVR IRVVH GL HQRUPH YDQWDJJLR HFRQRPLFR SHU OD &RPSDJQLD XWLOL]]DQGR XRPLQL PHUFL H FDSLWDOL JLj SUHVHQWL QHO FRQWHVWR D VLDWLFROD92&VLLQVHULYDQHLQHWZRUNVPHUFDQWLOLLQWHUQD]LRQDOLSUHHVLVWHQWL SHUDIILDQFDUVLSULPDHVRVWLWXLUVLJUDGXDOPHQWHSRLDOOHPDULQHULHRULHQWDOL QHOODFRQGX]LRQHGLWDOLFRPPHUFL8QDSDUWHGHLWUDIILFLUDJJLXQJHYDVLFXUD PHQWHO¶(XURSDHJDUDQWLYDXWLOLFRQVLGHUHYROLVSHFLDOPHQWHQHOSHULRGRFRP SUHVR IUD LO H LO PD OD YHUD VSHFXOD]LRQH GHULYDYD GDO VLVWHPD GL FRPPHUFLRLQWHUDVLDWLFRPHVVRLQRSHUD /DPHGLD]LRQHFLQHVH $OPRPHQWRGHOODYLWWRULDRODQGHVHLOPDJJLRODVLWXD]LRQHDS SDULYDSLXWWRVWRFULWLFDWXWWLJOLDELWDQWLGL-DFDWUDDYHYDQRVHJXLWRLOSULQFLSH UHJQDQWH H WURYDWR ULIXJLR D %DQWHQ 6H SHU XQ YHUVR TXHVWR VLJQLILFDYD QRQ GRYHUWHPHUHDWWLGLULEHOOLRQHRGLERLFRWWDJJLRSHUXQDOWURODVFLDYDOD&RP SDJQLD 5LXQLWD VHQ]D PDQRGRSHUD SHU OD FRVWUX]LRQHGHOOD VXD EDVH 8QD VL WXD]LRQHSLXWWRVWRLQXVXDOHTXHOODGLFRQTXLVWDUHXQDFLWWjYXRWD*OLXQLFLFKH DYHYDQR VFHOWR GL ULPDQHUH HUDQR L FLQHVL LYL UHVLGHQWL FRQ OH ORUR DWWLYLWj FRPPHUFLDOLIRUVHLVROLDLTXDOLXQFDPELRQHOODJHVWLRQHSROLWLFDQRQFUHDYD SUREOHPL DQ]L LQ SURVSHWWLYD JDUDQWLYD XQ SRVVLELOH PLJOLRUDPHQWR,Q DJ JLXQWD LO JRYHUQDWRUH JHQHUDOH &RHQ GRYHWWH VRSSRUWDUH QHO VHJXHQWH DQQR O¶DUPLVWL]LR VRWWRVFULWWR GDOO¶2ODQGD FRQ O¶,QJKLOWHUUD H OD FRVWLWX]LRQH %OXVVpSS3DUWKHVLXV6LYHGDLQROWUH1DJD]XPL+DQHGD .HDUQH\ -DFT+HUJRXDOF¶K /DFK 9DQ .OH\ 0F3KHUVRQ 5DEHQ 7D\ORU:LOOV$UDVDUDWQDP,G$QFRUDGLDSSURIRQGLPHQWR $UDVDUDWQDPSS%KDZDQSSQD3RPEHMUDSSYDQ *RRUSSGH*URRW1DJDVKLPDSSƿWDSS 3UDNDVKSS 6KLPDGD SS 7VXNDKDUD SS :DGD SS %OXVVpSS 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL GHOOD)OHHWRI'HIHQVHSHUO¶HQHUJLFRJRYHUQDWRUHFKHDYHYDDSSHQDFRPEDW WXWRHYLQWRLULYDOLLQJOHVLHUDGDYYHURXQERFFRQHLQGLJHVWR 1HOOD QHRQDWD VHGH GL %DWDYLD OD PHGLD]LRQH FLQHVH H LO VXR FRLQYROJL PHQWRQHOODFRVWUX]LRQHGHOODFLWWjHGHOVXRQHWZRUNFRPPHUFLDOHIXURQRHV VHQ]LDOL,OFLQHVH-DQ&RQQRPHFRQFXLqFRQRVFLXWRQHOOHIRQWLRODQGHVLGL YHQQHLOEUDFFLRGHVWURGHLGHOHJDWLGHOOD92&HJOLULPDVHXQDGHOOHSHUVRQD OLWjSLLPSRUWDQWLGHOODORFDOHFRPXQLWjFLQHVHHDWWHVHDOOHIXQ]LRQLGLFRQVL JOLHUH GL ILGXFLD SHU OH DXWRULWj GHOOD &RPSDJQLD ,QGHIHVVR ODYRUDWRUH QHO FRUVRGLXQYHQWHQQLRVLDIILDQFzDJRYHUQDWRULJHQHUDOLTXDOL-DQ3LHWHUV]RRQ &RHQRILQDQFKH$QWRQYDQ'LHPHQ/DVWHVVDJHVWLRQHGLJUDQSDUWHGHLOD YRULSXEEOLFLSHUHGLILFDUHODFLWWjGL%DWDYLDIXDVVHJQDWDD-DQ&RQFKHJR GHYDGHOODPDVVLPDVWLPDHILGXFLD*OLDSSDOWLSHUODFRVWUX]LRQHGHLFDQDOL ODERQLILFDGLQXRYHWHUUHHODORURFROWLYD]LRQHO¶DVVXQ]LRQHGLPDQRG¶RSHUD WUD JOL VWHVVL FLQHVL FRVu FRPH O¶HVD]LRQH GHOOH WDVVH VXOOH DWWLYLWj GHL SURSUL FRQQD]LRQDOLIXURQRFRPSLWLFKH-DQ&RQVYROVHVXPDQGDWRHSHUFRQWRGHJOL RODQGHVL $QFRUSLVLJQLILFDWLYROHDXWRULWjGL%DWDYLDJOLGHOHJDURQRSLYROWHOD FRQGX]LRQHGHLFRPPHUFLGHOOD92&JDUDQWHQGRJOLXQFUHGLWRHFFHVVLYRGL IDWWR LPSRVVLELOH GD ULVFXRWHUH $QWRQ YDQ 'LHPHQ QH WUDVVH LO GRYXWR LQVH JQDPHQWRULWHQHQGRFKHODSUHVHQ]DFLQHVHQRQIRVVHVRORULYROWDDXQ¶LQWHU PHGLD]LRQH GHL WUDIILFL FRQ OD GRYXWD FRPPLVVLRQHPD FKH WHQGHVVH DG DS SURSULDUVLGHOODJHVWLRQHLQVpGHOOHWUDQVD]LRQLFRPPHUFLDOLHLQTXHVWRLOJR YHUQDWRUHJHQHUDOHFHQWUzDSSLHQRODTXHVWLRQH,QHIIHWWLGLHWURODIXQ]LRQH LQGLVSHQVDELOH GL PHGLDWRUL TXDOL -DQ &RQ HVLVWHYDQR EHQ SUHFLVH HVLJHQ]H FKH GL FHUWR QRQ FRLQFLGHYDQR FRQ TXHOOH GHJOL HXURSHL ,O FRPPHUFLR GHOOH JLXQFKH FLQHVL FKH OLEHUDPHQWH DSSURGDYDQR H VDOSDYDQR GD %DWDYLD q VHQ]¶DOWURXQHOHPHQWRGLQRWHYROHLQWHUHVVH3XUDYHQGRULJLGDPHQWHLPSRVWR LO PRQRSROLR VX WXWWL L FRPPHUFL LQ HQWUDWD H LQ XVFLWD GDO SURSULR TXDUWLHUH JHQHUDOH OD &RPSDJQLD 5LXQLWD GRYHYD ULFRQRVFHUH O¶LPSRVVLELOLWj GL SRUUH VRWWRLOSURSULRFRQWUROOROHPDULQHULHFLQHVLHSHUTXDVLWXWWRLO6HLFHQWRGL VWDELOLUH XQ DFFHVVR FRPPHUFLDOH GLUHWWR DOOH FRVWH FRQWLQHQWDOL GHOOD &LQD 1HOO¶DFXWD VWUDWHJLDGL HVSDQVLRQLVPR SHUVHJXLWD WUD JOLRELHWWLYL QRQ SRWHYD FHUWRPDQFDUHOD&LQDODYHUDXOWLPDPHWDGLWXWWLLQDYLJDWRULHXURSHLLOFRQ 9DQ'\NHSS %OXVVpSS 6WDSHOSS :LOOV,G /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ WLQHQWH FLQHVH UDSSUHVHQWDYD OD JUDQGH VILGD OD SRVWD SHU OD TXDOH YDOHYD OD SHQDGLJLRFDUHLOWXWWRSHUWXWWR ,OFRPPHUFLRGHOOHJLXQFKHFLQHVLD%DWDYLDHUDGLJUDQOXQJDDQWHFHGHQ WHDOO¶DUULYRGHOOD92&HLOIOXVVRGLFRPPHUFLJHVWLWRGDOOHPDULQHULHFLQHVL VX %DWDYLD ULIRUQLYD OD &RPSDJQLD SURSULR GL TXHL SURGRWWL FLQHVL FKH DOWUL PHQWLQRQDYUHEEHSRWXWRRWWHQHUHTXDOLOHVHWHGL=KHQJ]KRXOR]XFFKHUROH SRUFHOODQHODFDUWDYDULRJJHWWLLQOHJQRIUXWWDIUHVFDHGHVVLFFDWDLQFDPELR HVSRUWDYDQRPRQHWHG¶DUJHQWRSURGRWWLWURSLFDOLHVSH]LHLOSHSHLQGLDQRDG HVHPSLRDYRULRHFRUQRYDULHGURJKH,QHIIHWWLOHQDYLFLQHVLODVFLDYDQR%D WDYLDSHUUHFDUVLD1DJDVDNLGRYHVLXQLYDQRDLQDYLJOLFLQHVLFKHIDFHYDQROD VSRODFRQLOPHULGLRQHGHOOD&LQDHLQSDUWLFRODUHFRQLO)XMLDQFKLXGHQGRFR VuXQFLUFXLWRFKHFROOHJDYDDQFKHO¶LQWHUR(VWUHPR2ULHQWH ,OµTXDUWLHUHJLDSSRQHVH¶ %DWDYLDRVSLWzVLQGDJOLLQL]LDQFKHXQDSLFFRODSUHVHQ]DJLDSSRQHVHFKH ORVWRULFR0XUDNDPL1DRMLUǀQXPHUDLQQHOVXXQWRWDOHFRPSOHVVL YR GL UHVLGHQWL*Lj GDOOD IRQGD]LRQH GHOOD EDVH 92& D +LUDGR QHO LGHOHJDWLGHOOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDDYHYDQRDSSUH]]DWRODVWUDRUGLQDULD DELOLWjGHLJLDSSRQHVLQHOFRPEDWWLPHQWRVHPEUDFKHQHODOFXQLGLHVVL IRVVHUR LPEDUFDWL VXOOH QDYL GHOOD 92& LQSDUWHQ]DGDO.\njVKnj SHU-DYD'L FHUWRORIXURQRQHO+HQGULFN%URXZHUDOO¶HSRFDDFDSRGHOODVHGH92& GL+LUDGRLQYLDYDD-DFDWUDJLDSSRQHVLLQIRUPDQGRLO*RYHUQDWRUH*HQH UDOH 3LHWHU %RWK QHOOD OHWWHUD GHO JHQQDLR FKH SHU SUREOHPL GL FD SLHQ]DGHOOHQDYLQRQDYHYDSRWXWRPDQGDUHLXRPLQLULFKLHVWL1HO D+LUDGRYHQLYDVWLSXODWRXQFRQWUDWWRWULHQQDOHFRQJLDSSRQHVLDVVROGDWL DO VHUYL]LR GHOOD &RPSDJQLD 5LXQLWD SUHYDOHQWHPHQWH LQ TXDOLWj GL PDULQDL H FRPEDWWHQWLPDDQFKHFRQDOFXQLFDUSHQWLHULWUDGLHVVL,VROGDWLJLDSSRQHVL /DFK9DQ.OH\,,,SS*DDVWUDSS%OXVVpGH0RRU SSSDVVLP)XUEHUSS%R[HU 6LYHGDVXOWHPD&DULRWLE 6XOODµGLDVSRUDJLDSSRQHVH¶EHQSRFRVLqVFULWWRVRSUDWWXWWRQHOOHOLQJXHRFFLGHQWDOLJLjGDOOD PHWjGHOVHFROR;9,LOVHFRODUHIOXVVRGLWUDIILFLHFRPPHUFLGHOOHPDULQHULHJLDSSRQHVLDYH YDGDWRYLWDDSLFFROLLQVHGLDPHQWLVXLOLWRUDOLGHO6XG(VW$VLDWLFRILQRDOOHFRVWHGHOO¶2FHDQR ,QGLDQR6LHUDDQFRUDORQWDQLGDOODSROLWLFDFRVLGGHWWDGLµFKLXVXUD¶VDNRNXGHOEDNXIX7R NXJDZDFKHDYUHEEHSURLELWRDLJLDSSRQHVLGLUHFDUVLDOO¶HVWHURQRQFKpULGRWWRQRWHYROPHQWH LUDSSRUWLLQWHUQD]LRQDOLGHOO¶DUFLSHODJROLPLWDQGRGDODOODVRODEDVH92&GL'HVKLPDOH SUHVHQ]HHXURSHH 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL LPSDYLGLHLQSULPDILODLQEDWWDJOLDHFFHOOHYDQRQHOO¶DUWHGHOFRPEDWWLPHQWR H IXURQR GL IDWWR XQ HOHPHQWR YLQFHQWH QHO FRQIOLWWR GHO DOO¶DWWR GHOOD FRQTXLVWDGL-DFDWUD,PHUFHQDULJLDSSRQHVLHUDQRPROWRTXRWDWLQHOO¶LQWHUR FRQWHVWRGHOO¶$VLD2ULHQWDOHHQRQHUDUDURFKHIRVVHURDVVROGDWLGDJOLHXUR SHL FRVu FRPH GDOOH ORFDOL DXWRULWj DVLDWLFKH LQ FDVR GL FRQIOLWWL LQWHUQL /D 92&QRQIDFHYDHFFH]LRQHHXWLOL]]zLOVXSSRUWREHOOLFRGHLVROGDWLGLYHQWXUD GHOO¶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j7RNXJDZDWXWWDYLDQRQYHGHYDQRDIIDWWRGLEXRQJUDGRTXH VWRHVSDWULRGLJLDSSRQHVLSRVWLDOVROGRGHOOD92&HWUDGRWWLGLHWURFRPSHQVR QHOOHVHGLGHOOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDLQSULPLVD%DWDYLD*LjQHOLOED NXIX 7RNXJDZD SURLELYD DOOD 92& GL LPEDUFDUH VXOOH SURSULH QDYL L VXGGLWL JLDSSRQHVLSHUFRQGXUOLDOO¶HVWHURRUGLQDQGRDOGDLP\ǀ0DWVXXUDGLFRQWURO ODUH DWWHQWDPHQWH FKH LO YHWR IRVVH ULVSHWWDWR QHOO¶RWWREUH GHOOR VWHVVR DQQR DYYHQLYDO¶HVHFX]LRQHFDSLWDOHGLWUHJLDSSRQHVLFKHDYHYDQRFHUFDWRGL LPEDUFDUVL FODQGHVWLQDPHQWH YLRODQGR O¶RUGLQH VKRJXQDOH 7XWWDYLD DOPHQR SHU LO PRPHQWR OH QDYL GHOO¶DUFLSHODJR SRWHYDQR DQFRUD UHFDUVL ROWUHPDUH VHEEHQHIRVVHRUPDLLQDWWRLOVLVWHPDGHJOLVKXLQVHQDOO¶LQGRPDQLGHOFOLPD GLDSHUWXUDLQWHUQD]LRQDOHGHOIRQGDWRUH,H\DVXLOVHFRQGRVKǀJXQ+LGHWDGD DYRFDYDDVpLOGLUHWWRFRQWUROORVXOOHDWWLYLWjPDULWWLPRFRPPHUFLDOLGHOO¶DUFL SHODJR3HUWDQWRGDOOHDOWUHGHVWLQD]LRQLUDJJLXQWHGDLPHUFDQWLOLJLDSSRQHVL GRYHSXUHVRUJHYDQRSLFFROLµTXDUWLHULJLDSSRQHVL¶LQLKRQPDFKLDGHVHPSLR QHO7RQFKLQRLQ6LDP±O¶DWWXDOH7DLODQGLD±RLQ&DPERJLDOD&RPSDJQLD 5LXQLWDSRWHYDFRPXQTXHFRQWLQXDUHDGDVVROGDUHPHUFHQDULJLDSSRQHVL,Q HIIHWWLXQDYROWDIRQGDWDODEDVHGL%DWDYLDOHDXWRULWjGHOOD92&SURPRVVHUR 0XUDNDPLSS 6LULFRUGDQRVXOWHPDLIRQGDPHQWDOLODYRULGL,ZDR6HLLFKLH /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ LQ SL RFFDVLRQL O¶LQVHGLDUVL GL XQD SLFFROD FRPXQLWj GL µJLDSSRQHVL G¶ROWUH PDUH¶ FRQ SUHYDOHQ]DGL FRPEDWWHQWL FRPH VL FRPSUHQGH PD FDOGHJJLDQGR DQFKHO¶DUULYRGLYHUVLILFDWRGLFLYLOLFRQVYDULDWHPDQVLRQLHGXQTXHLOWUDVIH ULPHQWRGHOODUHODWLYDFRPSRQHQWHIHPPLQLOHLQPRGRGDGDUYLWDDGXQLQVH GLDPHQWRVWDELOH 6HEEHQH O¶HOHPHQWR PHUFHQDULR IRVVH VWDWR SULRULWDULR QHOOD IRUPD]LRQH GHOSLFFRORLQVHGLDPHQWRJLDSSRQHVHD%DWDYLDODIXQ]LRQHVYROWDGDLJLDSSR QHVLQRQVLOLPLWzHVFOXVLYDPHQWHDOO¶DSSRUWREHOOLFRQHOFRUVRGHOWHPSROD SUHVHQ]DJLDSSRQHVHJUDGXDOPHQWHVLGLYHUVLILFzQHLFRPSLWLHQHLPHVWLHULH DQFKH L PHUFDQWL IXURQR SDUWH VLJQLILFDWLYD GHOOD FRPXQLWj QLSSRQLFD $Q]L QHOFRUVRGHO;9,,VHFRORLOUXRORHFRQRPLFRGHOODFRPXQLWjJLDSSRQHVHGL YHQQHGLXQFHUWRULOLHYRVSHVVRLPHUFDQWLJLDSSRQHVLILQDQ]LDYDQROHDWWLYLWj FRPPHUFLDOLGHLFLQHVLGL%DWDYLDSRLFKpSUHVWDYDQRORURLFDSLWDOLQHFHVVDUL DOO¶DOOHVWLPHQWRHDOODUHDOL]]D]LRQHGHLWUDIILFLPDULWWLPRFRPPHUFLDOLDGXQ WDVVRG¶LQWHUHVVHUDJLRQHYROPHQWHPRGHUDWR§LQWHUHVVDQWHQRWDUHFKHVLUL SURSRQHYDD%DWDYLDORVWHVVRWLSRUDSSRUWRFKHVHFRODUPHQWHDYHYDFRQWUDG GLVWLQWROHUHOD]LRQLFRPPHUFLDOLVLQRJLDSSRQHVLRYYHURXQLQYHVWLPHQWRGL FDSLWDOLGHOO¶DUFLSHODJRHVSOLFLWRRQDVFRVWRDVRVWHJQRGHLWUDIILFLPHUFDQWLOL FLQHVLOHFLWLRLOOHFLWLDVHFRQGDGHLWHPSLHGHOOHFLUFRVWDQ]H 9HUVRLOGHFOLQR 1HOOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDFHOHEUzLOVXRFHQWHQDULRXQDGDWDLP SRUWDQWH FKH VL DFFRPSDJQz D JUDQGL IHVWHJJLDPHQWL 1HL IDWWL OD 92& HUD O¶LPSUHVDSLULFFDHLPSRUWDQWHGHL3DHVL%DVVLGDYDODYRURDPLJOLDLDGLGL SHQGHQWLSURYYHGHYDFRQVXFFHVVRDULIRUQLUHOHFDVVHGHOOR6WDWRWHQHYDDOWD ODEDQGLHUDGHOO¶2ODQGDDYHYDVHGLHEDVLLQWXWWDO¶$VLDHXQDIORWWDLQSHUIHW WRDVVHWWRHFRPPHUFLDOHHPLOLWDUH0DODVWUXWWXUDSRUWDQWHGHOOD&RPSD JQLDFRPLQFLDYDDPRVWUDUHVHJQLGLFHGLPHQWR8QSULPRPDOHVVHUHVLHVSOL FLWDYDQHOODTXDOLWjQRQFKpQHOODTXDQWLWjGHLVHUYLJLUHVLGDOODIORWWD$SDUWL UHGDOODILQHGHO6HLFHQWROHWLSRORJLHGHJOLHTXLSDJJLHUDQRGLYHQXWHGLLQIL PR OLYHOOR H GLYHQWDYD VHPSUH SL DUGXR WURYDUH XRPLQL YDOLGL SHU OH QDYL FLzFRPHVLFRPSUHQGHSURGXFHYDFRQVHJXHQ]HQHJDWLYHVLDGXUDQWHODQD 0XUDNDPLSS &DULRWLD *DDVWUD,G%R[HU 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL YLJD]LRQHVLDQHOOHEDVLGL GHVWLQD]LRQHSHUORVFRUUHWWRFRPSRUWDPHQWRGHL PDULQDL*UDQSDUWHGHJOLHTXLSDJJLLQROWUHHUDQRFRVWLWXLWLGDHOHPHQWLFKH SURYHQLYDQRGDDOWULSDHVLHXURSHLHQXPHURVHVLFRQWDYDQROHGHIH]LRQLXQD YROWDUDJJLXQWDO¶$VLD0DDQFKHULJXDUGRDOODTXDQWLWjVLUHJLVWUDYDXQDIOHV VLRQHVHQHOOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDGLVSRQHYDGLQDYLRSHUDQWLQHL PDULDVLDWLFLQHOQHDYHYDVROR (JLjDSSDULYDQRLSULPLFRQIURQWLSHUGHQWLFRQODULYDOH&RPSDJQLD,Q JOHVHODTXDOHVXOODURWWDGHOOH,QGLH2ULHQWDOLVHPEUDYDRUPDLSRVVHGHUHXQD PDUFLDLQSLULVSHWWRDOOD92&VRSUDWWXWWRSHUFKpDQFKHVHSDUWLWDLQULWDUGR RIRUVHSURSULRSHUTXHVWRDYHYDVDSXWRVIUXWWDUHDOPHJOLROHSRWHQ]LDOLWjLQ VLWHQHOFRXQWU\WUDGH(VHEEHQHO¶2ODQGDDYHVVHVRWWRVFULWWRXQ¶DOOHDQ]DFRQ O¶,QJKLOWHUUD FRQWUR OD )UDQFLD QHO GRSR OD *ORULRVD 5LYROX]LRQH FKH DYHYD SRUWDWR VXO WURQR LQJOHVH *XJOLHOPR ,,, G¶2UDQJHVWDWROGHU GHOOH3UR YLQFH 8QLWH H OD UHJLQD 0DULD ,, OD FRPSHWL]LRQHIUD OH GXH FRPSDJQLH HUD SXU VHPSUH DFFHVD H D YROWH YLROHQWD VRSUDWWXWWR DOO¶LQGRPDQL GHOOD FRDWWD HVSXOVLRQHGHJOLLQJOHVLGD%DQWHQQHO,;9,,6LJQRULVSHUDYDQRFKHOD IRQGD]LRQHGLXQD³1XRYD´&RPSDJQLD,QJOHVHLQFRPSHWL]LRQHFRQOD³9HF FKLD´ SRWHVVH LQGHEROLUH O¶HVSDQVLRQH LQJOHVH LQ $VLDPD QRQ IX FRVu QHJOL DQQLOHGXHFRPSDJQLHVLIXVHURLQVLHPHUDIIRU]DQGRFRVuOHORUR SRWHQ]LDOLWj/¶HVLWRLQFHUWRGHOOHGXHSULPHJXHUUHDQJORRODQGHVLQRQFRQ WULEXu FHUWR D UDIIRU]DUH OD SRVL]LRQH GHOOD 92& OD SULPD TXHOOD GHO IXFDXVDWDGDOULILXWRRODQGHVHGLHQWUDUHDIDUSDUWHGHO&RPPRQZHDOWK GL&URPZHOOFRQODFRQVHJXHQWHGHFLVLRQHGLHPDQDUHXQ$WWRGL1DYLJD]LR QHFKHREEOLJDYDDWUDVSRUWDUHOHPHUFLYHUVRLSRUWLLQJOHVLHVFOXVLYDPHQWHVX QDYL EDWWHQWL EDQGLHUD EULWDQQLFD R GHL SDHVL GDL TXDOL SURYHQLYDQR OH PHUFL HOLPLQDQGR FRVu GL IDWWR O¶LQWHUPHGLD]LRQH RODQGHVH OD VHFRQGD FRPEDWWXWD GDODOIXGHWHUPLQDWDGDULYDOLWjGLVWDPSRSUHWWDPHQWHFRORQLDOH 9D GHWWR DQFKH FKH LQ TXHO SHULRGR VWDYD PXWDQGR OD QDWXUD VWHVVD GHL FRPPHUFLWUDO¶(XURSDHOH ,QGLH2ULHQWDOLSHUFKpDOGRPLQLRDVVROXWRGHOOH VSH]LHVLHUDYHQXWDVRVWLWXHQGRQHOFRUVRGHO6HLFHQWRXQDSDQRSOLDGLJHQH UL GLYHUVL FKH UDSSUHVHQWDYDQR XQD VFHOWD PROWR SL ULFFD H DOODUJDWD LQ FXL &DWHULQRSS %R[HUS0RUVH 1HL QXPHURVL VFDOL LQWHUQD]LRQDOL GHOOH URWWH RULHQWDOL VLD QHOOH EDVL FRPXQL FKH QHL VLQJROL DYDPSRVWLODULYDOLWjWUDOD&RPSDJQLD,QJOHVHHOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDVLDFFUHVFHYDGLJLRU QRLQJLRUQRDYDQWDJJLRGHJOLLQJOHVL%R[HUSS0RUVH*DDVWUD ,G /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ O¶HVSRUWD]LRQHGHOWqGDOOD&LQDVLDYYLDYDDGLYHQWDUHXQDGHOOHYRFLSLLP SRUWDQWL QHL WUDIILFL LQWHUDVLDWLFL YLVWR LO FRVWDQWH DXPHQWR GHOOD ULFKLHVWD VXO PHUFDWRHXURSHR0DOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDVHEEHQHIRVVHVWDWDODSULPDD LQWURGXUUHLOWqLQ(XURSDQHOFRQWLQXzDGDVWHQHUVLGDOPDQGDUHLVXRL PHUFDQWLOL D &DQWRQ ILQR DO H VL DFFRQWHQWz GL DFTXLVWDUH LO SURGRWWR D %DWDYLDGDOOHJLXQFKHFLQHVLSURYHQLHQWLGDOFRQWLQHQWHRYYLDPHQWHSDJDQGR ORSLFDUR1HOFRUVRGHO6HLFHQWROD92&VLLPSHJQzVDOWXDULDPHQWHDGL VWULEXLUHGHOWqVXLPHUFDWLHXURSHLPDVHQ]DLQYHVWLUHSLGLWDQWRQHOODULFHU FDGLXQSURGRWWRLOFXLDSSURYYLJLRQDPHQWRDSSDULYDFRVuGLIILFLOH7XWWDYLD IXSURSULRWUDODILQHGHO;9,,HLSULPLGHFHQQLGHO;9,,,VHFRORFKHLOWqFR QREEHXQRVWUDRUGLQDULRVXFFHVVRGLYHQHQGRODEHYDQGDSLDPDWDLQ(XURSD SDUWLFRODUPHQWH LQ ,QJKLOWHUUD'L FRQVHJXHQ]D OD (,& IHFH GHO Wq XQR GHL VXRLSURGRWWLGLVFDPELRSLLPSRUWDQWLGLYHQHQGRQHDSDUWLUHGDOODVHFRQGD PHWjGHO6HWWHFHQWRLOSULQFLSDOHVHQRQO¶XQLFRHVSRUWDWRUH$QFKHOHHVSRU WD]LRQLHIIHWWXDWHGDOOHDOWUHFRPSDJQLHIUDO¶DOWURHUDQRGLUHWWHDOPHUFDWRLQ JOHVHRSHUPHJOLRGLUHHUDQRXWLOLDOULIRUQLPHQWRGHOJLJDQWHVFRVLVWHPDGL FRPPHUFLOHFLWLHLOOHFLWLGLFXLDSSURILWWDYDQRLYLFLQLGHOO¶,QJKLOWHUUD ,OFDIIpFROWLYDWRQHOOHSLDQWDJLRQLFKHOD92&LPSLDQWzVXOO¶LVRODGL*LD YDFRPHDOWHUQDWLYDDOOHVSH]LHWUDGL]LRQDOLQRQULXVFLYDDSHQHWUDUHVXLPHU FDWLDVLDWLFLWUDGL]LRQDOPHQWHLQWHUHVVDWLDGDOWULWLSLGLSURGRWWLVHEEHQHWUR YDVVHXQDEXRQDULVSRVWDLQ(XURSDTXHVWDEHYDQGDLQRJQLFDVRLQTXHOSH ULRGR QRQ SRWHYD ULYDOHJJLDUH FRQ OD EHQ SL VLJQLILFDWLYD GRPDQGD GL Wq &RQWHVWXDOPHQWHDOJUDQGHHQWXVLDVPRVXVFLWDWRGDOO¶LQIXVRLQ(XURSDLVHUYL ]LGDWqFRVuFRPHWXWWDO¶RJJHWWLVWLFDLQSRUFHOODQDHUDQRGLYHQXWLXQLPSRU WDQWLVVLPREHQHGLOXVVRLQYLDJJLRSHULO9HFFKLR&RQWLQHQWH(OD92&JLj GDO 6HLFHQWR DYHYD LQIDWWL WURYDWR XQD SURSULD GLPHQVLRQH FRPPHUFLDOH QHO O¶HVSRUWD]LRQHLQ(XURSDGLSRUFHOODQHFLQHVLHJLDSSRQHVLJUD]LHDQFKHHVR SUDWWXWWR DOO¶HVFOXVLYD EDVH LQ *LDSSRQH 3HU FRQWUR O¶DUJHQWR JLDSSRQHVH =KXDQJ,GSS =KXDQJS ,Q PHULWR DOOD PHGLD]LRQH FRPPHUFLDOH FLQHVH D%DWDYLDVL YHGDQR L IRQGDPHQWDOL ODYRUL GL /HRQDUG%OXVVp%OXVVp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uQHOODVWRULFDLP SUHVDGLURPSHUH LO PRQRSROLRRODQGHVHWUDSLDQWDQGRFRQVXFFHVVRDOEHULGL QRFHPRVFDWDHGLFKLRGLGLJDURIDQRQHOO¶RUWRERWDQLFRGHOO¶LVRODHGLIIRQGHQ GROLSRLLQDOWUHFRORQLHIUDQFHVL $OO¶LQL]LRGHO6HWWHFHQWRTXLQGLO¶LQWHURFRQWHVWRLQWHUQD]LRQDOHDSSDUL YDPXWDWRVLDQHJOLHTXLOLEULSROLWLFLVLDQHOODQDWXUDGHJOLVFDPEL1HOFRUVR GHOVHFRORPHQWUHO¶LQL]LDWLYDSULYDWDEULWDQQLFDVLHVSDQGHYDUDSLGDPHQWHLO FRPPHUFLRGLWHUUDGHOOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDUHJLVWUDYDXQUHJUHVVRHYLGHQWH SHUFKpLVXRLPH]]LVLULYHODURQRLQVXIILFLHQWLSHUVRVWHQHUHODFRQFRUUHQ]D 1HOOD92&DOOHQWzLOGLYLHWRGLFRPPHUFLRSULYDWRLPSRVWRDLVXRLFRO ODERUDWRULFRQODVSHUDQ]DGLULDQLPDUHOHFRUUHQWLGLWUDIILFRPDWDOHGHFLVLR QHJLXQVHWURSSRWDUGL'DWHPSRLQIDWWLLIXQ]LRQDULGHOOD&RPSDJQLDSDUWH FLSDYDQR DL FRPPHUFL GL WHUUD LQJOHVL VSHVVR D GDQQR GHJOL VWHVVL LQWHUHVVL GHOOD92&FRPHQHOFDVRGHOFRQWUDEEDQGRQHOOHDFTXHGL*LDYD /H GLVSRVL]LRQL GLVFLSOLQDUL HEEHUR XQ HIIHWWR LUULOHYDQWH DQFKH SHUFKp SHUVLQRLSLDOWLGLJQLWDULFRPHLOGLUHWWRUHJHQHUDOHHVXFFHVVLYRJRYHUQDWRUH JHQHUDOH -DFRE 0RVVHO QHJOL DQQL µ SDUWHFLSDYDQR DWWLYDPHQWH DJOL DIIDUL SULYDWL GHO JRYHUQDWRUH LQJOHVH GL %RPED\ :LOOLDP:DNH/D FRUUX]LRQH DOO¶LQWHUQRGHOOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDRSHUDYDDWXWWRYDQWDJJLRGHJOLLQJOHVLLQ TXDQWR JOL RODQGHVL PLQDFFLDWL GDL SURYYHGLPHQWL GLVFLSOLQDUL SRWHYDQR VHP SUHULIXJLDUVLVRWWRODORURDODSURWHWWULFH9HUVRODILQHGHO6HWWHFHQWRQDFTXH URDGGLULWWXUDGHOOHDJHQF\KRXVHVUHJRODULVRFLHWjGLILQDQ]LDPHQWRGHOFRXQ 6XOFRVLGGHWWRVDNRNXVLYHGD&DULRWLD *ODPDQQ,VUDHO%R[HU*DDVWUD,G 0DYHULFNSS 6WDUNH\YDQ (\FNYDQ+HVOLQJDGH 0RRU:\DWWSS*ODPDQQ ,VUDHO)XUEHU *DDVWUD,G )XUEHUS6WDSHOSS /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ WU\ WUDGH DWWLUDWH VRSUDWWXWWR GDOOH SRWHQ]LDOLWj GHO PHUFDWR FLQHVH ( OD 92&FKHWUDODILQHGHO6HLFHQWRHLSULPLGHO6HWWHFHQWRDYHYDYLVVXWRXQD GHOLFDWDIDVHGLULDVVHWWRVLDQHOODVWUXWWXUDFKHQHOOHIXQ]LRQLQRQULXVFLYDD WHQHUHLOSDVVRFRQOHQRWHYROLHUDSLGHWUDVIRUPD]LRQLLQDWWRHUDO¶LQL]LRGL XQLQHVRUDELOHGHFOLQR$QFKHDFDXVDGHOOHRSSRVL]LRQLHGHOOHGLVFRUGLHLQ VRUWHWUDL;9,,6LJQRULHO¶$OWR&RQVLJOLRGL%DWDYLDLQPHULWRDOODSROLWLFDGD DGRWWDUHLQ$VLDIXVRORQHOFKHOD92&GHFLVHILQDOPHQWHGLHQWUDUHQHO PHUFDWRGL&DQWRQFRQHFFHVVLYRULWDUGRULVSHWWRDOODULYDOHEULWDQQLFD ,UDSSRUWLWUD OD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDHOD&LQDPHULWDQRXQEUHYHFHQQR XQLQWHUFRUVRGLFLUFDGXHVHFROLFRPSOHVVRIDWLFRVRHSHUFHUWLYHUVLHFFH]LR QDOHPDVLFXUDPHQWHQRQFRVuSURILFXRTXDQWROD92&DYHVVHVSHUDWR(SHU JLXQWDFRQWUDWWLDPELJXLHXIILFLRVLFKHVSHVVRDYHYDQRFRVWUHWWROD&RPSD JQLD5LXQLWDDSLHJDUVLDFRPSURPHVVLSRFRJUDGHYROL/¶DFFHVRFRQWUDVWRFRQ L=KHQJHLOUDSSRUWRIUXVWUDQWHFRQJOLXOWLPL0LQJHSRLFRQL4LQJDYHYDQR DFFRPSDJQDWROHYLFHQGHGHOOD92&OXQJRLO6HLFHQWR1HO6HWWHFHQWRXQD SUHVHQ]DD&DQWRQLQFRQGLYLVLRQHFRQDOWUH&RPSDJQLHHXURSHHDYHYDFRQ WUDGGLVWLQWROHDWWLYLWjFRPPHUFLDOLGHOOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDLQWHUULWRULRFLQH VHXQFRQWHVWRFKHSXUYDQWDJJLRVRHFRQRPLFDPHQWHHUDEHQORQWDQRGDLVR JQLGLJORULDHGLULFFKH]]DFKHLO³&HOHVWH,PSHUR´DYHYDLVSLUDWR /DILQHGHOO¶DYYHQWXUD 6XOOHUDJLRQLFKHSRUWDURQRDOORVFLRJOLPHQWRGHOOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDLO GLEDWWLWRVWRULRJUDILFRqVWDWRPROWRYLYDFHDWXWW¶RJJLOHSRVL]LRQLGHLPDJ JLRULVWRULFLGHOOD92&QRQFRQFRUGDQRSLHQDPHQWHVXLIDWWRULFKHGHWHUPLQD URQR OD GRORURVD VFHOWD GL QRQ ULQQRYDUH ROWUH OD &DUWD GHOOD &RPSDJQLD /¶XOWLPR JLRUQR GL YDOLGLWj GHOOR VWDWXWR XIILFLDOH GDWDYD GLFHPEUH GDOJHQQDLROD92&QRQHVLVWHYDSLÊLQGXEELRWXWWDYLDFKHQX PHURVL IXURQR JOL HOHPHQWL FKH FRQFRUVHUR DOO¶LQHVRUDELOH GHFOLQR H SRL DO )XUEHUSS *ODPDQQ,VUDHO*DDVWUD,G%R[HU6LYHGDLQILQH&DULRWL DSS 6XOFRPSOHVVRLQWHUFRUVRVWRULFRWUDOD92&HL=KHQJ&DULRWL&DWHULQD ,QPHULWRDOODVHGH92&GL&DQWRQ&DULRWLDSS *DDVWUDSS *DDVWUDS 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL FUROORGLTXHOODFKHHUDVWDWDODSLVLJQLILFDWLYDLPSUHVDQD]LRQDOHGHL3DHVL %DVVLQRQFKpXQDSRWHQ]DPHUFDQWLOHFKHDYHYDDOXQJRSULPHJJLDWRQHLPDUL GHOO¶$VLD1HO6HWWHFHQWRDYHYDSUHVRIRUPDXQQXRYRDVVHWWRLQWHUQD]LRQDOH QHO TXDOH JOL HTXLOLEUL HFRQRPLFL SROLWLFL H PLOLWDUL GLIIHULYDQR VLJQLILFDWLYD PHQWHULVSHWWRDOVHFRORSUHFHGHQWHVLDQHJOLDPELWLWHUULWRULDOLSURSULDPHQWH DVLDWLFLVLDSHUOHFRPSHWLWLYHSUHVHQ]HGLDOWUHFRPSDJQLHHXURSHHSULPDIUD WXWWHODYLQFHQWH(,&(VLFXUDPHQWHLOFRQIURQWRLQFHVVDQWHHSHUGHQWHFRQ ODULYDOHLQJOHVHDYHYDFRQWULEXLWRQRQSRFRDOGHFOLQRGHOOD&RPSDJQLD5LX QLWD FRVWUHWWD JUDGXDOPHQWH D FHGHUH PROWH GHOOH VXH SRVWD]LRQL DOOD VRFLHWj FRQFRUUHQWHDQFKHDFDXVDGHOOHJXHUUHDQJORRODQGHVLFKHVLVXVVHJXLYDQRD VLQJKLR]]RILQRDTXHOODIDWDOHGHO /D 92& YHQQH EDWWXWD GDOOD &RPSDJQLD ,QJOHVH VX GXH GLVWLQWL IURQWL FKH ILQLURQR FRQ LO VRPPDUVL QHOOD FRPSHWL]LRQH FRPPHUFLDOH VXOOH URWWH D VLDWLFKHGRYHOD92&SHUGHYDFRQWLQXDPHQWHWHUUHQRULVSHWWRDOODPHJOLRRU JDQL]]DWDSLDJLOHHSLIRUWH(,&HVXOIURQWHPLOLWDUHSHULFRQIOLWWL WUDL 3DHVL%DVVLHO¶,QJKLOWHUUDFKHWHUPLQDURQRFRQODVFRQILWWDRODQGHVHHODFHV VLRQHDOO¶,QJKLOWHUUDGHOOHEDVLGHOOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDLQ$VLD1RQY¶qGXE ELRFKHLGDQQLLQIHUWLDOOD92&LQWDOPRGRIXURQRHQRUPLDFRPLQFLDUHGDOOD WRWDOHHVFOXVLRQHRODQGHVHGDOPHUFDWRLQGLDQR/HFRQWLQXHVFRQILWWHPLOLWDUL GHQRWDYDQRLQROWUHXQDSUHRFFXSDQWHGHILFLHQ]DQHOODVWUXWWXUDSRUWDQWHGHOOD &RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDRYYHUROHIORWWH$QFKHQHLFRPSLWLGLUDFFRUGRFRPPHU FLDOH OH QDYL RODQGHVL PDQLIHVWDYDQR HVSOLFLWDPHQWH VLJQLILFDWLYH FDUHQ]H QHOO¶DXPHQWDWDPRUWDOLWjDERUGRLQFRQWLQXLHLQVSLHJDELOLQDXIUDJLQHOODUL GRWWDFDSDFLWjEHOOLFD,QHIIHWWLDOO¶LQL]LRGHO;9,,,VHFRORL3DHVL%DVVLDYH YDQRRUPDLSHUVRLOSULPDWRQHOODFDQWLHULVWLFDSDVVDWRDJOLLQJOHVLHDLIUDQFH VLHOHORURQDYLQRQHUDQRSLDOO¶DOWH]]DGHLJUDYRVLFRPSLWLFKHFRPSRUWDYD 1HJOLDQQLOD&RPSDJQLD,QJOHVHLQYLDYDLQ&LQDQDYL$QFKHOD&RPSDJQLD )UDQFHVHUDJJLXQJHYDOD&LQDQHO/D&RPSDJQLD6YHGHVHHOD&RPSDJQLD'DQHVHSXUH DUULYDYDQR DL OLWRUDOL GHOO¶LPSHURPDQFHVH FRQ LO VRSUDJJLXQJHUH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR /D &RPSD JQLDGL2VWHQGDIDFHYDDOWUHWWDQWRODVXDFRPSDUVDD&DQWRQQHOSHUHVVHUHVFLROWDGRSR SRFKL DQQL =KXDQJ SS 6WDUNH\YDQ (\FNGH 0RRU YDQ *RRU %ULOODYDSHUODVXDDVVHQ]DLQTXHJOLDQQLOD92&OD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDPDQGDYDOHVXHUD UH QDYL D &DQWRQ ILQR DO PD LO IDOOLPHQWR GHOO¶DPEDVFHULD GL 9LQFHQW 3DDWV GHJOL DQQL LQYLDWDDOO¶LPSHUDWRUH.DQJ[LVFRUDJJLDYDQRQSRFRO¶$OWR&RQVLJOLRGL%DWDYLDHOD 92& DYUHEEH DWWHVR TXDOFKH GHFHQQLR SULPD GL ULDIIDFFLDUVL DL OLWRUDOL GHOOD &LQD :LOOV SS*DDVWUD,G%R[HU6LYHGDLQILQH&DULRWLDSS %R[HUSS /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ OD GLIHVD GL XQ LPSHUR PRQGLDOH ,Q SDUWLFRODUH DSSDULYDQR HFFHVVLYDPHQWH FRVWRVHHLQJHQHUDOHPHQRUREXVWHULVSHWWRDTXHOOHGHOOHFRPSDJQLHFRQFRU UHQWLFKHSRWHYDQRFRQWDUHVHQ]DGXEELRVXSLDPSLHULVRUVHXPDQHILQDQ ]LDUHHGLPDWHULHSULPH 8QJHQHUDOHODVVLVPRWUDLVHUYDQWVVRSUDWWXWWRWUDJOLXIILFLDOLVXSHULRUL YHQLYDUHJLVWUDWRSUHVVRQXPHURVHVHGLLQ$VLDGRYHO¶DUULFFKLPHQWRSHUVRQD OHHUDVSHVVRHYROHQWLHULDQWHSRVWRDJOLLQWHUHVVLGHOOD&RPSDJQLDDWWUDYHUVR LOFRQWUDEEDQGRO¶HVWRUVLRQHHO¶DEXVRGLSRWHUH/DFRUUX]LRQHGLODJDYDWUDOH DOWHVIHUHGHOOD92&HFLzFRVWLWXuVHQ]DGXEELRXQDVHULDDJJUDYDQWHSHUOD YLWD HFRQRPLFD GHOOD VRFLHWj 6HFRQGR L VXRL GHWUDWWRUL VRWWR LO JRYHUQDWRUH JHQHUDOH6SHHOPDQLQFDULFDGDODOOHYHQGLWHGLWHVVXWLFDODURQR GHOXRPLQLOLEHULIXURQRYHQGXWLFRPHVFKLDYLHYHQQHURSDJDWHWUXSSH LQHVLVWHQWL3HUIDUOXFHVXWDOLHSLVRGLL;9,,6LJQRULQRPLQDURQRGHLFRP PLVVDULDGDFWDLTXDOLWXWWDYLDWURYDQGRVLGLIURQWHDSRWHQWLLQWHUHVVLFRVWL WXLWLQRQULXVFLURQRDVDQDUHODVLWXD]LRQH1HOVLVFRSUuFKHLOFDSRGHO O¶DJHQ]LDFRPPHUFLDOHGHO%HQJDODJHVWLYDFRQODFRSHUWXUDGHOODPRJOLHXQ LPSRQHQWHWUDIILFRGLDUWLFROLGLJUDQGHYDORUHHVFDUVRYROXPHLQSDUWLFRODUH GLRSSLRWXWWLSURFXUDWLWUDPLWHLFDQDOLGHOOD&RPSDJQLDHWUDVSRUWDWLVXOOHVXH QDYL,QHIIHWWLXQ¶HVLVWHQ]DIDWWDGLR]LRGLIDVWLHGLEDQFKHWWLHGXQTXHGL VSHQGLRVD FDUDWWHUL]]DYD LO TXRWLGLDQR GL PROWL DOWL IXQ]LRQDUL RODQGHVL LQ $VLD'¶DOWURFDQWRODQRPLQDDLSRVWLGLULOLHYRHGLFRPDQGRQHOODJHUDUFKLD GHOOD&RPSDJQLDDYYHQLYD±FRPHTXDVLVHPSUHHUDVWDWR±VXOODEDVHGLOH JDPLGLVDQJXHHGLDPLFL]LDQHLFLUFROLHQHOOHVIHUHGHOO¶DULVWRFUD]LDRODQGH VHSLXWWRVWRFKHVXTXHOODGHOOHUHDOLFDSDFLWjGHLFDQGLGDWL%DWDYLDGLYHQQH IDPRVDSHUORVWLOHGLYLWDVTXLVLWDPHQWHµFRORQLDOH¶FKHYLFRQGXFHYDQRLGH OHJDWLGHOOD&RPSDJQLDHOHORURIDPLJOLHFKHDELWDYDQRLQFDVHVRQWXRVHFRQ VWXROLGLVHUYLWRULLQGLJHQLXQRVSDFFDWRGLYLWDVRFLDOHFRVWRVRHXQSR¶JURV VRODQRRVWHQWDWRQHLPRGLYROJDULHQHOO¶RSXOHQ]DWLSLFRGLXQLQVHGLDPHQWR FKHDYHYDRUPDLPXWDWROHSURSULHFDUDWWHULVWLFKHLQWULQVHFKHGDVHGHFRPPHU FLDOHDFDSLWDOHFRORQLDOH (SURSULRLQTXHVWRDVSHWWRVLSXzLQGLYLGXDUHXQDOWURHOHPHQWRVLJQLIL FDWLYRGHOSURFHVVRGLGHFDGHQ]DGHOOD92&ODWUDVIRUPD]LRQHGHOOD&RPSD *DDVWUDSS%R[HUSS&DWHULQRSS)XUEHU 6LQQDSSDK0F3KHUVRQ 6WDSHOSS,VUDHOSS %R[HUSS&DWHULQRSS*DDVWUDSS %R[HUSS 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL JQLDGDVRFLHWjFRPPHUFLDOHDSRWHUHFRORQLDOHLQSDUWLFRODUPRGRD%DWDYLD *OLHYHQWLFKHVLVXVVHJXLURQRSHUWXWWRO¶DUFRGHO6HWWHFHQWRLQTXHOODFKHXQ WHPSRHUDVWDWDODµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ILQRDWUDVIRUPDUODLQXQOXRJRGLPRUWH DFDXVDGHOODPDODULDQHOODVHFRQGDPHWjGHOVHFRORVRQRLQWDOVHQVRSLFKH HORTXHQWL*LjQHOOD92&GRYHWWHLQWHUYHQLUHPLOLWDUPHQWHSHUVHGDUH XQDULYROWDGHLJLDYDQHVL0DQHOLOPDVVDFURGHLFLQHVLFLUFDFL YLOLGLFXLVLPDFFKLzFRQWLQXDQGRDIRPHQWDUHDWWLGLJXHUULJOLDILQRDO UDSSUHVHQWzIRUVHXQHPEOHPDWLFRSXQWRGLVYROWDSHUO¶LQVHGLDPHQWRRODQGHVH D%DWDYLDFKHQHVHJQzLQHVRUDELOPHQWHOHVRUWL/¶DXPHQWRGHOOHVSHVHPL OLWDUL SHU PDQWHQHUH LO FRQWUROOR VX YDVWH ]RQH GHOO¶LVROD LQIDWWL UHVH VHPSUH SLRQHURVRLOELODQFLRGHOODILOLDOHRULHQWDOHGHOOD&RPSDJQLDFKHQRQHUDSL LQJUDGRGLIDUIURQWHDWXWWLJOLLPSHJQLFRQOHULVRUVHDGLVSRVL]LRQH 8QDVSDFFDWXUDSLRPHQRHYLGHQWHWUDO¶$OWR&RQVLJOLRGL%DWDYLDHL ;9,,6LJQRULFRVWLWXuXQ¶XOWHULRUHDJJUDYDQWHQHJOLDQQL¶O¶$OWR&RQVLJOLR GL%DWDYLDDXWRUL]]zODFUHD]LRQHGLXQD]HFFDDXWRQRPDHFRPLQFLzDFRQLDUH PRQHWHLQORFRDOORVFRSRGLGLVSRUUHGLPH]]LGLSDJDPHQWRDGHJXDWLDLPHU FDWL GL ULIHULPHQWR *OL 6WDWL *HQHUDOL LQWHUYHQQHUR VXELWR H FRVu L ;9,, 6L JQRUL SHU EORFFDUH TXHVWD SHULFRORVD LQL]LDWLYD PD O¶HSLVRGLR q VLQWRPDWLFR GHOFOLPDGLHFFHVVLYDDXWRQRPLDHLQGLSHQGHQ]DFUHDWRVLQHOODEDVHGL%DWD YLD/D SROLWLFD GHOOD 92& YROWD DO FRQWHQLPHQWR GHL SUH]]L LQ ,QGRQHVLD DOO¶HOLPLQD]LRQH GHOOD FRQFRUUHQ]D H DOOD OLPLWD]LRQH GHOOD SURGX]LRQH SRUWz DOFUROORGHLPHUFDWLORFDOLHDOGLODJDUHGHOODSRYHUWjHGHOODSLUDWHULD 0D LO GHFOLQR GL %DWDYLD HUD VROR OD SXQWD GHOO¶LFHEHUJ GL XQD FULVL SL SURIRQGD1HOODVHFRQGDPHWjGHO6HWWHFHQWRO¶LPSHURPDULWWLPRFRPPHUFLD OHGHOOD&RPSDJQLD5LXQLWDVHPEUDYDRUPDLVXOSXQWRGLVJUHWRODUVLOD92& SHUGHYDLQIOXHQ]DLQ0DOHVLDVXELYDDWWDFFKLQHOOR6WUHWWRGL0DODFFDHUDD GLUSRFRSUHFDULDQHO%RUQHRHSHUVLQRQHOOH0ROXFFKHVWHQWDYDDPDQWHQHUVL $&H\ORQQHOVFRSSLzXQFRQIOLWWRDUPDWRGHVWLQDWRDGXUDUHXQOXVWUR FKHVLFRQFOXVHFRQODYLWWRULDILQDOHRODQGHVHPDSDJDWDDFDURSUH]]RSRL FKpJOLRSSRVLWRULULXVFLURQRDGRPLQDUHOR6UL/DQNDQHJOLDQQL( SURSULR QHOOR VWHVVR SHULRGR OD GLVDVWURVD JXHUUDFRQ O¶,QJKLOWHUUD GHO 4XDQGR QHO JOL 2ODQGHVL SUHVHQWDURQR OH VFXVH XIILFLDOL DOO¶LPSHUDWRUH 4LDQORQJ SHU LO PDVVDFURGHOO¶DQQRSUHFHGHQWHHEEHURLQULVSRVWDXQIUHGGR GLVFRQRVFLPHQWRGHLFLQHVLFKH DYHYDQRDEEDQGRQDWRODORURSDWULDSHUPHULILQLGLSURILWWRHFKHTXLQGLO¶LPSHURQRQFRQVL GHUDYDSLVXRLVXGGLWL'HQJ*DQJS %OXVVpSS%OXVVpSS %R[HUS /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ FRVWzDOOD92&WXWWHOHDJHQ]LHFRPPHUFLDOLVLWXDWHLQ,QGLD,O&DSRGL %XRQD6SHUDQ]DH&H\ORQIXURQRVDOYDWLVRORJUD]LHDOO¶LQWHUYHQWRGHOOHIORWWH IUDQFHVL$QFKH6XPDWUDFDGGHLQPDQRDJOLLQJOHVLVHQ]DFKHODORFDOHVHGH RODQGHVH ULXVFLVVH DG DSSURQWDUH XQ PLQLPR GL GLIHVD /D URFFDIRUWH GHOOD &RPSDJQLDO¶,QGRQHVLDIXULSHWXWDPHQWHYLRODWDULVFKLDQGRGLDQGDUHSHUGX WDSHUVHPSUH/¶LQWHUDVWUXWWXUDGHOOD92&QHOOHVXHVHGLFRVuFRPHQHOOHVXH IORWWHHDQFRUSLQHLVXRLXRPLQLDYHYDVPDUULWRRJQLIRU]DHFRHVLRQHODIL QH HUD DQQXQFLDWD 3HU FRQVHUYDUH XQ¶LPPDJLQH GL SURVSHULWj H VXFFHVVR OD &RPSDJQLDFRQWLQXzDSDJDUHLGLYLGHQGLDJOLD]LRQLVWLPDHUDXQSXURHVSH GLHQWHSHUFKpSHUIDUHFLzGRYHWWHFKLHGHUHGHQDURLQSUHVWLWR1HODYHYD DFFXPXODWRXQGHELWRGLPLOLRQLGLILRULQL 1HO FRQWHVWR SL SURSULDPHQWH HVWUHPRRULHQWDOH OD VLWXD]LRQH GHOOD 92&QRQHUDFHUWRPLJOLRUHVRWWRORVWUHWWRFRQWUROORGHOOHDXWRULWjGHOEDNXIX 7RNXJDZDHUHOHJDWLQHOODPLQXVFRODLVROHWWDDUWLILFLDOHGL'HVKLPDJOLRODQ GHVLODQJXLYDQRQHOO¶LQHGLD,QDOFXQLSHULRGLQHOFRUVRGHO6HWWHFHQWRO¶LQYLR DQQXDOHGHOODQDYHGLUDFFRUGRFRPPHUFLDOHGD%DWDYLDYHQQHULWDUGDWRDYRO WHSHUSLDQQLGLVHJXLWRFRQJUDYHSUHRFFXSD]LRQHGHLGHOHJDWLRODQGHVLFKH QRQVDSHYDQRFRPHJLXVWLILFDUHXQDWDOHPDQFDQ]DFRQOHDXWRULWjJLDSSRQHVL /D EDVH JLDSSRQHVH VWHQWDYD HFRQRPLFDPHQWH H L VXRL UDSSUHVHQWDQWL HUDQR GHO WXWWR LQ EDOLD GHOOH ORFDOL DXWRULWj LQ SL GL XQ¶RFFDVLRQH OD VHGH GHOOD &RPSDJQLDULVFKLzGLHVVHUHFKLXVD1RQRVWDQWHODFULVLSHUzO¶LQVHGLDPHQWR RODQGHVHGL'HVKLPDDYUHEEHDYXWRYLWDSL OXQJDGHOOD92&VWHVVDDQFRUD SHUWXWWDODSULPDPHWjGHOO¶2WWRFHQWRHUDXWLOHVLDDO*LDSSRQHFKHDOO¶2ODQ GD JRGHUH GL XQD ILQHVWUD DSHUWD VXL UHFLSURFL PRQGL SRLFKp GL Ou D EUHYH LO FRQIOLWWRDYUHEEHULGHILQLWRDQFRUDXQDYROWDJOLHTXLOLEULLQWHUQD]LRQDOLVLDLQ &LQDFKHLQ*LDSSRQHFRQO¶DSHUWXUDIRU]DWDGHLSRUWLDOOHQDYLRFFLGHQWDOL/D &LQDSLGLRJQLDOWUROXRJRLQ$VLDDYHYDLPSRVWRDLGHOHJDWLGHOOD&RPSD JQLDLOGXURULVYHJOLRGDRJQLLOOXVLRQHGLSRWHUFRQWLQXDUHDGRPLQDUHLWUDIILFL QHOOH,QGLH2ULHQWDOL(IRUVHQRQqXQFDVRFKHODFKLXVXUDGHOODEDVHRODQGH VHGL&DQWRQQHOSUHFHGHVVHGLSRFKLDQQLORVFLRJOLPHQWRGHOOD&RPSD JQLDVWHVVD /¶DOED GHO JHQQDLR SRQHYD ILQH DOO¶DYYLQFHQWH DYYHQWXUD GHOOD &RPSDJQLD5LXQLWD %R[HUSS*DDVWUDSS 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL %,%/,2*5$),$ $UDVDUDWQDP6LQQDSSDK0DULWLPH,QGLDLQWKH6HYHQWHHQWK&HQWXU\'HOKL2[IRUG8QL YHUVLW\3UHVV%RPED\±&DOFXWWD±0DGUDV ²³0HUFKDQWVDQG&RPPHUFHLQ&RURPDQGHO7UHQGVDQG7HQGHQFLHVLQWKH(LJKWHHQWK &HQWXU\´ LQ / %OXVVp ) *DDVWUD D F 2Q WKH (LJKWHHQWK &HQWXU\ DV D &DWHJRU\ RI $VLDQ+LVWRU\9DQ/HXULQ5HWURVSHFW$OGHUVKRW±%URRNILHOG86$±6LQJDSRUH±6\G QH\$VKJDWHSS ² 0DULWLPH ,QGLD LQ WKH 6HYHQWHHQWK &HQWXU\ LQ 0DULWLPH ,QGLD 1HZ 'HOKL 2[IRUG 8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV $\PDUG0DF'XWFK&DSLWDOLVP:RUG&DSLWDOLVP&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHU VLW\3UHVV %DUHQGVH 5- 7KH $UDELDQ 6HD 7KH ,QGLDQ 2FHDQ :RUOG RI WKH 6HYHQWHHQWK &HQWXU\ $UPRQN1<±/RQGRQ0(6KDUSH %KDZDQ5³'XWFK,QWHUDFWLRQZLWK6LDPHVH/DZDQGWKH&LW\5XOHVRI$\XWWKD\DLQWKH 6HYHQWHHQWK DQG (LJKWHHQWK &HQWXULHV´ LQ + 0DVDVKL D F $VLDQ 3RUW &LWLHV /RFDO DQG )RUHLJQ &XOWXUDO ,QWHUDFWLRQV 6LQJDSRUH 1XVV 3UHVV -DSDQ .\ǀWR 8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSS %ODLU (+ 5REHUWVRQ -$ 7KH 3KLOLSSLQH ,VODQGV YROO &OHYH ODQG$+&ODUN&R %OXVVp / 6WUDQJH &RPSDQ\ &KLQHVH 6HWWOHUV 0HVWL]R :RPHQ DQG WKH 'XWFK LQ 92& %DWDYLD'RUGUHFKW+ROODQG3URYLGHQFH86$)RULV3XEOLFDWLRQV ²7ULEXXWDDQ&KLQD$PVWHUGDP2WWR&UDPZLQFNHO8LWJHYHU ²³2QWKH:DWHUIURQW/LIHDQG/DERXUDURXQGWKH%DWDYLDQ5RDGVWHDG´LQ+0DVDVKL DF$VLDQ3RUW&LWLHV/RFDODQG)RUHLJQ&XOWXUDO,QWHUDFWLRQV7ǀN\ǀ6LQ JDSRUH1XV3UHVV-DSDQ.\ǀWR8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSS %OXVVp / GH 0RRU - 1HGHUODQGHUV RYHU]HH *HWKRRUQ0HSSHO 8LWJHYHULM 7 :HYHU %9)UDQHNHU %R[HU&K56RXWK&KLQDLQWKHWK&HQWXU\1HQGHOQ±/HLFKWHQVWHLQ+DNOX\W6RFLH W\.UDXV5HSULQW/LPLWHG ²-DQ&RPSDJQLHLQ:DUDQG3HDFH+RQJ.RQJ±6LQJDSRUH±.XDOD/XP SXU+LQHPDQQ$VLD ²'XWFK0HUFKDQWVDQG0DULQHUVLQ$VLD/RQGRQ9DULRUXP5HSULQWV&RO OHFWHG6WXGLHV ²D 3RUWXJXHVH &RQTXHVW DQG &RPPHUFH LQ 6RXWKHUQ $VLD 1HZFDVWOHRQ 7\QH*RZHU ²E7KH'XWFK6HDERUQH(PSLUH/RQGRQ3HQJXLQ%RRNV &DULRWL3=KHQJ&KHQJJRQJ1DSROL,VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOH6HULHV0LQRU ²>@³7KH=KHQJ¶V0DULWLPH3RZHULQWKH,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQWH[WRIWKHWK&HQWXU\ )DU(DVWHUQ6HDV7KH5LVHRIDµ&HQWUDOL]HG3LUDWLFDO2UJDQL]DWLRQ¶DQG,WV*UDGXDO'H YHORSPHQW LQWR DQ ,QIRUPDO µ6WDWH¶´ LQ 3 6DQWDQJHOR D F 0LQJ 4LQJ <DQMLX 1DSROL 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL 6WXGL $VLDWLFL ,VWLWXWR 8QLYHUVLWDULR 2ULHQWDOH ± 5RPD ,VWLWXWR ,WDOLDQR SHUO¶$IULFDHO¶2ULHQWHSS ²³7KH,QWHUQDWLRQDO6HWWLQJRI)DU(DVWHUQ6HDVGXULQJWKH)LUVW+DOIRIWKHWK&HQWX U\$1HZ%DODQFHRI3RZHU´LQ-0'RV6DQWRV$OYHVDF3RUWXJDOHD&KLQD/LV ERQDSS ² ³0DULWLPH 7UDGH WKH µ6DNRNX 3ROLF\¶ DQG WKH &KLQHVH LQ 1DJDVDNL GXULQJ WKH (DUO\ 7RNXJDZD3HULRG´LQ$VLDQ&XOWXUHSS /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ ²³7KH3RUWXJXHVH6HWWOHPHQWDW0DFDX3RUWXJXHVHSROLF\RIH[SDQVLRQLQWKH)DU(DVW LQWKHOLJKWRI&KLQHVHDQG-DSDQHVHKLVWRULFDOLQWHUFRXUVHDQGPDULWLPHDFWLYLWLHV´LQ5H YLVWDGH&XOWXUD5HYLHZRI&XOWXUH,QWHUQDWLRQDO(GLWLRQSS ² ³7KH 'XWFK $WWHPSW WR &RQTXHU 0DFDR LQ WKH ,QWHUQDWLRQDO &RQWH[W RI (DUO\ 6HYHQWHHQWK &HQWXU\ (DVW $VLD LQ5HYLVWD GH &XOWXUD 5HYLHZ RI &XOWXUH ,QWHUQD WLRQDO(GLWLRQSS ²D&LQDH*LDSSRQHVXLPDULQHLVHFROL;9,H;9,,1DSROL(GL]LRQL6FLHQWLILFKH,WDOLD QH ²E³+DLZDLKXDUHQODGLDVSRUDFLQHVHGDOO¶DQWLFKLWjDLSULPL4LQJ´LQ36DQWDQJHOR 9 9DULDQR D F 'DO =KHMLDQJ DOOD &DPSDQLD $OFXQL DVSHWWL GHOOD PLJUD]LRQH FLQHVH 1DSROL(GL]LRQL1XRYD&XOWXUDSS ²F³+LUDGRGXULQJWKH)LUVW+DOIRIWKHWK&HQWXU\IURPD&RPPHUFLDO2XWSRVWIRU6L QR-DSDQHVH0DULWLPH$FWLYLWLHVWRDQ,QWHUQDWLRQDO&URVVURDGVRI)DU(DVWHUQ5RXWHV´LQ &K/LQJ<HRQJ'*XLGDDF$3DVVLRQIRU&KLQD(VVD\VLQ+RQRXURI3DROR6DQ WDQJHORIRU+LVWK%LUWKGD\/HLGHQ±%RVWRQ%ULOOSS ²³/DWUDQVL]LRQHGLQDVWLFD0LQJ4LQJQHOFRQWHVWRGHOO¶$VLD2ULHQWDOH´LQ$&DWHULQR D F 5LIOHVVL G¶2ULHQWH /¶LPPDJLQH GHOOD &LQD QHOOD &DUWRJUDILD (XURSHD *HQRYD ,O 3RUWRODQRSS ²³3RUWXJXHVH 6WUDWHJLHV RI ([SDQVLRQ 0DFDRDQG +LUDGR &RPSDUHG´ LQ ( *URHQHQ GLMN & 9LDOOp / %OXVVp D F &DQWRQ DQG 1DJDVDNL &RPSDUHG 'XWFK &KLQHVH-DSDQHVH5HODWLRQV/HLGHQ,QVWLWXWHIRUWKH+LVWRU\RI(XURSHDQ([SDQVLRQSS ²D³&DQWRQXQRVJXDUGRDOOD&LQDPDULWWLPDQHOQXRYRDVVHWWRLQWHUQD]LRQDOHGHO6HWWH FHQWR´LQ)0D]]HL3&DULRWLDF2ULHQWH2FFLGHQWHHGLQWRUQL«6FULWWLLQRQRUHGL $GROIR7DPEXUHOORYROO1DSROL,O7RUFROLHUHYROSS ²E ³)RFXVLQJ RQ WKH 2YHUVHDV &KLQHVH LQ 6HYHQWHHQWK &HQWXU\ 1DJDVDNL 7KH 5ROH RI WKH7ǀWVnjMLLQWKH/LJKWRIWKH(DUO\7RNXJDZD)RUHLJQ3ROLF\´LQ1<ǀNRDF/DUJH DQG%URDG7KH'XWFK,PSDFWRQ(DUO\0RGHUQ$VLD(VVD\VLQ+RQRXURI/HRQDUG%OXV Vp7ǀN\ǀ7ǀ\ǀ%XQNǀSS ²&DWHULQD//DYLDGHOOD3RUFHOODQD/D92&HOD&LQD*HQRYD,O3RUWRODQR&HQ WUR6WXGL0DUWLQR0DUWLQL&ROODQD2UVD0LQRUH &DWHULQR$³/DYLDRODQGHVHSHUOH,QGLH2ULHQWDOL´LQ%ROOHWWLQRGHL0XVHL&LYLFL*HQR YHVL;9,,SS ²/¶XQLYHUVRLQXQDPDQR6WRULDGHLJORELQHOPRQGRRFFLGHQWDOH*HQRYD,O3RUWRODQR &HQWUR6WXGL0DUWLQR0DUWLQL&ROODQD2UVD0LQRUH &KDXGKXUL.1$VLDEHIRUH(XURSH(FRQRP\DQG&LYLOLVDWLRQRIWKH,QGLDQ2FHDQIURP WKH5LVHRI,VODPWR&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV 9DQGHU&KLMV-$DF'DJK5HJLVWHUVJHKRXGHQLQW&DVWHHO%DWDYLDZDQWSDVVH UHQGHGDHUWHUSODHWVHDOVRYHUJHKHHO1HGHUODQGWV,QGLDYROO¶V*UDYHQ KDJH±%DWDYLD &RROKDDV :3K ³'H 9HUHQLJGH 2RVWLQGLVFKH &RPSDJQLH´ LQ $OJHPHQH *HVFKLHGHQLV GHU1HGHUODQGHQ,9SS ²D F *HQHUDOH 0LVVLYHQ YDQ *RXYHUQHXUV*HQHUDDO HQ 5DGHQ YDQ ,QGLs DDQ +HUHQ ;9,, GHU 9HUHQLJGH 2RVWLQGLVFKH &RPSDQLH YROO ¶V *UDYHQKDJH 5LMNV*HVFKLHGNXQGLJH3XEOLFDWLsQ &URFKHW%1DYLGLWXWWLLWHPSLWHVWLPRQLGHOODVWRULD%RORJQD(GLVRQ 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL 9DQ'\NH3³7KH$QJOR'XWFK)OHHWRI'HIHQFH3UHOXGHWRWKH'XWFK2F FXSDWLRQRI7DLZDQ´LQ/%OXVVpDF$URXQGDQGDERXW)RUPRVD7DLSHL7V¶DR<XQJ KR)RXQGDWLRQIRU&XOWXUHDQG(GXFDWLRQSS )HOL[$-UDF7KH&KLQHVHLQWKH3KLOLSSLQHV0DQLOD±%RPED\±1HZ <RUN7V¶DR<XQJKR)RXQGDWLRQIRU&XOWXUHDQG(GXFDWLRQ )XUEHU+5LYDO(PSLUHVRI7UDGHLQWKH2ULHQWLQ0DULWLPH,QGLD1HZ'HO KL2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSS *DDVWUD )6 'H JHVFKLHGHQLV YDQ GH 92& /HLGHQ ± :DOEXUJ 3HUV =XWSKHQ :DOEXUJ 3HUV ²7KH'XWFK(DVW,QGLD&RPSDQ\([SDQVLRQDQG'HFOLQH/HLGHQ:DOEXUJ3HUV *LO-+LGDOJRV\VDPXUDLV(VSDQD\-DSzQVLQJORV;9,\;9,,0DGULG$OLDQ]D8QL YHUVLGDG(GLWRULDO *ODPDQQ.U'XWFK$VLDWLF7UDGH&RSHQKDJHQ±7KH+DJXH0DUWLQXV1LM KRII *RRGPDQ *. -DSDQ WKH 'XWFK ([SHULHQFH /RQGRQ ± 'RYHU 1HZ +DPSVKLUH 7KH $WKORQH3UHVV 9DQ*RRU-DF7UDGLQJ&RPSDQ\LQ$VLD8WUHFKW+HV8LWJHYHUV 'H*URRW$+³7KH2UJDQLVDWLRQRIWKH:HVWHUQ7UDGHLQWKH/HYDQW´LQ/ %OXVVp±)6*DDVWUDDF&RPSDQLHVDQG7UDGH(VVD\VRQ2YHUVHDV7UDGLQJ&RPSD QLVGXULQJWKH$QFLHQW5pJLPH/HLGHQ/HLGHQ8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSS 'HQ +DDQ + 0RHGHUQHJRWLH HQ JURWH YDDUW $PVWHUGDP /HLGHQ 8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV SS +DQHGD0DF$VLDQ3RUW&LWLHV/RFDODQG)RUHLJQ&XOWXUDO,QWHUDFWLRQV 6LQJDSRUH1XV3UHVV-DSDQ.\ǀWR8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV ,VUDHO-,'XWFK3ULPDF\LQ:RUOG7UDGH2[IRUG&ODUHQGRQ3UHVV ,ZDR66KXLQVHQEǀHNLVKLQRNHQN\nj7ǀN\ǀ<RVKLNDZD.REXQNDQ ²6KXLQVHQWR1LKRQPDFKL7ǀN\ǀ6KLQEXQGǀ -DFT+HUJRXDOF¶K07KH0DOD\3HQLQVXOD&URVVURDGVRIWKH0DULWLPH6LON5RDG %&$'/HLGHQ±%RVWRQ±.|OQ%ULOO .DWKLULWKDPE\:HOOV-³7KH/RQJ(LJKWHHQWK&HQWXU\DQGWKH1HZ$JHRI&RPPHUFH LQWKH0HODND6WUDLWV´LQ/%OXVVp)6*DDVWUDDF2QWKH(LJKWHHQWK&HQWXU\DVD &DWHJRU\RI$VLDQ+LVWRU\9DQ/HXULQ5HWURVSHFW$OGHUVKRW%URRNILHOG86$6LQ JDSRUH6\GQH\$VKJDWHSS .HDUQH\07KH,QGLDQ2FHDQLQ:RUOG+LVWRU\1HZ<RUN±/RQGRQ5RXWOHGJH .QDSS*-³&RIIHHIRU&DVK7KH'XWFK(DVW,QGLD&RPSDQ\DQGWKH([SDQVLRQRI&RI IHH &XOWLYDWLRQ LQ -DYD $PERQ DQG &H\ORQ ´ LQ - YDQ *RRU D F 7UDGLQJ &RPSDQ\LQ$VLD8WUHFKW+HV8LWJHYHUVSS /DFK')-9DQ.OH\(-$VLDLQWKH0DNLQJRI(XURSHYROO&KLFDJR±/RQGRQ7KH 8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR3UHVV 0DQVYHOW:0)5HFKWVYRUPHQJHOGHOLMNEHKHHUELMGH2RVW,QGLHVFKH&RPSDJQLH$P VWHUGDP6ZHWV=HLWOLQJHU 0DVVDUHOOD'$:RUOG(OVHZKHUH(XURSH¶V(QFRXQWHUZLWK-DSDQLQWKH6L[WHHQWKDQG 6HYHQWHHQWK&HQWXULHV1HZ+DYHQ/RQGRQ<DOH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV 0DYHULFN/$³3LHUUH3RLYUHWK&HQWXU\([SORUHURI6RXWKHDVW$VLD´LQ7KH3DFLILF +LVWRULFDO5HYLHZ;SS 0RUVH +% 7KH &KURQLFOHV RI WKH (DVW ,QGLD &RPSDQ\ 7UDGLQJ WR &KLQD YROO 2[ IRUG&ODUHQGRQ3UHVV 0XOGHU:=VG+ROODQGHUVLQ+LUDGR+DDUOHP)LEXOD9DQ'LVKRHFN /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ 0XUDNDPL1³7KH-DSDQHVHDW%DWUDYLDLQWKH;9,,WK&HQWXU\´LQ0RQXPHQWD1LSSRQL FDSS 1DJDVKLPD+³7KH)DFWRULHVDQG)DFLOLWLHVRIWKH(DVW,QGLD&RPSDQLHVLQ6XUDW/RFD WLRQ %XLOGLQJ &KDUDFWHULVWLFV DQG 2ZQHUVKLS´ LQ + 0DVDVKL D F $VLDQ 3RUW &LWLHV /RFDODQG)RUHLJQ&XOWXUDO,QWHUDFWLRQV6LQJDSRUH1XV3UHVV-DSDQ.\ǀWR 8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSS 1DJD]XPL<³)URP&RPSDQ\WR,QGLYLGXDO&RPSDQ\ 6HUYDQWV'XWFK7UDGHLQ(LJKW HHQWKFHQWXU\ -DSDQ´ LQ /%OXVVp- )6 *DDVWUD D F2Q WKH (LJKWHHQWK &HQWXU\ DVD &DWHJRU\RI$VLDQ+LVWRU\9DQ/HXULQ5HWURVSHFW$OGHUVKRW%URRNILHOG86$6LQJD SRUH6\GQH\$VKJDWHSS ²DF/DUJHDQG%URDG7KH'XWFK,PSDFWRQ(DUO\0RGHUQ$VLD(VVD\VLQ+RQRXURI /HRQDUG%OXVVp7ǀN\ǀ7ǀ\ǀ%XQNǀ 1LHPHLMHU+(%DWDYLD(HQ.RORQLDOH6DPHQOHYLQJLQGHGH(HXZ$PVWHUGDP%D ODQV 'H2OLYHLUD0DUTXHV$++LVWyULDGRV3RUWXJXHVHVQR([WUHPR2ULHQWH9RO3DUW, (PWRUQRGH0DFDX/LVERD)XQGDomR2ULHQWH ²+LVWyULDGRV3RUWXJXHVHVQR([WUHPR2ULHQWH9RO3DUW,,'H0DFDXjSHULIHULD /LVERD)XQGDomR2ULHQWH 2OOp0/DLQYHQFLyQGH&KLQD3HUFHSFLRQHV\HVWUDWHJLDVILOLSLQDVUHVSHFWRD&KLQDGX UDQWHHOVLJOR;9,:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW] ƿWD$³,PDJLQHG/LQN'RPHVWLFDWHG5HOLJLRQ7KH6WDWHDQGWKH2XWVLGH,VODPLF1HW ZRUNLQ%DQWHQ:HVW-DYDF´LQ<1DJD]XPLDF/DUJHDQG%URDG7KH 'XWFK,PSDFWRQ(DUO\0RGHUQ$VLD(VVD\VLQ+RQRXURI/HRQDUG%OXVVp7ǀN\ǀ7ǀ\ǀ %XQNǀSS 3DUWKHVLXV5'XWFK6KLSVLQ7URSLFDO:DWHUV7KH'HYHORSPHQWRIWKH'XWFK(DVW,QGLD &RPSDQ\ 92& 6KLSSLQJ 1HWZRUN LQ $VLD 3K 'LVVHUWDWLRQ 8QLYHUVLW\ RI $PVWHUGDP 0F3KHUVRQ . 7KH ,QGLDQ2FHDQ $ +LVWRU\RI 3HRSOH DQG WKH 6HD LQ0DULWLPH ,QGLD 1HZ'HOKL2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV QD3RPEHMUD ' ³3ULQFHVV3UHWHQGHUVDQG WKH &KLQHVH 3KUDNKODQJ $Q $QDO\VLV RI WKH 'XWFK(YLGHQFH&RQFHUQLQJ6LDPHVH&RXUW3ROLWLFV´LQ/%OXVVp)6*DD VWUDDF2QWKH(LJKWHHQWK&HQWXU\DVD&DWHJRU\RI$VLDQ+LVWRU\9DQ/HXULQ5HWUR VSHFW$OGHUVKRW%URRNILHOG86$±6LQJDSRUH6\GQH\$VKJDWHSS 3UDNDVK2³(XURSHDQ7UDGHDQGWKH(FRQRP\RI%HQJDOLQWKH6HYHQWHHQWKDQGWKH(DU O\ (LJKWHHQWK &HQWXU\´ LQ - YDQ *RRU D F7UDGLQJ &RPSDQ\ LQ $VLD 8 WUHFKW+HV8LWJHYHUVSS 5DEHQ 5 %DWDYLD DQG &RORPER 7KH (WKQLF DQG 6SDWLDO 2UGHURI 7ZR &RORQLDO &LWLHV 8QSXEOLVKHG3K'LVVHUWDWLRQ5LMNXQLYHUVLWHLW/HLGHQ ²QD3RPEHMUD',QWKH.LQJ¶V7UDLO$QWK&HQWXU\'XWFK-RXUQH\WRWKH%XGGKD¶V )RRWSULQW%DQJNRN7KH5R\DO1HWKHUODQGV(PEDVV\ 5RHSHU92PGH=XLGGH(HUVWH6FKLSYDDUWQDDU2RVW,QGLsRQGHU&RUQHOLVGH+RXW PDQ1LMPHJHQ6XQ 5RZH:7³'RPHVWLF,QWHUUHJLRQDO7UDGHLQ(LJKWHHQWKFHQWXU\&KLQD´LQ/%OXVVp )6*DDVWUDDF2QWKH(LJKWHHQWK&HQWXU\DVD&DWHJRU\RI$VLDQ+LVWRU\9DQ/HXU LQ5HWURVSHFW$OGHUVKRW%URRNILHOG86$6LQJDSRUH6\GQH\$VKJDWHSS 'H6DOGDQKD$9,XVWXP,PSHULXP'RVWUDGDWRVFRPRIXQGDPHQWRGR,PSpULRGRV3RU WXJXHVHVQR2ULHQWH/LVERD)XQGDomR2ULHQWH,VWLWXWR3RUWXJXrVGR2ULHQWH 6KDIIHU/10DULWLPH6RXWKHDVW$VLDWR$UPRQN1HZ<RUN0(6KDUSH 3DWUL]LD&DULRWL 6KLPDGD5³6LDPHVH3URGXFWVLQWKH-DSDQHVH0DUNHWGXULQJWKH6HYHQWHHQWKDQG(LJKW HHQWK &HQWXULHV´ LQ < 1DJD]XPL D F/DUJH DQG %URDG 7KH 'XWFK ,PSDFW RQ (DUO\ 0RGHUQ$VLD(VVD\VLQ+RQRURI/HRQDUG%OXVVp7ǀN\ǀ7ǀ\ǀ%XQNǀSS ²7KH,QWUD$VLDQ7UDGHLQ-DSDQHVH&RSSHUE\WKH'XWFK(DVW,QGLD&RPSDQ\GXULQJ WKH(LJKWHHQWK&HQWXU\/HLGHQ±%RVWRQ%ULOO 6RPHUV -$ 'H 9RF DOV YRONHQUHFKWHOLMNH DFWRU 'HYHQWHU *RXGD4XLQW 5RWWHUGDP 6DQGHUV,QVWLWXXW 6RX]D *% 7KH 6XUYLYDO RI (PSLUH 3RUWXJXHVH 7UDGH DQG 6RFLHW\ LQ &KLQD DQG WKH 6RXWK&KLQD6HD&DPEULGJH8.&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV 6WDSHO):*HVFKLGHQLHVYDQ1HGHUODQGVFK,QGLsYROO$PVWHUGDP-RRVWYDQGHQ 9RQGHO ²'H*RXYHUQHXUV*HQHUDDOYDQ1HGHUODQGVFK,QGLsLQEHHOGHQZRRUG'HQ+DDJ9DQ 6WRFNXP 6WDUNH\'-9DQ(\FNYDQ+HVOLQJD(6GH0RRU-$3LUDWHVDQG3ULYDWHHUV1HZ 3HUVSHFWLYLHVRQWKH:DUDQG7UDGHLQWKH(LJKWHHQWKDQG1LQHWHHQWK&HQWXULHV([HWHU 8.8QLYHUVLW\RI([HWHU3UHVV 6WHHQVJDDUG 1 ³7KH 'XWFK (DVW ,QGLD &RPSDQ\ DV DQ ,QVWLWXWLRQDO ,QQRYDWLRQ´ LQ 0 $\PDUGDF'XWFK&DSLWDOLVP:RUG&DSLWDOLVP&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV 7D\ORU-*7KH6RFLDO:RUOGRI%DWDYLD(XURSHDQDQG(XUDVLDQLQ'XWFK$VLD0DGL VRQ8QLYHUVLW\RI:LVFRQVLQ3UHVV 7VXNDKDUD7³'XWFK+LVWRULFDO5HVRXUFHVRQ&OLPDWH5HFRQVWUXFWLRQ´LQ<1DJD]XPL DF/DUJH DQG %URDG 7KH 'XWFK,PSDFWRQ (DUO\ 0RGHUQ $VLD (VVD\V LQ +RQRXURI /HRQDUG%OXVVp7ǀN\ǀ7ǀ\ǀ%XQNǀSS 7HUSVWUD + -DFRE YDQ 1HFN $PVWHUGDPV $GPLUDDO HQ 5HJHQW $PVWHUGDP 31 YDQ .DPSHQHQ=RRQ19 9DQ9HHQ(.OLMQ'DF$*XLGHWRWKH6RXUFHVRIWKH+LVWRU\RI'XWFK3RUWXJXHVH 5HODWLRQVLQ$VLD/HLGHQ,QWHUFRQWLQHQWD :DGD,³'LDPRQG7UDGHE\WKH'XWFK(DVW,QGLD&RPSDQ\LQ6HYHQWHHQWK&HQWXU\,Q GLD´LQ<1DJD]XPLDF/DUJHDQG%URDG7KH'XWFK,PSDFWRQ(DUO\0RGHUQ$VLD (VVD\VLQ+RQRURI/HRQDUG%OXVVp7ǀN\ǀ7ǀ\ǀ%XQNǀSS :DWVRQ$QGD\D%$QGD\D/<$+LVWRU\RI0DOD\VLD+RQJ.RQJ0DF0LOODQ3UHVV :LOOV-(-U(PEDVVLHVDQG,OOXVLRQV'XWFKDQG3RUWXJXHVH(QYR\VWR.¶DQJKLV &DPEULGJH+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV :LOOV-(3HSSHU*XQVDQG3DUOH\V7KH'XWFK(DVW,QGLD&RPSDQ\DQG&KLQD &DPEULGJH0DVV+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV :LQLXV *' 7KH )DWDO +LVWRU\ RI 3RUWXJXHVH &H\ORQ 7UDQVLWLRQ WR WKH 'XWFK 5XOH &DPEULGJH0DVV+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV :LWWHYHHQ0(HQ2QGHUQHPLQJYDQ/DQGVEHODQJGH2SULFKWLQJYDQGH9HUHQLJGH2RVW ,QGLVFKH&RPSDJQLHLQ$PVWHUGDP$PVWHUGDP8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV :\DWW'.³7KH(LJKWHHQWK&HQWXU\LQ6RXWKHDVW$VLD´LQ/%OXVVp)6*DDVWUDD F 2Q WKH (LJKWHHQWK &HQWXU\DVD &DWHJRU\ RI $VLDQ +LVWRU\ 9DQ/HXU LQ 5HWURVSHFW $OGHUVKRW%URRNILHOG86$6LQJDSRUH6\GQH\$VKJDWHSS <DR . ³7KH )XQGDPHQWDOO\ 'LIIHUHQW 5ROHV RI /LQJXLVWV LQ WKH 3RUW RI 1DJDVDNL DQG &DQWRQ´LQ(*URHQHQGLMN&9LDOOp/%OXVVpDF&DQWRQDQG1DJDVDNL&RPSDUHG 'XWFK&KLQHVH-DSDQHVH5HODWLRQV/HLGHQ,QVWLWXWHIRUWKH+LVWRU\RI(XUR SHDQ([SDQVLRQSS /¶DYYHQWXUDGHOOD92&LQ$VLD%DWDYLDµ5HJLQDG¶2ULHQWH¶ =KXDQJ * ³&DQWRQ 6\VWHP &KLQD¶V 5HDFWLRQ WR (XURSHDQ &RPPHUFLDO ([SDQVLRQ LQ WK&HQWXU\´LQ36DQWDQJHORDF0LQJ4LQJ<DQMLX1DSROL5RPD1XRYD3ROLJUD ILFD/DWLQDSS ²³7KH,PSDFWRIWKH,QWHUQDWLRQDO7HD7UDGHRQWKH6RFLDO(FRQRP\RI1RUWKZHVW)X MLDQLQWKH(LJKWHHQWK&HQWXU\´LQ/%OXVVp6*DDVWUDDF2QWKH(LJKWHHQWK&HQWXU\ DVD&DWHJRU\RI$VLDQ+LVWRU\9DQ/HXULQ5HWURVSHFW$OGHUVKRW%URRNILHOG86$ 6LQJDSRUH±6\GQH\$VKJDWHSS ²7KH,QWHUQDWLRQDO7HD7UDGHDQG:HVWHUQ&RPPHUFLDO([SDQVLRQLQWR&KLQDLQ ;LDPHQ;LDPHQ8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV 6$1'5$0$5,1$&$5/(77, 4XDQGRLOJLDOORVLWLQJHGLURVVRLURPDQ]LGL4LX;LDRORQJ &LVRQRPROWLPRGLGLUDFFRQWDUHXQSDHVHFRQOHVXHUHDOWjGLXQFHUWR PRPHQWRLVXRLHQWXVLDVPLHLVXRLSUREOHPLOHVXHDELWXGLQLHLVXRLWLF/D OHWWHUDWXUDqFHUWRXQRGLTXHVWLHWDOYROWDXQRGHLSLHIILFDFL 1RQIDHFFH]LRQHLOSROL]LHVFRFKHLQWXWWHOHVXHGHFOLQD]LRQLqVHPSUH VWDWRRYXQTXHXQPRGRGLUDFFRQWDUHXQSDHVHHODVXDFXOWXUDÊXQJHQHUH FKHLQ&LQDKDXQDOXQJDWUDGL]LRQHPROWRGLYHUVDGDOSROL]LHVFRRFFLGHQWD OHODQDUUDWLYDVXFDVLJLXGL]LDULJRQJ¶DQ[LDRVKXRޜṸሿ䈤SUHQGHVSXQ WRHURPDQ]DLFDVLULVROWLGDIDPRVLJLXGLFLGHOO¶DQWLFKLWjHGDVHFROLQRQKD PDLVPHVVRGLDSSDVVLRQDUHLOOHWWRUHFLQHVHULIHUHQGRYLFHQGHGHOODYLWDTXR WLGLDQD GL TXHL FRPXQL FLQHVL GHL TXDOL OH VWRULH GLQDVWLFKH QRQ SDUODQR /D ©*ROGHQ$JHRIWKH&KLQHVHGHWHFWLYHVWRU\ªVDUjODSULPDPHWjGHO;;VHFR OR XQ¶HSRFD GL ULFFD SURGX]LRQH ODUJR FRQVXPR H JUDQGH FRQWDPLQD]LRQH FRQ OD WUDGL]LRQH RFFLGHQWDOH .LQNOH\ SS GRSR HVVHUH VFRPSDUVRSHUWUHGHFHQQLGDJOLVFDIIDOLGHOOHOLEUHULHFRQGDQQDWRGDXQDUL JLGDSROLWLFDFXOWXUDOHQHJOLDQQLVXFFHVVLYLDOOD5LYROX]LRQHFXOWXUDOHLOSROL ]LHVFRqWRUQDWRDHVVHUHXQDGHOOHOHWWXUHSUHIHULWHGHLFLQHVLLQXQDYDULHWjGL IRUPHSXQWLGLYLVWDWHPLHDXWRULFKHQRQVPHWWHGLFUHVFHUH,ELGSS ILQRD+H-LDKRQJօᇦᕈSURIHVVRUHDOOD)DFROWjGLGLULWWRGHO OD5HQPLQGD[XHGL3HFKLQRLFXLURPDQ]LFHQWUDWLVXOODILJXUDGHOO¶DYYRFDWR 3HUHVHPSLRODQDUUDWLYDVXFDVLJLXGL]LDULQRQSUHYHGHVXVSHQVHWXWWLLGHWWDJOLGHOFULPLQH VRQRQRWLVLQGDOOHSULPHSDJLQHH O¶LQWHUHVVHGHOWHVWRqWXWWRQHOSLDFHUHLQWHOOHWWXDOHGLVH JXLUHLUDJLRQDPHQWLFKHSRUWDQRLOPDJLVWUDWRDOODVROX]LRQHGHOFDVRYDQ*XOLNSSLL LY (DQFKHLOOHWWRUHRFFLGHQWDOHGDTXDQGRXQHFFHQWULFRGLSORPDWLFRVLQRORJRRODQGHVH5REHUW YDQ*XOLNKDSXEEOLFDWRQHJOLDQQL¶ODWUDGX]LRQHSLSUHFLVDPHQWHODULVFULWWXUDGLYDUL URPDQ]LEDVDWLVXOOHYLFHQGHGHOPDJLVWUDWRGLHSRFD7DQJ'L5HQMLH⣴ӱᶠ 6DQGUD0DULQD&DUOHWWL GHWHFWLYHSHFKLQHVH+RQJ-XQKDQQRODUJRVHJXLWRLQ&LQDHVRQRRUDWUDGRWWL LQYDULHOLQJXHRFFLGHQWDOLXQRDQFKHLQLWDOLDQR+H-LDKRQJ 4XHVWD q OD VWUDGD VFHOWD DQFKH GD 4LX ;LDRORQJ㼈ሿ嗉 SHU L VXRLSROL]LHVFKLGLJUDQGHVXFFHVVRLQ2FFLGHQWHHRUDWUDGRWWLDQFKHLQFLQH VH 3HUFKp 4LX ;LDRORQJ VFULYH L VXRL URPDQ]L LQ LQJOHVH 6RQR DG RJJL VHL URPDQ]L4LX;LDRORQJWXWWLDPELHQWD WLQHOOD6KDQJKDLGHJOLDQQL¶ODPHWURSROLLQSLHQDWUDVIRUPD]LRQHHFRQR PLFDHXUEDQLVWLFDFRQLSUREOHPLHUHGLWDWLGDOSDVVDWRGHOOD5LYROX]LRQHFXO WXUDOHHFRQTXHOOLQXRYLSRUWDWLGDOOHULIRUPHGRYHVLLQWUHFFLDQROHYLFHQGH GHLYHFFKLEXURFUDWLGLIHQVRULGHOSDUWLWRXQLFRJOLXOWLPLRQHVWLHXQSR¶LGH DOLVWL QRVWDOJLFL GHOO¶HJXDOLWDULVPR VRFLDOLVWD L QXRYL LPSUHQGLWRUL DIIDULVWL H VHQ]DVFUXSROLLOWXWWRSHUFRUVRGDOODQRVWDOJLDUHDOHRVSHFXODWLYDSHULOEULO ODQWHSDVVDWRGHOODFLWWjTXDQGRHUDODµ3DULJLG¶2ULHQWH¶ (6KDQJKDLqVLQHGGRFKHSHU&LQD4LX;LDRORQJVWHVVRKDSLYROWHGL FKLDUDWR LQ YDULH LQWHUYLVWH H DQFRUD SL FKLDUDPHQWH QHOO¶LQWURGX]LRQH DOOD WUDGX]LRQHFLQHVHGHOVXRSULPRURPDQ]RFKHVXDLQWHQ]LRQHHUDLQL]LDOPHQWH VFULYHUHXQOLEURVXOOD&LQDFRQWHPSRUDQHDSHUSUHVHQWDUQHXQ¶LPPDJLQHSL UHDOHHVIDFFHWWDWDVHQ]DQDVFRQGHUQHLSUREOHPLPDVHQ]DLSUHJLXGL]LHJOL VWHUHRWLSLFKHODFDUDWWHUL]]DQRQHOODSHUFH]LRQHRFFLGHQWDOHXQD&LQDFKHQRQ VLDVRORTXHOODGHJOLDQQL¶RGHOOD5LYROX]LRQHFXOWXUDOHDELWDWDQRQVROR GDFRQWDGLQLH*XDUGLHURVVH6KDQJKDLqODUHDOWjFKHPHJOLRFRQRVFHLOSROL ]LHVFRKDRIIHUWRDOXLSRHWDHFRQSRFDGLPHVWLFKH]]DFRQOHIRUPHGHOODQDU ,SULPLWUHVRQRWUDGRWWLLQFLQHVHLSULPLTXDWWURDQFKHLQLWDOLDQR 6KDQJKDLqDOFHQWURGLWXWWDODSURGX]LRQHLQSURVDGL4LX;LDRORQJFKHQHOKDSXEEOL FDWRDQFKHVRORQHOODWUDGX]LRQHIUDQFHVH4LX;LDRORQJDXQDUDFFROWDGLPLFURUDF FRQWLSLFFROLVNHWFKGLYLWDVKDQJKDLHVHLQXQDVRUWDGLVWRULDGHOODFLWWjOD3LFFROD6WRULDFKH VRWWHQGH H FRQWUDVWD OD *UDQGH 6WRULD )UDPPHQWL GL TXHVWL UDFFRQWL FRPSDLRQR SUHVVRFKpL GHQWLFLQHLURPDQ]L /DWUDVIRUPD]LRQHQHOODWUDGX]LRQHFLQHVHGL6KDQJKDLLQXQ¶DQRQLPDµFLWWj+¶qVWDWDLQSL RFFDVLRQLODPHQWDWDGD4LX;LDRORQJFRPHFHQVRULD,QUHDOWjSDUDGRVVDOPHQWHO¶LQWHUYHQWR GHOWUDGXWWRUHFRUURERUDLOSURSRVLWRGHOO¶DXWRUHGLSDUODUHGL6KDQJKDLSHUSDUODUHGHOOD&LQD WRXWFRXUW1pEDVWDODGHIRUPD]LRQHGHOODWRSRQRPDVWLFDDUHQGHUH6KDQJKDLLUULFRQRVFLELOH JOLVWHVVLWLWROLVFHOWLSHUO¶HGL]LRQHFLQHVHHOLPLQDQRRJQLHYHQWXDOHDPELJXLWjVHSHU'HDWK RID5HG+HURLQHVLqDGRWWDWDXQDWUDGX]LRQHOHWWHUDOH,OSDUFRGHO%XQGqLOWLWRORFLQHVHSHU $/R\DO&KDUDFWHU'DQFHUH$GGLRDJOLVKLNXPHQTXHOORSHU:KHQ5HGLV%ODFN2JQLOHWWRUH FLQHVHVDFKHJOLVKLNXPHQVRQRDELWD]LRQLWLSLFKHGL6KDQJKDLHLO%XQGqD6KDQJKDL 4XDQGRLOJLDOORVLWLQJHGLURVVRLURPDQ]LGL4LX;LDRORQJ UD]LRQHODFRUQLFHLQFXLLQVHULUHVHQ]DJUDQGHGLIILFROWjOHVXHVWRULHO¶LQJOH VHODOLQJXDGHOOHWWRUHDOTXDOHLWHVWLVRQRGHVWLQDWL 6RQRTXLQGLURPDQ]LFKHSRVVRQRHVVHUHOHWWLLQYDULHSURVSHWWLYHFRPH SROL]LHVFKL DOO¶LQFURFLR GHOOD WUDGL]LRQH RFFLGHQWDOH H RULHQWDOH FRPH SDUWH GHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD GHL FLQHVL GL $PHULFD RSSXUH LQILQH VHPSOLFHPHQWH GLUHL VRSUDWWXWWRFRPHURPDQ]LFLQHVLQRQVRORSHUFKpSDUODQRGL&LQDHLQPRGR QLHQWHDIIDWWRQHXWURPDDQFKHSHUFKpQHOODVWUXWWXUDVWHVVDWUDVXGDQRFXOWXUD HWUDGL]LRQHFLQHVH 4LX;LDRORQJqXQLQWHOOHWWXDOHFLQHVHWRWDOPHQWHLPPHUVRQHLSUREOHPL VRFLDOLSROLWLFLHFXOWXUDOLGHOOD&LQDGHOWHU]RPLOOHQQLRPDDQFKHGRWDWR GLXQDVROLGDFXOWXUDWUDGL]LRQDOH3RHWDVWXGLRVRHWUDGXWWRUHGLSRHVLDDPHUL FDQDHUDULFHUFDWRUHDOO¶$FFDGHPLDFLQHVHGLVFLHQ]HVRFLDOLGL6KDQJKDLILQR DTXDQGRQHOVLqUHFDWRQHJOL6WDWL8QLWLSHUXQVRJJLRUQRGLVWXGLRHYL VLqSRLVWDELOLWR2JJLLQVHJQDDOOD:DVKLQJWRQ8QLYHUVLW\LQ6W/RXLVHGq LQ$PHULFDFKHKDFRPLQFLDWRDVFULYHUHURPDQ]LLQLQJOHVH $OOHWWRUHDYYHUWLWRLURPDQ]LVLSUHVHQWDQRFRPHXQJLJDQWHVFRSX]]OH GLµFLWD]LRQL¶HDOOXVLRQLXQDFRVWUX]LRQHFKHULPDQGDDTXHOODGHOODSRHVLDFL QHVHFODVVLFD6FULWWRGDXQOHWWHUDWRSHUXQOHWWHUDWRLOWHVWRFLQHVHqSURGRWWR GL XQD FXOWXUD FKH GD VHPSUH KD IDWWR GHOOD SUDWLFD GHOOD FLWD]LRQH XQD GHOOH VXHFLIUHSHFXOLDULDPSOLDWDWURQFDWDDQFKHGHIRUPDWDRUDSHUDOOXGHUHVHQ]D GLUHHVSOLFLWDPHQWHHGHWWDJOLDWDPHQWHRUDSLHJDWDDXQQXRYRVLJQLILFDWRSHU DWWULEXLUVLO¶DXWRULWjGHOWHVWRFLWDWRRDOFRQWUDULRSHUUHQGHUJOLRPDJJLRQHOOD WUDGL]LRQHFLQHVHODSDURODFLWDWDqVHPSUHGRSSLDPHQWHFDULFDGLVLJQLILFDWR ,GHQWLILFDUH OD FLWD]LRQH R O¶DOOXVLRQH GHFRGLILFDUQH O¶XVR q JUDQGH SDUWH GHO ODYRURGHOILORORJRFLQHVHVLDVXLWHVWLDQWLFKLFKHVXTXHOOLPRGHUQLHILQFRQ WHPSRUDQHL &KHPOD 0DUWLQ 8QD IXQ]LRQH VLPLOH KDQQR OH VWRULH R IUDPPHQWLGLVWRULHFKHVRQRODPDWHULDFRQODTXDOH4LX;LDRORQJFRVWUXLVFH O¶HGLILFLRGHLVXRLSROL]LHVFKLSHUFRJOLHUQHWXWWDODGHQVLWjXQFRPSLWRDQDOR JRDTXHOORGHOILORORJRVLSRQHDOOHWWRUHGLTXHVWLURPDQ]LWHQWDUHFLRqGLGH FLIUDUHFLzFKHUDFFRQWDQRDQFKHDOGLOjGHOODOHWWHUDÊXQDVILGDGHOODTXDOH &KHLOSURSRVLWRIRVVHVFULYHUHOLEULVXOOD&LQDFRQWHPSRUDQHDHQRQQHFHVVDULDPHQWHSROL]LH VFKLqHYLGHQWHQHOODFRVWUX]LRQHGHOOHVWRULHGRYHO¶LQGDJLQHWDOYROWDDVVDLHVLOHULVXOWDTXDVL XQ SUHWHVWR SHU UDFFRQWDUH XQSH]]R GL UHDOWj FLQHVHOD SULPDSDUWH GHL URPDQ]L q LQ JHQHUH SDUWLFRODUPHQWH ULFFD GL GLJUHVVLRQL GL YDULR JHQHUH PHQWUH QHL FDSLWROL ILQDOL OD QDUUD]LRQH µSUHFLSLWD¶UDSLGDPHQWHYHUVRODVROX]LRQHGHOµFDVR¶ ÊGHOUHVWRORVWHVVR4LX;LDRORQJFKHVROOHFLWDDµLQGDJDUH¶DOGLOjGLTXDQWRGHWWRHVSOLFLWD PHQWH TXDQGR DSSDUHQWD OD FULWLFD OHWWHUDULD D XQ¶LQGDJLQH GL SROL]LD H DOOD SVLFDQDOLVL 4LX ;LDRORQJSS 6DQGUD0DULQD&DUOHWWL LOOHWWRUHQRQVSHFLDOLVWDFXLLOWHVWRqRYYLDPHQWHLQQDQ]LWXWWRGHVWLQDWRqGD VXSSRUUHUHVWLVRVWDQ]LDOPHQWHHIHOLFHPHQWH"LQFRQVDSHYROHFRQILQDWRSHUz GLIDWWRDXQDFRPSUHQVLRQHSDU]LDOHHVRPPDULDGHOWHVWR'LHWURODILQ]LRQH QDUUDWLYDHLOSDUDYHQWRGLQRPLILWWL]LPDWDOYROWDILQWURSSRIDFLOPHQWHGHFL IUDELOL4LX;LDRORQJFRVWUXLVFHLOVXRDIIUHVFRGHOOD&LQDFRQWHPSRUDQHDFRQ µFLWD]LRQL¶GLSHUVRQDJJLHVWRULHUHDOL4XHVWRqYHURSHUODVWRULDSULQFLSDOH FKHLQWURGXFHLWHPLGLULOLHYRVRFLDOHQRQFRQRVFHUHRULFRQRVFHUHODVWRULD UHDOHFKHVRWWHQGHTXHOODGHOODILFWLRQQRQSHQDOL]]DODOHWWXUDLQPRGRVRVWDQ ]LDOHYHUHRLQYHQWDWHOHVWRULHYRJOLRQRHVVHUHHUHVWDQRHPEOHPDWLFKH(Gq YHURDQFKHSHUOHSLFFROHVWRULHVHFRQGDULHGLJUHVVLRQLVRVWDQ]LDOPHQWHDXWR QRPHFKHDUULFFKLVFRQRLOWHVWRDOODUJDQGRLOTXDGURGDOPRQGRGHJOLDIIDULH GHOODSROLWLFDDTXHOORGHOODFXOWXUDLQTXHVWRFDVRSHUzSHUGHUHLOVLJQLILFDWR µQDVFRVWR¶QRQFRJOLHUHODQRQFDVXDOLWjGLXQDFLWD]LRQHRGLXQGHWWDJOLRUL GXFHFRQVLGHUHYROPHQWHODFRPSUHQVLRQHFRPSOHVVLYDDQFKHSHUFKpVRQRGL JUHVVLRQL VHPSUH PROWR LOOXPLQDQWL VXOOD FRQILJXUD]LRQH FXOWXUDOH GL 4LX ;LDRORQJVWHVVRODVXDIRUPD]LRQHOHVXHSUHIHUHQ]HOHWWHUDULH 3HUVRQDJJLHVWRULHKDQQRSUDWLFDPHQWHVHPSUHXQUHIHUHQWHUHDOHVSHVVR DQFKHSLGLXQRVWRULHFRPSRVLWHHSHUVRQDJJLFRPSRVLWLVRQRODQRUPDÊ SUDWLFDPHQWHLPSRVVLELOHGDUHFRQWRGLWXWWHOHFLWD]LRQLHDOOXVLRQLFKHDIIRO ODQROHSDJLQHGHOWHVWRGHOO¶LQWUHFFLRGLULFKLDPLDVWRULHHSHUVRQDJJLGLYHU VLXQODELULQWRQHOTXDOHFLVLSHUGHRGDOTXDOHVLULHPHUJHIUDVWRUQDWLÊXQ DPPLFFDUH FRQWLQXR GHOOR VFULWWRUH DO VXR OHWWRUHFRPH GHO UHVWR KD VHPSUH IDWWRLOOHWWHUDWRFLQHVHWUDGL]LRQDOH&RQO¶DJJLXQWDGHJOLµLQVHUWL¶LQIRUPDWLYL QHFHVVDULSHUXQOHWWRUHQRQFLQHVHGHLGHWWDJOLJUDQGLHSLFFROLGLYLWDTXRWL GLDQD GHO WXWWR YHULWLHUL PD VSHVVR DOWUHWWDQWR LUULOHYDQWL QHOO¶HFRQRPLD GHO O¶LQGDJLQHHGHOODQDUUD]LRQHLWHVWLILQLVFRQRFRQO¶HVVHUHXQDYHUDHSURSULD HQFLFORSHGLDGHOOD&LQDFRQWHPSRUDQHDÊLQFUHGLELOHTXDQWD&LQDµUHDOH¶4LX ;LDRORQJ VLD ULXVFLWR D PHWWHUH QHL VXRL URPDQ]L GHO SUHVHQWH H GHO SDVVDWR UHFHQWHGHOODVRFLHWjGHOODFXOWXUDHGHOODYLWDTXRWLGLDQD1RQVRUSUHQGHFKH 7LSLFRHVHPSLRqODVWRULDGL6KHQ:HQFKDQJO¶HVSHUWRGLVWRULDGHOO¶DEELJOLDPHQWRFKHPDO JUDGR OH µLPSUHFLVLRQL¶LGHQWLILFD LQHTXLYRFDELOPHQWH 6KHQ &RQJZHQ⊸Ӿ᮷ H WXWWRFLzFKHODVXDYLFHQGDELRJUDILFDHODYDOXWD]LRQHGHOODVXDRSHUDFRPSRUWDQHOODVWRULD GHOODOHWWHUDWXUDFLQHVHPRGHUQD4LX;LDRORQJSSRSSXUHDQFRUDLQ5HG0DQ GDULQ'UHVVLOSURIHVVRU%LDQ/RQJKXDQHOODFXLILJXUD4LX;LDRORQJUHQGHSDOHVHPHQWHR PDJJLRDOVXRUHDOHPDHVWURLOIDPRVRSRHWDHWUDGXWWRUH%LDQ=KLOLQѻ⩣ ,WHVWLGRYUHEEHURHVVHUHFRUUHGDWLGDXQDWDOHTXDQWLWjGLJORVVHGDYDQLILFDUHFRPSOHWDPHQWH LOSLDFHUHGLOHJJHUHXQSROL]LHVFR 4XDQGRLOJLDOORVLWLQJHGLURVVRLURPDQ]LGL4LX;LDRORQJ TXDOFKHXQLYHUVLWjDPHULFDQDOLDEELDDGRWWDWLFRPHOHWWXUDREEOLJDWRULDSHUOR VWXGLRGHOOD&LQDFRQWHPSRUDQHD<DQ<LQJSS 4LX;LDRORQJPHWWHPROWRGLVpQHOOHVXHVWRULHHQHLVXRLSHUVRQDJJLH LQQDQ]LWXWWRLQ&KHQ&DRLOSURWDJRQLVWDGLWXWWHOHLQGDJLQLWUDDXWRUHHSHU VRQDJJLRODFRQIXVLRQHqFRVWDQWH3ROL]LRWWRHSRHWD&KHQ&DRqDFDSRGHOOD 6TXDGUDFDVLVSHFLDOLTXHOODFLRqLQFDULFDWDGHOOHLQGDJLQLµSROLWLFDPHQWHVHQ VLELOL¶VLRIIUHTXLQGLFRPHRWWLPRSXQWRGLRVVHUYD]LRQHSHUHYHQWLHSUREOH PLSDUWLFRODUPHQWHVLJQLILFDWLYLSHU6KDQJKDLHSHUOD&LQDÊXQLQFDULFRGH OLFDWR FXL OR KD SRUWDWR QRQ VHQ]D RELH]LRQL GD SDUWH GHL YHFFKL TXDGUL OD QXRYDSROLWLFDGL'HQJ;LDRSLQJFKHGDYDLQILQHODUJRVSD]LRDJLRYDQLFRQ XQ DOWR OLYHOOR GL LVWUX]LRQH D SUHIHUHQ]D GHOOH TXDOLILFD]LRQL SROLWLFKH &KHQ &DRqFRPXQTXHPHPEURGHO3DUWLWRFRQYLQWRHOHDOHDSSDUHQWHPHQWHGHVWL QDWRDSLDOWLWUDJXDUGLPDOJUDGRODULVFKLRVDUHSXWD]LRQHGLHVVHUH©WRROLEH UDOª0D&KHQ&DRqDQFKHXQLQWHOOHWWXDOHHQRQPDQFDPDLGLDFFRPSDJQDUH LOVXRODYRURFRQDQDOLVLHULIOHVVLRQLVXOOHYLFHQGHFKHVLWURYDDGDIIURQWDUH )LJOLRGLXQQRWRVWXGLRVRGLQHRFRQIXFLDQHVLPRqILQLWRDIDUHLOSROL]LRWWR TXDVLSHUFDVRPDFRQWLQXDFRQVXFFHVVRODVXDDWWLYLWjGLSRHWDHWUDGXWWRUH GLSRHVLDPDDQFKHLQXQDULFRUUHQWHPLVHHQDEvPHSROL]LHVFKLSUHVRLQ JLURGDFROOHJKLHDPLFLKDVHPSUHSURQWDXQDFLWD]LRQHSHUORSLGDSRHWL 7DQJH6RQJFRQ/L6KDQJ\LQGHFLVDPHQWHHGHVSOLFLWDPHQWHLOVXRIDYRULWR 4LX;LDRORQJSSHUFRPPHQWDUHXQDVLWXD]LRQHRVHPSOLFHPHQWH HVSULPHUHXQVHQWLPHQWR&KHQ&DRVDGHVWUHJJLDUVLHGqFDSDFHGLPDQWHQH UHODVXDLQWHJULWjQHOOHORWWHSROLWLFKHFKHSXUHORFRLQYROJRQRHLQXQFRQWH /D UDGLFH DUFKHWLSLFD GHL VXRL FRPSRUWDPHQWL q LQGLFDWD LQ PRGR LQHTXLYRFR DQFKH VH ©+H GLGQRWOLNH&RQIXFLDQLVPGHVSLWHKLVODWHIDWKHU¶VLQIOXHQFH/LNHPDQ\RWKHUSHRSOHRIKLV JHQHUDWLRQ&KHQEHOLHYHGWKDW&RQIXFLDQLGHRORJ\KDGFDXVHGUDWKHUWKDQVROYHGSUREOHPVLQ WKHFRXUVHRIWKHKLVWRU\RI&KLQHVHFLYLOL]DWLRQª4LX;LDRORQJSqLQGHILQLWLYD XQDPDVVLPDGLGHULYD]LRQHFRQIXFLDQDLQVHJQDPHQWRGHOSDGUHODVXDEXVVRODQHLPRPHQWL GLGXEELR©7KHUHDUHWKLQJVDPDQFDQGRDQGWKLQJVDPDQFDQQRWGRªYHGLDGHVHPSLR ,ELGSS 0ROWLGHLYHUVLFKHFLWDVRQRGDWHVWLFKH4LX;LDRORQJKDWUDGRWWRHSXEEOLFDWR LQLQJOHVHHDQFKHLYHUVLµGL&KHQ&DR¶VRQRLQSDUWHSXEEOLFDWL,GE6XOODSUHGLOH ]LRQHSHU/L6KDQJ\LQWUDJOLVFULWWRULFLQHVLFRQWHPSRUDQHLYHGL,RYHQH ,OPDJLVWUDWRFKHqDQFKHXQILQHOHWWHUDWRQRQqFRVDQXRYDQHOODQDUUDWLYDSROL]LHVFDFLQHVHH OXQJKHFLWD]LRQLLQIDUFLVFRQRLOSROL]LHVFRWUDGL]LRQDOHQHOOD&LQDLPSHULDOHO¶DPPLQLVWUD]LR QHGHOODJLXVWL]LDHUDFRPSHWHQ]DGHOPDJLVWUDWRORFDOHLOTXDOHDYHYDLQJHQHUHVFDUVDRQHV VXQDSUHSDUD]LRQHJLXULGLFDPDFRPHWXWWLLIXQ]LRQDULGHOO¶LPSHURDYHYDVXSHUDWRJOLHVDPL FKHGDYDQRDFFHVVRDOODFDUULHUDEXURFUDWLFDHDYHYDTXLQGLQHFHVVDULDPHQWHXQ¶HVWHVDFRQR VFHQ]DGHOODOHWWHUDWXUDFDQRQLFD 6DQGUD0DULQD&DUOHWWL VWRFRUURWWRPRUDOPHQWHSULPDFKHSHQDOPHQWHDYHQGRFRPHEXVVRODLSULQ FLSLGHOODJLXVWL]LDVRFLDOHFKHDFTXLVWDQRVHPSUHSLXQVDSRUHUpWURHLSUH FHWWL FRQIXFLDQL DVVLPLODWL QHOO¶LQIDQ]LD O¶HJXDOLWDULVPR GL PDWULFH PDRLVWD FRQYLYHSHUIHWWDPHQWHFRQHOHPHQWLGLHWLFDFRQIXFLDQDUDIIRU]DQGRVLDQ]LD YLFHQGD&RPXQTXHDJOLRFFKLGLPROWLXQSULYLOHJLDWRSULPDHRUD 'L WXWW¶DOWUD IRUPD]LRQH q LO VXR FROODERUDWRUH FRVWDQWH H ILGDWR LO SROL ]LRWWRVHPSOLFH<X*XDQJPLQJ)LJOLRGLSROL]LRWWRGLSRFKHOHWWXUHXQSR¶ IUXVWUDWRPDGLWHPSHUDPHQWRPHQRIOHPPDWLFRHSLHVSOLFLWRGHOVXRFDSR UDSSUHVHQWDEHQHJOLXPRULGHOFLQHVHFRPXQHVHPSUHELVWUDWWDWRGDLYDULPR YLPHQWLSROLWLFLPDULPDVWRIRQGDPHQWDOPHQWHRQHVWRTXHOORFKHQRQKDXVX IUXLWRGHOOHULIRUPHGL'HQJVHQRQGHOOHEULFLROHHIRUVHPDLQHXVXIUXLUj$ &KHQOROHJDODUHFLSURFDILGXFLDEDVDWDVXXQDFRQGLYLVDJUDQGHRQHVWjSHU VRQDOH H LQWHOOHWWXDOH H OD FRQYLQ]LRQH FKH L SULQFLSL GHOOD JLXVWL]LD VRFLDOH QRQSRVVRQRHQRQGHYRQRHVVHUHVDFULILFDWLQHDQFKHLQQRPHGHOOHULIRUPH LQFDULFDWL GHOOH LQGDJLQL SL SROLWLFDPHQWH VHQVLELOL SHU <X IRUVH DQFRU SL FKHSHU&KHQQRQVLWUDWWDVRORGLVFRSULUHHDUUHVWDUHXQFULPLQDOHPDDQFKH GLUDGGUL]]DUHGHLWRUWL&RPHSHULOPDJLVWUDWRGHOODWUDGL]LRQHSHUHQWUDPEL LOPHVWLHUHGHOSROL]LRWWRKDXQ¶DOWDFRPSRQHQWHHWLFDHSROLWLFD 'XH VRQR OH WHPDWLFKH SULQFLSDOL GHL URPDQ]L H FRUULVSRQGRQR DOOH GXH DQLPHGL&KHQ&DRLSUREOHPLVRFLDOLQHOOD&LQDGHOOHULIRUPHFKHVRQRLOILOR SULQFLSDOH LQWRUQR DO TXDOH UXRWDQR OH LQGDJLQL HFRPH WHPD VHFRQGDULR PD DPSLDPHQWHSUHVHQWHLOPRQGRGHOODOHWWHUDWXUDVHO¶LVSHWWRUH&KHQ&DRVHP EUDSDUODUHSLXWWRVWRDOSXEEOLFRRFFLGHQWDOHLOSRHWD&KHQ&DRKDO¶RFFKLRUL YROWRDOOHWWRUHFLQHVH6LWUDWWDVHPSUHGLSUREOHPLUHDOLGL6KDQJKDLHGHOOD &LQDJOLVWUDVFLFKLGHOOD5LYROX]LRQHFXOWXUDOHPDLQVLHPHDQFKHJOLHVLWLQH JDWLYLGHOOHULIRUPHOHQXRYHLQJLXVWL]LHVRFLDOLGDXQODWRODFRUUX]LRQHGDO O¶DOWUR6RQRWXWWLDUJRPHQWLGLFXLVLSDUODDPSLDPHQWHDQFKHLQ&LQDSXEEOL FDPHQWH H DQFRU SL LQ SULYDWR /HY\ =KDR <XH]KL .LQNOH\ /H VWRULH UDFFRQWDWH RYYLDPHQWH QRQ YDQQR SUHVH DOOD OHWWHUD VRQR OD VRPPDURPDQ]DWDGLIUDPPHQWLGLVWRULHGLYHUVHPDULQYLDQRVHPSUHDOPHQR ©$SURGXFWRIKLVHGXFDWLRQLQWKHVL[WLHV&KHQPDLQWDLQHGDQRVWDOJLFSDVVLRQIRUDVRUWRI HJDOLWDULDQVRFLHW\ª4LX;LDRORQJS 6HPEUDOHJJHUHGLSLVXDPRJOLH3HLTLQFRQODTXDOHKDFRQGLYLVRO¶HVSHULHQ]DGLµJLRYDQH LVWUXLWR¶ QHOOR <XQQDQ VDUjOHL O¶XQLFDFKH KD OHWWR LO URPDQ]R GHOODVFULWWULFH DVVDVVLQDWD LQ :KHQ5HGLV%ODFNDQFKHVHVHPEUDDYHUOROHWWRSUHYDOHQWHPHQWHLQFKLDYHURPDQWLFDFRPH GHOUHVWRLO6RJQRGHOODFDPHUDURVVD4LX;LDRORQJSS 4XDQGRLOJLDOORVLWLQJHGLURVVRLURPDQ]LGL4LX;LDRORQJ LQSDUWHDIDWWLUHDOPHQWHDFFDGXWL,OSLVHYHURWUDLURPDQ]LHLOSLFRP SOHVVRqVHQ]DGXEELR5HG0DQGDULQ'UHVVGRYHXQDWUDJHGLDSHUVRQDOHHVL WRGHLWUDXPLGHOOD5LYROX]LRQHFXOWXUDOHVLQDVFRQGHGLHWURODIDFFLDWDGLXQD WLSLFDILJXUDµPRGHUQD¶LOEULOODQWHDYYRFDWRLPSHJQDWRLQXQSURFHVVRVRFLDO PHQWHHSROLWLFDPHQWHULOHYDQWHLOSULPRHO¶XOWLPRDWWRGHOGUDPPDVLVYRO JRQR QHOOD OXVVXRVD UHVLGHQ]D GL XQ EDQFKLHUH GHJOL DQQL ¶ FKH VXOO¶RQGD GHOODQRVWDOJLDFROOHWWLYDqVWDWDWUDVIRUPDWDLQXQULVWRUDQWHDOODPRGDLOWXWWR PHQWUHO¶LVSHWWRUH&KHQ&DRVWDVFULYHQGRODVXDWHVLGLPDVWHUVXOODGHPRQL] ]D]LRQHGHOODGRQQDQHOODOHWWHUDWXUDFLQHVHWUDGL]LRQDOH7XWWLLILOLGHOODVWRULD VL LQWUHFFLDQR H O¶DUULQJD ILQDOH GHO JLRYDQH DYYRFDWR q XQ GXULVVLPR DWWR G¶DFFXVDVXOODVRSUDYYLYHQ]DVRWWRODSDWLQDGHOOHULIRUPHGLSHVDQWLUHWDJJL GHOSDVVDWRYLFLQRHORQWDQRqLQGLIHVDGHOOHYLWWLPHGHOODSRWHQWHLPPREL OLDUHPDDQFKHSHUTXHOOHGHOOD5LYROX]LRQHFXOWXUDOHQXOODSRWUHEEHPHJOLR UDSSUHVHQWDUH LO JURYLJOLR GHO SUHVHQWH FRQ LO SDVVDWR GHO QXRYR FRQ LO YHF FKLR 7DOYROWDQHLURPDQ]LVHPEUDGLOHJJHUHQRVWDOJLD©,I&KDLUPDQ0DRZH UHVWLOODOLYHKHZRXOGQHYHUKDYHDOORZHGWKLVWRKDSSHQWRRXUFRXQWU\ª4LX ;LDRORQJSGLFHXQSHUVRQDJJLRWURYDQGRODFRPSUHQVLRQHVHQRQ ODVROLGDULHWjGL<XHORVIRJRqIHGHOPHQWHWUDGRWWRSHULOOHWWRUHFLQHVH,Q UHDOWj q OD FRQVWDWD]LRQH FKH OH ULIRUPH SHU TXDQWR SRVLWLYH QRQ OR VRQR SHU WXWWLHVRSUDWWXWWRqODSUHRFFXSD]LRQHSHU©WKHJDSEHWZHHQULFKDQGSRRU« ZLGHQLQJ OLNH DQ DSSURDFKLQJ HDUWKTXDNHª ,G S 0D ©$IWHU DOO&KLQD¶VEHHQPDNLQJJUHDWSURJUHVVªH&KHQSXzHVVHUHVSHVVR©F\QLFDO DERXWRUFULWLFDORIWKHV\VWHPEXWLQWKHODVWDQDO\VLV«LVUDWKHUGHIHQVLYHRI LWª,GS ,URPDQ]LVLSUHVHQWDQRTXLQGLFRPHXQJUDQGHTXDGURVRFLRSROLWLFRGHO OHWUDVIRUPD]LRQLLQDWWRD6KDQJKDLFRQGLYLGHQGRVRORLQSDUWHPDQRQULILX WDQGRODQRVWDOJLDGLODJDQWHSHUJOLDQQL¶HVHPSUHFRQJUDQGHDWWHQ]LRQH LQYHFH DL SUREOHPL FKH OH QXRYH SROLWLFKH URYHVFLDQR VXOOH IDVFH SL GHEROL GHOODSRSROD]LRQH3LLQJHQHUDOHYHQJRQRSUHVHQWDWLDFFDQWRDJOLDVSHWWLSR $&DVHRI7ZR&LWLHVSHUHVHPSLRULHODERUDODYLFHQGDGL/DL&KDQJ[LQJ䎆᰼ᱏDOFHQWURGL XQRVFDQGDORFKHDYHYDIDWWRJUDQGLVVLPRVFDOSRUHHFDGHUHWHVWHSUHVWLJLRVHODVXDVWRULDqDO FHQWURGLYDULURPDQ]LSXEEOLFDWLLQ53&.LQNOH\SSHQHKDVFULWWRDQFKHLO FRUULVSRQGHQWHGHO7LPHV$XJXVW /DSUHRFFXSD]LRQHSHULULVFKLFKHXQDVLWXD]LRQHFRVuSRWHQ]LDOPHQWHHVSORVLYDFRPSRUWDWUD SHODDQFKHQHOO¶LQVLVWHQ]DGHOGLVFRUVRXIILFLDOHVXOODQHFHVVLWjGLFRVWUXLUHXQDµVRFLHWjDUPR QLRVD¶ 6DQGUD0DULQD&DUOHWWL VLWLYL DQFKH L IHQRPHQL QHJDWLYL FKH OD µPRGHUQL]]D]LRQH¶ DFFHOHUDWD YROXWD GD'HQJFRPSRUWDFRQODFRPPLVWLRQHGLXQFDSLWDOLVPRVHQ]DUHJROHFRQXQ VLVWHPDDSDUWLWRXQLFRHFRQXQ3DUWLWRUHVWLRDFHGHUHOHVXHSUHURJDWLYHPD VSHVVRGLVSRQLELOHDVFHQGHUHDFRPSURPHVVLFRQLQXRYLIHQRPHQLSLVSUH JLXGLFDWL 1p OD FHQWUDOLWj GHO 3DUWLWR YLHQH PHVVD UHDOPHQWH LQ GLVFXVVLRQH FRPHJDUDQWHGLXQDJLXVWL]LDVRFLDOHRJJLSLQHFHVVDULDGLLHULQpYLHQHULIL WDWDODµPRGHUQL]]D]LRQH¶FKHKDFRPXQTXHSRUWDWRPLJOLRUDPHQWLQHOOHFRQ GL]LRQLGLYLWDGLPROWL&LzFKHYLHQHLQYHFHDYDULHULSUHVHVHJQDODWRLQPRGR FULWLFRVRQRJOLHIIHWWLFROODWHUDOLQHJDWLYLGHOODµHFRQRPLDVRFLDOLVWDGLPHUFD WR¶HVRSUDWWXWWROD©VRFLDOSRODUL]DWLRQª6RQRSRVL]LRQLHDUJRPHQWLFKHUL FRUGDQRDOPHQRLQSDUWHTXHOOLGHOODFRVLGGHWWD[LQ]XRSDLᯠᐖ⍮©QXRYD VLQLVWUDª LO WHUPLQH YDJDPHQWH VSUHJLDWLYR FRPXQTXHFULWLFR FRQ LO TXDOH VRQR LQGLFDWL QHO GLEDWWLWR SROLWLFR FLQHVH XQ JUXSSR GL EULOODQWL LQWHOOHWWXDOL FKHKDQQRFHQWUDWRODORURDWWHQ]LRQHSUHRFFXSDWDVXJOLDVSHWWLSROLWLFLHLFRQ IOLWWLVRFLDOLGHOOD&LQDSRVW7LDQ¶DQPHQ:DQJ+XL ÊTXHVWDOD&LQDFKH4LX;LDRORQJYXROHUDFFRQWDUHDOOHWWRUHRFFLGHQWD OHXQDSUHVHQWD]LRQHGHOOD&LQDGLRJJLGDOO¶LQWHUQRHPROWRDUWLFRODWDROWUH FKHSROLWLFDPHQWHVFKLHUDWDDFRPSOHPHQWRRFRUUH]LRQHVLDGHOGLVFRUVRXIIL FLDOHDFULWLFRHWRWDOPHQWHRWWLPLVWLFRVLDGHOOHSRVL]LRQLGLFRQGDQQDDOWUHW WDQWRDFULWLFKHGLPROWLRVVHUYDWRULRFFLGHQWDOLFKHFRQFHQWUDQRODORURDWWHQ ]LRQHVXXQDJHUDUFKLDGLHVLJHQ]HHSUREOHPLFKHULVXOWDQRHVWUDQHLRFRPXQ TXHQRQSULRULWDULSHUWDQWLFLQHVLVLDLQILQHGHJOLVWHUHRWLSLFRVu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q YHUR LQ OLQHD JHQHUDOH FKH XQ WHVWR WUDGRWWR SXz GLUH FRVH SUHFOXVHDXQWHVWRVFULWWRLQFLQHVHGDDXWRUHFLQHVHDOFXQHSRFKHGLIIHUHQ ]HVRQRULVFRQWUDELOLWUDOHGXHYHUVLRQLHDOPHQRXQDQLHQWHDIIDWWRLUULOHYDQ WHFRPHqFRQVXHWRQHOGLVFRUVRSROLWLFRFLQHVHVLFULWLFDQROHLGHHHQRQOH SHUVRQH L FXL QRPL VRQR IDFLOPHQWH LQGLYLGXDWL GDO OHWWRUH 6FRPSDLRQR TXLQGL L QRPL GHL GLULJHQWL SROLWLFL VRQR VRSSUHVVH PROWH SDUWL VHPSOLFH PHQWH HVSOLFDWLYH QRQ QHFHVVDULH SHU XQ OHWWRUH FLQHVH PD LQILQH VRQR RPHVVLLGLDORJKLHOHULIOHVVLRQLVXWHPLµFDOGL¶GLVWUHWWLVVLPDDWWXDOLWjFRQ IHUPDQGR O¶HVWUHPD VHQVLELOLWj DO ULJXDUGR GD SDUWH GHOOH DXWRULWj FLQHVL DG 4XDQGRLOJLDOORVLWLQJHGLURVVRLURPDQ]LGL4LX;LDRORQJ HVHPSLRO¶DOOXVLRQHDLGLVVLGHQWLµIDWWLVSDULUH¶FRPHIRVVHFRVDRYYLDHFRU UHQWHLQ&LQD4LX;LDRORQJSS /¶DOWURJUDQGHWHPDSUHVHQWHQHLURPDQ]LqODOHWWHUDWXUDFRQWLQXHFLWD ]LRQLGDOODSRHVLDFODVVLFDHGDLWHVWLFRQIXFLDQLDPSLVWUDOFLGDLUDFFRQWLFKH &KHQ&DROHJJHSHUODVXDWHVLGLPDVWHULQ5HG0DQGDULQ'UHVVHVHUFL]LGL FULWLFDOHWWHUDULDDWWULEXLWLD3HLTLQLQ:KHQ5HGLV%ODFNLQVHUWLVSDUVLTXDH OjVXSHUVRQDJJLHHYHQWLGHOPRQGROHWWHUDULRQRWD]LRQLYDULHHULSHWXWHVXO PRQGROHWWHUDULRLQVHQVRODWRO¶LQGXVWULDILRUHQWLVVLPD GHOOHHGL]LRQLSLUDWD PRGHHWUHQGGLOHWWXUDSHUILQROHWDULIIHULFRQRVFLXWHDDXWRULHFXUDWRULHLQ XQFDVRXQHSLVRGLRGDOPRQGRGHOODOHWWHUDWXUDSUHQGHODVFHQDDOFHQWURGHO URPDQ]R ODVFLDQGR DOOD WUDVIRUPD]LRQH XUEDQLVWLFD GL 6KDQJKDL LO UDFFRQWR VHFRQGDULR&RQLOVXRLQWUHFFLRGLUHDOWjHILQ]LRQHJOLLQFDVWULGLIUDPPHQWL GLRULJLQHGLYHUVDODUDJQDWHODGLFLWD]LRQLHDOOXVLRQLqXQURPDQ]RPROWRWL SLFRGHOODQDUUDWLYDGL4LX;LDRORQJ ,Q:KHQ5HGLV%ODFNORVFULWWRUHqSURWDJRQLVWDWUHYROWHSRHWDqLOSROL ]LRWWRFKHFRQGXFHO¶LQGDJLQHVFULWWULFHqODYLWWLPDVFULWWRUHqODYLWWLPDGHOOD 5LYROX]LRQHFXOWXUDOHSURWDJRQLVWDDVXDYROWDGHOURPDQ]RGHOODYLWWLPDSHU QRQSDUODUHGL4LX;LDRORQJVWHVVRFKHSUHVWDSDUWLGLVpDLVXRLSHUVRQDJJL ,O µFDVR¶ GD LQGDJDUH ULFKLDPD LPPHGLDWDPHQWH OD ILQH WUDJLFD GL 'DL +RX\LQJ ᡤ㤡 OD VFULWWULFH DVVDVVLQDWD QHO VXR DSSDUWDPHQWR GL6KDQJKDLLODJRVWRO¶RPLFLGDULVXOWHUjHVVHUHXQUDJD]]RDUULYDWR GDOODFDPSDJQDDFHUFDUHODYRURQLSRWHGLXQH[LQVHJQDQWHGL'DL+RX\LQJ 3HUHVHPSLRGLHWURORSVHXGRQLPRµ5DLQ&ORXG¶FHUWRQRQFDVXDOH\XQ\XӁ䴘©QXYROHH SLRJJLDªQHOODWUDGL]LRQHSRHWLFDFLQHVHqVLQRQLPRGLµUDSSRUWRVHVVXDOH¶VLQDVFRQGH+RQJ <LQJ 㲩ᖡ H OD VLQJRODUHVWRULD GL FXLqVWDWDSURWDJRQLVWD4LX ;LDRORQJ S ,Q . +RQJ <LQJ KD URPDQ]DWR OD EUHYH UHOD]LRQH QHOOD &LQD GHJOL DQQL ¶ WUD -XOLDQ %HOOILJOLRGL9DQHVVDHODVFULWWULFHFLQHVH/LQJ6KXKXDॾHODYLFHQGDq LQWHUSUHWDWDFRPHO¶LQFRQWURVFRQWURWUDGXHPRGLRFFLGHQWDOHHRULHQWDOHGLLQWHQGHUHO¶DPR UHHLOVHVVR6DUjFLWDWDLQJLXGL]LRGDYDQWLDXQWULEXQDOHFLQHVHGDOODILJOLDGL/LQJ6KXKXD HQWUDPEHVRQRFLWWDGLQHEULWDQQLFKHSHUµGLIIDPD]LRQHGHJOLDQWHQDWL¶HVDUjFRQGDQQDWD ,OSURJHWWRFLQRDPHULFDQR©1HZ:RUOGª;LQVKLMLHᯠц⭼QHOODYHUVLRQHFLQHVHGHOODFXL WUDGX]LRQH&KHQ&DRVLGHYHRFFXSDUHDOOXGHFRQWXWWDHYLGHQ]DD;LQWLDQGLᯠཙൠ©QXRYR XQLYHUVRªRDQFKH©QXRYRPRQGRªXQQRPHFKHDVXDYROWDHYRFDLO'DVKLMLHབྷц⭼©JUDQ GHPRQGRªLOSLFHOHEUHOXRJRGHOGLYHUWLPHQWR±HGHOYL]LR±QHOOD6KDQJKDLSUHq ODQXRYLVVLPDDUHDGLQHJR]LHORFDOLGLOXVVRQHOODTXDOHqVWDWRFRQVHUYDWRO¶HVWHUQRGHLYHF FKLVKLNXPHQPHQWUHJOLLQWHUQLVRQRUDGLFDOPHQWHULVWUXWWXUDWL©DQFLHQWPHPRULHVMX[WDSRVHG ZLWKPRGHUQOX[XULHVª4LX;LDRORQJS&¶qHIIHWWLYDPHQWHDQFKHXQPXVHRPD QRQ GL ©DQFLHQWFRLQVª,ELGSJOLµDQFLHQWFRLQV¶VRQRQHOODUHDOWjODVWRULFDVHGHGHO SULPRFRQJUHVVRGHO3&&FKHLURQLFDPHQWHqULPDVWDLQJOREDWDQHO;LQWLDQGL 6DQGUD0DULQD&DUOHWWL H FRQRVFLXWR DOOD VFULWWULFH FKH OR DYHYD VRUSUHVR D UXEDUH :X =KRQJMLH ,O IDWWR DYHYD VXVFLWDWR JUDQGH HPR]LRQH QHJOL DPELHQWL OHWWHUDUL GL 6KDQJKDLGRYH'DL+RX\LQJHUDPROWRQRWDGRSRFKHLVXRLURPDQ]LDYHYDQR FRQRVFLXWR EXRQD SRSRODULWj DOO¶LQL]LR GHJOL DQQL ¶ QRQ HVDWWDPHQWH XQD VFULWWULFHµGLVVLGHQWH¶FRPHODSURWDJRQLVWDGL4LX;LDRORQJPDFRLQYROWDQHO GLEDWWLWRVXOWHPDFRQWURYHUVRGHOO¶XPDQHVLPR/¶LGHQWLILFD]LRQHGL<LQ/LJH FRQ'DL+RX\LQJqXOWHULRUPHQWHFRUURERUDWDGDYDULDOWULHOHPHQWLDOFXQLPL QRULPDQRQSULYLGLVLJQLILFDWRSULPRWUDWXWWLLOWLWRORGHOURPDQ]RVHPLDX WRELRJUDILFRGHOTXDOHVRQRDXWULFL6KLUHQ]KLVL䈇Ӫѻ↫©0RUWHGLXQSRH WDªLOWLWRORGL'DL+RX\LQJ-LDRVKRX]KLVLᮉᦸѻ↫©0RUWHGLXQSURIHVVR UHªQHOODILQ]LRQH$QFKH'DLDYHYDDYXWRXQDUHOD]LRQHPROWRFKLDFFKLHUDWD GXUDQWH OD 5LYROX]LRQH FXOWXUDOH XQD VWRULD QRQ WURSSR GLYHUVD GD TXHOOD GL <LQ/LJHH<DQJ%LQJHGHOODTXDOHVLFRQRVFHUDQQRLGHWWDJOLVRORGRSROD VXDPRUWH&RSURWDJRQLVWDGHOODORYHVWRU\HUD:HQ-LH䰫ᦧQR WRSRHWDGHJOLDQQL¶LOµSRHWDURVVR¶DXWRUHGLYHUVLYLVLRQDULVXOOHUHDOL]]D ]LRQL H SURVSHWWLYH GHOOD &LQD VRFLDOLVWD FKH FRPELQDQGR OLULVPR H VRFLDOL VPR DYHYD PHVVR OD VXD SRHVLD DO VHUYL]LR GHOOH VXH FRQYLQ]LRQL SROLWLFKH :DQJSSFLRQRQRVWDQWHHUDVWDWRWUDLSULPLDHVVHUHFULWLFD WRGXUDQWHOD5LYROX]LRQHFXOWXUDOHH'DL+RX\LQJHUDDFDSRGHOJUXSSRGL *XDUGLHURVVHLQFDULFDWRGLµSURFHVVDUOR¶1HLWRUWXRVLVYLOXSSLGHOODORWWDSROL WLFDGHOSHULRGRLGXHVLULWURYHUDQQRLQVLHPHLQFDPSDJQDLQXQDVFXRODSHU ODULHGXFD]LRQHGHLTXDGULHGqOuFKHLQFXUDQWLGLWXWWRHGLWXWWLVLFRQVXPD XQDEUHYHHWUDYROJHQWHVWRULDG¶DPRUHDVVROXWDPHQWHVFDQGDORVD4XDQGROD ORURGRPDQGDGLPDWULPRQLRYLHQHUHVSLQWDHOHLWUDVIHULWDDOWURYHOXLVLVXLFL GDFRQLOJDV,ELG 4LX ;LDRORQJ FKH SUHVHQWD LQ PRGR VRVWDQ]LDOPHQWHIHGHOH OD VWRULD GL <LQ /LJH'DL +RX\LQJ VFHJOLH LQYHFH GL PRGLILFDUHOD FDUDWWHUL]]D]LRQH GHO SURWDJRQLVWDPDVFKLOHQHIDXQSRHWDPROWRSRSRODUHWUDLJLRYDQLQHJOLDQQL FKHSUHFHGRQROD5LYROX]LRQHFXOWXUDOHFRPHGHOUHVWR:HQ-LHSURIHVVRUH GLLQJOHVHFRQXQSHUFRUVRGLVWXGLLQ8VDDOODIRQGD]LRQHGHOOD53&qSD WULRWWLFDPHQWHULHQWUDWRLQ&LQDPDDOODILQHGHJOLDQQL¶qVWDWRFRLQYROWR QHOODFDPSDJQDFRQWURJOLµHOHPHQWLGLGHVWUD¶HSRLGXUDPHQWHFULWLFDWRDOOR VFRSSLRGHOOD5LYROX]LRQHFXOWXUDOHXQWULVWHSHUFRUVRGLYLWDIUHTXHQWHSUHVVR PROWLLQWHOOHWWXDOLHDUJRPHQWRGLWDQWDQDUUDWLYDQHOGHFHQQLRVXFFHVVLYRDOOD 5LYROX]LRQHFXOWXUDOH1HJOLDQQLDPHULFDQL<DQJKDFRPLQFLDWRDVFULYHUHLQ ÊOXLLOµURVVR¶GHOWLWRORLOµSRHWDURVVR¶SRLFULWLFDWRFRPHµQHUR¶GXUDQWHOD5LYROX]LRQHFXO WXUDOH 4XDQGRLOJLDOORVLWLQJHGLURVVRLURPDQ]LGL4LX;LDRORQJ LQJOHVHHDQFKHLOVXRURPDQ]RXQµ'RWWRUäLYDJRFLQHVH¶FKHVHJUHWDPHQWH qULXVFLWRDVFULYHUHPHQWUHHUDDOODµVFXRODGHLTXDGUL¶VDUHEEHVFULWWRLQLQ JOHVH0DqLQWURYDELOH 4XLOHVWRULHGHOSRHWD:HQ-LHHGHOSRHWDSURIHVVRUH<DQJ%LQJWRUQDQR DVRYUDSSRUVL/¶XOWLPDSDUWHGLXQOXQJRSRHPDFKH:HQ-LHFRQVLGHUDYDLO VXRFDSRODYRURqVWDWDSUHOHYDWDGDOOH*XDUGLHURVVHQHOFRUVRGLXQ¶LQFXUVLR QHQHOODVXDFDVDHGqSHUGXWDSHUVHPSUH 3LIRUWXQDWRLOVXRDOWHUHJROHWWHUDULR$FRQFOXVLRQHGHOO¶LQFKLHVWDO¶L VSHWWRUH&KHQ&DRULHVFHDWURYDUHLOPDQRVFULWWRLQHGLWRGHOYHFFKLRSURIHV VRUHHSULPDGLFRQVHJQDUORDOO¶8IILFLRGLSROL]LDLQVHJUHWRORIRWRFRSLDFRQ LOSURSRVLWRGLIDUORSXEEOLFDUHÊDOORUDLOSRHWD&KHQ&DRFKHUHDOL]]DLOVR JQRGL<DQJ%LQJHQHOODILQ]LRQHOHWWHUDULDYHQGLFDO¶ROWUDJJLRGHOOH*XDU GLHURVVHDOSRHWD:HQ-LH %,%/,2*5$),$ $XJXVW2,QVLGHWKH5HG0DQVLRQ2QWKH7UDLORI&KLQD¶V0RVW:DQWHG0DQ/RQGRQ -RKQ0XUUD\>WUDGLW,OIXJJLDVFRGL;LDPHQ0LODQR$GHOSKL@ &KHPOD.0DUWLQ)³©5HQGUHj&pVDUª"2XGHO¶LGHQWLILFDWLRQGHVWHFKQLTXHVGHVVL JQLILFDWLRQV GHV VRXUFHV HW GHV PRWLYDWLRQV GH ODFLWDWLRQ´ LQ([WUrPH2ULHQW ([WUrPH 2FFLGHQW/HWUDYDLOGHODFLWDWLRQHQ&KLQHHWDX-DSRQSS YDQ *XOLN 5+ ³7UDQVODWHU¶V 3UHIDFH´ LQ ,G WUDG 7KUHH 0XUGHU &DVHV 6ROYHG E\ -XGJH'HH7RN\R7RSSDQ3ULQWLQJ&RPSDQ\SSL[[LLL +H-LDKRQJ/DGRQQDSD]]D0LODQR0XUVLD ,RYHQH 3 ³:K\ LV 7KHUH D 3RHP LQ 7KLV 6WRU\" /L 6KDQJ\LQ¶V 3RHWU\ &RQWHPSRUDU\ &KLQHVH/LWHUDWXUHDQGWKH)XWXUHVRIWKH3DVW´LQ0RGHUQ&KLQHVH/LWHUDWXUHDQG&XO WXUHSS .LQNOH\ -& &KLQHVH -XVWLFH WKH )LFWLRQ /DZ DQG /LWHUDWXUH LQ 0RGHUQ &KLQD 6WDQ IRUG6WDQIRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV &RPH4LX;LDRORQJ<DQJ%LQJqXQWLSLFRSHUVRQDJJLRFRPSRVLWRVRQRTXDQWRPHQRULFR QRVFLELOLHOHPHQWLFKHULQYLDQRD:HQ-LHDOWULD<DQJ;LDQ\Lᶘᇚ⳺LOIDPRVRWUD GXWWRUHGLWDQWLFODVVLFLFLQHVLSHUQRQGLUHGHOORVWHVVR4LX;LDRORQJVH&KHQ&DRFHUWRLQ VLQWRQLD FRQ 4LX ©IHOW DQ DIILQLW\ WR <DQJ D SRHW DV ZHOO DV D WUDQVODWRUª 4LX ;LDRORQJ SO¶DQWRORJLDGLWUDGX]LRQLGLSRHVLDFLQHVHGL<DQJGHVFULYHLQHTXLYRFDELOPHQWH 7UHDVXU\RI&KLQHVH/RYH3RHPV,ELGSSHXQDSRHVLDµGL<DQJ¶qSXEEOLFDWDLQXQD UDFFROWDGL4LX;LDRORQJSSES 8QDUHFHQWHUDFFROWDGLSRHVLHGL:HQ-LHSSFRQWLHQHLOSRHPDHGqPXWLOR GHOODTXLQWDSDUWH 6DQGUD0DULQD&DUOHWWL ² &RUUXSWLRQ DQG 5HDOLVP LQ /DWH 6RFLDOLVW &KLQD 7KH 5HWXUQ RI WKH 3ROLWLFDO 1RYHO 6WDQIRUG6WDQIRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV /HY\ 5 ³&RUUXSWLRQ LQ 3RSXODU &XOWXUH´ LQ3 /LQN 53 0DGVHQ 3* 3LFNRZLF] HGV3RSXODU&KLQD8QRIILFLDO&XOWXUHLQD*OREDOL]LQJ6RFLHW\/DQKDP5RZPDQ /LWWOHILHOG3XEOLVKHUVSS 4LX;LDRORQJ'HDWKRID5HG+HURLQH1HZ<RUN6RKR3UHVV>WUDGFLQ+RQJ\LQJ]KLVL 㓒㤡ѻ↫6KDQJKDL6KDQJKDLZHQ\LFKXEDQVKHWUDGLW/DPLVWHULRVDPRUWHGHOOD FRPSDJQD*XDQ9HQH]LD0DUVLOLR@ ²$/R\DO&KDUDFWHU'DQFHU1HZ<RUN6RKR3UHVV>WUDGFLQ:DLWDQKXD\XDQཆ┙㣡 ഝ 6KDQJKDL 6KDQJKDL ZHQ\L FKXEDQVKH WUDG LW 9LVWR SHU 6KDQJKDL 9HQH]LD 0DUVLOLR@ ²WUDG7UHDVXU\RI&KLQHVH/RYH3RHPVLQ&KLQHVHDQG(QJOLVK1HZ<RUN+LSSR FUHQH%RRNV ² :KHQ 5HG LV %ODFN 1HZ <RUN 6RKR 3UHVV >WUDG FLQ 6KLNXPHQ OLJH⸣ᓃ䰘傺ⅼ 6KDQJKDL 6KDQJKDL ZHQ\L FKXEDQVKH WUDG LW 4XDQGR LO URVVR q QHUR 9HQH]LD 0DUVLOLR@ ²WUDG7DQJ6RQJVKLFLVKRXୀᆻ䈇䇽俆3RHPVRI7DQJDQG6RQJ'\QDVWLHV 6KDQJKDL+XDGRQJVKLIDQGD[XHFKXEDQVKH ² $ &DVH RI 7ZR &LWLHV 1HZ <RUN 6W 0DUWLQ¶V 3UHVV >WUDG LW 5DWWL URVVL 9HQH]LD 0DUVLOLR@ ²5HG0DQGDULQ'UHVV1HZ<RUN6W0DUWLQ¶V3UHVV ²D&LWpGHOD3RXVVLqUH5RXJH3DULV/LDQD/HYL ²E/LQHV$URXQG&KLQD6W/RXLV1HVKXL3UHVV ²7KH0DR&DVH1HZ<RUN6W0DUWLQ¶V3UHVV :DQJ'DYLG'HUZHL³7KH(QGRIWKH/LQH´LQ,G7KH0RQVWHUWKDWLV+LVWRU\+LVWRU\ 9LROHQFHDQG)LFWLRQDO:ULWLQJLQ7ZHQWLHWKFHQWXU\&KLQD%HUNHOH\8QLYHUVLW\RI&DOL IRUQLD3UHVVSS :DQJ+XL&KLQD¶V1HZ2UGHU6RFLHW\3ROLWLFVDQG(FRQRP\LQ7UDQVLWLRQ&DPEULGJH +DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV>WUDGLW,OQXRYRRUGLQHFLQHVH6RFLHWjSROLWLFDHGHFRQRPLDLQ WUDQVL]LRQH5RPD0DQLIHVWROLEUL@ :HQ-LH䰫ᦧ=KRQJJXRGDQJGDLPLQJVKLUHQ[XDQML:HQ-LHѝഭᖃԓ䈇Ӫ䘹䳶䰫 ᦧ>$QWRORJLH GL IDPRVL SRHWL FLQHVL FRQWHPSRUDQHL :HQ -LH@%HLMLQJ 5HQPLQ ZHQ[XH FKXEDQVKH :X=KRQJMLHѝᶠ³'DL+RX\LQJ]KLVLᡤ㤡ѻ↫´>/DPRUWHGL'DL+RX\LQJ@LQ,G 5HQVKHQJGD[LFKDQJӪ⭏བྷᠿ൪-LQDQ6KDQGRQJ\RX\LFKXEDQVKHSS <DQ<LQJ5HFHQVLRQHGL4LX;LDRORQJLQ0RGHUQ/DQJXDJH6WXGLHV SS =KDR<XH]KL³7KH5LFKWKH/DLGRIIDQGWKH&ULPLQDOLQ7DEORLG7DOHV5HDG$OODERXW ,W´LQ3HUU\/LQN530DGVHQ3*3LFNRZLF]HGV3RSXODU&KLQD8QRIILFLDO&XO WXUHLQD*OREDOL]LQJ6RFLHW\/DQKDP5RZPDQ/LWWOHILHOG3XEOLVKHUVSS /8&,$&$7(5,1$ %UHYLQRWHVXOO¶LFRQRJUDILDFLQHVHGHOO¶DUWHG¶HVSRUWD]LRQH /DSDVVLRQHGHJOLRFFLGHQWDOLSHULPDWHULDOLSURYHQLHQWLGDOO¶(VWUHPR2 ULHQWHVLqEDVDWDILQGDOO¶LQL]LRVXDOFXQHLPSRUWDQWLFDUDWWHULVWLFKHFKHKDQ QR FRQWULEXLWR LQ PRGR GHWHUPLQDQWH DOOR VYLOXSSR H DOOD IRUWXQD GL WDOL SUR GRWWL5HTXLVLWLHVVHQ]LDOLVRQRVWDWLO¶HOHYDWDTXDOLWjGHLPDQXIDWWLHVSRUWDWLL FRVWLDFFHVVLELOLHVRSUDWWXWWRLOULFFRUHSHUWRULRLFRQRJUDILFRFKHODVFLDYDLP PDJLQDUH PRQGL ORQWDQL H PLVWHULRVL H VRGGLVIDFHYDXQ GLIIXVR GHVLGHULR GL HVRWLVPR /D SUHVHQ]D WUD TXHVWL SURGRWWL GL PDWHULDOL VFRQRVFLXWL LQ (XURSD TXDOLSRUFHOODQDHODFFDQRQSRWHYDFKHDFXLUHLOGHVLGHULRGHOSRVVHVVRGLWDOL EHQL/DSDUWLFRODUHDWWUDWWLYDVXVFLWDWDGDOODYDULHWjHGDOODULFFKH]]DGHLGHFR UL KD FRQWULEXLWR HQRUPHPHQWH DOO¶DPPLUD]LRQH SHU L PDQXIDWWL RULHQWDOL DS SUH]]DWLHJUDGLWLGDOOHpOLWHVRFFLGHQWDOLGLFXLPROWRVSHVVRKDQQRUDSSUHVHQ WDWRXQRVWDWXVV\PERO ÊSRVVLELOHDQDOL]]DUHLOUHSHUWRULRLFRQRJUDILFRFLQHVHGHLPDWHULDOLGH VWLQDWLDOO¶HVSRUWD]LRQHHVDPLQDQGRLYDULVFKHPLGHFRUDWLYLFKHGDQQROXRJR DLPSDJLQDWLGLIIHUHQWLGDTXHOOLFRQRUQDWLHVFOXVLYDPHQWHFLQHVLDTXHOOLFRQ XQ¶LQWHJUD]LRQHGLHOHPHQWLRFFLGHQWDOLDGDOWULDQFRUDFRQPRWLYLXQLFDPHQWH RFFLGHQWDOLHLQILQHDTXHOOLWLSLFDPHQWHFLQHVLUHDOL]]DWL SHULOPHUFDWRRFFL GHQWDOH$WWUDYHUVRDOFXQLHVHPSLVDUjSRVVLELOHYHULILFDUHO¶HYROX]LRQHGLWDOL LFRQRJUDILHQHOFRUVRGHLVHFROLILQGDOPRPHQWRLQL]LDOHGHLFRQWDWWLGLUHWWLWUD HXURSHLHFLQHVL 1HO&LQTXHFHQWRO¶DUULYRGHLSRUWRJKHVLLQ&LQDIDYRULVFHXQ¶LQWHQVDDW WLYLWjFRPPHUFLDOHHSULPH IRUPHGLFRPPLWWHQ]D*LXQJRQRFRVuLQ(XURSD PDJQLILFKHSRUFHOODQHGHFRUDWHLQEOXFREDOWRVRWWRFRSHUWDFRQRUQDWLLQVWLOH FLQHVH FDUDWWHUL]]DWH GD PRWLYL IORUHDOL JLRFKL GL ELPEL DQLPDOL IDQWDVWLFL SDHVDJJL DFTXDWLFL ILRUL H XFFHOOL (VHPSOLILFDQRTXHVWL SULPL SH]]L DOFXQH /XFLD&DWHULQD FRSSHFRQVFULWWHLQODWLQRFKHVLULIHULVFRQRDOJRYHUQDWRUHGL0DODFFD3HGUR GH )DULDHUHFDQRODGDWDGHORSSXUHERWWLJOLHUHDOL]]DWHVXRUGLQHGHO FDSLWDQR-RUJH$OYDUHV GDWDWH RDQFRUDFRSSH SLDWWL EURFFKH H ERWWL JOLH FRQ VFULWWH UHOLJLRVH FKH VL DFFRPSDJQDQR DOOD VIHUD DUPLOODUH HPEOHPD GHOUH0DQXHO,EODVRQLUHDOLHQRELOLDULVLPEROLUHOLJLRVL PR QRJUDPPLGHOOD&RPSDJQDGL*HVILJJ/¶RUQDWRqGLWLSRFLQHVHFRQ PRWLYL IORUHDOL JHRPHWULFL H DQLPDOL IDQWDVWLFL PHQWUH OD WDYROR]]D LQL]LDO PHQWHLQELDQFRHEOXGLYHQWDVXFFHVVLYDPHQWHSROLFURPDFRQXQ¶HQIDVLSDU WLFRODUH SHU XQR VWLOH GL GHULYD]LRQH JLDSSRQHVH GHQRPLQDWR ³,PDUL FLQHVH´ FDUDWWHUL]]DWRGDOEOXFREDOWRVRWWRFRSHUWDHGDOURVVRIHUURHGDOO¶RURVRSUD FRSHUWD 1HO 6HLFHQWR FRQWLQXD OD SURGX]LRQH GHO ELDQFR H EOX LQ SDUWLFRODUH GL TXHOOR FKLDPDWR ³NUDDN´ GDO QRPH GHOOH FDUDFFKH SRUWRJKHVL FDWWXUDWH GDJOL RODQGHVLFKHVXEHQWUDQRDTXHVWLXOWLPLQHLFRPPHUFLLQ2ULHQWHÊ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qVRJJHWWDDLQFUHGLELOLHSHVDQ WLUHVWUL]LRQLWUDFXLO¶LPSRVVLELOLWjGLSRWHUVLPXRYHUHVHQRQQHOODVWUHWWDVWUL VFLDGLWHUUDOXQJRLOILXPHGHOOH3HUOHGRYHVLWURYDQRLYDULVWDELOLPHQWLGHOOH &RPSDJQLHHLOGLYLHWRGLFRPXQLFDUHFRQODSRSROD]LRQHORFDOHDHFFH]LRQH GHJOL LQWHUSUHWL H GHJOL LQWHUPHGLDUL DXWRUL]]DWL *OL RFFLGHQWDOL FRQGXFRQR TXLQGLXQDYLWDGDUHFOXVLVHQ]DGRQQHHLQDWWHVDGHOPRQVRQHIDYRUHYROHSHU SRWHU ULSDUWLUH FRQ QDYL FDULFKH GL PHUFL SUH]LRVHFKH VRQR ORUR FRQVHJQDWH VHQ]DDOFXQDSRVVLELOLWjGLFRQWUROORGDJOLLQWHUPHGLDULDLTXDOLYHQJRQRIDWWH RUGLQD]LRQLGLRJQLWLSRVSHVVRLQFRPSUHQVLELOLDJOLDUWLJLDQLFLQHVL,GHFRUL SUHVHQWDQREODVRQLQRELOLDULLQVHULWLVSHVVRLQRUQDWLLQVWLOHFLQHVHPHQWUHOH &DWHULQDSSILJJ&DWHULQD /LRQ*ROGVFKPLGWSSGH&DVWUR 5LQDOGL %HXUGHOH\-|UJ %UHYLQRWHVXOO¶LFRQRJUDIDFLQHVHGHOO¶DUWHG¶HVSRUWD]LRQH ULFKLHVWHHXURSHHVLEDVDQRVRSUDWWXWWRVXOOHIRUPHGHOYDVHOODPHGDWDYRODFKH VLGHYRQRDGDWWDUHDXQDPHQVDRFFLGHQWDOHILJ6RQRFRVuRUGLQDWLLQWHUL VHUYL]LFRQXQQXPHURLQFUHGLELOHGLSH]]LGDOOHWHUULQHDOOH]XSSLHUHPRVWDU GLHUHROLHUHVDOVLHUHSHSLHUHFDIIHWWLHUHERFFDOLILJ$LVHUYL]LGDWDYROD VLDIILDQFDQRRUGLQD]LRQLSHURJJHWWLRUQDPHQWDOLGDXWLOL]]DUHQHOO¶DUUHGRGHO OHGLPRUHLQSDWULDFRVWLWXLWLGDVHULHGLYDVLGDVLVWHPDUHVXFDPLQLRPHQVROH H GD VWDWXHWWH GL YDULH GLPHQVLRQL ILJJ /¶LPSRVVLELOLWj GL FRPXQLFDUH GLUHWWDPHQWHFRQJOLDUWLJLDQLGHOOHPDQLIDWWXUHFRVWULQJHJOLHXURSHLDVHUYLUVL GLPRGHOOLUHDOL]]DWLLQYDULPDWHULDOLTXDOLOHJQRRPHWDOORRSSXUHGLGLVHJQL HVWDPSHGDIDUULSURGXUUHVXLSH]]LFRPPLVVLRQDWL /HIRUPHGHLUHFLSLHQWLUHDOL]]DWLLQVHULHRTXHOOLGLJUDQGLGLPHQVLRQLUL SURGXFRQRO¶DELWXGLQHFLQHVHGLVLVWHPDUHJUXSSLGLYDVLWUHJOREXODULHGXHD WURPEDGDYDQWLDJOLDOWDULFRPHSXUHOHVWDWXHWWHFRVWLWXLVFRQRVSHVVRO¶DUUH GR GL ³VWDQ]H FLQHVL´HSUHVHQWDQRXQD JUDQGH YDULHWj VLD QHOOD WDYROR]]D VLD QHOO¶LFRQRJUDILDILJ7UDTXHOOHLQSRUFHOODQDSROLFURPDFRPSDLRQRWUDOH DOWUHOHLPPDJLQLGHOUHGL)UDQFLD/XLJL;,9FRQDFFDQWR0DGDPHGH0DLQ WHQRQR0DGDPHGH0RQWHVSDQULSURGRWWHGDVWDPSHLQYLDWHLQ2ULHQWHDEEL JOLDWLVHFRQGRODPRGDGHOO¶HSRFDFRQSDUUXFFKHHFULQROLQHILJ&RPXQL VRQRSXUHILJXUHSROLFURPHGLSHUVRQDJJLHXURSHLLQSDUWLFRODUHRODQGHVL 0ROWRSRSRODULVRQRVRSUDWWXWWRVWDWXHWWHLQXQWLSRGLSRUFHOODQDELDQFD SURGRWWD D 'HKXD QHOOD SURYLQFLD PHULGLRQDOH GHO )XMLDQ FKLDPDWDEODQF GH &KLQH4XHVWHVFXOWXUHSHUODPDJJLRUSDUWHUDSSUHVHQWDQRXQ¶LFRQRJUDILDFL QHVHFRQXQDSUHIHUHQ]DSHUOHGLYLQLWjEXGGKLVWHHGDRLVWH0DDFFDQWRDXQ UHSHUWRULRWLSLFDPHQWHFLQHVHYLVRQRDQFKHUDIILJXUD]LRQLGLVWUDQLHULVLDLVR ODWLVLDLQJUXSSLDLOOXVWUDUHODYLWDGHJOLRODQGHVLHGHOOHORURIDPLJOLHFDUDW WHUL]]DWL GD OLQHDPHQWL DELWL H DFFRQFLDWXUH RFFLGHQWDOL ULFDYDWL GD VWDPSH H GLVHJQLLQYLDWLDOOHPDQLIDWWXUHFLQHVLHULSURGRWWLGDJOLDUWLJLDQLVSHVVRLQPR GRDEEDVWDQ]DJRIIRILJ/DSURGX]LRQHGHOEODQFGH&KLQHFKHGLYHQWD PROWRSRSRODUHLQ2FFLGHQWHVDUjLPLWDWDDQFKHLQ(XURSDDJOLLQL]LGHO6HWWH FHQWRTXDQGRVLFRPLQFHUjDIDEEULFDUHODSRUFHOODQD /DUDSSUHVHQWD]LRQHGLSHUVRQDJJLVWUDQLHULQRQFRVWLWXLVFHSHUzXQDQR YLWjSHUOHPDHVWUDQ]HFLQHVL*LjLQHSRFD7DQJTXDQGRODVRFLHWj HUDFRVPRSROLWDHPROWLHUDQRJOLVWUDQLHULFKHYLYHYDQRHODYRUDYDQRLQ&LQD IUHTXHQWLHUDQRWDOLLPPDJLQLFKHDOO¶HSRFDULSURGXFHYDQRSRSROD]LRQLDVLDWL FKHPHQWUHQHLVHFROL;9,,H;9,,,JOLVWUDQLHULUDIILJXUDWLVRQRHXURSHLHOD +RZDUG/XQVLQJK6FKHXUOHHU 'RQQHOO\%OXPHQILHOG /XFLD&DWHULQD GHVWLQD]LRQH GHL SH]]L UHDOL]]DWL q YHUVR O¶2FFLGHQWH /D UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH GL SHUVRQDJJLHVRWLFLGXUDQWHODGLQDVWLD7DQJHQIDWL]]DYDLQPRGRTXDVLFDUL FDWXUDOH DOFXQH FDUDWWHULVWLFKH VRPDWLFKH DFFHQWXDQGR OD JUDQGH]]D GHL QDVL ODVSRUJHQ]DGHJOLRFFKLODSUHVHQ]DGLILWWDSHOXULDJOLDELWLGLWDJOLRVWUDQLH UR PHQWUH QHO ;9,,, VHFROR OD UDIILJXUD]LRQH GHJOL HXURSHL PRVWUD FDUDWWHUL VWLFKHILVLFKHPHQRDFFHQWXDWHHPHQRJURWWHVFKH $OWULVRJJHWWLRFFLGHQWDOLVXOOHSRUFHOODQHG¶HVSRUWD]LRQHVLGLYHUVLILFDQR DVHFRQGDGHOODGHVWLQD]LRQH3HULOPHUFDWRRODQGHVHIUHTXHQWLVRQROHYHGX WHGHOOHFLWWjRODQGHVLVRSUDWWXWWRGL$PVWHUGDPFRPHSXUHORVWHPPDGHOOD &RPSDJQLDGHOOH,QGLH2ULHQWDOL92&QDYLHPHUFDQWLVWRULDGHOO¶DPEDVFH ULDRODQGHVHLQ&LQDQHOPHQWUHSHULOPHUFDWRLQJOHVHFRPXQLVRQROH YHGXWHGHLSRVVHGLPHQWLLQJOHVLLQ,QGLDVFHQHGL/RQGUDEODVRQLQRELOLDULOR VWHPPDGHOOD&RPSDJQLD,QJOHVHVROGDWLVFR]]HVLULWUDWWLGLQRELOL ,O6HWWHFHQWRqLOVHFRORLQFXLFLVDUDQQRRUGLQDWLYLHULFKLHVWHGLRJQLWL SR1XPHURVLVRJJHWWLHPRWLYLRFFLGHQWDOLHQWUHUDQQRDIDUSDUWHGHOUHSHUWR ULRFLQHVHFRQERUGXUHHFDUWLJOLHVHJXLWL³DOO¶RFFLGHQWDOH´FRQO¶LQVHULPHQWR GLHOHPHQWLIORUHDOLGLYHUVLHFRQVFHQHPLWRORJLFKHVWRULFKHOHWWHUDULHVLP EROLPDVVRQLFLULFDYDWLGDOODWUDGL]LRQHRFFLGHQWDOHHGHVHJXLWLGDLFLQHVLDW WUDYHUVR L PRGHOOL PDQGDWL GDOOH &RPSDJQLH GHOOH ,QGLH 2ULHQWDOL 6RQR FRVu UHDOL]]DWLDGHVHPSLRSHULOPHUFDWRIUDQFHVHDOODILQHGHO6HWWHFHQWRVHUYL]L GDWDYRODLQPHPRULDGL/XLJL;9,HGL0DULD$QWRQLHWWDEDVDWLVXOODULSURGX ]LRQHGLXQDVWDPSDDQRQLPD³/¶XUQDPLVWHULRVD´LQFXLVXOSLHGLVWDOORGHO O¶XUQDHWUDLUDPLGLVDOLFHVLVWDJOLDQRLQELDQFRLSURILOLGHLUHDOLGL)UDQFLD 6X DOWUL HVHPSODUL WUD LO IRJOLDPH GHJOL DOEHUL VLVFRUJRQR DQFKH L SURILOL GHO GHOILQRHGHOODPDGDPDUHDOHILJ )UHTXHQWLVRQROHUDSSUHVHQWD]LRQLGHOODYLWDGHJOLHXURSHLHVHPSOLILFDWH GDVFHQHVWRULFKHSROLWLFKHOHWWHUDULHGLFDFFLDJDODQWLHGHURWLFKHRSSXUHGD ILJXUHGHOOD&RPPHGLDGHOO¶$UWHXWLOL]]DWHFRQVFULWWHVDWLULFKHLQRODQGHVHFR PHDPPRQLPHQWRFRQWUROHGLVDVWURVHVSHFXOD]LRQLILQDQ]LDULHHFFILJ /¶LQWHUHVVH QHO ULFHYHUH SURGRWWL SL YLFLQL DO JXVWR RFFLGHQWDOH SRUWD OD &RPSDJQLD 2ODQGHVH D FRPPLVVLRQDUH QHO DO SLWWRUH &RUQHOLV 3URQN DOFXQL GLVHJQL GD IDU HVHJXLUH DOOH PDHVWUDQ]H FLQHVL /D GLIIX VLRQH GL PDWHULDOL RULHQWDOL q WDOH FKH OR VWHVVR 3URQN ILQLVFH FRO ULFKLDPDUVL QHLVXRLGLVHJQLDLFRQRJUDILHSUHVHQWLLQSDUWLFRODUHVXSRUFHOODQHVLDFLQHVL -|UJ+\GH*RUGRQ 3HU XQ HVDXULHQWH UHSHUWRULR VXOOH SRUFHOODQH FLQHVL FRQ GHFRUL RFFLGHQWDOL YHGL +RZDUG $\HUV+HUYRXsW+HUYRXsW%UXQHDX %UHYLQRWHVXOO¶LFRQRJUDIDFLQHVHGHOO¶DUWHG¶HVSRUWD]LRQH VLDJLDSSRQHVLFXVWRGLWHDOO¶HSRFDLQPROWHGLPRUHHXURSHHÊFRVuSURGRWWRLQ &LQDLQYDULHWDYROR]]HYDVHOODPHFRQGHFRULFUHDWLGD3URQNTXDOL³ODGDPD FRQO¶RPEUHOOLQR´³LGRWWRUL´³LOSHUJRODWR´6RORLOGLVHJQRGDOOD³GDPDFRQ O¶RPEUHOOLQR´ULVFXRWHXQQRWHYROHVXFFHVVRHGqUHDOL]]DWRSHUWXWWRLO6HWWH FHQWR DQFKH LQ *LDSSRQH PHQWUH JOL DOWUL GHFRUL FRQVLGHUDWL WURSSR FRVWRVL VRQRUDSLGDPHQWHHOLPLQDWLGDOODSURGX]LRQHILJJ /¶HVSRUWD]LRQHGLSRUFHOODQDJLDSSRQHVHDYHYDDYXWRXQULIOHVVRVLJQLIL FDWLYRHDYHYDRULHQWDWRLQPRGRGLYHUVRLOJXVWRGHJOLRFFLGHQWDOLFKHFRPLQ FLDQRDSUHIHULUHWDYROR]]HSROLFURPHLQFXLVLFRPELQDQRLOEOXFREDOWRVRWWR FRSHUWDHLOURVVRIHUURHO¶RURVRSUDFRSHUWDLQXQWLSRFKLDPDWR,PDULGDOQR PHGHOSRUWRJLDSSRQHVHGDFXLDYYHQJRQROHHVSRUWD]LRQLRSSXUHXQDJDP PDGLVPDOWLSROLFURPLWUDLTXDOLVLVWDJOLDXQURVVRDUDQFLDWRFRORUNDNLGD FXLLOQRPH.DNLHPRQDOODIDPLJOLDGLYDVDLFKHLQL]LDODSURGX]LRQH,OVXF FHVVRGHOOHWDYROR]]HSROLFURPHJLDSSRQHVLqLOULVXOWDWRGLXQDGLIIHUHQWHLP SDJLQD]LRQHGHOGHFRURGLXQDYLVWRVDULFFKH]]DFURPDWLFDGHULYDWDGDJOLRU QDWLGHLWHVVXWLQHOFDVRGHOORVWLOH,PDULPHQWUHXQDWDYROR]]DGDOOHWRQDOLWj GHOLFDWHHGDJOLDPSvVSD]LYXRWLFDUDWWHUL]]DORVWLOHNDNLHPRQ ,OYDVHOODPHJLDSSRQHVHJLXQJHLQ2FFLGHQWHQHOODVHFRQGDPHWjGHO6HL FHQWR SHU IDU IURQWH DOOD PDQFDQ]DGL HVSRUWD]LRQLGDOOD &LQD LQWHUURWWH SHU L JUDYLSUREOHPLSROLWLFLFKHDWWUDYHUVDLOSDHVH /DULDSHUWXUDGHOPHUFDWRFLQHVHDOODILQHGHO;9,,VHFRORSLHFRQRPL FRHPHJOLRRUJDQL]]DWRSHUIDUIURQWHDXQDSURGX]LRQHGLPDVVDFRQWULEXL VFHDVRGGLVIDUHFRQWLQXHHVWUDYDJDQWLULFKLHVWHRFFLGHQWDOLVLDGLIRUPHVLDGL GHFRUL /D ULSURGX]LRQH SXQWXDOH GHOOH VWDPSH RFFLGHQWDOLSXU VH FRQ XQD UHVD LQGLVFXWLELOPHQWH FLQHVH Gj OXRJR D XQ WLSR GL SRUFHOODQD GHILQLWD HQFUH GH &KLQHSURSULRSHULOWHQWDWLYRSLRPHQRULXVFLWRGLLPLWDUHOHVWDPSHHLGL VHJQLRFFLGHQWDOLFRQWHFQLFKHGHILQLWHHQFDPDLHXRHQJULVDLOOH/¶HVHFX]LR QHFLQHVHqYLVLELOHVRSUDWWXWWRQHOOHUDIILJXUD]LRQLGHLSHUVRQDJJLHQHOODGH VFUL]LRQHGLDFFHVVRULHSDUWLFRODULFRQLPPDJLQLHDELWLGDOO¶DVSHWWRLEULGRH GDOOHSURSRU]LRQLSRFRHTXLOLEUDWH8QHVHPSLRLQWDOVHQVRqXQSLDWWRFXVWR GLWR QHO PXVHR 'XFD GL 0DUWLQD GL 1DSROL LVSLUDWR D XQD VWDPSD GL &ODXGH 'XIORVGDOWLWROR³/HEDLQ´LQFXLqUDIILJXUDWDXQDGRQQDLQWHQWD DIDUHXQEDJQRDVVLVWLWDGDXQGRPHVWLFRFKHYHUVDGHOO¶DFTXDQHOODYDVFD/D VFHQDWUDWWDGDOODVWDPSDIUDQFHVHqOLPLWDWDVXOO¶RUORGDXQDERUGXUDGHOWLSR -|UJ&DWHULQD /XFLD&DWHULQD ODXEXQGEDXGHOZHUNFDUDWWHULVWLFDGHOODSURGX]LRQHYLHQQHVHGL&ODXGLXV,Q QRFHQWLXV'X3DTXLHULQYRJDWUDLOHLOILJ 1HOODVHFRQGDPHWjGHO6HWWHFHQWRPROWLSURGRWWLSHUO¶HVSRUWD]LRQHVRQR UHDOL]]DWLQHLODERUDWRULGL&DQWRQGRYHqSRVVLELOHFKHFLVLDXQFRQWUROORGL UHWWRGHJOLRFFLGHQWDOLFKHULHVFRQRFRVuDVHJXLUHO¶LQWHURSURFHVVRODYRUDWLYR 1RQ VL GHFRUDQR VROR SRUFHOODQH PDQGDWH LQ ELDQFR GDOOH IRUQDFL GL -LQJGH ]KHQQHOODSURYLQFLDGHO-LDQJ[LLOSULQFLSDOHFHQWURSHUODPDQLIDWWXUDGHOOD SRUFHOODQDG¶HVSRUWD]LRQHPDVLHVHJXRQRPROWLDOWULPDQXIDWWLULFKLHVWLGDJOL VWUDQLHUL6LSURGXFRQRVPDOWLODFFKHDFTXHUHOOLDOEXPFRQLPPDJLQLGLSLQ WHFDUWHGDSDUDWLRJJHWWLLQPDGUHSHUODLQDYRULR6LXWLOL]]DXQRVWHVVRUH SHUWRULRLFRQRJUDILFRGHULYDWRTXDVLVHPSUHGDOODSLWWXUDULSURGRWWRVXFFHVVL YDPHQWHVXLPDQXDOLDGXVRGHLODERUDWRULHDGRSHUDWRDQFKHVXLPDWHULDOLGH VWLQDWL DOO¶HVSRUWD]LRQH 7DOL UHDOL]]D]LRQL DYYHQJRQR LQ ERWWHJKH DWWUH]]DWH FKH GL VROLWR DGRWWDQR OH VWHVVH IRQWL LFRQRJUDILFKH GHULYDWH GDL UHSHUWRUL D VWDPSDLQFLUFROD]LRQHILQGDOO¶HSRFD0LQJHFKHLOOXVWUDQRWHVWL OHWWHUDULHQFLFORSHGLHWUDWWDWLYDULYHGXWHFHOHEULHFF,ODERUDWRULFLQHVLGL VSRQJRQRGLXQDPSLRPDWHULDOHLOOXVWUDWLYRFKHSRVVRQRFRPELQDUHGLYROWD LQYROWDFRQPRGDOLWjGLYHUVHSXUQHOODVHULDOLWjHVWDQGDUGL]]D]LRQHGHOOHLP PDJLQL &DUDWWHULVWLFL ULVXOWDQR DOFXQL GHFRUL GL WLSR FLQHVH GHVWLQDWL DO PHUFDWR RFFLGHQWDOH'DSDUWHGHOOHPDHVWUDQ]HORFDOLVLFHUFDGLHVHJXLUHVXGLIIHUHQWL PDWHULDOLGLVHJQLFKHUDIILJXUDQRODYLWDTXRWLGLDQDFLQHVHWDQWRQHOOHDWWLYLWj SURGXWWLYHTXDQWRLQTXHOOHOXGLFKH/HUDSSUHVHQWD]LRQLLOOXVWUDQRVWHUHRWLSDWL SHUVRQDJJL IHPPLQLOL H PDVFKLOL VLD JLRYDQL FKH DQ]LDQL FKH SDVVHJJLDQR EHYRQRLOWqFRQYHUVDQRDPDELOPHQWHYDQQRDSHVFDVLVSRVWDQRLQSRUWDQWL QHJLRFDQRFRQELPELFRPHTXHOOHDGHVHPSLRUDIILJXUDWHVXOOHFDUWHGDSD UDWLQHOOHVDOHFLQHVLGHO&DVWHOORGL5DFFRQLJLD7RULQRILJ,OUHSHUWR ULRLFRQRJUDILFRYROWRDSURSRUUHXQDJDOOHULDGLSHUVRQDJJLFKHWDOYROWDVHP EUDQRWUDWWLGDRSHUHOHWWHUDULHHWHDWUDOLILQLVFHFROGLYHQWDUHULSHWLWLYRXWLOL] ]DWR LQ PRGR VHPSUH GLYHUVR VX YDUL PDWHULDOL GDOOH SRUFHOODQH DOOH ODFFKH DOOH FDUWH GLSLQWHÊ O¶LPPDJLQH GL XQ PRQGR IHOLFH GL XQD &LQD LGLOOLDFD PLWL]]DWDGDOO¶2FFLGHQWHHFKHLFLQHVLUHDOL]]DQRDGXVRGHJOLHXURSHL$QFKH -RXUGDLQ-HQ\QV&URVVPDQ 3HUOHVWDQ]HFLQHVLQHO&DVWHOORGL5DFFRQLJLY&DWHULQD0RVVHWWLSS &DUWH GD SDUDWL FLQHVL DEEHOOLVFRQR PROWH VWDQ]H GL FDVWHOOL H UHVLGHQ]H QRELOLDULVLDLQ ,WDOLD FKHLQDOWULSDHVLHXURSHL3HUOHVWDQ]HFLQHVLLQ,WDOLDY&DWHULQDDHE &DWHULQD0RVVHWWLH %UHYLQRWHVXOO¶LFRQRJUDIDFLQHVHGHOO¶DUWHG¶HVSRUWD]LRQH QHOOHDWWLYLWjODYRUDWLYHOHILJXUHUDSSUHVHQWDWHVRQRVLPLOLHSXUVHLPSHJQDWH LQPHVWLHULIDWLFRVLULHVFRQRVHPSUHDFRQVHUYDUHPRYHQ]HOHJJLDGUHHDJJUD ]LDWHFRPHVXOOHFDUWHGLSLQWHQHOODVDODFLQHVHGL3DOD]]R*URVVRD5LYDSUHV VR&KLHULLQ3LHPRQWHLQFXLVRQRLOOXVWUDWLLSULQFLSDOLFLFOLSURGXWWLYLTXDOLOD PDQLIDWWXUD GHOOD SRUFHOODQD OH FROWLYD]LRQL GHO ULVR H GHO Wq OD ODYRUD]LRQH GHOODVHWDILJ,PPDJLQLVLPLOLVLULWURYDQRROWUHFKHVXIRJOLG¶DOEXP DQFKHVXXQWLSRGLYDVHOODPHILJXUDWRFKLDPDWR³SRUFHOODQDPDQGDULQD´SHU ODSUHVHQ]DFRVWDQWHGLIXQ]LRQDULHVHJXLWRLQWDYROR]]HSROLFURPHFRQXQDE ERQGDQWHXVRGLIRQGLRURHGLHODERUDWLFDUWLJOL %,%/,2*5$),$ %HXUGHOH\03RUFHODLQHGHOD&RPSDJQLHGHV,QGHV)ULERXUJ2IILFHGX/LYUH %OXPHQILHOG5+%ODQFGH&KLQH7KH*UHDW3RUFHODLQRI'HKXD%HUNHOH\7HQ6SHHG 3UHVV &DWHULQD / ³&KLQHVH %OXHDQG:KLWH LQ WKH µ'XFD GL 0DUWLQD¶ 0XVHXP LQ 1DSOHV´ LQ (DVWDQG:HVWQVSS ²,O0XVHR'XFDGL0DUWLQD/DFROOH]LRQHRULHQWDOH1DSROL(OHFWD ²³/HVWDQ]HFLQHVLGHO&DVWHOORGHL6RODURD*RYRQHOHWWXUDVWRULFRDUWLVWLFD´LQ/0R URDF,O&DVWHOORGL*RYRQH*OL$SSDUWDPHQWL7RULQR&HOLGSS ²³4XDGUHWWLFLQHVLQHOOHFROOH]LRQLERUERQLFKH´LQ/&DWHULQD$3RU]LRDF³4XD GUHWWL FLQHVL´ GL FROOH]LRQH ERUERQLFD GDOOD ³)DYRULWD´ GL 1DSROL H GL 3DOHUPR 1DSROL $UWH7LSRJUDILFD4XDGHUQLGL3DOD]]R5HDOHSS ²D³/HVWDQ]HFLQHVLQHOOHUHVLGHQ]HSLHPRQWHVL´LQ06FDUSDUL7/LSSLHOORDF&D UR 0DHVWUR«6FULWWL LQRQRUH GL /LRQHOOR /DQFLRWWLSHU O¶RWWDQWHVLPRFRPSOHDQQR 9HQH ]LD&DIRVFDULQDSS ²E³&DUWHFLQHVLD)LUHQ]HXQDULFRJQL]LRQHSUHOLPLQDUH´LQ*$PLWUDQR/&DWHULQD *'H0DUFRDF6WXGLLQRQRUHGL/XLJL3ROHVH5HPDJJL1DSROL8QLYHUVLWjGHJOL6WX GLGL1DSROL³/¶2ULHQWDOH´'LSDUWLPHQWRGL6WXGL$VLDWLFL6HULH0LQRUSS ²³/D6DODFLQHVH´LQ)'DOPDVVRDF3DOD]]R*URVVRD5LYDSUHVVR&KLHUL/HFD PHUHGHOOHPHUDYLJOLHHLOJLDUGLQRGL)DXVWD0D]]HWWL5LYDSUHVVR&KLHUL7RULQR(GL 7RSS ²³&LQDH*LDSSRQHULIOHVVLRQLVXOO¶DUWHSHUO¶HVSRUWD]LRQHLQ2FFLGHQWH´LQ3&DULRWL )0D]]HLDF2ULHQWH2FFLGHQWHHGLQWRUQL«6WXGLLQRQRUHGL$GROIR7DPEXUHOOR YROO1DSROL8QLYHUVLWjGHJOL6WXGLGL1DSROL³/¶2ULHQWDOH´YROSS &DWHULQD/0RVVHWWL&DF9LOODGHOOD5HJLQD,OULIOHVVRGHOO¶2ULHQWHQHO3LHPRQWH GHO6HWWHFHQWR7RULQR$OOHPDQGL ²³0RGHOOLRULHQWDOLSHUOHERWWHJKHSLHPRQWHVLGHO6HWWHFHQWR2ULHQWDO0RGHOVIRU(LJK WHHQWK&HQWXU\:RUNVKRSVLQWKH3LHGPRQW´LQ'HF$UW>DXWXQQR@SS &DWHULQDSS /XFLD&DWHULQD ²³,OJXVWRGHOO¶HVRWLFRLQ3LHPRQWHQHO6HWWHFHQWR5LIOHVVLRQLLQFRUVR´LQ3$PDOILWD QR/,QQRFHQWLDF/¶2ULHQWH6WRULDGLXQDILJXUDQHOOHDUWLRFFLGHQWDOL 'DO6HWWHFHQWRDO1RYHFHQWRYRO,5RPD%XO]RQL(GLWRUH,/LEULGHOO¶$VVRFLD]LRQH6L JLVPRQGR0DODWHVWDSS &URVVPDQ&/7KH&KLQD7UDGH([SRUW3DLQWLQJV)XUQLWXUH6LOYHUDQGRWKHU2EMHFWV 3ULQFHWRQ7KH3\QH3UHVV &DVWUR1GH$3RUFHODQD&KLQHVDHRV%UDV}HVGR,PSpULR3RUWR/LYUDULD&LYLOL]DomR 'RQQHOO\3-%ODQFGH&KLQH/RQGRQ)DEHUDQG)DEHU *RUGRQ(&ROOHFWLQJ&KLQHVH([SRUW3RUFHODLQ/RQGRQ-0XUUD\ +HUYRXsW)+HUYRXsW1%UXQHDX</D3RUFHODLQHGHV&RPSDJQLHGHV,QGHVDGp FRURFFLGHQWDO3DULV)ODPPDULRQ +RZDUG6&KLQHVH$UPRULDO3RUFHODLQ/RQGRQ)DEHUDQG)DEHU +RZDUG6$\HUV-&KLQDIRUWKH:HVW&KLQHVH3RUFHODLQRWKHU'HFRUDWLYH$UWVIRU ([SRUWLOOXVWUDWHG IURP WKH 0RWWDKHGHK &ROOHFWLRQ /RQGRQ ± 1HZ <RUN 6RWKHE\ 3DUNH %HUQHW +\GH-$/2ULHQWDO/RZHVWRIW&KLQHVH([SRUW3RUFHODLQ1HZSRUW±0RQPRXWKVKLUH &HUDPLF%RRN&R -|UJ&-$3URQN3RUVHOHLQ3RUVHOHLQQDDURQWZHUSHQYDQ&RUQHOLV3URQN±3URQN3RU FHODLQ3RUFHODLQDIWHUGHVLJQVE\&RUQHOLV3URQN>&DWDORJRGHOODPRVWUD*URQLQJHU0X VHXP+DDJV*HPHHQWHPXVHXP@*URQLQJHQ*URQLQJHU0XVHXP ²3RUFHODLQDQGWKH'XWFK&KLQD7UDGH7KH+DJXH0DUWLQXV1LMKRII -RXUGDLQ0-HQ\QV56&KLQHVH([SRUW$UWLQWKH(LJKWHHQWK&HQWXU\/RQGRQ&RXQ WU\/LIH/WG /H&RUEHLOOHU&&KLQD7UDGH3RUFHODLQ3DWWHUQVRI([FKDQJH1HZ<RUN0HWURSROLWDQ 0XVHXPRI$UW /LRQ*ROGVFKPLGW'/DSRUFHODLQ0LQJ)ULERXUJ2IILFHGX/LYUH /XQVLQJK6FKHXUOHHU')&KLQHVH([SRUW3RUFHODLQ&KLQHGH&RPPDQGH/RQGRQ3LW PDQ3XEOLVKLQJ&RUS 5LQDOGL 0.UDDN 3RUFHODLQ $ 0RPHQW LQ WKH +LVWRU\ RI 7UDGH /RQGRQ %DPERR 3X EOLVKLQJ/WG Fig. 1. Coppa in porcellana bianca e blu con iscrizione latina, datata 1541. Fig. 2. Bottiglia in porcellana bianca e blu con iscrizione portoghese, datata 1552. Fig. 3. Brocca in porcellana bianca e blu con sfera armillare, inizi XVI secolo. Fig. 4. Piatto in porcellana bianca e blu di tipo kraak, circa 1575-1605. Fig. 5. Piatti in porcellana policroma con blasoni nobiliari, prima metà XVIII secolo. Fig. 6. Servizio di piatti in porcellana policroma, fine XVIII secolo. Fig. 7. Serie di cinque vasi in porcellana famiglia rosa, metà XVIII secolo. Fig. 8. Statuette in porcellana blanc de Chine, Castello di Rosenborg, Copenhagen, inizi XVIII secolo. Fig. 9. Statuette in porcellana policroma raffiguranti Luigi XIV e la sua favorita, inizi XVIII secolo. Fig. 10. Gruppo in porcellana blanc de Chine raffigurante personaggi occidentali, inizi XVIII secolo. Fig. 11. Urna in porcellana policroma con riproduzione tratta da stampa, fine XVIII secolo. Fig. 12. Piatti in porcellana policroma raffiguranti figure della &RPPHGLDGHOO¶$UWHHVFULWWHVDWLULFKHLQRODQGHVHSULPR quarto XVIII secolo. Fig. 13. Piatto in porcellana policroma con decoro di Cornelis Pronk ³/DGDPDFRQO¶RPEUHOOLQR´SULPDPHWj;9,,,VHFROR Fig. 14. Piatto in porcellana policroma con decoro di Cornelis Pronk ³,GRWWRUL´SULPDPHWj;9,,,VHFROR Fig. 15. Piatto in porcellana policroma con decoro di &RUQHOLV3URQN³,OSHUJRODWR´SULPDPHWj;9,,,VHFROR Fig. 16. Piatto in porcellana encre de Chine con decoro tratto GDOODVWDPSD³/HEDLQ´PHWj;9,,,VHFROR Fig. 17. 3DUWLFRODUHGLXQFDUWDGDSDUDWLLQXQD³VWDQ]DFLQHVH´QHO&DVWHOOR di Racconigi in Piemonte, metà XVIII secolo. Fig. 18. 3DUWLFRODUH GL XQD FDUWD GD SDUDWL QHOOD ³VWDQ]D FLQHVH´ D 3DOD]]R Grosso a Riva presso Chieri in Piemonte, metà XVIII secolo. *,2,$/&+,$8==, &XIUD±7LPEXFWX0XWD]LRQL 3LDQRGHOO¶RSHUDHGLVFRUVRGHOVHFRQGRVDKDULDQR 3,$12'(//¶23(5$ &RQVLGHURGXHWHVWLPRQLDQ]HVXO6DKDUDUHVHQHOHQHOGDGXH VDKDULDQLOLELFL3ULPDQHWUDGXFRLWHVWL4XLQGLOHFRQIURQWRWUDORURODYRUDQ GRVXOODPLDHVSHULHQ]DGLFDPSRQHOO¶DUHDGDXQ¶HSRFDDOO¶DOWUD$FKHVFR SR"ÊXQHVSHULPHQWRFKHULJXDUGDLOUDSSRUWRWUDVSHFLILFLWjHJHQHUDOL]]D]LR QLVXOSLDQRVLDGHLFRQWHQXWLFKHGHOODVFULWWXUD3HULFRQWHQXWLPLSRQJROD TXHVWLRQHVHHFRPHUDSSUHVHQWDQRVWUXWWXUHHLGHRORJLHSLDPSLHGLWDOHVR FLHWjQHOODSURSULDHQHOOHGXHHSRFKHHSRLLQFDVRFRPHQHUHQGRQROHWUD VIRUPD]LRQLDYYHQXWHGDXQ¶HSRFDDOO¶DOWUD,QYHFHSHUODVFULWWXUDPLSRQJRLO SUREOHPDGLFRPHVFULYHUHDPLDYROWDTXDQWRVXGGHWWRÊODTXHVWLRQH±QRQ IDFLOH±GLUDFFRUGDUHLOSLDQRHWQRJUDILFRDULIOHVVLRQLSLJHQHUDOLSDVVDQGR SHUUHJLVWULDQFKHGLYHUVLPDWHULDOLGLFDPSRWUDGX]LRQLGLFROORTXLHGLWHVWL VFULWWLULIOHVVLRQL /¶DQDOLVL GHOOH GXH WHVWLPRQLDQ]H WLHQH FRQWR GL SL YDULDELOL ,QIDWWL JOL DXWRULGLIIHULVFRQRSHUJHQHUD]LRQHSHUFRUVRGLYLWDHUXROROHHQXQFLD]LRQL SHUXELFD]LRQHFRQWHVWRHRELHWWLYRLGRFXPHQWLSHUHSRFDWLSRORJLDHFRQWH QXWR,VHJXHQWLFHQQLDELRJUDILHHDPELWLFKLDULVFRQRGLUHWWDPHQWHDJJDQFLH GLVWDQ]HIUDOHSDUWL ,OSULPRWHVWLPRQHSDUODGDO6DKDUDQRUGRULHQWDOHGD&XIUDFKH qLQ/LELDQHOGHVHUWRFLUHQDLFRGHO&DODQVFLRʵ$Enj.GHOODFDELODDO0D ÷ƗEUDXQ¶H[JXLGDGHOOHFDURYDQHFRPPHUFLDOLWUDQVDKDULDQHGLUHWWHLQ&LDGH LQ6XGDQRUPDLREVROHWHÊQDWRDJOLLQL]LGHO¶RSRFRSULPDDQFRUDVRWWR ,OSUHVHQWHODYRURqVWDWRFRQVHJQDWRQHO3HUWDQWRQRQDFFHQQDDOODUHFHQWHIDVHVRFLR SROLWLFDOLELFDDSHUWDVLFRQODJXHUUDFLYLOHGHOWXWWRUDLQDWWR *LRLD/&KLDX]]L LWXUFKLQHOO¶RDVLGL*LDORDOOHSRUWHGHO&DODQVFLR6LqVWDELOLWRD&XIUDRYH O¶LQFRQWURQHOµHSRVVLHGHGHLJLDUGLQLFKHIDFROWLYDUHDL©VHUYLªFDEƯG QHULVXGDQHVL0LWURYROuSHUDOFXQHULFHUFKHHGHJOLPLLOOXVWUDSULYDWDPHQWH DOFXQL DVSHWWL VRFLRDQWURSRORJLFL GHOO¶DUHD 1HO ODYRUR WUDGXUUz DOFXQL SDVVL GDOVXRDUDERORFDOHDIILDQFDQGRYLGHOOHPLHFRQWHVWXDOLQRWHGLFDPSR,PD WHULDOLVRQRWUDWWLGDLPLHLDUFKLYLHWQRJUDILFLFKHKRVWUDWLILFDWRQHOOHULFHUFKH VXOWHUUHQRLQ/LELDDSDUWLUHGDOJXDUGDQGRDUHWURWHUUDHPRGHUQLWjFRQ XVRGHOO¶DUDERVFULWWRHSDUODWRORFDOPHQWH,QYHFHLOVHFRQGRWHVWLPRQHSDUOD GDO 6DKDUD VXGRFFLGHQWDOH GD 7LPEXFWX LQ0DOL Ê LO OHDGHU OLELFR 0XµDPPDUHO*KHGGDILDO4DƗIƯQDWRQHOOD6LUWLFDGDQRPDGLGHOODFDELOD DO4DƗID DWWRUQR DO VXO ILQLUH GHO FRORQLDOLVPR LWDOLDQR1HO LQ TXHVWLRQHVLUHFDD7LPEXFWSHUODFHOHEUD]LRQHGHO1DWDOHSURIHWLFRHLOFRQ WHVWXDOH©3ULPRUDGXQRVWRULFRGHOOHWULEGHO*UDQGH6DKDUDªDO0XOWDTjDO WD¶UƯېƯDODZZDOOLTDEƗ¶LODO܇DۊUƗ¶DO.XEUj'DOuLQGLUL]]DDOODFRPXQLWj LVODPLFD H DOO¶HFXPHQH XQ GLVFRUVR PHGLDWLFR FRPPHPRUDWLYR GHO 3URIHWD FDULFRG¶LGHRORJLDHVWUDWHJLHVDKDULDQH/RWUDGXFRGDOWHVWRDVWDPSDFKHKR UHSHULWRVXOFDPSRD7ULSROLQHOOD©&HOHEUD]LRQHGL7ULSROLFDSLWDOHGHOODFXO WXUDLVODPLFDSHUO¶DQQRGDOODPRUWHGHO3URIHWDG&ª,ۊWLIƗOL\\DW ܑDUƗEXOXV FƗ܈LPDW DOܔDTƗIDK DOLVOƗPL\\DK OLOFƗP Z5 G& LQDXJXUDWDFRQIRUWLUDSSUHVHQWDQ]HDIULFDQHHVDKDULDQH ,OODYRURFRPSOHVVLYRV¶DUWLFROHUjLQSLSDUWLDWWXDOPHQWHLQGLYHUVRVWD WR GL DYDQ]DPHQWR,QYHFH LO SUHVHQWH FRQWULEXWR VL OLPLWD DO SURJHWWR H DOOD /DFHULPRQLDLQDXJXUDOHDFXUDGHDO/D÷QDKDOãDFEL\\DKDOFƗPPDKOLOܔDTƗIDKZDOLFOƗP ©&RPLWDWRJHQHUDOHGHOSRSRORSHUODFXOWXUDHO¶LQIRUPD]LRQHªVLqDSHUWDD7ULSROLLODO ܒD\U³O¶XFFHOOR´P3DSULOHG&HSURWUDWWDDOFXQLJLRUQL7UDTXDOFKHFHQWL QDLRGLRVSLWLGDLSDHVLLVODPLFLRLQSDUWHWDOLVSLFFDYDQROHUDSSUHVHQWDQ]HDIULFDQH,JQRUR VHIRVVLO¶XQLFDRVSLWHQRQPXVXOPDQDFRPHIRUVHTXDOFKHDIULFDQRRTXDOFKHDUDERPHGLR ULHQWDOH9LKRLQFURFLDWRDOFXQLFRQYHUWLWLRFFLGHQWDOLQRQLWDOLDQLORIDFFLRSUHVHQWHLQUHOD ]LRQHDLSXQWL>$H$@GHOGLVFRUVRGL7LPEXFWX'DGRFXPHQWD]LRQHDFXUDGHOVXGGHW WR&RPLWDWRHFFROHDWWLYLWjFHOHEUDWLYHSUHYLVWHD7ULSROLHQHOSDHVHQHOO¶DUFRGHOO¶DQQDWDFRQ SDUWHFLSD]LRQHXIILFLDOHHSRSRODUHSURGX]LRQHGLGRFXPHQWDULVXOUXRORGHOOHDGHUQHOODGLI IXVLRQHHGLIHVDGHOO¶LVODPLQFRQWULGHLPLQLVWULGHOODFXOWXUDGHLSDHVLLVODPLFLLQDXJXUD]LRQH HSRVDLQRSHUDGLHGLILFLFXOWXUDOLSXEEOLFD]LRQLHILOPDWLFRQFRQIHUHQ]HHVHPLQDULH WDYROHURWRQGHVXOO¶LVODPVHGXWHGLUHFLWD]LRQLSRHWLFKHVSHWWDFROLWHDWUDOLHIHVWLYDOV HVSRVL]LRQLHPRVWUHOLEUDULHHDUWLVWLFKHVHUDWHGLPXVLFDHFDQWLGDOOHWUDGL]LRQLHFF6XO FDOHQGDULRLQYLJRUHLQ/LELDFIUDOODQ ,QOLQHDGLPDVVLPD߃$5*20(172(2%,(77,9,߃/$7(67,021,$1=$'(/ 35,026$+$5,$12&8)5$߃3UHPHVVD߃0DWHULDOLGLFDPSRWUDGX]LRQH GDLFROORTXLHDOWUR߃&RQWHVWXDOL]]D]LRQHDQDOLVLHFF߃/$7(67,021,$1=$'(/ &XIUD±7LPEXFWX0XWD]LRQL WUDGX]LRQHGHOODVHFRQGDWHVWLPRQLDQ]DLOWHVWRGHOGLVFRUVRGD7LPEXFWX,O ODYRURILQDOHQHULFKLDPHUjTXDOFKHSDVVRFRQDOWULGDHQXQFLDWLSDUDOOHOLGHO O¶RUDWRUH /¶HVSHULHQ]D GL FDPSR FKH PL LQGXFH D WDOH HVSHULPHQWR q LQL]LDWD QHO +DWUDYHUVDWROHWUDVIRUPD]LRQLVRFLDOLQHOOHYDULHIRUPHGLJRYHUQRGHO OD/LELDLQGLSHQGHQWHJOLXOWLPLWUHDQQLGHOODPRQDUFKLDOD UHSXEEOLFDOD³PDVVRFUD]LD´GDO5LQJUD]LRSULYDWLHLVWLWX]LR 6(&21'26$+$5,$127,0%8&78 ߃3UHPHVVD߃,OGLVFRUVRGHO0DZ OLGDOFXQLSDVVLHDOWUR߃&RQWHVWXDOL]]D]LRQHDQDOLVLHFF߃&21)5217, )5$/( '8( 7(67,021,$1=( ( 5,)/(66,21, '$//¶(63(5,(1=$ ', 7(55(12 ,1 ',$ &521,$(&& +RWUDGRWWRTXHVW¶XOWLPLSHUXQVHFRQGRSURJHWWRDVXDYROWDLQFHQWUDWRVXHVSHULHQ]HGLFDP SRLQGLDFURQLD /D'LFKLDUD]LRQHG¶LQGLSHQGHQ]DHVRYUDQLWjGHOOD/LELD5HJQRGL/LELDIXIDWWDGDOUH,GUƯV 0XতDPPDGDO6DQnjVƯLORWWREUH3HUODGLFKLDUD]LRQHG¶LQVWDXUD]LRQHGHOOD5HSXEEOLFD öXPKnjUL\\DKIDWWDGDOOHDGHUFIUDO%D\ƗQDODZZDOOLOWDZUDK0D÷OLV4L\ƗGDWDOWDZUDK ©3ULPRPDQLIHVWRGHOODULYROX]LRQH&RQVLJOLRGHO&RPDQGRGHOODULYROX]LRQHª>%HQJDVL VHWWHPEUH @ 3HU OD ³0DVVRFUD]LD´ FIU ,FOƗQ TL\àP VXOܒDW DOãDFE ©3URFODPD G¶LQVWDX UD]LRQHGHOSRWHUHGHOSRSRORªDO4ƗKLUDK>©OD9LQFHQWHªFRPH³LO&DLUR´QRPHGDWRDG DO4ƗUDK ORF DO*ƝUD ©O¶$OWXUDª GL 6HEKƗ SHU O¶HYHQWR JLRFDQGR VXOOD TXDVL RPRIRQLD@ 6HEKƗ PDU]R 'D DOORUD OD GHQRPLQD]LRQH GHO 3DHVH q DOöDPƗKƯUL\\DK DOFDUD EL\\DKDOOƯEL\\DKDOãDFEL\\DKDOLãWLUƗNL\\DK©³0DVVRFUD]LD´DUDEDOLELFDSRSRODUHVRFLDOL VWDª&LzVHFRQGRO¶LGHRORJLDXIILFLDOHGHO³/LEUR9HUGH´FKHSURVSHWWDXQDIRUPDGL©GHPR FUD]LDGLUHWWDªDOGLPXTUƗܒL\\DKDOPXEƗãLUDKWUDPLWHO¶LQVWDXUD]LRQHGL/L÷ƗQãDFEL\\DKZD 0X¶WDPDUƗW ãDFEL\\DK ©&RPLWDWL SRSRODUL H &RQJUHVVL SRSRODULª GL GLYHUVR OLYHOOR VHQ]D GHOHJKHHUDSSUHVHQWDQ]HSDUODPHQWDULHGLSDUWLWRFIU0DO4DƗIƯDO.LWƗEDO$ڲېDU$O )D܈ODODZZDOۉDOOPXãNLODWDOGLPXTUƗܒL\\DKVXOܒDWDOãDFEDO)D܈ODOܔƗQƯۉDOODOPXãNLO DOLTWL܈ƗGƯDO,ãWLUƗNL\\DKDO)D܈ODOܔƗOLܔDO5XNQDOL÷WLPƗFƯOLO1DܲDUL\\DKDOFƗODPL\\DK DOܔƗOLܔDK©,O/LEUR9HUGH3ULPDSDUWH/DVROX]LRQHGHOSUREOHPDGHOODGHPRFUD]LDLOSRWH UHGHOSRSROR6HFRQGDSDUWH/DVROX]LRQHGHOSUREOHPDHFRQRPLFRLOVRFLDOLVPR7HU]DSDU WH/DEDVHVRFLDOHGHOOD7HU]DWHRULDXQLYHUVDOHªVOVG>PDU]R@/HWUHSDUWLHGLWHLQ VXFFHVVLRQHQHO±GDWHLQGLFDWHPLGDO0DNWDEDO܇LۊƗIDK©8IILFLR6WDPSDªGHOOD öDPƗKƯUL\\DK±HQHOFRVWLWXLVFRQROD³7HU]DWHRULDXQLYHUVDOH´FRVLGGHWWDGDOO¶$UL VSHWWRDOOHGXHSUHFHGHQWLFDSLWDOLVWLFDUD¶VPƗOL\\DKHFRPXQLVWDãX\njFL\\DK/¶LVODPQRQ qPHQ]LRQDWRPDODãDUƯFDK/HJJHVDFUDGHOO¶LVODPqGDWDFRPHODOHJJHQDWXUDOHGHOO¶XRPR ODTXDOHGHYHIRQGDUVLVXOODUHOLJLRQHGƯQHLOFRVWXPHGHLSRSROLFXUIFKHQHqDVVRUELWR FIUDO.LWƗEFLW,âDUƯFDWDOPX÷WDPDF©/D/HJJHGHOODVRFLHWjªSS,VSLUDWDDLFLWD WL3ULPR0DQLIHVWR3URFODPDH/LEUR9HUGHVHJXLUjDO:DܔƯTDKDOېDڲUƗ¶DO NXEUjOLۊXTnjTDOLQVƗQIƯ FD܈UDO÷DPƗKƯU0X¶WDPDUDOãDFEDOFƗPPELOöDPƗKƯUL\\DKDO F DUDEL\\D DOOƯEL\\DK DOãDFEL\\DK DOLãWLUƗNL\\DKDOFXܲPj DO%D\ڲƗ¶ PLQ ãDZZƗO Z5PLQãDKUDO܈D\IPDVƯۊƯ©/D*UDQGH&DUWD9HUGHGHL'LULWWLGHOO¶XRPRQHOO¶H *LRLD/&KLDX]]L QLORFDOLFKHQHJOLDQQLPLKDQQRFRQVHQWLWRWUDQVLWLHULFHUFKHLQWHPSLHVLWL DQFKHGLIILFLOL ',6&2562'(/6(&21'26$+$5,$12 7,0%8&78 3UHPHVVD ,OWHVWRDUDERDVWDPSDGDFXLWUDGXFRWUDVFULYHODUHJLVWUD]LRQHRUDOHWDV ÷ƯO ܈DZWƯ XIILFLDOH GHOO¶DOORFX]LRQH6¶LQWLWROD ©'LVFRUVR GHO IUDWHOOR OHDGHU GHOOD *XLGD SRSRODUH LVODPLFD PRQGLDOH QHO 1DWDOH GHO 6LJLOOR GHL SURIHWL H GHJOLLQYLDWLSEQHOODFLWWjGL7LPEXFWXQHOOD5HSXEEOLFDGHO0DOLWHQXWRLO GHO PHVH UDEƯF , GHO PHVH ³O¶XFFHOOR´ >DSULOH@ GDOOD PRUWH GHO 3URIHWDG&ª6LFRPSRQHGLSDJLQHVHQ]DLQGLFD]LRQHGLOXRJRH DQQR9DGDWDWRIUDLOPDU]RHO¶DSULOHQRQSULPDGHOODGHFODPD ]LRQHHQRQROWUHLOUHSHULPHQWRGHOORVWDPSDWR)RUPDOPHQWHQRQSUHVHQWDGL YLVLRQLLQFDSLWROLRDOWUR2OWUHOHFLWD]LRQLFRUDQLFKHODOLQJXDqXQDUDERLQ SUHYDOHQ]D SRSRODUH H FROORTXLDOH FƗPPL\\DK LQGLUL]]DWR DOOH PDVVH LQ IOXHQ]DWRGDOOLELFRSDUODWRGƗUL÷DKORFGƗUåD,OWRQRqDOTXDQWRGLGDVFDOL FR UDGHOOHPDVVH&RQJUHVVRJHQHUDOHGHOSRSROR*UDQGH³0DVVRFUD]LD´DUDEDOLELFDSRSRODUH VRFLDOLVWDDO%DLGDãDZZƗOP3³HVWDWH´>JLXJQR@G&ª ,QSDUWLDYHQLUHWRUQHUzVXOUDSSRUWRIUDRUDOLWjHVFULWWXUDQHOOHGXHWHVWLPRQLDQ]HGDO6DKDUD 3HULOWLWRORDUDERGHOGLVFRUVRFIUODWUDGX]LRQHLQ,QUDSSRUWRDGDOFXQLWHUPLQLULFRUUHQWL QHOODYRURLQRWWHPSHUDQ]DDO3ULPRPDQLIHVWRGHOODULYROX]LRQHFLWFKHSURFODPDOƗVD\\LG ZDOƗPDVFnjGEDOLېZDKDۊUƗU©QHVVXQSDGURQHHQHVVXQVHUYRPDIUDWHOOLOLEHULªFRQO¶DY YHQWRGHOOD5HSXEEOLFDLWHUPLQL©VLJQRUHªVD\\LGORFVƯGH©VLJQRUDªVD\\LGDKORF VƯGDVRQRVRVWLWXLWLGD©IUDWHOORªDېORFېnjSOLېZDKORFېnjWH©VRUHOODªXېWSODېDZƗW ORFېZƗW*KHGGDILqLO©IUDWHOORFRORQQHOORªDODېDOFDTƯGH©OHDGHUGHOODULYROX]LRQHGHO ,JLRUQR>GLVHWWHPEUH@ªTƗ¶LGܔDZUDWDO)ƗWL&ۊRQWUDVIRUPD]LRQLVWUXWWXUDOLHLGHROR JLFKH ©0LQLVWHURª :L]ƗUDK ORF :D]ƗUD H ©PLQLVWURª ZD]ƯU ORF DQFKH nj]ƯU GLYHUUDQQR JUDGXDOPHQWH©6HJUHWDULDWRª$PƗQDKH©VHJUHWDULRªDPƯQHSRLQHOODöDPƗKƯUL\\DK ©8IILFLR SRSRODUHª DO0DNWDE DOãDFEƯ H ©VHJUHWDULR GHOO¶8Sª DPƯQ DO0DNWDE DOãDFEƯ GHQRPLQD]LRQLFRQGLYLVHDQFKHGD©$PEDVFLDWDªH©DPEDVFLDWRUHªöDPƗKƯUL\\DKqXQQHR ORJLVPRFRQLDWRGDOOHDGHUIRUPDDVWUDWWDGDOSO÷DPƗKƯU©PDVVHªGDOFXLVLQJ÷XPKnjUqLO FRUUHQWH÷XPKnjUL\\DK©UHSXEEOLFDª &XIUD±7LPEXFWX0XWD]LRQL ,QWUDGX]LRQHSHUIDFLOLWDUHODOHWWXUDLQGLFKHUzIUD>«@VXGGLYLVLRQLHWHPLGHO GLVFRUVRTXDOLGDPHLQGLYLGXDWLRVVLD >3DUWH08ণ$00$'&+,8'(,/&,&/2'(//$5,9(/$=,21(SS@ >,OUDEƯF,DQQLYHUVDULRGLQDVFLWDHPRUWHGHO3URIHWDS@ >3HUFKpO¶HUDGDOODPRUWHGHO3URIHWDSS@ >3DUWH/¶2&&,'(17(1(0,&2'(//¶,6/$0SS@ >/HYLJQHWWHVDWLULFKHFRQWUR0XতDPPDG,QYLDWRGLYLQRXQLYHUVDOHSS@ >0LVFRQRVFHUH0XতDPPDGqODIDOVLILFD]LRQHGHOOH6FULWWXUHS@ >5HWWLILFDGHOPRGRGLSHQVDUHRFFLGHQWDOHS@ >3DUWH&217526),'('(//¶,6/$0$//¶2&&,'(17(SS@ >$©/DFRQWURVILGDUHOLJLRVDDOWDۊDGGƯ¶OGƯQƯªSS@ >$,OWULRQIRGHOO¶LVODPS@ >$/DFUHVFLWDGHOO¶LVODPLQRFFLGHQWHSS@ >$/¶LQYLWRDOSHOOHJULQDJJLRqXQLYHUVDOHSS@ >$3URSRVWDGLDSHUWXUDGHOSHOOHJULQDJJLRDOOD*HQWHGHO/LEURVLF ,O3UHVLGHQWHGHJOL86$qDFFROWRDOSHOOHJULQDJJLRVLFSS@ >%©/DFRQWURVILGDVRFLDOHGHOOHQD]LRQLªDOWDDGGƯ¶OTDZPƯSS@ >%/HWUDPHVWRULFKHGHOFRORQLDOLVPRSS@ >%/HWUDPHDWWXDOLGHOQHRFRORQLDOLVPRS@ >%/D/HJDGHOOH©WULEªTDEƗ¶LOGHO*UDQGH6DKDUDSS@ 1HOOD SUHVHQWH VHGH PL OLPLWR DOOD WUDGX]LRQH DQQRWDWD &RQWHVWXDOL]]D ]LRQHHFRPPHQWLVHJXLUDQQRLQDOWUDSDUWHGHOODYRUR7XWWDYLDVRWWROLQHRWUH SXQWL DO¶RUDWRUH ©PXVXOPDQR ULYROX]LRQDULRª DOPXVOLP DOـDZUƯ SDUOD TXDOH OHDGHU GHOOD ©*XLGD SRSRODUH LVODPLFD PRQGLDOHª DO4L\ƗGDK DOãDFEL\\DK DOLVOƗPL\\DK DOFƗODPL\\DK GD OXL SURSRVWD LQ VHQR D XQ FRQJUHVVR GHOOD ©'DFZDK LVODPLFDª DO'DFZDK DOLVOƗPL\\DK /D *XLGD YXROH HVVHUHXQSDUWLWRXQLYHUVDOHLVODPLFRGLPDVVDDXWRJHVWLWRFKH©LQFRUSRUDGH FLQH GL RUJDQL]]D]LRQL SDUWLWL HG HQWL LVODPLFL GD GLYHUVH SDUWL GHO PRQGRª § XQD PLD LQWHUSROD]LRQH 1HOOD WUDGX]LRQH OL LQGLFKHUz IUD >«@ FRPH DQFKH OH SDJLQH GHO O¶RULJLQDOHDUDER ©\DڲXPP FDãUƗWDOWDQܲLPƗWZD¶OD]ۊƗEZD¶OKD\L¶ƗWDOLVOƗPL\\DKPLQPXېWDOLIDQۊƗ¶DO F ƗODPªFIU©,FOƗQܑDUƗEXOXVDO܈ƗGLUFDQDO0X¶WDPDUDOFƗPDOUƗELFOLO4L\ƗGDKDOãDFEL\ \DKDOLVOƗPL\\DKDOFƗODPL\\DKܑDUƗEXOXVDODUـZ5P'LFKLDUD]LRQHGL *LRLD/&KLDX]]L +DSHUGRWWULQDLO&RUDQROD3DURODGL'LRFKHqO¶DXWRULWjVXSUHPDHODIRQWH GL XQLWj GHL PXVXOPDQL DO GL VRSUD GHOOH GLYLVLRQLLQWHUQH +D SHU RELHWWLYR O¶XQLWjGHOODFRPXQLWjLVODPLFDXPPDKLVOƗPL\\DKHODVXDYLWWRULDWUDPLWHOD ORWWDFRQWURLOGXSOLFHQHPLFRGDXQODWRLOIUD]LRQDPHQWRLQWHUQRG¶RJQLWLSR VXQQD VFƯFD VFXROH JLXULGLFKH GLVSXWH WHRORJLFKH SDUWLWL HFF GDOO¶DOWUR O¶LPSHULDOLVPRRFFLGHQWDOHHLOFRORQLDOLVPR³FURFLDWR´FKH³IRPHQWDQR´SXUH GLYLVLRQL HQWUR O¶³LVODP´ 3HU OD *XLGD O¶D]LRQH qFRPSLWR GHOOH PDVVH (VVD YXROH PRELOLWDUOH H UHVSRQVDELOL]]DUOH DOO¶DXWRJHVWLRQH SHU O¶HVHUFL]LR GLUHWWR GHLGLULWWLGHOSRWHUHVRYUDQLWjGHOSRSRORVHQ]DJRYHUQDQWLHODGHWHUPLQD ]LRQHGHLGHVWLQL /DULFKLHVWDG¶LVWLWX]LRQHGHOOD*XLGDIXDYDQ]DWDGDOOHDGHUQHOVXRGLVFRUVR DOODVHGXWDLQDXJXUDOHGHOFRQJUHVVRWHQXWRD%HQJDVLVHWWHPEUH GDOOD 'DFZDK LVODPLFD FRQ OD SDUWHFLSD]LRQH GL ROWUH GRWWL LQWHOOHWWXDOL HFFGDSDHVLLVODPLFL&LzIXDOODYLJLOLDGHOO¶9,,,VHVVLRQHGHO&RQVLJOLR LVODPLFRPRQGLDOHVHWWHPEUHGHOODPHGHVLPD,QYHFHO¶DWWRFR VWLWXWLYRGHOO¶HQWHULVDOHDOPDU]RVXFFHVVLYRIDFHQGRVHJXLWRDOOHULX QLRQLGHOO¶©8IILFLRHVHFXWLYRª0DNWDEWDQIƯڴƯ 7ULSROLHPHVVDGDO4XDUWR&RQJUHVVRJHQHUDOHGHOOD*XLGDSRSRODUHLVODPLFDPRQGLDOHª7UL SROL³O¶DUDWXUD´>QRYHPEUH@P3G& &IULQDO0XIDNNLUDKDOLVOƗPL\\DKOLOFƗPPLQZDIƗWDO5DVnjO©O¶$JHQGDLVODPLFDSHU O¶DQQR>VRODUH@GDOODPRUWHGHO3URIHWD>G&@ªVOVG>R@VYDO UDEƯF ³ODSULPDYHUD´>PDU]R@1DۊQIƯ¶O4L\ƗGDKDOãDFEL\\DKDOLVOƗPL\\DKDOFƗODPL\\DK ÷ƗGnjQIƯWDFEL¶DWTXZZDWDOLVOƗPZDLܲKƗULKƗOLOFƗODP©1RLGHOOD*XLGDSRSRODUHLVODPLFD PRQGLDOHFLSURGLJKLDPRSHUPRELOLWDUHODIRU]DGHOO¶LVODPHSHUUHQGHUODPDQLIHVWDDOPRQ GRª6XOODGHPRFUD]LDGLUHWWDHO¶HVHUFL]LRGHLGLULWWLHGHOSRWHUHFIUDOODQ 3HUODSURSRVWDFIUۉDGƯܔDOܔƗ¶LUDOPXVOLP0XFDPPDUDO4DڴڴƗIƯ©'LVFRUVRGHOULYROX]LR QDULRPXVXOPDQR0XFDPPDUDO4DסƗIƯªSSLQDO'DFZDKDOLVOƗPL\\DK FDOjDEZƗE DOTDUQ DO÷DGƯG ©OD 'DFZDK LVODPLFD DOOH SRUWH GHO QXRYR VHFRORª >%HQJDVL ܈DIDU P3 VHWWHPEUH @ LQ 5LVƗODW DO÷LKƗG UDEƯF , DOWXPnjU ³L GDWWHUL´ P3RWWREUHSS,ELGSSqLOPDQLIHVWRGHOOD*XLGDUHGDWWRLQFKLX VXUD GHL ODYRUL LO VHWWHPEUH %D\ƗQ ELTL\ƗP 4L\ƗGDK ãDFEL\\DK LVOƗPL\\DK FƗODPL\\DK ©0DQLIHVWRSHUO¶LVWLWX]LRQHGLXQD*XLGDSRSRODUHPRQGLDOHLVODPLFDª DO0D÷OLV DOFƗODPƯ OLO'DFZDK DOLVOƗPL\\DK \DFTLG L÷WLPƗFDK DOܔƗPLQ IƯ ܑDUƗEXOXV ELO öDPƗKƯUL\\DKDOF8ܲPDK©LO &RQVLJOLR PRQGLDOH GHOOD'DFZDK LVODPLFD WLHQH ODVXD RWWDYD 6HVVLRQH D 7ULSROL QHOOD *UDQGH öDPƗKƯUL\\DKª > ܈DIDU P3 VHWWHPEUH @LQ5LVƗODWDO÷LKƗGUDEƯF,DOWXPnjU³LGDWWHUL´P3RWWREUHSS 6XOODSULPDIHEEUDLRHODVHFRQGDPDU]RULXQLRQHGHOO¶8IILFLRHVHFXWLYR 0DNWDE WDQIƯڴƯ GHOOD FRVWLWXHQGD *XLGD FIU LQ 5LVƗODW DO÷LKƗG ãDFEƗQ DOUDEƯF ³OD SULPDYHUD´ P3 RWWREUH SS 6XOO¶DWWR FRVWLWXWLYR FIUDO0XIDNNLUDK DO &XIUD±7LPEXFWX0XWD]LRQL EOD FLWDWD 'DFZDK LVODPLFD ± SURSULDPHQWHöDPFL\\DW DO'DFZDK DOLVOƗ PL\\DKDOFDOƗPL\\DK©$VVRFLD]LRQHPRQGLDOHSHUOD0LVVLRQHLVODPLFDª± q O¶RUJDQR XIILFLDOH GHOOD öDPƗKƯUL\\DK OLELFD SHU OD SUHGLFD]LRQH GHOO¶L VODPÊ VWDWD IRQGDWDWD D 7ULSROL DQFK¶HVVD GLHWUR LQYLWR GHO OHDGHU O¶DQQR GRSR OD ULYROX]LRQH /¶HYHQWR FRQJUHVVXDOH SUHOLPLQDUH DOOD IRQGD]LRQHqPHVVRLQULVDOWRQHJOL<DZPL\\ƗWDOWDZUDK©'LDULGHOODULYROX ]LRQHªãDZZƗOGƯVDPEDU±±,IWDWDۊDODDOFDTƯG 0X¶WDPDU DO'DFZDK DOLVOƗPL\\DK DODZZDO DO\DZP ELܑDUƗEXOXV ZD ۊDڲDU DOLIWLWƗ ۊEDF ڲDOLېZDK DFڲƗ¶ 0D÷OLV 4L\ƗGDW DOܔDZUDK ãDZZƗO GLFHPEUH ± >Q@ 2JJL D 7ULSROL LO IUDWHOOR FRORQQHOOR >0XFDPPDUDO4DƗIƯ@KDLQDXJXUDWRLOSULPR&RQJUHVVRGHOOD'DFZDKLVOD PLFD +DQQRSUHVHQ]LDWRDOO¶LQDXJXUD]LRQH DOFXQL IUDWHOOL PHPEUL GHO &RQVL JOLRGHO&RPDQGRGHOODULYROX]LRQHªHFFVXOOHLQGLFD]LRQLGHOOHDGHUFLUFDOH UHVSRQVDELOLWj GHOO¶HQWH/D VWUXWWXUD FRPSOHVVD H SRWHQWH LQJUDQGLWDVL QHO WHPSRGRWDWDGLSURSULIRQGLHDWWLYLWjG¶LQYHVWLPHQWRRJJLDVVROYHDPROWH SOLFLLPSHJQLDOLYHOORQD]LRQDOHHLQWHUQD]LRQDOHQHOODYLVLRQHXIILFLDOHOLELFD GHOO¶LVODP LVOƗPL\\DKFLWVWHVVDYRFH ©GHOPHVH³ODSULPDYHUD´>PDU]R@)RQGD]LRQHWD¶VƯV GHOOD*XLGDSRSRODUHLVODPLFDPRQGLDOHª 7UDGXFLELOHDQFKH ©$VVRFLD]LRQHPRQGLDOH SHU OD3URSDJDQGDLVODPLFD SHUO¶$SSHOORDOO¶L VODPª ,O WHUPLQH RSWDWR GDOO¶HQWH SHU OH OLQJXH RFFLGHQWDOL q ©$SSHOORª7KH :RUOG ,VODPLF &DOO6RFLHW\:,&6$VVRFLDWLRQ0RQGLDOHGHO¶$SSHOOH,VODPLTXH6LWUDWWDGLXQLPSRUWDQWH 0LQLVWHURPDLQöDPƗKƯUL\\DKQRQVLXVDWDOHWHUPLQHFIUDOODQ ,Q<DZPL\\ƗWܔDZUDWDO)ƗWLۊPLQVLEWDPELU$O4LVPDODZZDOPLQVLEWDPELULOjƗېDUDƥX VܒXV DOöXPKnjUL\\DK DOFDUDEL\\DK DOOƯEL\\DK DO$PƗQDK DOFƗPPDK OLOLUãƗG DOTDZPƯ ©'LDUL GHOOD ULYROX]LRQH GHO VHWWHPEUH 3DUWH , GDO VHWWHPEUH DO DJRVWR 5HSXEEOLFDDUDEDOLELFD6HJUHWDULDWRJHQHUDOHSHUO¶RULHQWDPHQWRQD]LRQDOHªVOVGS SS/DIRQGD]LRQHDYYHQQHLOPDJJLRLQHVHFX]LRQHDOOH5LVROX]LRQLGHO©3UL PR&RQJUHVVRGHOOD'DFZDKLVODPLFDªFLWDWRQHOWHVWR (GXFD]LRQHDGLYHUVLOLYHOOLSHUODWUDVPLVVLRQHGHLVDSHULLVODPLFLHO¶LQVHJQDPHQWRGHOODOLQ JXDDUDEDGDOO¶DOIDEHWL]]D]LRQHDOODIRUPD]LRQHXQLYHUVLWDULDHGLLPƗPSHUOHPRVFKHHFRQ JUHVVLHGLWRULDHPHGLDFRVWUX]LRQHHRUJDQL]]D]LRQHGLVFXROHLVWLWXWLXQLYHUVLWjLVODPLFKHH G¶DOWUHRSHUHVRVWHJQLLQFDPSRVDQLWDULRIRQGD]LRQHGLRVSHGDOLHDVVLVWHQ]DPHGLFDHDOWUH UHDOL]]D]LRQL XPDQLWDULH FRRSHUD]LRQH FRQ RUJDQL]D]LRQL LQWHUQD]LRQDOL H ORFDOL GLDORJR LQ WHUUHOLJLRVRHFF&IUDQFKHODQ *LRLD/&KLDX]]L FVROR O¶XOWLPD SDUWH GHO GLVFRUVR ULJXDUGD GLUHWWDPHQWH LO 6DKDUD DQFKH VH O¶KR WUDGRWWR TXDVL SHU LQWHUR1HOOR VYLOXSSR GHO ODYRUR VFHJOLHUz TXDOFKH SDVVRSHUHYLGHQ]LDUHLQYLDLPPHGLDWDOHSURVSHWWLYHGHOO¶RUDWRUHVXWDOLWHPL FLQUDSSRUWRDLUHWURWHUUDHDOO¶DQWLRFFLGHQWDOLWj O¶LQQHVWR GHL FRQWHQXWL VDKDULDQL QHO SL DPSLR HQXQFLDWR LVODPLFR H QHOO¶LGHRORJLD÷DPƗKƯULDQD ODFRQWLQXDULFHUFDGLOHJLWWLPD]LRQHQHO&RUDQRWUDPLWHO¶©LQWHUSUHWD ]LRQH LQGLYLGXDOHª WDIVƯU ãD܈ېƯ GLUHWWD VHQ]D PHGLD]LRQH GL WHRORJL FXOD PƗ¶JLXVSHULWLIXTDKƗ¶QpãX\njېFDSLUHOLJLRVLLQJHQHUH ODIRU]DWXUDGLWDOHSURFHGLPHQWRLQWHUSUHWDWLYR³LQGLYLGXDOH´VLQRDOOD SURSRVWDGLXQD©VILGDUHOLJLRVDªWDۊDGGƯGƯQƯFKHQRQWURYDSUHFHGHQWLQHOOD WUDGL]LRQHLVODPLFDO¶DSHUWXUDGHOSHOOHJULQDJJLRD0HFFDDOOD*HQWHGHO/L EURHEUHLHFULVWLDQLVLF OD ULYDOVD PHGLDWLFD VXO PDVVLPR YHUWLFH GHOO¶HJHPRQLD H LPSHULDOL VPRRFFLGHQWDOHUDIILJXUD]LRQHGHO3UHVLGHQWHGHJOL86$QHO*%XVK LPSHJQDWRQHOODJXHUUDFRQWURO¶,UDTHFFDOSHOOHJULQDJJLRFKHqGRYHUHLQ GLYLGXDOHIDU ڲFD\QGLRJQLPXVXOPDQRHXQRGHLFLQTXHSLODVWULGHOO¶LVODP DUNƗQDOLVOƗP FLQUDSSRUWRDOOHDPEL]LRQLGLXQUXRORJXLGDQHOO¶LVODPHVXOFRQWLQHQWH DIULFDQR O¶XWLOL]]D]LRQH GL IRUPH VLPEROLFKH WUDGL]LRQDOL LVODP FHOHEUD]LRQH GHO0DZOLGVXJJHVWLRQLWULEDOLSHUOHJLWWLPDUHLFRQWHQXWLQXRYLHRUJDQL]]D UHLFRPSRUWDPHQWLSROLWLFLULYROX]LRQDUL +RHVFOXVRDOFXQHULSHWL]LRQLHDOFXQLFRPSXWLVXOOHIUHTXHQ]HGL*HV0DULDHSURIHWLELEOLFL QHO &RUDQR 2OWUHWXWWR QRQ VRQR GLUHWWDPHQWH FROOHJDWH DOOH WHPDWLFKH VDKDULDQH LQ IXQ]LRQH GHOOHTXDOLWUDGXFRLOGLVFRUVR 7DOHVFHOWDVFULWWXUDOLVWDHVWUHPDYROXWDGDOOHDGHUDOODILQHGHJOLDQQL߇HWXWWRUD YLJHQWH LQ /LELD KD VYXRWDWR LO SRWHUH GHOO¶DXWRULWj UHOLJLRVD VRWWUDHQGROH LO PRQRSROLR GHO O¶LQWHUSUHWD]LRQHKDDFFDQWRQDWRLOFRUSXVGHLFRPPHQWDULFRUDQLFLHFFPHWWHQGRLQTXHVWLR QHODVWUXWWXUDGHOGLULWWRILTKWUDGL]LRQDOHHOLEHUDQGRVLGDQXPHURVLYLQFROLJLXULGLFL,QSD UDOOHORLOSRSXOLVPRGHLFRPLWDWLULYROX]LRQDULDQGDYDVYXRWDQGRFDSLOODUPHQWHO¶DXWRULWjGHOOH IXQ]LRQLSXEEOLFKHHGHOOHLPSUHVHHSULPLDQQL߇³SXULILFDYD´OHPRVFKHH 1RQDFDVRLOSURFHVVRGLFRVWLWX]LRQHGHOO¶8$8QLWj$IULFDQD/RPp7RJRQDWDGDOOD WUDVIRUPD]LRQH GHOO¶28$ 2UJDQL]]D]LRQH GHOO¶8QLWj$IULFDQD VL q DYYLDWR QHOOD 6HVVLRQH VWUDRUGLQDULDGL6LUWH/¶8$ODFXLDVVHPEOHDqIRUPDWDGDLFDSLGLVWDWRDIULFDQLYXR OHFRRUGLQDUHHDFFHOHUDUHO¶LQWHJUD]LRQHSROLWLFDHGHFRQRPLFDIUDLSDHVLQHLGLYHUVLVHWWRUL ROWUHODVDOYDJXDUGLDGHOO¶LQGLSHQGHQ]DGHLGLULWWLXPDQLHO¶HOLPLQD]LRQHGHLUHVLGXLFRORQLD OLVWLFL &XIUD±7LPEXFWX0XWD]LRQL LOWHQWDWLYRGLXQDPRELOLWD]LRQHXQLWDULVWDHDQWLPSHULDOLVWDVXGXSOLFH IURQWHLOIURQWHXQLYHUVDOHGHOO¶LVODPSHULOTXDOHqVWDWRDSSURQWDWRLOSDUWLWR ³*XLGD´JLjGHWWRLOIURQWHUHJLRQDOHGHOOHJHQWLGHO6DKDUDSHULOTXDOHYHUUj DSSURQWDWD XQD ©/HJD VRFLDOH XQLFDGHOOH WULE GHO*UDQGH 6DKDUDª 5ƗELؾDK L÷WLPƗFL\\DKZƗۊLGDKOLTDEƗ¶LODOشDUƗ¶DO.XEUj 7UDGX]LRQH 'LVFRUVR GHO IUDWHOOR OHDGHU GHOOD JXLGD SRSRODUH LVODPLFD PRQGLDOH QHO QDWDOHGHOVLJLOORGHLSURIHWLHGHJOLLQYLDWLSEQHOODFLWWjGL7LPEXFWXQHOOD 5HSXEEOLFDGHO0DOLWHQXWRLOGHOPHVHGL5DEƯF,GHOPHVHGH³O¶XF FHOOR´ >DSULOH@ GDOOD PRUWH GHO SURIHWD '& ,7Ɩ% $/$ 4Ɩ¶,' $/4,<Ɩ'$+ $/â$&%,<<$+ $/,6/Ɩ0,<<$+ $/&Ɩ/$0,<<$+ )Ʈ 0$:/,' Ɩ7,0 $/$1%,<Ɩ¶ :$ /085Ɩ6,/Ʈ1 %,0$'Ʈ1$7 7,0 %8.7Nj %,ö80+Nj5,<<$7 0Ɩ/Ʈ %,7$¶5Ʈ 0,1 â$+5 5$%Ʈ& $/ $::$/ 0,1 â$+5 $/ؽ$<5 0,1 :$)Ɩ7 $/5$6Nj/ 0$6ƮƮ &IULQ7UDGX]LRQHODSDUWH>%@ /DYHUVLRQHLWDOLDQDGHLSDVVLFRUDQLFLFKHULSRUWRVHQ]DDOWUDLQGLFD]LRQHqGL%DXVDQL $JJLXQJRLQQRWDFRPH³:,&6´ODYHUVLRQHDFXUDGHOODFLWDWD'DFZDKLVODPLFDDFRQIHUPD GHOVXRLPSHJQRPLVVLRQDULRFIU:,&6 ,OUDEƯF,HIHEEUDLRLOOHDGHUGHFUHWzO¶LQL]LRGLXQDQXRYDHUDLVODPLFDLQ öDPƗKƯUL\\DK(VVDSDUWHGDOO¶DQQRGLPRUWHGHO3URIHWDLOG&GXQTXHDQQLGRSRO¶H JLUDHG&GDFXLGDWDLOFDOHQGDULROXQDUHLVODPLFRLQYLJRUHGDVHFROL3HUOD PRWLYD]LRQHSDU]LDOPHQWHULSUHVDDOSXQWR>@GHOGLVFRUVRLQWUDGX]LRQHFIUDGHV/LPƗ ڴƗOWD¶UƯېPLQZDIƗWDO5DVnjO©3HUFKpGDWDUHLOWHPSRGDOODPRUWHGHOO¶,QYLDWRª"LQ5LVƗODW DO÷LKƗGPXۊDUUDPP3RWWREUH/¶DWWXDOHFDOHQGDULRFLYLOHOLELFRXVDO¶HUD QXRYDP3G&PDqVRODUH+DJLRUQLHPHVLULQRPLQDWLGDHYHQWLVWDJLRQDOL VWRULD HG HURL GHOO¶DUHD ³SULPDYHUD´ IHEEUDLR ³GDWWHUL´ RWWREUH ³1DVVHU´ OXJOLR JLj GD *LXOLR&HVDUH³$QQLEDOH´DJRVWRJLjGD$XJXVWRHFF/¶HUDOLELFDP3qFDOFRODWDLQGXH PRGL,OFRQWRLQDQQLOXQDULVRWWUDHGDOO¶DQQROXQDUHHJLULDQRLQYHFHLOFRQWRLQDQQLVR ODULVRWWUDHGDOO¶DQQRVRODUHGHOFDOHQGDULRJUHJRULDQR$GHVLOFRQWRSHUO¶DQQROXQDUH P3QHOODFLWD]LRQHSUHFHGHQWHPXۊDUUDPqPHVHOXQDUHULVXOWDHVVHUH>H @ P3G&TXHOORLQQRWDq>H @P3G&HFF,QYHFHLOFRQWR SHUO¶DQQRVRODUHP3DGHVQHOODQRWDqG&> @>VRODUH@P3QHOGLVFRU VRLQWUDGX]LRQHULVXOWDG&> @>VRODUH@P3PDSHURVFLOOD]LRQHGLPHVLDO ODQFDPELDLQG&P3HFF1HOSUHVHQWHODYRURULSRUWHUzGLPRVWUDWLYDPHQWH ODGXSOLFHGDWD]LRQHP3G&TXDOHQHLWHVWL6XHUDPHVLHLGHRORJLDGLWDOHFDOHQGDULRFIU &KLDX]]L *LRLD/&KLDX]]L >S@1HOQRPHGL'LR&OHPHQWHH0LVHULFRUGLRVR ©,QYHULWj,GGLRHJOLDQJHOL6XRLSUHJDQRSHO3URIHWD2YRLFKHFUHGHWH3UHJDWHDQ FKHYRLSHUOXLHVDOXWDWHORGLVDOXWRGLSDFHª&RU >3DUWH08ণ$00$'&+,8'(,/&,&/2'(//$5,9(/$=,21(@ >,O5DEƯF,DQQLYHUVDULRGLQDVFLWDHPRUWHGHO3URIHWD@ 'DOODVWRULFDFLWWjPDGƯQDKGL7LPEXFWXFLULYROJLDPRDOOD&RPXQLWj LVODPLFD8PPDKLVOƗPL\\DKHDOPRQGRLQWHURLQXQJLRUQRJUDQGLRVRQHOOD VWRULDGHOO¶XPDQLWjOXQHGuUDEƯF,ÊXQJLRUQRPHPRUDELOHHVWUDRUGLQDULR QHOODVWRULDGHOJHQHUHXPDQR,QIDWWLOXQHGuGLWDOHPHVHOXQDUHqQDWRH± VDSSLDWH±qDQFKHPRUWR>G&@0XDPPDGVXGLOXLVLDQRODSUHJKLHUDH ODEHQHGL]LRQHGLYLQDLO6LJLOORGHLSURIHWL >3HUFKpO¶HUDGDOODPRUWHGHO3URIHWD@ /¶XPDQLWj KD GXH JLRUQL GD FXL GRYUHEEH LQL]LDUH OD GDWD]LRQH /¶XQR q TXHOORLQFXLQDFTXH*HVFƮVjVXGLOXLVLDODEHQHGL]LRQH>ILJOLRGL0DULD@ SHUFKp LO VXR QDWDOH >YHUJLQDOH@ IX XQ PLUDFROR PXF÷L]DK H XQR GHL VHJQL Ɨ\DKGL'LRO¶DOWURqRJJLJLRUQRLQFXLQDFTXHHPRUuLO6LJLOORGHLSURIH WL'REELDPRGDWDUHLOWHPSRGDLGXHHYHQWLDIILDQFDWLGDOODQDVFLWDGL*HV SHUFKqqXQPLUDFRORHGDOODPRUWHGL0XDPPDGSESHUFKpHJOLqLO6LJLO ORGHLSURIHWL6RQRWUDVFRUVLDQQLGDOODPRUWHGL0XDPPDGSELO6L JLOORGHLSURIHWL>«@>S@'DTXHOJLRUQRODULYHOD]LRQH>GLYLQD@ZD\ۊVLq LQWHUURWWD,OFLHORKDVPHVVRGLSDUODUHDOODWHUUDHDOOHVXHJHQWL6LQRDO*LRU :,&6©,QYHUR$OODKHL6XRLDQJHOLEHQHGLFRQRLO3URIHWDRFUHGHQWLEHQHGLWHORGXQTXHH DXVSLFDWHJOLODSDFHª&RU 3LROWUHO¶$XVHUjLOWHUPLQHTDU\DKFIULQ7UDGX]LRQHDOSXQWR>%@ 3DVVR FRUDQLFR IRQGDPHQWDOH D ULJXDUGR FKH FKLXGH OD ULYHOD]LRQH GRSR 0XতDPPDG ©0X ۊDPPDGQRQqSDGUHGLQHVVXQRIUDLYRVWULXRPLQLEHQVuqLO0HVVDJJHURUDVnjODGL'LRHLO 6XJJHOOR ېƗWDPD ¶ODQEL\j¶ GHL 3URIHWLª &RU :,&6 ©0XতDPPHG QRQ q SDGUH GL QHVVXQRGHLYRVWULXRPLQLEHQVu0HVVDJJHURGL'LRHLO6XJJHOORGHL3URIHWLª&RU 3HUO¶LVODPFKHULILXWDLGRJPLGLEDVHGHOODFULVWLDQLWj7ULQLWj,QFDUQD]LRQH&URFH*HVIL JOLRGL0DULDq3URIHWDH,QYLDWRGL'LRFKHQRQKDVFHOWR³FRPSDJQDQpILJOLR´&RUH ³QRQJHQHUzQpIXJHQHUDWR´&RU6XOODQDVFLWDYHUJLQDOHGL*HV©(UDPPHQWDDQ FRUD FROHL FKH FXVWRGu OD VXD YHUJLQLWj Vu FKH 1RL DOLWDPPR LQ OHL GHO 1RVWUR VSLULWR H UHQ GHPPROHLHVXRILJOLRXQ6HJQRƗ\DWDQSHUOHFUHDWXUHª&RU:,&6©(ULFRUGDFR OHLFKHSUHVHUYzLOVXRJUHPERLQFXLVRIILDPGHO1RVWUR6SLULWRHIDFHPPRGLHVVDHGHOGLOHL ILJOLRORXQSURGLJLRSHUO¶XPDQLWjª&RU &XIUD±7LPEXFWX0XWD]LRQL QRGHOOD5HVXUUH]LRQH<DZPDO4L\ƗPDKQRQFLVDUDQQRDOWUDULYHOD]LRQHQp DOWURPHVVDJJLRGDOFLHOR ©HDLPHVVDJJHULVDUjILVVDWRLOWHPSR±3HUTXDOJLRUQRTXDOJLRUQRVDUDQFKLDPDWLD FRQYHJQR"±3HO'uGHOOD'HFLVLRQH<DZPLDO)DصOLª&RU /¶XPDQLWj KD ULFHYXWR O¶XOWLPR PHVVDJJLR FHOHVWH WUDPLWH 0XতDPPDG SE>«@ 3XUWURSSRODVWRULDHODIRUPD]LRQHFKHRJJLVLULFHYHDOPDQKD÷DOODסƯQD TUD¶njKX ORF pOOƯ QpJUDK VRQR VEDJOLDWL LQDWWHQGLELOL>*OL RFFLGHQWDOL@ ULWHQJRQRHUURQHDPHQWHFKH0XতDPPDGSEVLD3URIHWDVRORSHUJOLDUDELR SHU L PXVXOPDQL &Lz q IDOVR SHUFKp HJOL q3URIHWDSHU O¶XPDQLWj LQWHUD H KD DEURJDWRWXWWHOHUHOLJLRQLSUHFHGHQWLDOXL6H*HVIRVVHYLVVXWRDOO¶HSRFDLQ FXLIXLQYLDWR0XতDPPDGSEQHVDUHEEHGLYHQXWRVHJXDFH/¶XPDQLWjLQWH UDGHYHHVVHUHPXVXOPDQDSHUFKpORYXROH'LR7XWWDYLDQRQORGLYHQWHUjID FLOPHQWH'LRDIIHUPD ©,Q YHULWj OD 5HOLJLRQH SUHVVR 'LR q O¶,VOjPª &RU ©( FKLXQTXH GHVLGHUL XQDUHOLJLRQHGLYHUVDGDOO¶,VOjPQRQJOLVDUjDFFHWWDWDGD'LRHGHJOLQHOO¶DOWUDYLWD VDUjIUDLSHUGHQWLª&RU >3DUWH/¶2&&,'(17(1(0,&2'(//¶,6/$0@ >/HYLJQHWWHVDWLULFKHFRQWUR0XতDPPDG,QYLDWRGLYLQRXQLYHUVDOH@ >«@6LDPRYHQXWLDFRQRVFHQ]DGHOO¶LQJLXULRVRDWWDFFRWDKD÷÷XPFRQ WURLO3URIHWD0XতDPPDGSEODJJL>LQ6FDQGLQDYLD@7XWWLL PXVXOPDQL VL VRQR DGLUDWL (UDQR FRQYLQWL FKH VL WUDWWDVVH GL XQD IRUPD GL GHQLJUD]LRQH GHOORUR3URIHWD7XWWDYLDFKLKDUHFDWRWDOHRIIHVDDOO¶LQGLUL]]RGL0XতDPPDG :,&6©(TXDQGRLSURIHWLVDUDQFRQYRFDWL³3HUTXDOJLRUQRqVWDWRFLzILVVDWR"´3HO*LRUQR GHO *LXGL]LRª &RU 7DOH *LRUQR q XQD GHOOH YHULj GL IHGH FDTƗ¶LG LQGLFDWH QHO &RUDQR©ODYHUDSLHWjqTXHOODGLFKLFUHGHLQ'LRHQHOO¶8OWLPR*LRUQRDO<DZPLDOƖېLUL HQHJOL$QJHOLHQHO/LEURHQHL3URIHWLª&RU:,&6©/DSLHWjqGLTXHOOLFKHFUHGR QRLQ'LRQHO*LRUQR(VWUHPRQHJOLDQJHOLQHO/LEURHQHL3URIHWLª&RU /HWW ©LO FXUULFXOXP FKH VWXGLDPRª &IU QHO WHVWR DQFKH DL SXQWL >@ H SL HVSOLFLWDPHQWH >@©FXUULFXOXPVFRODVWLFRªPDQKD÷PDGUDVƯROWUHDOODQ :,&6©/D5HOLJLRQHSUHVVR$OODKqO¶,VOjPª&RU :,&6 ©( FKL VHJXH XQD IHGH GLIIHUHQWH GDOO¶,VOjP TXHVWD QRQ YHUUj DFFHWWDWD GD /XL H DO O¶$OGLOjVDUjSHUGHQWHª&RU &IU GLVHJXLWR QHO WHVWR 6FDQGLQDYLD LQ JHQHUH LQ FXL qFRPSUHVDOD 'DQLPDUFD RYH IXURQR HGLWHOHYLJQHWWHVDWLULFKHLQTXHVWLRQH *LRLD/&KLDX]]L SE KD LQJLXULDWR DQFKH LO SURSULR 3URIHWD SRLFKp 0XDPPDG SE q WDOH SHUWXWWLJOLHVVHULXPDQLVLDQRLQ6FDQGLQDYLDLQ(XURSDLQ$PHULFDLQ$VLD RLQ$IULFD>S@,QYHULWjODIRUPD]LRQHFKHULFHYRQRDOPDQKD÷DOODڴƯ\D TUD¶njQDKXORFpOOƯ\pJUDK¶OOƯƯJUDLQ6FDQGLQDYLDqIDOVDPX]DZZDU HLQFLWDDOO¶RGLR6RQRFRQYLQWLFKH0XতDPPDGSEQRQVLD3URIHWDSHUOR URPHQWUHHJOLqVWDWRLQYLDWRDOO¶XPDQLWjLQWHUD>«@ >0LVFRQRVFHUH0XতDPPDGqODIDOVLILFD]LRQHGHOOH6FULWWXUH@ &RPXQTXHQRQF¶qGXEELRFKHLOPRGRGLSHQVDUHGHOO¶RFFLGHQWH(XURSD H $PHULFD LQFLWD DOO¶RGLR >S @ Ê FRUURWWR LQXPDQR H VL IRQGD VXOO¶HUURUH ېDܒD¶ ,QIDWWL L FRVLGGHWWL $QWLFR 7HVWDPHQWR DOF$KG DO4DGƯP H 1XRYR 7HVWDPHQWRDOF$KGDOöDGƯGQRQVRQRTXHOOLDXWHQWLFL>ULYHODWLGD'LR@6L WUDWWD GL GXH IDOVL PX]DZZDUƗQ VFULWWL SHU PDQR >XPDQD@ FHQWLQDLD G¶DQQL GRSR*HV,QWDOHFRVLGGHWWD%LEELDYLVRQRSDUROHFKHQRQqYHURVLPLOHDWWUL EXLUHNDOƗPOƗ\DOƯTD*HVHQHSSXUHD0RVq6HYRJOLDPRUHWWLILFDUHODVL WXD]LRQH GHO JHQHUH XPDQRH YLYHUH LQ XQ YLOODJJLRXQLYHUVDOH TDU\DK NDZ QL\\DKFKHVLDFRQIRUPHDOODJOREDOL]]D]LRQHFDZODPDKGREELDPRFHUFDUH OD%LEELDDXWHQWLFD܈DۊƯۊSHUFKpTXHOODDWWXDOHqIDOVLILFDWD/¶DWWXDOH%LEELD QRQSDUODGL0XতDPPDGSEPHQWUHTXHOODULYHODWDGDO6LJQRUHORPHQ]LR QDYDULSHWXWDPHQWH'REELDPRFHUFDUHLO9DQJHORGL%DUQDED±GL6DQ%DUQD ED±SHUFKpqTXHOORDXWHQWLFR(VVRPHQ]LRQD0XতDPPDGSESUHFLVDQGR FKHYHUUjGRSR*HVFKHQHDEURJKHUjODUHOLJLRQHHFKHVDUjLQYLDWRGD'LR TXDOH3URIHWDSHUWXWWDO¶XPDQLWj>«@ /HWW©LOFXUULFXOXPFKHVWXGLDQRª&IUDOODQ /¶LVODPFRQVHUYDO¶DFFXVDFRUDQLFDGLIDOVLILFD]LRQHWDۊUvIGHOOH6FULWWXUHGDSDUWHGHOOD*HQ WHGHO/LEURUHODWLYDPHQWHDOWHVWRQD߃܈܈ULEDGLWDDQFKHQHO'LVFRUVRLQWUDGX]LRQH߃H DOVL JQLILFDWR PDFkQj /¶DFFXVD ULFRUUH LQ QXPHURVL SDVVL GHO &RUDQR DG HV &RU HFFVSHVVRQHOWHVWRFIUODYRFH WDۊUƯIDFXUDGL+/D]DUXV<DIHKLQ(QF\ FORSpGLHGHO¶,VODPQpW;/HLGHQ±%RVWRQ%ULOO,ELGULQYLLDOOHVXUHFRUDQLFKHH ELEOLRJUDILD6XOODFRQYLQ]LRQHGHOULWURYDPHQWRGHOO¶DXWHQWLFR9DQJHORGHOOHRULJLQLFIUODQ VHJXHQWH 3HUO¶LVODPOHDXWHQWLFKHHGL]LRQLRULJLQDULHPRVDLFDHFULVWLDQDGHOOH6FULWWXUHDQQXQFLDYDQR 0XতDPPDG &RU PHQWUH O¶$QWLFR H LO 1XRYR 7HVWDPHQWR ³IDOVLILFDWL´ GDOOD *HQWHGHO/LEURQRQORPHQ]LRQDQRDIIDWWRGDTXLLOVXRPLVFRQRVFLPHQWR,O9DQJHORGL%DU QDEDGDOODPRGHUQDDSRORJHWLFDPXVXOPDQDqULWHQXWRLOSHUGXWRYDQJHOR©VHPLWLFRªFRQGDQ QDWRGDSDSD*HODVLR,QHOVHF9(VVDYLUDYYLVDLO³ULWURYDWR´DXWHQWLFR9DQJHOR,Q÷ƯOGHO OHRULJLQLGDVRVWLWXLUHDTXHOOL³IDOVLILFDWL´GDLFULVWLDQL,QYHFHODFULWLFDVWRULFDORULWLHQHXQ PDQRVFULWWRLWDOLDQRGHO;9,;9,,VHFROR%LEOLRWHFDGL9LHQQDDOWUDYHUVLRQHLQVSDJQRORUL WURYDWD D 6LGQH\ $XVWUDOLD GL SUREDELOH RULJLQH R DGDWWDPHQWR LQ FRQWHVWR LVSDQRPRUHVFR FKHULVSRQGHDXQDFULVWRORJLDFRUDQLFDHDXQDYLVLRQHLVODPLFDGHO0HVVLD6XOODFULWLFDVWR &XIUD±7LPEXFWX0XWD]LRQL >5HWWLILFDGHOPRGRGLSHQVDUHRFFLGHQWDOH@ >S@>«@6H>JOLRFFLGHQWDOL@YRJOLRQRVWDUHLQSDFHFRQQRL>PXVXOPD QL@RFFRUUHIRUPDUHGHLFRPLWDWLSHUODUHYLVLRQHGHOORURPRGRGLSHQVDUHH GHOOD VWHVVD %LEELD GDWR FKH q FRQWUDIIDWWD 6RQRVWDWL FRVWLWXLWL GHL FRPLWDWL DPHULFDQRPXVXOPDQLSHUODUHYLVLRQHGHOFXUULFXOXPVFRODVWLFRPDQKD÷PD GUDVƯQHLSDHVLLVODPLFLSDULPHQWLVHQHGHYRQRIRUPDUHDOWULLVODPRDPHUL FDQLSHUODUHYLVLRQHGLTXHOORDPHULFDQRHGHXURSHR>«@ >3DUWH&217526),'('(//¶,6/$0$//¶2&&,'(17(@ >$©/DFRQWURVILGDUHOLJLRVDªDOWDDGGƯDOGƯQƯ@ >$,OWULRQIRGHOO¶LVODP@ >S@>«@'LRKDGHWWR ©Ê/XLFKHKDPDQGDWRLO6XR0HVVDJJHURFRQOD5HWWD*XLGDFRQOD5HOLJLRQH9HUD GƯQLDOۊDTTLSHUIDUODWULRQIDUHOL\XܲKLUDKXVXRJQLDOWUDUHOLJLRQHDQFKHDGLVSHW WRGHLSDJDQLPXãULNnjQDSROLWHLVWLLGRODWULª&RU /R KD ULSHWXWR LQ GXH VXUH GHO &RUDQR &RU 3HUFLz QRQ YL SUHRFFXSDWHYRJOLDQRRPHQRODUHOLJLRQHGL0XতDPPDGSEWULRQIHUjVX WXWWHOHDOWUHSHUFKpORKDGHWWR'LR ULFDFIU6ORPSH'H(SDOVD3HUODYHUVLRQHLQLWDOLDQRPRGHUQRGLWDOH9DQJHOR VLYHGD*LXVWROLVL5L]]DUGL ,OWHPDGHLFRPLWDWLSHUODUHYLVLRQHGHLWHVWLQRQqQXRYRDOO¶$*LjQHOLO6HPLQDULRLQ WHUQD]LRQDOH LVODPRFULVWLDQR WHQXWR D 7ULSROL VRWWR LO SDWURQDWR XIILFLDOH GHOOD /LELD H GHOOD 6DQWD6HGH9DWLFDQRDOSXQWRGHOOH©5LVROX]LRQLHUDFFRPDQGD]LRQLª7DZ܈L\\ƗWZDPX TDUUDUƗWFRPSUHVHQHOOD©'LFKLDUD]LRQHILQDOHªDO%D\ƗQDOQLKƗ¶ƯSUHYHGHYDODFRRSHUD ]LRQHDOFDPDODOPXãWDUDNELODWHUDOHSHUODUHYLVLRQHGHLFXUULFXODDOPDQƗKL÷GHLWHVWLGL VFXRODDONXWXEDOGLUƗVL\\DKHG¶DOWULRULHQWDOLVWLPXVWDãULTnjQHGRWWLFXOƗPƗ¶G¶DPEROH SDUWLSLODSURPHVVDZDFGGDSDUWHFULVWLDQDGLFRQVXOWDUHLVWLãƗUDKFXOƗPƗ¶PXVXOPDQLVX TXDQWR VL VFULYH VXOO¶LVODP QHOOH VFXROH FULVWLDQH&IU QHJOL $WWL 1DGZDW DOۉLZƗU DOLVOƗPƯ DOPDVƯۊƯܑDUƗEXOXVصDIDUKILEUƗ\UãXEƗܒPDO0DNWDEDOãDFEƯOLO LWWL܈ƗODOېƗUL÷Ư0X¶WDPDUDOãDFEDOFƗPDOöDPƗKƯUL\\DKDOFDUDEL\\DKDOOƯEL\\DKDOãDFD EL\\DKDOLãWLUƗNL\\DKZ5P©6HPLQDULRGHO'LDORJRLVODPRFULVWLDQR7ULSROL صDIDUHIHEEUDLRãXEƗؾG&8IILFLRSRSRODUHSHULO&ROOHJDPHQWRHVWH UR&RQJUHVVRJHQHUDOHGHOSRSRORöDPƗKƯUL\\DKDUDEDOLELFDSRSRODUHVRFLDOLVWDP3 G&ªSSS :,&6©(G(JOLq&ROXLFKHLQYLzLO6XR0HVVRFRQODUHWWD*XLGDHODYHUD)HGHSHUIDUOD SUHYDOHUHVXRJQLDOWUDFUHGHQ]DDGLVSHWWRGHLSROLWHLVWLª&RU *LRLD/&KLDX]]L ©SHUFKp SUHYDOJD VXOOH UHOLJLRQL WXWWH DQFKH D GLVSHWWR GHJOL LGRODWUL PXãULNnjQDª &RU >$/DFUHVFLWDGHOO¶LVODPLQRFFLGHQWH@ 1RQ FL RFFRUURQR OD VSDGDR OH ERPEH SHU GLIIRQGHUH O¶LVODP 2UPDL LQ (XURSDDEELDPRFLQTXDQWDPLOLRQLGLPXVXOPDQL/uDQFKHDOWULVHJQDOLLQ GLFDQR FKH'LR YL IDUj WULRQIDUH O¶LVODP VHQ]D >ULFRUVR D@ VSDGD IXFLOH FRQ TXLVWD PLOLWDUH IDW> ۊS @ , FLQTXDQWD PLOLRQL GL PXVXOPDQL LQ (XURSD IUD TXDOFKHGHFLQDG¶DQQLODWUDVIRUPHUDQQRLQXQFRQWLQHQWHPXVXOPDQR'LRKD SXUH LQGRWWRXQDQD]LRQH XPPDK PXVXOPDQD OD 7XUFKLD D HQWUDUH QHOO¶8 QLRQH(XURSHD6LWUDWWDGLDOWULFLQTXDQWDPLOLRQLVLFFKpLPXVXOPDQLLQ(X URSDGLYHUUDQQRFHQWRPLOLRQL1HOO¶8QLRQH(XURSHDVRQRHQWUDWHDQFKHO¶$O EDQLDFKHqXQR6WDWRPXVXOPDQRHOD%RVQLDDOWUR6WDWRPXVXOPDQRRDOFLQ TXDQWDSHUFHQWRWDOH$EELDPRVWDWLVWLFKHFKHPRVWUDQRFRPHLOQXPHURGHOOH PRVFKHHPDVƗ÷LGLQ(XURSDVLFRQWLDPLJOLDLD(SRLOjDEELDPRDQFKHPL JOLDLD GL RUJDQL]]D]LRQL PXQDܲܲDPƗW H GL DVVRFLD]LRQL ÷DPFL\\ƗW LVODPL FKH/¶(XURSDRJJLVLWURYDQHOORVWHVVRGLOHPPDGHOO¶$PHULFDRFROSDVVD UHGHOWHPSRDFFHWWDGLGLYHQWDUHPXVXOPDQDRSSXUHGLFKLDUDJXHUUDۊDUEDL PXVXOPDQL >$/¶LQYLWRDOSHOOHJULQDJJLRqXQLYHUVDOH@ 'DWRFKHVHFRQGRLO&RUDQR0XতDPPDGSEq3URIHWDSHUWXWWLJOLXR PLQLQƗVWXWWLVRQRLQYLWDWLDULVSRQGHUHDOVXRDSSHOOR'LRKDGHWWRD0X তDPPDGSEGLLQYLWDUHJOLXRPLQLDOSHOOHJULQDJJLRۊD÷÷'LRJOLKDGHWWR ³LQYLWDWXWWLJOLXRPLQLQƗV :,&6 ©3HU IDUOD SUHYDOHUH VX WXWWH TXDQWH OH UHOLJLRQL PDOJUDGR FKH TXHVWR GLVSLDFFLD LP PHQVDPHQWHDJOLLGRODWULª&RU 3HU XQ DJHYROH DJJLRUQDPHQWR DQQXR VXOO¶LPPLJUD]LRQH FRQ ULIHULPHQWL DL SDHVL GL SURYH QLHQ]DHVLWXD]LRQLVRFLDOLFIULO'RVVLHUGHOOD&DULWDVSHULO&$5,7$60,*5$17(6 $>SS@ULSUHQGH ©+RGHOOHVWDWLVWLFKHFRLQXPHUL&RPHDEELDPRGHWWRLQ(XURSDFL VRQRFLQTXDQWDPLOLRQLGLPXVXOPDQLTXDWWRUGLFLPLODPRVFKHHHFHQWULLVODPLFLPLOOHFLQTXH FHQWRIUDRUJDQL]]D]LRQLDVVRFLD]LRQLHGHQWLLVODPLFL&ROWHPSRDXPHQWHUDQQRHSRLYDQQR DJJLXQWH OD 7XUFKLD OD %RVQLD H O¶$OEDQLD 6LVWDFRPSLHQGR TXDQWR 'LR KD GHWWR QHO &RUD QRª &XIUD±7LPEXFWX0XWD]LRQL ©( OHYD IUD JOL XRPLQL >QƗVL@ YRFH G¶LQYLWR DO SHOOHJULQDJJLR Vu FKH YHQJDQR D WH D SLHGL H VX FDPPHOOL VODQFLDWL FKH YHQJDQR D WH GDRJQL YDOLFR IRQGR WUD L PRQWLª &RU QRQ VROR JOL DUDEL R VROR L PXVXOPDQL´ 3HUFKp" 3HUFKp 0XতDPPDG SEq3URIHWDSHUO¶XPDQLWjHSHUFKpOD>.DFEDKD@0HFFDqLOSULPR7HPSLR %D\WFKH'LR KD HGLILFDWRSHU JOL XRPLQL SHU LO FXOWR VXOOD WHUUD ,O &RUDQR UHFLWD ©,QYHULWjLOSULPR7HPSLR>%D\WLQ@FKHVLDVWDWRIRQGDWRSHUJOLXRPLQLqFHUWRTXHO ORFKHqLQ%DNNDEHQHGHWWRH*XLGDSHUWXWWRLO&UHDWR>FƖODPƯQD@ª&RU ³3HUWXWWRLO&UHDWRFƖODPƯQµLO&UHDWR¶LQFOXVLJOLHVVHULYLYHQWL´VLJQL ILFDQRQVRORSHUJOLDUDELRLPXVXOPDQLPDSHUWXWWLJOLXRPLQL4XHVWRSUL PR7HPSLRFKHqVWDWRIRQGDWRGD'LRVXOODWHUUDSHULOFXOWRIXIRQGDWRSHU WXWWL>S@ ©(JOLXRPLQL>QƗVL@GHEERQRD'LRLOSHOOHJULQDJJLRDO7HPSLR%D\WLTXHOOLGLORUR FKHDEELDQODSRVVLELOLWjGLIDUHTXHOYLDJJLRª&RU 'LRQRQORKDGHWWRVRORDJOLDUDELRVRORDLPXVXOPDQLORKDGHWWRDWXW WL+DSXUHDJJLXQWR ©(TXDQGRIDFHPPRGHOOD6DQWD&DVDOXRJRGLULXQLRQHHGLVLFXURULIXJLRSHUJOLXR PLQL>PDܔƗEDWDQOLOQƗVL@ª&RU ³/XRJRGLULXQLRQHHGLVLFXURULIXJLRPDܔƗEDK´VLJQLILFD³OXRJRGLUL WURYRGLUDGXQRPXOWDTj´SHUWXWWLJOLXRPLQL7XWWLKDQQRLOGLULWWRGLFRP SLHUHLOSHOOHJULQDJJLRD0HFFDODFLUFXPDPEXOD]LRQHDWWRUQRDOOD.DFEDKGL FRUUHUH WUD ৡDIƗ H 0DUZD GL VRVWDUH SUHVVR LO PRQWH >QHOOD SLDQD@ GL F$UDID :,&6©6HFKLDPLLIHGHOLDOSHOOHJULQDJJLRWLYHQJRQRDSLHGLHVXVQHOOHFDYDOFDWXUHDUUL YDQGRGDRJQLUHPRWDYDOOHª&RU/¶$ULFKLDPDLYHUVHWWLFRUDQLFL&RUVHJJ DOODEDVHGHOO¶REEOLJRULWXDOHGHOSHOOHJULQDJJLRFKHqXQRGHLFLQTXHSLODVWULDUNƗQGHOO¶L VODPDVVLHPH D SURIHVVLRQH GL IHGH SUHJKLHUDFDQRQLFD HOHPRVLQD OHJDOH GLJLXQR GL UDPD ঌƗQ :,&6©/DSULPDFDVDFKHVLHUHVVHSHUODJHQWHqTXHOODFKHVLWURYDDOOD0HFFDIDXVWDHJXL GDSHUO¶XPDQLWjª&RU :,&6 ©§ GRYHU GHJOL XRPLQL IDU LO SHOOHJULQDJJLR DOOD &DVD TXDQGR QH DEELD OD FDSDFLWjª &RU :,&6©(DOORUDFKHIDFHPPRGHOOD&DVDLOSXQWRGLULIHULPHQWRSHUXRPLQLª&RU *LRLD/&KLDX]]L F$UDIƗWHGLODSLGDUHOHILJXUHGL6DWDQDQHOOH>WUH@VWHOLFKHVRQRDGF$TDEDK >IUD 0HFFD H 0X]GDOLIDK@ 7XWWL VRQR LQYLWDWL D FRPSLHUH >L VXGGHWWL ULWL GHO SHOOHJULQDJJLR@QRQVRORJOLDUDELHLPXVXOPDQLODFLUFXPDPEXOD]LRQHؾD ZƗIDWWRUQRDOOD.DFEDKSHUFKpHVVDqLO7HPSLRGL'LRSHUWXWWLODFRUVDVD F \IUDৡDIƗH0DUZDODVRVWDZXTnjISUHVVRLOPRQWH>QHOODSLDQD@GLF$UDID ODODSLGD]LRQHUD÷PGHOOHILJXUHGL6DWDQDQHOOH>WUH@VWHOL >$3URSRVWDGLDSHUWXUDGHOSHOOHJULQDJJLRDOOD*HQWHGHO/LEURVLF ,O3UHVLGHQWHGHJOL86$qDFFROWRDOSHOOHJULQDJJLRVLF@ 2JJLJLRUQRQRLFRPPHWWLDPRXQHUURUHېDܒƗ¶&KLSURLELVFHDWXWWLJOL XRPLQLGLFRPSLHUHLOSHOOHJULQDJJLRDO7HPSLRGL'LR"4XDOHqODUDJLRQH" >«@ 1RQ DEELDPR DOFXQD JLXVWLILFD]LRQH PXEDUULU SHU LPSHGLUOR D FRORUR >FKH DSSDUWHQJRQR DOOD *HQWH GHO /LEUR HEUHL H FULVWLDQL@ 6H YLHQH LO 3UHVL GHQWH GHOOD )UDQFLD GHJOL 6WDWL 8QLWL G¶$PHULFD RGHOO¶,WDOLD H DIIHUPD ©+R ULVSRVWRDOO¶LQYLWRODEED\WX¶OQLGƗ¶HFRPSLUzODFLUFXPDPEXOD]LRQHDWWRUQR DOOD .DFEDKª FRVD JOL ULVSRQGHUHPR" 1RQ DEELDPR DUJRPHQWL ۊX÷÷DK 1HO&RUDQRDEELDPRXQVRORYHUVHWWRFKH±VHVLDSSOLFDDORUR>*HQWHGHO/L EUR@±GLFRQVHJXHQ]DQRQVRQRDELOLWDWLDFRPSLHUHLOSHOOHJULQDJJLR4XDO¶q" $VFROWDWHOREHQH/¶XQLFRYHUVHWWRFRUDQLFRFKHOLLPSHGLVFHGLDYYLFLQDUVL>S @DO7HPSLR6DFURDO%D\WDOۉDUƗPUHFLWD ©2YRLFKHFUHGHWH,QYHULWjJOLLGRODWULPXãULNnjQDSROLWHLVWLLGRODWULVRQRVR]]XUD QD÷DVXQ LPSXULWj H QRQ V¶DFFRVWLQR GXQTXH DO 7HPSLR 6DFUR DO0DV÷LGD ¶OۉD UƗPDGRSRTXHVWRORURDQQRª&RU 7XWWDYLD SRVVLDPR GLUH ORUR>*HQWHGHO /LEUR@ ©9RL VLHWH LPSXULWj QD ÷DVHSROLWHLVWLPXãULNnjQ"ª4XDQGRLO3UHVLGHQWHGHJOL6WDWL8QLWLG¶$PHUL FDYLHQH>D0HFFD@DFRPSLHUHLOSHOOHJULQDJJLROLVILGLDPRDGLUJOL©7XVHL LPSXURHVHLSROLWHLVWDPXãULNª&LULVSRQGHUHEEH©,RQRQVRQRSROLWHLVWDH QRQVRQRLPSXUR&RPHPDLPLLPSXWDWHDFFXVHFRVuJUDYLېDܒƯUDK"6HIRV VL LPSXUR SHUFKp PL VWULQJHUHVWH OD PDQR PDQJHUHVWH H EHUUHVWH FRQ PH" ( FRPHSRWUHVWHIDUHDPLFL]LDHDOOHDQ]DFRQPHHVWDUHLQPLDFRPSDJQLD"6H 0LQ÷ƗQLELQƗ ©'D SDUWH QRVWUDª PD SRWUHEEHDQFKH LQWHQGHUVL ©6HFRQGR QRL QHOOD QRVWUD RSLQLRQHª /DEED\ND$OOƗKXPPD©(FFRPLD7HR'LRªqODIRUPXODWDOEL\DKULSHWXWDGDL3HOOHJULQLDL /XRJKL6DQWLTXDOHULVSRVWDDOO¶LQYLWRGL'LR :,&6©2FUHGHQWL,SDJDQLVRQRLQYHURXQODLGXPH&KHQRQV¶DYYLFLQLQRDOOD0RVFKHD6D FUDDGHFRUUHUHGDTXHVWRORURDQQRª&RU &XIUD±7LPEXFWX0XWD]LRQL IRVVLLPSXURQRQPLWRFFKHUHVWHª'LUHEEHORUR©,RQRQVRQRQpLPSXURQp SROLWHLVWDª &L WLUHUHEEH IXRUL LO GROODUR FRQ FXLWUDWWDWH HVFODPDQGR ©3UHJR OHJJHWHFKHVWDVFULWWRVXOGROODURFRQFXLWUDWWDWHª&RPHKDSUHFLVDWRLOWUD GXWWRUHF¶qVFULWWR©,Q*RG:H7UXVWª(EEHQHVROWDQWRDOSROLWHLVWDHDOO¶LP SXURqYLHWDWRDFFRVWDUVLDO7HPSLR6DFUR0DFKLqLOSROLWHLVWD"&KLO¶LPSX UR"1HVVXQRGHOOH*HQWLGHO/LEURFLGLUj©,RVRQRSROLWHLVWDªR©VRQRLPSX URª3LXWWRVWRDIIHUPHUj©1HO&RUDQRLOSHOOHJULQDJJLRD0HFFDqSURLELWRDO SROLWHLVWDHDOO¶LPSXURPDLQGHILQLWLYDOD*HQWHGHO/LEURQRQORqª 6L WUDWWD GL XQD TXHVWLRQH SUREOHPDWLFD LãNƗOL\\DK Ê XQD QXRYD VILGD ODQFLDWDGD7LPEXFWXLQTXHVWDJUDQGHJLRUQDWD2JJLGRSRTXHVWRJLRUQRGL 7LPEXFWXLOPRQGRGHYHULFRQVLGHUDUHGDWL>FRPXQHPHQWHDFFHWWDWLFRPH@LQ FRQWHVWDELOL>«@ >%/DFRQWURVILGDVRFLDOHGHOOHQD]LRQLDOWDۊDGGƯDOTDZPƯ@ >%/HWUDPHVWRULFKHGHOFRORQLDOLVPR@ >S@>«@0DSHUFKpDEELDPRVFHOWR>GLODQFLDUH@WDOHVILGDWDDGGƯ GD7LPEXFWXHQRQGDXQDOWUROXRJRGLWXWWRLOPRQGRLVODPLFR"/DUDJLRQHq FKHTXHVWRSDHVHTDU\DKRTXHVW¶RDVLZƗۊDKKDULOHYDQ]DVWRULFDGDOSXQWR GLYLVWDUHOLJLRVRHVRFLDOH'DTXLLQSDVVDWRO¶LVODPVLqLUUDGLDWRQHOFRQWL QHQWHDIULFDQRHVLqHVWHVRLQRJQLSDUWHGHOPRQGRLVODPLFRqJUDQGHJORULD PD÷GHVWRULFRRQRUHãDUDISHUJOLDELWDQWLGL7LPEXFWX/DVXDLPPDJLQH ROWUHSDVVDYD JOL RUL]]RQWL , VXRL DELWDQWL HUDQR GRWWL FKH LQ TXHVW¶RDVL QHO FXRUHGHO6DKDUDGHGLFDYDQRODYLWDDGLIIRQGHUHOD3DURODGL'LR0DSRLFKH qDFFDGXWR",QHPLFLGL'LRLQHPLFLGL0XDPPDGSELO6LJLOORGHLSURIH WLGLYLQLLQHPLFLGHO/LEURGL'LRLO&RUDQR>S@>«@FRORURFKHRGLDQR WDOH/LEURVHQWLURQRFKHQHO*UDQGH6DKDUDHVLVWHYDXQIDURFKLDPDWR7LPEXF WXHGHFLVHURGLVSHJQHUQHODOXFH$QGDURQRDFHUFDUHGRY¶HUD7XWWDO¶(XURSD SUHVHDFHUFDUH7LPEXFWXPDQRQQHLQGLYLGXDYDQRLOOXRJRSHUFKpDOO¶HSRFD QRQQHHVLWHYDDQFRUDXQDFDUWDJHRJUDILFDېƗULؾDK2FFXSDURQROD7XQLVLDH DQFRUDSULPDO¶$OJHULDRFFXSDURQRLO6HQHJDOHLO&LDG0DQGDURQRGHOOHSDW WXJOLHULFRJQLWLYHGDZUL\\ƗWLVWLؾOƗFQHO*UDQGH6DKDUD9HQQHXQDVSHGL]LR QHEDFܔDKVHJXHQGRLOILXPH1LJHUILQFKpJLXQVHTXLD7LPEXFWX4XDQGR FKLHVHUR ORUR ©&RVD IDWH TXL"ª KDQQR ULVSRVWR ©6LDPR YHQXWL SHU VHJXLUH LO 7LPEXFWTXLGHWWD³TDU\DK´HDOSXQWRGHOWHVWR>@³PDGƯQDK´6WRULFDPHQWHIXLPSRUWDQWH QRGRSHULOFRPPHUFLRFDURYDQLHURHIOXYLDOHVXOO¶DQVDGHOILXPH1LJHUHQHLVHFF;9;9,, XQRGHLPDVVLPLFHQWULGLVDSHUHLVODPLFRGHOO¶$IULFDRFFLGHQWDOH)XRFFXSDWDGDOOD)UDQFLD QHO&IUODYRFH7LPEXNWXDF-2+XQZLFNLQ(QF\FORSpGLHGHO¶,VODPFLW,ELGVWR ULDYLDJJLDWRUL߃IUDFXLORVWHVVR,EQ%DؾؾnjؾDVHF;,9ELEOLRJUDILD *LRLD/&KLDX]]L FRUVR GHO 1LJHUª PD HUD XQD PHQ]RJQD SHUFKp VWDYDQR LQGDJDQGR VX 7LP EXFWX 3RL PDQGDURQR GHOOH VSHGL]LRQL ILUDT FRVLGGHWWH ³JHRJUDILFKH´ FXL GLHGHURYDULHGHQRPLQD]LRQL,QUHDOWjHUDQRFRPSRVWHGDXIILFLDOLGLULFRJQL ]LRQHHG¶LQWHOOLJHQFHڲXEEƗWLVWLܒOƗF ZDڲXEEƗWPXېƗEDUƗWFRQORVFRSRGL RFFXSDUH7LPEXFWXHVSHJQHUHTXHVWRIDURSHUFKpODUHOLJLRQHGL'LRQRQVL HVSDQGHVVH&RVWRUR±VLWUDWWDGLXQJUXSSRIDUƯTGL*HQWHGHO/LEURGHOOH TXDOLKDDSSHQDUHFLWDWRLOOHWWRUHGHO&RUDQR±YLKDQQRSHUOXVWUDWROD]RQD VRQRHQWUDWLLQTXHVWRSDHVHTDU\DKKDQQRDQQRWDWRLQRPLGHOOHWULEKDQ QRDFTXLVWDWRIDPLOLDULWjFRQLORURFDSLãX\njېHFRLFRPPHUFLDQWLKDQQRGL VHJQDWR OH >FDUWH FRQ OH@ VWUDGH ܒXUXT FKH SRUWDYDQR D 7LPEXFWX >S @ +DQQRWURYDWRFKHODJHQWHHUDGLVDUPDWDEXRQDQRQDYHYDFKHLOLEULLOVD SHUHHLO&RUDQR ,Q(XURSDKDQQRGLVHJQDWRODPDSSDHVRQRPRVVLDOO¶DWWDFFRGDSLGL UH]LRQLGDOOD7XQLVLDGDO6HQHJDOGDO&LDG+DQQRPDUFLDWRVX7LPEXFWXH O¶KDQQRRFFXSDWD6HQHVRQRYHQGLFDWLHO¶KDQQRGLVWUXWWD+DQQRSUHVRLOL EULHOLKDQQRJHWWDWLQHOILXPH1LJHU+DQQRWUDVIRUPDWROHPRVFKHHLQVWDO OHSHULFDYDOOL,QILQHKDQQRLQWHUUDWRLOFDQDOHWXUFDKFKHFRQYRJOLDYDOHDF TXHGDOILXPH1LJHUDOODFLWWjHFKHRJJLKRYLVLWDWR,YRVWULIUDWHOOLOLELFLKDQ QRGHFLVRGLVWHUUDUORGDFFDSRSHUFKpWRUQLDSRUWDUHOHDFTXHGDOILXPHD7LP EXFWX&RVu±VH'LRYRUUj±OHDFTXHDUULYHUDQQR>GLQXRYR@GDOILXPHD7LP EXFWDWWUDYHUVRTXHOFDQDOHFKHLOFRORQLDOLVPRHEEHDLQWHUUDUH >%/HWUDPHDWWXDOLGHOQHRFRORQLDOLVPR@ 7DOHqVWDWRLOFRPSORWWRPX¶ƗPDUDKVWRULFRDQWLFRFRQWUR7LPEXFWXÊ SHUzSRVVLELOHFKHHVVDFRUUDLOULVFKLRGLGRYHUHDIIURQWDUHXQDOWURFRPSORWWR 5LSHUFRUULDPR OD VHTXHQ]D ېLܒܒDK SLDQR GL TXHOOR DQWLFR >FRPH DOORUD DQ FKHRJJL@JOLRFFLGHQWDOLSHUULFRORQL]]DUHLO6DKDUDSRVVRQRPDQGDUHQXRYH 5DVDPnj DOېLܒܒDK O¶KR UHVR FRQ ©+DQQR GLVHJQDWR OD PDSSDª SLXWWRVWR FKH ©+DQQR IDWWR LO SLDQR OD OLQHD GL D]LRQHª DQFKH VH DSSHQDLQIUD QHO WHVWR ېLܒܒDK q ©,O SLDQR GHO FRPSORWWR ېLܒܒDWDOPX¶ƗPDUDKªHDSSHQDVXSUDQHOWHVWROD©FDUWDJHRJUDILFDPDSSDªq©ېƗULܒDKª ,O JHQQDLR OD WHOHYLVLRQH OLELFD FDQDOH DOöDPƗKƯUL\\DK WUDVPHWWHYD XQ IODVK VXOOD SRVDLQRSHUDGHOODSULPDSLHWUDSHUODIRQGD]LRQHD7LPEXFWXGLXQ&HQWURSHUODFRQVHUYD ]LRQHGLWHVWLHPDQRVFULWWLFRQO¶LQWHUYHQWRGHOODFLWDWD'DFZDKOLELFD$YHQGRQHFROWRO¶XOWL PRVFRUFLRQRQSRVVRDWWHVWDUHQpDTXDQGRULVDOLYDODUHJLVWUD]LRQHQpVHVLFROOHJDYDDGDO WURHYHQWRDGHVLOGLVFRUVRGHO0DZOLGRDOWULPHQWLQpTXDOHIRVVHO¶HQWHOLELFRILQDQ ]LDWRUH'DFZDKRDOWUL &RPHDOODQSUHFHGHQWHODVWHVVDWYLOGLFHPEUHWUDVPHWWHYDXQIODVKVXOO¶LQDXJXUD]LR QHGHOORVFDYRGHOFDQDOHGDSDUWHGLXQD³VRFLHWjOLELFD´ &XIUD±7LPEXFWX0XWD]LRQL VSHGL]LRQLULFRJQLWLYHFXLGDQQRHWLFKHWWHXPDQLWDULH3RVVRQRSXUHFKLDPDUOH ©8QLWjGLSDFHª)LUDTDOVDOƗPPDLQUHDOWjVRQRIRUPDWHGDQXRYLJUXSSL PD÷PnjFƗW FRORQLDOLVWLFL GL XIILFLDOL G¶LQWHOOLJHQFH H ULFRJQL]LRQH 3RVVRQR FKLDPDUOH ©*LRUQDOLVWL VHQ]D IURQWLHUHª ܇LۊDIL\\njQ ELOƗ ۊXGnjG ©0HGLFL VHQ]DIURQWLHUHª$ܒLEEƗ¶ELOƗۊXGnjG©2SHUDWRULSHUODGLIHVDGHOO¶DPELHQ WHª $Q܈ƗU DOEƯD¶ RSSXUH ©$VVRFLD]LRQL PLVVLRQDULH >FULVWLDQH@ª öDPƗFƗW DOWDEãƯUR©*UXSSLPLVVLRQDUL>FULVWLDQL@ª)LUDTDOWDEãƯUHGDUHORURTXDO VLDVLGHQRPLQD]LRQHDWWXDOH DOORVFRSRGLFRORQL]]DUHGDFFDSRLO*UDQGH6D KDUD0DQRLGD7LPEXFWXSURFODPLDPRODVHFRQGDVILGD >%/D/HJDGHOOH©WULEªTDEƗ¶LOGHO*UDQGH6DKDUD@ 6LqJLjGHWWRGHOODSULPDVILGDULJXDUGDQWHODUHOLJLRQHLOSHOOHJULQDJJLR DOOD.DFEDKHO¶LWHUQHFHVVDULRSHUPRGLILFDUOL2UDGLUHPRGHOODVHFRQGDVIL GD TXHOOD QD]LRQDOH TDZPƯ H VRFLDOH FRQWUR LO FRORQLDOLVPR >S @ 1RL OL DYYLVLDPR ©6H DYHWH LQWHQ]LRQH GL RFFXSDUH LO *UDQGH 6DKDUDª H YRJOLDPR DQQXQFLDUJOLHORSULPDFKHVLPHWWDQRLQXQJXDLR©HEEHQHHVVRqPROWRGLIIL FLOH>GDFRQTXLVWDUH@,VXRLDELWDQWLVRQROHRQLIDOFKLUDSDFLHEHOYHIHURFL/D VXD VDEELD SXz WUDVIRUPDUVL LQ XQ WHUUHQR URYHQWH GL WL]]RQL OH VXH SLHWUH LQ FDUERQHDUGHQWHODVXDDULDLQILDPPDGLIXRFR9LPHWWLDPRLQJXDUGLDSULPD FKH YHQLDWH D LQJXDLDUYL TXL QHO 6DKDUD 6H FL LPSLDQWHUHWH GHOOH EDVL VH GL VSUH]]HUHWH L VXRL DELWDQWL VH OR FRORQL]]HUHWH VH YH QHSUHQGHUHWH JLRFR VH YRUUHWHVIUXWWDUQHOHULFFKH]]HVHQHGHPROLUHWHODSDFHODVWDELOLWjHODVLFX UH]]DLQWDOFDVRQRLDELWDQWLGHO6DKDUDFLWUDVIRUPHUHPRLQOHRQLHIDOFKLHOH VXHVDEELHLQWHUUHQRURYHQWHLQFDUERQHDUGHQWHHLQIXRFRª&KLKDSUHDYYL VDWRV¶qJLjVFXVDWRZDTDGDFסDUPDQDQסDU 1RL DELWDQWL GHO 6DKDUD ULXQLWL D 7LPEXFWX LQ TXHVWR JLRUQR VROHQQHSHU FRPPHPRUDUH OD QDVFLWD H OD PRUWH GHO 6LJLOOR GHL SURIHWL IDFFLDPR OD SDFH FRQFKLODIDFRQQRLDJLDPRRVWLOPHQWHFRQWURFKLFLqQHPLFR,O&RUDQRGL FH ©0DVHHVVLSUHIHULVFRQRODSDFHSUHIHULVFLODª&RU 6HYRJOLRQRODSDFHQRLVLDPRJHQWHGLSDFH6HLQYHFHDJJUHGLUDQQRQRL OD QRVWUD LQGLSHQGHQ]D LVWLTOƗO H LO 6DKDUD DOORUD FL WUDVIRUPHUHPR LQ XQD IRU]DWHUULELOHUDKƯEL\\DKLQFXLV¶LQILDPPHUjWXWWRLO6DKDUDGDOOD0DXULWD QLDHGDO6HQHJDOVLQRDOO¶,UDTHDO'HVHUWRVLULDFR%ƗG\DWDOâƗP :,&6©6HRSWDQRSHUODSDFHRSWDFLDQFKHWXª&RU *LRLD/&KLDX]]L 1RL DELWDQWL GHO *UDQGH 6DKDUD FRQGLYLGLDPR XQ¶XQLFD LGHQWLWj KXZL\ \DKZƗۊLGDKTXHOODGLVXRLDELWDQWL9LVLDPRYLVVXWLSHUPLJOLDLDGLDQQLYL VLDPRVWDWLOLEHULHYRJOLDPRFRQWLQXDUHDHVVHUORGDO6HQHJDOHGDOOD0DXUL WDQLDVLQRDO&UHVFHQWH)HUWLOH,O6DKDUDqLOQRVWURWHUULWRULRODQRVWUDJUDQGH GLPRUD 1RL VLDPR XQD VROD IDPLJOLD XVUDK ZƗLGDK IRUPDWD GD QXPHURVL LQGLYLGXLDIUƗGFLDVFXQRGHLTXDOLKD>S@LOSURSULRQRPHFKLVLFKLDPD WXDUHJFKLEDUDELVKFKLVRQJKDLFKLIXODQLFKLEDPEDUDFKLWHEXFKL$ZOƗG F $OƯFKLWULETDEƗ¶LOGHO6XGDQFKLWULEGHO&LDGFKLWULEGHO1LJHUFKL WULEVDKDULDQHGHO1LORRULHQWDOHHRFFLGHQWDOHFKLWULEGHO6LQDLFKLWULE GHOOD*LRUGDQLDHGHO'HVHUWRVLULDFRFKLWULEGHOOD3HQLVRODDUDEDFKLWULE GHOO¶,UDTHGHO&UHVFHQWH)HUWLOH7DOLVRQRLQRPLGHLPHPEULGHOO¶XQLFDID PLJOLDGHJOLDELWDQWLGHO*UDQGH6DKDUD7UDQRLFLDLXWHUHPRUHFLSURFDPHQWH FL GLIHQGHUHPR QRQ FL DEEDQGRQHUHPR O¶XQ O¶DOWURQRQ SUHQGHUHPR OH DUPL SHUFRPEDWWHUFL1RLFLVWULQJLDPRODPDQRFLDEEUDFFLDPRFROODERUHUHPRLQ JXHUUDYDORUL]]HUHPRLOQRVWUR6DKDUDHYLYLDPRLQSDFHVLFXUH]]DHVWDELOLWj 4XHVWDqODJUDQGHHXQLFDIDPLJOLDGHJOLDELWDQWLGHO6DKDUD1RLSUHQGLDPR OH DUPL LQ XQ VROR FDVR FRQWUR O¶DJJUHVVLRQH FXGZƗQ GDOO¶HVWHUQR $OORUD PRULUHPRSHULO6DKDUDLUULJDQGRORFROVDQJXHVHQ]DODVFLDUHDQGDUHXQVROR JUDQHOOR GHOOH VXH VDEELH /H VXH WULE VL HVWHQGRQR GDO &UHVFHQWH )HUWLOH DO ILXPH6HQHJDOÊLOOHFLWRFKHYHUVLQRVDQJXHIUDORURQRQSUHQGHUHPROHDU PLO¶XQRFRQWURO¶DOWUR1RLYLYLDPRFRPHXQ¶XQLFDIDPLJOLDSHUSURWHJJHUHLO 6DKDUD 4XHVWR 6DKDUD q DPELWR GDJOL XRPLQL DYLGL G¶RJQL HSRFD 'REELDPR XQLUFLHIRUPDUHXQD/HJDVRFLDOHXQLFDGHOOHWULEGHO*UDQGH6DKDUD5ƗEL ؾDKL÷WLPƗFL\\DKZƗLGDKOLTDEƗ¶LODO܇DۊUƗ¶DO.XEUD6WHQGHUHPRXQSDW WRVRWWRVFULYHQGRORFROOHJLDOPHQWHLO³3DWWRGL7LPEXFWX0LܔƗT7LPEXNWnj´ 2UD VRQR TXL FRQ QRL UH PXOnjN VXOWDQL VDOƗܒƯQ DQ]LDQL H FDSL ãX\nj ېZD F XPDGƗ¶GLWXWWHOHWULEXGHO*UDQGH6DKDUDFDSLTƗGDKGLVWDWLLVODPLFL &LVRQRSXUHRUJDQL]]D]LRQLPXQDܲܲDPƗWSDUWLWLD]ۊƗEJUXSSL÷DPƗFƗW HG HQWL PX¶DVVDVƗW LVODPLFL GD WXWWL OH SDUWL GHO PRQGR Ê FRQ QRL DQFKH LO $ZOƗGF$OƯORF8OƗG F$OƯ8OrGF$OvWULEEHGXLQDOLELFDGHOGHVHUWRFLUHQDLFRVHWWHQWULRQDOH GL ULYHQGLFDWD GLVFHQGHQ]D GDO 3URIHWD WUDPLWH LO FXJLQR H JHQHUR F$OƯ $OFXQH IUD]LRQL VRQR PLJUDWH D RYHVW GHO 1LOR QHO GHVHUWR HJL]LDQR JHRJUDILFDPHQWH SDUWH GHO GHVHUWR OLELFR 3HU DVSHWWLVWRULFRSROLWLFLGHJOL$F$FIU'H$JRVWLQLSSHFF DQFKH(YDQV3ULWFKDUGSS3HUWUDGL]LRQLHWUDVIRUPD]LRQLGHJOL $F$HPLJUDWHQHOGHVHUWRHJL]LDQRFIU$EX/XJKRG ,GLYHUVLWHUPLQLFRQFXLO¶$LQGLFDL³FDSL´FRQIHUPDQRO¶HWHURJHQHLWjGHJOLLVWLWXWLHGHLUXROL FKHHVRUWDDGDVVHPEODUVLDQFKHVHQRPLQDOPHWHIDDSSHOORDOOH³WULE´7RUQHUzVXOWHPD &XIUD±7LPEXFWX0XWD]LRQL QRVWURIUDWHOOR/RXLV)DUUDƗQOHDGHU]DFƯPGHOOD&RPXQLWjLVODPLFDLQ$PH ULFD $GHVVRqLOPRPHQWRGHOODSUHJKLHUDVHUDOH %,%/,2*5$),$ $EX /XJKRG / 9HLOHG VHQWLPHQWV +RQRU DQG SRZHU LQ D EHGRXLQ VRFLHW\ %HUNHOH\ ± /RV$QJHOHV±/RQGRQ8QLYHUVLW\RI&DOLIRUQLD3UHVV>WUDGLW6HQWLPHUQWLYHODWL2QRUHH SRHVLDLQXQDVRFLHWjEHGXLQD7RULQR/H1XRYH0XVH@ 'H$JRVWLQL(/HSRSROD]LRQLGHOOD&LUHQDLFD%HQJDVL*RYHUQRGHOOD&LUHQDLFD %DXVDQL$,O&RUDQR)LUHQ]H6DQVRQLULVW0LODQR5L]]ROL &$5,7$60,*5$17(6,PPLJUD]LRQH'RVVLHUVWDWLVWLFR;,;5DSSRUWR,'26 5RPD &KLDX]]L * ³/D WULQLWj FRORQLDOLVWDDOـƗOnjـDOLVWLFPƗUƯ O¶$JHQGD LVODPLFDSHU O¶DQQR VRODUHGDOODPRUWHGHO3URIHWD>G&@´LQ6WXGL0DJUHELQLSS 'H(SDOVD0³/HPLOLHXKLVSDQRPRUHVTXHGHO¶(YDQJLOH,VODPLVDQWGH%DUQDEp;9,H ;9,,HV´LQ,VODPRFKULVWLDQDSS (YDQV3ULWFKDUG(7KH6DQXVLRI&\UHQDLFD2[IRUG&ODUHQGRQ3UHVV>WUDGLW&RORQLD OLVPRHUHVLVWHQ]DUHOLJLRVDQHOO¶$IULFDVHWWHQWULRQDOH,6HQXVVLGL&LUHQDLFD&DWDQLD3UL VPD@ *LXVWROLVL(5L]]DUGL(DF,O9DQJHORGL%DUQDED8QYDQJHORSHULPXVXOPDQL" 0LODQR,VWLWXWR3URSDJDQGD/LEUDULD DO4DàIƯ0VG$O.LWƗEDO$ןDU$O)DصODODZZDODOOPXãNLODWDOGLPXTUƗؾL\\DKVXO ؾDWDOãDFEDO)DصODOـƗQƯDOODOPXãNLODOLTWLصƗGƯDO,ãWLUƗNL\\DKDO)DصODOـƗOLـDO 5XNQDOL÷WLPƗFƯOLO1D٤DUL\\DKDOFƗODPL\\DKDOـƗOLـDK©,O/LEUR9HUGH3ULPDSDUWH/D VROX]LRQHGHOSUREOHPDGHOODGHPRFUD]LDLOSRWHUHGHOSRSROR6HFRQGDSDUWH/DVROX]LR QHGHOSUREOHPDHFRQRPLFRLOVRFLDOLVPR7HU]DSDUWH/DEDVHVRFLDOHGHOOD7HU]DWHRULD XQLYHUVDOHªVO 6ORPS-³7KH*RVSHOLQGLVSXWH´LQ,VODPRFKULVWLDQDSS :,&6*ORULRVR&RUDQR(GL]LRQHLWDOLDQD7ULSROL/LE\D5RPD:RUOG,VODPLF&DOO6R FLHW\ )LJ'D0DO4DƗIƯ'LVFRUVRFLW>SS@3DVVR VXOOD©VILGDUHOLJLRVDDOWDۊDGGƯDOGƯQƯªODQFLDWDGD7LP EXFWX&RQWLHQHO¶LQWHUSUHWD]LRQHSHUVRQDOHWDIVƯUãD܈ېƯ GHOO¶$VXOO¶DSHUWXUDDOOD*HQWHGHO/LEURGHOSHOOHJULQDJJLR D 0HFFD FKH q GRYHUH LQGLYLGXDOH IDU ڲҳD\QGLRJQL PX VXOPDQR HG XQR GHL FLQTXH SLODVWUL GHOO¶LVODP DUNƗQ DOL VOƗP7DOHLQWHUSUHWD]LRQHQRQWURYDSUHFHGHQWLQHOODWUDGL ]LRQHLVODPLFDXQDULYDOVDLVODPLFDPHGLDWLFDVXOPDVVL PROLYHOORGLLQLPLFL]LDHSHULFRORRFFLGHQWDOHODUDIILJXUD ]LRQH GHO 3UHVLGHQWH 86$ QHO * %XVK LPSHJQDWR QHOODJXHUUDFRQWURO¶,UDTDOSHOOHJULQDJJLRġ $*267,12&,/$5'2 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD 7HUPLQLUHODWLYLDOOHSUDWLFKHGLFXOWR 3URVHJXHQGR DOFXQH ULFHUFKH VXOOD WHUPLQRORJLD GHOGLULWWR LVODPLFRLQ SDUWLFRODUH TXHOOD ULJXDUGDQWH OH VXFFHVVLRQLTXHVWR ODYRUR YXROH LQGDJDUH GD XQ¶DQJRODWXUD OLQJXLVWLFD XQ DPELWR IRQGDPHQWDOH SHU OD YLWD TXRWLGLDQD GHOPXVXOPDQROHSUDWLFKHGLFXOWRµLEƗGƗW ,O FRPSOHVVR GHL GRYHUL LQFRPEHQWL VXO PXVXOPDQR qGHWWR ãDUƯµD 8QD VXDVXGGLYLVLRQHVLVWHPDWLFDQRQqVWDWDPDLUDJJLXQWD,OFULWHULRSLFRPXQH XWLOL]]DWRSHUFODVVLILFDUHOHSUHVFUL]LRQLVKDUDLWLFKHqGLGLVWLQJXHUOHDVHFRQ GDGHOORURRJJHWWRLOSULPRJUXSSRFRPSUHQGHOHµLEƗGƗWRVVLDOHUHJROHUL WXDOLUHODWLYHDOUDSSRUWRWUDODFUHDWXUDHLO&UHDWRUHGLPHQVLRQH³YHUWLFDOH´ LOVHFRQGRULJXDUGDLQYHFHLUDSSRUWLJLXULGLFLFKHLQWHUFRUURQRWUDODFUHDWXUD HLVXRLVLPLOLGLPHQVLRQH³RUL]]RQWDOH´ /¶REEOLJDWRULHWj GHOOH SUHVFUL]LRQL GHOODãDUƯµD QRQ q WXWWDYLD DVVROXWD SHUWXWWHOHQRUPH,JLXULVWLGLVWLQJXRQRFLQTXHFDWHJRULHGLD]LRQLDODNƗP DODPVDDWWRREEOLJDWRULRIDU ןZƗdžLEDVXDYROWDGLVWLQWRLQIDUןµDOƗ¶O µD\QREEOLJRLQGLYLGXDOHHIDUןµDOƗ¶ONLIƗ\DREEOLJRFROOHWWLYRDWWRPHUL WRULRPDQGŊEDWWROHFLWRPXEƗDWWRELDVLPHYROHPDNUŊKDWWRLOOHFLWR DUƗP ,SULQFLSDOLDWWLREEOLJDWRULGLQDWXUDSHUVRQDOHVRQROHSUDWLFKHGLFXOWR RYYHURLFLQTXHSLODVWULGHOO¶LVODPDUNƗQDOLVOƗPLVXRLHOHPHQWLFRVWLWXWLYL OHVXHLVWLWX]LRQLãDKƗGDSURIHVVLRQHGLIHGHصDOƗWSUHJKLHUDFDQRQLFD]D NƗWHOHPRVLQDOHJDOHصDZPGLJLXQRQHOPHVHGL5DPDןƗQDdždžSHOOHJUL QDJJLRDOOD.DµED &LODUGR &LODUGR $JRVWLQR&LODUGR /D ãDKƗGD q VWDWD RJJHWWR GL DSSURIRQGLPHQWR GD SDUWH GHL GRWWL FKH VL RFFXSDQR GHOOD VFLHQ]D GHONDOƗP , JLXULVWL LQYHFH SUHPHWWRQR DOO¶HVSRVL ]LRQHGHOOHDOWUHTXDWWURSUDWLFKHGLFXOWRO¶DQDOLVLGHOOHTXHVWLRQLULJXDUGDQWL ODؾDKƗUDSXULWjULWXDOH$QFKHTXHVWRODYRURVLqFRQFHQWUDWRVXOODWHUPLQR ORJLDUHODWLYDDOODؾDKƗUDصDOƗW]DNƗWصDZPDdždž 1HOOH RSHUH VHFRQGDULH FKH WUDWWDQR TXHVWL DUJRPHQWL VL ULSRUWDQR JHQH UDOPHQWH LSULQFLSDOL WHUPLQLJLXULGLFL0DXQDORURUDFFROWDVLVWHPDWLFDQRQ SXzFKHIDUVLDQDOL]]DQGROHIRQWLSULPDULHFRPHDONXWXEDOVLWWDLOFRUSXV WUDGL]LRQLVWLFRFDQRQLFRDOWUHUDFFROWHWUDGL]LRQLVWLFKHOHRSHUHGHLJLXULVWL FRPHDO0XGDZZDQDDONXEUƗGL6DQŊQPLO.LWƗEDO0DEVŊؾ GLDO6DUDVƯPDO0XĀQƯGL,EQ4XGƗPDP4XDO FKHRSHUDFODVVLFDqFRQVXOWDELOHDQFKHLQWUDGX]LRQH5LVXOWDSRLXWLOHO¶DQD OLVLGRWWULQDOHFRPSDUDWDIDWWDGDDODžD]ƯUƯ.LWƗEDOILTKµDOƗ¶OPDסƗKLEDODU EDµD *OLHOHPHQWLFRVWLWXWLYLGHOOHSUDWLFKHGLFXOWRVLGHVXPRQRGDO&RUDQROH FXLULYHOD]LRQLDQGDYDQRSODVPDQGRXQDQXRYDFRPXQLWjFKHSHUzYLYHYD LQ XQFRQWHVWRVRFLDOHLVSLUDWRDQFRUDDLYDORULSDJDQLHDOO¶LQIOXVVRGHOOHFRPX QLWjHEUDLFKHVWDQ]LDWHVXOWHUULWRULRSHUFLzVRQRHYLGHQWLLOHJDPLGRWWULQDOL DFTXLVLWLULJHWWDWLRULIRUPDWLFRQO¶HSRFDSDJDQDHLSUHVWLWLGDOGLULWWRHEUDL FR 3UHJKLHUD /DSUDWLFDGHOODSUHJKLHUDULWXDOHRFDQRQLFDqULFKLDPDWDLQPROWLSDVVL FRUDQLFLqVWDWDSHUzUHJRODPHQWDWDLQPRGRGHILQLWLYRHGHVDXVWLYRGDLJLXUL VWL/RVWHVVRQXPHURGLFLQTXHSUHJKLHUHTXRWLGLDQHREEOLJDWRULHQRQVLWURYD 5XELQDFFLH $EŊ'ƗZŊGDO6LdžLVWƗQƯP.LWƗEDO6XQDQDO%XপƗUƯP܇DۊƯۊFRQOR ãDUGLDO.LUPƗQƯ,EQ0ƗdžDP.LWƗEDO6XQDQ0XVOLPPشDƯFRQ ORãDUGLDO1DZDZƯDO1DVƗ¶ƯP.LWƗEDO6XQDQDO7LUPLסƯP.LWƗE DO6XQDQRDODžƗPLǥDOشDƯ ǥ$EGDO5D]]ƗTDOشDQǥƗQƯP$O0XصDQQDI$EŊ'ƗZŊGDOؽD\ƗOLVƯP .LWƗE DO0XVQDG DO%D\KDTƯ P $O6XQDQ DONXEUƗ DO'ƗUDTXؾQƯ P $O6XQDQDO'ƗULPƯP$O0XVQDGDODžƗPLǥRDO6XQDQ,EQ$EƯâD\ED P$O.LWƗEDO0X܈DQQDIIƯ¶ODƗGƯـZD¶OƗـƗU 0ƗOLNE$QDVP.LWƗEDO0XZDؾؾD¶WUDG$LVKD$EGXUUDKPDQ%HZOH\D OƯOLEQ,VƗTP$O0XWDصDUWUDG*XLGL6DQWLOODQD,*LXULVSUXGHQ]DUH OLJLRVDǥLEƗGƗW 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD QHO&RUDQRLOTXDOHSUHVFULYHVRORGXHSUHJKLHUHSLXQDYHJOLDQRWWXUQDFR PHSUDWLFDVXSHUHURJDWRULDSRLWUHSUHJKLHUH,,ROWUHDSUHFLVHUH JROHVXOODSXULWjULWXDOH,99HVXOODTLEOD&RU,,$WWR PHULWRULRqFRQVLGHUDWDODSUHJKLHUDLQGLYLGXDOH&RU9,,HSDUWLFR ODULQRUPH&RU,9ULJXDUGDQRODصDOƗWDODZI 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD O¶LQYLWR DOOD SUHJKLHUD QHO &RUDQR ULFRUUH LO YHUER QƗGƗ FRQ O¶DJJLXQWD LOƗ¶OصDODZƗW &RU 9 R OL¶OصDODZƗW &RU /;,, PHQWUHLOWHUPLQHDסƗQ&RU,;FKHVDUjSRLXWLOL]]DWRSHULQGLFDUHTXHVWD IXQ]LRQHFRPHSXUHLOSDVVDWRDססDQDHLOSDUWLFLSLRSUHVHQWHPX¶DססLQ&RU 9,, ;,, VRQR DGRSHUDWL QHO &RUDQR QHOOD ORUR DFFH]LRQH JHQHULFD GL ³DQQXQFLDUHDGDOWDYRFH´ /D SUHJKLHUD q SHU LO PXVXOPDQR GL SUHPLQHQWH LPSRUWDQ]D VLD SHUFKp TXHVWRIXLOSULPRGRYHUHLPSRVWRDOSURIHWDVLDSHU LOIDWWRFKHVHEEHQHOD SUHJKLHUDHOD]DNƗWVLDQRVSHVVRQRPLQDWHDVVLHPHQHO&RUDQRODSUHJKLHUD KDVHPSUHODSUHFHGHQ]D(VVDFRVWLWXLVFHXQSRWHQWHPH]]RGLDVFHVLVSLULWXD OHSHUVRQDOHHGDOPRGRLQFXLVLIRUPDQROHILOHGHJOLRUDQWLQHOODSUHJKLHUD FRPXQLWDULDWHQGHDOLYHOODUHWXWWHOHGLIIHUHQ]HGLFRQGL]LRQHVRFLDOHHGHFR QRPLFDGLFRORUHHQD]LRQDOLWj ,OFRQFHWWRGLDXWRVYLOXSSRDWWUDYHUVRODSUHJKLHUDqVLQWHWL]]DWRQHOWHU PLQH IDOƗ SURQXQFLDWR GXUDQWH O¶DסƗQ ³9LHQL DOOD SURVSHULWj´ 6HFRQGR LO &RUDQR O¶DXWRVYLOXSSR VL UDJJLXQJH FRQ O¶DFFHWWD]LRQH GL WUH SULQFLSL O¶HVL VWHQ]DGL'LRODVXDULYHOD]LRQHDOO¶XRPRHO¶DOGLOjHFRQO¶HVHUFL]LRGLGXH GRYHULRVVHUYDUHODSUHJKLHUDHGDUHGHLSURSULEHQLDJOLDOWUL 4XHVWRqLO/LEURVFHYURGLGXEELGDWRFRPHJXLGDSHULWLPRUDWLGL'LRLTXDOLFUHGR QRQHOO¶,QYLVLELOHHVHJXRQROD3UHJKLHUDHGHODUJLVFRQRGLFLzFKHORURDEELDPRGR QDWRHFKHFUHGRQRLQFLzFKHqVWDWRULYHODWRDWHHLQFLzFKHqVWDWRULYHODWRSULPDGL WHHVRQFHUWLGHOPRQGRGHOO¶2OWUH4XHVWLVRQRLEHQJXLGDWLGDOORUR6LJQRUHTXHVWL VRQFRORURFKHSURVSHUHUDQQRPXIOLŊQ&RU,, ;,;9,,;;;///,,/;;9, $-:HQVLQFN>[email protected]ǥEDLQ(, ,QXQSDVVRVLGLFH³%HDWLLFUHGHQWL4DGDIODDDOPX¶PLQŊQFKHQHOODSUHJKLHUDORURVRQ XPLOL´&RU;;,,,,QXQDOWURSDVVRDQFRUDVLGLFH³(VLIRUPLGDYRLXQDQD]LRQHG¶XR PLQLFKHLQYLWDQRDOEHQHFKHSURPXRYRQRODJLXVWL]LDHLPSHGLVFRQRO¶LQJLXVWL]LD4XHVWLVD UDQQRLIRUWXQDWL´DOPXIOLŊQ&RU,,,/DWUDGX]LRQHGHLSDVVLFRUDQLFLqWUDWWDGD%DX VDQL $JRVWLQR&LODUGR /DOLQJXDGHOODSUHJKLHUDqJHQHUDOPHQWHO¶DUDER7XWWDYLDVLSXzXVDUH XQD TXDOVLDVL OLQJXD WUDQQH FKH SHU OD UHFLWD]LRQH GHO &RUDQR ULYHODWR DJOL DUDELLQDUDER&RU;,;HSHUDOFXQHHVFODPD]LRQLEUHYLHQRWHDWXWWLL PXVXOPDQLFRPH$OOƗK$NEDU6XEƗQD¶OOƗK/DXؾEDSXzHVVHUHIDWWDQHOOD OLQJXDFRPSUHQVLELOHDOO¶XGLWRULR/DSUHJKLHUDLVODPLFDQRQqPDLDFFRPSD JQDWDGDPXVLFD /DPRVFKHDqLOOXRJRGRYHFLVLSURVWUDLQTXHVWRVHQVRWXWWDODWHUUDSXz HVVHUHFRQVLGHUDWD³PRVFKHD´,OOXRJRVSHFLILFRDGLELWRDOODSUHJKLHUDFDQR QLFDFRVWUXLWRULYROWRYHUVROD.DµEDQRQGHYHHVVHUHFRQVDFUDWRqVXIILFLHQ WHFKHLOFRVWUXWWRUHGLFKLDULO¶LQWHQ]LRQHGLYROHUORGHVWLQDUHDTXHVWRVFRSR /DVXDFDUDWWHULVWLFDGLVWLQWLYDGLFKLDUDWDQHO&RUDQR;;,,qFKHLOQRPH GL$OOƗKYLqULFRUGDWRSLFKHDOWURYHDFDXVDGHOO¶REEOLJRGHOOHFLQTXHSUH JKLHUHTXRWLGLDQH/DPRVFKHDqFRQVLGHUDWDFHQWURUHOLJLRVRPDqDQFKHFHQ WURFXOWXUDOHGRYHODFRPXQLWjLVODPLFDYLHQHHGXFDWDVXOOHTXHVWLRQLGHOSUR SULREHQHVVHUH/DPRVFKHDqFRQFHSLWDFRPHFHQWURJHQHUDOHLQFXLVLSRVVR QRGLEDWWHUHWXWWHOHTXHVWLRQLULJXDUGDQWLODYLWDGHOODFRPXQLWjLVODPLFD3HU TXHVWRHVVDJLRFDQHOO¶LVODPXQUXRORSLLPSRUWDQWHULVSHWWRDLOXRJKLGLFXOWR GL DOWUH UHOLJLRQL 7XWWDYLD q SURLELWR SUDWLFDUYL DIIDUL H FRPPHUFLR ,O OXRJR ULFKLHGHULVSHWWRSHUWDQWRELVRJQDSDUODUHDYRFHEDVVDHYLVLHQWUDODVFLDQGR OHVFDUSHDOODSRUWD$OWHPSRGHOSURIHWDQHOODPRVFKHDLQXQOXRJRDQQHVVR GHWWRصXIIDDOORJJLDYDQRJOLXRPLQLFKHYHQLYDQRIRUPDWLFRPHPLVVLRQDUL$ TXHO WHPSR JHQHUDOPHQWH OD PRVFKHD DYHYD LOPDNWDE R OD PDGUDVD SHU OD IRUPD]LRQHGHJOLVWXGHQWL =DNƗW /D]DNƗWFRQVLVWHQHOSDJDPHQWRREEOLJDWRULRVXDOFXQHFDWHJRULHGLEHQL OHJLWWLPDPHQWH SRVVHGXWL GL XQ¶DOLTXRWD GHWHUPLQDWD D YDQWDJJLR GL DOFXQH SHUVRQH&RU,;6HFRQGRO¶RSLQLRQHFRPXQHPHQWHDFFHWWDWDTXHVWRRE EOLJRIXLPSRVWRQHOVHFRQGRDQQRGHOO¶(JLUD 1HO&RUDQRVLSDUODGL]DNƗWVXLUDFFROWL,,9,RURHDUJHQWR ,; EHQL ,, /, /;; PD OH FDWHJRULH GL SURSULHWj VRJJHWWH DOOD]DNƗWODTXDQWLWjPLQLPDLPSRQLELOHQLصƗEO¶DOLTXRWDGDDSSOLFDUHHLO SHULRGR PLQLPR GL XQ DQQRGL SRVVHVVR GHO EHQHSHUSRWHUOD DSSOLFDUH VRQR WXWWLHOHPHQWLFKHVLWURYDQRQHOODOHWWHUDWXUDWUDGL]LRQLVWLFD/HVFXROHJLXULGL 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD FKHFRQDOFXQHGLYHUJHQ]HWUDGLORURKDQQRSRLHODERUDWRTXHVWRPDWHULDOH FUHDQGRXQVLVWHPDGRWWULQDOHHFDVXLVWLFR 'LJLXQR ,O GLJLXQR QHO PHVH GL 5DPDןƗQ ³LO PHVH LQ FXL IX ULYHODWR LO &RUDQR´ &RU,,IXLVWLWXLWRQHOVHFRQGRDQQRGHOO¶(JLUD4XHVWRREEOLJR VRVWLWXuVHFRQGRXQDWUDGL]LRQHULSRUWDWDGDµƖ¶LãDODSUDWLFDGL0XDPPDG GLGLJLXQDUHLOJLRUQRGLµƖãnjUƗ¶FLRqLOGHOPHVHGLDO0XDUUDPVHFRQGR O¶XVR SDJDQR GHL 4XUD\ã GXUDQWH O¶HSRFD GHOOD DžƗKLOL\\D 4XDQGR SRL 0X DPPDGHPLJUzD0HGLQDLPSRVHTXHVWDSUDWLFDDQFKHDLVXRLVHJXDFLILQR DOODLVWLWX]LRQHFRUDQLFDGHOGLJLXQRGL5DPDןƗQ3DUHSHUzGDHVFOXGHUHFKH ODSUDWLFDGHOGLJLXQRSRVVDDIIRQGDUHOHUDGLFLLQHSRFDSDJDQDVHPEUDLQYH FHFKHTXDQGR0XDPPDGDQGzD0HGLQDDGRWWzODSUDWLFDHEUDLFDILQRD TXDQGRQHOO¶DQQRGHOO¶(JLUDLOGLJLXQRIXFROOHJDWRDOO¶LQL]LRGHOODULYHOD ]LRQHQHOPHVHGL5DPDןƗQPHQWUHLOSUHFHGHQWHGLJLXQRGHOGLDO0XDU UDPqVWDWRFRQVLGHUDWRGDDOORUDSUDWLFDPHULWRULD ,OGLJLXQRLVWLWX]LRQHLVODPLFRQRQqOHJDWRDOO¶LGHDGLULSDUD]LRQHGLXQ WRUWRD'LRQpWHQGHDVXVFLWDUHODFRPSDVVLRQHGLYLQDDWWUDYHUVRXQDVRIIHUHQ ]DYRORQWDULDPDqUHJRODUHHFRQWLQXRLQTXDQWRSUHVFLQGHGDOODFRQGL]LRQH GHOO¶LQGLYLGXR(VVRqFRQVLGHUDWRGLVFLSOLQDVSLULWXDOHPRUDOHHILVLFDTXDOH PH]]RSHUVYLOXSSDUHOHIDFROWjLQWHULRULGHOO¶XRPRFRPHqSHUODSUHJKLHUD 3URSULRSHUTXHVWDVXDYDOHQ]DSULPDULDLQGXHSDVVLFRUDQLFL,;/;9, FKLGLJLXQDqFKLDPDWRVƗ¶LGDVƗDYLDJJLDUHSHOOHJULQR ,O&RUDQRUHJRODPHQWDDQFKHLGLJLXQLHVSLDWRULHLGLJLXQLFRPSHQVDWRUL PD HVVL VRQR QHWWDPHQWH GLVWLQWL GDO GLJLXQRLVWLWX]LRQH , GLJLXQL HVSLDWRUL &RU,99/9,,,GHYRQRHVVHUHDGHPSLXWLLQDOFXQLFDVLGLYLR OD]LRQHGHOODOHJJHVRORFRPHDOWHUQDWLYDDOODPDQRPLVVLRQHGLXQRVFKLDYRR DOO¶REEOLJRGLQXWULUHLSRYHUL,GLJLXQLFRPSHQVDWRULLQYHFHGHYRQRHVVHUH DGHPSLXWL FRPH FRPSHQVD]LRQH SHU O¶RPLVVLRQH GL XQGRYHUH UHOLJLRVR &RU ,,,OGLJLXQRYRORQWDULRSXUDPPHVVRQRQGHYHLQWHUIHULUHFRQO¶HVSOH $=\VRZVY=DNƗWLQ(, 0ƗOLNE$QDV.LWƗEDO0XZDؾؾD¶WUDG$LVKD$EGXUUDKPDQ%HZOH\SQ /HYLWLFR;9,;;,,,1XPHUL;;,; $-:HQVLQFNVYǥƖVKŊUƗ¶LQ(, $JRVWLQR&LODUGR WDPHQWRGHLGRYHULGHOODYLWDTXRWLGLDQDHFRPXQTXHGHYHHVVHUHGLEUHYHGX UDWD ,O PHVH GL GLJLXQR LQL]LD FRQ LO QRYLOXQLR GL 5DPDןƗQ H WHUPLQD FRQ LO QRYLOXQLRGLâDZZƗO6HFRQGRO¶XVRSLDQWLFRO¶LQL]LRGHOQRYLOXQLRqDWWH VWDWR VHFRQGR OH UHJROH GHOOD WHVWLPRQLDQ]D H VL GHYH WUDWWDUH GL XQ¶DWWHVWD ]LRQHFHUWDLQTXDQWRqSURLELWRGLJLXQDUHQHO³JLRUQRGHOGXEELR´\DZPDO ãDNNTXDQGRFLRqF¶qLQFHUWH]]DVXOODFRPSDUVDGHOODOXQDQXRYD /¶REEOLJRGLGLJLXQDUHLQFRPEHVXFRORURFKHVDQQR³WHVWLPRQLDUHLOQR YLOXQLR´PDQãDKLGDPLQNXPDOãDKUDHFKHUHDOL]]DQRTXHVWHWUHFRQGL]LR QLHVVHUHSXEHULEƗOLĀILVLFDPHQWHLGRQHLTƗGLUHVDQLGLPHQWHµƗTLO , YLDJJLDWRUL H L PDODWL VRQR HVHQWDWL SHU LO WHPSR GHOO¶LPSHGLPHQWR &RU ,, *HQHUDOPHQWHVLULWLHQHFKHODPDODWWLDGHEEDHVVHUHWDOHFKHLOGLJLXQR SRVVDFDXVDUHSUHJLXGL]LRDOODVDOXWHGHOPDODWRPHQWUHLOYLDJJLRGHYHHVVHUH SLOXQJRGLXQJLRUQRRVHFRQGRDOWULGXHRSHUDOWULWUHJLRUQL3HUDQDOR JLDO¶HVHQ]LRQHWHPSRUDQHDGDOGLJLXQRqHVWHVDDFRORURFKHVRQRLQJXHUUDH DFKLIDODYRULPROWRGXUL/DGRQQDPHVWUXDWDqWUDWWDWDFRPHODSHUVRQDPD ODWDSHUWDQWRQRQGLJLXQDTXDQGRKDOHPHVWUXD]LRQLPDFRPHQHLFDVLSUH FHGHQWLGHYHFRPSOHWDUHLJLRUQLGLGLJLXQRRPHVVLGRSRLOPHVHGL5DPDןƗQ HILQRDOVHJXHQWHPHVHGL5DPDןƗQ/DWUDGL]LRQHSHUPHWWHGLRPHWWHUHLOGL JLXQR³DFRORURFKHWURYDQRGLIILFLOHIDUOR´SHUVRQHDQ]LDQHGRQQHLQFLQWHH GRQQHFKHDOODWWDQRVHLOGLJLXQRSRVVDDUUHFDUHSUHJLXGL]LRSHULOEDPELQR VRVWLWXHQGRORFRQO¶REEOLJRGLQXWULUHXQSRYHUR$QFKHSHULOGLJLXQRYDOHLO SULQFLSLRJHQHUDOHFRUDQLFR³,GGLRQRQLPSRUUjDQHVVXQ¶DQLPDSHVLSLJUD YLGLTXHOFKHSRVVDSRUWDUH´&RU,, (VLVWHLOGLYLHWRDVVROXWRGLGLJLXQDUHQHOODULFRUUHQ]DGHOOHGXHIHVWHLVOD PLFKHƯGDODןƗƯGDOILؾULOYHQHUGuHXQRRGXHJLRUQLSULPDGL5DPD ןƗQ ,O GLJLXQR FRQVLVWH QHOO¶DVWHQVLRQH YRORQWDULD H LQWHQ]LRQDOH GDO FLER GDOOHEHYDQGHHGDLUDSSRUWLVHVVXDOLGDOO¶DOEDDOWUDPRQWR6HTXDOFKHD]LRQH FRQWUDULDqIDWWDSHULQDYYHUWHQ]DRGLPHQWLFDQ]DLOGLJLXQRVXVVLVWHPDGHYH HVVHUHFRPSOHWDWR 3HOOHJULQDJJLR 1RQVRORLOVDQWXDULRGHOOD.DµEDPDDQFKHLWUDWWLFDUDWWHULVWLFLGHOSHO OHJULQDJJLR ULVDOJRQR D XQD UHPRWD DQWLFKLWj ,O SHOOHJULQDJJLR LVODPLFR q OD WUDVIRUPD]LRQHGLTXHVWDSUDWLFDFRQO¶HOLPLQD]LRQHWXWWDYLDGLTXDOVLDVLULIH 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD ULPHQWRDHOHPHQWLSDJDQL&RVuGXUDQWHODDžƗKLOL\\DVXOOHGXHFROOLQHGLDO شDIƗ H DO0DUZD VL DGRUDYDQR GXH LGROL ,VƗI H 1Ɨ¶LODPHQWUH QHO SHOOHJUL QDJJLRLVODPLFRLOWUDJLWWRVDµ\WUDTXHVWHGXHFROOLQHULFRUGDODFRUVDGL$ JDUDOODULFHUFDGLDFTXDSHU,VPDHOH&RU,,ODFLUFXPDPEXOD]LRQHGHOOD .DµEDؾDZƗI SRLLQHSRFDSDJDQDYHQLYDIDWWDVWDQGRQXGLLQROWUHGXUDQWH ODDžƗKLOL\\DOHWULEGL4XUD\ãH.LQƗQDHUDQRVROLWHULPDQHUHD0X]GDOLIDUH SXWDQGRVFRQYHQLHQWHSHUORURXQLUVLDLSHOOHJULQLILQRDOODSLDQXUDGLµ$UDIƗW DQFRUDLSHOOHJULQLQRQODVFLDYDQR0X]GDOLIDODPDWWLQDILQRDOVRUJHUHGHO VROHLQFRQQHVVLRQHFRQXQFXOWRVRODUHPHQWUHQHOO¶LVODPSHUQRQULFKLDPD UHTXHVWDSUDWLFDOD PDUFLD GD0X]GDOLIDFRPLQFLDSULPDGHOO¶DXURUDSHUOR VWHVVRPRWLYRODPDUFLDGDµ$UDIƗWIXGLIIHULWDQHOO¶LVODPDGRSRLOWUDPRQWR DQFKH LO VDFULILFLR GHJOL DQLPDOL DFTXLVWD QHOO¶LVODP LO VLJQLILFDWR GL FRPPH PRUD]LRQHGHOVDFULILFLRGL,VPDHOHFKLHVWRGD'LRDG$EUDPRSRLORVSD]LR DSHUWRDOGLIXRULGHOOD.DµEDGHQRPLQDWRDOLdžULQHSRFDSDJDQDDYHYDDW WLQHQ]DFRQLJLXUDPHQWLPHQWUHVHFRQGRODWUDGL]LRQHLVODPLFDLQTXHOOXR JRYLVDUHEEHUROHWRPEHGL,VPDHOHHGLVXDPDGUH$JDUqDQFKHSUREDELOH FKHLQHSRFDSDJDQDODODSLGD]LRQHIDWWDD0LQƗIRVVHGLUHWWDFRQWURXQGHPR QHVROHLQILQHLOUXRORGHOOD.DµEDGXUDQWHODDžƗKLOL\\DTXDOHFHQWURGLGLEDW WLWR VX WXWWH OH TXHVWLRQL FRQFHUQHQWL OD YLWD GHOOD FRPXQLWj SHU OD SUHVHQ]D GHOOD'ƗUDO1DGZDFDVDGHOFRQVLJOLRqVWDWRULEDGLWRQHOO¶LVODP /¶REEOLJRGHOSHOOHJULQDJJLRDOPHQRXQDYROWDLQYLWDLQFRPEHVXRJQL PXVXOPDQRDGXOWRDFRQGL]LRQHFKHVLDDELOHDLQWUDSUHQGHUHLOYLDJJLR5LSH WHUOR q DWWR YRORQWDULR PHULWRULR &RU ,,, *OL LPSHGLPHQWL SRVVRQR SHU WDQWR ULVXOWDUH GD IDWWRUL ILVLFL HV PDODWWLDHWj DYDQ]DWD GD UDJLRQL ILQDQ ]LDULHPDQFDQ]DGLPH]]LHFRQRPLFLSHULOYLDJJLR&RU,,PDQFDQ]DGL EHQLVXIILFLHQWLGDODVFLDUHDFKLULPDQHDFDVDRSSXUHGDXQLQFRPEHQWHSH ULFRORGLYLWDGXUDQWHLOYLDJJLR ÊSURLELWRIDUHYRWRGLDQGDUHLQSHOOHJULQDJJLRDSLHGLFRPHSXUHIDUH YRWRRFRPXQTXHHIIHWWXDUHLOSHOOHJULQDJJLRVWDQGRVFDO]L ,OSHOOHJULQDJJLRLVWLWX]LRQHFKHGHFRUUHGDOO¶DOGLסŊ¶OLdždžDVLGL VWLQJXHGDOODµXPUDODYLVLWDDOOD.DµED&RU,,LQTXDQWRTXHVW¶XOWLPD SXzHVVHUHHIIHWWXDWDLQRJQLWHPSRWUDQQHGXUDQWHLJLRUQLGHOSHOOHJULQDJJLR /HQRUPHUHODWLYHDODdždžYDOJRQRDQFKHSHUODµXPUDWUDQQHFKHVLRPHWWHGL DQGDUH H GL VWD]LRQDUH ZXTŊI DG µ$UDIƗW H GL VDFULILFDUH XQ DQLPDOH FRPH DWWRFRQFOXVLYRGHOSHOOHJULQDJJLR,OSHOOHJULQRSXzFRPELQDUHODµXPUDFRQ &IU7)DKGVY,VƗIZD1Ɨ¶LODLQ(, $JRVWLQR&LODUGR LODdždžRFROOHJDQGROLWUDORURTLUƗQRSSXUHXVFHQGRGDOORVWDWRGLLUƗPWUD OHGXHSUDWLFKHWDPDWWXµ 4XDQGRVLHQWUDQHOORVWDWRGLLUƗPO¶XRPRQRQSXzLQGRVVDUHFDPLFLDR WXUEDQWHRSDQWDORQLRFRSULFDSRQpYHVWLWLFRORUDWL,OYHVWLWRGHOO¶LUƗPFRQ VLVWHLQGXHOHQ]XRODVHQ]DFXFLWXUDSUHIHULELOPHQWHELDQFKHXQRYDGDOO¶RP EHOLFRDVRWWROHJLQRFFKLDO¶DOWURFRSUHODSDUWHVXSHULRUHGHOFRUSRÊSURLEL WR LQROWUH SURIXPDUVL UDVDUVL R WDJOLDUVL OH XQJKLH /H GRQQH SRVVRQR LQYHFH LQGRVVDUHYHVWLWLRUGLQDULHQRQqSURLELWRFDPELDUVLGLDELWRWXWWDYLDVRQRWH QXWHDYHVWLUVLLQPRGRVHPSOLFH/DGRQQDLQTXHVWRSHULRGRQRQVLFRSUHLO YROWR H QRQ PHWWH LO YHOR 'XUDQWH OR VWDWR GLLUƗP PD JLj GDOO¶LQL]LR GHO YLDJJLRYHUVR0HFFDQRQqSHUPHVVRDOSHOOHJULQRDOFXQGLVFRUVROHJJHURHL UDSSRUWLVHVVXDOLVRQRLQWHUURWWL&RU,, Ȉdzǫȓ DGƗ¶ ǤǪdzǫȓ FRPSLPHQWR LO FRPSLHUH XQD SUDWLFD UHOLJLRVD REEOLJDWRULD QHO WHPSRSUHVFULWWRRSSRVWRDTDןƗ¶ ȅǴǫȓ ȅǪǴǫȓ DסƗQ SULPR LQYLWR DOOD SUHJKLHUD ,O WHUPLQHDסƗQ&RU,;LOSDVVDWR DססDQDHLOSDUWLFLSLRSUHVHQWHPX ¶DססLQ &RU 9,, ;,, VRQR XVDWLQHO&RUDQRQHOVHQVRFRPXQH GL³DQQXQFLDUHDGDOWDYRFH´PHQ WUH SHU OD FKLDPDWD DOOD SUHJKLHUD LO&RUDQRXVDLOYHUERGLWHU]DIRU PDQƗGƗFKHVLJQLILFD³FRQYRFDUH JULGDUH FKLDPDUH FRQ JULGD´ DJ JLXQJHQGR³DOODSUHJKLHUD´&RU9 ZDLסƗQƗGD\WXPLOƗ¶OصDODZƗW /;,,LסƗ QŊGL\D OL¶OصDODZƗW LO YHUERQƗGƗULFRUUHQHOVHQVRJHQH UDOHGL³JULGDUH´DQFKHLQ&RU9,, QŊGŊHLQ&RU9,,QƗGƗ ȅǴʼ̪ PX¶DססLQ FKLLQYLWDDOODSUHJKLHUD ǵǶǫȓ ǵǪǶǪȔ SDQQR DWWRUQR DL ILDQFKL SURSULRGHLEHGXLQLYHVWHULWXD OH GHO SHOOHJULQR PXVXOPDQR OHQ ]XRORSUHIHULELOPHQWHELDQFRVHQ ]DFXFLWXUHFKHO¶XRPRFLQJHDWWRU QRDOODYLWDTXDQGRHQWUDQHOORVWD WRGLLUƗPGXUDQWHLOSHOOHJULQDJ JLR L]ƗU Ȅǫȓ Ȅ˅̪ȔǪ LPƗP FKLJXLGDODSUHJKLHUDIDWWD LQ FRPXQH XRPR YHUVDWR QHO &R UDQRHLGRQHRDIDUHODXؾEDLOYH QHUGu O¶LPƗP QRQ q FRQVDFUDWR PD TXDOVLDVL SHUVRQD SXz GLULJHUH ODSUHJKLHUDLQDVVHQ]DGLXQLPƗP LQFDULFDWR FDSR VXSUHPR GHOOD FRPXQLWj LVODPLFD VRSUDWWXWWR ãƯ µLWDVLGLFHDQFKHGLRJQL&DSRGL 6WDWR PXVXOPDQR DXWRULWj LQ JHQHUHLO3ULQFLSH Ȅ̸̪ȓˆ̪ PD¶PŊP DVVHPEOHD FRPXQLWj GL FUH GHQWL FKH VHJXH O¶LPƗP QHOOD SUH 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD JKLHUDFRPXQLWDULDRUDQWHJXLGDWR GDOO¶LPƗP ȅȒǫ˲̝̤ǪȄǫȓ 8PPDO4XU¶ƗQ SULPDVŊUDGHO&RUDQROD)Ɨ WLD Ȉ˲̝̤ǪȄǫȓ 8PPDO4XUƗ ³0DGUHGHOOH&LWWj´ 0HFFD &RU 9, ³LO OXRJR GHOOD .DµED IX FUHDWR SULPD FKH LO UHVWR GHO PRQGRSRL$OOƗKYHQQHFUHDQGRLQ FHUFKL FRQFHQWULFL LO SHULPHWUR GL 0HFFDDUDPRWHUULWRULRVDFURFKH FLUFRQGD 0HFFD H LO PRQGR FRVu 0HFFDVLSXzFKLDPDUHXPPDOTX UƗ OD PDGUH GHOOH FLWWj FHQWUR GHO PRQGR RPEHOLFR GHOOD WHUUD´ 3D UHMD%DXVDQL+HUOLQJ> ,@ S ̬̪ǫȓ ۸̪ȓˆ˒ WD¶PƯQ LOSURQXQFLDUHQHOODSUHJKLHUD ODSDUROD³DPHQ´ƗPƯQ ̜̈˲ˊ DOEXUTXµ ̜̤̈ٴǪ YHORQRPHGDWRLQ(JLWWRDOOD NLVZD ߧ̫˸ˉ ߧ̫˸ˉ EDVPDOD HVFODPD]LRQH ȅࠇ˧˲̤Ǫ ߷ ̩˸ˉ ̤˲˧ۮǪ EL¶VPL¶OOƗK DO5DPƗQ DO 5DƯP QHO QRPH GL'LR FOHPHQWH HPLVHULFRUGLRVR ̣̄ˈ ̣̄ˈ EDؾDOD HVVHUH R GLYHQWDUH QXOORR LQ YDOLGRDWWRJLXULGLFR ̣̃Դ EƗؾLO DWWRQXOORLQYDOLGR %DNND&RU,,, 0HFFD ː̢ˊ ߲ˈ ǭ߲ˈǙ߲ˈ EDODG&RU;,9;&;&9 EDOGD&RU;;9,, FRQWUDGD SDHVH FKH 'LR KD UHVRVDFUR 0HFFD ̧̌ˈ ̧̌ˈ EDOƗĀ ǾҠˈ LO VXIILFLHQWH FRQWUDWWR GL VXIILFLHQ]D FRQWUDWWR VWLSXODWR GDO PDQGDQWH GL GDUH DO PDQGDWD ULRLPH]]LVXIILFLHQWLEDOƗĀSHULO YLDJJLR GL DQGDWD H ULWRUQR SHU HI IHWWXDUH LO SHOOHJULQDJJLR IRUQHQ GRJOLTXDQWRRFFRUUHSHULOYLDJJLR EDOƗĀPƗOƯ RSSXUHSDWWXHQGRXQ SUH]]R D FRWWLPR EDOƗĀ µDPDOƯ QHO FRQWUDWWR VL SXz GHWHUPLQDUH O¶DQQR GHO SHOOHJULQDJJLR RSSXUH ODVFLDUORLQGHWHUPLQDWR ܳˈ ELQƗ¶ Ǥ˅̰ˈ O¶LQWHJUDUH R LO FRPSOHWDUH XQ DWWRSLRSHUHVXQDSUHJKLHUDFKH VL q GRYXWD LQWHUURPSHUH ULSUHQ GHQGRODGDOSXQWRLQFXLqLQWHUYH QXWDO¶LQWHUUX]LRQH DZԴ ː˨ԴȔǪ LEƗD VHPSOLFH SHUPLVVLRQH GL XQ DWWR DZ˅ˍ̪ PXEƗ DWWR OHFLWR SHUPHVVR DWWR LQGLIIHUHQWH OD FXL RPLVVLRQH QRQ qSXQLWDHLOFXLFRPSLPHQWRQRQq ULFRPSHQVDWRVLQGLdžƗ¶L] $JRVWLQR&LODUGR ǮԴ DO%D\WDOµ$WƯT ̛̾˕̤̋Ǫˑ̿ˋ̤Ǫ ³OD &DVD $QWLFD &RU ;;,, OD .DµED OD .DµED q ODUJD P OXQJD P H DOWD P VWD DO FHQWUR GL XQ SDUDOOHOR JUDPPD 6HFRQGR OD GRWWULQD LVOD PLFD OD .DµED q OD SULPD FDVD GL FXOWR D 'LR FKH VLD PDL VWDWD FR VWUXLWDVXTXHVWDWHUUDXQDFFHQQR DOODVXDFRVWUX]LRQHGDSDUWHGL$ EUDPR VWD LQ &RU ,, WXWWDYLD &RU,,VHPEUDLQGLFDUHFKH$ EUDPRDEELDVRORULFRVWUXLWRXQH GLILFLRGLURFFDWRSUHHVLVWHQWH DO%D\W%D\W$OOàK ߷ˑ̿ˈˑ̿ˋ̤Ǫ ³OD &DVD GL 'LR´ ³OD 6DQWD &DVD´³LO 6DFUR7HPSLR´ &RU ,, ,,,;;,, &9, OD.DµED Ȅ˲߾Ǫˑ̿ˋ̤Ǫȇǫȓ ȄǪ˲߬Ǫˑ̿ˋ̤Ǫ DO%D\W DODUƗP &RU 9 R DO%D\W DO0XDUUDP &RU ;,9 ³OD &DVD 6DFUD´ ³OD 6DQWD &DVD´ OD .DµED OXRJR OD FXL VDQWLWjQRQGHYHHVVHUHYLRODWD Ȃ˲˔ Ȃ˲˔ RPLVVLRQH GL XQ DWWR GRYXWR QHO FRPSLPHQWR GL XQD SUDWLFD GL FXOWR WDUN ܳ˙ ـDQ\ ̴̧̾ˡǵܳ˙˙ܩ PRGR GL PHWWHUH L SLHGL QHOOD SUHJKLHUD LO PHWWHUH OH JDPEH ³D GXH´FKLqFRVWUHWWRDVHGHUVLqH VRUWDWRDVHGHUHQHOODSURVWUD]LRQH H IUD OH GXH SURVWUD]LRQL PHWWHQGR OH JDPEH ³D GXH´ FIU DOƯO E , VƗT ,O ³0XWDصDU´ >*XLGL 6DQ WLOODQD +@,SQ ـXQƗ¶L\\D ː̾ʿ˅̰˙ SUHJKLHUD FRPSRVWD GD GXH UDNµD Ȉ˴ ˠ ǮǪǤǪ˴ˠǰǤǪ˴ˠ džD]Ɨ¶SOdžD]Ɨ¶ƗW ULSDUD]LRQHHVSLD]LRQH ˰̾˾̤ǪǤǪ˴ˠ džD]Ɨ¶DOصD\G HVSLD]LRQH SHU O¶XFFLVLRQH GL XQDQLPDOHVHOYDWLFRGXUDQWHLOSHO OHJULQDJJLR OD FDFFLD q SURLELWD TXDQGRVLqLQVWDWRGLLUƗP&RU 9 ˶̧ˡ ː˸̧ˡ džDOVD ORVWDUHVHGXWREUHYHSRVL]LR QH GL VWDUH VHGXWR WUD GXH VXdžŊG OR VWDUH VHGXWR GHOO¶LPƗP QHOO¶LQ WHUYDOORWUDOHGXHSDUWLGHOODXؾED ̹̄˷̸̤Ǫː˸̧߫Ǫ DOdžDOVDDOZXVؾƗ SRVL]LRQHGLVWDUHVHGXWRSUH VD QHOOD SDUWH FHQWUDOH GHOOD SUH JKLHUD Ƿ̸̧ˡ džXOŊV SRVL]LRQHGLVWDUHVHGXWRQHOOD SUHJKLHUDUHVWDQGRLQJLQRFFKLRFL VLVLHGHVXLWDOORQLWHQHQGROHPDQL XQSR¶VRSUDDLJLQRFFKLVXOOHFR VFH ˲ݟ ǵࠇˠǰǭ˲ݟ džDPUDSOdžLPƗU SLHWUX]]DVDVVROLQR ǵ˅߮Ǫࠒǵ UDP\DOdžLPƗU ODQFLR R WLUR GHOOH SLHWUX]]H O¶XOWLPRJLRUQRGHOSHOOHJULQDJJLR LOGLסŊ¶OLdždžDHQHLWUHJLRUQL GL WDãUƯT L SHOOHJULQL UDFFROJRQR 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD GHOOHSLHWUX]]HGHOODJUDQGH]]DGL XQDIDYDRGLXQFHFHFKHYHQJR QR ODQFLDWH D 0LQƗ LQ WUH VWD]LRQL FKLDPDWHdžDPUDOXRJRRVWD]LRQH GRYHVLJHWWDQROHSLHWUHDOdžDP UDDOŊOƗDOdžDPUDDOZXVؾƗdžDP UDW DOµDTDED R DOdžDPUD DONX EUƗ LQ RJQL džDPUD ELVRJQD ODQ FLDUH WUH YROWH VHWWH SLHWUX]]H H R JQL ODQFLR GHYH HVVHUH DFFRPSD JQDWRGDOWDNEƯULOODQFLRGHOOHSLH WUH GHO SXz YHQLU WUDODVFLDWR GD FKLKDIUHWWDO¶DQLPDOHSXzHVVHUH VDFULILFDWRLOJLRUQRGHOƯGDODןƗ RSSXUH GXUDQWH TXHVWL GXH R WUH JLRUQL ̈ݟ džDPPDµD ̈Ȑݟ IDUH OD SUHJKLHUD GHO PH]]R JLRUQR GL YHQHUGu LQ FRPXQH QRQ VRODPHQWHTXHOODVROHQQHIDWWDQHO ODPRVFKHD džƗPLµ ̪̈˅ˡ PRVFKHD ː̋߮ǪȄ̸̻ȇǫȓ ː̋߮Ǫ DOdžXPµDR\DZPDOdžXPµD&RU /;,,\DZPDOdžXPXµD ³LOJLRUQRGHOO¶$GXQDQ]D´YH QHUGu LO JLRUQR GHOOD SUHJKLHUD FR PXQLWDULD TXDQGR OD SUHJKLHUD YD IDWWDLQFRPXQHILQLWDODSUHJKLHUD FLDVFXQR ULWRUQD DO SURSULR ODYRUR &RU/;,, ̈ ݟ džDPµ DVVHPEOHD ULXQLRQH ³OXRJR GL UDGXQR´ IRUVH O¶DQWLFR QRPH GL 0X]GDOLID GRYH LO GL סŊ¶OLdždžD VL UDGXQDQR H VWD]LR QDQR L SHOOHJULQL SURYHQLHQWL GD µ$UDIƗW ODVFLDWD GRSR LO WUDPRQWR DUULYDQGRTXLLSHOOHJULQLIDQQROD SUHJKLHUD GHO PDĀULE H GHO µLãƗ¶ FRPELQDWHLQVLHPHTXLVLSDVVDOD QRWWH SRL GRSR OD SUHJKLHUD GHO PDWWLQR GL EXRQ¶RUD L SHOOHJULQL YDQQRD0LQƗ ۸˒Ҡ˾̤Ǫ۸ˈ̈ݟ džDPµED\QDDOصDOƗWD\Q LO IDWWR GL FRPELQDUH OH GXH SUHJKLHUHGL٤XKUHµDصURSSXUHGL PDĀULE H µLãƗ¶ UHFLWDQGROH DVVLH PH VL KD LO džDPµ WDTGƯP VH VRQR IDWWH DO WHPSR VWDELOLWR SHU OD SUL PD SUHJKLHUD YLFHYHUVD VL KD LO džDPµ WD¶ƯU VH HQWUDPEH YHQJRQR UHFLWDWHDOWHPSRGHOODVHFRQGDSUH JKLHUD ˇ̲ˠ džDQƗED ːˈ˅̲ˠ LPSXULWj ³PDJJLRUH´ HV SHU IDWWLVHVVXDOLVWDWRGLJUDYHLPSX ULWjULWXDOHFKHSHUHVVHUHULPRVVD ULFKLHGH O¶DEOX]LRQH WRWDOH ĀXVO VLDORVWDWRGLLPSXULWj³PDJJLRUH´ VLDTXHOOR³PLQRUH´DGD ـLPSH GLVFRQRGLIDUHODSUHJKLHUDULWXDOH HLOؾDZƗIGLWRFFDUHXQHVHPSODUH GL&RUDQRVFULWWRLQDUDERRGLUH FLWDUQHXQDSDUWH&RU/9, ˇ̲ˠ džXQXE XRPRLQVWDWRGLLPSXULWjPDJ JLRUH VLD QHO FDVR GL SROOXWLR QRF WXUQDLWLOƗPVLDQHOFDVRGLFRLWXV RUDSSRUWRVHVVXDOHFKLqREEOLJDWR DIDUHO¶DEOX]LRQHWRWDOHREDJQRWD OH SHUVRQD q ³D ODWR GLVWDFFDWR D SDUWHHVWUDQHR´FLRqLPSHGLWRDSUH JDUH4XHVWDFRQGL]LRQHQRQSXzHV VHUH GHILQLWD FRPH FRQWDPLQD]LRQH $JRVWLQR&LODUGR SHUWDQWRFKLqdžXQXEQRQSXzHVVH UHGHILQLWRQDdžLVFRQWDPLQDWR Ǫȇ˲̶̃˅̙˅ˋ̲ˠ̰̟۫ȅǪȔȇ ZDLQNXQWXPdžXQXE DQID¶ؾؾDKKDUŊ ³«HVHVLHWHLQVWDWRGLLPSX ULWj SXULILFDWHYL «´ &RU 9 FIUDQFKH&RU,9 ˦̲ˠ ˦Ȑ̲ˠ džDQQDD IDUH XQ PRYLPHQWR VLPLOH D TXHOORFRQOHDOLTXDQGRVLDO]DQR OH PDQL GD WHUUD DOOD ILQH GL XQD SURVWUD]LRQH VXdžŊG GXUDQWH OD SUHJKLHUD ۸˨˅̰߫ǪȄǫȓ XPPDOdžDQƗƯQ QRPH GL XQ WLSR GL SUHJKLHUD FRPSRVWDGDTXDWWURUDNµD 4XDQGRVLUHFLWDXQDSUHJKLH UDFRPSRVWDGDTXDWWURUDNµDSUH VLHGXWDGDOO¶LPƗPYDULHFLUFRVWDQ ]H SRVVRQR LPSHGLUH DOO¶RUDQWH GL IDUODLQPRGRLQWHJUDOHSHUDGHP SLHUHO¶REEOLJRHJOLODGHYHSHUFLz LQWHJUDUH VL SRVVRQR YHULILFDUH OH VHJXHQWLLSRWHVL O¶RUDQWHDUULYDGRSRFKHO¶L PƗPKDJLjIDWWRODSULPDUDNµDID TXLQGL OH GXH VHJXHQWL UDNµD PD RPHWWHGLFRPSLHUHODTXDUWDUDNµD SHU XQD FDXVD VRSUDYYHQXWD SHU FKpSHUHVqVRUSUHVRGDHPRUUD JLD QDVDOH GD VRQQR HFF TXDQGR O¶RUDQWHULSUHQGHLQGLYLGXDOPHQWHOD SUHJKLHUDSHULQWHJUDUODHJOLODGHYH FRPSOHWDUH SURQXQFLDQGR OD )ƗWL DKSRLVLDFFRVFLDSHULOVDOXWRIL QDOH LQ TXDQWR TXHVWDUDNµD FRUUL VSRQGH DOOD TXDUWD GHOO¶LPƗP DQ FKHVHSHUOXLqODWHU]DLQILQHO¶R UDQWH ID OD VXD TXDUWDUDNµD FRUUL VSRQGHQWH DOOD SULPD UDNµD GHOO¶L PƗP GD OXL RPHVVD FRQ OD )ƗWL DK H OD VnjUD TXHVWR WLSR GL SUH JKLHUD q FKLDPDWR ۸˨˅̰߫ǪȄǫȓ SHUFKp ODUHFLWDGHO&RUDQRVLIDQHOOHGXH DOLRHVWUHPLWj O¶RUDQWHIDFRQ O¶LPƗPVROR ODWHU]DUDNµDLQTXDQWRKDRPHVVR OHSULPHGXHSHUFKpqDUULYDWRLQUL WDUGRHRPHWWHODTXDUWDSHUFKpVRU SUHVR GD XQ IDWWR LPSURYYLVR O¶R UDQWHTXDQGRULSUHQGHODSUHJKLHUD LQGLYLGXDOPHQWH FRQWLQXD FRPH VH VWHVVH IDFHQGR OD TXDUWDUDNµD GHO O¶LPƗP SHU OXL q OD VHFRQGD H VL DFFRVFLDSRLIDOHSULPHGXHUDNµD GD OXL RPHVVH FRQ OD )ƗWLDK H OD VnjUD VHQ]D DFFRVFLDUVL SHUFKp SHU OXLVRQRODWHU]DHODTXDUWDTXHVWR WLSR GL SUHJKLHUD q FKLDPDWR ːˈ̸̧̝Ǫ SHUFKp LQYHUWHQGR O¶RUGLQHOHVnj UHVRQRUHFLWDWHDOODILQH /¶RUDQWHIDFRQO¶LPƗPVROR OD VHFRQGD UDNµD LQ TXHVWR FDVR SHUFRPSOHWDUHODSUHJKLHUDHJOLID XQDUDNµDHVLDFFRVFLDSHUFKpFRU ULVSRQGHDOODWHU]DUDNµDGHOO¶LPƗP PDSHU OXLq OD VHFRQGDSRLIDX Q¶DOWUD UDNµD H VL DFFRVFLD SHUFKp FRUULVSRQGHDOODTXDUWDUDNµDGHOO¶L PƗPPDSHUOXLqODWHU]DLQILQH ID OD VXD TXDUWD UDNµD TXHVWR WLSR GLSUHJKLHUDqFKLDPDWR۸˨˅̰߫ǪǮǪǴ FIU+,SSQ ۸˨˅̰߫ǪǮǪǴ סƗWDOdžDQƗƯQ QRPH GL XQ WLSR GL SUHJKLHUD FRPSRVWD GD TXDWWUR UDNµD FIU XPPDOdžDQƗƯQ 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD ǵ˅ˡ džLZƗU ǵǪ̸ˠ VWD]LRQH VDFUD R ULWLUR QHOOD PRVFKHD VLPLOH DOO¶LµWLNàI OD VROD LQWHQ]LRQHGLIDUHLOdžLZàUQRQFUHD XQD REEOLJD]LRQH OD VWD]LRQH GHYH HVVHUH IDWWD LQ PRGR FRQWLQXR D PHQRFKHQRQVLVLDIRUPDWDXQDLQ WHQ]LRQH GLYHUVD GXUDQWH LO džLZàU QRQ VL HVFH GDOOD PRVFKHD VL SXz IRUPXODUH O¶LQWHQ]LRQH GL QRQ GL JLXQDUH GXUDQWH TXHVWR SHULRGR VH QRQVLGHWHUPLQDO¶LQWHQ]LRQHGLID UHRLOdžLZàURSSXUHO¶LµWLNàIVLGH YH IDUH O¶LµWLNàI +,SSH Q ˇ˧ Ǭȇ˰̲̪ȇǫȓ ˇ˩˕̑˸̪ PXVWDDEERPDQGŊE UDFFRPDQGDELOH GHVLGHUDELOH DWWRFKHVHRPHVVRQRQYLHQHSX QLWR GD'LR Qp PHULWD ELDVLPR FKL QRQORRVVHUYLPDqULFRPSHQVDWR VH FRPSLXWR SUDWLFD UHOLJLRVD FKH q RJJHWWR GL UDFFRPDQGD]LRQH R HVRUWD]LRQH DWWR FKH VL GLVWLQJXH GDOOHSUDWLFKHGLVXQQDSHUFKpqUL FRPSHQVDWR LQ PRGR PLQRUH VH FRPSLXWR DWWR VLPLOH DOOD SUDWLFD TXDOLILFDWDIDןĊOD Ǭ˅ˋ˩˕̑˷ǪȔ LVWLEƗE LO FRQVLGHUDUH UDFFRPDQGDELOL R GHVLGHUDELOL FHUWH SUDWLFKH UHOL JLRVH ݎ Ddždž ݎ OHWW³UHFDUVL´GDTXDOFKHSDUWH DOOR VFRSR GL IDUH XQD YLVLWD DO TDصG OL¶O]L\ƗUD DQGDUH DOOD &DVD GL'LR%D\W$OOƗKSHUFRPSLHUYLL ULWL SUHVFULWWL LTƗPDWDQ OL¶OQXVXN SHOOHJULQDJJLRLVWLWX]LRQH&RU;;,, VŊUD;;,,/DVŊUDGHOSHO OHJULQDJJLR REEOLJDWRULR SHU FKL KD OD SRVVLELOLWj ILVLFD H ILQDQ]LD ULD GL IDUH LO YLDJJLR &RU ,, ,,,QHL³JLRUQLGHWHUPLQDWL´D\ \ƗPPDµOŊPƗW&RU;;,,FLRq L SULPL GLHFL JLRUQL GHO PHVH GL סŊ¶OLdždžD&RU/;;;,; ˟߬Ǫ̪ٸǫȓ DPƯUDODdždž FDSR R JXLGD GHO SHOOHJULQDJ JLR ˟߬Ǫː̜˅̾̑˷ VL\ƗTDWDODdždž ³GDUGDEHUHDLSHOOHJULQL´&RU ,; ³$FFHQQR D FHUWL XIILFL GL VRUYHJOLDQ]DHDPPLQLVWUD]LRQHGHO OD.DµEDGLFDUDWWHUHVHPLVDFHUGR WDOH FKH VL WUDPDQGDYDQR GL SDGUH LQILJOLRLQFHUWHIDPLJOLHPHFFDQH 6LWUDWWDGHOODFRVLGGHWWDVL\ƗTDTXL DFFHQQDWD FLRq LO GDU GD EHUH DL SHOOHJULQL H GL DOWUL XIILFL TXL UDF FROWLVRWWRLOWHUPLQHFRPXQHGLµL PƗUDW DOPDVdžLG µVHUYLUH LO 7HP SLR 6DQWR¶ H FKH VL GLVWLQJXHYDQR LQ ULIƗGD QXWULPHQWR GHL SHOOHJUL QLVLGƗQDJXDUGLDGHOOD.DµEDL džƗEDIRUQLWXUDGHOYHORVDFUR´%D XVDQL> %@S ˲ݓ dz̸˷ҡȓ Ǫ˲ˣ߬Ǫ DODdžDUDO$VZDG OD3LHWUD1HUDLQFDVWRQDWDQHO O¶DQJROR HVW GHOOD .DµED LO SHOOH JULQRLQVWDWRGLLUƗPGRSRHVVH UH HQWUDWR QHOOD PRVFKHD GHOOD .D µED EDFLD OD 3LHWUD 1HUD SULPD GL FRPLQFLDUHLOؾDZƗI $JRVWLQR&LODUGR ̣̾̉ࠇ˷ȔǪ˲ݓȇǫȓ ˲ˣ߬Ǫ DOLdžURLdžU,VPƗµƯO OHWWSURLELWRYLHWDWRVDFURUH FLQWR VHPLFHUFKLR FKH VL VWDFFD GDOODSDUHWHGHOOD.DµEDGLIURQWHDO PXUR GL QRUGRYHVW GHOOD .DµED VSD]LRDSHUWRGHOLPLWDWRGDXQPX URVHPLFLUFRODUHDODؾƯP ǯ˰˨ ǯ˰˨ DGDـ LPSXULWjLPSXULWjULWXDOH³PL QRUH´ HV SHU DYHU VRGGLVIDWWR D QHFHVVLWj TXDOLWj G¶LPSXUR FKH FRVWLWXLVFHLPSHGLPHQWRDFRPSLH UHXQDWWRUHOLJLRVRµLEƗGDVLHOL PLQDFRQO¶DEOX]LRQHGLDOFXQHSDU WLGHOFRUSRZXןŊ¶ ǯ˰ࠌ PXGLـ FKLVLWURYDLQVWDWRGLLPSXUL WjPLQRUH Ǭ˲˧ ǬǪ˲ࠌ PLUƗE QLFFKLDFKHQHOODPRVFKHDLQ GLFD OD TLEOD R GLUH]LRQH YHUVR OD .DµED Ȅ˲˧ Ȅ˲˧ DUDP WHUULWRULRVDFURSURLELWRFKHFLU FRQGD 0HFFD QHO TXDOH q SURLELWD OD FDFFLD H QHO TXDOH FKL IDLO SHO OHJULQDJJLR GHYH RVVHUYDUH UHJROH SDUWLFRODUL GL FRPSRUWDPHQWR HV QHOYHVWLUHRSSRVWRDDOƗO ȅ˅̪˲߬Ǫ DODUDPƗQL LGXHOXRJKLVDFULGL0HFFDH 0HGLQD ȄǪ˲˧ȔǪ LUƗP VWDWR GL FRQVDFUD]LRQH ULWXDOH O¶HQWUDUHLQXQDWWRUHOLJLRVRVWD WR VDFUR QHOOD SUHJKLHUD QHO TXDOH VL HQWUD SURQXQFLDQGR LOWDNEƯU LQL ]LDOHVWDWRVDFURGHOSHOOHJULQRD 0HFFDQHOTXDOHHJOLHQWUDLQWHPSL HORFDOLWjGHWHUPLQDWH PƯTƗWH YL UHVWDVLQRDOODILQHGHOSHOOHJULQDJ JLR HQWUDQGR LQ TXHVWR VWDWR VL LQ GRVVDQR VSHFLDOL YHVWL H DOFXQH D ]LRQL LQ JHQHUH OHFLWH GLYHQWDQR SURLELWH QRQ q SHUPHVVR DOFXQ GL VFRUVR OHJJHUR ELVRJQD DVWHQHUVL GDOOD FRQWDPLQD]LRQH GHJOL LGROL H GDO GLVFRUVR PHQGDFH &RU ;;,, L UDSSRUWL VHVVXDOL VRQR LQWHU URWWLQpVLSRVVRQRFRPPHWWHUHDWWL RVFHQLQpULVVH&RU,,qSURL ELWDODFDFFLD&RU9qSURLELWR SURIXPDUVLUDVDUVLHWDJOLDUVLOHXQ JKLHqO¶XQLFRSHULRGRGLDVFHWLVPR REEOLJDWRULRLQTXDQWRSHUO¶LVODP LO PRQDFKHVLPR QRQ q LVWLWXLWR GD 'LR&RU/9,,YHVWHLQGRV VDWD GDO SHOOHJULQR FRQVLVWHQWH LQ GXH SH]]H GL VWRIID ELDQFD VHQ]D FXFLWXUHXQDGHOOHTXDOLVLDYYROJH DOFRUSRFRSUHQGRORGDOODFLQWRODLQ JL PHQWUH O¶DOWUD VL JHWWD VXOOH VSDOOH Ȅ˲߬Ǫ˲̶˺ҡȓ ǫȓ ǙȄǪ˲߬Ǫ˲̶˻̤Ǫ DOãDKUDODUƗPDODãKXUDOXUXP ³LOPHVHVDFUR´&RU,,³L PHVLVDFUL´&RU,;LTXDW WURPHVLVDFULVRQR5DdžDEסŊ¶OLdždžDסŊ¶O4DµGDHDO0XDUUDP ȄǪ˲߬Ǫ˲̋˻Ǫ DO0DãµDUDODUƗP ³PRQXPHQWR VDFUR´ &RU ,, VWD]LRQHGLDO0DãµDUDOD UƗP OD PRVFKHD D VLQLVWUD GL FKL YDD0LQƗFLUFDNPGD0HFFD 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD IUD L GXH PRQWL GL DO0X]GDOLID H GL4X]D Ȅ˲ࠌ PXULP SHOOHJULQR FKH VWD LQ VWDWR GL SXULWjULWXDOH ˧˲ DUƯP VSD]LR ULVHUYDWR ]RQD GL UL VSHWWR Ǭ˴˧ Ǭ˴˧ L]E XQD GHOOH SDUWL LQ FXL q VXGGLYLVR LO &RUDQR SDUWH GHWHU PLQDWDGHO&RUDQRFIU&RU;9,, ;;9 ̬˸˧ ̬˷˅ࠌ PDƗVLQ ³SDUWL EHOOH´ TXHOOH SDUWL GHO FRUSRQRQLQFOXVHWUDOH³SDUWLYHU JRJQRVH´FIUµDZUDGDQRQPR VWUDUH ̩̄˧ ߬̄ۮǪ DODؾƯP GD DؾDPD VWULWRODUH IUDQWX PDUHVSH]]DUHVFKLDFFLDUHPXUR VHPLFLUFRODUHGLPDUPRDOWRFLUFD FPFKHFRUUHGLIURQWHDOPXUR GL QRUGRYHVW GHOOD .DµED L GXH HVWUHPLGHOPXURVRQRGLVWDQWLFLU FD P GDJOL DQJROL QRUG H R YHVWGHOOD.DµED ̬̚˧ ː̲̚˧ DIQD SXJQRSLHQRGLFLERFKHVLGj DLSRYHULFRPHDPPHQGDSHUPDQ FDQ]H FRPPHVVH GXUDQWH LO SHOOH JULQDJJLR ̣˨ DOƗORLOO ̣˨ȇǫȓ ȃҠ˨ WHUULWRULR QRQ VDFUR RSSRVWR DDUƗP ̣˨ LOO WHPSR LQ FXL DOFXQH FRVH SUL PD SURLELWH D FDXVD GHO SHOOHJUL QDJJLR GLYHQJRQR OHFLWH WUDQQH L UDSSRUWLFRQGRQQHLQFOXVRLOIDWWR GL FRQWUDUUH PDWULPRQLR H OD FDF FLDSURIXPDUVLqULSURYDWRPDQRQ YL q DPPHQGD ILG\D SHU FKL VL SURIXPL ̧̣֡ WDDOOXO O¶XVFLUH GDOOR VWDWR VDFUR LUƗPQHOSHOOHJULQDJJLRHULHQWUDUH QHOORVWDWRSURIDQRDOWDDOOXODO DNEDU PDJJLRUH GLYLHQH OHFLWR WXWWRFLzFKHHUDSURLELWRQHOORVWDWR GL LUƗP DOWDDOOXO DODصĀDU PL QRUH HQWUDWD PLQRUH QHOOR VWDWR SURIDQR GRSR LO TXDOH UHVWDQR DQ FRUDSURLELWHOHUHOD]LRQLVHVVXDOLH OD FDFFLD HG q ULSURYDWR LO SURIX PDUVL ˰ݔ ߦ˰ݔ DPGDOD HVSUHVVLRQH ߸˰߯Ǫ6LDORGDWR 'LR ̣ݔ PDPDOPDPLO ̣ࠉ VHOODDPR¶GLSRUWDQWLQDSHU GRQQHXVDWDGXUDQWHLOSHOOHJULQDJ JLR ³FRVWUX]LRQH D IRUPD GL SDODQFKLQRFRSHUWDGLULFFKHVWRI IHFKHLVRYUDQLYLFLQLLQYLDYDQRD 0HFFDFRQODFDURYDQDXIILFLDOHGHL SHOOHJULQL FRPH DIIHUPD]LRQH GHL $JRVWLQR&LODUGR ORURGLULWWLGLSURWH]LRQHHGLLQWHU YHQWR´, ̣̫߾Ǫ DOPDPDODOPDPLO FDVVD GL OHJQR SLUDPLGDOH UL YHVWLWDGLEURFFDWRFKHVHUYHSHULO WUDVSRUWR GHOODNLVZD GDOO¶(JLWWR D 0HFFD ߧ̋̀˧ OHSDUROHGHOO¶DסƗQ ݫǭҠ˾̤Ǫ ࠄ̊ ݫ DZҠ̤̚Ǫࠄ̊9HQLWHDOODSUHJKLHUDYH QLWHDOODSURVSHULWj ˘ˍˬ DEDـ ˘ˍˬ VRVWDQ]D LPPRQGD VX TF SHU HV VX XQ SXQWR GHOOD YHVWH GL FKL VL DSSUHVWD D FRPSLHUH R VWD FRPSLHQGRXQDSUDWLFDGLFXOWROD ULPR]LRQHGLTXHVWDVRVWDQ]DQRQq VXIILFLHQWH SHU UHQGHUH PRQGD OD PDWHULDFKHQHqVWDWDVSRUFDWDPD VLULFKLHGHODVXDSXULILFD]LRQHOH JDOH ˇ̄ˬ XؾED ːˋ̄ˬ SUHGLFD VHUPRQH IDWWR GDOO¶L PƗP GXUDQWH OD SUHJKLHUD GHO YH QHUGuHQHOOHIHVWHLVODPLFKH4XDO VLDVLDUJRPHQWRUHODWLYRDOEHQHGHO OD FRPXQLWj SXz FRVWLWXLUH RJJHWWR GHOVHUPRQHSHUTXHVWRGHYHHVVH UHIDWWRLQXQDOLQJXDFRPSUHVDGDO O¶DVVHPEOHDLQIDWWLLOVHUPRQHqFR VD GLYHUVD GDOOD VWUXWWXUD GHOOD SUH JKLHUDFKHqILVVDHVWDELOH ˇ̾̄ˬ DؾƯE FKLIDODSUHGLFD ̘ˬ ILµO DIƯI ̘̀̚ˬ̣̙̋ PDQFDQ]DVFXVDELOHOHJJHUD LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH GHOOD SDUYLWj GHOODPDWHULD ̧̂˭ DOƯؾ ̧̂̾˭ VRFLR LQ DIIDUH SL SHUVRQH FRQVHUYDQGR FLDVFXQD OD SURSULHWj GHO SURSULR EHVWLDPH OR WHQJRQR ULXQLWR RWWHQHQGR XQD HFRQRPLD VXOO¶RYLOHHDOWUHFRVHFKHVRQRFR PXQL JOL DVVRFLDWL QHO EHVWLDPH SXUFKp VLD GHOOD PHGHVLPD VSHFLH VRQRFRQVLGHUDWLFRPHVHIRVVHURXQ VROR SURSULHWDULR FIU + , S QRWD ̧̛˭ DOŊT.DµED ːˋ̡̋ȁ̸̧˭ SURIXPR FRPSRVWR GL ]DIIH UDQR H DOWUL DURPL QHO TXDOH SUH GRPLQDQR L FRORUL URVVR H JLDOOR QRQYLqDPPHQGDSHULOSHOOHJUL QRFKHORXVLSXUFKpORWROJDVXEL WRGLGRVVR+,S ̣˭ ̧̣̾֫ WDOƯO LOSXOLUHLGHQWLFRQORVWX]]L FDGHQWLQHOO¶DEOX]LRQH ǻ˅˭ ̂̾ࠍ PDƯؾ DELWRFXFLWRFRQIH]LRQDWRSURL ELWRDJOLXRPLQLLQGRVVDUORGXUDQWH LOSHOOHJULQDJJLR ˅̊dz Ǥ˅̊dz GXµƗ¶ VXSSOLFDRLQYRFD]LRQHD'LR SLDLQYRFD]LRQHSUHJKLHUDGLVXS 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD SOLFD SUHJKLHUD LQGLYLGXDOH GL UL FKLHVWD SUHJKLHUD FKH GHYH HVVHUH SURQXQFLDWD GXUDQWH O¶HVHFX]LRQH GLXQULWR ߵdz ߵ˰˒ WDGDOOXN LO PDVVDJJLDUVL OR VWURILQDUVL PHQWUH VL YHUVD O¶DFTXD SHU O¶D EOX]LRQH ࠒdz Ǥ˅̪dzǰȄdz GDPSOGLPƗ¶ YLWWLPDPLQRUHHVSLDWRULDYLW WLPD GL EHVWLDPH PLQXWR LQ HVSLD ]LRQHRDPPHQGDVLQȉ˰̵yː̻˰̙ ˟߬ǪǤ˅̪dz GLPƗ¶DODdždž DPPHQGHHVSLD]LRQLSHUPDQ FDQ]H FRPPHVVH GXUDQWH LO SHOOH JULQDJJLRSHUHVFRPH˰̾˾̤ǪǤǪ˴ˠ ՆǴ ՆǴ סDE PRGRGLPDFHOOD]LRQHPDWWD ]LRQHPHGLDQWHVJR]]DPHQWRVFDQ QDPHQWR ˲̠Ǵ ǵߐǴǫȓ ǰ˲̠Ǵ סLNUSODסNƗU PHPRULDOH SUHJKLHUD VSRQ WDQHD FRQVLVWHQWH LQ ORGL GL 'LR LQYRFD]LRQLFKHVLUHFLWDQRTXDQ GR VL ODYDQR GHWHUPLQDWH SDUWL GHO FRUSRLQYRFD]LRQLFRUULVSRQGHQWL DG RJQL SRVL]LRQH DVVXQWD GXUDQWH ODSUHJKLHUDULWXDOHO¶LQWHUDSUH JKLHUD ULWXDOH YD VRWWR LO QRPH GL סLNU $OOƗK &RU ;;,; IUH TXHQWHPHQWHLOWHUPLQHסLNUVLULIH ULVFHDOORVWHVVR&RUDQR ߐǴ סDNƗWRWDסNL\D ː̠̾˱˒ȇǫȓ ǭߐǴ PDWWD]LRQH OHJDOH PDFHOOD ]LRQH OHJDOH &L VRQR WUH PRGL OH FLWL GL XFFLGHUH XQ DQLPDOH GHVWL QDWRDGHVVHUPDQJLDWRסDER QDU µDTU IDUHTFFKHFDXVL OD PRUWH GHOO¶DQLPDOH FRPH JHW WDUORQHOO¶DFTXDEROOHQWHRWDJOLDUH OHDOLDGXQDORFXVWD ̈ˈǵ ̈ˈ˲˔ WDUDEEXµ ORVWDUHVHGXWLDYHQGROHJDP EHLQFURFLDWHJDPEHLQFURFLDWH³D TXDWWUR´ LO SUHQGHUH GXUDQWH OD SUHJKLHUD OD SRVWXUD FKH FRQVLVWH QHOPHWWHUVLDJDPEHLQFURFLDWHFRO SLHGHGHVWURVRWWRLOJLQRFFKLRRLO IHPRUHVLQLVWURHLOVLQLVWURVRWWRLO JLQRFFKLR R IHPRUH GHVWUR ³FKL q FRVWUHWWRDVHGHUVLqHVRUWDWRDVH GHUVLQHLSXQWLFKHVHORSRWHVVH VWDUHEEHGLULWWRVXOOHJDPEHLQFUR FLDWH SRL QHOOD SURVWUD]LRQH H IUD OH GXH SURVWUD]LRQL FDPELD PRGR GLVHGHUVLHPHWWHOHJDPEHµDGX H¶´̴̧̾ˡǵ˙ܩ+SHQRWD UXEƗµL\\D ː̾̉Դǵ SUHJKLHUD FRPSRVWD GD TXDW WURUDNµD ˇ˒ǵ ˇ˒Ǫȇǵǰˇ˒Ǫǵ UƗWLESOUDZƗWLE SUHJKLHUH VXSHUHURJDWRULH FKHVLUHFLWDQRLQJLRUQLHRUHGHWHU PLQDWHUDFFROWDGLSUHJKLHUH ˇ˒Ǫ˲̤ǪȄ˅̪ȔҟǪ DOLPƗPDOUƗWLE O¶LPƗP UHJRODUH WLWRODUH QRQ DYYHQWL]LR LQ XQD PRVFKHD SHU OD SUHJKLHUDGHOYHQHUGu $JRVWLQR&LODUGR WDUWƯE ˇ̿˒˲˔ VHTXHQ]DGLDWWLD]LRQLFRP SRUWDPHQWLQHOOHSUDWLFKHGLFXOWR O¶RUGLQH GL RSHUD]LRQL JHVWL GD FRPSLHUH ݏǵ DžDEDODO5DPD ː̤˲ݔǪ̣ˍˠ ³0RQWH GHOOD 0LVHULFRUGLD´ FROOLQDGLFLUFDWUHQWD PHWULGLDO WH]]DVLWXDWDQHOODYDOOHGLµ$UDIƗW VXFXLF¶qLOSXOSLWRGDFXLO¶LPƗP ID LO VHUPRQH XؾED GXUDQWH OD VRVWDZXTŊI GHLSHOOHJULQLDGµ$ UDIƗWLOGLסŊ¶OLdždžDJUDGLQL GLSLHWUDSRUWDQRDOODVRPPLWj Ȁdzǵ ȀǪdzǵȔǪ LUGƗI LOIDUVHJXLUHLPPHGLDWDPHQWH LODdždžDOODµXPUD Ȉdzǵ ː̻dzǵǫȓ ǰǤǪdzǵ ULGƗ¶SODUGL\D PDQWRPDQWHOORPDQWHOORVXO OH VSDOOH PHVVR DQFKH QHOOD SUH JKLHUDVXSHUHURJDWRULDVLUDFFRQWD FKH0XDPPDGQHOORVWDWRGLLUƗPSRUWDVVHXQSDQQRQRQFXFLWR FLQWRDLILDQFKLL]ƗUHXQPDQWHO OR QRQ FXFLWR ULGƗ¶ FKH FRSULYD ODSDUWHVXSHULRUHGHOFRUSR ǤǪdz˲̤Ǫ˱˭ǫȓ DסDOULGƗ¶ O¶DYHUHVXOOHVSDOOHLOPDQWHOOR GXUDQWHODSUHJKLHUDSUDWLFDUDF FRPDQGDWD ޫǵ WDUןL\D ː̾̀˲˔ LOSURQXQFLDUHO¶HXORJLDUDןL \D$OOƗKµDQKX'LRVLFRPSLDFFLD GLOXLSHUL&RPSDJQLGHO3URIHWD SHUHVQHOODSUHGLFDGHOYHQHUGu ˇ̍ǵ ˅̪˲̍ˇ̙زǙˇʿ˅̎ǵǰːˋ̾̍ǵ UDĀƯEDSOUDĀƗ¶LEPXUDĀĀDEIƯKD SUDWLFD UHOLJLRVD GHVLGHUDEL OH GL YDORUH LQIHULRUH DOOD SUDWLFD TXDOLILFDWD VXQQD PD VXSHULRUH D TXHOOD TXDOLILFDWD VXSHUHURJDWRULD FRPH SHU HV OD SUHJKLHUD VXSH UHURJDWRULDGHOODPDWWLQDWD ̙̈ǵ ̙̈ǵ ULPR]LRQH GDO FRUSR H GDOOH YHVWLGLVRVWDQ]DLPPRQGD UDIµ ̡̈ǵ UDNµD ː̡̋ǵ XQFLFORGLDWWLHGLSDUROHYD ULDELOHQHOQXPHURDVHFRQGDGHOOH FLQTXHSUHJKLHUHFDQRQLFKH ǽ̸̠ǵ UXNŊµ O¶LQFKLQDUVLSURIRQGDPHQWHQHO OD SUHJKLHUD O¶RUDQWH VL LQFKLQD LQ DYDQWL H SRQH OH GXH SDOPH GHOOH PDQLVXLJLQRFFKLVHQRQJLXQJR QRDLJLQRFFKLQRQqYHUDUDNµDq UDFFRPDQGDELOHFKHO¶RUDQWHPHWWD OD PDQR DOO¶HVWUHPLWj GHOOD FRVFLD HODIDFFLDWRFFDUHqDQFKHUDFFR PDQGDELOHIDUVuFKHOHGXHSDOPH GHOOHPDQLSUHQGDQRHRFFXSLQROD VXSHUILFLH GHL GXH JLQRFFKL VODU JDQGROHGLWDHWHQHQGRLJLQRFFKL GLULWWLSHUSHQGLFRODUL ̬̠ǵ ȄҠ˷Գȅߐǵǫȓ DUNƗQDOLVOƗP SLODVWUL R FRORQQH GHOO¶LVODP SURIHVVLRQH GL IHGH SUHJKLHUD H 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD OHPRVLQDOHJDOHGLJLXQRSHOOHJUL QDJJLR ߇Ǫ˲̤̋Ǫ̬̠˲̤Ǫ DOUXNQDOµLUƗTƯ DQJROR QRUG GHOOD .DµED LQ GLUH]LRQHGHOO¶,UDT DOUXNQDO\DPDQƯ ̦ܳؒǪ̬̠˲̤Ǫ DQJRORVXGGHOOD.DµEDLQGL UH]LRQHGHO<HPHQ ࠒȓˆ˻̤Ǫ̬̠˲̤Ǫ DOUXNQDOãD¶PƯ DQJROR RYHVW GHOOD .DµED LQ GLUH]LRQH GHOOD *UDQGH 6LULD DO âD¶P dz̸˷ҡȓ Ǫ̬̠˲̤Ǫ DOUXNQDODVZDG DQJROR HVW GHOOD .DµED GRYH qLQFDVWRQDWDOD3LHWUD1HUD ̣̪ǵ ̣̪ǵ UDPDO DQGDWXUDFHOHUHSUHVDGDJOLXR PLQL QRQ GDOOH GRQQH QHO ؾDZƗI VDOWHOODQGROHJJHUPHQWHHVFXRWHQGR OHVSDOOHQHLSULPLWUHJLULQHODdždž RQHOODµXPUDLUHVWDQWLTXDWWURJLUL VLIDQQRDGDQGDWXUDQRUPDOH Ȉȇǵ \DZPDOWDUZL\D ː̻ȇ̤ٵǪȄ̸̻ OHWW LO JLRUQR GHOO¶DSSURYYL JLRQDPHQWR GL DFTXD R GHOOD VRG GLVID]LRQHGHOODVHWHqLOJLRUQR GL סŊ¶OLdždžD TXDQGR FRPLQFLD LO SHOOHJULQDJJLRYHURHSURSULRHWXWWL L SHOOHJULQL GHYRQR IDUH OH VWHVVH IXQ]LRQL R ULWL FROOHWWLYL VL FKLDPD FRVu SHUFKp L SHOOHJULQL VL ULIRUQL VFRQRGLDFTXDSHULJLRUQLVHJXHQ WLLQVHQVRVSLULWXDOHLQGLFDFKHO¶L QL]LRGHODdždžYHURHSURSULRVLJQL ILFD VRGGLVID]LRQH GHOOD VHWH VSLUL WXDOH ߐǶ ]DNƗW ǭߐǶ OHWW SURELWj SXULWj SXULILFD ]LRQH LPSRVWD OHJDOH &RU ,, ,; ;;,, ;;;,,, /9,,, DOOD TXDOHKDQQRGLULWWRLSRYHULLELVR JQRVLJOLLQFDULFDWLGLUDFFRJOLHUOD HFF&RU,;GLYHUVDGDTXHOOD YRORQWDULD܈DGDTD&RU,; KD Ǯ˅̜˰˽ FKH SHUz LQ TXHVWR FRQ WHVWR QRQ LQGLFD OD EHQHILFHQ]D R OH³HOHPRVLQHYRORQWDULHRVSRQWD QHH´ &RU ,, /9,,, PDOD]DNàW ǭߐǶȇǫȓ ȅ˅̪́ǵǭߐǶȇǫȓ ˲̤̄̚Ǫː̜˰˽ȇǫȓ ˲̤̄̚ǪǭߐǶ Ƿǫȓ ˲̤ǪǭߐǶȇǫȓ ȅ˰ˋ̤ǪǭߐǶȇǫȓ Ȅ̸˾̤Ǫ ]DNƗWDOILؾURصDGDTDWDOILؾUR]D NƗW5DPDןƗQR]DNƗWDOصDZPR ]DNƗWDOEDGDQR]DNƗWDOUD¶V ]DNƗWFKHGHYHHVVHUHGDWDSUR FDSLWH GD RJQL PXVXOPDQR PD VFKLRR IHPPLQD PLQRUHR DGXOWR OLEHURRVFKLDYRDOWHUPLQHGHOPH VHGL5DPDןƗQDIDYRUHGHLSRYH UL OLEHUDOLWj LQ JHQHUL DOLPHQWDUL GRYXWD LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOµƯG DOILؾU DPPRQWD D FLUFD WUH R TXDWWUR NJ GL IUXPHQWR RU]R ULVR R TXDOVLDVL DOWUD GHUUDWD DOLPHQWDUH GHO SDHVH RLOVXRHTXLYDOHQWHLQPRQHWDSHU RJQLPHPEURGHOODIDPLJOLD Ȅ˴̪Ƕ =DP]DP SR]]R GD FXL VFDWXUu DFTXD ]DPSLOODQWHSHUGLVVHWDUH$JDUH, VPDHOH VLWXDWR DOO¶LQWHUQR GHOO¶D UHDGHOOD6DFUD0RVFKHDGLFXLID SDUWHO¶HGLILFLRVXOSR]]R $JRVWLQR&LODUGR ȃǪǶ ]DZƗO ȃǪȇǶ PH]]RJLRUQR LO SULQFLSLR GHO GHFOLQDUH GHO VROH GDO PHULGLDQR YHUVRRFFLGHQWH ˦ˋ̑˷ WDVEƯ ˦̀ˌ˸˓ JORULILFD]LRQH GL 'LR HVFOD PDQGRVXEƗQD¶OOƗK ߸ȅ˅˪ˋ̑˷ VXEƗQD¶OOƗK ³JORULDD'LR´FRQTXHVWDH VFODPD]LRQH O¶RUDQWH KD DYYHUWLWR O¶LPƗPGL TXDOFKH RPLVVLRQH R LU UHJRODULWj GD OXL FRPPHVVD QHOOD SUHJKLHUD ˰ݶ ˰ݶ VDdžDGD IDUHXQDVDdžGDRSURVWUD]LRQH GL ULSDUD]LRQH SHU TXDOFKH PDQ FDQ]D FRPPHVVD GXUDQWH OD SUH JKLHUD dz̸ݶ VXdžŊG SURVWUD]LRQHOHSXQWHGHLSLH GLFRQLOFDOFDJQRVROOHYDWROHJL QRFFKLD OH PDQL H OD IURQWH GHO O¶RUDQWH WRFFDQR SHU WHUUD DSSRJ JLDQGROHJJHUPHQWHDQFKHLOQDVR ǭdz˅Ȑݶ VDdždžƗGD WDSSHWLQRSHUODSUHJKLHUD PDVdžLG ˰ˤ˸̪ OXRJR GRYH FL VL SURVWUD OXR JR GL FXOWR OXRJR GL SUHJKLHUD &RU,,9,,;;,,PR VFKHDODFRVWUX]LRQHqULYROWDYHU VROD.DµED ȄǪ˲߬Ǫ˰ˤ˸Ǫ DO0DVdžLGDODUƗP ³7HPSLR6DQWR´³7HPSLR6D FUR´ &RU ,, 9,;;9,,;;,, ;/9,,, OD 6DFUD 0RVFKHD GL0HFFD ߷˰ˡ˅˸̪ 0DVƗdžLG$OOƗK ³7HPSOL GL 'LR´ &RU ,; ³1RQV¶DGGLFHDJOLLGRODWULYL VLWDUH L 7HPSOL GL 'LR« >FIU DQ FKH &RU ,;@ 6ROL YLVLWHUDQQR L 7HPSOL GL 'LR TXHOOL FKH FUHGRQR LQ 'LR H QHO *LRUQR (VWUHPR H FRPSLRQROD3UHJKLHUDHSDJDQROD 'qFLPD H QRQ KDQ SDXUD G¶DOWUL FKH'LR«´ ެ̜ҡȓ Ǫ˰ˤ˸Ǫ DO0DVdžLGDO$TصƗ ³7HPSLR 8OWLPR´ &RU ;9,, OD 0RVFKHD UHPRWD LO 7HPSLR GL*HUXVDOHPPH ǵǪ̤ޢǪ˰ˤ˸̪ 0DVdžLGDOמLUƗU ³0RVFKHD GHO 'DQQR´ &RU ,; ³PRVFKHD FRVWUXLWD LQYLFLQDQ]DGHOODPRVFKHDGL4X EƗSRFRD6(GL0HGLQDODSUL PD H SHU PROWR WHPSR XQLFD PR VFKHD GHOO¶,VOjP GL FXL 0XDP PDG VWHVVR SRVH OD SULPD SLHWUD SULPDGLHQWUDUHD0HGLQDGXUDQWH O¶ÊJLUDDOORVFRSRGLµFDXVDUGDQ QR¶DTXHOODPRVFKHDPXVXOPDQD´ %S ˲ݷ ǵ̸ݷ VDŊUVXŊU XOWLPR SDVWR FRQVXPDWR SUL PDGHOO¶DOEDQHOPHVHGL5DPDןƗQ &RU,,³9LqSHUPHVVRQHOOH QRWWL GHO PHVH GHO GLJLXQR G¶DF FRVWDUYLDOOHYRVWUHGRQQH«EHYH WH H PDQJLDWH ILQR D TXHOO¶RUD LQ FXL SRWUHWH GLVWLQJXHUH XQ ILOR ELDQFRGDXQILORQHUR«´ 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD ̺̋˷ ̺̋˷ VDµ\ FRUVD FRUVD ULWXDOH GHO SHOOH JULQDJJLR XQR GHL ULWL HVVHQ]LDOL GHO SHOOHJULQDJJLR WUDJLWWR IDWWR GDLSHOOHJULQLWUDGXHFROOLQHWWHQHL SUHVVLGL0HFFDDOشDIƗHDO0DU ZD&RU,,QRQXVDLOWHUPLQH VDµ\ PD GLFH ³«H QRQ VDUj PD OH GL JLUDUYL DWWRUQR«´ DZ˅̲ˠ Ҡ̙ ࠇ ؙȀ̸̻̄ ȅǫȓ ̴̧̾̊ ³OD GLVWDQ]D WUD OH GXH PHWH GHOOH FROOLQH q GL FLUFD PHWUL H ELVRJQD IDUH OD FRUVD VHWWH YROWH YDULDQGR LO SDVVR LQ SXQWL GHWHUPLQDWL H UHFLWDQGR OH IRUPXOH SUHVFULWWH´ ,S 6H FRQGRXQDWUDGL]LRQHOHGXHFROOL QH IXURQR OD VFHQD GHOOD FRUVD GL $JDU DOOD ULFHUFD GHOO¶DFTXD SHU LO SLFFROR,VPDHOHTXDQGRIXODVFLDWR Ou GD $EUDPR VL FRQVLGHUDQR XQ PRQXPHQWR GL SD]LHQ]D QHOOH SL JUDQGLWULEROD]LRQLVHFRQGRXQ¶DO WUD WUDGL]LRQH TXL $EUDPR FRUVH SLYHORFHGHOGLDYRORFKHJOLDYH YD WHVR XQ¶LPERVFDWD FIU , S ǽ˅˷ VƗµ LQ HVDWWRUHGHOOD]DNƗW ˷ VDOƗPDOWDOƯO ̧̣̾˪˕̤ǪȄҠ˷ ³VDOXWR GL SHUPLVVLRQH´ WDV OƯP IDWWR DOOD ILQH GHOOD SUHJKLHUD GDOOD SRVL]LRQH GL DFFRVFLDWR džX OnjV FRO TXDOH VL ULVROYH OR VWDWR VDFUR LUàP UHQGHQGR SHUPHVVR FLz FKH HUD YLHWDWR GXUDQWH OD SUH JKLHUD ˓˸̧ۮ WDVOƯP IRUPXOD ߷ːݔǵȇߝ̧̾̊ȄҠ˸̤ǪVX GLYRLVLDODSDFHHODPLVHULFRUGLD GL'LRסLNUFRQFOXVLYRGHOODSUH JKLHUDFKHVLUHFLWDVWDQGRVHGXWL ȄҠ˕̑˷ǪȔ LVWLOƗP WRFFDUH FRQ OD PDQR O¶DQJROR \HPHQLWDGHOOD.DµEDTXDQGRVLID LO ؾDZƗI H SRUWDUOD DOOD ERFFD QHO SULPRJLURGHOؾDZƗI ࠇ˷ ː̫̾˸˓ WDVPL\D HVFODPD]LRQH ߷ ̩˸ˉ EL ¶VPL¶OOƗK³LPSRVL]LRQHGHOQR PHHIIHWWXDWDGDOSDGUHRGDTXDO FKH SHUVRQD DXWRUHYROH OD TXDOH GRSR LO ELVPLOOƗK LQ QRPH GL $O OƗK SURQXQ]LD QHOO¶RUHFFKLR GHO QHRQDWR O¶LQYLWR DOOD SUHJKLHUD R DOWUD IRUPXOD SLD DFFHWWDWD GDOO¶X VR H GRSR XQD EUHYH DOORFX]LRQH GHYRWD LPSRQH LO QRPH GLFHQGR µLR WL FKLDPR FRPH $OOƗK WL KD FKLDPDWR&DLRILJOLRGL7L]LR¶´, S ̈ކ ̫̈̾˸˓ WDVPƯµ LOSURQXQFLDUHGXUDQWHODSUH JKLHUDOHSDUROH̳˰'ކ̈߷̬ݔLR DVFROWDFKLORORGD ̬˷ ۷˷ǰː̰̑˷ VXQQDSOVXQDQ SUDWLFD R XVR DELWXDOH PRGR GL IDUH R D]LRQH FRQVXHWXGLQDULD PRGRGLDJLUHRFRQVXHWXGLQHGL 0XDPPDG QHOOH YDULH FLUFRVWDQ ]H GHOOD YLWD FLz FKH 0XDPPDG KD GHWWR R FLz FKH KD IDWWR R FLz FKH KD WDFLWDPHQWH DSSURYDWR $JRVWLQR&LODUGR DWWRUDFFRPDQGDWRSUHFHWWRGLWUD GL]LRQH SUDWLFD WUDGL]LRQDOH OD SUDWLFD GL VXQQD q TXHOOD SHU OD TXDOHLOPXVXOPDQRqULFRPSHQVD WR GD 'LR VH O¶RVVHUYL PD QRQ q SXQLWRVHQRQO¶RVVHUYL VXQQDPX¶DNNDGD ǭ˰̟ʼ̪ː̰̑˷ VXQQDJUDYHR³LQFXOFDWD´FRQ IHUPDWDFHUWDSUDWLFDUDFFRPDQGDWD FHUWD GHILQLWD GLVWLQWD GDOOD VXQQD ³OHJJHUD´ q ELDVLPHYROH QRQ RV VHUYDUHSRWHQGRORODVXQQDVRSUDW WXWWR VH VL WUDWWD GL VXQQD JUDYH OD FXL RPLVVLRQH HYHQWXDOPHQWH HVLJH ULSDUD]LRQH ḛ̸̏̑˸̪ PDVQŊQ FLz FKH q UDFFRPDQGDWR SUH VFULWWRFRPHVXQQD ˅̶˷ ̸̶˷ VDKZ LQDYYHUWHQ]DGLVDWWHQ]LRQHGL VWUD]LRQHQHJOLJHQ]DRPLVVLRQHGX UDQWHODSUHJKLHUDFIUȅ˅̾̑˸̮Ǚߧ̍̚ ̳Ȍ˅˷ VƗK LQ FKL VHQ]D LQWHQ]LRQH GLPHQ WLFDGLDGHPSLHUHTXDOFXQRGHLGR YHULUHOLJLRVL ̸̶˸̤Ǫdz̸ݶȇǫȓ ̸̶˸̤Ǫǭ˰ݶ VDdžGDWDOVDKZRVXdžŊGDOVDKZ GRSSLDSURVWUD]LRQHFRPHTXHO OD RUGLQDULD GHOOD SUHJKLHUD IDWWD GDOO¶RUDQWH DOOD ILQH GHOOD SUHJKLH UDSULPDGHOWDVOƯPSUHVFULWWDTXDQ GR HJOL FRPPHWWH XQR VEDJOLR GX UDQWH OD SUHJKLHUD RSSXUH TXDQGR KD GHL GXEEL VXO QXPHUR GHOOH UD NµD6HLQYHFHqO¶LPƗPDFRPPHW WHUHXQRVEDJOLRGXUDQWHODSUHJKLH UD HJOL DVVLHPH D WXWWD O¶DVVHP EOHDIDODVDdžGDWDOVDKZ DZ˅˷ VƗ¶L Յ˅˷ SHOOHJULQR YLDQGDQWH YLDJ JLDWRUH VSLULWXDOH FKL FRPSLH LO GLJLXQR XQD SHUVRQD FKH VL DVWLH QH QRQ VROR GDO FLER H GDOOH EH YDQGH PD GD RJQL WLSR GL PDOH &RU,;/;9, Ȃ̸˷ ȂǪ̸˸̪ȇǫȓ ȂǪ̸˷ VLZƗNRPLVZƗN VWHFFKLQR SHU QHWWDUVL L GHQWL GXUDQWH O¶DEOX]LRQH EDVWRQFLQR X VDWRSHUSXOLUHLGHQWLVWX]]LFDGHQWL VSD]]ROLQRGDGHQWLTXDQGRVLIDO¶D EOX]LRQH VL VFLDFTXD OD ERFFD FRQ O¶DLXWRGLXQRVSD]]ROLQRGDGHQWL ǻݾ ãXUŊؾDOصDOƗW ǭҠ˾̤Ǫǻȇݾ FRQGL]LRQLGHOODSUHJKLHUDO¶HV VHUHPXVXOPDQRPHQWDOPHQWHVDQR H GRWDWR GL GLVFHUQLPHQWR ± VHWWH DQQL±SXULWjULWXDOHFRSHUWXUDGHO OH SXGHQGD O¶HVVHUH SUHVHQWH QHO WHPSR GL RJQL SUHJKLHUD SUHVFULWWD GLUH]LRQH YHUVR OD .DµED IRUPXOD ]LRQHGHOO¶LQWHQ]LRQH ȁݾ ̛̻̤˖ނǪȄԹȓǫ D\\ƗPDOWDãUƯT GXHRWUHJLRUQLGRSRLO\DZP DOQDU GXUDQWH LO SHOOHJULQDJJLR L³JLRUQLQXPHUDWL´&RU,,LO WHPSRGXUDQWHLOTXDOHLSHOOHJULQL VWD]LRQDQRD0LQƗGRYHVWDQQRJOL XOWLPLGXHRWUHJLRUQLGRSRLO\D ZPDOQDUFLRqQHLJLRUQL HGLnj¶OণLۜۜD 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD ˘̋˺ ãDµDـ ˘̋˺ IRUPD LQFROWD GHL FDSHOOL SUR SULD GHO SHOOHJULQR VWDWR LQFROWR GHOODSHUVRQD ˲̋˺ ãDµƯUDSOãDµƗ¶LU ˲ˁ˅̋˺ǰǭ˺̋ٸ FHULPRQLDIXQ]LRQHUHOLJLRVD ULWRDWWRGLFXOWR ߷˲ˁ˅̋˺ ãDµƗ¶LU$OOƗK ³LULWLGL'LR´&RU9;;,, ULWLGHOSHOOHJULQDJJLR ̈̚˺ ̈̚˺ QXPHUR SDUL GL UDNµD SUH JKLHUD FRQ QXPHUR SDUL GL UDNµD SUHJKLHUDDSSDLDWDRSDULRGRSSLD ãDIµ ̞˺ ̞˻̤ǪȄ̸̻ \DZPDOãDNN ³JLRUQR GL GXEELR´ TXDQGR QRQF¶qFHUWH]]DFKHVLDFRPLQFLD WRLOQRYLOXQLRGL5DPD¹àQQRQVL GHYHGLJLXQDUHFRVuSXUHVHQHOOD QRWWHGHOGHOPHVHGL5DPD¹àQ LOFLHORqQXYRORVRHQRQVLqYLVWD ODOXQDQXRYDLO PDWWLQRVHJXHQWH q PDWWLQR GHO ³JLRUQR GL GXEELR´ VHVLDRPHQR5DPD¹àQLQTXHVWR JLRUQRqYLHWDWRGLJLXQDUHFRPHVH IRVVH5DPD¹ƗQ ˰̶˺ ǭdz˅̶˺ȇǫȓ ˰̶˻˓ WDãDKKXGRãDKƗGD OHWW DWWHVWD]LRQH LO SURQXQ FLDUH OD ãDKƗGD OD SURIHVVLRQH GL IHGH LVODPLFD HVSUHVVLRQH RUDOH NDOLPDGHOWDZƯGSULQFLSLRGHO ODXQLWjHXQLFLWjGL'LR߷ҟȔǪࠀȔǪҟ ߷ȃ̸˷ǵ˰ࠉȇ1RQF¶qDOWURGLRFKH $OOƗK H 0XDPPDG q LO 6XR ,Q YLDWR ǭ˲̶˻̤Ǫߝ̲̪˰̶˺̬̪ PDQãDKLGDPLQNXPDOãDKUD ³FKL WUD YRL SXz WHVWLPRQLDUH FKHODOXQDGHOPHVHGL5DPDןƗQ qVRUWD´KDO¶REEOLJRGLGLJLXQDUH ǵ˅˺ ̈ˋ˽ҟԴǭǵ˅˺ȔǪ LãƗUDEL¶OLصEDµ JHVWR FRQ OH GLWD VL HVRUWD D ³VWULQJHUH ULSLHJDQGROL QHOOD SDO PDGHOODPDQRVRWWRLOSROOLFHLWUH GLWL XOWLPL GHOOD GHVWUD QRQ GHOOD VLQLVWUDGLVWHQGHQGRLQYHFHO¶LQGL FH H LO SROOLFH QHO SURQXQ]LDUH OH GXHDWWHVWD]LRQL>VLHVRUWDD@PXR YHUH VHPSUH GXUDQWH O¶DWWHVWD]LR QH D GHVWUD H D VLQLVWUD HVVR GLWR LQGLFH´+,S ̬ޗ ̬ޗ صDQ FRUWLOH LQWHUQR GL XQD PR VFKHD ˰̋˽ ˰̾̋˽ صDµƯG SROYHUHVDEELDVRWWLOLVVLPDX VDWD QHOOD OXVWUD]LRQH SXOYHUDOH &RU ,9 9 3HU L PƗOLNLWL q WXWWRFLzFKHDIILRUDDOODVXSHUILFLH GHOWHUUHQRROWUHODSROYHUHDQFKH VDEELD FLRWWROL H VLPLOL SDUWLFHOOH GL WHUUD FKH VRQR VXOOD VXSHUILFLH GHOWHUUHQR ̘˽ صDIISOصXIŊI ̘˽Ȁ̸̚˽ǰ ULJD ILOD FKH VL IRUPD TXDQ GRVLIDODSUHJKLHUDFRPXQLWDULD $JRVWLQR&LODUGR صXIID ː̚˽ DJJHWWR OXRJR DQQHVVR DOOD PRVFKHDGRYHHUDQRDOORJJLDWLJOL XRPLQLFKHYHQLYDQRIRUPDWLQHOOD PRVFKHD H VL SUHSDUDYDQR FRPH PLVVLRQDULSHUGLIIRQGHUHODIHGHL VODPLFD /D صXIID HUD VLWXDWD QHOOD SDUWH QRUG GHOOD PRVFKHD FRSHUWD GDXQWHWWRHDSHUWDVXLODWL ː̚˾̤ǪǬ˅ޗǫȓ ȇǫȓ ː̚˾̤Ǫ̵̣ǫȓ DKODOصXIIDRDصƗEDOصXIID DELWDQWLGHOODصXIIDJOLVWXGHQWL FKHVLSUHSDUDYDQRFRPHPLVVLRQD ULSUHVVRXQDPRVFKHD ̸̧˽ ǮǪ̸̧˽ǰǭҠ˽ صDOƗWSOصDODZƗW SUHJKLHUDULWXDOHRFDQRQLFD ǭҠ˾̤Ǫȅߐǵǫȓ DUNƗQDOصDOƗW HOHPHQWL IRQGDPHQWDOL GHOOD SUHJKLHUD ˲ˣ̤̚ǪǭҠ˽ȇǫȓ ˦ˋ˾̤ǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOصXERصDOƗWDOIDdžU SUHJKLHUD GHO SULPR PDWWLQR GHOO¶DOED&RU;9,,;;,9 //;;9,FKHKDXQSDUWL FRODUHYDORUHVDFUDOH³FKpDOOD5H FLWD]LRQH GHOO¶$OED DVVLVWRQR JOL DQJHOL´ &RU ;9,, ³,O WHPSR GHOOD SUHJKLHUD GHO PDWWLQR q GDO VRUJHUHGHOO¶DOEDHIIHWWLYRTXDQGR OD OXFH JLj VL GLIIRQGH VXOO¶RUL] ]RQWH ILQR DO IDUVL FKLDUR GHOO¶DW PRVIHUDFRPSOHWDPHQWHWDQWRFKH VL SRVVD ULFRQRVFHUH LO YLVR GHOOH SHUVRQH´+,SVLKDLQJH QHUH O¶DOED FLUFD XQ¶RUD H PH]]R SULPDGHOVRUJHUHGHOVROH ̹̄˷̸̤ǪǭҠ˾̤ǪǙ˲̶̤̇ǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDO٤XKUDOصDOƗWDOZXVؾƗ SUHJKLHUDGLPH]]RJLRUQR&RU ,,;;,9SUHJKLHUDPHGLD &RU,,VLGLFHTXDQGRLOVROH FRPLQFLD D WUDPRQWDUH PH]]R JLRUQR FRUUH GDOO¶LQL]LR GHO GHFOL QDUH GHO VROH TXDQGR ROWUHSDVVD LO PHULGLDQR ILQR D TXDQGR O¶RPEUD GHOFRUSRRGLXQTXDOVLDVLRJJHWWR qOXQJDFRPHODVXDDOWH]]D ̤̋ޠǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOµDصU SUHJKLHUD GHO SRPHULJJLR VL GLFH TXDQGR LO VROH VWD D PHWj GHO WUDPRQWR LO WHPSR FRUUH GDTXDQ GR ILQLVFH ٤XKU ILQR DOO¶LQJLDOOLUH GHJOL RJJHWWL LOOXPLQDWL GDO VROH YHUVRLOWUDPRQWRWUDWWRGHOODJLRU QDWD TXDQGR LO VROH LQL]LD LO VXR GHFOLQR&RU&,,, Ǭ˲̏ǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOPDĀULE SUHJKLHUD GHO WUDPRQWR GHO WDUGR SRPHULJJLR VL GLFH LPPH GLDWDPHQWH GRSR FKH LO VROH q WUD PRQWDWR LO WHPSR VL HVWHQGH GD TXDQGRWUDPRQWDO¶LQWHURGLVFRGHO VROH ILQR D TXDQGR OD OLQHD URVVD DOO¶RUL]]RQWHVSDULVFH Ǥ˅˻̤̋ǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOµLãƗ¶ SUHJKLHUDGHOODVHUD&RU;9,, ;;,9//;;9, VL GLFH GD TXDQGR OD OLQHD URVVD GHO FUHSXVFROR DOO¶RUL]]RQWH VFRPSDUH ILQRDOSULPRWHU]RGHOODQRWWH ̹˩̤́ǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOןXƗ SUHJKLHUD GHO PDWWLQR SUH JKLHUDDQWLPHULGLDQDWHPSRSULPD GLPH]]RJLRUQRPDWWLQDWDDYDQ]D WD FRVu q FKLDPDWD XQD SUHJKLHUD YRORQWDULDIDWWDLQTXHVWRWHPSR 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD ː̊˅߮Ǫ߆ǭҠ˾̤Ǫȇǫȓ ː̊˅߮ǪǭҠ˽ȇǫȓ ː̋߮ǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOdžXPµDRصDOƗWDOdžDPƗµDR DOصDOƗWIƯ¶OdžDPƗµD SUHJKLHUDFRPXQLWDULDGHOYH QHUGu SUHJKLHUD LQ JUXSSR &RU /;,, صDOƗWDOµƯGD\QL ̬̽˰̤̾̋ǪǭҠ˽ SUHJKLHUDGHOOHGXH)HVWHLVOD PLFKHµƯGDODןƗµƯGDOILؾU ˱̤̚ǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOIDסס SUHJKLHUDIDWWD LQGLYLGXDOPHQ WHQRQVHJXHQGRO¶LPàP DOصDOƗWµDOƗ¶O1DEƯ ̰̤ܰǪࠄ̊ǭҠ˾̤Ǫ SUHJKLHUD SHU LO 3URIHWD q OD IRUPXOD LVODPLFD FKH VHJXH UHJR ODUPHQWH LO QRPH GHO 3URIHWDصDO OƗ¶OOƗKµDOD\KLZDVDOODPD3UHJKL ,GGLRSHU/XLH*OLGLDVDOXWHIRU PXODEDVDWDVX&RU;;;ODG GRYHLOYHUERصDOOƗVLJQLILFD³SUR GXUUH XQD IRU]D VDFUDOH EHQHILFD SRVLWLYD´QHOODIDWWLVSHFLH³'LRR SHUDVDFUDOPHQWHVXGLYRLSHUWUDU YLGDOOHWHQHEUHDOODOXFH´FIU&RU ;;;,,,%SS ˴ˁ˅̰߫Ǫࠄ̊ǭҠ˾̤Ǫȇǫȓ ǭǶ˅̰߫ǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOdžLQƗ]DRDOصDOƗW µDOƗ¶OdžDQƗ¶L] SUHJKLHUD VXOOD EDUD SUHJKLH UDSHULOGHFHGXWR ˑ̾Ǫࠄ̊ǭҠ˾̤Ǫȇǫȓ ˇʿ˅̤̏ǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOĀƗ¶LERDOصDOƗWµDOƗ¶O PD\\LW SUHJKLHUDSHULOPRUWR ˲̫̝̤ǪȀ̸˸ˬǭҠ˽ȇǫȓ Ȁ̸˸߭ǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOXVŊIRصDOƗWXVŊIDO TDPDU SUHJKLHUDLQRFFDVLRQHGHOO¶H FOLVVLOXQDUH صDOƗWDONXVŊI Ȁ̸˸̢̤ǪǭҠ˽ SUHJKLHUDLQRFFDVLRQHGHOO¶H FOLVVLVRODUH Ȁ̸߭ǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDODZI ³SUHJKLHUD GHOOD SDXUD´ SUH JKLHUD GL IURQWH DO QHPLFR SUH JKLHUD LQ FDVRGL SHULFROR &RU ,, ,9 ՊȇǪ̤ٵǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOWDUƗZƯ SUHJKLHUD ³GHOOH SDXVH´ SUH JKLHUDVXSHUHURJDWRULDFKHVLUHFL WD GXUDQWH OH QRWWL GL 5DPDןƗQ q SUDVVL QHOOH QRWWL GHO PHVH GL 5D PDןƗQUHFLWDUHWXWWRLO&RUDQRQHO OD SUHJKLHUD VXSHUHURJDWRULD FRVu GHQRPLQDWD QHO FRPSLHUH TXHVWD SUHJKLHUD VL IDQQR GRSR RJQL GXH UDNµD GHOOH SDXVH R ULSRVL WDUZƯ DSOWDUƗZƯ DWWRGLULSRVDUH Ǥ˅̝˸˖˷ԳǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOLVWLVTƗ¶ SUHJKLHUD SHU LPSORUDUH OD SLRJJLDQHOODVLFFLWj ˲˔ȇǙ˲˔̸̤ǪǭҠ˽ صDOƗWDOZLWUZLWU ³SUHJKLHUDGLVSDUL´SUHJKLHUD ³GHOQXPHURGLVSDUL´QXPHURGLV SDULGLUDNµDSUHJKLHUDQRWWXUQD IDWWDLQGLYLGXDOPHQWHQRQREEOLJD WRULD PD VSHFLDOPHQWH UDFFRPDQ GDWDFKH VL FRPSRQH GLXQD R SL UDNµD PD VHPSUH LQ QXPHUR GLV SDUL GRSR OD SUHJKLHUD GHO µLãƗ¶ FRPH VXQQD VL UHFLWDQR GXH UDNµD VHJXLWHGDWUHUDNµDFKLDPDWHZLWU ǭ˨˅ޞǭҠ˽ صDOƗWƗןLUD SUHJKLHUDSURSULDGHOPRPHQ WRSUHVHQWHVWDELOLWR ːˈ̸˗̢ǪǭҠ˾̤Ǫ DOصDOàWDOPDNWnjED SUHJKLHUD SUHVFULWWD O¶RSSR VWRGLQƗILOD $JRVWLQR&LODUGR Ḛ̸̤̏Ǫ̬̪˭ٸǭҠ˾̤Ǫ DOصDODWD\U XQPLQDOQDZP OD SUHJKLHUD YDO PHJOLR GHO VRQQROHXOWLPHSDUROHGHOO¶LQYLWR DOODSUHJKLHUDGHOO¶DOED ǭҠ˾̤Ǫː̪˅̜ȔǪ LTƗPDWDOصDOƗW VHFRQGR LQYLWR DOOD SUHJKLHUD IDWWRLQPRVFKHD ̣Ȑ ˾̪ PXصDOO LQ FKLSUHJDRUDQWH Ǯ˅̧̾˾̪ǰ̣Ȑ ˾̪ DQ PXصDOO SOPXصDOOD\ƗW OXRJR GL SUHJKLHUD RUDWRULR FDSSHOOD Ȅ˅˽ Ȅ˅̾˽ȇǫȓ Ȅ̸˽ صDZPRصL\ƗP GLJLXQR LVWLWX]LRQDOH GXUDQWH LO PHVH GL 5DPD¹àQ GLJLXQR R DVWHQVLRQH GDO FLER GDOOH EHYDQGH H GDL UDSSRUWL VHVVXDOL GDOO¶DOED DO WUDPRQWRDYHQGRQHLQWHQ]LRQH&RU ,, ǽ̸̄˕̤ǪȄ̸˽ صDZPDOWDؾDZZXµ GLJLXQR YRORQWDULR R VXSHUH URJDWRULR ˅ޚ ̹ޚ ןXƗ WHPSR SULPD GL PH]]RJLRUQR TXDQGR LO VROH q DOWR DOO¶RUL]]RQWH &RU 9,, /;;,; ;&, ;&,,, \DZPDODןƗ ̹ޚҡȓ ǪȄ̸̻ JLRUQR GHL VDFULILFL LO GL nj¶OণLۜۜD Թ˅ޚǰː̾ޚ ןDL\\DSOןDƗ\Ɨ YLWWLPD FKH YLHQH VDFULILFDWD QHOµƯGDODןƗ Ǭޞ ןDUEDIƯI ̘̀̚ˬǬޞ LOSUHPHUHOHJJHUPHQWHODPD QR SLHQD GL SROYHUH QHOOD OXVWUD ]LRQHSXOYHUDOH ːˈޞ ןDUED OHJJHURFROSRFRQODSROYHUH XQRDOYLVRO¶DOWURDOOHPDQLQHOOD OXVWUD]LRQHSXOYHUDOH ˲̶̃ ؾDKƗUD ǭǵ˅̶̃ SXULWj SXULILFD]LRQH VWDWR GL SXULWj ULWXDOH &RU ,9 9 ODSXULWj³VLSHUGHSHUGHWHUPLQDWL DWWL ILVLRORJLFL GHOO¶LQGLYLGXR VWHV VRFRPHLOVRQQRLELVRJQLFRUSRUD OL OH UHOD]LRQL VHVVXDOL RYYHUR SHU FRQWDWWR FRQ SHUVRQH R FRVH FRQVL GHUDWH LPSXUH 6HFRQGR XQD WUDGL ]LRQHLSDJDQLVRQRLPSXUL0ROWL PXVXOPDQLFRQVLGHUDQRLPSXULDQ FKHFULVWLDQLHGHEUHLHSHUWDQWRVL SXULILFDQR GRSR DYHU WUDWWDWR FRQ HVVL &RVH LPSXUH VRQR DG HVHP SLR LO YLQR LO PDLDOH FDGDYHUL H UHVWLGLDQLPDOLQRQFRPPHVWLELOL´ +,SS Ȁ˅̃ ȀǪ̸̃ ؾDZƗI JLUR ULWXDOH DWWRUQR DOOD .Dµ ED FLUFXPDPEXOD]LRQH GHOOD .Dµ ED &RU ;;,, ZD¶O\DؾؾDZZD IŊ VHWWH YROWHLQVHQVRDQWLRUDULR DYHQGROD.DµEDVXOODVLQLVWUDIHU PDQGRVLDFLDVFXQJLURSHUEDFLDUH RWRFFDUHOD3LHWUD1HUDQHOؾDZƗI QRQ VL HQWUD QHO LdžU PD VL VWD LO SL SRVVLELOH YLFLQR DOOD SDUWH H VWHUQDGHODؾƯP 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD ؾDZƗIDOTXGŊP Ȅȇ˰̝̤ǪȀǪ̸̃ ؾDZƗI GL DUULYR FLUFXPDPEX OD]LRQHGHOOD.DµEDIDWWDDOO¶DUULYR GHOSHOOHJULQRD0HFFD ǽǪdz̸̤ǪȀǪ̸̃ ؾDZƗIDOZDGƗµ ؾDZƗIGLDGGLRFRPPLDWRVD OXWR GL FRQJHGR FLUFXPDPEXOD ]LRQHGHOOD.DµEDIDWWDDOODSDUWHQ ]DGHOSHOOHJULQRGD0HFFD ǭǵԹ˴̤ǪȀǪ̸̃ ؾDZƗIDO]L\ƗUD ؾDZƗI GL YLVLWD FLUFXPDPEX OD]LRQH GHOOD .DµED IDWWD QHO JLRU QRGHOVDFULILFLR\DZPDOQDULO GLסŊ¶OLdždžD ː̀˅̙ȔҟǪȀǪ̸̃ ؾDZƗIDOLIƗןD PDUFLD YHUVR OD .DµED LO GLסŊ¶OLdždžDLOJLRUQRGHOµƯGDO DןƗLSHOOHJULQLGRSRDYHUVDFUL ILFDWR JOL DQLPDOL ULWRUQDQR D 0HFFD H IDQQR OD FLUFXPDPEXOD ]LRQHGHOOD.DµEDFRPHULWRLQGL YLGXDOH GRSR TXHVWR ULWR FHVVDQR SHULOSHOOHJULQRWXWWHOHLQWHUGL]LR QLDOWDDOOXODODNEDU ̣̤̾dzǙ˫̾̑˺ǙȀ̸̪̄ PXؾDZZLIãD\GDOƯO JXLGD GL XQ JUXSSR GL SHOOH JULQL Ȁ˅̪̄ PDؾƗI VXROR VX FXL VL ID OD FLUFXP DPEXOD]LRQH GHOOD .DµED SLVWD FLUFRODUH DWWRUQR DOOD .DµED GRYH VLIDLOJLURULWXDOH Ǭ˅̃ ˇ̾̃ ؾD\\LE IHUWLOH SXUR VHFFR OHFLWR &RU ,9 9 VLQ GL ؾƗKLU VRQROHTXDOLWjFKHGHYHSRVVHGHUH OD SROYHUH صDµƯG SHU LO WD\DP PXP µLEƗGƗW SUDWLFKHGLFXOWR ˰ˋ̉ ǮǪdz˅ˋ̉ ȃ˰̊ ȃǪ˰˕̉ȔǪ LµWLGƗO QHOOD SUHJKLHUD GRSR LO UX NŊµ ULWRUQR DOOD SRVL]LRQH HUHWWD FRQOHPDQLHOHYDWHDOO¶DOWH]]DGHO FDSRFRQLOSDOPRLQDYDQWL DOLµWLGƗOIƯ¶OIDصO ̣˾̤̚Ǫ߆ȃǪ˰˕̉Գ SURSRU]LRQH ELODQFLDPHQWR VLPPHWULD WUD OH GLYHUVH VH]LRQL GHOODSUHJKLHUD LµWLGƗODOصXIŊI Ȁ̸̚˾̤ǪȃǪ˰˕̉ȔǪ SURSRU]LRQH VLPPHWULD GHOOH ILOHGHJOLRUDQWL ˅˾̉ PDµصL\D ː̾˾̪̋ YLROD]LRQH GHOOD OHJJH HWLFR UHOLJLRVD ˲̝̉ ˲̝̉ µDTU PRGR GL PDFHOOD]LRQH PRGR GL XFFLGHUH XQ DQLPDOH GHVWLQDWR DG HVVHU PDQJLDWR IHUHQGROR FRQ TXDOFKH DUPD DFXPLQDWD PXQLWD R PHQR GL IHUUR QHOOD SXQWD RYYHUR SHU PH]]R GL DQLPDOH DPPDHVWUD WRFRPHFDQLIDOFRQLHFFGXUDQ WH OD FDFFLD PRGR XVXDOH GL XFFL GHUHJOLDQLPDOLDFDFFLD ̢̘̉ Ȁߑ˕̉ȔǪ LµWLNƗI ULWLUR ³LO PXVXOPDQR >PXµWD NLI @ FKH KD O¶XVR GHOOD UDJLRQH H GHOGLVFHUQLPHQWRSURYDWRGDOIDW WRFKHLQWHQGHFLzFKHJOLVLGLFHH YLGjULVSRVWDFRUULVSRQGHQWHHUD $JRVWLQR&LODUGR JLRQHYROH QRQ TXLQGL XQ PDWWR R XQ EDPELQR VRWWR DL DQQL FKH XQWDOPXVXOPDQRGXQTXHVLULWLUL LQXQDPRVFKHDSXEEOLFDHQRQQH HVFDPDLVDOYRFKHSHUVRGGLVIDUH D QHFHVVLWj SHU IDUH OH DEOX]LRQL HFFGLJLXQDQGRHDVWHQHQGRVLGD UHOD]LRQL VHVVXDOL R GD FLz FKH OH SUHFHGHSHUXQWHPSRSLRPHQR OXQJRPDQRQPLQRUHGLXQJLRUQR HXQDQRWWHSHUORVFRSRGLIDUDWWR GL GHYR]LRQH FROOD UHODWLYD LQWHQ ]LRQH³ + S Q VSHFLDO PHQWH JOL XOWLPL GLHFL JLRUQL GL 5DPDןƗQSHUXQFHQQRDOO¶LµWLNƗI FIU&RU,,³«PDULWLUDWHYLLQ SUHJKLHUD QHL OXRJKL G¶RUD]LR QH«´˰ˤ˸Ǫ߆ȅ̸̟̚˅̭̊۫ǫȓ ȇ ˲ ǭ˲ µXPUD YLVLWD DOOD .DµED &RU ,, SHOOHJULQDJJLR PLQRUH FKH FRQVLVWH QHOO¶HQWUDUH QHOOR VWDWR GL LUƗP FRQ O¶LQWHQ]LRQH GL FRP SLHUODQHOIDUHXQؾDZƗIHLOWUDJLW WRVDµ\WUDDOشDIƗHDO0DUZDH LQILQH QHOO¶XVFLUH GDOO¶LUƗP SUHV VRDO0DUZDUDGHQGRVLODWHVWD ǵ̸̫̋Ǫˑ̿ˋ̤Ǫ DO%D\WDOPDµPŊU ³OD &DVD YLVLWDWD´ &RU /,, .DµED ǵ̸̉ ǭǵ̸̉ µDZUD SDUWL YHUJRJQRVH FKH QRQ VL SRVVRQR PRVWUDUH GDOO¶RPEHOLFR DLJLQRFFKLVFKLDYDWXWWHOHSDUWL WUDQQH YLVR H PDQL GRQQD OLEHUD QRQYHFFKLD ˰̾̉ DOµƯGƗQL ȅǪ˰̤̾̋Ǫ OHGXHIHVWHLVODPLFKHµƯGDO DןƗHµƯGDOILؾU ̹ޚҡȓ Ǫ˰̾̉ µƯGDODןƗRDOµƯGDONDEƯU OD IHVWD GHL VDFULILFL LO GL סŊ¶OLdždžD OD PDJJLRUH GHOOH GXH IHVWH DQQXDOL LQ FRQQHVVLRQH FRQ LO GRYHUH GHO VDFULILFLR OD IHVWD IRUQLVFH XQD RFFDVLRQH SHU O¶HVHU FL]LRGHOODFDULWjLOVDFULILFLRGLXQ DQLPDOHSHUPHWWHODSDUWHFLSD]LRQH DQFKH GHL SRYHUL DO SDVWR LQROWUH QHL SRVWL LQ FXL VL VDFULILFDQR DQL PDOL LQ HFFHVVR LO VRYUDSSL SXz HVVHUHFRQVHUYDWRHYHQGXWRHLOUL FDYDWRGDWRSHUVFRSLFDULWDWLYL µƯGDOILؾURDOµƯGDOصDĀƯU˲̤̄̚Ǫ˰̾̉ IHVWD GHOOD URWWXUD R FHVVD]LR QHGHOGLJLXQRGL5DPDןƗQRPL QRUH GHOOH GXH IHVWH DQQXDOL FHOH EUDWDLOâDZZƗOLPPHGLDWDPHQ WHGRSRLOPHVHGHOGLJLXQR ̣˸̍ ̣˸̍ ĀXVO ODYDQGDODYDQGDJHQHUDOHGHO FRUSRULFKLHVWDQHOFDVRGLLPSXUL WjPDJJLRUHODODYDQGDqREEOLJD WRULD SHU IDWWL VHVVXDOL HPLVVLRQH GL VSHUPD PHVWUXR H ORFKL PH VFRODWL FRQ VDQJXH &RU ,9 9 ˲̍̚ ǵ˅̏̚˕̑˷ǪȔ LVWLĀIƗU ULFKLHVWDGLSHUGRQRD'LR 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD ̣̍̚ ĀDIOD ߧ̍̚ LQDYYHUWHQ]D GXUDQWH OD SUH JKLHUDFIUȅ˅̾̑˸̮Ǚ̸̶˷ Ȉ˰̙ ː̻˰̙ ILG\D ULVFDWWRUHGHQ]LRQHHVSLD]LR QH DPPHQGD HVSLDWRULD SHU DYHU RPHVVR FHUWL GRYHUL UHOLJLRVL GR QDQGRGHLEHQLRFRPSLHQGRTXDO FKH SUDWLFD ULWXDOH DPPHQGD SHU XQDGHWHUPLQDWDPDQFDQ]DSUH]]R GHO ULVFDWWR HVSLD]LRQH PLQRUH SHUHVSHUFRPSHQVDUHLOGLJLXQR RPHVVR FIU L FDVL LQ &RU ,, ,99/9,,, dz˲̙ LIUƗG dzǪ˲̙ȔǪ O¶HQWUDUH LQ VWDWR GL SXULWj UL WXDOHLUƗPIRUPDQGRO¶LQWHQ]LR QHGLIDUHRVRORLODdždžRVROROD µXPUDRSSRVWRDTLUƗQ Ǻ˲̙ IDUןRIDUƯןD ː̻́˲̙ȇǫȓ Ǻ˲̙ SUDWLFD REEOLJDWRULD SUHFHWWR VWUHWWDPHQWHREEOLJDWRULRQHOODOHJ JHUHOLJLRVDLVODPLFDãDUƯµDLOFXL DGHPSLPHQWR'LRULFRPSHQVDHOD FXLLQRVVHUYDQ]D'LRSXQLVFHSUH FHWWRHVVHQ]LDOH ۸̤̋Ǫࠄ̊Ǻ˲̙ȇǫȓ ۸̊Ǻ˲̙ IDUןµD\QRIDUןµDOƗ¶OµD\Q GRYHUHRREEOLJRLQGLYLGXDOH ː̻˅̢̤̚Ǫࠄ̊Ǻ˲̙ȇǫȓ ː̻˅̟̚Ǻ˲̙ IDUןNLIƗ\DRIDUןµDOƗ¶ONLIƗ\D GRYHUHRREEOLJRFROOHWWLYR ː̾̀˲̙ IDUןL\\D OD TXDOLWj GL XQ¶D]LRQH GL HV VHUH SUHFHWWR REEOLJDWRULR q ː̧̾˽ǫȓ TXDQGR q REEOLJR ILVVR H IRQGD PHQWDOH SHU WXWWL HV GLJLXQR GL 5DPDןƗQLQFDVRFRQWUDULRVLGL FH ː̀ǵ˅̊ µƗULןD DFFHVVRULD QRQ HVVHQ]LDOH SHU HV GLJLXQR GL FXL VLqIDWWRYRWR Ǻȇ˲̪̚ PDIUŊן FLzFKHqREEOLJDWRULR ̩ؒ˕̤Ǫȇǫȓ ˟߬Ǫȇǫȓ ǭҠ˾̤Ǫ˿ʿǪ˲̙ IDUƗ¶LןDOصDOƗWRDODdždžRDO WD\DPPXP SUDWLFKH REEOLJDWRULH UHODWLYH DOODSUHJKLHUDRDOSHOOHJULQDJJLRR DOWD\DPPXP ̣̙́ ̣ʿ˅̙́ǰߧ̙̾́ IDןƯODSOIDןƗ¶LO YLUW PHULWR SUHJLR PHUL WRULRDWWRPHULWRULRVHFRPSLX WR VL DFTXLVWD TXDOFKH PHULWR LQ SL GL TXHOOR GRYXWR SHU O¶DWWR UH OLJLRVRFKHVLVWDFRPSLHQGRVLPL OHDOO¶DWWRPDQGŊE ː̧̙̾́Գ DODIןDOL\\D ODTXDOLWjGLHVVHUHSUHIHULELOH RPLJOLRUH ˲̙̄ ǵ˅̙̄ȔǪȇǫȓ ˲̙̄ ILؾURLIؾƗU URWWXUD GHO GLJLXQR FHVVD]LR QHGHOGLJLXQR IDؾŊUIXؾŊU ǵ̸̙̄ SDVWR FRQ FXL DOOD VHUD VL URPSH LO GLJLXQR QHO PHVH GL 5D PDןƗQ PXIؾLU SODOPXIؾLUƗWǮǪ˲̙̄ǭǰ˲̪̄̚ FRVH FKH FDXVDQR OD URWWXUD GHOGLJLXQRPDQJLDUHEHUHRDYH UHUDSSRUWLVHVVXDOLIDWWLSHUOLEHUD VFHOWD H LQWHQ]LRQDOPHQWH GDOO¶DO EDDOWUDPRQWR $JRVWLQR&LODUGR ˦̧̙ IDOƗ DZҠ̙ EHQHVVHUH VXFFHVVR IRUWXQD DXWRVYLOXSSR SLHQR DXWRVYLOXSSR GLXQDSHUVRQDFRPSOHWRVYLOXSSR GHOOHIDFROWjLQWHULRULRWWHQLPHQWR GHOOD JUDQGH]]D VLD PDWHULDOH FKH PRUDOHSURVSHULWjLQUHOD]LRQHVLD DOOD YLWD SUHVHQWH FKH D TXHOOD IX WXUDLQTXHVWDYLWDRWWHQHQGRWXWWR FLz FKH q EXRQR H UHQGH EXRQD OD YLWD LQ TXHVWR PRQGR FLRq EDTƗ¶ HVLVWHQ]DĀDQƗOLEHUWjGDOELVR JQR YDOH D GLUH ULFFKH]]D H µL]] RQRUH QHOOD YLWD IXWXUD LO IDOƗ LQFOXGH OD YLWD FKH QRQ VDUj SL VRJJHWWD DOOD PRUWH ULFFKH]]D FRQ OD TXDOH QRQ VL DYUDQQR SL ELVR JQLRQRUHFRQLOTXDOHQRQFLVDUj SL YHUJRJQD FRQRVFHQ]D FRQ OD TXDOHQRQFLVDUjSLLJQRUDQ]D ȅ̸˩̧̪̚ PXIOLŊQVLQJPXIOL FRORUR FKH SURVSHUDQR &RU ,,;;,,, Ǯ˅̙ ǮǪ̸̙ IDZƗW OHWWLOWUDVFRUUHUHVIXJJLUH HVVHUH LUUHWUDWWDELOH TXLQGL O¶HV VHUH JLj SUHJLXGLFDWR LO QRQ SRWHU SLHVVHUHVDQDWRGLXQDWWRRQH JR]LR JLXULGLFR LO GLYHQWDUH QRQ UHVWLWXLELOHHVVHODFRVDqSHULWD RqVWDWDWUDVIRUPDWDRVHLOYDORUH YHQDOH QH q PXWDWR LO QRQ HV VHU SL LQ WHPSR DG DGHPSLHUH TF SDUODQGRGLSUDWLFDUHOLJLRVD Ǻ˅̙ LIƗןD ː̀˅̙ȔǪ XQR GHL ULWL GHO SHOOHJULQDJ JLR FRQVLVWHQWH LQ XQD FRUVD GD µ$UDIƗW D 0X]GDOLID LO GL סŊ¶O LdždžD GRSR OD VRVWD ZXTŊI DG µ$UDIƗWD0X]GDOLIDVLIDXQEUHYH ZXTŊI VWD]LRQH SRL DL SULPL DO ERUL GHO JLRUQR H SULPD FKH VRUJD LO VROH VL ID XQ¶DOWUD LIƗןD FRUVD YHUWLJLQRVD GD 0X]GDOLID LQ GLUH ]LRQH GL 0LQƗ &RU ,, FIUFHQQRDOODLIƗןDGHJOLDQLPDOL LQ&RU& ˿ˍ̜ ː́ˍ̜ TDEןD SXJQRGLFLERQRQSLHQRPL QRUHGHOODDIQD ̣ˍ̜ ̣ˍ̜ TDEEDOD YROJHUH H RULHQWDUH TF YHUVR XQDGLUH]LRQH ߧˍ̜ TLEOD OHWW GLUH]LRQH GLUH]LRQH YHU VRFXLVLYROJHODIDFFLDQHOODSUH JKLHUD RULHQWDPHQWR GLUH]LRQH R SXQWR YHUVR FXL L PXVXOPDQL GH YRQR ULYROJHUVL TXDQGR SUHJDQR FLRq OD .DµED QHL SULPL PHVLGRSRO¶(JLUDODTLEODHUD*H UXVDOHPPH&RU,, ߧˍ̝̤Ǫ̵̣ǫȓ DKODO4LEOD FRORUR FKH VL RULHQWDQR YHUVR OD .DµED TXDQGR SUHJDQR L PX VXOPDQL WDZDdždžXKLOƗ¶OTLEOD ߧˍ̝̤ǪࠃȔǪ̴ˡ̸˒ RULHQWDPHQWRYHUVROD.DµED 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD ˅ˍ̜ TDEƗ¶ Ǥ˅ˍ̜ DELWRPDVFKLOHDSHUWRGDYDQWL FRQ PDQLFKH OXQJKH FRPH LOTXI WƗQ SURLELWR SRUWDUOR GXUDQWH LO SHOOHJULQDJJLR Ǫ˰̜ ȅȇ˰˗̝̪ PXTWDGŊQ FRORUR FKH VHJXRQR O¶LPƗP QHOODSUHJKLHUD ȓǫ˲̜ ǤǪ˲̜ǰǤǵ˅̜ TƗUL¶SOTXUUƗ¶ OHWWRUHGHO&RUDQR ǭǤǪ˲̜ TLUƗ¶D UHFLWD]LRQH GHO &RUDQR OD UH FLWD]LRQH GHOOD SULPD VŊUD )ƗWL DQHOODSUHJKLHUDqVHJXLWDGDOOD UHFLWD]LRQHGLDOWULYHUVHWWLFRUDQLFL ȅ˲̜ ȅǪ˲̜ TLUƗQ OHWWLOULXQLUHDVVLHPHLOULXQL UH LQVLHPH LO SHOOHJULQDJJLR PDJ JLRUHDdždžHTXHOORPLQRUHµXP UD YDOH D GLUH LO SHOOHJULQR QHL PHVL GHODdždž HQWUD QHOOR VWDWR GL SXULWjFRQO¶LQWHQ]LRQHGLIDUHVLDLO Ddždž VLD OD µXPUD VHQ]D XVFLUQH ILQFKp QRQ VLDQR VWDWL HQWUDPEL HI IHWWXDWLRSSXUHFRQO¶LQWHQ]LRQHGL HIIHWWXDUH OD µXPUD ULPDQHQGR SRL QHOORVWDWRGLSXULWjILQRDOFRPSOH WDPHQWRGHODdždžRSSRVWRDLIUƗG ̬̽˲̜ݎ DdždžTDUƯQ LO IDUH GL VHJXLWR LODdždž H OD µXPUD VHQ]D XVFLUH GDOOR VWDWR GL LUƗP ޭ̜ TDןƗ¶ Ǥ˅̀ DGHPSLPHQWR DVVROYLPHQWR FRPSOHWDPHQWRO¶DVVROYHUHRFRP SLHUHLQULWDUGRXQDSUDWLFDUHOLJLRVD REEOLJDWRULD FKH VLD VWDWD RPHVVD QHOWHPSRSHUHVVDGHWHUPLQDWRGDO OD OHJJH SHU HV IDUH OD SUHJKLHUD LQ ULWDUGR GRSR SDVVDWR LO WHPSR SURSULRRSSXUHULPHWWHUHXQGLJLX QRRPHVVR ˰̜̋ TXµŊG dz̸̉ SRVL]LRQH DFFRVFLDWD GHOO¶R UDQWH FKH VL SUHQGH RJQL GXH UD NµD L SLHGL VWDQQR LQ SRVL]LRQH RUL]]RQWDOHFRQOHSXQWHGHOOHGLWD GHL SLHGL FKH WRFFDQR LO VXROR H FRQ OH PDQL DSHUWH SRVWH XQ SR¶ VRSUDDLJLQRFFKLVXOOHFRVFH ̺̜̋ Ǥ˅̜̋ȔǪ LTµƗ¶ QHOODSUHJKLHUD³VHGHUVLGR SR OD SURVWUD]LRQH VXOOD SDUWH DQ WHULRUHGHLSLHGL´>qULSURYDWR@ + ,S ˇ̧̜ ːˈ̸̧̝Ǫ DOPDTOŊED QRPHGLXQWLSRGLUDNµDQHOOD SUHJKLHUDFRPSRVWDGDTXDWWURUD NµDFIUXPPDOdžDQƗƯQ ߲̜ ˰ʿҠ̜ǰǭdzҠ̜ TLOƗGDSOTDOƗ¶LG FROODQD DWWRUQR DO FROOR GHOOD EHVWLD&RU9FKHVLSRUWDFRPH YLWWLPDSHULOVDFULILFLRKDG\ $JRVWLQR&LODUGR ̣̜ LVWLTOƗO ȃҠ̝˕̑˷Ǫ OR VWDUH LQ SRVL]LRQH HUHWWD VHQ]D DSSRJJLDUVL DG DOFXQR R DG DOFXQDFRVDQHOODSUHJKLHUD ˇ̧̜ DOPDTOnjED ːˈ̸̧̝Ǫ QRPH GL XQ WLSR GL SUHJKLHUD FRPSRVWD GD TXDWWUR UDNµD FIU XPPDOdžDQƗƯQ ˑ̲̜ TDQDWD ˑ̲̜ HVVHUH XPLOH LQ REEHGLHQ]D D 'LR Ǯ̸̲̜ TXQŊW REEHGLHQ]D D 'LR XPLOWj GDYDQWL D 'LR SLHWj SUHJKLHUD GLXPLOWjLPSUHFD]LRQHFRQWURL QHPLFLSROLWLFLGXUDQWHODSUHJKLH UD ULWXDOH SUHJKLHUD ULYROWD D 'LR LQRFFDVLRQHGLTXDOFKHJUDQGHWUL EROD]LRQHFRQODTXDOHVLFKLHGHD 'LR OD SXQL]LRQH GHL WLUDQQL FKH RSSULPRQRSHUVRQHLQQRFHQWL&RU ,,, LO TXQŊW SL QRWR q TXHOORIDWWRQHOODWHU]DUDNµDGHOOD صDOƗW DOZLWU XOWLPD UDNµD GHOOD QRWWHTXQŊWDOZLWU ̲̜̈ TLQƗµ ǽ˅̲̜ YHOR FKH FRSUH OD GRQQD GX UDQWHODSUHJKLHUD Ȅ˅̜ Ȅ˅̜̀ TL\ƗP ORVWDUHULWWRLQSLHGLSRVL]LR QH HUHWWD FRQ OD TXDOH VL LQL]LD OD SUHJKLHUD H FKH VL ULSUHQGH GRSR RJQL UDNµD VH TXHVWD SRVL]LRQH q RPHVVDGLSURSRVLWRODSUHJKLHUDq QXOOD ǭҠ˾̤Ǫː̪˅̜ȔǪ LTƗPDWDOصDOƗW VHFRQGR LQYLWR DOOD SUHJKLHUD FKH OD SUHFHGH LPPHGLDWDPHQWH IDWWR QHOOD PRVFKHD SURQXQFLDWR D YRFHDOWDLQGLFDQWHFKHO¶LQL]LRGHO ODSUHJKLHUDqLPPLQHQWHOHIRUPX OHGHOO¶DסƗQVRQROHVWHVVHGHOO¶LTƗ PDFRQODGLIIHUHQ]DFKHVLGLFRQR XQDVRODYROWDWUDQQHLOWDNEƯUULSH WXWRGXHYROWHDOO¶LQL]LRHDOWHUPLQH GHOODLTƗPDLQROWUHGRSRDYHUGHW WR D\\D µDOƗ¶OIDOƗ VL DJJLXQJH GXHYROWHTDGTƗPDWDOصDOƗWqO¶R UDGHOODSUHJKLHUD ̝ۮǪ DOPXTƯP FKL ID LO VHFRQGR LQYLWR DOOD SUHJKLHUD ̵ۮǪ˲ˊȔǪȄ˅̝̪ 0DTƗP,EUƗKƯP OXRJR VDFUR GL $EUDPR VWD ]LRQHGL$EUDPR&RU,,,SLF FROR HGLILFLR DOO¶LQWHUQR GHOOD 6D FUD 0RVFKHD GL 0HFFD TXDGUDWR GLPVRUUHWWRGDVHLFRORQQHDO WH FLUFD P LQ &RU ,, O¶H VSUHVVLRQH0DTƗP,EUƗKƯPVLULIH ULVFHDOOD.DµED ̟ٴ ˔̢ˍٸ WDNEƯU HVFODPD]LRQH $OOƗK DNEDU ³,GGLR q LO SL JUDQGH´ LO SUR QXQFLDUHOHSDUROH$OOƗK$NEDU ȄǪ˲˧Գǭ˔̢ˍٸ WDNEƯUDWDOLUƗP HVFODPD]LRQH$OOƗKDNEDUSUR FODPDWDTXDQGRVLHQWUDQHOORVWDWR GL SXULWj ULWXDOH SHU LO SHOOHJULQDJ JLRRSHUODSUHJKLHUD 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD ˅˸̠ NLVZD ǭ̸˸̠ WHQGDJJLRQHURGLVHWDFKHUL FRSUHOHTXDWWURSDUHWLHVWHUQHGHO OD .DµED WUDQQH OD SRUWD FKH VL WURYDQHOODSDUHWHGLQRUGHVWQRQ DO FHQWUR PD SL SURVVLPD DOOD 3LHWUD 1HUD ULYHVWLPHQWR GHOOD .DµED D IRUPD GL IRGHUD IDWWD GL ULFFKH VWRIIH QHUH ULFDPDWH FRQ YHUVHWWLGHO&RUDQR ̘ߚ PXNDOOLI ̘ߛ̪ PXVXOPDQR SXEHUH H VDQR GL PHQWH WHQXWR DOO¶RVVHUYDQ]D GHL SUHFHWWLUHOLJLRVLREEOLJDWRUL ̘̾ߛ˔ WDNOƯI O¶HVVHUH SXEHUH H VDQR GL PHQWHFRQSLHQDFDSDFLWjG¶DJLUH ̤ܰ ː̾ˋ̧˒ WDOEL\D IRUPXOD FRQ OD TXDOH LO SHOOH JULQR VL ULYROJH D 'LR /DEED\ND $OOƗKXPPD /DEED\ND /Ɨ ãDUƯND ODND/DEED\ND,QQD¶ODPGDZD ¶OQLµPDWD ODND ZD¶OPXOND /DE ED\ND´ ³(FFRPL D 7H HFFRPL D 7HR$OOƗK7XQRQKDLVRFLR(F FRPL D 7H 7XD q OD ORGH H OD JUD ]LD 7XR LO UHJQR (FFRPL D 7H´ FKHLOSHOOHJULQRSURQXQFLDTXDQGR HQWUD QHOOR VWDWR GL LUƗP H ULSHWH FRVWDQWHPHQWH GXUDQWH LO SHOOHJUL QDJJLR SULPD GL LQGRVVDUH OH GXH OHQ]XRODVHQ]DFXFLWXUHLOSHOOHJUL QRIDXQEDJQRHSURQXQFLDDGDOWD YRFHODWDOEL\DULYROWRDOOD.DµED ˰߬ ODG ˰߬ OR³VFDYDUHODIRVVDQHOEDVVR GHO VHSROFUR GDO ODWR GHOOD TLEOD GD RFFLGHQWH DG RULHQWH QHOOD PL VXUD GD SRWHU GHSRUYL LO FDGDYHUH &RVuVLIDVHLOWHUUHQRqGXURHQRQ VL VJUHWROD DOWULPHQWL VL ID OR Ȑ̛˺ VFDYDQGRODWHUUDSHUTXDQWRSRVVD FRQWHQHUH LO FDGDYHUH FROOD SDUWH LQIHULRUHSLVWUHWWDGHOODVXSHULRUH HTXLQGLVLFRSUHO¶DSHUWXUDHYLVL JLWWD OD WHUUD 6L ULFRUGD XQD WUDGL ]LRQH FKH GLFH Է̤˻̛ ̤̏ٸǪ Ȑ ȇ ˅̰̤ ˰˪̧̥Ǫ FLRqLOODGqSHUQRLORãDTTSHU FKL QRQ q FRPH QRL FLRq (EUHL H &ULVWLDQL´+,SQ Ȅ˴̤ PXOWD]DP Ȩ̪̏ٿ SDUWHGHOPXURGHOOD.DµEDWUD OD3LHWUD1HUDHODSRUWDVLFKLDPD FRVu SHUFKp L SHOOHJULQL PHQWUH SUHJDQR IHUYHQWHPHQWH YL SUHVVD QRVRSUD\DOWD]LPXKXLOSHWWROD IDFFLD H OH EUDFFLD VWHQGHQGR OH PDQL ³GRSR LO ؾDZƗI L SHOOHJULQL VRJOLRQRDQGDUHDGDJJUDSSDUVLDG HVVD >NLVZD@ SUHPHQGRVL FRQWUR LO PXUR GHOO¶HGLILFLR FRPH XQ VHUYR VXSSOLFDQWH VL DJJUDSSHUHEEH DOOH YHVWLGHOSDGURQH´,S ̸̤̚ Ȍ ȀҠ˒ WDOƗI LQ LO ULPHGLDUH D GLIHWWL GHOOD SUHJKLHUD ̣̤̾ ǰǪ˲̋Ǫߧ̤̾ OD\ODWDOPLµUƗdž OD QRWWH GHOO¶DVFHQVLRQH GL 0XDPPDG DO FLHOR &RU ;9,, $JRVWLQR&LODUGR LGHQWLILFDWD FRQ TXHOOD GHO 5DdžDE Ǥ˅̝̤́Ǫߧ̤̾ȇǫȓ ǵ˰̝̤Ǫߧ̤̾ OD\ODWDOTDGUROD\ODWDOTDןƗ¶ ³OD 1RWWH GHO 'HVWLQR´ &RU ;&9,,³QRWWHEHQHGHWWD´OD \ODPXEƗUDND&RU;/,9XQD GHOOH XOWLPH GLHFL QRWWL GL 5DPD ןƗQ LQ FXL HEEH LQL]LR OD ULYHOD ]LRQH GHO &RUDQR ,, DQQL YHUVDULR GHOOD ULYHOD]LRQH GHO &R UDQR OD WUDGL]LRQH LQGLYLGXD OD OD\ODWDOTDGULQXQDGHOOHQRWWLGL VSDUL GHJOL XOWLPL JLRUQL GL 5DPD ןƗQLOLORLO ̈˗̪ ̈˕ WDPDWWXµ LOFRPELQDUHDVVLHPHLODdždžH OD µXPUD LO SHOOHJULQR HQWUD QHOOR VWDWR GL SXULWj QHL PHVL GHO Ddždž FRQ O¶LQWHQ]LRQH GL HIIHWWXDUH XQD µXPUDIDWWDODTXDOHHVFHGDOORVWD WR GL LUƗP H YL ULHQWUD QHL JLRUQL GHO SHOOHJULQDJJLR QHOO¶LQWHUYDOOR WUDODµXPUDHLODdždžLOSHOOHJULQR XVXIUXLVFH WDPDWWDµD OHWW DSSUR ILWWDUH JRGHUH XVXIUXLUH GHOOH RS SRUWXQLWj FKH RIIUH XQD FRQGL]LRQH GL YLWD RUGLQDULD SHU TXHVWR GHYH IDUHXQVDFULILFLRKDG\RLQDOWHU QDWLYDGLJLXQDUHWUHJLRUQLGXUDQWH LODdždžHVHWWHJLRUQLDOVXRULWRUQR &RU,, ˦˸̪ PDV ˦˸̪ OR VWURSLFFLDUH VWURILQDUH VIUHJDUH FRQ OD PDQR EDJQDWD OH VFDUSHODWHVWDHFFLQVRVWLWX]LR QH GHOOD ODYDQGD R GHOO¶DEOX]LRQH TXDQGRQRQVLSRVVRQRIDUH PDVµDOƗ¶OXIID\Q ۸߭̚Ǫࠄ̊˦˸̪ OR VWURSLFFLDUH FRQ OD PDQR EDJQDWDOHFDO]DWXUHLQOXRJRGHOOD ODYDQGDGHLSLHGL ˿̫̪́ ː̫̪́́ PDןPDןD ULVFLDFTXDWXUD GHOOD ERFFD SXOL]LDGHOODERFFDXQDGHOOHD]LR QLGHOO¶DEOX]LRQH ̭ٴ PLQEDU ̪̲ٴ SXOSLWR GD FXL O¶LPƗP ID OD SUHGLFD ̭ٶ LVWLQـƗU ǵ˅˞̱˕̑˷ǪȔ LO FDFFLDU IXRUL LO VRIILDUH IXRUL GDO QDVR O¶DFTXD FKH SULPD HUD VWDWD DVSLUDWD SHU ODYDUOR XQD GHOOHD]LRQLGHOO¶DEOX]LRQH ˶֙ QDdžLVSODQdžƗV Ƿ˅֙ǫȓ ǰ˶֙ LPSXURFRQWDPLQDWR ː˷˅֙ȇǫȓ ˶֙ QDdžDVRQDdžƗVD VRVWDQ]D LPSXUD LPPRQGD LPSXULWjVR]]XUD&RU,;VLQ GL ˶ˠǵULdžVVR]]XUD&RU,; FRQWDPLQD]LRQH&RU;;,, ˲֣ ˲֣ QDU PRGR GL PDFHOOD]LRQH VJR] ]DPHQWR VJR]]DWXUD VFDQQDPHQ WRPDFHOOD]LRQHLPPROD]LRQH ˲˩̰̤ǪȄ̸̻ \DZPDOQDU JLRUQR GHOO¶LPPROD]LRQH R GHL VDFULILFL µƯG DOLןƗ LO GL סŊ¶OLdždžD TXDQGR L SHOOHJULQL 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD UDJJLXQJRQR 0LQƗ GL PDWWLQD GR SRDYHUGHWWROHSUHJKLHUHGHOµƯGD 0LQƗ YHQJRQR VDFULILFDWL JOL DQL PDOL SRL D 0LQƗ L SHOOHJULQL UL WRUQDQR DOOR VWDWR SURIDQR DOWD DOOXODODصĀDUUDGHQGRVLLFDSHO OL GHSRQHQGR OH YHVWL GL LUƗP H ULDVVXPHQGRJOLDELWLRUGLQDULSRL IDQQR LO ؾDZƗI GHOOD .DµED ؾDZƗI DOLIƗןD Ǭ˰̭ FIUǬȇ˰̲̪ˇ˩˕̑˸̪ Ǫ˰̭ ǭȇ˰̰̤ǪǵǪdz 'ƗUDO1DGZD FDVDGHOFRQVLJOLRDVVHPEOHD SULPDGHOO¶LVODPOD'ƗUDO1DGZD HUD DOO¶LQWHUQR GHOOD 6DFUD 0R VFKHDOuYHQLYDQRGLEDWWXWHWXWWHOH TXHVWLRQL FRQFHUQHQWL OD YLWD SROL WLFDHVRFLDOHDQFKHFRQO¶DYYHQWR GHOO¶LVODP OD 6DFUD 0RVFKHD q UL PDVWD LO SHUQR GHOOH DWWLYLWj FXOWX UDOL ȓˆ˸̮ Ǥ̤̱ގǪ DOQDVƯ¶ ³PHVH LQWHUFDODUH´ &RU ,; LQ HSRFD SDJDQD ³JOL DUDEL DYHYDQR XQ FDOHQGDULR OXQDUH H D YHYDQR DSSUHVR GDJOL HEUHL O¶XVR GL LQWHUFDODUH XQ PHVH TXDQGR OD GLIIHUHQ]D IUD LO SULQFLSLR GHOO¶DQ QR VRODUH H OXQDUH HUD WURSSR SHU FHSLELOH LO FKH VL IDFHYD SXEEOL FDPHQWHRJQLGXHRWUHDQQLDSSUR ILWWDQGR GHOO¶HSRFD GHO SHOOHJUL QDJJLR DO 3DOODGLR 1D]LRQDOH DUD ER OD .DµED LQVHUHQGROR GRSR LO PHVHGHOSHOOHJULQDJJLRסŊ¶OLdždžD &RQ TXHVWD ULYHOD]LRQH 0X DPPDGDEROLVFHLPHVLLQWHUFDODUL QDVƯ ULWRUQDQGRDOFDOHQGDULROX QDUHSXUR´%S ̞˸̮ PDQVDNSOPDQƗVLN ̞˷˅̲̪ǰ̬˸̱̪ L ³VDQWL ULWL´ DWWL GHODdždž &RU ,, DWWL ULWXDOL SUH VFULWWL QHODdždž LQ JHQHUH VRWWR LO WLWRORPDQƗVLNVRQRULSRUWDWHQHOOH UDFFROWHGLWUDGL]LRQLOHSUHVFUL]LR QLUHODWLYHDOSHOOHJULQDJJLR ̞˸̮ QXVXN DWWRSLRDWWRGLFXOWRRGHYR ]LRQH &RU ,, µLEƗGD R ؾƗ µD ̮ގ ȅ˅̾̑˸̮ QLV\ƗQ GLPHQWLFDQ]D GL XQ DWWR SUH VFULWWRLQXQDSUDWLFDGLFXOWRFIU ߧ̍̚Ǚ̸̶˷ ̛˻̮ ȁ˅˻̱˕̑˷ǪȔ LVWLQãƗT LQDOD]LRQHDVSLUD]LRQHGLDF TXD QHO QDVR TXDQGR VL ID O¶DEOX ]LRQHSHUODYDUOR ˇ˾̭ ȓ ȓ ːˋ˾̭ǫȇǫˇ˾̭ǰǬ˅˾̭ QLصƗESOQXصXERDQصLED PLQLPRLPSRQLELOHGLEHVWLD PH FDPPHOOL ERYLQL H RYLQL SHU LO SDJDPHQWR GHOOD]DNƗW RJQL XO WHULRUHGHWHUPLQDWRLQFUHPHQWRFR VWLWXLVFHXQVXFFHVVLYRQLصƗE ˑ˾̭ Ȅ˅̪ҠȔ ̤Ǯ˅˾̭ȔҟǪ DOLQصƗWOL¶OLPƗP LO SUHVWDUH LQ VLOHQ]LR DWWHQ WDPHQWH DVFROWR DOO¶LPƗP TXDQGR $JRVWLQR&LODUGR O¶RUDQWH OR VHJXH QHOOD SUHJKLHUD DQFKHTXDQGRO¶LPƗPQRQOHJJHR O¶RUDQWHQRQORVHQWHqULSURYHYR OHFKHO¶RUDQWHOHJJDGDVp ̣̭̚ Ụ̭̣̙̈̌̚Ǫ̸̭ǰߧ̙Է QDIOQƗILODSOQDZƗILO SUDWLFDRDWWRUHOLJLRVRQRQRE EOLJDWRULR SDUWH YRORQWDULD GHOOH SUDWLFKH GL FXOWR SUHJKLHUD ]DNƗW GLJLXQR H SHOOHJULQDJJLR SUHJKLH UD VXSHUHURJDWRULD FKLDPDWD FRVu SHUFKp q XQ ³VRYUDSSL´ ]L\ƗGD DWWRUHOLJLRVRFKHLO3URIHWDQRQID FHYD FRVWDQWHPHQWH DO FRQWUDULR JOL DWWL FKH IDFHYD FRVWDQWHPHQWH FRVWLWXLVFRQRVXQQDFKHSHULOPX VXOPDQR VRQR XQ SUHFHWWR GL WUDGL ]LRQHÊELDVLPHYROHQRQRVVHUYDUH XQD SUDWLFD TXDOLILFDWD QƗILOD VSH FLDOPHQWH VH LQFXOFDWD P¶DNNDGD WXWWDYLD O¶DWWR VXSHUHURJDWRULR DQ FKH VH PX¶DNNDG UHVWD VHPSUH GL GLJQLWjLQIHULRUHDOODVXQQD ˿̝̭ ˿̝̭ QDTDןD DQQXOODUHO¶DEOX]LRQHHODOX VWUD]LRQHSXOYHUDOH ˰ˤ̵ KDdžDGD ˰ˤ̵ YHJOLDUH SDVVDUH OD QRWWH LQ YHJOLD ˰ˤ؛ WDKDdždžXG YHJOLD LO YHJOLDU OD QRWWH LQ SUHJKLHUD SUHJKLHUD GL QRWWH YH JOLD QRWWXUQD YHJOLD RUDQWH O¶XQL FD SUHJKLHUD YRORQWDULD QƗILOD GL FXL SDUOD LO &RUDQR ;9,, VL GLFH GRSR PH]]DQRWWH TXDQGR O¶R UDQWHKDSRWXWRJLjEUHYHPHQWHGRU PLUH &RU ;, ;; ;;9 / /, /,, /;;,,, /;;9, ȉ˰̵ KDG\ ȉ˰̵ EHVWLDPH GD VDFULILFDUH YLWWL PDGDLPPRODUHFDPPHOORERYL QR R HYHQWXDOPHQWH EHVWLDPH PL QXWRRIIHUWDLQHVSLD]LRQHSHUHV SHU TXDOFKH PDQFDQ]D FRPPHVVD GXUDQWHLOSHOOHJULQDJJLRFIU&RU 9 ˇˠȇ ˇˠǪȇ ZƗdžLE SUHFHWWR REEOLJDWRULR SHU L PƗOLNLWLqXQDREEOLJDWRULHWjLQIH ULRUH D TXHOOD GHOO¶DWWR TXDOLILFDWR FRPHIDUן ̴ˡȇ ̴ˡȇ ZDdžK YLVR RVVLD OR VSD]LR WUD OH SURPLQHQ]HGHOOHRUHFFKLHHGDOOL PLWHGHLFDSHOOLVXOODIURQWHVLQRDO PHQWR XQD GHOOH SDUWL GHO FRUSR RJJHWWRGHOO¶DEOX]LRQH dzǵȇ ZLUGSODZUƗG dzǪǵȇǫȓ ǰdzǵȇ SRU]LRQH GHO &RUDQR SDUWH GHOJLRUQRRGHOODQRWWHGHGLFDWDD SUHJKLHUH VXSHUHURJDWRULH SDUWH GHO&RUDQRUHFLWDWDLQWDOHSHULRGR GLWHPSR ̣˽ȇ ȃ˅˽ȇ ZLصƗO OHWW LO FRQJLXQJHUH ULXQLUH PHWWHUH LQ UHOD]LRQH OD FRQWLQXD 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD ]LRQHGHOGLJLXQRDQFKHGXUDQWHOD QRWWHHLOJLRUQRVHJXHQWHLQPRGR GDQRQDYHUVLLQWHUUX]LRQHSUDWLFD SURLELWD ʼ̀ȇ Ǥ̸̀ȇ ZXןŊ¶ DEOX]LRQHULWXDOHLOODYDUHDO FXQH SDUWL GHO FRUSR SULPD GHOOD SUHJKLHUDDEOX]LRQHSDU]LDOH&RU 9VLODYDQROHPDQLILQRDLSRO VL OD ERFFD q ODYDWD FRQ DFTXD R XVDQGR XQR VSD]]ROLQR GD GHQWL H IDFHQGRJDUJDULVPLVHQHFHVVDULR VRQR SRL ODYDWH OH QDULFL DVSLUDQ GRYL XQ SR¶ G¶DFTXD H VRIILDQGR FRQ LO QDVR VH QHFHVVDULR VL ODYD SRLODIDFFLDGDOODIURQWHDOPHQWR H GD XQ RUHFFKLR DOO¶DOWUR SRL OD PDQRGHVWUDHTXLQGLODVLQLVWUDGDO SROVR ILQR DO JRPLWR OD WHVWD q VWURILQDWDFRQOHPDQLEDJQDWHXWL OL]]DQGR WUH GLWD GL HQWUDPEH OH PDQL WUD LO PLJQROR H LO SROOLFH XQLWHLQVLHPHODSDUWHLQWHUQDGHO OHRUHFFKLHqVWURILQDWDFRQO¶LQGL FHHODSDUWHHVWHUQDFRQLOSROOLFH L SLHGL VRQR ODYDWL ILQR DOOH FDYL JOLHFRPLQFLDQGRGDOGHVWUR ˑ̜ȇ PƯTƗWSOPDZƗTƯW ˑ̜̀Ǫ̸̪ǰǮ˅̝̪̀ WHPSLGHOODSUHJKLHUDHOXRJKL GHWHUPLQDWL R VWDELOLWL LQ FXL ELVR JQD HQWUDUH QHOOR VWDWR GL LUƗP WHPSR H OXRJKL QHOOH GLYHUVH GLUH ]LRQL YHUVR 0HFFD D VHFRQGD GHO SDHVHGLSURYHQLHQ]DGRYHLSHOOH JULQL HQWUDQR QHOOR VWDWR GLLUƗP נŊ¶OXOD\IDː̧̾߬̚Ǫ ȇǴSHULSHOOH JULQLFKHSURYHQJRQRGDOODGLUH]LR QHGL0HGLQDDODžXID ː̚˩߫Ǫ SHU TXHOOLFKHDUULYDQRGD6LULD(JLWWR 0DĀULE 6SDJQD 4DUQ ȅ˲̜ SHU TXHOOL GHO 1DdžG <DODPODP ̧̫̻ SHU TXHOOL SURYHQLHQWL GD <HPHQ ,QGLD 3DNLVWDQ ,QGRQHVLD H DOWUL SDHVLGDFXLVLDUULYDSHUQDYHYLD $GHQנƗWµ,UTȁ˲̉ǮǪǴSHUTXHOOL SURYHQLHQWLGD,UDT)ƗULVXUƗVƗQ HROWUH3HULPHFFDQLLOPƯTƗWqOD VWHVVDFLWWjGL0HFFD ̘̜ȇ ZXTŊI Ȁ̸̜ȇ DWWRGLVWDUHLQSLHGLVWD]LRQH VRVWD LQ SLHGL GHL SHOOHJULQL DG µ$UDIƗWGDOSRPHULJJLRDOWUDPRQ WR GHO JLRUQR GLסŊ¶OLdždžD TXL JLXQJRQR L SHOOHJULQL SURYHQLHQWL GD0LQƗLQWHPSRSHUIDUHODSUH JKLHUDGL٤XKUHµDصU³,SHOOHJULQL RFFXSDQR OD SLDQXUD YLFLQR DO PRQWH >³0RQWH GHOOD 0LVHULFRU GLD´@ H GRSR XQD DOORFX]LRQH GHO O¶LPƗPGRYUHEEHURUHVWDUHLQSLH GLULSHWHQGRODWDOEL\DSUHJDQGRH UHFLWDQGRLO&RUDQRILQRDOWUDPRQ WR GHO VROH TXDQGR D XQ VHJQDOH GDWRVLLQL]LDODLIƗןDFRUVDYHUWL JLQRVD YHUVR 0X]GDOLID GRYH VL SHUQRWWD´ , SS LO SHOOH JULQDJJLR VL FRQVLGHUD IDWWR VH LO SHOOHJULQRUDJJLXQJHLQWHPSRµ$ UDIƗWLOGLסŊ¶OLdždžDO¶XQLFDFR VD FKH UHQGH LQYDOLGR LO SHOOHJUL QDJJLR q O¶DVVHQ]D WRWDOH GHO ZX TŊIDGµ$UDIƗW ࠃȇ ȃȌȐ ̸˗̪ PXWDZDOO LQ JXDUGLDQR GHOOD PRVFKHD FKH YLHQHLQFDULFDWRGHOODVXDJHVWLRQH $JRVWLQR&LODUGR GDFRORURFKHO¶KDQQRFRVWUXLWDKD LO GLULWWR GL QRPLQDUH O¶LPƗP PD QRQSXzLPSHGLUHDLPXVXOPDQLD PRWLYR GHOOH ORUR GLYHUJHQ]H GRW WULQDOLGLHQWUDUHQHOODPRVFKHD WD\DPPXP ̩ؒ˔ OXVWUD]LRQH SXOYHUDOH FRQVL VWHQHOORVWURILQDUVLLOYLVRHOHPD QL FRQ VDEELD VRWWLOLVVLPD TXDQGR PDQFDO¶DFTXDLQTXDQWLWjVXIILFLH QWHRVLWHPHXVDQGRODGLFDGHUH LQ XQD PDODWWLD R GL DJJUDYDUOD R FKHYHQJDDPDQFDUHSHUOHSHUVR QH H JOL DQLPDOL OHFLWL R TXDQGR PDQFDFKLGLDO¶DFTXD&RU,9 9 %,%/,2*5$),$ $LVKD$EGXUUDKPDQ%HZOH\DO0XZDWWDRI,PDP0DOLNLEQ$QDV7KHILUVW)RUPXODWLRQ RI,VODPLF/DZ/RQGRQ±1HZ<RUN.HJDQ3DXO,QWHUQDWLRQDO % %DXVDQL %DXVDQL$WUDG,O&RUDQR,QWURGX]LRQHWUDGX]LRQHHFRPPHQWR)LUHQ]H6DQVRQL %RVZRUWK&(HWDOHGV7KH(QF\FORSDHGLDRI,VODP/HLGHQ%ULOODHGL]LRQH &LODUGR$³5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFDWHUPLQLUHODWLYLDOGLULWWR VXFFHVVRULRLQ(JLWWR´LQ$QQDOLGHOO¶,VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOHGL1DSROLSS ²³3UHOLPLQDU\QRWHVRQWKH4XU¶ƗQLFWHUPNDOƗOD´LQ89HUPHXOHQ-0)YDQ5HHWK HGV/DZ&KULVWLDQLW\DQG0RGHUQLVPLQ,VODPLF6RFLHW\3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH(LJKWHHQWK &RQJUHVVRI WKH 8QLRQ (XURSpHQQH GHV $UDELVDQWV HW,VODPLVDQWVKHOG DWWKH .DWKROLHNH 8QLYHUVLWHLW/HXYHQ6HSWHPEHU/HXYHQ3HHWHUV3XEOLVKHUV2ULHQWDOLD/RYD QLHQVLD$QDOHFWDSS ²7KH4XU¶DQLFWHUPNDOƗOD6WXGLHVLQWKH$UDELFODQJXDJHDQGSRHWU\DGƯWKWDIVƯUDQG ILTK1RWHVRQWKHRULJLQRIWKH,VODPLFODZ(GLQEXUJK(GLQEXUJK8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV ²³'LULWWRLVODPLFRGLULWWRRFFLGHQWDOHDPELJXLWjVHPDQWLFD´LQ97R]]L*0DFUuD F(XURSDH,VODP5LGLVFXWHUHLIRQGDPHQWLSHUODGLVFLSOLQDGHOOHOLEHUWjUHOLJLRVH$WWL GHO 6HPLQDULR GL 6WXGL RUJDQL]]DWR GDOOD )DFROWj GL 6FLHQ]H 3ROLWLFKH 8QLYHUVLWj GHJOL 6WXGLGL6DOHUQR)LVFLDQRGLFHPEUH6RYHULD0DQQHOOL5XEHWWLQR&ROODQD6FLHQ WLILFD$WWLGL&RQYHJQRH0LVFHOODQHH ² ³7UDGXUUH LO GLULWWR LVODPLFR´ LQ & 0RQWHOOD D F 7DYROD 5RWRQGD VX ³7UDGXUUH VDJJLVWLFD7UDGXWWRULWUDGXWWRORJLHGHVSHUWLDFRQIURQWR´8QLYHUVLWjGHJOL6WXGLGL1D SROL³/¶2ULHQWDOH´1DSROLGLFHPEUH0LODQR)UDQFR$QJHOLVUO/LQJXDWUD GX]LRQHGLGDWWLFD (, %RVZRUWKHWDO DODžD]ƯUƯ.LWƗEDOILTKµDOƗ¶OPDסƗKLEDODUEDµDYROO%HLUXW *XLGL , 6DQWLOODQD ',O³0XېWD܈DU´R 6RPPDULRGHOGLULWWR PDOHFKLWD , *LXULVSUX GHQ]DUHOLJLRVDµLEƗGƗW0LODQR8+RHSOL + *XLGL6DQWLOODQD , 3DUHMD%DXVDQL+HUWOLQJ 3DUHMD)0%DXVDQL$+HUWOLQJ/,VODPRORJLD5RPD2UELV&DWKROLFXV 5XELQDFFL5³/DSXULWjULWXDOHVHFRQGRJOL,EƗןLWL´LQ$QQDOLGHOO¶,VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWDULR 2ULHQWDOHGL1DSROLSS 5LFHUFKHVXOOHVVLFRDUDER7HUPLQRORJLDJLXULGLFD ²³/¶DڴƗQSUHVVRJOL,EƗןLWL´LQ)ROLD2ULHQWDOLDSS )217, µ$EGDO5D]]ƗTDOشDQµƗQƯP$O0XصDQQDILQDEƯEDO5DPƗQDO$µ٤DPƯHG YROO.DUDFKL $EŊ'ƗZŊGDO6LdžLVWƗQƯP.LWƗEDO6XQDQLQ0X\ƯDO'ƯQµ$EGDODPƯGHG YROO&DLURHGDVDQĉUƗQƯYROO%HLUXW $EŊ'ƗZŊGDOؽD\ƗOLVƯP.LWƗEDO0XVQDGD\GDUƗEƗGULVW%HL UXW DO%D\KDTƯ P $O6XQDQDONXEUƗ YROOD\GDUƗEƗG UL VWDPSDYROOSLLQGLFH%HLUXW DO%XƗUƯPشDƯFRQORãDU GLDO.LUPƗQƯLQ0XDPPDG0XDPPDGµ$EG DO /DؾƯIHGYROO&DLURULVWYROO%HLUXW DO'ƗUDTXؾQƯP$O6XQDQLQµ$EG$OOƗK+ƗãLP<DPƗQƯDO0DGDQƯHGYROODO 0DGƯQDDHGYROO%HLUXW DO'ƗULPƯP$O0XVQDGDODžƗPLµRDO6XQDQLQµ$EG$OOƗK+ƗãLP<DPƗQƯDO0D GDQƯHGYROO&DLUR DOƯOLEQ,VƗTP$O0XWDصDU3DULJL ,EQ$EƯâD\EDP$O.LWƗEDO0XصDQQDIIƯ¶ODƗGƯـZD¶OƗـƗULQµ$EGDOƗOLTDO$I ĀƗQƯµƖPLUDOµ8PUƯDO$µ٤DPƯHGVYROO%RPED\ ,EQ0ƗdžDP.LWƗEDO6XQDQLQ0XDPPDG)X¶ƗGµ$EGDO%ƗTƯHGYROO&DLUR ,EQ4XGƗPDP$O0XƥQƯYROO&DLUR 0ƗOLNE$QDVP.LWƗEDO0XZDؾؾD¶LQµ$EGDO:DKKƗEµ$EGDO/DؾƯIHGDHG &DLURWUDG$LVKD$EGXUUDKPDQ%HZOH\ 0XVOLPPشDƯFRQORãDUGLDO1DZDZƯYROO&DLUR DO1DVƗ¶ƯP.LWƗEDO6XQDQYROO&DLUR 6DতQnjQP$O0XGDZZDQDDONXEUƗYROO&DLUR DO6DUDVƯP.LWƗEDO0DEVnjؾYROO&DLUR DO7LUPLסƯP.LWƗEDO6XQDQRDODžƗPLµDOشDƯLQµ$EGDO:DKKƗEµ$EGDO/DؾƯI µ$EGDO5DPƗQ0XDPPDGµ8ـPƗQHGVYROO&DLUR 526$&217( /¶(WLRSLDHLO3UHWH*LDQQL )RQWLOHWWHUDULH 1XPHURVHVRQROHIRQWLFKHIRUQLVFRQRLQIRUPD]LRQLVXOODORFDOL]]D]LRQH GLTXHVWRSHUVRQDJJLROHJJHQGDULRLOFXLQRPHFRPLQFLzDFLUFRODUHGLIIXVD PHQWHDOODILQHGHO;,,VHFJUD]LHDXQDPLVVLYDUHGDWWDLQPROWHSOLFLOLQJXHH GLVSRQLELOH LQ SL UHGD]LRQLLQ FXL VLGHILQLYD ©3UHVELWHU-RKDQQHVSRWHQWLD HWYLUWXWHGRPLQL-HVX&KULVWLUH[UHJXPHWGRPLQXVGRPLQDQWLXPª/¶RULJLQH GHOPLWRSRWUHEEHHVVHUHSUHFHGHQWHDWDOHGLIIXVLRQHSHUFKp©/DOHWWHUDqX Q¶DELOH FRPSLOD]LRQH XQD VLQWHVL GL SURGLJL H GL PHUDYLJOLH WUDWWH GD PROWH IRQWLª 8WLOH DOOD QRVWUD ULFHUFD q FHUWDPHQWH *LRUGDQR &DWDODQL GD 6pYpUDF XQ GRPHQLFDQRG¶RULJLQHIUDQFHVHYHVFRYRGL4XLORQGDOPDUWLUL]]DWRGDL PXVXOPDQLD7DQDQHO1HOORVFULWWRGDOWLWROR0LUDELOLDGHVFULSWDR/L EURGHOOH0HUDYLJOLHWUDGuWRGDXQXQLFRPV/RQGUD%ULWLVK/LEUDU\$GG RULJLQDULRGHOOD)UDQFLDVXGRULHQWDOHFDODQRVWUDIRQWHORFD OL]]DLOSUHVELWHUR*LRYDQQLLPSHUDWRUHGHJOL(WtRSLQHOO¶,QGLDWHUWLD $WDOHVFRSRVDUHEEHXWLOHDQDOL]]DUHOHDXFWRULWDWHVGDFXLGLSHQGHLOFURFLDWRSLFFDUGR5REHUW GH&ODULSRVWSHUFKpVRQRULOHYDELOLDIILQLWjGLVRVWDQ]DHVWLOHWUDODVXDFURQDFDHOD /HWWHUDGHO3UHWH*LDQQL)XURQRSURSULRYLDJJLDWRULPHUFDQWLSHOOHJULQLDYHLFRODUHQRWL]LH YHUHRSUHVXQWHWDOLUHODWLYHDWHUUHORQWDQH5REHUWGH&ODULS 6LOYHUEHUJS *LRUGDQR&DWDODQLGD6pYpUDFSFIU*DGUDW /DGLYLVLRQHGHOO¶,QGLDHIIHWWXDWDGD*LRUGDQRSUHYHGHXQ¶,QGLDPLQRUHFKHDEEUDFFLDLO6LQG SUREDELOPHQWH 0HNUDQ XQ¶,QGLD FRVWLHUD D QRUG ILQR D 0DODEƗU XQ¶,QGLD PDJJLRUH FKH VL HVWHQGHJHQHULFDPHQWHGDO0DODEƗUYHUVR2ULHQWHWDQWRGDLQFOXGHUH&KDPSDRYYHUR&DPER GLDGDXOWLPRXQ¶,QGLD7HUWLDDRULHQWHGHOO¶$IULFD 5RVD&RQWH ,O PV GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD &LYLFD GL 9HURQD ;9 VHF FRQWHQHQWH XQ YROJDUL]]DPHQWRGHOOD/HWWHUDGL3UHWH*LDQQLDWWHVWDFKLDUDPHQWHODGLVORFD ]LRQHGLTXHVWRSHUVRQDJJLRLQ©(WLRSLDªDQFKHVHYLVFRUUHLO7LJULHSHUVLVWH O¶LGHQWLILFD]LRQHFRQO¶©,QGLDª ,R3UHWH,DQLSHUODGLRJUDWLDGHVDQWR7RPDLRDSRVWRORVXPPRSRQWLILFKR,PSHUD WRUH LQ OH SDUWH (QGLDQH QHO WHU]R GHO PRQGR LQ ODSURYLQFLD GH (WKLRSLD VDOXWH LQ TXHOOR6LJQRUHHOTXDOHIXKREHGLHQWHSHUQX\LQILQDODPRUWHLQVXOOLJQRGHODFURFH GHODDSRVWROLFKDEHQHGLFWLRQHGHGLRGHPLVHUHVDQFWR7KRPD[R ,QXQSDVVRGHOO¶,JJHUHWRURWµRODP(SLVWRODVXJOLLWLQHUDULGHOPRQGR XQRVFULWWRUHGDWWRLQHEUDLFRGDOJHRJUDIRIHUUDUHVH$EUDKDPEHQ0RUGHFD\ )DULVVROFKHWUDOHVXHIRQWLDQQRYHUDDQFKH*LDFRPR)LOLSSR)RUH VWLGD%HUJDPRVLOHJJH ,QYHQL ǕFULSWXP LQ /LEULV HRUXP LQ /LEUR TXL YRFDWXU 1RYXV RUELV OLE GR FDS YRTXRGj/LǕERQDTX HǕWSULQFLSLXPUHJQL3RUWXJDOOL DG&DOHFXWTX LQ$ǕLk LQLQLWLR,QGL ǕLQWWHUPLOOHRFWLQJHQW 3DUDǕDQJ «(WǕLFLQKRF&DSLWHH[SOLFDW GLFLWTXRG3UHWL*LDQLLQYHQLWXUǕXSUD&DOHFXWLQ&RQWLQHQWHLQ3URYLQFLLVǕXSHULR ULEXV SURFXO GLǕWDQWLEXV j PDUL (W K F HǕW GHPRQVWUDWLR YHUD QRWLWLD PDQLIHǕWD -XG LVLELLQYHQLWLVLQYLFLQLD3UHWLJLDQLXWLDXGLYLPXVRPQLEXVGLHEXVQRǕWULVDERUH &RQIXVLRQL VRYUDSSRVL]LRQL H LGHQWLILFD]LRQL GHLILXPL 7LJUL (XIUDWH *LKRQ H 3LãRQ 1LOR $]]XUUR"FKHDYUHEEHURRULJLQHGDOJLDUGLQRGHOO¶(GHQ*QVRQREHQGRFXPHQWDWH 1HO/LEURGHOFRQRVoLPLHQWR;,9VHFSHUHVHPSLR©«7LJULV(XIUDWHV*LRQH)LF[LRQ 4XHVWLTXDWWURILXPLEDJQDQRWXWWDOD1XELDHO¶(WLRSLD«ª)UDQFHVFRGD&DVWLJOLDS 3RFRROWUHODQRVWUDIRQWHGLVWLQJXHGXH(XIUDWLXQRLQ1XELDO¶DOWURLQ&DOGHD *LRYDQQL/HDUGRS $EUDKDP EHQ 0RUGHFDL )DULVVRO FIU 5XGHUPDQ SS V /R VFULWWR IX WUD GRWWRSULPDLQODWLQRQHOHVXFFHVVLYDPHQWHLQLWDOLDQRQHO6XOODILJXUDGLTXHVWR HUXGLWRGLFXLqWXWWRUDFRQWURYHUVDODGDWDGLPRUWHVLYHGD=D]]X 0ROWHVRQROHHGL]LRQLGLVSRQLELOLGHO6XSSOHPHQWXP&KURQLFDUXPSLYROWHULVWDPSDWRHDJ JLRUQDWR ,OULIHULPHQWRqDO©/LEUR6HFRQGRGHOD1DXLJDWLRQHGH/LVERQDD&DOOLFKXWGHOHQJXD3RUWR JDOOHVHLQWDOLDQDªXQ¶RSHUDFKHHEEHPROWRVXFFHVVRWUDGRWWDLQODWLQRQHOHULVWDPSDWD YDULH YROWH q GLVSRQLELOH SXUH LQ WHGHVFR H IUDQFHVH FIU )UDFDQ]LR GD 0RQWDOERGGR 7K +\GH LQYHFH DQQRWDYD ©1RYXV 2UELV@ $XWKRU HǕW$OEHULFXV 9HǕSXWLXV TXL OLQJXk3RUWXJDOOLFkǕFULSǕLWQRQDXWHPKDEHPXVQLǕLHMXV(SLWRPHQHDPTXH ,WDOLFHWDQWXPª $EUDKDPEHQ0RUGHFDL)DULVVROSQ 6L WUDWWHUHEEH GL XQ JUDQGH SRUWR GDORFDOL]]DUVLVXOO¶,QGR +DOOEHUJS VY³&DOL FXW´ /¶(WLRSLDHLO3UHWH*LDQQL 6DFHUGRWXPQLJULWDUXPTXLYHQHUXQWYHQLXQWǕLQJXOLVGLHEXVQDUUDQWSURFHUWR LQYHQWLRQHPPXOWRUXP-XG RUXPDSXGLSVRV(WTXRTLQ5RPDHǕWLǕWRUXP6DFHUGR WXP6RFLHWDVXQDQXPHURIHUHKDELWDQWHVLQ([FHOǕRXQRQRYRTXRGGHQRYRIXQ GDWXPHǕW1RPLQLLSVRUXP2PQLDK FDXGLYLjYLULV'RFWLVTXLIXHUXQWLQ&DOHFXW ELVLQWUDELHQQLXPGLHUXPKLFFRUDP+HUFXOH'XFH)HUUDULHQǕLQDUUDUXQWQHJRWLXP &DOHFXWOD0HFF 3UHWHJLDQLGHPROWLWXGLQH-XG RUXPLELLQYHQWRUXPGH 5HJLEXVHRUXPDFWLRQLEXVHRUXP>FDS;;9'HQHJRWLLV&DOHFXW«GHUHJQR3UH WLJLDQLTXRGHÕFRQILQHHǕWjODWHUHTXRHǕWYHUǕXV)OXYÕXP6DEEDWLFXPSU GLFWXP@ *OL(EUHLGLTXHVWRSDVVRVHPEUHUHEEHURJOLHEUHLGL&RFKLQPHQWUHOD VHWWD GRYUHEEH HVVHUH FRVWLWXLWD GD FULVWLDQL QHVWRULDQL WXWWDYLD QRQ VL SXz VFDUWDUHFRPSOHWDPHQWHODSRVVLELOLWjFKHVLWUDWWLGLVHPSOLFLPRQDFLEHQHGHW WLQLGHQRPLQDWLQHOPHGLRHYR©PRQDFLQHULª ,Q UHDOWj OD FRPSLOD]LRQH GL )UDQFD]LR GD 0RQWDOERGGR ± RFFDVLRQDO PHQWHDWWULEXLWDDOO¶HUXGLWRYLDJJLDWRUHYHQHWR$OHVVDQGUR=RU]LR*LRUJL HIRQWHGLLQIRUPD]LRQHSHU$EUDKDPEHQ0RUGHFDL)DULVVRO±VHPEUDORFDOL] ]DUHLOSUHWH*LDQQLWUD(WLRSLDHG(JLWWR >«@6}QRÿTGDOLVERQDÿGFm&LWDGHFDOLFKXWOHJKHWUH0GFFFDUDJL}HRWPL OLDLLLSOHJKDImQRPLOLD[Y0FFDOWUHWmWRDOWRUQDĚ«1HODIXGLFWD&LWD>FDOL FKXW@KmQRDOFKNJHQRWL]LHGHO3UHWLmQL>«@>'HODWHUUDJLXGDLFDGRXHDELWDHO 3UHWH,mQL@«FKHTXHOOLGHOSUHWLmQLPROWRGLVFRVWRGD&DOLFKXWFKHGDODEDQGDGLTXD GDOFROIR'DUDELDF}ILQDFNJTOOR5HGH0HOLQGUDUNJFXPOLHWuRSLFLRH1HULGH *OLHEUHLJLXQVHURLQ,QGLDEHQSULPDGHLFULVWLDQLHGHLPXVXOPDQLHVLGLVWLQJXHYDQRLQ(EUHL 1HULH%LDQFKL,SULPLDSSDUWHQHYDQRDOODWULEGL0DQDVVHFDSWLYLLQ%DELORQLD5H DOWHPSRGHOIRQGDWRUHGHOO¶LPSHURQHREDELORQHVH1DEXFRGRQRVRUD&JOLDO WULHUDQRIXJJLWLGD*HUXVDOHPPHLQVHJXLWRDOOHSHUVHFX]LRQLGHLURPDQL6XOOHFRPXQLWjJLX GDLFKHHVXLSDUODQWLDUDPDLFRLQ2ULHQWHH,QGLDVLYHGD1HXVQHUSS $EELDPRQRWL]LDGLFLUFDPRQDFLHWLRSLLQVHGLDWLD5RPDD6DQWR6WHIDQRGHL0RULDSDU WLUHGDOFKH©GDYDQRDLQWHQGHUHFKHLO3UHWH*LDQQLIRVVHSURSULRHWLRSHHFKHJOLHEUHL GHOVXRUHJQRIRVVHURLIDODVKDLQHULGLRULJLQHHEUDLFDGHOFHQWURGHOO¶(WLRSLDGHOQRUGRJJL LQJUDQSDUWHWUDVIHULWLVLLQ,VUDHOHª3LUHQQHS6LPLOPHQWHXQIUDPPHQWRLQHEUDL FRGHOOD/HWWHUDGHO3UHWH*LDQQLDOSDSD©SUHWLQHULFKHVRQR YHQXWLH YHQJRQRTXRWLGLDQD PHQWHHFKHFLSDUODQR>«@(TXHVWLSUHWLVRQRD5RPDLQXQDFRPXQLWjGLTXDVLWUHQWDSHUVR QHQHOODQXRYDFDSSHOODUHFHQWHPHQWHFRVWUXLWDSHUORURªFIU8OOHQGRUI%HFNLQJKDP SS &IUFDS9,,,$EUDKDPEHQ0RUGHFDL)DULVVROS6LIDQRWDUHFKHOHGLVFUHSDQ]H QHOODIRUPDGHOQRPHGHOQRVWURSHUVRQDJJLRVRQRULOHYDELOLDQFKHQHOWHVWRHEUDLFR )LVFKHOSS6HJDOSS:HLOSS 3HUO¶,WHU,IIGL=RU]LVLYHGD&UDZIRUGSSV 5RVD&RQWH *LQHDEHQHIUDWHUUDDOVLF}ILQDFNJTOOLGHHJLSWRFLRHFNJHO6ROGDQRGH%DELOR QLDTVWRSUHWLmQLWLӁVDFHUGRWLImQRVDFULILFLLREVHUXDQROL(XDQJHOLLHOGHFUHWR GHODJLHVLDVHFXGRTOORF}VHUXDQRDOWUL[SLDQLQ}XLV}QRGLIHUӁWLDPROWD« $QFKHLQTXHVWRFDVRqYHULILFDELOHO¶HVLVWHQ]DGLXQDFDWHQDGLLQIRUPD ]LRQHSLDQWLFD$OODILQHGHO;,9VHFTXHVWROHJJHQGDULRSHUVRQDJJLRHUD FRQVLGHUDWR LO VRYUDQR GHOO¶,QGLD PDLRU (WLRSLD" H SDGURQH GHOOH FDWHUDWWH GHO1LORHFLzSRWHYDFRVWLWXLUHXQVHULRSUREOHPDSHUO¶(JLWWR *LDFRPR R -DFRSR GD 9HURQD SULRUH GHO PRQDVWHUR GL 6 (XIHPLD D 9HURQDFKHYLVLWzOD3DOHVWLQDQHOFRQIRQGHQGRSUREDELOPHQWHJOL©,Q GLDQLGL67RPPDVRª±QHVWRULDQLHRULJLQDULGHO0DODEƗU±FRQJOL©,QGLDQLª (WLRSLULIHULVFH 1XELDQLFDORJHUL«TXLVXQW(WKLRSHVQLJULGHJHQWH3UHVE\WHUL-RKDQQLVTXLHVWXQXV GHPDMRULEXVSULQFLSLEXVPXQGL«YRFDQWXUFULVWLDQL6DQFWL7KRPH«TXLDSUHVE\WHU -RKDQQHVGRPLQXV1XELHHW(WKLRSLH«>IROUY@ 4XLGDPGLFXQWXU1XELDQLQLJULGHSURYLQFLD1XELHVXQW(WKLRSHVFRQYHUVLDVDQFWR 0DWKHRVXEUHJQRSUHVE\WHUL-RKDQQLVTXLKDEHW*\RQXQXPGHTXDWXRUIOXPLQLEXV SDUDGLVL GH DOYHR VXR HW KDEHW SRWHVWDWHP DXIHUHQGL VROGDQR HW HFLDP 1LOOXP IOX YLXPHWLGHRVROGDQXVPXOWXPWLPHWHXPTXLDLOOHIOXYLXVLUULJDWWRWDP(JLSWXP>IRO Y@ 8Q UHVRFRQWR VLPLODUH q GDWR GD *LRYDQQL GH¶ 0DULJQROOL GHWWR DQFKH *LRYDQQLGL6/RUHQ]RYHVFRYRGL%LVLJQDQRQHOFKHDJJLXQJH SXUHFKHLOOHJJHQGDULRILXPH*\RQFLRqLO1LORDWWUDYHUVDO¶(WLRSLD *\RQTXLFLUFXLWWHUUDP(WKLRSHXELVXQWPRGRKRPLQHVQLJULTXHGLFLWXUWHUUD3UH VELWHUL-RKDQQLVHWLVWHSXWDWXUHVVH1\OXVTXLGHVFHQGLWLQ(J\SWXPSHULQWHUUXSWLR ,O6ROGDQRqLOVXOWDQRSHUDQWRQRPDVLDشDOƗDO'ƯQLHLO6DODGLQRQRWLVVLPRSHU O¶RSSRVL]LRQHDLFURFLDWLPDSUHVWRDVVXUWRDILJXUDPLWLFDSHUOLEHUDOLWjHVDJJH]]D ,OWRSRQLPR%ƗEDO\njQLQRULJLQHULIHULWRDXQDIRUWH]]DEL]DQWLQDFRQTXLVWDWDGDJOLDUDELQHO HIXVDVLSRLFRQO¶DFFDPSDPHQWRPLOLWDUHGL)XVؾƗW0LصUqULPDVWRDOXQJRSUHVVRLFRSWL HQHOOHIRQWLRFFLGHQWDOLDGHVLJQDUHLO&DLURHSHUHVWHQVLRQHO¶LQWHUR(JLWWR«FIU0LQHUYL QLS8QD%DELORQLDFRQILQDQWHFRO&DLURqDWWHVWDWDLQYHFHQHLULFRUGLGHOO¶DP EDVFLDWRUHILRUHQWLQR)HOLFHGL0LFKHOH%UDQFDFFLULFFRPHUFDQWHGHOODVHWD©>«@H YHGXWRTXHVWRFHQ¶DQGDPRLQ%DELORQLDWHUUDDQWLFDHGLVIDWWDLQJUDQSDUWHFKHFRQILQDFRO &DLURSHUPRGRFKHWXWWDSDUHXQDWHUUDHLYLYLFLWDPRTXDWWURFKLHVHGL&KULVWLDQLGLFLQWX UDHXQDGL*UHFLªLQ)HOLFH%UDQFDFFLS )UDFDQ]LRGD0RQWDOERGGR *LDFRPRGD9HURQDSSH&HUXOOL,SS /¶(WLRSLDHLO3UHWH*LDQQL QHP IDFWDP LQ ORFR TXL GLFLWXU$EDVW\ XEL VXQW &KULVWLDQL VDQFWL 0DWKHL DSRVWROL TXLEXV 6ROGDQXV HVW WULEXWDULXV SURSWHU LVWXP IOXYLXP TXLD SRVVXQW FODXGHUH YLDP DTXHHWSHULUHW(J\SWXV>©&DSLWXOXPGH3DUDGLVRª@ 6LPRQH6LJROLR6LQJROLFKHQHOLQWUDSUHVHXQSHOOHJUL QDJJLRLQ7HUUDVDQWDQHOVXRGLDULRGLYLDJJLRULSRUWDODVWHVVDORFDOL]]D]LR QH Ê YHUR FKH TXHVWR 6ROGDQR FRQYLHQH FK¶RJQL DQQR VL ULFRPSHULRYYHUR IDFFLD R PDJJLR D3UHVWR *LRYDQQL 4XHVWR VLJQRUH3UHVWR *LRYDQQL DELWD LQ ,QGLD HG q FUL VWLDQRHSRVVLHGHPROWHWHUUHGLFULVWLDQLHDQFKHLQIHGHOL(ODFDJLRQHSHUFKpLO6RO GDQRIDRPDJJLRDFRVWXLVLqFKHRJQLYROWDFKHTXHVWR3UHVWR*LRYDQQLIDFHVVHDSUL UHFHUWHFDWHUDWWHGLXQILXPHDOODJKHUHEEHLO&DLURH$OHVVDQGULDHWXWWRTXHOSDHVHH GLFHVLFKHTXHVWRILXPHqLO1LORLOTXDOHFRUUHDOODWRDO&DLUR/HGHWWHFDWHUDWWHVWDQ QR DSHUWH SRFR H SXU FRVu LO ILXPH q JURVVLVVLPR 6LFFKp SHU TXHVWD FDJLRQH FLRq SDXUDLO6ROGDQR JOL PDQGD XQDSDOOD G¶RUR FRQ XQD FURFH VXVR GL YDOXWDGL ELVDQWL WUHPLODG¶RURHLO6ROGDQRqD¶FRQILQLFRQTXHVWR3UHVWR*LRYDQQLFROVXRWHUUHQR 8Q DOWUR SHOOHJULQR SRFR FRQRVFLXWR LO YHVFRYR IUDQFHVH /RXLV GH 5R FKHFKRXDUWWUDLFULVWLDQLSUHVHQWLD*HUXVDOHPPHULFRUGD/DWL QL*UHFL$UPHQL*RUJLDQLYHO*HRUJLDQL-DFRELWH6\ULDQL,QGLTXLRDOLR PRGRGLFXQWXU$EDVVLV0DURQHV1HVWRULDQLHWFKULVWLDQLGH=RQDSLDYDQWL DJJLXQJH ,QGLVHX2ULHQWDOHVVXEGRPLQLRSUHVELWHUL-RKDQQLV +LREVHUYDQWFLUFXPFLVLRQHPFHOHEUDQWLQIHUPHQWDWRFRQYHQLXQWLQPXOWLVFXP-D FRELWLVFDQWDQWGLYLQDWHQHQWHVEDFXORVLQPDQLEXVFLUFXOXPIDFLXQWLQPRGXPFR UHH HW XOXODQW PRUH OXSRUXP TXDQGR GLFXQW&KULVWH HOH\VRQ YHO $OOHOX\D GLFXQW PLOOH YLFLEXV)DFLXQWDEVWLQHQFLDV PXOWDVD&HQD'RPLQLDGGLHPGRPLQLFDPQRQ FRPHGXQWQRQFRQILWHQWXU>@ 3DUWLFRODUL LQWHUHVVDQWL SRVVRQR HVVHUH HVWUDSRODWL GDO SDVVR GL XQ JUDP PDWLFR HEUHR SHU OXQJR WHPSR DO VHUYL]LR GHO FDUGLQDOH (JLGLR GD 9LWHUER &IU*ROXERYLFK,9S ©ULFRPSHUDUHªTXLKDLOVHQVRGL©ULVFDWWDUHOLEHUDUHULFXSHUDUHª 6LPRQHGL*HQWLOH6LJROLSSV&HUXOOL,SSVV /RXLVGH5RFKHFKRXDUWSS &IU&HUXOOL,SSVV 5RVD&RQWH QRWRDQFKHVRWWRLOQRPHGL(OLD/HYLWD4XHVWLDWWHVWDOD SUHVHQ]DGLDOFXQLSDUODQWLFDOGHRD5RPDFLWWjFKHDEEDQGRQzGRSRLOVDF FRGHO $GHVVRTXDQGRHURD5RPDLRKRYLVWRWUH&DOGHLFKHSURYHQLYDQRGDOODWHUUDGHO SUHVELWHUR*LRYDQQLFKHHUDQRVWDWLFRQYRFDWLGDOSDSD/HRQH;(UDQRYHUVDWLQHOOD OLQJXDVLULDFDHLQOHWWHUDWXUDVHEEHQHLOORURYHUQDFRORIRVVHO¶DUDER/DVSHFLDOHOLQ JXDWXWWDYLDQHOODTXDOHLOLEULHUDQRVFULWWLFRVuFRPHTXHOODGHLYDQJHOLGHLFULVWLDQL FKHHVVLSRUWDYDQRFRQVpHUDLOVLULDFRFKHHUDDQFKHFKLDPDWRDUDPDLFREDELORQHVH DVVLUR«,OSDSD/HRQH;OLDYHYDFRQYRFDWLDOORVFRSRGLFRUUHJJHUHWUDPLWHLORUR FRGLFLODVXDFRSLDGHO1XRYR7HVWDPHQWRUHGDWWDLQODWLQR«4XDQGROLRVVHUYROHJ JHUHTXHVWR6DOWHULRVHQ]DSXQWLFKLHGRORURµ$YHWHSXQWLRDOWULVHJQLFKHLQGLFDQR OHYRFDOL"¶(GHVVLULVSRQGRQRµ1R0DDEELDPRFRQYHUVDWRLQTXHVWDOLQJXDILQGDO ODIDQFLXOOH]]DSHUFLzVDSSLDPROHJJHUHVHQ]DSXQWL¶ $SULPDYLVWDODORFDOL]]D]LRQHGHOQRVWURSUHVELWHURSDUUHEEHGLYHUVDVH QRQIRVVHFKH/HRQH;*LRYDQQLGH¶0HGLFLQHOFRUVRGHOVXR SRQWLILFDWRLQFRQWUzSHOOHJULQLHSUHODWLHWuRSLHFLzqFHUWR 1HOORVFULWWRUHJHRSROLWLFR*LRYDQQL%RWHURQHOO¶HGL]LR QHDPSOLDWDGHOOHVXH5HOD]LRQLXQLYHUVDOLLQFXLGHVFULYHWXWWRLOPRQGRDOOR UDFRQRVFLXWRGHGLFDXQOXQJRFDSLWRORDOO¶$ELVVLQLDLPSHURGHOSUHWH*LDQ QL'DOUDFFRQWRVLHYLQFHSXUHFKHLOSRWHUHGLTXHVWRSHUVRQDJJLRULFRUGD WR DQFKH GD *LRYDQQL %RFFDFFLR QHOOD 1RYHOOD QRQD GHOO¶2WWDYD JLRUQDWDVDUHEEHVWDWRULGLPHQVLRQDWRGDLPXVXOPDQL $EHVVLQLVLDGGLPDQGRQRLSRSROLVXGGLWLDO3UHVWH*LDQQLLOFXLLPSHULRVHQRLFRQ VLGHULDPRLWLWROLGHL5HJQLFKHHJOLXVDQHOOHVXHOHWWHUHKHEEHJLjDPSOLVVLPLFRQ ILQLFRQFLRVLDFK¶HJOLVLLQWLWROD5HGL*RLDPHFKHJLDFHWUDLO1LORHLO=DLUHHGL 9DQJXH5HJQRSRVWRROWUHLO=DLUHHGL'DPXW>«@,O3UHVWHGDOO¶DPPLQLVWUDWLRQH ƜOL\\ƗKXEHQƖVKƝUKD/ƝZƯ$VKNHQD]LSSWUDOHVXHRSHUHXQGL]LRQDULRWUL OLQJXH JUHFRHEUDLFRFDOGHR HGLWLR SULQFHSV%DVLOH 4XDOFKH WHPSR SULPD LQYHFH IXGDWRDOOHVWDPSHLO6DOWHULRHWLRSLFRHGLWLRSULQFHSV5RP 1XPHURVHOHIRQWLFKHWHVWLPRQLDQRWDOHGHQRPLQD]LRQHWUDTXHVWHLOUHVRFRQWRGHOSUHWH(OL VHRIRUVHO¶XQLFRVXSHUVWLWHGLXQ¶DPEDVFHUuDJLXQWDD5RPDQHOFD4XHVWL IRUVHXQ QHVWRULDQRRULJLQDULRGHOOD6LULDVHWWHQWULRQDOHULIHULVFHFKHODOLQJXDGHOSDHVHGHOSUHWH*LDQ QL HUD GHWWD ©FKDOGDLFDª 0DULQHVFX S 8Q¶LGHQWLFD GHQRPLQD]LRQH qDWWULEXLWD GD IRQWLWDUGHDQFKHDOODOLQJXDHWLRSLFD/HIHYUHSSV *LRYDQQL%RWHUR 4XDOFKHVHFRORGRSR7RUTXDWR7DVVR©5HVVHJLjO¶(WLRSLDHIRUVHUHJJH6HQDSR DQFRUFRQIRUWXQDWRLPSHURLOTXDOGHOILJOLRGL0DULDODOHJJHRVVHUYDHO¶RVVHUYDDQFRULO SRSROQHURª*HUXVDOHPPHOLEHUDWD;,, /¶(WLRSLDHLO3UHWH*LDQQL GHL6DFUDPHQWLHGDOO¶RUGLQDWLRQHGHLFKLHULFLDO6DFHUGRWLRLQSRLJRYHUQDDVVROX WDPHQWHRJQLFRVD'jHWRJOLHLEHQHILFLMjVXREHQHSODFLWRHQHOSXQLUHQRQIDGLIIH UHQ]DWUDLFKLHULFLHLODLFL>«@,0DRPHWWDQLKDQQRULGRWWRTXHVWR3ULQFLSHjJUDQGH HVWUHPLWj0DSULPDTXDQGRHJOLILRULYDYLYHYDFRQWDQWDJUDQGH]]DFKHQRQSDUOD YDVHQRQSHULQWHUSUHWHQpVLODVFLDYDYHGHUHIXRULFKHQHLJLRUQLVROHQQL )RQWLFDUWRJUDILFKH ,QIRUPD]LRQLLQWHUHVVDQWLVRQRIRUQLWHSRLGDOOHIRQWLFDUWRJUDILFKHFKH GDSSULPD FROORFDQR LQ ,QGLD LO UHJQR GHOSUHWHUH*LDQQL PD FRO SURJUHGLUH GHOOH FRQRVFHQ]H OR VSRVWDQR QHOOH VFRQRVFLXWH UHJLRQL GHOO¶$IULFD JHQHUDO PHQWHQRWHFRPH©(WLRSLDªHFLzSHUFKpDOFXQHIRQWLOHWWHUDULHULIHULVFRQRGL WHUUHLQFXLLUHVDUHEEHURDQFKHVDFUHGRWL ,OFDUWRJUDIRJHQRYHVH*LRYDQQLGL0DXURGD&DULJQDQRDXWR UHGLXQ0DSSDPRQGRRUDSHUGXWRqXQDGHOOHSULPHIRQWLDORFDOL]]DUHTXH VWROHJJHQGDULRSHUVRQDJJLRLQ$IULFDQHOORVSHFLILFRLQ(WLRSLDFRPHULIH ULVFH*LDFRPR)LOLSSR)RUHVWLQHOFDSLWROHWWRGHGLFDWRDOO¶DSRVWROR 0DWWHR ÊTXHVWRLOFDVRGL*LUDOGR&DPEUHQVHFDFRQRVFLXWRDQFKHFRPH*HUDOOW*\PURR *HUDOG GH %DUU\ ©2ULHQWDOLXP UH[ HUDW DWTXH VDFHUGRVª 3L VSHFLILFDPHQWH O¶DUPHQR $Enj شƗOLDWWLYRLQ(JLWWRQHO;,,,VHF©7XWWLLUHGHOO¶$ELVVLQLDVRQRSUHWLHFHOHEUDQRODOLWXUJLD QHO VDQWXDULR«ª 4XDOFKH WHPSR GRSR LO GRPHQLFDQR *LRYDQQL YHVFRYR GL 1DNKVKLZDQ SRLGDODUFLYHVFRYRGL6XOؾƗQƯ\HKLQ3HUVLDODSULPDIRQWHDWUDVPHWWHUHLQ(XURSDQR WL]LHVLFXUHULJXDUGR7DPHUODQRLQXQRVFULWWRUHGDWWRQHOULSRUWD©$OWLV VLPXVUH[LSVRUXPSUHVE\WHU,RKDQQHVYRFDWXUOLFHWVLWUH[PDJQLILFXVHWVHFXODULVVHGSURS WHU GHYRWLRQHP HW UHOLJLRVLWDWHP GLFLWXU TXDVL SUHVE\WHUª *LUDOGR &DPEUHQVH S $EnjشƗOLSIROYGHOPVDUDER*LRYDQQLGD6XOؾƗQƯ\HKS 4XHVWLDYUHEEHLQFRQWUDWRDOFXQLPHPEULGLXQDPLVVLRQHGLSORPDWLFDLQYLDWDGDOVRYUDQRH WLRSH:HGHP5DµDGR$UµDGDOODFRUWHSDSDOHULXQLWDQHOODVHGHGL$YLJQRQHQHO SHUWDOHPRWLYRODVXDWHVWLPRQLDQ]DVHYHUDVDUHEEHDWWHQGLELOH6NHOWRQLQ&UDZIRUG SS%HFNLQJKDPSS /DSULPDFRQQHVVLRQHLQDVVROXWRFRQO¶(WLRSLDqGHOIUDQFHVFDQR6LPHRQH6HPHRQLV FKHSRFRGRSRDYHUGHVFULWWRO¶(JLWWRDJJLXQJH©«3UHGLFWXVDXWHPIOXYLXV>1LOXV@HVWLOOH LQJHQVHWIDPRVXVFXMXVORQJLWXGLQLVQRQHVWILQLV3HUTXHPDVFHQGLWXUQDYLJLRD0DUL0HGL WHUUDQHRXVTXHDG,QGLDP6XSHULRUHPLQTXDVWDW3UHVELWHU-RKDQQHVXELVXQWO[[GLHWHPD JQHXWGLFLWXUª>IROU@6LPHRQH6HPHRQLVSSV 0ROWHVRQROHHGL]LRQLGLVSRQLELOLGLTXHVW¶RSHUDSLYROWHULVWDPSDWDHDJJLRUQDWD*LDFRPR )LOLSSR)RUHVWLGD%HUJDPRS 5RVD&RQWH /¶DSRVWROR 0DWWHR« DYHQGR GHOLEHUDWR GL SDVVDUH DOOH JHQWL VWUDQLHUH LQ (WLRSLD VFULVVHODSULPDYROWDLO9DQJHORLQOLQJXDHEUDLFD3DVVDWRSRLGDOOD*LXGHDDOO¶(WLR SLDDQGzSUHGLFDQGRTXDVLSHUWXWWDTXHOODSURYLQFLD«HFULVWLDQL]]zTXDVLWXWWDO¶(WL RSLD(TXHVWDFKLHVDFRVuIRQGDWDIXSRLPHUDYLJOLRVDPHQWHDFFUHVFLXWDGDOO¶HXQXFR EDWWH]]DWRGD)LOLSSR«8QFHUWRVDFHUGRWHJHQRYHVHVHSROWRQHOODFKLHVDGL60DU FRVFULYHQGRXQGHJQRWUDWWDWRVXJOL(WLRSLFKHqFKLDPDWR0DSSDPRQGRPROWRGLI IXVDPHQWHWUDWWDGHLORURFRVWXPLULIHULVFHGHOSUHVELWHUR*LRYDQQLFRPHSDWULDUFDGL TXHLSRSROLJOLVRQRVRWWRSRVWLDUFLYHVFRYLGHLTXDOLRJQXQRGLORURKDYHVFR YLVXIIUDJDQHL«>6XSSOHPHQWXP&KURQLFDUXP9,,,@ /D &DUWD QDXWLFRJHRJUDILFD GL $QJHOLQR 'DORUWR R 'DORUFR 'XOFHUW" GDWDWDHFRQVLGHUDWDODSLDQWLFDUHGDWWDD0DLRUFDQHOFDUWL JOLR UHODWLYR DO UH GL 1XELD LQGLFD FKLDUDPHQWH O¶RULJLQH DIULFDQD GHO QRVWUR SHUVRQDJJLR ,VWHUH[VDUDFHQXVKDEHWFRQWLQXRJXHUDPFXPFKULVWLDQLV1XELHHW(WLRSLHTXLVXQW VXEGRPLQLR3UHVWH-DQHFKULVWLDQXVQLJHU $QFKH LO 0DSSDPRQGR GL IUD 0DXUR GDWDWR XQR GHL PDVVLPL PRQXPHQWL FDUWRJUDILFL WDUGRPHGLHYDOL SHU OD FRPSOHVVLWj H O¶LPSRQHQ]D GHOODFRVWUX]LRQH±GLSHQGHQGRIRUVHGDOOD/HWWHUDGHOSUHWH*LDQQL±ULSRUWD XQ¶LQIRUPD]LRQHVLPLODUH 7DYROD;F$EDVVLDLQ(WK\RSLD«H4XLHOSUHVWR-DQQH_IDUHVVLGHQ WLDSULQ_FLSDO«)6HGLFHFKHSUHVWR-D_QHKDSLGHUHJQL_VRWRHOVXR GRPLQLR_GLTXDOSLGH_VRQRGHGLIIH_UHQWHOHQJXH_(GHWXWRTXHVWRQXPHUR ]R>q_VHGLFHFKHVRQRSRW>HQWLVLJQR_ULHOUHVWRQRQqGDIDUF>RQWR *LRYDQQL /HDUGR XQ FDUWRJUDIR YHQH]LDQR DWWLYR QHOOD SULPD PHWj GHO ;9VHFHDXWRUHGLXQ0DSSDPRQGRGDWDWRFRQVHUYDWRQHOOD%LEOLRWHFD %HUWROLDQDGL9LFHQ]DRULHQWDWRFRQO¶HVWLQDOWR±XQDGHOOHSULPHUDSSUHVHQ WD]LRQL FLUFRODUL GHOOD 7HUUD ± FROORFD DOO¶HVWUHPD SDUWH GHOO¶$VLD RULHQWDOH O¶,QGLDGHVRWRO¶,QGLDGHPH]RO¶,QGLDGHVRUDHORFDOL]]DVHPSUHLQ$IULFD O¶,PSHULRGHOSUHVWRLDQL 0ROWHDOWUHFDUWHQDXWLFKHPHGLHYDOLWUDTXHVWHLO0DSSDPRQGR&DWDOD QR(VWHQVHLO3DGUmRUHDOOD&DUWDGHO&DQWLQRHLO3ODQLVIHUR&DVWLJOLRQL± &RQVHUYDWDD3DULJLSUHVVROD%LEOLRWKqTXH1DWLRQDOH&ROO6PLWK/HVRXHI5HV*H% qULSURGRWWDLQGH/D5RQFLqUH0ROODWGX-RXUGLQ *DVSDUULQL/HSRUDFH *LRYDQQL/HDUGRS /¶(WLRSLDHLO3UHWH*LDQQL GRFXPHQWL FKH LOOXVWUDQR LOSDVVDJJLRGDO 0HGLRHYRDOO¶HWj GHOOH JUDQGL VFR SHUWH±FRQWLQXDQRDORFDOL]]DUHLOSUHWH*LDQQLLQ(WLRSLD 8QR GHL GRFXPHQWL SL UDIILQDWL GHOOD FDUWRJUDILD PHGLWHUUDQHD LO0DS SDPRQGR&DWDODQR(VWHQVHFKHVHFRQGRVWXGLSLUHFHQWLVDUHEEHVWDWRHVH JXLWRWUDLOHLOQHOOD6H]LRQH,,,FHQWURRFFLGHQWDOH±UHODWLYDPHQ WHDOOH]RQHRULHQWDOLGHOO¶$IULFD±UHFLWD ,QTXHVWDSURYLQFLDVWDLOJUDQGHLPSHUDWRUH3UHWH*LDQQLVLJQRUHGHOOH,QGLH*OLDEL WDQWLVRQRQHULSHUQDWXUDHQHOO¶RWWDYRJLRUQRGRSRODQDVFLWDOLVHJQDQRLQWUHSXQWL GHOYLVRHOLEDWWH]]DQRQHOO¶DFTXDVHFRQGRLOULWRGL5RPD ,O 3DGUmR UHDO XQ SURWRWLSR FDUWRJUDILFR FRVWDQWHPHQWH LQWHJUDWR FRQ L GDWL IRUQLWL GDOOH QXRYH VFRSHUWH H L UHODWLYL ULOLHYL IX FRVWUXLWR H FRQVHUYDWR QHOOD&DVDGD,QGLDIRQGDWDD/LVERQDQHO3URWHWWRGDOVHJUHWRGL6WDWR ±SHQDODPRUWHSHULWUDVJUHVVRUL±ULSRUWDLQWHUHVVDQWLLQIRUPD]LRQL1HOO¶$ IULFD VHWWHQWULRQDOH LQ ULIHULPHQWR DOOH ©0RQWDJQH FKLDUHª H FLRq DOOD FDWHQD GHOO¶$WODQWHULSRUWD 7HUUDGHO5HGHOOD1XELDFKHqXQ0RURHXQJUDQGHQHPLFRGHL&ULVWLDQLSHUHQQH PHQWHLQORWWDFRQLO3UHWH*LDQQL« ODVFLDQGRLQWHQGHUHFKHLOSUHWH*LDQQLGRYHYDDOPHQRFRQWUROODUHLWHUULWRUL OLPLWURILDOOD1XELD $OWURGRFXPHQWRLQWHUHVVDQWHqOD&DUWDGHO&DQWLQR±YHUDHSURSULDFR SLD FODQGHVWLQD GHO 3DGUmR UHDO ± FRQVHUYDWD SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH 8QLYHUVLWDULD GL 0RGHQD H GRQDWD QHO DO GXFD GL )HUUDUD GD $OEHUWR &DQWLQRGLSORPDWLFRD/LVERQDSHUFRQWRGHOODFDVDG¶(VWHFKHULSRUWDLQIRU PD]LRQLVLPLODUL ,O3ODQLVIHUR&DVWLJOLRQLXQDJUDQGHFDUWDQDXWLFD±GDWDWDHDWWUL EXLWDD'LHJR5LEHLURFDUWRJUDIRFDSRSLORWRPDLRUGHOOD&DVDGH&RQWUDF 6XOO¶XVRGHOIXRFRQHOEDWWHVLPRGHJOL(WuRSL&HUXOOLSSVV*URVVDE VV 1HO0DSSDPRQGRGLIUD0DXURLQIDWWL7DYROD;©«$'HVRSUDHO5HJQR>GH_DE EDVVLD q XQD oHQ>WH IHUR_FLVVLPD H \GRODWUD O>D TXDO _ q VHSDUDGD GD OD DE>EDVVLD SHU XQD _ ILXPHUDHSHUPRQWDJ>QHDOLSDVVLGHOHTXDO_L5HGHDEDVVLDKDQR>IDWRIRUWHoHJUDQ GLVVLPH_DoRFKqTXHOLSRSXOLQRQ>SRVVDQRSDVVDUHGDQLIL_FDUHOVXRSDHVH4X>HVWLVR QRKRPHQLIRUWLV_VLPLHGHJUDQVWDWXUD>HVRQRWULEXWDULLGHO_3UHVWR-DQQH5HGH>DEDVVLD HVHUXHQRDOGLWR_GHFHUWRQXPHURGHPLDUD_GHKRPLQLDVXRELVRJQLHWFHWHUD@ª %LQL0LODQR 5RVD&RQWH WLyQGH/DV,QGLDVGL6LYLJOLD±FODVVLILFDO¶DOWRSLDQRHWLRSLFRFRPH©$UDELD VXE(JLSWRªFKHqDQFRUDOD7LHUDGHO3UHVWH,YDQ ,O FDUWLJOLR GL XQD FDUWD GHOO¶$IULFD GL -DQ -DQVVRQ FRQVHUYDWD SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD &HQWUDOH GL %LUPLQJKDP ULSRUWD DQFRUD FKH O¶(WLRSLD QHOODVXDLQWHUH]]DqQRWDFRPXQHPHQWHFRPHOD ©7HUUDLQFXLUHJQDLO3UH VELWHUR*LRYDQQLªLQIDWWL©WKLRSLDVYSHULRUYHOLQWHULRUYXOJR$ELVVLQRUYP VLYH3UHVELWHUL,RKDQQLV,PSHULXPª 8Q¶LQIRUPD]LRQH VLPLODUH q ULIHULWD GDO ULIRUPDWRUH GHOOD FDUWRJUDILD VFLHQWLILFDLOILDPPLQJR*HUDUG0HUFDWRUHR.UHPHUFD8QDGHOOH VXHFDUWHGDWDWDULSRUWDODOHJHQGD©$ELVVLQRUXPVLYH3UHFLRVL-RKDQ QLV,PSHULXPª 4XDQWR ILQRUD HVSRVWR ODVFLD LQWHQGHUH FKH SDUWH GHOOD WUDGL]LRQH FDUWR JUDILFDHDOFXQLFURQDFKLVWLVHPEUDQRFRQQHWWHUHLOSUHWH*LDQQLDOO¶(WLRSLDR SHU OR PHQR DSSDUH VRWWLQWHVD XQD VXD ORFDOL]]D]LRQH DIULFDQD $OFXQH IRQWL FRQIHUPDQRFKHODTXDOLILFD©SUHWH*LDQQLªqDWWULEXLWDQHOFRUVRGHOWHPSRD PROWLVRYUDQLSUHYDOHQWHPHQWHRULHQWDOL,QROWUHSHUDOFXQLGLORURVRQRDWWH VWDWLSXUHDOWULWLWROLHQRPLGDLVLJQLILFDWLSLGLYHUVL©$EHFKLª©$EHO6H OLSH>³FHQWRXRPLQL´@ª©%HO*LDQ>³VRPPR3UHQFLSH´@ª©'DYLGª©6H QDSRª FRUUX]LRQH GHOO¶DUDER µ$EG DOشDOƯE ³VHUYR GHOOD FURFH´ ©6XOWDQ 3UHVFLXWWLQLSD .DPPHUHU,,,SWDY&/ ©>«@LOSUHWH-DQLLOTXDOHLQVXDOLQJXDFKLDPRQR$EDFKLFK¶YXROGLUHIHUDGRSFKHFXVLLQ HIIHFWRFǀIHUURDIIRFKDWRVHVHJQDQRµWFXVLVRQREDSWL]DWLVHQFLDDTXDª0DQRHOLO)RUWXQD WRS,OWHUPLQH©$EHFKLªULFRUGDO¶HWQRQLPR©DEDãƯªFKHLQGLFDJOLDELWDQWLGHOOD VSRQGDDIULFDQDGHOPDU5RVVR%HHVWRQSSV/XVLQLSSV :DOFNHQDHU*UnEHUS )LOLSSR3LJDIHWWDSS 8QDGHQRPLQD]LRQHIDPLOLDUHDGDOFXQHIRQWL5HODWLRGH5HJH'DYLGH«HWDOFKHVLLVSLUD IRUVHDXQDUFKHWLSRFRPXQHFRQRVFHXQ©UH['DYLGSUHVELWHU-RKDQQHVDSSHOODWXUª$OEHULFR GDOOH7UH)RQWDQHS$OWULFRQVLGHUDQRTXHVWRUHXQGLVFHQGHQWHILJOLRRQLSRWH GHOSUHWH*LDQQL©5H['DYLGILOLXV,RKDQQLVSUHVELWHUL>«@H[LWDWHUUDVXDFXPPDJQRH[HUFL WX DG VXFFXUVXP WHUU VDQFW ª -DFTXHV GH 9LWU\ S ,O SDVVR GHO YHVFRYR GL 6 *LRYDQQLG¶$FULVLULIHULUHEEHDOFRQGRWWLHURPRQJROR*HQJLV.KDQ /XGRYLFR$ULRVWR2UODQGR)XULRVR;;;,,,HV$OWURYH ©>«@$EGHVHOLEFKH YXROGLUH³6HUYRGHOOD&URFH´4XHVWR$EGHVHOLEqLOGLIHQVRUHGHOODFKLHVDGL1XELDHGL(WLR SLDHSURWHJJHLO3UHWH*LDQQLSDWULDUFDGL1XELDHGL(WLRSLDª)UDQFHVFRGD&DVWLJOLD S /¶(WLRSLDHLO3UHWH*LDQQL %DWLª«,QTXDOFKHPRGRWXWWLDSSDLRQRFRQQHVVLFRQO¶$ELVVLQLDO¶(WLRSLD ROD1XELDHFLzFRQIHUPDO¶HVLVWHQ]DGLXQDSSDUDWRVWRULFR©WDUGRªPDSHU IHWWDPHQWH VRYUDSSRQLELOH DOPHQR LQ SDUWH D XQD OHJJHQGD PHGLHYDOH QRWH YROPHQWHGLIIXVD/HLQFUHGLELOLFRQIXVLRQLHOHLQFHUWH]]HULOHYDELOLQHOOHLQ QXPHUHYROL IRQWL GLVSRQLELOL QRQ WXWWH VHOH]LRQDWH VHPEUDQR GLSHQGHUH GDO O¶XVRJHQHULFRHGDOODVRYUDSSRVL]LRQHGHLWRSRQLPL©(WLRSLDªH©,QGLDªXVDWL TXDVL IRVVHUR VLQRQLPL H DWWULEXLWL D WHUULWRUL PROWR YDVWL 1HPPHQR DOFXQH DPEDVFHULHSHUDOWUREHQGRFXPHQWDWHSDLRQRHVVHUHG¶DLXWR,OULIHULPHQWRq DOOHGHOHJD]LRQLJLXQWHGXUDQWHLOSRQWLILFDWRGHOYHQH]LDQR*DEULHOH&RQGXO PHU(XJHQLR,9HLQYLDWHDOFRQFLOLRGL)LUHQ]HGHODO WUHIRUVHWUHVRQRDWWHVWDWHQHOFRUVRGHOPDQRQVROR%LVRJQDFR PXQTXH ULFRUGDUH FKH DQFKH VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH DOOH SULPH PLVVLRQL FDWWROLFKH GHO;9,VHFODGHQRPLQD]LRQH©,QGLH2ULHQWDOLªLQFOXGHYDO¶$IULFDRULHQWDOH ILQRDO*LDSSRQHFRQODGLVWLQ]LRQHGL,QGLDFLVJDQJHWLFDRLQIHULRUH,QGLD WUDQVJDQJHWLFDRVXSHULRUODSULPDFRPSUHQVLYDDSSXQWRGHOO¶(WLRSLD %,%/,2*5$),$ $EnjشƗOL7KH&KXUFKHVDQG0RQDVWHULHVRI(J\SWDQGVRPH1HLJKERXULQJ&RXQWULHVDW WULEXWHGWR$EnjشƗOLWKH$UPHQLDQ2[IRUG&ODUHQGRQ3U$QHFGRWD2[RQLHQVLD6HPL WLF6HULHV $OEHULFR GDOOH 7UH )RQWDQH ³&KURQLFD $OEULFLPRQDFKL 7ULXP )RQWLXP D PRQDFKR QRYL PRQDVWHULL +RLHQVLV LQWHUSRODWD´ LQ 3 6FKHIIHU%RLFKRUVW HG 0RQXPHQWD *HUPDQL +LVWRULFD6FULSWRUXP;;,,,+DQQRYHUDH,PSHQVLV%LEOLRSROLL$XOLFL+DKQLDQLSS %HFNLQJKDP&)$Q(WKLRSLDQ(PEDVV\WR(XURSHFLQ&)%HFNLQJKDP%+D PLOWRQ HGV3UHVWHU-RKQWKH 0RQJROVDQGWKH 7HQ /RVW 7ULEHV $OGHUVKRW 9DULRUXP SS %HHVWRQ$)/³DEDVKDWDQGDƗEƯVK´LQ3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH6HPLQDUIRU$UDELDQ6WX GLHVSS %LQL0DF$QWLFKLSODQLVIHULHSRUWRODQL0RGHQD,O%XOLQR±<3UHVV,7HVRULGHOOH %LEOLRWHFKH,WDOLDQH *URVVSD *LOO /D GLFLWXUD FRUUHWWD SHU TXHVWR FRQFLOLR VDUHEEH ©&RQFLOLR GL %DVLOHD)HUUDUD)L UHQ]H5RPDª,OFRQFLOLRFRQYRFDWRGD0DUWLQR92GGRQH&RORQQDVLVYROVHD%D VLOHDVHVVLRQL)HUUDUDVHVVLRQL)LUHQ]HVHVVLRQLH5RPDVHVVLRQLGDOOXJOLR DODJRVWR &DUGLQL /HIHYUH,G 5RVD&RQWH %RWHUR*/H5HODWLRQL8QLYHUVDOL9LFHQ]D*LRUJLR*UHFR %UDQFDFFL)³'LDULRGL)HOLFH%UDQFDFFLDPEDVFLDWRUHFRQ&DUOR)HGHULJKLDO&DLURSHULO &RPXQHGL)LUHQ]H´LQ'&DWHOODFFLDFLQ$UFKLYLRVWRULFRLWDOLDQRVHUD SS &DUGLQL)³8QDYHUVLRQHYROJDUHGHOGLVFRUVRGHJOL©DPEDVFLDWRULªHWLRSLFLDOFRQFLOLRGL )LUHQ]H´LQ$UFKLYLRVWRULFRLWDOLDQRSS &DWDODQLGD6pYpUDF*0LUDELOLDGHVFULSWD7KH:RQGHUVRIWKH(DVWE\)ULDU-RUGDQXV WUDQVODWHGIURPWKH/DWLQ2ULJLQDODVSXEOLVKHGDW3DULVLQLQWKH5HFXHLOGHYR\DJ HVHWGHPpPRLUHVRIWKH6RFLHW\RI*HRJUDSK\ZLWKWKH$GGLWLRQRID&RPPHQWDU\LQ+ <XOHHG/RQGRQ+DNOX\W6RFLHW\:RUNVLVVXHGE\WKH+DNOX\W6RFLHW\ &HUXOOL(³,OYRORGL$VWROIRQHOO¶(WLRSLDQHOO¶2UODQGR)XULRVR´LQ5HDOH$FFDGHPLDGHL /LQFHL5HQGLFRQWLGHOODFODVVHGLVFLHQ]HPRUDOLVWRULFKHHILORORJLFKHVHUDSS ² (WLRSL LQ 3DOHVWLQD VWRULDGHOODFRPXQLWjHWLRSLFD GL*HUXVDOHPPH 5RPD /L EUHULDGHOOR6WDWR&ROOH]LRQHVFLHQWLILFDHGRFXPHQWDULD &UDZIRUG2&6HG(WKLRSLDQ,WLQHUDULHVFD&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QL YHUVLW\3UHVV7KH+DNOX\W6RFLHW\6HFRQG6HULHV ƜOL\\ƗKXEHQƖVKƝUKD/ƝZƯ$VKNHQD]L7KH0DVVRUHWKKD0DVVRUHWKRI(OLDV/HYLWDEH LQJDQH[SRVLWLRQRIWKH0DVVRUHWLFQRWHVRQWKHKHEUHZ%LEOH«LQKHEUHZZLWKDQHQJ OLVK WUDQVODWLRQ DQG FULWLFDO DQG H[SODQDWRU\ QRWHV LQ &K' *LQVEXUJ HG 1HZ <RUN .WDY3XE+RXVH7KH/LEUDU\RI%LEOLFDO6WXGLHV )DULVVRO$EUDKDPEHQ0RUGHFDL>@,JJHUHWRURW FRODPKDPHODPHGHWDGDPGHFDW ۊHOۘHKD]¶DۘOLPLPVLQLWVL¶DK=XDQGL*DUDKLH9HQH]LD*LRYDQQLGH*DUD ² ,JHUHW RUۊRܒK FRODP LG HVW ,WLQHUD PXQGL VLF GLFWD QHPSH &RVPRJUDSKLD LQ 7K +\GH$%RER\LXVHGG2[RQLL(WKHDWUR6KHOGRQLDQRLPSHQVLV+HQULFL%RQZLFNWH VWRHEUDLFRDIURQWH ²,WLQHUDPXQGLFXPLQWHUSUHWDWLRQHLQ%8JROLQLHG7KHVDXUXVDQWLTXLWDWXPVDFUD UXP FRPSOHFWHQV VHOHFWLVVLPD FODULVVLPRUXP YLURUXP RSXVFXOD LQ TXLEXV YHWHUXP KHEU RUXPPRUHVOHJHVLQVWLWXWDULWXVVDFULHWFLXLOHVLOOXVWUDQWXURSXVDGLOOXVWUDWLR QHP XWULXVTXH 7HVWDPHQWL HW DG SKLORORJLDP VDFUDP HW SURIDQDP XWLOLVVLPXP PD[L PHTXHQHFHVVDULXPYROO9HQHWLLVDS-RDQQHP*DEULHOHP+HUWK]YRO )LVFKHO:-³&RFKLQLQ-HZLVK+LVWRU\´LQ3URFHHGLQJVRI WKH $PHULFDQ $FDGHP\IRU -HZLVK5HVHDUFKSS )RUHVWLGD%HUJDPR*)6XSSOHPHQWXP&KURQLFDUXP3DULVLLVDS*DOLRWXP )UDFDQ]LRGD0RQWDOERGGRFRPSLODWRUH3DHVLQRXDPHQWHUHWURYDWL«9LFHQWLD+HQULFR 9LFHQWRVHQ]DSDJLQD]LRQH>FIU3DHVLQRXDPHQWHULWURXDWLSHUODQDXLJDWLRQHGL6SDJQD LQ&DOLFXW(WGD$OEHUWXWLR9HVSXWLR)LRUHQWLQRLQWLWXODGR0RQGR1RXR1RXDPHQWH,P SUHVVD9HQH]LD*HRUJLXVGH5XVFRQLEXVFIUKWWSJDOOLFDEQIIUVHQ]DSDJLQD]LR QHFIU3DHVLQRXDPHQWHUHWURYDWL1RYRPRQGRGD$OEHULFR9HVSXWLR)ORUHQWLQRLQWLWX ODWR5HSURGXFHGLQIDFVLPLOHIURPWKH0F&RUPLFN+RHFRS\LQWKH3ULQFHWRQ8QLYHUVLW\ /LEUDU\9HVSXFFLUHSULQWVWH[WVDQGVWXGLHV3ULQFHWRQ8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV@ ²,WLQHUDULXP3RUWXJDOOHQVLXPH/XVLWDQLDLQ,QGLDHWLQGHLQRFFLGHQWHPHWGHPXPDG DTXLORQHP0LODQR*LRYDQQL$QJHOR6FLQ]HQ]HOHU )UDQFHVFRGD&DVWLJOLD,O/LEURGHOODFRQRVFHQ]DGLWXWWLLUHJQLSDHVLHVLJQRULHFKHHVL VWRQRQHOPRQGRHGHOOHEDQGLHUHHGHJOLVWHPPLGLFLDVFXQSDHVHHVLJQRULDFRPHGHLUHH VLJQRULFKHOLJRYHUQDQRLQ&$VWHQJRDF*HQRYD(UJD0DQXDOL *DGUDW&8QHLPDJHGHO¶2ULHQWDX;,9HVLqFOH/H©0LUDELOLDGHVFULSWDªGH-RUGDQGH 6pYpUDF3DULVeFROHGHVFKDUWHV0pPRLUHVHWGRFXPHQWVGHO¶eFROHGHVFKDUWHV /¶(WLRSLDHLO3UHWH*LDQQL *DVSDUULQL/HSRUDFH7DF,O0DSSDPRQGRGL)UD0DXUR5RPD,VWLWXWR3ROLJUDILFRH =HFFDGHOOR6WDWR *LDFRPRGD9HURQD³/HSqOHULQDJHGXPRLQHDXJXVWLQ-DFTXHVGH9pURQH´LQ5 5|KULFKWpGLQ5HYXHGHO¶2ULHQW/DWLQSS *LOO-7KH&RXQFLORI)ORUHQFH1HZ<RUN$063UHVV *LRYDQQLGD6XOؾƗQƯ\HK³'HUµ/LEHOOXVGHQRWLWLDRUELV¶,RKDQQHV,,,GH*DORQLIRQWLEXV" 23(U]ELVFKRIVYRQ6XOWDQ\HK´LQ$.HUQHGLQ$UFKLYLXP)UDWUXP3U GLFDWRUXP SS &DPEUHQVH * *LUDOGL &DPEUHQVLV RSHUD ,9 6SHFXOXP (FFOHVL 'H 9LWD *DOIULGL $UFKLHSLVFRSL(ERUDFHQVLVVLYH&HUWDPLQD*DOIULGL(ERUDFHQVLV$UFKLHSLVFRSLFD LQ -6 %UHZHU HG 0LOOZRRG .UDXV UHSULQW 5HUXP %ULWDQQLFDUXP PHGLL YL VFULSWR UHV«5ROOVVHULHV>ULSUIDFVHG/RQGRQ+HU0DMHVW\¶V6WDWLRQDU\2IILFH@ *ROXERYLFK * D F %LEOLRWKHFD ELRELEOLRJUDILFD GHOOD 7HUUD 6DQWD H GHOO¶2ULHQWH )UDQFHVFDQR)LUHQ]H7LSGHO&ROOHJLRGL6%RQDYHQWXUD *URVV $ ³2QWKH %DSWLVPE\ )LUH DQG WKH 'HVLJQDWLRQV RI3UHVWHU -RKQ LQWKH +HEUHZ DQG&KULVWLDQ6RXUFHV´LQ0DWHULD*LXGDLFDSS +DOOEHUJ , /¶([WUrPH 2ULHQW GDQV OD OLWWpUDWXUH HW OD FDUWRJUDSKLH GH O¶2FFLGHQW GHV ;,,,H ;,9H HW ;9H VLqFOHV eWXGH VXU O¶KLVWRLUH GH OD JpRJUDSKLH *|WHERUJ :DOG =D FKULVVRQV%RNWU\FNHUL$% GH9LWU\-/HWWUHVGH-DFTXHVGH9LWU\pYrTXHGH6DLQW-HDQG¶$FUHLQ 5%&+X\JHQVpG/HLGHQ(-%ULOO .DPPHUHU$/DFDUWRJUDSKLHGXPRQGHRULHQWDO0HU5RXJH2FpDQ,QGLHQHW([WUrPH RULHQWMXVTX¶DX;9,,,HVLqFOH&DUWRJUDSKHVSRUWXJDLVHWIUDQoDLV/H&DLUH,QVWLWXWG¶$U FKpRORJLH2ULHQWDOH0pPRLUHVGHOD6RFLpWp5R\DOGH*pRJUDSKLHG¶(J\SWH /HDUGR*0DSSDPRQGRGL*LRYDQQL/HDUGRH/HWWHUDGHOSUHWH*LDQQLLQ$&RQWzD F0RGHQD,O%XOLQR±<3UHVV,7HVRULGHOOH%LEOLRWHFKH,WDOLDQH /HIHYUH 5 ³/D OHJJHQGD PHGLHYDOH GHO 3UHWH*LDQQL´ LQ /¶$IULFD LWDOLDQD %ROOHWWLQR GHOODVRFLHWjDIULFDQDG¶,WDOLDSS ²³1RWHVXDOFXQLSHOOHJULQLHWLRSLLQ5RPDDOWHPSRGL/HRQH;´LQ5DVVHJQDGL6WXGL (WLRSLFLSS ²³3UHVHQ]HHWLRSLFKHLQ,WDOLDSULPDGHOFRQFLOLRGL)LUHQ]HGHO´LQ5DVVHJQDGL 6WXGL(WLRSLFLSS GH 5RFKHFKRXDUW / 9R\DJH j -HUXVDOHP GH /RXLV GH 5RFKHFKRXDUW pYrTXH GH 6DLQWHV LQ&&RXGHUFpGLQ5HYXHGHO¶2ULHQW/DWLQSS /XVLQL*³$SURSRVLWRGHOOHLVFUL]LRQLVXGDUDELFKHG¶(WLRSLD´LQ6WXGLHSLJUDILFLHOLQ JXLVWLFLVXO9LFLQR2ULHQWHDQWLFRSS 0DQRHOLO)RUWXQDWRUHGL3RUWRJDOOR7KHLWDOLDQYHUVLRQRIDOHWWHUIURPWKHNLQJRI3RU WXJDO 'RP 0DQXHO WR WKH NLQJ RI &DVWLOOH )HUGLQDQG ZULWWHQ LQ JLYLQJ DQ DF FRXQWRIWKHYR\DJHVWRDQGFRQTXHVWVLQWKH(DVW,QGLHVIURPWR$'LQ$& %XUQHOOHG/RQGRQ:\PDQVRQV>HG5RP -%HVLFNHQ@ 0DULQHVFX&³/H3UrWUH-HDQ6RQSD\V([SOLFDWLRQGHVRQQRP´LQ%XOOHWLQGHOD6HF WLRQ+LVWRULTXHGHO¶$FDGpPLH5RXPDLQHSS 0LODQR(DF3ODQLVIHUR&DVWLJOLRQL&DUWDGHOQDYHJDUHXQLYHUVDOLVVLPDHWGLOLJHQWLV VLPD&*$0RGHQD%LEOLRWHFDHVWHQVHXQLYHUVLWDULDFRPPHQWDULRDOO¶HGL]LR QHLQIDFVLPLOH0RGHQD,O%XOLQR±<3UHVV$UVLOOXPLQDQGL 0LQHUYLQL / D F &URQDFD GHO 7HPSODUH GL 7LUR /D FDGXWD GHJOL 6WDWL &URFLDWL QHO UDFFRQWR GL XQ WHVWLPRQH RFXODUH >WHVWR IUDQFHVH D IURQWH@ 1DSROL /LJXRUL HGLWRUH1XRYR0HGLRHYR 5RVD&RQWH 1HXVQHU-³7KH-HZV(DVWRIWKH(XSKUDWHVDQGWKH5RPDQ(PSLUH,VWUG&HQWXULHV $'´LQ+7HPSRULQL:+DDVHHGV%HUOLQ±1HZ<RUN:DOWHUGH*UX\WHU&R $XIVWLHJXQG1LHGHUJDQJGHUU|PLVFKHQ:HOW,,SS 3LJDIHWWD ) 5HOD]LRQH GHO UHDPH GL &RQJR LQ *5 &DUGRQD D F 0LODQR %RPSLDQL 1XRYD&RURQD 3LUHQQH-/DOHJJHQGDGHO3UHWH*LDQQL*HQRYD0DULHWWL,5RPELQXRYDVHULH 3UHVFLXWWLQL 3 &RVWH GHO 0RQGR QHOOD FDUWRJUDILD HXURSHD ,YUHD 3ULXOL 9HUOXFFDHGLWRUL GH/D5RQFLqUH00ROODWGX-RXUGLQ0pGV/HV3RUWXODQVFDUWHVPDULQHVGX;,,,H VLqFOH)ULERXUJ2IILFHGX/LYUHGLII3DULV1DWKDQ GH&ODUL5/DFRQTXLVWDGL&RVWDQWLQRSROLWUDG$01DGD3DWURQH*HQR YDVH&ROODQDVWRULFDGLIRQWLHVWXGL 5XGHUPDQ'%7KH:RUOGRID5HQDLVVDQFH-HZ7KH/LIHDQG7KRXJKWRI$EUDKDPEHQ 0RUGHFDL)DULVVRO&LQFLQQDWL+HEUHZ8QLRQ&ROOHJH3U 6HJDO-%³7KH-HZVRI&RFKLQDQGWKHLU1HLJKERXUV´LQ+-=LPPHOV-5DEELQRZLW] HGV (VVD\V SUHVHQWHG WR &KLHI 5DEEL ,VUDHO %URGLH /RQGRQ -HZV¶ &ROOHJH 3XEOLFD WLRQV7KH6RQFLQR3USS 6LOYHUEHUJ5/DOHJJHQGDGHOSUHWH*LDQQL,OPLWLFRUHG¶2ULHQWHFKHLSRSROLG¶(XURSD VRJQDURQRSHUVHFROLWUDG)*HQWD%RQHOOL&DVDOH0RQIHUUDWR3LHPPH 6HPHRQLV6,WLQHUDULXP6\PRQLV6HPHRQLVDE+\EHUQLDDG7HUUDP6DQFWDPLQ 0(VSRVLWRHG'XEOLQ,QVWLWXWHIRU$GYDQFHG6WXGLHV6FULSWRUHVODWLQL+LEHUQL GL*HQWLOH6LJROL69LDJJLRDO0RQWH6LQDLWHVWRGLOLQJXDSXEEOLFDWRGDO3RJJLLQ)L UHQ]HQHOO¶DQQRHGLQXRYRPHVVRDVWDPSDLQ%3XRWLDF1DSROLGDOOD2IILFLQD 7LSRJUDILFD 8OOHQGRUI ( %HFNLQJKDP &) 7KH +HEUHZ /HWWHUV RI 3UHVWHU -RKQ 2[IRUG ± 1HZ <RUN2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV :DOFNHQDHU&$*UnEHU*³&RUUHVSRQGDQFHGH00:DOFNHQDHUHW*UnEHUVXUOHV 0DQXVFULWVG¶8VRGLPDUHFRQVHUYpVj*rQHV´LQ&0DOWH%UXQHG$QQDOHVGHV9R\D JHVGHODJpRJUDSKLHHWGHO¶KLVWRLUHYROOYRO6HFRQG6RXVFULSWLRQ>@SS :HLO6K³6\PPHWU\EHWZHHQ&KULVWLDQVDQG-HZVLQ,QGLD7KH&QDQLWH&KULVWLDQVDQG WKH&RFKLQ-HZVRI.HUDOD´LQ7+7LPEHUJHG-HZVLQ,QGLD1HZ<RUN±/RQGRQ $GYHQW%RRNV,QFSS 5,&&$5'2&217,1, 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH /DOHWWHUDWXUDGLYLDJJLRFRPHIRQWHGLLQIRUPD]LRQLOLQJXLVWLFKH 1HOO¶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¶,QVWLWXWG¶eWXGHVVpPLWLTXHVGHO&ROOqJH GH )UDQFH,Q ,WDOLD q VWDWD VRSUDWWXWWR OD SHUVSLFDFLD GL *LRUJLR 5DLPRQGR &DUGRQDSLRQLHUHLQTXHVWRFRPHLQPROWLDOWULDPELWLGHOODVXD YHUVDWLOHHFRSLRVDDWWLYLWj DVHJQDODUHO¶LPSRUWDQ]DGHLGDWLOLQJXLVWLFLGHOOD OHWWHUDWXUDRGHSRULFDQHOTXDGURGLXQDSSURFFLRHWQROLQJXLVWLFRGLDPSLHSUR 'LTXHVWRUHFDDEERQGDQWHWHVWLPRQLDQ]DO¶HFFHOOHQWHFDWDORJR±RUGLQDWRSHUFRUULVSRQGHQWL WHPDWLFKHSHUWLQHQ]DJHRJUDILFDHOLQJXLVWLFD±GHO1DFKODVVHSLVWRODUHGL6FKXFKDUGWFRQVHU YDWRQHOODELEOLRWHFDXQLYHUVLWDULDGL*UD]:ROI &RPHqQRWRQHOOHVXHFDSLWDOLULFHUFKHGLOLQJXLVWLFDQHRHWLRSLFD0DUFHO&RKHQIHFHODUJD PHQWHULFRUVRDLGRFXPHQWLOLQJXLVWLFLULSRUWDWLGDLYLDJJLDWRULSHUOLPLWDUPLDJOLHVHPSLSL VDOLHQWLULFRUGHUzVRORLFDVLGHLPDWHULDOLGL-DPHV%UXFHSHULOJDIDWGL$QWRLQH 7KRPSVRQG¶$EEDGLHSHULOJXUDJKqHGL8OULFK-DVSHU6HHW]HQSHU O¶DUJREEDPHVVLDSURILWWRLQ0&RKHQSSYL[ 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL VSHWWLYH6XTXHVWDYLDqVWDWRSURILFXDPHQWHVHJXLWRWUDJOLDOWULGD0DUFR 0DQFLQL DWWHQWR D YDJOLDUH JOL HVRWLVPL OHVVLFDOLH OH WHVWLPRQLDQ]H VRFLROLQ JXLVWLFKH UHJLVWUDWH GD DXWRUL LWDOLDQL VRSUDWWXWWR QHOOH VFULWWXUH GL YLDJJLR GL HWjXPDQLVWLFD 3HUO¶DUHDVHPLWRIRQDODOHWWHUDWXUDRGHSRULFDQRQqVWDWDDQFRUDSLHQD PHQWH ULFRQRVFLXWD QHO VXR YDORUH GRFXPHQWDULR FKH VL OLPLWD D FRQIHULUH PDJJLRUHSURIRQGLWjGLDFURQLFDDVWRULHOLQJXLVWLFKHSHUFXLDEERQGLODGRFX PHQWD]LRQHGLUHWWDPDDVVXPHLPSRUWDQ]DSULPDULDQHLFDVLLQFXLO¶LQGDJLQH GLUHWWDVXOWHUUHQRQRQVLDSRVVLELOHRSSXUHFLDWWHVWLVRORXQDGLPHQVLRQHFUR QRORJLFDPROWRUHFHQWH/DUHJLRQHGLJUDQOXQJDSULYLOHJLDWDSHUDEERQGDQ]D GLGRFXPHQWD]LRQHqVHQ]DGXEELROD3DOHVWLQDSHUFXLVRQRJLj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qVWDWDOD3HQLVRODDUDELFD5LVSHWWRDOOR<HPHQRJJHWWRGDVHFROLGLXQD ULFFDOHWWHUDWXUDRGHSRULFDVRQRVWDWHVSHFLOODWHOHQRWL]LHOHVVLFDOL±VRSUDWWXW WRLQPDWHULDGLILWRQLPL±ULSRUWDWHGDOODVSHGL]LRQHGDQHVHGHJOLDQQL GLFXLIXXQLFRWHVWLPRQHVXSHUVWLWHLOWHGHVFR&DUVWHQ1LHEXKU HQHLGLDULGLYLDJJLRGHOO¶HSLJUDILVWDDXVWULDFR(GXDUG*ODVHU $FFDQWRDOVDJJLRSURJUDPPDWLFRGL&DUGRQDPHWWHFRQWRULFRUGDUHDOPHQRLOVXRVX SHUERLQGLFHUDJLRQDWRDOODYHUVLRQHWRVFDQDGHO0LOLRQHGL0DUFR3ROR 0DQFLQLHYDULVWXGLVXFFHVVLYL 7DQWRFKHQRQqLQFOXVDWUDOHIRQWLSHUODGLDOHWWRORJLDDUDEDHOHQFDWHQHOODSHUDOWURHFFHOOHQWH UDVVHJQDGL9LFHQWHQHSSXUHLOPDJQLILFRDWODQWHRQRPDVLRORJLFRPHVVRLQFDQWLHUHQH JOLXOWLPLDQQLGD3HWHU%HKQVWHGWH0DQIUHG:RLGLFK :$'FKHDWWLQJHDIRQWLDELWXDO PHQWH SRFR IUHTXHQWDWH GDL GLDOHWWRORJL GHO QHRDUDER TXDOL L VLWL LQWHUQHW ID ULFRUVR SL FKH VSRUDGLFRDOOHVFULWWXUHGLYLDJJLR *URW]IHOG PD PROWL DOWUL GRFXPHQWL GL TXHVWR WLSR ± GL FXL PDQFD WXWWRUD XQ HOHQFR FRPSOHWR±ULPDQJRQRLQDWWHVDGLXQDGHJXDWRVFUXWLQLROLQJXLVWLFR %HFNHUV%UDOO7XFKHOH5HLFKHUWHXOWLPDPHQWH%M¡UQV¡V 6WRULDGHOODVSHGL]LRQHHULIHULPHQWLELEOLRJUDILFLHVVHQ]LDOLLQ3IXOOPDQQSSH SDVVLP ,ULVXOWDWLOHVVLFRORJLFLGHOODVSHGL]LRQHVRQRYDJOLDWLLQ3URYHQoDO 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH H LQILQH LO FRORULWRXQLFXP UDSSUHVHQWDWR GDOOD SRWHQ]LDOPHQWH DVVDL SUH]LRVDPHVVHGLLQVHUWLLQDUDER±FROORFDWLQHOGLVFRUVRGLUHWWRFRVuGDDF FUHGLWDUHTXDVLXQ¶LPSUHVVLRQHGL³UHJLVWUD]LRQHIRQRJUDILFD´VHFRQGRODIH OLFHHVSUHVVLRQHGL&DUGRQD±GHOFHOHEUH,WLQHUDULR5RPDGHOO¶DY YHQWXULHURERORJQHVH/XGRYLFRGL9DUWHPDDYYLQFHQWHVHSXUHLQEXRQDSDU WH ILWWL]LR UHVRFRQWR GL XQ¶HVSHULHQ]D GL YLDJJLRFKH VSD]LD GD 9HQH]LD DOOH 0ROXFFKH SDVVDQGR SHU LO /HYDQWH OD 3HQLVROD DUDELFD O¶(WLRSLD OD 3HUVLD O¶,QGLDHOD0DOHVLD1HLVXRLVSH]]RQLGLDUDERSDUODWRVLqYROXWRYHGHUHOD WHVWLPRQLDQ]D DGGLULWWXUD GL XQ SLGJLQ DEDVH DUDED FRUUHQWH LQ $UDELD PHUL GLRQDOHQHO;9,VHFRORVHTXHVWDLSRWHVLGL*LXOLR6RUDYLDQRQKDWUR YDWR PROWRFUHGLWRSDUHQGRSUHIHULELOHLQWHUSUHWDUHO¶DUDERYDUWHPLDQRFRPH OD IRVVLOL]]D]LRQH GL XQD YDULHWj G¶DSSUHQGLPHQWR R LQWHUOLQJXDO¶LQWHUHVVH WLSRORJLFRGLTXHVWDIRUPDGLDUDERGLUDULVVLPDDWWHVWD]LRQHULPDQHLQQHJD ELOHHUDIIRU]DODIDPDGLDFXWRRVVHUYDWRUHGHOODUHDOWjOLQJXLVWLFD³DOWUD´JLj JXDGDJQDWD D 9DUWHPD GDOOD VXD FHOHEUH GHVFUL]LRQHGHL VXRQL DYXOVLYL GHOOH OLQJXHEDQWXGDOXLXGLWLGXUDQWHXQRVFDORLQ0R]DPELFRVXOODYLDGHOULWRUQR LQ(XURSD6RQRSHUzLQSULPROXRJROHWHVWLPRQLDQ]HGLDUDEREHGXLQRGHO O¶$UDELD FHQWUDOH VRSUDWWXWWR GHO WLSR FKH RJJL VL GHILQLVFHQDЂGƯULSRUWDWH GDLYLDJJLDWRULHXURSHLGHO;,;HSULPR;;VHFRORFKHKDQQRVXVFLWDWRO¶LQWH UHVVH GHL GLDOHWWRORJL GHOO¶DUDER PHQWUH +HLNNL 3DOYD KD RSHUDWR XQR VFDQGDJOLRUDSSUHVHQWDWLYRGHOOHQRWL]LHOLQJXLVWLFKHULSRUWDWHGDYLDJJLDWRULLQ $UDELDFHQWUDOHFRQFHQWUDQGRVLVXLGLDULSRVWXPLLQVYHGHVHGHOVXRFRPSD WULRWDILQODQGHVH*HRUJ$XJXVWXV:DOOLQORVFULYHQWHVLqVIRU]D WRGLDUJRPHQWDUHO¶DWWHQGLELOLWjILQRUDSHUORSLPLVFRQRVFLXWDGLDOPHQRXQD SDUWHGHOOHVVLFRDUDERQDЂGƯULFRQRVFLELOHQHOJORVVDULRDFXUDGL0LFKHO-DQ GH *RHMH JUDQGH FRQRVFLWRUH GHOO¶DUDER FODVVLFR SLXWWRVWR FKH GHOOHSDUODWHEHGXLQHFKHDFFRPSDJQDLPRQXPHQWDOL7UDYHOVLQ$UDELD'H VHUWDñGL&KDUOHV0RQWDJXH'RXJKW\ 0ROWLVVLPRODYRURULPDQHWXWWDYLDDQFRUDGDVYROJHUHQRQVROWDQWRQHOOD ULFRJQL]LRQHGHOOHUHOD]LRQLGLYLDJJLRSRWHQ]LDOPHQWHSLLQWHUHVVDQWLRELHW 4XHVWRSUH]LRVRPDWHULDOHqVFUXSRORVDPHQWHFHQVLWRHLQWHUSUHWDWRQHOJORVVDULRGL%HKQVWHGW &DUGRQDS 6LYHGDQRLQSDUWLFRODUHOHFRQVLGHUD]LRQLGL0DQFLQLSSH&RQWLQL 5LIHULPHQWLLQ&RQWLQLSHQ 3HUFXLLOSXQWRGLULIHULPHQWRLPSUHVFLQGLELOHqODPRQRJUDILDGL,QJKDP &RQWLQL 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL WLYRIDFLOLWDWRSHUO¶$UDELDGDOODGLVSRQLELOLWjGLELEOLRJUDILHVSHFLILFKHHGLUH SHUWRUvVXJJHVWLYLFRPHLOUHFHQWH'XUFK:VWHXQG6WHSSH(QWGHFNHUOH[LNRQ DUDELVFKH+DOELQVHOGL8ZH3IXOOPDQQPDVRSUDWWXWWRQHOYDJOLRGHOO¶DWWHQ GLELOLWj GHOOH ORUR WHVWLPRQLDQ]H SHU OD ULFRVWUX]LRQH GL XQD VWRULD OLQJXLVWLFD SHUFXLODQRVWUDGRFXPHQWD]LRQHGLUHWWDqODFXQRVDRDGGLULWWXUDGHOWXWWRDV VHQWHVRORO¶HVDPHGHOODFRPSHWHQ]DOLQJXLVWLFDGHLGLYHUVLDXWRULUDUDPHQWH OLQJXLVWLGLSURIHVVLRQHDUDELVWLRVHPLWLVWLSLVSHVVRYLDJJLDWRULWDQWRHQWX VLDVWLGHOOHFXOWXUHFRQFXLHQWUDYDQRLQFRQWDWWRTXDQWRVSURYYLVWLGHJOLVWUX PHQWL HXULVWLFL SHU FRPSUHQGHUOH R DQFKH VROR SHUDFTXLVLUQH OH SURGX]LRQL OLQJXLVWLFKH6RORXQRVFUXWLQLRFDVRSHUFDVRSRWUjGXQTXHOLPLWDUHLOULVFKLR GLGDUHFUHGLWRDWHVWLPRQLDQ]HGXEELHHGLVRYUDLQWHUSUHWDUHLOULVXOWDWRGHOOR URVFDQGDJOLR$SSXQWRDOORVFRSRGLUHFXSHUDUHPDWHULDOLOHVVLFDOLQHRVHPL WLFL SRWHQ]LDOPHQWH SUH]LRVL GDOOD1HEHQEHUOLHIHUXQJ RGHSRULFD RFFLGHQWDOH PLVRQRGHGLFDWRLQTXHVWDVHGHDWUHVROLFDVHVWXGLHVWUDLPROWLSRVVLELOLGL OLVWHGLYRFDEROLULSRUWDWLQHOODFRSLRVLVVLPDOHWWHUDWXUDGLYLDJJLRFKHGREELD PRDOODSHQQDGLXQRGHLSLFHOHEUL±HIDPRVDPHQWHSROLWLFDOO\XQFRUUHFW± YLDJJLDWRULEULWDQQLFLGLHWjYLWWRULDQD5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQ 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHOHVXHFDSDFLWjGLOLQJXLVWD 3HUODPDJJLRUSDUWHGHLOHWWRULLOQRPHGL5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQ qDVVRFLDWRDOVXRYLDJJLRDOOD0HFFDQHOWUDYHVWLWRGDSHOOHJULQR DIJDQR R DO VXR VIRUWXQDWR WHQWDWLYR GL HVSORUDUH OH VRUJHQWL GHO1LOR%LDQFR FRQ-RKQ+DQQLQJ6SHNHWUDLOHLOJOLDSSDVVLRQDWLGHOOHQRW WHFRQRVFHUDQQRDOPHQRGLIDPDODVXDWUDGX]LRQHLQWHJUDOH±FLRqRVWHQWDWD PHQWHOLFHQ]LRVD±GLTXHVWRFODVVLFRGHOODQRYHOOLVWLFDRULHQWDOH 0D%XUWRQQHOVHJXLWR%qVWDWRPROWRSLGLTXHVWRSHUFRQYLQFHUVH QHqVXIILFLHQWHXQVHPSOLFHVJXDUGRDOODVXDELEOLRJUDILDFRPSLODWDIDPRVD PHQWHGD1LFKRODV3HQ]HUQHOHVXFFHVVLYDPHQWHLQWHJUDWDVRSUDWWXWWRGD -DPHV &DVDGD H GDO FROOH]LRQLVWD GL %XUWRQLDQD %XUNH &DVDULRSSXUH DO O¶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qIRUVHLOTXDVLDOWUHWWDQWRLQ JHQWH7KHWDQJOHGZHEGL-RQ5*RGVDOO/DVXDRSHUDHODVXDILJXUDGL DYYHQWXULHURURPDQWLFRKDQQRDQFKHLVSLUDWRPROWHSOLFLURPDQ]LLYLFRPSUH VRXQ³JLDOOR´SHUELEOLRILOL7KHERRNPDQ¶VSURPLVHGL-RKQ'XQQLQJ HDOPHQRXQILOP0RXQWDLQVRIWKHPRRQGL%RE5DIHOVRQ 8Q³PHGDJOLRQH´GLTXHOORFKHLVXRLFRQWHPSRUDQHLEULWDQQLFLDYHYDQR VRSUDQQRPLQDWR³'LUW\'LFN´R³5XIILDQ'LFN´VLSXzULFDYDUHGDXQDFROODQD GL DOFXQH GHOOH IUDVL SL VLJQLILFDWLYH FKH JOL GHGLFD LO UHFHQWH FRPSHQGLR,O YLDJJLRLQ2ULHQWHGHOO¶DQJOLVWDGHOO¶8QLYHUVLWjGL6LHQDHGHVSHUWRGLOHWWHUD WXUDRGHSRULFD$WWLOLR%ULOOL 3HUORVSLULWRG¶DYYHQWXUDHLOWHPSHUDPHQWRVDQJXLJQRODYLVLRQHLPSHULDOLVWLFDHOD VWHUPLQDWDFXOWXUDHJOLYLHQHFRQVLGHUDWRGDLFRQWHPSRUDQHLXQSHUVRQDJJLRGLSXUR VWDPSRHOLVDEHWWLDQR/DVXDVWHVVDILVLRQRPLDKDTXDOFRVDGLLQTXLHWDQWHVHDOSRHWD HVSORUDWRUH:LOIULG6FDZHQ%OXQWLOYROWRGL%XUWRQ±GHWXUSDWRVRWWROR]LJRPRGDXQ WHUULELOHFROSRGL]DJDJOLD±DSSDUHLOSL³VLQLVWUR´FKHJOLVLDFDSLWDWRGLYHGHUH³R VFXURFUXGHOHWUDGLWRUHFRQJOLRFFKLGLXQDQLPDOHVHOYDJJLR´ $QFRUDWUHULJKHFRQGHQVDQRODSROLHGULFLWjGHOODILJXUDGL%HGDQQRUL VDOWRDOVXROLEURSLULXVFLWRVHSXUHQRQSHUPHLOSLXWLOHDLSUHVHQWLILQL 1HOO¶LPPHQVD SURGX]LRQH GRFXPHQWDULD H QDUUDWLYD GL % YLDJJLDWRUH DYYHQWXULHUR OLQJXLVWDWUDGXWWRUHDUFKHRORJRGLSORPDWLFRDQWURSRORJRVHVVXRORJRHGHURWRPDQH ODUHOD]LRQHGHOSHOOHJULQDJJLRD0HGLQDHDOOD0HFFDUHVWDO¶RSHUDGLPDJJLRUULOLHYR HTXHOODFKHPHJOLRHSLFRPSLXWDPHQWHGLRJQLDOWUDORUDSSUHVHQWD 6RVWLHQHLQILQH%ULOOL >%@SHUODSUROLILFLWjGHOODVFULWWXUDHSHUO¶DPSLRUDJJLRHODSHUVSLFDFLDGHOORVJXDU GRqXQDVRUWDGL&KDUOHV'LFNHQVGHOODOHWWHUDWXUDGLYLDJJLR %ULOOLSHQ/¶LFRQRJUDILDYXOJDWDGL%SDUUHEEHJLXVWLILFDUHTXHVWRJLXGL]LRGL %OXQWDQFK¶HJOLHVSORUDWRUHGHOO¶$UDELDFHQWUDOHLOFHOHEUHULWUDWWRGL)UHGHULFN /HLJKWRQULSURGRWWRLQPROWHGHOOHELRJUDILHGL%LQJHQWLOLVFHDOTXDQWRO¶HIIHWWRGHOODFLFDWUL FHGHOODIHULWDGL%HUEHUDVHSXUHQRQGLVVLPXODGHOWXWWRLOVXRVJXDUGRGLEDVLOLVFR &RPH YHGUHPRDOWULVFULWWLGLPROWRPLQRUYDORUHQDUUDWLYRHSHULHJHWLFRGLIDWWRLOOXVWUDQR PHJOLRLOFRQWULEXWRGL%DOODQRVWUDFRQRVFHQ]DGHOOHVVLFRDUDERGLDOHWWDOH %ULOOLS %ULOOLS 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL 4XHVW¶XOWLPR JLXGL]LR q FHUWR FDO]DQWH SHU LO UHVRFRQWR GHO YLDJJLR DOOD 0HFFDGDFXLVRQRWUDWWLJOLHVHPSLFKHLOOXVWUDQRTXHVWDYLYDFHYHQDGHVFULW WLYDHSHUSRFKLDOWULGHLVXRLOLEULGHJOLDQQLLQRSHUHVXFFHVVLYHSHUz L EUDQL GL % GL PDJJLRUH LQWHUHVVH DQWURSRORJLFR VRQR VSHVVR DSSHVDQWLWL GD XQ DFFXPXOR GL QRWH HUXGLWH H GL GLJUHVVLRQL SROHPLFKH FKH FRPSURPHWWRQR VHQVLELOPHQWH O¶DPHQLWj GHOOD OHWWXUD VHQ]D SHUDOWUR LQWDFFDUQH LO YDORUH GR FXPHQWDULR /DSHUWLQHQ]DGL%DJOLVWXGLOLQJXLVWLFLVLGHYHLQSULPROXRJRDOODVXD UHSXWD]LRQHGLHVVHUHVWDWRXQRGHLOLQJXLVWVSLGRWDWLGHO;,;VHFRORTXHVWR YDOHHYLGHQWHPHQWHQHOVHQVRGL©SROLJORWWDªHVSUHVVRGDOWHUPLQHLQJOHVHPD QRQ VRQR PDQFDWL WUD JOL DPLFL H L ELRJUDIL GL %GHOOD FDWHJRULD FKH VSLULWL SLFULWLFLKDQQRVRSUDQQRPLQDWRLNHHSHUVRIWKHIODPHFRORURFKHKDQQRDV VHULWRODWHVLFKH%DYHVVHDQFKHOHTXDOLWjGLXQSURIHVVLRQLVWDGHOOHVFLHQ]H GHOOLQJXDJJLRGLXQYHUROLQJXLVWDO¶DOWURVHQVRGLOLQJXLVWDYUHEEHLQVRPPD SRVVHGXWRVHFRQGRODWHUPLQRORJLDLQWURGRWWDGD6\OYDLQ$XURX[WDOHQWLWDQWR HSLOLQJXLVWLFLTXDQWRPHWDOLQJXLVWLFLÊTXHVWDO¶RSLQLRQHWUDJOLDOWULGHOVXR SLJLRYDQHDPLFR$UFKLEDOG+HQU\6D\FHSUROLILFRDVVLULRORJR HGHJLWWRORJRFKHIXSHUTXDOFKHDQQRSURIHVVRUHGLOLQJXLVWLFDFRPSDUDWDD 2[IRUGHLPSOLFLWDPHQWHDQFKHGHOO¶LQVLJQHVSHFLDOLVWDGLVWRULRJUDILDOLQJXL VWLFD.RQUDG.RHUQHUFKHKDLQFOXVR%QHOVXRUHJHVWRELRJUDILFRGHLSUDWL FDQWLGHOOHVFLHQ]HGHOOLQJXDJJLR/DJUDQGHUHSXWD]LRQHGLSROLJORWWDGL% qGRYXWDLQSULPROXRJRDOODVXDFDUULHUDDOVHUYL]LRGHOOD(DVW,QGLD&RPSD Q\GRYHDYHYDVXSHUDWREULOODQWHPHQWHJOLHVDPLGLLQWHUSUHWHLQ³KLQGXVWDQL´ KLQGLXUGXVDQVFULWREHQJDOLJXMDUDWLSDVKWRSHUVLDQRH±DTXHOFKHHJOL VWHVVR ODVFLz FUHGHUH ± GL DUDER 1HJOL DQQL VXFFHVVLYL % DYUHEEH DSSUHVR PROWH DOWUH OLQJXH DVLDWLFKHH DIULFDQH FKH YHQLYDQR DGDJJLXQJHUVL DOOH OLQ JXHFODVVLFKHHDOOHSULQFLSDOLHXURSHHIUDQFHVHWHGHVFRLWDOLDQRSRUWRJKH VH FKH LQ SDUWH SUDWLFDYD ILQ GDOO¶DGROHVFHQ]D SDVVDWD LQ GLYHUVL SDHVL GHO O¶(XURSD FRQWLQHQWDOH ROWUH FKH LQ ,QJKLOWHUUD 8QD VWHUPLQDWD VHULH GL WUDGX ]LRQLOHWWHUDULHGDOVDQVFULWRGDOODWLQRGDOO¶LWDOLDQRHVRSUDWWXWWRGDOO¶DUDER DSSDUVHQHJOLDQQLGHOODPDWXULWjHGHOODYHFFKLDLDDYHYDXOWHULRUPHQWHDFFUH VFLXWRODVXDIDPDGLFRQRVFLWRUHGLOLQJXH%VWHVVRKDODVFLDWRXQDFHOHEUH GHVFUL]LRQH GHO VXR PHWRGR GL DSSUHQGLPHQWR GL XQDOLQJXD HYLGHQWHPHQWH GL XQD OLQJXD JLj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«@:KHQHYHU,FRQYHUVHGZLWKDQ\ERG\LQDODQJXDJHWKDW,ZDVOHDUQLQJ, WRRNWKHWURXEOHWRUHSHDWWKHLUZRUGVLQDXGLEO\DIWHUWKHPDQGVRWROHDUQWKHWULFNRI SURQXQFLDWLRQDQGHPSKDVLV 5HFHQWHPHQWH SHUz OD VXD FRPSHWHQ]D GL DUDELVWDDPPHVVD VHQ]D GL VFXVVLRQHSHUVLQRGDLGHQXQFLDWRULGHLVXRLSUHJLXGL]LHWQRFHQWULFLGL2ULHQWD OLVWFRPH(GZDUG6DLGqVWDWDUHYRFDWDLQGXEELRGDSLSDUWLVLDSHUTXDQ WR ULJXDUGD OD VXD FRQRVFHQ]D GHOO¶DUDER OHWWHUDULR H PHGLR FKH HPHUJH LQ SDUWLFRODUHGDOODVXDSUHFLWDWDIDPRVDWUDGX]LRQHGHOOHQRWWHSHUFXLHUD VWDWR DFFXVDWR ± JLj FLUFD XQ VHFROR ID ± GL DYHU SODJLDWR LO VXR FRQFRUUHQWH -RKQ3DLQHVLDDSURSRVLWRGHOODVXDSDGURQDQ]DGHLGLDOHWWLQHRDUDELDSUR SRVLWRGLTXHVWD:LOKHOP6SLWWD±LQVLJQHDUDELVWDWHGHVFRUHVL GHQWHDO&DLURDXWRUHGLXQDDQFRUDIRQGDPHQWDOHJUDPPDWLFDGHOGLDOHWWRD UDERORFDOH>@±FRQVLGHUDYDO¶DUDERSDUODWRGL%TXDOLWDWLYDPHQWHLQIH ULRUH D TXHOOR GHO VXR SL JLRYDQH DPLFR :LOOLDP 5REHUWVRQ 6PLWK &LWRGDOODVH]LRQHDXWRELRJUDILFDGL%LQFRUSRUDWDLQ,%XUWRQ,S6XOOHFRPSH WHQ]HOLQJXLVWLFKHGL%HVXOODVWRULDGHOODORURDFTXLVL]LRQHVLYHGDVRSUDWWXWWR*RGVDOO SSHOLQJXHLQGLDQHSHUVLDQRDUWLFROLOLQJXLVWLFLJLRYDQLOLVXOSDVKWRH VXOEDORFLVRPDORKDUDULQROLQJXHDPHULQGLDQHGHJOL6WDWL8QLWL OLQJXHGHO'DKRPH\HSDVVLP%qLQFOXVRWUDJOLLSHUSROLJORWWLGHOSDVVDWRGLVFXVVLXOWLPD PHQWH GD 0LFKDHO (UDUG S H Q HSDVVLP FKH ULOHYD SHUz FKH HJOL QRQ VHPEUD DYHUFRQWUROODWRFRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH³OHOLQJXHHJOLGLDOHWWL´GLFXLJOLRPHJOLRVL HUD DFFUHGLWDWD OD FRQRVFHQ]D 0L q ILQRUD ULPDVWRLQDFFHVVLELOH LO VDJJLR GL -DPHV 0LOWRQ ³7KHOHVVRQV RI H[FHOOHQFH 6LU 5LFKDUG )UDQFLV %XUWRQ DQG ODQJXDJH OHDUQLQJ´LQ7KH /LQ JXLVWSS 6DLGSSHSDVVLP 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL LOTXDOHSHUSDUWHVXDUDFFRQWDYDFRQXQFHUWRFRPSLDFLPHQWRFKHGX UDQWH XQ YLDJJLR FRQ % QHOGHVHUWR RFFLGHQWDOHGHOO¶(JLWWR QHO ODORUR JXLGDEHGXLQDDYUHEEHGHWWRDOVXRãD\ې³1RQSDUODUHFRQTXHOORJURVVR>% HUDDOWRPHODUJRFRPHXQDUPDGLR@LOSLFFROHWWR>:56P@FDSL VFHODQRVWUDOLQJXDPROWRPHJOLR´1RQKRFRPSHWHQ]DVXIILFLHQWHSHUJLX GLFDUH VXO SLDQR OLQJXLVWLFR OD IDPRVD ± H IDPLJHUDWD ± YHUVLRQH EXUWRQLDQD GHOOHQRWWHPDWHQWHUzGLYDOXWDUHODVXDFRQRVFHQ]DGHOO¶DUDERGLDOHW WDOHVXOODEDVHGLXQRVSRJOLRTXDVLHVDXVWLYRGHOOHRVVHUYD]LRQLOLQJXLVWLFKH GLVVHPLQDWHGD%QHLVXRLUHVRFRQWLGLYLDJJLRLQUHJLRQLDUDERIRQHHDQFKH DOODOXFHGHLGDWLFKHHJOLIRUQLVFHVXDOWUHOLQJXHVHPLWLFKHPRGHUQHQRQFKp GHOODFRQVXOWD]LRQHGHOFDWDORJRGHLVXSHUVWLWLOLEULGDOXLSRVVHGXWLFRPSLODWR GD-HDQ.LUNSDWULFNDOILQHGLULQWUDFFLDUYLODSUHVHQ]DGLRSHUHGLOLQ JXLVWLFDVHPLWLFDHJHQHUDOHVRQRWXWWDYLDFRQVDSHYROHFKHVROWDQWRO¶LVSH]LR QHGLUHWWDGHLTXDVLYROXPLGHOODVXDELEOLRWHFDVIXJJLWLDOODGLVWUX]LRQH RDOODGLVSHUVLRQHHRJJLFRQVHUYDWLQHOIRQGR%XUWRQGHOOD+XQWLQJWRQ/LEUD U\GL6DQ0DULQRLQ&DOLIRUQLDSRWUHEEHULYHODUHLPSRUWDQWLDSSXQWLGLOHWWXUD DXWRJUDILFRPHTXHOOLGLFXLqVWDWRSRVVLELOHWUDUUHSDUWLWRQHOGLEDWWLWRUHFHQ WHVXDOWULDVSHWWLGHOODVXDRSHUD ,QTXHVWDRFFDVLRQHPLOLPLWHUzDSDVVDUHLQUDVVHJQDPROWRUDSLGDPHQWH VRSUDWWXWWRLPDWHULDOLGLQDWXUDOHVVLFDOHRIIHUWLGD%VXOKDUDULQRQHRHWLRSL FRPHULGLRQDOHHVXOQHRDUDPDLFRGL0DµOnjODQRQFKpXQDVFHOWDVRORUDSSUH VHQWDWLYDGHOOHVXHRVVHUYD]LRQLVXGXHYDULHWjGLDUDERGLDOHWWDOH /DSULPDGHVFUL]LRQHGHOKDUDULQR ,OPHULWRPDJJLRUHGL%SHUODOLQJXLVWLFDVHPLWLFDVLSXzULFRQRVFHUHQHO VXRHVVHUHVWDWRLOSULPRDIRUQLUHLQXQ¶DSSHQGLFH±VSHVVRRPHVVDQHOOHUL VWDPSH±GL)LUVWIRRWVWHSVLQ(DVW$IULFDXQDGHVFUL]LRQHJUDPPDWLFD 6HQ]DSUHWHVDGLFRPSOHWH]]DVLYHGDQRDOPHQR*RGVDOO7KURZHUDQHGGRWLGL 6SLWWDH6PLWK,UZLQSSV*RGVDOOSSVVVHSDVVLP 'LFXLLOIRUWXQDWRFRPSDQLRQGL,UZLQðSSKDGDWRXQJLXGL]LRSLXWWRVWRVHYHUR XQD ³GLVWLQFWO\ XQDWWUDFWLYH WUDQVODWLRQ´ ³DQ RPQLXP JDWKHUXP WUDQVODWLRQ´ EDVDWD VX XQD FROOD]LRQHDFULWLFDGLXQDFRQJHULHHWHURJHQHDGLWHVWLDVWDPSDHGLPDQRVFULWWLDUDELHVHJXLWD QRQVHQ]DHUURULHGHVSHUHQGRXQDWUDVOLWWHUD]LRQHGHOO¶DUDERFKHSDUHRJJLDUFDLFDHIDUUDJL QRVD 6LYHGDLQSDUWLFRODUH-XW]LEFKHFRPSXWDDFDLOQXPHURGLOLEULFKH%DYHYDD 7ULHVWHROWUHPHWjPDQFKHUHEEHURGXQTXHDOO¶DSSHOOR 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH OH>%SS %,,SS@HXQJORVVDULRSLXWWRVWR FRQVLVWHQWH >% SS % ,, SS @ FRPH SXUH SRFKLEUHYL³WHVWLGLOLQJXD´>TXDOFKHIUDVHHGLDORJRHXQDFDQ]RQHLQWUDVFUL ]LRQH H WUDGX]LRQH LQJOHVH % SS % ,, SS @GHOODYDULHWjHWLRVHPLWLFDGHOO¶HPLUDWRLVODPLFRGL+DUDUFKHHJOLYLVLWz LQPRGRIUHWWRORVRQHOFRUVRGHOO¶LQYHUQRGDQGRSURYDGLXQFRUDJ JLR H GL XQR VSLULWR G¶RVVHUYD]LRQH YHUDPHQWH QRWHYROL 4XHVWR LPSRUWDQWH FRQWULEXWRqVWDWRWXWWDYLDQHOVHJXLWRVSHVVRWUDVFXUDWRVHQRQDGGLULWWXUDGHO WXWWRGLPHQWLFDWRÊTXHVWRLOFDVR±YDGHWWRSLXWWRVWRSDUDGRVVDOH±SHUVLQR GHOO¶DUWLFRORFKH-RQ$EELQNKDGHGLFDWRD%XUWRQQHOODQXRYDDXWRUHYROH(Q F\FORSDHGLD$HWKLRSLFDLQFRUVRGLILQDOL]]D]LRQHDG$PEXUJRLOVXRYLDJJLR D +DUDU q FHUWR PHQ]LRQDWR FRPH SXUH O¶RPDJJLR UHVR GDL VXFFHVVRUL GL % QHOORVWXGLRGL+DUDUDOODVXDDFFXUDWDGHVFUL]LRQHGHOODFLWWjPDQRQXQDSD URODVXOSULPRSURILORGHOODOLQJXDFKHDOXLVLGHYH ,SURIHVVLRQLVWLGHOODOLQJXLVWLFDHWLRVHPLWLFDSHUDOWURDSDUWLUHGD)UDQ] 3UDHWRULXVKDQQRWHQXWRFRQWRGHOODYRURSLRQLHULVWLFRGL%PDLQXRYL PDWHULDOL WHVWXDOL H OHVVLFDOL SURFXUDWL VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH VRSUDWWXWWR GD3KLOLSS 3DXOLWVFKNHH/XLJL5REHFFKL%ULFFKHWWL)UDQoRLV0D ULH &DVLPLU 0RQGRQ9LGDLOKHW H &DUOR &RQWL 5RVVLQL WXWWL ULHGLWLFRQXQLPSRUWDQWHFRPPHQWROLQJXLVWLFRGD(QQR/LWWPDQQKDQ QRFRQVHQWLWRSURJUHVVLGHFLVLYLQHOORVWXGLRGHOKDUDULQRVHJQDWRGDQXPHUR VLVWXGLGLFXLPLOLPLWHUzDHQXPHUDUHTXLOHWDSSHIRQGDPHQWDOLOHeWXGHV G¶pWKLRSLHQPpULGLRQDOGL0DUFHO&RKHQ/DOLQJXDHODVWRULDGL+DUDU GL(QULFR&HUXOOL7KHYHUELQ+DUDULHO¶(W\PRORJLFDOGLFWLRQD U\RI+DUDULGL:ROI/HVODXILQRDLODYRULSLUHFHQWLGL (ZDOG:DJQHUGLFXLEDVWHUjTXLULFRUGDUHO¶HFFHOOHQWHVLQWHVLJUDPPDWLFDOH QHOYROXPH6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVGLUHWWRGD5REHUW+HW]URQHLOJUDQGHUH SHUWRULR ELEOLRJUDILFR FKH UHJLVWUD WDQWR L FRQWULEXWL GL % TXDQWR JOL VWXGL SULQFLSDOL VXO VXR YLDJJLR G¶HVSORUD]LRQH SUHVVR LO WHPLELOH HPLUR $ত PDGE$EƯ%DNUHLOVXRJlUƗGFDSRWULEDOH$GDQ 1HOOD ELEOLRJUDILD HWLRVHPLWLFD GL /HVODX VRQR ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH L OHPPL H $EELQNS1RQFRQGLYLGHLQYHFHTXHVWDRPLVVLRQHFRPHYHGUHPRLOSLUHFHQWH SURILORGHOKDUDULQRVWLODWRGD(ZDOG:DJQHU :DJQHUSSDE$TXHVWRUHSHUWRULRVLULQYLDSHUEUHYLWjDQFKHSHUOHFRRUGLQD WHELEOLRJUDILFKHGHJOLVWXGLVXHOHQFDWL 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL 9D VXELWR SUHFLVDWR FKH TXHVWD RSHUD GL SLRQLHUH IX UHDOL]]DWD LQ FRQGL ]LRQLGLHVWUHPDGLIILFROWjLQWUHJLRUQLVROWDQWRGXUDQWHXQDWDSSD±VXLPRQ WL*LUKL±GHOVXRYLDJJLRGLULWRUQRGD+DUDUYHUVRODFRVWD%ODYRUzFRQ LQIRUPDWRUL ©XQ FLWWDGLQR GL +DUDU EDQGLWR GDOOD FLWWjª ULPDVWR DQRQLPR O¶DQ]LDQREHGXLQR6DµLG:DOHO¶HORTXHQWHSRHWDVRPDOR$OL6KDµLULQVHJXLWR ULYLGHLVXRLDSSXQWLDG$GHQFRQO¶DLXWRGHOO¶DPLFRWHQHQWH(GZDUG'DQVH\ DVVLVWHQWHGHO3ROLWLFDO$JHQWEULWDQQLFRORFDOHHUHSXWDWRHVVHUH XQ©WDOHQWHGOLQJXLVWªHGHOVRPDOR)DULK'LEDQL,QYHULWj%QRQLGHQWLIL FzLOKDUDULQRFRPHXQDOLQJXDVHPLWLFDLQGLSHQGHQWHPDSLXWWRVWRFRPH©VH PLVHPLWLFDªVRWWROLQHDQGRQHODFRPSRQHQWHFXVFLWLFDRURPRFKHYLFRQYLYH FRQO¶DUDED/DGHVFUL]LRQHJUDPPDWLFDOHGL%qLQROWUHFRPSURPHVVDGDOIDW WRFKHIXRUYLDWRGDLVXRLLQIRUPDWRULDOPHQRXQRGHLTXDOLFRPHVLqYLVWR QRQHUDPDGUHOLQJXDQRQULFRQREEHGLYHUVLDVSHWWLGHOODPRUIRORJLDVRSUDW WXWWRYHUEDOHSHVLGLYHUVLWLSLYHUEDOLLGHQWLILFDWLGDOODYRFDOHFKHVHJXHOD SULPD FRQVRQDQWH UDGLFDOH LO ULFFR VLVWHPD GL GHULYD]LRQH O¶HVSUHVVLRQH GHO SDVVLYR H O¶DVVHQ]D GL XQ YHUR SDUWLFLSLR VRVWLWXLWR GD XQD IUDVH UHODWLYD q FRQ RJQL SUREDELOLWj SHU TXHVWH UDJLRQL FKH /HVODX QHOO¶LQWURGX]LRQH DO VXR GL]LRQDULRHWLPRORJLFRGHOKDUDULQRULFKLDPDJOLVSHFLPLQDWHVWXDOLHOHVVLFDOL GL%PDQRQLOVXRVFKL]]RJUDPPDWLFDOH 6HLWHVWLUHJLVWUDWLGD%QHOOHFLUFRVWDQ]HPDODJHYROLFKHDEELDPRDSSH QDHYRFDWRKDQQRGRYXWRHVVHUHULYLVWLLQSURIRQGLWjGD/LWWPDQQSULPDGLHV VHUHXWLOL]]DELOLLOVXRJORVVDULRLQYHFHULYHVWHDQFRUDRJJLQRWHYROHLQWHUHVVH SHUULFRVWUXLUHLOVXRPHWRGRG¶LQFKLHVWD*XLGDWRGDOVXRLVWLQWRGLDQWURSROR JR DYYHGXWR IX WUD O¶DOWUR XQR GHL IRQGDWRUL QHO GHOOD $QWKURSRORJLFDO 6RFLHW\GL/RQGUD%VFHOVHLOVXRHOHQFROHVVLFDOHLQJOHVHKDUDULQR±G¶LP SLDQWRHYLGHQWHPHQWHRQRPDVLRORJLFR±WHQHQGRLQFRQVLGHUD]LRQHJOLDPELWL VHPDQWLFLSULQFLSDOLGLTXHOORFKHLOLQJXLVWLQRQPHQRGHJOLHWQRORJLFKLDPD QRLO³OHVVLFRIRQGDPHQWDOH´8QDPRGLFLVVLPDVFHOWDGLYRFLOLPLWDWDDOOH OHWWHUH $ ± & VDUj VXIILFLHQWH D PRVWUDUH OD WLSRORJLD VHPDQWLFD H OD TXDOLWj GHLVXRLSUHOLHYLOHVVLFDOLDJJLXQJRSHURJQLWHUPLQHODIRUPDFRUUHQWHQHOGL ]LRQDULRGL/HVODXTXL /QXPHURGLSDJLQDIRQGDWRVXXQDVSHFLIL FDLQFKLHVWDGLFDPSRHVXGHFHQQLGLSUDWLFDGHOODOLQJXLVWLFDHWLRSLFD *RGVDOOSQULIHULVFHFKH'DQVH\HUDLQWHUSUHWHTXDOLILFDWRSHUORKLQGXVWDQL LOPDKUDWLHLOSHUVLDQRVLSXzSUHVXPHUHFKHGLVWDQ]DQHOFHQWURSULQFLSDOHGHOOR<HPHQPH ULGLRQDOHSDUODVVHDQFKHO¶DUDER /HVODXSS 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH $ERGH*iUJƗU/ $ERYH/i¶D\Ol¶D\OƗ\/ $GXOWHUHU)iVLN$FIUILVTLµFRUUXSWLRQ¶/ $JH8PUt$XPUL/ $OO-DPPtЂDPPL¶/ $OZD\V'iLPH$GƗ¶LP/ $PLU¶VZLIH*tVWtJƯVWLµPLVWUHVVRIWKHKRXVHODG\TXHHQ¶/ $QFLHQW5iJiIHP5iJtWUƗJDIHPUƗJƯWµROGPDQREMHFW¶/ $QVZHU-DZiE$ЂlZƗEµDQVZHUOHWWHU¶/ $QWEODFN&K~FKধnjধµVPDOOEODFNDQW¶/ ±ZKLWH.D\QK~UTDxۊnjUµNLQGRIUHGDQW¶/ $XQWPDWHUQDO,NKLVWiΩ[LVWD/ $[H.DONiSO.DONiVKNDOND/ %DVNHW0XGitPXGƗ\µNLQGRIEDVNHWZLWKFRQLFDOFRYHU¶/ %HDUG'DEDQGlElQµFKLQEHDUGEHDUGDQGZKLVNHUV¶/ %LUGÒISOXUÒIiVKnjI/ %ODFN7i\ܒl\/ %RDW=D¶tPDK$VDۊƯPD/ %R\VRQ/LMMD\OLЂL/ %UHDG¶8NKiWX[ƗWµIODWEUHDG¶/ %XOO%iUiEƗUDED¶DUDµR[EXOO¶/ &DW$G~UU~$GDQ"DGXUUXDGlQ/ &KDUFRDO.DVDONlVlO/ &LUFXPFLVLRQ$EVXPDEVXP/ &OLPEY,VDODVlODµFOLPEDVFHQGJRXS¶/ &ORXGV'iQDKGƗQD/ &RRNLQJSRWHDUWKHQ0DNiWRPlTlܒXµSRWRIFOD\¶/ &RZ/iPOƗP/ &UHSLWXV)DV$IlVµIDUW¶Q/ &XS*HEJƝEµMDURIFOD\VHUYLQJIRUGULQNLQJ¶/ &RPHVLYHGHPDOJUDGRLVXRLHUURULGLWUDVFUL]LRQH±GRYXWLDXQ¶LPSHU IHWWD DQDOLVL IRQRORJLFD ROWUH FKH PRUIRORJLFD GL TXHOOD YDULHWj QHRHWLRSLFD PHULGLRQDOH±LOJORVVDULRGL%GDYDJLjXQDEXRQDLGHDGHOSDWULPRQLROHVVL FDOH GHOOD OLQJXD H VL VIRU]DYD LQROWUHGL LGHQWLILFDUH L SUHVWLWL DUDEL PDUFDWL FRQO¶DEEUHYLD]LRQH©$ªQHOVXRHOHQFRXQFRPSLWRFKHDVVROVHLQPRGRUL /HVODXUHVSLQJHSHUzXQ¶HWLPRORJLDDUDEDGHOWHUPLQH 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL VSHWWDELOHSHUVLQRLQFRQIURQWRFRQ/HVODXFKHDYUHEEHIDWWRGHOO¶DQDOLVLGH JOLDUDELVPLLQQHRHWLRSLFRXQRGHLVXRLFDYDOOLGLEDWWDJOLD ,QROWUH % QRQ LJQRUDYD O¶HVLVWHQ]D GL XQD OHWWHUDWXUD KDUDULQD VFULWWD LQ FDUDWWHULDUDELOR©KDUDULQRDQWLFRªSRLDQDOL]]DWRGD&HUXOOLH:DJQHUHD YHYDDSSUH]]DWRODVRILVWLFDWDWUDGL]LRQHSRHWLFDRUDOHGHOODOLQJXD©ZLWKUXOHV RIHORTXHQFHDQGDSRHWU\FXOWLYDWHGDIWHUWKHFDQRQVRIUK\WKPDQGUK\PHª 7XWWRFRQVLGHUDWRVLULPDQHRJJLDPPLUDWLGHLULVXOWDWL±DOPHQRVXOSLD QR OHVVLFDOH ± GHO ODYRUR GL GHVFUL]LRQH VXO WHUUHQR GL XQD OLQJXD SHU OXL GHO WXWWRQXRYDFKH%ULXVFuDGHIIHWWXDUHLQXQODVVRGLWHPSRFRVuHVLJXRHUDOD SULPDSURYDGLXQWDOHQWRGLDPDWRUHGHOODOLQJXLVWLFDQHRVHPLWLFDFKHFRPH VLFHUFKHUjGLPRVWUDUHTXLQRQVDUHEEHULPDVWRLQDWWLYRQHOVHJXLWRGHOODVXD FDUULHUDGLYLDJJLDWRUHHGLVFULWWRUH %UHYLFDPSLRQLGHOQHRDUDPDLFRGL0DµOnjOD ,QRFFDVLRQHGLXQYLDJJLRVXLPRQWLGHOO¶$QWL/LEDQRLQFRPSDJQLDGHO OD PRJOLH ,VDEHO H GHO ORUR JLRYDQH DPLFR &KDUOHV 7\UZKLWW 'UDNH DOO¶HSRFDGHOVXRFRQVRODWRD'DPDVFRRWWREUHDJRVWR %YLVLWz0DµOnjODGDOXLWUDVFULWWR0D¶DO~ODK!LOVHWWHPEUHLOVXR LQWHUHVVHIXDWWUDWWRVRSUDWWXWWRGDOOHDQWLFKLWjFULVWLDQHGHOYLOODJJLRHGHLVXRL GLQWRUQLFRPHGHOO¶DOWRSLDQRGHO4DODPnjQQHOVXRFRPSOHVVRPDQRQPDQ FzGLVRIIHUPDUVLDQFKHVXO©GHEDVHG$UDER6\ULDFªORFDOH D%IRUPXODVHFRQGRODVXDDELWXGLQHQRWD]LRQLLPSUHVVLRQLVWLFKHVXOOD OLQJXDGHOOXRJRHVXOVXRUDSSRUWRFRQO¶DUDERVLULDQRQHOVHJXLWR$U6LUD VXRGLUHOHSDUROHVDUHEEHURSURQXQFLDWHLQPRGR©HYLGHQWO\KDUVKHUWKDQWKH FRUUHVSRQGLQJ$UDELFªHPRVWUHUHEEHURODFDUDWWHULVWLFDGHO©PHHWLQJRIWZR TXLHVFHQW FRQVRQDQWVª FRVu FRQWUDULR DOO¶DUDER FRUDQLFRH FRVu WLSLFR GHOO¶D 6LYHGDQRLVDJJLULXQLWLLQ/HVODX :DJQHUSULOHYDFKH%SSqLOSLDQWLFRWHVWLPRQHGHOODSUHVHQ ]DGLWUDWWLGHOKDUDULQRPRGHUQRQHOTXDQGRDQFRUDVLVFULYHYDLQKDUDULQRDQWLFRDQ FKHVH%QRQDFFHQQDHVSOLFLWDPHQWHDTXHVWDVLWXD]LRQHGLGLJORVVLD 5LQYLRD%XUWRQ'UDNHSSVVIRQWHGLWXWWLLGDWLTXLGLVFXVVLLOOLEURqXQDFRQ JHULHSLXWWRVWRGLVRUGLQDWDGLLPSUHVVLRQLGLYLDJJLRHVDJJLPRQRJUDILFLGLYDULDDPSLH]]DH WHPDWLFD FRPSLODWL GDL WUH FRPSDJQL GL YLD PD OD VH]LRQH FKH FL LQWHUHVVD LQ TXHVWD VHGH q FKLDUDPHQWHRSHUDGL%XUWRQ/DFRQWURYHUVDYLFHQGDGHOVRJJLRUQRGL%XUWRQLQ6LULDFRQFOX VRVLFRQXQULFKLDPRLQSDWULDFKHUDSSUHVHQWzXQ¶LQVRUPRQWDELOHLSRWHFDVXOSURVLHJXRGHOOD VXDFDUULHUDSUHVVRLO)RUHLJQ2IILFHqHIILFDFHPHQWHULHSLORJDWDGD*RGVDOOSS FRQDPSLDGRFXPHQWD]LRQHG¶DUFKLYLR 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH UDEROHYDQWLQRHVHPSOLILFDWRGD¶%UiKtP!SHU¶,EUiKtP!IHQRPHQRFKHVL RVVHUYDSLFKLDUDPHQWHTXDQGRHVVR©ILUVWVWULNHVWKHHDURIWKH$UDELVWODQ GLQJ LQ%D\UXWª /D VHFRQGD RVVHUYD]LRQH SDUUHEEH DOOXGHUH LQ PRGR SHU OD YHULWjQRQSURSULROLPSLGRDOIHQRPHQRGHOO¶HOLVLRQHGHOOHYRFDOLEUHYLSUHWR QLFKHLQVLOODEDDSHUWDFKHFRQWUDVVHJQDXQDSDUWHGHOOHYDULHWjDUDEHGHO4D ODPnjQ E6WLODXQEUHYHHOHQFRGLSDUROHLQQHRDUDPDLFRRFFLGHQWDOHQHOVHJXL WRQ$2FFHGHLORURSDUDOOHOLLQ$U6LUFKH±DQFKHLQDVVHQ]DGLXQGL]LRQD ULRHVWHVRGHOODOLQJXD±VLSUHVWDQRDXQDFRPSDUD]LRQHFRQTXHOFKHDWWXDO PHQWHVLFRQRVFHGHOOHVVLFRQ$2FFVXOODEDVHGHLODYRULGL*%HUJVWUlVVHU 65HLFK$6SLWDOHU&&RUUHOOHVRSUDWWXWWRGHOORVWHVVR$UQROG µWKHVHD¶%RKU!%DKU! µDWDQN¶%RKUDWD!%XKD\UDK%LUNDK! µDPRQDVWHU\¶'D\Ui!'D\U! µDZDOQXWWUHH¶*KDX]WD!-DX]HK! µDKRUVH¶+RVRQi!+RVDQ! µDQDVV¶+XP~UD!+LPiU! µZKLWH¶+XZZD!+RZDUHK!µFKDON¶ µEUHDG¶/DKPDK!/DKP!µIOHVK¶ µDKRXVH¶3D\Wi!%D\W! µDWDOOIRUWOLNHURFN¶6KLQQD! µWUHH¶6¶MDUWi!6KDMDU!6\ULDQ6DMDU! µVQRZ¶7VDOMD!7DOM! µDPXOEHUU\WUHH¶7XWVKi!7XW! µDPRXQWDLQ¶7RUi!7XU! YL 4XHVWDEUHYHFDPSLRQDWXUDOHVVLFDOHVXVFLWDLVHJXHQWLULOLHYLFRPSDUDWL FIUQ$2FFEDۊUDµPDUH¶$UQROGðS±µEDFLQRYDVFD¶ FIUQ$2FFEDۊUܔDµ:DVVHUEDVVLQLP+RIGHV+DXVHV¶%HUJVWUlVVHUS ±FIUQ$2FFڴD\UDµFRQYHQWR¶$UQROGðS±FIUQ$2FF &RPHULVXOWDGDOOHHFFHOOHQWLFDUWHOLQJXLVWLFKHGHJOLVSHFLDOLVWLGHOO¶DUHD:HUQHU$UQROGH3H WHU%HKQVWHGWQUUH ,OGL]LRQDULRQHRDUDPDLFRRFFLGHQWDOHGL:HUQHU$UQROGqRUPDLSURVVLPRDOODSXEEOLFD]LRQH QHOODFROODQD³6HPLWLFD9LYD´ %RVVHUYDTXLDSURSRVLWRGHOO¶DOWHUQDQ]DWUDãHVLQ$U6LU³XSRQWKHVDPHSULQFLSOHZKLFK PDNHVVRPHRIXVSUHIHUµVULPS¶WRµVKULPS¶´ 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL ƥDX]DµDOEHURGLQRFH¶ƥDX]ǀµQRFL¶%HUJVWUlVVHUS$U6LUåǀ]H± FIUQ$2FF܈ۊǀQDµFDYDOOR¶%HUJVWUlVVHUS$U6LU܈ۊƗQ± FIU Q$2FF ۊPǀUD µDVLQR¶ $UQROG ð S $U6LU ۊPƗU ± FIU Q$2FF ۊXZZDU µELDQFR¶ $UQROG ð S $U6LU ۊDZZkUH µEkWRQ GH FUDLH¶'HQL]HDXS±FIUQ$2FFOHۊPDµSDQH¶%HUJVWUlVVHU SSGLHWLPRORJLDDUDPDLFDYVLOSUHVWLWRDUDERGDOODVWHVVDUDGLFH ODۊۊǀPDµPDFHOODLR¶±FIUQ$2FFSD\ܔDED\ܔDۛXEEµ$GƯQµFDVD¶$U QROGðS±µXQDJUDQGHURFFLDFKHVRPLJOLDDXQDIRUWH]]D¶FIU Q$2FFãHQQDµGHQWH¶µURFFLD¶%HUJVWUlVVHUSFHUWRSHUHVWHQVLR QHPHWDIRULFDGDOO¶DPELWRFRUSRUHRDOJHRPRUIRORJLFRIHQRPHQREHQQRWRLQ HWQROLQJXLVWLFD±FIUQ$2FFVDåUܔDµDOEHUR¶%HUJVWUlVVHUS ±ODYRFHPDQFDQHOODOHWWHUDWXUDOHVVLFRORJLFDGLVSRQLELOHVLSRWUHEEHUL FRVWUXLUH TXDOFRVD FRPH þDOå µQHYH¶ LO FROOHJD $UQROG FRPXQLFD]LRQH GHO PL LQIRUPD WXWWDYLD FKH LO WHUPLQH FRUUHQWH SHU µQHYH¶ LQ QHRDUD PDLFRGL0DµOnjODqRJJLҌHOND±FIUQ$2FFܔnjܔþDµSLDQWDGLJHOVR¶FROO ܔnjܔD%HUJVWUlVVHUSDUDPWnjܔD$U6LUWnjWµSLDQWHGLJHOVRPRUH GLJHOVR¶FROOWnjWHµJHOVR¶VLQJ±FIUQ$2FFܒnjUDµPRQWH¶%HUJVWUlV VHUSDUDEROHYDQWLQRܒnjUµPRQWH¶QHJOLRURQLPLGLRULJLQHDUDPDL FDSHVLOOLEDQHVHäDEDOܑnjUDFRQULGHWHUPLQD]LRQHWDXWRORJLFDVXOWLSRGHO VLFLOLDQR0RQJLEHOOR 6LWUDWWDPROWRSUREDELOPHQWHGHLSULPLGDWLOHVVLFDOLSXEEOLFDWLVXOQHRD UDPDLFR RFFLGHQWDOH LQ OLQJXD LQJOHVH VH QRQ LQ TXDOVLDVL OLQJXDEHQFKp LO ORURQXPHURHVLJXRHODORURWLSRORJLDSLXWWRVWRIRUWXLWDFLVHPEULQRQHOFRP SOHVVR GHOXGHQWL VH FRPSDUDWL FRQ OH LQIRUPD]LRQL RIIHUWH GD % VHGLFL DQQL SULPDSHULOKDUDULQR$SDUWHO¶LPSUHFLVLRQHQHOODJUDILDGHOOHFRQVRQDQWLHQ IDWLFKHHJXWWXUDOLFRPHSXUHODGLIHWWRVDQRWD]LRQHGHOOHVSLUDQWLGHQWDOLDE &DUGRQDSSFRQHVHPSLGDOLQJXHDPHULQGLDQH :LOGS ,PDWHULDOLPROWRSLLPSRUWDQWLLQSDUWLFRODUHUDFFRQWLSRSRODULUDFFROWLGD(XJHQ3U\PH $OEHUW6RFLQJLjQHOVDUHEEHURVWDWLSXEEOLFDWLGD%HUJVWUlVVHUVRORQHOVROWDQWRXQ UDSSRUWRHSLVWRODUHGL3U\PDOVXRPDHVWUR+/)OHLVFKHUSXEEOLFDWRVXOO¶RUJDQRGHOOD 'HXWVFKH0RUJHQOlQGLVFKH*HVHOOVFKDIWGDOXLSUHVLHGXWDDQQXQFLzTXHVWDDWWLYLWjGLFXL%± FKHSHQGRODYDWUDODVXDVHGHFRQVRODUHGL'DPDVFRHLOVXREXHQUHWLURPRQWDQRGL%OXGƗQ± SXz EHQ HVVHUH ULPDVWR DOO¶RVFXUR FRPH DQFRUD DO PRPHQWR GHOOD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHO OLEUR 6DOYR PLR HUURUH L YLDJJLDWRUL FKH O¶DYHYDQR SUHFHGXWR QHO 4DODPnjQ SDVVDWLLQ UDVVHJQD GD 1DVUDOODKQRQULSRUWDQRVLPLOLHOHQFKLOHVVLFDOL6XOO¶XWLOLWjGHOOHRVVHUYD]LRQLOLQJXLVWL FKHGHLYLDJJLDWRULSLUHFHQWLQHOODUHJLRQHPLSHUPHWWRGLULQYLDUHDOPLRDUWLFRORVXO ODPLVFHOODQHDSHU/XLJL6HUUD 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH EDVWDQ]D QRUPDOH QHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD RGHSRULFD GHOO¶HSRFD WXWWDYLD OD PDJJLRU SDUWHGHOOHIRUPHGL%ULVXOWDQRFRUUHWWHDOQUO¶RPLVVLRQHGHOOD±UILQDOHq SUREDELOPHQWH XQ VHPSOLFH HUURUH GL VWDPSD H SHUVLQR L ULQYLL DL SDUDOOHOL VHPDQWLFDPHQWHGLYHUJHQWLGHOO¶DUDERVLULDQRFLSDLRQRDQFRUDWXWWRVRPPDWR ULVSHWWDELOL$OQU%VLqVIRU]DWRGLUHQGHUHFRQLOGLJUDPPDWV!O¶DIIUL FDWDþFKHVLULFRVWUXLVFHLQFRUULVSRQGHQ]DGLXQSUHVWLWRDUDERVLULDQRLQL ]LDQWHFRQW±DOQUKDWUDVFULWWRFRQLOWULJUDPPDWVK!LOQHVVRFRQVR QDQWLFR৮þGHOQ$2FF$OQU%VLPRVWUDFRQVDSHYROHGHOODGLYDULFD]LRQH VHPDQWLFDGHOODUDGLFH/ণ0DOO¶LQWHUQRGHOVHPLWLFRFRQO¶DWWULEXLUHDOQ$2FF XQDSUHVXQWD©+HEUHZIRUPªODFXLDQDORJLDVSHFLILFDFRQO¶HEUDLFRDOGLIXR ULGHOVLJQLILFDWRULVLHGHUHEEHDOSLQHOODSULPDYRFDOHGLFXLSHUDOWUR%QRQ HUDFRQVDSHYROHDYHQGRUHJLVWUDWRXQD>D@GHOODIRUPD³VHJKRODWD´OİۊİPPD ORVWDWRFRVWUXWWRqODۊP±FRPHLQGLFDDQFKHLOFRUULVSRQGHQWHVWDWRGHWHUPL QDWRLQDUDPDLFRJLXGDLFRODۊPƗ$OQULQILQH%DOOHJDDGGLULWWXUDXQD IRUPDGLIIXVDQHOODWRSRQRPDVWLFDVLUROLEDQHVHSHUIRUQLUHXQFRUULVSRQGHQWH HWLPRORJLFRGHOO¶DUDPܒnjUƗµPRQWH¶ 1HOO¶LQVLHPH TXHVWD QRQ SDUH RJJL XQD FDWWLYD SUHVWD]LRQH SHU HVVHUH LO ULVXOWDWRGLXQVRJJLRUQRGLQRQSLGLTXDOFKHRUDD0DµOnjOD %XUWRQHLGLDOHWWLQHRDUDEL ,OGHEXWWRGL%QHOORVWXGLRGHOO¶DUDERD2[IRUGIXTXDQWRPHQREL]]DU URVHFRQGRTXDQWRULIHULVFHHJOLVWHVVRULSXGLDWRFRPHDOOLHYRGDOSURIHVVRUH WLWRODUHGLDUDER%DYUHEEHLQL]LDWRDGDSSUHQGHUHODOLQJXDSHUFRQWRSUR SULR VX XQD YHFFKLD JUDPPDWLFDH VROR LO JHQWLOH LQWHUYHQWR GHOO¶HPLQHQWH DUDELVWDVSDJQROR'RQ3DVFXDOGH*D\DQJRVLQYLVLWDDOOD%RG OHLDQ/LEUDU\YDOVHDLQIRUPDUORFKHODGLUH]LRQHGLVFULWWXUDDUDEDSURFHGHYD GDGHVWUDYHUVRVLQLVWUD1HJOLDQQLVXFFHVVLYLWXWWDYLDRUPDLDOVHUYL]LRGHOOD (DVW ,QGLD &RPSDQ\ % DYHYD FRQWLQXDWR D VWXGLDUHO¶DUDER VHQ]D GXEELR OHWWHUDULRFRQXQSUHFHWWRUHLQGLJHQRPXQVKLQHO*XMDUDWSULPDGLVRWWR SRUVLDOO¶HVDPHGLLQWHUSUHWHG¶DUDERSHUOD(DVW,QGLD&RPSDQ\QHODG $OPHQR TXHVWD SDUWH GHOO¶DQHGGRWR VHPEUD WXWWDYLDVSXULD FIU *RGVDOO SS OD ELRJUDILDSLDWWHQWDDOSURJUHVVLYRDPSOLDUVLGHOOHFRPSHWHQ]HOLQJXLVWLFKHGL%XUWRQ 3RWUHEEHWUDWWDUVLGHOODJUDPPDWLFDDUDEDLQWURGXWWLYDGL-$5LFKDUGVRQHVSUHVVDPHQ WHGHVWLQDWDDOSHUVRQDOHGHOOD(DVW,QGLD&RPSDQ\FKHHUDSUHVHQWHQHOODELEOLRWHFDGL%XU WRQFRPHDWWHVWD.LUNSDWULFNSQU *RGVDOOSS 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL $GHQSURYDFKHGDOSXQWRGLYLVWDDPPLQLVWUDWLYRVLULVROVHSHUzLQXQDERF FLDWXUDFRPHULVXOWDGDOOHULFHUFKHGL-RQ*RGVDOOXQDYHULWjLPEDUD]]DQWH FKH%WHQQHFHODWDFRQVXFFHVVRSHUWXWWDODYLWD ÊFHUWRVLJQLILFDWLYRFKHSHULOVXRFHOHEUHYLDJJLRDOOD0HFFDQHO %±FKHDYHYDJLjGDWRSURYDLQ,QGLDGLJUDQGHDELOLWjQHOWUDYHVWLUVLHSDVVD UHSHULQGLJHQRQHOFRUVRGLPLVVLRQLVHJUHWHSHULOJRYHUQREULWDQQLFR±DE ELDDVVXQWRO¶LGHQWLWjGLXQSHOOHJULQRQRQJLjDUDEREHQVuDIJDQRDOOHYDWRLQ ,QGLD0ROWRSUREDELOPHQWHODVXDFRQRVFHQ]DGHOO¶DUDERGLDOHWWDOHSXUSHU IH]LRQDWD QHL VXRL VRJJLRUQL LQ (JLWWR SULPD GHOODSDUWHQ]D LQ EDWWHOOR SHU LO SRUWRGL<DQERµQHOণLۜƗ]QRQHUDVXIILFLHQWHDIDUVLSDVVDUHSHUDUDERIRQR QRQRVWDQWHODVXDVWUDRUGLQDULDFDSDFLWjPQHPRQLFDHSHUFRVuGLUHPLPHWLFD QHOOD UHFLWD]LRQH GHOOH SUHJKLHUH LVODPLFKH GHOOHGHFLQH GL VXUH GHO &RUDQR FKHFRQRVFHYDDPHPRULDHDQFKHGLSDUHFFKLUDFFRQWLGHOOHQRWWHXQWD OHQWRGLFXLGLHGHULSHWXWHSURYHGXUDQWHTXDVLDQQLGLVXRLFRQWDWWLFRQLO PRQGR GL OLQJXD DUDED &RPH VL q DFFHQQDWR YHQWLFLQTXH DQQL GRSR OD VXD VSHGL]LRQHDOOD0HFFDJOLDUDELVWLHXURSHLDO&DLURJLXGLFDYDQRO¶DUDERSDUOD WRGL%PROWRIOXHQWHPDSURQXQFLDWRFRQXQSHVDQWHDFFHQWR 1HLVXRLUHVRFRQWLGLYLDJJLRLQ$UDELDHLQ$IULFDRULHQWDOH%HVSULPH VSHVVR JLXGL]L GL SRUWDWD GLDOHWWRORJLFD H VRFLROLQJXLVWLFD VXOOD OLQJXD DUDED VRSUDWWXWWRQHOVXR3HUVRQDOQDUUDWLYHRIDSLOJULPDJHWRDO0DGLQDK0HF FDKGRYHPDQLIHVWDXQDWWHJJLDPHQWRSLXWWRVWRVFHWWLFRYHUVRDOFX QLPLWLOLQJXLVWLFLFRUUHQWLVXOO¶DUDEREHGXLQRSHV 7KH WUDYHOOHU LQ $UDELD ZLOO DOZD\V EH WROG WKDW VRPH UHPRWH FODQ VWLOO SURGXFHV PLJKW\EDUGVDQGXVHVLQFRQYHUVDWLRQWKHWHUPLQDOYRZHOVRIWKHFODVVLFWRQJXHEXW KHZLOOQRWEHOLHYHWKHVHDVVHUWLRQVWLOOSHUVRQDOO\FRQYLQFHGRIWKHLUWUXWK7KH%DGD ZLGLDOHFWKRZHYHUWKRXJKGHEDVHGLVVWLOODVRI \RUHSXUHUWKDQWKHODQJXDJHRI WKHFLWL]HQV%,,SQ *RGVDOOSSHSQHOLO%RPED\([DPLQDWLRQ&RPPLWWHH SUHVLHGXWRGDOO¶DQWLFRULYDOHHVXFFHVVLYDPHQWHDYYHUVDULRGL%LOFDSLWDQR&KULVWRSKHU3DO PHU5LJE\ULSXGLzLOJLXGL]LRIDYRUHYROHGHOODFRPPLVVLRQHGL$GHQIRUPDWDGDGXHHVSHUWL PROWR VWLPDWL DQFKH GDJOL DUDELVWL DFFDGHPLFL G¶(XURSD TXDOL LO FDSLWDQR 5REHUW /DPEHUW 3OD\IDLUWUDO¶DOWURIRUQLWRUHGLPDWHULDOLVXGDUDELFLDQWLFKLD:LOOLDP:ULJKWFKH OLVPLVWzDVHPLWLVWLWHGHVFKLHLO5HY*HRUJH3HUF\%DGJHUDXWRUHGL7KH1H VWRULDQVDQGWKHLUULWXDOV/RQGRQHGLXQDQFRUDXWLOHPRQXPHQWDOHGL]LRQDULRLQJOH VHDUDERLQFOXVRQHOODELEOLRWHFDGL%.LUNSDWULFNSQUFIU0DLHU SSH 6X%³WKH,PSHUVRQDWRU´VLYHGD.HQQHG\SSDQFKHSHUODULSURGX]LRQHS GHOIDPRVRULWUDWWRGL%LQYHVWLGLEHGXLQRDUDER 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH % q G¶DOWURQGH SHUIHWWDPHQWH DO FRUUHQWH GHOOD VLWXD]LRQH GLJORWWLFD GHO O¶DUDERFKHULDVVXPHFRPHVHJXH ,WLVVWUDQJHKRZWUDYHOOHUVDQGOLQJXLVWVGLIIHUXSRQWKHVXEMHFWRI$UDELFDQGLWVGLD OHFWV 1LHEXKU FRPSDUHV WKHLU UHODWLRQ WR WKDW RI 3URYHQoDO 6SDQLVK DQG ,WDOLDQ ZKHUHDV/DQHGHFODUHVWKHGLDOHFWVWRUHVHPEOHHDFKRWKHUPRUHWKDQWKRVHRIVRPH GLIIHUHQWFRXQWULHVLQ(QJODQG>«@%XWLWPXVWEHUHPHPEHUHGWKDWWKH$UDEVGLYLGH WKHLUVSRNHQDQGHYHQZULWWHQODQJXDJHLQWRWZRRUGHUVWKH.iODP:iWL!> NDOƗP ZDܒƯ@ RU YXOJDU WRQJXH VRPHWLPHV HPSOR\HG LQ HSLVWRODU\ FRUUHVSRQGHQFH DQG WKH 1DKZL!> NDOƗPQDۊZƯ@RUJUDPPDWLFDODQGFODVVLFDOODQJXDJH(YHU\PDQRIHG XFDWLRQXVHVWKHIRUPHUDQGFDQXVHWKHODWWHU$QGWKH.RUDQLVQRPRUHDPRGHORI $UDELFDVLVRIWHQDVVXPHGWREHWKDQµ3DUDGLVH/RVW¶LVRI(QJOLVK,QLPLWDEOHQR PDQLPLWDWHVWKHP%,,SQ 4XHVWLGXHFHOHEULEUDQLPHVVLLQULOLHYRDQFKHGD+HLNNL3DOYDQHOODVXD UDVVHJQDGHOOHRVVHUYD]LRQLOLQJXLVWLFKHGHJOLHVSORUDWRULGHOO¶$UDELDFHQWUDOH QHO;,;VHFRORQRQVRQRG¶DOWUDSDUWHJOLXQLFLLQFXL%DEELDGDWRSURYD GHOODVXDVHQVLELOLWjYHUVRODVLWXD]LRQHOLQJXLVWLFDGHOO¶DUDERLQ$UDELDFHQWUD OHRVHWWHQWULRQDOHDQFKHQHLVXRLYROXPL±LQQHJDELOPHQWHPROWRPHQRULFFKL H VHGXFHQWL GHO OLEUR VXO YLDJJLR DOOD 0HFFD ± GHGLFDWL % H DL VXRLVIRUWXQDWLWHQWDWLYLQHOHQHOGLULYLWDOL]]DUHLJLDFLPHQWLGLPL QHUDOLSUHJLDWLQHOSDHVHGL©0LGLDQªFLRqO¶DQJRORSLQRUGRFFLGHQWDOHGHOOD 3HQLVROD DUDELFD WUD OD ণLVPƗ H LO ণLۜƗ] D YDQWDJJLR GHO .KHGLYp G¶(JLWWR ,VPDLO , FKH VL VREEDUFz O¶LQJHQWH VSHVD GHOO¶LPSUREDELOH VSHGL]LRQH H QHO JLj FLWDWR OLEUR D VHL PDQL VFULWWR FRQ VXD PRJOLH ,VDEHO H FRQ&KDUOHV 7\U ZKLWW'UDNHVXLVXRLYLDJJLQHOOD6LULDFHQWUDOH7UHHVHPSLEDVWHUDQQR LOWULERQLPRণXZD\৬iW!VLQJণXZD\৬t!ODWULEGHOIDPRVRHPL UR F$ZGD $Enj ৫Ɨ\H O¶DOOHDWR GL /DZUHQFH G¶$UDELD GHULYHUHEEH D VXRGLUHGDণXZD\৬!GLPLQXWLYRGLণi¶L৬!µZDOORULQFORVXUHJH QHUDOO\URXQGDSDOPRUFKDUG¶ DUFOۊƗ\LܒµPXUR¶HDYUHEEHRULJL QDULDPHQWH LO VLJQLILFDWR GL µD PDQ RI WKH VPDOO ZDOOV¶ % S QTXDOHFKHQHVLDO¶RULJLQHFKHQRQVDSSLDPRVH%DEELD UDFFROWRGDXQRGHLVXRLLQIRUPDQWLPLGLDQLWLTXHVWDVSLHJD]LRQHSD UHWLPRORJLFD QRQ q PHQ]LRQDWD QHJOL VWXGL SL UHFHQWL VXO GLDOHWWR DUDERGHJOLণZƝ৬ƗWFKHVLGHYRQRD+HLNNL3DOYD OD WULE SDULD GHL +XWD\P! VDUHEEH FDUDWWHUL]]DWDGD XQ ©DFFHQWR SDUWLFRODUHªGLFXLWXWWDYLD%QRQIRUQLVFHHVHPSLQRQFKpGDOO¶XVR 3DOYDSSHFXLVLULPDQGDSHUXQDGLVFXVVLRQHSLDSSURIRQGLWD 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL GL©FHUWDLQSHFXOLDUZRUGVDV+DUUZKHQGRQNH\GULYLQJª% S LO VRJJLRUQR GL % QHO YLOODJJLR GL 0DTQƗ VXO ODWR VXGRULHQWDOH GHO *ROIR GL µ$TDED IX WURSSR EUHYH SHU FRQVHQWLUJOL GL DFFHUWDUH VH LO GLDOHWWR 0DNQiZL! FRQVHUYDVVH HVSUHVVLRQL LJQRWH DOOH WULE FRQIL QDQWL WXWWDYLD ©WKH\ DSSHDUHG WR VSHDN WKH KDOI)HOODK DQG KDOI %HGDZL WRQJXH RI WKHLU QHLJKERXUVª % S V Q LQ DVVHQ]D GL HVHPSOLILFD]LRQH TXHVWR WLSR GL ULOLHYL JHQHUDOL]]DQWL H LPSUHVVLRQLVWLFLSLXWWRVWRIUHTXHQWLQHJOLVFULWWLGL%HYLGHQWHPHQWH QRQ q GL JUDQGH DLXWR DL GLDOHWWRORJL GHOO¶DUDER VH QRQ FRPH DVVHU ]LRQHHVSOLFLWDGHOO¶DVVHQ]DLQTXHVWDYDULHWj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¶H UXGL]LRQH FHUWR QRQ VROWDQWR LQ TXHVWLRQL DWWLQHQWL DO OLQJXDJJLR QRQ KD PDQFDWRGLLUULWDUH LVHPLWLVWLSURIHVVLRQLVWL LQSDUWLFRODUHJOLVSHFLDOLVWLGHO O¶$UDELDFKHQRQFLDYHYDQRPDLPHVVRSLHGHTXDOLJOLHPLQHQWLVWXGLRVLWH GHVFKL7KHRGRU1|OGHNHH-XOLXV:HOOKDXVHQFRPH SRVVLDPRRJJLFRQVWDWDUHOHJJHQGROHOHWWHUHGDORURVFDPELDWHFRQLOJLjPHQ ]LRQDWRDUDELVWDVFR]]HVH:LOOLDP5REHUWVRQ6PLWKFLWDWHQHOODELRJUDILDFKH JOLKDXOWLPDPHQWHGHGLFDWR%HUQKDUG0DLHU1RQRQRVWDQWHTXHVWRODQRVWUD FRQRVFHQ]D GHOO¶DUDER QDMGL GHOO¶$UDELD FHQWUDOH GHOOH YDULHWj GHO 0LGLDQ H SHUVLQRGHOGLDOHWWRGLRULJLQHRPDQLWDSDUODWRGDLPHUFDQWLHGDLFRORQLDUDER 8Q VROR HVHPSLR VDUj VXIILFLHQWH% VLSHUPHWWH GL FHQVXUDUH *HRUJ :DOOLQIRUVHLO SURIHV VLRQLVWDGLPDJJLRUWDOHQWRFKHVLVLDLQWHUHVVDWRGHLGLDOHWWLGHOO¶$UDELDFHQWUDOHSULPDGL$O EHUW6RFLQQHLWHUPLQLVHJXHQWL©>:DOOLQ@ZDVDQH[FHOOHQWWUDYHOOHUKDUG\DQGWHPSHUDWHDV D%HGDZLEXWKHODFNHGWKHILQHHDUWKDWGLVWLQJXLVKHG%XUFNKDUGWª%SQ O¶LPSOLFD]LRQHHUDHYLGHQWHPHQWHFKHO¶RUHFFKLRGLFKLIRUPXODYDTXHVWRJLXGL]LRHUDDQFRUD SLILQH 0DLHU SS H SDVVLP DQDORJKL JLXGL]L GHURJDWRUL VL ULWURYDQR QHOOD FRUULVSRQ GHQ]DGHOJLjFLWDWR:LOOLDP:ULJKWSULQFLSHGHLILORORJLDUDELHVHPLWLFLEULWDQ QLFLFRQWHPSRUDQHLGL%FIU0DLHUSSVH 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH IRQLGL=DQ]LEDUHGHOODUHJLRQHGHL*UDQGL/DJKLGHOO¶$IULFDFHQWUDOHHVSORUD WD GD % SXz DQFRUD WUDUUH SDUWLWR GDOOH VXH QRWD]LRQL OHVVLFDOL WDOYROWD SUR EOHPDWLFKHFKHYHUWRQRVRSUDWWXWWRVXLQRPLGLSLDQWHHGLDQLPDOLFRPHSXUH VXWHUPLQLFKHGHVLJQDQRHOHPHQWLGHOODJHRJUDILDILVLFDDOLPHQWLHFDSLG¶DE ELJOLDPHQWR /D VHOH]LRQH GL YRFDEROL ± WXWWL UHODWLYL DOO¶DUDER RPDQLWD GL =DQ]LEDUTXHOORFKH%SVWLJPDWL]]DFRPH©WKHJURWHVTXH$UD ELFRI2PDQªWUDQQHO¶XOWLPRWUDWWRGDOO¶DUDERGHO0LGLDQ7KH*ROG0L QHVRI0LGLDQ±FKHSUHVHQWRTXLLQWHQGHVRORHVHPSOLILFDUHLQYLDGHO WXWWRSURYYLVRULDLVRQGDJJLFKHYDGRFRQGXFHQGRFRQLQWHQVLWjG¶DSSOLFD]LR QHYDULDELOHGDWUHDQQLFRQOHORURSRVVLELOLLPSOLFD]LRQLHWQRJUDILFKHHGHW QROLQJXLVWLFKH DNLED!µHQGLQJ¶ ©WKDWSULYDWHVWRUH«JHQHUDOO\VWROHQIURPWKHPDVWHU DQGFRQFHDOHGIRUHPHUJHQFLHVZLWKFXQQLQJFDUHª%S KLVKPDW O¶LO JKDULE ! ©WKH JXHVWZHOFRPH LQ WKH VKDSH RI D JRDW DQG D ORDGRIZKLWHULFHª%S MDPDOHOZDKVKt!µJLUDIIH¶FDOFDWRVXOORVZDKLOLQJDPLD\DPX\WX!³FD PHORIWKHZLOG´%S MRKK!µZDWHUPHORQ¶%S MXQVDO!µSXPSNLQ¶%S NKD\PDK!µWKLQSROHRUULGJHWHQW¶%S HONLVKVKDK!µDQDUURZFUHVWRIKDLUOLNHDFR[¶VFRPEIURPQDSHWREURZ¶ %S KXEXE! ©OLW µWKH EORZLQJ RI ZLQG¶ PHWDSKRULFDOO\ µSRVVHVVLRQ¶ª % S 6DOLE! ©OLW µFURVV¶ µD IRUNHG SROH WR ZKLFKWKH QHFN DQG DQNOHV >RI D VODYH@DUHODVKHG¶ª%SSV *KDXW!µDPXGG\UXQRUFOHDULQJLQWKHWKLFNHWRIVWLIIJUDVVZKLFKFURV VHGWKHVWUHDP¶%S MHPDOHO\iK~G!OHWWµFDPPHOORGHJOLHEUHL¶©ODUJHGDUNOHDWKHU\JUDV VKRSSHUª ©VRPH %HGRXLQV DSSO\ µ-HZV¶ &DPHO¶ WR WKH FKDPHOHRQ DQG FDOOWKHJUDVVKRSSHUKLPiUHOEDQiW!DVVRIWKHJLUOV RUHOVKD\WDQ! RI6DWDQª%SHQ 8QR VFDQGDJOLR DEEDVWDQ]D UDSLGR GHOOD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH OHVVLFRORJLFD FRUUHQWHGjOXRJRDLVHJXHQWLULVFRQWUL SLXWWRVWRFKHODUDGµ4%µSXQLUH¶GHOO¶DUDERGHO*ROIR$U*RLOYDOR UHµVHJXLUHVXFFHGHUH¶GHOODVWHVVDUDGLFHµ4%LQDURPDQLWDHJLjLQDUFODV VLFRPLJOLRUHSXQWHOORVXOSLDQRVHPDQWLFRVHPEUDRIIULUHO¶DUDEREHGXLQRGH JOLµ$]Ɨ]PLKGHO1HJHYLQFXLqGRFXPHQWDWRµDJƗEµUHVWRUHVLGXR¶6KDZDU EDKS±FIU$U*ۊLãPDµPRGHVW\GHFHQF\FRQVHUYDWLYHQHVV¶ 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL 4DILVKHKSHVRSUDWWXWWRO¶DUDERµ$]Ɨ]PLKKDããƗPµWRUHVSHFW WR KRQRXU WR RIIHU UHIUHVKPHQWV IRRG DQG GULQN WR D JXHVW¶ 6KDZDUEDKP SGRYHODVHFRQGDDFFH]LRQHGHOYHUERPRVWUDXQ¶HVWHQVLRQHVH PDQWLFDDQDORJDDTXHOODUHJLVWUDWDGD%±1DNDQRSQU UHJLVWUDSHUzVRORJUiDISHUµJLUDIID¶LQDUDERGL=DQ]LEDU$U=±FIUµDQ JXULD¶LQ$U*ЂL\ۊۊLۊۊ$U1DMGLЂLۊۊ%URFNHWWS+ROHV S$U=$U*JXۊۊD1DNDQRSQUHODFRUULVSRQGHQWHGL VWULEX]LRQHGHOWLSRJX\ۊۊLۊۊЂL[[LQ:$',SSFDUWD± 1DNDQRSQUIRUQLVFHVROWDQWREyREUDEyREDUSHUµ]XFFD¶ FKHULFKLDPDODIRUPDEǀEDUVHJQDODWD±LQDOWHUQDQ]DFRQJDUDµ±GD:$', SFDUWDSHUO¶DUDERGHO*ROIRHRPDQLWD±FIU$U*[ƝPD[Ư PDµWHQGD¶+ROHVSPDFRUULVSRQGHQWLQHRDUDELGHOO¶DUDERFODV VLFRېD\PDKFKHVHPEUDGHQRWDUHSLXWWRVWRµFDSDQQDGLIUDVFKH¶FKHµWHQGD¶ VRQRGLIIXVLLQWXWWRLOPRQGRDUDERIRQRQHOO¶DFFH]LRQHGLµWHQGDGLVWRIID¶GL VWULEX]LRQH HVSRVWD LQ GHWWDJOLR LQ:$' ,, SS FDUWD VHQ]D UL VFRQWUR HVDWWR ULPDUUHEEH SHUDOWUR OD VSHFLILFD]LRQH VHPDQWLFD ULSRUWDWD GD %XUWRQ±FIU$U*NLããDµFDSHOOLWLSLFDDFFRQFLDWXUDPDVFKLOHGHOO¶2PDQ¶ +ROHVS±+ROHVSSVUHJLVWUDVROWDQWRLOVLJQLIL FDWR OHWWHUDOH GHO QRPH YHUEDOHKEnjE µVRIILDUH GHO YHQWR¶ ± QHL GL]LRQDUL GHOO¶DUDERGHO*ROIRVLULSRUWDVRORLOVHQVROHWWHUDOH܈DOƯEµFURFH¶4DILVKHK S±IRUVHFROOHJDWRHWLPRORJLFDPHQWHDOO¶DUDERFODVVLFRƥD\ܔ µSOXLHDERQGDQWHHWTXLV¶pWHQGDX[HQYLURQVYHJHWDWLRQTXLVXUJLWjODVXLWH G¶XQH SOXLH DERQGDQWH¶ .D]LPLUVNL S D DUDER \HPHQLWD ƥDZܔ µSLRJJLD¶%HKQVWHGWSSV±QRQKRSRWXWRULWURYDUHOHGHQR PLQD]LRQL PHWDIRULFKH GL TXHVWD VSHFLH GL ORFXVWD QHOOD ± QRWRULDPHQWH QRQ DEERQGDQWH ± OHWWHUDWXUD OHVVLFRORJLFD GLVSRQLELOH SHU O¶DUDER EHGXLQR GHO QRUGGHOOD3HQLVROD ÊEHQSRVVLELOHFKHXQDSDUWHGLTXHVWLYRFDEROLULVXOWLQRLQXOWLPDDQDOLVL GHL©JKRVWZRUGVªPDLQDWWHVDGLXQRVFUXWLQLRSLSXQWXDOHQRQVLGRYUjGD UHWURSSDLPSRUWDQ]DDOODORURDVVHQ]DQHOODVWUXPHQWD]LRQHOHVVLFRORJLFDGL VSRQLELOH SHU TXHVWR WLSR GL DUDER OD FRQVLVWHQWH PRQRJUDILD GL &DUO 5HLQ 5LQJUD]LRO¶DPLFR$GULDQR5RVVLSHUO¶LQIRUPD]LRQHFKHODIRUPDMXQVDO!GL%QRQWURYDUL VFRQWURQHOOHVVLFRSHUVLDQRHQHSSXUHQHOEDORFLOLQJXDLUDQLFDULPDVWDSHUVHFROLLQFRQWDWWR FRQO¶DUDERRPDQLWD ,OUHSHUWRULRGL%HKQVWHGWH:RLGLFKQRQFRQWHPSODXQDVFKHGDRQRPDVLRORJLDSHUµFDYDOOHW WD¶RµORFXVWD¶PHQWUHJOLROWUHWHUPLQLFKHGHVLJQDQRLOµFDPDOHRQWH¶LYLFHQVLWL:$', SSFDUWDQRQLQFOXGRQRODORFX]LRQHPHWDIRULFDULSRUWDWDGD%XUWRQ 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH KDUGWqSULYDGLJORVVDULRTXHOODDVVDLSLVPLO]DGL-D\DNDUKD XQLQGLFHOHVVLFDOHPROWRHOHPHQWDUHHLOYROXPHWWRGL1DNDQRVXOOHV VLFRIRQGDPHQWDOHGHOO¶DUDERGL=DQ]LEDUVLIRQGDVXXQ¶LQFKLHVWDFRQGRWWDLQ *LDSSRQHFRQXQVRORLQIRUPDQWHSHUXQWRWDOHGLRUHFLUFDDQQLGRSR ODVSHGL]LRQHGL%XUWRQ&RPHVLqYLVWREXRQDSDUWHGLTXHVWHYRFLULVXOWDDO PHQRSODXVLELOHVHVRWWRSRVWDDXQ¶LQGDJLQHFRPSDUDWLYD 2FFDVLRQDOPHQWH%LQWHUYHQLYDGDOODVXDVHGHFRQVRODUHGL7ULHVWHSHU FXL &RULQQD9DOHQWLQL KD FRQLDWR O¶LFDVWLFDPHWDIRUD ©O¶HVLOLR GHO OHR QHª SHU FRPPHQWDUH L UHVRFRQWL GL YLDJJLR GHL VXRL VXFFHVVRUL QHOO¶HVSORUD ]LRQH GHOO¶$UDELD TXDOL &KDUOHV 0RQWDJXH 'RXJKW\ GL FXL VWLJPDWL]]z WUD O¶DOWURJOLHUURULGLDUDERFRQXQ¶HVLEL]LRQHGLH[SHUWLVHYHQDWDGLPDOHYROHQ ]DFKHXQOLEURFDSLWDOHFRPH7UDYHOVLQ$UDELD'HVHUWDQRQRVWDQWHLVXRLGL IHWWLGDYYHURQRQPHULWDYD%HUDSHUDOWURFDSDFHGLJHQHURVLWjYHUVRJOLD UDELVWL SL JLRYDQL SXUFKpGLVSRVWL D ULFRQRVFHUHOD VXDSURSULD HPLQHQ]D LQ TXDQWRFRQRVFLWRUHGHJOL$UDELHGHOO¶DUDERQHGLHGHDEERQGDQWHPHQWHSURYD YHUVR GXH RULHQWDOLVWL GHVWLQDWL D XQD PRUWH SUHFRFH LO VXR FROODERUDWRUH SHU 8QH[SORUHG6\ULD&KDUOHV7\UZKLWW'UDNHHLO/RUG$OPRQHU¶V5HDGHUIRU$ UDELF GL &DPEULGJH (GZDUG + 3DOPHU DVVDVVLQDWR GDOOH VXH JXLGHEHGXLQHQHOGHVHUWRGHO6LQDLGXUDQWHXQDPLVVLRQHSHULOJRYHUQREUL WDQQLFR 'RXJKW\ DYHYD LQYHFH FRPPHVVR LO WRUWR LPSHUGRQDELOH GL QRQ PHQ]LRQDUHPDLQHOVXROLEURLUHVRFRQWLGLYLDJJLRGL%DOOD0HFFDHQHO0L GLDQ ÊDSSHQDLOFDVRGLVHJQDODUHLQILQHFKHOHQXPHURVHRVVHUYD]LRQLGL% VXOOHOLQJXHDIULFDQHQRQVHPLWLFKHFKHLQFRQWUzQHOFRUVRGHLVXRLYLDJJLLQ $IULFDRULHQWDOHHRFFLGHQWDOHVRSUDWWXWWRO¶RURPRJDOODLOVRPDORHORVZD KLOL PHULWHUHEEHUR FHUWDPHQWH XQ¶DWWHQWD DQDOLVL GD SDUWH GL XQR VSHFLDOLVWD QRQPHQRGHLVXRLULOLHYLVXOO¶DUDERGLDOHWWDOHEHQFKpLQSDUWHHVVHQRQHFFH GDQRODQRWD]LRQHVXSHUILFLDOHRLPSUHVVLRQLVWLFD %XUWRQ7DEDFKQLN&RQWLQLSHQFXLULQYLRSHUXOWHULRULULIHUL PHQWLDOOHGLYHUVHLQWHUSUHWD]LRQLGLTXHVWDTXHUHOOH *RGVDOOSSHQQ *RGVDOOSS 6LYHGDLQSDUWLFRODUHLOUDFFRQWRHVLODUDQWHGHJOLVIRU]LGL%SSVSHUUDFFRJOLHUH L QXPHUDOL GL GLYHUVH OLQJXH QHJURDIULFDQH WUDPLWH O¶DLXWR GL XQ PHUFDQWH DUDERIRQR VXVFL WDQGRXQDUHD]LRQHGLVFHWWLFLVPRGDSDUWHGLXQDOWURLQIRUPDWRUHLQFLGHQWHFKHJOLULFKLDPz DOOD PHPRULD L FRPPHQWL GHO VXR SUHFHWWRUH $EED *UHJRULRV ULSRUWDWL GD +LRE /XGROI QHOOD VXDJUDPPDWLFDDPDULFD,OFDWDORJRGL-HDQ.LUNSDWULFNSSLQFOXGHXQD 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL $PR¶GLFRQFOXVLRQH 'XUDQWH OD VXD OXQJD FDUULHUD GL HVSORUDWRUH GLSORPDWLFR H RULHQWDOLVWD SURIHVVLRQLVWD % QRQ VL q RFFXSDWR GL DOWUH OLQJXH VHPLWLFKH PRGHUQH 6RU SUHQGHXQSR¶FKHQRQRVWDQWHGXHGLYHUVLVRJJLRUQLQHOO¶DUFLSHODJRHJOLVHP EUL QRQ HVVHUVL PDL LQWHUHVVDWR DO PDOWHVH FKH SUREDELOPHQWH GLVGHJQDYD FRQVLGHUDQGROR VROR XQD YHUVLRQH FRUURWWD GHOO¶DUDER &LUFRVWDQ]H SROLWLFKH VIDYRUHYROL JOL LPSHGLURQR GL UHDOL]]DUH O¶HVSORUD]LRQH GHO ণDঌUDPDXW H GHO 0DKUDFKHDYHYDSURJHWWDWRLQYLVWDGHOODFRPSLOD]LRQHGLXQ³H[WHQVLYHYR FDEXODU\RIWKH0DKULRU0RGHUQ+LP\DULWLFGLDOHFWV´FLRqGHOOHOLQJXHVXGD UDELFKHPRGHUQHQHOO¶DPELWRGHOSURJUDPPDGHOYLDJJLRHVSORUDWLYRLQ$UD ELD VXGRULHQWDOH ± UDFFRJOLHQGR OD VXFFHVVLRQH GHO ILQODQGHVH *HRUJ :DOOLQ VFRPSDUVR SRFKL PHVL SULPD ± GD OXL SUHVHQWDWR DOOD 5R\DO *HRJUDSKLFDO 6RFLHW\LOQRYHPEUHSULPDGLSDUWLUHSHUODVXDFHOHEUHVSHGL]LRQHDOOD 0HFFD1RQ FRQRVFR WUDFFH GHL VXRL VWXGL GL DPDULFR WUDQQH OD PHQ]LRQH GHOOD SUHVHQ]D GHOOD JUDPPDWLFD GL ,VHQEHUJQHL VXRL EDJDJOL LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOODVXDSDUWHQ]DSHUOD1LOH([SHGLWLRQGHJOLDQQLFRQ6SHNH *LjQHOODUHJLVWUD]LRQHHQHOODYDOXWD]LRQHGHLGDWLOHVVLFDOLGHOOHWUHOLQ JXHFKHKRTXLPROWRVRPPDULDPHQWHSUHVHQWDWRWXWWDYLDULVXOWDFRPH%DE ELD QXWULWR SHU WXWWD OD VXD FDUULHUD GL YLDJJLDWRUH H GL VFULWWRUH XQ LQWHUHVVH PROWRYLYRSHUOHOLQJXHVHPLWLFKHSDUODWHQRQGLVVRFLDWRGDXQDFHUWDSUDWLFD GLDOFXQHPHWRGRORJLHGHOOHVFLHQ]HGHOOLQJXDJJLRGDGLOHWWDQWHVHQ]DGXE ELRPDXQGLOHWWDQWHDYYHGXWRHQRQLJQDURGLSDUWHGHOODOHWWHUDWXUDWHFQLFD %HQLQWHVRqGLIILFLOHVXSHUDUHORVWDGLRGHOOHFRQJHWWXUHSHUTXDQWRFRQFHUQH TXDUDQWLQDGLJUDPPDWLFKHHGL]LRQDULGLOLQJXHGHOO¶$IULFDVXEVDKDULDQDGLHJL]LDQRHFRSWR HGLYDULHOLQJXHEHUEHUH %XUWRQ,,SPHQ]LRQD0DOWDVHQ]DIDUFHQQRDOODOLQJXDVHPLWLFDORFDOH *RGVDOOSS,QHIIHWWL%XUWRQ,,SDFFHQQDDOODSRSROD]LRQHLQ GLJHQD GHO 0DKUDK PD QRQ PHQ]LRQD OH OLQJXH VHPLWLFKH SDUODWH QHOODUHJLRQH SHUDOWUR JLj QRWHDLGRWWLHXURSHLGDDOPHQRXQTXLQGLFHQQLRGDJOLVFULWWLGHOGLSORPDWLFRIUDQFHVH)XOJHQ FH)UHVQHOHGHOYLDJJLDWRUHLQJOHVH-DPHV5D\PRQG:HOOVWHG .:,VHQEHUJ*UDPPDURIWKH$PKDULFODQJXDJH/RQGRQWKH&KXUFK0LVVLRQDU\6RFLHW\ ,OYROXPHQRQqSHUDOWURFHQVLWRLQ.LUNSDWULFN 2OWUHYROXPLGLOLQJXLVWLFDJHQHUDOHHGHVFULWWLYDGHJOLLGLRPLGHLPROWLSDHVLYLVLWDWLRD ELWDWLGD%VRQRLQFOXVLQHOFDWDORJRGL-HDQ.LUNSDWULFNSSPDPROWHDOWUHR SHUHVRQRFLWDWHRDOOXVHVSHVVRLQPRGRSROHPLFRQHLVXRLVFULWWLVHQ]DULOHYDQ]DVWULQJHQWH FRQLOWHPDGLYROWDLQYROWDWUDWWDWRDGLPRVWUDUHFXULRVLWjFRVWDQWHSHUOHVFLHQ]HGHOOLQJXDJ JLRQRQPHQRFKHSHUOHOLQJXH 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH ODVXDHIIHWWLYDSDGURQDQ]DGHOOHOLQJXHSDUODWHPDLOVXRDWWHJJLDPHQWRSLR PHQR³VFLHQWLILFR´YHUVRLOQHRVHPLWLFRDWWHQGHDQFRUDGLHVVHUHYDJOLDWRVXOOD EDVHGHOO¶DQDOLVLGHOVXRWUDWWDPHQWRGHLSUREOHPLJUDPPDWLFDOLHDQFKHGHOOH VXH QXPHURVLVVLPH LSRWHVL HWLPRORJLFKH O¶HWLPRORJLD q XQD GHOOH GLVFLSOLQH OLQJXLVWLFKHFKH%KDSLSUDWLFDWRHGqIRUVHODSLSHULFRORVDGDDIIURQWDUH SHUXQGLOHWWDQWH6RQRFRPSLWLLQRJQLFDVRFKHGHEERULQYLDUHDLQGDJLQLIX WXUH %HQDUDJLRQHLOSULQFLSHGHLEXUWRQLVWLFRQWHPSRUDQHL-DPHV&DVDGDDI IHUPDYDSSVFKH%©DVDOLQJXLVWªUDSSUHVHQWLDQFRUD©XQSOR ZHGJURXQGªPDPROWDULFHUFDXOWHULRUHqDQFRUDQHFHVVDULDSULPDFKHVLSRV VDULVROYHUHLOTXHVLWRGDOXLSRVWRLQWHUPLQLSDUWLFRODUPHQWHLQFLVLYL©:DV% D VFKRODU RI WKH ILUVW PDJQLWXGH RU UDWKHU D SUROLILF GDEEOHU ZKR ORYHG GDE EOLQJLQWRIRRWQRWHV"ª6RORXQDVHULHGLDQDOLVLPLUDWHQHLGLYHUVLDPELWLVFLHQ WLILFLSUDWLFDWLGD%SRWUjPRVWUDUHTXDQWRIRVVHVROLGDOD³VWHUPLQDWDFXOWXUD´ FKHJOLDWWULEXLVFH$WWLOLR%ULOOLLQTXHVWDVHGHKRFHUFDWRSHUSDUWHPLDGLPR VWUDUHFRPHTXHOORFKHLOVXRELRJUDIR,OLMD7URMDQRZKDLFDVWLFDPHQWHGHILQL WRXQ³FROOH]LRQLVWDGLPRQGL´:HOWHQVDPPOHUVLDVWDWRDQFKH±FRQFXULR VLWjQRQVFRPSDJQDWDGDDXWHQWLFRWDOHQWR±XQQRQEDQDOHFROOH]LRQLVWDGLSD UROH %,%/,2*5$),$ $EELQN-*³%XUWRQ5LFKDUG)UDQFLV´LQ68KOLJHG(QF\FORSDHGLD$HWKLRSLFD9R OXPH$&:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]9HUODJSS $UQROG:ð/HKUEXFKGHV1HXZHVWDUDPlLVFKHQ:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]6HPLWLFD9L YD±6HULHV'LGDFWLFD $UQROG:%HKQVWHGW3$UDELVFKDUDPlLVFKH6SUDFKEH]LHKXQJHQLP4DODPnjQ6\UL HQ(LQHGLDOHNWJHRJUDSKLVFKH8QWHUVXFKXQJPLWHLQHUZLUWVFKDIWVXQGVR]LDOJHRJUDSKL VFKHQ(LQIKUXQJYRQ$(VFKHU:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]6HPLWLFD9LYD %HFNHUV + ³=X GHQ )UHPGDOSKDEHWHQ XQG )UHPGVSUDFKHQVSUREHQ LP 5HLVHEHULFKW $U QROGVYRQ+DUII´LQ*+HLQ]36FKPLWWHU+UVJJ&ROOHFWDQHD3KLORORJL FD)HVWVFKULIWIU+*LSSHU]XP*HEXUWVWDJ,%DGHQ%DGHQ9DOHQWLQ.RHUQHUSS %HKQVWHGW3*ORVVDUGHUMHPHQLWLVFKHQ'LDOHNWZ|UWHULQ(GXDUG*ODVHUV7DJHEFKHU,, ,,, 9, 9,, 9,,, ; :LHQ 9HUODJ GHU |VWHUUHLFKLVFKHQ $NDGHPLH GHU :LVVHQVFKDIWHQ 6LW]XQJVEHULFKWH GHU gVWHUUHLFKLVFKHQ $NDGHPLH GHU:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ 9HU|IIHQWOL FKXQJHQGHUDUDELVFKHQ.RPPLVVLRQ 7URMDQRZDFFDWWLYDQWHELRJUDILDURPDQ]DWDDOORVWHVVRDXWRUHVLGHYHDQFKH XQDSL FDQRQLFDELRJUDILDLOOXVWUDWDGLVFRUVLYD 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL ² 'LH QRUGMHPHQLWLVFKHQ 'LDOHNWH 7HLO *ORVVDU ,, 'ƗOƤD\Q :LHVEDGHQ 5HLFKHUW -HPHQ6WXGLHQ %HUJVWUlVVHU**ORVVDUGHVQHXDUDPlLVFKHQ'LDOHNWVYRQ0DµOnjOD/HLS]LJ)$%URFN KDXV$EKDQGOXQJHQIUGLH.XQGHGHV0RUJHQODQGHV %M¡UQV¡V $ UHFHQVLRQH GL 8 6HHJHU'HU DUDELVFKH 'LDOHNW GHU '|UIHU XP 5DPDOODK :LHVEDGHQ LQ =HLWVFKULIW GHU 'HXWVFKHQ 0RUJHQOlQGLVFKHQ *HVHOOVFKDIW SS %UDOO7XFKHO+5HLFKHUW)5RP±-HUXVDOHP±6DQWLDJR'DV3LOJHUWDJHEXFKGHV5LW WHUV$UQROGYRQ+DUII.|OQ:HLPDU:LHQ%|KODX9HUODJ %ULOOL$,OYLDJJLRLQ2ULHQWH%RORJQD,O0XOLQR%LEOLRWHFDVWRULFD %URFNHWW$$7KHVSRNHQ$UDELFRI.KƗEnjUDRQWKH%ƗܒLQDRI2PDQ0DQFKHVWHU0DQ FKHVWHU83-RXUQDORI6HPLWLF6WXGLHV6XSSOHPHQW %XUWRQ/,7KH/LIHRI&DSWDLQ6LU5LFKDUG)%XUWRQ.&0*)5*6E\KLVZLIH ,%,,,/RQGRQ&KDSPDQ+DOO/WG %XUWRQ5)U3HUVRQDOQDUUDWLYHRIDSLOJULPDJHWRDO0DGLQDK0HFFDK,,,,/RQ GRQ >FLW QHOOD ULVW 1HZ <RUN 'RYHU GHOOD³0HPRULDO (GLWLRQ´ YROO /RQGRQ @ ²)LUVWIRRWVWHSVLQ(DVW$IULFDRUDQH[SORUDWLRQRI+DUDU/RQGRQ>FLWQHOODULVW1HZ <RUN'RYHUGHOOD³0HPRULDO´HGLWLRQ/RQGRQ@ ² 7KH ODNHUHJLRQVRI &HQWUDO $IULFD ,,, /RQGRQ /RQJPDQ %URZQ *UHHQ /RQJ PDQV ²=DQ]LEDUFLW\LVODQGDQGFRDVW,,,/RQGRQ7LQVOH\%URV ²7KHJROGPLQHVRI0LGLDQDQGWKHUXLQHG0LGLDQLWHFLWLHV$IRUWQLJKW¶VWRXULQ1RUWK ZHVWHUQ$UDELD/RQGRQ.HJDQ3DXO&R ²7KHODQGRI0LGLDQUHYLVLWHG,,,/RQGRQ.HJDQ3DXO&R ²WU7KH%RRNRIWKH7KRXVDQG1LJKWVDQGD1LJKW,;%HQDUHV/RQGRQ%XUWRQ &OXE ²WU6XSSOHPHQWDO1LJKWVWRWKH%RRNRIWKH7KRXVDQG1LJKWVDQGD1LJKW,9,%H QDUHV/RQGRQ%XUWRQ&OXE ²³0U'RXJKW\¶VWUDYHOV´LQ$FDGHP\/RQGRQSS ²/¶2ULHQWHLVODPLFR1RWHDQWURSRORJLFKHDOOH0LOOHHXQD1RWWH$FGL*UD]LHOOD0DU WLQD&RPR3DYLD,ELV ²7\UZKLWW'UDNH&K)8QH[SORUHG6\ULD9LVLWVWRWKH/LEDQXVWKH7XO~OHO6DIiWKH $QWL/LEDQXVWKHQRUWKHUQ/LEDQXVDQGWKH¶$OiK,,,/RQGRQ7LQVOH\%URWKHUV &DUGRQD*5³,YLDJJLHOHVFRSHUWH´LQ$$VRU5RVDDF/DOHWWHUDWXUDLWDOLDQD9 /HTXHVWLRQL7RULQR(LQDXGLSS *5&,OLQJXDJJLGHOVDSHUH3UHID]LRQH GL$$VRU5RVD5RPD%DUL/DWHU]DSS ²,QWURGX]LRQHDOO¶HWQROLQJXLVWLFD,QWURGX]LRQH GL0DUFR0DQFLQL7RULQR87(78QL YHUVLWj &DVDGD-$6LU5LFKDUG)%XUWRQDELRELEOLRJUDSKLFDOVWXG\/RQGRQ0DQVHOO ²³&RQFOXGLQJUHPDUNV´LQ-XW]LDSS &DVDUL%(³$GGLWLRQVWR%XUWRQ¶VELEOLRJUDSK\´LQ-XW]LDSS &RKHQ0eWXGHVG¶pWKLRSLHQPpULGLRQDO3DULV/LEUDLULH2ULHQWDOLVWH3DXO*HXWKQHU6R FLpWp$VLDWLTXH&ROOHFWLRQG¶2XYUDJHV2ULHQWDX[ &RQWLQL5³µ,DVHWLDQHPDRPLJHQRQGHODLQ¶SRVWLOODDOO¶DUDERYDUWHPLDQR´LQ'GH5R EHUWLV)*DYD]]HQLDF2SHURVDSDUYDSHU*LDQQL$QWRQLPL9HURQD(GL]LRQL9DOGR QHJDSS 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH ²³$SSXQWL VXOOH PLQRUDQ]H OLQJXLVWLFKH DUDPHRIRQH LQ 6LULD´ LQ $0 'L 7ROOD D F 6WXGL EHUEHUL H PHGLWHUUDQHL 0LVFHOODQHD RIIHUWD LQ RQRUH GL /XLJL 6HUUD , 6WXGL 0DƥUHELQL1DSROL,82SS ²³7UDYHOOLWHUDWXUHDVDOLQJXLVWLFVRXUFHDQRWKHUORRNDW'RXJKW\¶V1DMGL$UDELFJORV VDU\´LQ)0)DOHV*)*UDVVLDF&$06(08'3URFHHGLQJVRIWKHWK,WD OLDQ 0HHWLQJ RI $IURDVLDWLF /LQJXLVWLFV KHOG LQ 8GLQH 0D\ VWWK 3DGRYD 6$5*21(GLWULFHH/LEUHULDSS ² ³µ« OLNH DQ $WWLF VZHHWQHVV LQ WKH $UDELDQWRQJXH¶ &KDUOHV 0 'RXJKW\ H O¶DUDER QDۜGL´LQ)0D]]HL3&DULRWLDF2ULHQWH2FFLGHQWHHGLQWRUQL«6FULWWLLQRQRUHGL $GROIR 7DPEXUHOOR 1DSROL 8QLYHUVLWj GL 1DSROL ³/¶2ULHQWDOH´ 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL 6WXGL $VLDWLFL,VWLWXWR,WDOLDQRSHUO¶$IULFDHO¶2ULHQWHSS 'HQL]HDX&O'LFWLRQQDLUHGHVSDUOHUVDUDEHVGH6\ULH/LEDQHW3DOHVWLQH3DULVeGLWLRQV *30DLVRQQHXYHeWXGHV$UDEHVHW,VODPLTXHVeWXGHVHW'RFXPHQWV (UDUG0%DEHOQRPRUH7KHVHDUFKIRUWKHZRUOG¶VPRVWH[WUDRUGLQDU\ODQJXDJHOHDU QHUV1HZ<RUNHWF)UHH3UHVV *RGVDOO-5³)DFWDQGILFWLRQLQ5LFKDUG%XUWRQ¶V3HUVRQDOQDUUDWLYHRIDSLOJULPDJHWR HO0HGLQDKDQG0HFFDK´LQ-RXUQDORIWKH5R\DO$VLDWLF6RFLHW\SS ²7KHWDQJOHGZHEDOLIHRI6LU5LFKDUG%XUWRQ/HLFHVWHU0DWDGRU>FLWULVWSDSHUEDFN @ *URW]IHOG + ³$UDELVFKH :RUWOLVWHQ LQ 3LOJHUKDQGEFKHUQ GHV -DKUKXQGHUWV´ LQ $ )RGRUDF3URFHHGLQJVRIWKHWK&RQJUHVVRIWKH8QLRQ(XURSpHQQHGHV$UDELVDQWVHW ,VODPLVDQWV%XGDSHVWWK$XJXVW±UG6HSWHPEHU,,%XGDSHVW(|WY|V/RUiQG 8QLYHUVLW\&KDLUIRU$UDELF6WXGLHV%XGDSHVW6WXGLHVLQ$UDELFSS +ROHV&'LDOHFWFXOWXUHDQGVRFLHW\LQ(DVWHUQ$UDELD,*ORVVDU\/HLGHQ%RVWRQ %ULOO+DQGEXFKGHU2ULHQWDOLVWLN, ,QJKDP % 1DMGL $UDELF &HQWUDO $UDELDQ $PVWHUGDP -%HQMDPLQV /RQGRQ 2ULHQWDO DQG$IULFDQ/DQJXDJH/LEUDU\ ,UZLQ57KH$UDELDQ1LJKWVDFRPSDQLRQ/RQGRQ1HZ<RUN7DXULV3DUNH3DSHU EDFNV ²)RUOXVWRINQRZLQJWKH2ULHQWDOLVWVDQGWKHLUHQHPLHV/RQGRQ3HQJXLQ -D\DNDU$6*³7KH2¶PDQHHGLDOHFWRI$UDELF3DUWV,,,´LQ-RXUQDORIWKH5R\DO$VLD WLF6RFLHW\SS -XW]L $+ HG D ,Q VHDUFK RI 6LU 5LFKDUG %XUWRQ 3DSHUV IURP D +XQWLQJWRQ /LEUDU\ 6\PSRVLXP6DQ0DULQR&$+HQU\$+XQWLQJWRQ/LEUDU\DQG$UW*DOOHU\ ²E³%XUWRQDQGKLVOLEUDU\´LQ-XW]LDSS .D]LPLUVNL$GH%LEHUVWHLQ'LFWLRQQDLUHDUDEHIUDQoDLV,,,3DULV0DLVRQQHXYH&LH .HQQHG\ ' 7KH KLJKO\ FLYLOL]HG PDQ 5LFKDUG %XUWRQ DQG WKH 9LFWRULDQ ZRUOG &DP EULGJH0$/RQGRQ+DUYDUG83 .LUNSDWULFN %- $ FDWDORJXH RI WKH OLEUDU\ RI 6LU 5LFKDUG %XUWRQ /RQGRQ 5R\DO $Q WKURSRORJLFDO,QVWLWXWH .RHUQHU()U.8QLYHUVDOLQGH[RIELRJUDSKLFDOQDPHVLQWKHODQJXDJHVFLHQFHV6WXGLHV LQWKH+LVWRU\RIWKH/DQJXDJHV6FLHQFHV$PVWHUGDP3KLODGHOSKLD-%HQMDPLQV /HVODX:(W\PRORJLFDOGLFWLRQDU\RI+DUDUL%HUNHOH\/RV$QJHOHV8QLYHUVLW\RI&D OLIRUQLD3UHVV ²$QDQQRWDWHGELEOLRJUDSK\RIWKH6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVRI(WKLRSLD/RQGRQ7KH+DJXH 3DULV0RXWRQ&R%LEOLRJUDSKLHVRQWKH1HDU(DVW ²$UDELFORDQZRUGVLQ(WKLRSLDQ6HPLWLF:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW] 5LFFDUGR&RQWLQL /LWWPDQQ(³+DUDUL6WXGLHQ´LQ=HLWVFKULIWIU6HPLWLVWLNXQGYHUZDQGWH*HELHWHSS 0DLHU%:LOOLDP5REHUWVRQ6PLWKKLVOLIHKLVZRUNDQGKLVWLPHV7ELQJHQ0RKU6LH EHFN)RUVFKXQJHQ]XP$OWHQ7HVWDPHQW ² 6HPLWLF VWXGLHV LQ 9LFWRULDQ %ULWDLQ $ SRUWUDLW RI :LOOLDP :ULJKW DQG KLV ZRUOG WKURXJKKLVOHWWHUV$UEHLWVPDWHULDOLHQ]XP2ULHQW%G:U]EXUJ(UJRQ9HUODJ 0DQFLQL0/¶HVRWLVPRQHOOHVVLFRLWDOLDQR9LWHUER8QLYHUVLWjGHOOD7XVFLD%LEOLRWHFD GLULFHUFKHOLQJXLVWLFKHHILORORJLFKH 1DNDQR $ $ EDVLF YRFDEXODU\ RI =DQ]LEDU $UDELF 7RN\R ,QVWLWXWH IRU WKH 6WXG\ RI /DQJXDJHVDQG&XOWXUHVRI$VLDDQG$IULFD 1DVUDOODK - ³9R\DJHXUV HW SpOHULQV DX 4DODPRXQ´ LQ %XOOHWLQ G¶eWXGHV 2ULHQWDOHV >@SS 3DOYD+³/LQJXLVWLFREVHUYDWLRQVRQWKHH[SORUHUVRI$UDELDLQWKHWKFHQWXU\´LQ( :DUGLQLHG%XLOWRQ6ROLG5RFN6WXGLHVLQ+RQRXURI3URIHVVRU(EEH(JHGH.QXGVHQ RQWKH2FFDVLRQRIKLVWK%LUWKGD\$SULOWK2VOR1RYXVSS ²³5HPDUNVRQWKH$UDELFGLDOHFWVRIWKHণZƝ৬ƗWWULEH´LQ-HUXVDOHP6WXGLHVLQ$UDELF DQG,VODPSS 3HQ]HU 10 $Q DQQRWDWHG ELEOLRJUDSK\ RI 6LU 5LFKDUG )UDQFLV %XUWRQ /RQGRQ $0 3KLOSRW/WG 3IXOOPDQQ8'XUFK:VWHXQG6WHSSH(QWGHFNHUOH[LNRQDUDELVFKH+DOELQVHO±%LRJUD SKLHQXQG%HULFKWH%HUOLQ7UDIR9HUODJ 3URYHQoDO 3K ³7KH FXOWXUDO VLJQLILFDQFH RI WKH UHVXOWV LQ QDWXUDO KLVWRU\ PDGH E\ WKH $UDELFWUDYHO3HWHU)RUVNnO¶VFRQWULEXWLRQWR$UDELFOH[LFRJUDSK\´LQ-:LH VHK|IHU6&RQHUPDQQ+UVJJ&DUVWHQ1LHEXKUXQGVHLQH=HLW%HLWUlJH HLQHV LQWHUGLV]LSOLQlUHQ 6\PSRVLXP YRP 2NWREHU LQ (XWLQ 6WXWWJDUW )UDQ] 6WHLQHU9HUODJ2ULHQVHW2FFLGHQVSS 3U\P ( ³$XV HLQHP %ULHI GHV +HUUQ 'U 3U\P DQ 3URI )OHLVFKHU´ LQ =HLWVFKULIW GHU 'HXWVFKHQ0RUJHQOlQGLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWSS 4DILVKHK+$17&¶V<HPHQL$UDELF±(QJOLVKGLFWLRQDU\$FRPSDFWGLFWLRQDU\RIWKH &RQWHPSRUDU\$UDELFRI<HPHQ/LQFROQZRRG&KLFDJR,/17&3XEOLVKLQJ*URXS 5HLQKDUGW&(LQDUDELVFKHU'LDOHNWJHVSURFKHQLQµ2PDQXQG=DQ]LEDU6WXWWJDUW%HU OLQ:6SHPDQQ/HKUEFKHUGHV6HPLQDUVIU2ULHQWDOLVFKH6SUDFKHQ]X%HUOLQ 6DLG(:2ULHQWDOLVP1HZ<RUN9LQWDJH%RRNV 6D\FH$+³6LU5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQ´LQ*HRJUDSKLFDO-RXUQDOSS 6KDZDUEDK0$JUDPPDURI1HJHY$UDELF&RPSDUDWLYHVWXGLHVWH[WVDQGJORVVDU\LQ WKH%HGRXLQGLDOHFWRIWKHF$]Ɨ]PLKWULEH:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]6HPLWLFD9LYD 6RUDYLD*³,OIUDVDULRDUDERGL/XGRYLFRGH9DUWKHPD´LQ*5)UDQFLDF/D EHQHGL]LRQHGL%DEHOH&RQWULEXWLDOODVWRULDGHJOLVWXGLRULHQWDOLHOLQJXLVWLFLHGHOOHSUH VHQ]HRULHQWDOLD%RORJQD%RORJQD&/8(%SS 7DEDFKQLN6(³%XUWRQ¶VUHYLHZRI'RXJKW\¶V$UDELD'HVHUWD´LQ-XW]LDSS 7DOPRQ5³WKFHQWXU\3DOHVWLQLDQ$UDELF:HVWHUQWUDYHOOHUV¶WHVWLPRQ\´LQ-HUXVD OHP6WXGLHVLQ$UDELFDQG,VODPSS 7KURZHU-$³7ZRXQOLNHO\WUDYHOOLQJFRPSDQLRQV6LU5LFKDUG%XUWRQDQG:LOOLDP5R EHUWVRQ6PLWKLQ(J\SW´LQ:-RKQVWRQHDF:LOOLDP5REHUWVRQ6PLWK(VVD\VLQ UHDVVHVVPHQW 6KHIILHOG 6KHIILHOG $FDGHPLF 3UHVV -RXUQDO IRUWKH 6WXG\ RI 2OG 7HVWD PHQW6XSSOHPHQW6HULHVSS 7URMDQRZ,'HU:HOWHQVDPPOHU0QFKHQ&DUO+DQVHU9HUODJ 5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQHVSORUDWRUHGHOOHOLQJXHQHRVHPLWLFKH ²1RPDGHDXIYLHU.RQWLQHQWHQ$XIGHQ6SXUHQYRQ6LU5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQ)UDQN IXUWDP0DLQ(LFKERUQ9HUODJ 9DOHQWLQL&/¶HVLOLRGHOOHRQH5LFKDUG)UDQFLV%XUWRQGDOO¶$IULFDD7ULHVWH0HPRULH 7ULHVWH0*63UHVV 9LFHQWHȳ)XHQWHVSDUDHOHVWXGLRGHORVGLDOHFWRViUDEHV´LQ(VWXGLRVGHGLDOHFWRORJtD QRUWHDIULFDQD\DQGDOXVt>@SS :$',,, %HKQVWHGW3:RLGLFK0:RUWDWODVGHUDUDELVFKHQ'LDOHNWH%G,0HQVFK1D WXU )DXQD XQG )ORUD %G ,, 0DWHULHOOH .XOWXU /HLGHQ %RVWRQ %ULOO +DQGEXFK GHU 2ULHQWDOLVWLN,,,, :DJQHU(+DUDUDQQRWLHUWH%LEOLRJUDSKLH]XP6FKULIWWXPEHUGLH6WDGWXQGGHQ,VODP LQ6GRVWlWKLRSLHQ:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]$HWKLRSLVWLVFKH)RUVFKXQJHQ ²³+DUDUL´LQ6:HQLQJHUHWDOHGV7KH6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVDQLQWHUQDWLRQDOKDQG ERRN +DQGEXFKHU ]XU 6SUDFK XQG .RPPXQLNDWLRQV:LVVHQVFKDIW %HUOLQ 1HZ <RUN'H*UX\WHU0RXWRQSS :LOG6/LEDQHVLVFKH2UWVQDPHQ7\SRORJLHXQG'HXWXQJ%HLUXW:LHVEDGHQ)6WHL QHU%HLUXWHU6WXGLHQXQG7H[WH :RLGLFK0=DFN/³7KHJЂTXHVWLRQLQ(J\SWLDQ$UDELFUHYLVLWHG´LQ($O:HU5 GH-RQJHGV$UDELFGLDOHFWRORJ\,QKRQRXURI&OLYH+ROHVRQWKHRFFDVLRQRIKLVVL[ WLHWKELUWKGD\6WXGLHVLQ6HPLWLF/DQJXDJHVDQG/LQJXLVWLFV/HLGHQ%RVWRQ%ULOO SS :ROI0+XJR6FKXFKDUGW1DFKODVV6FKOVVHO]XP1DFKODVVGHV/LQJXLVWHQXQG5RPD QLVWHQ +XJR 6FKXFKDUGW *UD] /H\NDP $UEHLWHQ DXV GHU $EWHLOXQJ µ9HU JOHLFKHQGH6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW¶ )5$1&2&5(9$7,1 7UHQRWHGLILORORJLDHJL]LDQD ,OYLOODJJLRGLQRPH$QWDLRV 'LRGRURQHOODVXDYHUVLRQHGHOPLWRGL2VLULGHDWWULEXLVFHODYHQGHWWDGHO FULPLQHGL6HWKDG,VLGHHD+RUXVVHFRQGRORVWRULFR*UHFRODGHDDYUHEEH VWHUPLQDWRO¶DVVDVVLQRHLVXRLFRPSOLFLLQXQDEDWWDJOLDFKHVLVDUHEEHVYROWD ǜǍǝʋ ǠʓǙ ǜǛǠǍǘʓǙ ǜǗǓǟʒǛǙ Ǡ˝Ǟ Ǚ˺Ǚ ȫǙǠǍʒǛǡ ǖʘǘǓǞ ǖǍǗǛǡǘʎǙǓǞ ɂǙ ǖǑ˫ǟǔǍǕ ǘʍǙ ǗʎǏǛǡǟǕǙ ȳǙ Ǡ̈ ǖǍǠʋ ǠʏǙ ȫǝǍǎʒǍǙ ǘʎǝǑǕ ǠʏǙ ǜǝǛǟǓǏǛǝʒǍǙ ǐ˕ ȷǣǑǕǙ ȣǜʓ ǠǛ˺ ǖǛǗǍ ǟǔʎǙǠǛǞ ɬǢ˕ ɈǝǍǖǗʎǛǡǞ ȫǙǠǍʒǛǡ ǠǛ˺ ǖǍǠʋ ǠʏǙ ɥǟʒǝǕǐǛǞ ɀǗǕǖʒǍǙ ǏǑǙǛǘʎǙǛǡ%LEO KLVW, /DJLXVWLILFD]LRQHHWLPRORJLFDFKHGLSHQGH±VHFRQGRO¶DELWXGLQHGL'LR GRUR ± GDL PLWL JUHFL PHWWH LQ RPEUD LQYRORQWDULDPHQWH XQ SDUWLFRODUH LP SRUWDQWHRVVLDFKHLOYLOODJJLRGL$QWDLRVHUDQRWRHVFOXVLYDPHQWHLQUHOD]LRQH DOIDWWRPLWLFRÊSHUFLzQHFHVVDULRHVFOXGHUHTXDOVLDVLUHOD]LRQHGLUHWWDRLQGL UHWWD FRQ OD FLWWj GL $QWDHRSROLV HJL]ؿEZ H FRQ LO VXR GLR $QWLXQD FLWWj ǜʔǗǕǞ T ǘǓǠǝʔǜǛǗǕǞ PDL GHILQLWD XQ YLOODJJLR 'LRGRUR KD SUREDELOPHQWH VHQWLWRSDUODUHǗʎǏǛǡǟǕǙGL$QWDLRVGXUDQWHODVXDSHUPDQHQ]DLQ(JLWWRGX UDQWH LO UHJQR GL 7RORPHR $XOHWH (VVHQGR LO WRSRQLPR ULFRUGDWR DOO¶LQWHUQR GHOPLWRGHOODPRUWHGL2VLULGHFKH'LRGRURUDFFRQWDGLIIXVDPHQWHqOHJLWWL PRVXSSRUUHFKHOHVXHIRQWLIRVVHURVDFHUGRWDOL$QWDLRVDYHYDGXQTXHXQVL JQLILFDWRUHOLJLRVRQRQDPPLQLVWUDWLYRRWRSRJUDILFRHGqSRVVLELOHDQ]LSUR EDELOHFKHIRVVHSRFRSLGLXQOLHXGLWFRPHVSHVVRDYYLHQHQHOODJHRJUDILD UHOLJLRVDSRLFKpQRQWURYLDPRQHOODGRFXPHQWD]LRQHSDSLURORJLFDJUHFDDOFXQ YLOODJJLRFRQTXHVWRQRPH %UXQQHU )UDQFR&UHYDWLQ 3HQVRFKHODUHVDJUHFD$QWDLRVSRVVDFRUULVSRQGHUHDOODFpOqEUHORFDOLWj 1G\W)XD1G\WFKH2VLULVIXXFFLVRVHFRQGRXQDWUDGL]LRQHPROWR GL DQWLFDSUHVHQWHJLjQHL7HVWLGHOOH3LUDPLGLDGHVHFFHGqQHOOR VWHVVROXRJRFKHHEEHOXRJRODGHFLVLYDEDWWDJOLDQHOODTXDOH6HWKHLVXRLDF FROLWLYHQQHURGLVWUXWWL4XHOODEDWWDJOLDHUDRJJHWWRDQQXDOPHQWHGLXQDVDFUD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQHGXUDQWHL³PLVWHUL´GL2VLULGHDG$E\GRVFRPHVLULIHULVFH QHOODVWHOHGL,NKHUQRIUHW0HGLR5HJQR%HUOLQ ©,RKRDEEDWWXWWRWXWWL,VXRLGL2VLULGHQHPLFLVXOEDQFRGLVDEELDLQ1G\Wª $OWULWHVWLFLWDQRLOEDQFRGL1G\WDGHV3\UVW0HWWHUQLFKHFF R LQ DOWHUQDWLYD DOOD ZµUW O¶DUHD GHVHUWLFD GHO SODWHDX GHOOD QHFURSROL GL $E\GRV &7 D FKH HUDFKLDUDPHQWH GDOOD SDUWH GHO1LOR&RPH VL YHGH F¶qGXQTXHXQDQRWHYROHFRLQFLGHQ]DFRQODFROORFD]LRQHLQGLFDWDGD'LRGRUR 5LFRUGHUHPRGDXOWLPRFKHQHOOHIRQWLHJL]LDQHLOWRSRQLPR1G\WQRQVHPEUD DYHUHFRQQHVVLRQHFRQLQVHGLDPHQWLXPDQLPDVRORFRQFDUDWWHULGLRUGLQHUH OLJLRVR6LFFRPHLOWRSRQLPRQRQqDWWHVWDWRLQFRSWRSRVVLDPRGLUSRFRVXO ODVXDIRUPDIRQHWLFDÊFRPXQTXHFHUWRFKHQXOODVLRSSRQHDOO¶LGHQWLILFD]LR QHTXLSURSRVWDSHUFKpLOVXIILVVRGHOIHPPLQLOHHUDFDGXWRGDWHPSRHODG LQWHUQDHUDVWDWDGHVRQRUL]]DWDDOWUHWWDQWRDQWLFDPHQWHʶPROWRSUREDELOHFKH ODIRUPDXGLWDGD'LRGRURVLDVWDWDƼQWDMRVLPGDOODTXDOHHUDSUHVVRFKpLQH YLWDELOHSHUXQ*UHFRSURSRUUHXQ¶DVVRFLD]LRQHFRQLOQRPHGHOO¶HURH$QWDLRV /¶RPEUDGL5Dµ 4XDQWRVDSSLDPRVXOFRQFHWWRHJL]LDQRGLãZW³RPEUD´qVLQWHWL]]DWRGD : 6FKHQNHO&UHGR WXWWDYLD FKH TXDOFKH SDUDOOHOR HWQRJUDILFR DLXWL D FRP SUHQGHUHPHJOLRODGLPHQVLRQHVHPDQWLFDGHOSUREOHPD/¶³RPEUD´ãZWqLO SURGRWWR GL XQ RVWDFROR IUDSSRVWR D XQD VRUJHQWH OXPLQRVD ± RPEUD GXQTXH FRPH DVVHQ]D GL OXFH H ULSDUR ULVSHWWR DOOD OXFH VWHVVDLO GHYRWR SRWHYD GL FKLDUDUH TXDQWR IRVVH SLDFHYROH VHGHUH DOO¶RPEUD GHO WHPSLR GHO SURSULR GLR 0RQWHWS 6FKHQNHO /DVFHOWDGHOO¶LGHRJUDPPDGHOIODEHOOR SHULQGLFDUHO¶RPEUDqVLJQLILFDWLYD 7UHQRWHGLILORORJLDHJL]LDQD HVHQWLUHJOLLQQLUHFLWDWLGDLVDFHUGRWLDGHV%HUOLQ/¶³RP EUD´qDOWUHVuXQDFRPSRQHQWHDXWRQRPDGHOODSHUVRQDXPDQDXQDFRPSRQHQ WHVHQ]LHQWHLQJUDGRGLDJLUHHVXOODTXDOHSRWHYDQRDJLUHIRU]HVRSUDQQDWXUD OLEHQHILFKHRPDOYDJLH&LVRQRWHVWLQHLTXDOLDOFRQFHWWRGLRPEUDGLXQGLR RGHO)DUDRQHqDVVRFLDWRTXHOORGLSRWHQ]DGLLQWHUYHQWR$WXWWRFLzYDDJ JLXQWD OD GHVLJQD]LRQH GL XQ SDUWLFRODUH WLSR GL WHPSLR GHGLFDWR QHO 1XRYR 5HJQRDOFXOWRVRODUHHGHILQLWRãW5µZO¶RPEUDGHOGLRVRODUH5Dµ'DWRFKH WDOHHGLILFLRHUDDFLHORDSHUWRO¶DVVHQ]DGLOXFHQRQHUDODVXDFDUDWWHULVWLFD SL HYLGHQWHVL SRWUHEEH DQ]L SHQVDUH FKH LQ TXHVWR FDVR OD SDURODãZW SR WHVVHYDOHUH%HVWUDKOXQJ &¶qGXQTXHXQLPEDUD]]DQWHFRQIOLWWRWUDODFRQFH]LRQHGLXQ¶RPEUDLQDW WLYDULSDURGDOODOXFHHXQ¶RPEUDDWWLYDVHQ]LHQWHSRWHQWHHGHYHQWXDOPHQWH HVSRVWDDULVFKLXQFRQIOLWWRFKHQRQqWDOHVHYLVWRLQXQ¶RWWLFDHWQROLQJXLVWL FD,QPROWHOLQJXHHFXOWXUHGHOO¶$IULFDRFFLGHQWDOHEDZOpNXODQJRZRORI HFFHVLVWHXQDGLVWLQ]LRQHSUHFLVDWUDO¶RPEUDGLXQDUHDOWjULWHQXWDLQDQLPDWD DGHVXQDURFFLDXQDOEHURHO¶RPEUDGLXQHVVHUHYLYHQWHDGHVEDZOpIRQ YzZDZpQHOSULPRFDVRO¶RPEUDqGLIDWWRDVVHQ]DGLOXFHHGXQTXHSXzH TXLYDOHUHDXQULSDURPHQWUHQHOVHFRQGRODOXPLQRVLWjRPEUDQRQKDQQRDO FXQDULOHYDQ]DVRQRO¶DVSHWWRHVWHULRUHGLTXDOFRVDGLSURIRQGDPHQWHGLYHUVR ,OEDZOpZDZpLQGLFDLQIDWWLVLDO¶RPEUDGLXQXRPRVLDLOULIOHVVRGHOODVXD LPPDJLQHQHOO¶DFTXDVLDLOVXRSULQFLSLRYLWDOHXQSULQFLSLRLQGLYLGXDOHHSR WHQ]LDOPHQWHHVSRVWRDULVFKLGLDJJUHVVLRQHPDJLFD 5LWHQJRPROWRSUREDELOHFKHQHOODFXOWXUDUHOLJLRVDHJL]LDQDLOFRQFHWWRGL ãZWIRVVHLQQDQ]LWXWWRTXHOORGLSURLH]LRQHDQLPDWDGLXQHVVHUHSURLH]LRQH FKHSHUXQGLRQRQHUDDVVHQ]DGLOXFHPDODOXFHVWHVVDHGHUDGXQTXHGR WDWDGHOOHTXDOLWjHVVHQ]LDOLSURSULHGHOO¶HVVHUHVWHVVR 5LFRUGRDOFXQLWHVWLSHULTXDOLO¶LQWHUSUHWD]LRQHRUDDYDQ]DWDSDUHO¶XQLFD UDJLRQHYROH1HOODFHOHEUH7UDXPVWHOHGL7KXWPRVL,9ODVILQJHGL*L]DYLHQH GHVFULWWD FRVu©/D JUDQGLRVD LPPDJLQH GL .KHSHUL JLDFH LQ TXHVWROXRJR -DQVHQ:LQNHOQS *HRUJH *HRUJHSVV 6WDGHOPDQQFRO.RQUDGSVV 6WDGHOPDQQFLW (FLzUHQGHUHEEHUDJLRQHGHOODGHVLJQD]LRQHGHLWHPSOLVRODULVRSUDULFRUGDWL +HOFNS )UDQFR&UHYDWLQ JUDQGHGLSRWHQ]DHVDQWDGLYHQHUDELOLWjHO¶RPEUDGL5DµVLqSRVDWDVXGLHV VDª 1HOO¶LQQRDG$PRQGL3DS/HLGHQ,YHUVRVLGLFHGHOGLRWHEDQR ©/HWXHLPPDJLQLVRQRLQRVWULWHPSOLODWXDRPEUDqRJQLGLRª ÊDPLRSDUHUHFKLDURFKHLQFDVLFRPHTXHVWLDEELDPRDFKHIDUHFRQOD SURLH]LRQHGLTXDOLWjHVVHQ]LDOLWUDPLWHDSSXQWRO¶©RPEUDª 8QDWUDFFLDGHOQD]LRQDOLVPRHJL]LDQR 8Q¶LVFUL]LRQHGHOWHPSLRWROHPDLFRGL%LJDKDXQFRQWHQXWRVRUSUHQGHQ WHLOWHVWRUHFLWD ©$EDWRQ%LJJD(GIX7HEH'HQGHUD0HPILSHUWXWWLLVHFROLGHLVHFROLÊJLXVWLIL FDWR5DµQHOVXRGLVFRVRODUHLOSULQFLSHGHJOLGHLFRQWURLVXRLQHPLFLqJLXVWLILFDWR -DK7KRWLOSULQFLSHGHJOLGHLFRQWUR>LVXRLQHPL@FLª ,O WHVWR q FRVWLWXLWR GD GXH SDUWL WUD ORUR LQGLSHQGHQWL LO VHQVR GHOOD VH FRQGDSDUWHSXzHVVHUULWHQXWRODWRVHQVXOLWXUJLFRTXHOORGHOODSULPD±O¶HVDO WD]LRQHGLDOFXQLLPSRUWDQWLOXRJKLGLFXOWR±GHULYDDPLRSDUHUHGDOODULIRU PXOD]LRQH GL XQ PRGHOOR LQQLFR GHO 1XRYR 5HJQR 1HOO¶LQQR DG $PRQ GHO 3DS/HLGHQ,,9qGHWWR =DQGHH; $OWUHRFFRUUHQ]HLQ*HRUJH %ODFNPDQS 7UHQRWHGLILORORJLDHJL]LDQD ©7UHVRQRWXWWLJOLGHL$PRQ5Dµ3WDKFKHQRQKDQQRSDUL&ROXLLOFXL1RPHq1D VFRVWRLQTXDQWR$PRQHGHJOLq5DµSHULOVXRDVSHWWRH3WDKSHULOFRUSR/HORURFLW WjVXOODWHUUDVRQRVWDELOLSHUO¶HWHUQLWj7HEH+HOLRSROLV0HPILSHUVHPSUHª 4XHVWRLQQRHVSULPHLQIRUPDFKLDUDODWHRORJLDWULQLWDULDLPSHULDOHFKH VLFRQWLQXHUjQHOSURJUDPPDGHFRUDWLYRGHLWHPSOLGLHWjWROHPDLFD1HOQR VWURFDVRWXWWDYLDROWUHDGXQFRPSUHQVLELOHORFDOLVPR$EDWRQ%LJDqSUH VHQWHXQDULIRUPXOD]LRQHFKHHVFOXGHVRUSUHQGHQWHPHQWH+HOLRSROLVHLQFOXGH (GIXH'HQGHUDÊGLIILFLOHSURSRUUHXQDUDJLRQHWHRORJLFDSHUTXHVWRVWDWRGL FRVH PHQWUH VHPEUD D SRUWDWD GL PDQR XQD UDJLRQH SROLWLFD LO WHVWR ULIOHWWH O¶LPSRUWDQ]D DFTXLVLWD GD DOFXQL VLWL WHPSODUL H OD DFFRPXQD DO SUHVWLJLR GL 0HPILHGL7HEH1RQRFFRUUHLQVLVWHUHVXOIDWWRFKHDOO¶DQWLFDLPSRUWDQ]DUH OLJLRVDHSROLWLFDGL0HPILVLHUDDJJLXQWRLOIDWWRFKHQHOWHPSLRGL3WDKYHQL YDQRGLQRUPDLQFRURQDWLLVRYUDQLWROHPDLFLHFKH7HEHIRUWHGLXQDYHQHUD ELOHWUDGL]LRQHHGLXQDSUHVWLJLRVDVFXRODWHRORJLFDHUDVLFXUDPHQWHXQRGHL PDVVLPL FHQWUL SURSXJQDWRUL GHOO¶LGHQWLWj FXOWXUDOH HJL]LDQD 6RWWROLQHDUH O¶LPSRUWDQ]DGL(GIXH'HQGHUDREEHGLVFHDOODORJLFDFXOWXUDOHHJL]LDQDFKH IDFHYDGHOWHPSLRO¶HTXLYDOHQWHVXEOLPDWRGHOODFLWWjQRQqHVDOWDWRLOODYRUR FRPPLVVLRQDWRGDL7RORPHLPDODSUHVHQ]DVHPSLWHUQDGHOGLRQHOO¶RUL]]RQWH WHUUHVWUHFKHJOLHUDSURSULRHLQGHILQLWLYDqHVDOWDWRO¶(JLWWRFHQWURGHOPRQ GRXPDQRLQTXDQWRULIOHVVRGHOPRQGRGLYLQR ,O WHPSLR GL %LJD q VWDWR LQL]LDWR DOO¶HSRFD GL 7RORPHR ;,, $XOHWHV XQ SHULRGR WUDYDJOLDWR GL WRUELGL SUREOHPL GLQDVWLFL H SROLWLFL VXO TXDOH RUPDL VL VWDJOLDYD O¶RPEUD GL 5RPD ± XQ SHULRGR QHO TXDOH SRWHYD HVVHUH SDUWLFRODU PHQWHFRPSUHQVLELOHXQDUHD]LRQHFXOWXUDOHLGHQWLWDULDGDSDUWHGHLVDFHUGRWL HJL]LDQL '¶DOWUD SDUWH VDFHUGRWL H WHPSOL HUDQR SHU ORUR QDWXUD H YRFD]LRQH VRJJHWWLFDSDFLGLD]LRQHSROLWLFD )RUVH q SURSULR OD PDWULFH SROLWLFD GHO QRVWUR WHVWR FKHKD SRUWDWR DOO¶H VFOXVLRQHGL+HOLRSROLVFLWWjFHOHEUHSHUODVXDVWRULDFXOWXDOH³FLHORGHOO¶( JLWWR´PDLQHWjWROHPDLFDVHPSUHSLLQJUDYHGHFDGHQ]DVHQ]DRUPDLDOFXQ )UDQNHSS &DXYLOOH /DWHRORJLDGL)LOHDFFHWWDYDO¶RULJLQHWHEDQDGL2VLULGH QHGD7HEHFIU-XQNHUS 9HwVVH &IU*ULIILWKV&DV]RU3IHLIIHU LOEXRQVRYUDQRFKHSURYLH )UDQFR&UHYDWLQ ULOLHYR QHOOD JHRJUDILD GHO SDHVH VL ULFRUGHUj FKH TXDQWR 6WUDERQH OD YLVLWz +HOLRSROLVHUDRUPDLXQDFLWWjTXDVLGHVHUWD %,%/,2*5$),$ %ODFNPDQ$07KH7HPSOHRI%vJHK&DLUR,QVWLWXW)UDQoDLVG¶$UFKpRORJLH2ULHQWDOH %UXQQHU + ³$QWDLRV´ LQ : +HOFN ( 2WWR+UVJ /H[LNRQ GHU bJ\SWRORJLH YRO :LHVEDGHQ2WWR+DUUDVVRZLW]FROO &DV]RU3IHLIIHU6³=XU5HIOH[LRQ3WROHPlLVFKHU*HFKLFKWHLQGHQbJ\SWLVFKHQ7HPSHOQ DXVGHU=HLW3WROHPDLRV,;3KLORPHWRU,,6RWHU,,XQG3WROHPDLRV;$OH[DQGHU, 9&KU´LQ-RXUQDORI(J\SWLDQ+LVWRU\SS &DXYLOOH 6 (VVDL VXU OD WKpRORJLH GX WHPSOH G¶+RUXV j (GIRX &DLUH ,QVWLWXW )UDQoDLV G¶$UFKpRORJLH2ULHQWDOH )UDQNH ' ³7KHEHQ XQG 0HPSKLV ± 0HWURSROHQ LP DOWHQ bJ\SWHQ´ LQ 0 -DQVHQ % 5RHFN+UVJ(QWVWHKXQJXQG(QWZLFNOXQJYRQ0HWURSROHQ$DFKHQ9HUHLQGHU)UHXQGH GHV5HLII:LVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH6FKULIWHQDQGHU)DNXOWlWIU$UFKLWHNWXUGHU5:7+$DFKHQ SS *HRUJH%=XGHQDOWlJ\SWLVFKHQ9RUVWHOOXQJHQYRP6FKDWWHQDOV6HHOH%RQQ5+DEHOW *ULIILWKV-*³(J\SWLDQ1DWLRQDOLVPLQWKH(GIX7HPSOH7H[WV´LQ-5XIIOH*$*D EDOOD.$.LWFKHQHGV*OLPSVHVRI$QFLHQW(J\SW6WXGLHVLQ+RQRXURI+:)DLU PDQ:DUPLQVWHU$ULV3KLOOLSVSS +HOFN:8UNXQGHQGHU'\QDVWLH+HIW+LVWRULVFKH,QVFKULIWHQ7KXWPRVLV¶,9XQG ELRJUDSKLVFKH,QVFKULIWHQVHLQHU=HLWJHQRVVHQ%HUOLQ$NDGHPLH9HUODJ -DQVHQ:LQNHOQ.,QVFKULIWHQGHU6SlW]HLW,,:LHVEDGHQ2WWR+DUUDVVRZLW] -XQNHU+'DV*|WWHUGHNUHWEHUGDV$EDWRQ:LHQ,QWHUGRFXPHQWDWLRQgVWHUUHLFKLVFKH $NDGHPLHGHU:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ3KLORVRSKLVFK+LVWRULVFKH.ODVVH±'HQNVFKULIWHQ .RQUDG.$UFKLWHNWXUXQG7KHRORJLH3KDUDRQLVFKH7HPSHOWHUPLQRORJLHXQWHU%HUFN VLFKWLJXQJN|QLJVLGHRORJLVFKHU$VSHNWH:LHVEDGHQ2WWR+DUUDVVRZLW] 0RQWHW3*pRJUDSKLHGHO¶eJ\SWHDQFLHQQHYRO3DULV&.OLQFNVLHFN 6FKHQNHO:³6FKDWWHQ´LQ:+HOFN::HVWHQGRUI+UVJ/H[LNRQGHUbJ\SWRORJLH YRO:LHVEDGHQ2WWR+DUUDVVRZLW]FRO 6WDGHOPDQQ 5 ³6RQQHQVFKDWWHQ´ LQ : +HOFN : :HVWHQGRUI +UVJ /H[LNRQ GHU bJ\SWRORJLHYRO:LHVEDGHQ2WWR+DUUDVVRZLW]FRO 9HwVVH$(/HV³UpYROWHVpJ\SWLHQQHV´5HFKHUFKHVVXUOHVWURXEOHVLQWpULHXUVHQeJ\S WHGXUqJQHGH3WROpPpH,,,jODFRQTXr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³XUEDQ´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±7KH(QJOLVKUHYLVLRQLVE\SURI$XJXVW 9LJOLRQH8QLYHUVLW\RI 1DSOHV³/¶2ULHQWDOH´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³SHULSKHUDOXUEDQL]DWLRQ´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± DKLJKSRSXODWLRQHQJDJHGLQVPDOOKROGHUZHWULFHFXOWLYDWLRQ ± DZHOOGHYHORSHGWUDQVSRUWLQIUDVWUXFWXUH ± KLJKO\LQWHJUDWHGPRYHPHQWVRISHRSOHDQGFRPPRGLWLHV ± DQLQFUHDVHLQQRQDJULFXOWXUDODFWLYLWLHVDODUJHFKHDSODERXU ± DQ LQWHQVH PL[WXUH RI ODQG XVH DQG D SHUFHSWLRQRI WKH VWDWH DV EHLQJ µLQYLVLEOH¶ RU KDYLQJ µJUH\¶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¶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³UHJLRQEDVHG´ UDWKHU WKDQ D ³FLW\EDVHG´ XUEDQL]DWLRQ SDWWHUQ QRW QHFHVVDULO\ RFFXUULQJ LQ LVRODWLRQ IURP H[LVWLQJ FLWLHV %XW LW FRXOGEHPRUHSURSHUO\UHJDUGHGDVDQH[WHQGLQJSURFHVVRIPDUNHWRULHQWHG DFWLYLWLHV LQWR D UXUDO VRFLHW\ WKDQ D 5XUDORSROLV ZKLFK KDV EHHQ UHFHQWO\ 5HFHQWO\WKHGHVDNRWDPRGHOZDVVWURQJO\FULWLFL]HGE\'LFNDQG5LPPHUDVLWVKXWV RXWXUEDQHOHPHQWVRIGHYHORSHG&RXQWULHV,QIDFWWKH\PDLQWDLQWKDWVLQFHWKHVLQPRVW OHDGLQJFLWLHVRI6RXWKHDVW$VLDKDGHPHUJHGDSDWWHUQRIQHZWRZQGHYHORSPHQWFRPPRQWR WKH :HVWHUQ FLW\ EHLQJ WKH UHVXOW RI ERWK µFRQYHUJHQFH¶ DQG µGLYHUJHQFH¶ SKDVHV EHWZHHQ 6RXWKHDVW$VLDQFLWLHVDQGPHWURSROLWDQRQHV 7KHWHUP.DPSXQJLVJHQHUDOO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWKµYLOODJH¶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¶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µFRQYHUJHQFH¶EXWDO VRSHULRGVRIµGLYHUJHQFH¶EHWZHHQ0HWURSROLWDQFLWLHVDQG$VLDQFLWLHV2YHU WKHFHQWXULHVWKH\LGHQWLI\WKUHHSKDVHVRIGLIIHUHQWLQWHUDFWLRQEHWZHHQXUEDQ IRUPVLQ0HWURSROLWDQ&RXQWULHVDQG6RXWKHDVW$VLDZKLFKDUHµ&RQYHUJHQFH¶ IURP DERXW WKH V WR WKH V µ'LYHUJHQFH¶ IURP WKH V WR WKH V DQG UHQHZHG µ&RQYHUJHQFH¶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µ+LJKO\ &HQWUDOL]DWLRQ *RYHUQDQFH¶ %HLMLQJ 6KDQJKDL +DQRL DQG +R &KL 0LQK &LW\ µ'HFHQWUDOL]DWLRQ DQG $XWRQRP\ *RYHUQDQFH¶ 0HWUR 0DQLOD DQG µ0L[HG&HQWUDO/RFDO *RYHUQPHQWV¶ -DNDUWD RU%DQJNRN ZKHUH LW KDV DULVHQDVDPDLQWRSLFRIXUEDQGHYHORSPHQWLQ$VLDEHFRPLQJDVHULRXVSUR EOHPLQVRPHODUJHFLWLHVOLNH0HWUR0DQLODDQG+R&KL0LQK&LW\0XVFDUj /HDI/R0DUFRWXOOLR1JX\HQDQG'DQLHUH HWDO 7KHVHWZRODUJHFLWLHVGHVSLWHDVLPLODUODQGVL]HVTXDUH.P0HWUR 0DQLODDJDLQVWVTXDUH.PRI+R&KL0LQK&LW\KDYHDGLIIHUHQWSRSX ODWLRQVL]H0HWUR0DQLODKDVDERXWPLOOLRQUHVLGHQWVLQZKLOH+R &KL 0LQK&LW\ URXJKO\ PLOOLRQ RQO\ EXW DOVR DGLIIHUHQW SK\VLFDO XUEDQ SDWWHUQDQGPRUHLPSRUWDQWDGLIIHUHQWXUEDQJRYHUQDQFH,QIDFWZKLOH+R &KL0LQK&LW\LVVWLOODVLQJOHFLW\ZLWKRQO\RQHFHQWUDO]RQH'LVWULFWVDQG ZLWKDQDUHDRIDURXQGVTXDUH.PDQGDVSDWLDOH[SDQVLRQIROORZLQJWKH FODVVLFDOµFRQFHQWULFFLUFOHV¶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µSULPDWH¶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µSULPDWH¶FLW\KDVEHHQJURZLQJLQDQH[WUHPHO\XQEDODQFHGVWDWHZKHUHSRSXODWLRQHFR QRPLFDFWLYLWLHVLQIUDVWUXFWXUHDQGVHUYLFHVDUHFRQFHQWUDWHGLQRQHFLW\JHQHUDOO\WKHQDWLR QDOFDSLWDO8VXDOO\LWLVWKHFRPPHUFLDODQGLQGXVWULDOSROHWKHKXERIWUDQVSRUWDWLRQDQGWKH FXOWXUDODQGHGXFDWLRQDOFHQWUHDVZHOODVWKHPDJQHWRISRSXODWLRQRIWKHZKROHFRXQWU\2 YHUWKHFHQWXULHVFRORQLDOLQIOXHQFHVKDYHKDGDPDMRULPSDFWRQWKHXUEDQV\VWHPVLQ6RXWK HDVW$VLDZKHUHLWFUHDWHGRUERDVWHGFRDVWDOµSULPDWH¶FLWLHVVXFKDV0DQLOD-DNDUWD6LQJD SRUH6DLJRQ%DQJNRNDQGRWKHUV$QGGXULQJWKHODVWGHFDGHVWKHUDSLGHFRQRPLFGHYHORS PHQWKDVHPSKDVL]HGWKHH[SORVLRQRIµSULPDWH¶FLWLHVDVHULRXVREVWDFOHIRUHFRQRPLFGHYHO RSPHQWVRFLDOMXVWLFHDQGSROLWLFDOVWDELOLW\LQPDQ\6RXWKHDVW$VLDQ&RXQWULHV 0HJDFLWLHV3ULPDWH&LWLHVDQG:RUOG*OREDO&LWLHV &KLQDDOORWKHUFRXQWULHVKDYHWKHLUXUEDQV\VWHPVGRPLQDWHGE\DµSULPDWH¶ FLW\7KHRYHUPHQWLRQHGH[DPSOHLVWKH%DQJNRN0HWURSROLWDQ5HJLRQFRQ WDLQLQJDERXWKDOIRI7KDLODQG¶VXUEDQSRSXODWLRQRIWKHQDWLRQDOSRSX ODWLRQ RI WKH*URVV'RPHVWLF 3URGXFW WZRWKLUGV RI WHOHSKRQH OLQHFD SDFLW\DQGURXJKO\RIWKHQXPEHURIKRVSLWDOEHGVRIWKH&RXQWU\MXVW WR TXRWH D IHZ LQGLFDWRUV RI SULPDF\ LQ %DQJNRN 2Q\\DQRQW 0HJD 7KLV SKHQRPHQRQ LV DOVR HYLGHQW LQ FRXQWULHV OLNH 6RXWK .RUHD ZKHUH WKHQDWLRQDOXUEDQV\VWHPLVIRFXVHGRQ6HRXOWKHFHQWUHRIFRQWURODQGPDQ DJHPHQW7KHRXWEUHDNRIWKH.RUHDQ:DULQUHLQIRUFHGE\WKHJRYHUQ PHQW¶VLQGXVWULDOSROLF\DQGSURJUDPPHVIURPWKHVEURXJKWDERXWPDV VLYHIORZVRILPPLJUDQWVWR6HRXODQG%XVDQWKHVHFRQGODUJHVWFLW\ORFDWHG RQWKHVRXWKHUQWLSRIWKH3HQLQVXODVRWKDWDODUJHSRUWLRQRISRSXODWLRQVHW WOHGLQWKHVHWZRODUJHFLWLHVFDXVLQJUHJLRQDOGLVSDULWLHVDFURVVWKH&RXQWU\ ,QIDFWE\ODWHVWKH\KDGDOUHDG\DEVRUEHGRQHWKLUGRIWKHWRWDOSRSXOD WLRQZKLOHRFFXSLHGRQO\RIWKHQDWLRQDOODQGDUHDRI6RXWK.RUHD%XW WRGD\ RQO\ WKH 6HRXO 0HWURSROLWDQ $UHD ZKLFK LQFOXGHV .\ǀQJJL 3URYLQFH KDVUHDFKHGDSRSXODWLRQRIDERXWPLOOLRQWKDWLVURXJKO\RIWKHWRWDO SRSXODWLRQ ZKLOH FRYHULQJ RI WKH QDWLRQDO ODQGDUHD /HH <X &KXQJ 6RPH$VLDQFRXQWULHV¶XUEDQKLHUDUFK\LVGRPLQDWHGE\WZRµSULPDWH¶FL WLHVDVLQWKHFDVHRI9LHWQDPZKHUHWKHWZRODUJHFLWLHVRI+DQRLDQG+R&KL 0LQK&LW\H[6DLJRQDWWHVWWKDWWKHGHJUHHRISULPDF\GRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\ GHFUHDVHDVDUHVXOWRIQDWLRQEXLOGLQJEXWRQWKHFRQWUDU\LWPD\VWUHQJWKHQ HYHQ IXUWKHU 'XULQJ WKH WKUHH GHFDGHV SULRU WR WKH UHXQLILFDWLRQ PDVVLYH IORZV RI LPPLJUDQWV KDG DUULYHG LQWR 6DLJRQ IURP DOO RYHU WKH &RXQWU\ LQ VHDUFKRIZRUNDQGLQYHVWPHQWRSSRUWXQLWLHVDQGLQFUHDVHGWKHFLW\¶VSRSXOD WLRQWRURXJKO\PLOOLRQUHVLGHQWVE\$IWHUUHXQLILFDWLRQWKHSDWWHUQ RI FRQWUROOHG XUEDQL]DWLRQ HYROYHG LQ WKH 1RUWK ZDV H[WHQGHG DV D QDWLRQDO SROLF\DQGJRYHUQPHQWWRIRVWHUVORZXUEDQJURZWK7KH*RYHUQPHQWEHJDQ WRSXUVXHDULJLGSURJUDPPHRIGHXUEDQL]DWLRQRIWKHQHZO\UHQDPHG+R&KL 0LQK &LW\ DQG PRUH WKDQ D PLOOLRQ SHRSOH ZHUH H[SHOOHG IURP WKH VRXWKHUQ PHWURSROLVDQGUHWXUQHGWRWKHLUQDWLYHYLOODJHVRUZHUHUHORFDWHGLQ1HZ(FR QRPLF =RQHV EH\RQG WKH LPPHGLDWH FLW\ SHULSKHU\ 2Q WKH FRQWUDU\ +DQRL ORFDWHGLQWKH5HG5LYHU%DVLQLQQRUWKHUQ9LHWQDPKDVEHHQGHYHORSHGLQWR DQRWKHUµSULPDWH¶FLW\ZLWKWKHDLPWRFRXQWHUEDODQFHWKHSUHYLRXVGRPLQDQW XUEDQUROHRI6DLJRQKDYLQJDPRQRSRO\RQJRYHUQPHQWLQVWLWXWLRQV*XEU\ +XRQJ1JX\HQ ,QWKHODWHVW\HDUV VRPH³ZRUOG´FLWLHVFRPSHWLQJIRUWKHPDMRUSROHVLQ WKHJOREDOHFRQRP\DUHVWLOODSSHDULQJRQWKHSROLF\DJHQGDDQGJRYHUQPHQW 6DOYDWRUH'LJOLR VWUDWHJ\RIWKHPRVWG\QDPLFODUJHFLWLHVLQ$VLD$PRQJWKHµZRUOGFLW LHV¶LGHQWLILHGE\7D\ORUHWDOLQWKHHDUO\;;,FHQWXU\DUHLQ3D FLILF $VLD 7RN\R 6LQJDSRUH +RQJ .RQJ 6HRXO -DNDUWD 2VDND 7DLSHL %DQJNRN%HLMLQJ.XDOD/XPSXU0DQLODDQG6KDQJKDLDQGDQRWKHU+R &KL 0LQK &LW\ *XDQJ]KRX DQG+DQRL DUH µHPHUJLQJZRUOG FLWLHV¶ 2QO\ D IHZ\HDUVEHIRUHVRPH)UHQFKVFKRODUVRIWKH8QLYHUVLW\RI3DULVKDGFODVVL ILHGDPRQJWKHZRUOGHFRQRPLFFLWLHVWKH WZR-DSDQHVHPHWURSROLVRI7ǀ N\ǀDQGƿVDND$QGE\WKHHQGRIWKHODWHVWµ(PHUJLQJ0DUNHW,QGH[¶ SXEOLVKHGE\0DVWHUFDUG:RUOGZLGH&HQWHUVRI&RPPHUFHUHSRUWVµJOREDO FLWLHV¶GLVWULEXWHGWKURXJKRXWWKHHPHUJLQJPDUNHWVRI$VLD$IULFD6RXWKHUQ $PHULFDDQG(DVWHUQ(XURSH%XWRIWKHVHDODUJHQXPEHULVORFDOL]HGLQ$ VLD FLWLHV DUH LQ &KLQD DQG DQRWKHU LQ ,QGLD WKH IHGHUDO FDSLWDO FLW\ RI .XDOD/XPSXUUDQNVWKLQWKHOLVWIROORZHGE\%DQJNRNWK,VWDQEXOWK DQGIXUWKHUEDFN-DNDUWD0DQLODDQG+R&KL0LQK&LW\ $PRQJWKHµJOREDOFLWLHV¶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µZRUOGFLW\¶KDV EHHQUHYLVHGDQGGXULQJWKHVLWZDVUHODWHGWRWKH³FRPPDQGDQGFRQWUROFHQWUHV´RIWKH QHZHFRQRP\EHLQJGHYHORSHGE\PXOWLQDWLRQDOFRUSRUDWLRQV6RPH\HDUVODWHU6DVVHQ FRQVROLGDWHGWKLVDSSURDFKOLQNLQJLQWULQVLFDOO\µZRUOGFLWLHV¶WRWKHIRUPDQGFRQWHQWRIFRQ WHPSRUDU\JOREDOL]DWLRQJLYHQDPRUHSUHFLVHGHILQLWLRQRIµZRUOGJOREDOFLW\¶IRFXVLQJXSRQ PXOWLQDWLRQDOFRUSRUDWLRQVZKLFKSURYLGHFRUSRUDWHVHUYLFHV 7KHWKHRUHWLFDOIUDPHZRUNLGHQWLI\LQJµZRUOGFLWLHV¶LQWHUPVRIWKHRIILFHQHWZRUNVRIDGYDQ FHGSURGXFHUVHUYLFHILUPVDWWULEXWHGWKHUROHRI³QRGDOFHQWUHVRIWKHQHZJOREDOHFRQRP\´WR ³VSHFLDO SODFHV´ ZKHUH WKH FRQFHQWUDWLRQ RI VSHFLDOLVHG NQRZOHGJH LQWHUVHFWV ZLWK IORZV RI WKHODWHVWLQIRUPDWLRQWHFKQRORJ\&DVWHOOV 7KHRWKHUµZRUOGFLWLHV¶ZHUH1HZ<RUN/RV$QJHOHV3DULVDQG/RQGRQ 7KHOLVWHGFLWLHVDUHWKHµHPHUJLQJJURZWKSROHV¶WKDWVSUHDGWKHLUHFRQRPLFFRPPHUFLDODQG FXOWXUDOYLWDOLW\ZHOORYHUWKHQDWLRQDOWHUULWRULDOOLPLWV7KH&KLQHVHODUJHFLWLHVKDYHEHFRPH ZRUOGFRPPHUFLDOFHQWUHVIRUWKHLULQIUDVWUXFWXUHDQGH[FHOOHQWVHUYLFHRIIHUHGWRWKHOHDGLQJ PXOWLQDWLRQDO HQWHUSULVHV ZKLFK DUH HDJHU WR HVWDEOLVK WKHLU UHJLRQDO KHDGTXDUWHUV LQ &KLQD .XDOD/XPSXUDQG%DQJNRNDUHDWWKHWRSRIWKHOLVWIRUWKHLUFRPPHUFLDOUROHDQGDWWUDFWLYH HQYLURQPHQWIRUWKHILQDQFLDOLQVWLWXWLRQVDQGWKH,7PXOWLQDWLRQDOVERWKUHJLRQDODQGORFDO 0HJDFLWLHV3ULPDWH&LWLHVDQG:RUOG*OREDO&LWLHV PHQWV GHUHOLFW LQGXVWULDO DUHDV WUDIILF FRQJHVWLRQ DQG RWKHU HQYLURQPHQWDO SUREOHPV,QIDFWVLQFHWKHHDUO\VWKHFLW\$XWKRULWLHVKDYHEHHQILUPO\ SODQQLQJ6LQJDSRUHDVD7URSLFDO&LW\RI([FHOOHQFHZLWKWKHYLVLRQWRUHDOL]H DµJOREDOFLW\¶DQGWKHILUVWµYLUWXDOFLW\¶RIWKHVWFHQWXU\7KHPDLQJRDORI WKH FXUUHQW WHQ \HDU &RQFHSW 3ODQLV WKH FUHDWLRQ RI D µJDUGHQ FLW\¶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± $QHZZRUOGFODVVGRZQWRZQDUHDDURXQG0DULQD%D\ ± )RXU5HJLRQDO&HQWUHVDW7DPSLQHV6HODWDU-XURQJ(DVWDQG:RRGODQGVHDFKUHFHLYLQJXS WRUHVLGHQWVLQQHZµVDWHOOLWHUHJLRQV¶ ± 7KHFUHDWLRQRI7HFKQRORJLFDO&RUULGRUVDQG7HOHFLWLHV ± 7KHLQFUHDVHRIWKHSURSRUWLRQRIORZULVHDQGPHGLXPULVHKRXVLQJV ± 7KHH[WHQVLRQDQGLPSURYHPHQWRIWKHWUDQVSRUWV\VWHPZLWKQHZH[SUHVVZD\VDQH[WHQGHG 057QHWZRUNDQGWKHSURSRVHG/LJKW5DLO6\VWHP/57 ± 7KHSURPRWLRQRIWKHTXDOLW\RIOLIHDQGD*DUGHQ&LW\ 7KH,75HSRUWWKH1DWLRQDO,70DVWHUSODQLVVXHGLQWKHLQDXJXUDWLRQLQRI WKHORQJHVW.PXQGHUZDWHURSWLFILEUHFDEOHLQWKHZRUOGNQRZQDVWKHµ6($0( :(¶RUWKH6RXWKHDVW$VLD0LGGOH(DVW:HVWHUQ(XURSHWHOHPDWLFKLJKZD\OLQNLQJ6LQJD SRUHWR0DUVHLOOHV6RXWK)UDQFHDQGWKHODXQFKLQJLQ-XO\RIWKHPXOWLPLOOLRQGROODU QDWLRQZLGH PXOWLPHGLD EURDGEDQG LQIUDVWUXFWXUH SURMHFW NQRZQ DV µ6LQJDSRUH 21(¶ RU µ2QH 1HWZRUN IRU (YHU\RQH¶ ZLOO WXUQ 6LQJDSRUH LQWR WKH ILUVW µYLUWXDO¶ RIWKH VW &HQWXU\ 8UEDQ5HGHYHORSPHQW$XWKRULW\/R<HXQJ)RRHWDO$UXQ 6DOYDWRUH'LJOLR SDUWLDOO\SODQQHGLVEHFRPLQJDSHUPDQHQWIHDWXUHRIWKH$VLDQXUEDQODQG VFDSH'RXJODVV1J+LOOLV7DNHVKL7HWVX\D+XGDODK &KRX&KDQJ 7KHYLVLWRIRQHRIWKHVHPHJDFLWLHVFOHDUO\UHYHDOVWKDWQXPHURXVSROLF\ DQG GHFLVLRQ PDNHUV WKH VRFDOOHG µDFWRUV¶ RI XUEDQ FKDQJH KDYH YLVLRQDU\ LGHDVDERXWXUEDQIRUPZKLFKGRQRWILWYHU\ZHOOZLWKWUDGLWLRQDODQGORFDO FRQFHSWVRIXUEDQL]DWLRQ$VLDQFLWLHVFRPSHWHLQEXLOGLQJWKHWDOOHVWWRZHURU WKHODUJHVWVKRSSLQJPDOOLQWKHZRUOGUHVLGHQWLDOKLJKULVHEXLOGLQJVILQDQ FLDO FHQWUHV DQG 6WRFN ([FKDQJHV DQG SRVWPRGHUQ VN\VFUDSHUV DUH PXVK URRPLQJLQHYHU\ODUJHFLW\DVWKHQHZV\PERORIDQHFRQRPLFKLJKVWDWXVDQG DIIOXHQWVRFLHW\6KRSSLQJDUFDGHVKRWHOVLQWHUQDWLRQDOIDVWIRRGFKDLQV0F 'RQDOG¶V3L]]D+XWDQGVRRQDUHUHSODFLQJWUDGLWLRQDOKRXVHVDQGGHVWUR\ LQJ PRVW RI WKH ORFDO FXOWXUDO LGHQWLW\ 7KH\ DUH EHFRPLQJ µYHUWLFDO¶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³6LQJDSRUH,QIRUPDWLRQ7HFKQRORJ\LQDQ,QWHOOLJHQW,VODQG´LQ6RXWKHDVW$ VLDQ$IIDLUVSS $UXQ 0 <DS 07 ³6LQJDSRUH7KH GHYHORSPHQW RI DQ ,QWHOOLJHQW ,VODQG DQG 6RFLDO 'LYLGHQGVRI,QIRUPDWLRQ7HFKQRORJ\´LQ8UEDQ6WXGLHVSS $UXQ0+XDQJ6³7KHFRQVHUYDWLRQUHGHYHORSPHQWGLOHPPDLQ6LQJDSRUH7KHFDVH RI.DPSRQJ*ODP+LVWRULF'LVWULFW´LQ&LWLHVSS ²³$VLD¶V*OREDO&LWLHV´LQ8UEDQ6WXG\6SHFLDO,VVXH %HDYHUVWRFN-96PLWK5*7D\ORU3-³:RUOGFLW\1HWZRUN$QHZ0HWDJHRJUD SK\"´LQ$QQDOVRIWKH$VVRFLDWLRQRI$PHULFDQJHRJUDSKHUVSS 7KHIRXUWKLQWHUQDWLRQDOIRUXPRI³*OREDO&LW\´VFKHGXOHGWREHKHOGLQ$EX'KDELDWWKHEH JLQQLQJRI$SULOZLOOHQDEOHXUEDQGHYHORSPHQWGHFLVLRQPDNHUVWRIRFXVRQJOREDOL]D WLRQDQGVXVWDLQDELOLW\RIFLWLHV 0HJDFLWLHV3ULPDWH&LWLHVDQG:RUOG*OREDO&LWLHV &DVWHOOV0³(XURSHDQFLWLHVWKHLQIRUPDWLRQDOVRFLHW\DQGWKHJOREDOHFRQRP\´LQ7LMG VFKULIWYRRU(FRQRPLVFKHHQ6RFLDOH*HRJUDILHSS %XQQHOO7%DUWHU3$0RUVKLGL6³.XDOD/XPSXU0HWURSROLWDQ$UHD$JOREDOL]LQJ FLW\UHJLRQ´LQ&LWLHVSS &KDQJ7&³5HQDLVVDQFHUHYLVLWHG6LQJDSRUHDVDµJOREDOFLW\IRUWKHDUWV¶´LQ,QWHUQD WLRQDO-RXUQDORI8UEDQ5HJLRQDO5HVHDUFKSS &KDQJ7&+XDQJ6³5HFUHDWLQJSODFHUHSODFLQJPHPRU\&UHDWLYHGHVWUXFWLRQRIWKH 6LQJDSRUH5LYHU´LQ$VLD3DFLILF9LHZSRLQWSS ²³*HRJUDSKLHVRIHYHU\ZKHUHDQG QRZKHUH3ODFHXQPDNLQJLQD:RUOG&LW\´LQ,Q WHUQDWLRQDO'HYHORSPHQW3ODQQLQJ5HYLHZSS &KDQJ7&+XDQJ66DYDJH9³2QWKHZDWHUIURQWJOREDOLVDWLRQDQGXUEDQL]DWLRQLQ 6LQJDSRUH´LQ8UEDQ*HRJUDSK\SS &KRX 7 &KDQJ - ³8UEDQ VSUDZODQG WKH SROLWLFV RI ODQG XVH SODQQLQJ LQ XUEDQ 7DL ZDQ´LQ,QWHUQDWLRQDO'HYHORSPHQW3ODQQLQJ5HYLHZSS &KXQJ.³7HFKQRORJLFDOLPSDFWRQVSDWLDOIRUPDWLRQDQGLQWHJULW\RIXUEDQVSDFHVIRUD VXVWDLQDEOHDQGFRPSHWLWLYHGHYHORSPHQWLQ6HRXO´LQ(DVW$VLDQ5HYLHZSS 'DQLHUH $ 7DNDKDVKL /0 1D5DQRQJ $ /DQ 971 ³6RFLDO FDSLWDODQG XUEDQ HQYLURQPHQWVLQ6RXWKHDVW$VLD/HVVRQVIURPVHWWOHPHQWVLQ%DQJNRNDQG+R&KL0LQK &LW\´LQ,QWHUQDWLRQDO'HYHORSPHQW3ODQQLQJ5HYLHZSS 'LFN+:5LPPHU3-³%H\RQGWKH7KLUG:RUOG&LW\7KH1HZ8UEDQ*HRJUDSK\RI 6RXWKHDVW$VLD´LQ8UEDQ6WXGLHVSS 'LJOLR6³/¶,QGRQHVLDHLVXRLµ7ULDQJROLGL&UHVFLWD¶$OFXQHFRQVLGHUD]LRQLHFRQRPL FKH H JHRSROLWLFKH´ LQ 6) 6RHQRWR 5LYDL D F3HUVHPEDKDQ 6WXGL LQ RQRUH GL /XLJL 6DQWD0DULD1DSROL,VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOH'LSDUWLPHQWRGL6WXGL$VLDWLFL6HULH 0LQRUSS ² ³3RVWWUDQVLWLRQ +RQJ .RQJ DQG 0DFDX(FRQRPLF LQWHJUDWLRQ RU FRPSHWLWLRQ ZLWKLQ 6RXWK&KLQD"´LQ(VWXGRVVREUHD&KLQDSS ²³6KDQJKDLDVDQHPHUJLQJµZRUOGFLW\¶RIWKHVW&HQWXU\´LQ(VWXGRVVREUHD&KLQD SS ²D³5HFHQW8UEDQ'HYHORSPHQWDQG+LVWRULF+HULWDJH3URWHFWLRQLQ&KLQD7KH([DP SOHVRI%HLMLQJDQG6KDQJKDL´LQ(VWXGRVVREUHD&KLQDSS ²E³8UEDQ'HYHORSPHQWDQG+LVWRULF3URWHFWLRQLQ6KDQJKDL´LQ:HE-RXUQDORQ&XO WXUDO3DWULPRQ\SS 'RXJODVV0³0HJDXUEDQUHJLRQVDQGZRUOGFLW\IRUPDWLRQJOREDOL]DWLRQWKHHFRQRPLF FULVLVDQGXUEDQSROLF\LVVXHVLQ3DFLILF$VLD´LQ8UEDQ6WXGLHVSS )RR$)HWDO6LQJDSRUHLQWKHVW&HQWXU\7KHYLUWXDOFLW\VWDWH6LQJDSRUH*RYHUQ PHQW3UHVV )RUEHV'$VLDQ0HWURSROLV8UEDQLVDWLRQDQGWKH6RXWKHDVW$VLDQ&LW\0HOERXUQH2[ IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV ²³0HWURSROLVDQGPHJDXUEDQUHJLRQLQ3DFLILF$VLD´LQ7LMGVFKULIWYRRU(FRQRPLVFKH HQ6RFLDOH*HRJUDILHSS )RUG , ³$ PRGHO RI ,QGRQHVLDQFLW\ VWUXFWXUH´LQ7KH *HRJUDSKLFDO 5HYLHZ SS )RUG/5³0LGWRZQV0HJDVWUXFWXUHVDQG:RUOG&LWLHV´LQ7KH*HRJUDSKLFDO5HYLHZ SS )ULHGPDQQ-³7KHZRUOGFLWLHVK\SRWKHVLV´LQ'HYHORSPHQWDQG&KDQJHSS )XORQJ:³7KHJOREDODQG/RFDO'LPHQVLRQRISODFHPDNLQJ5HPDNLQJ6KDQJKDLDVD :RUOG&LW\´LQ8UEDQ6WXGLHVSS 6DOYDWRUH'LJOLR *DXEDW]3³&KLQD¶VXUEDQWUDQVIRUPDWLRQ3DWWHUQVDQGSURFHVVHVRIPRUSKRORJLFDOFKDQJH LQ%HLMLQJ6KDQJKDLDQG*XDQJ]KRX´LQ8UEDQ6WXGLHVSS *LOEHUW$³+RXVLQJLQWKH7KLUG:RUOG&LWLHV7KHFULWLFDOLVVXHV´LQ*HRJUDSK\ SS *ROGEOXP&:RQJ7&³*URZWKFULVLVDQGVSDWLDOFKDQJHDVWXG\RIKDSKD]DUGXU EDQLVDWLRQLQ-DNDUWD,QGRQHVLD´LQ/DQG8VH3ROLF\SS *XEU\3+XRQJ/7³+R&KL0LQK&LW\DIXWXUHPHJDFLW\LQ9LHWQDP´LQ9LHWQDP¶V 6RFLR(FRQRPLF'HYHORSPHQWSS *XJOHU - :RUOG &LWLHV EH\RQG WKH :HVW *OREDOL]DWLRQ 'HYHORSPHQW DQG ,QHTXDOLW\ &DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV *XOGLQ*6³0HWURSROLVDQGPHJDXUEDQUHJLRQLQ3DFLILF$VLD´LQ7LMGVFKULIWYRRU(FR QRPLVFKHHQ6RFLDOH*HRJUDILHSS +DOO37KH:RUOG&LWLHV/RQGRQ:HLGHQIHOG1LFROVRQ +R.&'RXJODV0³*OREDOLVDWLRQDQGOLYHDEOHFLWLHVH[SHULHQFHVLQSODFHPDNLQJLQ 3DFLILF$VLD´LQ,QWHUQDWLRQDO'HYHORSPHQW3ODQQLQJ5HYLHZSS +RDQJ'.³9DOXHVRIXUEDQKHULWDJHDQGDUFKLWHFWXUHRI+DQRL´LQ9LHWQDP6RFLDO6FL HQFHVSS +XGDODK'³3HULXUEDQLVDWLRQLQ(DVW$VLD$QHZFKDOOHQJHIRU3ODQQLQJ"´LQ,QWHUQD WLRQDO'HYHORSPHQW3ODQQLQJ5HYLHZSS .RUII5³*OREDODQG/RFDO6SKHUHV7KH'LYHUVLW\RI6RXWKHDVW$VLDQ8UEDQLVP´LQ6R MRXUQ-RXUQDORI6RFLDO,VVXHVLQ6RXWKHDVW$VLDSS /HDI0³9LHWQDP¶V8UEDQ(GJH7KH$GPLQLVWUDWLRQRI8UEDQ'HYHORSPHQWLQ+DQRL´ LQ7KLUG:RUOG3ODQQLQJ5HYLHZSS /H 9DQ 1 ³&RQVWUXFWLRQ 3ODQQLQJ IRU +RFKLPLQK &LW\´ LQ9LHWQDP¶V 6RFLR(FRQRPLF 'HYHORSPHQWSS /HH*³+RZWRPDNH6HRXODZRUOGFLW\´LQ.RUHD)RFXVSS /HLVFK+³*DWHG3DUDGLVH"4XDOLW\RI/LIHLQ3ULYDWH1HZ7RZQV-$%27$%(;,QGR QHVLD´LQ6)7XDQ//<XDQ*:RQJ.KHL0LHHGV3ODQQLQJIRUD%HWWHU4XDOLW\ RI/LIHLQ&LWLHV6LQJDSRUH6FKRRORI%XLOGLQJDQG5HDO(VWDWHSS /R )& 0DUFRWXOOLR 3-³*OREDOL]DWLRQ DQG XUEDQ WUDQVIRUPDWLRQ LQ WKH $VLD 3DFLILF 5HJLRQVD5HYLHZ´LQ8UEDQ6WXGLHVSS ²*OREDOL]DWLRQDQGWKH6XVWDLQDELOLW\RI&LWLHVLQWKH$VLD3DFLILF5HJLRQ7RN\R8QLW HG1DWLRQV8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV /R)&<HXQJ<(PHUJLQJ:RUOG&LWLHVLQ3DFLILF$VLD7RN\R8QLWHG1DWLRQV8QL YHUVLW\3UHVV /RJDQ:67KHGLVDSSHDULQJRI$VLDQ&LW\3URWHFWLQJ$VLD¶VXUEDQKHULWDJHLQDJORED OL]LQJZRUOG2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV /RR/6³8UEDQFRQVHUYDWLRQSROLF\DQGWKHSUHVHUYDWLRQRIKLVWRULFDODQGFXOWXUDOKHUL WDJHWKHFDVHRI6LQJDSRUH´LQ&LWLHVSS 0DVDL<³7RN\R)URPD)HXGDO0LOOLRQ&LW\WRD*OREDO6XSHUFLW\´LQ7KH*HRJUDSKL FDO5HYLHZRI-DSDQVHU%SS 0DVWHUFDUG:RUOGZLGH&HQWHUVRI&RPPHUFH(PHUJLQJ0DUNHW,QGH[1HZ<RUN0DV WHUFDUG:RUOGZLGH 0HJD9³%DQJNRN7KHPHJDFLW\RIDQJHOV´LQ(NLVWLFVSS 0F*HH7&7KH6RXWKHDVW$VLDQ&LW\D6RFLDO*HRJUDSK\RIWKH3ULPDWH&LWLHVRI6RXW KHDVW$VLD/RQGRQ*%HOO6RQV ²³8UEDQLVDVLRU.RWDGHVDVL"(YROYLQJSDWWHUQVRIXUEDQL]DWLRQLQ$VLD´LQ)-&RVWDHW DOHGV8UEDQL]DWLRQLQ$VLD+RQROXOX8QLYHUVLW\RI+DZDLL3UHVVSS 0HJDFLWLHV3ULPDWH&LWLHVDQG:RUOG*OREDO&LWLHV ²³7KHHPHUJHQFHRIGHVDNRWDUHJLRQVLQ$VLDH[SDQGLQJDK\SRWKHVLV´LQ%*LQVEXUJ %.RSSHO7&0F*HHHGV7KH([WHQGHG0HWURSROLV6HWWOHPHQW7UDQVLWLRQLQ$VLD +RQROXOX8QLYHUVLW\RI+DZDLL3UHVVSS ²³0HWURILWWLQJWKHHPHUJLQJPHJDXUEDQUHJLRQVRI$6($1DQRYHUYLHZ´LQ7&0F *HH,05RELQVRQHGV7KH0HJD8UEDQ5HJLRQVRI6RXWKHDVW$VLD9DQFRXYHU8QL YHUVLW\RI%ULWLVK&ROXPELD3UHVVSS 0XVFDUj & ³*LDQW FLWLHV XUEDQ PDQDJHPHQW DQG WKH JOREDO HFRQRP\´ LQ(NLVWLFV SS 1J0.+LOOLV3³:RUOGFLWLHVRUJUHDWFLWLHV"$FRPSDUDWLYHVWXG\RIILYH$VLDQ0H WURSROLVHV´LQ&LWLHVSS 1JX\HQ 0+ ³8UEDQ *RYHUQDQFH $ FRPSDULVRQ EHWZHHQ +RFKLPLQK &LW\ DQG 0HWUR 0DQLOD´LQ9LHWQDP¶V6RFLR(FRQRPLF'HYHORSPHQWSS ²³1HZ+RXVLQJ7UHQGVLQ+R&KL0LQK&LW\´LQ9LHWQDP¶V6RFLR(FRQRPLF'HYHORS PHQWSS 2Q\\DQRQW3³%DQJNRNDVDPDJQHWIRUUXUDOODERXUFKDQJLQJFRQGLWLRQV´ LQ6RXWKHDVW$VLDQ6WXGLHVSS 2RL*/+RXVLQJLQ6RXWKHDVW$VLD&DSLWDO&LWLHV6LQJDSRUH,QVWLWXWHRI6RXWKHDVW$ VLDQ6WXGLHV6RXWKHDVW$VLD%DFNJURXQG6HULHV1R 3DQJ;³7KHFRQFHSWLRQIUDPHZRUNRI$VLDQXUEDQGHYHORSPHQWLQWUDQVLWLRQ´LQ7KH -RXUQDORI&KLQHVH*HRJUDSK\SS 3DSDLRDQQX-*³0HJDFLWLHVYHUVXV0HJDORSROLVHVDFKDOOHQJHIRUWKHIXWXUH´LQ(NLV WLFVSS 4DGHHU0$³5XUDORSROLVHV7KH6SDWLDO2UJDQLVDWLRQDQG5HVLGHQWLDO/DQG(FRQRP\RI +LJKGHQVLW\5XUDO5HJLRQVLQ6RXWK$VLD´LQ8UEDQ6WXGLHVSS 5ODQG-7KH'\QDPLFVRI0HWURSROLWDQ0DQDJHPHQWLQ6RXWKHDVW$VLD6LQJDSRUH,Q VWLWXWHRI6RXWKHDVW$VLDQ6WXGLHV 6DVVHQ67KH*OREDO&LW\3ULQFHWRQ3ULQFHWRQ8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV ²³*OREDOFLWLHVDQGGHYHORSPHQWDOLVWVWDWHVKRZWRGHUDLOZKDWFRXOGEHDQLQWHUHVWLQJ GHEDWHDUHVSRQVHWR+LOODQG.LP´LQ8UEDQ6WXGLHVSS 6DYDJH95+XDQJ6&KDQJ7&³7KH6LQJDSRUH5LYHU7KHPDWLF=RQH6XVWDLQDEOH 7RXULVPLQDQ8UEDQ&RQWH[W´LQ7KH*HRJUDSKLFDO-RXUQDOSS 6LW9)6<DQJ&³)RUHLJQLQYHVWPHQWLQGXFHG([RXUEDQLVDWLRQLQ7KH3HDUO5LYHU 'HOWD&KLQD´LQ8UEDQ6WXGLHVSS 6RUHQVHQ$³/DQGUHDGMXVWPHQWXUEDQSODQQLQJDQGXUEDQVSUDZOLQWKH7RN\R0HWUR SROLWDQ$UHD´LQ8UEDQ6WXGLHVSS 7DNHVKL$7HWVX\D$³(PSLULFDODQDO\VLVIRUHVWLPDWLQJODQGXVHWUDQVLWLRQSRWHQWLDO IXQFWLRQV&DVHLQWKH7RN\R0HWURSROLWDQ5HJLRQ´LQ&RPSXWHUV(QYLURQPHQWDQG8U EDQ6\VWHPVSS 7D\ORU3-³+LHUDUFKLFDOWHQGHQFLHVDPRQJVWZRUOGFLWLHVDJOREDOUHVHDUFKSURSRVDO´LQ &LWLHVSS ²³:RUOGFLWLHVDQG7HUULWRULDO6WDWHVXQGHUFRQGLWLRQVRIFRQWHPSRUDU\JOREDOL]DWLRQ´ LQ3ROLWLFDO*HRJUDSK\SS ²HWDO³:RUOG&LWLHVLQWKH3DFLILF5LP$1HZ*OREDO7HVWRI5HJLRQDO&RKHUHQFH´ LQ6LQJDSRUH-RXUQDORI7URSLFDO*HRJUDSK\SS 7RQXPD.³7RN\R3ROLFLHVWRZDUGWKHVW&HQWXU\´LQ(NLVWLFVSS 8QLWHG1DWLRQV6WDWHRIWKH:RUOG¶VFLWLHV+DUPRQLRXV&LWLHV/RQGRQ±6WHU OLQ9$(DUWKVFDQ 6DOYDWRUH'LJOLR 8UEDQ5HGHYHORSPHQW$XWKRULW\/LYLQJWKH1H[W/DS7RZDUGVD7URSLFDO&LW\RI([FHO OHQFH6LQJDSRUH8UEDQ5HGHYHORSPHQW$XWKRULW\ 9DQ *UXQVYHQ / ³,QGXVWULDO 5HJLRQDOL]DWLRQ DQG 8UED5HJLRQDO 7UDQVIRUPDWLRQ LQ 6RXWKHDVW$VLD7KH6,-25,*URZWK7ULDQJOH&RQVLGHUHG´LQ0DOD\VLDQ-RXUQDORI7UR SLFDO*HRJUDSK\SS 9LUDWNDSDQ9HWDO³)DFWRUVFRQWULEXWLQJWRWKHGHYHORSPHQWSHUIRUPDQFHRIVOXPUHOR FDWLRQ SURMHFWV LQ %DQJNRN 7KDLODQG´ LQ ,QWHUQDWLRQDO 'HYHORSPHQW 3ODQQLQJ 5HYLHZ SS <HXQJ<08UEDQ'HYHORSPHQWLQ$VLD+RQJ.RQJ,QVWLWXWHRI$VLD3DFLILF6WXGLHV 7KH&KLQHVH8QLYHUVLW\RI+RQJ.RQJ <HRK%6$&KDQJ7&³7KHFRQVHUYDWLRQUHGHYHORSPHQWGLOHPPDLQ6LQJDSRUH7KH FDVHRIWKH.DPSRQJ*ODPKLVWRULFGLVWULFW´LQ&LWLHVSS ²³*OREDOLVLQJ6LQJDSRUH'HEDWLQJ7UDQVQDWLRQDO)ORZVLQWKH&LW\´LQ8UEDQ6WXGLHV SS <X:³6HRXO7KHFLW\RIYLWDOLW\´LQ,*8%XOOHWLQSS <XHQ%³&UHDWLQJWKH*DUGHQ&LW\7KH6LQJDSRUH([SHULHQFH´LQ8UEDQ6WXGLHV SS <XHQ%³5RPDQFLQJWKHKLJKULVHLQ6LQJDSRUH´LQ&LWLHVSS $11$0$5,$',72//$ 1RWHVXLWHVWLRUDOLEHUEHULGHO0DURFFR /HVRFLHWjEHUEHURIRQHGHOOHGLYHUVHDUHHGHO0DURFFRKDQQRSURGRWWRWH VWLRUDOLFKHKDQQRGDWRXQ¶LPSRUWDQ]DSDUWLFRODUHDOSDWULPRQLRFXOWXUDOHRUD OHQD]LRQDOH/HVRFLHWjEHUEHURIRQHVLWURYDQRDGDIIURQWDUHRJJLLOSUREOH PDGHOODVDOYDJXDUGLDGHOSDWULPRQLRRUDOHSLXUJHQWHFKHPDLLQXQPRQGR GRPLQDWRGDOODVFULWWXUD %LVRJQDSUHFLVDUHFKHOHVRFLHWjEHUEHUHSXUDYHQGRFRQVHUYDWRODWUDGL ]LRQHRUDOHFRVWLWXLVFRQRXQFDVRPROWRSDUWLFRODUHFRPHDIIHUPD/*DODQG ³/HEHUEqUHRIIUHO¶pWUDQJHSDUWLFXODULWpG¶rWUHXQHODQJXHRUDOHSRXUYXHG¶XQH pFULWXUH´ /D VFULWWXUD H O¶RUDOLWj KDQQR FRQYLVVXWR DQFKH VH OD VFULWWXUD KD VXELWR FRQGL]LRQLVWRULFKHGLPDUJLQDOLWjDFDXVDGHOODGLIIXVLRQHGHOODOLQJXDDUDED $FLzVLqDJJLXQWRLOPDQFDWRULWURYDPHQWRGLGLYHUVHRSHUHLQEHUEHURGHOOH TXDOLVLFRQRVFHO¶HVLVWHQ]DVRORDWWUDYHUVRFLWD]LRQLFRPHQHOFDVRGHO&RUD QRGHL%DUJDZDWDGHJOLVFULWWLUHOLJLRVLGHOSHULRGRPHGLHYDOHHFRVuYLD /D SURGX]LRQH OHWWHUDULD EHUEHUD FRPSUHQGH GLYHUVL FRQWHVWL OLQJXLVWLFL ORFDOLLTXDOLKDQQRFUHDWRXQDNRLQqOHWWHUDULDUHJLRQDOHDGHVHPSLRODSUR GX]LRQHOHWWHUDULDFKOHXKVHJXLWDGDO5LIGDOPRQGRWXDUHJHGDO0]DE 2JJLXQVHWWRUHSDUWLFRODUPHQWHPLQDFFLDWRGLVFRPSDULUHQHOO¶DPELWRGL FLzFKHVLGHILQLVFH³OHWWHUDWXUDRUDOH´qO¶LQVLHPHGHLUDFFRQWLGHOOHOHJJHQ ,%HUEHULSRVVHJJRQRXQDQWLFRDOIDEHWRFKHFKLDPDQRWLILQDJK*DODQG ©2QFRQVLGqUHOHVVRFLpWpVEHUEqUHVFRPPHGHVVRFLpWpVGHWUDGLWLRQRUDOHDORUVTX¶LOHVWLQ GpQLDEOHTX¶HOOHVRQWXWLOLVpGDQVOHSDVVpXQDOSKDEHWSURYHQDQWGHO¶pFULWXUHOLE\TXHOHVWLIL QDJK'DQVFHFDVjFDXVHELHQVXUGXFRXSGHIRUFHRSpUpSDUOHVVRFLpWpVDUDEHVHWODUHOL JLRQ LVODPLTXH WRXWHV GHX[ SRUWpHV SDU XQH DXWUH SLFWXUDOLWp O¶DOSKDEHW DUDEH O¶LWLQpUDLUH VHPEOHDYRLUpWpO¶LQYHUVHG¶XQHFHUWDLQHSLFWXUDOLWpjO¶RUDOLWpHQDWWHQGDQWSHXWrWUHXQHDXWUH SLFWXUDOLWpª&DOYHWS $QQD0DULD'L7ROOD GHGHOOHFDQ]RQLHGHLSURYHUELGHJOLDQHGGRWLGHJOLLQGRYLQHOOLGHJOLHQLJ PLHFF ÊLQWDOHFRQWHVWRFKHVLLQVHULVFHODULFHUFDLQFRUVRGLXQDUDFFROWDGLWH VWLRUDOLLQ0DURFFRVLDSHUO¶LQWHUHVVHVFLHQWLILFRVLDSHUODQHFHVVLWjGLFRQ VHUYDUHLOSDWULPRQLRRUDOHEHUEHUR,OSUREOHPDFRQVLVWHQHOFRPSUHQGHUHLQ FKHPDQLHUDELVRJQDFRQVHUYDUHODPHPRULDGHOO¶HVSHULHQ]DGHOOHVRFLHWjEHU EHUHHUHQGHUHSUHVHQWHQHOWHPSRHQHOORVSD]LRFLzFKHULVXOWDRUPDLORQWDQR HGXQTXHSDVVDWR $OODOXFHGHOOHHYROX]LRQLDWWXDOLFKHVLVRQRSURGRWWHLQ0DURFFRLQ$O JHULDHLQ)UDQFLDSDHVLLQFXLODOLQJXDEHUEHUDqLQVHJQDWDDGLYHUVLOLYHOOL QHOOHVFXROHSULPDULHHQHOOHXQLYHUVLWjWDOLWHPDWLFKHVRQRPROWRDWWXDOLQHO GLEDWWLWRVFLHQWLILFRHODOLQJXDEHUEHUDYLYHXQDVYROWDVWRULFDGHWHUPLQDQWH TXHOODGHOSDVVDJJLRDOORVFULWWR ,Q TXHVWD HVSRVL]LRQH FHUFKHUHPR GL FRPSUHQGHUH DWWUDYHUVR O¶HVHPSLR GLXQEUHYHUDFFRQWRODVWUXWWXUDGLXQWHVWRRUDOHHDOFXQHIDVLUHODWLYHDOSDV VDJJLRDOORVFULWWRLQSDUWLFRODUHO¶RELHWWLYRqTXHOORGLFDSLUHTXDOLVRQRJOL HOHPHQWLFKHGLVWLQJXRQRLGXHUHJLVWULHTXDOLVRQRLSXQWLGLFRQWDWWRQHOO¶DW WYLWjGHOODVFULWWXUDGLXQSURGRWWRRUDOH 3ULPDSHUzGLSDVVDUHDOO¶DQDOLVLGHOWHVWRDFFHQQHUHPRDXQDUDSLGLVVL PDUHWURVSHWWLYDGHLODYRULJLjHVLVWHQWLVXLWHVWLRUDOLGHO6XGPDURFFKLQRHLQ JHQHUDOHLQGLFKHUHPRDOFXQHPHWRGRORJLHOHWWHUDULHSHUORVWXGLRGHLWHVWLRUD OL /DSURGX]LRQHGHLWHVWLRUDOLEHUEHUL , WHVWL RUDOL EHUEHUL KDQQR FRQRVFLXWR GDJOL LQL]L GHO ;; VHFROR XQ¶H VSDQVLRQHVHQ]DSUHFHGHQWL1RQYRJOLDPRGDUHXQDOLVWDGHOOHSXEEOLFD]LRQL SRLFKpHVLVWRQRELEOLRJUDILHDJJLRUQDWHTXDOLOD%LEOLRJUDSKLHGL/DPDUD%RXJ FKLFKHHODULYLVWDeWXGHVHW'RFXPHQWVEHUEqUHVLQFXLVRQRSXEEOLFDWLQXPH URVLDUWLFROLVXLWHVWLRUDOL /DUDFFROWDGHLWHVWLRUDOLWUDGL]LRQDOLHPRGHUQLDUULFFKLVFHLOSDWULPRQLR HOHSRVVLELOLWjGLDQDOLVL,WHVWLWUDGL]LRQDOLVRQRUDFFROWLLQORFRDQFKHVHRJ JLqGLIILFLOHLQFRQWUDUHRWWXDJHQDULRFHQWHQDULPDODWUDGL]LRQHSUHVVRLJLR YDQLqDQFRUDWHQDFHDOPHQRLQDOFXQHUHJLRQL *DODQG3HUQHW 1RWHVXLWHVWLRUDOLEHUEHULGHO0DURFFR *OLVWXGLVXLWHVWLRUDOL *OLVWXGLOHWWHUDUvEHUEHULVLVRQRSRVWLUDUDPHQWHTXHVWLRQLWHRULFKHSUR SULHLQjPELWROHWWHUDULR6SHVVRO¶DQDOLVLGHLWHVWLKDVHJXLWROHFRUUHQWLOLQJXL VWLFKHGHOPRPHQWR8QRGHLPHWRGLSLXWLOL]]DWLDQFRUDRJJLqTXHOORGHOOD FRPSDUD]LRQH GHL WHPL SUHVHQWL QHL UDFFRQWL EHUEHUL ,Q HIIHWWL FRPSDUDQGR GLYHUVHYHUVLRQLGLUDFFRQWLLQOXRJKLJHRJUDILFLGLYHUVLVLVRQRULFDYDWLGHLYH ULVFKHPLEHUEHULFKHSUHQGRQRLOSRVWRQHOOHWLSRORJLH PHGLWHUUDQHHHQHOOD UHWHJHQHUDOHQDWDGDLODYRULGL$QWWL$DUQHH6WLWK7KRPSVRQRGL9ODGLPLU 3URSS /HWHRULHGHOORVWUXWWXUDOLVPRHGHOIXQ]LRQDOLVPRKDQQRGDWRXQDVSHFLIL FLWjDOORVWXGLRGHLUDFFRQWLFRPHGLPRVWUDQROHULFHUFKHGL&DPLOOH/DFRVWH 'XMDUGLQ OD TXDOH DVVRFLDQR XWLOPHQWH FRPSDUDWLYLVPR H VWUXWWXUDOLVPR LQ XQDSURVSHWWLYDHWQRORJLFD 3HUFLzFKHFRQFHUQHO¶DQDOLVLSURSULDPHQWHOHWWHUDULDORVWXGLRGHOFRQWH QXWRKDSUHFHGXWRRJQLDOWURWLSRGLLQGDJLQH 1HOSHULRGRFRORQLDOHLULFHUFDWRULFRQVLGHUDYDQRLWHVWLOHWWHUDULFRPHIRQ WLGLLQIRUPD]LRQLVXOODVRFLHWj'RSRO¶LQGLSHQGHQ]DDOFXQLULFHUFDWRULEHUEHUR IRQLGHOO¶HSRFDKDQQRQHJDWRDLQRQEHUEHURIRQLODSRVVLELOLWjVHQRQLOGLULWWR GLLQWHUSUHWDUHLWHVWLEHUEHUL$SDUWHODUHD]LRQHDIIHWWLYDFRPHDVVHULVFH*D ODQG3HUQHWLOGLEDWWLWRqLQWHUHVVDQWHSRLFKpSRQHLOSUREOHPDGHOODULFH]LRQH GLRJQLOHWWHUDWXUDVWUDQLHUDVXOSLDQRVLQFURQLFRHGLDFURQLFR 1HOODOHWWHUDWXUDEHUEHUDODGHILQL]LRQHGLOHWWHUDWXUDRGLOHWWHUDWXUDRUDOH FRPSRUWD GLYHUVL SUREOHPL DG HVHPSLR OD QR]LRQH GL ³JHQHUH OHWWHUDULR´ UL PDQH DQFRUD GD VWXGLDUH , QRPL JHQHULFL DWWULEXLWL GDL EHUEHURIRQL VWHVVL DO UDFFRQWRYDULDQRDVHFRQGDGHOOHUHJLRQLLQRPLGDWLGDJOLHGLWRULDTXHVWLWH VWL LQ IUDQFHVH R LQ DOWUH OLQJXH RFFLGHQWDOL VRQR SUHVWDWL D VLVWHPL OHWWHUDUL FKHGLIIHULVFRQRGDLVLVWHPLEHUEHUL ,OFRQWHVWRVRFLRFXOWXUDOHGHO7DILODOW 3ULPDGLSUHVHQWDUHORVWXGLRGLXQEUHYHWHVWRRUDOHHGHOOHVXHSUREOH PDWLFKHQHOSDVVDJJLRDOORVFULWWRGREELDPRSUHVHQWDUHEUHYHPHQWHLOFRQWH VWRVRFLRFXOWXUDOHHOLQJXLVWLFRGHO7DILODOWODUHJLRQHGLVWXGLR $DUQH7KRPSVRQ 3URSS /DFRVWH'XMDUGLQ $QQD0DULD'L7ROOD 6XOSLDQROLQJXLVWLFRQHO7DILODOWVLSUDWLFDQRHVVHQ]LDOPHQWHGXHSDUODUL LO EHUEHUR WDPD]LJKW H LO SDUODUH DUDER GLDOHWWDOH ORFDOH /D FRHVLVWHQ]D GL TXHVWLGXHSDUODULSDVVDDWWUDYHUVRXQUDSSRUWRGLGRPLQD]LRQHQHOVHQVROLQ JXLVWLFRGHOWHUPLQHXQDUHDOWjFKHVLPDQLIHVWDQHOTXRWLGLDQRHFKHSURYLHQH GDOFRQWDWWRGHOOHGXHOLQJXHODWDPD]LJKWFRQO¶DUDERORFDOH4XHVWDGRPLQD ]LRQHHPHUJHRJQLTXDOYROWDXQVRJJHWWRFKHSDUODWDPD]LJKWVLWURYDREEOLJD WRDSDUODUHO¶DUDERFRQLOVXRLQWHUORFXWRUHDUDERSHUWUDVPHWWHUHXQPHVVDJ JLR8QRGHLOXRJKLGRYHDYYLHQHO¶LQWHUD]LRQHYHUEDOHqLOVXTFKHUDSSUHVHQ WD XQ FRQWHVWR VRFLRFXOWXUDOH LQ FXL O¶DUDER ORFDOH VL LPSRQH $G HVHPSLR TXDQGRTXDOFXQRSHUGHXQRJJHWWRDOVXTLOULWURYDPHQWRDYYLHQHWUDPLWHXQ DOWRSDUODQWH H VL GLFH FKH O¶RJJHWWR VPDUULWR VL WURYD DOOD PRVFKHD SRVWD QHO PHUFDWR /¶DSSHOOR q IDWWR HVFOXVLYDPHQWH LQ DUDER WUDVFXUDQGR FRPSOHWD PHQWHLOEHUEHUR 1RQRVWDQWHOHUHVWUL]LRQLVXELWHGDOODWDPD]LJKWTXHVWDOLQJXDPLOOHQDULD QRQFHVVDGLWUDUUHODVXDIRU]DGLVRSUDYYLYHQ]DHGLUHVLVWHQ]DGDOVXRLQH VDXULELOH SDWULPRQLR FXOWXUDOH FRVWXPL GLULWWR FRQVXHWXGLQDULR DUWH VWRULD OHWWHUDWXUDRUDOHHFF ,OUDFFRQWR ,O WHVWR SUHVR LQ HVDPH q XQ UDFFRQWR RUDOH LQHGLWR LQ EHUEHUR UDFFROWR QHOO¶DJRVWRQHOODFLWWDGLQDGL5LVVDQLQHO7DILODOWQHOVXGHVWGHO0DURF FR H UDFFRQWDWR GD $LFKD 0EXUNDSSDUWHQHQWH DJOL $LW ,KDWXFKHQ $wW $WWD FKHDYHYDIUHTXHQWDWRODVFXRODSULPDULD,OUDFFRQWRPROWREUHYHqFDUDWWHUL VWLFRGLTXHJOLDQHGGRWLVXLFRVWXPLQRWLQHOODFODVVLILFD]LRQHLQWHUQD]LRQDOH FRPH³UDFFRQWLIDFHWL´PROWRIUHTXHQWLQHOUHSHUWRULRGHLEHUEHULHGHLTXDOLVL WURYDQRPROWLHVHPSLQHOOHGLYHUVHUDFFROWHGHOODOHWWHUDWXUDRUDOH 3HU OD WUDVFUL]LRQH GHO WHVWR DEELDPR VHJXLWR OH UDFFRPDQGD]LRQL GHJOL ³DWHOLHUV´VXOODJUDILDSHUJOLXVLFRUUHQWLGHOEHUEHURVWDELOLWRGDO&HQWURGLUL FHUFDEHUEHUDGHOO¶,1$/&2,QVWLWXW1DWLRQDOGHV/DQJXHVHW&LYLOLVDWLRQV2 ULHQWDOHVGL3DULJL ,Q WDFKHOKLW H WDPD]LJKW OT܈LW OTLVDW ©VWRULD UDFFRQWR QDUUD]LRQH $IIDUH IDWWR GLYHUVRª 7DLILS $LFKDDQQLSDUODVRORLQEHUEHURHSRVVLHGHQR]LRQLGLIUDQFHVHHGLDUDERGLDOHWWDOHPD URFFKLQR ,QTXHVWDVHGHFROJRO¶RFFDVLRQHSHUULQJUD]LDUHOHSHUVRQHFKHPLKDQQRDLXWDWDDWUDVFULYHUH TXHVWRUDFFRQWR 1RWHVXLWHVWLRUDOLEHUEHULGHO0DURFFR ,O UDFFRQWR V¶LQWLWROD /DTT Q OZDOGD\Q ©, GRYHUL YHUVR L JHQLWRULª ,Q TXHVWDVHGHSUHVHQWHUHPRODWUDVFUL]LRQHGHOWHVWRLQOLQJXDEHUEHUDQHOODYD ULDQWHWDPD]LJKWGHO0DURFFRFHQWUDOHODWUDGX]LRQHOHWWHUDOHHLQILQHODWUDGX ]LRQHLQWHOOLJLELOH,OWHVWRqFRUUHGDWRGLQRWHOLQJXLVWLFKHHWQRJUDILFKHHVWLOL VWLFKHFKHWHQJRQRFRQWRGHOFRQWHVWRVRFLROLQJXLVWLFRHVWRULFR3HUTXDQWRUL JXDUGDODGLVSRVL]LRQHPDWHULDOHGHOUDFFRQWRLOWHVWRVDUjVXGGLYLVRLQIUDVL EUHYLQXPHUDWH /DTTQOZDOGD\Q PHVȖUDZQWHQQDWOOD\DWWPؾؾX\ؾDZȖHUVWLVOLW ©UDFFRQWDQRVLGLFHF¶HUDXQDGRQQDWLHQHSUHVVRGLOHLQXRUDª 6LUDFFRQWDFKHXQDVXRFHUDHXQDQXRUDDELWDYDQRDVVLHPH DUWWD٤٤LVWLVOLWQQV ©GLVFXWHFRQQXRUDVXDª /DVXRFHUDGLVFXWHYDVHPSUHFRQVXDQXRUD LGGXDUEDQQVWHQQD\DV ©DUULYzILJOLRVXROHLGLFHDOXLª 4XDQGRWRUQzDFDVDLOILJOLRODPRJOLHJOLGLVVH LWWDG٤LQVPPDQ؇ ©KROLWLJDWRFRQPDGUHWXDª ³&RPHDOVROLWRKROLWLJDWRFRQWXDPDGUH´ ,OVHQVRGL©GRQQDDQ]LDQDªqVSHFLILFRGHOODUHJLRQHLQDOWUHDUHHVLXWLOL]]DWDPȖDUW 4XHVWDHVSUHVVLRQHVLJQLILFD©IDUHWHQHUHDSSDUWHQHUHªQHOVHQVRGHOSRVVHVVR 7LVOLW VLJQLILFD ©VSRVDª ©VSRVD QRYHOODª PD DQFKH QXRUD RSSXUH ©PRJOLH LQ UDSSRUWR DOOD IDPLJOLDGHOPDULWRª7DwILS /DSDUWLFHOODDULQGLFDODFRQWLQXLWjQHOSDVVDWR©VXOSXQWRGL«ªH©FRQWLQXDDIDUHª /¶LQFRPSLXWRGjLOVHQVRGHOODFRQWLQXLWjRGHOODULSHWL]LRQH $QQD0DULD'L7ROOD \DVLWLG ©HJOLSUHQGHOHLª $OORUDLOILJOLRSUHVHVXDPDGUH LJWLGJZDQXLNND\DVPUDZİDãحDQWL\QLZLQ ©PHWWHODOHLQHOSR]]RGjDOHLGLHFLGLGDWWHULª ODJHWWzQHOSR]]ROHGLHGHGLHFLGDWWHUL ؇XOOWL\QLWLZDVV ©RJQLGDWWHURDOJLRUQRª XQRDOJLRUQRSHUVRSUDYYLYHUH LGGXLGGX ©HJOLqSDUWLWRHJOLqSDUWLWRª HVHQHDQGz \DWOPXGGDDUWPPDȖ ©XQFHUWRWHPSROHLORWWDª 3HUXQFHUWRWHPSRODPDGUHORWWz LVWUDDUWȖOLVDIHOOD ©TXHOORFKHOHLYROHYDVDOHLQDOWRª SHUFHUFDUHGLULVDOLUHLOSR]]RHXVFLUH LGGXG \DQ XUHKKDO LGGXG \DQ XUHKKDO \DVLWLGL \DVLWLG \DVLWLG ©DUULYD TXL XQ QRPDGH DUULYD TXL XQ QRPDGH SUHQGH OD OHL SUHQGHODOHLª )LQDOPHQWHDUULYzXQQRPDGHFKHODSUHVHHODSRUWzYLD WHGGXWHGGXWHGGX\DWOPXGGDLPODTD\GPPDQQV ©OHLqSDUWLWDSDUWLWDSDUWLWDXQFHUWRWHPSRLQFRQWUDPDGUHVXDª 'RSRTXDOFKHWHPSRLOILJOLRLQFRQWUzVXDPDGUH /DSDUWLFHOODGLSURVVLPLWjGjLOVHQVRLQTXHVWRFDVRGLIXWXURSURVVLPR 3HULQGLFDUHLOGLPLQXWLYRDOSOXUDOHVLXWLOL]]DVSHVVRLOVXIILVVRZLQ ,QTXHVWDHVSUHVVLRQHLVWUD©/HLYXROH"ªGjLOVHQVRGLORWWDUHWHQDFHPHQWH 4XHVWRYHUERLPODTDUVLJQLILFD©LQFRQWUDUVLª 1RWHVXLWHVWLRUDOLEHUEHULGHO0DURFFR \DIWLG\DIPPDQQVLQQD\DVPPD ©WURYDOHLOjWURYDPDGUHVXDGLFHDOXLPDPPDª HODFKLDPz³0DPPD´ WHQQD\DVPPDQQNPPDQ؇D\GJLȖ ©OHLGLFHDOHLVWHVVDPDGUHWXDPDGUHWXDLRVRQRª /DPDGUHVLGRPDQGz³6RQRVXDPDGUH"´ WHQQD\DVPPDQ؇DGJLȖ ©OHLGLFHDOXLPDGUHWXDVRQRLRª 3RLJOLULVSRVH³6RQRLRWXDPDGUH ZDQQDPPLȖH]]LIOHİPPHUXUQQDGLPPHW ©TXHOODFKHKDOXQJDYLWDQRQqPRUWDª &KLKDLOGHVWLQRGLXQDOXQJDYLWDQRQPXRUH LJDWLGȖZDQXDIDGDGWPPW ©PHWWHOHLQHOSR]]RDIILQFKpOHLPXRUHª DQFKHVHWXO¶KDLJHWWDWDQHOSR]]RSHUIDUODPRULUH ZDODNLQQHWWDWWȖH]]LIDVOHİPPHUXUWHPPXW ©PDOHLSHUGXUDjOHLO¶HWjQRQqPRUWDª PDOHLqVRSUDYYLVVXWDQRQqPRUWD XUWPPXWWHGGHUVDIL ©QRQqPRUWDOHLYLYHEDVWDª OHLqYLYD´ LULDUWLWD\LU٤PDVDWPDؾؾXؾ ©HJOLYXROHDOORQWDQDUHODOHLURPSHUHFRQODPRJOLHª $TXHVWRSXQWRLOILJOLRYROOHDOORQWDQDUHODPRJOLHGLYRU]LDQGR ,QTXHVWRSDVVDJJLRVLXWLOL]]DXQSURYHUELR6SHVVRQHLSURYHUELVLXVDXQLQILQLWLYRSHUGDUH LOVHQVRGLXQDYHULWjJHQHUDOH 'RSRDIDG©DIILQFKpªLOYHUERYDFRQLXJDWRDOFRQJLXQWLYRSUHVHQWHDGDRULVWR LȖH]]LIDVOİDPDU©WX YLYUDLDOXQJRªVLGLFHGLTXDOFXQRFKHDUULYDSURSULRDOPRPHQWRLQ FXLVLSDUODGLOXL7DwILS 4XHVWRYHUERKDLOVHQVRGL©DSULUHVWDFFDUHURPSHUHLOOHJDPHª $QQD0DULD'L7ROOD LOODJLVDGLVVHQODTQPPDQQV ©F¶qLQOXLHJOLFRQRVFHLOGLULWWRYHUVRPDGUHVXDª ,OILJOLRULFRQRVFHLVXRLGRYHULYHUVRODPDGUH LOODJLVODTQOZDOGD\Q ©F¶qLQOXLLOGLULWWRYHUVRLJHQLWRULª (JOLVDGHLGRYHULYHUVRLJHQLWRUL $OFXQHRVVHUYD]LRQL ,OWHVWRRUDOHIDDSSHOORDXQRVWLOHFKHSHUPHWWHDFKLUDFFRQWDXQ¶HIILFD FLD PQHPRWHFQLFD &KL UDFFRQWD XQLVFH DOOH SDUROH L JHVWL OH LQWRQD]LRQL OD VLPEROLFDJHVWXDOHFKHVRQRSLHVSUHVVLYLGHOOHSDUROH,QTXHVWRWHVWROHSDU WLLQFRUVLYRVRQRULSHWXWHGXUDQWHODSHUIRUPDQFHGHOUDFFRQWR6LWUDWWDGLUL SHWL]LRQLRPHJOLRGLULGRQGDQ]HULSHWL]LRQLLQSDUROHVRWWROLQHDWXUHGLWRQR SDXVHHFF/HULGRQGDQ]HVRQRHOHPHQWLDFFHVVRULFKHQXOODF¶HQWUDQRFRQLO UHVWRGHOWHVWR$GHVHPSLRLOUXPRUHRXQ¶LQWHUIHUHQ]DSXzLPSHGLUHODWUD VPLVVLRQHGLXQPHVVDJJLRODULGRQGDQ]DVHUYHDFRUUHJJHUHTXHVWRLQFRQYH QLHQWH &RPXQTXH OD ULFRUUHQ]D GL ULSHWL]LRQL FKHGDQQR D XQ WHVWR RUDOH LO VXRDVSHWWRSDUWLFRODUHQRQLPSOLFDORVWDWXWRSDVVLYRGLFKLUDFFRQWDSRLFKp RJQLSURIHULPHQWRqXQDULFUHD]LRQHHXQDULWUDVPLVVLRQHLQXQWHVWRRUDOH,Q VRPPDO¶LPSURYYLVD]LRQHHODPHPRUL]]D]LRQHSRVVRQRYDULDUHFLzFKHFRQ WDSHUzqODFRQYHUJHQ]DGLTXHVWLGXHSULQFLSv ,O WHVWR VL DSUH FRQ XQD IRUPXODPHVȖDZQ ³UDFFRQWDQR´ ³VL UDFFRQWD´ /DIRUPXODSHUPHWWHGLIDUHDFKLUDFFRQWDXQDGLVWLQ]LRQHIUDLOPRQGRUHDOHH LOPRQGRGHOUDFFRQWR ,OWHVWRLQVHULVFHGHLSURYHUELRPDVVLPH,OSURYHUELRqLOJHQHUHSHUHF FHOOHQ]DGHOO¶RUDOLWjSRLFKpqFUHDWRXWLOL]]DWRHWUDVPHVVRRUDOPHQWH3HUOH VXHFDUDWWHULVWLFKHVLLQWHJUDLQTXDOXQTXHWLSRGLGLVFRUVR3HUO¶DVSHWWRQRU PDWLYRLOSURYHUELRFRVWLWXLVFHXQJHQHUHUDSSUHVHQWDWLYRGHOODVRFLHWjEHUEH UDWUDGL]LRQDOHLQJHQHUDOH1HOTXDGURGHOO¶RUDOLWjLOSURYHUELRVHUYHDQFKHD FKLXGHUHXQGLVFRUVR 3HUFLzFKHULJXDUGDO¶DWWLYLWjGLUHGD]LRQHGHLWHVWLUDFFRQWDWLRUDOPHQWH ODIHGHOWjDOWHVWRRUDOHQRQqSRVVLELOHLQWRWR1HOO¶RSHUD]LRQHGHOODVFULWWXUD F¶qXQUHODWLYR³WUDGLPHQWR´SHUSHUPHWWHUHDOOHWWRUHGL³IDUSDVVDUHLOUDFFRQ /KDTKDLOVLJQLILFDWRGL©GLULWWRJLXVWL]LDªHDQFKH©GRYHULª1HOO¶HVSUHVVLRQH,OODJLVOKDT ©KDUDJLRQHKDSUHVRFRVFLHQ]DGHLGRYHULKDO¶REEOLJRGHLGRYHULª 1RWHVXLWHVWLRUDOLEHUEHULGHO0DURFFR WR´'XQTXHSHU³IDUSDVVDUHLOWHVWR´FRPHLPSRQHODVFULWWXUDVLHYLWDQROH ULSHWL]LRQL VL VHJQDOD OD SXQWHJJLDWXUD TXHVW¶XOWLPD q LPSRUWDQWH SHU ULFR VWUXLUH LO VHQVR GHO WHVWR SHU RUJDQL]]DUH H GHOLPLWDUH LO IOXVVR GHOOH SDUROH GHOOHIUDVLHSHUPHWWHUHLQHYLGHQ]DLOGLVFRUVRGLUHWWR /DTXHVWLRQHSULQFLSDOHQHOO¶DQDOL]]DUHTXHVWRUDFFRQWRFRQVLVWHQHOIDWWR GLFRPSUHQGHUQHLOVLJQLILFDWR 8QDGHOOHSLVWHGDVHJXLUHSHUWHQWDUHGLFRPSUHQGHUHLOVHQVRGHOWHVWRq OD VHJXHQWH OD VDJJH]]D IDSDUWH GHL YDORUL H ID RWWHQHUH HVLWL SRVLWLYL OD GL VREEHGLHQ]DqGLVWUXWWLYD7DOHLGHDDVVXPHUjVHPSUHSLFKLDUH]]DDWWUDYHUVR OHPROWHSOLFLRSSRVL]LRQLFKHULOHYHUHPRGDTXHVWRWHVWRVHJXHQGRORVFKHPD VWHVVRGHOUDFFRQWR 6FKHPDGHOUDFFRQWR ,SHUVRQDJJLHOHD]LRQLSLLPSRUWDQWLFKHVLWURYDQRLQTXHVWREUHYHUDF FRQWRVRQRLVHJXHQWL ODVXRFHUDHODQXRUD ODPRJOLHHLOPDULWR LOILJOLRDEEDQGRQDQHOSR]]RODPDGUH LOQRPDGHVDOYDODPDGUH O¶LQFRQWURGHOILJOLRFRQODPDGUH LOILJOLRGLYRU]LDGDOODPRJOLH /HGLYHUVHVHTXHQ]HGHOUDFFRQWRWHQHQGRFRQWRGHOO¶DPELHQWHFXOWXUDOH QHOTXDOHLOUDFFRQWRqVWDWRQDUUDWRVLULIHULVFRQRDOODYHUVLRQHGHOWLSR³&DW WLYHUHOD]LRQLIUDVXRFHUDHQXRUD´R³0DGUHHILJOLR´/DUDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH GHOUDFFRQWRSURLHWWDXQDYLVLRQHGHOPRQGRODGGRYHVRQRWUDVSRVWLFHUWLYD ORULTXDOLTXHOOLFKHVLULIHULVFRQRDOO¶DPRUHILOLDOHDOGRYHUHYHUVRLJHQLWRUL FKHGHYRQRSULPHJJLDUHVXOOHDOWUHFRQVLGHUD]LRQLSDVVLRQDOL &RQFOXVLRQL )LQGDO;;VHFRORODYRORQWjGLIDUHPHUJHUHODOLQJXDGDOO¶RUDOLWjVLWUD GXFHFRQLOSDVVDJJLRDOORVFULWWRHODSXEEOLFD]LRQHGLLPSRUWDQWLRSHUHOHWWH ³3 &RQIOLFW EHWZHHQ PRWKHU PDWULDUFK DQG KHU VRQ¶V ZLIH´ ³3 3DUHQWV DQG FKLOGUHQ´(O6KDPL $QQD0DULD'L7ROOD UDULHRGLWHVWLVXOODYLWDTXRWLGLDQDSHUFXLRJJLVLSXzSDUODUHGLXQXVROHW WHUDULRVFULWWRGHOEHUEHUR /R VWXGLR GHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD WUDGL]LRQDOH LQ SDUWLFRODUH GHL UDFFRQWL H GHL WHVWLRUDOLROWUHDOODFRQRVFHQ]DGHOODFXOWXUDGHOODVRFLHWjEHUEHUDqXQDEDVH HVVHQ]LDOH SHU OR VWXGLR GHOO¶HYROX]LRQH OHWWHUDULD DWWXDOH H DQFKH SHU O¶LQVH JQDPHQWRGHOODOHWWHUDWXUDEHUEHUD 0ROWL DXWRUL FRQWHPSRUDQHL JUD]LH DO ODYRUR VXOODWUDGL]LRQH KDQQR UL SUHVRLWHVWLUDFFROWLRUDOPHQWHHOLKDQQRLQWHJUDWLDOODSURSULDSURGX]LRQHOHW WHUDULDFKHSUHQGHRJJLGLYHUVDGHQRPLQD]LRQHTXDOHOHWWHUDWXUDEHUEHUDFRQ WHPSRUDQHDOHWWHUDWXUDPRGHUQDRQHROHWWHUDWXUD2JJLQHO6XGGHO0DURF FR H LQ SDUWLFRODUH QHOOH UHJLRQLFKOHXK VL VWD VYLOXSSDQGR XQD SURGX]LRQH OHWWHUDULDVFULWWDLPSRUWDQWHVRSUDWWXWWRQHOFDPSRGHOODSRHVLDGHOODQRYHOOD HGHOODFUHD]LRQHWHDWUDOHDWWUDYHUVRVFULWWRULHSRHWLTXDOL0RXVWDRXL$]D\ NRX ,G %HONDFHP -RXKDGL+RXVVHLQ H DOWUL 'DJOLDQQL VHWWDQWD VRSUDWWXWWR FRQODFUHD]LRQHGHOOHDVVRFLD]LRQLFXOWXUDOLDPD]LJKHVODSURGX]LRQHOHWWHUD ULDqGLYHQXWDXQPH]]RGLVHQVLELOL]]D]LRQHHGLULYHQGLFD]LRQHLGHQWLWDULDLQ FXLORVFULWWRUDSSUHVHQWDODUHD]LRQHHODUHVLVWHQ]DDOODGRPLQD]LRQHOLQJXL VWLFDHFXOWXUDOHFKHPROWHFRPXQLWjEHUEHUHRJJLVXELVFRQR %,%/,2*5$),$ $DUQH$7KRPSVRQ67KH7\SHVRIWKH)RONWDOH$&ODVVLILFDWLRQDQG%LELRJUDSK\ +HOVLQNL7KH)LQQLVK$FDGHP\RI6FLHQFHVDQG/HWWHUV %RXQIRXU$³3UpVHQWDWLRQGHODOLWWpUDWXUHEHUEqUHFRQWHPSRUDLQH´LQeWXGHV/LWWpUDLUHV $IULFDLQHV/LWWpUDWXUHEHUEqUH3DULV.DUWKDODSS &DOYHW/-/DWUDGLWLRQRUDOH3DULV3UHVVHV8QLYHUVLWDLUHVGH)UDQFH &KDNHU6/LQJXLVWLTXHEHUEqUHeWXGHVGHV\QWD[HHWGHGLDFKURQLH3DULV±/RXYDLQ3HH WHUV 'HVWDLQJ(eWXGHVXUOHGLDOHFWHEHUEqUHGHV$wW6HJKURXFKHQ0R\HQ$WODVPDURFDLQ 3DULV(/HURX[ 'XUDQG2/LQHDPHQWLGLOLQJXDEHUEHUD9DULHWjWDPD]LJKWGHO0DURFFR&HQWUDOH5R PD8QLYHUVLWjGHJOL6WXGL³/D6DSLHQ]D´ (O6KDPL+07\SHVRIWKH)RONWDOHLQWKH$UDE:RUOG%ORRPLQJWRQ,QGLDQD8QLYHUVL W\3UHVV )LQQHJDQ52UDO/LWHUDWXUHLQ$IULFD2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV 6&KDNHU/LQJXLVWLTXHEHUEqUHeWXGHVGHV\QWD[HHWGHGLDFKURQLH3DULV±/RXYDLQ 3HHWHUV %RXQIRXU 1RWHVXLWHVWLRUDOLEHUEHULGHO0DURFFR *DODQG/³/HVODQJXHVEHUEqUHV´LQ,)RGRU&+DJqJHHGV/DQJXDJH5HIRUP+LV WRU\DQG)XWXUH+DPEXUJ%XVNHSS *DODQG3HUQHW35HFXHLOGHSRqPHVFKOHXKV,&KDQWVGHWURXYHXUV3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN ²³/HVGLIIpUHQWVDSSRUWVGHODUHFKHUFKHOLWWpUDLUHEHUEqUH´LQ',EULV]LPRZ59RV VHQpGVeWXGHVEHUEqUHV.|OQ.|SSH)UDQNIXUWHU$IULNDQLVWLVFKH%OlWWHUSS /DFRVWH'XMDUGLQ&/HFRQWHNDE\OHeWXGHHWKQRJUDSKLTXH3DULV0DVSHUR /DRXVW(0RWVHWFKRVHVEHUEqUHV3DULV&KDOODPHO 3URSS90RUIRORJLDGHOODILDED/HUDGLFLVWRULFKHGHLUDFFRQWLGLPDJLD5RPDQ1HZ WRQ&RPSWRQ 6HUUD/³,QPDUJLQHDXQWHVWRRUDOHDYHQWHDWLWRORµ/DVWRULDGHOODJHQWHGL6LJLOPDVVD¶´ LQ6WXGLPDJUHELQLSS 7DwIL0'LFWLRQQDLUHWDPD]LJKWIUDQoDLV3DULV/¶+DUPDWWDQ$ZDO *,$11,'25( 1RWHVXOOHVVLFRSDVWRUDOHNXQDPD 3UHPHVVD /D VWULVFLD FHQWURPHULGLRQDOH GHO EDVVRSLDQR RFFLGHQWDOH GHOO¶(ULWUHD GDOSXQWRGLYLVWDHFRORJLFRSDUWHGHOODSLDQDVXGDQHVHXQTXDGULODWHURGLFLU FDNPqDELWDWDGDL.XQDPDDQFKHVHQHOFRUVRGHLDQQLGLYLWD GHOOR 6WDWR HULWUHR LQGLSHQGHQWH OD SUHVHQ]D GL WLJULQL SURYHQLHQWL GDOO¶DOWR SLDQRROuVWDELOL]]DWLGRSRO¶HVLOLRLQ6XGDQQHJOLDQQLGLJXHUULJOLDFXLVLDJ JLXQJRQRRJJLSHUODSROLWLFDGLUHVHWWOHPHQWDQFKHIDPLJOLHVDKRKDPRGLIL FDWRODFRPSRVL]LRQHLQWHUQDQHLFHQWULDELWDWLSLLPSRUWDQWLGHO*RYHUQDWRUD WRGHO*DVK%DUNDN*iã%DUNi 6L q FRVu LQWHUURWWR XQ PRGHOOR SOXULVHFRODUH SHU FXL L WLJULQRIRQL GHOOH SHQGLFLGHODPDVHQHGHO6lUD\lRGHLPl]lJJDGHOO¶µ$GGL$EǀRGHO:lO TD\W VFHQGHYDQR QHO EDVVRSLDQR WHPSRUDQHDPHQWH H LQ SDVVDWR VROR GRSR L $EEUHYLD]LRQL) )HUPRGD&DVWHOQXRYR5 5HLQLVFKNE NXQDPDEDU NDNP NXQDPDPDUGD±5LQJUD]LR$QGUHDV=HLQX7DQQLSHUODUHYLVLRQHGHOO¶DSSRVL]LRQH GHL WRQL H GHOO¶RUWRJUDILD GL TXHVWR DUWLFROR ± 1RWD OLQJXLVWLFD ± ,O NXQDPD DZUD OLQJXD D VWUXWWXUDWRQDOHVFULWWDLQFDUDWWHULODWLQLVHQ]DJHQHUHXQDGHOOHQRYHOLQJXHULFRQRVFLXWHQHO O¶(ULWUHDqDWWXDOPHQWHFODVVLILFDWRWUDOHOLQJXHQLORVKDULDQH6LFDOFRODVLDSDUODWRGDFLUFD SHUVRQHLQ(ULWUHDHIRUVHDOWUHWWDQWHRUPDLLQ6XGDQVSHFLHD.DVVDODH.KDUWXPH QHLYLOODJJLGHO7LJUƗ\FRPH6KLUDUR,QDFFRUGRFRQORVWDQGDUGDWWXDOPHQWHVHJXLWRGDO.X QDPD3DQHO&XUULFXOXPGHO0LQLVWHURGHOO¶(GXFD]LRQHHULWUHRVLVHJQDQRLGXHWRQLGLEDVH DOWRHPHGLRDOWRHOHYRFDOLOXQJKHDQFK¶HVVHIRQGDPHQWDOLSHUODGLVWLQWLYLWjVHPDQWLFDLQ VLHPHFRQODJHPLQD]LRQHFRQVRQDQWLFDUDGGRSSLDPHQWR,O.XQDPD3DQHOQHOO¶DOIDEHWRNX QDPDULVSHWWRDOOHVFHOWHGLQRWD]LRQHIRQHWLFDGHLPLVVLRQDULVYHGHVLHLWDOLDQLUHQGHSORVLYD YHODUHVRUGDNIULFDWLYDSDODWDOHVRUGDãDIIULFDWDSDODWRDOYHDUHVRQRUDMSORVLYDYHODUH VRQRUDJQDVDOHSDODWDOHVRQRUDxO¶DOYHRODUHQDVDOHQ&IUSHUODOLVWDGHOO¶DOIDEHWR%HQ GHUH$EUDKD *LDQQL'RUH UDFFROWLQHOSHULRGRVHFFRHSHUUD]]LHQHOOHTXDOLSUHOHYDYDQRVWRFNGLDQLPDOL HGLFHUHDOLHGHVVHULXPDQLGHVWLQDWLDOODYRURVFKLDYLOH&RPHWHUUHGLElUDKD OH ]RQH NXQDPD QRQ YHQLYDQR JLXGLFDWH DGDWWH DOOD YLWD GL JHQWL DFFOLPDWDWH QHOO¶DOWRSLDQR ,OFRUVRGHOPHGLR*DVKWLJU0lUlEN6RRQDqLOFHQWURGLDWWUD]LRQH SHUTXHVWDYDVWDDUHDHLSDVFROLLQWRUQRDOOHDFTXHDIILRUDQWLRDSSHQDVRWWR WHUUD QHL SHULRGL GL PDJUD KDQQR VHPSUH YLVWR PLVXUDUVL SDVWRUL H DJULFROWRUL VHGHQWDUL/HPDQGULHHJUHJJLGHLSDVWRUL%HQL$PHUXQWHPSRGHQRPLQDWL âLOHGDL.RGLSDVWRUL1DUDVSHVVRDOVHUYL]LRGHLSULPLVRQRXQDSUHVHQ]D GLOXQJDGXUDWDQHLSHUFRUVLGLWUDQVXPDQ]DGDOEDFLQRGHO%DUND$QVlEDYHU VRVXGLOVDL¶G4XHVWLSDVWRULSUHFHGXWLGDDYDQJXDUGLHSHUHVSORUDUHSDVFROL H DFTXH OR UDJJLXQJRQR WUD QRYHPEUH H GLFHPEUH FRQ LO EHVWLDPH FRQ OH IL JOLRODQ]HHSRLFRQJOLDOWULFDSLILQRDPDU]RDUULYDQGRDQFKHDOOHDFTXHGHO 6HWLWWLJU7DND]]HN7LLNDVSHFLHODGGRYHTXHVWRILXPHSHUTXDOFKHFKLOR PHWUR PDQWLHQH GHOOH DFTXH SHUHQQL H ROWUH ILQR DO :lOTD\W H DO %lJHPGۑU 6XOO¶DUHD DUULYDQR VRSUDWWXWWR GRSR OD VHFRQGD JXHUUD PRQGLDOH DQFKH FDSL GHL SURSULHWDUL WLJULQL XQ WHPSR FKLDPDWL'DOH GDL . JUD]LH D FRQWUDWWL GL FRQGX]LRQHVWLSXODWLFRQSDVWRUL%HQL$PHURDQFKHFRQ6DKR(VVLSHUHQWUD UHQHOO¶DUHDVWDELOPHQWHGRSRLSULPLIDOOLPHQWLGRYHWWHURFRQYHUWLUHOHUD]]H VRVWLWXHQGRLERYLQLDUDGRFRQLEČJDLWGHO%DUNDODFXLILVLRORJLDHUDDGDWWDWD DOO¶HFRORJLDGHOEDVVRSLDQRRDQFKHIDYRUHQGRJOLLQFURFL$UDGRqWLSRGLFR ORU URVVR R SH]]DWR GL WDJOLD JUDQGH H DGDWWR DO ODYRUR DJULFROR SUHYDOHQWH QHOO¶DOWRSLDQR EČJDLW q LO WLSR GRPLQDQWH QHO EDFLQR GHO %DUND$QVlED SHU VHOH]LRQHJHQHWLFDSH]]DWRGLSHOOHILQHSULQFLSDOPHQWHSHUODWWHPHQRDGDW WRDOODYRURDJULFROR 6HFRQGRXQSDWWHUQGLOXQJDGXUDWDSHUDUULYDUHGDOO¶DOWRSLDQRDOOHSDVWX UH GHL JUDQGL ILXPL VL SHUFRUUH OD OLQHD GL WUDQVXPDQ]D FKH DJJLUDQGR .lUlQ VFHQGHGD0DQVnjUDDWWUDYHUVRLO'HPEH¶DRVLSDVVDDVXGSHUODSLVWDGLµ$U Ul]DILQRDOODJUDQGHFXUYDGHO*DVKHILQRDO6HWLW,OWUDJLWWRGLWUDQVXPDQ]D GHLSDVWRULEHMDDWWUDYHUVDQGROHFROOLQHQDUDDUULYDDO*DVKLQGLUH]LRQHGHL SDHVLGL)RRGHHGL'XNDPE\D , SLFFROL PHUFDQWL MDEHUWL H EHQL DPHU VHJXHQGR OD WUDWWD ODWHUDOH YHUVR VXGGHOODYLDFDURYDQLHUDFKHGDO6DPKDUDQGDYDD.DVVDODYLDUULYDYDQRSHU YHQGHUHVDOHWHOHULHHPDQXIDWWLGLIHUURVFDPELDQGROLVRSUDWWXWWRFRQLOVRUJR NLLQDSHUL.XQDPDSHUFXLHUDHULPDQHDQFKHRJJLODSULQFLSDOHFROWXUDDW WHQWDPHQWH FHULPRQLDOL]]DWD ULVSHWWR D FROWXUH FRPH LO PLJOLR ERUWiD R EHF FiDHLOPDLVDDI΅NQD'DLFHQVLPHQWLLWDOLDQLGLHWjFRORQLDOHDSSDUHXQD OLQHDGLFRQILQHWUDL.XQDPDHL1DUDL%DU\DGLDOORUDFKHVRQRDQFKHHVVL SDVWRULHVSHVVRFRQGXWWRULGLEHVWLDPHSHUFRQWRGHL%HQL$PHULGHWHQWRUL GHO VDSHUH WHFQLFRSL VRILVWLFDWR /H PDQGULH GL GURPHGDUL HUDQR GRPLQDQWL 1RWHVXOOHVVLFRSDVWRUDOHNXQDPD WUDLVHFRQGLTXDVLDVVHQWLWUDL.XQDPDFKHRJJLLQYHFHQHVRQRDOOHYDWRULD ODWR GL FDSUH SHFRUH H ERYLQL 6L FUHDYD FRVu XQ FRQWHVWR VWRULFR QHYUDOJLFR SHUODFRVWUX]LRQHGHOO¶HWQRVLVWHPDSHULO YDULDUHHVIXPDUHGLLGHQWLWjHVL DWWXDYDXQDUHFLSURFLWjGLVFDPELSRVLWLYLHQRQVRORQHJDWLYLFRPHTXHOODGH WHUPLQDWDGDOOHUD]]LHHFRQWURUD]]LHHGDLFRQIOLWWLVXLSDVFROLHO¶DFTXDFRQL FROWLYDWRUL VHGHQWDUL 4XHVWD DUHD VL q FRVu VWRULFDPHQWH FRVWLWXLWD FRPH XQR VSD]LR VRFLDOH SURGXWWLYR SHU HWQRDQWURSRORJLH LQFURFLDWH UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQL GHQRPLQD]LRQL H SHU WUDVIHULPHQWL GL VDSHUH WHFQLFR &HUWDPHQWH XQ ODYRUR FRPSDUDWLYR FKH TXL QRQ DIIURQWHUHPR PRVWUHUHEEH SDVVDJJL GL FRPSHWHQ]H WHFQLFKHSUHVWLWLOHVVLFDOLDVLPPHWULFLFKHKDQQRLQYHVWLWRTXHOORFKHSRWUHP PRGHILQLUHO¶LQVLHPHWHFQLFRSDVWRUDOHGLTXHVWDDUHDLQWHVRQHOVXR³IDUH´H QHOVXR³GLUH´ 3ULPHRVVHUYD]LRQLVXOODWDVVRQRPLD /H QRWD]LRQL FKH TXL SURSRQJR FKLDPDQR LQ FDXVDXQVDSHUH OHVVLFDOH H WHFQLFRSDVWRUDOHFKHTXHVWLDOOHYDWRULKDQQRFRQGLYLVRFRQJOLDOWULJUXSSLH FKHqSRVVLELOHLSRWL]]DUHSHUzPHQRULFFRPHQRUDIILQDWRGDWRFKHHVVLHUD QRHFRQWLQXDQRDHVVHUHLQSULPROXRJRDJULFROWRUL,QTXHVWROHVVLFRSDU]LDOH SURSRUUzGHOOHWDVVRQRPLHUHODWLYHDOFLFORGLYLWDGLERYLQLHRYLFDSULQLFRQ TXDOFKHULIHULPHQWRDOODHWQRILVLRORJLDDOODILWRQRPLDXWLOHRGDQQRVDDGDO WUHPRGDOLWjGLFRQGX]LRQHFRPHLULSDULLULFKLDPLULQXQFLDQGRTXLDOOHVVLFR UHODWLYR DOOD LQGLYLGXD]LRQH H FXUD GL PDODWWLH DL PDUFKL DOOD DQDWRPLD JH VWXDOLWjWHFQLFKHHSURGRWWL /HULOHYD]LRQLDSDUWHPHQRVLVWHPDWLFKHQRWD]LRQLGDPHUDFFROWHLQSUH FHGHQ]DVRQRVWDWHHIIHWWXDWHWUDLOHLOFRQLOSUH]LRVRDLXWRGL*D EULHOH*DVKD\HGL9LWWRULR$QWXWX6KRPD\FRQDOFXQLSDVWRULGLRULJLQH$\ PDVDH7DZGDFRQVLGHUDWHIUD]LRQLRVXEDUHHNXQDPDHDQFKHYDULDQWLGLDOHW WDOLHFRQXQSDVWRUHHVSHUWRGL%LPELOQDYLOODJJLREDUNDVXO*DVK,YLOODJJL ULFRQRVFLXWLFRPH7DJZGDRJJLVRQR7DZGD0ROOR'DPDURSSXUH+RUGD 'DUDPEDW$OHPDOHâXPLQLWL%DNNRP%LNLQL.RJLQL$UDURVXND,YLOODJJL ULFRQRVFLXWL $\PDVD RJJL VRQR *RJQH 8NXQDP 'RGR 0HQVXOX $\NHWD /D\GH 'HOOH âXOD ,ãLOHWD\ *XQL *XFFL" .DQNDU.RURQGD ,O YLOODJJLR GL 8JDUR DO WHPSR LWDOLDQR VHGH GL XQD PLQLHUD G¶RUR KD XQD DSSDUWHQHQ]D DPELJXDYHQHQGRDWWULEXLWRRUDDJOLXQLRUDDJOLDOWUL,SDVWRULVRQRSHUzVWDWL LQWHUYLVWDWLLQORFDOLWjYLFLQHDOFDSROXRJR%DUHQWHLQRJQLFDVRPROWLD\PD VDHWDZGDVRQRRJJLGLVSHUVLQHOOHGLYHUVHSDUWLGHOWHUULWRULR /HWDVVRQRPLHULOHYDWHULPDQGDQRDOODFROORFD]LRQHFKHJOLDQLPDOLKDQ QRQHOODFRQFH]LRQHGHOPRQGRGHLNXQDPDDOOHUHOD]LRQLVRFLDOLWUDXPDQLH DQLPDOLDOOHYDWLHQRQVRORWUDJOLRSHUDWRULLPSHJQDWLFRQJOLDQLPDOL4XHVWH *LDQQL'RUH UHOD]LRQL DQLPDOLHVVHUL XPDQL VRQR GD YHGHUVL DQFKH LQ FRQQHVVLRQH FRQ L UDSSRUWLDVLPPHWULFLGLJHQHUHFKHUHJRODQRO¶DFFHVVRGLIIHUHQ]LDWRGLXRPLQL HGRQQHDOOHSUDWLFKHRDORURSDUWLDJOLVWUXPHQWLDOVDSHUHWHFQLFRHWDVVRQR PLFR 6HFHUFKLDPRGLFRJOLHUHLOLYHOOLGLVWUXWWXUD]LRQHOLQJXLVWLFDHFODVVLILFD WRULDOLPLWDWDPHQWHDOOHGHQRPLQD]LRQLILQRUDUDFFROWHVHPEUDHPHUJHUHXQR VWDWXVGHVLJQDWLYRHVHPDQWLFRGLãLJtGHLQUDSSRUWRGLRSSRVL]LRQHFRQJOLD QLPDOLVHOYDWLFLLVRVRQH âLJtGHDSSDUHFRPHWD[RQJHQHULFRFKHHVSULPHVLDXQDVRFLDOLWjSURGXW WLYDVLDXQOHJDPHIXQ]LRQDOHVSHFLILFRFRQO¶XRPR6RQRJOLDQLPDOLDOOHYDWL SHUHOH]LRQHDQLPDOLDOOHYDWLLQPDQGULDHJUHJJHRVHFRQGDULDPHQWHIXQ]LRQD OLDOWUDVSRUWRRDOODYRURGHLFDPSL9LVRQRLQFOXVLLERYLQLD\OHLFDSULQL VpVHNEODããHD\PDVDWDZGDOiNNHOHSHFRUHJXUPHHLGURPHGDULUN~ EH *OL DVLQLVQGH H L PXOLEiJLOH YL VRQR DQFKH HVVL LQFOXGLELOL PD QRQ FRPHDOOHYDWLLQFROOHWWLYL%XXWDHãLQQiVRQRJOLVSHFLILFDWLYLGHLWHUPLQLJH QHULFLSHULGHQWLILFDUHLOPDVFKLRHODIHPPLQD1HVRQRSHUzHVFOXVLDOWULDQL PDOLDOOHYDWLFRPHLOSROODPHGRRUpHHDQFRUDDODWRXQGRPHVWLFRQRQHGLEL OHFRPHWD\iDLOFDQH ,QVRVRQHVHPEUDQRLQFOXVLFRPHSHULOVDKRDOOXXODPDPPLIHULFDFFLD WRULHTXDGUXSHGLFRPHDELQDPRUNDDQJZDNRLWDVDOiQJDHOHIDQWHOHRQH LHQD OHRSDUGR VFLDFDOOR PHQWUH QH VRQR HVFOXVLDOWUL DQLPDOL GHOOD VDYDQD FRPHILLOiDJHQHULFRSHUWRSRWULFNVWHUQHOOHILDEHFRPHORVFLDFDOORHGDU PiDJHQHULFRSHUVHUSHQWHFKHVRQRFROORFDELOLDILDQFRPDFKHQRQVHPEUD QRDYHUHXQWD[RQVXSHULRUH2YYLDPHQWHFLVRQRULFFKLWD[DVXERUGLQDWLGLIL OqHGLGDUPq,QXQDORJLFDFODVVLILFDWRULDVROOHFLWDWDFKHVSLQJHDFODVVLILFDUH LQPRGRGDJHUDUFKL]]DUHULHPSHQGRLYXRWLJOLLQVHWWLVRQRFODVVLILFDWLFRPH VRVRQD IHIHQLQiD VHOYDWLFL FRQ OH DOL PD QHL FRQWHVWL GLVFRUVLYL PL SDUH FKHHVVLVLDQRLQYHFHFROORFDWLDODWRGHLVRVRQHDOORVWHVVROLYHOOR$QFRUDD ODWRVRQRJOLXFFHOOLã·UNH$OFXQLVRVRQHVRQRSRVWLLQUHOD]LRQHGLUHWWDFRQLO EHVWLDPHLQTXDQWRQHPLFLGDFXLJXDUGDUVLFRPHODLHQDDQJZDFKHGLYHQWD JHQHULFRVRVRQDRKDXQQRPHVRVWLWXWLYRGLQRWWHO¶LSRFRULVWLFRKDVVDQEXR QRRSSXUHGČGHNRLELGDSURLELWRDLEDPELQLFRVuDQFKHODVFLPPLDJDEDOD 2YYLDPHQWH YLqXQDULFDGXWDOLQJXLVWLFDVXJOLHQXQFLDWLFKHGHVFULYRQR JOLHVVHULXPDQLDGHVHPSLRVRVRQDVLGLFHLQVHQVRPHWDIRULFRDQFKHGLXR PLQLVHOYDWLFLFRPHDYYLHQHSHUDOOXXODWUDL6DKR1HLOLEULGLWHVWRVLVWDRJJL SURSRQHQGRXQDWDVVRQRPLDXIILFLDOHQRUPDOL]]DQWHFKHULHPSLHLYXRWLLQXQ IUDVDULRNXQDPDWLJULQRHQHLWHVWLGHOOHVFXROHYLHQHGDWRVRVRQDFRPHJHQH ULFRSHUDQLPDOLFRQOHVSHFLILFD]LRQLtWDVRVRQHGHOODFDVD GRPHVWLFLHjM MDREttODVRVRQHVHOYDWLFLGHOODFDPSDJQDFRQQHWWRVOLWWDPHQWRULVSHWWRDOOD WDVVRQRPLDSRSRODUHGRYHXQWD[RQVRYUDRUGLQDWRFRPHDQLPDOLRHVVHULYL 1RWHVXOOHVVLFRSDVWRUDOHNXQDPD YHQWLDQLPDOLVHPEUDDVVHQWH/RVWHVVRGLVWDFFRGDXQDWDVVRQRPLDSRSRODUH VWDDYYHQHQGRSHUODOLQJXDVDKRGRYHQHLOLEULGLWHVWRSHUOHVFXROHHOHPHQWD UL EDKDD\LP JHQHULFR SHU DQLPDOL RUGLQD L WD[DFDUL R PHHOL EDKDD\LP JOL DQLPDOLGRPHVWLFLH]LELEDKDD\LPJOLDQLPDOLVHOYDWLFL 7UDJOLDOOHYDWLVRQRSUHSRQGHUDQWLVXOSLDQRTXDQWLWDWLYRLFDSULQLLQUHOD ]LRQH SL SRVLWLYD FRQ O¶HFRORJLD GL TXHVWD SDUWH GHO EDVVRSLDQR RFFLGHQWDOH HULWUHRULVSHWWRDLERYLQLHDJOLRYLQL 'DLGDWLUDFFROWLqSRVVLELOHHVWUDUQHFRQVXIILFLHQWHFKLDUH]]DLSURFHGL PHQWLSHUFHWWLYLLPSOLFLWL2YYLDPHQWHVLFRPSRQHSULPDGLWXWWRXQDOLVWDOHV VLFDOHFKHGHWWDJOLDOHGHQRPLQD]LRQLLQUDSSRUWRDOGLQDPLVPRGHOODILVLROR JLDGHOO¶DQLPDOHQHOVLVWHPDGLDOOHYDPHQWR4XLHPHUJHODGHEROH]]DGHLWHU PLQLUDFFROWLLQSUHFHGHQ]DQHLSRFKLGL]LRQDULROHVVLFLQRQVSHFLDOL]]DWLGR YHVSHVVRGHJOLVSHFLILFLYHQJRQRGDWLSHUJHQHULFL 'DOO¶HVDPHGHLWHUPLQLUDFFROWLDJJHWWLYLVRVWDQWLYLRSDUROHVRVWDQWLYD WHYHGLDPRFKHODWDVVRQRPLDqUHWWDGDWUDWWLFODVVLILFDWRULSULYLOHJLDWLHSHU WLQHQWL 1HOO¶HVDPLQDUH OH GHQRPLQD]LRQL FKH GLVWLQJXRQR OH IDVL GLYHUVH GHO FLFORGLYLWDL YDORULVHOH]LRQDWLVRQRLQUDSSRUWRFRQODULSURGX]LRQHFRQOD FRQGX]LRQHHSDVFROLHRYYLDPHQWHFRQLOVHVVRWHUPLQLVHQ]DJHQHUHDOHP PDXQLFRFRQTXDOLILFDWLYRFRPHD\ODEXXWDSHUEXHHD\ODãLQQDSHUYDFFDR DOHPPDXQLFRSHUXQJHQHUHFRPHVDDUDSHULOFDSURQH&RQO¶DJJLXQWDGL QXPHUDOLVLSXzLQGLFDUHODSRVL]LRQHQHOFLFORGHOODYLWDLQUDJLRQHGLHWj 1HOODRQRPDVWLFDGHLERYLQLSLULFFDULVSHWWRDTXHOODGHJOLRYLFDSULQL DQFKHVHORQWDQDGDOODLSHUGLIIHUHQ]LD]LRQHOHVVLFDOHGHLSDVWRULVDKRREHMD DJLVFRQRSULQFLSLHVWHWLFLJHQHDORJLFLPRUIRORJLFLHFRPSRUWDPHQWDOL ,YDORULPRUIRORJLFLVHOH]LRQDQRSULPDGLWXWWRLFRORULGHOPDQWRHODORUR GLVWULEX]LRQH R FRQILJXUD]LRQH DG HVãLãLQQD SH]]DWD D FKLD]]H R SXQWL ,O PDQWRqFRPXQTXHO¶HOHPHQWRGLUHWWLYR,FURQRQLPLFKHFRPSDLRQRVRQRD UDELDQFRHDFFRPSDJQDWRGDPRGXODWRUHDUDJUJDYHUGDVWURDUDOpGGD JLDOORVSRUFRDUDV~UPDEUXQRFKLDURDUDyUDJULJLR*OLDOWULFURQRQLPLVR QR~PPDQHURV~XODEUXQRELLEiURVVLFFLRPDUURQHOpGGDFKHLGHQWLILFD XQDJDPPDGLYDULD]LRQLGDOJLDOORSDJOLHULQRDXQPDUURQHFKLDURLQGLFDDQ FKHXQDIDVHGLPDWXUD]LRQHGHOVRUJRFRPHSHUDOWURJUJDFKHKDUHIHUHQWL FRQFUHWLQHOORVWDWRGHOIUHVFRGHOODYHJHWD]LRQHSHUXQDFDSUDVLSXzXVDUH DQFKHDQWRNDEUXFLDWD ,OFRORUHGHOPDQWRSXzSURGXUUHGHQRPLQD]LRQHDQFKHLQFRPELQD]LRQH FRQODIRUPDGHOFRUSRRFRPHLQVLHPHFRUWRFRPSDWWRHFFRFRQXQDVH OH]LRQH GL VXH SDUWL FRPH OD IRUPD GHOOH FRUQD GHOOH RUHFFKLH GHOOH ]DPSH HFFDGHVNXQGiUDFRQVWULVFLDELDQFDVXOODIURQWH/HGLYHUVHSDUWLFRUSRUHH SRVVRQRHVVHUHVHOH]LRQDWHFRPHHVFOXVLYHRQHOOHORURUHOD]LRQLFRPHODGL VWDQ]DUHFLSURFDODGLUH]LRQHO¶LQFOLQD]LRQHHFF/HSDUWLGHOFRUSRFKHTXL *LDQQL'RUH FRPSDLRQRVRQRGiUJDLILDQFKLVHUDLOFROORJLLODOHFRUQDNXQGDODIURQ WHDQDVQJDODWHVWDGDLO PXVRNXWDOHPDPPHOOHXNQDOHRUHFFKLH &RVuXNXQDDODqXQDFDSUDFRQRUHFFKLHSLFFROHXNXQGXUDTXDVLVHQ]DRUHF FKLH PD DQFKH WUDVODWR SHU WHVWDUGD NXWD JHHUD q FDSR DSSUH]]DWR SHU OH PDPPHOOHJURVVH0DFLVRQRGHQRPLQD]LRQLFKHLPSOLFLWDPHQWHULFRQGXFRQR DOODYDULD]LRQHQHOODGHQWDWXUDLQGLFHIRQGDPHQWDOHSHUO¶HWjRDOODSRVVDQ]D GHOSHWWRFRRODHDOODHOHJDQ]DGHOSRUWDPHQWR ,OHPPLFKHVLULIHULVFRQRDOODIHUWLOLWjHFDSDFLWjULSURGXWWLYDPDVFKLOHR IHPPLQLOHQRQKDQQRELVRJQRGLXQRVSHFLILFDWLYRGLJHQHUHPDVRORGLVSH FLHFRPHNWDJUDYLGDGDJRVDSXHUSHUDPDTXDOFXQRGjLGXHWHUPLQLSHU HTXLYDOHQWL NRNREEDODIHPPLQDFKHLQL]LDDGDOODWWDUHHGqSULPLSDUDGDO VDQJXHPHVWUXDOHFRPHPDWHULDFKHVLFRDJXODQHOYHQWUHSHULOFRQFHSLPHQ WRHLOILJOLRDQHVWLPRODODODWWD]LRQHDZVDNHHUHNH,QttQtxD VXDPDGUH qODYDFFDRFDSUDGLRDQQLFRQILJOLRMEDODWWLIHUDHDQFRUDNDODDODFRQ SRFRODWWHVHQRQIXQ]LRQDEHQHODSDUWHGHOOHPDPPHOOHHJKLDQGROHPDP PDULHQDQDHRORQNRRQDTXDQGRLOODWWHVWDRUPDLGLYHQWDQGROLTXLGRHFDF FLDYLDLOILJOLRVLGLFHDQFKHOLLVDILOuW&RQVXIILVVLSULYDWLYLVLSXzLQGLFDUH LO GHILFLW SURGXWWLYR VHPSUH LQ UHOD]LRQH DOOD FDSDFLWj ODWWLIHUD FRPH LQD\OD DZVWWDVHQ]DODWWH/DFDSUDSULPLSDUDqWXIIDGDW·VNHW~IHVNHILFFDUOROD VFLDQGRORULWWR ,OEXHFDVWUDWRqxUDWHUPLQHFKHSXzHVVHUHDVVRFLDWRDOODVWHULOLWjPD VFKLOH&RQDOWULWHUPLQLVLLQGLFDQRSUDWLFKHGLJRYHUQRGHOFDSRIHPPLQDFR PHJXUMjODYDFFDLOFXLSULPRRVHFRQGRJHQLWRqVWDWRXFFLVRSHUODODWWD]LR QHFRPHQHL6DKRHODFXLSHOOHqGjDUjPDVHUYHDGDYYLFLQDUOHXQODWWDQWH HVWUDQHR R O¶XVR DQFRUD SRVVLELOH DOO¶XVFLWD GDOOD ULSURGX]LRQH FRPH D\OD JRGGyRED O¶DQ]LDQD FKH SXz HVVHUH GHVWLQDWD DO PDFHOOR HVFOXGHQGR SHUz L FDSLPDODWLPHQWUHEXXWDDDGtNtãDqLOFRUULVSRQGHQWHPDVFKLOHRDQFKHEXXWD tWyyNHLQYHFFKLzLOEXHDQ]LDQRVHQ]DLPSXOVRVHVVXDOHVHQ]DIRU]DSHUO¶D UDWURGHVWLQDWRDQFK¶HVVRDOODYHQGLWDRDOPDFHOOR 7HUPLQLVHQ]DJHQHUHHDVSHFLILFLLQOHPPLFRPHGDJRVDSLFFRORDNL ãDPLQRUHDGLJLODSULPRJHQLWRDVLXVDQRDQFKHSHUJOLXPDQLPHQWUHPpU NDODWWDQWHVLXVDVRORSHUJOLDQLPDOLHFRQDGLPLLWDFDSUHWWDFKHQRQKDDQ FRUDSDUWRULWRFLVLSXzVFKHU]RVDPHQWHULIHULUHDOOHUDJD]]H $QFKH LO WHPSHUDPHQWR LQ UHOD]LRQH DOOD GLVSRQLELOLWj DOOD VRFLDOLWj H DL GLYHUVLDVSHWWLGHOODGLVFLSOLQDULFKLHVWDHDOO¶XVRGHOFDSRSXzHQWUDUHGDVROR RLQFRPELQD]LRQHQHLWHUPLQL 3DUWLFRODUH DWWHQ]LRQH YLHQH GDWD DOOD VHOH]LRQH GHO WRUR SHU FXL WHUPLQL FKHULJXDUGDQRODIRU]DODFDSDFLWjULSURGXWWLYDFRQFRUURQRDIRUPDUHO¶RQR PDVWLFDFRPHEXXWDLGGtUDSRWHQWHHFRUDJJLRVRWHUPLQHDSSOLFDELOHDQFKH SHUXRPLQL,OSURWRWLSRFKHVLWUDWWLGLERYLQLRGLRYLFDSULQLYLHQHFRVWUXL 1RWHVXOOHVVLFRSDVWRUDOHNXQDPD WRGXQTXHQRQVRORLQUHOD]LRQHDOODVXDSRWHQ]DILVLRORJLFDHULSURGXWWLYDPD DQFKHDOODDWWLWXGLQHSRVLWLYDRQHJDWLYDDOODVRFLDOLWjQHOODPDQGULDLQDOOHDQ ]DFRQLOFRQGXWWRUHXPDQR$WWUDYHUVRODFDVWUD]LRQHxUDVLVHSDUDQRLEXRL SHULOODYRURGHLFDPSLDQFKHVHQRQqUDURRJJLFRPHLQSDVVDWRFRQGXUUHDO O¶DUDWXUDXQGURPHGDULR,OULIHULPHQWRDOODFDSDFLWjDUDWRULDLQIOXLVFHVXOODQR PHQFODWXUDHVXOOHVWUDWHJLHGLDOOHYDPHQWRIDWDNjYXROGLUHFKHVLSXzRUPDL DGGHVWUDUHDGDUDUHEXXWDNLãjRDQFKHEXXWDNRWRNRQDFKHqLQJUDGRGLDUD UHD\ODHNNpQDqJHQHULFRSHULOEXHFKHVLDJJLRJDSHUODSULPDYROWDPDq SLVSHFLILFRWRNRQLGGDDGDGDDGGHVWUDUHDGDUDUH6LGLFHDQFKHSHUXQFD SRIHPPLQDQRQUDUDPHQWHLPSLHJDWRSHUO¶DUDWXUD$\ODMDEXUjqLOEXHDEL WXDWR DO JLRJR RNRPDDGD $QJHUiD q LO EXH GL GHVWUD QHOO¶DUDWXUD SHUFKp q TXHOORDELWXDWRDJLUDUHDIDUFHUFKLRGDOjqLOEXHGLVLQLVWUDRVHUJDDODPD KRDYXWRDQFKHWi\WDDNNjWDUDHLQDUHDEDUNDWi\WDHOi\GDOi\VVHqDSSDLD WROi\V NLE΅NH DUz FRQ XQ SDLR GL EXRLEXXWD DQGD NLãiiGtQy ELãiD EiDO G~NNXGWWDJDVVHHVVHQGRVLLOEXHPROWRLUUREXVWLWRFDPPLQzQHOVROFRDUz VHQ]DSXQJRODUORY)VYOHLGD,OFROORVHUDKDTXLYDORUHVLPEROLFR1RQ VRORLGHQWLILFDO¶DQLPDOHSHUO¶DUDWXUDVRWWRSRVWRDOJLRJRPDODFRVWUL]LRQHH OD IDWLFD GHO ODYRUR QHOOD VRFLHWj XPDQD LQGLFD OD VSHFLILFD UHOD]LRQH GL XQD GRQQDFRQLNHEpVHLSDUHQWLGHOPDULWRFKHQRQQHDFTXLVWDQRFRQLEHQLPD WULPRQLDOL OH RVVDVQJD PHWDIRUD GHOOD SDUHQWHOD PDWULOLQHDUH PDVHUD LO VXRODYRUR /DFRQGX]LRQHGHOOHPDQGULH ,QTXHVWDWHUUDGLVDYDQDPDFRQFROOLQHWUDJOLHLPHWULGLDOWL WXGLQHLSDVWRULNXQDPDHVHUFLWDQRODSDVWRUL]LDNRQGDRãLJtGDQGDVH FRQGROHYDULD]LRQLVWDJLRQDOLGHOO¶DQQRJDOODKƱJLGDHSHUFRUURQRHXVDQR OHSRU]LRQLGLjGGDHGLEttODDWWHQWLVRSUDWWXWWRLQSURVVLPLWjGHLYLOODJJLDOUL VSHWWRGHOOHSRU]LRQLGLELãDWHUUDFROWLYDWDHGLYHUVDPHQWHDGGRPHVWLFDWDjG GDRjMMDqORVSD]LRDSHUWRGLUDGDERVFDJOLDWDDUDHYHJHWD]LRQHGLVDYDQD FKHVLSXzGLVWLQJXHUHGDEuLODVSD]LRGHVHUWLFRFKHSHUzSHUFHUWLSDUODQWLH TXLYDOHDGjGGDVRVRQjFRPHVSD]LRRSSRVWRDOFROWLYDWRHDELWDWRGDDQLPDOL VHOYDWLFL8QDOWURWHUPLQHqWDNXUDFKHLQGLFDXQDSLDQDFRPHQHOPDFURWR SRQLPRFRQFXLVLLQGLFDODYDVWDDUHDWUDLO*DVKHLO6HWLWODNDWDNXUDRSLDQD GHOODSDOPDGXP%DDG·PPDLQGLFDLQYHFHXQWHUUHQRLQDGDWWRDOOHFROWLYD]LR QL H GLVDJHYROH DQFKH SHU LO EHVWLDPH DFTXLWULQRVR GXUDQWH OH JUDQGL SLRJJH WUDJLXJQRHDJRVWRPDXWLOL]]DELOHSHUDWWLYLWjDFTXLVLWLYHFRPHODFDFFLDOD UDFFROWDGHOODJRPPDHGHOPLHOHWXWWHDWWLYLWjRJJLLQGHFOLQRHTXDOLWjQHJD WLYHGLWHUUDODJiDLQGLFDQRDQFKHJOLDJJHWWLYLEDGGDEHHUHVXQJD *LDQQL'RUH ,OSDVWRUHFRQGXWWRUHGLDOOHYDWLVLFKLDPDãLJtGDDGDXQVXRGLSHQGHQWH LQULIHULPHQWRVDUjLQGLFDWRFRQLOVXIILVVRSRVVHVVLYRãLJtGDDGDQDLOPLRSD VWRUH ãLJtGDDGL\D LO VXR SDVWRUH HFF 4XHVWL SHU FRQYHUVR XVHUjD\Q\D ãLJt GDDGDSHULOSURSULRSDGURQH,OVHUYRSDVWRUHVHFROWLYDSXzDIILWWDUHXQEXH SHUO¶DUDWXUDVHUDEDGzVVHRVHUDNLWjjNHXQJLRUQROXLXQJLRUQRLOSDGURQH RQHDEEHYHUDLOEHVWLDPHLQFDPELRGLYHVWLHSXzFKLDPDUVLEXXWDGD /DããD DZDGD R ODããDGD q LO FDSUDLR LQ EDUNDVpVDDGD LQ PDUGD VL SXz DQFKHGLUHODããDOLLGDLOJXDUGLDQRGHOOHFDSUHQRQQHFHVVDULDPHQWHLOSDGUR QH)VYODVFLDULSRUWDDLOOLGjGDOLLGjFDSUDVHOYDWLFDGHO6HWLWHODVFLDqXD FHWULROLDPDURJQROLSDVWXUDGHOOHFDSUH *XMiqVLDLOEDVWRQHDUFXDWRGDFXLLOSDVWRUHQRQVLVHSDUDVLDLOWHUPLQH XWLOL]]DWRFRQVSHFLILFD]LRQLSHULQGLFDUHLOJUHJJHRODPDQGULD&RPHLQ6D KRLOWHUPLQHLORLQWLJUqPRUDHLQWLJULQRElWULLOEDVWRQHYDOHFRPHODTXDQ WLWjRWWLPDOH3HULNXQDPDRVFLOODWUDLHLFDSLLOFROOHWWLYRFKHSXz HVVHUHFRQGRWWRDSSXQWRGDXQVROREDVWRQH SDVWRUH/DFRQVLVWHQ]DGHPR JUDILFDKDXQDUDJLRQHWHFQLFDUHODWLYDDOOHFRVWUL]LRQLGLFRQGX]LRQHDOO¶DQ QDWD H DOOD SRVVLELOLWj GL UHDOL]]DUH QHO WHPSR OD JUDQGH]]D RWWLPDOH 2OWUH TXHVWDGLPHQVLRQHLQWHUYLHQHODQHFHVVLWjGLXQDXVLOLRFRRSHUDWLYRSHULOVXR JRYHUQR R GL XQD DVVRFLD]LRQH FRQ DOWUL SDVWRUL /¶HQWLWj H OD FRPSRVL]LRQH GHOODPDQGULDVRQRTXLQGLGHWHUPLQDELOLLQIXQ]LRQHGLYDULDELOLFRPHO¶DELOLWj GHOSDVWRUHODTXDOLWjGHLSDVFROLGLVSRQLELOLLOUDSSRUWRWUDFDSLFKHKDQQRIL JOLDWRJUDYLGLRVHQ]DSUROH.LUDPDqO¶HQWLWjLQIHULRUHDJXMiD%LPELOQDVL XVDLQYHFHFKHNLUDPDLOWHUPLQHJXPPDWWiHVLLQWHQGHDOGLVRWWRGHLFDSL %LVRJQDWHQHUSUHVHQWHFKHWUDLSDVWRULNXQDPDYLJHO¶LQWHUGL]LRQHDFRQ WDUHJOLDQLPDOLSHUFKpTXHVWRSURGXUUHEEHHIIHWWLQHJDWLYLVXOOHVRUWLGHOFRO OHWWLYRLSDVWRUL VDQQRFRQDOWUHVWUDWHJLHFRJQLWLYHFDOFRODUHO¶LQVLHPHHDQ FKHYHGHUHVHPDQFDTXDOFKHHOHPHQWRHLOVLVWHPDGLGHQRPLQD]LRQHqDTXH VWRIXQ]LRQDOH 3HULERYLQLFRPHSHULFDSULQLQHOODFRQGX]LRQHVLSRVVRQRDYHUHPDQ GULHRJUHJJLFRQSLGLXQSDVWRUHRSLIDPLJOLHFKHVLDVVRFLDQRSHUODFRQ GX]LRQH Wi\WH ULIHULWR DOOH PDQGULH YXRO GLUH ³DVVRFLDWH´ H ULFRQGXFH FRPH PL FRQIHUPD 2VXPDQH DOO¶LGHD GL DVVRFLD]LRQHHVSUHVVD DQFKH LQWi\WD EXH GLGHVWUDQHOJLRJRHQHOODJLUDWDGHOVROFRDOO¶DUDWXUDFRPHDEELDPRYLVWRSUL PD 6HF¶qVWDWDXQDUD]]LDDOILXPHVLFKLHGH©7D\WpH\NiOOHQR"$\ODJ~MH \NiOOHQR"ª 4XDQWL ERYLQL GHOOD VWHVVD PDQGULD" ( VL ULVSRQGH ©JXMH EUH VDWWH«HOOzND«ª'XHWUH«RXQRVRORGHOORVWHVVRFROOHWWLYR *OL DQLPDOL DOOHYDWL VRQR H VRSUDWWXWWR VRQR VWDWLLQWLPDPHQWH FRQQHVVL FRQDWWLGLUHFLSURFLWjQHJDWLYDFRPHOHUD]]LHHLIXUWLGLEHVWLDPH6RSUDWWXWWR LQUHOD]LRQHDTXHVWLHYHQWLDYYHQLYDODYDORUL]]D]LRQHGLTXDOLWjFRPHLOFR 1RWHVXOOHVVLFRSDVWRUDOHNXQDPD UDJJLRHO¶DVWX]LDDWWULEXLWHDJOLXRPLQLDGXOWLPDDQFKHDGDQLPDOLOHDGHUHVL VRQRSURGRWWHHVSUHVVLRQLPHWDIRULFKHHPHWRQLPLFKHLQFDQWLHUDFFRQWLHQHL NPiãDOH³YDQWHULH´HVSUHVVLRQLYHUEDOLFRQVLJQLILFDWRQDVFRVWRDFFRPSD JQDWHGDLFRQRJUDILHJHVWXDOLFRGLILFDWHFRQFXLJOLDGXOWLVLJORULDYDQRGLDWWL GLYDORUH6LSDUWLYDFRPHJUXSSRGLVRGDOLNROOHPDQHJOLVSD]LORQWDQLHD SHUWL SHU OD UD]]LD EDDGiD H VL WRUQDYD FRQ iQQyRGD LO ERWWLQR SUHYDOHQWH PHQWHGLEHVWLDPHiQ\~~\QHVRQROHEHVWLHFKHVLVRVSHWWDUXEDWHtEiONLãDD NHTXHOOHSHUGXWHLOFKHLQQHVFDFRPSRUWDPHQWLGLYHUVL0DLQHQWUDPELLFDVL LOSDVWRUHGHYHDYHUHOHFRPSHWHQ]HSHUVHJXLUHJOLLQGL]LGHOEHVWLDPHSHUGX WRDViUDOLNtGDULFHUFDGHOOHWUDFFHHJHVWLUHQHOO¶DPELJXLWjWUDOHGXHSRVVL ELOLWjOHUHOD]LRQLXPDQHGXUDQWHO¶LQGDJLQH ,IDWWLGHOODULSURGX]LRQHVRQRGLYLWDOHLPSRUWDQ]DFRPHSHUWXWWLLSDVWR ULHGDOOHWDEHOOHULVXOWDODSURGXWWLYLWjOHVVLFDOHSHULFDSLPDVFKLHSHUOHIHP PLQH FKH GHWWDJOLD OD SRVL]LRQH ULVSHWWR DOOD HWjULSURGXWWLYD OD VXD IHUWLOLWj YLUWXDOHHHIIHWWLYDODVXDXVFLWDGDOODULSURGX]LRQH/DVHOH]LRQHULSURGXWWLYD IDSHUQRVXOODJHVWLRQHGHOODPRQWDSHUPHWRGLHWHPSLLQUDSSRUWRDOODVSHFLH HDOODTXDOLWjGHLFDSL$%LPELOQDVLXVDNHWWDDGDSHUODPRQWDHODVWDJLRQH GHOOD PRQWD qNHWWDDGD IDQiND NHWD JUDYLGD VL XVD VROR SHU OH IHPPLQH GL DQLPDOL 1RQ VL ODVFLDQR PRQWDUH L PDVFKL GXUDQWH OD VWDJLRQH GHOOH SLRJJH JDOODWUDJLXJQRHDJRVWRHSHUFLzVLOHJDQRSHUXQDSDUWHVWUHWWDDWWRUQRDXQ URJQRQHEDDOLNDNLHOHNHOHJDWRFRQXQDFRUGLFHOOD'XUDQWHHUPiDIDQiND ODVWDJLRQHGHOVHFFRDIHEEUDLRHDPDU]RLQYHFHVLOLEHUDQRSHUDYHUHDJQHO OLQLDOOHSLRJJHTXDQGRVLWURYDO¶HUED 'LYHQWD IRQGDPHQWDOH OD FUHD]LRQH GL XQD EXRQD JHQHDORJLD H SHUFLz OD ULFHUFD GL XQ FDSRVWLSLWH q HOHPHQWR QHYUDOJLFR QHOOD FRVWLWX]LRQH H JHVWLRQH GHOFROOHWWLYR,OQRPHSHULQGLFDUHODUD]]DRWLSRqWDZDEDOHEHVWLHPLJOLRUL YDQQR FHUFDWH QHL YDUL PHUFDWL GD 2P +DJHU D âDPEXNR 0RJROR +DNRWD 'XNDPE\D1HOODJHVWLRQHGHOFROOHWWLYRqDQFKHIRQGDPHQWDOHO¶LGHQWLILFD]LR QHFRQLPDUFKLDOHHPiWDqLOPDUFKLRFKHLQGLFDO¶DSSDUWHQHQ]DGHOFDSRDOOD PDQGULDRJUHJJHDOjJDWDWLJUqFRQO¶LPSUHVVLRQHGHOVHJQRFRQLOIHUURUR YHQWHRFRQWDJOLRFRQXQDFRPELQD]LRQHODFXLYDULHWjQRQWUDWWLDPRTXL /¶DQLPDOH OHDGHU q YLWDOH SHU OD FRQGX]LRQH GHO FROOHWWLYR H GHYH DYHUH TXDOLWj GL LQWUDSUHQGHQ]D GL FDSDFLWj GL ULVSRQGHUH WHPSHVWLYDPHQWH DL FR PDQGLGHOSDVWRUHQHOODJHVWLRQHRUGLQDULDFRPHQHLPRPHQWLGLSHULFRORDVVX PHQGRVLODJXLGD&RPHSUHFLVD2VXPDQHD\ODRMuEDQRQLQGLFDVRORFKHXQD YDFFDqODWWLIHUDPDFKHKDDQFKHDOWUHTXDOLWjqSHUIHWWDqJXLGDQHOSDVFROR HDOO¶RYLOHqGLVFLSOLQDWDQHOFRPSRUWDPHQWRqOHDGHUGHOODPDQGULDSUHQGH O¶LQL]LDWLYDDQFKHVHQ]DLOSDVWRUHVHDUULYDLOQHPLFRIXJJHLQVRPPDLOSUR WRWLSRVXFXLPLVXUDUHLOYDORUHGHLFDSLHFRVWUXLUHXQDJHUDUFKLDHDQFKHXQD JHQHDORJLD6DOXXJDNPãDOXXIDSHUDOFXQLHTXLYDOHSHUDOWULHVSULPHXQD *LDQQL'RUH JUDGD]LRQHGLTXDOLWjFRLQFLGHVRORSDU]LDOPHQWHFRQRMuEDqXEELGLHQWHYDD ILDQFRGHOSDVWRUHPDQRQqOHDGHUFRPHO¶DOWUD$SSHQGHUHVRQDJOLRXQFDP SDQHOOR DO FROODUHPDFHUiPD IDFLOLWD LO UXROR GL OHDGHU FRQIHULVFH DQFKH DO FROOHWWLYR XQ VXRQR GLVWLQWLYR LO FKH QRQ HVFOXGH O¶DSSUH]]DPHQWR HVWHWLFR $QGDQGRDOOHTXDOLWjSHUGLIHWWRD\ODiGiPDqDJJUHVVLYDDQFKHVHDOODILQHVL ULHVFH D GRPDUOD EXXWD IXUXXUD q LQGLVFLSOLQDWR UHFDOFLWUDQWH QRQ VL ODVFLD GRPDUHPDQRQVLIDFDWWXUDUHGDOQHPLFRJiQJiPDqD\ODFKHKDIRU]DUH FDOFLWUDVHODVLYXROHDOODWWDUHqSRWHQWH 9LVRQRGLYHUVHHVSUHVVLRQLUHODWLYHDOOHSUDWLFKHGLFRQGX]LRQHGHOJUHJ JH 3HU UDJLRQL GL VSD]LR LQGLFR TXLGHOOHVVH HVSUHVVLRQH YHUEDOH FKH LQGLFD O¶DWWRGLGLVFLSOLQDUHOHSHFRUHHFDSUHQHOO¶HQWUDWDHXVFLWDGDOUHFLQWRLQILODX QDSHUXQD&RPSDUHQHOVRVWDQWLYRNHGHOODFKHQHOVLVWHPDGLSDUHQWHODLQGLFD O¶DVVRFLD]LRQH GL XQD VRUHOOD FRQ XQ IUDWHOOR QHOO¶RUGLQH GL VHQLRULWj DL ILQL GHOODUHOD]LRQHHGHLFRQVHJXHQWLGLULWWLHREEOLJD]LRQLGHLILJOLGLOHLVHFRQGR OHUHJROHGHOODGLVFHQGHQ]DNXQDPDFKHqPDWULOLQHDUH /¶RUJDQL]]D]LRQH GHOOD JLRUQDWD VHJXH O¶DVVH QHYUDOJLFR GHOO¶DOWHUQDQ]D WUDLOULSRVRULSDUDWRGDOVROHVHOODODDOO¶RPEUDHO¶DEEHYHUDWDRULWDODO~JD X\iD RUWD X\iD q LO WXUQR JLRUQDOLHUR GHL FDSL SHU OD DEEHYHUDWD SURSULD PHQWHiMMDUDqLOWXUQRSHUTXHOOLFKHDVSHWWDQRPHQWUHJOLDOWULYHQJRQRSRUWD WLSHUSULPLDGDEEHYHUDUH,OOXRJRGRYHVLIHUPDLOEHVWLDPHQHOOHRUHFDOGH SRPHULGLDQH VL FKLDPD IiUGD FKH LQGLFD JHQHULFDPHQWH XQR VSLD]]R DQFKH QHOO¶DELWDWR SHU FXL O¶DOWHUQDQ]D WUD ULSRVR LQ VSD]LR DSHUWR H LQ UHFLQWR SXz GLUVL IiUGDDOD yUDDOD âLUiDWD q XQD SLFFROD YDOOH UDGXUD GRYH FUHVFH EHQH O¶HUED VppQD H TXLQGL EXRQD SHU OH EHVWLH %LãDOD LQGLNH q LO SDVFRODUH OH VWRSSLH GL XQ FROWLYDWR HXPXPXxDNH LO FRQFLPDUOR FRQ LO EHVWLDPH 2YYLD PHQWHLSDVWRULKDQQRXQDSURSULDILWRQRPLDLQUDSSRUWRDOEHVWLDPHDGHVHP SLRGDVDNXQWXNXQWDHDOPiWDVRQRHUEHFRPPHVWLELOLFRQO¶΅UyWDEDVWRQHD JDQFLRVLVFXRWRQRHIDQQRFDGHUHOHIRJOLROLQHGLãLJtODPHQWUHDOWUHVRQRGD HYLWDUHFRPHWDPIiD(WUDDJRVWRHVHWWHPEUHVLFRQGXFRQROHEHVWLHYHUVRLO ILXPH*DVK*iãVXEiLQSRVWLGRYHF¶qEL\DDUDDFTXDELDQFDFKHFRQWLHQH VDOLPLQHUDOLFKHGHSXUDQR *OL DOOHYDWL KDQQR ELVRJQR GL ULSDUL H FKLXVL GL QRUPD GLIIHUHQ]LDWL SHU VSHFLHPDDQFKHSHUIDVHQHOFLFORGHOODYLWDHLQUDSSRUWRDOODULSURGX]LRQH ,OUHFLQWRSHUERYLQLqyUDyODLOSLFFRORUHFLQWRGLRYLQLHFDSULQLVpVHGDD PDGDDPDqDQFKHODFDSDQQDGRUPLWRULRSHUODUDJD]]DGDPDULWRVRRODRLO JLRYDQHFKHKDUDJJLXQWRO¶HWjSHUVSRVDUVLQI~UDâLUiDWDqODPDQJLDWRLD LQWHVDFRPHORVSD]LRGHOLPLWDWRLQFXLOHEHVWLHPDQJLDQRPDVWDDQFKHSHU XQDYDOOHWWDUDGXUDGRYHFUHVFHEHQHO¶HUEDVppQDHTXLQGLEXRQDSHUOHEH VWLHNiDEDYDOHFRPHUHFLQWR 1RWHVXOOHVVLFRSDVWRUDOHNXQDPD 7UD JOL VWUXPHQWL FKH LO SDVWRUH XVD ROWUH DOJXMi ãLQNiq LO VDFFKHWWLQR FKHVLPHWWHDOPXVRGLFDSUHWWLHGLDJQHOOLSHUFKpQRQDOODWWLQR0QNiOiiVD qLO PRUGDFFKLRXQEHFFKHWWLQRSRVWRLQERFFDSHUOHFDSUHSHUFKpPDQJLQR O¶HUEDHQRQLOODWWH*DPPDWWiqSHUFDSUHWWLHDJQHOOLORVWUDFFLRFRVSDUVRGL VWHUFRGHOODPDGUHDWWRUFLJOLDWRDOODPDPPHOODSHUVYH]]DUH$UJDMMDqODFRU GDFKHOHJDOHJDPEHGHOODPXFFDQHOODPXQJLWXUDãDNDODqODFDYH]]D 2YYLDPHQWHLPSRUWDQWLVRQRLULFKLDPLHFRPDQGL7UDTXHVWLVHJQDORSHU EUHYLWjOHJODJSHULQWLPRULUHXQWRURHVH~VSHULQWLPRULUHXQDD\ODDWuHV SHU XQDãLQQD DVVu DZj DOOq XVDWR SHU JLUDUH LO EXH QHOO¶DUDWXUD /¶LGLRIRQR KjXVVHVNH³IHUPR´DNpVNHGLVVHqXVDWRSHUIHUPDUHLEXRLTXDQGRDUDQ GRDUULYDQRLQIRQGRDOFDPSRHVLYROJRQRDOO¶LQGLHWUR6HNSHUFDFFLDUHYLD XQDQLPDOHRIDUORWRUQDUH,UUzVLXVDSHUIDUWRUQDUHODSHFRUDLQGLHWURRSHU IDUOHFDPELDUHGLUH]LRQH$QFRUDLGLRIRQLSHULYHUVLGLDQLPDOLVRQREHUHVNH EHODWRGHOOHSHFRUHPHVNHGHOOHFDSUHEXVNHEDVNHLOPXJJLWRGHLERYLQL 5VHJQDODFXUKXUFRPHULFKLDPLSHUJDOOLQHHSHUFDSUH 'HQRPLQD]LRQLGHOEHVWLDULRVDFULILFDOHHFHULPRQLDOH ,O YDORUHVRFLDOHGHOEHVWLDPHQHOOHRFFDVLRQLGHOFLFORGHOODYLWDXPDQD FRVWUXLVFHGHQRPLQD]LRQLVSHFLDOLSHUJOLDQLPDOLDOOHYDWL &RPHQRWDYDLO3ROOHUDQHO ³/¶XQLFDSDVVLRQHqLOEHVWLDPHPDTXHVWRqVRJJHWWRDQ]LWXWWRDSHUGLWHGHULYDQWLGD HSL]RR]LHIUHTXHQWLHGDOOHVWUDJLGHJOLDQLPDOLIHURFLHLQROWUHFKLQHSRVVLHGHLQQX PHURVXIILFLHQWHKDDQFKHGHJOLRQHULGHULYDQWLGDOODWUDGL]LRQHDLTXDOLGLIILFLOPHQWH SRWUHEEHVRWWUDUVLFRPHDYYLHQH DSSXQWRLQRFFDVLRQHGLIHVWHSXEEOLFKHHGLIDPL JOLD SHU SRPSH IXQHEUL L SDUHQWL H SHU PDWULPRQL QHL TXDOL HJOL ILQLVFH FRO GRYHU VHPSUHFRQFRUUHUHRUHJDODUHTXDOFKHEXH'DOEHVWLDPHSRLQRQVLULFDYDDOFXQIUXWWR FKHYDGDDGDXPHQWRGHOFDSLWDOHSHUFKpQRQVHQHULWUDJJRQRWXWWLLSURGRWWLFKHO¶LQ GXVWULDHGLOFRPPHUFLRGHOODJHQWHFLYLOHVDQQRWUDUUH´3ROOHUDS ,OEHVWLDPHKDDYXWRHFRQWLQXDDGDYHUHWUDLNXQDPDSXUSULQFLSDOPHQWH FROWLYDWRULXQDOWRYDORUHVRFLDOHLQTXDQWRVHUYHSHUFRVWLWXLUHLGLJLQDPDDOD LEHQLPDWULPRQLDOLFLRqO¶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zLPSRUWDQWHDQQRWDUHDQFKHOHGHQRPLQD]LRQLDWWULEXLWHDO O¶DQLPDOHVFHOWRDVHFRQGDGHOODLPSRUWDQ]DHGHOODVSHFLILFLWjGHOO¶RFFDVLRQH H DQFKH GHOOD TXDOLWj VRFLDOH GHL FRQYHQXWL WUDJOL RYLFDSULQL R WUD L ERYLQL FKH FRPSDUH QHL VDFULILFL H LQ SDUWLFRODUL FHULPRQLH DQFKH VH QRQ WXWWH RJJL XJXDOPHQWHDWWLYHRFRQGLYLVHPDDQFKHLQTXHVWRFDVRDQFRUDLPSUHVVHQHOOD PHPRULDFROOHWWLYD8VRFRPXQTXHLOSUHVHQWHHWQRJUDILFRQHOULSRUWDUHLOVL JQLILFDWRHODPRWLYD]LRQHGHOOHPPD /HGHQRPLQD]LRQLTXLULSRUWDWHVRQRFRQIHUPDWHLQSDUWHLQ5HLQLVFKLQ )HUPRLQXQPDQRVFULWWRVYHGHVHFRQWHQHQWHWHVWLNXQDPDFKHKRULWURYDWR D%DUHQWQHO'RUHHLQ&LWWDGLQLPDRJQXQRGHLOHPPLHGH VSUHVVLRQLqVWDWRDQFKHULOHYDWRGD PHLQTXHVWLDQQLGLULFHUFDVXYDULWHPL GDODRJJL DUDPDDWDODYDFFDSHULOEDQFKHWWRIXQHEUHQHOODULFRPPHPRUD]LRQHGD FXLSUHQGHLOQRPH EXXWDD\OjEXHFKHVLDPPD]]DQHOJLRUQRGHOPDWULPRQLR DEXXWDDQLVLQiD³SULPDGHOJLRYDQHWRUR´VDFULILFLRGLXQDFDSUDELDQ FDQHOODFHULPRQLDPDWULPRQLDOHNiODLQ)QRPHFKHL7LNDHL%DUFDGDQQR DOFDSURQHGDVDFULILFDUHTXDQGRQHOJLRUQRGHOPDWULPRQLRXQDUDJD]]DULILX WDLONLZLãDJLXUDPHQWRGHFLVRULRGLYHUJLQLWj NXVVH\WDD\ODLOERYLQRFKHLOPDULWRSXEEOLFDPHQWHRIIUHLQYHFHSHUOD GLFKLDUD]LRQHSRVLWLYDGLYHUJLQLWjGHOODVSRVD ODããjNRNRELLEjFDSUDURVVDFKHLOPDULWRUHJDODDLSDUHQWLGHOODPRJOLH VWD OHJDWD SHU GXH QRWWL D XQ SDOR QHOOD FDSDQQD GHOOD VSRVD QRYHOOD H YLHQH DPPD]]DWDFRQXQFROSRDOFXRUHXUIjNLIjNHNHHQRQDOODJRODFRPHDOVROL WR ODããj~PPDFDSUDQHUDFKHYLHQHLPPRODWDSHUSURSL]LD]LRQHQHOOHSXE EOLFKHFDODPLWj)VYODVFLD PDãNiEDUDSHQDOLWjLQIOLWWDDOJLRYDQHUHVSRQVDELOHFRQVLVWHQWHQHOODPD FHOOD]LRQHGLXQEXHRFRPSHQVRHTXLYDOHQWHSHUYHUJLQLWjYLRODWDHJUDYLGDQ ]DGLGRQQDQRQVSRVDWD PLãLODOD ODããj OHWW XQD FDSUD FKH VLD VWDWD ODVFLDWD OLEHUD GLSDVFRODUH HTXLYDOHLQNPDVDOPDWDVpVDOHWWFDSUDGHOFRPPLDWR6DODPDWDqVLDLO IHUHWUR FLRq OD OHWWLJD GL UDPL LQWUHFFLDWL VLD O¶LQWHUR EDQFKHWWR IXQHEUH H OD VSHFLILFDFHULPRQLDIXQHEUH ãLQRRWiDqLOEHVWLDPHFKHVLRIIUHFRPHWUDVIHULPHQWRGLEHQLGDOORVSR VRSHUWUDVIRUPDUHO¶XQLRQHFRQLXJDOHVHFRQGDULDGLJ΅GtQJyyGDLQGLJLQDLO PDWULPRQLRFKHFRLQYROJHHREEOLJDLNHEpVHGLHQWUDPELLQXEHQGL 1RWHVXOOHVVLFRSDVWRUDOHNXQDPD D\ODNRxDPHqLOFDSRGLEHVWLDPHGHOORVSRVRDSDUHQWLGHOODVSRVDWUDL .XQDPDPDUGD ãQJLGDqODFDSUDFKHVLVDFULILFDSHUXQJLXUDPHQWRGHFLVRULR,QTXHVWR WLSRGLJLXUDPHQWRO¶DFFXVDWRGHYHYROWDUVLD2ULHQWHHJXDUGDUHO¶DFFXVDWRUH FKH DO WHUPLQH GHOO¶DEOX]LRQH SURQXQFLD OD IRUPXOD ³*DOOj VDOOq JRGD $XD DIDWDEuEDVFLQJKLGHDPDVRQDPj´6HSDVVHUDQQRTXDWWURDQQLVHQ]DFKH(YDWL DEELDIDWWRYHQLUHPDOHDOFXQRWXDYUDLXQDFDSUDURVVDFRVuWHVWRHWUDGLQ 3ROOHUD JDOOHVDOOHJRRGD$ZDDIiWDELLEiDãLJtGH\DPiVyyQDPDPD DIiWDqSURSULDPHQWHLOFDSUHWWRâQJLGDqWHUPLQHVSHFLILFRSHUFDSRGLEH VWLDPHFKHYLHQHLPPRODWRSHUHVSLD]LRQH)VYFRVFLQJKLFKHRIIUuO¶HVSLD ]LRQHGLXQFDSRSHUWUDVJUHVVLRQHJUDYHGHOODOHJJH /R VTXDUWDPHQWR DYYLHQH FRQ XQ FROWHOOR VSHFLDOHPDQWHLGD ) VY LO FROWHOOR DGXQFR FKH VL XVD VROR SHU WDJOLDUH LO FROOR DOOD EHVWLD GHO VDFULILFLR $WWUDYHUVROHD]LRQLGLWDJOLRGLTXHVWRVWUXPHQWRFRPHQHOOHDOWUHVRFLHWjVL HVHUFLWDYDLOVDSHUHWDVVRQRPLFRGHOO¶RSHUDWRUHVXOO¶DQDWRPLDDQLPDOH 7DEHOOD±&LFORGLYLWDGHLERYLQL,ãLPDL.HQQDQDWRD0ROOR7DJZGD DLãDDGLJLOD DLãDNLãjPHUND DLãDNLVjVppQDNLELQLPD DLãDNLãDãLQQDJDOODNLLQiDPD DLãDNLãDEXXWDJDOODNLLQiDPD D\ãDãLQQDJDOOHEUH D\ãDEXXWDJDOOHEUHNLLQiDPD OLLVDNLãD EXXWDNLãD OLLVD IDDWDGD NRNREEDOD NWD GDJRVD D\ODtQttQtxD EXXWDLGGtUD EXXWDxUD D\ODJRGGyRED D\ODNDODDOD SULPRJHQLWRGLYDFFD YLWHOORDSSHQDQDWR YLWHOORFKHPDQJLDEHQHO¶HUED HFKHVLDOODWWDLQGLSHQGHQWH YLWHOODGLXQDQQR YLWHOORGLXQDQQR YLWHOODGLGXHDQQL YLWHOORGLGXHDQQL JLRYHQFDGLDQQL YLWHOORGLDQQL JLRYHQFDGLDQQL YLWHOORGLDQQL JLRYHQFDSULPRSHULRGRJUDYLGDQ]D JLRYHQFDDLWHPSLGLJUDYLGDQ]DFRQRVFLXWD JLRYHQFDSXHUSHUD JLRYHQFDGLDQQLFRQILJOL EXHGLDQQL EXHRWRURGLDQQLFDVWUDWR YDFFDHWjDYDQ]DWD YDFFDFRQSRFRODWWH *LDQQL'RUH D\ODRMED D\ODEDDMD YDFFDODWWLIHUDRSULYDWDGHOYLWHOORSHUPXQ JHUHRYDFFDFKHVWDVPHWWHQGRGLODWWDUH YDFFDVWHULOH 2VXPDQHSUHFLVDSHUzFKHSULPDGLtQttQtxDF¶qOLLVDDGLJLODFRPHYDFFD FRQ LO SULPRJHQLWR SRL VL FKLDPHUj DEDUPDVDWWj WXVVH 6ROR GRSR GLYHQWD tQttQtxDFRQLOFKHVLLQWHQGHFKHGLYHQWDDQFKHFDSRVWLSLWHGLXQDOLQHDJH QHDORJLFD4XLQGLODTXDQWLWjGLILJOLGHWHUPLQDOHSRVL]LRQL3HULOYLWHOORFKH SDVFROD LQGLSHQGHQWH VL SXz GLUH VppQD PHODVVH 1RQ VRQR RUD LQ JUDGR GL VWDELOLUHVHOHSUHFLVD]LRQLFKH2VXPDQHKDIDWWRDOOHOLVWHVRQRGRYXWHDYD ULD]LRQLDUHDOLRDXQDVXDSLVRILVWLFDWDFRPSHWHQ]DRDGHQWUDPEH 7DEHOOD±2QRPDVWLFDGHLERYLQL3DVWRUH'DEL.HODL D\OD~PPDGDUJD EXXWD~PPD~PPDãLãLQQD D\ODDUD EXXWDDUD D\ODDGDPD EXXWDDGDPD D\ODOLVDELLEDãLãLQQD D\ODXGDDUD EXXWDXGDDUD D\ODELLED D\ODJiQJiPD EXXWDJiQJiPD D\OD~PPD EXXWD~PPD D\ODNXQGDDUD EXXWDNXQGDDUD D\ODGDUJDãDUDDUD EXXWDGDUJDDUDãDUD YDFFDGDOPDQWHOORSH]]DWRELDQFRHQHUR EXHVFUH]LDWRELDQFRHQHUR YDFFDGDOPDQWHOORFRPSOHWDPHQWHELDQFR EXHGDOPDQWHOORFRPSOHWDPHQWHELDQFR YDFFDYLYDFHRPEURVDLQGLSHQGHQWHPHQWH GDOFRORUHPDQWHOOR EXHYLYDFHDWWDFFDEULJKH YDFFDGDOPDQWHOORDPDFFKLHELDQFKHH URVVH YDFFDGDOPXVRELDQFRLQGLSHQGHQWHPHQWH GDOFRORUHGHOFRUSR PDVFKLRGDOPXVRELDQFRLQGLSHQGHQWH PHQWHGDOFRORUHGHOFRUSR YDFFDGDOPDQWHOORURVVLFFLR GDOPDQWHOORURVVRHVYHOWDDQFKHYLYDFH IRFRVDDOGLOjGHOFRORUH PDVFKLRLGHP GDOPDQWHOORFRPSOHWDPHQWHQHUR PDVFKLRLGHP PDQWHOORJULJLRFKLDURFRQIURQWHELDQFD PDVFKLRFRQODIURQWHELDQFD PDQWHOORURVVLFFLRFRQIDVFLDELDQFDILQR DLUHQL PDVFKLRLGHP 1RWHVXOOHVVLFRSDVWRUDOHNXQDPD D\ODDUDOpGGD D\ODXPPDãLãLQQD EXXWD~PPDãLãLQQD D\ODDQVQJDELLED EXXWDDQVQJDELLED EXXWDELãDJDGD D\ODV~XODNXWDJČUD D\ODJLLODDQGXUD EXXWDJLLODDQGXUD PDQWHOORPDUURQHFKLDURDQGDWXUDOHQWD IHPPLQDGDOPDQWHOORQHURDSLFFROHPDF FKLHELDQFKH PDVFKLRLGHP PDQWHOORELDQFRFRQWHVWDURVVLFFLD PDVFKLRLGHP FKHODYRUDFRQEXRQDYRORQWjFKHYDDO FDPSRSHUDUDUH FRUQDOXQJKHPDPPHOOHHPDQWHOOREUXQR FRUQDFRUWHULYROWHYHUVRLOEDVVR PDVFKLRFRQFRUQDFRUWHULYROWHYHUVRLO EDVVR 7DEHOOD±&LFORGHOODYLWDGHOOHFDSUH DIiWDNLãDDGLJLOD VpVDGDJRVD DIiWDNLãDPpUND DIiWDNLãDVppQDNLELQLPD DIiWDNLãDPLãLLUDNRUD DIiWDNLãDãLQQiJDOODNLLQiDPD DIiWDNLãDEXXWDVDDUDJDOOD NLLQiDPD DIiWDãLQQiJDOOHEUHNLLQiDPD VDDUDJDOOHEUHNLLQiDPD DGLPLLWD VpVDNRNREEDOD VDDUDNXUN~XUD VpVDGDJRVD VDDUDLGGtUD VpVDtQttQtxD VDDUDxUD VpVDEDDMD SULPRJHQLWRGLFDSUD ILJOLRGLFDSUDFKHKDDSSHQDSDUWRULWR FDSUHWWRDSSHQDQDWR FDSUHWWRFKHLQL]LDDSDVFRODUH FDSUHWWRFKHVLDOODWWDLQGLSHQGHQWH FDSUHWWDGLXQDQQR FDSUHWWRGLXQDQQR FDSUHWWDGLGXHDQQL FDSUHWWRGLGXHDQQL FDSUHWWDGLDQQLFKHQRQKDDQFRUDSDU WRULWR FDSUDDSSHQDFRQRVFLXWDFRPHJUDYLGD FDSUHWWRGDDQQL FDSUDGDDQQLLQVXFKHKDDSSHQDSDUWR ULWR FDSURGDDQQLLQVX FDSUDFKHKDIDWWRILJOL FDSURFDVWUDWR FDSUDVWHULOH *LDQQL'RUH 2VXPDQH SUHFLVD FKH PHODGD R PHQWRGD YD SULPD GL DIiWD NLãD VppQD NLELQLPDLQGLFDQGRXQRVWDGLRLQL]LDOHGHOEUXFDUH$JJLXQJHFKHXQPDVFKLR QRQ q SL DIDWD NLãj TXDQGR FRPLQFLD D GLVWLQJXHUVL GDOOD IHPPLQD $OORUD FRQDQQLqDJXQNRIDWDDPDFLRqXQVDDUDFKHSURYDDPRQWDUHQRQUHJJH DQFRUDHFDGHVWDDSSHQDLQL]LDQGRDHQWUDUHLQFDORUHSXzVRVWLWXLUHEUHNLL QiDPDHGRSRGLYHQWDVDDUDNXUN~UD /D OLVWD GL GHQRPLQD]LRQL GHOOD SHFRUD ULFDOFD TXHOOD GHL FDSULQL EDVWD VRVWLWXLUHJDUPD JDPPDGRYHRFFRUURQRDVpVDDIiWDHVDDUDSHULOTXDOH XOWLPRVLSXzDYHUHJDUPDEXXWDRVLQFRSDWRJDPEXXWD %,%/,2*5$),$ $EUDKD-³.XQDPD'LDOHFWVDQG0RUSKRORJ\´LQ-RXUQDORI(ULWUHDQ6WXGLHVSS %HQGHU0/.XQDPD0XQLFK/LQFRP ²³(QJOLVK.XQDPD/H[LFRQ´LQ$IULNDQLVWLVFKH$UEHLWVSDSLHUHSS &LWWDGLQL07KH.XQDPDDQGWKHLU0DUULDJH&HULPRQLHV$GGLV$EDED+DLOq6HOODVVLq 8QLYHUVLW\)DFXOW\RI$UWV ²,QIHULDHSLDQWHIXQHEUL&XQDPD$GGLV$EHED4XDGHUQLGHOO¶,VWLWXWR,WDOLDQRGL&XO WXUD &RQWL5RVVLQL&³3HUODFRQRVFHQ]DGHOODOLQJXDFXQDPD´LQ*LRUQDOHGHOOD6RFLHWjD VLDWLFDLWDOLDQDSS 'LQXFFL $ HW DO 8QGHUVWDQGLQJ WKH LQGLJHQRXV NQRZOHGJH DQG LQIRUPDWLRQ V\VWHPV RI SDVWRUDOLVWVLQ(ULWUHD5RPD)RRGDQG$JULFXOWXUH2UJDQL]DWLRQRIWKH86(&RPPX QLFDWLRQIRU'HYHORSPHQWFDVHVWXG\ 'RUH*³7DVVRQRPLDSDVWRUDOHGHL6DKR$VDRUWD0DWHULDOLFRORQLDOL´LQ$0HQGLFLQR 13DQWHUD00DGGDORQDF(WQROLQJXLVWLFDH]RRQLPLD/HGHQRPLQD]LRQLSRSRODUL GHJOLDQLPDOL5HQGH8QLYHUVLWjGHOOD&DODEULD&HQWUR(GLWRULDOHHOLEUDULRSS ²³µ&KLQRQKDXQDSDUHQWH$QGLQQD"¶'RQQHHSRVVHVVLRQHFRPHDUFKLYLRVWRULFRHH VSHULHQ]DGHOO¶DOWHULWjWUDL.XQDPDG¶(ULWUHD´LQ(WKQRUHPDSS (QJOXQG3(WWOLWHWSURISn.XQDPDVSUnNHW6WRFNROP()6 )HUPR*LXVHSSHGD&DVWHOQXRYR9RFDERODULRGHOODOLQJXD&XQDPD5RPD&XULD*HQH UDOL]LD))&DSSXFFLQL 0DUFKL(6WXGLVXOODSDVWRUL]LDGHOOD&RORQLD(ULWUHD)LUHQ]H,VWLWXWR$JULFRORFRORQLD OH 1DWL$³/LQJXLVWLFGLYHUVLW\LQ(ULWUHD´LQ$IULFD5RPDSS 1LNRGHPRV,GULV7KH.XQDPDDQGWKHLU/DQJXDJH0$7KHVLV$GGLV$EDED8QLYHUVLW\ 3LUDQL $ ³7HUDSLD LQGLJHQD HULWUHD´ LQ5DVVHJQD HFRQRPLFD GHOOH &RORQLH QR YHPEUHGLFHPEUHSS ²$OFXQHSLDQWHYHOHQRVHSHUJOLDQLPDOLLQ(ULWUHD$VPDUD8IILFLRHULWUHRGHOO¶(FRQR PLD 5HLQLVFK/'LH.XQDPD6SUDFKHLQ1RUGRVW$IULNDYROO:LHQ&*HUROG¶V6RKQ :ROGHWHQVDH7HZROGH³3HUVSHFWLYHRQSDVWRUDOLVPLQ(ULWUHD´LQ-RXUQDORI(ULWUHDQ6WX GLHVSS 52'2/)2)$7729,&+ /DFDGXWDGL0HQJKLVWXXQULFRUGRSHUVRQDOH 1HOOD SULPDYHUD GHO KR DYXWR OD SRVVLELOLWj GL WURYDUPL DG $GGLV $EDEDFRPHGRFHQWHGL$UFKHRORJLDSUHVVRLO'LSDUWLPHQWRGL6WRULDGHOO¶8 QLYHUVLWj GL $GGLV $EDED QHOO¶DPELWR GHO 3URJUDPPDGL &RRSHUD]LRQH 8QL YHUVLWDULD,WDOR(WLRSLFD&LzPLKDSHUPHVVRGLHVVHUHVSHWWDWRUHGLUHWWRGLX QRGHJOLHYHQWLSLGUDPPDWLFLGHOODVWRULDUHFHQWHGHOO¶(WLRSLDODFDGXWDGHO UHJLPHVRFLDOLVWDGL0HQJKLVWX+DLOH0DULDPHODSUHVDGLSRWHUHGDSDUWHGHO )URQWHGL/LEHUD]LRQH7LJULQRWUDPDU]RHJLXJQRGLTXHOO¶DQQRLQGLPHQWLFD ELOH6RQRDUULYDWRLQIDWWLDG$GGLV$EDEDLOIHEEUDLRDOODYLJLOLDGHOODILQH GHOOD³*XHUUDGHO*ROIR´HVRQRULHQWUDWRLQ,WDOLDLO JLXJQRLQVHJXLWRDO O¶RUGLQH GL HYDFXD]LRQH GL WXWWR LO SHUVRQDOH QRQ VWUHWWDPHQWH QHFHVVDULR LP SDUWLWRGDOO¶$PEDVFLDWD,WDOLDQDGRSRO¶HVSORVLRQHGHOGHSRVLWRPLOLWDUHVXOOD VWUDGDSHU'HEUH=HLW &RPH q PLD FRQVXHWXGLQH RUPDL GD PROWL DQQL DQFKHLQ TXHL JLRUQL KR WHQXWRXQVXFFLQWRGLDULRSHUVRQDOHQHOTXDOHUHJLVWUDYRWXWWHOHPLHRVVHUYD ]LRQLHLPSUHVVLRQLVXJOLHYHQWLFKHVWDYDQRDFFDGHQGRDWWRUQRDPH2YYLD PHQWHTXHOOHSDJLQHQRQDYHYDQRHQRQKDQQRDOFXQYDORUHFRPHGRFXPHQWR VWRULFRLQTXDQWRQpLRQpJOLDOWULGRFHQWLHVSDWULDWLGHOSURJUDPPDGLFRRSH UD]LRQHXQLYHUVLWDULDSRWHYDPRDYHUHLQIRUPD]LRQLGLUHWWHVXFRVDVWHVVHHIIHW WLYDPHQWH VXFFHGHQGR DO GL IXRUL GL TXHOOH IRUQLWHRJQL JLRYHGu SRPHULJJLR GDOO¶$PEDVFLDWD FKH D VXD YROWD VSHVVR ULIHULYD LQIRUPD]LRQL RWWHQXWH GDJOL $PHULFDQLLQVSHVVRUXPRURVHDVVHPEOHHSUHVVRO¶$XGLWRULXPGHOO¶,VWLWXWR, WDOLDQRGL&XOWXUDRQHOODSDOHVWUDGHO&LUFROR,WDOLDQR³-XYHQWXV´0LWHQHYR FRPXQTXHGLUHWWDPHQWHLQFRQWDWWRFRQ<DTRE%H\HQHFKHLQWHJUDYDOH PLH LQIRUPD]LRQL FRQ TXHOOH RWWHQXWH GD DPLFL SUHVVR OD 6DQWD 6HGH 1RQRVWDQWH TXHVWLOLPLWLILQGDO PLR ULHQWURLQ ,WDOLDLOFRPSLDQWR3URI /DQIUDQFR5LFFL PLDYHYDSLYROWHFDOGDPHQWHFKLHVWRGLSXEEOLFDUHLOPLRGLDULRSURSULRSHU TXHOORFKHHUDHGqXQDGHVFUL]LRQHGHOO¶DWPRVIHUDLQFXLVLDPRYLVVXWLQRLH VSDWULDWLHLQRVWULDPLFLHFROOHJKLHWLRSLFLGXUDQWHTXHLJLRUQLGLFRVuLQWHQVD 5RGROIR)DWWRYLFK HPR]LRQHHWHQVLRQH&RQSURIRQGRUDPPDULFRSHUQRQDYHUDFFRQWHQWDWRLQ WHPSRLO3URI5LFFLFXLGRYHYRPROWRPLVRQRILQDOPHQWHGHFLVRDGDUHDOOH VWDPSHTXHVWLPLHLULFRUGLHVRQROLHWRGLGHGLFDUOLD<DTRE%H\HQHFXLPLOH JDGDWUHQWDFLQTXHDQQLXQDSURIRQGDDPLFL]LDRQRUDQGRFRVuDQFKHXQDSUR PHVVDIDWWDHQRQPDQWHQXWDDO3URI5LFFLQRVWURPDHVWURHPHQWRUH 'DWLLOLPLWLHGLWRULDOLLPSRVWLQRQPLqSRVVLELOHULSRUWDUHWXWWHOHSDJLQH GHOPLRGLDULR+RVFHOWROHSDUWLFKHPLVHPEUDQRSLVLJQLILFDWLYHHSRVVRQR PHJOLRGDUHXQ¶LGHDGHOO¶HVSHULHQ]DFKHKRDYXWRLOSULYLOHJLRLQTXDQWRVWX GLRVRGLFRVHHWLRSLFKHGLYLYHUH0LVFXVRVHLOWHVWRVDUjVSHVVRVXFFLQWRH WHOHJUDILFRPDKRSUHIHULWRPDQWHQHUHLQDOWHUDWHOHPLHQRWHSLXWWRVWRFKHDE EHOOLUOHFRQLQWHJUD]LRQLDSRVWHULRUL+RQDWXUDOPHQWHULSRUWDWRVROROHQRWD ]LRQL GL TXDOFKH LQWHUHVVH /D PLD HVSHULHQ]D SULYDWD UHVWD XQ IDWWR GHO WXWWR SHUVRQDOH IHEEUDLR 6LWXD]LRQHPROWRGLIILFLOHQHOSDHVH,JXHUULJOLHULVRQRDNPVXO1LOR $]]XUUR %DKU 'DU q VWDWD FDWWXUDWD 6FDUVHJJLD WXWWR VRSUDWWXWWR OD EHQ]LQD /DFLWWjFRPXQTXHqWUDQTXLOODHQRQYLqQHUYRVLVPRWUDJOLRFFLGHQWDOLDQ FKHVHQRQPDQFDXQDFHUWDSUHRFFXSD]LRQH6SHULDPRWXWWRYDGDEHQH PDU]R /DEHQ]LQDqXQSUREOHPDYHUDPHQWHJUDYH3HULOUHVWRLOQXPHURGLVWRU SLHPHQGLFDQWLFKHVLYHGHLQFLWWjqVHPSUHQRWHYROH«7LPRUHQRQGHOWXW WRLQIRQGDWRFKHODVLWXD]LRQHSUHFLSLWLUDSLGDPHQWHH$GGLV$EDEDUHVWLLVROD WD PDU]R /DVLWXD]LRQHJHQHUDOHVHPEUDPROWR PHQRSHULFRORVD$OOHYRFLGLXQD SRVVLELOH DYDQ]DWD GHL JXHUULJOLHUL VL FRQWUDSSRQJRQR YRFL FKH VLD WXWWR XQ EOXIIHFKHLQUHDOWjLOSRQWHVXO1LORVLDDSHUWRHFKHLOIURQWHQRQFRQWUROOLDI IDWWRLO%HJHPHGHU PDU]R 'LVWULEXLWHLVWUX]LRQLSHUHYHQWXDOHHYDFXD]LRQH6HPEUDFKHLSUREOHPL VLDQRVHUL«/DVLWXD]LRQHORJLVWLFDLQFLWWjqGLIILFLOHPDQRQLPSRVVLELOHH ODYLWDVFRUUHWUDQTXLOOD7XWWDYLDqJLjLQDWWRXQSLDQRGLSUHDOODUPHGDSDUWH GHOO¶$PEDVFLDWD « /D VLWXD]LRQH VHPEUD YHUDPHQWH FULWLFD Ê LQ DWWRXQ¶D ]LRQHDWHQDJOLDFRQL7LJULQLGD1RUGHJOL2URPRGDVXG7XWWRSXzSUHFLSL WDUHQHLSURVVLPLJLRUQLVHQRQQHOOHSURVVLPHRUH /DFDGXWDGL0HQJKLVWXXQULFRUGRSHUVRQDOH PDU]R 8QLYHUVLWjFKLXVDSHUGLVFRUVRGL0HQJKLVWXDJOLVWXGHQWLHVWDII7HQVLR QHQHOODFRPXQLWj8QLYHUVLWjSUHVLGLDWDGDOO¶HVHUFLWR&LWWjWUDQTXLOOD3URED ELOHFROSRGLVWDWR$OFXQLPLQLVWULVLVRQRGLPHVVLSHUSDVVDUHFRLULEHOOL7L PRUH GL LQVXUUH]LRQH SRSRODUH LQ $$ >$GGLV $EDED@ 6HPEUD FKH O¶HVHUFLWR RSSRQJDQXRYDPHQWHTXDOFKHUHVLVWHQ]DDQRUG)RUVH$NVXPULRFFXSDWDGDL JRYHUQDWLYL PDU]R *RQGDUqFDGXWD&LVLDSHWWDLOSHJJLR6WXGHQWLLQDFFRUGRFRQ0HQJKL VWX GRSR LO GLVFRUVR GL LHUL 6HPEUD FKH JOL 2URPRVL VLDQR DYYLFLQDWL QRWH YROPHQWHDG$GGLV$EDEDPDQRQYLqPRWLYRGLSDUWLFRODUHSUHRFFXSD]LRQH $WPRVIHUDVRVWDQ]LDOPHQWHULODVVDWD PDU]R 6LSDUODVHULDPHQWHGLXQSRVVLELOHFROSRGLVWDWRFKHSRWUHEEHDYYHQLUH QHOOHSURVVLPHVHWWLPDQHHFDXVDUHXQDQRWHYROHFRQIXVLRQHFRQXQFHUWRPDU JLQHGLULVFKLR,O&RQJUHVVR>GL6WXGL(WLRSLFL@QRQqDIIDWWRVLFXUR PDU]R *OLVWXGHQWLQRQVRQRDQFRUDVRGGLVIDWWLGHOGLVFRUVRGL0HQJKLVWXGLYH QHUGu > PDU]R@ $WWHQGRQR XQ¶XOWHULRUH ULVSRVWD DOOD ORUR SDUWHFLSD]LRQH R PHQRDOODJXHUUD6DUHEEHURGLYLVLWUDIDYRUHYROLHFRQWUDUL0LKDFROSLWROD ORUR UHWLFHQ]D D SDUODUH GHOO¶DUJRPHQWR « 9LVWR O¶$PEDVFLDWRUH >FKH@ KD FRQIHUPDWRODSRVVLELOLWjGLXQFROSRGLVWDWRPLOLWDUHLQ(WLRSLDLQWHPSLEUH YL2UPDLLOIURQWHWLJULQRFXLDGHULUHEEHURDQFKH$PKDUDDYDQ]DSURJUHVVL YDPHQWH,OSRQWHVXO1LORqWHUUDGLQHVVXQR«7XWWLVLDVSHWWDQRFKHDFFDGD TXDOFRVDLQWHPSLPROWREUHYL PDU]R (VHUFLWRHWLRSLFRUHVSLQWRGDL7LJULQLLQRIIHQVLYDYHUVR*RMMDPH%HJH PHGHU PDU]R 6LWXD]LRQH VWD SHJJLRUDQGR )URQWH HULWUHR DYDQ]D YHUVR $VVDE $PED VFLDWD IUDQFHVH WUDQTXLOOD $PEDVFLDWD ,WDOLDQD LQFRVWDQWH SUHDOODUPH 6HP EUDYLVLDWHQVLRQHPDFLWWjDSSDUHQWHPHQWHWUDQTXLOOD PDU]R 6WXGHQWLFKLDPDWLDOOHDUPL 5RGROIR)DWWRYLFK PDU]R 6LWXD]LRQH PROWR WHVD 6HFRQGR JOL $PHULFDQL $GGLV q D FLQTXH JLRUQL GDOFROODVVRÊGLIILFLOHODYRUDUHLQTXHVWHFRQGL]LRQL&LUFDGHJOLVWXGHQ WLVRQRVWDWLDUUXRODWL9HGUHPR PDU]R 8QLYHUVLWjYXRWDSHUHVDPLGLVWDWRHUHFOXWDPHQWRVWXGHQWL1HUYRVLVPR WUDLGRFHQWL9LVWLSROL]LRWWLDUPDWLQHOFDPSXV3UHVHQ]DSROL]LDDUPDWDQRQ QXPHURVLVVLPDSHUOHVWUDGH)LOHSHUODGLVWULEX]LRQHGHOODIDULQD"3HULO UHVWRFLWWjUHODWLYDPHQWHWUDQTXLOOD3UREOHPLVHULSHURWWHQHUHSHUPHVVLSHUOD EHQ]LQD 6HPEUDFKHJOL$PHULFDQLYRJOLDQRWUDVIHULUH0HQJKLVWXD+DUDUHIDYR ULUHXQFROSRGLVWDWRVRVWLWXHQGRORFRQXQJHQHUDOHEHQDFFHWWRDLIURQWL$ PHULFDQLH ,VUDHOLDQLKDQQRJLjDYYLDWRO¶HYDFXD]LRQHGHLFLYLOL$OWULDQFRUD UHODWLYDPHQWHWUDQTXLOOL&LzSXzLQGLFDUHFKHODVLWXD]LRQHqSURVVLPDDOFRO ODVVR)RUVHVLWUDWWDGLSRFKLVVLPLJLRUQL1HUYRVLVPRGLIIXVRWUDJOL2FFLGHQ WDOL PDU]R )URQWHVLDYYLFLQDUDSLGDPHQWHDG$$0ROWHYRFLPDSRFKLGDWLUHDOL PDU]R >6HFRQGRLFROOHJKLHWLRSLFL@VLWXD]LRQHPROWRVHULD'HEUH6LQDLQPDQR D7/)FKHFRQWUROODSULQFLSDOLDFFHVVLDOODFLWWj(ULWUHLPHQRIRUWLGL7/)FKH VWDRWWHQHQGRXQJURVVRSHVRSROLWLFR1HVVXQDVROX]LRQHSUHYHGLELOHSHU(UL WUHDLQTXDQWR7LJULQLYRJOLRQRPDQWHQHUHDFFHVVRDOPDUHLQFOXGHQGR$VVDE LQ 7LJUDL 1RQ VL FUHGH FKH YL VDUDQQR PROWL VFRQWUL LQ FLWWj FRPXQTXH WXWWL VDQQRFKHLOUHJLPHqILQLWRHDVSHWWDQRFRVDDFFDGUj 8QLYHUVLWjWUDQTXLOODSHUVRVSHQVLRQHOH]LRQL3ROL]LDSUHVHQWHPDLQQX PHURDSSDUHQWHPHQWHQRUPDOH«7XWWLDOO¶8QLYHUVLWjKDQQRHVSUHVVLRQHPRO WRWHVDHSUHRFFXSDWD0ROWRQHUYRVLVPRWUDODJHQWH&RQJUHVVRLQIRUVH PDU]R 6LWXD]LRQHWHVDHFRQIXVD 9RFL FKH VDEDWR YHUUj SURFODPDWR OR VWDWR GL HPHUJHQ]D H YHUUDQQR IDWWHSHUTXLVL]LRQLQHOOHFDVH PDU]R 6HFRQGR 5DGLR (WLRSLFD O¶HVHUFLWR DYUHEEH VFRQILWWR L 7LJULQL VXOOD YLD $$ ± 'HVVLH >6HFRQGR $PEDVFLDWD ,WDOLDQD@ VLWXD]LRQH DO PRPHQWR VRWWR /DFDGXWDGL0HQJKLVWXXQULFRUGRSHUVRQDOH FRQWUROOR$OODUPLVPRHFFHVVLYR*UDQSDUWHGHOSDHVHLQPDQRDL)URQWL$$ QRQLQLPPHGLDWRSHULFROR PDU]R $WPRVIHUD FDOPD H WUDQTXLOOD 6LDPR FRQVFL FKH XQ¶HYDFXD]LRQH q VROR WHRULFDPHQWH SRVVLELOH PD LQ SUDWLFD LUUHDOL]]DELOH SHU OD JUDQGH FRQIXVLRQH FKHFUHHUHEEH>,OSLDQRGLHYDFXD]LRQHSUHYHGHXQXQLFRFRQYRJOLRGLPDF FKLQHSHUWUDVIHULUHWXWWLJOLVWUDQLHULGD$GGLV$EDEDYHUVRLO.HQ\DULGLFR OR@ PDU]R 2JJLQRQF¶HUDQRVWXGHQWLDOH]LRQH/DVLWXD]LRQHTXLqFULWLFD2JJLGH YRQR GHFLGHUH VH WHQHUH DSHUWD R QR O¶XQLYHUVLWj « ,O &RQJUHVVR SUREDELO PHQWHYHUUjULGRWWR PDU]R &KLDFFKLHUDWR FRQ O¶LGUDXOLFR H[FDUDELQLHUH >2URPR@ 0L GLFHYD FKH RUPDLODJHQWHQRQVRVWLHQHSLLOUHJLPHSHUFKpKDSRUWDWRVRORSRYHUWjFRQ IRUWLWDVVHSHUODJXHUUDPDKDSDXUDSHULOULVFKLRGLHVVHUHXFFLVD&RPXQTXH L7LJULQLQRQVRQRYLVWLFRPHOLEHUDWRULPDFRPHVKLIWjFKHYRJOLRQRXJXDO PHQWH GHUXEDUH OD SRSROD]LRQH 5LPSLDQWR SHU +DLOH6HODVVLH $OO¶XQLYHUVLWj >PL KDQQR GHWWR@ FKH O¶HVHUFLWR QRQ VRVWLHQH SL LO UHJLPH H OD VLWXD]LRQH q PROWRVLPLOHDTXHOODLPPHGLDWDPHQWHSUHFHGHQWHODULYROX]LRQH6LUHVSLUDD ULDGLXQSRVVLELOHFROSRGLVWDWRFKHDYUHEEHO¶DSSRJJLRGHL7LJULQL$QFKHOD PLOLWDUL]]D]LRQHGHJOLVWXGHQWLDQGUHEEHLQTXHVWRVHQVRVHQVLELOL]]DQGROLPL OLWDUPHQWHFRQWURLOUHJLPH PDU]R 4XHVWDPDWWLQDJOLVWXGHQWLVRQRSDUWLWLDOOHSHUO¶DGGHVWUDPHQWRPL OLWDUH6HPEUDWXWWDYLDFKHODPDJJLRUSDUWHQRQVLVLDSUHVHQWDWD1HO&ROOHJH RI6RFLDO6FLHQFHVVRORVXVDUHEEHURSDUWLWL8JXDOPHQWHLGRFHQWLFKH DYUHEEHUR GRYXWR SUHVHQ]LDUH DOOD ORUR SDUWHQ]D HGHYHQWXDOPHQWH DFFRPSD JQDUOLQRQVLVDUHEEHURSUHVHQWDWLÊHYLGHQWHLOEUDFFLRGLIHUURWUD8QLYHUVLWj H*RYHUQRLQFXLFRPXQTXHO¶8QLYHUVLWjDSSDUHSHUGHQWH9LVWLSDUFKHJJLDWL JOLDXWREXVSHULOVHFRQGRVFDJOLRQHFKHGRYUHEEHSDUWLUHGRPHQLFD>PDU ]R@$ULDSHVDQWHQHOFDPSXVDQFKHVHQRQSLWHVDGHOODVHWWLPDQDVFRUVD PDU]R &RUVL GHILQLWLYDPHQWH VRVSHVL 6ROR XQD SLFFROD SHUFHQWXDOH GL VWXGHQWL GHO&66>&ROOHJHRI6RFLDO6FLHQFHV@VXDUUXRODWLqSDUWLWD3HUTXHOOLFKH 5RGROIR)DWWRYLFK QRQVLVRQRDUUXRODWLGHVWLQRLJQRWR3HUTXDQWRFRQFHUQHO¶8QLYHUVLWjGHYRQR UHVWLWXLUHHYHQWXDOLOLEULLQSUHVWLWRHDWWHQGHUHULSUHVDXIILFLDOHGHOOHOH]LRQL PDU]R 6HPEUDFKH(3/)VWLDDYDQ]DQGRYHUVR$VVDE DSULOH 2URPRKDQQRVFRQILWWRQHO:ROOHJDTXDWWUREULJDWHHWLRSLFKH6LWXD]LRQH GLQXRYRPROWRWHVD DSULOH &ROOHJKLHWLRSLFLDSSDUHQWHPHQWHSLULODVVDWLDQFKHVHVLWXD]LRQHPROWR FULWLFDGDOSXQWRGLYLVWDGHJOL$PKDUD DSULOH &RQWURIIHQVLYDQHO:ROOHJDVHPEUD PROWRVDQJXLQRVD2IIHQVLYDHULWUHD YHUVR$VVDEHVFRQWULDFLUFDNPGDOODFLWWj(YDFXDWLJOL,WDOLDQLOuUHVLGHQ WL6HFRQGRO¶$PEDVFLDWD,VUDHOLDQDQRQF¶qDQFRUDSHULFRORDG$$&ROSRGL VWDWRSUHYLVWRHQWURLODSULOH&DOPDJHQHUDOHVHQ]DVHJQLGLQHUYRVLVPR DSULOH >6HFRQGRDPLFLGHOOH1D]LRQL8QLWH@$VPDUDFRPSOHWDPHQWHDFFHUFKLDWD &KHUHQUDJJLXQJLELOHYLDWHUUD&RQGL]LRQLDOLPHQWDULLQ(ULWUHDWHUULELOL NJGLWHISHU%LUU5LIXJLDWLVFDSSDQRGD6XGDQYHUVR(ULWUHDSHUFKpFRQ GL]LRQLLQ6XGDQSHJJLRUL6HPEUDSRVVLELOHFKHLIURQWLWHQWLQRXQDPDQRYUD GLDFFHUFKLDPHQWRGL$$ &LUFROD YRFH QRQ YHULILFDELOH FKH $VVDE VLD FDGXWD 1HO FRPSOHVVR DW PRVIHUDDEEDVWDQ]DWUDQTXLOOD1HVVXQRWUDQQHJOL2FFLGHQWDOLVHPEUDYHUD PHQWHSUHRFFXSDWRSHUODVLWXD]LRQH 'RPDQL VHFRQGR LO QRVWUR $PEDVFLDWRUH 0HQJKLVWX GRYUHEEH ODQFLDUH XQ DSSHOOR SHU OD SDFH 0D FRPH VL RVVHUYD GD SDUWH HWLRSLFD OD VLWXD]LRQH QRQqSLQHOOHVXHPDQL DSULOH /HWUHVWUDGHSULQFLSDOLFKHGD$$VLGLULJRQRYHUVRQRUGHGRYHVWVRQR FRQWUROODWHGDLIURQWL$YDQ]DWD(3/)ILQRDNPGD$VVDEÊLQWHUHVVDQWH FRPHODJHQWHSURJUHVVLYDPHQWHVLDELWXLDTXHVWDVLWXD]LRQHHWXWWLFHUFKLQR GLPLQLPL]]DUH,QUHDOWjVLWXD]LRQHPROWRHVSORVLYD DSULOH 1HNHPWHULRFFXSDWDGDLJRYHUQDWLYLPRUWL /DFDGXWDGL0HQJKLVWXXQULFRUGRSHUVRQDOH DSULOH -LPELFDGXWDLQPDQR2URPR1HNHPWHVHFRQGRODUDGLRDQFRUDLQPDQR 2URPR6HFRQGROD%%&VLDPRDOODVYROWDILQDOHÊSDUWLWRDQFKHLOSHUVRQDOH GHOODFDIIHWWHULDSHUJOLVWXGHQWLGHOO¶8QLYHUVLWj2/)DYDQ]DYHUVR-LPPDJLj HYDFXDWDGDJOL2FFLGHQWDOL(3/)DFLUFDNPGDOO¶DHURSRUWRGL$VVDE 1HOFRPSOHVVRVLWXD]LRQHFDOPD$WWHVDSHUFROSRGLVWDWRHQWUROHSURV VLPHVHWWLPDQH DSULOH -LPPDHYDFXDWDGDRFFLGHQWDOL,OXEDERULQPDQR2/)FKHDYDQ]DYHOR FHPHQWH YHUVR *DPEHOD .DIID VHWWHQWULRQDOH SXUH VRWWR FRQWUROOR 2/) « &LUFRODGRFXPHQWRDQWLJRYHUQDWLYRGLGRFHQWLXQLYHUVLWDULILUPDWRGD0HVILQ :ROGH0DULDP'RFXPHQWRGLVRVWHJQRGDSDUWHGHO&RQJUHVVRGL6WXGL(WLR SLFL ,Q$PEDVFLDWDGLQXRYRPROWRQHUYRVLVPR(YDFXD]LRQHSUHYLVWDVHFRQ TXLVWDWDXQDGLTXHVWHFLWWj-LPPD$PER%DKU'DU$VVDE$OODUPLVPRJLX VWLILFDWR PD HFFHVVLYR 6RSUDWWXWWR UHJQD JUDQGH SDXUD GL VLWXD]LRQH GL WLSR VRPDOR6LQGURPHGL0RJDGLVKR DSULOH 3DUWLWLDOWULDXWREXVFRQVWXGHQWLGHOO¶8QLYHUVLWj DSULOH 6HFRQGR $PEDVFLDWRUH IUDQFHVH VLWXD]LRQH WUDQTXLOOD H VRWWR FRQWUROOR /XQHGu>DSULOH@ULDSUHLO/LFHR)UDQFHVH DSULOH 6LDPRWXWWLLQDWWHVDGHOGLVFRUVRGL0HQJKLVWXDOOD1D]LRQHFKHGRYUHE EHLQL]LDUHWUDSRFR>RUH@9HGUHPRFRVDGLFH0ROWLVLDVSHWWDQRODILQH GHOUHJLPHRFRPXQTXHXQFDPELDPHQWR0ROWRQHUYRVLVPRVLDDOO¶8QLYHUVLWj VLD DO 0XVHR . SDUWLFRODUPHQWH SHVVLPLVWD H WHPH GLVRUGLQL QHL SURVVLPL JLRUQL+UDWWULVWDWRSHUORVSUHFRGLHQHUJLDILVLFDHLQWHOOHWWXDOHGDSDUWHGHO SDHVH $QFKH ( PROWR SUHRFFXSDWD PD SUHYHGH FKH QRQ FDPELHUj QLHQWH TXDOXQTXH FRVDDFFDGD H WXWWL VDUDQQR SRYHUL FRPHSULPD &L q VWDWR FRQVL JOLDWRGLUHVWDUHDFDVDRJJLHGRPDQL+RIDWWRXQSR¶GLSURYYLVWH ,OGLVFRUVRVLWHUUjDOOH 6WDSDUODQGR>@HWXWWRDOPHQRDWWRUQRDFDVDPLDVLqIHUPDWR(D VFROWD PROWR VHULD H DQFKH ' QRQ ULGH FRPH DO VROLWR 7UDQQH SHU TXDOFKH PDFFKLQDF¶qXQVLOHQ]LRLUUHDOHÊXQDVHQVD]LRQHVWUDQD/DVXDYRFHVHPEUD WHVDPDQRQGLVFRQILWWRDOFRQWUDULRLOWRQRVHPEUDWUDQTXLOOR 5RGROIR)DWWRYLFK 18//$ ', )$772 5HVWD DO SRWHUH FRQWLQXD OD JXHUUD PRELOLWD]LRQH JHQHUDOH .qGLVSHUDWRSHULOFUROORGHOO¶LOOXVLRQHGHOO¶8QLWj(WLRSLFD DSULOH 6HPEUDFKHL7LJULQLVLDQRVWDWLIHUPDWLD)LQFKD¶D7XWWDYLD5PLKDIDW WRFDSLUHFKHVRQRYLFLQLDG$PER 'RPDQLSDUODPHQWRYRWDVX0HQJKLVWX DSULOH 2JJLLOSDUODPHQWRYRWDVX0HQJKLVWX,QVHUDWDVLVDSUjTXDOFRVD*UDQ GHLQFHUWH]]DHDWWHVD 4XHVWD PDWWLQD TXDVL WXWWR OR VWDII GHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL 6WRULD GLVFXWHYD VXOIXWXUR3UHRFFXSD]LRQHSHUO¶DYDQ]DWDGHL7LJULQLVHQWLWLFRPHXQQHPLFR LQYDVRUHFKHSXzFRPPHWWHUHDWURFLWj5HJQDXQVHQVRGLDQVLDHSDXUD .VHPSOLFHPHQWHWHUURUL]]DWRHFRPSOHWDPHQWHEORFFDWR+XJXDOPHQWH QRQVLFRQFHQWUDVXQXOOD7LPRUHSHUSRVVLELOHDQDUFKLD9HGUHPRFRVDVXF FHGH $QIUD\PROWRWUDQTXLOOR5XVVLLQIXJD DSULOH ,O 3DUDPHQWR QRQ KD GHFLVR QXOOD GL IDWWR 3URFODPDWD OD PRELOLWD]LRQH JHQHUDOH$TXHVWRSXQWRQRQF¶qYLDGLXVFLWD )LQFKD¶DqFDGXWD2UDVLVWDQQRDYYLFLQDQGRD$PER6HQWLWLVSDULPROWR YLFLQRDFDVD DSULOH )RUWHFULWLFDD0HQJKLVWXGDSDUWHGHO3DUODPHQWROXQHGuVFRUVRFRQLP SRVL]LRQH GHOOH ULVROX]LRQL SROLWLFKH 7UH ULVROX]LRQL DSSURYDWH 0RELOLWD ]LRQHJHQHUDOHSXUDPHQWHIRUPDOH$SHUWXUDQHJR]LDWLFRQLQYLWRDOOHRS SRVL]LRQLDYHQLUHD$GGLV$EDED&UHD]LRQHGLXQDFRPPLVVLRQHFKHJHVWL VFDLOSHULRGRGLWUDQVL]LRQHVRWWRLOFRQWUROORGHOOHRUJDQL]]D]LRQLLQWHUQD]LR QDOL*LXVWDPHQWH.PLKDIDWWRQRWDUHGXHSXQWLGHEROLQHVVXQDJDUDQ]LDSHU OHRSSRVL]LRQLQHVVXQWHPSRGHILQLWRSHUODWUDQVL]LRQH 5HVWDSRVVLELOHSHULFRORGLXQFROSRGLVWDWRPLOLWDUHLQFDVRGLYXRWRGL SRWHUHHGLDQDUFKLDFKHVHJQHUHEEHODILQHGHOO¶(WLRSLD 6LWXD]LRQH PLOLWDUH FULWLFD 0DQFD LO WHPSR SHU XQD VROX]LRQH SROLWLFD" 9HGUHPR $WPRVIHUD DSSDUHQWHPHQWH SL WUDQTXLOOD . RUPDL VHPEUD UDVVH JQDWRHGHOXVR6LUHQGHFRQWRFKHLQWHOOHWWXDOLQRQKDQQRSHVRLQSROLWLFD /DFDGXWDGL0HQJKLVWXXQULFRUGRSHUVRQDOH $YYLFLQDPHQWR D $PER VHPEUD SUHOXGHUH DG DFFHUFKLDPHQWR $$ GD RYHVW H VXG YHUVR *UDQGL /DJKL GHO 5LIW 6WUDQR VHQVR GL FDOPD H DO WHPSR VWHVVRSDXUDLQFLWWj DSULOH 6HFRQGRYRFL7LJULQLUHVSLQWLSHVDQWHPHQWHGD$PER6LWXD]LRQHLQDS SDUHQ]DSLVHUHQD,QRJQLFDVRGHSRVLWRGLPXQL]LRQLD$PERJLjVYXRWDWR LQSUHFHGHQ]D 2JJLDUULYDXQDGHOHJD]LRQHDPHULFDQD DSULOH $PER SUDWLFDPHQWH FDGXWD ,HUL JURVVD GLVIDWWD GHL JRYHUQDWLYL 2JJL VHPEUDFKHODEDWWDJOLDFRQWLQXLDWWRUQRDOODFLWWj6HFRQGROD5DGLR,WDOLDQDFL VDUHEEHURSXQWDWHGL7LJULQLILQRDNPGD$$ &LWWjDSSDUHQWHPHQWHFDOPDPDLQUHDOWjPROWDWHQVLRQH>6HFRQGRDOFX QL DPLFL@ FL VDUHEEH SRFD JHQWH LQ VWUDGD $ PH q VHPEUDWRGL YHGHUH SL R PHQRORVWHVVRQXPHURGLSHUVRQH0DJJLRUQXPHURGLVROGDWLHUDIIRU]DPHQ WRGHOOHGLIHVHDHUHHPLOLWDUL 7HQVLRQHHGHPRUDOL]]D]LRQHDOO¶8QLYHUVLWj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¶+LOWRQ FRPHSULYDWLFLWWDGLQL%XRQVHJQR.PROWRWUDQTXLOOR 5RGROIR)DWWRYLFK DSULOH 6LWXD]LRQHPROWRWUDQTXLOODQRQRVWDQWHDOODUPLVPRGHOOD5DGLR,WDOLDQD DSULOH $WPRVIHUDDO0XVHRHDOO¶8QLYHUVLWjILQDOPHQWHPROWRWUDQTXLOOD 0HQJKLVWXRUPDLFRPSOHWDPHQWHLVRODWR PDJJLR *LRUQDWDPROWRWUDQTXLOOD9RFLGLDWWDFFRD$VVDE PDJJLR $OPRPHQWRWXWWRVHPEUDWUDQTXLOOR $OOD%%&VHUYL]LRRWWLPLVWLFRVXLQHJR]LDWLGL/RQGUDFKHVLWHUUDQQRWUD GXHVHWWLPDQH PDJJLR 6LWXD]LRQHWUDQTXLOOD)RUPDWRQXRYRJRYHUQR0LQLVWURGHOOD&XOWXUDqLO UHWWRUHGHOO¶8QLYHUVLWjGL$VPDUD*RYHUQRFRVWLWXLWRGDWHFQRFUDWL«(PD QDWRGHFUHWRGLPRELOLWD]LRQHJHQHUDOH3UHFHGHQWHqVWDWROHWWHUDPRUWD PDJJLR $QIUD\ H 6FKQHLGHU KDQQR FKLXVR LO ORUR XIILFLR DO0XVHR /D 0LVVLRQH $UFKHRORJLFD)UDQFHVHqFKLXVD&RQORURqILQLWDXQ¶HSRFD2UDWRFFDDPH PDJJLR 2FFXSDWD%DWLVXOODVWUDGD$VVDE'HVVLHFKHqEORFFDWD PDJJLR 6HPEUDFKH%DWLVLDVWDWDVXELWRULSUHVD PDJJLR 'HVVLHFLUFRQGDWD6WUDGDSHU$VVDESUDWLFDPHQWHWDJOLDWD$YDQ]DWDYHU VR$PER"6HFRQGR.ODVLWXD]LRQHQRQqSLVRWWRFRQWUROOR$G$GGLV$ EDEDWXWWDYLDDWPRVIHUDDSSDUHQWHPHQWHWUDQTXLOOD PDJJLR 6LWXD]LRQH GL QXRYR PROWR JUDYH 'HVVLH H $PER FDGXWH $WWDFFDWD $ VPDUD 2IIHQVLYD GD PHWWHUH LQ UHOD]LRQH FRQ QHJR]LDWL GHOOD SURVVLPD VHWWL PDQD$PHULFDQLLQDWWHVD PDJJLR >0DWWLQD@6LWXD]LRQHVHULDPDVWD]LRQDULD /DFDGXWDGL0HQJKLVWXXQULFRUGRSHUVRQDOH *,251$7$6725,&$0HQJKLVWXKDGDWROHGLPLVVLRQLHGKDODVFLDWR O¶(WLRSLDSHUULIXJLDUVLLQ=LPEDEZH 6RVWLWXLWRGDXQDOWURJHQHUDOH7HVID\*.LGDQHEHQYLVWRGDJOL$PHUL FDQL 3HULOPRPHQWRQRQVLSUHYHGRQRGLVRUGLQLLQFLWWjHVLWXD]LRQHFRQVLGH UDWDQRUPDOHHWUDQTXLOODGDOO¶$PEDVFLDWD 6HFRQGR79LWDOLDQD$VVDESUHVDPDQRWL]LDQRQFRQIHUPDWD 5KDSUHVRXQDOWUR]DEDJQDQRWWXUQRSHUPDJJLRUVLFXUH]]D&RSULIXRFR DQWLFLSDWRDOOH GH PDJJLR 6RQRDUULYDWLD$GGLV$OHPNPDRYHVWGL$$9HGLDPRFRVDVXFFH +RDYXWRODIRUWXQDGLWURYDUPLDG$UDW.LORQHOPRPHQWRLQFXL WRJOLHYDQRLOULWUDWWRGL0HQJKLVWX&¶HUDPROWLVVLPDJHQWHPDWXWWLVLOHQ]LRVL HDWWHQWL1HVVXQDPDQLIHVWD]LRQHGLJLXELORPDSLXWWRVWRFRPPR]LRQHHSHU SOHVVLWj7XWWLFKLDUDPHQWHLPSUHVVLRQDWLÊVWDWRXQPRPHQWRVWRULFRSHUFKp ODJHQWHKDDYXWRODSHUFH]LRQHFRQFUHWDFKHqDQGDWRYLDHFKHXQSHULRGRq ILQLWR2UDODVWRULDORJLXGLFKHUj PDJJLR ),1$/0(17(6212$55,9$7,>@6HFRQGRO¶$PEDVFLDWDL7L JULQLVWDQQRHQWUDQGRLQ$GGLV$EDED0LqVHPEUDWRGLVHQWLUHVSDULLQORQWD QDQ]D $QFRUD TXHVWD PDWWLQD VL SHQVDYD H VSHUDYD FKH DYUHEEHUR FLUFRQGDWR $$VHQ]DRFFXSDUODTXHVWDHUDDQFKHO¶RSLQLRQHGHOO¶$PEDVFLDWD$WPRVIHUD FDOPDPDGLDWWHVD9LVWDPHQRJHQWHLQVWUDGDHSRFKLDOO¶8QLYHUVLWj >3RPHULJJLR@ $IIOXVVR FRQWLQXR GL WUXSSH LQ ULWLUDWD $OFXQL LQTXDGUDWL PROWL DOOR VEDQGR 9LVWL VRSUDWWXWWR VXOOD VWUDGD GHO 9HFFKLR $HURSRUWR 8Q UHSDUWRSLRPHQRLQTXDGUDWRYLVWRVXVWUDGDSHU$PER ,PSUHVVLRQDQWHYHGHUHXQHVHUFLWRDOORVIDVFLR5DSSUHVHQWDYDQRXQSRV VLELOHSHULFRORSHUUD]]LHODJHQWHFRPXQTXHOLFRQIRUWDYDHDLXWDYD 6HFRQGRYRFLFDUULDUPDWLSUHVVRLO*KHEu6HPEUDFKH5XVVLH$PHULFD QLDEELDQRFHUFDWRGLIHUPDUOLPDLQXWLOPHQWH 2UGLQHqVWDUHDOPRPHQWRDFDVD6RQRPROWRWUDQTXLOORHFXULRVR PDJJLR >@)DOVRDOODUPH6RQRIHUPLHVRQRLQFRUVRWUDWWDWLYH*LRUQDWDFDR WLFD7LJULQLDFFHUFKLDQR$$&LWWjWXWWDYLDSHUIHWWDPHQWHWUDQTXLOODHFRQRU GLQHPDQWHQXWRDQFKHVHFRUUHYRFHGLTXDOFKHIXUWRQHOOD]RQDGHO0HUFDWR 9LWDDEEDVWDQ]DQRUPDOHDQFKHVHFRQSRFDJHQWHDOO¶8QLYHUVLWj0ROWDIUHQH 5RGROIR)DWWRYLFK VLDLQYHFHDOO¶$PEDVFLDWDSHUXQYRORVWUDRUGLQDULR$=FKHULSRUWDDFDVDXQ SR¶GLFRQQD]LRQDOL«,VWLWXWRGL&XOWXUD6FXROH,WDOLDQHH&RQVRODWRFKLXVL 7UDO¶DOWURLOFRQVRODWRqXQRGHLFHQWULGLUDFFROWDSHUO¶HYDFXD]LRQH$QFKHOD &DSR]RQDqQHJOL86$RWWLPDRUJDQL]]D]LRQHSHUO¶HYDFXD]LRQH /DFLWWjqSLHQDGLVROGDWLHJXDUGLHDUPDWHFKHILQRUDVHPEUDQRDWWRQLWL ÊSRVVLELOHDFTXLVWDUHXQNDODVKLNRYDOPHUFDWRSHU%LUU >@ 5LFHYLPHQWR GHO 0LQLVWHUR GHOOD &XOWXUD LQ RQRUH GL $QIUD\ H 6FKQHLGHUPROWRFRPPRYHQWH(QWUDPELKDQQRSLDQWR $VPDUDqFDGXWDVHQ]DFRPEDWWLPHQWL >@7XWWLVSDUDQRLQDULDFRQOHDUPLGDSRFRDFTXLVWDWH&RQ WLQXLPRYLPHQWLGLDXWRPH]]LPLOLWDULDSSDUHQWHPHQWHVX$PER5RDG PDJJLR )8*$'$$'',6$%$%$2JJLqSDUWLWRLOYROR$=FRQHYDFXDWL6L WXD]LRQHFDOPDHDOPRPHQWRRWWLPLVWLFD1RQVLVSLHJDHYDFXD]LRQHG¶XUJHQ ]D GHL )UDQFHVL $QIUD\ PL KD WHOHIRQDWR TXHVWD QRWWH DOO¶ SHU GLUPL FKH SDUWLYD2YYLDPHQWHWLPRUHFKH7LJULQLHQWULQRTXHVWDQRWWHLQTXDQWRVRQRDW WHVWDWLDNPGD$$$PHULFDQLULWHQJRQRLPSUREDELOHTXHVWDPRVVD &LWWjWUDQTXLOODHRUGLQDWDPDDVVDLVLOHQ]LRVDFRQPHQRVEDQGDWLPROWL VFDSSDWLLQERUJKHVHRSSXUHULHQWUDWLLQFDVHUPD$WWHVD 'XUDQWHODQRWWHSRQWHDHUHRFRQWLQXRSHUL)DODVKD PDJJLR $YYLVRGHOO¶DPEDVFLDWDGLGXHXOWLPLYROLSHU*LEXWLH1DLURELPDGLIIL FROWjDWURYDUHSRVWL$PEDVFLDWDFRQVLJOLDGLULPDQHUHDFDVD 'DTXHVWDVHUDO¶DHURSRUWRqFKLXVR/DFLWWjqFRPSOHWDPHQWHFLUFRQGDWD HL7LJULQLKDQQRGLFKLDUDWRGLQRQSHUPHWWHUHDJOLDHUHLGLSDUWLUHRDWWHUUDUH 6LVHQWRQRFROSLGLFDQQRQHHFDUULDUPDWLVLVSRVWDQRYHUVRODSHULIHULD 0LVRQRWUDVIHULWRDG$UDW.LOR63(5,$02787726,5,62/9$%( 1( PDJJLR *LRUQDWD FDRWLFD 6LVWHPDWH YDULH SUDWLFKH 5LXQLRQH OD PDWWLQD DOO¶8QL YHUVLWjVXOSURJUDPPDGL0DVWHULQ$UFKHRORJLD 6LWXD]LRQHPROWRVHULD'RPDQLRGRSRGRPDQLYHQLDPRWUDVIHULWLD1DL URELFRQ&$HURSRUWRVRWWRWLURGHL7LJULQLFKHKDQQRGLFKLDUDWRGLQRQ SHUPHWWHUHDOFXQDSDUWHQ]DRDUULYR,QROWUHKDQQRFRQFHVVRGXHJLRUQLDOO¶H VHUFLWRSHUDUUHQGHUVL*LRUQDWDGLSUHJKLHUDSHUODSDFHHPDUFLDSHUODSDFH GHOOHVFXROHGD$UDW.LORD%HWD*L\RUJLV ,HULVHUDHTXHVWDPDWWLQDVFRQWULSUHVVR*KHEuWUDHVHUFLWRH*XDUGLD5H SXEEOLFDQD6FRQWULULSUHVLYHUVROH /DFDGXWDGL0HQJKLVWXXQULFRUGRSHUVRQDOH 2UD>@DSSDUHQWHWUHJXDPDWXWWDOD]RQDGL$UDW.LORFLUFRQGDWDGD WUXSSH 6HPEUD FKH 7HVID\ VLD PRUWR XFFLVR R VXLFLGDWR" $OPHQR FLQTXH PRUWLLQVFRQWULSUHVVRLO*KHEu3DUWHQ]DSUHYLVWDSHUPHUFROHGu>PDJJLR@ VHDHUHLSRWUDQQRDWWHUUDUH >@³%DWWDJOLD´FRQXVRGLDXWREOLQGHSHUWXWWDODVHUDDWWRUQRDOSD OD]]RHVSDUDWRULHDQFKHLQDOWUH]RQHGHOODFLWWj7ROWDODOXFHDWXWWDODFLWWj >@ /LEHUDWL WXWWL L GHOLQTXHQWL FRPXQL 7LJULQL VWDQQR HQWUDQGR DQ QXQFLDWRDOOD79 PDJJLR >@ 'DOOH SHVDQWH EDWWDJOLD FRQ FDUUL DUPDWL H FDQQRQL SUHVVR LO *KHEu,OUHVWRGHOODFLWWjqWUDQTXLOOR'DFDVDVLYHGRQROHHVSORVLRQLHLOIX PRPROWRGHQVRGHQWURLOSDOD]]R $OOHEUHYHVSDUDWRULDLQWHQVDDQFKHVX$GZD5RDGVRWWRFDVD 6HPEUDFKHL7LJULQLVLDQRILQDOPHQWHHQWUDWLHVWLDQRDWWDFFDQGRLOSDOD] ]RSRLFKp7HVID\KDGLFKLDUDWRGLQRQDFFHWWDUHLOORURLQJUHVVRLQFLWWj6HQ VD]LRQHVWUDQDVHJXLUHXQDEDWWDJOLDDVFROWDQGRPXVLFDURFN /DEDWWDJOLDqILQLWDYHUVROH9LVWLL7LJULQLHQWUDUHOXQJR$GZD5RDG HRFFXSDUH$UDW.LORILJ$OOHVSDULVSRUDGLFLPDVLWXD]LRQHVRVWDQ ]LDOPHQWHWUDQTXLOOD/DJHQWHOLVDOXWDYDFDQWDQGR6XRQDYDQRPXVLFKHWLJUL QH 'DOOHEDWWDJOLDSHVDQWHDWWRUQRDOODFDVHUPDGHOOD*XDUGLD5HSXEEOL FDQDGLHWURDG$UDW.LOR(VSORVLLGHSRVLWLGLPXQL]LRQL >3RPHULJJLR@7LJULQLFRQWUROODQRWXWWDODFLWWjWUDQQHOD]RQDGHO0HUFDWR 1HOWDUGRSRPHULJJLRVSDULLVRODWL PDJJLR 0DWWLQD WUDQTXLOOD FRQ PROWD JHQWH LQ VWUDGD &LWWj VRWWR FRPSOHWR FRQ WUROOR GHL 7LJULQL WUDQQH ]RQD GHO 0HUFDWR H 9HFFKLR $HURSRUWR 3UHVLGLDWH EDQFKHH]RQHFRPPHUFLDOL7LJULQLPROWRFLYLOLHVHUL3RSROD]LRQHLQVWUDGD FXULRVDSLFKHSHUSOHVVDRRVWLOHILJ 9HUVRPDQLIHVWD]LRQHFRQWUR$PEDVFLDWD$PHULFDQDSDUWLWDGD$ UDW.LORGLTXDOFKHFHQWLQDLRGLVWXGHQWL$PHULFDQLDFFXVDWLGLDYHUGDWRYLD OLEHUDDL7LJULQL9HUVROHPDQLIHVWD]LRQHGD0HUFDWRYHUVR$UDW .LORHVXFFHVVLYDPHQWHPDQLIHVWD]LRQLLQDOWUH]RQHGHOODFLWWj0H[LFR6TXD UH6WDGLR$OOHPDQLIHVWD]LRQHGLFHQWLQDLDGLUDJD]]LOXQJR$ GZD5RDGYHUVR$PEDVFLDWD$PHULFDQDFRQVSDULGDSDUWHGHL7LJULQL0DQL IHVWD]LRQLFRQWURJRYHUQRWLJULQRGL$$ILQRDOXJOLR2UGLQHWLJULQRGLFRSUL IXRFRWRWDOHSURLELWRXVFLUHDSLHGLRLQPDFFKLQDSHUWXWWLFRPSUHVRSHUVR QDOHGLSORPDWLFR$OOHVFRQWURDIXRFRSUHVVR%HWD*L\RUJLVH0HQHOLN 5RGROIR)DWWRYLFK 6TXDUH$OOHIRUWHVFDULFDGLPLWUDJOLDWULFLD$UDW.LOR6HPEUDYLVLDQR VWDWLPRUWL PDJJLR /DFLWWjqVRVWDQ]LDOPHQWHVRWWRFRQWUROOR5LSUHVDDWWLYLWjODYRUDWLYDFRQ FRSULIXRFRGDOOH &L VRQR VWDWL FRPXQTXH DOFXQLGLVRUGLQL SHU PDQLIH VWD]LRQHGHJOLVWXGHQWLWUDO¶DOWURSURLELWHD0H[LFR6TXDUH4XDWWURVROGDWL XFFLVLDOOR6WDGLRGDYDQWLDOO¶$PEDVFLDWRUH,WDOLDQRSHUFKpQRQYROHYDQRFRQ VHJQDUHOHDUPL 6HPEUDFKH7HVID\HVLVLDULIXJLDWRQHOO¶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¶(WLRSLD 8QLYHUVLWjSUHVLGLDWDGDL7LJULQL(YDFXD]LRQHULQYLDWDDOXQHGuJLXJQR JLXJQR $PEDVFLDWD,WDOLDQDFLUFRQGDWDGDLHULSHUDYHUHGDWRULIXJLRD7HVID\HH DOWULLPSRUWDQWLHVSRQHQWLGHO'HUJ7UDWWDWLYHLQFRUVR$YYLVDWLGLQRQFLUFR ODUHFRQPDFFKLQDFRQWDUJD 6RQRGLQXRYRDG$UDW.LOR)RUVHOXQHGu>JLXJQR@ULSUHQGRQRLYROL 8QLYHUVLWjFKLXVDSHUXQWHQWDWLYRGLGLPRVWUD]LRQHGDSDUWHGHJOLVWXGHQ WLFRQDOFXQLPRUWL 6LSXzFLUFRODUHLQFLWWjPDDOFXQLVHJQLGLRVWLOLWjYHUVRGLQRL/DWHQ VLRQHqGLQXRYRDOWDSUREOHPLSHULVDODULFRQDVVHPEUDPHQWRTXHVWDPDWWLQD DG$UDW.LOR JLXJQR /DJLRUQDWDLQL]LDFRQTXDOFKHVSDURLVRODWRPDSRLWUDQTXLOOD$OO¶+LO WRQWXWWRVHPEUDILQWURSSRQRUPDOHFRQRFFLGHQWDOLLQSLVFLQDSUDQ]RHWHQ QLV /DFDGXWDGL0HQJKLVWXXQULFRUGRSHUVRQDOH 9HUVROHO¶DPEDVFLDWDYLHQHOLEHUDWD8QRGHLVHLULIXJLDWL0LQLVWUR GHOO¶,QGXVWULDVLqXFFLVRFRQXQFROSRGLSLVWROD JLXJQR *LRUQDWDQXRYDPHQWHFDRWLFD$HURSRUWRFKLXVRHQHVVXQDQRWL]LDVXUL SUHVDGHLYROL(WKLRSLDQ$LUOLQHV9RFLVXYRORVSHFLDOH$=SHUGRPDQL PD QRQFRQIHUPDWH$PEDVFLDWDDSHUWDGLSULPDPDWWLQDSRLQXRYDPHQWHFKLXVD YHUVROH,VWLWXWRGL&XOWXUDDSHUWR ,Q VXSHUILFLH VLWXD]LRQH SHUIHWWDPHQWH WUDQTXLOODWUDQQH SHU VSDUL VSRUD GLFLYLFLQRDFDVD9RFLGLSRVVLELOHWHQWDWLYRGLDWWDFFRGDSDUWHGLWUXSSHJR YHUQDWLYHFKHDQFRUDUHVLVWRQRDG$PERPDSRWUHEEHWUDWWDUVLGLXQ¶LOOXVLRQH DPKDUD7HQVLRQHSHULVDODULPDEDQFKHULDSHUWH 1HOSRPHULJJLRYRFLGLULDSHUWXUDGHJOLXIILFLSHUGRPDQL(WKLRSLDQ$LU OLQHVQRQYRODILQRDOODSURVVLPDVHWWLPDQD9RFLGLDHUHLPLOLWDULSHUGRPDQL $=IRUVHULSUHQGHJLRYHGu>JLXJQR@PDSLSUREDELOPHQWHLO 3DVVHJJLDWRSHUFLWWjQHVVXQRFFLGHQWDOHLQJLUR JLXJQR $OOH LQL]LDWR SHVDQWH FDQQRQHJJLDPHQWR VHPEUDYHUVR (QWRWWR PD LQ UHDOWj YHUVR %ROH H DHURSRUWR 1RQ VL VD HVDWWDPHQWH FRVD VLD 6HPEUD H VSORVLRQH GHO GHSRVLWR PXQL]LRQL WUD 'HEUH =HLW 5RDG H 9HFFKLD 6WD]LRQH ILJ(VSORVLRQLFRQWLQXH6HPEUDDWWHQWDWRSHUFKpEDQGLHUDWLJULQDVXOGH SRVLWRLQYHFHGLTXHOODHWLRSLFD$OOHIRUWLVVLPDHVSORVLRQHFRQSDOODGL IXRFRHIXQJRVLPLOHDGXQDERPEDDWRPLFD0LIDQQRDQFRUDPDOHOHRUHF FKLH(VSORVLRQLFRQWLQXH6WDQQREUXFLDQGRLGHSRVLWLGLEHQ]LQD1XEH PROWRGHQVDLQFRQWUDVWRFRQVSOHQGLGRFLHOROLPSLGRHVROH&RQWUDVWRWUDUX PRUHGHOOHHVSORVLRQLHVLOHQ]LRWRWDOHGHOODFLWWjDTXHVW¶RUDGLVROLWRJLjPRO WRUXPRURVD $OOHqILQLWRWXWWRHODYLWDULSUHQGHQRUPDOH&RQIHUPDWRDWWHQWDWR FRQFHQWLQDLDGLPRUWL&DUULDUPDWLGRYXQTXH1HVVXQDVSHUDQ]DSHUYROLLQ SURVVLPRIXWXUR $OOHIDWWRJLURLQFLWWjSRFKHPDFFKLQHHJHQWHDWWRQLWDPROWLFX ULRVL1HOOD]RQDGL3LD]]DH$GZD5RDGYLWDDSSDUHQWHPHQWHQRUPDOH)XPR PHQRGHQVR3DOD]]RVWUHWWDPHQWHGLIHVRGDFDUULDUPDWLVSHFLDOPHQWHGDYDQWL DOO¶LQJUHVVRSULQFLSDOH7XWWHOHDXWREOLQGHFRQLVHUYHQWLDLSH]]L $OOHO¶DPEDVFLDWDLQIRUPDSRVVLELOHDUULYRYRORPLOLWDUHRJJL JLXJQR $OOHDOO¶DHURSRUWRSHUO¶HYDFXD]LRQH6RQROHHVLDPRDQFRUD TXL,7LJULQLKDQQRSRVWRWXWWDXQDVHULHGLOXQJDJJLQLEXURFUDWLFKH9HUVROH LQL]LDWHSUDWLFKHGLLPEDUFRHVWDYRJLjSHUUHFDUPLYHUVRO¶DHUHRTXDQ 5RGROIR)DWWRYLFK GROD6HFXULW\KDIHUPDWRWXWWR'DDOORUDDWWHVDVHQ]DVDSHUHFRVDVWDYDVXF FHGHQGR /¶$PEDVFLDWRUH VL q UHFDWR DO 0LQLVWHUR GHJOL $IIDUL (VWHUL SHU XQ XOWHULRUH FRQWUROOR GHOOD OLVWD GL SHUVRQH HYDFXDWH $WPRVIHUD IRU]DWDPHQWH UDVVHJQDWDDOODILQHULPDQGDWLDGRUPLUHQHOOHQRVWUHFDVH JLXJQR $OOHWXWWLQXRYDPHQWHDOO¶DHURSRUWRPDILQRDOOHLQFHUWH]]DVX SDUWHQ]DSHUFKpJOLDFFRUGLGHOJLRUQRSUHFHGHQWHQRQFRQVLGHUDWLQHFHVVDULD PHQWHYDOLGL'LVWULEXLWHUD]LRQL.SHVVLPHFRPHDOWHPSRGHOVHUYL]LRPLOL WDUH )LQDOPHQWH LPEDUFDWL DOOH H SDUWLWL DOOH 6LVWHPDWR VX XQ &7XWWLVHGXWLVXOSDYLPHQWRLQILOHGLSHUVRQHSHURFFXSDUHWXWWRORVSD ]LRGLVSRQLELOHSLXQFRQWDLQHUSHULOEDJDJOLR $OOH DUULYR D *LEXWL H VLVWHPDWL LQ EDVH GHOOD /HJLRQH 6WUDQLHUD IUDQFHVH2WWLPDFHQDLQFLWWjDEDVHGLSHVFHEDUUDFXGDPDFDOGRXPLGRLQ IHUQDOH JLXJQR $OOHSDUWHQ]DFRQYROR$=GD*LEXWLHULHQWURD5RPD 2UPDLWXWWRTXHVWRqVWRULD/DSULPDYHUDGHOKDVHJQDWRXQDVYROWD UDGLFDOHQHOODVWRULDGHOO¶(WLRSLDHSHUYDULPRWLYLPLDSHUVRQDOH1pLOSDHVH QpLRVLDPRSLTXHOOLFKHHUDYDPRSULPDGLTXHVWLHYHQWLPDSRWUzVHPSUH GLUH,RF¶HUR 3HU<DTREGDVHPSUHDPLFRIUDWHUQRDPHPRULDLPSHULWXUD Fig. 1. 28 maggio 1991, i guerriglieri tigrini su Adua Road, circa ore 6. Fig. 2. 29 maggio 1991, curiosi davanti al Gebì, circa ore 10. Fig. JLXJQR O¶HVSORVLRQH GHO GHSRVLWR GL PXQL]LRQL YLVWD GD Aratkilo, circa ore 6. Prodotto da IL TORCOLIERE • Officine Grafico-Editoriali d’Ateneo U niversità degli stUdi di n apoli “L’Orientale” finito di stampare nel mese di Novembre 2012