Relazione Publication Committee
ATLAS Italia – 24 Ottobre 2012
F. Ceradini (Roma Tre) - C. Gemme (INFN Genova)
Outline:
Stato delle pubblicazioni in ATLAS (al 30/9), based onT.Doyle reports
Contributo italiano
1
Publications
http://atlasresults.web.cern.ch/atlasresults/
To end-Sept. ATLAS produced:
192 Journal Papers
usingCollisionData
including
7 Performance
79 Measurements
103 Searches!
405 Preliminary
Conference Notes
24/10/2012
PubComm Report
2
Publications
http://atlasresults.web.cern.ch/atlasresults/
Al 23/10
Number of public papers with
collision data: 206 (era 192 al 30/09)
To end-Sept. ATLAS produced:
192 Journal Papers
usingCollisionData
including
7 Performance
79 Measurements
103 Searches!
405 Preliminary
Conference Notes
24/10/2012
PubComm Report
3
Publications
http://atlasresults.web.cern.ch/atlasresults/
30/09/2012
24/10/2012
PubComm Report
4
Publications
http://atlasresults.web.cern.ch/atlasresults/
30/09/2012
24/10/2012
PubComm Report
5
Paper approval and Publication Process
PGC*: Submit the analysis and request and Edboard
EdB. Approval
PGC Phys.Group
Physics
Goup
Conveners.
Princ. Group Approval
Draft1 signed off by PGC and EdBoard
Ed.Board
Draft1 circulation
Open Discussion
Draft2 circulation
Possible Draft1 in
CONF-NOTE
Spokeperson Sign-off
Public Reading
PUB Comm Sign-off
Spokeperson Sign-off
6
SUBMISSION to ArXiv & Journal
Publications
http://atlasresults.web.cern.ch/atlasresults/
7 Ed Boards to be fixed (“not started”)
95 ongoing analyses (“Phase 1 active”)
25 submitted 1st draft (“Phase 2 active”)
49 “Submission active” di cui 41 al “journal
interaction stage” quindi inclusi nei 192
To end-Sept. ATLAS produced:
192 Journal Papers
usingCollisionData
including
7 Performance
79 Measurements
103 Searches!
405 Preliminary
Conference Notes
24/10/2012
PubComm Report
7
Publications Timescales - Internal
We can also analyse internally the chain from Draft 1... ~ 66 days , ~ 150 days to published.
Mean Time
Elapsed [days]
(Draft 1 -> Publication)
Submitted
Completed
count
count
Referees Accepted Proofs Published Total
Group
<Draft 2>
<Submit>
BPHY
46.9
32.7
7
25.2
22.0
9.6
24.0
176.8
5
DAPR
24.0
43.0
1
31.0
35.0
33.0
7.0
173.0
1
EXOT
28.7
32.5
37
31.4
32.2
16.7
18.6
156.3
28
HIGG
26.4
28.7
21
25.1
23.9
11.5
13.7
111.1
15
HION
32.3
35.8
6
30.4
53.8
8.6
17.4
169.6
5
STDM
27.3
32.5
54
33.2
28.7
22.0
22.0
161.5
44
SUSY
33.0
33.4
39
30.4
27.5
14.6
17.9
155.0
27
TOPQ
34.2
39.1
20
35.1
32.9
13.2
12.1
158.4
16
PERF
35.0
66.4
7
29.4
46.7
18.2
12.0
207.0
5
All
31.1
34.5
31.2
32.9
16.5
18.4
156.7
Count
192
146
Contributo italiano in Pubcomm
 Pubcomm: 12 membri con incarico biennale, 6 nuovi ogni anno.
 Responsabilita’:
Discussione procedure (All)
Circolazione paper, approval (Chair/Deputy)
Monitoring Proceeding (2 membri)
Pre-review al draft 2 (8 membri) + Pubcomm sign-off (Chair/Deputy)
•
•
•
•
 In PubComm rappresentanza
italiana ottima (12% in media dal
2001).
• Due Chair (17% in media dal
2001)
24/10/2012
PubComm Report
9
Contributo Italiano nel paper reading
 Da Maggio 2011 gli istituti sono
coinvolti nella review dei paper
in circolazione.
•
•
Inizialmente ~ 90 istituti
coinvolti.
Dopo seconda call, da Feb
2012, moltii gli istituti (125)
sono coinvolti nella lettura dei
paper.
• 4 gruppi assegnati a ogni paper
alla prima circolazione.
• Circa una assegnazione ogni 2
mesi.
• Alcuni istituti utilizzano la
lettura per coinvolgere studenti
in discussioni di fisica.
• Contributo italiano: 11.5
10
Contributo italiano Paper Editorial Board
 Contributo* nella media sia come chair che come membri
• Editorial board: 68/816 = 8.3%
• Ed.board chair: 23/204 = 11.3%
Membri Ed board
* Considerati solo paper circolati come Draft1 dal 2011
Ed Board Chair
11
Contributo italiano paper Main editors
 Per semplicita’ di calcolo, abbiamo considerato solo i main editors del
Draft1 e non gli autori delle supp.note
• Autori: 16/552 (2.9%)
• Italiani poco rappresentati
se non in BPhysics e Performance:
Main Editors
i) la tendenza a esporsi poco ?
ii) una mancanza di continuità
perche' molte analisi si fanno al Cern ?
iii) una mancanza di organizzazione ?
24/10/2012
PubComm Report
12
Contributo italiano conf notes editors
 Per i gruppi di performance che pubblicano un numero minore di
paper dei gruppi di fisica, considerate anche le CONF note (solo
2012 per semplicita’)
• Editorial board = 3.4%
• Ed.board chair 3/25 = 12%
• Autori 17/110 =16%
• Contributo dominato dai gruppi con convener italiano/storici
Edboard Membri
24/10/2012
Edboard
Chair
PubComm Report
Main Editors
13
Proceedings
 Recentemente lunghe discussioni in Pub Comm sul meccanismo di
revisione dei proceeding, in particolare visto il grosso flusso derivante
dalle scadenze in autunno (ICHEP, …).
• In media 1.5 proc/giorno, su tutto lo scibile: Phys Analysis, Phys
Performance, Detector, e ora anche Upgrade;
• parte (non grande) con problemi di Inglese, di sintassi, di logica; parte
(non piccola) non rispetta tempi, guidelines.
 Principali modifiche implementate:
• Revisione, aggiornamento, ampliamento delle liste degli esperti (per
gruppi di fisica e detector) che rivedono i proceedings
• Richiesta di sottomettere i proceeding a ATLAS in largo anticipo rispetto
alla data di sottomissione della conferenza: da 10 gg richiesti in
precedenza fino a 30 gg.
• Per studenti/dottorandi richiesta per il responsabile del gruppo di rivedere
i proceedings prima della richiesta di review.
• Leggere le istruzioni!


24/10/2012
https://twiki.cern.ch/twiki/bin/viewauth/Atlas/PubComProcNotes
https://twiki.cern.ch/twiki/pub/Atlas/PubComProcNotes/Guidelines_for_proceedings.pdf
PubComm Report
14
Spares
24/10/2012
PubComm Report
15
My stat
paper
Conf
24/10/2012
PubComm Report
16
Publications
(30/9/12)
http://atlasresults.web.cern.ch/atlasresults/
Publications Timescales - Journals
We now have a significant data sample to analyse:
Experience with the publication of the first 200(!) ATLAS papers
with 192 using collision data
Mean Time Elapsed [days]
Journal
30/09/2012
Submitted count <Referees> <Accepted> <Proofs> <Published> <Total> Completed count
EPJC
38
27.5
39.3
15.0
13.0
92.2
28
JHEP
21
25.3
20.8
17.2
9.5
69.9
14
NCOMMS
1
14.0
107.0
15.0
18.0
154.0
1
NJP
2
22.5
0.0
43.0
41.0
106.5
2
NPB
2
20.0
12.5
4.0
15.5
52.0
2
PLB
67
42.4
35.0
7.2
15.2
96.6
51
PRD
30
28.4
24.8
30.4
27.3
110.3
24
PRL
30
20.6
21.8
25.1
25.0
93.3
23
PRC
1
35.0
61.0
8.0
28.0
132.0
1
31.2
32.9
16.5
18.4
94.8
All
Count
192
NOTE: no major change since the last ATLAS week (based on 155 papers)
146
ATLAS h-index? = 43 (30/9/12)
c.f. CMS h-index = 41
For those who aren’t
aware of this parameter, if
you are younger than your
h-index, you are usually
considered a great
scientist.
Using http://inspirehep.net/ -> fin cn atlas and ac 1000+
(Hirsch-index “43 papers have 43 citations or more”)
ATLAS Top 10 by citation (30/9/12)
900 Expected Performance of
the ATLAS Experiment Detector, Trigger and Physics
678 The ATLAS Experiment at
the CERN Large Hadron
Collider
329 Combined search for the
Standard Model Higgs boson
using up to 4.9 fb-1
213 The ATLAS Simulation
Infrastructure
193 Search for squarks and
gluinos using final states with
jets and missing transverse
momentum (Sep 11)
24/10/2012
167 Observation of a CentralityDependent Dijet Asymmetry
in Lead-Lead Collisions
157 Search for squarks and
gluinos using final states with
jets and missing transverse
momentum (Feb 11)
153 Luminosity Determination in
pp Collisions at √s =7 TeV
151 Observation of a new
particle in the search for the
Standard Model Higgs Boson
151 Search for supersymmetry
using final states with one
lepton, jets, and missing
transverse momentum
PubComm Report
20
paper reading
ANL/NIU
Prague TU
KEK
LUND
Minsk
SLAC
UC Irvine
UCL
Goettingen
Sydney
DESY(Zn)/HU
Albany
LIP
JINR
Nijmegen
Bergen
Sheffield/Dallas SMU
Orsay
Udine
MPI
Stony Brook
TRIUMF |
Victoria
Weizmann
Acad. Sinica Taiwan
CERN
Dallas UT
Edinburgh
BNL
Frascati
Michigan SU
Birmingham
Bologna
Oklahoma SU
DESY (HH)
Simon Fraser
Bern
Cracow
Duke
NIU
Nikhef
Iowa
Glasgow
McGill
Massachuss.
Tokyo University
Oxford
Ohio
LAPP
NTU-Athens
Shinshu
Milano
Kobe
Roma II
Boston
Prague AS
Pavia
Saclay
Prague
Oregon
Tufts
Protvino
Alberta
Technion Haifa
Dresden
Buenos Aires
Bogazici
Heidelberg
Barcelona
Bonn/Kyushu
Chicago
CERN
Liverpool
Roma 1
RAL
LMU Muenchen
Pennsylvania
Columbia
Cambridge
Harvard
Genova
Manchester
Cosenza
Geneva
Indiana
Freiburg
Belgrade IP
Melbourne
Tel Aviv
Copenhagen NBI
Roma3
LPNHE-Paris
Queen Mary
Grenoble LPSC
Michigan
Montreal
Pisa/Clermont
Thessaloniki
Pittsburgh
London RHBNC
Iowa
Arizona
Oslo
Santa Cruz
Brandeis
UT-Arlington
Bucharest
Marseille
UA Madrid
University of Athens
Yale
Wuppertal
Wisconsin
Sussex
Toronto
Tokyo IoT
NYU New York
Moscow SU
Nagoya
Lecce
Kosice
Lancaster
Johannesburg
Stockholm
21